00:00:02 Speaker 1: Bloomberg Audio Studios, podcasts, radio. 00:00:06 Speaker 2: News chez VIBM trading near the lowest level since November twenty four. September twenty twenty four, the company dialed back its full year sales forecast after a pretty steep drop in mainframe sales, which weighed on results. Joining us from New York is the co host of Bloomberg's The Clothes Remain Bustic alongside IBM CEO Avin Krishna remain Arvan. 00:00:28 Speaker 1: You've seen the reaction amongst investors. Here are some concerns here about that lowered sales forecast overall, as well as softness in software. You've characterized this as basically a shortfall for one quarter that is limited to CAPEX sensitive areas of the portfolio, but that's still a meaningful area of your portfolio. Were sales coming into that quarter? Was that pipeline overstated? 00:00:52 Speaker 3: I don't believe so, because when we look at all the deals that didn't close, I think we have done enough verification include with the clients to know that they were very real and it was a reprioritization of the CAPEC spend. At the end of the quarter. This was pretty confined to I'll call it the fortune one hundred the deals that were within a subset of those, now one third of what didn't happen has already come back, So that tells us that this was a reprioritization and those deals are very real as opposed to us being optimistic in our projections and Romain I would also add, I think that maintaining a free cash flow tells us that we have levels around productivity and conviction and confidence in the business, and that is also I think going to serve our investor as well. 00:01:42 Speaker 4: But the next few months will tell us that. 00:01:43 Speaker 1: Well on that cash flow figure, yes, and that certainly pleased a lot of analysts and investors out there, that billion dollar number of protective free cash flow growth. You maintaining the dividend as well, but you're largely done that so far by cutting costs. So that raises the question that if we are anticipating slower growth on the revenue side, does that mean more cost cuts are in store. 00:02:05 Speaker 3: So the bulk of our cash flow growth over the last four years has actually been on a just adbita, so that tells you that this is mostly through revenue growth. And our model has always been that we are the last dollar is more productive and more profitable than the first dollar. So we've been growing revenue four five percent and we've been growing cash flow up in the seven eight nine percent. So that's kind of our model and we intend to keep maintaining that now. Right now, if we drop revenue by one point because we said four to five instead of five plus, we can absolutely make it through productivity. Cost cuts is an interesting question. Costcuts doesn't always come down to people reduction in headcount. Our headcount has been more or less flat over the last many years. I think there's a lot of third party spend where we are going to get a lot more efficient that third party spend than we have been always. 00:03:04 Speaker 2: Bloomberg Tech is live on Bloomberg Television and Bloomberg Radio and we're speaking with the IBM CEO of in Krishna IV in good morning. You want to focus on accelerating revenue growth and accelerating profitability and just really simply, I'd love to hear what you're asking the team to do differently now in response to all of the factors that you outlined. 00:03:25 Speaker 3: So ed really, so if I look at our software business, eighty percent of it is already an annuity consumption opics BUSS business. Twenty percent of it is a CAPEX business. If we think that the CAPEX headwinds are going to continue, but eighty percent is already growing at about eight percent, we want to put a lot more focus. So we are going to direct a lot of the team with forward deployment engineers, with people who are focused on deploying the software at clients, much more technical help and make that eighty percent grow even faster. Product red Hat, Confluent, Harshi all fit that model. On the capech side, we have to make sure that while we can continue to do it, don't depend upon outsized growth on that side to go there. Then on the supply chain, can we leverage all of our capability and supply chain to make sure we have enough distributed infrastructure in storage in Unix systems that people can fulfill all of the demand. Because we came out of the second quarter with half a billion dollars of backlog in that part of the portfolio. So those give you an idea of the kind of changes that we're making already, not just for the rest of the half. 00:04:39 Speaker 2: You summarize the state of the world beautifully you said that customers shifted spending towards servers, storage and memory in late June, and when I posted on social media You're coming on the show that The question from the audience really simple. Did that trend continue from June into July? And for how long do you expect it to last? 00:05:00 Speaker 3: We have not seen it in July, but I would tell you, Look, the semiconductor pricing memory is up what three to four times over the last eighteen months. Networking infrastructure is up sixty to eighty percent, Fiber is up, connectors are up. I do think that some of these trends on the underlying components are going to carry on for some more time that works its way up into those things. So people are going to have those prices. Now, the question is is that going to maintain a reprioritization of the capex spent? If I take the signal that a third of our deals closed, then that says no, people are going to get more careful about how to spend their capex. If that goes into September, because a lot of capex does get committed at the end of a quarter, not always through, then it means that that carries on for some more time, and that is why we gave a guide of four to five percent. Depending upon if that carries on, we'll be at the low end of the ring, but some of it comes back, then we'll be at the high end of the range. 00:06:03 Speaker 1: So Aravin, I know there's a big focus right now on sort of the clients that sort of did not necessarily materialize in the quarter. With regards to the existing clients that you have, and I'm primarily referring to your mainframe business, I mean, can you share, like sort of what percentage of those clients are actually increasing their spending? Is that going up still? 00:06:22 Speaker 3: Absolutely so. The current machine is called the Z seventeen. The Z seventeen has been from the beginning, which was May of twenty twenty five to today at one hundred and thirty percent in terms of the capacity growth compared to the prior machine. That's one very strong signal, and that's an aggregate. Then you can say, hey, is everybody in there or only a few eighty five percent of the clients are increasing their capacity as opposed to the fifteen who are not. That optimization goes on all the time, and I would tell you this is probably the best that we have seen in a long time of what is going on there. Software to lag? 00:07:02 Speaker 1: Yeah, software is going to I mean, look, we know the hardware capacity is there. Software is lag and I understand why it's lagging in the moment. And I'm gonna ask you a question, and I forgive me if it's a bit unfair, but I look back to the nineteen nineties and whether there are some parallels to some of the mainframe issues that IBM went through back then under a predecessor two or three times removed from you, John Acres, and this idea that at that time we were going through this paradigm shift in computing and how companies spent and allocated their money. And there was a lot of talk by the CEO then that the issues were temporary, that they were economic, and that they were right them sales. We know in hindsight that it was much more structural. Why should we now look at this major shift going on with AI and the computation involved in that and think that this time is different. 00:07:49 Speaker 3: Well, we have to look at what the clients are doing. I always thought there our opinion is an opinion, what clients do is what matters. So when I check with my clients, those who do a credit card authorizations, are you going to maintain the mainframe and they go to all the resilience, the amount of capacity, the unit cost of it being five to fifteen times cheaper is important. The big difference from that time early nineteen nineties to today Romain is the cost issue. You could not argue that the mainframe was cheaper on a unit cost basis for the workloads that. 00:08:25 Speaker 4: Are moving off. 00:08:26 Speaker 3: Then at that time, the mid range computers I'll call it the whole Unix, it wasn't really client server, it was Unix taking the workloads off in the early nineteen nineties. That issue you have to look at if there is a cheaper alternate for that workload. I'll sort of look at you and say that means in five to fifteen years it will move off. 00:08:47 Speaker 4: But that's not the case right now. For the workloads that are on. 00:08:50 Speaker 3: We can show the clients that it's five to fifteen times cheaper to keep it on the mainframe, they're not. But that's not all workloads. That is workloads that need protection, that need resilience, that need the bus capacity that comes. And so for those kinds of workloads, the main frame is the architecturally superior platform that was not the case thirty years ago. For the workloads that did go off. 00:09:14 Speaker 2: Live on Bloomberg Television and on Bloomberg Radio. This is Bloomberg Tech speaking with IBMCO r Vin Krishna. I've been listening to you a lot recently on long form podcasts, some clips on the social media about your view of the world, what it's like to be a CEO in the domains that IBM operates in. And it's interesting how quickly it comes back to the macroeconomic backdrop. A lot of people looked at the guidance for the balance of this year and would say, and they do say, are in on this show memory prices are not changing, they continue to push higher. They look at the outlook for growth. Could you just explain the data points you rely on that give you the confidence on the new guidance that you've given and whether it is actually achievable or it will be difficult to meet. 00:10:02 Speaker 3: Yeah, so, Ed, I'll come back to For ourselves, we have to look at our demand pipelines and our yields and how we get things going. But I think for your audience, let's look at it this way. Number one most important is what is GDP growth going to be. We think that that's between two and three percent for the year. If I look at the globe and it is going to be consistent, even in the Middle East, even in Asia where there is a lot more energy and disruption. 00:10:30 Speaker 4: We actually see a lot of growth. 00:10:33 Speaker 3: Tech is going to be I think two to three to four points above that. So that puts tech in terms of what the market is somewhere in the five six seven percent. Then that comes back to what parts of our portfolio can play against that demand and what parts cannot. And so I look at the parts of the software portfolio. That's what I talked about, the eight percent growth in the eighty percent of it that can play right into that. Then I look at our distributed infrastructure that can play right into that. I think consulting will be that one two three percent. It is not going to be in the double digit growers. But we see the demand and we see the signings, and we see the clients leaning in to say they want transformational work done. That's how we kind of know beginning with the macro and then coming down I'll make a prediction for you. I think technology spend is going to become a larger and larger part of every enterprise's budget. 00:11:29 Speaker 4: Used to be three percent. 00:11:30 Speaker 3: Since remain raised the thirty years ago, is probably up at five six percent on average. I will not be surprised if by twenty thirty five it's ten percent of everyone's budget. Give you a quick micro case study. Bloomberg reported that Starbucks is replacing some IBM tools on the software side with in house. 00:11:50 Speaker 4: Let's talk to that. 00:11:51 Speaker 3: So Starbucks is about a little over two million dollars a year client for IBM. The portion they're replacing is a product called tri Regard that it does real estate Lee's management. The version of it that Starbucks has is almost ten years old. I'm not surprised at a replacing it because I've actually been describing publicly software which is largely interaction based and is based on ease of use as opposed to anything else, can be easily replaced by AI and AI agents, and that is what is going on there. However, if I see other parts of Starbucks and maybe the ability for our harshy portfolio or security portfolio, I'm a loutf afraid it this way, I would not be surprised if Starbucks is a larger client next year than it was last year. 00:12:40 Speaker 1: With regards to how this world is evolving, Arvin, I am curious that just internally about your plans to hire, particularly when it comes to the technological side. Have you been able to keep pace with some of the other companies out there also trying to do what you do and pay some of the salaries that you have to pay. 00:13:00 Speaker 3: Well, we hired three times as many college hires this year than we did last year, and I think that given others seem to be backing off college hiring, it gives us an incredible ability to bring in great talent and to then grow them inside our company and to offer them great careers. I think if I looked at it last we had I think twenty million resumes in our applicant database, so that gives us a huge field to go look at. So I mean I don't worry about bringing in talent. I actually worry much more about can we give them a great career and a great pathway because not everybody is cut out to do work that is going to be demanded. Because I don't think there's a lack of employment, but the nature of the work. If you can't use AI tools, if you can't use the productivity tools, then it's going to be really hard for you to be competitive with your peers. 00:13:56 Speaker 1: We always we already know sort of the potential impact what AI means for the economy and for your business. There are a lot of people looking around the corner, including yourself, to quantum. Is that a viable business on the horizon or is that just a moonshot that you're hoping actually. 00:14:12 Speaker 3: Sticks well when things are two years away. I wouldn't call them a moonshot. I think quantum is now in the engineering realm, as opposed to the science realm for the next five years, and I believe that by twenty twenty nine we will deliver a machine that does one hundred million competitions of large scale, fault tolerant quantum computer in the next two years. I think that's an incredible opportunity. I'll quantify it. And this is not just our work, a lot of third parties. By the end of twenty thirties, we think it's about a trillion dollar total market opportunity in terms of value that quantum will create. That is why we also double down this morning and announced that we bought HRL from GM and Boeing and that is going to help us bring people with a lot of talent around materials, spintronics, quantum sensing and other sense that technology is to add to our own effort, so we are even more well positioned to go win in this market. 00:15:17 Speaker 2: Avin Krishna IBM CEO, of course, alongside Bloomberg's remain bustic. Thank you both very much,