WEBVTT - Equities, Bonds, and AI

0:00:02.529 --> 0:00:04.210
<v Speaker 1>Bloomberg Audio Studios.

0:00:04.690 --> 0:00:07.050
<v Speaker 2>Podcasts. Radio. News.

0:00:12.530 --> 0:00:16.680
<v Speaker 3>This is the Bloomberg Surveillance Podcast. Catch us live weekdays

0:00:16.739 --> 0:00:20.220
<v Speaker 3>at 7 a.m. Eastern on Apple CarPlay or Android Auto

0:00:20.300 --> 0:00:23.880
<v Speaker 3>with the Bloomberg Business App. Listen on demand wherever you

0:00:23.920 --> 0:00:26.980
<v Speaker 3>get your podcasts or watch us live on YouTube.

0:00:27.590 --> 0:00:30.389
<v Speaker 4>What a wonderful time to speak to Alicia Levine, CIO, BNY.

0:00:31.340 --> 0:00:34.650
<v Speaker 4>at Wealthier who has enjoyed this bull market. How has

0:00:34.670 --> 0:00:38.440
<v Speaker 4>this bull market changed over the last 12 months?

0:00:39.190 --> 0:00:41.910
<v Speaker 5>Well, it's been a jarring 12 months. I think in

0:00:41.930 --> 0:00:44.290
<v Speaker 5>the last two years, we came into the year expecting

0:00:44.409 --> 0:00:48.410
<v Speaker 5>one thing. We got disruption. It's sort of end of

0:00:48.470 --> 0:00:52.120
<v Speaker 5>first quarter, early second quarter, and the market stabilized. And

0:00:52.140 --> 0:00:54.980
<v Speaker 5>that sort of echoed the first two years of this administration.

0:00:55.120 --> 0:00:59.180
<v Speaker 5>And yet the market is fine. Look, the market today

0:00:59.200 --> 0:01:05.510
<v Speaker 5>is echoing the market. from 2023 and some of 24,

0:01:05.510 --> 0:01:09.310
<v Speaker 5>which was the top line index is being carried by

0:01:09.370 --> 0:01:12.690
<v Speaker 5>a handful of names and everybody's wringing their hands that

0:01:12.709 --> 0:01:17.020
<v Speaker 5>it cannot continue when in fact it can continue. And

0:01:17.140 --> 0:01:20.160
<v Speaker 5>if you simply own the S &amp; P, you've been

0:01:20.260 --> 0:01:26.100
<v Speaker 5>fine throughout the All the policy discussions, the rate sell off,

0:01:26.720 --> 0:01:31.800
<v Speaker 5>the hawkishness of the Fed, chaos in the European bond markets.

0:01:32.660 --> 0:01:34.840
<v Speaker 6>And, you know, you've been just fine.

0:01:34.900 --> 0:01:36.860
<v Speaker 5>And there's a very simple reason for that, which is

0:01:36.920 --> 0:01:41.050
<v Speaker 5>that growth keeps on exceeding expectations as normal.

0:01:41.850 --> 0:01:42.610
<v Speaker 6>As do earnings.

0:01:43.110 --> 0:01:45.170
<v Speaker 5>And it seems very simple, but that has been a

0:01:45.230 --> 0:01:46.730
<v Speaker 5>very resilient place to be.

0:01:46.810 --> 0:01:49.050
<v Speaker 6>So the question for us now is, where do we

0:01:49.090 --> 0:01:49.770
<v Speaker 6>go with all this?

0:01:49.990 --> 0:01:56.860
<v Speaker 5>We're back to 15 stocks driving the market higher. Very interestingly,

0:01:57.780 --> 0:02:03.060
<v Speaker 5>the semis and software are rallying together. The Mag7 are rallying.

0:02:03.100 --> 0:02:05.860
<v Speaker 5>You've seen something of a seesaw. When semis have been

0:02:05.970 --> 0:02:08.470
<v Speaker 5>moving better, the software is down and vice versa. Right.

0:02:09.990 --> 0:02:12.590
<v Speaker 5>And so what you're seeing is growth is winning in

0:02:12.610 --> 0:02:16.250
<v Speaker 5>a market where rates are higher and it's very hard

0:02:16.389 --> 0:02:19.560
<v Speaker 5>for the market to price in the Fed reaction function.

0:02:19.960 --> 0:02:24.640
<v Speaker 5>But we assume higher for longer that essentially investors are

0:02:24.660 --> 0:02:25.280
<v Speaker 5>going back to growth.

0:02:25.320 --> 0:02:28.940
<v Speaker 7>Is growth winning because companies are spending ridiculous amounts of

0:02:29.000 --> 0:02:32.690
<v Speaker 7>money on A.I.? Because not even the growth story is diversified,

0:02:32.810 --> 0:02:34.610
<v Speaker 7>or there's no breadth in the growth story.

0:02:34.669 --> 0:02:37.490
<v Speaker 5>There's no breadth in the growth story. Look, there's competition

0:02:37.530 --> 0:02:41.769
<v Speaker 5>for capital. We had news this morning about raising new

0:02:41.790 --> 0:02:43.850
<v Speaker 5>capital for a company that just went public.

0:02:43.970 --> 0:02:44.230
<v Speaker 3>SpaceX.

0:02:44.250 --> 0:02:47.030
<v Speaker 5>What are you doing with all the cash that you raised?

0:02:47.490 --> 0:02:50.210
<v Speaker 5>But in the end, there's demand for it. And as

0:02:50.250 --> 0:02:52.460
<v Speaker 5>we know, and we've had this conversation about deficits, if

0:02:52.470 --> 0:02:56.080
<v Speaker 5>there's demand for the debt, it's fine. The dollar amount

0:02:56.139 --> 0:02:59.580
<v Speaker 5>is eye-popping, but if there's demand... Then you can place it.

0:03:00.060 --> 0:03:02.339
<v Speaker 5>And so move on next. And that's kind of where

0:03:02.360 --> 0:03:04.020
<v Speaker 5>the market is now. Is there a price at which

0:03:04.080 --> 0:03:06.950
<v Speaker 5>that doesn't happen? But we think we think the 10

0:03:06.950 --> 0:03:07.870
<v Speaker 5>year can easily get to.

0:03:07.830 --> 0:03:08.490
<v Speaker 6>Five and a half.

0:03:08.850 --> 0:03:11.889
<v Speaker 5>That works with nominal growth at six point two, six

0:03:11.910 --> 0:03:13.710
<v Speaker 5>point three percent. There's kind of a boom out there

0:03:13.750 --> 0:03:17.070
<v Speaker 5>in the industrial economy. You see it in wages. You

0:03:17.130 --> 0:03:19.460
<v Speaker 5>see it just on the manufacturing. The line straight up.

0:03:20.680 --> 0:03:24.660
<v Speaker 5>And that's what's causing the 10-year to move higher, really.

0:03:24.900 --> 0:03:28.110
<v Speaker 4>Alicia Levine with us, BNY at Wealth here on the

0:03:28.169 --> 0:03:30.810
<v Speaker 4>Equity Markets. A lot of discussion today across the show

0:03:30.850 --> 0:03:34.010
<v Speaker 4>on the Equity Markets as I celebrate my essay of

0:03:34.030 --> 0:03:36.290
<v Speaker 4>the year. I'm catching Alicia blind on this, which is

0:03:36.370 --> 0:03:40.510
<v Speaker 4>okay because she's so good at the game. Rob Arnott,

0:03:40.650 --> 0:03:43.750
<v Speaker 4>Cam Harvey and team out of Duke and out of

0:03:44.350 --> 0:03:45.360
<v Speaker 4>Research Affiliates.

0:03:45.820 --> 0:03:47.540
<v Speaker 8>This is for the CFA Institute.

0:03:48.160 --> 0:03:52.340
<v Speaker 4>And what they basically say, Alicia, which is Alicia Levine 101,

0:03:52.340 --> 0:03:56.700
<v Speaker 4>is stop looking at expensive price ratios, GARP and the rest,

0:03:57.180 --> 0:04:01.440
<v Speaker 4>and get back to fundamental analysis. And the distinction they

0:04:01.520 --> 0:04:05.260
<v Speaker 4>have is down the income statement, don't go too far down.

0:04:06.030 --> 0:04:09.450
<v Speaker 4>This is like 19th century. Look at gross profit here.

0:04:09.830 --> 0:04:11.690
<v Speaker 4>That's the heart of the AI matter.

0:04:11.810 --> 0:04:12.250
<v Speaker 6>Correct.

0:04:12.290 --> 0:04:12.890
<v Speaker 8>These people.

0:04:14.490 --> 0:04:18.390
<v Speaker 4>You know, the Dario on Saturday Night Live folks, they're

0:04:18.430 --> 0:04:23.060
<v Speaker 4>popping massive gross profit. We don't even understand the magnitude,

0:04:23.100 --> 0:04:26.600
<v Speaker 4>do we, Professor Levine, of the gross profit.

0:04:26.740 --> 0:04:28.350
<v Speaker 7>She's looking at us like, duh.

0:04:28.950 --> 0:04:29.310
<v Speaker 2>Yeah.

0:04:29.450 --> 0:04:30.810
<v Speaker 6>Yeah. So, I mean, look.

0:04:32.930 --> 0:04:35.190
<v Speaker 1>Oh, Paul, I miss you so much.

0:04:35.250 --> 0:04:38.100
<v Speaker 5>As they say at the University of Chicago, y'all. I mean, look,

0:04:38.500 --> 0:04:41.080
<v Speaker 5>you know, like, let's keep it simple. Like, what is

0:04:41.140 --> 0:04:41.979
<v Speaker 5>the engine here?

0:04:42.040 --> 0:04:42.840
<v Speaker 6>The engine is growth.

0:04:42.860 --> 0:04:43.560
<v Speaker 8>The engine is profit.

0:04:49.800 --> 0:04:53.030
<v Speaker 5>But massive profit generation because margins keep on moving higher.

0:04:53.350 --> 0:04:55.010
<v Speaker 5>Look at the margin of the S &amp; P over

0:04:55.029 --> 0:04:57.929
<v Speaker 5>the last 20 years. We've been on a margin walk

0:04:58.370 --> 0:04:58.869
<v Speaker 5>much higher.

0:04:58.970 --> 0:05:01.920
<v Speaker 6>It's structural. It is not just what's happening this year.

0:05:01.960 --> 0:05:04.480
<v Speaker 8>Alexis wants to get into your relationship. One more quick

0:05:04.520 --> 0:05:05.100
<v Speaker 8>question then.

0:05:05.540 --> 0:05:09.930
<v Speaker 4>What's the efficacy of looking up the income statement away

0:05:10.010 --> 0:05:12.010
<v Speaker 4>from all the noise of taxes and interest?

0:05:12.850 --> 0:05:16.110
<v Speaker 6>So you spot the opportunities better, right?

0:05:16.130 --> 0:05:19.250
<v Speaker 5>Because what happens is if your revenue line is growing

0:05:19.770 --> 0:05:23.539
<v Speaker 5>very fast, it's just a matter of time for that

0:05:23.580 --> 0:05:26.979
<v Speaker 5>to be passed down to the bottom line and for

0:05:27.040 --> 0:05:29.100
<v Speaker 5>the company to become more efficient. And actually, if you

0:05:29.120 --> 0:05:31.940
<v Speaker 5>think about it, if you have a fixed cost... situation,

0:05:31.960 --> 0:05:35.420
<v Speaker 5>the higher your growth rate, you know, the exponential growth

0:05:35.480 --> 0:05:38.200
<v Speaker 5>on the bottom line. That's where you can grow at 12%.

0:05:38.200 --> 0:05:40.120
<v Speaker 8>It's sick. We could go for an hour with it.

0:05:40.320 --> 0:05:42.400
<v Speaker 7>I love our conversations with Alicia.

0:05:42.460 --> 0:05:44.880
<v Speaker 6>It's math. It's our math conversation.

0:05:45.000 --> 0:05:47.400
<v Speaker 8>Saving the interview, Alexis Christophers.

0:05:47.460 --> 0:05:50.460
<v Speaker 7>Math conversation, not my kind of conversation. I'm going to

0:05:50.480 --> 0:05:52.839
<v Speaker 7>go down the road less traveled and talk about deeply

0:05:52.920 --> 0:05:53.930
<v Speaker 7>distressed U.S.

0:05:53.990 --> 0:05:54.400
<v Speaker 4>Loans.

0:05:54.700 --> 0:05:56.750
<v Speaker 7>There's a great story on the Terminal about this today,

0:05:56.870 --> 0:06:00.030
<v Speaker 7>rising to the highest level since the pandemic. Value of

0:06:00.089 --> 0:06:02.870
<v Speaker 7>loans trading below 60 cents on the dollar. These are

0:06:02.930 --> 0:06:05.050
<v Speaker 7>a lot of loans that are held by software companies

0:06:05.089 --> 0:06:08.210
<v Speaker 7>in particular, some of the AI trade involved in this.

0:06:08.750 --> 0:06:12.250
<v Speaker 7>Are we turning a blind eye to things we shouldn't be?

0:06:12.330 --> 0:06:14.420
<v Speaker 7>Are things percolating in the background that are going to

0:06:14.460 --> 0:06:16.620
<v Speaker 7>be real challenges for this market that we're not paying

0:06:16.660 --> 0:06:17.140
<v Speaker 7>attention to?

0:06:17.300 --> 0:06:20.000
<v Speaker 5>It's a great question because in the end, markets always

0:06:20.040 --> 0:06:22.620
<v Speaker 5>trade on the margin, and that's what's happening on the margin,

0:06:22.660 --> 0:06:25.440
<v Speaker 5>that the weaker companies that borrowed at lower rates and

0:06:25.490 --> 0:06:28.150
<v Speaker 5>funded through maybe some of the private credit a few.

0:06:28.029 --> 0:06:28.790
<v Speaker 6>Years ago.

0:06:30.410 --> 0:06:34.190
<v Speaker 5>Outside of the traditional financing system, but in the alternative capital,

0:06:34.250 --> 0:06:36.500
<v Speaker 5>providers are showing some stress.

0:06:37.020 --> 0:06:39.039
<v Speaker 6>That is what you would expect, but it's also.

0:06:38.880 --> 0:06:41.460
<v Speaker 5>Like a normal part of the cycle that, you know,

0:06:41.480 --> 0:06:43.580
<v Speaker 5>the weaker are going to show the problem first when

0:06:43.600 --> 0:06:47.880
<v Speaker 5>you have 145 move, basis point move in the 10

0:06:47.880 --> 0:06:49.990
<v Speaker 5>year and a Fed that looks to be a lot

0:06:50.000 --> 0:06:52.830
<v Speaker 5>more hawkish than the market priced in six months ago.

0:06:53.330 --> 0:06:55.410
<v Speaker 7>So Darwinism is alive and well.

0:06:55.529 --> 0:07:01.510
<v Speaker 5>Darwinism is alive and well. Not all of those distressed

0:07:01.670 --> 0:07:05.130
<v Speaker 5>trades are priced at the right place. And there are

0:07:05.170 --> 0:07:08.000
<v Speaker 5>distressed marketplaces for this. And there are distressed players that

0:07:08.060 --> 0:07:11.260
<v Speaker 5>are coming with capital to take care of some of that.

0:07:11.320 --> 0:07:13.980
<v Speaker 5>I mean, that's what a market is. But it's no

0:07:14.060 --> 0:07:18.740
<v Speaker 5>surprise that we're here. The cutting cycle... we've had for

0:07:18.760 --> 0:07:22.870
<v Speaker 5>the last two years, again, we talk about go for

0:07:22.880 --> 0:07:23.410
<v Speaker 5>the goodness.

0:07:23.470 --> 0:07:24.490
<v Speaker 6>It hit a lot of badness.

0:07:25.430 --> 0:07:27.650
<v Speaker 5>And so now we're going to see who can get

0:07:27.690 --> 0:07:28.730
<v Speaker 5>refunded and who can.

0:07:29.290 --> 0:07:32.550
<v Speaker 6>Am I worried about it? I'm not worried. It's what

0:07:32.570 --> 0:07:33.370
<v Speaker 6>I would expect.

0:07:33.410 --> 0:07:36.370
<v Speaker 5>But I'd say the strength is really those who are

0:07:36.410 --> 0:07:39.520
<v Speaker 5>levered to using AI tools to expand their business and

0:07:39.560 --> 0:07:41.560
<v Speaker 5>expand their margins. And you're going to get a lot

0:07:41.580 --> 0:07:44.510
<v Speaker 5>of operating leverage from in many, many companies as a

0:07:44.530 --> 0:07:45.100
<v Speaker 5>result of it.

0:07:45.240 --> 0:07:48.720
<v Speaker 4>Alicia Levine, thank you so much. With BNY Wealth this morning,

0:07:48.740 --> 0:07:53.520
<v Speaker 4>there's CI. Oh, there's some really, really interesting dynamics there, folks,

0:07:53.600 --> 0:07:55.780
<v Speaker 4>as she and I were going back and forth on

0:07:55.820 --> 0:07:58.990
<v Speaker 4>the income statement, like where to look at revenues all

0:07:59.010 --> 0:08:02.710
<v Speaker 4>the way down to the traditional net income. Alicia Levine

0:08:03.350 --> 0:08:05.190
<v Speaker 4>reading 1934 Graham Dodd when she was 15 years old.

0:08:05.210 --> 0:08:05.890
<v Speaker 8>This is known.

0:08:11.930 --> 0:08:13.310
<v Speaker 7>Did you know this about yourself, Alicia?

0:08:14.410 --> 0:08:16.010
<v Speaker 6>I read it later.

0:08:16.040 --> 0:08:17.920
<v Speaker 9>Okay, okay, very good.

0:08:18.240 --> 0:08:20.240
<v Speaker 8>This is, this is, no, wait, that was me.

0:08:22.000 --> 0:08:26.150
<v Speaker 4>Stay with us. More from Bloomberg Surveillance coming up after this.

0:08:33.410 --> 0:08:37.020
<v Speaker 3>You're listening to the Bloomberg Surveillance Podcast. Catch us live

0:08:37.100 --> 0:08:39.180
<v Speaker 3>weekday afternoons from 7 to 10 a.m.

0:08:39.220 --> 0:08:39.640
<v Speaker 1>Eastern.

0:08:39.720 --> 0:08:43.020
<v Speaker 3>Listen on Apple CarPlay and Android Auto with the Bloomberg

0:08:43.040 --> 0:08:43.640
<v Speaker 3>Business app.

0:08:43.840 --> 0:08:45.540
<v Speaker 1>Or watch us live on YouTube.

0:08:45.940 --> 0:08:49.220
<v Speaker 4>Our interview of the day, without question, Chuck Clow is

0:08:49.280 --> 0:08:51.800
<v Speaker 4>a legend. If you look at his bio, his resume,

0:08:52.740 --> 0:08:59.140
<v Speaker 4>these are names from the past. Colonial of Boston. Donaldson, Lufkin,

0:08:59.200 --> 0:09:03.650
<v Speaker 4>Jen Redd. That young whippersnapper, Tom Gelvin, was there. at

0:09:03.690 --> 0:09:06.849
<v Speaker 4>the knee of Chuck Clow ages ago in studio with

0:09:06.910 --> 0:09:11.089
<v Speaker 4>us with a hugely optimistic note. I'm sorry, Chuck, this

0:09:11.150 --> 0:09:12.410
<v Speaker 4>is a glass half.

0:09:12.250 --> 0:09:14.569
<v Speaker 8>Full note that you're writing right now.

0:09:15.110 --> 0:09:20.319
<v Speaker 4>Why can we rely on productivity gains to drive equity

0:09:20.380 --> 0:09:21.280
<v Speaker 4>shares higher?

0:09:23.120 --> 0:09:28.800
<v Speaker 10>Well, productivity equals profits was probably the simplest answer of all.

0:09:30.290 --> 0:09:32.250
<v Speaker 10>I think there are reasons to be positive about the

0:09:32.290 --> 0:09:35.350
<v Speaker 10>financial markets, and the fact that financial markets themselves are

0:09:35.690 --> 0:09:38.860
<v Speaker 10>giving a lot of evidence of that. Stocks are strong

0:09:39.050 --> 0:09:42.559
<v Speaker 10>even in the face of a hawkish Fed. Quality spreads

0:09:42.600 --> 0:09:45.059
<v Speaker 10>still stay narrow. They widen a bit, but they're still

0:09:45.100 --> 0:09:49.500
<v Speaker 10>pretty narrow. And the dollar, a year or so ago,

0:09:49.600 --> 0:09:51.849
<v Speaker 10>the overriding consensus was the dollar was in a lot

0:09:51.870 --> 0:09:54.130
<v Speaker 10>of trouble because of heavy government borrowing.

0:09:54.150 --> 0:09:55.370
<v Speaker 9>The dollar's held up fairly well.

0:09:55.410 --> 0:09:57.650
<v Speaker 10>And of course it's strengthened with just really a modest

0:09:57.690 --> 0:10:00.240
<v Speaker 10>increase in interest rates. So I think the market are

0:10:00.260 --> 0:10:06.079
<v Speaker 10>telling you that they're okay, and inflation is there because

0:10:06.140 --> 0:10:10.300
<v Speaker 10>of a series of shortages, and everybody understands that. But

0:10:10.620 --> 0:10:12.890
<v Speaker 10>the one thing I want to bring to the discussion is,

0:10:13.250 --> 0:10:15.729
<v Speaker 10>why is the dollar so strong, and why was it

0:10:15.770 --> 0:10:17.990
<v Speaker 10>strong even before.

0:10:17.690 --> 0:10:19.189
<v Speaker 9>The recent interest rate rise? Please.

0:10:20.030 --> 0:10:24.350
<v Speaker 10>I would argue because everybody focuses on government funding and,

0:10:24.390 --> 0:10:29.040
<v Speaker 10>of course, government's in a deficit. But the private sector borrowing,

0:10:29.080 --> 0:10:32.500
<v Speaker 10>if you total it up, it's larger than total government borrowing.

0:10:33.040 --> 0:10:35.780
<v Speaker 10>And as a percentage of GDP, private borrowing has been declining.

0:10:35.900 --> 0:10:39.479
<v Speaker 10>Household borrowing has been declining since 2009. And corporate borrowing

0:10:39.520 --> 0:10:44.870
<v Speaker 10>now has been declining since 2022. We're a nation whose

0:10:44.910 --> 0:10:46.630
<v Speaker 10>population isn't growing very now.

0:10:46.690 --> 0:10:49.990
<v Speaker 9>The capital stock is pretty well built. I would argue

0:10:50.070 --> 0:10:51.150
<v Speaker 9>that if you look at.

0:10:51.600 --> 0:10:56.880
<v Speaker 10>Total debt outstanding, which is what creates dollars, as a

0:10:56.920 --> 0:10:59.699
<v Speaker 10>percentage of GDP, it's been declining now on the private

0:10:59.720 --> 0:11:04.560
<v Speaker 10>sector for years. And even relative to GDP, even government

0:11:04.580 --> 0:11:06.679
<v Speaker 10>debt growth is leveling off.

0:11:06.840 --> 0:11:10.140
<v Speaker 4>Across the arc of Chuck Clow from your evenings with

0:11:10.179 --> 0:11:13.179
<v Speaker 4>Lou Rukeyser years ago, I went back and did a

0:11:13.260 --> 0:11:18.130
<v Speaker 4>chart of nominal GDP. And this is highly unusual. this

0:11:18.230 --> 0:11:21.820
<v Speaker 4>buoyancy that we have in a boom economy. Ed Yardeni,

0:11:22.120 --> 0:11:25.490
<v Speaker 4>a close colleague of yours, talks about the roaring 20s.

0:11:26.380 --> 0:11:29.819
<v Speaker 4>How do you interpret, how do you analyze this boom

0:11:29.880 --> 0:11:31.280
<v Speaker 4>economy that we're in now?

0:11:32.300 --> 0:11:35.079
<v Speaker 10>Well, productivity has been rising for some time. A lot

0:11:35.100 --> 0:11:38.990
<v Speaker 10>of it is technology-based. But I think, like I say,

0:11:39.000 --> 0:11:43.730
<v Speaker 10>I think the disconnect is that directly translates into profits.

0:11:44.230 --> 0:11:48.150
<v Speaker 10>And The more productivity grows, the higher profits will grow.

0:11:48.630 --> 0:11:50.570
<v Speaker 10>In an important way, I think the market's telling you

0:11:50.630 --> 0:11:55.050
<v Speaker 10>that final demand will slow, and it's telling you that

0:11:55.100 --> 0:11:58.340
<v Speaker 10>by virtually every cyclical sector has been under pressure for

0:11:58.360 --> 0:12:01.140
<v Speaker 10>a long time, whether it's autos, even the big retailers,

0:12:01.240 --> 0:12:08.000
<v Speaker 10>even McDonald's is fighting tailwinds. People adjust to inflation very quickly,

0:12:08.200 --> 0:12:09.640
<v Speaker 10>even in the airline industry.

0:12:10.640 --> 0:12:11.400
<v Speaker 9>We all know there's a.

0:12:11.400 --> 0:12:15.970
<v Speaker 10>Shortage of narrow-bodied aircraft, But airlines are already beginning to

0:12:16.020 --> 0:12:17.490
<v Speaker 10>extend the time that.

0:12:17.370 --> 0:12:18.770
<v Speaker 9>They hold older aircraft.

0:12:18.809 --> 0:12:21.750
<v Speaker 10>So there's enough adjustments going on in the economy right

0:12:21.890 --> 0:12:26.189
<v Speaker 10>now that these are supply shocks. But there's plenty of

0:12:26.250 --> 0:12:29.319
<v Speaker 10>liquidity and plenty of investment capital in the economy to

0:12:29.940 --> 0:12:31.700
<v Speaker 10>solve it. The best example is insurance.

0:12:31.860 --> 0:12:35.940
<v Speaker 4>I would editorialize here, Alexis, that this is classic Chuck Clowell.

0:12:36.400 --> 0:12:40.530
<v Speaker 4>that the economy in its microcosm adjusts along the way

0:12:41.190 --> 0:12:44.189
<v Speaker 4>where all the media blather is a certitude about where

0:12:44.230 --> 0:12:47.370
<v Speaker 4>we are, static versus a dynamic analysis.

0:12:48.590 --> 0:12:50.730
<v Speaker 7>Chuck, do you think that the U.S. is still the

0:12:50.830 --> 0:12:53.260
<v Speaker 7>best place to be right now when you look at

0:12:53.880 --> 0:12:57.780
<v Speaker 7>the international markets and including the emerging markets like China,

0:12:57.820 --> 0:12:59.179
<v Speaker 7>if we want to call it an emerging market?

0:12:59.480 --> 0:13:01.760
<v Speaker 9>Well, for a while, it's been the only place to be.

0:13:03.950 --> 0:13:07.540
<v Speaker 10>Europe is regulating itself into a no-growth environment, certainly a

0:13:07.580 --> 0:13:10.580
<v Speaker 10>no-profit growth environment, and now you're beginning.

0:13:10.280 --> 0:13:12.570
<v Speaker 9>To see breaks in society there.

0:13:13.050 --> 0:13:15.690
<v Speaker 10>I'd say the only area in the world that I think.

0:13:15.570 --> 0:13:19.290
<v Speaker 9>Is becoming more interesting is Latin America. We've had a

0:13:19.820 --> 0:13:20.420
<v Speaker 9>number of.

0:13:21.620 --> 0:13:25.700
<v Speaker 10>of elections that have brought more conservative in Argentina.

0:13:25.220 --> 0:13:27.500
<v Speaker 9>A few years ago and, of course, Brazil lately.

0:13:29.100 --> 0:13:33.220
<v Speaker 10>It's resource rich. The rule of law is becoming more

0:13:35.100 --> 0:13:39.520
<v Speaker 10>intense across Latin America. I think China is uninvestable right now.

0:13:39.540 --> 0:13:43.360
<v Speaker 10>And the other markets are too small to even think about.

0:13:44.690 --> 0:13:47.650
<v Speaker 10>So I would say that the U.S. is the place

0:13:47.690 --> 0:13:50.110
<v Speaker 10>to be. And if you look at overall investment flows,

0:13:50.170 --> 0:13:53.890
<v Speaker 10>especially corporate investment flows, they're coming here. They're moving from

0:13:53.970 --> 0:13:57.050
<v Speaker 10>Europe to the United States. So that's one of the

0:13:57.090 --> 0:13:58.590
<v Speaker 10>reasons the dollar is so strong as well.

0:13:58.790 --> 0:14:01.030
<v Speaker 4>You and I go back far enough to remember when

0:14:01.050 --> 0:14:03.199
<v Speaker 4>the Boston Red Sox were actually.

0:14:02.820 --> 0:14:03.680
<v Speaker 8>A good team.

0:14:04.440 --> 0:14:08.699
<v Speaker 4>I mean, we go back that far. How do you

0:14:08.800 --> 0:14:13.270
<v Speaker 4>fold the politics into... and optimism to invest. When you

0:14:13.290 --> 0:14:16.370
<v Speaker 4>look at the midterms, or on the Wednesday in November,

0:14:16.410 --> 0:14:18.170
<v Speaker 4>we start a presidential campaign.

0:14:18.730 --> 0:14:20.050
<v Speaker 8>Is that just noise to you?

0:14:21.190 --> 0:14:22.490
<v Speaker 1>Most of the time, it is.

0:14:22.890 --> 0:14:26.680
<v Speaker 10>And in fact, if you look at fiscal policy, markets

0:14:26.900 --> 0:14:30.200
<v Speaker 10>don't usually respond to fiscal policy. They respond to monetary policy,

0:14:30.220 --> 0:14:34.479
<v Speaker 10>but not fiscal policy. So yeah, politics can be overemphasized.

0:14:35.460 --> 0:14:36.780
<v Speaker 9>I would say this. Markets love.

0:14:38.340 --> 0:14:42.090
<v Speaker 9>That's the word I'm trying to grasp for. Congress can't

0:14:42.110 --> 0:14:42.950
<v Speaker 9>get anything done.

0:14:43.040 --> 0:14:43.990
<v Speaker 8>Gridlock.

0:14:44.010 --> 0:14:46.850
<v Speaker 9>That's the word I'm grasping for. Markets love gridlock, and

0:14:46.910 --> 0:14:47.670
<v Speaker 9>it sure looks like.

0:14:47.570 --> 0:14:50.570
<v Speaker 10>We're heading for a gridlock-causing election here.

0:14:50.630 --> 0:14:53.050
<v Speaker 9>So I wouldn't worry about the political side.

0:14:53.430 --> 0:14:56.590
<v Speaker 10>And quite frankly, I think there's way too much emphasis

0:14:56.730 --> 0:15:00.210
<v Speaker 10>on translating what's going on in the war to a

0:15:00.510 --> 0:15:04.440
<v Speaker 10>permanent inflation. It is not a permanent inflation. It's inflation

0:15:04.720 --> 0:15:06.700
<v Speaker 10>raised on a supply shock, and there's plenty of investment

0:15:06.720 --> 0:15:08.830
<v Speaker 10>capital to fix it. I wanted to use the example

0:15:08.850 --> 0:15:11.410
<v Speaker 10>of the insurance industry. Um, if we were here 15

0:15:11.410 --> 0:15:14.130
<v Speaker 10>months ago, uh, property insurance rates.

0:15:14.010 --> 0:15:14.710
<v Speaker 9>Would be soaring.

0:15:14.750 --> 0:15:17.010
<v Speaker 10>And that would be the, if you Google it, you

0:15:17.030 --> 0:15:20.210
<v Speaker 10>find property insurance rates are now down between nine and 30%

0:15:20.210 --> 0:15:23.430
<v Speaker 10>year over year because a hold of capital ran into

0:15:23.450 --> 0:15:26.630
<v Speaker 10>the insurance industry and, and, and, and pricing is beginning

0:15:26.650 --> 0:15:30.210
<v Speaker 10>to be beginning to break there. Um, so I, I,

0:15:30.290 --> 0:15:32.010
<v Speaker 10>I think that's the way to look at it. These

0:15:32.080 --> 0:15:37.040
<v Speaker 10>are supply shocks. The underlying reality is demographically demographically based.

0:15:38.080 --> 0:15:40.739
<v Speaker 10>The private borrowing will continue to decline. Government borrowing has

0:15:40.780 --> 0:15:42.739
<v Speaker 10>plenty of room to do what it needs to do,

0:15:43.720 --> 0:15:46.090
<v Speaker 10>but it's not a long-term effect on the capital markets here.

0:15:46.350 --> 0:15:49.750
<v Speaker 7>So you think this disinflationary environment is going to continue

0:15:49.810 --> 0:15:52.270
<v Speaker 7>for some time? I was reading your note. You say

0:15:52.290 --> 0:15:54.690
<v Speaker 7>you wouldn't be surprised to see short-term interest rates go

0:15:54.710 --> 0:15:57.740
<v Speaker 7>to 1% to 2%. What's going to get us there?

0:15:58.240 --> 0:16:00.600
<v Speaker 10>Well, interest rates and inflation went down for 40 years,

0:16:01.140 --> 0:16:04.580
<v Speaker 10>from 1982 until the COVID hit.

0:16:05.140 --> 0:16:08.020
<v Speaker 9>And of course, the The government response was enormous.

0:16:08.670 --> 0:16:14.750
<v Speaker 10>Not only tremendous liquidity environment caused by the Fed, but

0:16:14.820 --> 0:16:17.180
<v Speaker 10>heavy fiscal stimulus as well.

0:16:17.420 --> 0:16:18.660
<v Speaker 9>It takes a while to work that off.

0:16:19.740 --> 0:16:22.140
<v Speaker 10>And then see we've had a series of shocks since

0:16:22.200 --> 0:16:27.390
<v Speaker 10>then and I suspect that if you look at what

0:16:27.410 --> 0:16:30.030
<v Speaker 10>were the reasons why interest rates and inflation came down

0:16:30.050 --> 0:16:32.610
<v Speaker 10>they really three of them one is demographics the baby

0:16:32.630 --> 0:16:36.670
<v Speaker 10>boomers are starting to retire biggest bending and sparring demographic

0:16:36.710 --> 0:16:42.060
<v Speaker 10>in history short rates are rates are Quality rates are

0:16:42.100 --> 0:16:45.160
<v Speaker 10>narrow which means the corporate sector is this basically structurally

0:16:45.220 --> 0:16:47.880
<v Speaker 10>very healthy and And three, the dollar is strong, which

0:16:47.920 --> 0:16:50.480
<v Speaker 10>means investment is coming here. So the real question is,

0:16:50.660 --> 0:16:54.160
<v Speaker 10>if private borrowing continues to decline, what happens to the

0:16:54.180 --> 0:16:54.940
<v Speaker 10>financial sector?

0:16:55.100 --> 0:16:57.610
<v Speaker 9>Now, I'll try to make my point this way.

0:16:58.430 --> 0:17:04.950
<v Speaker 10>The relative capitalization of industries can change dramatically. The energy

0:17:04.990 --> 0:17:06.899
<v Speaker 10>industry represented 33% of the S &amp; P 500 in 1981.

0:17:06.880 --> 0:17:07.360
<v Speaker 9>It's three today.

0:17:10.390 --> 0:17:14.139
<v Speaker 10>So you can have massive changes in that. The financial sector,

0:17:14.220 --> 0:17:17.000
<v Speaker 10>I think, is too large. I think spreads may be

0:17:17.020 --> 0:17:20.080
<v Speaker 10>good for a while, but that's not really what's happening.

0:17:20.119 --> 0:17:23.679
<v Speaker 10>There's consolidation throughout the financial sector. The financial sector was 33%

0:17:23.680 --> 0:17:24.359
<v Speaker 10>of the S &amp; P 500 in 2006.

0:17:24.340 --> 0:17:26.190
<v Speaker 9>If you include balance sheets of General Electric, Ford Motor,

0:17:26.210 --> 0:17:26.810
<v Speaker 9>it was 37%.

0:17:26.810 --> 0:17:27.950
<v Speaker 4>It's 13% today.

0:17:37.740 --> 0:17:41.449
<v Speaker 10>So the profitability of the financial sector is shrinking, and

0:17:41.490 --> 0:17:44.389
<v Speaker 10>as it does, the financial sector, we're already seeing it

0:17:44.410 --> 0:17:47.190
<v Speaker 10>in the banking industry. That means, think of what the

0:17:47.290 --> 0:17:50.770
<v Speaker 10>short rate is. Other than the Fed, the most important

0:17:51.369 --> 0:17:54.250
<v Speaker 10>determinant of what the short rate is, what is the

0:17:54.290 --> 0:17:56.409
<v Speaker 10>financial sector willing to bid for its own liabilities?

0:17:56.990 --> 0:17:59.750
<v Speaker 9>A deposit or commercial paper or asset-backed security.

0:18:00.109 --> 0:18:04.580
<v Speaker 10>And if it shrinks, the bid for that liability is

0:18:04.619 --> 0:18:05.260
<v Speaker 10>going to go down.

0:18:05.280 --> 0:18:05.939
<v Speaker 9>It's going to go down.

0:18:06.609 --> 0:18:08.630
<v Speaker 10>And it may take a while until some of these

0:18:08.670 --> 0:18:11.090
<v Speaker 10>supply shocks have worked their way out. But that short

0:18:11.150 --> 0:18:12.850
<v Speaker 10>rate is a very vulnerable number.

0:18:13.190 --> 0:18:15.380
<v Speaker 4>Chuck Clough, thank you so much for coming. We'd love

0:18:15.400 --> 0:18:16.520
<v Speaker 4>to do this. I'd love to do this on a

0:18:16.560 --> 0:18:19.479
<v Speaker 4>monthly basis. John, we've got to get Chuck Clough down

0:18:19.520 --> 0:18:20.560
<v Speaker 4>here on a monthly basis.

0:18:21.020 --> 0:18:22.450
<v Speaker 8>All right, Chuck. You into it?

0:18:22.540 --> 0:18:23.600
<v Speaker 9>Can I do that from my bedroom?

0:18:23.900 --> 0:18:25.400
<v Speaker 1>You can do it from anywhere you like.

0:18:25.590 --> 0:18:29.470
<v Speaker 8>Chuck Clough, thank you so much. Chairman Clough, Capital, Concord, Massachusetts.

0:18:31.170 --> 0:18:35.310
<v Speaker 4>Stay with us. More from Bloomberg Surveillance coming up after this.

0:18:42.570 --> 0:18:46.169
<v Speaker 3>You're listening to the Bloomberg Surveillance Podcast. Catch us live

0:18:46.250 --> 0:18:48.330
<v Speaker 3>weekday afternoons from 7 to 10 a.m.

0:18:48.369 --> 0:18:48.770
<v Speaker 9>Eastern.

0:18:48.869 --> 0:18:52.170
<v Speaker 3>Listen on Apple CarPlay and Android Auto with the Bloomberg

0:18:52.190 --> 0:18:52.800
<v Speaker 3>Business app.

0:18:52.990 --> 0:18:54.740
<v Speaker 1>Or watch us live on YouTube.

0:18:55.200 --> 0:18:55.639
<v Speaker 8>The way it.

0:18:55.619 --> 0:18:58.719
<v Speaker 4>Works in the street, you have an investor's day. And,

0:18:58.740 --> 0:19:00.480
<v Speaker 4>you know, people just think it's sort of cushy and

0:19:00.520 --> 0:19:03.420
<v Speaker 4>there's horse divorce and, you know, beverages of your choice

0:19:03.460 --> 0:19:05.869
<v Speaker 4>and all that. Fatima Bulani was up till 2 a.m.

0:19:06.830 --> 0:19:09.560
<v Speaker 4>You know, the last people here on Investor's Day. She

0:19:09.619 --> 0:19:13.740
<v Speaker 4>joins us, I hope, Cogent, from Citigroup today, because this

0:19:13.820 --> 0:19:15.100
<v Speaker 4>is like serious stuff.

0:19:15.160 --> 0:19:17.859
<v Speaker 8>People make jokes about it. How many people were your

0:19:17.880 --> 0:19:18.760
<v Speaker 8>investor day, Fatima?

0:19:22.280 --> 0:19:24.840
<v Speaker 2>The investor day was packed to the gills. So we

0:19:24.880 --> 0:19:30.179
<v Speaker 2>had Zscaler. It's one of the lesser known but leading

0:19:30.240 --> 0:19:34.080
<v Speaker 2>and more preeminent cybersecurity companies. They don't necessarily get talked

0:19:34.140 --> 0:19:38.900
<v Speaker 2>about in the same breath as the Goliaths, CrowdStrike and Apollo.

0:19:38.980 --> 0:19:40.250
<v Speaker 6>But yeah, it was packed.

0:19:40.030 --> 0:19:40.530
<v Speaker 1>To the gills.

0:19:40.550 --> 0:19:41.689
<v Speaker 2>There's a lot of interest.

0:19:41.690 --> 0:19:45.379
<v Speaker 4>What is the interest to get away from 12 stocks

0:19:45.380 --> 0:19:46.740
<v Speaker 4>everybody knows?

0:19:46.740 --> 0:19:47.530
<v Speaker 8>Do people are.

0:19:47.480 --> 0:19:51.990
<v Speaker 4>They really searching for a deeper breadth of this ai

0:19:52.050 --> 0:19:53.830
<v Speaker 4>revolution You.

0:19:53.780 --> 0:19:57.260
<v Speaker 2>Know, what we've broadly seen, and this kind of harkens

0:19:57.300 --> 0:19:59.780
<v Speaker 2>back to the last discussion you were having around this

0:19:59.840 --> 0:20:05.610
<v Speaker 2>chasing for growth, right? So there has been an absolute interest, focus,

0:20:05.670 --> 0:20:08.590
<v Speaker 2>and concentration on some of the largest assets in their

0:20:08.630 --> 0:20:12.640
<v Speaker 2>representative industries. So really the willingness to pay a pretty

0:20:12.680 --> 0:20:16.640
<v Speaker 2>hefty premiums for marquee assets in their space. So again,

0:20:16.740 --> 0:20:21.459
<v Speaker 2>CrowdStrike and Polo and cybersecurity, those are known entities. They've, uh,

0:20:21.640 --> 0:20:26.020
<v Speaker 2>you know, uh, produced an excellent track record of, of execution.

0:20:26.520 --> 0:20:30.460
<v Speaker 2>And so, you know, investor sentiment and mentality has generally been, Hey,

0:20:30.700 --> 0:20:31.859
<v Speaker 2>let the winners win more.

0:20:32.109 --> 0:20:33.400
<v Speaker 1>So, uh, there.

0:20:33.420 --> 0:20:38.090
<v Speaker 2>Absolutely has been this bifurcation of, of haves and have nots. And, uh,

0:20:38.660 --> 0:20:40.620
<v Speaker 2>that sort of compounded over the last year.

0:20:41.750 --> 0:20:44.090
<v Speaker 7>Zscaler, coming off the investor day, I'm just taking a

0:20:44.090 --> 0:20:48.020
<v Speaker 7>look at the stock market cap, $ 34. 5 billion. Not too shabby. Year-to-date, though,

0:20:48.040 --> 0:20:50.480
<v Speaker 7>the stock is down nearly 6%. What was your big

0:20:50.500 --> 0:20:52.020
<v Speaker 7>takeaway from investor day?

0:20:53.340 --> 0:20:56.159
<v Speaker 2>Look, there were two major areas that I think the

0:20:56.200 --> 0:20:59.310
<v Speaker 2>management team did a very solid job on, right? Number one,

0:20:59.940 --> 0:21:02.740
<v Speaker 2>providing us with a financial framework over the next several

0:21:02.830 --> 0:21:06.030
<v Speaker 2>years on what the growth trajectory of the business is going.

0:21:05.869 --> 0:21:06.370
<v Speaker 4>To look like.

0:21:07.130 --> 0:21:08.689
<v Speaker 2>You know, I don't have to tell you that we

0:21:08.810 --> 0:21:15.230
<v Speaker 2>are in an absolutely generational period for cybersecurity risks, cybersecurity investments,

0:21:15.590 --> 0:21:17.290
<v Speaker 2>but at the same time, you know, a lot of

0:21:17.350 --> 0:21:20.879
<v Speaker 2>dizzying amount of change that organizations have to you know,

0:21:20.900 --> 0:21:24.899
<v Speaker 2>batten down the hatches around, right? So, you know, articulating

0:21:24.940 --> 0:21:31.649
<v Speaker 2>a financial set of targets around that. And then secondarily,

0:21:31.690 --> 0:21:37.210
<v Speaker 2>this idea of leveraging what their core principles around effectively

0:21:37.260 --> 0:21:41.060
<v Speaker 2>being a communications switchboard and applying that to agents, right?

0:21:41.440 --> 0:21:41.700
<v Speaker 4>Right?

0:21:41.720 --> 0:21:43.800
<v Speaker 2>I think three to five years from now, no one

0:21:43.859 --> 0:21:46.240
<v Speaker 2>is going to bat an eyelash. If I say agents

0:21:46.290 --> 0:21:48.310
<v Speaker 2>are going to be my teammates, agents are going to

0:21:48.350 --> 0:21:56.010
<v Speaker 2>be undertaking important business processes, completely autonomously, completely unmediated by humans.

0:21:56.230 --> 0:22:00.320
<v Speaker 2>And so who's going to govern those exchanges and who's

0:22:00.340 --> 0:22:02.420
<v Speaker 2>going to govern those interactions. And, you know, I think

0:22:02.440 --> 0:22:07.990
<v Speaker 2>they mounted a pretty compelling vision and architectural strategy around that. And,

0:22:08.320 --> 0:22:10.180
<v Speaker 2>you know, at the end of the day, tying this

0:22:10.240 --> 0:22:14.340
<v Speaker 2>back to valuations feel stretched, the expensive names and the

0:22:14.380 --> 0:22:17.659
<v Speaker 2>high quality names continue to be bid up. This is

0:22:17.810 --> 0:22:19.940
<v Speaker 2>one that sort of is interesting, right? There's a little

0:22:19.960 --> 0:22:23.330
<v Speaker 2>bit of a valuation arbitrage, right? So a diamond in

0:22:23.350 --> 0:22:26.270
<v Speaker 2>the rough strategy in a market where, you know, things

0:22:26.330 --> 0:22:28.990
<v Speaker 2>feel sort of instantly and instantaneously priced in.

0:22:29.109 --> 0:22:33.510
<v Speaker 4>We continue with Fatima Bulani, co-head software equity Citigroup, having

0:22:33.530 --> 0:22:35.850
<v Speaker 4>the privilege of working with Heath Terry. I believe Heath's

0:22:35.869 --> 0:22:38.359
<v Speaker 4>on our schedule. at some point here in the coming

0:22:38.380 --> 0:22:41.220
<v Speaker 4>days as well. Fatima, I want to go off script here.

0:22:41.730 --> 0:22:44.390
<v Speaker 4>We just did a thing on MetaMoose. I know Ron

0:22:44.430 --> 0:22:47.190
<v Speaker 4>Josie follows Meta. I don't need a buy, hold, sell

0:22:47.690 --> 0:22:51.210
<v Speaker 4>on Meta. But Fatima, I mean, folks, you got to understand,

0:22:51.550 --> 0:22:55.760
<v Speaker 4>Fatima was 15 years old at Thomas Y. Sell like

0:22:55.800 --> 0:22:58.340
<v Speaker 4>a million years ago. I mean, she started out, she

0:22:58.359 --> 0:23:00.899
<v Speaker 4>was like a junior in high school, I think, when

0:23:00.960 --> 0:23:03.540
<v Speaker 4>she was getting her CFN.

0:23:03.859 --> 0:23:07.330
<v Speaker 2>They called me a child prodigy.

0:23:07.350 --> 0:23:08.830
<v Speaker 6>Those aren't my words.

0:23:08.990 --> 0:23:12.590
<v Speaker 4>But Fatima, I look at this and the heart of

0:23:12.630 --> 0:23:16.570
<v Speaker 4>the matter within a conversation we had earlier is they

0:23:16.609 --> 0:23:21.040
<v Speaker 4>want us to give them our financial data, our personal data.

0:23:21.440 --> 0:23:24.919
<v Speaker 4>Claude needs to look into my computer. Muse wants to

0:23:24.960 --> 0:23:29.020
<v Speaker 4>know this, this. Are you kidding me, Fatima? Nobody's going

0:23:29.040 --> 0:23:29.600
<v Speaker 4>to do that.

0:23:31.580 --> 0:23:34.460
<v Speaker 2>Well, you know, I think data privacy and consumer data

0:23:34.500 --> 0:23:39.310
<v Speaker 2>privacy is certainly going to be a very topical matter.

0:23:40.050 --> 0:23:42.790
<v Speaker 6>And, you know, this puts me out of my depth.

0:23:43.350 --> 0:23:46.050
<v Speaker 2>You know, there's likely going to be, you know, political

0:23:46.130 --> 0:23:50.230
<v Speaker 2>standoffs about this and around this. But, you know, I

0:23:50.280 --> 0:23:53.139
<v Speaker 2>love going off-roading with you on this, Tom. But Muse

0:23:53.160 --> 0:23:57.460
<v Speaker 2>has very interesting implications as it relates to commerce and

0:23:57.560 --> 0:24:01.240
<v Speaker 2>e-commerce at large. Right. And so, you know, to the

0:24:01.280 --> 0:24:04.570
<v Speaker 2>extent you and I were browsing and shopping, well, we're

0:24:04.609 --> 0:24:07.770
<v Speaker 2>going to, in an ideal world, have Muse or some

0:24:07.790 --> 0:24:10.710
<v Speaker 2>of its competitors who act as personal.

0:24:10.490 --> 0:24:11.290
<v Speaker 6>Agents do that.

0:24:11.750 --> 0:24:14.580
<v Speaker 2>And at the end of the day, organizations have to

0:24:14.670 --> 0:24:16.300
<v Speaker 2>prepare for that eventuality.

0:24:16.400 --> 0:24:16.680
<v Speaker 11>Right.

0:24:17.160 --> 0:24:19.419
<v Speaker 2>You know, I think there may be an impasse and

0:24:19.460 --> 0:24:23.649
<v Speaker 2>a scuttle there. around some companies just saying, no, bots

0:24:23.730 --> 0:24:25.530
<v Speaker 2>and agents can't transact on my website.

0:24:25.590 --> 0:24:27.590
<v Speaker 6>It has to be an authentic human.

0:24:28.320 --> 0:24:28.939
<v Speaker 1>But by and.

0:24:28.910 --> 0:24:32.540
<v Speaker 2>Large, there is going to be a movement around, hey,

0:24:32.660 --> 0:24:36.500
<v Speaker 2>I can dispatch Muse to pick up my morning smoothie for.

0:24:36.340 --> 0:24:38.250
<v Speaker 6>Me at Joe and the Juice, right?

0:24:39.250 --> 0:24:44.480
<v Speaker 2>And so agentic commerce becomes So much more of a

0:24:44.560 --> 0:24:49.710
<v Speaker 2>multifaceted and interesting topic to discover, right? And we've been

0:24:49.750 --> 0:24:53.070
<v Speaker 2>spending a lot of time thinking about, hey, now the

0:24:53.150 --> 0:24:57.630
<v Speaker 2>burden of managing that digital experience for the end customer

0:24:57.730 --> 0:24:59.530
<v Speaker 2>falls on the company, right?

0:24:59.550 --> 0:25:00.450
<v Speaker 8>Exactly.

0:25:00.710 --> 0:25:03.639
<v Speaker 2>And who wins there? So there's going to likely be

0:25:03.680 --> 0:25:04.619
<v Speaker 2>more investment there.

0:25:04.640 --> 0:25:04.740
<v Speaker 5>Right.

0:25:05.100 --> 0:25:07.380
<v Speaker 2>Oh, by the way, you're going to have agents trawling

0:25:07.420 --> 0:25:10.120
<v Speaker 2>your website. You ought to have the right, you know,

0:25:10.180 --> 0:25:13.500
<v Speaker 2>gates and firewalls put up. And, you know, there's investment

0:25:13.540 --> 0:25:16.730
<v Speaker 2>opportunities there. And, you know, Cloudflare and Datadog are the

0:25:16.810 --> 0:25:19.570
<v Speaker 2>ones that we've thought of very highly in this sort

0:25:19.630 --> 0:25:21.650
<v Speaker 2>of incremental opportunity.

0:25:22.250 --> 0:25:24.909
<v Speaker 4>Oh, by the way, Compliance at Citigroup just emailed me

0:25:24.950 --> 0:25:27.550
<v Speaker 4>and said you nailed that answer. You know, there's all

0:25:27.570 --> 0:25:29.870
<v Speaker 4>sorts of, you know, ranchos.

0:25:29.930 --> 0:25:31.650
<v Speaker 2>My handlers are proud.

0:25:31.670 --> 0:25:32.470
<v Speaker 6>So good.

0:25:32.490 --> 0:25:34.030
<v Speaker 8>Right. Fatima, thank you so much.

0:25:34.070 --> 0:25:39.760
<v Speaker 4>Fatima Boulani, co-head of software equity research at Citigroup. Stay

0:25:39.780 --> 0:25:43.660
<v Speaker 4>with us. More from Bloomberg Surveillance coming up after this.

0:25:50.920 --> 0:25:54.500
<v Speaker 3>You're listening to the Bloomberg Surveillance Podcast. Catch us live

0:25:54.590 --> 0:25:56.670
<v Speaker 3>weekday afternoons from 7 to 10 a.m.

0:25:56.730 --> 0:25:57.130
<v Speaker 1>Eastern.

0:25:57.210 --> 0:26:00.510
<v Speaker 3>Listen on Apple CarPlay and Android Auto with the Bloomberg

0:26:00.530 --> 0:26:03.050
<v Speaker 3>Business app. Or watch us live on YouTube.

0:26:03.410 --> 0:26:07.310
<v Speaker 4>This research note is extraordinary. And it is the work

0:26:07.350 --> 0:26:10.430
<v Speaker 4>that you have to do to glean BLS, Bureau of

0:26:10.470 --> 0:26:14.320
<v Speaker 4>Labor Statistics data, to come up with a state of America.

0:26:14.720 --> 0:26:19.420
<v Speaker 4>Kyra Ficteau is with Wellington Management Boston. are titled Fixed

0:26:19.480 --> 0:26:25.480
<v Speaker 4>Income Portfolio Manager, which barely describes the depth of this memo.

0:26:25.680 --> 0:26:30.690
<v Speaker 4>And I love what you say about experienced inflation. The

0:26:30.730 --> 0:26:36.580
<v Speaker 4>haves have inflation and they're like, and the rest of America,

0:26:36.890 --> 0:26:40.260
<v Speaker 4>I get more mail on this than anything else. How

0:26:40.340 --> 0:26:42.100
<v Speaker 4>bad is it for half of America?

0:26:42.560 --> 0:26:42.859
<v Speaker 6>Thanks.

0:26:42.880 --> 0:26:43.080
<v Speaker 10>Yeah.

0:26:43.119 --> 0:26:45.889
<v Speaker 11>Thanks for having me, Tom. I look, I think the

0:26:45.950 --> 0:26:51.230
<v Speaker 11>way inflation was supposed to crush the consumer by now,

0:26:51.730 --> 0:26:54.070
<v Speaker 11>and people are sick of talking about the K-shaped economy,

0:26:54.109 --> 0:26:57.230
<v Speaker 11>but the reality is that under the hood, dispersion continues

0:26:57.290 --> 0:27:00.010
<v Speaker 11>to grow. And because the inflation that we see in

0:27:00.109 --> 0:27:04.389
<v Speaker 11>headline numbers is not really the inflation that consumers are experiencing.

0:27:04.770 --> 0:27:08.430
<v Speaker 11>The BLS puts out a consumption basket for consumers that

0:27:09.800 --> 0:27:12.859
<v Speaker 11>assumes that we consume the same types of products as

0:27:13.080 --> 0:27:16.820
<v Speaker 11>everybody else. But the reality is that people on a

0:27:16.859 --> 0:27:21.320
<v Speaker 11>lower income spectrum are more exposed to food and energy

0:27:21.359 --> 0:27:25.580
<v Speaker 11>inflation than consumers on a higher income spectrum. sector. And

0:27:25.600 --> 0:27:28.600
<v Speaker 11>so when I dig into the data and really rip

0:27:28.640 --> 0:27:32.270
<v Speaker 11>it apart, what I observe is that cumulative inflation over

0:27:32.310 --> 0:27:34.710
<v Speaker 11>the last six and a half years in the post-pandemic

0:27:34.850 --> 0:27:39.409
<v Speaker 11>era was upwards of 30%. But that lower income people

0:27:39.550 --> 0:27:43.150
<v Speaker 11>experienced more inflation than higher income people.

0:27:43.170 --> 0:27:45.469
<v Speaker 8>Do you have a statistic on that? From 30, did

0:27:45.490 --> 0:27:46.990
<v Speaker 8>they do 40 or 50?

0:27:46.990 --> 0:27:51.320
<v Speaker 11>So we're talking about points and when you actually strip

0:27:51.340 --> 0:27:54.359
<v Speaker 11>out shelter inflation, which is the biggest issue, right? Like,

0:27:55.060 --> 0:27:59.290
<v Speaker 11>Two-thirds of this country are homeowners. Forty percent of people

0:27:59.310 --> 0:28:01.730
<v Speaker 11>in this country own their home outright. They were exposed

0:28:01.770 --> 0:28:05.030
<v Speaker 11>to zero, zero shelter inflation over the last six and

0:28:05.050 --> 0:28:07.449
<v Speaker 11>a half years. If you strip out shelter inflation and

0:28:07.490 --> 0:28:11.220
<v Speaker 11>adjust for the inflation consumers actually experience, I would suggest

0:28:11.260 --> 0:28:15.320
<v Speaker 11>that consumers experience six points less. less inflation than what

0:28:15.380 --> 0:28:17.740
<v Speaker 11>headlines suggest. And over the course of a couple of years,

0:28:17.960 --> 0:28:20.369
<v Speaker 11>you annualize that. The numbers are much smaller.

0:28:20.430 --> 0:28:23.449
<v Speaker 8>There's talk about we need a better new inflation.

0:28:23.470 --> 0:28:25.210
<v Speaker 4>I don't have the research in front of me, folks.

0:28:25.270 --> 0:28:28.750
<v Speaker 4>I'm sorry I can't cite it. But basically, PCE misses

0:28:28.790 --> 0:28:32.470
<v Speaker 4>the grocery store is a stereotype of what I'm talking about.

0:28:32.490 --> 0:28:36.449
<v Speaker 4>Does the Fed or does Wellington management need a better

0:28:36.619 --> 0:28:38.140
<v Speaker 4>analysis of inflation?

0:28:38.430 --> 0:28:42.340
<v Speaker 11>Well, that's what we're doing, right? For the last several years,

0:28:42.360 --> 0:28:44.820
<v Speaker 11>I've been pounding the table saying, look, the data that

0:28:44.860 --> 0:28:50.160
<v Speaker 11>we've all been trained to observe, the metrics that we're

0:28:50.220 --> 0:28:54.900
<v Speaker 11>taught to predict the economy are becoming less relevant. And

0:28:54.920 --> 0:28:57.610
<v Speaker 11>you see this in affordability, too. We talk a lot

0:28:57.630 --> 0:29:00.650
<v Speaker 11>about affordability. It was all over surveillance this morning.

0:29:01.210 --> 0:29:03.050
<v Speaker 6>Mortgages are up. The mortgage rates are up to 7.5%.

0:29:03.050 --> 0:29:05.970
<v Speaker 1>You listen to us? I have to prep.

0:29:06.130 --> 0:29:09.209
<v Speaker 8>Sorry, we're up to 42 listeners. Yes, continue.

0:29:09.630 --> 0:29:10.680
<v Speaker 1>Yeah.

0:29:10.740 --> 0:29:13.060
<v Speaker 11>You know, mortgage rates are high, of course, but we're

0:29:13.120 --> 0:29:18.940
<v Speaker 11>forgetting that so many people are locked into extraordinarily low rates.

0:29:19.220 --> 0:29:20.719
<v Speaker 8>Yes, we call that Paul Sweeney.

0:29:20.940 --> 0:29:21.220
<v Speaker 1>Yes.

0:29:22.330 --> 0:29:23.450
<v Speaker 7>And John Tucker, apparently.

0:29:23.470 --> 0:29:24.170
<v Speaker 8>Pick it up here, Alex.

0:29:24.190 --> 0:29:25.110
<v Speaker 9>Hello, three and a quarter.

0:29:25.130 --> 0:29:25.300
<v Speaker 6>But....

0:29:27.750 --> 0:29:30.340
<v Speaker 7>In the same breath, you've got people using buy now,

0:29:30.380 --> 0:29:32.840
<v Speaker 7>pay later more. You've got, you know, so many people

0:29:33.160 --> 0:29:38.580
<v Speaker 7>squeezed borrowing against their credit cards. Is credit stress starting

0:29:38.600 --> 0:29:41.660
<v Speaker 7>to seep up that ladder to the consumer now and

0:29:42.100 --> 0:29:43.440
<v Speaker 7>in a worrying way?

0:29:44.400 --> 0:29:46.459
<v Speaker 11>So catch the chase, not in a worrying way, but

0:29:46.480 --> 0:29:50.720
<v Speaker 11>we are absolutely seeing credit stress migration up the quality spectrum.

0:29:50.740 --> 0:29:51.420
<v Speaker 6>So where it was.

0:29:51.460 --> 0:29:55.360
<v Speaker 11>Isolated more to your subprime and near prime borrowers, we

0:29:55.520 --> 0:29:58.530
<v Speaker 11>are seeing it migrate up into the prime spectrum. However,

0:29:58.980 --> 0:30:02.510
<v Speaker 11>Credit extension, so the amount of credit that consumers have

0:30:02.590 --> 0:30:06.030
<v Speaker 11>on balance sheet is at historic low levels.

0:30:06.050 --> 0:30:08.090
<v Speaker 8>Nobody believes what you just said.

0:30:08.210 --> 0:30:10.410
<v Speaker 11>I know, I know, but you've got to look at

0:30:10.450 --> 0:30:10.870
<v Speaker 11>the data.

0:30:10.910 --> 0:30:13.320
<v Speaker 8>The only one that believes that is Michelle Meyer over

0:30:13.340 --> 0:30:17.970
<v Speaker 8>at MasterCard. Really? Are credits at historic lows?

0:30:18.410 --> 0:30:21.990
<v Speaker 11>The amount of credit that consumers have on their balance

0:30:22.010 --> 0:30:25.900
<v Speaker 11>sheet is at historic low. The amount of dollars they

0:30:25.960 --> 0:30:29.320
<v Speaker 11>have in their money market accounts is at historic highs.

0:30:29.580 --> 0:30:31.959
<v Speaker 11>The amount of equity that they have in their home

0:30:32.020 --> 0:30:33.870
<v Speaker 11>values is at historic highs.

0:30:33.880 --> 0:30:35.570
<v Speaker 7>We're at delinquency rates, though, I wonder.

0:30:35.930 --> 0:30:40.690
<v Speaker 11>Delinquency rates are climbing, and we are seeing a swelling

0:30:40.850 --> 0:30:43.290
<v Speaker 11>in what we call roll rates, so the amount of

0:30:43.690 --> 0:30:48.350
<v Speaker 11>transition from 30- to 60-day delinquent to 60- to 90-day delinquent.

0:30:48.450 --> 0:30:50.930
<v Speaker 11>I like to call that the pressure cooker that is

0:30:50.990 --> 0:30:53.950
<v Speaker 11>going to stay contained as long as the labor market

0:30:53.990 --> 0:30:57.430
<v Speaker 11>continues to do what it's doing. If jobs go, all

0:30:57.470 --> 0:30:58.040
<v Speaker 11>bets are off.

0:30:58.490 --> 0:31:02.360
<v Speaker 4>Kyra Ficteau with us with Wellington. The only reason she's

0:31:02.400 --> 0:31:05.160
<v Speaker 4>here is you should see the Wellington box at TD

0:31:05.200 --> 0:31:07.130
<v Speaker 4>Gardens for the Bruins game.

0:31:07.730 --> 0:31:10.010
<v Speaker 8>Unbelievable, the angles.

0:31:11.000 --> 0:31:12.080
<v Speaker 7>I haven't gotten an invite.

0:31:12.120 --> 0:31:16.740
<v Speaker 11>It's even better when it's.

0:31:14.960 --> 0:31:17.570
<v Speaker 8>Canadians and Bruins. It's even better.

0:31:17.610 --> 0:31:21.410
<v Speaker 4>Kyra, you come down below your experienced inflation, and I

0:31:21.590 --> 0:31:24.950
<v Speaker 4>love what you're doing here on experienced wage growth.

0:31:25.510 --> 0:31:29.000
<v Speaker 8>It's at least two, if not three, Americas, isn't it?

0:31:29.340 --> 0:31:29.940
<v Speaker 7>It really is.

0:31:30.000 --> 0:31:33.380
<v Speaker 11>And so, again, when you pull apart the numbers and

0:31:33.420 --> 0:31:38.880
<v Speaker 11>adjust inflation for what consumers actually experience, how much energy

0:31:38.900 --> 0:31:41.180
<v Speaker 11>they experience, how much shelter they experience, and that varies

0:31:41.220 --> 0:31:44.800
<v Speaker 11>based on their income cohort and their consumption patterns, what

0:31:44.860 --> 0:31:48.960
<v Speaker 11>we observe is that when you apply that to wage growth,

0:31:48.980 --> 0:31:51.440
<v Speaker 11>what we observe is that real wage growth for the

0:31:51.480 --> 0:31:57.120
<v Speaker 11>top 60% of income earners is still positive and healthy

0:31:57.210 --> 0:32:02.340
<v Speaker 11>at 1%, where lower-income cohorts, your bottom 20% and even

0:32:02.480 --> 0:32:05.220
<v Speaker 11>now migrating up to the bottom 20% to 40% is

0:32:05.340 --> 0:32:09.820
<v Speaker 11>actually in negative or approaching negative territory. So those consumers

0:32:10.020 --> 0:32:12.930
<v Speaker 11>are in a bad way, and they need some help

0:32:13.010 --> 0:32:17.110
<v Speaker 11>in terms of higher wages and or slowing inflation from

0:32:17.130 --> 0:32:19.170
<v Speaker 11>the things that matter most to them, like energy.

0:32:19.930 --> 0:32:22.050
<v Speaker 7>We started our show today with David Rosenberg in the

0:32:22.090 --> 0:32:25.100
<v Speaker 7>seven o'clock hour, and he was talking about how inflation

0:32:25.580 --> 0:32:28.180
<v Speaker 7>is a little overblown. I don't know if you agree

0:32:28.220 --> 0:32:30.300
<v Speaker 7>with that, but are we, if that is the case,

0:32:30.400 --> 0:32:32.480
<v Speaker 7>are we, or maybe it's not the case, but are

0:32:32.520 --> 0:32:35.600
<v Speaker 7>we underestimating weakness in the job market?

0:32:35.980 --> 0:32:38.500
<v Speaker 11>So that's exactly what I'm saying here is that we,

0:32:38.640 --> 0:32:43.130
<v Speaker 11>I think we're, consumers have actually been less burdened by

0:32:43.250 --> 0:32:47.690
<v Speaker 11>inflation as headline numbers would suggest. However, they're, And there

0:32:47.730 --> 0:32:50.230
<v Speaker 11>are things that are coming up that would suggest that

0:32:50.250 --> 0:32:55.530
<v Speaker 11>this could be persistent and then continue to erode consumer health, particularly.

0:32:54.950 --> 0:32:55.750
<v Speaker 6>For the lower end.

0:32:56.150 --> 0:32:58.170
<v Speaker 11>You know, I don't I'm not a meteorologist, but you

0:32:58.210 --> 0:33:00.160
<v Speaker 11>did have one just on the show now. And I mean,

0:33:00.200 --> 0:33:02.719
<v Speaker 11>El Nino is a real thing and it's and it's

0:33:02.740 --> 0:33:06.460
<v Speaker 11>going to affect crops and food and food inflation is

0:33:06.480 --> 0:33:08.380
<v Speaker 11>going to go higher. And that's something that is also

0:33:08.420 --> 0:33:11.560
<v Speaker 11>going to hurt those income cohorts that that are already

0:33:11.600 --> 0:33:12.400
<v Speaker 11>that are already struggling.

0:33:12.720 --> 0:33:13.080
<v Speaker 8>Thank you.

0:33:13.120 --> 0:33:16.570
<v Speaker 4>Cara Factor with us, the Wellington management, Boston. fixed income

0:33:16.590 --> 0:33:20.190
<v Speaker 4>portfolio manager, but just a brilliant note. And the number

0:33:20.290 --> 0:33:22.540
<v Speaker 4>one thing I get in my mail is on the

0:33:22.660 --> 0:33:24.100
<v Speaker 4>two Americas out there.

0:33:24.500 --> 0:33:29.420
<v Speaker 3>This is the Bloomberg Surveillance Podcast, available on Apple, Spotify,

0:33:29.550 --> 0:33:33.790
<v Speaker 3>and anywhere else you get your podcasts. Listen live each weekday,

0:33:33.790 --> 0:33:39.230
<v Speaker 3>7 to 10 a.m. Eastern on Bloomberg.com, the iHeartRadio app, TuneIn,

0:33:39.550 --> 0:33:42.620
<v Speaker 3>and the Bloomberg Business app. You can also watch us

0:33:42.720 --> 0:33:46.720
<v Speaker 3>live every weekday on YouTube and always on the Bloomberg Terminal.