WEBVTT - 6/3/26: Larry Ellison Net Worth Skyrockets On Data Centers, ICE Protests Erupt At Delaney Hall

0:00:00.080 --> 0:00:01.599
<v Speaker 1>Hey guys, Saga and Crystal here.

0:00:01.680 --> 0:00:05.200
<v Speaker 2>Independent media just played a truly massive role in this election,

0:00:05.360 --> 0:00:07.840
<v Speaker 2>and we are so excited about what that means for

0:00:07.880 --> 0:00:08.760
<v Speaker 2>the future of the show.

0:00:08.880 --> 0:00:10.760
<v Speaker 1>This is the only place where you can find honest

0:00:10.760 --> 0:00:13.280
<v Speaker 1>perspectives from the left and the right that simply does

0:00:13.320 --> 0:00:14.640
<v Speaker 1>not exist anywhere else.

0:00:14.720 --> 0:00:17.080
<v Speaker 2>So if that is something that's important to you, please

0:00:17.120 --> 0:00:19.599
<v Speaker 2>go to Breakingpoints dot com. Become a member today and

0:00:19.640 --> 0:00:22.800
<v Speaker 2>you'll get access to our full shows, unedited, ad free,

0:00:22.800 --> 0:00:25.600
<v Speaker 2>and all put together for you every morning in your inbox.

0:00:25.680 --> 0:00:27.560
<v Speaker 1>We need your help to build the future of independent

0:00:27.560 --> 0:00:29.920
<v Speaker 1>news media and we hope to see you at Breakingpoints

0:00:29.960 --> 0:00:33.559
<v Speaker 1>dot com.

0:00:33.800 --> 0:00:38.360
<v Speaker 3>A huge congratulations to Larry Ellison. The data center build

0:00:38.400 --> 0:00:41.640
<v Speaker 3>out and the AI boom has a vaulted him. We

0:00:41.640 --> 0:00:44.479
<v Speaker 3>can put up this first elements involved in the third

0:00:44.600 --> 0:00:47.280
<v Speaker 3>richest man in the world. You know, I love it

0:00:47.320 --> 0:00:50.199
<v Speaker 3>when good things happen to good people, don't. We'd love

0:00:50.240 --> 0:00:51.400
<v Speaker 3>to celebrate success here.

0:00:51.440 --> 0:00:52.200
<v Speaker 4>We call it karma.

0:00:52.400 --> 0:00:56.920
<v Speaker 3>We do absolutely beautiful. His net worth went up I

0:00:56.920 --> 0:01:01.720
<v Speaker 3>think seventy billion dollars in the last month, modest because

0:01:01.760 --> 0:01:05.520
<v Speaker 3>he's you know, he really he woke up earlier. You know,

0:01:05.560 --> 0:01:08.080
<v Speaker 3>he put in the hours and when you do that,

0:01:08.200 --> 0:01:12.080
<v Speaker 3>you know success comes your way coming out of that.

0:01:12.160 --> 0:01:15.520
<v Speaker 3>What he'd like to see is uh. Stenny Hoyer, the

0:01:15.600 --> 0:01:19.440
<v Speaker 3>longtime representative from southern Maryland who was the number two

0:01:19.480 --> 0:01:23.000
<v Speaker 3>in the House for really many decades, wants to see

0:01:23.080 --> 0:01:26.440
<v Speaker 3>him replaced by an Oracle lobbyist. Larry Allison. Of course,

0:01:26.720 --> 0:01:32.080
<v Speaker 3>Uh the founder of the CAA linked Oracle and Adrian Boafo,

0:01:32.160 --> 0:01:37.760
<v Speaker 3>now running former Stenny Hoyer campaign manager, has been a

0:01:37.800 --> 0:01:42.400
<v Speaker 3>lobbyist for Oracle for data centers for the last five

0:01:42.480 --> 0:01:46.560
<v Speaker 3>years and is now running with Hoyer's support to replace him.

0:01:47.080 --> 0:01:49.200
<v Speaker 3>Standing in his way, Harry Dunn is a Capitol police

0:01:49.200 --> 0:01:55.560
<v Speaker 3>officer but also Prince George's councilwoman h Wallable Gay. We

0:01:55.600 --> 0:01:59.560
<v Speaker 3>are joined today by Wallable Gay. So your your opponent's

0:01:59.720 --> 0:02:05.840
<v Speaker 3>b US made seventy billion dollars last month, but you

0:02:05.880 --> 0:02:09.560
<v Speaker 3>know anything can happen, So thank you for being here

0:02:09.600 --> 0:02:10.520
<v Speaker 3>in the studio.

0:02:10.520 --> 0:02:14.080
<v Speaker 5>We really appreciate it, right, and we have no tolerance

0:02:14.080 --> 0:02:17.160
<v Speaker 5>for the billionaires living big in the United States while

0:02:17.200 --> 0:02:18.320
<v Speaker 5>the rest of us are suffering.

0:02:18.600 --> 0:02:19.519
<v Speaker 6>And that's why I'm running.

0:02:19.919 --> 0:02:23.720
<v Speaker 3>What's so crazy is we could have minted seventy one

0:02:23.800 --> 0:02:29.520
<v Speaker 3>new billionaires in the last month instead one billionaire's worth

0:02:29.560 --> 0:02:31.120
<v Speaker 3>seventy one billion dollars more.

0:02:31.320 --> 0:02:35.639
<v Speaker 5>The richer are getting richer. It is getting out of control.

0:02:35.720 --> 0:02:38.040
<v Speaker 5>It is in our faces and it's like they just

0:02:38.040 --> 0:02:42.200
<v Speaker 5>don't care anymore. And that's why we are we have

0:02:42.480 --> 0:02:45.680
<v Speaker 5>we are ground zero for the attacks. It is amazing

0:02:46.040 --> 0:02:48.480
<v Speaker 5>how we have billionaires who are getting richer, but yet

0:02:48.480 --> 0:02:51.239
<v Speaker 5>and still we're ripping. Our federal workers have gotten the

0:02:51.360 --> 0:02:57.480
<v Speaker 5>jobs taken our federal contractors anything di you understand, Maryland's

0:02:57.680 --> 0:03:00.680
<v Speaker 5>fifth Congressional district has two of the wealthy as African

0:03:00.720 --> 0:03:03.600
<v Speaker 5>American communities in the country that have been torn down

0:03:03.960 --> 0:03:07.560
<v Speaker 5>because contracts have been taking Anything DEI in this administration

0:03:07.960 --> 0:03:11.560
<v Speaker 5>has been snatched. Like we literally are hearing weekly from

0:03:11.560 --> 0:03:15.040
<v Speaker 5>people looking for new opportunities because they can barely make payroll.

0:03:15.320 --> 0:03:18.560
<v Speaker 5>We have federal workers who are peacemeialing side jobs to

0:03:18.600 --> 0:03:21.120
<v Speaker 5>get the jobs to get the income that they have before,

0:03:21.160 --> 0:03:24.919
<v Speaker 5>which they're barely getting. We are dealing with the highest

0:03:25.240 --> 0:03:28.320
<v Speaker 5>grocery bills, utility bills. I'm as you mentioned, one of

0:03:28.320 --> 0:03:31.880
<v Speaker 5>my opponents is a lobbyist for Oracle and we have

0:03:32.120 --> 0:03:35.120
<v Speaker 5>data centers that are on our grid we are on

0:03:35.160 --> 0:03:38.080
<v Speaker 5>the same grid as the capital of data centers just

0:03:38.120 --> 0:03:42.320
<v Speaker 5>about yessue. It is a huge issue in Prince George's.

0:03:42.360 --> 0:03:45.080
<v Speaker 5>I stopped the data center in Prince George's. We have

0:03:45.360 --> 0:03:48.040
<v Speaker 5>ones that they just stopped in Charles County, and Calvert

0:03:48.160 --> 0:03:50.440
<v Speaker 5>is not having it. So we have at least three

0:03:50.680 --> 0:03:56.160
<v Speaker 5>of the five jurisdictions within Congressional five fighting data centers.

0:03:56.240 --> 0:04:00.440
<v Speaker 5>And yet and still we're looking at Oracle possible. And

0:04:00.640 --> 0:04:03.960
<v Speaker 5>they even even before the four million dollars that's coming

0:04:04.400 --> 0:04:07.280
<v Speaker 5>from AI, Crypto Oracle, all of these things, they were

0:04:07.280 --> 0:04:10.400
<v Speaker 5>getting money from Oracle Data Center folks. And I would

0:04:10.440 --> 0:04:13.920
<v Speaker 5>just tell you this, Our bills are going up high.

0:04:14.480 --> 0:04:15.840
<v Speaker 6>We are on the same grid.

0:04:15.840 --> 0:04:18.159
<v Speaker 5>We are on the thirteenth state grid with the same

0:04:18.240 --> 0:04:22.880
<v Speaker 5>grid as the capitol data centers Virginia. So that's why

0:04:22.920 --> 0:04:25.760
<v Speaker 5>our bills are even higher than other areas. We are

0:04:25.880 --> 0:04:29.760
<v Speaker 5>struggling to stop. We have in Prince William County twenty

0:04:30.120 --> 0:04:32.880
<v Speaker 5>hyper skilled data centers coming up. And if that and

0:04:32.920 --> 0:04:36.599
<v Speaker 5>our pjam our administrator told us, if the hyper skilled

0:04:36.640 --> 0:04:40.400
<v Speaker 5>data centers keep coming up, we are going to have blackouts.

0:04:40.839 --> 0:04:44.800
<v Speaker 5>So we are in trouble, and it's because of data centers.

0:04:44.880 --> 0:04:47.360
<v Speaker 5>We have got to pause data centers. I am full

0:04:47.400 --> 0:04:50.880
<v Speaker 5>support of Senator Sanders bill pause moratorium one data centers.

0:04:50.880 --> 0:04:54.080
<v Speaker 5>In back, I introduced one in Prince George's county when

0:04:54.120 --> 0:04:55.960
<v Speaker 5>we were going to have one at the Landover Moore

0:04:56.160 --> 0:05:00.560
<v Speaker 5>Mall and Senator Van Hollins build that we're requires them

0:05:00.600 --> 0:05:04.120
<v Speaker 5>to bring their own generation. Their pressure on the grid

0:05:04.320 --> 0:05:06.719
<v Speaker 5>is making it worse for everyone. And then if you

0:05:06.800 --> 0:05:10.560
<v Speaker 5>elect a lobbyist that is a data centered lobbyist, it

0:05:10.600 --> 0:05:15.640
<v Speaker 5>will get worse. You're almost like asking for increasing utility bills,

0:05:15.800 --> 0:05:19.440
<v Speaker 5>and yet instead we have, as you said, the oracle

0:05:19.520 --> 0:05:23.320
<v Speaker 5>man is now more richer than he ever has, and

0:05:23.360 --> 0:05:25.200
<v Speaker 5>we have seniors that can't pay their bills.

0:05:25.240 --> 0:05:27.640
<v Speaker 6>In fact, my office, we're paying bills.

0:05:28.040 --> 0:05:30.760
<v Speaker 3>I feel like if Howard Zenn had been immortal and

0:05:30.920 --> 0:05:34.239
<v Speaker 3>was around today, like writing and writing a new book,

0:05:34.279 --> 0:05:37.960
<v Speaker 3>it'd be like Larry Ellison oracle lobbyists trying to replace

0:05:38.040 --> 0:05:42.200
<v Speaker 3>Stenny Hoyer in southern Maryland. Now. The thing that makes

0:05:42.200 --> 0:05:45.680
<v Speaker 3>this race interesting though, is there seem like they're two

0:05:45.760 --> 0:05:48.799
<v Speaker 3>hundred and fifty five people running. How many people running

0:05:48.800 --> 0:05:49.280
<v Speaker 3>in this race?

0:05:49.560 --> 0:05:52.839
<v Speaker 5>It's twenty three now we had one dropout for the

0:05:52.920 --> 0:05:56.120
<v Speaker 5>Democratic side doesn't include the Republican side. And it's because

0:05:56.400 --> 0:05:58.960
<v Speaker 5>hor who stayed in office for almost He's stayed in

0:05:59.000 --> 0:06:02.640
<v Speaker 5>office longer than I've been born, so it is he

0:06:02.800 --> 0:06:07.000
<v Speaker 5>has been forty forty five years in office, and that

0:06:07.080 --> 0:06:09.480
<v Speaker 5>has caused people to have to say, this is a moment.

0:06:09.560 --> 0:06:11.560
<v Speaker 6>And I will tell you this, the suffering.

0:06:12.040 --> 0:06:13.919
<v Speaker 5>I know that we have people I'm running against that

0:06:13.920 --> 0:06:16.440
<v Speaker 5>I don't know very well. But what I know is

0:06:16.480 --> 0:06:19.440
<v Speaker 5>that they're mostly laid off in federal workers that are

0:06:19.480 --> 0:06:22.000
<v Speaker 5>just sick of it and deciding they want to get involved.

0:06:22.360 --> 0:06:25.359
<v Speaker 5>It is the suffering that's going on that's costing the

0:06:25.400 --> 0:06:28.280
<v Speaker 5>twenty four people to run because people are seeing we've

0:06:28.320 --> 0:06:31.760
<v Speaker 5>never seen this before. Like twenty years ago, this was

0:06:32.120 --> 0:06:35.880
<v Speaker 5>the Middle America where they were taking away those factory jobs,

0:06:35.920 --> 0:06:37.599
<v Speaker 5>and those factory jobs were leaving the country.

0:06:37.720 --> 0:06:39.200
<v Speaker 6>Now it's us.

0:06:39.680 --> 0:06:42.720
<v Speaker 5>We are little federal workers are losing jobs and they

0:06:42.880 --> 0:06:45.880
<v Speaker 5>cannot find anything that would pay them or give them

0:06:45.920 --> 0:06:49.080
<v Speaker 5>anything before and the ones who've keeping their jobs, they

0:06:49.120 --> 0:06:52.720
<v Speaker 5>feel that they have been pretty much nobody appreciates them.

0:06:53.160 --> 0:06:56.320
<v Speaker 5>And meanwhile, this is happening. We're spending a billion dollars

0:06:56.400 --> 0:07:00.240
<v Speaker 5>a day in the around war. While we've got peopleeople

0:07:00.279 --> 0:07:03.040
<v Speaker 5>who have been told their jobs were cut to save money.

0:07:03.720 --> 0:07:05.880
<v Speaker 3>Oh, go ahead, correct me if I'm wrong. In your district,

0:07:06.720 --> 0:07:10.640
<v Speaker 3>whenever there's a government shut down at a lot of

0:07:10.680 --> 0:07:14.680
<v Speaker 3>your workers are contractors, and the actual employees will get

0:07:14.680 --> 0:07:17.520
<v Speaker 3>back paid, but the contractors get stiffed usually.

0:07:18.160 --> 0:07:21.480
<v Speaker 5>Yeah, but understand don't because the employees, if they hear this,

0:07:21.640 --> 0:07:25.000
<v Speaker 5>they will just cringe, right, because the reality is that

0:07:25.400 --> 0:07:28.520
<v Speaker 5>as you're waiting, there's a late bill, there's bill payments

0:07:28.840 --> 0:07:32.440
<v Speaker 5>that need to be paid back. Yeah, and then they

0:07:32.480 --> 0:07:34.920
<v Speaker 5>are looking at back pay. But the reality is that

0:07:35.640 --> 0:07:38.800
<v Speaker 5>getting all those late fees waiting for things to come,

0:07:38.880 --> 0:07:41.200
<v Speaker 5>money come. I mean, there were people that called and said,

0:07:41.760 --> 0:07:43.600
<v Speaker 5>I know what's to shut down, but while I'm about

0:07:43.640 --> 0:07:45.920
<v Speaker 5>to get my LFE turned off because we're already behind.

0:07:46.160 --> 0:07:48.560
<v Speaker 5>So is that then the federal contractors, Yes, they don't

0:07:48.560 --> 0:07:51.600
<v Speaker 5>get job and federal contracts even worse. We have about

0:07:51.600 --> 0:07:53.720
<v Speaker 5>in Prince George's County alone, we have about a seventy

0:07:53.720 --> 0:07:57.520
<v Speaker 5>five thousand federal workers, and in each county they have

0:07:57.680 --> 0:08:00.320
<v Speaker 5>a big number. But what's even bigger is a federal

0:08:00.320 --> 0:08:03.200
<v Speaker 5>contractors and federal contracts don't have the same protection, so

0:08:03.200 --> 0:08:05.440
<v Speaker 5>they don't get the notice. They don't get a lot

0:08:05.440 --> 0:08:07.320
<v Speaker 5>of them are getting last minute notice that they have

0:08:07.400 --> 0:08:10.640
<v Speaker 5>been the contracts have been ended, and they don't get

0:08:10.680 --> 0:08:15.080
<v Speaker 5>all of these packages and all that that's required with

0:08:15.120 --> 0:08:18.080
<v Speaker 5>a federal worker. So we have federal contractors who are

0:08:18.120 --> 0:08:20.240
<v Speaker 5>just getting quick notice that they've been laid that they're

0:08:20.280 --> 0:08:22.960
<v Speaker 5>going to be laid off, and no money to really go.

0:08:23.120 --> 0:08:24.560
<v Speaker 6>Like, people are struggling.

0:08:24.920 --> 0:08:28.800
<v Speaker 5>We did put out something about paying bills from my

0:08:29.000 --> 0:08:31.880
<v Speaker 5>with the nonprofit because we fund a nonprofit and we

0:08:31.960 --> 0:08:34.400
<v Speaker 5>had to say no to a lot of people.

0:08:35.600 --> 0:08:36.920
<v Speaker 6>So it is struggle right now.

0:08:37.000 --> 0:08:38.880
<v Speaker 5>I think that it is something that many people are

0:08:38.920 --> 0:08:42.320
<v Speaker 5>not used to, so they're trying to kind of go

0:08:42.440 --> 0:08:48.160
<v Speaker 5>through it. So right now, what a Horrior endorsement ten

0:08:48.240 --> 0:08:50.760
<v Speaker 5>years ago would have sealed to deal right it would

0:08:50.760 --> 0:08:52.280
<v Speaker 5>have been, it would be over.

0:08:52.280 --> 0:08:53.560
<v Speaker 6>Because I've been a.

0:08:53.480 --> 0:08:56.040
<v Speaker 5>Council member for four years now in Push George's County,

0:08:56.040 --> 0:08:59.720
<v Speaker 5>and prior to that, I was a labor lawyer involved

0:08:59.720 --> 0:09:00.480
<v Speaker 5>in the community.

0:09:00.480 --> 0:09:01.880
<v Speaker 6>I had a show chat with the lawyer.

0:09:02.080 --> 0:09:04.360
<v Speaker 5>I've run against a ticket before, and when I ran

0:09:04.360 --> 0:09:07.640
<v Speaker 5>against a ticket that with normal times, people just say,

0:09:07.679 --> 0:09:09.719
<v Speaker 5>look I know these people. I'm going to vote for

0:09:09.760 --> 0:09:13.000
<v Speaker 5>whoever they recommend. Now, we went door knocking yesterday. People

0:09:13.040 --> 0:09:15.640
<v Speaker 5>are asking questions. They say, we got to research candidates

0:09:15.640 --> 0:09:16.880
<v Speaker 5>because the hurt.

0:09:16.679 --> 0:09:17.160
<v Speaker 6>Is too much.

0:09:17.480 --> 0:09:19.280
<v Speaker 7>Yeah, and I was gonna ask. I mean, so your

0:09:19.320 --> 0:09:22.480
<v Speaker 7>opponent might say data centers. If people are struggling in

0:09:22.480 --> 0:09:26.480
<v Speaker 7>PG County, they need jobs. Data centers bring jobs, data

0:09:26.480 --> 0:09:27.959
<v Speaker 7>centers bring tax relief.

0:09:28.000 --> 0:09:29.600
<v Speaker 6>We've been played before, right.

0:09:29.440 --> 0:09:30.319
<v Speaker 4>So tell us.

0:09:30.559 --> 0:09:32.520
<v Speaker 7>And I was also curious, when you're talking about this

0:09:32.600 --> 0:09:35.920
<v Speaker 7>on the campaign trail, what you're hearing from people, because

0:09:36.320 --> 0:09:38.640
<v Speaker 7>we're not being told by Kevin O'Leary and others that

0:09:38.720 --> 0:09:42.320
<v Speaker 7>this is just a giant Chinese psychological operation on the

0:09:42.320 --> 0:09:45.760
<v Speaker 7>American public. China is making us mad at data centers.

0:09:45.840 --> 0:09:46.280
<v Speaker 6>What are you.

0:09:46.240 --> 0:09:49.520
<v Speaker 5>Hearing, Well, we're here, so we're put it like this.

0:09:49.520 --> 0:09:53.760
<v Speaker 5>This was before this election. People found out in Prince

0:09:53.760 --> 0:09:56.360
<v Speaker 5>George's County they have fast tracked data centers, that Prime

0:09:56.400 --> 0:10:00.840
<v Speaker 5>administration have fast tracked data centers. The Council done counting executive.

0:10:01.120 --> 0:10:02.880
<v Speaker 5>When we came in, we didn't even know about the

0:10:02.880 --> 0:10:05.600
<v Speaker 5>fast tracking. But what happened was all of a sudden,

0:10:05.720 --> 0:10:09.920
<v Speaker 5>the work out to the community that one of the

0:10:10.040 --> 0:10:13.560
<v Speaker 5>data centers was at permitting and we found people called

0:10:13.600 --> 0:10:17.160
<v Speaker 5>the office demanding screaming. We had an event where people

0:10:17.200 --> 0:10:20.280
<v Speaker 5>took over. About almost a thousand people showed up screaming

0:10:20.320 --> 0:10:23.360
<v Speaker 5>and yelling, and they were like, why why do we

0:10:23.400 --> 0:10:26.480
<v Speaker 5>have this? We were already looking into the issue, and

0:10:26.520 --> 0:10:29.040
<v Speaker 5>I think we had a qualified data center task force

0:10:29.280 --> 0:10:31.480
<v Speaker 5>to look into the issue. But then I did a

0:10:31.640 --> 0:10:34.600
<v Speaker 5>pause because I was like, no, fast tracking, everything has

0:10:34.640 --> 0:10:38.439
<v Speaker 5>to stop the reality is that what's getting people the bills.

0:10:39.200 --> 0:10:44.200
<v Speaker 5>People are seeing a thousand dollar bill a month at

0:10:44.320 --> 0:10:45.760
<v Speaker 5>people who I used to have.

0:10:45.720 --> 0:10:47.320
<v Speaker 6>A bill that was less than one hundred dollars.

0:10:47.400 --> 0:10:50.360
<v Speaker 5>Even I myself and admit to you, yes that I

0:10:50.400 --> 0:10:53.440
<v Speaker 5>got a six hundred dollar bill in January, and so

0:10:54.120 --> 0:10:56.679
<v Speaker 5>if you were getting that I had an eighty five,

0:10:57.640 --> 0:10:59.400
<v Speaker 5>I mean it is really I had an eighty five

0:10:59.480 --> 0:11:02.960
<v Speaker 5>year old woman who said that she's got a fifteen

0:11:03.040 --> 0:11:04.880
<v Speaker 5>hundred dollar bill. She doesn't know if you have an

0:11:04.920 --> 0:11:09.400
<v Speaker 5>older house, it's even worse. That's what's really driving the frustration,

0:11:09.920 --> 0:11:12.320
<v Speaker 5>and I think people are feeling like what a data center.

0:11:12.360 --> 0:11:14.079
<v Speaker 5>They're seeing a lot of things, a lot of the

0:11:14.840 --> 0:11:17.160
<v Speaker 5>information online. They want to know, how does this impact

0:11:17.200 --> 0:11:19.400
<v Speaker 5>their life, how does it impact their environment, how does.

0:11:19.240 --> 0:11:20.160
<v Speaker 6>It impact their water?

0:11:21.120 --> 0:11:23.439
<v Speaker 5>So what we know is my opponent has been quiet

0:11:23.480 --> 0:11:25.640
<v Speaker 5>on what his work is with data centers. He even

0:11:25.640 --> 0:11:28.920
<v Speaker 5>says it's education. But the reality is that Oracle is

0:11:28.920 --> 0:11:29.959
<v Speaker 5>building data centers.

0:11:30.000 --> 0:11:31.800
<v Speaker 7>So he's not even trying to own it and say, listen,

0:11:31.840 --> 0:11:32.760
<v Speaker 7>I was bringing jobs.

0:11:32.840 --> 0:11:34.320
<v Speaker 4>He's just someone that doesn't want to talk about it.

0:11:34.480 --> 0:11:37.720
<v Speaker 5>We know that the job count for a data center,

0:11:38.200 --> 0:11:40.959
<v Speaker 5>for a regular data center, is about twelve to fifteen,

0:11:42.040 --> 0:11:46.080
<v Speaker 5>and so we are talking about it, and they even

0:11:46.240 --> 0:11:48.320
<v Speaker 5>said that what's even worse is that a lot of

0:11:48.320 --> 0:11:51.679
<v Speaker 5>the jobs are remote, so arguably they can hire somebody

0:11:51.679 --> 0:11:54.920
<v Speaker 5>from another state and so you might not need someone

0:11:54.960 --> 0:11:57.560
<v Speaker 5>in town. Now, the unions will argue, and I know

0:11:57.640 --> 0:11:59.960
<v Speaker 5>that because they were the ones that I found out

0:12:00.080 --> 0:12:01.920
<v Speaker 5>that my opponent worked for data center.

0:12:01.960 --> 0:12:03.000
<v Speaker 6>I found out through the unions.

0:12:03.000 --> 0:12:06.200
<v Speaker 5>The unions actually says, well, this is unionized jobs, but

0:12:06.240 --> 0:12:08.760
<v Speaker 5>the reality is that the construction jobs, those.

0:12:08.600 --> 0:12:11.360
<v Speaker 6>Are temporary jobs. I am pro labor. I am a

0:12:11.480 --> 0:12:13.319
<v Speaker 6>labor lawyer, so I am I.

0:12:13.520 --> 0:12:17.600
<v Speaker 5>Believe any data center built should be built under a

0:12:17.679 --> 0:12:21.559
<v Speaker 5>labor agreement. However, is this good for the residents the

0:12:21.679 --> 0:12:23.600
<v Speaker 5>answer is no, no, no, no.

0:12:24.080 --> 0:12:27.839
<v Speaker 3>So you also made news in Prince Georgie County as

0:12:27.840 --> 0:12:32.160
<v Speaker 3>you were pushing a ceasefire resolution, or talk about what

0:12:32.640 --> 0:12:36.080
<v Speaker 3>you did you know after October seventh, what the pushback

0:12:36.120 --> 0:12:37.920
<v Speaker 3>has been and how that's playing into the rate because

0:12:38.240 --> 0:12:40.520
<v Speaker 3>Adrian Boff of course, because this is a Howard Zen

0:12:41.040 --> 0:12:44.000
<v Speaker 3>story also has a support of democratic majority for Israel.

0:12:44.000 --> 0:12:46.040
<v Speaker 3>I don't know if apacs officially gotten in yet, but

0:12:46.080 --> 0:12:50.520
<v Speaker 3>they have the APAX. Yes, DMFI is basically an apex right.

0:12:50.520 --> 0:12:54.480
<v Speaker 5>Right right, yeah, So we when October seventh, and of

0:12:54.520 --> 0:12:59.479
<v Speaker 5>course I am in no support of killing of Harma's actions. However,

0:13:00.400 --> 0:13:05.920
<v Speaker 5>the story, the visuals of those killings in Gaza got

0:13:05.960 --> 0:13:09.560
<v Speaker 5>to me. We had we did a ceasefire resolution. I

0:13:09.600 --> 0:13:12.319
<v Speaker 5>tried to lobby my colleagues to do a permanent sea

0:13:12.600 --> 0:13:15.720
<v Speaker 5>cease fire resolution. A lot of people were afraid because

0:13:15.720 --> 0:13:20.760
<v Speaker 5>of Abac, but I wasn't because I felt strongly that

0:13:20.840 --> 0:13:22.040
<v Speaker 5>this was wrong.

0:13:22.160 --> 0:13:22.920
<v Speaker 6>On all sides.

0:13:22.960 --> 0:13:26.319
<v Speaker 5>We don't we shouldn't have Hamas killing people, We shouldn't

0:13:26.400 --> 0:13:32.000
<v Speaker 5>have an Israel government killing people. So we did a

0:13:32.040 --> 0:13:35.640
<v Speaker 5>ceasefire rally with the Muslim community and Christian community.

0:13:35.679 --> 0:13:36.880
<v Speaker 6>We had pastors.

0:13:36.920 --> 0:13:41.560
<v Speaker 5>We had everyone come out and so now of course,

0:13:41.800 --> 0:13:46.199
<v Speaker 5>and we're not for putting our money into a war

0:13:46.600 --> 0:13:49.000
<v Speaker 5>that makes no sense, especially when our federal workers are

0:13:49.040 --> 0:13:52.600
<v Speaker 5>not back to work. We are not for just giving

0:13:52.880 --> 0:13:59.079
<v Speaker 5>arms with no restrictions. And that's not being anti semitic,

0:13:59.559 --> 0:14:03.000
<v Speaker 5>that is just being That is just the position that

0:14:03.080 --> 0:14:04.000
<v Speaker 5>America should take.

0:14:04.120 --> 0:14:06.200
<v Speaker 6>They will take you with any other country.

0:14:07.000 --> 0:14:12.040
<v Speaker 3>Right right, Wallible gay candidate for Maryland's fifth congressional district.

0:14:12.400 --> 0:14:13.440
<v Speaker 3>Where can people find more?

0:14:14.280 --> 0:14:17.320
<v Speaker 5>Go to wallablagaye dot com. W A L A B

0:14:17.480 --> 0:14:20.480
<v Speaker 5>L E G A Y. I've been an activist, you

0:14:20.520 --> 0:14:22.160
<v Speaker 5>know a lot in Prince George's county. They know me

0:14:22.200 --> 0:14:24.440
<v Speaker 5>and my work has been known around the community. So

0:14:24.480 --> 0:14:27.480
<v Speaker 5>we're on the ground and what we see. Don't let

0:14:27.560 --> 0:14:32.040
<v Speaker 5>the the the four million dollars of AI crypto and

0:14:32.080 --> 0:14:33.840
<v Speaker 5>all that. So that's what that's the number week at

0:14:34.240 --> 0:14:36.200
<v Speaker 5>fool you into thinking that this is over.

0:14:36.360 --> 0:14:38.520
<v Speaker 6>This race is over. We're talking to voters.

0:14:38.800 --> 0:14:41.200
<v Speaker 3>The election is two weeks yeah roughly. All right, so

0:14:41.360 --> 0:14:43.480
<v Speaker 3>we'll be watching it closely. Thanks so much for being here.

0:14:43.640 --> 0:14:44.200
<v Speaker 6>Thank you.

0:14:47.040 --> 0:14:49.480
<v Speaker 7>We're joined now by Orrin cass He's the founder and

0:14:49.560 --> 0:14:52.800
<v Speaker 7>chief economist over at American Compass or in thanks for

0:14:52.840 --> 0:14:53.400
<v Speaker 7>coming back.

0:14:53.240 --> 0:14:53.640
<v Speaker 4>On the show.

0:14:53.720 --> 0:14:55.280
<v Speaker 8>Thank you guys for having me fresh.

0:14:55.040 --> 0:14:58.000
<v Speaker 7>Off an interview with Treasury Secretary at Scott Bessett last

0:14:58.080 --> 0:15:01.400
<v Speaker 7>night at an American Compass event and disculture. I'm an

0:15:01.440 --> 0:15:03.280
<v Speaker 7>American Compass member and a big.

0:15:03.080 --> 0:15:05.480
<v Speaker 4>Fan of American Compass. Of course, what does it mean

0:15:05.600 --> 0:15:08.040
<v Speaker 4>or I go to events? It means we get a

0:15:08.080 --> 0:15:08.760
<v Speaker 4>free dinner.

0:15:08.520 --> 0:15:09.160
<v Speaker 3>Every once in a while.

0:15:09.600 --> 0:15:13.080
<v Speaker 8>No, no, it's there's no financial relationship. We just we

0:15:13.120 --> 0:15:17.800
<v Speaker 8>are trying to support a network of policy professionals, journalists, lawyers,

0:15:18.280 --> 0:15:22.280
<v Speaker 8>folks in government who are nerds like you.

0:15:22.480 --> 0:15:24.720
<v Speaker 3>Remember it means like you get an AMA for free

0:15:24.800 --> 0:15:25.240
<v Speaker 3>or something.

0:15:25.720 --> 0:15:28.560
<v Speaker 8>We should have something like that. But no, it means

0:15:28.560 --> 0:15:32.440
<v Speaker 8>we're hopefully working together on improving the policy environment.

0:15:32.000 --> 0:15:32.560
<v Speaker 3>In this talent.

0:15:33.000 --> 0:15:33.280
<v Speaker 6>Right.

0:15:33.440 --> 0:15:36.600
<v Speaker 7>And now you are out with a new initiative on

0:15:36.680 --> 0:15:37.720
<v Speaker 7>American citizenship.

0:15:37.720 --> 0:15:39.440
<v Speaker 4>We can put this up on the screen.

0:15:39.680 --> 0:15:44.880
<v Speaker 7>American Compass has this new reclaiming American Citizenship initiative announced

0:15:44.960 --> 0:15:47.800
<v Speaker 7>last night, And we might have to add this in post,

0:15:47.960 --> 0:15:50.640
<v Speaker 7>but just announced and or we're going to ask you

0:15:50.680 --> 0:15:53.640
<v Speaker 7>all about what you're trying to do on the right

0:15:54.520 --> 0:15:57.960
<v Speaker 7>to build a sort of initiative or to build a

0:15:57.960 --> 0:16:00.240
<v Speaker 7>framework for how the right should be thinking about in

0:16:00.280 --> 0:16:02.120
<v Speaker 7>ship right now, especially as.

0:16:01.960 --> 0:16:03.760
<v Speaker 4>Let's put F one on the screen.

0:16:04.280 --> 0:16:10.040
<v Speaker 7>This is protests erupting outside of Delaney Hall in New Jersey,

0:16:10.240 --> 0:16:12.840
<v Speaker 7>and Ryan, you could probably tell us more about the

0:16:12.920 --> 0:16:16.000
<v Speaker 7>left's mobilization here. Obviously this is over the treatment of

0:16:16.080 --> 0:16:19.800
<v Speaker 7>people detained, which again it gets us back to this

0:16:19.920 --> 0:16:22.040
<v Speaker 7>conversation about what it means to be a citizen and

0:16:22.040 --> 0:16:22.400
<v Speaker 7>the like.

0:16:22.440 --> 0:16:24.440
<v Speaker 4>But the left is outside of Delaney Hall. It doesn't

0:16:24.440 --> 0:16:26.160
<v Speaker 4>seem to be going anywhere right.

0:16:26.120 --> 0:16:30.120
<v Speaker 3>There are there are hunger strikes going on inside over

0:16:30.800 --> 0:16:34.120
<v Speaker 3>on the one hand, over conditions, also access to different

0:16:34.200 --> 0:16:39.160
<v Speaker 3>kinds of food, also over the protesting kind of the

0:16:39.280 --> 0:16:43.280
<v Speaker 3>entire apparatus. We could actually roll F four because Hassan

0:16:43.320 --> 0:16:46.000
<v Speaker 3>Piker was there recently. Earlier on the show, we talked

0:16:46.000 --> 0:16:49.040
<v Speaker 3>about Adam Hamoy, new Jersey congressional candidate who just won.

0:16:49.120 --> 0:16:52.440
<v Speaker 3>Last night, Hammoey and Hassan Piker went to the Delaney

0:16:53.040 --> 0:16:56.720
<v Speaker 3>protests and here's Piker reading out some of the demands

0:16:56.760 --> 0:17:00.119
<v Speaker 3>from the hunger strikers and protesters inside.

0:17:00.480 --> 0:17:03.240
<v Speaker 9>What are these Lady Hall hunger strikers demanding? Many people

0:17:03.240 --> 0:17:05.480
<v Speaker 9>have questions about what is happening inside of the Laney Hall.

0:17:05.960 --> 0:17:08.919
<v Speaker 9>The detainees on hunger strike have stated that their demands

0:17:08.920 --> 0:17:11.960
<v Speaker 9>are Number one, to meet with the governor. They want

0:17:12.000 --> 0:17:14.560
<v Speaker 9>to meet with Governor Mickey Cheryl to go inside of

0:17:14.600 --> 0:17:18.240
<v Speaker 9>the facility and meet the actual detainees. Number two, they

0:17:18.240 --> 0:17:21.399
<v Speaker 9>want the release of the medically vulnerable people. They demand

0:17:21.440 --> 0:17:24.720
<v Speaker 9>the immediate release of those with serious medical conditions. Number three,

0:17:25.040 --> 0:17:29.399
<v Speaker 9>release young and elderly detainees. They demand the immediate release

0:17:29.680 --> 0:17:32.920
<v Speaker 9>of young and elderly people. In number four, freedom, We're

0:17:32.920 --> 0:17:36.200
<v Speaker 9>not striking to demand better conditions and treatment. We're going

0:17:36.520 --> 0:17:39.400
<v Speaker 9>We're doing this to demand our freedom. And they've said

0:17:39.440 --> 0:17:42.240
<v Speaker 9>that they're going to continue the strike until they get hurt.

0:17:42.440 --> 0:17:44.840
<v Speaker 9>The hunger strike is not about improving the conditions of

0:17:44.840 --> 0:17:48.120
<v Speaker 9>the facility necessarily, but to meet these demands.

0:17:48.400 --> 0:17:57.800
<v Speaker 2>Most recently, they want medical attention at.

0:17:57.640 --> 0:18:01.280
<v Speaker 3>Play for and protesters have altered only accused New Jersey

0:18:01.280 --> 0:18:04.840
<v Speaker 3>Governor Mikey Cheryl of either you know, collaborating with with

0:18:05.000 --> 0:18:09.199
<v Speaker 3>ice here or abandoning them, but meanwhile put up F

0:18:09.240 --> 0:18:14.919
<v Speaker 3>three here. She has sued the sued the facility over

0:18:15.080 --> 0:18:20.679
<v Speaker 3>unsanitary conditions and in particular for barring access to health inspectors.

0:18:20.680 --> 0:18:23.040
<v Speaker 3>She has said, you know, if there's actually nothing to hide,

0:18:23.080 --> 0:18:26.160
<v Speaker 3>if everything's fine in there, why are you blocking state

0:18:26.520 --> 0:18:32.520
<v Speaker 3>health inspectors from from going from going inside. About ten

0:18:32.560 --> 0:18:36.520
<v Speaker 3>ten thousand plus people have gone through this facility, most

0:18:36.520 --> 0:18:40.119
<v Speaker 3>of them, I think the medians stay is about nine days.

0:18:40.480 --> 0:18:43.000
<v Speaker 3>I think seventy percent or so have no criminal record,

0:18:43.280 --> 0:18:48.400
<v Speaker 3>which means it's some thirty percent due and so foreign.

0:18:49.880 --> 0:18:54.359
<v Speaker 3>You know, thank thanks for being here. The piece, the

0:18:54.359 --> 0:18:58.560
<v Speaker 3>piece that you wrote, you know, it's it's this an

0:18:58.560 --> 0:19:01.120
<v Speaker 3>elevent you can describe becase, this elevation of the idea

0:19:01.480 --> 0:19:04.760
<v Speaker 3>of citizenship. As I and as I was reading it,

0:19:06.880 --> 0:19:09.760
<v Speaker 3>I was thinking, like, as far as I understand, as

0:19:09.800 --> 0:19:13.240
<v Speaker 3>far as I remember, the idea of citizen kind of

0:19:13.480 --> 0:19:16.359
<v Speaker 3>originates sort of with the French Revolution, I think the

0:19:16.359 --> 0:19:21.080
<v Speaker 3>American Revolution which inspired the French Revolution. But people, you know,

0:19:21.119 --> 0:19:23.639
<v Speaker 3>people in the streets of Paris were calling themselves like

0:19:23.720 --> 0:19:27.200
<v Speaker 3>citizen so and so, citizens so and so, And the

0:19:27.280 --> 0:19:31.439
<v Speaker 3>purpose was to do pretty much what you're suggesting in

0:19:31.480 --> 0:19:34.679
<v Speaker 3>the in the essay here, which is to establish kind

0:19:34.720 --> 0:19:38.800
<v Speaker 3>of a level of baseline humanity and equality among the people,

0:19:38.880 --> 0:19:42.080
<v Speaker 3>and to say the Republican. Yeah, well there's that too,

0:19:42.520 --> 0:19:44.760
<v Speaker 3>and to say that we write and a call back

0:19:44.800 --> 0:19:48.879
<v Speaker 3>to that, to say that we we have duties and

0:19:48.960 --> 0:19:53.359
<v Speaker 3>responsibilities to you know, to the to the state. There

0:19:53.359 --> 0:19:55.720
<v Speaker 3>are things that we are obliged to do for the state,

0:19:55.880 --> 0:19:57.600
<v Speaker 3>and there are things the state that is obliged to

0:19:57.600 --> 0:19:59.879
<v Speaker 3>do for us because we are citizens. And it's a

0:20:00.080 --> 0:20:01.879
<v Speaker 3>and it's a two way street. I don't know, how

0:20:01.920 --> 0:20:03.880
<v Speaker 3>do you like, how do you think about it?

0:20:04.320 --> 0:20:06.080
<v Speaker 8>I guess I would put a little differently, I think,

0:20:06.119 --> 0:20:08.680
<v Speaker 8>for one thing, to Emily's point, you know, the citizen

0:20:08.720 --> 0:20:11.320
<v Speaker 8>concept goes back to Rome and the Roman Republic, and

0:20:11.359 --> 0:20:15.200
<v Speaker 8>it was certainly very central to the American founding.

0:20:15.320 --> 0:20:17.719
<v Speaker 3>I guess it's a contemporary issue.

0:20:17.800 --> 0:20:20.639
<v Speaker 8>Well sure, I mean French Revolution. French Revolution is a

0:20:20.640 --> 0:20:22.919
<v Speaker 8>strange place to go as the start. You're right, they

0:20:22.960 --> 0:20:25.720
<v Speaker 8>called each other's citizens. But I think also, you know,

0:20:25.800 --> 0:20:29.399
<v Speaker 8>this captures a way in which the French relation is

0:20:29.400 --> 0:20:33.080
<v Speaker 8>obviously less successful. I think most people would say, and

0:20:33.320 --> 0:20:36.080
<v Speaker 8>how you're describing as kind of just a fundamental claim

0:20:36.119 --> 0:20:38.679
<v Speaker 8>of equality of things that that the people owe to

0:20:38.720 --> 0:20:42.720
<v Speaker 8>the state. I think this is what's most important about citizenship,

0:20:42.760 --> 0:20:45.600
<v Speaker 8>which is that it's a it's a reciprocal obligation among

0:20:45.840 --> 0:20:48.760
<v Speaker 8>the people. And and that goes back again to this

0:20:48.840 --> 0:20:51.399
<v Speaker 8>notion I mean of what is a republic? Right. The

0:20:51.920 --> 0:20:54.960
<v Speaker 8>one thing that's so unique about the United States is

0:20:55.000 --> 0:20:57.320
<v Speaker 8>that it's really, you know, the nation that was brought

0:20:57.359 --> 0:21:01.480
<v Speaker 8>into being by the sheer will of citizens who wanted

0:21:01.480 --> 0:21:07.040
<v Speaker 8>to create this thing to serve them. And I think,

0:21:07.640 --> 0:21:09.719
<v Speaker 8>you know, if you go back and you look historically

0:21:09.840 --> 0:21:13.400
<v Speaker 8>really up to very close in the twentieth century, certainly

0:21:14.000 --> 0:21:16.000
<v Speaker 8>you know in the US there was very much an

0:21:16.080 --> 0:21:19.320
<v Speaker 8>understanding of citizenship. You again, it has its legal meaning

0:21:19.359 --> 0:21:24.520
<v Speaker 8>who can live where, but citizenship really meant something much broader.

0:21:24.560 --> 0:21:28.280
<v Speaker 8>It meant full participation in communal life, in economic life,

0:21:28.320 --> 0:21:33.439
<v Speaker 8>in national life. It meant a sense of solidarity. It meant,

0:21:34.119 --> 0:21:38.600
<v Speaker 8>you know, ultimately that you also had this connection between generations,

0:21:38.640 --> 0:21:41.280
<v Speaker 8>that you were inheriting something from the people who had

0:21:41.280 --> 0:21:43.320
<v Speaker 8>invested to give it to you, that you in turn

0:21:43.359 --> 0:21:46.399
<v Speaker 8>had an obligation to invest and give it to the

0:21:46.440 --> 0:21:50.760
<v Speaker 8>next generation. And it seems to me that and what

0:21:50.840 --> 0:21:53.560
<v Speaker 8>we're really focused on American compass, is that that's just

0:21:53.720 --> 0:21:59.520
<v Speaker 8>fundamental to human flourishing, to a well functioning society, and

0:22:00.080 --> 0:22:02.720
<v Speaker 8>I think it's something that we've lost. And you know,

0:22:02.720 --> 0:22:04.879
<v Speaker 8>we obviously do a lot of work on economic policy,

0:22:05.000 --> 0:22:07.199
<v Speaker 8>I think in terms of what do policymakers need to

0:22:07.200 --> 0:22:09.639
<v Speaker 8>do better, economic policy is a huge piece of it.

0:22:10.480 --> 0:22:12.800
<v Speaker 8>But the reality is that you also need a political

0:22:12.840 --> 0:22:14.960
<v Speaker 8>culture that's going to be able to make those kinds

0:22:14.960 --> 0:22:18.320
<v Speaker 8>of changes. You need people who are bought into the system.

0:22:18.480 --> 0:22:20.920
<v Speaker 8>This thing we spoke about a lot with Secretary Bessett

0:22:21.000 --> 0:22:24.240
<v Speaker 8>last night that especially when you talk to young people,

0:22:24.760 --> 0:22:26.520
<v Speaker 8>you know, the problem isn't that they don't have enough

0:22:26.560 --> 0:22:31.639
<v Speaker 8>stuff right like that we have more material abundance than ever,

0:22:31.960 --> 0:22:34.679
<v Speaker 8>I think, but they're very well founded. Frustration is that

0:22:34.760 --> 0:22:38.360
<v Speaker 8>it's not clear what any of it's for. And so

0:22:38.440 --> 0:22:41.760
<v Speaker 8>when we think about reclaiming American citizenship, and the reclaiming

0:22:41.800 --> 0:22:44.240
<v Speaker 8>is very important because I think there really is something

0:22:44.240 --> 0:22:47.359
<v Speaker 8>that was sort of stripped away that over really the

0:22:47.440 --> 0:22:53.399
<v Speaker 8>past generation, we've degraded that kind of relationship into something

0:22:53.440 --> 0:22:55.679
<v Speaker 8>that is just more you know, you are a consumer,

0:22:56.160 --> 0:23:00.280
<v Speaker 8>not an actual productive participant necessarily in the act to me,

0:23:01.119 --> 0:23:03.520
<v Speaker 8>you know, you are sort of this individual with radical

0:23:03.560 --> 0:23:06.320
<v Speaker 8>autonomy to invent your own truth, not somebody who is

0:23:06.320 --> 0:23:10.360
<v Speaker 8>a member of a community and lives within those obligations,

0:23:10.560 --> 0:23:13.119
<v Speaker 8>and at the national level, to some extent, even you know,

0:23:13.200 --> 0:23:17.680
<v Speaker 8>outright shame or disdain for what is an incredible heritage

0:23:17.720 --> 0:23:21.879
<v Speaker 8>that we have inherited and should be trying to carry forward.

0:23:22.080 --> 0:23:25.320
<v Speaker 8>And so I think in substantive terms, I mean, there's

0:23:25.359 --> 0:23:28.280
<v Speaker 8>a lot of policy that canct that has caused some

0:23:28.320 --> 0:23:30.119
<v Speaker 8>of these problems, that could address.

0:23:29.760 --> 0:23:30.280
<v Speaker 10>Some of them.

0:23:30.840 --> 0:23:33.200
<v Speaker 8>But also just as a matter of how we approach

0:23:33.200 --> 0:23:35.960
<v Speaker 8>our politics, I think, you know, what is really missing

0:23:36.000 --> 0:23:40.480
<v Speaker 8>out there right now is an aspirational, positive vision that's

0:23:40.560 --> 0:23:43.119
<v Speaker 8>not you know, the traditional rights center message has just

0:23:43.119 --> 0:23:44.800
<v Speaker 8>been like, well, we'll just get government out of the

0:23:44.840 --> 0:23:48.200
<v Speaker 8>way and everyone will flourish. That that's obviously not sufficient.

0:23:48.359 --> 0:23:48.560
<v Speaker 3>You know.

0:23:48.600 --> 0:23:51.040
<v Speaker 8>The message from the left of center tends to be more,

0:23:51.200 --> 0:23:53.040
<v Speaker 8>you know, we'll hear the things that are lacking that

0:23:53.080 --> 0:23:56.400
<v Speaker 8>we will therefore give you. I don't think that's sufficient either,

0:23:56.440 --> 0:23:59.239
<v Speaker 8>and so we're trying to figure out, you know, what

0:23:59.359 --> 0:24:01.359
<v Speaker 8>is the message that actually acknowledge and speak to the

0:24:01.480 --> 0:24:06.400
<v Speaker 8>very real problems, but in a way that actually reclaims

0:24:06.640 --> 0:24:07.679
<v Speaker 8>some of what we've lost.

0:24:08.280 --> 0:24:12.600
<v Speaker 7>And the Delaney protests remind me of a distinction that

0:24:12.640 --> 0:24:15.560
<v Speaker 7>I think has been raised, whether it was in Minneapolis

0:24:15.680 --> 0:24:17.800
<v Speaker 7>or elsewhere. And I actually don't mean this in the

0:24:17.840 --> 0:24:21.000
<v Speaker 7>context of Delaney, because I believe people in our detention

0:24:21.200 --> 0:24:24.879
<v Speaker 7>should be treated humanly, of course, but there has been

0:24:24.880 --> 0:24:28.119
<v Speaker 7>a blurring of the distinction between resident and citizen. That

0:24:28.119 --> 0:24:31.280
<v Speaker 7>I find very interesting is sometimes it seems as though, yes,

0:24:31.359 --> 0:24:33.760
<v Speaker 7>we should be affording certain rights people who are in detention,

0:24:33.920 --> 0:24:36.639
<v Speaker 7>people who are here on green cards, visas and the like,

0:24:36.720 --> 0:24:39.720
<v Speaker 7>especially if we said we were going to But also

0:24:39.880 --> 0:24:42.320
<v Speaker 7>there is a distinction between somebody who's living here in

0:24:42.359 --> 0:24:45.280
<v Speaker 7>the United States legally or in some cases illegally, and

0:24:45.359 --> 0:24:49.280
<v Speaker 7>a citizen. And I think the meaning of citizen is why,

0:24:49.320 --> 0:24:51.879
<v Speaker 7>I mean, the degraded meaning of citizen is probably why

0:24:52.160 --> 0:24:53.639
<v Speaker 7>that distinction has been blurred.

0:24:53.640 --> 0:24:54.679
<v Speaker 4>I don't know if you have any thoughts on.

0:24:54.760 --> 0:24:56.640
<v Speaker 8>Foreign No, I think it's a great point. I think,

0:24:56.760 --> 0:24:58.800
<v Speaker 8>you know, so much of what we're seeing in our

0:24:58.840 --> 0:25:04.080
<v Speaker 8>struggles with illegal andration now are really way downstream of okay,

0:25:04.080 --> 0:25:06.879
<v Speaker 8>but what is citizenship in the first place, Because I

0:25:06.960 --> 0:25:09.399
<v Speaker 8>you know, I don't think it would be controversial to

0:25:09.400 --> 0:25:11.840
<v Speaker 8>say on the left of center there has been much

0:25:11.880 --> 0:25:14.879
<v Speaker 8>more a view that anybody has a right to come here,

0:25:16.359 --> 0:25:20.480
<v Speaker 8>and the reality is that for citizenship to work, for

0:25:20.560 --> 0:25:24.920
<v Speaker 8>that sense of solidarity to exist, it's actually incredibly important,

0:25:25.240 --> 0:25:27.800
<v Speaker 8>both in theory and in practice, that the people who

0:25:27.840 --> 0:25:30.800
<v Speaker 8>are the citizens of the nation have the right to

0:25:30.880 --> 0:25:34.080
<v Speaker 8>decide who becomes a citizen. If you're telling me, I'm

0:25:34.119 --> 0:25:37.199
<v Speaker 8>supposed to have some relationship to the other people, but

0:25:37.400 --> 0:25:39.359
<v Speaker 8>also I have no say in who those people are

0:25:39.359 --> 0:25:41.919
<v Speaker 8>going to be, that breaks down very quickly, and so

0:25:41.960 --> 0:25:44.440
<v Speaker 8>that's not necessarily an argument for or against any level

0:25:44.440 --> 0:25:47.720
<v Speaker 8>of immigration. Right you could have a very well functioning

0:25:47.760 --> 0:25:51.320
<v Speaker 8>system that has many immigrants coming in, but it needs

0:25:51.359 --> 0:25:54.640
<v Speaker 8>to be happening in a way that citizens who already

0:25:54.880 --> 0:25:57.600
<v Speaker 8>here feel like and in fact do have control over.

0:25:58.200 --> 0:25:59.800
<v Speaker 8>And then it has to be happening in a way

0:25:59.800 --> 0:26:04.120
<v Speaker 8>that actually imposes obligations on those people as well. That says,

0:26:04.160 --> 0:26:05.960
<v Speaker 8>if you want to come and be a part of

0:26:06.000 --> 0:26:10.359
<v Speaker 8>this community, you know it is not simply having that

0:26:10.400 --> 0:26:14.840
<v Speaker 8>piece of paper. There are obviously enormous benefits and privileges

0:26:14.880 --> 0:26:18.200
<v Speaker 8>that come with being here, with being a citizen, and

0:26:18.400 --> 0:26:21.840
<v Speaker 8>that also then comes with obligations that we have to

0:26:21.840 --> 0:26:24.439
<v Speaker 8>be willing to uphold. And so when I see, you know,

0:26:24.480 --> 0:26:27.080
<v Speaker 8>the Hassan Piker protest. That to me, it's just a

0:26:27.119 --> 0:26:30.400
<v Speaker 8>perfect illustration of you know, look, if the approach you're

0:26:30.400 --> 0:26:32.280
<v Speaker 8>going to have is, well, all of these people are,

0:26:32.600 --> 0:26:35.440
<v Speaker 8>you know, entitled their freedom, I think it's safe to

0:26:35.480 --> 0:26:38.560
<v Speaker 8>say also, you know, anybody who's concerned whether they can

0:26:38.600 --> 0:26:41.320
<v Speaker 8>speak English, anyone who's willing to embrace and share a culture,

0:26:41.359 --> 0:26:44.800
<v Speaker 8>that these are somehow you know, racist or uncouth things

0:26:44.840 --> 0:26:48.200
<v Speaker 8>to demand. These are actually the core things to demand.

0:26:48.760 --> 0:26:51.320
<v Speaker 8>And one thing we really want to focus on is like,

0:26:51.560 --> 0:26:53.000
<v Speaker 8>and by the way, even if you are sort of

0:26:53.040 --> 0:26:55.080
<v Speaker 8>a you know, more to the left of center, you

0:26:55.119 --> 0:26:58.359
<v Speaker 8>want a much larger and more generous welfare state, you

0:26:58.359 --> 0:27:01.840
<v Speaker 8>should almost be more concerned about demanding those things. I mean,

0:27:01.840 --> 0:27:05.360
<v Speaker 8>it makes some sense. The libertarians are crazy, but they

0:27:05.359 --> 0:27:08.480
<v Speaker 8>have an internal coherence. Right libertarians will say, like, we

0:27:08.560 --> 0:27:11.000
<v Speaker 8>want help in borders, and we want no welfare state

0:27:11.040 --> 0:27:14.280
<v Speaker 8>that provides anything to anybody, Like, well, that's a terrible

0:27:14.320 --> 0:27:17.960
<v Speaker 8>idea of like that sounds awful, but also like at

0:27:18.040 --> 0:27:20.040
<v Speaker 8>least like you're putting your money where your mouth is

0:27:20.080 --> 0:27:23.200
<v Speaker 8>sort of. And I think what's been a huge problem

0:27:23.200 --> 0:27:25.159
<v Speaker 8>for the left of center is to say no, no,

0:27:25.200 --> 0:27:27.760
<v Speaker 8>we are going to uphold all of these things that

0:27:27.840 --> 0:27:32.080
<v Speaker 8>we must give to everybody, but we absolutely reject this

0:27:32.200 --> 0:27:35.200
<v Speaker 8>idea that we are going to, you know, impose anything

0:27:35.200 --> 0:27:38.720
<v Speaker 8>that's going to maintain the kind of solidarity and bonds

0:27:38.840 --> 0:27:41.760
<v Speaker 8>of genuine citizenship. And that's where then in turn, you

0:27:41.800 --> 0:27:44.280
<v Speaker 8>just see trust start to break down. You see both

0:27:44.320 --> 0:27:46.680
<v Speaker 8>at the community level, trust in the government. You see

0:27:46.680 --> 0:27:50.040
<v Speaker 8>people feel like, why am I even paying taxes? What

0:27:50.160 --> 0:27:50.879
<v Speaker 8>is this going to?

0:27:52.000 --> 0:27:55.520
<v Speaker 7>And real Grand Valley Hispanics voting for Trump, and then.

0:27:55.400 --> 0:27:57.919
<v Speaker 8>You see it is a really important point that a

0:27:58.000 --> 0:28:00.520
<v Speaker 8>lot of you know, people who have immigrate to this

0:28:00.520 --> 0:28:03.400
<v Speaker 8>country it have become citizens the right way, or often

0:28:03.440 --> 0:28:06.760
<v Speaker 8>those who get this more than anybody and are especially

0:28:06.800 --> 0:28:10.840
<v Speaker 8>frustrated by people who are not doing those things.

0:28:10.920 --> 0:28:12.600
<v Speaker 6>And so, you know, I.

0:28:12.560 --> 0:28:16.280
<v Speaker 8>Think it's really important to think about this as really

0:28:16.320 --> 0:28:18.560
<v Speaker 8>at the root of a lot of the problems we're

0:28:18.600 --> 0:28:22.520
<v Speaker 8>having here, but also to divorce it from what has

0:28:22.560 --> 0:28:25.800
<v Speaker 8>been the fight about immigration for so long, which is like, well,

0:28:25.840 --> 0:28:29.159
<v Speaker 8>either your pro immigration and that is the sort of

0:28:29.680 --> 0:28:33.320
<v Speaker 8>humane we care about every rights, or you're anti immigration

0:28:33.480 --> 0:28:37.880
<v Speaker 8>and that's somehow xenophobic or racist or whatever else. Either

0:28:37.920 --> 0:28:42.400
<v Speaker 8>you're pro a good concept of citizenship which can absolutely

0:28:42.400 --> 0:28:45.040
<v Speaker 8>incorporate immigration, but does it in a way that's going

0:28:45.080 --> 0:28:49.040
<v Speaker 8>to work, or you're against that and you're ending up

0:28:49.040 --> 0:28:51.360
<v Speaker 8>where we are today, which is a giant mess.

0:28:51.920 --> 0:28:55.720
<v Speaker 3>One kind of adjacent disagreement I would have with you

0:28:55.800 --> 0:29:00.000
<v Speaker 3>guys talking about that we would treat citizens and nonsense.

0:29:00.040 --> 0:29:01.840
<v Speaker 3>Is it's Differently, I think it's kind of a fundamental

0:29:01.840 --> 0:29:06.000
<v Speaker 3>American thing that the Constitution says, you know, all people

0:29:06.440 --> 0:29:09.800
<v Speaker 3>who are here, however they're here, even murderers in prison,

0:29:10.400 --> 0:29:12.800
<v Speaker 3>like have the Bill of Rights applies to them? Our

0:29:12.880 --> 0:29:13.719
<v Speaker 3>Constitution applies.

0:29:13.840 --> 0:29:16.880
<v Speaker 7>I just mean like non citizens voting in DC elections something.

0:29:16.600 --> 0:29:22.200
<v Speaker 3>Like that, right, right, And yes, and we could that

0:29:22.320 --> 0:29:24.120
<v Speaker 3>that's an interesting one too, because like if you if

0:29:24.160 --> 0:29:25.600
<v Speaker 3>you live there and you have a stake, you want

0:29:25.640 --> 0:29:29.480
<v Speaker 3>people to have a stake in the society. But I

0:29:29.480 --> 0:29:31.760
<v Speaker 3>feel like, and often when I'm reading American compas stuff,

0:29:31.760 --> 0:29:34.400
<v Speaker 3>I'm like, how is this right wing? I agree with

0:29:34.440 --> 0:29:35.880
<v Speaker 3>all of this stuff for the most.

0:29:35.680 --> 0:29:38.600
<v Speaker 4>Part, like the libertarians who are or.

0:29:38.640 --> 0:29:41.920
<v Speaker 3>In critics, Yeah, real, there you go. But so I

0:29:41.960 --> 0:29:47.760
<v Speaker 3>do feel like there is a a compromise that kind

0:29:47.760 --> 0:29:50.960
<v Speaker 3>of reinvigorates the kind of Bernie Sanders kind of a

0:29:51.120 --> 0:29:55.720
<v Speaker 3>fl Cio mid two thousands kind of position, and one

0:29:56.120 --> 0:29:59.440
<v Speaker 3>in one place I disagree, somewhat disagree, and maybe I'm wrong,

0:30:00.360 --> 0:30:04.120
<v Speaker 3>but it particularly during the Biden administration, and there's a

0:30:04.160 --> 0:30:10.680
<v Speaker 3>belief on the right that the Biden administration deliberately unleashed

0:30:11.640 --> 0:30:14.880
<v Speaker 3>and pulled in a massive wave of mirants because they

0:30:15.720 --> 0:30:19.400
<v Speaker 3>wanted to destroy the country and that they thought these

0:30:19.400 --> 0:30:21.480
<v Speaker 3>people are going to then become Democratic voters and they're

0:30:21.480 --> 0:30:23.360
<v Speaker 3>going to lock down the country forever. Like I think

0:30:23.360 --> 0:30:26.240
<v Speaker 3>that is a genuinely held view among a lot of

0:30:26.800 --> 0:30:28.720
<v Speaker 3>people on the right, which I just think is incorrect

0:30:28.760 --> 0:30:33.320
<v Speaker 3>and to your point, like analytically, like a lot of

0:30:33.920 --> 0:30:37.000
<v Speaker 3>people who come in and are immigrants and become citizens,

0:30:37.000 --> 0:30:41.080
<v Speaker 3>they voted Republicans, like like even from even on its

0:30:41.080 --> 0:30:45.560
<v Speaker 3>own terms, like this idea that millions of people coming

0:30:45.600 --> 0:30:48.760
<v Speaker 3>in is automatically and Matt And also they can't vote,

0:30:49.480 --> 0:30:51.160
<v Speaker 3>and let's say, okay, their kids are going to vote,

0:30:51.160 --> 0:30:53.280
<v Speaker 3>and let's say it's Chuck Schumer's like twenty year plan,

0:30:54.160 --> 0:30:56.880
<v Speaker 3>Like it's not. There's no guarantee that they're going to

0:30:56.920 --> 0:30:59.920
<v Speaker 3>be Democrats, Like you're going to cheat to like, you know,

0:31:00.280 --> 0:31:04.400
<v Speaker 3>take over the country. This would be the craziest way

0:31:04.440 --> 0:31:07.200
<v Speaker 3>to go about doing it. I think what actually happened

0:31:07.240 --> 0:31:11.440
<v Speaker 3>is that Trump did slow immigration significantly in his first term,

0:31:11.800 --> 0:31:14.680
<v Speaker 3>and then COVID shut it down completely in like March

0:31:14.720 --> 0:31:17.680
<v Speaker 3>of two thousand and and you had.

0:31:17.560 --> 0:31:18.920
<v Speaker 4>Border crossings were going up.

0:31:19.160 --> 0:31:21.920
<v Speaker 7>There were caravans that were sending a lot of migrantce

0:31:21.920 --> 0:31:22.840
<v Speaker 7>border crossings were growing up.

0:31:22.840 --> 0:31:24.800
<v Speaker 4>I don't know about the net, but yeah, I.

0:31:24.720 --> 0:31:27.480
<v Speaker 3>Mean, but and then you had the economic collapse in

0:31:27.520 --> 0:31:30.200
<v Speaker 3>Venzuela and Cuba, and you had this mass push to

0:31:30.240 --> 0:31:33.320
<v Speaker 3>the border and then it pours over. But my point

0:31:33.400 --> 0:31:37.840
<v Speaker 3>is whether, however you feel about that. I think it's

0:31:37.880 --> 0:31:40.000
<v Speaker 3>crazy to think it was a giant conspiracy. I think

0:31:40.200 --> 0:31:42.520
<v Speaker 3>it happened, and they like, because I knew people involved

0:31:42.520 --> 0:31:45.760
<v Speaker 3>with they like they were just overwhelmed at what was

0:31:45.800 --> 0:31:48.600
<v Speaker 3>going on and wasn't something and they were trying to

0:31:48.640 --> 0:31:52.560
<v Speaker 3>just deal with it. Regardless of that, I feel like

0:31:52.600 --> 0:31:56.480
<v Speaker 3>Democrats overall, maybe not the activist groups, but Democrats overall

0:31:56.800 --> 0:31:58.360
<v Speaker 3>are at a place where they're like, Okay, you know

0:31:58.440 --> 0:32:01.680
<v Speaker 3>what we were wrong about that, Like that was bad policy,

0:32:02.240 --> 0:32:06.160
<v Speaker 3>It didn't help the migrants, it didn't help workers, didn't

0:32:06.160 --> 0:32:11.360
<v Speaker 3>help anybody, and it hurt us politically, and so fine,

0:32:12.040 --> 0:32:14.560
<v Speaker 3>you know, we need a stronger border, but we're not

0:32:14.560 --> 0:32:17.880
<v Speaker 3>going to do that again. At the same time, what's

0:32:17.880 --> 0:32:21.600
<v Speaker 3>happening in Delaney Hall and at these ice attention facilities

0:32:21.600 --> 0:32:25.880
<v Speaker 3>across the country, and you know, thankfully they're not sending

0:32:26.040 --> 0:32:31.120
<v Speaker 3>ice as viciously through places like Minneapolis as they were before.

0:32:31.120 --> 0:32:33.880
<v Speaker 3>But that that kind of thing where you're where you're.

0:32:33.840 --> 0:32:36.760
<v Speaker 8>Jump in here because I really disagree with a few elements.

0:32:36.800 --> 0:32:38.920
<v Speaker 8>First of all, the idea. I think you're right that

0:32:39.240 --> 0:32:42.080
<v Speaker 8>it can be overwritten as a sort of elaborate, multi

0:32:42.120 --> 0:32:46.200
<v Speaker 8>decade conspiracy theory. It is unquestionably the case that the

0:32:46.240 --> 0:32:50.760
<v Speaker 8>Biden administration could have controlled immigration and chose not to difference.

0:32:50.800 --> 0:32:53.040
<v Speaker 8>And the way that we know that is because six

0:32:53.080 --> 0:32:56.120
<v Speaker 8>months before the election, when they realized they were going

0:32:56.160 --> 0:32:58.800
<v Speaker 8>to get crushed, they did they did. So this was

0:32:58.840 --> 0:33:02.280
<v Speaker 8>a choice by the bidenstration and it was a disastrously

0:33:02.320 --> 0:33:04.760
<v Speaker 8>bad one. The segment, I think it's very important to

0:33:04.800 --> 0:33:07.960
<v Speaker 8>say about now the challenges that we're having and enforcing

0:33:08.000 --> 0:33:12.280
<v Speaker 8>the law is that this is the inevitable downstream consequence

0:33:12.560 --> 0:33:15.920
<v Speaker 8>of what the FIDE administration did you cannot say we

0:33:15.960 --> 0:33:18.720
<v Speaker 8>are going to lawlessly allow millions of people into the

0:33:18.720 --> 0:33:22.560
<v Speaker 8>country and then when the voters, as you say, even

0:33:22.600 --> 0:33:24.720
<v Speaker 8>the Democratic Party is ready to admit, Wow, that wasn't

0:33:24.760 --> 0:33:28.200
<v Speaker 8>a really good idea, say, whoa, whoa, whoa. We can't believe.

0:33:28.360 --> 0:33:30.520
<v Speaker 8>Now it's hard to actually enforce law and do something

0:33:30.560 --> 0:33:32.320
<v Speaker 8>about it. And you know, I don't know about the

0:33:32.600 --> 0:33:35.160
<v Speaker 8>details in cleanning Hall. I think to your point, you know,

0:33:35.280 --> 0:33:38.760
<v Speaker 8>humane detention and so forth, it is critical. But I

0:33:38.840 --> 0:33:40.840
<v Speaker 8>also really take issue with this idea that you know,

0:33:40.920 --> 0:33:44.200
<v Speaker 8>oh well, ICE is like viciously going to Minneapolis. Because

0:33:44.240 --> 0:33:48.320
<v Speaker 8>here's the thing. Most ICE activity and detentions and deportations

0:33:48.360 --> 0:33:51.600
<v Speaker 8>are happening in states. We don't hear anything about why

0:33:51.680 --> 0:33:52.240
<v Speaker 8>is that.

0:33:52.680 --> 0:33:56.640
<v Speaker 3>Well, because they're going to U VISA appointments or.

0:33:56.720 --> 0:33:59.080
<v Speaker 8>No, they're because they're doing it in states where the

0:33:59.160 --> 0:34:01.880
<v Speaker 8>governments in the states and the cities agree to work

0:34:01.880 --> 0:34:03.320
<v Speaker 8>with ICE and enforce the law.

0:34:03.240 --> 0:34:05.480
<v Speaker 4>Maybe like New Orleans or Memphis in Texas.

0:34:05.800 --> 0:34:07.720
<v Speaker 8>What you are seeing in a conflict in place like

0:34:07.760 --> 0:34:11.120
<v Speaker 8>Minneapolis is a sanctuary city. You're seeing a city that

0:34:11.239 --> 0:34:14.640
<v Speaker 8>is saying we refuse to support the enforcement of the law.

0:34:14.920 --> 0:34:17.120
<v Speaker 8>And in fact, we're going to obstruct it in all

0:34:17.160 --> 0:34:20.040
<v Speaker 8>sorts of ways. And in that context, yes, it's going

0:34:20.080 --> 0:34:22.080
<v Speaker 8>to be very messy. And so to your point, oh,

0:34:22.080 --> 0:34:25.600
<v Speaker 8>will democrats understand this now? Sanctuary cities is question number one.

0:34:25.760 --> 0:34:29.680
<v Speaker 8>When I see the sanctuary cities reversing those policies, I'll

0:34:29.680 --> 0:34:32.080
<v Speaker 8>believe you that in fact, we're ready to get serious

0:34:32.120 --> 0:34:34.600
<v Speaker 8>about this. And if I don't see that, and I

0:34:34.600 --> 0:34:36.480
<v Speaker 8>think the American people don't see that, it's going to

0:34:36.520 --> 0:34:39.480
<v Speaker 8>be very hard to take seriously this like, no, no,

0:34:39.520 --> 0:34:40.920
<v Speaker 8>we want to just do this the right way. We

0:34:40.960 --> 0:34:43.320
<v Speaker 8>want to do this humanly. Unfortunately, it looks like you

0:34:43.360 --> 0:34:45.480
<v Speaker 8>don't want to enforce the law at all, and that's

0:34:45.480 --> 0:34:46.480
<v Speaker 8>a huge challenge.

0:34:46.600 --> 0:34:48.359
<v Speaker 3>Yeah, I guess the point is that, like, if we're

0:34:48.360 --> 0:34:51.200
<v Speaker 3>really going to take this idea of citizenship seriously and

0:34:51.200 --> 0:34:53.719
<v Speaker 3>if we're all citizens first, then it has to get

0:34:53.719 --> 0:34:59.440
<v Speaker 3>beyond this left verset right, Democrat versus Republican. I think

0:34:59.480 --> 0:35:02.600
<v Speaker 3>somebody like Stephen Miller, who even Trump has said, you know,

0:35:03.239 --> 0:35:05.160
<v Speaker 3>if you had your way, there'd be one hundred million

0:35:05.160 --> 0:35:08.279
<v Speaker 3>people here and they'd all look like you, and that

0:35:08.280 --> 0:35:11.880
<v Speaker 3>that is then expressed as as policy where he's you know,

0:35:11.960 --> 0:35:15.640
<v Speaker 3>mandating these you know, three thousand, four thousand whatever. It

0:35:15.719 --> 0:35:19.000
<v Speaker 3>is a day, and it's and it's and it's producing

0:35:20.400 --> 0:35:22.919
<v Speaker 3>you mean deportations, right, three three thousand deep?

0:35:23.000 --> 0:35:24.520
<v Speaker 8>Yeah, Now do you remember how many people were coming

0:35:24.560 --> 0:35:25.280
<v Speaker 8>across the border.

0:35:25.560 --> 0:35:27.960
<v Speaker 3>There's a lot. There was a lot, it was right.

0:35:27.960 --> 0:35:30.240
<v Speaker 8>Right, So at what rate would you like to deport

0:35:30.280 --> 0:35:32.360
<v Speaker 8>the millions and millions of people that we agree with?

0:35:32.360 --> 0:35:34.840
<v Speaker 11>Theistry I think shows I think this would be the

0:35:34.880 --> 0:35:39.239
<v Speaker 11>interesting place where if we're serious about a compromising, a compromise,

0:35:39.280 --> 0:35:42.839
<v Speaker 11>I think it would look something like violent criminals and.

0:35:42.880 --> 0:35:47.399
<v Speaker 3>Let but as citizens come together and say, look, we're

0:35:47.400 --> 0:35:51.680
<v Speaker 3>going to focus on deporting violent criminals. That's the first

0:35:51.680 --> 0:35:54.880
<v Speaker 3>thing we can all agree on this. So we're going

0:35:54.920 --> 0:35:58.680
<v Speaker 3>to focus on that as citizens of this country, people

0:35:58.719 --> 0:36:01.319
<v Speaker 3>who are following the law, and we're gonna and we're

0:36:01.320 --> 0:36:03.239
<v Speaker 3>going to close the border in a serious way as

0:36:03.239 --> 0:36:06.800
<v Speaker 3>you as you guys want, and people who are following

0:36:06.880 --> 0:36:10.600
<v Speaker 3>the law and who who love our country and are

0:36:10.600 --> 0:36:13.400
<v Speaker 3>here for the right reasons, we're going to find a

0:36:13.640 --> 0:36:18.719
<v Speaker 3>pathway to make them citizens. If we can't come to

0:36:18.719 --> 0:36:21.600
<v Speaker 3>that kind of agreement, then we'll just do every two

0:36:21.719 --> 0:36:26.200
<v Speaker 3>years war back and forth, and uh, so what it is?

0:36:26.280 --> 0:36:27.839
<v Speaker 8>So I just want to put out the irony heres

0:36:27.840 --> 0:36:30.440
<v Speaker 8>you were telling me there was no Biden conspiracy. These

0:36:30.480 --> 0:36:32.920
<v Speaker 8>people aren't going to be able to vote anyway, But

0:36:33.040 --> 0:36:36.080
<v Speaker 8>now the only acceptable compromise is no. No, with the

0:36:36.080 --> 0:36:39.399
<v Speaker 8>exception of the violent criminals, they should all be given citizenship.

0:36:39.840 --> 0:36:44.960
<v Speaker 8>So I so I questioned that the common sense compromise. Secondly,

0:36:45.040 --> 0:36:46.320
<v Speaker 8>it seems to me there are some other things we

0:36:46.320 --> 0:36:50.120
<v Speaker 8>could do here, for instance, workplace enforcement right if we

0:36:50.239 --> 0:36:52.799
<v Speaker 8>just if right because in fact, every one of these

0:36:52.800 --> 0:36:56.560
<v Speaker 8>people who are here legally and working, uh, there is

0:36:56.600 --> 0:36:59.239
<v Speaker 8>a violation of the law there as well. And so

0:36:59.560 --> 0:37:01.040
<v Speaker 8>you know that that's one place I think, you know

0:37:01.080 --> 0:37:04.280
<v Speaker 8>where publican party is overwhelmingly in favor of mandatory you verify.

0:37:04.880 --> 0:37:07.120
<v Speaker 8>I think that's a great place we could be taking

0:37:07.200 --> 0:37:08.040
<v Speaker 8>much firmer action.

0:37:08.280 --> 0:37:10.840
<v Speaker 4>Well, I'm curious to actually here's some contrast between both.

0:37:10.680 --> 0:37:12.400
<v Speaker 3>Of you on the labor question, you know, on the

0:37:12.440 --> 0:37:15.399
<v Speaker 3>and yes, and on the citizen question. Let's say, really

0:37:15.400 --> 0:37:17.400
<v Speaker 3>worried that these people are going to vote for Democrats.

0:37:17.640 --> 0:37:20.120
<v Speaker 3>I think it's I think it's overblown. But you could say, okay,

0:37:20.120 --> 0:37:23.439
<v Speaker 3>here's the pathway to citizenship is here's a legal work

0:37:23.440 --> 0:37:26.600
<v Speaker 3>requirement you have to work for you can work for

0:37:26.600 --> 0:37:31.520
<v Speaker 3>twelve years, but that's compliant with you verify that that

0:37:31.560 --> 0:37:34.320
<v Speaker 3>it's not a second class kind of workforce that it

0:37:34.360 --> 0:37:35.920
<v Speaker 3>is working in the shadows.

0:37:35.760 --> 0:37:39.480
<v Speaker 8>Fake social security, right, So the also and then but

0:37:39.520 --> 0:37:42.160
<v Speaker 8>they are citizens or they after say twelve years.

0:37:42.239 --> 0:37:47.239
<v Speaker 7>Okay, let's roll this clip of Scott Bessett, and I'll

0:37:47.239 --> 0:37:49.040
<v Speaker 7>get your take on this orn because you interviewed him

0:37:49.080 --> 0:37:52.560
<v Speaker 7>last night. But Scott Bessett gave what he's what a

0:37:52.600 --> 0:37:54.920
<v Speaker 7>lot of people are reacting to as a major economic

0:37:54.920 --> 0:37:57.480
<v Speaker 7>speech at the Reagan Library last week, and he was

0:37:57.480 --> 0:38:01.040
<v Speaker 7>talking about economic security as national security and how we've

0:38:01.239 --> 0:38:03.960
<v Speaker 7>kind of the way he sees it, that we've sort

0:38:03.960 --> 0:38:06.000
<v Speaker 7>of divorced these two things when they should always be

0:38:06.160 --> 0:38:09.279
<v Speaker 7>thought of together. And citizenship and labor are obviously a

0:38:09.320 --> 0:38:10.040
<v Speaker 7>huge component of this.

0:38:10.200 --> 0:38:11.080
<v Speaker 4>So let's roll the clip.

0:38:11.320 --> 0:38:15.440
<v Speaker 10>Well, America's slept our vulnerabilities grew, but under President Trump's

0:38:15.480 --> 0:38:18.720
<v Speaker 10>leadership were alert to the risk we can no longer ignore,

0:38:19.200 --> 0:38:22.320
<v Speaker 10>and a tune to the responsibility we can no longer defer.

0:38:23.000 --> 0:38:26.160
<v Speaker 10>Under President Trump, we have awoken to mourning again in

0:38:26.239 --> 0:38:29.840
<v Speaker 10>America and our best days I believe still lie ahead.

0:38:30.280 --> 0:38:32.279
<v Speaker 7>So not to interrupt the conversation you were having, but

0:38:32.320 --> 0:38:36.080
<v Speaker 7>to continue it, Ryan, you would say, our birth rate

0:38:36.239 --> 0:38:39.480
<v Speaker 7>is a serious problem, you would say, and Orin you

0:38:39.480 --> 0:38:41.479
<v Speaker 7>would probably agree with Ryan on that. You would say

0:38:42.280 --> 0:38:46.280
<v Speaker 7>also that we need people to work more of these jobs.

0:38:46.320 --> 0:38:48.920
<v Speaker 7>We have a huge chunk of actually, like working aage man,

0:38:48.960 --> 0:38:51.320
<v Speaker 7>ten percent of working age men outside of the labor force.

0:38:52.200 --> 0:38:54.840
<v Speaker 7>But also it's hard to fill some of these jobs.

0:38:55.480 --> 0:39:00.000
<v Speaker 7>So Orin, if we're bringing manufacturing back to the United States,

0:39:00.400 --> 0:39:02.640
<v Speaker 7>first of all, are we the Second of all, is

0:39:02.680 --> 0:39:05.359
<v Speaker 7>that going to do we have workers for that? If

0:39:05.400 --> 0:39:08.560
<v Speaker 7>we're also engaged in mass deportations.

0:39:08.080 --> 0:39:10.759
<v Speaker 8>Well so I think we certainly are breing manufacturing back.

0:39:11.440 --> 0:39:13.239
<v Speaker 8>Wall Street journals. Greg yp has been calling it a

0:39:13.280 --> 0:39:17.040
<v Speaker 8>stealth manufacturing boom, because the reality is step point is

0:39:17.080 --> 0:39:19.840
<v Speaker 8>you actually have to build new factories. Right, You're not

0:39:19.880 --> 0:39:24.120
<v Speaker 8>going to see the actual hiring for some time. But

0:39:24.760 --> 0:39:26.759
<v Speaker 8>you know, to your point, we certainly have plenty of

0:39:26.840 --> 0:39:29.799
<v Speaker 8>people outside the labor force. We have plenty of people

0:39:29.800 --> 0:39:33.720
<v Speaker 8>in much lower productivity jobs that might be well served

0:39:33.719 --> 0:39:36.759
<v Speaker 8>by jobs in the manufacturing sector. We also have a

0:39:36.800 --> 0:39:40.000
<v Speaker 8>lot of technological change happening that people think of going

0:39:40.040 --> 0:39:46.200
<v Speaker 8>to vastly increase productivity. If anything, they're concerned that, you know,

0:39:46.440 --> 0:39:50.799
<v Speaker 8>we won't have enough work for everybody. And so you know,

0:39:50.880 --> 0:39:53.680
<v Speaker 8>I think both on this question of sort of immigration,

0:39:53.880 --> 0:39:57.200
<v Speaker 8>forcement on this question of the labor market, and reshoring

0:39:57.800 --> 0:40:00.520
<v Speaker 8>it again all comes back to this idea for me

0:40:00.800 --> 0:40:03.719
<v Speaker 8>of the first question here is what sort of nation

0:40:03.840 --> 0:40:07.239
<v Speaker 8>do we want to be, and you know, what sort

0:40:07.239 --> 0:40:09.640
<v Speaker 8>of model do we want to go forward on? And

0:40:09.719 --> 0:40:13.200
<v Speaker 8>then questions of economic policy, questions of how much growth

0:40:13.200 --> 0:40:16.920
<v Speaker 8>are you getting? These questions you then decide those within

0:40:17.000 --> 0:40:19.520
<v Speaker 8>the confines of the kind of country that you want

0:40:19.560 --> 0:40:22.200
<v Speaker 8>to be. And so you know, the phrase jobs Americans

0:40:22.239 --> 0:40:25.480
<v Speaker 8>won't do, I think is a quintessential example of the

0:40:25.480 --> 0:40:27.120
<v Speaker 8>problem here. The idea that we're going to have a

0:40:27.160 --> 0:40:30.080
<v Speaker 8>whole class of jobs in our economy that the people

0:40:30.120 --> 0:40:34.640
<v Speaker 8>who live here won't do is sort of simultaneously demeaning

0:40:34.680 --> 0:40:37.440
<v Speaker 8>to the people who absolutely will work if there are

0:40:37.880 --> 0:40:42.080
<v Speaker 8>jobs with good conditions that pay a living wage. And

0:40:42.120 --> 0:40:45.480
<v Speaker 8>it's ridiculous to suggest that employers in business models should

0:40:45.520 --> 0:40:48.239
<v Speaker 8>be operating in ways that create jobs that don't meet

0:40:48.640 --> 0:40:53.120
<v Speaker 8>those conditions. So I think you know, we really have

0:40:53.200 --> 0:40:56.200
<v Speaker 8>to focus on is saying there need to be some

0:40:56.480 --> 0:41:01.759
<v Speaker 8>constraints here. Citizenship, in one respects is a constraint. We

0:41:02.160 --> 0:41:06.719
<v Speaker 8>have the citizens of this country for whom the market operates, right,

0:41:07.160 --> 0:41:08.960
<v Speaker 8>it is not the point. It's not for citizens to

0:41:09.000 --> 0:41:11.239
<v Speaker 8>serve the market. The point is for the market to

0:41:11.280 --> 0:41:16.120
<v Speaker 8>be serving citizens. And so how do we change policies

0:41:16.160 --> 0:41:18.920
<v Speaker 8>to actually generate those kinds of results some of the

0:41:18.920 --> 0:41:21.520
<v Speaker 8>things we're doing with trade and industrial policy as a

0:41:21.520 --> 0:41:24.200
<v Speaker 8>way to drive more investment, you know, get more of

0:41:24.200 --> 0:41:27.680
<v Speaker 8>a focus on creating these kinds of jobs. I think

0:41:27.719 --> 0:41:32.120
<v Speaker 8>an element of the immigration policy definitely has to be Okay,

0:41:32.200 --> 0:41:34.520
<v Speaker 8>you know, what is the premise of immigration policy. If

0:41:34.520 --> 0:41:37.560
<v Speaker 8>the premises we just need to add people to do jobs,

0:41:38.160 --> 0:41:42.360
<v Speaker 8>that I think very much demeans the notion of citizenship

0:41:42.400 --> 0:41:47.000
<v Speaker 8>as as a community in a nation first and foremost.

0:41:47.120 --> 0:41:49.399
<v Speaker 8>And so you know, I actually appreciated, you know, Ryan,

0:41:49.440 --> 0:41:52.120
<v Speaker 8>you mentioned sort of the Bernie Sanders a fl Cio

0:41:52.480 --> 0:41:54.960
<v Speaker 8>view of the you know, maybe mid two thousands on

0:41:55.000 --> 0:41:56.440
<v Speaker 8>something like immigration.

0:41:56.440 --> 0:41:58.920
<v Speaker 4>Teams to responsor the team series.

0:41:58.680 --> 0:42:01.279
<v Speaker 8>Responsor the gaalast Night teams. I think, you know, are

0:42:01.880 --> 0:42:05.480
<v Speaker 8>are much less beholden to some of the more left

0:42:05.520 --> 0:42:08.440
<v Speaker 8>wing activist groups. At this point, the reality is that

0:42:08.560 --> 0:42:11.840
<v Speaker 8>the afl CIO no longer has the nfl C oppositionion,

0:42:11.880 --> 0:42:14.400
<v Speaker 8>Bernie Sanders no longer has the Bertie Sanders position. And

0:42:14.440 --> 0:42:18.160
<v Speaker 8>so I think you're absolutely right that there is a

0:42:18.400 --> 0:42:21.520
<v Speaker 8>point of view on what immigration should look like that

0:42:22.000 --> 0:42:25.680
<v Speaker 8>Democrats historically talled and Republicans historically held right. It did

0:42:25.680 --> 0:42:29.200
<v Speaker 8>not used to be nearly as contentious an issue, and reality,

0:42:29.239 --> 0:42:31.440
<v Speaker 8>I think it was the Financial Times had had some

0:42:31.520 --> 0:42:34.080
<v Speaker 8>wonderful charts on this a year or two ago where

0:42:34.120 --> 0:42:37.719
<v Speaker 8>they showed, you know, with various measures, you know, what

0:42:37.880 --> 0:42:43.560
<v Speaker 8>was the republican, independent Democrat or conservative moderate liberal perspective

0:42:43.600 --> 0:42:47.720
<v Speaker 8>on immigration, And what showed was the right of center

0:42:47.760 --> 0:42:51.600
<v Speaker 8>and center's view just sort of proceeding without any real change,

0:42:52.000 --> 0:42:56.399
<v Speaker 8>and the left of center view veering way off. And

0:42:57.440 --> 0:42:59.239
<v Speaker 8>you know, look, you can say and the left center

0:42:59.320 --> 0:43:01.000
<v Speaker 8>view was right to do that they should be pulling

0:43:01.040 --> 0:43:05.279
<v Speaker 8>everyone over. But as a descriptive matter, the divisiveness of

0:43:05.320 --> 0:43:08.439
<v Speaker 8>this issue, the shift in how we talk and argue

0:43:08.480 --> 0:43:11.759
<v Speaker 8>about it and ultimately are i would say, sort of

0:43:12.320 --> 0:43:16.120
<v Speaker 8>loss of that concept of citizenship to the extent we're

0:43:16.120 --> 0:43:19.400
<v Speaker 8>in the immigration context that veer on the left is

0:43:19.440 --> 0:43:21.520
<v Speaker 8>the thing that is causing the change, and I think

0:43:21.560 --> 0:43:23.960
<v Speaker 8>we really have to grapple with But then I would

0:43:24.000 --> 0:43:29.720
<v Speaker 8>just say that also that you know, immigration is one

0:43:29.840 --> 0:43:34.560
<v Speaker 8>obviously very relevant piece of the citizenship conversation, but it's

0:43:34.560 --> 0:43:36.839
<v Speaker 8>certainly not all or even most of it, right. I mean,

0:43:36.840 --> 0:43:39.520
<v Speaker 8>even if you completely fixed all of our immigration problems,

0:43:40.239 --> 0:43:45.320
<v Speaker 8>we would still have this broader breakdown in communal life,

0:43:45.320 --> 0:43:49.520
<v Speaker 8>in economic life, in national life. And so, you know,

0:43:49.520 --> 0:43:52.759
<v Speaker 8>it's unfortunate some respects to the extent that because of

0:43:52.760 --> 0:43:55.480
<v Speaker 8>the direction immigration has gone it it has become as

0:43:55.480 --> 0:43:59.400
<v Speaker 8>central a focus as it is. But moving beyond that

0:43:59.440 --> 0:44:03.760
<v Speaker 8>really requires is not just making sure we have a stable,

0:44:03.800 --> 0:44:08.400
<v Speaker 8>insane immigration system, you know, it just as much requires

0:44:08.440 --> 0:44:12.200
<v Speaker 8>thinking about what is the pathway for a young person

0:44:12.480 --> 0:44:14.239
<v Speaker 8>into adulthood? Right, you know, the way that we did

0:44:14.320 --> 0:44:17.520
<v Speaker 8>sort of college for all, I think it's been a disaster.

0:44:17.600 --> 0:44:19.239
<v Speaker 8>We've sort of said, either you're somebody who's going to

0:44:19.280 --> 0:44:21.960
<v Speaker 8>go to college, succeed there and head off in life,

0:44:22.080 --> 0:44:24.560
<v Speaker 8>or we just kind of have nothing for you. And so,

0:44:25.000 --> 0:44:26.960
<v Speaker 8>you know, how do we think about the role of education,

0:44:27.200 --> 0:44:30.920
<v Speaker 8>How do we think about transitioning into adulthood all that.

0:44:31.880 --> 0:44:34.440
<v Speaker 8>It's a big piece of discussion. I think you know,

0:44:34.640 --> 0:44:37.800
<v Speaker 8>place and just caring about it and not saying webron

0:44:37.840 --> 0:44:40.520
<v Speaker 8>can move to opportunity and frankly, we're going to strip

0:44:40.560 --> 0:44:42.880
<v Speaker 8>mine all of the most talented people out of a

0:44:42.920 --> 0:44:46.440
<v Speaker 8>lot of communities, say saying that place is the most

0:44:46.480 --> 0:44:48.319
<v Speaker 8>important thing in a lot of ways, in a lot

0:44:48.400 --> 0:44:51.160
<v Speaker 8>of people's lives. And so how do we make sure

0:44:52.120 --> 0:44:55.840
<v Speaker 8>you know, the economic growth and opportunity the vitality of

0:44:55.880 --> 0:44:59.239
<v Speaker 8>communities is getting out everywhere instead of saying, well, here

0:44:59.239 --> 0:45:01.520
<v Speaker 8>are the enclaves you can come to if you want it.

0:45:02.640 --> 0:45:04.480
<v Speaker 8>Those are the kinds of things we're really going to

0:45:04.560 --> 0:45:08.080
<v Speaker 8>have to address and and prioritize over the next quarter's

0:45:08.320 --> 0:45:09.240
<v Speaker 8>GDP number.

0:45:09.719 --> 0:45:11.680
<v Speaker 3>Well, what I mean, one thing that keeps people in

0:45:11.760 --> 0:45:14.480
<v Speaker 3>places is you got to have a hospital. You got

0:45:14.480 --> 0:45:16.320
<v Speaker 3>to have a hospital. You gotta have a rural hospital.

0:45:16.360 --> 0:45:18.360
<v Speaker 3>You got it. And it helps if you have a

0:45:18.360 --> 0:45:21.560
<v Speaker 3>college or a university, even a small one that just

0:45:21.640 --> 0:45:24.040
<v Speaker 3>statistically like that's going to keep people.

0:45:24.760 --> 0:45:27.280
<v Speaker 8>Who Yeah, so I totally agree with that. The problem

0:45:27.320 --> 0:45:30.799
<v Speaker 8>is what's special about those two things, It's that they

0:45:30.800 --> 0:45:34.520
<v Speaker 8>attract massive amounts of government spending. In other words, the.

0:45:34.560 --> 0:45:37.640
<v Speaker 3>Hospital health no, no, but but they're important in its

0:45:37.640 --> 0:45:37.960
<v Speaker 3>own right.

0:45:38.040 --> 0:45:40.680
<v Speaker 8>Is that's absolutely true? But but economically what's going on

0:45:40.760 --> 0:45:42.920
<v Speaker 8>here is that as you'vell it used to be well,

0:45:42.920 --> 0:45:44.759
<v Speaker 8>of course you'd have a hospital there, because if you

0:45:44.760 --> 0:45:47.560
<v Speaker 8>have a vibrant community and people who are doing well

0:45:47.600 --> 0:45:49.800
<v Speaker 8>and prospering, you would want to have a hospital.

0:45:50.280 --> 0:45:51.879
<v Speaker 4>You're saying it would follow the.

0:45:52.080 --> 0:45:54.160
<v Speaker 8>Right You didn't used to have to worry about Wait

0:45:54.160 --> 0:45:56.560
<v Speaker 8>a minute, why how do we get healthcare to this place?

0:45:56.640 --> 0:45:58.320
<v Speaker 8>Because if it was a vibrant place.

0:45:58.080 --> 0:46:01.600
<v Speaker 3>Of well, you have a doctor that had likes.

0:46:01.520 --> 0:46:04.839
<v Speaker 8>Them at at some point. You know, that's right. Our

0:46:04.840 --> 0:46:08.439
<v Speaker 8>healthcare system has obviously evolved, and you know in rural

0:46:08.480 --> 0:46:12.160
<v Speaker 8>communities you also just have a scale problem. But the

0:46:12.239 --> 0:46:14.160
<v Speaker 8>extent to which we now think, oh well, in a

0:46:14.160 --> 0:46:15.759
<v Speaker 8>lot of places you have to have a hospital and

0:46:15.760 --> 0:46:18.319
<v Speaker 8>you have to have a college is because those are

0:46:18.360 --> 0:46:20.880
<v Speaker 8>the two things that you can put there that simply

0:46:20.920 --> 0:46:24.920
<v Speaker 8>by enrolling people or admitting people entitle you to massive

0:46:24.960 --> 0:46:26.720
<v Speaker 8>amounts of federal money.

0:46:26.960 --> 0:46:30.720
<v Speaker 3>Right, and like Land Grant University is being a critical linkage.

0:46:30.760 --> 0:46:34.080
<v Speaker 8>Well, and think what's upon TIMEO was Lang Grant universities.

0:46:34.120 --> 0:46:37.120
<v Speaker 8>Now it's just anybody whose students are eligible for financial

0:46:37.120 --> 0:46:39.839
<v Speaker 8>aid and student loans, many of which will never even

0:46:39.880 --> 0:46:40.560
<v Speaker 8>be paid back.

0:46:40.760 --> 0:46:43.239
<v Speaker 7>But that's the vicious cycle, because you were saying people

0:46:43.280 --> 0:46:45.759
<v Speaker 7>can't exist in some of these areas without the federal spending.

0:46:45.800 --> 0:46:47.800
<v Speaker 7>At the Royal Hospital now because they don't have private

0:46:47.840 --> 0:46:51.280
<v Speaker 7>sector insurance, they're the big factory that employed people, it's gone,

0:46:51.480 --> 0:46:54.759
<v Speaker 7>and so there basically we're in a vicious cycle kind

0:46:54.800 --> 0:46:56.600
<v Speaker 7>of as how it's.

0:46:56.480 --> 0:46:58.440
<v Speaker 3>Very hard to attract companies to move to an area

0:46:58.560 --> 0:47:02.440
<v Speaker 3>if there's no there's no hospital, and a university helps too.

0:47:02.800 --> 0:47:05.200
<v Speaker 8>Yeah, I think certainly. And you know, one thing with

0:47:05.200 --> 0:47:07.440
<v Speaker 8>the respect at university, I think that's very important is

0:47:07.840 --> 0:47:11.320
<v Speaker 8>we concentrate all of our you know, federal research spending

0:47:11.440 --> 0:47:15.959
<v Speaker 8>for leading edge research in a very few places. There's

0:47:15.960 --> 0:47:18.520
<v Speaker 8>no reason we have to do that, especially in the

0:47:18.680 --> 0:47:21.759
<v Speaker 8>sort of modern communication and so forth. It's not like

0:47:21.800 --> 0:47:24.600
<v Speaker 8>you need all the best scientists of every kind living

0:47:24.640 --> 0:47:28.520
<v Speaker 8>in Cambridge, Massachusetts, or you know, Palo Alto, California, or

0:47:28.560 --> 0:47:31.200
<v Speaker 8>even New York City. There's no reason you can't take

0:47:31.800 --> 0:47:34.720
<v Speaker 8>that sort of funding and direct it more towards having

0:47:34.960 --> 0:47:38.080
<v Speaker 8>great labs in every state university around the country and

0:47:38.360 --> 0:47:42.600
<v Speaker 8>start pushing things back out that way. The reason I

0:47:42.719 --> 0:47:45.840
<v Speaker 8>just emphasized the sort of public spending of eds and

0:47:45.920 --> 0:47:49.680
<v Speaker 8>meds as they call it, is just to say, you know,

0:47:49.760 --> 0:47:51.960
<v Speaker 8>the reason that's how with the landscape books today is

0:47:52.000 --> 0:47:54.759
<v Speaker 8>because we've hollowed out the rest of it so completely.

0:47:55.040 --> 0:47:57.200
<v Speaker 8>And you're right, given that the vicious cycle that we're in,

0:47:57.680 --> 0:48:00.200
<v Speaker 8>bootstrapping it the other way requires a lot, a lot

0:48:00.200 --> 0:48:02.680
<v Speaker 8>of attention to these things. But I think it's very

0:48:02.680 --> 0:48:05.520
<v Speaker 8>important that the aspiration not be well. As long as

0:48:05.520 --> 0:48:08.799
<v Speaker 8>we have enough funding for healthcare and higher education, all

0:48:08.800 --> 0:48:11.960
<v Speaker 8>of these places can survive. But rather to say no, no,

0:48:12.000 --> 0:48:14.800
<v Speaker 8>the long term goal has to be that these are productive,

0:48:14.840 --> 0:48:19.320
<v Speaker 8>flourishing places that can also support a healthy hospital system

0:48:19.760 --> 0:48:23.440
<v Speaker 8>that wants to have a college and so forth, but

0:48:23.480 --> 0:48:27.560
<v Speaker 8>that first and foremost is a viable community.

0:48:28.040 --> 0:48:30.719
<v Speaker 3>I would just finish one practical and pragmatic point that

0:48:30.760 --> 0:48:32.279
<v Speaker 3>if we want to get to a place where as

0:48:32.320 --> 0:48:35.880
<v Speaker 3>American citizens, we're actually discussing among ourselves how we're going

0:48:35.920 --> 0:48:37.560
<v Speaker 3>to solve some of these problems, because I agree with you,

0:48:37.600 --> 0:48:42.120
<v Speaker 3>it's not sufficient to get to bed meaning and citizenship

0:48:42.600 --> 0:48:45.239
<v Speaker 3>to deal with immigration but it is necessary to deal

0:48:45.280 --> 0:48:47.719
<v Speaker 3>with first. I would just say to the millions of

0:48:47.719 --> 0:48:52.640
<v Speaker 3>people that came across during the Bide administration, like their

0:48:52.640 --> 0:48:54.920
<v Speaker 3>policy or don't like the policy, it was the policy

0:48:55.040 --> 0:48:57.360
<v Speaker 3>that was in place, and they actually did follow the

0:48:57.440 --> 0:49:02.960
<v Speaker 3>rules of this policy that was in place. If if

0:49:02.960 --> 0:49:05.400
<v Speaker 3>there's insistence that it has to be a Stephen Miller approach,

0:49:05.440 --> 0:49:09.239
<v Speaker 3>where you know, mandatory detention is required for people who

0:49:09.239 --> 0:49:12.680
<v Speaker 3>haven't committed any crimes, like not even not even bail

0:49:13.120 --> 0:49:16.480
<v Speaker 3>while they're like contesting that these asylum claims or anything else,

0:49:16.480 --> 0:49:19.000
<v Speaker 3>they are just locked in these detention facilities and they're

0:49:19.000 --> 0:49:22.440
<v Speaker 3>getting scooped up off the street. If that's going to

0:49:22.520 --> 0:49:25.600
<v Speaker 3>be the way that Republicans, when they're in power, insist

0:49:25.680 --> 0:49:28.560
<v Speaker 3>on dealing with immigration, then Democrats are never going to

0:49:29.200 --> 0:49:31.600
<v Speaker 3>come around on the other parts of it. They're never

0:49:31.600 --> 0:49:34.040
<v Speaker 3>going to say, Okay, we're wrong on this, wrong on this,

0:49:34.080 --> 0:49:36.879
<v Speaker 3>let let's let's let's do let's do a comprehensive type

0:49:36.880 --> 0:49:38.960
<v Speaker 3>of reform that gets us to a place where we

0:49:39.000 --> 0:49:41.799
<v Speaker 3>can have a rational policy. That's just my guess, this

0:49:41.840 --> 0:49:45.920
<v Speaker 3>is not very hopeful that if that Republicans have to say, okay, well,

0:49:46.000 --> 0:49:49.080
<v Speaker 3>let's focus on violent criminals, then let's focus on but

0:49:50.640 --> 0:49:52.799
<v Speaker 3>they have Republicans have their own agency if they just

0:49:52.880 --> 0:49:53.640
<v Speaker 3>want to like.

0:49:53.760 --> 0:49:55.680
<v Speaker 8>Well, look, this is why I say there are different

0:49:55.719 --> 0:49:57.640
<v Speaker 8>ways to enforcement, and this is why I think the

0:49:57.640 --> 0:50:01.200
<v Speaker 8>workplace enforcement is a much fair tests because I agree

0:50:01.239 --> 0:50:04.440
<v Speaker 8>with you. You know, one thing we've found in certainly it

0:50:04.520 --> 0:50:08.000
<v Speaker 8>shows from the polling data. We've had folks who had

0:50:08.000 --> 0:50:12.640
<v Speaker 8>folks for people writing for Commonplace about this that that's right.

0:50:12.719 --> 0:50:17.759
<v Speaker 8>The most sort of confrontational, aggressive approach to enforcement is

0:50:17.800 --> 0:50:22.840
<v Speaker 8>not popular with a lot of people. Workplace enforcement saying

0:50:23.360 --> 0:50:27.200
<v Speaker 8>if you're not here legally, if you are not allowed

0:50:27.239 --> 0:50:31.640
<v Speaker 8>to work here, you in fact can't work here. That

0:50:31.719 --> 0:50:36.280
<v Speaker 8>has an extraordinarily powerful effect, again not in overnight detaining

0:50:36.280 --> 0:50:40.319
<v Speaker 8>people and destroying their lives necessarily, but in creating a

0:50:40.440 --> 0:50:44.080
<v Speaker 8>very strong pressure for people to depart in an orderly way.

0:50:44.680 --> 0:50:47.000
<v Speaker 8>And so I think it's a very helpful litmus test.

0:50:47.320 --> 0:50:49.680
<v Speaker 8>Is your objection to the way they're doing it, or

0:50:49.719 --> 0:50:52.360
<v Speaker 8>is your objection to the notion that these people really

0:50:52.400 --> 0:50:57.040
<v Speaker 8>need do need to leave? And if it's if it's

0:50:57.200 --> 0:50:59.120
<v Speaker 8>just you know, we would like to do this in

0:50:59.160 --> 0:51:03.520
<v Speaker 8>a human way. Workforce enforcement offers that right, and so

0:51:03.560 --> 0:51:04.600
<v Speaker 8>I think that's where.

0:51:05.880 --> 0:51:09.200
<v Speaker 3>Miller's approach requires the inhumanity.

0:51:09.440 --> 0:51:13.319
<v Speaker 8>That's and and and I understand that, I understand that

0:51:13.360 --> 0:51:17.720
<v Speaker 8>Christian people Trump is doing today. I think the flip

0:51:17.719 --> 0:51:19.600
<v Speaker 8>side of your point about what Democrats will accept is, well,

0:51:19.600 --> 0:51:23.359
<v Speaker 8>if Democrats won't even accept workforce enforcement, if we can't

0:51:23.360 --> 0:51:25.279
<v Speaker 8>actually get to a place where everybody agrees, I.

0:51:25.200 --> 0:51:26.880
<v Speaker 3>Think they would as long as there's a path for

0:51:26.920 --> 0:51:29.680
<v Speaker 3>people who came here through the process to get a

0:51:29.680 --> 0:51:31.840
<v Speaker 3>work permit, then that.

0:51:32.440 --> 0:51:34.200
<v Speaker 8>This is exactly what I'm telling you. This is the

0:51:34.239 --> 0:51:36.960
<v Speaker 8>actual question is that people is the millions and millions

0:51:36.960 --> 0:51:40.160
<v Speaker 8>of people who came in here who in frankly a

0:51:40.280 --> 0:51:43.359
<v Speaker 8>very lawless way during the Biden administration.

0:51:44.320 --> 0:51:46.400
<v Speaker 3>Is the end just the Bide administration?

0:51:46.520 --> 0:51:47.040
<v Speaker 8>Your right point.

0:51:47.120 --> 0:51:49.560
<v Speaker 3>Even before one of my one of my good friends

0:51:49.560 --> 0:51:52.839
<v Speaker 3>from growing up as a contractor, and he's like, give

0:51:52.880 --> 0:51:55.560
<v Speaker 3>me a union haul where I can go and hire

0:51:55.640 --> 0:51:59.080
<v Speaker 3>legal people. I'm happy to do that, love to pay

0:51:59.080 --> 0:52:02.400
<v Speaker 3>the wages whatever. I don't care you you as in

0:52:02.440 --> 0:52:06.680
<v Speaker 3>the broad you are our government, our society have built

0:52:06.719 --> 0:52:11.000
<v Speaker 3>a system where that is not possible. So then you

0:52:11.040 --> 0:52:14.880
<v Speaker 3>go in and then you take all these workers, and

0:52:14.920 --> 0:52:21.520
<v Speaker 3>then deport them without there being another option is completely

0:52:21.960 --> 0:52:26.359
<v Speaker 3>I agree with a political guy who's like, like, this.

0:52:26.400 --> 0:52:27.920
<v Speaker 8>Is just I think this is an instance where this

0:52:27.960 --> 0:52:31.000
<v Speaker 8>connects really to this richer sense of citizenship, which is

0:52:31.040 --> 0:52:33.920
<v Speaker 8>one of the reasons you as a contractor can't go

0:52:34.120 --> 0:52:36.480
<v Speaker 8>do that, because if you do, you'll just lose out

0:52:36.800 --> 0:52:38.840
<v Speaker 8>to the people who are doing the other thing. And

0:52:38.920 --> 0:52:41.399
<v Speaker 8>so it's fine to say, like the UNI hall doesn't exist, right,

0:52:41.400 --> 0:52:43.680
<v Speaker 8>but one reason the union hall doesn't exist is because

0:52:43.680 --> 0:52:46.600
<v Speaker 8>who would go higher from the union hall if there's

0:52:46.640 --> 0:52:51.000
<v Speaker 8>a massive exploitable population of undocumented immigrants to hire instead?

0:52:51.360 --> 0:52:54.440
<v Speaker 8>And so it is a it is a prerequisite again

0:52:54.520 --> 0:52:56.960
<v Speaker 8>to having the kind of economic life we want that

0:52:57.080 --> 0:52:59.640
<v Speaker 8>does give workers power, that does create that out of

0:52:59.640 --> 0:53:02.560
<v Speaker 8>the true let me just finish the point. It's a

0:53:02.560 --> 0:53:05.879
<v Speaker 8>fantasy to have an economic life where we enforce labor law,

0:53:05.960 --> 0:53:08.719
<v Speaker 8>have a tight labor market, and have good jobs for Americans.

0:53:08.920 --> 0:53:11.400
<v Speaker 3>It is a fantasy that you're going to be able

0:53:11.440 --> 0:53:13.120
<v Speaker 3>to grab twenty million people.

0:53:13.200 --> 0:53:15.000
<v Speaker 8>Will you just use grab again? Why can't I just

0:53:15.120 --> 0:53:19.080
<v Speaker 8>enforce Why can't I just enforce the law on the

0:53:19.120 --> 0:53:21.880
<v Speaker 8>books against employers who employ people leegally?

0:53:22.680 --> 0:53:24.880
<v Speaker 3>Well, you're still gonna have to grab people. No I'm not.

0:53:25.920 --> 0:53:28.520
<v Speaker 8>I'm going to find employers and perhaps even arrest some

0:53:28.560 --> 0:53:30.200
<v Speaker 8>employers if they continue to employ.

0:53:30.280 --> 0:53:32.680
<v Speaker 3>My point is you have to also support the other

0:53:32.760 --> 0:53:33.719
<v Speaker 3>side like you have to.

0:53:33.800 --> 0:53:35.560
<v Speaker 8>But you haven't told me why that's a fantasy. Why

0:53:35.560 --> 0:53:38.080
<v Speaker 8>can't I just require that employers follow the.

0:53:38.120 --> 0:53:41.560
<v Speaker 3>Law because all of the housing construction will stop.

0:53:42.040 --> 0:53:44.319
<v Speaker 8>So now we're back to jobs Americans won't do, and

0:53:44.360 --> 0:53:46.560
<v Speaker 8>that's just not the way to get citizenship.

0:53:46.160 --> 0:53:49.000
<v Speaker 4>Or at least still be a temporary pause.

0:53:49.920 --> 0:53:52.920
<v Speaker 3>I'm just saying practically speaking, I'm not down. I'm not

0:53:52.920 --> 0:53:56.359
<v Speaker 3>saying virtuous or not virtuous. It's just practically speaking, and

0:53:56.360 --> 0:53:59.719
<v Speaker 3>then politically you lose. So there has to be some

0:54:01.120 --> 0:54:04.760
<v Speaker 3>mechanism for people to hire people legally. I would say,

0:54:05.160 --> 0:54:08.160
<v Speaker 3>give people who are here, who are following the law

0:54:08.280 --> 0:54:12.200
<v Speaker 3>work permits. Why is that? What's wrong with that?

0:54:13.360 --> 0:54:17.480
<v Speaker 8>Well, for one thing, because they are not currently here

0:54:17.840 --> 0:54:21.919
<v Speaker 8>legally and we should have been enforcing the law long

0:54:22.400 --> 0:54:24.759
<v Speaker 8>and we can do that now. For a second thing,

0:54:24.880 --> 0:54:26.960
<v Speaker 8>because the exact work start competing.

0:54:27.080 --> 0:54:30.000
<v Speaker 3>We've built the wrong system. Nobody else coming in, but

0:54:30.280 --> 0:54:31.960
<v Speaker 3>the people here now are going to give them work

0:54:32.000 --> 0:54:36.280
<v Speaker 3>permits and anybody who hires somebody illegally, like you're getting

0:54:37.120 --> 0:54:38.480
<v Speaker 3>significant consequences.

0:54:38.719 --> 0:54:40.520
<v Speaker 8>Yeah, well, because a lot of the problem is that

0:54:40.560 --> 0:54:43.440
<v Speaker 8>the exact class of people who these workers are competing

0:54:43.440 --> 0:54:45.799
<v Speaker 8>with are the ones who have seen a very weak

0:54:45.920 --> 0:54:48.760
<v Speaker 8>job market for a very long time, in part because

0:54:48.760 --> 0:54:51.560
<v Speaker 8>of this competition, and we should be trying to tighten

0:54:51.600 --> 0:54:55.160
<v Speaker 8>that job market aggressively. People in the upper half of

0:54:55.200 --> 0:54:58.279
<v Speaker 8>the income distribution, people with college degrees. And this is

0:54:58.280 --> 0:55:02.600
<v Speaker 8>again where we've had this divergence society. You know, take

0:55:02.680 --> 0:55:06.520
<v Speaker 8>for granted that this stuff is all fine. We should

0:55:06.560 --> 0:55:08.960
<v Speaker 8>want the same kind of experience in the job market

0:55:09.239 --> 0:55:12.560
<v Speaker 8>for the construction worker that you or I get to experience,

0:55:13.120 --> 0:55:16.239
<v Speaker 8>and that requires a much tighter job market than we

0:55:16.320 --> 0:55:19.800
<v Speaker 8>have had. And so, you know, to some extent, I

0:55:19.840 --> 0:55:23.280
<v Speaker 8>guess I even question your premise that, you know, housing

0:55:24.040 --> 0:55:26.400
<v Speaker 8>construction come to a stop. I think one thing we

0:55:26.440 --> 0:55:29.080
<v Speaker 8>can do. If you want to say, you know, we

0:55:29.120 --> 0:55:32.440
<v Speaker 8>need a transition period, we need to phase this out

0:55:32.600 --> 0:55:36.560
<v Speaker 8>over a few years, that's fine. But the endpoint should

0:55:36.560 --> 0:55:40.840
<v Speaker 8>be essentially where we started here, which is that citizenship

0:55:40.960 --> 0:55:44.800
<v Speaker 8>is about the American citizens. That is who this republic

0:55:44.840 --> 0:55:47.600
<v Speaker 8>exists for. That is who formed the Republic and the

0:55:47.680 --> 0:55:49.440
<v Speaker 8>question is what is the set of policies that's going

0:55:49.520 --> 0:55:50.520
<v Speaker 8>to serve them best.

0:55:51.280 --> 0:55:54.080
<v Speaker 3>And my point you got to transition to it, and

0:55:54.200 --> 0:55:56.920
<v Speaker 3>what we're doing now isn't actually going to transition to that.

0:55:57.080 --> 0:55:58.919
<v Speaker 7>I don't think we'll probably have to leave it there.

0:55:59.520 --> 0:56:02.280
<v Speaker 7>But thank you so much, oron cast the American Compass.

0:56:02.360 --> 0:56:05.200
<v Speaker 7>That was a really interesting conversation. We appreciate it. Folks

0:56:05.239 --> 0:56:08.840
<v Speaker 7>can check out the new project in Commonplace on the

0:56:08.840 --> 0:56:09.799
<v Speaker 7>Compass website.

0:56:09.920 --> 0:56:11.240
<v Speaker 6>Thanks for thank you guys.

0:56:12.080 --> 0:56:12.880
<v Speaker 4>Well that does it for us.

0:56:12.920 --> 0:56:15.359
<v Speaker 7>In today's edition of Breaking Points, we apologize the show

0:56:15.440 --> 0:56:17.640
<v Speaker 7>is going to hit premium subs in boxes a little

0:56:17.640 --> 0:56:19.799
<v Speaker 7>bit late because we had such a great conversation with

0:56:19.960 --> 0:56:20.399
<v Speaker 7>oron casts.

0:56:20.400 --> 0:56:23.040
<v Speaker 4>Our producers were like rap rap, but we wanted to

0:56:23.080 --> 0:56:24.399
<v Speaker 4>just no. I thought it was great.

0:56:24.400 --> 0:56:28.799
<v Speaker 7>I didn't want to disrupt the flow of that. But

0:56:28.880 --> 0:56:31.600
<v Speaker 7>thank you everyone so much for joining us today. We

0:56:31.640 --> 0:56:34.160
<v Speaker 7>appreciate it, and we run and I'll be back Friday

0:56:34.200 --> 0:56:35.440
<v Speaker 7>with I think Crystal and Griffin.

0:56:35.520 --> 0:56:36.399
<v Speaker 3>All right, see you then.