WEBVTT - Doctors, Guns, and Money

0:00:15.356 --> 0:00:21.116
<v Speaker 1>Pushkin This season on Revisionist History, We're going to the

0:00:21.116 --> 0:00:26.076
<v Speaker 1>heart of America's gun violence crisis. Six episodes, some weird,

0:00:26.596 --> 0:00:30.916
<v Speaker 1>some whimsical, some heartbreaking, some angry, because so much of

0:00:30.956 --> 0:00:34.476
<v Speaker 1>what Americans tend to believe about guns and assault rifles

0:00:34.796 --> 0:00:40.156
<v Speaker 1>and mass shootings is actually wrong. We talk about TV westerns,

0:00:40.356 --> 0:00:42.956
<v Speaker 1>about a crime in a little town in rural Alabama,

0:00:43.316 --> 0:00:46.756
<v Speaker 1>About the nuttiness of the Supreme Court, about the assassination

0:00:47.276 --> 0:00:51.876
<v Speaker 1>of Robert Kennedy. The series will air weekly starting Thursday,

0:00:51.996 --> 0:00:55.396
<v Speaker 1>August thirty first, but you can binge listen to all

0:00:55.436 --> 0:00:59.396
<v Speaker 1>six episodes early and add free by subscribing to Pushkin

0:00:59.436 --> 0:01:03.996
<v Speaker 1>Plus on Apple Podcasts, or by visiting our website pushkin

0:01:04.116 --> 0:01:09.356
<v Speaker 1>dot fm, slash plus. Today we're sharing a short clip

0:01:09.396 --> 0:01:11.676
<v Speaker 1>from the series. It takes us to the world of

0:01:11.716 --> 0:01:14.556
<v Speaker 1>trauma surgery, which is actually why I started on this

0:01:14.636 --> 0:01:17.036
<v Speaker 1>deep dive in the first place. We hear a lot

0:01:17.036 --> 0:01:21.356
<v Speaker 1>about the gun crisis from law enforcement activists and politicians,

0:01:21.716 --> 0:01:24.436
<v Speaker 1>but not so much from the people who are quite

0:01:24.476 --> 0:01:29.276
<v Speaker 1>literally treating its victims. That's who I wanted to talk to. Doctors,

0:01:29.316 --> 0:01:32.996
<v Speaker 1>specifically trauma surgeons, to try and get a sense of

0:01:33.076 --> 0:01:36.876
<v Speaker 1>their view of the violence. In this clip, I'm talking

0:01:36.916 --> 0:01:40.916
<v Speaker 1>to a surgeon named doctor Babak Serrani on the subject

0:01:40.956 --> 0:01:48.236
<v Speaker 1>of time. The number of homicides in any community is

0:01:48.276 --> 0:01:52.236
<v Speaker 1>a combination of two completely unrelated variables, the number of

0:01:52.236 --> 0:01:55.676
<v Speaker 1>people victimized by acts of violence minus how good a

0:01:55.756 --> 0:01:58.396
<v Speaker 1>job the medical system does at saving the lives of

0:01:58.396 --> 0:02:01.676
<v Speaker 1>those victims. And a lot of times, what a murder

0:02:01.756 --> 0:02:04.756
<v Speaker 1>rate really tells you is how good your doctors are,

0:02:05.196 --> 0:02:07.876
<v Speaker 1>and not how safe your streets are. But there's a

0:02:07.956 --> 0:02:12.636
<v Speaker 1>twist on the observation, a really important twist which the

0:02:12.676 --> 0:02:15.676
<v Speaker 1>people who treat gunshots for a living have known about

0:02:16.156 --> 0:02:20.036
<v Speaker 1>for a long time. So I'm assuming over the course

0:02:20.076 --> 0:02:24.796
<v Speaker 1>of your career you have treated innumerable gunshot wounds.

0:02:25.516 --> 0:02:27.276
<v Speaker 2>Unfortunately true.

0:02:27.316 --> 0:02:31.556
<v Speaker 1>This is doctor Babach Serrani. He's a trauma surgeon at

0:02:31.556 --> 0:02:35.596
<v Speaker 1>George Washington University Hospital in Washington, d C. If you

0:02:35.636 --> 0:02:38.196
<v Speaker 1>get seriously injured by a bullet, you get taken to

0:02:38.236 --> 0:02:42.036
<v Speaker 1>a trauma center, more specifically a Level one trauma center,

0:02:42.316 --> 0:02:45.876
<v Speaker 1>which is a self contained, twenty four hour facility equipped

0:02:45.876 --> 0:02:52.596
<v Speaker 1>with everything necessary to treat traumatic injury. General surgeons, orthopedic surgeons, neurosurgeons,

0:02:52.596 --> 0:02:57.396
<v Speaker 1>plastic surgeons, an the caesiologists, er docs, radiologists, nurses with

0:02:57.436 --> 0:03:01.356
<v Speaker 1>the right qualifications on and on Level one. Trauma centers

0:03:01.396 --> 0:03:04.356
<v Speaker 1>cost hundreds of millions of dollars to build and operate.

0:03:04.836 --> 0:03:08.796
<v Speaker 1>They're relatively rare. DC has thirteen hospitals, but only four

0:03:08.836 --> 0:03:12.956
<v Speaker 1>Level once. One of those is at George Washington. Serrani

0:03:13.116 --> 0:03:17.516
<v Speaker 1>is the chief trauma sursion there. Do you know how many, roughly.

0:03:17.276 --> 0:03:22.836
<v Speaker 2>Speaking, Oh, my goodness, I would think probably by now,

0:03:23.556 --> 0:03:25.916
<v Speaker 2>the number of gunshot victims I've seen personally. I've been

0:03:25.916 --> 0:03:30.396
<v Speaker 2>in practice since two thousand and five. I would venture

0:03:30.596 --> 0:03:32.676
<v Speaker 2>miss Bladewell five hundred plus.

0:03:32.916 --> 0:03:33.276
<v Speaker 3>Wow.

0:03:33.836 --> 0:03:38.036
<v Speaker 1>Yeah, and you weren't even there during DC's darkest years.

0:03:38.036 --> 0:03:39.316
<v Speaker 2>Correct, Yeah, correct.

0:03:39.956 --> 0:03:43.996
<v Speaker 1>I wanted to talk to Serrani about time, because trauma

0:03:43.996 --> 0:03:47.636
<v Speaker 1>sursions are obsessed with time. There's a phrase common in

0:03:47.676 --> 0:03:51.236
<v Speaker 1>their world, the golden hour. If you get shot, they

0:03:51.276 --> 0:03:53.676
<v Speaker 1>really want to have you on the operating table as

0:03:53.716 --> 0:03:57.076
<v Speaker 1>soon as possible. That's why we pull over for ambulances.

0:03:58.076 --> 0:04:00.556
<v Speaker 1>Talk a little to me about time. You said, ems

0:04:00.596 --> 0:04:02.316
<v Speaker 1>tends to get there within ten minutes, and you tend

0:04:02.316 --> 0:04:05.276
<v Speaker 1>to get to the trauma centner between twenty and forty five.

0:04:06.156 --> 0:04:09.116
<v Speaker 1>What's the difference between twenty and forty five. What happened

0:04:09.396 --> 0:04:12.796
<v Speaker 1>in that extra period of time that would diminish someone's

0:04:12.876 --> 0:04:13.756
<v Speaker 1>chances of survival?

0:04:13.876 --> 0:04:16.676
<v Speaker 2>Yeah, I think it depends on where the injury is.

0:04:16.756 --> 0:04:18.516
<v Speaker 2>You know, if you've been injured in the abdomen and

0:04:18.516 --> 0:04:21.236
<v Speaker 2>it hits your intestine, honestly, nothing will happen between twenty

0:04:21.276 --> 0:04:24.116
<v Speaker 2>and forty five minutes. That's plenty of time. But if

0:04:24.116 --> 0:04:28.076
<v Speaker 2>you're bleeding, specifically speaking, if you're bleeding, then every minute

0:04:28.116 --> 0:04:30.596
<v Speaker 2>that goes by is you know the value of that

0:04:30.676 --> 0:04:31.956
<v Speaker 2>is plutonium.

0:04:32.396 --> 0:04:35.036
<v Speaker 1>Like for example, if you take a bullet to your liver,

0:04:35.676 --> 0:04:38.076
<v Speaker 1>the liver is a maze of blood vessels.

0:04:38.756 --> 0:04:42.916
<v Speaker 2>Making the liver, of all things, stop bleeding is exceedingly difficult.

0:04:43.236 --> 0:04:45.196
<v Speaker 2>You know, kidney, I can take it out, you have

0:04:45.236 --> 0:04:47.636
<v Speaker 2>two kidneys, spleen, I can take it out. You don't

0:04:47.676 --> 0:04:49.916
<v Speaker 2>need a spleen. I cannot take out your liver that

0:04:49.996 --> 0:04:52.716
<v Speaker 2>you need a liver to live, and so I'm obligated

0:04:52.756 --> 0:04:54.916
<v Speaker 2>to try to repair it while it just continues to bleed.

0:04:55.556 --> 0:04:58.596
<v Speaker 1>When we spoke, Serrouni had just treated someone who had

0:04:58.596 --> 0:05:00.116
<v Speaker 1>taken a rifle shot to the liver.

0:05:00.876 --> 0:05:03.236
<v Speaker 2>The reason he's alive. And I will take some credit

0:05:03.276 --> 0:05:05.636
<v Speaker 2>at George Washington, but honestly, one of the bigger reasons

0:05:05.636 --> 0:05:09.156
<v Speaker 2>he's alive is the paramedics. They completely scooped and and

0:05:09.316 --> 0:05:11.836
<v Speaker 2>with this guy. I think their entire scene time was

0:05:11.956 --> 0:05:15.396
<v Speaker 2>like ten or twelve minutes, and they just high tailed

0:05:15.396 --> 0:05:17.436
<v Speaker 2>it to the trauma center when he showed up on

0:05:17.476 --> 0:05:21.036
<v Speaker 2>our doorstep. You figure by now it's been twenty twenty

0:05:21.396 --> 0:05:23.556
<v Speaker 2>five minutes of the most from the moment of wounding

0:05:23.676 --> 0:05:28.636
<v Speaker 2>to arrival to the trauma center. He was probably five

0:05:28.676 --> 0:05:30.956
<v Speaker 2>to ten minutes away from dying. He was the extreme

0:05:31.116 --> 0:05:32.396
<v Speaker 2>end stages of shock.

0:05:33.356 --> 0:05:35.516
<v Speaker 1>Or what about a bullet to the lungs?

0:05:35.916 --> 0:05:38.076
<v Speaker 2>A paramedic can actually treat a gunshot win to the lung.

0:05:38.076 --> 0:05:40.756
<v Speaker 2>They can temporize that person very nicely. So do that.

0:05:40.836 --> 0:05:43.876
<v Speaker 1>How do you temporize someone who's had a gunshot win

0:05:43.956 --> 0:05:44.396
<v Speaker 1>to the lung?

0:05:45.116 --> 0:05:47.556
<v Speaker 2>So, when you have a gunshot to the lung, assuming

0:05:47.556 --> 0:05:49.836
<v Speaker 2>it has not hit a blood vessel, assuming you're not bleeding,

0:05:49.876 --> 0:05:51.876
<v Speaker 2>all you have is a gunshot to the lung, which

0:05:51.916 --> 0:05:56.716
<v Speaker 2>is I believe or not really really common. The problem

0:05:56.836 --> 0:05:59.316
<v Speaker 2>is you have air leaking from your lung, and that

0:05:59.396 --> 0:06:03.476
<v Speaker 2>air is accumulating inside the chest. As that air collects

0:06:03.516 --> 0:06:05.196
<v Speaker 2>more and more inside the chest because it's leaking out

0:06:05.196 --> 0:06:07.356
<v Speaker 2>of lung, it'll create a lot of pressure in the

0:06:07.436 --> 0:06:10.916
<v Speaker 2>chest and it'll cause it'll alter the blood flow to

0:06:10.996 --> 0:06:14.356
<v Speaker 2>your body. So the paramedic can simply put a needle

0:06:14.516 --> 0:06:16.716
<v Speaker 2>inside your chest, believe it or not, just like literally

0:06:16.756 --> 0:06:18.916
<v Speaker 2>in sort of needle through your skin into your chest

0:06:19.356 --> 0:06:21.876
<v Speaker 2>and it's like popping a balloon. It'll allow that air

0:06:21.916 --> 0:06:24.876
<v Speaker 2>that's accumulating to decompress, and that's all you have to do.

0:06:25.556 --> 0:06:29.276
<v Speaker 2>That will buy the person then tens of minutes if

0:06:29.316 --> 0:06:32.356
<v Speaker 2>not more, to get to the trauma center to allow

0:06:32.436 --> 0:06:35.636
<v Speaker 2>us to then fix the issue at hand. But that's

0:06:35.676 --> 0:06:36.556
<v Speaker 2>a paramedic.

0:06:36.196 --> 0:06:41.436
<v Speaker 1>Skill absince that intervention that would be a fatal event. Correct,

0:06:42.116 --> 0:06:44.796
<v Speaker 1>Just to deling on this time question for a moment.

0:06:45.196 --> 0:06:48.156
<v Speaker 1>So if I have a gunshot wound to the chest

0:06:48.196 --> 0:06:51.876
<v Speaker 1>and I have exactly happening to me what you just described,

0:06:52.396 --> 0:06:55.076
<v Speaker 1>how much time do I have without an AMS's intervention?

0:06:55.316 --> 0:06:55.836
<v Speaker 1>Half an hour?

0:06:56.236 --> 0:06:57.796
<v Speaker 2>Yeah, probably about half an hour or so, I mean

0:06:57.836 --> 0:07:01.676
<v Speaker 2>plus minus, But yes, I would think so.

0:07:01.676 --> 0:07:05.356
<v Speaker 1>So let's think through the logic of this. A city

0:07:05.516 --> 0:07:09.236
<v Speaker 1>or country's homicide rate is heavily dependent on how good

0:07:09.316 --> 0:07:13.716
<v Speaker 1>its medical system is a treating gunshot once. And what

0:07:13.796 --> 0:07:17.396
<v Speaker 1>determines how good a medical system is a treating gunshot ones,

0:07:17.756 --> 0:07:21.036
<v Speaker 1>at least in part, it's how quickly a gunshot victim

0:07:21.356 --> 0:07:25.476
<v Speaker 1>can get to a Level one trauma center. Okay, second question,

0:07:26.076 --> 0:07:29.316
<v Speaker 1>and in this case, let's use Chicago as our example,

0:07:29.836 --> 0:07:34.756
<v Speaker 1>classic big American city. Chicago absolutely confirms the theory that

0:07:34.876 --> 0:07:38.556
<v Speaker 1>proximity to a trauma center matters. According to a big

0:07:38.596 --> 0:07:41.276
<v Speaker 1>study done a couple of years ago by the epidemiologist

0:07:41.356 --> 0:07:44.396
<v Speaker 1>Marie Crandall, if you live more than five miles from

0:07:44.436 --> 0:07:47.036
<v Speaker 1>a Level one trauma center in Chicago, you had a

0:07:47.116 --> 0:07:50.716
<v Speaker 1>thirty five percent higher chance of dying from your wounds

0:07:51.196 --> 0:07:53.636
<v Speaker 1>than if you were shot less than five miles from

0:07:53.676 --> 0:07:58.716
<v Speaker 1>a Level one. So here's the second question. What determines

0:07:59.276 --> 0:08:01.676
<v Speaker 1>how quickly you get to a trauma center in Chicago?

0:08:02.476 --> 0:08:05.356
<v Speaker 1>Is it a random fact like whether there's an ambulance

0:08:05.396 --> 0:08:07.836
<v Speaker 1>nearby when you get shot, or how bad the traffic

0:08:07.916 --> 0:08:09.516
<v Speaker 1>is that day on the way to the hot hospital,

0:08:10.276 --> 0:08:13.756
<v Speaker 1>or is there a pattern to who lives within five

0:08:13.796 --> 0:08:17.276
<v Speaker 1>miles of a Level one and who doesen't a physician

0:08:17.556 --> 0:08:21.276
<v Speaker 1>at the University of Chicago named Elizabeth Tongue set out

0:08:21.316 --> 0:08:25.236
<v Speaker 1>to answer that question a few years ago, what do

0:08:25.316 --> 0:08:26.396
<v Speaker 1>you find in Chicago?

0:08:27.356 --> 0:08:30.396
<v Speaker 3>And so we found that black majority census tracks were

0:08:30.436 --> 0:08:32.556
<v Speaker 3>disproportionately in these trauma deserts.

0:08:32.996 --> 0:08:35.636
<v Speaker 1>A trauma desert, by the way, is what er docs

0:08:35.676 --> 0:08:38.316
<v Speaker 1>call places that are a long way from a level one.

0:08:39.076 --> 0:08:46.756
<v Speaker 3>That racial disparity was essentially very large, approximately a sevenfold

0:08:46.836 --> 0:08:50.236
<v Speaker 3>increase on the south Side in black communities.

0:08:50.396 --> 0:08:53.756
<v Speaker 1>Wait to explain the sevenfold the racial disparity between what

0:08:53.876 --> 0:08:55.236
<v Speaker 1>and what is sevenfold higher.

0:08:55.436 --> 0:08:58.956
<v Speaker 3>The racial disparity between black majority census tracks and white

0:08:58.956 --> 0:09:00.276
<v Speaker 3>majority census tracks.

0:09:00.156 --> 0:09:07.516
<v Speaker 1>Is seven x sevenfold sevenfold. Wow. For a period of

0:09:07.556 --> 0:09:11.836
<v Speaker 1>thirty years, between nineteen one and twenty eighteen, the south

0:09:11.876 --> 0:09:15.196
<v Speaker 1>side of Chicago didn't even have a Level one trauma center.

0:09:15.916 --> 0:09:17.756
<v Speaker 1>So if you got shot on the south Side, and

0:09:17.796 --> 0:09:19.836
<v Speaker 1>by the way, the south Side is the area of

0:09:19.916 --> 0:09:23.436
<v Speaker 1>Chicago where you're most likely to get shot, the ambulance

0:09:23.476 --> 0:09:25.676
<v Speaker 1>had to take you all the way across the city

0:09:26.076 --> 0:09:29.756
<v Speaker 1>uptown to Northwestern or Cook County or west to advocate

0:09:29.796 --> 0:09:34.476
<v Speaker 1>Christ Medical Center miles away. Now, why did the south

0:09:34.556 --> 0:09:37.756
<v Speaker 1>Side go so long without a trauma center? Because it

0:09:37.836 --> 0:09:40.596
<v Speaker 1>makes no sense for any hospital to open one on

0:09:40.636 --> 0:09:46.436
<v Speaker 1>the South Side. Treating gunshot wounds serious ones is incredibly expensive,

0:09:46.916 --> 0:09:49.756
<v Speaker 1>and the typical gunshot victim in Chicago is a young

0:09:49.756 --> 0:09:52.396
<v Speaker 1>black man from a poor neighborhood, and young black men

0:09:52.436 --> 0:09:55.876
<v Speaker 1>living in poor neighborhoods in Chicago typically don't have health

0:09:55.916 --> 0:10:00.036
<v Speaker 1>insurance or they're on Medicaid, which reimburses at a fraction

0:10:00.116 --> 0:10:04.316
<v Speaker 1>of what private insurance does. The euphemism used in the

0:10:04.316 --> 0:10:08.196
<v Speaker 1>healthcare world is payer mix, which refers to how many

0:10:08.196 --> 0:10:11.276
<v Speaker 1>of your patients come to you blessed with private coverage.

0:10:11.876 --> 0:10:15.316
<v Speaker 1>Opening a trauma center in a bad neighborhood messes with

0:10:15.396 --> 0:10:20.556
<v Speaker 1>your payer mix deeply, which is a paradox. Right. The

0:10:20.596 --> 0:10:23.396
<v Speaker 1>point of a trauma center is to be closest to

0:10:23.436 --> 0:10:25.996
<v Speaker 1>the places where people are getting shot. But if you

0:10:26.036 --> 0:10:28.996
<v Speaker 1>put your trauma center close to the places where people

0:10:29.036 --> 0:10:31.836
<v Speaker 1>get shot, your payer mix will go to hell in

0:10:31.876 --> 0:10:35.396
<v Speaker 1>a handbasket and you won't be able to afford to

0:10:35.476 --> 0:10:38.556
<v Speaker 1>run your trauma center. So you put your trauma center

0:10:39.196 --> 0:10:42.676
<v Speaker 1>as far away as possible from the people who most

0:10:42.756 --> 0:10:46.356
<v Speaker 1>need your trauma center. As I said at the very

0:10:46.356 --> 0:10:49.636
<v Speaker 1>beginning of this series, the way America deals with gun

0:10:49.716 --> 0:11:02.476
<v Speaker 1>violence is bonkers. You can hear this series starting August thirty,

0:11:02.476 --> 0:11:07.276
<v Speaker 1>first six episodes airing weekly with ads or ad free,

0:11:07.276 --> 0:11:11.076
<v Speaker 1>and all at once for Pushkin plusubscribers. Subscribe on Apple

0:11:11.116 --> 0:11:16.756
<v Speaker 1>Podcasts or at pushkin dot Fm, slash plus