WEBVTT - What Nvidia's Megaspeed Scandal Is Really All About

0:00:02.750 --> 0:00:05.590
<v Speaker 1>Bloomberg Audio Studios. Podcasts.

0:00:05.890 --> 0:00:07.270
<v Speaker 2>Radio. News.

0:00:09.369 --> 0:00:22.100
<v Speaker 3>Hello and welcome to another episode of the Odd Lot Podcast.

0:00:22.239 --> 0:00:23.340
<v Speaker 4>I'm Joe Wiesenthal.

0:00:23.579 --> 0:00:24.480
<v Speaker 2>And I'm Traci Alloway.

0:00:25.350 --> 0:00:28.030
<v Speaker 3>Tracy, I got to say, this Jensen Wong story, I

0:00:28.850 --> 0:00:30.290
<v Speaker 3>think it's one of the biggest stories ever.

0:00:30.530 --> 0:00:30.910
<v Speaker 2>Yeah.

0:00:30.950 --> 0:00:34.440
<v Speaker 3>Just as a news story, it's about as big as

0:00:34.479 --> 0:00:35.360
<v Speaker 3>it could possibly get.

0:00:35.580 --> 0:00:37.200
<v Speaker 4>It has everything. It has everything.

0:00:37.360 --> 0:00:42.840
<v Speaker 5>Alleged Chinese spies, chip smuggling. It's exciting stuff. Also, it's

0:00:42.940 --> 0:00:46.960
<v Speaker 5>birthed like 5,000 memes, some of which are quite good.

0:00:47.280 --> 0:00:48.560
<v Speaker 4>I've definitely seen some good memes.

0:00:48.580 --> 0:00:50.959
<v Speaker 5>But actually, so on a serious note, if you think

0:00:51.020 --> 0:00:54.540
<v Speaker 5>about the AI trade, I mean, the sun around which

0:00:54.620 --> 0:00:58.300
<v Speaker 5>it all revolves is NVIDIA, both in terms of like

0:00:58.450 --> 0:01:00.790
<v Speaker 5>providing the actual chips that powers a lot of this

0:01:00.850 --> 0:01:04.209
<v Speaker 5>technology and also providing a lot of the financing and

0:01:04.270 --> 0:01:07.690
<v Speaker 5>investments for these companies. Yeah. And so any hint of

0:01:07.750 --> 0:01:11.590
<v Speaker 5>a scandal has big implications for AI as a whole.

0:01:12.110 --> 0:01:13.970
<v Speaker 3>No, I really like the way you put that, that

0:01:14.190 --> 0:01:17.419
<v Speaker 3>they are the son of the universe. Both from it,

0:01:17.510 --> 0:01:21.110
<v Speaker 3>they have the crown jewel technology, the chips. They have

0:01:21.160 --> 0:01:25.560
<v Speaker 3>the financing to back all kinds of partners and neoclouds

0:01:25.620 --> 0:01:26.920
<v Speaker 3>and everything all around the world.

0:01:27.120 --> 0:01:28.029
<v Speaker 4>Everyone wants it.

0:01:28.520 --> 0:01:33.580
<v Speaker 3>And it is a technology that is both commercially intensely

0:01:33.700 --> 0:01:36.690
<v Speaker 3>in demand and geopolitically in demand. And so in addition

0:01:36.730 --> 0:01:38.149
<v Speaker 3>to the fact that the tech is good and they

0:01:38.170 --> 0:01:41.570
<v Speaker 3>have the financing, there are all these fights about who

0:01:41.590 --> 0:01:44.009
<v Speaker 3>they could even sell it to starting, you know, there

0:01:44.030 --> 0:01:46.330
<v Speaker 3>are all these things of the Biden administration, lobbying of

0:01:46.350 --> 0:01:49.810
<v Speaker 3>the Trump administration, how liberal should the policies be about

0:01:50.140 --> 0:01:52.740
<v Speaker 3>who gets to buy them, et cetera. That is why

0:01:52.820 --> 0:01:57.060
<v Speaker 3>this story is just like, so it's huge.

0:01:57.400 --> 0:01:57.680
<v Speaker 2>Yeah.

0:01:57.800 --> 0:02:00.980
<v Speaker 5>And just on the geopolitical, atomic's a good word. On

0:02:01.000 --> 0:02:04.080
<v Speaker 5>the geopolitical angle itself, I mean, there's this tension that

0:02:04.140 --> 0:02:07.120
<v Speaker 5>we've seen more and more in recent years where some

0:02:07.180 --> 0:02:10.270
<v Speaker 5>people will argue that, well, you want the U.S., you

0:02:10.310 --> 0:02:14.070
<v Speaker 5>want a company like NVIDIA to be the backbone of

0:02:14.190 --> 0:02:17.260
<v Speaker 5>like the AI tech stack, right? And so maybe you

0:02:17.300 --> 0:02:19.040
<v Speaker 5>want lots of people using their chips.

0:02:19.060 --> 0:02:19.420
<v Speaker 4>Totally, totally.

0:02:19.639 --> 0:02:22.120
<v Speaker 5>But on the other hand, you know, you have people

0:02:22.180 --> 0:02:24.800
<v Speaker 5>in the Trump administration who argue that we are in

0:02:25.060 --> 0:02:28.940
<v Speaker 5>this existential AI race with China, and therefore it's really

0:02:29.000 --> 0:02:32.210
<v Speaker 5>important that China does not have access to the most

0:02:32.370 --> 0:02:35.570
<v Speaker 5>advanced chips. And so we're seeing that sort of play

0:02:35.710 --> 0:02:37.490
<v Speaker 5>out in a lot of the discussion on what's going

0:02:37.530 --> 0:02:38.470
<v Speaker 5>on with NVIDIA right now.

0:02:39.020 --> 0:02:41.860
<v Speaker 3>The other thing that's very important, and this will allow

0:02:41.919 --> 0:02:45.100
<v Speaker 3>us to get into the guest, is that in some sense,

0:02:46.200 --> 0:02:48.880
<v Speaker 3>there's actually, like, the story's kind of old news, right?

0:02:48.900 --> 0:02:53.400
<v Speaker 3>There's been a lot of reporting on this company, Megaspeed,

0:02:55.139 --> 0:02:58.239
<v Speaker 3>and its CEO, and the company's closeness to NVIDIA and

0:02:58.280 --> 0:03:02.139
<v Speaker 3>Jensen specifically, and where they know. So, like, in a way, like,

0:03:02.500 --> 0:03:04.820
<v Speaker 3>what is the new news here is part of the question,

0:03:04.860 --> 0:03:07.760
<v Speaker 3>but whatever, you know. I guess on some level, the

0:03:07.800 --> 0:03:13.359
<v Speaker 3>new news... is just specifically Jensen Wong admitting to NVIDIA

0:03:13.380 --> 0:03:18.359
<v Speaker 3>that he had this relationship, an affair, with this executive

0:03:18.440 --> 0:03:23.430
<v Speaker 3>or someone associated with Megaspeed and the investigation into it. Anyway,

0:03:23.450 --> 0:03:26.590
<v Speaker 3>without further ado, we really do have the perfect guest,

0:03:26.910 --> 0:03:28.829
<v Speaker 3>someone who I think is like the best beat in

0:03:28.870 --> 0:03:32.070
<v Speaker 3>the world. Whenever we get a chance to chat, I'm

0:03:32.190 --> 0:03:35.760
<v Speaker 3>always learning more about both the sort of like politics,

0:03:35.900 --> 0:03:40.290
<v Speaker 3>geopolitics of chip flows and, around the world, someone who's

0:03:40.350 --> 0:03:43.310
<v Speaker 3>reported on chips all around the world, from D.C. to

0:03:43.330 --> 0:03:45.770
<v Speaker 3>San Francisco, and now based in Hong Kong. We're going

0:03:45.790 --> 0:03:48.130
<v Speaker 3>to be speaking with tech reporter here at Bloomberg News,

0:03:48.550 --> 0:03:51.900
<v Speaker 3>Mackenzie Hawkins. So, Mackenzie, thank you so much for coming

0:03:51.960 --> 0:03:52.500
<v Speaker 3>on Odd Lots.

0:03:53.680 --> 0:03:55.320
<v Speaker 2>Thank you so much for having me. Quite a week.

0:03:55.640 --> 0:03:58.440
<v Speaker 5>Staying up late and coming on Odd Lots, because you're

0:03:58.460 --> 0:03:59.860
<v Speaker 5>based in Hong Kong, so thank you.

0:04:00.000 --> 0:04:01.440
<v Speaker 3>And you were just in the U.S., so you're probably

0:04:01.460 --> 0:04:03.480
<v Speaker 3>still kind of jet-lagged.

0:04:03.600 --> 0:04:07.030
<v Speaker 2>You know, I'm actually, like, This week I've gone back

0:04:07.050 --> 0:04:09.340
<v Speaker 2>to working U.S. hours, so I feel like I never

0:04:09.380 --> 0:04:11.280
<v Speaker 2>left the U.S. I finally got over the jet lag

0:04:11.340 --> 0:04:12.720
<v Speaker 2>and Jensen Wong is jet lagging me.

0:04:12.800 --> 0:04:15.460
<v Speaker 3>I can't believe how fried you must be. So again,

0:04:15.500 --> 0:04:17.660
<v Speaker 3>thank you for taking the time. Let me start with

0:04:17.700 --> 0:04:22.400
<v Speaker 3>this question. You know, reporters always think they know a

0:04:22.400 --> 0:04:24.220
<v Speaker 3>little bit more than what they can write at any

0:04:24.260 --> 0:04:26.039
<v Speaker 3>given moment, etc.

0:04:26.640 --> 0:04:28.440
<v Speaker 4>Because, you know, you're waiting for verification.

0:04:28.760 --> 0:04:31.480
<v Speaker 1>Let's say we were talking a week ago.

0:04:32.010 --> 0:04:34.900
<v Speaker 3>And so based on only what you're allowed to report,

0:04:34.920 --> 0:04:37.720
<v Speaker 3>let's say this conversation is happening sometime in October and

0:04:37.740 --> 0:04:40.919
<v Speaker 3>we say, Mackenzie, what's the deal with this company Megaspeed?

0:04:41.700 --> 0:04:43.799
<v Speaker 3>What was the answer you gave me a week ago?

0:04:44.260 --> 0:04:48.060
<v Speaker 3>Just that you're totally able, who is Megaspeed? And why

0:04:48.110 --> 0:04:50.110
<v Speaker 3>should we care about this company called Megaspeed?

0:04:51.490 --> 0:04:56.450
<v Speaker 2>So pre-affair admission, Megaspeed is the single largest Southeast Asian

0:04:56.470 --> 0:04:59.290
<v Speaker 2>buyer of NVIDIA chips. It's a major supplier of AI

0:04:59.310 --> 0:05:02.419
<v Speaker 2>compute to Alibaba. which is one of the most important

0:05:02.490 --> 0:05:06.610
<v Speaker 2>tech companies and frontier AI leaders in China. It purchased

0:05:06.610 --> 0:05:11.250
<v Speaker 2>$ 4. 6 billion worth of NVIDIA hardware after being spun off

0:05:11.350 --> 0:05:14.740
<v Speaker 2>from a Chinese gaming company, passing through a BVI shell,

0:05:15.339 --> 0:05:18.580
<v Speaker 2>and incorporating in Singapore, then becoming an official NVIDIA partner

0:05:18.640 --> 0:05:24.020
<v Speaker 2>four days later. Its executive had a close relationship with Jensen.

0:05:24.400 --> 0:05:27.330
<v Speaker 2>We didn't know quite how close. And it had been

0:05:27.430 --> 0:05:31.599
<v Speaker 2>under U.S. investigation and Singapore investigation for, if we're talking

0:05:31.620 --> 0:05:33.480
<v Speaker 2>a week ago, at least a year.

0:05:34.960 --> 0:05:38.640
<v Speaker 5>So why did this raise eyebrows in the first place?

0:05:38.720 --> 0:05:43.430
<v Speaker 5>So Megaspeed renting out GPU capacity to a company like Alibaba.

0:05:43.520 --> 0:05:47.210
<v Speaker 5>My understanding is like, OK, that's allowed. People know that

0:05:47.250 --> 0:05:50.010
<v Speaker 5>this is happening. But at the same time, if you're

0:05:50.050 --> 0:05:55.060
<v Speaker 5>worried about Chinese companies having access to technologically advanced NVIDIA chips,

0:05:55.140 --> 0:05:56.440
<v Speaker 5>it seems like a pretty big loophole.

0:05:57.900 --> 0:06:01.350
<v Speaker 2>Yeah. So, I mean, the arrangement that Megaspeed has with

0:06:01.390 --> 0:06:06.510
<v Speaker 2>Alibaba is extraordinarily common across the Southeast Asian data center ecosystem.

0:06:06.770 --> 0:06:09.190
<v Speaker 2>You know, in some ways, the backbone of Chinese compute

0:06:09.339 --> 0:06:14.000
<v Speaker 2>is like Johor, Malaysia. So it's not actually the remote

0:06:14.060 --> 0:06:17.660
<v Speaker 2>access cloud computing arrangement that got Megaspeed sort of looked

0:06:17.700 --> 0:06:19.859
<v Speaker 2>at by the U.S. government, later by the Singapore government.

0:06:20.400 --> 0:06:23.359
<v Speaker 2>It's the suspicion that the company has not just rented

0:06:23.420 --> 0:06:27.940
<v Speaker 2>compute to Chinese offtakers, but actually diverted those, like the

0:06:28.020 --> 0:06:32.290
<v Speaker 2>physical hardware into mainland China. Right. So that's the focus

0:06:32.310 --> 0:06:34.650
<v Speaker 2>of the U.S. investigation. It was looking at whether Megaspeed

0:06:34.670 --> 0:06:37.350
<v Speaker 2>had smuggled chips, which the company has categorically denied having

0:06:37.390 --> 0:06:40.989
<v Speaker 2>ever done. And also looking into its ownership structure, because

0:06:41.190 --> 0:06:44.150
<v Speaker 2>even if Megaspeed is a Singaporean entity, if it were

0:06:44.370 --> 0:06:46.950
<v Speaker 2>owned by a Chinese company, it would also be illegal

0:06:46.970 --> 0:06:50.010
<v Speaker 2>to sell advanced NVIDIA chips to Megaspeed without a U.S. license.

0:06:50.430 --> 0:06:52.650
<v Speaker 2>It is 100 percent Singapore owned, but by a shell.

0:06:53.470 --> 0:06:57.410
<v Speaker 3>Let's get into like there is this question of, you know,

0:06:57.510 --> 0:07:01.530
<v Speaker 3>what do chip restrictions even mean if you could still

0:07:01.570 --> 0:07:04.710
<v Speaker 3>just access a cloud in a different country? And like,

0:07:04.990 --> 0:07:08.150
<v Speaker 3>is this the mother of all loopholes? But let's actually

0:07:08.170 --> 0:07:12.900
<v Speaker 3>just start on the smuggling question. Why might investigators have

0:07:12.940 --> 0:07:18.460
<v Speaker 3>been concerned that Megaspeed was literally smuggling chips or not? Like,

0:07:18.860 --> 0:07:21.880
<v Speaker 3>what are the details that we know around this question?

0:07:21.940 --> 0:07:25.520
<v Speaker 3>The actual, the physical movement of chips from, say, a

0:07:25.560 --> 0:07:29.400
<v Speaker 3>delivery address in Johor, Malaysia to an address inside of

0:07:29.720 --> 0:07:30.200
<v Speaker 3>mainland China.

0:07:30.920 --> 0:07:31.200
<v Speaker 4>Yeah.

0:07:31.300 --> 0:07:34.120
<v Speaker 2>So, I mean, the U.S. government has a handful of

0:07:34.140 --> 0:07:38.440
<v Speaker 2>export control officers overseas, including in Southeast Asia. And when

0:07:38.460 --> 0:07:40.000
<v Speaker 2>I say a handful, it's really a handful. It's like

0:07:40.040 --> 0:07:42.160
<v Speaker 2>a dozen. They're going to more than double the number

0:07:42.230 --> 0:07:44.370
<v Speaker 2>this year to 25. For context, you know, when we

0:07:44.380 --> 0:07:47.970
<v Speaker 2>did our investigation into Megaspeed last year, I think I

0:07:48.010 --> 0:07:51.630
<v Speaker 2>was on singular email chains that had like 50 Bloomberg people.

0:07:51.650 --> 0:07:54.290
<v Speaker 2>So the capacity of the U.S.

0:07:54.330 --> 0:07:55.010
<v Speaker 1>Government.

0:07:55.050 --> 0:07:55.700
<v Speaker 4>Hold up, hold up.

0:07:56.590 --> 0:07:57.830
<v Speaker 5>Probably says more about Bloomberg.

0:07:57.890 --> 0:08:01.280
<v Speaker 3>All of us in this room have been on email

0:08:01.340 --> 0:08:05.060
<v Speaker 3>change with 50 Bloomberg people. A little inside baseball here,

0:08:05.100 --> 0:08:06.380
<v Speaker 3>but this is a real phenomenon.

0:08:06.400 --> 0:08:07.080
<v Speaker 4>All right, keep going.

0:08:08.020 --> 0:08:11.050
<v Speaker 2>But no, in all seriousness, the U.S. government has fairly

0:08:11.130 --> 0:08:16.510
<v Speaker 2>limited enforcement capacity overseas, but they do checks. And there's

0:08:16.630 --> 0:08:19.230
<v Speaker 2>unfortunately not a ton that I can say about the

0:08:19.560 --> 0:08:22.690
<v Speaker 2>initial trigger for the probe into mega speed. But through

0:08:22.710 --> 0:08:25.810
<v Speaker 2>the course of looking at shipments through Southeast Asia, they

0:08:26.240 --> 0:08:28.420
<v Speaker 2>thought that this company was worth digging into more. I

0:08:28.640 --> 0:08:30.520
<v Speaker 2>can talk a little about why I started looking into

0:08:30.540 --> 0:08:31.420
<v Speaker 2>Max Speed. Sure, go for it.

0:08:31.440 --> 0:08:32.080
<v Speaker 5>If that would be helpful.

0:08:32.140 --> 0:08:37.000
<v Speaker 2>Yeah. So in April or May of last year, I

0:08:37.000 --> 0:08:39.179
<v Speaker 2>had sort of recently arrived in Hong Kong and I

0:08:39.200 --> 0:08:41.970
<v Speaker 2>was working with a couple of colleagues here and in

0:08:42.010 --> 0:08:46.290
<v Speaker 2>the mainland on a story about this cluster of data

0:08:46.309 --> 0:08:49.230
<v Speaker 2>center operators in China's western deserts that had issued reports

0:08:49.620 --> 0:08:53.830
<v Speaker 2>procurement orders and local government tender notices that they had

0:08:53.870 --> 0:08:58.290
<v Speaker 2>fulfilled to build data centers seeking 115,000 restricted NVIDIA chips.

0:08:58.750 --> 0:09:02.210
<v Speaker 2>This was, you know, in order of magnitude larger than

0:09:02.290 --> 0:09:05.130
<v Speaker 2>what anybody thought might be in China. And so a

0:09:05.150 --> 0:09:08.350
<v Speaker 2>big question that we were trying to probe is, you know,

0:09:09.170 --> 0:09:11.870
<v Speaker 2>it's one thing for them to be constructing buildings. You know,

0:09:11.929 --> 0:09:14.590
<v Speaker 2>Chinese companies love to construct shells. I mean, I mean

0:09:14.610 --> 0:09:16.890
<v Speaker 2>that physically in this sense, but obviously that is the

0:09:16.910 --> 0:09:19.590
<v Speaker 2>case for shell companies as well. But it's one thing

0:09:19.610 --> 0:09:21.109
<v Speaker 2>to build the buildings. It's another thing to put the

0:09:21.130 --> 0:09:23.110
<v Speaker 2>chips inside. And so one of the big questions that

0:09:23.130 --> 0:09:24.770
<v Speaker 2>we were trying to tease out that we weren't able

0:09:24.790 --> 0:09:28.610
<v Speaker 2>to answer in that investigation was whether these particular operators

0:09:29.050 --> 0:09:32.480
<v Speaker 2>had the supply chain, the black market supply chain necessary

0:09:32.510 --> 0:09:35.719
<v Speaker 2>to get the GPUs. And when I was asking around

0:09:36.100 --> 0:09:39.319
<v Speaker 2>in Southeast Asia supply chains, everyone just kept saying, look

0:09:39.340 --> 0:09:42.640
<v Speaker 2>at this company called Megaspeed. And so we started looking

0:09:42.720 --> 0:09:45.459
<v Speaker 2>at them a year and a half ago, maybe a

0:09:45.480 --> 0:09:47.780
<v Speaker 2>bit over a year and a half ago. and found out,

0:09:48.020 --> 0:09:51.300
<v Speaker 2>you know, several months actually into our own investigation that

0:09:51.330 --> 0:09:53.270
<v Speaker 2>the U.S. government had been looking into them as well.

0:09:53.730 --> 0:09:57.530
<v Speaker 2>The U.S. investigation remains ongoing in a sort of complicated way,

0:09:57.590 --> 0:10:00.100
<v Speaker 2>which we can get into a bit later. In our reporting,

0:10:00.140 --> 0:10:03.059
<v Speaker 2>we didn't find concrete evidence that Megaspeed had smuggled any

0:10:03.080 --> 0:10:07.600
<v Speaker 2>GPUs to China. We found an extraordinary number of inconsistencies

0:10:07.740 --> 0:10:10.580
<v Speaker 2>in their data center footprint that neither the company nor

0:10:10.660 --> 0:10:11.860
<v Speaker 2>NVIDIA have been able to explain.

0:10:12.480 --> 0:10:15.059
<v Speaker 5>I want to ask about those inconsistencies, but before we do,

0:10:15.320 --> 0:10:19.290
<v Speaker 5>can you just describe how chip smuggling typically works? Like,

0:10:19.470 --> 0:10:22.010
<v Speaker 5>how do people in the black market actually do this?

0:10:23.460 --> 0:10:27.580
<v Speaker 2>Yeah, so, you know, we have enough examples of, you know,

0:10:27.620 --> 0:10:30.860
<v Speaker 2>public allegations, things that are being actively prosecuted to sort

0:10:30.900 --> 0:10:35.020
<v Speaker 2>of draw some thematic conclusions. There is a secondary market

0:10:35.200 --> 0:10:38.860
<v Speaker 2>for NVIDIA hardware, but, you know, most NVIDIA chips get

0:10:38.900 --> 0:10:43.340
<v Speaker 2>to customers via official allocation from NVIDIA. And NVIDIA doesn't

0:10:43.380 --> 0:10:45.929
<v Speaker 2>sell chips directly to the end user, like they wouldn't

0:10:45.970 --> 0:10:48.690
<v Speaker 2>be selling hardware directly to Megaspeed or directly to CoreWeave

0:10:48.710 --> 0:10:53.839
<v Speaker 2>or whoever. They sell to OEMs, original equipped manufacturers, server

0:10:53.860 --> 0:10:57.760
<v Speaker 2>makers like Supermicro or Dell or HP. Those server makers

0:10:57.800 --> 0:11:00.800
<v Speaker 2>typically sell to distributors. Those distributors might sell to another distributor.

0:11:01.160 --> 0:11:02.750
<v Speaker 2>then they go into a data center, and then they're

0:11:02.790 --> 0:11:05.750
<v Speaker 2>often rented to another company. So it's this extremely vast

0:11:05.809 --> 0:11:09.690
<v Speaker 2>distribution network for NVIDIA chips. But ultimately, in order to

0:11:09.790 --> 0:11:13.390
<v Speaker 2>place an order and get your order approved by NVIDIA,

0:11:13.530 --> 0:11:15.929
<v Speaker 2>you need to say, like, this is where they're going. Like,

0:11:16.010 --> 0:11:18.390
<v Speaker 2>this is the customer, this is the data center location.

0:11:19.010 --> 0:11:22.110
<v Speaker 2>And a consistent theme across, you know, what's now like

0:11:22.150 --> 0:11:24.670
<v Speaker 2>half a dozen cases being prosecuted, and this is certainly

0:11:24.720 --> 0:11:29.340
<v Speaker 2>the case in the indictment of Supermicro's co-founder earlier this year,

0:11:30.130 --> 0:11:32.800
<v Speaker 2>The stated location of where the chips are going to

0:11:32.820 --> 0:11:35.220
<v Speaker 2>wind up was not the intended location. You know, it's

0:11:35.260 --> 0:11:37.540
<v Speaker 2>not that there was some sort of rogue person at

0:11:38.260 --> 0:11:40.520
<v Speaker 2>one node in the supply chain that was like, yeah,

0:11:40.540 --> 0:11:43.400
<v Speaker 2>I'm just going to grab them. You have companies or

0:11:43.460 --> 0:11:47.490
<v Speaker 2>individual actors that place orders that are purportedly for a

0:11:47.530 --> 0:11:50.370
<v Speaker 2>destination outside of China with the intent of diverting that

0:11:50.390 --> 0:11:53.069
<v Speaker 2>hardware to China the entire time is at least the

0:11:53.110 --> 0:11:56.030
<v Speaker 2>allegation that's sort of laid out in several indictments that

0:11:56.670 --> 0:11:59.170
<v Speaker 2>And then it's a question of, well, how much work

0:11:59.290 --> 0:12:01.860
<v Speaker 2>does NVIDIA need to do and do the server manufacturers

0:12:01.880 --> 0:12:04.359
<v Speaker 2>need to do to make sure that the actual stated

0:12:04.380 --> 0:12:08.140
<v Speaker 2>destination of the chips exists? And there are some cases

0:12:08.260 --> 0:12:11.660
<v Speaker 2>where prosecutors have alleged the data center literally didn't exist.

0:12:11.720 --> 0:12:13.739
<v Speaker 2>There was never a place for those chips to go.

0:12:13.820 --> 0:12:15.600
<v Speaker 2>They were just always intended to go to China.

0:12:16.140 --> 0:12:18.520
<v Speaker 5>Wait, can I just, I'm a little bit disappointed. Are

0:12:18.559 --> 0:12:22.570
<v Speaker 5>there no chip mules out there? People who are just like,

0:12:23.170 --> 0:12:24.820
<v Speaker 5>I don't know. I have this vision of someone in

0:12:24.860 --> 0:12:26.880
<v Speaker 5>a trench coat and they like open it up and

0:12:26.920 --> 0:12:30.460
<v Speaker 5>it's lined with like, probably not H-100s, with black wells

0:12:30.500 --> 0:12:30.939
<v Speaker 5>or something.

0:12:32.020 --> 0:12:34.220
<v Speaker 2>Well, you know, it's funny that you say that because,

0:12:34.360 --> 0:12:37.219
<v Speaker 2>you know, in one of Jensen's many denials of chip

0:12:37.240 --> 0:12:40.000
<v Speaker 2>smuggling as an issue, he said, you know, the Grace

0:12:40.040 --> 0:12:41.860
<v Speaker 2>black well system wastes you tons. You're not putting that

0:12:41.960 --> 0:12:45.160
<v Speaker 2>in your backpack or pocket anytime soon. We reported a

0:12:45.179 --> 0:12:48.280
<v Speaker 2>couple months ago that the U.S. government has been investigating

0:12:48.340 --> 0:12:53.270
<v Speaker 2>a Singapore headquarter logistics company that literally specializes in tech

0:12:53.290 --> 0:12:58.060
<v Speaker 2>hardware transportation through complicated logistics. Those are fragile systems and

0:12:58.100 --> 0:13:01.660
<v Speaker 2>transported or is believed to have transported restricted hardware. And

0:13:02.360 --> 0:13:03.500
<v Speaker 2>then it's a question of like, OK, if you're a

0:13:03.520 --> 0:13:06.480
<v Speaker 2>logistics company, then how much is it your job to

0:13:06.520 --> 0:13:09.220
<v Speaker 2>know what's in the package? So a lot of these

0:13:09.260 --> 0:13:14.130
<v Speaker 2>cases also involve false declaration or allegedly involve false declaration,

0:13:14.470 --> 0:13:16.490
<v Speaker 2>you know, putting on customs forms that it's just a

0:13:16.530 --> 0:13:21.319
<v Speaker 2>computer server. Ambiguous what type of computer server. Sometimes random electronics,

0:13:21.360 --> 0:13:24.350
<v Speaker 2>there was one case where, and this is a case

0:13:24.370 --> 0:13:28.130
<v Speaker 2>where one person's actually pled guilty already, where they declared

0:13:28.790 --> 0:13:31.870
<v Speaker 2>restricted NVIDIA hardware to be, quote unquote, adapter modules. This

0:13:31.910 --> 0:13:34.750
<v Speaker 2>is a category of electronics that includes the thing you

0:13:34.850 --> 0:13:36.830
<v Speaker 2>use to plug your phone into a foreign power outlet.

0:13:37.550 --> 0:13:37.809
<v Speaker 6>Really?

0:13:37.870 --> 0:13:42.270
<v Speaker 2>Adapter modules that weigh 2,000 pounds? So there are lots

0:13:42.309 --> 0:13:45.380
<v Speaker 2>of cases where it's like, really? That's an eyebrow-raising declaration

0:13:45.390 --> 0:13:50.640
<v Speaker 2>of But there are lots of colorful characters in broker markets.

0:13:51.559 --> 0:13:56.260
<v Speaker 2>It's actually a very sophisticated black market. There are contracts.

0:13:56.320 --> 0:14:00.590
<v Speaker 2>Brokers go and solicit hardware on behalf of specific suppliers.

0:14:00.650 --> 0:14:05.150
<v Speaker 2>There was one broker who complained to us that the

0:14:05.190 --> 0:14:06.750
<v Speaker 2>trade is so good and so many people are trying

0:14:06.770 --> 0:14:08.439
<v Speaker 2>to get in on it. that now you have these

0:14:08.500 --> 0:14:11.000
<v Speaker 2>scammers in the black market who are like purporting to

0:14:11.040 --> 0:14:11.540
<v Speaker 2>have hardware.

0:14:11.679 --> 0:14:12.490
<v Speaker 4>Oh, yeah.

0:14:12.540 --> 0:14:14.830
<v Speaker 5>Good, honest black markets.

0:14:14.510 --> 0:14:18.449
<v Speaker 2>For like legitimate, honest black market brokers. No, it's a

0:14:18.470 --> 0:14:20.860
<v Speaker 2>pretty extraordinary and sophisticated and sprawling ecosystem.

0:14:37.050 --> 0:14:41.210
<v Speaker 3>Just one slight detail. You said that technically an entity

0:14:41.290 --> 0:14:44.670
<v Speaker 3>like a Megaspeed or even a CoreWeave does not actually

0:14:44.750 --> 0:14:48.780
<v Speaker 3>buy the chips from NVIDIA directly? And that actually the

0:14:48.960 --> 0:14:51.540
<v Speaker 3>first buyer of the chips is the server maker?

0:14:52.600 --> 0:14:55.460
<v Speaker 2>Yeah, typically speaking, NVIDIA is not selling directly to the

0:14:55.480 --> 0:14:55.860
<v Speaker 2>end user.

0:14:56.000 --> 0:15:00.900
<v Speaker 3>But the end user gets the allocation. So the end user,

0:15:00.950 --> 0:15:04.550
<v Speaker 3>a CoreWeave, a Megaspeed, whoever, will get some allocation directly.

0:15:04.800 --> 0:15:07.380
<v Speaker 3>that NVIDIA decides, okay, they're gonna get this many, but

0:15:07.400 --> 0:15:11.090
<v Speaker 3>the actual chain first goes through one of the server

0:15:11.130 --> 0:15:13.490
<v Speaker 3>makers like a Dell or a Supermicro or something like that.

0:15:13.530 --> 0:15:13.770
<v Speaker 2>Correct.

0:15:14.010 --> 0:15:14.190
<v Speaker 6>Okay.

0:15:14.810 --> 0:15:16.450
<v Speaker 2>Yeah, that's what makes NVIDIA the kingmaker.

0:15:16.470 --> 0:15:17.070
<v Speaker 4>All right.

0:15:17.770 --> 0:15:22.580
<v Speaker 3>Explain, as you said, this question of smuggling is not

0:15:22.640 --> 0:15:26.800
<v Speaker 3>locked down, but you said inconsistencies discovered in your reporting.

0:15:27.040 --> 0:15:28.660
<v Speaker 3>Let's talk about these inconsistencies.

0:15:28.870 --> 0:15:29.500
<v Speaker 2>On Megaspeed?

0:15:29.570 --> 0:15:29.690
<v Speaker 5>Yeah.

0:15:29.770 --> 0:15:33.440
<v Speaker 2>All right, let's get into it. So, you know, one

0:15:33.480 --> 0:15:36.860
<v Speaker 2>of the sort of first ports of call that I

0:15:37.020 --> 0:15:39.160
<v Speaker 2>look at when I'm investing in a company for smuggling,

0:15:39.180 --> 0:15:41.120
<v Speaker 2>which has now become a big part of my job,

0:15:41.800 --> 0:15:45.850
<v Speaker 2>is do they have the requisite data center space? Like

0:15:46.030 --> 0:15:48.270
<v Speaker 2>literally just the physical space in the building, the power

0:15:48.290 --> 0:15:53.850
<v Speaker 2>supply to support the hardware that they have purchased. And we.

0:15:56.200 --> 0:15:59.060
<v Speaker 2>Learned at a point in our investigation the number of

0:15:59.120 --> 0:16:02.990
<v Speaker 2>GPUs that NVIDIA found when asked by the U.S. government

0:16:03.040 --> 0:16:05.950
<v Speaker 2>to go and check Megaspeed's facilities, which they did several times.

0:16:05.970 --> 0:16:08.850
<v Speaker 2>You know, they tabulated all of the chips across over

0:16:08.850 --> 0:16:12.130
<v Speaker 2>12 data centers owned by eight companies in three countries.

0:16:12.950 --> 0:16:15.230
<v Speaker 2>They added up all the chips. They reported to the U.S. government.

0:16:15.570 --> 0:16:18.290
<v Speaker 2>And around this time, you know, we got a statement

0:16:18.330 --> 0:16:22.410
<v Speaker 2>from them in mid-November last year that said everything that

0:16:22.450 --> 0:16:23.810
<v Speaker 2>was shipped to our partners is where it should be.

0:16:25.790 --> 0:16:31.790
<v Speaker 2>We compared that number to Malaysian and Indonesian trade records

0:16:31.970 --> 0:16:34.990
<v Speaker 2>that we had gotten and found that there were about

0:16:34.990 --> 0:16:39.140
<v Speaker 2>50,000 chips unaccounted for, which is like not a small

0:16:39.200 --> 0:16:42.200
<v Speaker 2>amount of compute. And most of them were Blackwell chips,

0:16:42.420 --> 0:16:46.140
<v Speaker 2>which at the time were NVIDIA's best hardware. And so

0:16:46.200 --> 0:16:48.660
<v Speaker 2>we went back to NVIDIA and we said, you know,

0:16:48.680 --> 0:16:50.830
<v Speaker 2>we're not talking about one or two chips that are missing.

0:16:50.850 --> 0:16:54.570
<v Speaker 2>We're talking about a significant proportion of the overall hardware

0:16:54.590 --> 0:16:58.000
<v Speaker 2>that Megaspeed has purchased. And after we asked about that,

0:16:58.120 --> 0:17:01.540
<v Speaker 2>they went back to Malaysia and they said, oh, we

0:17:01.620 --> 0:17:06.700
<v Speaker 2>found these warehouses that contain what's missing. And I said, OK, great.

0:17:07.080 --> 0:17:11.369
<v Speaker 2>So we're going to subtract from the amount of hardware

0:17:11.390 --> 0:17:14.540
<v Speaker 2>that we found in trade records and the number of

0:17:14.600 --> 0:17:17.400
<v Speaker 2>chips that we know you guys told the U.S. government

0:17:17.440 --> 0:17:19.320
<v Speaker 2>you found, and that should be the amount of hardware

0:17:19.359 --> 0:17:22.600
<v Speaker 2>that's in these warehouses that we didn't know existed until

0:17:22.619 --> 0:17:24.020
<v Speaker 2>a week ago. We have been talking to NVIDIA about

0:17:24.040 --> 0:17:27.060
<v Speaker 2>this for a really long time by this point. This

0:17:27.119 --> 0:17:29.250
<v Speaker 2>is the number, right? And they declined to comment on

0:17:29.350 --> 0:17:31.570
<v Speaker 2>whether that's the number. I was like, okay. And then

0:17:31.590 --> 0:17:36.250
<v Speaker 2>they eventually submitted an updated statement that said we've identified, quote-unquote,

0:17:36.290 --> 0:17:40.030
<v Speaker 2>substantially all of the chips that Megaspeed had purchased via

0:17:40.070 --> 0:17:43.010
<v Speaker 2>its hardware partners. And we'll do additional checks in the

0:17:43.030 --> 0:17:45.950
<v Speaker 2>near future. So that was December of last year. I've

0:17:46.090 --> 0:17:49.470
<v Speaker 2>probably asked NVIDIA 10 to 12 times over the past

0:17:49.510 --> 0:17:52.930
<v Speaker 2>year whether those additional checks have occurred. I'm interested in

0:17:52.990 --> 0:17:55.940
<v Speaker 2>particular in a handful of data centers. One, which is

0:17:55.960 --> 0:17:59.600
<v Speaker 2>Megaspeed's largest data center, dropped the company as a tenant

0:17:59.840 --> 0:18:03.540
<v Speaker 2>a couple of months after our investigation and a story

0:18:03.600 --> 0:18:05.740
<v Speaker 2>by the New York Times that first broke the news

0:18:05.810 --> 0:18:08.240
<v Speaker 2>of the U.S. investigation into Megaspeed. I don't know the

0:18:08.359 --> 0:18:10.340
<v Speaker 2>reason that they were dropped, but if they're no longer

0:18:10.380 --> 0:18:12.740
<v Speaker 2>a tenant and that's where a significant portion of the

0:18:12.830 --> 0:18:16.129
<v Speaker 2>NVIDIA GPUs that NVIDIA told the U.S. government it found

0:18:16.170 --> 0:18:19.070
<v Speaker 2>were located, that raises some questions about where that hardware

0:18:19.090 --> 0:18:22.590
<v Speaker 2>might be now. We've not gotten answers to those questions.

0:18:22.770 --> 0:18:25.270
<v Speaker 2>So that's one of the eight data center operators. Two

0:18:25.310 --> 0:18:28.710
<v Speaker 2>of the others directly contradicted to us on the record

0:18:28.880 --> 0:18:31.780
<v Speaker 2>NVIDIA's account of the hardware as described to the U.S. government.

0:18:32.250 --> 0:18:34.710
<v Speaker 2>And so that's of the hardware that NVIDIA said it

0:18:34.750 --> 0:18:36.380
<v Speaker 2>found in the data centers. And then you have this

0:18:36.390 --> 0:18:39.820
<v Speaker 2>stuff that's, you know, in these warehouses. And we asked, okay,

0:18:39.840 --> 0:18:44.139
<v Speaker 2>so NVIDIA's policy is, you know, we prioritize customers that

0:18:44.160 --> 0:18:46.840
<v Speaker 2>are ready to put their products to use. They don't

0:18:46.880 --> 0:18:49.590
<v Speaker 2>want GPUs sitting in warehouses for months and months on end.

0:18:49.650 --> 0:18:52.869
<v Speaker 2>We asked, you know, what is Megaspeed's plan with this hardware?

0:18:52.910 --> 0:18:54.210
<v Speaker 2>When are we going to see it installed in the

0:18:54.250 --> 0:18:57.869
<v Speaker 2>data center? We didn't get answers to those questions. So

0:18:57.910 --> 0:19:03.980
<v Speaker 2>that's just on the hardware side. allocation piece. Then we

0:19:04.020 --> 0:19:09.139
<v Speaker 2>look at what Megaspeed has represented to investors and its

0:19:09.200 --> 0:19:12.760
<v Speaker 2>data center footprint as the company describes it. And on

0:19:12.800 --> 0:19:15.899
<v Speaker 2>its website, it had three data centers listed. We know

0:19:15.920 --> 0:19:17.919
<v Speaker 2>that's an undercount of their total number of data centers,

0:19:18.140 --> 0:19:23.000
<v Speaker 2>all in Southeast Asia. But in a presentation to investors

0:19:23.200 --> 0:19:28.530
<v Speaker 2>in 2024, Megaspeed described five data centers across three countries

0:19:28.550 --> 0:19:32.919
<v Speaker 2>and Two in Indonesia, two in Malaysia, and one in

0:19:33.040 --> 0:19:36.399
<v Speaker 2>a specific area of an unnamed third country that on

0:19:36.460 --> 0:19:39.940
<v Speaker 2>another slide of that same investor deck was the only

0:19:40.020 --> 0:19:44.470
<v Speaker 2>one described as not in Southeast Asia. And the rendering

0:19:44.510 --> 0:19:48.210
<v Speaker 2>that Megaspeed used to represent that data center is of

0:19:48.310 --> 0:19:53.520
<v Speaker 2>a sprawling project in Shanghai. where Megaspeed's sort of Chinese

0:19:53.580 --> 0:19:57.420
<v Speaker 2>corporate twin has been hiring engineers to work on restricted

0:19:57.440 --> 0:20:02.720
<v Speaker 2>NVIDIA hardware. Companies that Alice, who has become sort of

0:20:02.830 --> 0:20:06.270
<v Speaker 2>infamous in this scandal over the past couple of weeks,

0:20:06.720 --> 0:20:11.020
<v Speaker 2>Companies that she has long-time business ties to have been

0:20:11.119 --> 0:20:15.760
<v Speaker 2>investors in that data center. And so we asked, what's

0:20:15.820 --> 0:20:17.960
<v Speaker 2>up with this product in Shanghai? Why is that the

0:20:18.020 --> 0:20:20.389
<v Speaker 2>rendering that Megaspeed used to represent this facility on its

0:20:20.430 --> 0:20:23.190
<v Speaker 2>investor deck? We never got answers to those questions either.

0:20:24.170 --> 0:20:26.770
<v Speaker 5>It's such a weird decision to talk about, oh, and

0:20:26.790 --> 0:20:28.830
<v Speaker 5>we also have this project in a country that we're

0:20:28.869 --> 0:20:34.410
<v Speaker 5>not going to name, but here's an illustration of Shanghai. Yeah. OK,

0:20:34.490 --> 0:20:37.260
<v Speaker 5>and just so we're clear, can you outline what exactly

0:20:37.300 --> 0:20:41.080
<v Speaker 5>are the responsibilities of NVIDIA here? So if it sells

0:20:41.220 --> 0:20:45.070
<v Speaker 5>chips to a server company and the server company declares

0:20:45.130 --> 0:20:49.050
<v Speaker 5>that like the end user is definitely not a Chinese firm,

0:20:49.650 --> 0:20:53.130
<v Speaker 5>is it incumbent on NVIDIA to like double check those

0:20:53.230 --> 0:20:56.659
<v Speaker 5>claims or investigate? Like what do they actually what are

0:20:56.680 --> 0:20:57.419
<v Speaker 5>they expected to do?

0:20:58.330 --> 0:21:02.070
<v Speaker 2>You know, this is sort of the central tension that

0:21:02.109 --> 0:21:05.100
<v Speaker 2>has been playing out over the past year is whose

0:21:05.160 --> 0:21:08.139
<v Speaker 2>job is it to know? So, you know, in the

0:21:08.160 --> 0:21:11.120
<v Speaker 2>case of Megaspeed, NVIDIA told us last year we asked

0:21:11.160 --> 0:21:13.530
<v Speaker 2>the U.S. government if we need to cut off Megaspeed

0:21:13.619 --> 0:21:18.250
<v Speaker 2>and we were told no. In the case where, you know,

0:21:18.290 --> 0:21:21.229
<v Speaker 2>Supermicro's co-founders alleged to have smuggled two and a half

0:21:21.250 --> 0:21:24.879
<v Speaker 2>billion or sold $ 2. 5 billion worth of hardware to an

0:21:25.010 --> 0:21:27.629
<v Speaker 2>unnamed Southeast Asian intermediary that then smuggled the majority of

0:21:27.670 --> 0:21:30.210
<v Speaker 2>it to China. We've reported that that Southeast Asian intermediary

0:21:30.410 --> 0:21:33.090
<v Speaker 2>is one of the most important AI companies in Thailand.

0:21:34.250 --> 0:21:37.660
<v Speaker 2>That company is alleged to never have had the data

0:21:37.680 --> 0:21:41.100
<v Speaker 2>centers to install that hardware. So a lot of people

0:21:41.140 --> 0:21:44.899
<v Speaker 2>have asked, did NVIDIA check did Supermicro check. And actually,

0:21:44.980 --> 0:21:49.290
<v Speaker 2>Supermicro did check, according to the U.S. indictment. They audited

0:21:49.350 --> 0:21:52.910
<v Speaker 2>because the volumes that this Thai company was purchasing were

0:21:52.950 --> 0:21:55.970
<v Speaker 2>so significant. They audited, but then they allowed the shipments

0:21:55.990 --> 0:22:01.470
<v Speaker 2>to continue multiple times. I think companies are always going

0:22:01.490 --> 0:22:03.840
<v Speaker 2>to say, tell us what the law is and we

0:22:03.859 --> 0:22:05.580
<v Speaker 2>will follow the law. If you don't want us to

0:22:05.600 --> 0:22:07.780
<v Speaker 2>sell to this particular company, then tell us we can't

0:22:07.800 --> 0:22:11.270
<v Speaker 2>sell to that company. But I think the question is,

0:22:11.550 --> 0:22:15.409
<v Speaker 2>are there red flags that are so obvious that if

0:22:15.450 --> 0:22:18.409
<v Speaker 2>you have sort of any competent due diligence program, you

0:22:18.430 --> 0:22:21.650
<v Speaker 2>should have seen that? This is it's it's a conversation

0:22:21.670 --> 0:22:24.900
<v Speaker 2>that's sort of being actively litigated in Washington, shall we say.

0:22:25.160 --> 0:22:31.060
<v Speaker 2>And NVIDIA has started actually in some ways to self-regulate. Um,

0:22:31.200 --> 0:22:35.060
<v Speaker 2>you know, they have this like top tier of NVIDIA

0:22:35.119 --> 0:22:38.690
<v Speaker 2>cloud partners, these sort of like stamp of approval companies

0:22:38.710 --> 0:22:41.430
<v Speaker 2>that are totally, you tell the industry, like these are,

0:22:41.710 --> 0:22:43.689
<v Speaker 2>these are our top tier, uh, these are our top

0:22:43.710 --> 0:22:46.190
<v Speaker 2>tier partners. Megaspeed is, is one of them, is still

0:22:46.270 --> 0:22:47.830
<v Speaker 2>one of them. It became one of them four days

0:22:47.930 --> 0:22:53.580
<v Speaker 2>after it was incorporated in Singapore. Another NCP, its CEO

0:22:53.619 --> 0:22:58.740
<v Speaker 2>is on trial in Singapore for, uh, document for defrauding

0:22:58.780 --> 0:23:01.760
<v Speaker 2>server suppliers about the ultimate destination of hardware. And there

0:23:01.780 --> 0:23:04.100
<v Speaker 2>was like a mansion seize that was the alleged approach

0:23:04.119 --> 0:23:08.180
<v Speaker 2>seize of chip smuggling. The Thai company was like sort

0:23:08.200 --> 0:23:14.330
<v Speaker 2>of the initial hardware supplier for the like national AI company,

0:23:14.369 --> 0:23:17.450
<v Speaker 2>Sovereign Cloud of Thailand, which is the first NCP in Thailand.

0:23:17.770 --> 0:23:19.990
<v Speaker 2>So you have like definitely this interesting set of connections

0:23:20.010 --> 0:23:21.109
<v Speaker 2>happening at the NCP layer.

0:23:21.390 --> 0:23:23.870
<v Speaker 4>The NCP stands for?

0:23:23.890 --> 0:23:25.330
<v Speaker 2>NVIDIA Cloud Partner. Oh, yeah, yeah.

0:23:25.369 --> 0:23:25.770
<v Speaker 4>Sorry, sorry.

0:23:26.250 --> 0:23:29.230
<v Speaker 2>Sorry. Yeah, yeah. So there's also like an internal whitelist

0:23:29.790 --> 0:23:33.090
<v Speaker 2>of companies that NVIDIA has sort of pre-approved for purchase.

0:23:33.869 --> 0:23:38.650
<v Speaker 2>And after the Supermicro co-founder's indictment earlier this year, NVIDIA

0:23:39.050 --> 0:23:41.430
<v Speaker 2>went and cleaved a lot of companies from that whitelist.

0:23:42.130 --> 0:23:45.290
<v Speaker 2>And it's this interesting thing because on the one hand,

0:23:45.350 --> 0:23:48.590
<v Speaker 2>this is the type of due diligence maybe that some

0:23:48.630 --> 0:23:51.429
<v Speaker 2>Washington regulators would like to see the chipmaker take. On

0:23:51.450 --> 0:23:53.709
<v Speaker 2>the other, it raises questions of, you know, On what

0:23:53.760 --> 0:23:55.899
<v Speaker 2>basis did you remove those companies? Why were they on

0:23:55.920 --> 0:23:58.439
<v Speaker 2>the whitelist in the first place? And so, you know,

0:23:58.460 --> 0:24:01.840
<v Speaker 2>I think also for NVIDIA, which is trying in some

0:24:01.859 --> 0:24:05.160
<v Speaker 2>ways to demonstrate to the U.S. that it does take

0:24:05.200 --> 0:24:09.470
<v Speaker 2>this seriously, but also has so deeply lost credibility on

0:24:09.490 --> 0:24:11.909
<v Speaker 2>this issue that it's like a little bit of a catch-22.

0:24:11.930 --> 0:24:13.929
<v Speaker 2>And that's not trying to absolve NVIDIA of responsibility, just

0:24:13.950 --> 0:24:16.490
<v Speaker 2>sort of explaining a political reality that the company now

0:24:16.530 --> 0:24:17.060
<v Speaker 2>finds itself in.

0:24:17.600 --> 0:24:19.770
<v Speaker 5>This was going to be my next question because NVIDIA,

0:24:19.850 --> 0:24:22.209
<v Speaker 5>I mean, the thing we hear constantly is chips are

0:24:22.270 --> 0:24:25.230
<v Speaker 5>in short supply. Everyone is scrambling to get chips. There's

0:24:25.270 --> 0:24:28.190
<v Speaker 5>so much demand out there. It's hard to fill it all.

0:24:28.609 --> 0:24:33.149
<v Speaker 5>They can afford to be selective with their customers, right?

0:24:33.540 --> 0:24:37.760
<v Speaker 5>Do you have a working theory for why would they

0:24:37.880 --> 0:24:40.959
<v Speaker 5>even take the chance if demand is so strong that

0:24:40.980 --> 0:24:42.340
<v Speaker 5>they could sell to pretty much anyone?

0:24:42.740 --> 0:24:49.040
<v Speaker 2>That's a good question. NVIDIA's primary arguments on export controls

0:24:49.340 --> 0:24:53.740
<v Speaker 2>are about the market share, the global market share of

0:24:53.859 --> 0:24:59.230
<v Speaker 2>AI infrastructure that is American. They sort of view Huawei,

0:24:59.290 --> 0:25:02.970
<v Speaker 2>their primary competitor in China, as this sort of existential

0:25:03.010 --> 0:25:06.070
<v Speaker 2>threat to U.S. dominance. And their arguments are basically that

0:25:06.130 --> 0:25:10.040
<v Speaker 2>NVIDIA's interests are U.S. interests. And so, you know, when

0:25:10.080 --> 0:25:14.680
<v Speaker 2>you talk about the question of remote access, you renting

0:25:14.800 --> 0:25:17.340
<v Speaker 2>the use of NVIDIA hardware that Chinese companies can't purchase

0:25:17.359 --> 0:25:20.900
<v Speaker 2>themselves to those Chinese companies. You know, that's a policy

0:25:20.940 --> 0:25:22.760
<v Speaker 2>choice by the U.S. government. You know, a lot of

0:25:22.780 --> 0:25:24.970
<v Speaker 2>people describe that as like, oh, it's a workaround of

0:25:25.010 --> 0:25:27.150
<v Speaker 2>the export controls. It's the loophole of the export controls.

0:25:27.830 --> 0:25:30.710
<v Speaker 2>It's legal. The U.S. has the ability to make it

0:25:30.830 --> 0:25:33.330
<v Speaker 2>illegal and it's legal in the vast majority of cases.

0:25:33.790 --> 0:25:36.790
<v Speaker 2>You know, for NVIDIA, that's a good thing because NVIDIA

0:25:36.810 --> 0:25:39.040
<v Speaker 2>chips are filling all these data centers in Southeast Asia

0:25:39.080 --> 0:25:41.820
<v Speaker 2>that in many cases wouldn't exist if not for the

0:25:41.880 --> 0:25:45.100
<v Speaker 2>offtake demand from Chinese companies. It's the same reason that

0:25:45.180 --> 0:25:47.420
<v Speaker 2>NVIDIA wants to be able to freely sell its chips

0:25:47.460 --> 0:25:49.219
<v Speaker 2>in China. We need to be able to compete with

0:25:49.270 --> 0:25:52.890
<v Speaker 2>Huawei on its own turf. A question that a lot

0:25:52.950 --> 0:25:56.050
<v Speaker 2>of regulators have pushed back on NVIDIA on this topic

0:25:56.130 --> 0:25:59.850
<v Speaker 2>is Huawei can't supply the world's data centers. We're so

0:25:59.910 --> 0:26:01.649
<v Speaker 2>far off from a world of Huawei being able to

0:26:01.670 --> 0:26:04.330
<v Speaker 2>supply the world's data centers. And so how existential is

0:26:04.369 --> 0:26:07.290
<v Speaker 2>the threat of Chinese compute on the global stage or

0:26:07.330 --> 0:26:10.909
<v Speaker 2>even within China that the NVIDIA sales are aiming to counteract?

0:26:11.570 --> 0:26:14.370
<v Speaker 2>But I think NVIDIA is very focused on these sort

0:26:14.390 --> 0:26:18.520
<v Speaker 2>of battleground or what could become intense battleground regions if

0:26:18.560 --> 0:26:22.000
<v Speaker 2>China builds its own AI ship production capacity that they

0:26:22.020 --> 0:26:24.460
<v Speaker 2>want to make sure that they're selling in these regions.

0:26:24.780 --> 0:26:26.200
<v Speaker 4>I just want to point out one thing.

0:26:26.700 --> 0:26:30.500
<v Speaker 3>We've talked to Ian Dunning twice from Hudson River Trading,

0:26:30.560 --> 0:26:33.790
<v Speaker 3>who has said he is not having a hard time

0:26:33.830 --> 0:26:36.790
<v Speaker 3>getting GPUs. He's having a hard time getting GPUs. GPU

0:26:36.869 --> 0:26:37.810
<v Speaker 3>places to plug in.

0:26:38.109 --> 0:26:38.350
<v Speaker 6>Yeah.

0:26:38.690 --> 0:26:42.580
<v Speaker 1>So one could, it's possible, at least it seems possible

0:26:43.119 --> 0:26:47.060
<v Speaker 1>that there is not as much like unlimited demand for

0:26:47.119 --> 0:26:51.320
<v Speaker 1>GPUs per se as maybe NVIDIA would.

0:26:51.220 --> 0:26:52.080
<v Speaker 4>Like to claim.

0:26:52.520 --> 0:26:55.699
<v Speaker 3>And that actually, like, let's say the bottleneck is in

0:26:55.900 --> 0:26:58.050
<v Speaker 3>places to plug them in, that if you want to

0:26:58.170 --> 0:27:00.630
<v Speaker 3>actually sell the most number of chips for the most

0:27:00.670 --> 0:27:03.590
<v Speaker 3>number of dollars, setting aside these sort of broad market

0:27:03.609 --> 0:27:07.650
<v Speaker 3>share questions, that actually the Southeast Asian customers are important

0:27:08.090 --> 0:27:11.770
<v Speaker 3>if we believe what we've heard from other purchasers of

0:27:11.869 --> 0:27:15.770
<v Speaker 3>NVIDIA GPUs, that they're available if you can plug them in.

0:27:15.810 --> 0:27:19.920
<v Speaker 3>But before we get into the sort of NVIDIA versus

0:27:19.940 --> 0:27:22.159
<v Speaker 3>Huawei part, which I do want to talk about, I

0:27:22.480 --> 0:27:26.780
<v Speaker 3>want to just clarify this remote access question. Are you

0:27:26.820 --> 0:27:29.540
<v Speaker 3>saying like, let's say I start a data center company

0:27:30.380 --> 0:27:33.400
<v Speaker 3>and I'm explicitly like, I'm going to build data centers

0:27:33.660 --> 0:27:38.480
<v Speaker 3>in Malaysia. and I'm going to rent them out to

0:27:39.590 --> 0:27:43.350
<v Speaker 3>deep seek and a bunch of other like Chinese frontier

0:27:43.530 --> 0:27:46.150
<v Speaker 3>AI companies, technically. And I'm going to buy a video,

0:27:46.170 --> 0:27:48.270
<v Speaker 3>like technically there is nothing as far as we know,

0:27:48.310 --> 0:27:51.730
<v Speaker 3>like per se illegal about that arrangement. And then beyond that,

0:27:52.190 --> 0:27:54.889
<v Speaker 3>how do the Hawks or the people who argue in

0:27:54.990 --> 0:28:01.760
<v Speaker 3>favor of export controls into mainland China, that seems really inconsistent.

0:28:02.020 --> 0:28:06.240
<v Speaker 1>Like, Can you walk me through, like, is that actually legal?

0:28:06.320 --> 0:28:08.780
<v Speaker 3>And how is that, you say it's not a loophole

0:28:08.840 --> 0:28:12.550
<v Speaker 3>that it's the law, but how is that law justified?

0:28:15.119 --> 0:28:17.129
<v Speaker 2>Yeah, in the vast majority of cases, this is legal.

0:28:17.310 --> 0:28:19.890
<v Speaker 2>I mean, this is like literally what Megaspeed's business is.

0:28:19.910 --> 0:28:22.109
<v Speaker 2>This is what a lot of Southeast Asian neoclouds do.

0:28:22.830 --> 0:28:25.270
<v Speaker 2>The exceptions to that would be if you know that

0:28:25.290 --> 0:28:29.010
<v Speaker 2>the compute is going to be used for intelligence activities

0:28:29.030 --> 0:28:32.070
<v Speaker 2>by a foreign adversary military. It's a very narrow band

0:28:32.109 --> 0:28:32.570
<v Speaker 2>of restrictions.

0:28:32.900 --> 0:28:37.560
<v Speaker 3>But there's no restrictions on like selling chips into Southeast

0:28:37.660 --> 0:28:41.520
<v Speaker 3>Asia to be used to train the most advanced open

0:28:41.580 --> 0:28:43.060
<v Speaker 3>source models from China.

0:28:43.120 --> 0:28:45.740
<v Speaker 4>There's actually nothing illegal about it.

0:28:45.740 --> 0:28:50.460
<v Speaker 5>Doesn't DeepSea rents from like a Southeast Asia data center, right?

0:28:51.800 --> 0:28:56.570
<v Speaker 2>So the U.S. government has said that Moonshot rents NVIDIA

0:28:56.610 --> 0:28:57.690
<v Speaker 2>compute in Thailand.

0:28:57.850 --> 0:28:58.190
<v Speaker 6>Okay.

0:28:58.930 --> 0:29:01.680
<v Speaker 2>DeepSeq, by my understanding, actually does more of it, has

0:29:01.700 --> 0:29:06.180
<v Speaker 2>more of its compute onshore. But, you know, generally speaking

0:29:06.520 --> 0:29:10.770
<v Speaker 2>across Chinese companies, you know, this is an existentially important

0:29:10.810 --> 0:29:14.510
<v Speaker 2>resource is NVIDIA compute in Southeast Asia. You ask, you know,

0:29:14.650 --> 0:29:16.970
<v Speaker 2>how is it that the hawks have not restricted this?

0:29:17.070 --> 0:29:20.860
<v Speaker 2>They actually did. They restricted it at the end of

0:29:20.920 --> 0:29:24.900
<v Speaker 2>the Biden administration. And it was part of this broad

0:29:24.980 --> 0:29:28.980
<v Speaker 2>set of global restrictions on NVIDIA hardware called the AI

0:29:29.020 --> 0:29:33.630
<v Speaker 2>diffusion rule that was set to take effect in May 2025.

0:29:33.630 --> 0:29:36.310
<v Speaker 2>And the Trump administration is not enforcing that regulation.

0:29:36.890 --> 0:29:41.400
<v Speaker 3>Sorry, just to be clear, NVIDIA still can't... sell their

0:29:41.440 --> 0:29:46.760
<v Speaker 3>most advanced chips into mainland China. But the Trump administration

0:29:47.240 --> 0:29:50.940
<v Speaker 3>so far has been cool with sell them into Southeast

0:29:51.000 --> 0:29:52.770
<v Speaker 3>Asia to then remote access.

0:29:53.050 --> 0:29:53.850
<v Speaker 4>I mean, it's the internet.

0:29:53.910 --> 0:29:55.610
<v Speaker 1>I don't even know what borders mean. Why are like,

0:29:56.950 --> 0:29:57.470
<v Speaker 1>It's the internet.

0:29:57.490 --> 0:29:59.190
<v Speaker 4>What are we talking about? What does it matter?

0:29:59.270 --> 0:30:05.150
<v Speaker 2>Export controls on hardware don't respect the cloud. Yeah, yeah. No,

0:30:05.250 --> 0:30:08.380
<v Speaker 2>it's sometimes a bit baffling.

0:30:08.440 --> 0:30:11.560
<v Speaker 1>As long as I'm not the only one who's baffled.

0:30:12.480 --> 0:30:15.520
<v Speaker 2>This is like an active, raging debate in Washington, to

0:30:15.560 --> 0:30:18.800
<v Speaker 2>be fair. And, you know, one interesting thing that happened

0:30:18.860 --> 0:30:23.160
<v Speaker 2>this summer. So, you know, after Kimmy comes out with K3,

0:30:23.540 --> 0:30:25.520
<v Speaker 2>it's sort of, it's like, seen as like a second

0:30:25.560 --> 0:30:30.740
<v Speaker 2>deep-seek moment almost. The science and tech advisor in the

0:30:30.760 --> 0:30:35.760
<v Speaker 2>White House, Michael Kratzios, posts on X that the Moonshot

0:30:35.780 --> 0:30:39.170
<v Speaker 2>team acquired Blackwell chips, which is illegal. It raises questions

0:30:39.210 --> 0:30:41.050
<v Speaker 2>of why has the U.S. government not, you know, why

0:30:41.070 --> 0:30:43.370
<v Speaker 2>does the Commerce Department not take any action if that's

0:30:43.410 --> 0:30:46.130
<v Speaker 2>the U.S. government's determination? And also that they had remotely

0:30:46.190 --> 0:30:48.250
<v Speaker 2>accessed these chips in Thailand. And a couple of days

0:30:48.330 --> 0:30:51.800
<v Speaker 2>after that, the enforcement unit of the part of the

0:30:51.820 --> 0:30:55.240
<v Speaker 2>Commerce Department that handles chip export control. So the people

0:30:55.260 --> 0:30:57.760
<v Speaker 2>who are like, oh, you violated, like you smuggled, we're

0:30:57.780 --> 0:31:02.060
<v Speaker 2>going to go after you. That unit started mapping where

0:31:02.100 --> 0:31:05.540
<v Speaker 2>in the world remote access happens, which is very interesting

0:31:05.640 --> 0:31:08.680
<v Speaker 2>because remote access is not illegal. And so if you're

0:31:08.700 --> 0:31:12.040
<v Speaker 2>an enforcer of export controls, you know, why is that

0:31:12.060 --> 0:31:16.140
<v Speaker 2>your purview? But they started sort of crafting this list

0:31:16.380 --> 0:31:19.660
<v Speaker 2>of countries where that's known to happen and And, you know,

0:31:19.700 --> 0:31:21.540
<v Speaker 2>there have been at a very senior level of the

0:31:21.560 --> 0:31:27.370
<v Speaker 2>Trump administration, pretty intense debate over whether to impose such restrictions.

0:31:28.130 --> 0:31:30.590
<v Speaker 2>There's also interest on Capitol Hill. There's interest in Capitol

0:31:30.610 --> 0:31:33.440
<v Speaker 2>Hill in being more hawkish on a lot of these policies,

0:31:33.820 --> 0:31:37.920
<v Speaker 2>but including remote access. It's, you know, this is sort

0:31:37.960 --> 0:31:41.460
<v Speaker 2>of nightmare scenario for NVIDIA if remote access were to

0:31:41.500 --> 0:31:44.920
<v Speaker 2>be restricted. It's also a nightmare scenario for some hyperscalers

0:31:44.940 --> 0:31:50.100
<v Speaker 2>like Oracle that counts Chinese offtakers as a significant portion

0:31:50.140 --> 0:31:52.959
<v Speaker 2>of its business. There was great reporting in the Financial

0:31:52.980 --> 0:31:56.640
<v Speaker 2>Times recently about Oracle having a cloud computing arrangement with

0:31:56.680 --> 0:32:00.440
<v Speaker 2>Tencent that then the Trump administration stepped in to kill, basically,

0:32:00.850 --> 0:32:02.560
<v Speaker 2>even though it was legal. And so it's like, OK,

0:32:02.590 --> 0:32:04.790
<v Speaker 2>are we just going to do this ad hoc? You know,

0:32:04.810 --> 0:32:06.310
<v Speaker 2>they do a lot of things ad hoc, but we'll see.

0:32:06.330 --> 0:32:09.080
<v Speaker 2>You know, there's it's an active regulatory debate. Like, you know,

0:32:09.120 --> 0:32:11.100
<v Speaker 2>the answer to this question could change by the time

0:32:11.120 --> 0:32:12.620
<v Speaker 2>this podcast airs, although I doubt it.

0:32:12.780 --> 0:32:15.360
<v Speaker 5>Well, OK, speaking of ad hoc, I mean, part of

0:32:15.400 --> 0:32:20.600
<v Speaker 5>the scandal here is that NVIDIA reportedly intervened in the U.S.

0:32:20.620 --> 0:32:24.850
<v Speaker 5>government's Megaspeed investigation and said, yeah, it's all good.

0:32:25.030 --> 0:32:25.810
<v Speaker 4>Yeah, they're cool.

0:32:26.140 --> 0:32:28.840
<v Speaker 5>They're cool. Trust us. What do you expect to happen?

0:32:29.120 --> 0:32:31.590
<v Speaker 5>I don't even know the status of that investigation now,

0:32:31.640 --> 0:32:34.170
<v Speaker 5>but like, is it picking up again or like what's

0:32:34.210 --> 0:32:36.550
<v Speaker 5>going on there? Would you expect the DOJ to actually

0:32:36.610 --> 0:32:37.150
<v Speaker 5>pursue those?

0:32:38.470 --> 0:32:41.410
<v Speaker 2>Yeah, yeah. So I just want to clarify quickly on

0:32:41.650 --> 0:32:45.090
<v Speaker 2>the sort of scope of NVIDIA's intervention. So this is

0:32:45.370 --> 0:32:47.910
<v Speaker 2>reporting from like two days ago. And this is such

0:32:47.930 --> 0:32:50.600
<v Speaker 2>an active story that I'm saying what I know as

0:32:50.640 --> 0:32:54.820
<v Speaker 2>of 10.38 p.m. Hong Kong time on Wednesday. So NVIDIA's

0:32:54.860 --> 0:32:58.410
<v Speaker 2>general counsel, a guy called Tim Teeter, called NVIDIA. the

0:32:58.650 --> 0:33:00.540
<v Speaker 2>head of the Bureau of Industry and Security, like the

0:33:00.640 --> 0:33:04.600
<v Speaker 2>export controls enforcement and the agency that writes and enforces

0:33:04.640 --> 0:33:07.400
<v Speaker 2>export controls at the Commerce Department in late summer last

0:33:07.460 --> 0:33:12.880
<v Speaker 2>year to inquire about whether BIS was involved in the

0:33:12.920 --> 0:33:16.390
<v Speaker 2>detention of Alice, who we now know was, you know,

0:33:16.430 --> 0:33:18.730
<v Speaker 2>having an extramarital affair with Jensen. But NVIDIA says that

0:33:18.770 --> 0:33:20.610
<v Speaker 2>Tim Teeter didn't know that at the time of this call,

0:33:21.210 --> 0:33:23.450
<v Speaker 2>called to ask if BIS was involved in her being

0:33:23.490 --> 0:33:26.550
<v Speaker 2>detained in Singapore. she had been brought in for questioning

0:33:26.690 --> 0:33:29.690
<v Speaker 2>and restricted from leaving the country as part of Singapore's

0:33:29.800 --> 0:33:34.980
<v Speaker 2>own investigation into Megaspeed, which Megaspeed said recently had concluded

0:33:35.080 --> 0:33:38.120
<v Speaker 2>this year with no adverse findings. So Tim Teeter called

0:33:38.140 --> 0:33:42.920
<v Speaker 2>to ask about that. He later emailed BIS staff who

0:33:42.940 --> 0:33:44.520
<v Speaker 2>were working on the case and asked to meet with

0:33:44.600 --> 0:33:47.740
<v Speaker 2>one of them. And they forwarded those emails to Jeffrey

0:33:47.760 --> 0:33:51.040
<v Speaker 2>Kessler because Tim Teeter invoked Kessler's name. He's like, oh,

0:33:51.060 --> 0:33:52.570
<v Speaker 2>like Kessler said it was OK to talk to you.

0:33:52.580 --> 0:33:55.010
<v Speaker 2>And this was like this is not normal practice for

0:33:55.030 --> 0:33:59.310
<v Speaker 2>an export enforcement investigation. And, you know, Kessler said, continue

0:33:59.330 --> 0:34:02.229
<v Speaker 2>doing things by the book. You know, the Commerce Department said,

0:34:02.650 --> 0:34:05.190
<v Speaker 2>or a spokesperson for this agency within the Commerce Department said,

0:34:05.210 --> 0:34:08.770
<v Speaker 2>you know, everything has been above board. But the sort

0:34:08.790 --> 0:34:11.439
<v Speaker 2>of nature of the investigation and the ability of export

0:34:11.460 --> 0:34:15.580
<v Speaker 2>enforcement agents to act in the weeks and months after

0:34:15.800 --> 0:34:19.660
<v Speaker 2>this sort of saga with Tim Teeter was diminished. You know,

0:34:19.920 --> 0:34:23.160
<v Speaker 2>and agents or people working on export enforcement investigations you know,

0:34:23.520 --> 0:34:28.489
<v Speaker 2>we're restricted from requesting information directly from NVIDIA without getting

0:34:28.510 --> 0:34:31.450
<v Speaker 2>Kessler's approval beforehand or routing it through him. That's a

0:34:31.469 --> 0:34:34.630
<v Speaker 2>policy that's unique to NVIDIA. It's not how things operate

0:34:34.670 --> 0:34:37.340
<v Speaker 2>with any other major tech company. You were told not

0:34:37.380 --> 0:34:39.760
<v Speaker 2>to mention Megaspeed or Speed Matrix, the name of Megaspeed's

0:34:39.780 --> 0:34:44.420
<v Speaker 2>Malaysian subsidiary and external communications. And eventually the Department of Justice,

0:34:44.560 --> 0:34:48.910
<v Speaker 2>which typically pursues these investigations alongside BIS. So, you know,

0:34:48.950 --> 0:34:50.610
<v Speaker 2>if anything is going to be turned into like a

0:34:50.750 --> 0:34:53.810
<v Speaker 2>criminal indictment, it's going to involve the DOJ. The Department

0:34:53.830 --> 0:34:56.450
<v Speaker 2>of Justice had been working alongside BIS for a bit

0:34:56.530 --> 0:35:01.590
<v Speaker 2>on this case, ended up asking BIS to stop its efforts.

0:35:01.950 --> 0:35:04.340
<v Speaker 2>So now that case is with DOJ. You know, I

0:35:04.380 --> 0:35:06.719
<v Speaker 2>think my my understanding of the status of the case

0:35:06.760 --> 0:35:09.000
<v Speaker 2>a few weeks ago is would be probably very different

0:35:09.040 --> 0:35:11.900
<v Speaker 2>from where things are right now. There's obviously intense interest

0:35:12.140 --> 0:35:15.549
<v Speaker 2>in this within the Trump administration on Capitol Hill. So,

0:35:15.570 --> 0:35:17.210
<v Speaker 2>you know, it's funny, like a lot of a lot

0:35:17.230 --> 0:35:20.150
<v Speaker 2>of what we're talking about now was known such a

0:35:20.190 --> 0:35:22.170
<v Speaker 2>long time ago. You know, New Times reported on it.

0:35:22.210 --> 0:35:24.830
<v Speaker 2>We reported on it. But it's got a new life,

0:35:24.969 --> 0:35:26.330
<v Speaker 2>shall we say, in the past couple of weeks.

0:35:26.730 --> 0:35:29.359
<v Speaker 5>I feel like we should mention BIS is the Bureau

0:35:29.380 --> 0:35:31.920
<v Speaker 5>of Industry and Security, because whenever I hear BIS, I

0:35:31.960 --> 0:35:34.260
<v Speaker 5>always think Bank for International Settlements.

0:35:34.420 --> 0:35:37.680
<v Speaker 2>But yes. Different type of nerd, you guys.

0:35:37.700 --> 0:35:41.469
<v Speaker 4>You can only have so many three-letter acronyms, right? That's true.

0:35:41.510 --> 0:35:42.730
<v Speaker 4>And so you're bound to.

0:35:42.750 --> 0:35:45.850
<v Speaker 2>No, DC says every day we will invent a new one. Oh, yeah.

0:36:02.670 --> 0:36:04.880
<v Speaker 3>One more question on Megaspeed before I want to get

0:36:04.920 --> 0:36:06.880
<v Speaker 3>a little bit, talk a little bit about Huawei. One

0:36:06.920 --> 0:36:11.060
<v Speaker 3>more question on Megaspeed. What do we know right now?

0:36:11.080 --> 0:36:13.950
<v Speaker 3>You know, you described at the very beginning, spun off

0:36:13.989 --> 0:36:17.850
<v Speaker 3>from this gaming company, BVI shell company, etc.

0:36:18.290 --> 0:36:19.629
<v Speaker 4>What do we know.

0:36:19.910 --> 0:36:24.540
<v Speaker 3>About its owners and its backers and how they have

0:36:24.560 --> 0:36:26.300
<v Speaker 3>the money to buy a bunch of NVIDIA chips.

0:36:26.120 --> 0:36:26.600
<v Speaker 4>And all that stuff?

0:36:27.460 --> 0:36:32.080
<v Speaker 2>Yeah, so Megaspeed on paper is 100% owned by a

0:36:32.239 --> 0:36:34.740
<v Speaker 2>Singapore shell company that is 100% owned by a CEO

0:36:34.760 --> 0:36:37.529
<v Speaker 2>who is a Singapore national. We tried many times to

0:36:37.550 --> 0:36:39.669
<v Speaker 2>get in touch with him last year. We were unsuccessful.

0:36:40.350 --> 0:36:44.469
<v Speaker 2>In terms of where it got the money, this is

0:36:44.530 --> 0:36:48.009
<v Speaker 2>a big open question. $ 4. 6 billion worth of hardware is

0:36:48.030 --> 0:36:53.160
<v Speaker 2>not a small amount of hardware. It has a compute

0:36:53.219 --> 0:36:56.410
<v Speaker 2>rental agreement with Alibaba. Alibaba, you know, the way that

0:36:56.450 --> 0:36:58.370
<v Speaker 2>these agreements often work is a company will put sort

0:36:58.410 --> 0:37:01.430
<v Speaker 2>of a prepayment, sort of a guarantee, like, hey, like,

0:37:01.489 --> 0:37:02.850
<v Speaker 2>you know, it's like you put a deposit down on

0:37:02.870 --> 0:37:05.350
<v Speaker 2>an expensive purchase. Like, we are going to offtake this

0:37:05.370 --> 0:37:08.820
<v Speaker 2>in the future. So there are, you know, financial transactions

0:37:08.890 --> 0:37:13.840
<v Speaker 2>between Alibaba via a Singaporean subsidiary of Alibaba's two mega

0:37:13.860 --> 0:37:17.920
<v Speaker 2>speeds where, you know, the entirety of its Malaysia business

0:37:17.940 --> 0:37:20.660
<v Speaker 2>was offered as collateral actually. These are transactions that happened

0:37:20.680 --> 0:37:22.810
<v Speaker 2>a couple of years ago, but don't sort of fully

0:37:22.890 --> 0:37:24.870
<v Speaker 2>answer the question of where it got all of the

0:37:24.910 --> 0:37:28.010
<v Speaker 2>money that it did to purchase the hardware. But on paper,

0:37:28.070 --> 0:37:30.430
<v Speaker 2>it is a Singaporean company, and I don't have evidence

0:37:30.469 --> 0:37:31.110
<v Speaker 2>to the contrary.

0:37:31.250 --> 0:37:34.590
<v Speaker 3>Let's talk a little bit about, you mentioned Huawei, and

0:37:34.630 --> 0:37:38.330
<v Speaker 3>you mentioned that Huawei just doesn't have the capacity, the

0:37:38.370 --> 0:37:41.770
<v Speaker 3>skill yet to replace NVIDIA on a global level, probably

0:37:41.810 --> 0:37:44.530
<v Speaker 3>not even at a China level, given the demand.

0:37:45.360 --> 0:37:47.020
<v Speaker 4>Among Chinese AI firms.

0:37:47.120 --> 0:37:50.600
<v Speaker 2>Yeah, you know, Huawei's senior executives themselves say it'll take

0:37:50.700 --> 0:37:53.020
<v Speaker 2>until 2030 to satiate domestic demand.

0:37:53.040 --> 0:37:55.580
<v Speaker 3>All right, so talk a little bit about, like, where

0:37:55.760 --> 0:37:59.900
<v Speaker 3>are they on this process? And, you know, in AI,

0:37:59.920 --> 0:38:01.700
<v Speaker 3>we're always talking about, like, are they six months behind,

0:38:01.739 --> 0:38:02.800
<v Speaker 3>two years behind, whatever.

0:38:02.860 --> 0:38:04.180
<v Speaker 1>Like, tell us a little.

0:38:03.980 --> 0:38:08.140
<v Speaker 3>Bit about, like, where Huawei is in its fight, I guess,

0:38:08.160 --> 0:38:09.819
<v Speaker 3>to be, like, a real competitor with Nvidia.

0:38:10.469 --> 0:38:14.160
<v Speaker 2>Yeah, so, you know, Huawei is... is such a black box.

0:38:15.400 --> 0:38:18.779
<v Speaker 2>It's the sort of preeminent competitor to NVIDIA in China.

0:38:18.800 --> 0:38:21.299
<v Speaker 2>There are a handful of other companies, of course, that are,

0:38:21.440 --> 0:38:23.259
<v Speaker 2>you know, a lot of in the same way that

0:38:23.280 --> 0:38:25.200
<v Speaker 2>a lot of American companies are like designing their own chips.

0:38:25.219 --> 0:38:26.700
<v Speaker 2>You have that same pattern among a lot of the

0:38:26.719 --> 0:38:28.839
<v Speaker 2>Chinese companies. It's just a matter of like whether they

0:38:28.860 --> 0:38:31.930
<v Speaker 2>can get the production capacity. You know, that's the constraint

0:38:32.250 --> 0:38:34.969
<v Speaker 2>in large part because the U.S. and allied nations have

0:38:35.010 --> 0:38:38.540
<v Speaker 2>restricted the flow of semiconductor manufacturing equipment into China. But

0:38:38.580 --> 0:38:42.390
<v Speaker 2>Huawei has made material progress on its chips over the

0:38:42.410 --> 0:38:46.810
<v Speaker 2>past couple of years. And you're starting to see Chinese

0:38:46.950 --> 0:38:50.430
<v Speaker 2>companies become more interested in adopting Huawei hardware. You know,

0:38:50.450 --> 0:38:52.170
<v Speaker 2>I remember actually coming on OddLots a year ago and

0:38:52.190 --> 0:38:53.830
<v Speaker 2>I was like, you know, one of the things that

0:38:53.850 --> 0:38:55.730
<v Speaker 2>I'm waiting for is like, is Huawei ever going to

0:38:55.830 --> 0:38:58.780
<v Speaker 2>export Ascend chips, which are the name of its AI chips?

0:38:59.140 --> 0:39:01.000
<v Speaker 2>And also, are we going to see, you know, a

0:39:01.040 --> 0:39:04.899
<v Speaker 2>frontier Chinese lab complete a successful training run on Huawei chips?

0:39:05.250 --> 0:39:07.330
<v Speaker 2>You know, right now you're starting to see model releases

0:39:07.370 --> 0:39:09.350
<v Speaker 2>out of China that have what are called like zero-day

0:39:09.390 --> 0:39:11.990
<v Speaker 2>inferencing capabilities on Huawei, which is like, this is sort

0:39:12.030 --> 0:39:14.580
<v Speaker 2>of optimized to run best on Huawei hardware from the

0:39:14.620 --> 0:39:16.759
<v Speaker 2>moment that we release it. But that's a very different

0:39:16.800 --> 0:39:21.440
<v Speaker 2>thing from doing, you know, pre-training on Huawei. And, you know,

0:39:21.520 --> 0:39:25.750
<v Speaker 2>one data point for this is, gosh, it's been a

0:39:25.770 --> 0:39:27.310
<v Speaker 2>busy news cycle, maybe like a month and a half ago,

0:39:27.370 --> 0:39:30.969
<v Speaker 2>two months ago, we reported that DeepSeq, had placed a

0:39:31.010 --> 0:39:36.450
<v Speaker 2>very substantial order for Huawei hardware, 160,000 of Huawei's best

0:39:36.530 --> 0:39:40.660
<v Speaker 2>AI chips called 950DTs for use at a data center

0:39:40.680 --> 0:39:43.140
<v Speaker 2>in Inner Mongolia that DeepSeq is building as its sort

0:39:43.160 --> 0:39:47.180
<v Speaker 2>of like next really, really large domestic computing cluster. Incidentally,

0:39:47.200 --> 0:39:50.279
<v Speaker 2>this is the same location within China that the U.S.

0:39:50.300 --> 0:39:54.080
<v Speaker 2>government believes that DeepSeq has installed NVIDIA's Blackwell chips. We

0:39:54.120 --> 0:39:56.319
<v Speaker 2>don't know what the overall composition of compute in that

0:39:56.360 --> 0:39:58.580
<v Speaker 2>data center will be. Huawei is not going to be

0:39:58.620 --> 0:40:01.359
<v Speaker 2>able to fulfill that order for more than a year.

0:40:01.700 --> 0:40:05.609
<v Speaker 2>DeepSeq is actually lobbying the Chinese government to pressure Huawei

0:40:05.640 --> 0:40:08.850
<v Speaker 2>to speed up its allocation. It would be great for

0:40:08.910 --> 0:40:12.730
<v Speaker 2>Chinese labs if they had this alternative source of supply, right?

0:40:12.770 --> 0:40:15.700
<v Speaker 2>It's obviously the U.S. government. you know, obviously we talked

0:40:15.719 --> 0:40:17.680
<v Speaker 2>about their Monaxis piece, but, you know, everybody would like

0:40:17.700 --> 0:40:20.759
<v Speaker 2>to own their chips, or at least have them in-country.

0:40:21.080 --> 0:40:23.500
<v Speaker 2>The U.S. government has made it very difficult to use NVIDIA.

0:40:23.760 --> 0:40:25.839
<v Speaker 2>They would love people to use Huawei. It's a matter

0:40:25.860 --> 0:40:28.319
<v Speaker 2>of whether they can do a training run. And, you know,

0:40:28.400 --> 0:40:31.160
<v Speaker 2>at the time of our reporting, Huawei was planning on

0:40:31.280 --> 0:40:35.020
<v Speaker 2>using these 950DTs for inference rather than training, even though,

0:40:35.040 --> 0:40:37.900
<v Speaker 2>or sorry, DeepSea was planning on using Huawei 950DTs for

0:40:37.940 --> 0:40:40.239
<v Speaker 2>inference rather than training, even though they were designed as

0:40:40.280 --> 0:40:43.620
<v Speaker 2>training chips. And Huawei's overall production capacity of that hardware

0:40:43.860 --> 0:40:46.920
<v Speaker 2>is in the low hundreds of thousands. You know, it's

0:40:47.020 --> 0:40:51.280
<v Speaker 2>just orders of magnitude less than what NVIDIA is shipping globally.

0:40:51.320 --> 0:40:54.799
<v Speaker 2>But you still have started to see Huawei make some

0:40:54.900 --> 0:40:59.310
<v Speaker 2>export attempts. You know, I wrote about a couple of

0:40:59.370 --> 0:41:03.350
<v Speaker 2>months ago as well that they had submitted in response

0:41:03.410 --> 0:41:06.549
<v Speaker 2>to a tender from the Egyptian government to build AI

0:41:06.570 --> 0:41:10.520
<v Speaker 2>compute for use by Egyptian defense companies. And it was

0:41:10.560 --> 0:41:13.160
<v Speaker 2>a very small amount of compute. It was like 2000 ships,

0:41:13.219 --> 0:41:15.350
<v Speaker 2>but they were prepared to offer their best ships. And

0:41:15.390 --> 0:41:17.549
<v Speaker 2>it was like, when you're that supply constraint, it's like

0:41:17.630 --> 0:41:20.149
<v Speaker 2>everything that you're offering overseas is something that you're not

0:41:20.250 --> 0:41:23.190
<v Speaker 2>offering domestically. And so as a company, you know, Huawei

0:41:23.230 --> 0:41:25.850
<v Speaker 2>has to decide like, you know, as important as it

0:41:25.969 --> 0:41:28.390
<v Speaker 2>is to get more Chinese developers, you know, working on

0:41:28.430 --> 0:41:30.569
<v Speaker 2>its ecosystem, because you also get the sort of like

0:41:30.760 --> 0:41:33.500
<v Speaker 2>iterative feedback loop when you have AI companies training on

0:41:33.520 --> 0:41:35.779
<v Speaker 2>your hardware that helps you make your hardware better. They

0:41:35.840 --> 0:41:38.040
<v Speaker 2>also want to make sure that they have these footholds

0:41:38.080 --> 0:41:40.339
<v Speaker 2>in global markets. It's the same strategy that made them

0:41:40.380 --> 0:41:43.960
<v Speaker 2>sort of the preeminent telecommunications provider. And that, you know,

0:41:43.980 --> 0:41:46.540
<v Speaker 2>the U.S. government watched that happen years ago when Huawei

0:41:46.580 --> 0:41:49.960
<v Speaker 2>became extremely successful in 3G, 4G. And they want to

0:41:50.020 --> 0:41:52.120
<v Speaker 2>avoid that happening with AI infrastructure. So actually, when they

0:41:52.180 --> 0:41:54.980
<v Speaker 2>learned of this bid that Huawei had made in Egypt,

0:41:55.580 --> 0:41:58.040
<v Speaker 2>they like gathered this consortium of American companies and they

0:41:58.060 --> 0:42:00.819
<v Speaker 2>were like, counterbid. And, you know, a lot of these

0:42:00.840 --> 0:42:04.180
<v Speaker 2>companies had never really thought of Egypt as an important market. But,

0:42:04.620 --> 0:42:07.850
<v Speaker 2>you know, they had these conversations with the Egyptian government.

0:42:07.989 --> 0:42:10.529
<v Speaker 2>You know, we don't know the outcome of that tender

0:42:10.570 --> 0:42:13.710
<v Speaker 2>process yet. But it's just sort of an interesting, you know,

0:42:13.930 --> 0:42:16.250
<v Speaker 2>Egypt is an interesting battleground for Huawei because they feel

0:42:16.290 --> 0:42:18.810
<v Speaker 2>a little bit blocked or boxed out of the Persian

0:42:18.850 --> 0:42:21.370
<v Speaker 2>Gulf because there were these, you know, big American AI

0:42:21.390 --> 0:42:24.350
<v Speaker 2>infrastructure deals last year, which I talked with you guys

0:42:24.390 --> 0:42:26.730
<v Speaker 2>about about a year ago, how controversial those were. And

0:42:27.650 --> 0:42:28.969
<v Speaker 2>Egypt is sort of an anchor in the Middle East,

0:42:29.010 --> 0:42:31.509
<v Speaker 2>also an anchor in Africa. So you're starting to see

0:42:31.530 --> 0:42:33.680
<v Speaker 2>these battles play out. You know, the Malaysian government is

0:42:34.530 --> 0:42:38.180
<v Speaker 2>seriously evaluating use of an earlier generation of Huawei Ascend

0:42:38.200 --> 0:42:41.040
<v Speaker 2>chips for its sovereign AI capabilities. But, you know, it's

0:42:41.060 --> 0:42:43.210
<v Speaker 2>important to remember that the volumes that we're talking about

0:42:43.250 --> 0:42:45.609
<v Speaker 2>here are just infinitesimally small at this time.

0:42:46.460 --> 0:42:49.759
<v Speaker 5>So this is very much a live story, as you've

0:42:49.780 --> 0:42:52.719
<v Speaker 5>been emphasizing throughout this conversation, and one reason why you're

0:42:52.760 --> 0:42:54.930
<v Speaker 5>very sleep deprived at the moment. But what are you

0:42:54.969 --> 0:42:58.149
<v Speaker 5>watching out for next? So we still we don't really

0:42:58.170 --> 0:43:00.089
<v Speaker 5>know what the DOJ is going to do. And now

0:43:00.130 --> 0:43:05.290
<v Speaker 5>we have this independent investigation going into Jensen and the

0:43:05.350 --> 0:43:09.200
<v Speaker 5>spy affair at NVIDIA. What do you think is going

0:43:09.219 --> 0:43:09.700
<v Speaker 5>to be important?

0:43:11.410 --> 0:43:14.330
<v Speaker 2>Yeah, I mean, look, obviously Jensen's fate is sort of

0:43:14.570 --> 0:43:18.590
<v Speaker 2>important for global markets, for the industry, you know, what

0:43:18.640 --> 0:43:23.460
<v Speaker 2>the board ends up deciding to do. I think from

0:43:23.800 --> 0:43:27.140
<v Speaker 2>a policy and regulatory perspective, you know, this is a

0:43:27.560 --> 0:43:33.550
<v Speaker 2>very unique moment in an administration that, generally speaking, has,

0:43:33.830 --> 0:43:36.730
<v Speaker 2>you know, adopted a lot of the policies that NVIDIA

0:43:36.750 --> 0:43:41.740
<v Speaker 2>would like it to. There is... rage, honestly, on Capitol

0:43:41.780 --> 0:43:44.180
<v Speaker 2>Hill and in many parts of the Trump administration about

0:43:44.219 --> 0:43:48.080
<v Speaker 2>the overall state of export controls. Obviously, this scandal with

0:43:48.140 --> 0:43:50.640
<v Speaker 2>NVIDIA gives people a lot of things to latch on to.

0:43:50.960 --> 0:43:53.589
<v Speaker 2>So you're starting to see these voices that have not

0:43:53.640 --> 0:43:58.290
<v Speaker 2>historically been particularly active on this issue take great interest

0:43:58.350 --> 0:44:00.430
<v Speaker 2>in it. And then you have this sort of baseline

0:44:00.469 --> 0:44:04.250
<v Speaker 2>contingent of China hawks who have been upset by what

0:44:04.290 --> 0:44:06.850
<v Speaker 2>they see as a lack of action by the Bureau

0:44:07.010 --> 0:44:10.690
<v Speaker 2>of Industry and Security, that BIS, within the Trump administration

0:44:10.870 --> 0:44:13.150
<v Speaker 2>on this topic and are trying to legislate some of

0:44:13.210 --> 0:44:15.109
<v Speaker 2>the rules to at least like, OK, let's not roll

0:44:15.150 --> 0:44:17.629
<v Speaker 2>back export controls more than they already have been. Let's

0:44:17.650 --> 0:44:22.529
<v Speaker 2>put additional restrictions on semiconductor equipment shipments into China. Let's

0:44:22.570 --> 0:44:25.330
<v Speaker 2>make sure that it's unambiguous that the executive branch has

0:44:25.370 --> 0:44:29.420
<v Speaker 2>the authority to restrict cloud compute access by Chinese companies.

0:44:29.940 --> 0:44:33.219
<v Speaker 2>And a lot of these measures are sort of going

0:44:33.239 --> 0:44:34.880
<v Speaker 2>to be litigated over the next couple of months as

0:44:34.920 --> 0:44:37.739
<v Speaker 2>part of an annual must pass defense package. So it'll

0:44:37.760 --> 0:44:40.529
<v Speaker 2>be a really interesting couple of months on Capitol Hill. Obviously,

0:44:40.550 --> 0:44:44.469
<v Speaker 2>you know, Democrats are taking Congress next year. I would

0:44:44.510 --> 0:44:48.089
<v Speaker 2>expect a significant amount of oversight into not just NVIDIA, but,

0:44:48.130 --> 0:44:51.270
<v Speaker 2>you know, the major players in the ecosystem. And then

0:44:51.310 --> 0:44:54.529
<v Speaker 2>I think, you know, for Southeast Asia, which is a

0:44:54.530 --> 0:44:57.049
<v Speaker 2>bit closer to where I sit, you know, there's been

0:44:57.090 --> 0:45:01.260
<v Speaker 2>this sort of whiplash over the past couple of years where,

0:45:01.360 --> 0:45:03.419
<v Speaker 2>you know, remember like the AI diffusion rule I mentioned

0:45:03.440 --> 0:45:06.380
<v Speaker 2>that the Trump administration is not enforcing? So this was

0:45:06.400 --> 0:45:09.480
<v Speaker 2>going to impose, you know, licensing requirements, meaning you need

0:45:09.500 --> 0:45:12.440
<v Speaker 2>to get the U.S. government's permission to ship NVIDIA ships

0:45:12.620 --> 0:45:16.739
<v Speaker 2>to Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, Indonesia, all these places where, you know,

0:45:16.760 --> 0:45:19.560
<v Speaker 2>we have these smuggling cases happening. And so actually some

0:45:19.580 --> 0:45:23.020
<v Speaker 2>of the companies that are suspected of being involved in

0:45:23.040 --> 0:45:26.140
<v Speaker 2>smuggling like massively ramped up their shipments right before those

0:45:26.200 --> 0:45:27.700
<v Speaker 2>restrictions were set to take effect. And then they didn't

0:45:27.719 --> 0:45:32.040
<v Speaker 2>take effect. And then the Trump administration worked on a regulation.

0:45:32.060 --> 0:45:33.759
<v Speaker 2>They were like, hey, we're not doing that, but we

0:45:33.820 --> 0:45:36.279
<v Speaker 2>are going to restrict to Malaysia and Thailand specifically. This

0:45:36.320 --> 0:45:38.800
<v Speaker 2>was a draft rule that I read about in June

0:45:38.960 --> 0:45:41.879
<v Speaker 2>or July of last year. And then they scrapped that

0:45:41.940 --> 0:45:45.410
<v Speaker 2>amid diplomatic pressure from the Malaysian government. And then they

0:45:45.430 --> 0:45:48.110
<v Speaker 2>worked on another replacement regulation that would have done global

0:45:48.230 --> 0:45:52.050
<v Speaker 2>export controls. We heard about that in March, I would say.

0:45:52.070 --> 0:45:54.770
<v Speaker 2>And that was withdrawn shortly after it was sent to

0:45:54.850 --> 0:45:58.660
<v Speaker 2>other U.S. government agencies. And so, you know, for companies

0:45:58.680 --> 0:46:01.700
<v Speaker 2>that are trying to build infrastructure in this region, you know,

0:46:02.400 --> 0:46:04.339
<v Speaker 2>even the ones that are doing it completely legally, it's like,

0:46:04.719 --> 0:46:06.219
<v Speaker 2>are we going to be able to get the chips?

0:46:06.300 --> 0:46:08.359
<v Speaker 2>Like it's this constant sort of, you know, the U.S.

0:46:08.390 --> 0:46:09.750
<v Speaker 2>government's a little bit the boy who cried wolf on

0:46:09.770 --> 0:46:13.489
<v Speaker 2>this issue. You know, we have this intense scrutiny into

0:46:13.530 --> 0:46:17.969
<v Speaker 2>mega speed. Asian banks sort of go through like ebbs

0:46:18.030 --> 0:46:20.779
<v Speaker 2>and flows of how comfortable they are with, you you know,

0:46:20.860 --> 0:46:24.500
<v Speaker 2>financing deals that have a significant amount of Chinese offtakes?

0:46:24.540 --> 0:46:26.400
<v Speaker 2>Or like, what if the U.S. government does restrict it

0:46:26.440 --> 0:46:28.299
<v Speaker 2>and then are suddenly, you know, left holding the bag?

0:46:28.860 --> 0:46:31.070
<v Speaker 2>And this is, you know, one of the fastest growing,

0:46:31.370 --> 0:46:34.029
<v Speaker 2>you know, AI infrastructure regions in the world. You know,

0:46:34.050 --> 0:46:36.270
<v Speaker 2>the amount of compute online right now is like, it

0:46:37.230 --> 0:46:39.490
<v Speaker 2>doesn't hold a candle to what exists in the U.S.,

0:46:39.510 --> 0:46:41.549
<v Speaker 2>but it is fast growing. A lot of companies are

0:46:41.570 --> 0:46:44.359
<v Speaker 2>investing here and it's just under, yeah, an intense period

0:46:44.380 --> 0:46:47.239
<v Speaker 2>of scrutiny. So it's, yes, that's the developments that I'll

0:46:47.280 --> 0:46:50.160
<v Speaker 2>be watching. And then on the Huawei front, you know,

0:46:50.750 --> 0:46:53.410
<v Speaker 2>Huawei is making export attempts. And I think, you know,

0:46:53.430 --> 0:46:55.989
<v Speaker 2>the U.S. government, it's funny, like over a year ago,

0:46:56.030 --> 0:46:58.640
<v Speaker 2>there was an executive order to promote the export of

0:46:58.680 --> 0:47:01.840
<v Speaker 2>the American AI stack to basically like design these packages

0:47:01.900 --> 0:47:05.149
<v Speaker 2>that you could sort of offer to you know, other

0:47:05.210 --> 0:47:08.069
<v Speaker 2>countries of like adopt, you know, up and down, you know,

0:47:08.110 --> 0:47:11.640
<v Speaker 2>from applications to models to infrastructure, the American AI stack.

0:47:12.180 --> 0:47:14.460
<v Speaker 2>And we haven't seen like anything come out of that

0:47:14.500 --> 0:47:17.460
<v Speaker 2>program yet. And now we actually do have Huawei like

0:47:17.500 --> 0:47:19.980
<v Speaker 2>starting to make these attempts. And the U.S. is sort

0:47:20.000 --> 0:47:22.320
<v Speaker 2>of responding to them on like an ad hoc basis.

0:47:23.030 --> 0:47:24.549
<v Speaker 2>And I'm sure that we'll see more of that over

0:47:24.570 --> 0:47:26.649
<v Speaker 2>the next year. So you'll start to see like these

0:47:26.730 --> 0:47:29.250
<v Speaker 2>battlegrounds in the global south that will be really interesting

0:47:29.310 --> 0:47:32.319
<v Speaker 2>to watch, you know, how foreign governments are make decisions

0:47:32.390 --> 0:47:34.870
<v Speaker 2>about their own sovereign capabilities and whether they think, you know,

0:47:34.890 --> 0:47:37.390
<v Speaker 2>the U.S. is a reliable partner or they're willing to take,

0:47:37.430 --> 0:47:39.890
<v Speaker 2>you know, maybe worse trips from China that, you know,

0:47:39.910 --> 0:47:41.950
<v Speaker 2>Huawei is happy to like send their engineers there and

0:47:41.969 --> 0:47:44.029
<v Speaker 2>do the whole data center for you. And yeah, I

0:47:44.050 --> 0:47:45.250
<v Speaker 2>know it's exciting times.

0:47:47.050 --> 0:47:48.190
<v Speaker 1>Mackenzie, that was fantastic.

0:47:48.210 --> 0:47:51.589
<v Speaker 4>Get some sleep. Well-deserved. You're going to need it. But no,

0:47:51.610 --> 0:47:52.110
<v Speaker 4>that was great.

0:47:52.160 --> 0:47:54.279
<v Speaker 3>Thank you for staying up late, catching us up to

0:47:54.320 --> 0:47:57.120
<v Speaker 3>speed on all this. And I don't think this will

0:47:57.140 --> 0:47:58.140
<v Speaker 3>be the last time we chat.

0:47:58.940 --> 0:48:00.339
<v Speaker 4>And I appreciate your coming on the hotline.

0:48:00.630 --> 0:48:14.990
<v Speaker 6>Yeah, thanks so much for having me. Always a pleasure, guys.

0:48:15.430 --> 0:48:21.160
<v Speaker 4>She's so great. These are such complicated stories.

0:48:21.219 --> 0:48:21.920
<v Speaker 5>They really are.

0:48:21.980 --> 0:48:26.299
<v Speaker 3>They're really complicated. There's so many different... dimensions to them.

0:48:26.580 --> 0:48:28.779
<v Speaker 5>Also, there's a lot of legal technicality in what can

0:48:28.820 --> 0:48:31.879
<v Speaker 5>and can't be said, which I think sometimes people don't

0:48:31.920 --> 0:48:35.620
<v Speaker 5>necessarily appreciate from a journalistic perspective. And she's doing that

0:48:35.840 --> 0:48:39.020
<v Speaker 5>all on like, I think she said she hadn't slept

0:48:39.040 --> 0:48:42.299
<v Speaker 5>for 70 hours or something. So that's pretty intense. No,

0:48:42.340 --> 0:48:45.740
<v Speaker 5>it's a fascinating story. I keep thinking it feels like

0:48:46.239 --> 0:48:48.620
<v Speaker 5>a big tail risk right now for the chip makers.

0:48:49.120 --> 0:48:53.050
<v Speaker 5>I mean, obviously what happens with Jensen and the investigation,

0:48:53.170 --> 0:48:56.649
<v Speaker 5>but just the idea that as a lot of this

0:48:56.930 --> 0:49:00.600
<v Speaker 5>becomes more public knowledge, as politicians become aware of it,

0:49:00.719 --> 0:49:05.460
<v Speaker 5>that that legal loophole of Chinese companies being able to

0:49:05.620 --> 0:49:11.260
<v Speaker 5>rent GPUs via Southeast Asia, even if they can't actually

0:49:11.340 --> 0:49:14.930
<v Speaker 5>buy certain chips, that comes under scrutiny. And you can

0:49:14.969 --> 0:49:18.620
<v Speaker 5>imagine if that... like it's such a weird one it's.

0:49:18.410 --> 0:49:22.500
<v Speaker 3>So weird this term remote access what does that even

0:49:22.580 --> 0:49:25.020
<v Speaker 3>mean it's a cloud of course it's remote access it's

0:49:25.060 --> 0:49:28.279
<v Speaker 3>like oh as opposed to like the tenant of the

0:49:28.380 --> 0:49:31.020
<v Speaker 3>user of the chips walking into the data instead of

0:49:31.040 --> 0:49:33.840
<v Speaker 3>themselves are plugging in a laptop it's all remote access

0:49:34.060 --> 0:49:37.589
<v Speaker 3>this so it's a it's always been very baffling to

0:49:37.620 --> 0:49:40.489
<v Speaker 3>me that we have these intense conversations about, oh, you

0:49:40.550 --> 0:49:41.710
<v Speaker 3>can't sell into China.

0:49:42.010 --> 0:49:43.870
<v Speaker 4>But actually, it's really not.

0:49:43.670 --> 0:49:47.629
<v Speaker 3>That big of a deal to sell into, and it's

0:49:47.690 --> 0:49:53.210
<v Speaker 3>not illegal currently, to sell into anywhere else who then

0:49:53.530 --> 0:49:55.830
<v Speaker 3>rents that capacity to Chinese firms.

0:49:55.910 --> 0:50:01.540
<v Speaker 4>Like, what? I don't know. I do, like, Who can

0:50:01.600 --> 0:50:02.280
<v Speaker 4>explain this.

0:50:02.200 --> 0:50:03.590
<v Speaker 1>In just a moment?

0:50:03.730 --> 0:50:05.770
<v Speaker 5>Yeah. The other thing that I thought was really interesting

0:50:05.870 --> 0:50:08.089
<v Speaker 5>and I wasn't aware of was McKenzie saying that there's

0:50:08.130 --> 0:50:12.790
<v Speaker 5>basically like a handful of U.S. Customs officers in Southeast Asia.

0:50:12.870 --> 0:50:15.160
<v Speaker 5>And you can imagine like if you're going to ramp

0:50:15.260 --> 0:50:19.120
<v Speaker 5>up export controls and expect them to be effective, you're

0:50:19.140 --> 0:50:22.399
<v Speaker 5>going to have to staff up, right? It reminds me,

0:50:22.420 --> 0:50:26.160
<v Speaker 5>I did an article on the corporate bond market many,

0:50:26.200 --> 0:50:28.730
<v Speaker 5>many years ago. And at the time, I think this

0:50:28.750 --> 0:50:31.780
<v Speaker 5>was like... well, I can't remember, maybe an eight trillion market.

0:50:32.260 --> 0:50:35.960
<v Speaker 5>And there was one guy at the SEC who devoted

0:50:36.180 --> 0:50:41.140
<v Speaker 5>half his time to actually monitoring the corporate bond market,

0:50:41.180 --> 0:50:42.220
<v Speaker 5>which blew my mind.

0:50:42.739 --> 0:50:46.419
<v Speaker 3>You know, I really think actually, and I hadn't appreciated

0:50:46.480 --> 0:50:51.430
<v Speaker 3>this until McKenzie brought up Huawei's sale to Egypt. That is,

0:50:51.550 --> 0:50:54.130
<v Speaker 3>I forget, you know, what is it? We did the

0:50:54.170 --> 0:50:56.790
<v Speaker 3>story with Eva Doe, who wrote the book, House of Huawei.

0:50:56.830 --> 0:51:00.010
<v Speaker 3>And what was the story there? The story there was

0:51:00.510 --> 0:51:04.560
<v Speaker 3>this is a company that is very aggressive about gaining

0:51:04.620 --> 0:51:08.260
<v Speaker 3>footholds in parts of the world that, like, other companies

0:51:08.320 --> 0:51:09.420
<v Speaker 3>aren't as aggressive about.

0:51:09.460 --> 0:51:12.259
<v Speaker 4>So Egypt is, like, as she explained, a pretty good

0:51:12.420 --> 0:51:13.020
<v Speaker 4>example of this.

0:51:13.460 --> 0:51:17.400
<v Speaker 3>Even with a scarce number of Ascend chips, that is

0:51:17.420 --> 0:51:20.540
<v Speaker 3>sort of, like, in their corporate DNA, like, go out and, like,

0:51:20.600 --> 0:51:24.469
<v Speaker 3>win these global markets, which then, of course, implicitly, as

0:51:24.510 --> 0:51:28.040
<v Speaker 3>you gain this foothold, then of course implicitly help sort

0:51:28.060 --> 0:51:31.020
<v Speaker 3>of like broader Chinese, like soft and hard power.

0:51:31.060 --> 0:51:31.379
<v Speaker 6>Et cetera.

0:51:31.880 --> 0:51:33.980
<v Speaker 3>But then I was thinking about, okay, let's say after

0:51:34.020 --> 0:51:36.880
<v Speaker 3>this mega speed scandal, you're like, you know what? We

0:51:36.920 --> 0:51:39.620
<v Speaker 3>really are no more of this remote stuff. We really

0:51:39.660 --> 0:51:41.680
<v Speaker 3>got to like crack down on who we're selling to

0:51:41.980 --> 0:51:47.160
<v Speaker 3>in Southeast Asia. It's clear that today, you know, it

0:51:47.200 --> 0:51:51.190
<v Speaker 3>doesn't sound like Huawei could replace Nvidia today, but if,

0:51:51.480 --> 0:51:54.860
<v Speaker 3>you know, maybe a few years from now, like a

0:51:55.010 --> 0:51:58.150
<v Speaker 3>number of these countries do become like Huawei countries.

0:51:58.230 --> 0:51:58.590
<v Speaker 2>Yeah.

0:51:58.870 --> 0:52:00.170
<v Speaker 4>It's going to be very tricky.

0:52:00.489 --> 0:52:04.830
<v Speaker 5>Well, the other thing I just want to reiterate is like, again,

0:52:05.310 --> 0:52:10.050
<v Speaker 5>with NVIDIA itself, there's a weird like contradiction here where

0:52:10.310 --> 0:52:14.669
<v Speaker 5>if chip demand is as strong as they describe, they

0:52:14.710 --> 0:52:17.450
<v Speaker 5>should be very selective with their customers, right?

0:52:17.469 --> 0:52:18.030
<v Speaker 2>Yes, yes.

0:52:18.050 --> 0:52:21.900
<v Speaker 5>Like there shouldn't be any question marks over anyone, basically.

0:52:21.940 --> 0:52:22.580
<v Speaker 2>Yeah, yeah.

0:52:23.250 --> 0:52:26.400
<v Speaker 5>And so I find that really interesting as well. And

0:52:26.480 --> 0:52:29.680
<v Speaker 5>probably like an under-discussed angle in all of this. Like

0:52:29.700 --> 0:52:32.799
<v Speaker 5>you can afford to like- Be discriminating. Be discriminating and

0:52:32.840 --> 0:52:36.400
<v Speaker 5>have like the most intense compliance process in the world

0:52:36.460 --> 0:52:39.170
<v Speaker 5>if you want. Anyway, shall we leave it there?

0:52:39.190 --> 0:52:40.390
<v Speaker 4>Let's leave it there.

0:52:40.630 --> 0:52:43.009
<v Speaker 5>This has been another episode of the All Thoughts Podcast.

0:52:43.150 --> 0:52:45.890
<v Speaker 5>I'm Tracy Allaway. You can follow me at Tracy Allaway.

0:52:46.090 --> 0:52:49.430
<v Speaker 3>And I'm Joe Wiesenthal. You can follow me at The Stalwart.

0:52:49.690 --> 0:52:51.419
<v Speaker 3>Follow our guest Mackenzie Hawkins.

0:52:51.560 --> 0:52:53.000
<v Speaker 4>She's at Mack Hawk.

0:52:53.290 --> 0:52:57.770
<v Speaker 3>Follow our producers, Carmen Rodriguez at CarmenArmond, Dashiell Bennett at Dashbot,

0:52:58.130 --> 0:53:01.010
<v Speaker 3>Kale Brooks at Kale Brooks, and Kevin Lozano at Kevin

0:53:01.030 --> 0:53:03.230
<v Speaker 3>Lloyd Lozano. And you can chat about all of these

0:53:03.270 --> 0:53:08.380
<v Speaker 3>topics 24-7 in our Discord, discord.gg slash oddlots. And for

0:53:08.390 --> 0:53:11.040
<v Speaker 3>more Oddlots content, check out our daily newsletter, which you

0:53:11.060 --> 0:53:13.200
<v Speaker 3>can find at bloomberg.com slash oddlots.

0:53:13.739 --> 0:53:16.060
<v Speaker 5>And if you enjoyed this conversation, if you like it

0:53:16.219 --> 0:53:18.660
<v Speaker 5>when we talk about chip smuggling, then please leave us

0:53:18.680 --> 0:53:21.730
<v Speaker 5>a positive review on your favorite podcast platform. And if

0:53:21.750 --> 0:53:24.509
<v Speaker 5>you're watching on video, then please like or leave a

0:53:24.530 --> 0:53:26.270
<v Speaker 5>comment or better yet, subscribe.

0:53:26.469 --> 0:53:28.910
<v Speaker 3>And remember, if you're a Bloomberg subscriber, you can listen

0:53:28.930 --> 0:53:31.830
<v Speaker 3>to all of our episodes absolutely ad-free. All you need

0:53:31.850 --> 0:53:35.410
<v Speaker 3>to do is find the Bloomberg channel on Apple Podcasts

0:53:35.489 --> 0:53:36.040
<v Speaker 3>and follow.

0:53:35.880 --> 0:53:36.660
<v Speaker 4>The instructions there.

0:53:37.200 --> 0:53:37.930
<v Speaker 5>Thanks for joining.

0:53:54.460 --> 0:53:54.890
<v Speaker 3>Thank you.