WEBVTT - Comey Charged for Third Time & Anthropic IPO

0:00:02.759 --> 0:00:07.040
<v Speaker 1>This is Bloomberg Law with June Grosso from Bloomberg Radio.

0:00:08.869 --> 0:00:11.830
<v Speaker 2>They say the third time is a charm, and the

0:00:11.869 --> 0:00:17.210
<v Speaker 2>Trump administration is charging former FBI Director James Comey for

0:00:17.250 --> 0:00:20.669
<v Speaker 2>the third time in a little over a year. Federal

0:00:20.750 --> 0:00:25.700
<v Speaker 2>prosecutors charged Comey with leaking secret national defense information to

0:00:25.739 --> 0:00:29.340
<v Speaker 2>the media a decade ago when he was FBI Director.

0:00:29.700 --> 0:00:33.840
<v Speaker 2>Comey has denied the allegations and vowed to fight the charges.

0:00:34.300 --> 0:00:37.670
<v Speaker 3>Well, they're back again. It would almost be funny if

0:00:37.729 --> 0:00:40.550
<v Speaker 3>it weren't such an appalling abuse of the Department of Justice,

0:00:41.470 --> 0:00:45.210
<v Speaker 3>one that we cannot become numb to. Nothing's changed with me.

0:00:45.270 --> 0:00:47.709
<v Speaker 3>I'm still innocent. I'm still not afraid of these people.

0:00:47.790 --> 0:00:50.610
<v Speaker 3>And I still believe in the independent federal judiciary.

0:00:51.210 --> 0:00:56.230
<v Speaker 2>President Trump has repeatedly criticized Comey and continued to do

0:00:56.350 --> 0:00:58.650
<v Speaker 2>so when asked about the new charges.

0:00:59.370 --> 0:01:01.630
<v Speaker 4>Well, I think he's a dirty cop, James Comey, but

0:01:01.700 --> 0:01:02.790
<v Speaker 4>I know nothing about it.

0:01:02.950 --> 0:01:06.679
<v Speaker 2>He's a dirty cop. The charges were originally filed under

0:01:06.819 --> 0:01:10.140
<v Speaker 2>seal earlier this month, and the case has been playing

0:01:10.240 --> 0:01:13.860
<v Speaker 2>out in secret for weeks. Joining me is former federal

0:01:13.920 --> 0:01:18.110
<v Speaker 2>prosecutor Robert Mintz, a partner in McCarter and English. Bob,

0:01:18.140 --> 0:01:21.730
<v Speaker 2>what do we know about the charges against Comey this time?

0:01:22.390 --> 0:01:25.850
<v Speaker 4>Well, this is the third federal case that this Department

0:01:25.870 --> 0:01:30.209
<v Speaker 4>of Justice has brought against former FBI Director James Comey.

0:01:30.709 --> 0:01:33.670
<v Speaker 4>And in this case, what we know is that he

0:01:33.890 --> 0:01:39.179
<v Speaker 4>is being charged by criminal information with two counts, transmission

0:01:39.220 --> 0:01:44.680
<v Speaker 4>of national defense information and conspiracy to transmit national defense information.

0:01:44.920 --> 0:01:49.270
<v Speaker 4>The allegations are tied to a New York Times article

0:01:49.550 --> 0:01:52.790
<v Speaker 4>in October 2016 that related.

0:01:52.390 --> 0:01:55.030
<v Speaker 1>To a secret court order that required Yahoo!

0:01:55.700 --> 0:01:59.780
<v Speaker 4>to scan emails for messages potentially linked to a foreign

0:01:59.860 --> 0:02:01.080
<v Speaker 4>terrorist organization.

0:02:01.580 --> 0:02:04.640
<v Speaker 1>The story cited two government officials.

0:02:04.200 --> 0:02:07.640
<v Speaker 4>Who spoke on condition of anonymity about the order from

0:02:07.700 --> 0:02:11.690
<v Speaker 4>a judge on the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court, also known

0:02:11.750 --> 0:02:16.089
<v Speaker 4>as the FISA Court, that Yahoo was barred from publicly disclosing.

0:02:16.470 --> 0:02:21.570
<v Speaker 4>The allegation is, according to prosecutors, that James Comey directed

0:02:22.160 --> 0:02:26.679
<v Speaker 4>his then general counsel to the FBI, to disclose information

0:02:27.000 --> 0:02:31.020
<v Speaker 4>that was classified, part of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court's

0:02:31.360 --> 0:02:34.590
<v Speaker 4>information that was then not to be disclosed publicly in

0:02:34.650 --> 0:02:38.950
<v Speaker 4>order to correct information that he viewed as inaccurate so

0:02:38.970 --> 0:02:41.670
<v Speaker 4>that the New York Times could write a more accurate story.

0:02:42.550 --> 0:02:45.350
<v Speaker 2>Bob, is there any way that they could have given

0:02:45.389 --> 0:02:50.180
<v Speaker 2>the Times that information without disclosing classified information, or don't

0:02:50.190 --> 0:02:50.820
<v Speaker 2>we know that?

0:02:51.470 --> 0:02:52.489
<v Speaker 1>Well, we really don't know.

0:02:52.590 --> 0:02:56.450
<v Speaker 4>At this point, James Comey's defense team has simply denied

0:02:56.510 --> 0:03:00.770
<v Speaker 4>these allegations. And what we do know is that this

0:03:01.030 --> 0:03:05.980
<v Speaker 4>issue about this particular leak dating back to October 2016

0:03:05.980 --> 0:03:10.520
<v Speaker 4>has been investigated twice prior by the Trump Department of

0:03:10.580 --> 0:03:15.240
<v Speaker 4>Justice during the first Trump term. Then Special Counsel John

0:03:15.320 --> 0:03:21.000
<v Speaker 4>Durham began investigating this leak. dating back to October 5th, 2016,

0:03:21.000 --> 0:03:25.560
<v Speaker 4>involving the New York Times. He began that investigation in

0:03:25.560 --> 0:03:29.260
<v Speaker 4>2017 and ultimately ended up writing a classified memo. This

0:03:29.320 --> 0:03:32.970
<v Speaker 4>is according to Comey's defense lawyers that recommended no criminal

0:03:33.010 --> 0:03:36.870
<v Speaker 4>charges be brought against anybody in connection with that disclosure.

0:03:36.890 --> 0:03:40.350
<v Speaker 4>It's also been alleged that in January 2019, the U.S.

0:03:40.370 --> 0:03:43.790
<v Speaker 4>Attorney's Office for the District of Columbia opened a second

0:03:43.830 --> 0:03:48.490
<v Speaker 4>investigation into the same alleged improper leak and close that

0:03:48.550 --> 0:03:53.350
<v Speaker 4>investigation without any charges filed in February 2020. These are

0:03:53.560 --> 0:03:57.040
<v Speaker 4>all allegations that the Comey defense team are going to

0:03:57.220 --> 0:04:01.280
<v Speaker 4>use to try to argue that this prosecution is vindictive

0:04:01.320 --> 0:04:04.970
<v Speaker 4>prosecution and should not be allowed to be pursued by

0:04:04.990 --> 0:04:07.390
<v Speaker 4>the Department of Justice and should be dismissed by the court.

0:04:08.150 --> 0:04:11.090
<v Speaker 2>Prosecutors didn't go to a grand jury to get an

0:04:11.170 --> 0:04:16.570
<v Speaker 2>indictment here. They filed a criminal information. Explain what that is.

0:04:18.279 --> 0:04:22.740
<v Speaker 4>That's very important to understand here because all felony charges,

0:04:23.160 --> 0:04:27.049
<v Speaker 4>meaning any charge that carries a penalty of imprisonment of

0:04:27.190 --> 0:04:30.950
<v Speaker 4>more than one year, has to go before a grand jury.

0:04:31.550 --> 0:04:34.510
<v Speaker 4>The framers of the Constitution did not want to give

0:04:34.589 --> 0:04:39.250
<v Speaker 4>prosecutors the ability to bring criminal charges, serious criminal charges,

0:04:39.310 --> 0:04:41.390
<v Speaker 4>where someone can go to jail for more than a year.

0:04:41.710 --> 0:04:44.270
<v Speaker 4>And so they set up a system in the Constitution

0:04:44.310 --> 0:04:47.710
<v Speaker 4>that says the prosecutors have to bring this case These

0:04:47.810 --> 0:04:51.330
<v Speaker 4>allegations before a federal grand jury, which is a panel

0:04:51.650 --> 0:04:55.849
<v Speaker 4>of between 16 and 23 average citizens who are summoned

0:04:56.180 --> 0:04:58.960
<v Speaker 4>by the court to sit on grand jury duty to

0:04:59.080 --> 0:05:02.200
<v Speaker 4>hear these allegations and to make a determination as to

0:05:02.240 --> 0:05:04.940
<v Speaker 4>whether or not there's something known as probable cause, which

0:05:05.000 --> 0:05:08.960
<v Speaker 4>means enough evidence to at least allow the case to

0:05:09.020 --> 0:05:12.910
<v Speaker 4>move forward. And this right to have your case heard

0:05:12.970 --> 0:05:15.469
<v Speaker 4>before a grand jury is rooted in the Fifth Amendment.

0:05:15.770 --> 0:05:18.800
<v Speaker 4>So there is an absolute legal requirement that any felony

0:05:18.860 --> 0:05:21.740
<v Speaker 4>case go before a grand jury and be voted by

0:05:21.800 --> 0:05:25.080
<v Speaker 4>that grand jury before it can proceed. One exception to

0:05:25.120 --> 0:05:28.190
<v Speaker 4>that is what's called a criminal information. That is a

0:05:28.230 --> 0:05:32.910
<v Speaker 4>case in which prosecutors can directly charge a defendant with

0:05:32.950 --> 0:05:35.350
<v Speaker 4>a felony without going in front of a grand jury.

0:05:35.750 --> 0:05:37.940
<v Speaker 4>But in that case, there has to be an explicit

0:05:38.150 --> 0:05:41.179
<v Speaker 4>waiver of the right to proceed before a grand jury

0:05:41.500 --> 0:05:44.039
<v Speaker 4>by a defendant. And the circumstance that you see that

0:05:44.100 --> 0:05:48.040
<v Speaker 4>coming up often as a federal prosecutor is when prosecutors

0:05:48.080 --> 0:05:51.180
<v Speaker 4>have worked out a criminal plea with a defendant. In

0:05:51.220 --> 0:05:54.690
<v Speaker 4>other words, no indictment has yet been returned. And prosecutors

0:05:54.710 --> 0:05:58.770
<v Speaker 4>have been negotiating a possible plea resolution with the defendant.

0:05:58.990 --> 0:06:02.190
<v Speaker 4>They ultimately reach a deal and they want to proceed

0:06:02.250 --> 0:06:05.380
<v Speaker 4>with criminal charges. There is no real reason at that

0:06:05.440 --> 0:06:08.180
<v Speaker 4>point to go before a grand jury because that's set

0:06:08.240 --> 0:06:10.880
<v Speaker 4>up to protect the rights of the defendant. In the

0:06:10.920 --> 0:06:14.039
<v Speaker 4>case in which a defendant has already agreed to plead guilty,

0:06:14.060 --> 0:06:17.140
<v Speaker 4>they can go before the federal judge immediately. who will

0:06:17.300 --> 0:06:19.940
<v Speaker 4>ask them whether they're willing to give up their right

0:06:20.140 --> 0:06:22.540
<v Speaker 4>to have their case go before a grand jury.

0:06:22.640 --> 0:06:23.950
<v Speaker 1>It's explained to.

0:06:23.820 --> 0:06:26.370
<v Speaker 4>The defendant on the record that they have an absolute

0:06:26.400 --> 0:06:29.990
<v Speaker 4>constitutional right to have their case presented to a grand jury,

0:06:30.410 --> 0:06:33.550
<v Speaker 4>and that by pleading guilty to an information, they're waiving

0:06:33.589 --> 0:06:34.050
<v Speaker 4>that right.

0:06:34.130 --> 0:06:35.390
<v Speaker 1>And once they waive that.

0:06:35.310 --> 0:06:39.270
<v Speaker 4>Right, then the court will accept the criminal information as

0:06:39.310 --> 0:06:42.590
<v Speaker 4>a charging document and allow that case to proceed. But

0:06:42.710 --> 0:06:46.320
<v Speaker 4>critical to that analysis is that the defendant has to

0:06:46.460 --> 0:06:50.080
<v Speaker 4>waive the right to proceed before a grand jury. In

0:06:50.120 --> 0:06:53.880
<v Speaker 4>this case, there was no such waiver. James Comey did

0:06:53.960 --> 0:06:57.400
<v Speaker 4>not agree to proceed with any criminal charges by waiving

0:06:57.480 --> 0:07:00.370
<v Speaker 4>his right to have the case go before a grand jury.

0:07:00.640 --> 0:07:03.050
<v Speaker 4>And so what happened here is that there was a

0:07:03.050 --> 0:07:06.750
<v Speaker 4>10-year statute of limitations that was set to expire on

0:07:06.790 --> 0:07:11.210
<v Speaker 4>these charges, and prosecutors went into court and filed this

0:07:11.330 --> 0:07:15.730
<v Speaker 4>criminal information solely for the purpose of tolling.

0:07:15.270 --> 0:07:16.810
<v Speaker 1>That statute of limitations.

0:07:16.920 --> 0:07:19.300
<v Speaker 4>And the Comey defense team has argued that that was

0:07:19.330 --> 0:07:23.660
<v Speaker 4>an improper use of a criminal information that is being

0:07:23.720 --> 0:07:27.940
<v Speaker 4>done solely to circumvent the 10-year statute of limitations. And

0:07:27.980 --> 0:07:30.420
<v Speaker 4>they've asked the judge to throw out these charges on

0:07:30.460 --> 0:07:31.080
<v Speaker 4>that basis.

0:07:31.580 --> 0:07:35.490
<v Speaker 2>The Justice Department said in a statement, Filing a criminal

0:07:35.530 --> 0:07:39.130
<v Speaker 2>information to toll the statute of limitations is a widely

0:07:39.210 --> 0:07:43.040
<v Speaker 2>recognized practice in federal court and has been approved by

0:07:43.150 --> 0:07:46.960
<v Speaker 2>multiple circuit courts of appeals. Is that true?

0:07:48.200 --> 0:07:50.720
<v Speaker 4>Well, it's certainly not true that it is a widely

0:07:50.940 --> 0:07:54.100
<v Speaker 4>used practice because I was a federal prosecutor for 10

0:07:54.100 --> 0:07:58.610
<v Speaker 4>years and I've never heard of prosecutors going in seeking

0:07:58.910 --> 0:08:01.990
<v Speaker 4>charges based on information in order to toll the statute

0:08:02.010 --> 0:08:02.750
<v Speaker 4>of limitations.

0:08:03.260 --> 0:08:06.040
<v Speaker 1>It rarely occurs, but it's not improper to say that

0:08:06.080 --> 0:08:06.920
<v Speaker 1>it never occurs.

0:08:06.960 --> 0:08:10.080
<v Speaker 4>And in fact, there is a case that was brought

0:08:10.250 --> 0:08:13.590
<v Speaker 4>in 2025 before the court of appeals for the 11th circuit,

0:08:13.610 --> 0:08:17.250
<v Speaker 4>where this very issue was addressed by the court. In

0:08:17.290 --> 0:08:21.130
<v Speaker 4>that case, the defendants had been charged with using stolen

0:08:21.270 --> 0:08:26.040
<v Speaker 4>social security numbers to get government benefits. And under federal law,

0:08:26.100 --> 0:08:30.200
<v Speaker 4>those charges had a five-year statute of limitations. The issue

0:08:30.240 --> 0:08:34.429
<v Speaker 4>in that case is, is that during the COVID-19 pandemic,

0:08:35.070 --> 0:08:38.710
<v Speaker 4>the court system in South Florida suspended grand juries for

0:08:38.750 --> 0:08:41.980
<v Speaker 4>a period of time. And so prosecutors, in order to

0:08:42.050 --> 0:08:46.680
<v Speaker 4>avoid letting the statute of limitations expire, went in and

0:08:46.720 --> 0:08:50.459
<v Speaker 4>they brought the allegation by way of a criminal information,

0:08:50.820 --> 0:08:53.740
<v Speaker 4>and then they later went before the grand jury and

0:08:53.820 --> 0:08:56.820
<v Speaker 4>got the indictment. In that case, the defendants tried to

0:08:56.960 --> 0:08:59.940
<v Speaker 4>argue that it was too late to get that indictment,

0:09:00.320 --> 0:09:03.930
<v Speaker 4>that the criminal charges had already expired because the statute

0:09:03.950 --> 0:09:08.290
<v Speaker 4>of limitations expired, and that they couldn't essentially take that

0:09:08.429 --> 0:09:12.309
<v Speaker 4>criminal indictment and have it revert back to the criminal

0:09:12.350 --> 0:09:15.620
<v Speaker 4>information in order to save it from a statute of

0:09:15.700 --> 0:09:20.660
<v Speaker 4>limitations defense. The Court of Appeals there upheld the lower

0:09:20.740 --> 0:09:24.120
<v Speaker 4>court and said that it was proper to use the

0:09:24.179 --> 0:09:28.190
<v Speaker 4>information for purposes of tolling the statute of limitations, which

0:09:28.250 --> 0:09:31.400
<v Speaker 4>is what prosecutors are doing here, So it has rarely

0:09:31.460 --> 0:09:34.740
<v Speaker 4>been used. In that case, there was a unique circumstance

0:09:34.900 --> 0:09:38.900
<v Speaker 4>of the COVID-19 pandemic where there was no grand jury sitting.

0:09:39.160 --> 0:09:41.880
<v Speaker 4>So prosecutors really had no choice but to do it

0:09:41.900 --> 0:09:44.780
<v Speaker 4>in that case. This is a different circumstance where this

0:09:44.840 --> 0:09:47.380
<v Speaker 4>case has been out there for more than 10 years

0:09:47.610 --> 0:09:50.670
<v Speaker 4>and has been investigated twice. And no doubt Comey's lawyers

0:09:50.730 --> 0:09:53.870
<v Speaker 4>are going to argue that it is an improper use

0:09:54.530 --> 0:09:57.810
<v Speaker 4>of the criminal information process and is done solely to

0:09:57.929 --> 0:10:02.210
<v Speaker 4>circumvent a 10-year statute of limitations when prosecutors had plenty

0:10:02.230 --> 0:10:05.480
<v Speaker 4>of time to investigate this charge and should have brought

0:10:05.510 --> 0:10:07.650
<v Speaker 4>an indictment if they intended to proceed with the case.

0:10:08.650 --> 0:10:11.300
<v Speaker 2>I mean, after 10 years, if they still can't bring

0:10:11.320 --> 0:10:14.520
<v Speaker 2>a case before a grand jury, it sounds like they

0:10:14.559 --> 0:10:16.199
<v Speaker 2>don't have enough evidence then.

0:10:16.840 --> 0:10:19.740
<v Speaker 4>That's exactly the question here, because even if the court

0:10:20.179 --> 0:10:24.200
<v Speaker 4>allows this case to move forward based on the criminal information,

0:10:24.220 --> 0:10:26.840
<v Speaker 4>and the court has not yet ruled on that question,

0:10:27.520 --> 0:10:31.030
<v Speaker 4>there's no question that prosecutors still have to go before

0:10:31.050 --> 0:10:33.990
<v Speaker 4>a grand jury and get an indictment. In other words,

0:10:34.050 --> 0:10:37.449
<v Speaker 4>without a waiver of the grand jury indictment process, which

0:10:37.530 --> 0:10:41.220
<v Speaker 4>Comey's defense team is not going to give, prosecutors still

0:10:41.260 --> 0:10:43.319
<v Speaker 4>have to go in front of a grand jury and

0:10:43.740 --> 0:10:46.600
<v Speaker 4>even if the statute of limitations has been told by

0:10:46.620 --> 0:10:49.320
<v Speaker 4>the filing of the information, and they have to convince

0:10:49.679 --> 0:10:53.199
<v Speaker 4>at least 12 of those jurors that there's probable cause

0:10:53.559 --> 0:10:56.459
<v Speaker 4>that James Comey has committed this crime and that they

0:10:56.500 --> 0:10:57.969
<v Speaker 4>should allow this case to proceed.

0:10:58.450 --> 0:11:01.010
<v Speaker 2>The 10-year statute of limitations, they went down to the

0:11:01.070 --> 0:11:03.850
<v Speaker 2>very day, to the last day they could, right? Because

0:11:03.890 --> 0:11:05.910
<v Speaker 2>the article was on October 5th of 2016.

0:11:05.910 --> 0:11:09.630
<v Speaker 4>Yeah, there's no question that their back was against the wall.

0:11:10.240 --> 0:11:13.520
<v Speaker 4>and that this was essentially a last-ditch effort to try

0:11:13.559 --> 0:11:16.650
<v Speaker 4>to preserve this investigation. So it's going to be interesting

0:11:16.690 --> 0:11:20.210
<v Speaker 4>to see what the judge does with this motion, whether

0:11:20.250 --> 0:11:23.500
<v Speaker 4>he throws out the case or lets it proceed on

0:11:23.520 --> 0:11:26.800
<v Speaker 4>the assumption that prosecutors still have to go before a

0:11:26.840 --> 0:11:28.900
<v Speaker 4>grand jury and obtain an indictment.

0:11:29.220 --> 0:11:31.350
<v Speaker 1>And even then, the defense can.

0:11:31.270 --> 0:11:34.830
<v Speaker 4>Still argue by virtue of the 10 years that had

0:11:34.870 --> 0:11:37.070
<v Speaker 4>gone by, by virtue of the fact that this case

0:11:37.090 --> 0:11:40.990
<v Speaker 4>had been investigated twice before, that this was really a

0:11:41.309 --> 0:11:46.059
<v Speaker 4>vindictive prosecution, that it's not based on an effort to

0:11:46.120 --> 0:11:49.620
<v Speaker 4>obtain justice here, but it is something like a personal

0:11:49.700 --> 0:11:52.980
<v Speaker 4>political vendetta that is being brought against James Comey.

0:11:54.000 --> 0:11:58.590
<v Speaker 2>Speaking about vindictive prosecutions, this is the third time They've

0:11:58.690 --> 0:12:01.550
<v Speaker 2>charged Comey in just a little over a year.

0:12:02.370 --> 0:12:03.310
<v Speaker 1>Well, we'll have to see.

0:12:03.330 --> 0:12:08.480
<v Speaker 4>Vindictive prosecution is basically the concept of where prosecutors are

0:12:08.530 --> 0:12:12.620
<v Speaker 4>alleged to have retaliated against a defendant by increasing the

0:12:12.740 --> 0:12:16.940
<v Speaker 4>number or severity of criminal charges based solely on the

0:12:16.980 --> 0:12:22.300
<v Speaker 4>defendant's choosing to exercise a protected constitutional or statutory right.

0:12:22.640 --> 0:12:25.920
<v Speaker 4>In this case, the argument would presumably be that James

0:12:25.940 --> 0:12:29.520
<v Speaker 4>Comey was exercising his free speech rights. He has been

0:12:29.700 --> 0:12:33.540
<v Speaker 4>openly critical of President Trump. He was fired by President

0:12:33.580 --> 0:12:36.160
<v Speaker 4>Trump when he was FBI director, and they have been

0:12:36.220 --> 0:12:37.520
<v Speaker 4>waging a very.

0:12:37.470 --> 0:12:39.280
<v Speaker 1>Public battle ever since.

0:12:39.610 --> 0:12:42.870
<v Speaker 4>So there's no love lost between James Comey and President Trump,

0:12:43.290 --> 0:12:46.150
<v Speaker 4>and President Trump has gone so far as to attack

0:12:46.210 --> 0:12:50.050
<v Speaker 4>James Comey publicly and to suggest, or perhaps you could

0:12:50.090 --> 0:12:53.860
<v Speaker 4>argue even direct, his Department of Justice to prosecute him.

0:12:54.179 --> 0:12:57.400
<v Speaker 4>So we will certainly see an argument that this is

0:12:57.470 --> 0:13:02.069
<v Speaker 4>a vindictive prosecution, that it's unconstitutional, a violation of Mr.

0:13:02.130 --> 0:13:06.270
<v Speaker 4>Comey's 5th and 14th Amendment rights to due process. And

0:13:06.309 --> 0:13:09.930
<v Speaker 4>they will likely trot out the fact that not only

0:13:09.990 --> 0:13:13.110
<v Speaker 4>has this case been investigated twice before, but Mr. Comey

0:13:13.130 --> 0:13:16.100
<v Speaker 4>has been charged twice before by this Department of Justice.

0:13:16.390 --> 0:13:18.360
<v Speaker 4>As you noted, there was a case brought in North

0:13:18.420 --> 0:13:22.310
<v Speaker 4>Carolina that is still pending. where Comey was indicted for

0:13:22.390 --> 0:13:25.890
<v Speaker 4>allegations that a photograph he took and posted on social

0:13:25.929 --> 0:13:28.990
<v Speaker 4>media in 2025 constituted.

0:13:28.340 --> 0:13:30.280
<v Speaker 1>A threat against the president's life.

0:13:30.540 --> 0:13:33.059
<v Speaker 4>In that case, the Comey defense has asked the judge

0:13:33.160 --> 0:13:36.000
<v Speaker 4>overseeing the case to dismiss the charges as improper.

0:13:36.280 --> 0:13:38.280
<v Speaker 1>The judge has not yet ruled on that case.

0:13:38.679 --> 0:13:41.870
<v Speaker 4>There was a second prosecution brought in the Eastern District

0:13:41.929 --> 0:13:45.530
<v Speaker 4>of Virginia, where Comey was charged with two counts alleging

0:13:45.550 --> 0:13:49.870
<v Speaker 4>that he lied to Congress during 2020 testimony about whether

0:13:50.290 --> 0:13:54.010
<v Speaker 4>James Comey ever authorized leaks to the media. That case

0:13:54.050 --> 0:13:57.050
<v Speaker 4>was ultimately tossed out by a federal judge after the

0:13:57.090 --> 0:14:01.030
<v Speaker 4>judge concluded that the prosecutor overseeing the case had been

0:14:01.050 --> 0:14:05.990
<v Speaker 4>illegally appointed. So there's a long history here between James

0:14:06.050 --> 0:14:09.690
<v Speaker 4>Comey and President Trump and the Department of Justice, both

0:14:09.750 --> 0:14:13.929
<v Speaker 4>in terms of prior prosecutions and prior investigations of these

0:14:13.990 --> 0:14:15.150
<v Speaker 4>very allegations.

0:14:15.510 --> 0:14:17.489
<v Speaker 1>And it's ultimately going to be up to the judge.

0:14:17.270 --> 0:14:20.450
<v Speaker 4>To decide whether this is a proper prosecution that should

0:14:20.490 --> 0:14:21.870
<v Speaker 4>be allowed to proceed to trial.

0:14:22.870 --> 0:14:26.860
<v Speaker 2>And the Justice Department isn't giving up on those Virginia charges.

0:14:27.160 --> 0:14:31.260
<v Speaker 2>They've appealed the dismissal. Now, as far as the latest case,

0:14:32.000 --> 0:14:34.580
<v Speaker 2>the prosecutors and the defense attorneys have been arguing over

0:14:34.640 --> 0:14:38.210
<v Speaker 2>this in secret. There are papers under seal. Why do

0:14:38.250 --> 0:14:40.590
<v Speaker 2>you think they were doing it in secret? Usually this

0:14:40.650 --> 0:14:42.630
<v Speaker 2>Justice Department would come out and say, we're charging him

0:14:42.670 --> 0:14:43.050
<v Speaker 2>with this.

0:14:43.930 --> 0:14:46.410
<v Speaker 4>Yeah, but that's a great question. It's unclear at this

0:14:46.510 --> 0:14:51.180
<v Speaker 4>point why this charge was ultimately filed under seal by

0:14:51.260 --> 0:14:56.900
<v Speaker 4>federal prosecutors. But ultimately, Comey's lawyers decided that they wanted

0:14:56.960 --> 0:15:00.700
<v Speaker 4>it unsealed. It's usually kind of the reverse where prosecutors

0:15:00.760 --> 0:15:04.590
<v Speaker 4>want a case unsealed and charges unsealed and a defendant

0:15:04.690 --> 0:15:07.870
<v Speaker 4>might prefer to have the information that they've been charged

0:15:07.890 --> 0:15:12.370
<v Speaker 4>with a crime not publicly known. Here, Comey's lawyers specifically

0:15:12.430 --> 0:15:14.650
<v Speaker 4>requested the judge to unseal these.

0:15:14.590 --> 0:15:16.980
<v Speaker 1>Allegations, and the court ruled in their favor.

0:15:17.030 --> 0:15:20.900
<v Speaker 4>The court said criminal charges against a former FBI director

0:15:21.320 --> 0:15:25.160
<v Speaker 4>for his conduct while in office are of significant public interest,

0:15:25.560 --> 0:15:26.320
<v Speaker 4>and he ordered that.

0:15:26.750 --> 0:15:29.230
<v Speaker 1>These allegations be unsealed.

0:15:28.790 --> 0:15:32.900
<v Speaker 4>And so all this burst into the public view and

0:15:32.980 --> 0:15:36.920
<v Speaker 4>now there's this huge debate over whether what the government

0:15:36.980 --> 0:15:40.680
<v Speaker 4>did here is proper in trying to avoid a statute

0:15:40.700 --> 0:15:44.450
<v Speaker 4>of limitations defense to this and there's also a question

0:15:44.550 --> 0:15:48.170
<v Speaker 4>as to what these charges will ultimately look like when

0:15:48.230 --> 0:15:51.750
<v Speaker 4>prosecutors presumably present it to a grand jury at some

0:15:51.790 --> 0:15:52.510
<v Speaker 4>point in the future.

0:15:53.290 --> 0:15:56.850
<v Speaker 2>And that will be before a federal grand jury in D.C.,

0:15:57.010 --> 0:15:58.010
<v Speaker 2>where the D.C.

0:15:58.150 --> 0:15:58.410
<v Speaker 3>U.S.

0:15:58.500 --> 0:16:01.180
<v Speaker 2>Attorney's Office has not always fared well.

0:16:01.780 --> 0:16:05.760
<v Speaker 4>Assuming the court allows this case to proceed based upon

0:16:06.040 --> 0:16:09.380
<v Speaker 4>the criminal information, prosecutors will still have to bring this

0:16:09.420 --> 0:16:12.770
<v Speaker 4>case before a federal grand jury. in order to obtain

0:16:12.810 --> 0:16:16.330
<v Speaker 4>an indictment. And in this case, the prosecution will have

0:16:16.530 --> 0:16:16.890
<v Speaker 4>to go.

0:16:16.870 --> 0:16:18.490
<v Speaker 1>Forward in the District of Columbia.

0:16:18.970 --> 0:16:22.270
<v Speaker 4>Grand juries in the District of Columbia have shown a

0:16:22.510 --> 0:16:27.140
<v Speaker 4>propensity for independence where they have recently refused to bring

0:16:27.160 --> 0:16:30.560
<v Speaker 4>an indictment in cases presented by the U.S. Attorney's Office

0:16:30.840 --> 0:16:33.120
<v Speaker 4>in the District of Columbia. So it's going to be

0:16:33.220 --> 0:16:37.040
<v Speaker 4>interesting to see not only what charges prosecutors are going

0:16:37.090 --> 0:16:40.250
<v Speaker 4>to present before the grand jury, but will those grand

0:16:40.270 --> 0:16:44.170
<v Speaker 4>jurors in fact vote in favor of this indictment and

0:16:44.210 --> 0:16:45.410
<v Speaker 4>allow the case to proceed.

0:16:45.830 --> 0:16:49.410
<v Speaker 2>Maybe a fear of D.C. grand juries is why the

0:16:49.450 --> 0:16:53.790
<v Speaker 2>prosecutors brought this by criminal information. Before that, though, there'll

0:16:53.830 --> 0:16:57.050
<v Speaker 2>have to be a finding by the federal judge about

0:16:57.070 --> 0:17:00.860
<v Speaker 2>whether prosecutors can proceed with the charges. Thanks so much

0:17:00.910 --> 0:17:04.400
<v Speaker 2>as always, Bob. That's Robert Mintz of McCarter &amp; English.

0:17:05.760 --> 0:17:10.540
<v Speaker 2>Anthropic has filed for its long-awaited IPO. a landmark moment

0:17:10.580 --> 0:17:15.500
<v Speaker 2>in the artificial intelligence industry hungry for cash to power ahead.

0:17:15.840 --> 0:17:19.179
<v Speaker 2>The company behind Claude expects to begin trading on the

0:17:19.240 --> 0:17:24.270
<v Speaker 2>Nasdaq global select market under the symbol ANT, according to

0:17:24.330 --> 0:17:28.270
<v Speaker 2>a filing with the SEC on Monday. The filing moves

0:17:28.369 --> 0:17:32.150
<v Speaker 2>Anthropic a step closer to being the first company focused

0:17:32.270 --> 0:17:37.060
<v Speaker 2>primarily on developing the most advanced AI models to go public.

0:17:37.660 --> 0:17:40.639
<v Speaker 2>Joining me is Dorothy Lund, a professor at Columbia Law

0:17:40.680 --> 0:17:45.260
<v Speaker 2>School with an expertise in corporate law and governance. Dorothy,

0:17:45.320 --> 0:17:50.070
<v Speaker 2>tell us a little about the IPO, Anthropic IPO.

0:17:50.640 --> 0:17:53.350
<v Speaker 5>So Anthropic has been operating for a while as a

0:17:53.390 --> 0:17:57.369
<v Speaker 5>private company, which means that its shares don't trade on

0:17:57.609 --> 0:18:00.189
<v Speaker 5>a public market. You can't go and buy them on

0:18:00.270 --> 0:18:03.790
<v Speaker 5>a stock exchange. But it's been a very, very valuable

0:18:03.869 --> 0:18:07.080
<v Speaker 5>private company with a lot of people participating. who've been

0:18:07.100 --> 0:18:11.379
<v Speaker 5>excited to invest. And so when Anthropic goes public, it

0:18:11.400 --> 0:18:14.340
<v Speaker 5>will mean that individuals like you and me can go

0:18:14.359 --> 0:18:17.200
<v Speaker 5>out and buy a share of Anthropic stock. And more likely,

0:18:17.220 --> 0:18:21.659
<v Speaker 5>our retirement plans will now include shares of Anthropic stock.

0:18:22.030 --> 0:18:25.869
<v Speaker 2>Is there anything unusual about Anthropic's IPO?

0:18:27.109 --> 0:18:30.450
<v Speaker 5>I think there's a few things that make this really unusual.

0:18:30.930 --> 0:18:31.109
<v Speaker 4>And I.

0:18:35.000 --> 0:18:38.420
<v Speaker 5>You know, typically with a public company, the default rule

0:18:38.460 --> 0:18:42.369
<v Speaker 5>is that every shareholder gets a vote. And sometimes companies

0:18:42.380 --> 0:18:45.590
<v Speaker 5>will depart from that default by giving, you know, certain

0:18:45.910 --> 0:18:50.070
<v Speaker 5>shareholders more say. So, you know, think about like Meta, right?

0:18:50.130 --> 0:18:52.970
<v Speaker 5>So in Meta, you have Mark Zuckerberg, who holds a

0:18:53.010 --> 0:18:55.669
<v Speaker 5>small fraction of the equity, but has voting control as

0:18:55.730 --> 0:18:58.609
<v Speaker 5>a result of having these special Class B shares with

0:18:58.609 --> 0:19:01.250
<v Speaker 5>10 votes per share. So this is a way of saying, well,

0:19:01.270 --> 0:19:04.430
<v Speaker 5>we've got some visionary person but we think should have

0:19:04.550 --> 0:19:06.609
<v Speaker 5>say over what's going on with this company over the

0:19:06.650 --> 0:19:10.830
<v Speaker 5>long term. And so here with Anthropix IPO, public investors

0:19:10.869 --> 0:19:13.910
<v Speaker 5>are going to end up owning most of the outstanding equity,

0:19:14.410 --> 0:19:17.360
<v Speaker 5>but they're going to have none of the control. And

0:19:17.380 --> 0:19:20.000
<v Speaker 5>the thing that makes this unique is that they're not

0:19:20.060 --> 0:19:23.659
<v Speaker 5>doing this in the typical sort of Mark Zuckerberg meta way.

0:19:24.260 --> 0:19:27.630
<v Speaker 5>They are splitting the control of the board between two

0:19:27.730 --> 0:19:32.700
<v Speaker 5>groups of shareholders that basically have no economic stake. So

0:19:32.840 --> 0:19:35.399
<v Speaker 5>one is this long-term benefit trust that's going to be

0:19:35.440 --> 0:19:40.260
<v Speaker 5>composed of outside experts. And by design, these experts are

0:19:40.300 --> 0:19:43.990
<v Speaker 5>given zero equity stake in the company. And then you

0:19:44.070 --> 0:19:48.690
<v Speaker 5>also have this LLC that's controlled by these seven founders,

0:19:49.190 --> 0:19:52.120
<v Speaker 5>and each of them get some board seats that they

0:19:52.140 --> 0:19:55.320
<v Speaker 5>get to elect. You know, again, this is very different

0:19:55.359 --> 0:19:58.220
<v Speaker 5>than having control with a single individual who has a

0:19:58.290 --> 0:20:00.770
<v Speaker 5>big equity stake, but not enough to get you over

0:20:00.810 --> 0:20:04.030
<v Speaker 5>that 50% hurdle. And so we're kind of building a

0:20:04.070 --> 0:20:06.550
<v Speaker 5>coalition of people who don't really have a very large

0:20:06.630 --> 0:20:08.169
<v Speaker 5>equity stake at all in the company.

0:20:08.940 --> 0:20:12.959
<v Speaker 2>Are there any disadvantages to that structure? Any dangers?

0:20:13.780 --> 0:20:18.179
<v Speaker 5>Well, so one danger is you might worry. One of

0:20:18.200 --> 0:20:21.530
<v Speaker 5>the things that's nice about not having a controlling shareholder

0:20:21.570 --> 0:20:24.070
<v Speaker 5>in a company is that over time, if things change,

0:20:24.770 --> 0:20:27.790
<v Speaker 5>outside investors can use their governance rights and kind of

0:20:27.830 --> 0:20:30.209
<v Speaker 5>sword rattle. They can wage proxy fights. They can do

0:20:30.350 --> 0:20:35.580
<v Speaker 5>all sorts of things that make the company redirect. So here... Basically,

0:20:35.640 --> 0:20:39.139
<v Speaker 5>Anthropic is saying trust that these seven people and the

0:20:39.180 --> 0:20:44.520
<v Speaker 5>founder LLC checked by this long-term benefits trust, they're going

0:20:44.560 --> 0:20:47.800
<v Speaker 5>to make the right decisions into the future. And that

0:20:47.900 --> 0:20:51.359
<v Speaker 5>there's not going to be any need for some outsider

0:20:51.400 --> 0:20:53.320
<v Speaker 5>to come in and check what they're doing. In fact,

0:20:53.600 --> 0:20:56.720
<v Speaker 5>having an outsider come in and weigh in or try

0:20:56.740 --> 0:20:59.500
<v Speaker 5>to redirect their vision is actually going to be harmful

0:20:59.540 --> 0:21:02.800
<v Speaker 5>for our goals. And so, you know, a risk you

0:21:02.840 --> 0:21:04.419
<v Speaker 5>might have is like, well, what if they don't have

0:21:04.440 --> 0:21:07.330
<v Speaker 5>the right ideas, right? What if this coalition, you know,

0:21:07.380 --> 0:21:11.990
<v Speaker 5>doesn't actually make the right choices? You know, there won't

0:21:12.030 --> 0:21:15.310
<v Speaker 5>be a lot of ways for investors to redirect the ship.

0:21:15.710 --> 0:21:18.950
<v Speaker 5>There's also, I think, sort of, it's an interesting governance

0:21:18.970 --> 0:21:21.490
<v Speaker 5>structure that is sort of a version of this was

0:21:21.750 --> 0:21:24.929
<v Speaker 5>used in the private company and also in OpenAI where

0:21:25.530 --> 0:21:27.770
<v Speaker 5>But I worry a little bit about, you know, you

0:21:27.790 --> 0:21:31.359
<v Speaker 5>have this long-term benefit trust that controls a majority of

0:21:31.390 --> 0:21:34.960
<v Speaker 5>the board seats. You've got the founder LLC that controls

0:21:35.000 --> 0:21:38.500
<v Speaker 5>the other three seats. What happens if they start to

0:21:38.540 --> 0:21:41.840
<v Speaker 5>disagree with each other about what the right path forward is, right?

0:21:42.040 --> 0:21:45.380
<v Speaker 5>And we saw something like this happen with OpenAI, right?

0:21:45.420 --> 0:21:50.040
<v Speaker 5>We had the trust that basically the directors who populated

0:21:50.080 --> 0:21:53.620
<v Speaker 5>the foundation decided to fire Sam Altman, right? They didn't

0:21:53.640 --> 0:21:56.090
<v Speaker 5>think it was a good idea. to have Sam Altman

0:21:56.119 --> 0:21:59.390
<v Speaker 5>at the helm, the people on the ground really disagreed

0:21:59.430 --> 0:22:02.130
<v Speaker 5>with that, right? And so you had this clash between

0:22:02.490 --> 0:22:06.690
<v Speaker 5>the trust and the founders. And, you know, could there

0:22:06.730 --> 0:22:10.210
<v Speaker 5>be similar power struggles going forward? I mean, there's room

0:22:10.290 --> 0:22:13.390
<v Speaker 5>for dealing with disagreement here. But, you know, again, these

0:22:13.430 --> 0:22:16.369
<v Speaker 5>are the two power brokers in this governance structure and

0:22:16.430 --> 0:22:17.790
<v Speaker 5>conflict can emerge.

0:22:18.390 --> 0:22:23.450
<v Speaker 2>The prospectus has flagged various risks to humanity. Extensive, it

0:22:23.490 --> 0:22:26.760
<v Speaker 2>runs for more than 90 pages, so it highlights the

0:22:26.859 --> 0:22:31.780
<v Speaker 2>existential risk that could be posed by its AI, including

0:22:31.880 --> 0:22:37.070
<v Speaker 2>attempts to resist shutdown and conceal or manipulate information, to

0:22:37.109 --> 0:22:41.830
<v Speaker 2>behave in unintended, misaligned, or autonomous ways. I mean, how

0:22:41.930 --> 0:22:44.940
<v Speaker 2>unusual is it to see something like that in a prospectus?

0:22:45.859 --> 0:22:47.740
<v Speaker 5>Yeah, I mean, there are so many things about this

0:22:47.800 --> 0:22:51.639
<v Speaker 5>company in this moment that are quite singular. Although I

0:22:51.700 --> 0:22:54.400
<v Speaker 5>will say, you know, in the SpaceX IPO, right, there

0:22:54.420 --> 0:22:57.980
<v Speaker 5>were a lot of highfalutin statements about the potential of

0:22:58.020 --> 0:23:01.040
<v Speaker 5>this technology to, you know, sort of take over the

0:23:01.080 --> 0:23:04.420
<v Speaker 5>whole market. And so I think we are in this

0:23:04.520 --> 0:23:09.590
<v Speaker 5>moment of these mega tech IPOs. People have high expectations

0:23:09.609 --> 0:23:12.080
<v Speaker 5>for them and the founders, of course, have ever reason

0:23:12.119 --> 0:23:16.540
<v Speaker 5>to want to convince you that there's incredible transformative potential

0:23:16.560 --> 0:23:18.920
<v Speaker 5>of the technology. Of course, you know, a big difference

0:23:18.960 --> 0:23:23.409
<v Speaker 5>between SpaceX and Anthropic is SpaceX wasn't going around and saying, well,

0:23:23.430 --> 0:23:25.850
<v Speaker 5>there's a chance that, you know, we'll all be extinct

0:23:25.910 --> 0:23:27.850
<v Speaker 5>in five years as a result of what we're doing.

0:23:27.910 --> 0:23:30.510
<v Speaker 5>And so that, I think, again, is quite singular.

0:23:31.170 --> 0:23:36.400
<v Speaker 2>What has Anthropic said about safety commitments once it's publicly traded?

0:23:37.140 --> 0:23:38.400
<v Speaker 2>And can we believe them?

0:23:38.720 --> 0:23:41.929
<v Speaker 5>This safety concern that takes up so much space in

0:23:41.950 --> 0:23:44.810
<v Speaker 5>this prospectus actually is also in the DNA of the

0:23:44.850 --> 0:23:47.230
<v Speaker 5>governance structure as well. And we talked about the way

0:23:47.270 --> 0:23:52.970
<v Speaker 5>that control of the board is basically split between this trust, right?

0:23:52.990 --> 0:23:58.480
<v Speaker 5>This nonprofit and these founders. And also another interesting aspect

0:23:58.520 --> 0:24:00.240
<v Speaker 5>of this that we haven't talked about is that the

0:24:00.280 --> 0:24:04.100
<v Speaker 5>company is actually incorporated as a public benefit corporation, which

0:24:04.320 --> 0:24:07.649
<v Speaker 5>gives the people who run the company the charge of

0:24:07.780 --> 0:24:13.920
<v Speaker 5>balancing shareholder and interest alongside the public interest mission. And here,

0:24:13.960 --> 0:24:16.960
<v Speaker 5>so if you're running Anthropic, you are duty bound to

0:24:17.020 --> 0:24:21.200
<v Speaker 5>not just think about your shareholders, but to develop AI

0:24:21.260 --> 0:24:24.530
<v Speaker 5>for the long-term benefit of humanity. So that's sort of

0:24:24.570 --> 0:24:28.429
<v Speaker 5>this other added wrinkle here. Again, if we wanted to

0:24:28.450 --> 0:24:30.670
<v Speaker 5>be a little cynical here, we could say, well, there's

0:24:30.710 --> 0:24:32.869
<v Speaker 5>probably a good reason to think that people have different

0:24:32.930 --> 0:24:35.860
<v Speaker 5>ideas about how to do this. And And we hope

0:24:35.880 --> 0:24:38.180
<v Speaker 5>they have the right ideas. You know, we're putting a

0:24:38.240 --> 0:24:41.010
<v Speaker 5>lot of trust in these seven people combined with, you know,

0:24:41.030 --> 0:24:44.570
<v Speaker 5>the people that run the trust to really chart this

0:24:44.630 --> 0:24:47.590
<v Speaker 5>path forward. And there's nothing about the governance that says

0:24:47.650 --> 0:24:50.729
<v Speaker 5>if they get it wrong, there's an easy way to redirect.

0:24:51.170 --> 0:24:53.090
<v Speaker 5>But at least, you know, you've got this sort of

0:24:53.650 --> 0:24:57.840
<v Speaker 5>protection from shareholder suits saying, you know, you made a

0:24:58.460 --> 0:25:00.980
<v Speaker 5>choice that was not profitable. You know, you slowed things

0:25:01.020 --> 0:25:03.600
<v Speaker 5>down and the stock price is suffering as a result.

0:25:04.510 --> 0:25:08.080
<v Speaker 5>at least the board will be insulated from those types

0:25:08.119 --> 0:25:11.600
<v Speaker 5>of challenges. It's an interesting thing. There are now about

0:25:11.600 --> 0:25:17.460
<v Speaker 5>20 public benefit corporations that have gone public, and most

0:25:17.500 --> 0:25:21.290
<v Speaker 5>of the ones that have gone public and stayed PBCs

0:25:22.070 --> 0:25:25.670
<v Speaker 5>are ones that implement some sort of protection from outside shareholders,

0:25:25.710 --> 0:25:29.590
<v Speaker 5>like a dual-class structure. That's, again, another benefit of this

0:25:29.630 --> 0:25:32.760
<v Speaker 5>installation is I think so long as they're able to

0:25:33.060 --> 0:25:36.550
<v Speaker 5>raise the money they need with this structure, they should

0:25:36.609 --> 0:25:40.710
<v Speaker 5>be able to prioritize safety. Although, you know, again, competitive pressure,

0:25:40.770 --> 0:25:45.250
<v Speaker 5>capital needs, all sorts of things can erode safety commitments

0:25:45.330 --> 0:25:45.850
<v Speaker 5>over time.

0:25:46.369 --> 0:25:48.840
<v Speaker 2>Stay with me, Dorothy. Coming up next on the Bloomberg

0:25:48.900 --> 0:25:52.560
<v Speaker 2>Law Show, I'll continue this conversation with Columbia Law School

0:25:52.600 --> 0:25:58.420
<v Speaker 2>Professor Dorothy Lund. What about government intervention or even control?

0:25:59.130 --> 0:26:02.360
<v Speaker 2>I'm June Grosso, and you're listening to Bloomberg. I've been

0:26:02.380 --> 0:26:07.100
<v Speaker 2>talking to Columbia Law School professor Dorothy Lund about Anthropic's

0:26:07.320 --> 0:26:10.379
<v Speaker 2>upcoming IPO. I mean, do you think that there is

0:26:10.440 --> 0:26:17.260
<v Speaker 2>a high possibility of government interference or control in the future?

0:26:17.300 --> 0:26:20.520
<v Speaker 2>I'm not saying the Trump administration, but let's say Democratic

0:26:20.580 --> 0:26:22.700
<v Speaker 2>administrations going forward.

0:26:23.359 --> 0:26:26.679
<v Speaker 5>Yeah, I absolutely do. You know, I think they themselves

0:26:26.740 --> 0:26:29.430
<v Speaker 5>have said, things to this degree that, you know, there's

0:26:29.470 --> 0:26:33.300
<v Speaker 5>a real risk of government regulation and even all the

0:26:33.340 --> 0:26:36.680
<v Speaker 5>way to nationalization. I mean, if this ends up being

0:26:36.940 --> 0:26:41.440
<v Speaker 5>as powerful as everyone expects it to be rivaling, you know,

0:26:41.500 --> 0:26:44.979
<v Speaker 5>governments and what, what this technology can do, you know,

0:26:45.100 --> 0:26:46.899
<v Speaker 5>every government is going to want to have an interest

0:26:46.980 --> 0:26:50.550
<v Speaker 5>in and having some way to, to control it. I

0:26:50.980 --> 0:26:54.840
<v Speaker 5>know regulation at this moment in time is, has not been, um,

0:26:55.320 --> 0:26:58.260
<v Speaker 5>a priority of the Trump administration. And, you know, you've

0:26:58.280 --> 0:27:01.020
<v Speaker 5>got a lot of these AI leaders saying we can

0:27:01.060 --> 0:27:03.280
<v Speaker 5>regulate ourselves and it'll be interesting. One of the other

0:27:03.340 --> 0:27:06.100
<v Speaker 5>interesting aspects of this being a public company, it's not

0:27:06.119 --> 0:27:07.979
<v Speaker 5>just that you and I can invest, but it's that

0:27:08.359 --> 0:27:09.900
<v Speaker 5>now they're going to have to show us a lot

0:27:09.960 --> 0:27:12.489
<v Speaker 5>more about what they're doing. And I think we'll get

0:27:12.570 --> 0:27:16.670
<v Speaker 5>some sense of like, Oh yeah, how exactly are you regulating?

0:27:16.730 --> 0:27:19.250
<v Speaker 5>How are you slowing things down? What steps are you taking? Um,

0:27:19.670 --> 0:27:21.490
<v Speaker 5>because this is all going to have to be disclosed.

0:27:21.550 --> 0:27:21.790
<v Speaker 2>Right.

0:27:21.810 --> 0:27:24.710
<v Speaker 5>Um, So I think that's actually a benefit of these

0:27:25.070 --> 0:27:31.119
<v Speaker 5>companies going public. But assuming self-regulation isn't up to the

0:27:31.160 --> 0:27:34.480
<v Speaker 5>task or assuming we get a new administration that's more

0:27:35.000 --> 0:27:41.940
<v Speaker 5>interested in regulating this technology, I think we will see regulation.

0:27:42.020 --> 0:27:44.780
<v Speaker 5>And again, I wouldn't be surprised if at some point

0:27:44.800 --> 0:27:49.200
<v Speaker 5>in the future we see nationalization or attempts at nationalization.

0:27:49.240 --> 0:27:53.590
<v Speaker 5>If you look back to other really impactful technologies in

0:27:53.670 --> 0:27:57.830
<v Speaker 5>human history. Think about like the Manhattan Project, right? We

0:27:57.850 --> 0:28:01.730
<v Speaker 5>didn't have private companies developing these technologies, right? These were

0:28:01.830 --> 0:28:06.879
<v Speaker 5>all done under the overhead of government authority. And so

0:28:07.359 --> 0:28:10.900
<v Speaker 5>to the extent that we are talking about really powerful technology,

0:28:10.920 --> 0:28:13.580
<v Speaker 5>I wouldn't be shocked to see us move in that direction.

0:28:14.200 --> 0:28:16.740
<v Speaker 2>There will be a lot of investors looking to get

0:28:16.840 --> 0:28:19.770
<v Speaker 2>in on this once the IPO is out. What risks

0:28:19.810 --> 0:28:21.149
<v Speaker 2>do investors face?

0:28:21.740 --> 0:28:24.290
<v Speaker 5>You know, there are some obvious business risks, like if

0:28:24.330 --> 0:28:26.870
<v Speaker 5>human extinction is happening in the next five years, right,

0:28:26.890 --> 0:28:28.830
<v Speaker 5>that's not going to be great for your stock portfolio,

0:28:28.850 --> 0:28:31.590
<v Speaker 5>your anthropic investment. And, you know, again, in this in

0:28:31.609 --> 0:28:34.990
<v Speaker 5>this sort of cutthroat race to AGI, if it's a

0:28:35.030 --> 0:28:37.450
<v Speaker 5>winner take all thing, you know, anthropic might in a

0:28:37.490 --> 0:28:40.310
<v Speaker 5>few years might end up not being very valuable at all.

0:28:40.990 --> 0:28:44.550
<v Speaker 5>So there are business risks, right? There's also the risks

0:28:44.590 --> 0:28:47.370
<v Speaker 5>that we talked about, about Do we think that this

0:28:47.430 --> 0:28:51.270
<v Speaker 5>coalition that has been baked into, you know, the only

0:28:51.310 --> 0:28:53.710
<v Speaker 5>people that can influence the direction of this company, do

0:28:53.730 --> 0:28:56.570
<v Speaker 5>we think they have the right ideas? Will they focus

0:28:56.610 --> 0:28:59.330
<v Speaker 5>too much on safety and not profitability or they focus

0:28:59.350 --> 0:29:02.100
<v Speaker 5>too little on safety and, you know, run into all

0:29:02.140 --> 0:29:05.400
<v Speaker 5>sorts of trouble there? And there's also, I think, again,

0:29:05.540 --> 0:29:10.420
<v Speaker 5>this issue of potential disagreements, right? Like, you know, sure,

0:29:10.520 --> 0:29:14.090
<v Speaker 5>everybody's friends now, but it's rare to see many people

0:29:14.800 --> 0:29:18.240
<v Speaker 5>people and companies that, you know, seven people all agree,

0:29:18.300 --> 0:29:22.080
<v Speaker 5>you know, that the best way to advance our mission

0:29:22.180 --> 0:29:24.500
<v Speaker 5>is to do X. Well, no, I think the best

0:29:24.540 --> 0:29:26.350
<v Speaker 5>way to do it is to do Y, right? And

0:29:26.370 --> 0:29:29.670
<v Speaker 5>then meanwhile, you've got the board with their own ideas, right?

0:29:29.950 --> 0:29:32.930
<v Speaker 5>And so, again, I kind of worry about how that

0:29:32.970 --> 0:29:36.950
<v Speaker 5>would look over time. And the empirical literature also studying

0:29:36.970 --> 0:29:40.920
<v Speaker 5>dual class shares often shows that everything is good early

0:29:41.140 --> 0:29:43.940
<v Speaker 5>on and then things start to go a little south.

0:29:44.580 --> 0:29:50.670
<v Speaker 5>But it's hard to pre-specify your leader forever, right? And

0:29:50.690 --> 0:29:52.770
<v Speaker 5>that one of the benefits of not having a dual

0:29:52.790 --> 0:29:55.610
<v Speaker 5>class structure is that if somebody stops having the right

0:29:55.650 --> 0:29:57.250
<v Speaker 5>ideas for the company, you can get rid of them

0:29:57.270 --> 0:29:59.370
<v Speaker 5>and you can bring somebody else in. So here, You're

0:29:59.410 --> 0:30:02.310
<v Speaker 5>locking in this power structure. You're locking in, you know,

0:30:02.330 --> 0:30:05.690
<v Speaker 5>these seven people's views and hoping that everybody gets along,

0:30:05.710 --> 0:30:06.970
<v Speaker 5>which could present some risks.

0:30:07.630 --> 0:30:12.320
<v Speaker 2>Let me give you a hypothetical. So suppose Anthropic delays

0:30:12.340 --> 0:30:15.720
<v Speaker 2>a major model for safety reasons. The stock price drops

0:30:15.820 --> 0:30:18.660
<v Speaker 2>like 20%. Can shareholders sue?

0:30:19.020 --> 0:30:21.580
<v Speaker 5>This is one of the key advantages of that public

0:30:21.620 --> 0:30:25.860
<v Speaker 5>benefit corporation structure. it's going to largely prevent those suits.

0:30:26.320 --> 0:30:29.520
<v Speaker 5>And instead, you know, a plaintiff would not be able

0:30:29.540 --> 0:30:33.620
<v Speaker 5>to just say, oh, you're not focusing on my profits

0:30:33.700 --> 0:30:37.050
<v Speaker 5>and you're choosing to benefit your mission at the expense

0:30:37.450 --> 0:30:40.370
<v Speaker 5>of profits. Instead, they'd have to look for some conflict

0:30:40.410 --> 0:30:44.610
<v Speaker 5>of interest or some grossly negligent process to challenge the decision.

0:30:44.630 --> 0:30:48.310
<v Speaker 5>I actually think, though, that the more likely shareholder suit

0:30:48.360 --> 0:30:52.640
<v Speaker 5>would happen in the other direction, which is, like, imagine...

0:30:52.770 --> 0:30:58.390
<v Speaker 5>Anthropics board fails to take safety into consideration for some

0:30:58.430 --> 0:31:02.890
<v Speaker 5>big decision. And it has huge economic repercussions. It leads

0:31:02.930 --> 0:31:06.540
<v Speaker 5>to regulation. It leads to fines and all sorts of

0:31:06.640 --> 0:31:11.100
<v Speaker 5>negative consequences from the company flow from that. A board

0:31:11.140 --> 0:31:14.060
<v Speaker 5>of directors has something called an oversight duty, a care

0:31:14.100 --> 0:31:16.840
<v Speaker 5>mark duty, where they're supposed to be looking out for

0:31:16.880 --> 0:31:20.240
<v Speaker 5>these really big risks. So there, I think if the

0:31:20.280 --> 0:31:24.140
<v Speaker 5>company really fails or the board really fails to take

0:31:24.260 --> 0:31:28.120
<v Speaker 5>safety into consideration for some key decision that creates problems

0:31:28.140 --> 0:31:30.540
<v Speaker 5>for the company, shareholders might be able to actually sue

0:31:30.640 --> 0:31:34.360
<v Speaker 5>and recover damages from the board for that decision, for

0:31:34.400 --> 0:31:36.180
<v Speaker 5>the negative harm that came from that.

0:31:36.570 --> 0:31:39.010
<v Speaker 2>I take it they're doing the IPO route because it's

0:31:39.070 --> 0:31:41.490
<v Speaker 2>going to be an advantage to them, you know, the

0:31:41.550 --> 0:31:46.710
<v Speaker 2>infusion of money. How will that affect their competition with other,

0:31:46.830 --> 0:31:47.950
<v Speaker 2>like OpenAI companies?

0:31:49.360 --> 0:31:53.790
<v Speaker 5>Yeah, so I'm sure OpenAI is watching this IPO to

0:31:53.910 --> 0:31:56.350
<v Speaker 5>see what happens. And if this is a smash success

0:31:56.390 --> 0:32:01.550
<v Speaker 5>for Anthropic, I imagine they're going to follow suit relatively soon. Because,

0:32:01.590 --> 0:32:05.780
<v Speaker 5>you know, as you said, the road to AGI is expensive, right?

0:32:05.800 --> 0:32:09.200
<v Speaker 5>We need a lot of money for AI infrastructure in

0:32:09.580 --> 0:32:13.720
<v Speaker 5>order to, you know, survive in this competitive race. You know,

0:32:13.800 --> 0:32:17.070
<v Speaker 5>so I think absolutely other, you know, frontier labs are

0:32:17.090 --> 0:32:20.840
<v Speaker 5>going to be paying attention here. I also think, again,

0:32:20.880 --> 0:32:24.060
<v Speaker 5>this sort of idea of disclosure, you know, now that

0:32:24.560 --> 0:32:28.010
<v Speaker 5>Anthropic's going to have to show everything and OpenAI won't, right?

0:32:28.030 --> 0:32:30.030
<v Speaker 5>They're going to have to show their revenue, their margins,

0:32:30.070 --> 0:32:34.170
<v Speaker 5>their compute commitments, their customer concentration. All of this is

0:32:34.190 --> 0:32:36.910
<v Speaker 5>going to be available for other people to see. And

0:32:37.090 --> 0:32:40.090
<v Speaker 5>in terms of, you know, what that means for the competition,

0:32:40.110 --> 0:32:43.910
<v Speaker 5>you know, OpenAI will see how well Anthropic is doing.

0:32:44.820 --> 0:32:47.020
<v Speaker 5>But at the same time, I think Anthropic is also

0:32:47.060 --> 0:32:49.880
<v Speaker 5>going to be, in being the first mover here, they're

0:32:49.900 --> 0:32:51.660
<v Speaker 5>going to be able to set sort of the template

0:32:51.760 --> 0:32:55.560
<v Speaker 5>for restraint. Like, how are we slowing things down, right?

0:32:55.860 --> 0:32:58.980
<v Speaker 5>And they'll disclose that, they'll show that, and maybe others

0:32:59.000 --> 0:33:01.200
<v Speaker 5>will follow the lead. You know, there is a risk

0:33:01.220 --> 0:33:03.440
<v Speaker 5>here too, which is like, if you start to show

0:33:03.890 --> 0:33:07.570
<v Speaker 5>the world, okay, this is how exactly we're slowing things down,

0:33:07.610 --> 0:33:10.330
<v Speaker 5>and this is the cost that it has. And if

0:33:10.350 --> 0:33:13.240
<v Speaker 5>your investors start to become very unhappy about Well, that's

0:33:13.380 --> 0:33:16.460
<v Speaker 5>also going to send a message, right? How costly is restraint?

0:33:16.840 --> 0:33:20.870
<v Speaker 5>And that could affect other competitors' choices. But at the

0:33:20.930 --> 0:33:22.770
<v Speaker 5>end of the day, I think the thing that makes

0:33:22.790 --> 0:33:26.570
<v Speaker 5>me really happy about this IPO is we are putting

0:33:26.690 --> 0:33:29.430
<v Speaker 5>so much faith in these companies. And as you mentioned,

0:33:29.750 --> 0:33:32.940
<v Speaker 5>they're not going to be regulated anytime soon. Instead, we're

0:33:32.960 --> 0:33:36.280
<v Speaker 5>putting a lot of faith in their ability to regulate themselves,

0:33:36.340 --> 0:33:40.090
<v Speaker 5>to slow things down, to act safely. And so the

0:33:40.130 --> 0:33:43.210
<v Speaker 5>more we see about what they're doing, I think that's

0:33:43.390 --> 0:33:46.580
<v Speaker 5>quite good, right, for the public to know exactly. And

0:33:46.600 --> 0:33:49.000
<v Speaker 5>so I think there is a public good that's coming

0:33:49.040 --> 0:33:49.840
<v Speaker 5>from this IPO.

0:33:50.380 --> 0:33:53.330
<v Speaker 2>Well, that would be nice to see. Thanks so much, Dorothy.

0:33:53.850 --> 0:33:57.710
<v Speaker 2>That's Professor Dorothy Lund of Columbia Law School. And that's

0:33:57.790 --> 0:34:00.350
<v Speaker 2>it for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Show. Remember,

0:34:00.370 --> 0:34:02.550
<v Speaker 2>you can always get the latest legal news on our

0:34:02.590 --> 0:34:06.830
<v Speaker 2>Bloomberg Law Podcast. You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,

0:34:06.910 --> 0:34:12.920
<v Speaker 2>and at www.bloomberg.com slash podcast slash law. And remember to

0:34:12.960 --> 0:34:16.380
<v Speaker 2>tune into the Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight at 10 p.m.

0:34:16.420 --> 0:34:20.460
<v Speaker 2>Wall Street time. I'm June Grosso, and you're listening to Bloomberg.