WEBVTT - Peter Thiel: “We Need to Hit the Accelerator As Hard As Possible” on AI

0:00:09.810 --> 0:00:14.150
<v Speaker 1>The Builders is a production of Kaleidoscope and iHeart, presented

0:00:14.310 --> 0:00:18.910
<v Speaker 1>by Ramp. Ramp is a financial operations platform that helps

0:00:19.030 --> 0:00:23.170
<v Speaker 1>ambitious companies manage their finances so their teams can spend

0:00:23.230 --> 0:00:27.050
<v Speaker 1>less time chasing receipts and approvals and more time bringing

0:00:27.170 --> 0:00:32.919
<v Speaker 1>extraordinary ideas to life. I'm Walter Isaacson. Welcome to The Builders,

0:00:33.420 --> 0:00:37.500
<v Speaker 1>my new series of interviews featuring the most consequential minds

0:00:37.640 --> 0:00:43.300
<v Speaker 1>shaping our future. In doing this series, I wanted to

0:00:43.450 --> 0:00:47.250
<v Speaker 1>understand the values and the moral views of the builders.

0:00:47.950 --> 0:00:51.450
<v Speaker 1>And I came to realize, better and for worse, they

0:00:51.490 --> 0:00:56.310
<v Speaker 1>were often quite unusual. Some were strongly libertarian. Others were

0:00:56.370 --> 0:00:59.970
<v Speaker 1>Nietzschean or dismissive of empathy. Some also had a very

0:01:00.110 --> 0:01:03.450
<v Speaker 1>dark view of humanity. I felt maybe they should touch

0:01:03.510 --> 0:01:05.929
<v Speaker 1>grass every now and then, get out of their billionaire

0:01:05.990 --> 0:01:09.130
<v Speaker 1>bubbles and understand what the rest of us feel like.

0:01:10.310 --> 0:01:14.190
<v Speaker 1>We may want these people to build, but especially with

0:01:14.350 --> 0:01:18.910
<v Speaker 1>powerful technology, we need to make sure that we all

0:01:18.950 --> 0:01:23.580
<v Speaker 1>have a say. And that begins with understanding what they

0:01:23.640 --> 0:01:27.650
<v Speaker 1>are doing and why. And so today I'm speaking with

0:01:27.910 --> 0:01:28.610
<v Speaker 1>Peter Thiel.

0:01:28.860 --> 0:01:30.980
<v Speaker 2>Billionaire Silicon Valley investor Peter Thiel.

0:01:31.140 --> 0:01:34.120
<v Speaker 3>Peter Thiel is a high profile figure in Silicon Valley.

0:01:34.160 --> 0:01:36.280
<v Speaker 3>Peter Thiel is one of the most respected names in

0:01:36.300 --> 0:01:39.600
<v Speaker 3>the world of venture capital. In addition to his co-founding

0:01:39.660 --> 0:01:42.020
<v Speaker 3>of PayPal, he was also an early investor in companies

0:01:42.380 --> 0:01:44.080
<v Speaker 3>such as Facebook and LinkedIn.

0:01:44.670 --> 0:01:49.610
<v Speaker 1>Peter Thiel occupies a different role. He's a builder of builders.

0:01:49.990 --> 0:01:53.690
<v Speaker 1>He makes bets on people. Elon Musk at PayPal. Alex

0:01:53.750 --> 0:01:57.660
<v Speaker 1>Karp at Palantir. Sam Altman and the founders of OpenAI.

0:01:57.960 --> 0:02:00.840
<v Speaker 1>And he backed politicians such as J.D. Vance.

0:02:01.140 --> 0:02:05.170
<v Speaker 3>There's two reasons that Senator Vance could be a heartbeat

0:02:05.200 --> 0:02:07.450
<v Speaker 3>from presidency and basically the president.

0:02:07.490 --> 0:02:09.530
<v Speaker 2>The first is Peter. The second is Thiel.

0:02:09.970 --> 0:02:12.450
<v Speaker 1>To some, he's a visionary investor.

0:02:12.790 --> 0:02:14.430
<v Speaker 2>I think Peter is one of the most brilliant people

0:02:14.450 --> 0:02:16.570
<v Speaker 2>I've ever met. He thinks of things no one else does.

0:02:16.970 --> 0:02:19.329
<v Speaker 1>To others, he's a shadowy figure.

0:02:19.810 --> 0:02:22.550
<v Speaker 2>Peter Thiel is quiet and deadly. I think Teal is

0:02:22.870 --> 0:02:24.030
<v Speaker 2>pulling all the strings here.

0:02:24.240 --> 0:02:25.859
<v Speaker 3>I think he seems like a dark lord to a

0:02:25.919 --> 0:02:27.720
<v Speaker 3>lot of us, and it's like, do you think he

0:02:27.760 --> 0:02:29.680
<v Speaker 3>has an endgame that is, like, happy?

0:02:29.880 --> 0:02:33.179
<v Speaker 4>It's so strange to have this, you build autonomous drone technology,

0:02:33.880 --> 0:02:38.530
<v Speaker 4>you build domestic surveillance technology, and then your other pet

0:02:38.590 --> 0:02:41.550
<v Speaker 4>passion is the Antichrist.

0:02:42.450 --> 0:02:45.630
<v Speaker 1>So I wanted to ask the builder of builders, what

0:02:45.669 --> 0:02:49.650
<v Speaker 1>does he believe we are building toward? Are the fears

0:02:49.900 --> 0:02:54.200
<v Speaker 1>that are sweeping the headlines grounded in reality? And what

0:02:54.220 --> 0:02:57.200
<v Speaker 1>does he mean when he goes around the world giving

0:02:57.360 --> 0:03:03.660
<v Speaker 1>lectures about the Antichrist? But perhaps most importantly, have we

0:03:03.780 --> 0:03:07.660
<v Speaker 1>concentrated way too much power in the hands of people

0:03:08.160 --> 0:03:10.820
<v Speaker 1>who have the demons in drive that allow them to

0:03:10.880 --> 0:03:15.290
<v Speaker 1>be audacious builders, but may not have the empathy and

0:03:15.370 --> 0:03:19.690
<v Speaker 1>stable moral compass to be good stewards of this technology?

0:03:22.280 --> 0:03:31.850
<v Speaker 1>So here's my conversation with Peter Thiel. Peter Thiel, thank

0:03:31.870 --> 0:03:33.010
<v Speaker 1>you for joining The Builders.

0:03:33.610 --> 0:03:34.550
<v Speaker 2>Thanks for having me.

0:03:34.570 --> 0:03:39.050
<v Speaker 1>We've seen this enormous backlash in the past few months

0:03:39.710 --> 0:03:42.490
<v Speaker 1>against AI. What is causing that?

0:03:43.790 --> 0:03:46.690
<v Speaker 2>Yeah, I agree with the what that it's happening. You know,

0:03:46.790 --> 0:03:51.090
<v Speaker 2>why questions are always much harder to much more speculative

0:03:51.110 --> 0:03:54.410
<v Speaker 2>in nature. I'm tempted to say it's somewhat overdetermined. It's

0:03:54.450 --> 0:03:57.750
<v Speaker 2>very unclear who the winners and losers from AI will be.

0:03:58.010 --> 0:04:00.610
<v Speaker 2>I think it's going to add a lot to growth,

0:04:00.650 --> 0:04:03.210
<v Speaker 2>but it will do so in a fairly disruptive kind

0:04:03.250 --> 0:04:06.350
<v Speaker 2>of a way. There are, of course, these dystopian science

0:04:06.400 --> 0:04:11.680
<v Speaker 2>fiction scenarios that in some ways we believe, and maybe

0:04:11.700 --> 0:04:14.580
<v Speaker 2>they're not entirely unreasonable. There's some Small tail.

0:04:14.600 --> 0:04:16.240
<v Speaker 1>Dystopian mean that we'll all be white.

0:04:16.260 --> 0:04:18.080
<v Speaker 2>The Terminator movie, the Matrix.

0:04:18.120 --> 0:04:21.060
<v Speaker 1>But we see that Dario and Elon and Sam are

0:04:21.100 --> 0:04:22.100
<v Speaker 1>now talking about that.

0:04:22.140 --> 0:04:26.520
<v Speaker 2>Yeah, to some extent they've leaned into it or partially

0:04:26.580 --> 0:04:29.040
<v Speaker 2>believed it or too many of their employees believed it.

0:04:29.630 --> 0:04:32.690
<v Speaker 2>And so there was, yeah, there's some prehistory where this

0:04:33.029 --> 0:04:34.469
<v Speaker 2>was in the air for a long time.

0:04:34.550 --> 0:04:37.490
<v Speaker 1>I think Elon believes it for a decade.

0:04:37.650 --> 0:04:41.909
<v Speaker 2>Well, you know, it was in some ways when Demis

0:04:41.970 --> 0:04:45.570
<v Speaker 2>has created DeepMind. And it gets sold to Google. Elon

0:04:45.589 --> 0:04:48.410
<v Speaker 2>and Sam create OpenAI, you know, the next year or

0:04:48.470 --> 0:04:52.190
<v Speaker 2>so after that. And it's basically, in some ways, it's

0:04:52.210 --> 0:04:56.170
<v Speaker 2>an anti-Google company, right? This technology is too important, too

0:04:56.210 --> 0:04:59.529
<v Speaker 2>dangerous to be just, you know, in a single company.

0:05:00.070 --> 0:05:01.630
<v Speaker 2>And then, of course, there are people who take it

0:05:01.670 --> 0:05:05.060
<v Speaker 2>even more seriously than Altman. I think Elon exits around 2018.

0:05:05.060 --> 0:05:09.919
<v Speaker 2>And then by 2020, you have, or thereabouts, it's the

0:05:09.960 --> 0:05:14.109
<v Speaker 2>seven people who start Anthropic exit. from open AI. In

0:05:14.190 --> 0:05:17.099
<v Speaker 2>some sense, they want to take these issues even more

0:05:17.150 --> 0:05:21.279
<v Speaker 2>seriously than before. You know, effective altruism, this idea had

0:05:21.300 --> 0:05:22.339
<v Speaker 2>been in the air for a while.

0:05:22.460 --> 0:05:25.440
<v Speaker 1>Wait, explain that because people are now saying it's sort

0:05:25.480 --> 0:05:30.339
<v Speaker 1>of a psyops or David Sachs conspiracy theory of effective altruism.

0:05:30.720 --> 0:05:33.180
<v Speaker 1>And I think even people like me vaguely know what

0:05:33.200 --> 0:05:35.500
<v Speaker 1>Sam Bankman Free was on about. Well, you don't get that.

0:05:35.580 --> 0:05:36.260
<v Speaker 1>Tell me about that.

0:05:36.920 --> 0:05:40.599
<v Speaker 2>Well, there's a lot of history, but even if you

0:05:40.700 --> 0:05:43.280
<v Speaker 2>go back to the 2000s in the East Bay of

0:05:43.360 --> 0:05:46.890
<v Speaker 2>Silicon Valley, Berkeley, Oakland, some of those places, it wasn't

0:05:46.910 --> 0:05:49.330
<v Speaker 2>where the big tech companies were being built, but there

0:05:49.370 --> 0:05:52.790
<v Speaker 2>was sort of a creativity with ideas. It was a

0:05:52.830 --> 0:05:57.230
<v Speaker 2>little bit adjacent to the new atheists. How could you

0:05:57.270 --> 0:06:00.750
<v Speaker 2>be more reasonable, rational? Where was the world heading? And

0:06:00.910 --> 0:06:06.060
<v Speaker 2>one big idea that these sort of futurists kept coming

0:06:06.120 --> 0:06:10.460
<v Speaker 2>back to was that perhaps something like AI could happen,

0:06:10.960 --> 0:06:13.730
<v Speaker 2>that perhaps it was closer than people thought. There had

0:06:13.770 --> 0:06:16.750
<v Speaker 2>been an AI desert for a long time. It had

0:06:16.770 --> 0:06:19.950
<v Speaker 2>been overpromised for many decades. But on the other hand,

0:06:20.330 --> 0:06:24.250
<v Speaker 2>Moore's law was still progressing. The computers were relentlessly getting

0:06:24.600 --> 0:06:27.159
<v Speaker 2>more powerful, and perhaps it was not a question of

0:06:27.860 --> 0:06:32.460
<v Speaker 2>necessarily a much better algorithm. Perhaps it was just almost

0:06:32.520 --> 0:06:35.260
<v Speaker 2>a hardware problem that once you got the chips and

0:06:35.279 --> 0:06:38.159
<v Speaker 2>the computers that were powerful enough, it would be more

0:06:38.200 --> 0:06:42.080
<v Speaker 2>likely that something like this would happen. And then that

0:06:42.100 --> 0:06:44.660
<v Speaker 2>this would be a very, very big thing when it happened,

0:06:44.980 --> 0:06:48.580
<v Speaker 2>that this would be an enormous, at least socially transformative thing.

0:06:49.140 --> 0:06:51.700
<v Speaker 2>It was potentially very dangerous. It could be, maybe it

0:06:51.720 --> 0:06:54.659
<v Speaker 2>could be weaponized. Maybe there were these science fiction scenarios

0:06:54.680 --> 0:06:57.060
<v Speaker 2>where the AI would almost become autonomous. So there were

0:06:57.080 --> 0:07:00.100
<v Speaker 2>sort of very many, very many different kinds of scenarios.

0:07:00.220 --> 0:07:01.800
<v Speaker 2>And then there were, of course, parts of it that were,

0:07:02.400 --> 0:07:06.860
<v Speaker 2>I don't know, crazy and almost cult-like. But it had

0:07:07.080 --> 0:07:09.440
<v Speaker 2>maybe the good dimension of a cult where there was

0:07:09.660 --> 0:07:13.200
<v Speaker 2>one big thing they knew that the other people did not.

0:07:13.220 --> 0:07:15.620
<v Speaker 2>And I think even though there are ways I'd like

0:07:15.640 --> 0:07:17.850
<v Speaker 2>to be very critical of them today, there were ways

0:07:17.870 --> 0:07:20.630
<v Speaker 2>they got that one big thing right. And then, you know,

0:07:20.890 --> 0:07:24.190
<v Speaker 2>has a cult ever started a company as successful as Anthropic?

0:07:24.570 --> 0:07:27.390
<v Speaker 2>Even a billion-dollar company seems like bigger than a crazed

0:07:27.430 --> 0:07:28.930
<v Speaker 2>cult could build. So if you have a cult that's

0:07:28.970 --> 0:07:32.560
<v Speaker 2>built a company that's worth probably close to $ 2 trillion

0:07:32.580 --> 0:07:35.510
<v Speaker 2>at the IPO, it would probably be the I don't know, sixth,

0:07:35.570 --> 0:07:39.050
<v Speaker 2>seventh largest company by market cap in the world, built

0:07:39.070 --> 0:07:42.490
<v Speaker 2>in like six, seven years. Has a cult ever done

0:07:42.550 --> 0:07:46.180
<v Speaker 2>something like that? So, yes. So I want to be

0:07:46.210 --> 0:07:49.920
<v Speaker 2>critical of them, and they're things I'm uncomfortable and critical about.

0:07:50.400 --> 0:07:52.820
<v Speaker 2>But the first thing I would try to do is always,

0:07:52.840 --> 0:07:54.460
<v Speaker 2>you always want to steel man your opponents. You want

0:07:54.480 --> 0:07:57.140
<v Speaker 2>to try to understand them as well as they understand

0:07:57.180 --> 0:08:00.140
<v Speaker 2>themselves or even make their arguments better. And the way

0:08:00.160 --> 0:08:02.500
<v Speaker 2>I would steel man the effective altruists is, first off,

0:08:02.540 --> 0:08:04.320
<v Speaker 2>they got one enormously big thing right.

0:08:04.970 --> 0:08:07.270
<v Speaker 1>And that one enormously big thing was.

0:08:07.420 --> 0:08:08.940
<v Speaker 2>AI is around the corner.

0:08:09.190 --> 0:08:13.380
<v Speaker 1>But also that it could become misaligned with human values?

0:08:15.860 --> 0:08:18.640
<v Speaker 2>The way AI was classically defined, let's say. There were

0:08:18.660 --> 0:08:21.680
<v Speaker 2>all these different definitions of AI, of course. It could

0:08:21.720 --> 0:08:25.160
<v Speaker 2>be just sort of machine learning and sort of like

0:08:25.300 --> 0:08:27.840
<v Speaker 2>maybe cameras everywhere or something like that. It's a sort

0:08:27.860 --> 0:08:30.470
<v Speaker 2>of totalitarian AI that you have in China. Or it

0:08:30.570 --> 0:08:33.990
<v Speaker 2>could be this sort of super-duper AI with a godlike

0:08:34.030 --> 0:08:36.690
<v Speaker 2>intelligence or something, which was sort of the Nick Bostrom

0:08:37.309 --> 0:08:41.000
<v Speaker 2>kind of fantasy. But the in-between version of AI was

0:08:41.480 --> 0:08:45.000
<v Speaker 2>not that it would be this dumb surveillance cameras, not

0:08:45.020 --> 0:08:47.579
<v Speaker 2>that it would be godlike, but it would be like

0:08:47.620 --> 0:08:50.400
<v Speaker 2>a human being. That had been the AI test. The

0:08:50.420 --> 0:08:53.849
<v Speaker 2>Turing test from the beginning was it's not that it

0:08:54.250 --> 0:08:57.130
<v Speaker 2>is a human being, but that it can fool you

0:08:57.230 --> 0:09:00.740
<v Speaker 2>into thinking. it's a person. And from the outputs, you

0:09:00.800 --> 0:09:04.740
<v Speaker 2>can't tell the difference. Yeah, that's going to be a very,

0:09:05.260 --> 0:09:07.660
<v Speaker 2>very big deal. And it raises all sorts of, you know,

0:09:07.920 --> 0:09:11.990
<v Speaker 2>raises even basic economics questions. Is it an economic compliment

0:09:12.000 --> 0:09:14.230
<v Speaker 2>to people? Is it a substitute for people?

0:09:14.390 --> 0:09:16.990
<v Speaker 1>Well, let's do both of those. There's two big things

0:09:17.050 --> 0:09:21.270
<v Speaker 1>it raises. One is, what will it do to human labor?

0:09:21.650 --> 0:09:24.469
<v Speaker 1>You know, will it create more jobs and more productivity?

0:09:24.990 --> 0:09:27.380
<v Speaker 1>Or will it, pretty much put us out of work

0:09:27.420 --> 0:09:30.920
<v Speaker 1>and we'll have to figure out what we do. That's

0:09:31.200 --> 0:09:35.040
<v Speaker 1>part of the backlash, especially my students at Tulane are like,

0:09:35.240 --> 0:09:39.940
<v Speaker 1>wait a minute. So tell me your feeling about that backlash.

0:09:40.660 --> 0:09:42.880
<v Speaker 2>Okay. So let me start by answering what I think

0:09:42.900 --> 0:09:45.850
<v Speaker 2>will happen with a qualifier that nobody really knows and

0:09:46.040 --> 0:09:49.589
<v Speaker 2>nobody can be certain. I think in aggregate, on a

0:09:49.630 --> 0:09:54.230
<v Speaker 2>macroeconomic level, AI will increase productivity a lot. It will

0:09:54.250 --> 0:09:58.650
<v Speaker 2>be a fairly... disinflationary force in our economy and then

0:09:59.130 --> 0:10:03.920
<v Speaker 2>unless it's incredibly narrowly captured by a few companies, you'd

0:10:03.960 --> 0:10:06.900
<v Speaker 2>expect the median person to be better off or things

0:10:06.970 --> 0:10:09.309
<v Speaker 2>like that. And this was, you know, the Luddites in

0:10:09.330 --> 0:10:11.569
<v Speaker 2>the 19th century were always worried that the machines would

0:10:11.590 --> 0:10:14.470
<v Speaker 2>replace the people. And then of course, you know, what

0:10:14.510 --> 0:10:17.830
<v Speaker 2>happened in practice was, yeah, there was definitely various industries,

0:10:17.870 --> 0:10:21.050
<v Speaker 2>sometimes even big industries where there was a lot of disruption,

0:10:21.640 --> 0:10:24.340
<v Speaker 2>then it would free people up to do more productive things,

0:10:24.420 --> 0:10:29.340
<v Speaker 2>to do other things. And that's still my intuition with AI.

0:10:29.500 --> 0:10:32.059
<v Speaker 1>But real quick, before you go on, you said unless

0:10:32.120 --> 0:10:34.939
<v Speaker 1>it's captured by a few companies, are you worried that

0:10:35.000 --> 0:10:38.420
<v Speaker 1>indeed we're about to have four or five companies capture it?

0:10:39.800 --> 0:10:45.809
<v Speaker 2>It's certainly, yeah, and certainly there's a history where most

0:10:45.830 --> 0:10:47.990
<v Speaker 2>of the history of tech innovation, I would say for 200,

0:10:47.990 --> 0:10:53.240
<v Speaker 2>250 years, relatively small parts of the innovation were captured

0:10:53.270 --> 0:10:57.360
<v Speaker 2>by business. They mostly went to consumers, to workers, to

0:10:57.380 --> 0:11:01.000
<v Speaker 2>the rest of the economy. There are ways that software

0:11:01.300 --> 0:11:04.300
<v Speaker 2>and the internet were somewhat of an exception. And so

0:11:05.020 --> 0:11:10.020
<v Speaker 2>we had these enormously successful businesses. Maybe they were natural

0:11:10.070 --> 0:11:14.190
<v Speaker 2>monopolies of sorts. They were in some sense good for consumers,

0:11:14.230 --> 0:11:19.050
<v Speaker 2>but also extremely profitable. And so there's a pattern matching

0:11:19.440 --> 0:11:22.840
<v Speaker 2>to what happened with the internet that I think people

0:11:23.820 --> 0:11:27.540
<v Speaker 2>quite reasonably are worried about will happen with AI. And

0:11:28.540 --> 0:11:31.890
<v Speaker 2>maybe it's an even bigger market. It's a bigger technology.

0:11:32.370 --> 0:11:32.990
<v Speaker 2>And so perhaps.

0:11:33.010 --> 0:11:34.750
<v Speaker 1>So you would try to stop that. In other words,

0:11:34.850 --> 0:11:35.929
<v Speaker 1>our antitrust laws.

0:11:36.590 --> 0:11:39.650
<v Speaker 2>Well, yeah, the question is, is that how likely do

0:11:39.670 --> 0:11:42.550
<v Speaker 2>you think that's going to happen? The intuition that I

0:11:42.590 --> 0:11:46.859
<v Speaker 2>have on the other side is that... One of the

0:11:46.900 --> 0:11:49.620
<v Speaker 2>questions I always like asking companies is, tell me why

0:11:49.660 --> 0:11:52.250
<v Speaker 2>you have a monopoly. Monopolies, we can sort of debate

0:11:52.270 --> 0:11:54.670
<v Speaker 2>whether they're good or bad for society. Obviously, we have IP.

0:11:54.690 --> 0:11:57.750
<v Speaker 2>We have all kinds of good forms of monopoly. But

0:11:58.110 --> 0:12:00.630
<v Speaker 2>on the inside, yeah, you don't want to have just

0:12:00.690 --> 0:12:04.080
<v Speaker 2>cutthroat competition where all the profits get competed away. And

0:12:04.100 --> 0:12:06.340
<v Speaker 2>the kind of narratives people tell me when they pitch

0:12:06.380 --> 0:12:12.559
<v Speaker 2>me on AI companies, they're narratives of growth, of terrific technology.

0:12:12.960 --> 0:12:16.500
<v Speaker 2>They are incredibly weak on the monopoly story. And then

0:12:16.520 --> 0:12:19.179
<v Speaker 2>the felt sense of it is that it's like this

0:12:19.220 --> 0:12:24.920
<v Speaker 2>incredibly fast, dynamic race where it's been changing a lot. DeepMind,

0:12:24.940 --> 0:12:27.270
<v Speaker 2>in a sense, was in the lead in the early 2010s.

0:12:28.100 --> 0:12:32.839
<v Speaker 2>Then OpenAI with ChatGPT and the transformer models was able

0:12:32.880 --> 0:12:37.300
<v Speaker 2>to replace that. And then in some ways, Altman locked

0:12:37.380 --> 0:12:39.440
<v Speaker 2>up a lot of the chips and built the data

0:12:39.460 --> 0:12:41.359
<v Speaker 2>centers preemptively. So there were sort of all sorts of

0:12:41.400 --> 0:12:47.400
<v Speaker 2>ways he correctly leaned into this incredibly cap X intensive strategy.

0:12:47.960 --> 0:12:50.020
<v Speaker 2>And then there still is a sense where, you know,

0:12:50.059 --> 0:12:53.720
<v Speaker 2>maybe anthropic is a little bit more in the pole

0:12:53.760 --> 0:12:56.620
<v Speaker 2>position now than open AI was. And, you know, it's

0:12:56.660 --> 0:12:59.020
<v Speaker 2>always hard to exactly score these things, but I would

0:12:59.070 --> 0:13:02.730
<v Speaker 2>say that it also still feels that Google and Meta

0:13:03.790 --> 0:13:07.530
<v Speaker 2>and Grok are not that far behind. I'm not sure

0:13:07.570 --> 0:13:10.010
<v Speaker 2>China is that far behind. Or if we, if we

0:13:10.150 --> 0:13:13.410
<v Speaker 2>described on the level of the Shakespearean drama among these people,

0:13:14.410 --> 0:13:18.460
<v Speaker 2>it's like really crazy. So they're acting like, man, it

0:13:18.500 --> 0:13:20.880
<v Speaker 2>is a fight to the death. It is the furthest

0:13:20.940 --> 0:13:24.380
<v Speaker 2>thing from monopoly imaginable. And if it's not a monopoly,

0:13:24.900 --> 0:13:28.460
<v Speaker 2>that's where I think the benefits will be likely distributed

0:13:28.540 --> 0:13:31.100
<v Speaker 2>pretty widely in society. Now, if I had to steel

0:13:31.120 --> 0:13:34.450
<v Speaker 2>man the anxiety, which was your starting question, you could

0:13:34.490 --> 0:13:36.970
<v Speaker 2>have a lot of growth and the median person could

0:13:36.990 --> 0:13:39.790
<v Speaker 2>be better off. But if it's with a lot of volatility,

0:13:40.330 --> 0:13:44.140
<v Speaker 2>you expect to get a 3% wage hike, but it's

0:13:44.260 --> 0:13:47.900
<v Speaker 2>plus or minus 10% or something like that. And we're

0:13:47.940 --> 0:13:51.540
<v Speaker 2>kind of in this society that doesn't really like risk,

0:13:51.660 --> 0:13:55.260
<v Speaker 2>doesn't like that sort of volatility. It doesn't like disruption.

0:13:55.750 --> 0:13:58.510
<v Speaker 2>So yes, it may be good for the median person.

0:13:58.990 --> 0:14:01.690
<v Speaker 2>The good may be sort of unknown. The bad things

0:14:01.730 --> 0:14:04.510
<v Speaker 2>are more predictable and the disruption is clear. So I

0:14:04.530 --> 0:14:07.750
<v Speaker 2>think even on the economic level, I can understand the anxiety,

0:14:07.790 --> 0:14:10.089
<v Speaker 2>even though I think it is misguided.

0:14:10.780 --> 0:14:13.459
<v Speaker 1>Well, you talk about there being a lot of competition

0:14:13.720 --> 0:14:17.850
<v Speaker 1>among these, and that seems like generally a good thing. Although,

0:14:18.110 --> 0:14:20.550
<v Speaker 1>in some ways, if it was just one or two companies,

0:14:21.050 --> 0:14:24.550
<v Speaker 1>you could control it better, regulate it for safety better.

0:14:25.050 --> 0:14:30.110
<v Speaker 1>And secondly, the competition, either amongst these companies or with China,

0:14:30.710 --> 0:14:34.730
<v Speaker 1>means you can't pause the way people are saying now,

0:14:35.050 --> 0:14:36.430
<v Speaker 1>shouldn't we be pausing this?

0:14:37.450 --> 0:14:40.760
<v Speaker 2>That seems correct to me. You know, there's sort of

0:14:40.800 --> 0:14:44.560
<v Speaker 2>all these very complicated questions one can ask about China

0:14:44.700 --> 0:14:49.130
<v Speaker 2>or the CCP, Chinese Communist Party. But I'm, you know,

0:14:50.610 --> 0:14:53.610
<v Speaker 2>I worry about totalitarianism. I don't like it. And I

0:14:53.650 --> 0:14:57.590
<v Speaker 2>think there is a certain type of, you know, high-tech

0:14:57.750 --> 0:15:02.000
<v Speaker 2>totalitarianism that's being tried out in China. It's not as

0:15:02.060 --> 0:15:06.080
<v Speaker 2>violent as, you know, Stalin or Mao or Hitler. You

0:15:06.100 --> 0:15:08.980
<v Speaker 2>don't need to kill as many people. But it's somehow...

0:15:10.210 --> 0:15:13.050
<v Speaker 2>knows more about you than you know about yourself. And

0:15:13.560 --> 0:15:16.820
<v Speaker 2>there's something about that that we really don't want that

0:15:16.840 --> 0:15:17.860
<v Speaker 2>to be the model that wins.

0:15:17.900 --> 0:15:20.700
<v Speaker 1>And your old friend, David Sachs, and of course, President

0:15:20.740 --> 0:15:24.260
<v Speaker 1>Trump are now saying, because of the competition with China,

0:15:24.680 --> 0:15:28.530
<v Speaker 1>stop talking about pausing AI, even if you think it

0:15:28.550 --> 0:15:35.290
<v Speaker 1>could be an existential threat. Do you agree with that? Yes.

0:15:35.470 --> 0:15:38.440
<v Speaker 2>Yes. I broadly agree with that. I would say the

0:15:39.080 --> 0:15:43.100
<v Speaker 2>challenge that I've been friends with David Sachs for many decades.

0:15:43.620 --> 0:15:47.600
<v Speaker 2>The thing that makes me less comfortable making those kinds

0:15:47.640 --> 0:15:52.370
<v Speaker 2>of arguments publicly is that on some level, it's hard

0:15:52.410 --> 0:15:54.930
<v Speaker 2>when the big companies themselves are telling you to stop

0:15:55.250 --> 0:15:55.930
<v Speaker 2>and to slow down.

0:15:56.210 --> 0:15:58.710
<v Speaker 1>So that's caused you to have some pause because you

0:15:58.790 --> 0:16:01.130
<v Speaker 1>were not in the pause button camp.

0:16:01.910 --> 0:16:04.200
<v Speaker 2>Well, I'm still not in the pause button camp. And

0:16:04.420 --> 0:16:05.980
<v Speaker 2>I'm saying this on your show that I'm not in

0:16:06.000 --> 0:16:08.990
<v Speaker 2>the pause button. We need to hit the accelerator as

0:16:09.070 --> 0:16:10.030
<v Speaker 2>hard as possible.

0:16:10.390 --> 0:16:12.330
<v Speaker 1>Well, wait a minute. Let me stop that. Why haven't

0:16:12.510 --> 0:16:16.750
<v Speaker 1>the past few weeks caused you to be more amenable

0:16:16.790 --> 0:16:19.930
<v Speaker 1>to a pause button? It's pretty scary, that hugging phase.

0:16:19.950 --> 0:16:22.850
<v Speaker 2>You know, I think in some ways you have to

0:16:22.890 --> 0:16:25.989
<v Speaker 2>develop the AI technology to control the AI technology. So

0:16:26.830 --> 0:16:29.950
<v Speaker 2>if you assume China will develop things like that, it's

0:16:30.030 --> 0:16:31.790
<v Speaker 2>more imperative than ever that we stay ahead of them.

0:16:31.850 --> 0:16:34.970
<v Speaker 2>So if you look at it geopolitically, maybe you can

0:16:35.010 --> 0:16:37.440
<v Speaker 2>even interpret something like the hugging phase thing as, It's

0:16:37.540 --> 0:16:40.400
<v Speaker 2>so imperative that we not lose the lead and that

0:16:40.420 --> 0:16:42.340
<v Speaker 2>we get cyber attack to death.

0:16:42.920 --> 0:16:43.380
<v Speaker 1>The sort of.

0:16:43.500 --> 0:16:48.590
<v Speaker 2>In-between economic question that I find more central is I

0:16:48.970 --> 0:16:52.250
<v Speaker 2>think the way our society works on some level is

0:16:52.290 --> 0:16:55.710
<v Speaker 2>through economic growth. I think the middle class as the

0:16:55.770 --> 0:16:58.850
<v Speaker 2>people who expect their kids to do better than themselves.

0:16:58.910 --> 0:17:01.320
<v Speaker 2>And in that sense, the United States has been a

0:17:01.380 --> 0:17:05.199
<v Speaker 2>middle class society. And then what's gone a little bit

0:17:05.260 --> 0:17:07.399
<v Speaker 2>haywire is and where it's sort of been fraying at

0:17:07.440 --> 0:17:11.460
<v Speaker 2>the edges, is that the millennials, to some extent Gen Z,

0:17:12.020 --> 0:17:15.899
<v Speaker 2>have lost that generational expectation of progress.

0:17:16.540 --> 0:17:17.440
<v Speaker 1>And rightfully so.

0:17:18.200 --> 0:17:20.810
<v Speaker 2>And I don't know if AI is enough to do it,

0:17:21.119 --> 0:17:24.770
<v Speaker 2>bring it back. There's a risk that AI is unevenly distributed.

0:17:24.990 --> 0:17:27.690
<v Speaker 2>But I would say if we had outlawed the internet,

0:17:28.490 --> 0:17:31.670
<v Speaker 2>and if we now outlaw AI, there will be virtually

0:17:31.730 --> 0:17:34.670
<v Speaker 2>no growth. We will be looking more like Europe, more

0:17:34.710 --> 0:17:40.830
<v Speaker 2>like Japan, And that's a much nastier, zero-sum society where

0:17:40.930 --> 0:17:44.450
<v Speaker 2>there's no growth, there's a loser for every winner, and

0:17:44.710 --> 0:17:46.430
<v Speaker 2>that's a much worse world in a lot of ways.

0:17:46.609 --> 0:17:50.149
<v Speaker 1>Yeah, but one reason for the past 40, 50 years, millennials,

0:17:50.330 --> 0:17:53.090
<v Speaker 1>and the stagnation, and the fact people are being left behind,

0:17:53.530 --> 0:17:57.909
<v Speaker 1>is a lot of people, like me, believed in globalization, immigration,

0:17:58.010 --> 0:18:00.909
<v Speaker 1>free trade, free movement of capital, and we thought it

0:18:00.930 --> 0:18:04.100
<v Speaker 1>would cause growth. And guess what? It did. We were right.

0:18:04.780 --> 0:18:07.660
<v Speaker 1>What we didn't know is how badly that would leave

0:18:07.700 --> 0:18:11.220
<v Speaker 1>people behind. Is that true? And could that be true

0:18:11.260 --> 0:18:11.740
<v Speaker 1>of AI?

0:18:14.040 --> 0:18:17.960
<v Speaker 2>I think it was true of globalization that it led

0:18:18.020 --> 0:18:20.639
<v Speaker 2>to a decent amount of growth, both in our country

0:18:20.680 --> 0:18:25.410
<v Speaker 2>and other countries. And the growth was pretty uneven. There's

0:18:25.430 --> 0:18:30.330
<v Speaker 2>a risk of that with technology. I think it's, I

0:18:30.350 --> 0:18:33.170
<v Speaker 2>don't know. My intuition is always that the tech form

0:18:33.210 --> 0:18:36.840
<v Speaker 2>of growth is the kind that's better for an advanced

0:18:36.890 --> 0:18:40.520
<v Speaker 2>country than the globalization kind. The globalization is we're just

0:18:40.540 --> 0:18:44.020
<v Speaker 2>sort of taking advantage of labor market arbitrages and things

0:18:44.060 --> 0:18:47.080
<v Speaker 2>like that. And it works when people in China make 5%

0:18:47.080 --> 0:18:48.419
<v Speaker 2>as much as they do in the US and we

0:18:48.440 --> 0:18:52.230
<v Speaker 2>get cheap t-shirts and almost everyone's better off. And at

0:18:52.270 --> 0:18:56.590
<v Speaker 2>some point, it becomes more zero sum as globalization succeeds

0:18:56.630 --> 0:19:01.609
<v Speaker 2>and these arbitrages go down. Whereas technology, if it actually works...

0:19:01.859 --> 0:19:05.440
<v Speaker 2>It means doing more with less. It means improving not

0:19:05.480 --> 0:19:09.040
<v Speaker 2>the GDP of the whole country, but per capita GDP.

0:19:09.440 --> 0:19:12.860
<v Speaker 2>And so at its best, it has a more progressive character.

0:19:12.880 --> 0:19:16.380
<v Speaker 2>The problem in some ways was that the internet wasn't

0:19:16.420 --> 0:19:19.950
<v Speaker 2>big enough. It added some growth. It wasn't big enough.

0:19:20.790 --> 0:19:23.250
<v Speaker 2>I think AI is bigger than the internet. I think

0:19:23.710 --> 0:19:27.110
<v Speaker 2>it could be a way for us to really improve

0:19:27.270 --> 0:19:31.489
<v Speaker 2>per capita GDP in a smoother way. way than, let's say,

0:19:31.510 --> 0:19:32.430
<v Speaker 2>globalization did.

0:19:33.570 --> 0:19:36.940
<v Speaker 1>Don't go anywhere. There's a lot more right after this break.

0:19:49.000 --> 0:19:54.130
<v Speaker 1>Let me get back to the doomsday scenario that suddenly has, yeah,

0:19:54.430 --> 0:19:57.170
<v Speaker 1>you talked about Nick Bostrom and everybody's talked about it

0:19:57.190 --> 0:19:59.690
<v Speaker 1>for a while, but in the past few weeks after

0:19:59.730 --> 0:20:03.290
<v Speaker 1>Hugging Face and everything else, and when I read what

0:20:03.510 --> 0:20:06.629
<v Speaker 1>some of these agents have done and how they conspire,

0:20:06.990 --> 0:20:10.869
<v Speaker 1>the notion that they could become unaligned with the good

0:20:11.050 --> 0:20:15.189
<v Speaker 1>of humans is something that Darionne Amadei is now on

0:20:15.230 --> 0:20:19.610
<v Speaker 1>about Elon. Musk is on about so many others. Do

0:20:19.670 --> 0:20:24.030
<v Speaker 1>you have any worry, whether it's 5% or 10%, that

0:20:24.050 --> 0:20:26.050
<v Speaker 1>there is a doomsday scenario? And do you have any

0:20:26.130 --> 0:20:27.850
<v Speaker 1>backup plans? Do you have some bunker?

0:20:28.520 --> 0:20:29.910
<v Speaker 2>I don't think a bunker would help for that kind

0:20:29.930 --> 0:20:35.620
<v Speaker 2>of doomsday scenario. I don't think, you know, I think

0:20:35.859 --> 0:20:40.460
<v Speaker 2>people are very bad on their probabilistic intuitions. If you

0:20:40.640 --> 0:20:43.850
<v Speaker 2>ask the question, yes, 5% to 10%, sounds way too

0:20:43.910 --> 0:20:47.670
<v Speaker 2>high for like everybody on this planet getting killed. Don't

0:20:47.810 --> 0:20:50.070
<v Speaker 2>think that's going to happen. Maybe even a tiny bit

0:20:50.090 --> 0:20:52.730
<v Speaker 2>above zero is too high. But I think, I think

0:20:52.770 --> 0:20:55.609
<v Speaker 2>the intuitions on this are, are very poor. The way

0:20:55.650 --> 0:20:59.640
<v Speaker 2>I would push back though, is it's always also risky

0:20:59.960 --> 0:21:02.760
<v Speaker 2>not to innovate. It's dangerous not to hit the accelerator

0:21:03.060 --> 0:21:07.540
<v Speaker 2>because if China leapfrogs the U S and AI, and

0:21:07.560 --> 0:21:11.060
<v Speaker 2>we have this, an intensification of the geopolitical rivalry with China,

0:21:11.460 --> 0:21:13.480
<v Speaker 2>they may very well be tempted to use it as

0:21:13.520 --> 0:21:14.369
<v Speaker 2>a weapon against us.

0:21:14.480 --> 0:21:17.159
<v Speaker 1>Let's hold on for a second. Imagine just thought experiment.

0:21:17.310 --> 0:21:19.680
<v Speaker 1>There's no China. Then do you just put a pause

0:21:19.740 --> 0:21:21.330
<v Speaker 1>on this because it could be a Tuesday?

0:21:22.390 --> 0:21:22.630
<v Speaker 3>Mrs.

0:21:22.710 --> 0:21:25.890
<v Speaker 2>Lincoln, imagine. Besides that, how'd you like the play? So

0:21:26.510 --> 0:21:29.490
<v Speaker 2>that's too crazy a thought experiment. But then of course,

0:21:29.810 --> 0:21:32.389
<v Speaker 2>even if we have these multiple companies and they are

0:21:33.210 --> 0:21:35.639
<v Speaker 2>under a lot of pressure to develop it, to innovate it,

0:21:35.970 --> 0:21:38.210
<v Speaker 2>they have to be pretty careful that it not go

0:21:38.450 --> 0:21:40.270
<v Speaker 2>badly wrong. So I think They have a lot of

0:21:40.330 --> 0:21:42.670
<v Speaker 2>internal controls. They know more about it than the government does.

0:21:43.010 --> 0:21:46.530
<v Speaker 2>The government doesn't really know how to regulate it. I

0:21:46.550 --> 0:21:49.149
<v Speaker 2>don't know. This is too cynical a cut. But I

0:21:49.650 --> 0:21:52.850
<v Speaker 2>always think when they're telling the government people, we want

0:21:52.890 --> 0:21:55.810
<v Speaker 2>you to regulate us, perhaps they know the government doesn't

0:21:56.030 --> 0:21:57.709
<v Speaker 2>know how to do it and that it will be slow.

0:21:58.230 --> 0:22:00.030
<v Speaker 2>And so it sort of gets them a little bit

0:22:00.109 --> 0:22:02.369
<v Speaker 2>off the hook. And then when Trump said, no, you

0:22:02.430 --> 0:22:05.970
<v Speaker 2>already are subject to all sorts of criminal penalties if

0:22:05.990 --> 0:22:08.650
<v Speaker 2>you mess this up. I don't need to regulate you more.

0:22:09.080 --> 0:22:11.060
<v Speaker 2>The way in which Trump was actually saying we need

0:22:11.100 --> 0:22:14.140
<v Speaker 2>to go slow is you need to do it yourselves

0:22:14.300 --> 0:22:17.360
<v Speaker 2>and it's your responsibility, not mine. There was a version

0:22:17.380 --> 0:22:20.370
<v Speaker 2>of this discussion that I had when Meta was sort

0:22:20.380 --> 0:22:23.390
<v Speaker 2>of in this very tricky spin cycle for many, many years.

0:22:23.430 --> 0:22:26.070
<v Speaker 2>And I was on the board there from 2005 to 2022.

0:22:26.070 --> 0:22:32.030
<v Speaker 2>And circa 2018, 2019, the sort of company line that

0:22:32.070 --> 0:22:35.020
<v Speaker 2>Zuckerberg adopted was, you know, we think there needs to

0:22:35.060 --> 0:22:37.260
<v Speaker 2>be regulation and we would like the government to tell

0:22:37.300 --> 0:22:39.690
<v Speaker 2>us what we can and cannot do. And at some point,

0:22:39.730 --> 0:22:43.240
<v Speaker 2>I told Zuckerberg, who I believe still has the all-time

0:22:43.320 --> 0:22:46.840
<v Speaker 2>record for a private citizen being hauled in front of Congress.

0:22:46.859 --> 0:22:48.659
<v Speaker 2>And he was hauled in front of eight congressional committees.

0:22:48.680 --> 0:22:51.060
<v Speaker 2>And I told him, you know, they don't want to

0:22:51.140 --> 0:22:53.639
<v Speaker 2>regulate you. They want to yell at you. They want

0:22:53.660 --> 0:22:56.560
<v Speaker 2>to complain about you and yell at you. And of course,

0:22:56.580 --> 0:22:59.930
<v Speaker 2>you know, the other in-between version where it's not about

0:23:00.510 --> 0:23:03.670
<v Speaker 2>them wanting regulation or them secretly trying to stop regulation.

0:23:04.070 --> 0:23:07.530
<v Speaker 2>The other interpretation, you know, there are different audiences these

0:23:07.570 --> 0:23:11.350
<v Speaker 2>people have when they're when they're pushing for regulation, the

0:23:11.390 --> 0:23:16.330
<v Speaker 2>internal audience for their employees is, yes, we're working on

0:23:16.350 --> 0:23:20.540
<v Speaker 2>a technology that's potentially really dangerous, but man, it's important.

0:23:20.820 --> 0:23:22.719
<v Speaker 2>This is the most important company in the world to

0:23:22.760 --> 0:23:25.900
<v Speaker 2>work at. This is going to be an incredibly successful company.

0:23:26.359 --> 0:23:29.359
<v Speaker 2>The risk is we're going too fast, which nobody says. Yeah,

0:23:29.380 --> 0:23:31.699
<v Speaker 2>there's some part of it where it occasionally scares people

0:23:32.200 --> 0:23:34.179
<v Speaker 2>in these companies, and there are various people who've quit

0:23:34.660 --> 0:23:37.629
<v Speaker 2>and said things. But on some other level, I would

0:23:37.650 --> 0:23:41.469
<v Speaker 2>think it's incredible incredibly motivational because when Dario says, yeah,

0:23:41.490 --> 0:23:45.149
<v Speaker 2>this is a technology that's really big and really dangerous,

0:23:45.850 --> 0:23:48.820
<v Speaker 2>that's a way to tell all his employees you're working

0:23:49.119 --> 0:23:51.119
<v Speaker 2>at the greatest, most important company in the history of

0:23:51.140 --> 0:23:53.679
<v Speaker 2>the world. And so it works on that level too.

0:23:53.700 --> 0:23:55.139
<v Speaker 2>So I think it works on many levels.

0:23:56.460 --> 0:23:59.240
<v Speaker 1>Let me read you something you once said, because I'm

0:23:59.420 --> 0:24:02.310
<v Speaker 1>sort of wrestling, and I mean this genuinely with the

0:24:02.330 --> 0:24:05.550
<v Speaker 1>whole antichrist thing and what you mean by that, but

0:24:05.590 --> 0:24:08.530
<v Speaker 1>it ties into this new AI moment we're in. which

0:24:08.570 --> 0:24:11.210
<v Speaker 1>you said the way the Antichrist would take over the

0:24:11.270 --> 0:24:15.980
<v Speaker 1>world is you talk about Armageddon nonstop. You talk about

0:24:16.000 --> 0:24:21.240
<v Speaker 1>existential risk nonstop. The Antichrist wouldn't seize power by creating

0:24:21.280 --> 0:24:26.420
<v Speaker 1>an AI apocalypse, but by convincing everyone that the apocalypse

0:24:26.590 --> 0:24:31.709
<v Speaker 1>was coming. Is that what's happening now? Well, since I.

0:24:31.710 --> 0:24:33.730
<v Speaker 2>Said that like a year and a half ago, yeah,

0:24:34.050 --> 0:24:37.230
<v Speaker 2>I'm tempted to take a victory lap of sorts that

0:24:37.630 --> 0:24:40.480
<v Speaker 2>you have to... You have to at least ask certain questions,

0:24:40.500 --> 0:24:43.900
<v Speaker 2>and that's what I would want people to do. And,

0:24:44.100 --> 0:24:49.859
<v Speaker 2>you know, Oppenheimer and the nuclear scientists who wanted, you know,

0:24:49.880 --> 0:24:53.800
<v Speaker 2>a global authority to control all the nuclear weapons and

0:24:53.840 --> 0:24:56.700
<v Speaker 2>who thought, you know, after 1945, no, it was too

0:24:56.740 --> 0:24:58.320
<v Speaker 2>dangerous for the U.S. to have them and they should

0:24:58.340 --> 0:25:01.340
<v Speaker 2>be handed over to the United Nations with, you know,

0:25:01.359 --> 0:25:04.619
<v Speaker 2>a stronger U.N., a real world government. And if you

0:25:04.660 --> 0:25:07.159
<v Speaker 2>didn't hand it over to the U.N., then we'd have

0:25:07.180 --> 0:25:09.570
<v Speaker 2>a nuclear war. And so there was a certain parallel

0:25:09.790 --> 0:25:14.139
<v Speaker 2>with the nuclear debates. We got partial global authorities where we,

0:25:14.150 --> 0:25:17.070
<v Speaker 2>you know, regulated, controlled nuclear weapons. We never got rid

0:25:17.090 --> 0:25:20.270
<v Speaker 2>of them altogether. So maybe, you know, maybe Oppenheimer's still

0:25:20.330 --> 0:25:21.030
<v Speaker 2>right in the long run.

0:25:21.150 --> 0:25:25.230
<v Speaker 1>Yeah, I mean, Oppenheimer's that morning led to Atchison, Lilienthal,

0:25:25.359 --> 0:25:27.520
<v Speaker 1>and it actually has kind of worked.

0:25:27.859 --> 0:25:30.580
<v Speaker 2>It partially worked, although, you know, it's only been 100

0:25:30.580 --> 0:25:35.620
<v Speaker 2>years or 80 years or whatever. But on the AI thing, yes,

0:25:35.760 --> 0:25:38.580
<v Speaker 2>let's I would always concede that there are a bunch

0:25:38.600 --> 0:25:42.070
<v Speaker 2>of these existential risks that are serious. I think climate

0:25:42.090 --> 0:25:45.570
<v Speaker 2>change is pretty serious. There are other environmental risks that

0:25:45.609 --> 0:25:48.409
<v Speaker 2>are serious. I still think the nuclear weapons thing is

0:25:48.510 --> 0:25:52.409
<v Speaker 2>pretty real. I think there probably are other technologies and

0:25:52.510 --> 0:25:56.840
<v Speaker 2>AI is this very fast, very big one. And so

0:25:57.100 --> 0:25:59.879
<v Speaker 2>there are existential risks surely that are also tied up

0:25:59.980 --> 0:26:03.220
<v Speaker 2>with AI. And then the existential risk that I also

0:26:03.260 --> 0:26:06.230
<v Speaker 2>want to always throw in the hopper and the balance

0:26:06.250 --> 0:26:09.830
<v Speaker 2>of the discussion is the risk of a, you know,

0:26:10.750 --> 0:26:16.870
<v Speaker 2>softly totalitarian one world government. And that also seems like,

0:26:16.890 --> 0:26:20.970
<v Speaker 2>you know, if the whole world becomes totalitarian, there's no

0:26:21.080 --> 0:26:27.260
<v Speaker 2>outside left, that feels like this catastrophic singularity, which might

0:26:27.320 --> 0:26:31.419
<v Speaker 2>not be reversible. You know, Soviet Union was a totalitarian system.

0:26:31.900 --> 0:26:34.480
<v Speaker 2>At some point, it could decay and fall apart because

0:26:34.500 --> 0:26:37.179
<v Speaker 2>there was still an outside left, you know, if the

0:26:37.220 --> 0:26:41.500
<v Speaker 2>whole world is North Korea, that might last for a really, or,

0:26:41.580 --> 0:26:41.880
<v Speaker 2>you know.

0:26:41.920 --> 0:26:44.340
<v Speaker 1>Wait, explain to me though, what you mean by the antichrist?

0:26:44.560 --> 0:26:48.260
<v Speaker 2>Um, well, it is, I mean, it's, it's a sort of,

0:26:48.260 --> 0:26:52.590
<v Speaker 2>I don't know, medieval biblical concept of sort of a

0:26:53.130 --> 0:26:57.510
<v Speaker 2>tyrant who will somehow rule the entire world at the

0:26:57.570 --> 0:27:00.310
<v Speaker 2>end of history. If you think of it in a

0:27:00.390 --> 0:27:03.990
<v Speaker 2>literary way or, you know, a, sort of a creative way,

0:27:04.010 --> 0:27:06.470
<v Speaker 2>you can say, well, how would the Antichrist come to

0:27:06.510 --> 0:27:11.409
<v Speaker 2>power in different times and different places? And in early modernity, 17th,

0:27:11.609 --> 0:27:15.950
<v Speaker 2>18th century, perhaps the Antichrist would use science and technology

0:27:15.990 --> 0:27:18.879
<v Speaker 2>to build weapons and take over the world. In my telling,

0:27:19.800 --> 0:27:23.100
<v Speaker 2>in late modernity, we in some ways still think of

0:27:23.119 --> 0:27:26.280
<v Speaker 2>the Antichrist in 17th century categories. We still think it's

0:27:26.340 --> 0:27:30.560
<v Speaker 2>like a Dr. Strangelove, Edward Teller type person who builds

0:27:30.960 --> 0:27:34.219
<v Speaker 2>nuclear bombs to to conquer the world. But if you

0:27:34.240 --> 0:27:37.690
<v Speaker 2>think of it as a political dimension, the way I

0:27:37.730 --> 0:27:40.669
<v Speaker 2>think the politics work in our society is that the

0:27:40.750 --> 0:27:44.230
<v Speaker 2>fear of science and technology are far more powerful, and

0:27:44.250 --> 0:27:47.070
<v Speaker 2>that that's the kind of thing that would really crystallize things.

0:27:47.310 --> 0:27:48.750
<v Speaker 2>I don't think Greta is the Antichrist.

0:27:49.230 --> 0:27:50.869
<v Speaker 1>I think Greta Thunberg, you mean.

0:27:50.970 --> 0:27:54.970
<v Speaker 2>I don't think she's the Antichrist, but I think environmentalism,

0:27:54.990 --> 0:27:56.580
<v Speaker 2>you know, there are real fears.

0:27:56.600 --> 0:27:59.080
<v Speaker 1>People pushing back on progress, is what you're saying.

0:27:59.100 --> 0:28:02.649
<v Speaker 2>Pushing back on progress, but then also pushing for these very,

0:28:02.710 --> 0:28:07.070
<v Speaker 2>very powerful global political structures. Because something like climate change,

0:28:07.750 --> 0:28:09.449
<v Speaker 2>it sounds like the sort of thing where you need

0:28:09.470 --> 0:28:11.030
<v Speaker 2>a global regulatory authority.

0:28:11.310 --> 0:28:15.960
<v Speaker 1>So your big feel is some global regulatory authority.

0:28:16.280 --> 0:28:16.440
<v Speaker 3>Yeah.

0:28:16.480 --> 0:28:18.959
<v Speaker 2>And again, there are probably versions of that that could

0:28:18.980 --> 0:28:21.119
<v Speaker 2>be good. You know, the nuclear ones we ended up

0:28:21.160 --> 0:28:24.000
<v Speaker 2>with were definitely more good than bad. But there also

0:28:24.060 --> 0:28:26.580
<v Speaker 2>are versions of it that can be quite bad. And

0:28:26.600 --> 0:28:29.290
<v Speaker 2>I tend to think they're bad if they're not theorized.

0:28:29.690 --> 0:28:31.990
<v Speaker 2>You know, globalization can be good. It can be bad.

0:28:32.270 --> 0:28:34.409
<v Speaker 2>We didn't think about it a lot. And because we

0:28:34.430 --> 0:28:36.409
<v Speaker 2>didn't think about it a lot, you know, there were

0:28:36.430 --> 0:28:39.110
<v Speaker 2>a lot of bad things that came with globalization that

0:28:39.150 --> 0:28:41.390
<v Speaker 2>maybe could have been avoided had we been able to

0:28:41.430 --> 0:28:45.510
<v Speaker 2>be more critical about it. You know, Eliezer Yudkowsky wrote

0:28:45.530 --> 0:28:48.630
<v Speaker 2>this book last fall, If Anyone Builds It, Everyone Dies.

0:28:49.130 --> 0:28:50.870
<v Speaker 1>And he's talking about AI.

0:28:50.990 --> 0:28:54.900
<v Speaker 2>He's talking about AI. And it's, again, very precise, detailed

0:28:54.960 --> 0:28:56.840
<v Speaker 2>on some of the risks, some of these scenarios. We

0:28:56.860 --> 0:29:00.250
<v Speaker 2>can debate what the probabilities really are. But that part

0:29:00.730 --> 0:29:05.170
<v Speaker 2>is quite detailed, quite technical. The part that's completely hand-wavy

0:29:05.810 --> 0:29:08.450
<v Speaker 2>is it needs to be globally regulated. He's very clear

0:29:08.510 --> 0:29:10.670
<v Speaker 2>on that. But then the details of how you do that,

0:29:11.150 --> 0:29:15.880
<v Speaker 2>that's incredibly fuzzy, incredibly vague. And so I worry that

0:29:15.890 --> 0:29:19.240
<v Speaker 2>we're not thinking about that. And so we're worrying about Armageddon.

0:29:19.640 --> 0:29:23.500
<v Speaker 2>We're not worrying about the Antichrist. And my contrarian intuition

0:29:23.560 --> 0:29:25.800
<v Speaker 2>is that alone tells you you need to worry more

0:29:25.820 --> 0:29:27.680
<v Speaker 2>about the Antichrist than Armageddon.

0:29:28.270 --> 0:29:30.620
<v Speaker 1>I sort of have a personal question. A lot of

0:29:30.630 --> 0:29:33.440
<v Speaker 1>people think you're kind of spooky or whatever it may be.

0:29:34.020 --> 0:29:39.010
<v Speaker 1>Why using the Antichrist? Why does that help clarify things?

0:29:39.570 --> 0:29:42.950
<v Speaker 1>when even I look at you giving lectures on the

0:29:43.040 --> 0:29:45.360
<v Speaker 1>Antichrist and I go, what's that all about?

0:29:46.620 --> 0:29:50.740
<v Speaker 2>Well, it got people's attention. So it certainly worked on

0:29:50.780 --> 0:29:53.940
<v Speaker 2>that level. There are probably ways you could describe all

0:29:53.980 --> 0:29:59.650
<v Speaker 2>these things in philosophical or more neutral, less religious language.

0:30:00.040 --> 0:30:03.280
<v Speaker 2>The way the Federation of Atomic Scientists, they put out

0:30:03.320 --> 0:30:06.700
<v Speaker 2>a short film after 1945, and it was One World

0:30:06.760 --> 0:30:08.960
<v Speaker 2>or None. It shows a nuclear bomb blowing up the world.

0:30:09.660 --> 0:30:12.180
<v Speaker 2>And the way I often describe it is, yeah, one

0:30:12.240 --> 0:30:14.660
<v Speaker 2>world or none. In a way, it's a very similar

0:30:14.740 --> 0:30:19.820
<v Speaker 2>question to Antichrist, the one world authority versus Armageddon. But

0:30:19.840 --> 0:30:23.520
<v Speaker 2>the reason I prefer the religious formulation to the, let's say,

0:30:23.540 --> 0:30:28.020
<v Speaker 2>the political formulation, one world or none, without asking any questions,

0:30:28.100 --> 0:30:30.780
<v Speaker 2>we sign up straight for the one world government. That's

0:30:30.860 --> 0:30:34.280
<v Speaker 2>clearly better. There's no debate, no thinking through it at all.

0:30:34.780 --> 0:30:38.560
<v Speaker 2>If you can reframe that question as antichrist or Armageddon,

0:30:39.300 --> 0:30:41.680
<v Speaker 2>the point of it is not to be fatalistic. The

0:30:41.720 --> 0:30:43.820
<v Speaker 2>point of it is, okay, we need to avoid both.

0:30:44.200 --> 0:30:46.880
<v Speaker 2>They're both equally bad. We need to think about all

0:30:46.920 --> 0:30:50.660
<v Speaker 2>these existential risks. They're serious, but also the risk of

0:30:50.680 --> 0:30:54.670
<v Speaker 2>this sort of totalitarian one world state and antichrist or

0:30:54.730 --> 0:30:58.600
<v Speaker 2>Armageddon pushes us to find a moderate third way. One

0:30:58.630 --> 0:31:03.580
<v Speaker 2>world or none pushes us towards an immoderately powerful UN.

0:31:04.380 --> 0:31:07.240
<v Speaker 1>This series has been talking to builders, many of whom

0:31:07.300 --> 0:31:10.460
<v Speaker 1>you help build. In other words, you know, Alex Karp

0:31:10.720 --> 0:31:13.820
<v Speaker 1>or Palmer Luckey or Elon Musk. There's been a real

0:31:14.020 --> 0:31:20.310
<v Speaker 1>backlash against the billionaire tech bro builders. And some of

0:31:20.370 --> 0:31:23.330
<v Speaker 1>it is understandable to me. I mean, it's like, whoa,

0:31:23.410 --> 0:31:27.410
<v Speaker 1>these people have gotten way too much power. They're out

0:31:27.450 --> 0:31:30.840
<v Speaker 1>of control. Don't you worry about that too as much

0:31:30.890 --> 0:31:32.640
<v Speaker 1>as other existential risks?

0:31:33.940 --> 0:31:36.800
<v Speaker 2>You mean power in an economic sense or power in

0:31:36.840 --> 0:31:38.440
<v Speaker 2>a narrowly political sense?

0:31:38.860 --> 0:31:41.640
<v Speaker 1>I meant both. Whatever happens to us in the future,

0:31:41.700 --> 0:31:44.940
<v Speaker 1>the future we're trying to build, there are very few

0:31:45.000 --> 0:31:49.660
<v Speaker 1>people now controlling it who seem to have less moral

0:31:49.780 --> 0:31:51.800
<v Speaker 1>guardrails than previous.

0:31:53.020 --> 0:31:54.540
<v Speaker 2>I was thinking about this a little bit in advance

0:31:54.560 --> 0:31:56.180
<v Speaker 2>of your interview. You know, I, my, my venture fund

0:31:56.200 --> 0:31:57.880
<v Speaker 2>is called founders fund. And I sort of invest in

0:31:57.900 --> 0:32:01.980
<v Speaker 2>the people who found these things. You're focused on the builders.

0:32:02.140 --> 0:32:05.490
<v Speaker 2>And in some ways that's a better framing than, than

0:32:05.650 --> 0:32:09.240
<v Speaker 2>the founders, because, uh, yeah, it's somehow very important to,

0:32:09.510 --> 0:32:11.890
<v Speaker 2>to start one of these businesses, but then the way

0:32:12.330 --> 0:32:15.130
<v Speaker 2>they really end up having impact, the way they end

0:32:15.150 --> 0:32:19.430
<v Speaker 2>up being transformative for better or worse is this enormous

0:32:19.490 --> 0:32:23.470
<v Speaker 2>growth compounding effect over time. And, uh, It's more a

0:32:23.490 --> 0:32:29.510
<v Speaker 2>marathon than a sprint. Yes, I'm tempted to quibble with

0:32:29.810 --> 0:32:32.350
<v Speaker 2>all of your characterizations. Let's grant all of them for

0:32:32.390 --> 0:32:36.280
<v Speaker 2>the sake of argument. What is the alternative? And on

0:32:36.300 --> 0:32:41.320
<v Speaker 2>a corporate level, the alternative to founder-led company where it's

0:32:41.340 --> 0:32:47.130
<v Speaker 2>sort of this slightly crazy, creative, Elon-like person, the alternative

0:32:47.670 --> 0:32:51.530
<v Speaker 2>is a bureaucrat with an MBA degree, with a very

0:32:51.590 --> 0:32:56.380
<v Speaker 2>bureaucratic board of people who never want to do anything.

0:32:56.940 --> 0:33:00.420
<v Speaker 2>And so, yes, it is. It is maybe too much

0:33:00.540 --> 0:33:05.360
<v Speaker 2>power in a charismatic leader or, or it is a

0:33:05.480 --> 0:33:08.690
<v Speaker 2>super lame bureaucracy. And my, my claim is it's a

0:33:08.790 --> 0:33:11.570
<v Speaker 2>bimodal distribution. Those are literally the only two kinds of

0:33:11.630 --> 0:33:17.630
<v Speaker 2>companies we have. It's yeah. The, the charismatic, maybe dangerous,

0:33:18.850 --> 0:33:23.220
<v Speaker 2>but very inspiring leader who will do new things. versus

0:33:23.620 --> 0:33:25.660
<v Speaker 2>the boring bureaucracy where it's just going to.

0:33:25.640 --> 0:33:28.980
<v Speaker 1>Be- But what about in Apple, that after the charismatic founder,

0:33:29.720 --> 0:33:31.979
<v Speaker 1>did it lose its way? Did it become bureaucratic?

0:33:32.960 --> 0:33:37.600
<v Speaker 2>It's an extraordinary story, but yes, in my telling, it

0:33:37.620 --> 0:33:41.640
<v Speaker 2>did nothing new after jobs. And there are all these

0:33:41.700 --> 0:33:43.660
<v Speaker 2>metrics we can look at. It was like, you know,

0:33:43.780 --> 0:33:47.500
<v Speaker 2>it was by far the lowest dollar spend on R &amp; D,

0:33:48.010 --> 0:33:51.030
<v Speaker 2>by far the largest on share buybacks. It was just,

0:33:51.050 --> 0:33:55.580
<v Speaker 2>you know, this pure- well-run value stock. And you can probably,

0:33:55.600 --> 0:33:59.750
<v Speaker 2>you know, the way Tim Cook, he was the anti-jobs.

0:33:59.790 --> 0:34:04.690
<v Speaker 2>He was the zero charisma, efficient operator. And then it

0:34:05.390 --> 0:34:08.710
<v Speaker 2>turned out, yeah, the mobile phone was this giant invention.

0:34:08.969 --> 0:34:10.969
<v Speaker 2>There was not that much more to do. And then

0:34:10.989 --> 0:34:15.620
<v Speaker 2>it was just scaling and branding and building it out

0:34:15.800 --> 0:34:18.299
<v Speaker 2>over 15 years or whatever. I don't know. If you

0:34:18.340 --> 0:34:21.799
<v Speaker 2>say what's good for the shareholders, they both can be good.

0:34:22.780 --> 0:34:28.720
<v Speaker 2>But I would still say somehow Elon or Steve Jobs

0:34:28.820 --> 0:34:31.370
<v Speaker 2>are way better for society than Tim Cook.

0:34:32.469 --> 0:34:35.089
<v Speaker 1>People always, when they talk about the characters I write about,

0:34:35.469 --> 0:34:37.330
<v Speaker 1>they try to explain them by saying, oh, they just

0:34:37.370 --> 0:34:41.890
<v Speaker 1>want money. I don't quite think so. What would you

0:34:42.250 --> 0:34:43.549
<v Speaker 1>call your scorecard?

0:34:44.790 --> 0:34:47.950
<v Speaker 2>Yeah, I think there are all these different dimensions, but

0:34:48.290 --> 0:34:52.779
<v Speaker 2>it is I probably do like winning too much. I

0:34:52.840 --> 0:34:55.750
<v Speaker 2>am really into ideas. It's not quite a hobby, but

0:34:56.530 --> 0:34:58.370
<v Speaker 2>the closest thing to a hobby I have is having

0:34:58.410 --> 0:35:02.270
<v Speaker 2>sort of interesting dinner conversations with people. I like figuring

0:35:02.310 --> 0:35:06.009
<v Speaker 2>things out for their own sake. I sometimes rationalize it as, yeah,

0:35:06.030 --> 0:35:08.239
<v Speaker 2>that somehow makes me a better investor. It probably has

0:35:08.320 --> 0:35:11.620
<v Speaker 2>nothing to do with it. It's probably just an excuse

0:35:11.640 --> 0:35:13.959
<v Speaker 2>for being somewhat of a dilettante or something like that.

0:35:14.500 --> 0:35:18.049
<v Speaker 2>But yeah, I think of myself as just really intellectually curious.

0:35:18.900 --> 0:35:21.620
<v Speaker 1>What's the purpose that we're building for now? If we

0:35:21.640 --> 0:35:25.680
<v Speaker 1>can have enormous amounts of productivity, is it that we're

0:35:25.700 --> 0:35:31.210
<v Speaker 1>trying to preserve democratic freedoms? Is it human flourishing? What

0:35:31.230 --> 0:35:34.790
<v Speaker 1>would you want your builders to have as their lodestar

0:35:35.330 --> 0:35:37.870
<v Speaker 1>other than I can find the new, new thing in

0:35:37.910 --> 0:35:38.730
<v Speaker 1>the era of AI?

0:35:41.650 --> 0:35:46.400
<v Speaker 2>There are all sorts of dimensions of, of, of progress that, uh,

0:35:46.780 --> 0:35:48.620
<v Speaker 2>we could have as a society. And, you know, there's

0:35:48.640 --> 0:35:53.370
<v Speaker 2>always this narrative I have that, you know, in some ways, progress,

0:35:53.870 --> 0:35:56.669
<v Speaker 2>it's hard to measure progress in the aggregate. In some ways,

0:35:56.730 --> 0:35:59.730
<v Speaker 2>it slowed down in the 1970s, where we had enormous

0:35:59.790 --> 0:36:02.590
<v Speaker 2>progress in the world of bits and somewhat less in

0:36:02.630 --> 0:36:04.950
<v Speaker 2>the world of atoms. And when I was an undergraduate

0:36:04.969 --> 0:36:07.990
<v Speaker 2>at Stanford in the late 80s, maybe it wasn't completely

0:36:08.050 --> 0:36:11.730
<v Speaker 2>obvious at the time, but already in retrospect, most engineering

0:36:11.810 --> 0:36:15.489
<v Speaker 2>fields were bad ones to go into, mechanical engineering, aero-astroengineering,

0:36:15.550 --> 0:36:19.180
<v Speaker 2>chemical engineering. Because the world of atoms was too slow,

0:36:19.500 --> 0:36:24.190
<v Speaker 2>too regulated. Nothing really dramatic and new happened there. Nuclear

0:36:24.210 --> 0:36:26.900
<v Speaker 2>engineering was already, you know, very passe by the late 80s.

0:36:27.489 --> 0:36:30.489
<v Speaker 2>And then there's still electrical engineering still had a few

0:36:30.530 --> 0:36:33.930
<v Speaker 2>good years. And then it really shifted to just this,

0:36:34.050 --> 0:36:37.110
<v Speaker 2>you know, computer science as the one field.

0:36:37.320 --> 0:36:38.500
<v Speaker 1>That's instead of atoms.

0:36:38.980 --> 0:36:42.940
<v Speaker 2>And so, you know, the hope that I always have

0:36:43.540 --> 0:36:47.760
<v Speaker 2>is that somehow we're, you know, humans, we are embodied

0:36:48.100 --> 0:36:50.400
<v Speaker 2>in this world. And the world of atoms in which

0:36:50.440 --> 0:36:53.980
<v Speaker 2>we live is a really important world. And there's some

0:36:54.040 --> 0:36:58.239
<v Speaker 2>part where going back to that, I know it's been

0:36:58.260 --> 0:37:00.990
<v Speaker 2>very hard. I would like there to be more progress

0:37:01.030 --> 0:37:05.590
<v Speaker 2>in medicine, in medical technology. Maybe the radical life extension

0:37:05.650 --> 0:37:09.969
<v Speaker 2>project strikes people as too creepy, but could we at

0:37:09.989 --> 0:37:13.110
<v Speaker 2>least cure dementia? Could we at least cure Alzheimer's or

0:37:13.170 --> 0:37:18.040
<v Speaker 2>something like that? And then The hope is that somehow

0:37:18.100 --> 0:37:22.969
<v Speaker 2>restarting science and engineering much more broadly will be stimulated

0:37:23.390 --> 0:37:24.950
<v Speaker 2>by AI in part.

0:37:25.090 --> 0:37:27.290
<v Speaker 1>Well, one reason I'm sort of going to this notion

0:37:27.330 --> 0:37:31.609
<v Speaker 1>of what is the purpose of progress, when you were

0:37:31.660 --> 0:37:34.280
<v Speaker 1>interviewed by Ross Luthat and he asked at one point,

0:37:34.760 --> 0:37:38.040
<v Speaker 1>you know, do you really care if humanity survives? And

0:37:38.060 --> 0:37:39.180
<v Speaker 1>you pause a long time.

0:37:39.760 --> 0:37:41.939
<v Speaker 2>You would prefer the human race to endure, right?

0:37:41.960 --> 0:37:43.260
<v Speaker 1>Uh-huh.

0:37:44.050 --> 0:37:45.230
<v Speaker 2>You're hesitating.

0:37:45.570 --> 0:37:45.790
<v Speaker 1>Yes?

0:37:45.950 --> 0:37:46.250
<v Speaker 2>I don't know.

0:37:46.750 --> 0:37:47.779
<v Speaker 1>I would....

0:37:49.010 --> 0:37:49.550
<v Speaker 5>I would.

0:37:50.710 --> 0:37:51.049
<v Speaker 2>This is.

0:37:51.030 --> 0:37:52.210
<v Speaker 1>A long hesitation.

0:37:52.370 --> 0:37:54.750
<v Speaker 2>This is a long hesitation. There's so many questions implicit

0:37:54.770 --> 0:37:56.589
<v Speaker 2>in this. Should the human race survive?

0:37:57.670 --> 0:38:00.740
<v Speaker 1>But I ask that again. Is that our main goal,

0:38:00.860 --> 0:38:06.160
<v Speaker 1>the sort of Asimov goal, that humanity survives? Or is

0:38:06.200 --> 0:38:06.819
<v Speaker 1>that not?

0:38:08.060 --> 0:38:12.040
<v Speaker 2>That is... Well, that is an extremely important goal. I

0:38:13.020 --> 0:38:15.070
<v Speaker 2>don't think it's I don't think it can be the

0:38:15.610 --> 0:38:20.969
<v Speaker 2>only goal. In some sense, humanity can survive if we

0:38:20.989 --> 0:38:26.320
<v Speaker 2>do nothing or presumably. Maybe things go very haywire, as

0:38:27.200 --> 0:38:29.400
<v Speaker 2>I say, without growth. But yes, I don't know. I

0:38:30.200 --> 0:38:34.680
<v Speaker 2>think Silicon Valley is always quite bad at the meaning

0:38:35.000 --> 0:38:38.690
<v Speaker 2>of technology. And maybe it's not fully up to Silicon

0:38:38.710 --> 0:38:43.850
<v Speaker 2>Valley to articulate the meaning. Maybe there's not a single meaning. Yeah,

0:38:43.969 --> 0:38:46.870
<v Speaker 2>certainly part of it has to be done in a

0:38:46.890 --> 0:38:50.390
<v Speaker 2>way where we avoid existential risks or maybe technology is

0:38:50.410 --> 0:38:54.900
<v Speaker 2>even a way to avoid existential risks. And maybe if

0:38:54.910 --> 0:38:58.080
<v Speaker 2>we go back to nuclear power, that would be a

0:38:58.100 --> 0:39:01.480
<v Speaker 2>carbon neutral technology. So nuclear power is a technology we

0:39:01.520 --> 0:39:05.520
<v Speaker 2>need to lean into so that humanity can survive in

0:39:05.540 --> 0:39:09.140
<v Speaker 2>a more carbon neutral way. The place where I pushed back,

0:39:09.400 --> 0:39:11.549
<v Speaker 2>the reason I paused when I answered that question that

0:39:11.630 --> 0:39:17.200
<v Speaker 2>Douth had asked Is that the question I heard behind

0:39:17.219 --> 0:39:21.029
<v Speaker 2>it was, you know, the Luddite question where maybe this

0:39:21.070 --> 0:39:24.569
<v Speaker 2>technology is dangerous and, you know, why isn't it good

0:39:24.610 --> 0:39:26.770
<v Speaker 2>enough for things just to continue the way they are

0:39:26.870 --> 0:39:29.230
<v Speaker 2>right now? And we don't need all this improvement and

0:39:29.250 --> 0:39:32.950
<v Speaker 2>all this change. that might be dangerous. And then my

0:39:32.989 --> 0:39:37.969
<v Speaker 2>intuition is, yeah, there are all these ways that things

0:39:38.010 --> 0:39:41.170
<v Speaker 2>are far from perfect with humanity. And this was the

0:39:41.290 --> 0:39:45.650
<v Speaker 2>core project of the Enlightenment, 17th, 18th century science. It

0:39:45.710 --> 0:39:48.810
<v Speaker 2>was the relief of man's estate. Life was supposed to

0:39:48.850 --> 0:39:52.469
<v Speaker 2>be more than nasty, brutish, and short in Hobbes. And

0:39:52.489 --> 0:39:57.170
<v Speaker 2>there was, it's longer, it's, you know, I don't see

0:39:57.670 --> 0:40:00.489
<v Speaker 2>why it's not desirable for us to make it significantly

0:40:00.530 --> 0:40:03.310
<v Speaker 2>longer still than it is, or at least to cure,

0:40:03.670 --> 0:40:06.610
<v Speaker 2>you know, a lot of these terrible diseases that still exist,

0:40:07.150 --> 0:40:10.430
<v Speaker 2>things like that. And so, yeah, so that's sort of

0:40:10.450 --> 0:40:14.190
<v Speaker 2>the other intuition. So yes, I want humanities to survive.

0:40:14.770 --> 0:40:17.759
<v Speaker 2>I want humanity to flourish. And then, yeah, there are

0:40:17.890 --> 0:40:21.740
<v Speaker 2>all these dimensions where where maybe this will not happen

0:40:22.020 --> 0:40:22.860
<v Speaker 2>without progress.

0:40:27.140 --> 0:40:46.840
<v Speaker 1>We'll be right back after this quick break. Let me

0:40:46.860 --> 0:40:49.410
<v Speaker 1>take you back to some of the philosophers who One,

0:40:49.610 --> 0:40:55.820
<v Speaker 1>Rene Girard, the notion of mimetic desire. Explain what that

0:40:55.840 --> 0:40:59.180
<v Speaker 1>is and why you feel the need to resist it.

0:40:59.920 --> 0:41:04.020
<v Speaker 2>Rene Girard, I studied philosophy as an undergraduate at Stanford.

0:41:04.300 --> 0:41:10.239
<v Speaker 2>And the human nature, the count of people is that

0:41:10.280 --> 0:41:16.899
<v Speaker 2>we're deeply mimetic, deeply imitative. Girard liked to quote, Aristotle,

0:41:16.920 --> 0:41:19.319
<v Speaker 2>you know, man differs from the other animals in his

0:41:19.400 --> 0:41:22.740
<v Speaker 2>greater aptitude for imitation. And then this is a way

0:41:22.989 --> 0:41:26.089
<v Speaker 2>you can combine Aristotle and Darwin. So Darwin's saying we're

0:41:26.130 --> 0:41:29.090
<v Speaker 2>linked to the apes. And then Aristotle says we differ

0:41:29.110 --> 0:41:32.089
<v Speaker 2>from the apes by being more imitative and saying we're

0:41:32.130 --> 0:41:35.589
<v Speaker 2>more ape-like than the apes because that's how you learn

0:41:35.640 --> 0:41:38.080
<v Speaker 2>language as a child. You copy your parents. And then

0:41:38.580 --> 0:41:42.140
<v Speaker 2>that's how human culture gets transmitted. And we wouldn't be

0:41:42.200 --> 0:41:47.840
<v Speaker 2>humans if we weren't these incredibly powerful imitation machines. And

0:41:47.860 --> 0:41:52.050
<v Speaker 2>then there also are ways that imitation can go haywire

0:41:52.090 --> 0:41:54.910
<v Speaker 2>when two apes reach for the same banana. There are ways,

0:41:54.930 --> 0:41:59.430
<v Speaker 2>you know, it can become extremely conflictual. And so, yes,

0:42:00.030 --> 0:42:04.460
<v Speaker 2>in Girard's telling, mimesis is this incredibly powerful thing in

0:42:04.480 --> 0:42:05.219
<v Speaker 2>the background.

0:42:05.540 --> 0:42:07.480
<v Speaker 1>Mimesis meaning mimicking, basically.

0:42:07.520 --> 0:42:11.520
<v Speaker 2>Bad, bad forms of imitation. It's very generative. And then

0:42:11.540 --> 0:42:15.210
<v Speaker 2>in various points, it also becomes destructive and you end

0:42:15.270 --> 0:42:18.930
<v Speaker 2>up with sort of these very sterile competitions for status

0:42:19.130 --> 0:42:23.930
<v Speaker 2>or for these positional goods that don't mean nearly as

0:42:23.989 --> 0:42:25.690
<v Speaker 2>much as you think you do. I think it was

0:42:25.830 --> 0:42:28.220
<v Speaker 2>Napoleon who said that it was amazing what you could

0:42:28.640 --> 0:42:31.140
<v Speaker 2>get generals to do if you gave them medals or

0:42:31.180 --> 0:42:35.500
<v Speaker 2>something like that. The psychological way one is tempted to

0:42:35.520 --> 0:42:37.680
<v Speaker 2>interpret Girard, even though this is not what he would

0:42:37.719 --> 0:42:41.080
<v Speaker 2>have done, but the psychological way you're tempted to interpret

0:42:41.100 --> 0:42:43.840
<v Speaker 2>it is, okay, you have to sort of, Think about

0:42:43.960 --> 0:42:47.169
<v Speaker 2>avoiding this bad mimesis and you want to avoid getting

0:42:47.250 --> 0:42:51.129
<v Speaker 2>caught up in these silly competitions. There's nothing new, nothing

0:42:51.190 --> 0:42:55.790
<v Speaker 2>creative that happens in that context. So that's the psychological

0:42:55.830 --> 0:43:00.670
<v Speaker 2>intuition against mimesis. Girard, as a Christian, would have said,

0:43:00.690 --> 0:43:02.989
<v Speaker 2>you know, it's actually out of your power to not

0:43:03.030 --> 0:43:04.850
<v Speaker 2>be a mimetic. The best you can do is just

0:43:04.890 --> 0:43:07.109
<v Speaker 2>go to church on Sundays or something like that. So

0:43:07.380 --> 0:43:09.219
<v Speaker 2>he would have been skeptical of this. The sort of

0:43:09.320 --> 0:43:13.460
<v Speaker 2>in-between way where I always think about it is, Yeah,

0:43:13.480 --> 0:43:16.200
<v Speaker 2>there are, there are parts of it that are very powerful.

0:43:16.469 --> 0:43:18.770
<v Speaker 2>There are also parts where, you know, there's a wisdom

0:43:18.810 --> 0:43:22.009
<v Speaker 2>of crowds, but there's also a madness of crowds. And

0:43:22.070 --> 0:43:24.350
<v Speaker 2>in some ways, you know, I see one of the,

0:43:26.450 --> 0:43:30.049
<v Speaker 2>and I don't think it's necessarily a character of all

0:43:30.090 --> 0:43:33.800
<v Speaker 2>the builders, but certainly a lot of the builders I

0:43:33.840 --> 0:43:38.840
<v Speaker 2>would admire the most are ones who had a somewhat

0:43:38.960 --> 0:43:43.750
<v Speaker 2>idiosyncratic sustained vision. Maybe it came from certain first principles,

0:43:44.510 --> 0:43:48.710
<v Speaker 2>certain fixed ideas. Like Elon going to Mars, you know,

0:43:48.750 --> 0:43:53.049
<v Speaker 2>it was somewhat out there, but man, it was not

0:43:53.090 --> 0:43:57.130
<v Speaker 2>a socially conventional idea. But the way in which this

0:43:57.170 --> 0:44:00.830
<v Speaker 2>was extremely generative was it suggested a whole avenue for

0:44:00.890 --> 0:44:04.540
<v Speaker 2>growth and for building where if you didn't do it,

0:44:04.710 --> 0:44:07.390
<v Speaker 2>maybe it would never have happened. You know, that's probably

0:44:07.410 --> 0:44:11.850
<v Speaker 2>where I would still, I don't know, maybe rank Elon,

0:44:11.890 --> 0:44:16.130
<v Speaker 2>and in some ways Steve Jobs as the two great

0:44:16.230 --> 0:44:20.830
<v Speaker 2>non-mimetic builders. And, you know, Jobs put together all these pieces,

0:44:20.870 --> 0:44:22.890
<v Speaker 2>and in some ways they were out there, but he

0:44:22.910 --> 0:44:26.750
<v Speaker 2>combined them in a unique way to bring forward, you know,

0:44:27.370 --> 0:44:28.430
<v Speaker 2>the internet-enabled phone.

0:44:28.450 --> 0:44:31.690
<v Speaker 1>All right, but listening to your answer, you maybe get

0:44:31.730 --> 0:44:34.029
<v Speaker 1>a sense of why I asked it. Because when you

0:44:34.090 --> 0:44:39.370
<v Speaker 1>say imitation, the imitation game, mimetic, generative from coming to

0:44:39.410 --> 0:44:44.920
<v Speaker 1>be mimetic, This is language we're now doing with AI,

0:44:45.320 --> 0:44:49.779
<v Speaker 1>which is basically, as Alan Turing would say, starts off

0:44:49.880 --> 0:44:55.020
<v Speaker 1>with being an imitation game. Secondly, it's generative. And you

0:44:55.100 --> 0:44:59.320
<v Speaker 1>say it's dangerous. Is there something about the creation of

0:44:59.460 --> 0:45:02.880
<v Speaker 1>AI that Rene Girard would warn us against?

0:45:04.239 --> 0:45:08.840
<v Speaker 2>You know, I think his general intuition on technology was

0:45:09.140 --> 0:45:12.549
<v Speaker 2>that we gave it too great an autonomy of its

0:45:12.750 --> 0:45:16.180
<v Speaker 2>own and that the real questions were these questions about

0:45:16.200 --> 0:45:18.379
<v Speaker 2>the human beings that used them. And we tend to,

0:45:18.400 --> 0:45:21.080
<v Speaker 2>you know, we talk about the nuclear bomb as though

0:45:21.100 --> 0:45:22.020
<v Speaker 2>it was this godlike thing.

0:45:22.040 --> 0:45:23.580
<v Speaker 1>Peter Robinson But Bingo, don't you think he's right?

0:45:23.600 --> 0:45:29.060
<v Speaker 2>Peter Robinson But then, you know, maybe the important, you know,

0:45:29.280 --> 0:45:32.390
<v Speaker 2>or an important dimension of the AI question is, you know,

0:45:32.870 --> 0:45:35.750
<v Speaker 2>it's not what the AI is going to do, but

0:45:35.790 --> 0:45:38.650
<v Speaker 2>it's what's really driving the people who are building these companies.

0:45:39.150 --> 0:45:41.290
<v Speaker 2>What are their motives? Peter Robinson you know, what are

0:45:41.350 --> 0:45:44.070
<v Speaker 2>they up to? So those are, yeah, those are the

0:45:44.110 --> 0:45:44.450
<v Speaker 2>kinds of.

0:45:45.570 --> 0:45:46.930
<v Speaker 1>Well, and answer me those questions.

0:45:47.150 --> 0:45:51.299
<v Speaker 2>Oh, it's hard to say. I've spent endless amounts of time,

0:45:52.560 --> 0:45:54.919
<v Speaker 2>endless amounts of time thinking about it, but yet there's

0:45:55.880 --> 0:45:58.700
<v Speaker 2>some dimension like that that's hard to figure out, but

0:45:58.780 --> 0:46:05.370
<v Speaker 2>is probably quite important. I don't know. I score them

0:46:05.430 --> 0:46:09.810
<v Speaker 2>as far more good than bad across the board. I

0:46:09.850 --> 0:46:15.080
<v Speaker 2>think they very easily get demonized and scapegoated. Let's say Elon, Dario,

0:46:15.160 --> 0:46:18.299
<v Speaker 2>Sam Altman. I'll pick on those. Let's say those three. Zuckerberg.

0:46:18.680 --> 0:46:21.859
<v Speaker 2>But I think even in the case of AI, this

0:46:22.160 --> 0:46:24.460
<v Speaker 2>question of who the people are that are doing it

0:46:24.580 --> 0:46:27.940
<v Speaker 2>is a really, really important question. When you write your biographies,

0:46:28.320 --> 0:46:31.020
<v Speaker 2>it's about the importance of these individuals and who they

0:46:31.060 --> 0:46:36.759
<v Speaker 2>are about. It's not just an idiosyncratic story that has

0:46:36.840 --> 0:46:42.239
<v Speaker 2>nothing to do with companies they built or with the

0:46:42.280 --> 0:46:47.080
<v Speaker 2>world they're helping to shape. It's this very, very important question.

0:46:47.100 --> 0:46:51.620
<v Speaker 2>The alternate view, and again, I don't want to simplify

0:46:51.860 --> 0:46:55.049
<v Speaker 2>your work too much, but most of your biographies have

0:46:55.070 --> 0:46:59.169
<v Speaker 2>the sense that these people are complicated. They're still more

0:46:59.230 --> 0:47:03.210
<v Speaker 2>good than bad. And the alternate view to it is

0:47:03.290 --> 0:47:09.239
<v Speaker 2>not that these people are more evil than good. The

0:47:09.320 --> 0:47:12.900
<v Speaker 2>alternate view is they don't matter at all. There are

0:47:12.940 --> 0:47:17.180
<v Speaker 2>no great men. There are no charismatic leaders. It doesn't

0:47:17.219 --> 0:47:18.140
<v Speaker 2>matter who they are at all.

0:47:18.160 --> 0:47:21.860
<v Speaker 1>Trevor Burrus And these people do matter, these builders. Does

0:47:22.000 --> 0:47:25.500
<v Speaker 1>it matter that they avoid being evil?

0:47:27.300 --> 0:47:35.170
<v Speaker 2>Peter Van Doren Yes. Well, I think yes on all–

0:47:35.350 --> 0:47:39.940
<v Speaker 2>there are all these versions of that. You know, there's

0:47:43.620 --> 0:47:47.120
<v Speaker 2>always a lot of complexity to that too, where, you know,

0:47:48.580 --> 0:47:52.140
<v Speaker 2>maybe appearing not to be evil is just a fake

0:47:52.200 --> 0:47:55.270
<v Speaker 2>PR stunt at this point. And so maybe, you know,

0:47:55.969 --> 0:47:59.509
<v Speaker 2>Bill Gates is into virtue signaling, Elon Musk is into

0:47:59.570 --> 0:48:03.530
<v Speaker 2>vice signaling, and in our world, maybe you're more honest

0:48:03.570 --> 0:48:05.750
<v Speaker 2>if you vice signal than if you virtue signal. So

0:48:06.300 --> 0:48:08.200
<v Speaker 2>Maybe honesty is a good thing, so you're actually a

0:48:08.239 --> 0:48:11.260
<v Speaker 2>better person if you vice signal than if you virtue signal.

0:48:11.320 --> 0:48:16.900
<v Speaker 2>So there's a lot of complexity to it. Again, this

0:48:16.940 --> 0:48:19.780
<v Speaker 2>is not a pro-evil argument I'm about to make, but

0:48:19.969 --> 0:48:22.830
<v Speaker 2>the qualifier that I always give on it is always

0:48:22.850 --> 0:48:27.270
<v Speaker 2>a question, what's the antonym of good? And is it evil,

0:48:27.690 --> 0:48:32.969
<v Speaker 2>as in morally evil? Or is it bad, as in incompetent?

0:48:33.280 --> 0:48:35.740
<v Speaker 2>You know, let's say a Ferrari is an evil car

0:48:35.780 --> 0:48:39.220
<v Speaker 2>because it doesn't get many miles to the gallon and whatever,

0:48:39.239 --> 0:48:43.080
<v Speaker 2>a Lada or Trabi, the Eastern block cars that don't

0:48:43.140 --> 0:48:45.950
<v Speaker 2>work are worse than a golf cart. That's a bad car.

0:48:45.989 --> 0:48:49.469
<v Speaker 2>It breaks down all the time. And so it's better

0:48:49.489 --> 0:48:52.310
<v Speaker 2>to be good than evil. But maybe if you're evil,

0:48:52.489 --> 0:48:55.090
<v Speaker 2>you're at least competent and at least you're not bad.

0:48:55.650 --> 0:48:59.270
<v Speaker 2>And the thing that even with all the demonization of

0:48:59.330 --> 0:49:04.160
<v Speaker 2>people like Elon, you know, where they get In some context,

0:49:04.380 --> 0:49:07.400
<v Speaker 2>constantly described as evil and also irrelevant because of this,

0:49:07.600 --> 0:49:10.069
<v Speaker 2>you know, we say there are no individuals. But to

0:49:10.090 --> 0:49:13.370
<v Speaker 2>the extent they're described as evil, they're at least not

0:49:13.390 --> 0:49:16.890
<v Speaker 2>described as bad. And if we're in a world full of,

0:49:17.010 --> 0:49:23.480
<v Speaker 2>you know, bland bureaucrats. running these companies, you know.

0:49:23.640 --> 0:49:25.960
<v Speaker 1>Well, wait a minute. Wouldn't you rather bland bureaucrats than

0:49:26.040 --> 0:49:26.580
<v Speaker 1>evil people?

0:49:27.580 --> 0:49:31.680
<v Speaker 2>Well, if the bland bureaucrat stands for bad, it's incompetent.

0:49:32.420 --> 0:49:36.460
<v Speaker 2>The evil person gets something done. And, you know, it's.

0:49:37.000 --> 0:49:38.319
<v Speaker 1>What side would you be on for that?

0:49:39.790 --> 0:49:44.410
<v Speaker 2>I'm ranking these. I'm good over evil. But evil is

0:49:44.450 --> 0:49:46.630
<v Speaker 2>better than bad. By the way, this is the difference

0:49:46.730 --> 0:49:51.460
<v Speaker 2>between the Faust of Goethe versus the Faust of Marlowe.

0:49:52.100 --> 0:49:56.600
<v Speaker 2>In Marlowe's Faust, Faust is kind of this fake scientist.

0:49:56.640 --> 0:49:59.380
<v Speaker 2>He's a fraud. He's a magician, sort of a trickster,

0:49:59.420 --> 0:50:02.840
<v Speaker 2>a fake alchemist. He rips people off. He is a

0:50:02.920 --> 0:50:07.420
<v Speaker 2>bad scientist. And he goes straight to hell. In Goethe's Faust,

0:50:08.020 --> 0:50:10.140
<v Speaker 2>Faust is kind of, he works with the devil, so

0:50:10.160 --> 0:50:13.700
<v Speaker 2>it's this evil place where he gets the knowledge. Then,

0:50:13.910 --> 0:50:17.550
<v Speaker 2>you know, it does stuff. It does more good than evil.

0:50:18.010 --> 0:50:22.670
<v Speaker 2>And Goethe's Faust gets saved. So, yes, I take, you know,

0:50:23.370 --> 0:50:25.469
<v Speaker 2>I don't want to be, I don't think of myself

0:50:25.530 --> 0:50:28.410
<v Speaker 2>as the devil in Faust. And I don't think of

0:50:28.450 --> 0:50:32.930
<v Speaker 2>myself as Faust even. But I prefer the sentiment of

0:50:32.950 --> 0:50:34.590
<v Speaker 2>a Goethe to that of a Marlowe.

0:50:35.160 --> 0:50:38.379
<v Speaker 1>And you'd prefer somebody evil who can get things done

0:50:38.560 --> 0:50:39.980
<v Speaker 1>to somebody who's incompetent?

0:50:40.420 --> 0:50:44.700
<v Speaker 2>I think, well, I'm just making a broad social observation.

0:50:44.719 --> 0:50:48.040
<v Speaker 2>I think in our society, that's the overwhelming preference to

0:50:48.080 --> 0:50:52.480
<v Speaker 2>have because people, they experience just incompetence everywhere. You know,

0:50:52.500 --> 0:50:56.100
<v Speaker 2>when you go to the DMV, you know, it's, I'm

0:50:56.140 --> 0:50:58.740
<v Speaker 2>not sure you describe it as evil. It's merely bad.

0:50:59.400 --> 0:51:00.320
<v Speaker 2>Bad is so much.

0:51:00.239 --> 0:51:01.719
<v Speaker 1>Worse than evil. How would you define evil?

0:51:03.700 --> 0:51:04.600
<v Speaker 2>Well, it's this.

0:51:06.030 --> 0:51:19.210
<v Speaker 5>It's where we stress these.

0:51:18.690 --> 0:51:23.299
<v Speaker 2>Moral dimensions, that it's morally questionable. This was the way

0:51:23.440 --> 0:51:27.759
<v Speaker 2>the conservatives attacked stem cell research in the 2000s. It

0:51:27.800 --> 0:51:30.940
<v Speaker 2>wasn't bad science because it would work. They didn't question

0:51:30.960 --> 0:51:33.020
<v Speaker 2>that it would lead to cures, but it was evil

0:51:33.060 --> 0:51:36.109
<v Speaker 2>science because you had to do embryo harvesting. And then

0:51:36.130 --> 0:51:40.070
<v Speaker 2>I think that's actually why they lost the debate because

0:51:40.270 --> 0:51:41.690
<v Speaker 2>it was like, wow, this is actually going to work.

0:51:41.730 --> 0:51:43.750
<v Speaker 2>It can't be all evil if it does so much good.

0:51:44.910 --> 0:51:48.529
<v Speaker 2>The conservatives won the debate about art in the 90s

0:51:48.660 --> 0:51:52.980
<v Speaker 2>where the liberals were saying, you know, art is supposed

0:51:53.020 --> 0:51:56.100
<v Speaker 2>to be transgressive. And it's really great art if it's

0:51:56.120 --> 0:51:58.819
<v Speaker 2>a little bit evil. It offends your sensibilities. Evil art

0:51:58.900 --> 0:52:01.620
<v Speaker 2>is great art. Conservatives didn't fall for that. They said

0:52:01.960 --> 0:52:04.969
<v Speaker 2>it's not even art. It's bad art. It's not even art.

0:52:05.719 --> 0:52:12.310
<v Speaker 2>It shouldn't get government funding. It's so bad. And so, yes,

0:52:13.450 --> 0:52:15.570
<v Speaker 2>if you say it's bad, you get the art defunded.

0:52:15.930 --> 0:52:18.210
<v Speaker 2>If you say the science is evil, you get it funded.

0:52:18.550 --> 0:52:21.190
<v Speaker 2>So I'm telling you something I think most people in

0:52:21.210 --> 0:52:22.280
<v Speaker 2>our society agree with me on.

0:52:22.290 --> 0:52:25.330
<v Speaker 1>Peter Robinson If you were to back a builder though,

0:52:26.830 --> 0:52:34.920
<v Speaker 1>where would you rank having a moral compass? I, I, I.

0:52:34.920 --> 0:52:38.180
<v Speaker 2>Rank that pretty high. I rank that highly.

0:52:38.200 --> 0:52:47.690
<v Speaker 6>Um, I, I would say, but let, let's, you know, I, I,

0:52:47.930 --> 0:52:48.430
<v Speaker 6>I don't.

0:52:48.310 --> 0:52:51.470
<v Speaker 2>Like investing in companies where it's, it's simply a business.

0:52:52.350 --> 0:52:56.000
<v Speaker 2>There's some transcendent purpose. There's something, you know, very important

0:52:56.020 --> 0:53:01.739
<v Speaker 2>that you're doing. So, you know, Elon going to Mars is.

0:53:03.200 --> 0:53:05.719
<v Speaker 2>I don't know exactly where I would rank that on

0:53:06.030 --> 0:53:09.830
<v Speaker 2>sort of a moral good versus evil dimension, but it

0:53:09.930 --> 0:53:15.150
<v Speaker 2>is transcendent. It's somehow, it's not just a business. We're

0:53:15.170 --> 0:53:18.890
<v Speaker 2>not just a stock brokerage where we're making a few

0:53:18.930 --> 0:53:21.770
<v Speaker 2>dollars and every time people buy and sell stocks. It's

0:53:21.850 --> 0:53:25.290
<v Speaker 2>not just this sort of short-term coin-operated business. It has

0:53:25.770 --> 0:53:29.089
<v Speaker 2>this transcendent sense of purpose. That's what I like.

0:53:30.010 --> 0:53:32.450
<v Speaker 1>And in this era of AI that we're worried about,

0:53:32.530 --> 0:53:35.469
<v Speaker 1>what do you think, if anything, there are things that

0:53:35.570 --> 0:53:37.219
<v Speaker 1>humans can uniquely do?

0:54:09.830 --> 0:54:12.190
<v Speaker 2>Well, this is the sense in which the question about

0:54:12.230 --> 0:54:14.810
<v Speaker 2>AI is a question about us. What does it mean

0:54:14.830 --> 0:54:21.950
<v Speaker 2>to be a human being? Someone like Chomsky, the MIT linguist.

0:54:22.820 --> 0:54:27.660
<v Speaker 2>Somehow language was this core human ability and then somehow

0:54:28.980 --> 0:54:30.380
<v Speaker 2>that seemed pretty good until 2022.

0:54:30.380 --> 0:54:32.940
<v Speaker 1>Now it's consciousness.

0:54:33.120 --> 0:54:37.920
<v Speaker 2>I think there is a hard problem of consciousness and probably.

0:54:39.690 --> 0:54:44.350
<v Speaker 2>Vaguely Cartesian in that I don't think AI is conscious

0:54:44.410 --> 0:54:48.500
<v Speaker 2>or ever will be. And so certainly one dimension where

0:54:48.540 --> 0:54:51.739
<v Speaker 2>humans are different is we experience the world in a

0:54:51.760 --> 0:54:55.340
<v Speaker 2>different way. We experience it consciously. You see a beautiful sunset.

0:54:55.360 --> 0:54:58.260
<v Speaker 2>There's a human way you see a beautiful sunset.

0:54:58.400 --> 0:55:01.120
<v Speaker 1>And we're self-aware about consciousness, as Descartes would say.

0:55:01.300 --> 0:55:05.350
<v Speaker 2>And if there were no humans in the world, I

0:55:05.370 --> 0:55:08.150
<v Speaker 2>don't think the computer would experience the sunset in the

0:55:08.190 --> 0:55:11.530
<v Speaker 2>same way And that would be a very big loss. Now,

0:55:11.840 --> 0:55:14.989
<v Speaker 2>I don't know if that's necessarily the single thing I

0:55:15.010 --> 0:55:19.290
<v Speaker 2>want to anchor on, on why it's imperative for humanity

0:55:19.310 --> 0:55:22.549
<v Speaker 2>to survive. But if humanity doesn't survive, you would at

0:55:22.590 --> 0:55:27.790
<v Speaker 2>least lose that. I think the Girardian intuition, we're also

0:55:27.830 --> 0:55:31.850
<v Speaker 2>very relational. And there are ways, a very important part

0:55:31.870 --> 0:55:36.210
<v Speaker 2>of our lives, it's not just this mind thinking itself,

0:55:36.850 --> 0:55:40.230
<v Speaker 2>a la Descartes. It's the way we relate to other people,

0:55:40.710 --> 0:55:44.450
<v Speaker 2>you know, in families and companies, in our larger society.

0:55:45.070 --> 0:55:48.910
<v Speaker 2>And the relational dimension of what it means to be human,

0:55:49.530 --> 0:55:55.680
<v Speaker 2>I think maybe it will be changed by AI. You know,

0:55:55.700 --> 0:55:58.420
<v Speaker 2>I think in theory it should improve that. There should

0:55:58.440 --> 0:56:01.100
<v Speaker 2>be ways we could get better at that. We could

0:56:01.120 --> 0:56:04.760
<v Speaker 2>spend more time on that, you know, less time doing

0:56:04.820 --> 0:56:07.650
<v Speaker 2>robotic labor in a factory or something like that. So

0:56:07.770 --> 0:56:11.570
<v Speaker 2>I think these relational dimensions maybe are very core and

0:56:11.590 --> 0:56:15.910
<v Speaker 2>will become more important. And yeah, if you replaced all

0:56:15.930 --> 0:56:18.800
<v Speaker 2>the humans with computers, you would at least lose those

0:56:18.840 --> 0:56:20.920
<v Speaker 2>two things. Those would be very severe.

0:56:22.340 --> 0:56:23.420
<v Speaker 1>Peter, thank you.

0:56:24.120 --> 0:56:24.380
<v Speaker 5>Awesome.

0:56:27.360 --> 0:56:31.560
<v Speaker 1>That's it for today's episode. I'm Walter Isaacson. We'll see

0:56:31.580 --> 0:56:32.860
<v Speaker 1>you next time on The Builders.

0:56:37.070 --> 0:56:40.270
<v Speaker 3>The Builders is a Kaleidoscope and iHeart production. This series

0:56:40.350 --> 0:56:43.730
<v Speaker 3>is hosted by Walter Isaacson. It's executive produced for Kaleidoscope

0:56:43.770 --> 0:56:48.470
<v Speaker 3>by Oz Wolishin, David Weisbord, and Mungesh Hetikadur. Sheena Uzaki

0:56:48.510 --> 0:56:52.640
<v Speaker 3>is the producer. Julia Nutter is supervising producer. Eva Zorich

0:56:52.680 --> 0:56:57.180
<v Speaker 3>is our consulting producer. Fact-checking by Eamon Whalen. Research by

0:56:57.219 --> 0:57:01.220
<v Speaker 3>Gloria Thiel. Maria Paz Mendez-Hodes is head of video. Marketing

0:57:01.280 --> 0:57:05.380
<v Speaker 3>by Christy Mirabal and Elle Lube. Production support by Dara

0:57:05.400 --> 0:57:10.260
<v Speaker 3>Look Potts. Music for this series was created by Spencer Stevenson, a.k.a. Botany,

0:57:10.460 --> 0:57:13.299
<v Speaker 3>and it was mixed by Steve Bohm. From iHeart, this

0:57:13.340 --> 0:57:16.840
<v Speaker 3>series is EP'd by Allie Perry and Katrina Norvell. Special

0:57:16.880 --> 0:57:20.840
<v Speaker 3>thanks to Bob Pittman, Conal Byrne, Will Pearson, John Sykes,

0:57:21.040 --> 0:57:25.850
<v Speaker 3>Nikki Etor, Carrie Lieberman, Binky Urban, Julia Prosser, Jeremy Blum,

0:57:26.110 --> 0:57:31.410
<v Speaker 3>Allison Goldberger, WYES, and ASL Studios. For more from Walter Isaacson,

0:57:31.510 --> 0:57:34.150
<v Speaker 3>be sure to check out his newest paperback, The Innovators,

0:57:34.330 --> 0:57:37.450
<v Speaker 3>how a group of hackers, geniuses, and geeks created the

0:57:37.530 --> 0:57:41.290
<v Speaker 3>digital revolution. It's available wherever fine books are sold. And

0:57:41.310 --> 0:57:44.230
<v Speaker 3>for more videos and podcasts from the frontiers of discovery,

0:57:44.570 --> 0:57:46.530
<v Speaker 3>be sure to check out kaleidoscope.nyc.