1
00:00:15,436 --> 00:00:20,316
Speaker 1: Pushkin ladies and gentlemen.

2
00:00:20,916 --> 00:00:25,436
Speaker 2: Give it up for the greatest capitalists in the history

3
00:00:25,876 --> 00:00:27,836
Speaker 2: of the United States of America.

4
00:00:28,596 --> 00:00:29,836
Speaker 3: Elon Musk.

5
00:00:30,996 --> 00:00:34,596
Speaker 1: In October twenty twenty four, nine days before the US

6
00:00:34,716 --> 00:00:39,196
Speaker 1: presidential election, Elon Musk, the world's richest man, took to

7
00:00:39,276 --> 00:00:42,276
Speaker 1: the stage at a rally for Donald Trump in New

8
00:00:42,396 --> 00:00:47,676
Speaker 1: York City. He wore black jeans, a black T shirt,

9
00:00:48,036 --> 00:00:51,716
Speaker 1: black blazer, and a black baseball hat. Had red in

10
00:00:51,876 --> 00:00:54,956
Speaker 1: dark gray embroidery Make America great Again.

11
00:00:55,436 --> 00:01:02,436
Speaker 4: I'm not just maga, I'm doc Gothic maga.

12
00:01:03,236 --> 00:01:07,956
Speaker 1: Elon Musk, an American oligarch and entrepreneurial genius, had stood

13
00:01:08,036 --> 00:01:11,596
Speaker 1: on many stages before he sees the podium at Madison

14
00:01:11,676 --> 00:01:17,916
Speaker 1: Square Garden. Ted talks, Tesla product rollouts, SpaceX launch pads.

15
00:01:18,436 --> 00:01:21,396
Speaker 1: He also owns a stage a platform ever since he

16
00:01:21,436 --> 00:01:24,676
Speaker 1: bought Twitter and renamed it x, and he owns a

17
00:01:24,716 --> 00:01:28,916
Speaker 1: sizable portion of the global communications infrastructure through his satellite

18
00:01:28,996 --> 00:01:33,756
Speaker 1: company Starlink. But this Madison Square Garden gig was part

19
00:01:33,796 --> 00:01:38,196
Speaker 1: of a different endeavor. Entirely, Musk spent a staggering amount

20
00:01:38,236 --> 00:01:42,316
Speaker 1: of money to help get Trump and Republicans elected. The

21
00:01:42,356 --> 00:01:45,396
Speaker 1: world's richest man, spent more than a quarter of a

22
00:01:45,516 --> 00:01:49,116
Speaker 1: billion dollars on the return to power of the world's

23
00:01:49,396 --> 00:01:55,756
Speaker 1: most powerful man, like some kind of superman or supervillain.

24
00:01:59,996 --> 00:02:02,956
Speaker 1: Returning to the White House, Trump promised to bring Musk

25
00:02:02,996 --> 00:02:07,116
Speaker 1: with him. You guys are awesome, And once Musk got

26
00:02:07,116 --> 00:02:09,316
Speaker 1: a taste for this kind of thing, he began to

27
00:02:09,396 --> 00:02:13,196
Speaker 1: involve himself in politics of other nations, in Germany, in

28
00:02:13,276 --> 00:02:16,636
Speaker 1: the UK. What does Musk's reinvention of himself as a

29
00:02:16,756 --> 00:02:20,556
Speaker 1: king maker mean for the United States and for the world.

30
00:02:21,076 --> 00:02:23,676
Speaker 1: How long will it last? No one knows what's going

31
00:02:23,756 --> 00:02:29,676
Speaker 1: to happen next, But what happened before in twenty twenty one,

32
00:02:29,956 --> 00:02:33,436
Speaker 1: before Musk joined forces with Trump, before Musk bought Twitter,

33
00:02:34,036 --> 00:02:37,276
Speaker 1: before Musk was in the news every day, He was

34
00:02:37,276 --> 00:02:40,796
Speaker 1: in the news every other day, with headlines that sounded

35
00:02:41,076 --> 00:02:45,556
Speaker 1: ripped from science fiction super fast underground trains, rockets to

36
00:02:45,636 --> 00:02:50,116
Speaker 1: Mars brain control implants. I made a BBC series in

37
00:02:50,156 --> 00:02:52,516
Speaker 1: which I tried to explain Musk by way of the

38
00:02:52,556 --> 00:02:56,316
Speaker 1: science fiction he grew up with, tales of superheroes with

39
00:02:56,396 --> 00:03:00,476
Speaker 1: origin stories that seemed to influence how he understands his

40
00:03:00,556 --> 00:03:04,236
Speaker 1: own life. But so much has happened since then that

41
00:03:04,316 --> 00:03:07,276
Speaker 1: we decided to update that series from four years ago,

42
00:03:07,756 --> 00:03:12,396
Speaker 1: rename it, and add new episodes because Musk keeps changing,

43
00:03:13,356 --> 00:03:25,236
Speaker 1: and so does his origin story. Welcome to X Man,

44
00:03:25,556 --> 00:03:29,676
Speaker 1: The Elon Musk Origin Story. I'm Jill Lapour. I'm a

45
00:03:29,676 --> 00:03:33,276
Speaker 1: professor of history and law at Harvard. I'm interested in

46
00:03:33,316 --> 00:03:36,796
Speaker 1: the past Musk. He's interested in the future.

47
00:03:37,196 --> 00:03:42,436
Speaker 5: The future is gonna be amazing or is he?

48
00:03:42,916 --> 00:03:46,636
Speaker 1: Is Musk really a futurist or is he maybe an

49
00:03:46,716 --> 00:03:50,836
Speaker 1: antique a throwback. I don't mean the retro vibe of

50
00:03:50,916 --> 00:03:55,636
Speaker 1: the amazing extraordinary gadgets, the Tesla cyber trucks and Starlink

51
00:03:55,676 --> 00:04:00,516
Speaker 1: satellites and SpaceX rockets. I mean Musk's ideas about politics

52
00:04:00,556 --> 00:04:06,796
Speaker 1: and economics. I mean Muskism, extravagant extreme capitalism, a political

53
00:04:06,836 --> 00:04:10,196
Speaker 1: economy with origins in the universe of comic books and

54
00:04:10,276 --> 00:04:14,476
Speaker 1: science fiction that has fired Musk's imagination since he was

55
00:04:14,516 --> 00:04:22,596
Speaker 1: a boy. In this series, I'm going to blast off

56
00:04:23,076 --> 00:04:30,476
Speaker 1: not to the future, but to the past. Part of

57
00:04:30,636 --> 00:04:34,916
Speaker 1: Musk's stick is that he's still boyish bit of a lad.

58
00:04:35,396 --> 00:04:41,156
Speaker 1: Plays video games, has smoked pot, watches superhero movies, talks

59
00:04:41,156 --> 00:04:43,236
Speaker 1: about testosterone.

60
00:04:42,636 --> 00:04:43,156
Speaker 3: Word has it.

61
00:04:43,196 --> 00:04:46,836
Speaker 2: Billionaires Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg possibly have now formally

62
00:04:46,876 --> 00:04:48,996
Speaker 2: agreed to a cage match face off.

63
00:04:49,436 --> 00:04:53,596
Speaker 1: He once changed his name on X to Kechius Maximus,

64
00:04:54,076 --> 00:04:56,716
Speaker 1: which is a joke about on the one hand, the

65
00:04:56,796 --> 00:05:00,796
Speaker 1: movie Gladiator and on the other hand, a cartoon frog

66
00:05:01,116 --> 00:05:04,676
Speaker 1: named Pepe. Musk does this kind of thing so often

67
00:05:04,996 --> 00:05:08,796
Speaker 1: people barely even notice it anymore. The tech bro va

68
00:05:09,676 --> 00:05:13,716
Speaker 1: men will be boys, Boys will be gladiators. Trump has

69
00:05:13,716 --> 00:05:17,396
Speaker 1: gotten into this too, tweeting during the campaign a picture

70
00:05:17,436 --> 00:05:20,716
Speaker 1: of himself as Superman with J. D. Vance as his

71
00:05:20,796 --> 00:05:26,236
Speaker 1: Batman and Musk as Cyborg. Why in grown men is

72
00:05:26,316 --> 00:05:30,876
Speaker 1: this kind of thing? Okay, honestly, it's a little bewildering. Anyway,

73
00:05:31,316 --> 00:05:36,396
Speaker 1: the stories Musk likes and the characters he identifies with matter.

74
00:05:37,236 --> 00:05:39,956
Speaker 1: He used to talk a lot about The Hitchhiker's Guide

75
00:05:39,996 --> 00:05:42,836
Speaker 1: to the Galaxy. Then he used to think of himself

76
00:05:42,876 --> 00:05:47,276
Speaker 1: as Tony Stark, a do gooding superhero from the Marvel comics.

77
00:05:48,076 --> 00:05:52,036
Speaker 1: Musk has always loved the Dark Night movies, which are awesome.

78
00:05:52,956 --> 00:05:57,716
Speaker 1: About two years ago, he likened himself to Batman, a brooding, angry,

79
00:05:57,876 --> 00:06:02,916
Speaker 1: fabulously wealthy vigilante. After he bought Twitter, he posted a

80
00:06:03,036 --> 00:06:05,556
Speaker 1: drawing of the dark Night standing on top of a

81
00:06:05,556 --> 00:06:12,916
Speaker 1: Gothic church, watching over Gotham, Musk wrote some nights online,

82
00:06:12,996 --> 00:06:15,316
Speaker 1: a lot of people started arguing about whether or not

83
00:06:15,436 --> 00:06:18,756
Speaker 1: Musk is a real life Bruce Wayne, And then two

84
00:06:18,796 --> 00:06:21,676
Speaker 1: when the cyber truck came out, people said, it looked

85
00:06:21,916 --> 00:06:25,076
Speaker 1: like the batmobile. Is that Batman?

86
00:06:26,476 --> 00:06:28,076
Speaker 6: Unless you're trying to be Batman?

87
00:06:28,956 --> 00:06:33,156
Speaker 1: Why isn't that out of my crown? I happen to

88
00:06:33,196 --> 00:06:36,076
Speaker 1: be pretty interested in Batman. I once wrote a book

89
00:06:36,116 --> 00:06:40,476
Speaker 1: called The Secret History of Wonder Woman. So this episode

90
00:06:40,716 --> 00:06:43,196
Speaker 1: I want to look at the original Batman to see

91
00:06:43,196 --> 00:06:47,396
Speaker 1: what he tells us about Elon Musk. Batman made his

92
00:06:47,476 --> 00:06:51,276
Speaker 1: debut in the nineteen thirties, and fairly soon he was

93
00:06:51,316 --> 00:06:51,916
Speaker 1: on the radio.

94
00:06:52,396 --> 00:06:55,236
Speaker 7: The whole masked figure wearing a bright blue hood and

95
00:06:55,316 --> 00:06:56,796
Speaker 7: cape approaches Listen.

96
00:06:57,836 --> 00:07:00,276
Speaker 1: It turns out that a whole lot of Elon Musk's

97
00:07:00,356 --> 00:07:03,756
Speaker 1: vision for the future, his ideas about politics and governments

98
00:07:03,796 --> 00:07:07,876
Speaker 1: and economics, come from the nineteen thirties, nearly a century ago.

99
00:07:08,636 --> 00:07:11,236
Speaker 1: They're old ideas, and a lot of them I think

100
00:07:11,556 --> 00:07:15,116
Speaker 1: are failed ideas, but they're also bound up with Batman.

101
00:07:15,356 --> 00:07:19,596
Speaker 1: That Dark Knight, a guy dark Maga really likes to

102
00:07:19,636 --> 00:07:20,196
Speaker 1: talk about.

103
00:07:20,836 --> 00:07:23,676
Speaker 4: It's like Dark Knight, like the friggant joker is in charge.

104
00:07:24,036 --> 00:07:27,236
Speaker 4: The criminals run free and the citizens are arrested.

105
00:07:27,556 --> 00:07:31,476
Speaker 1: That's Musk on The Joe Rogan Experience, the most popular

106
00:07:31,516 --> 00:07:35,076
Speaker 1: podcast in the US. They're talking about life and Democrat

107
00:07:35,196 --> 00:07:38,636
Speaker 1: run New York City and complaining about how authorities in

108
00:07:38,676 --> 00:07:43,476
Speaker 1: New York had seized and killed some guy's pet squirrel.

109
00:07:43,996 --> 00:07:46,756
Speaker 4: Still pretty suke about the freaking squirrel thing. It's like, meanwhile,

110
00:07:46,996 --> 00:07:49,076
Speaker 4: you know, violent falons are running free?

111
00:07:49,676 --> 00:07:54,756
Speaker 1: Is a joker, It's the Joker, Batman's arch nemesis, a madman,

112
00:07:55,156 --> 00:08:00,196
Speaker 1: a sadist, an anarchist. It's Mayhem? And who can save

113
00:08:00,396 --> 00:08:08,076
Speaker 1: the people of Gotham? If Elon Musk were Batman, what

114
00:08:08,236 --> 00:08:11,596
Speaker 1: would he intend to answer that question? I want to

115
00:08:11,636 --> 00:08:14,516
Speaker 1: go back to that night at Madison Square Garden, smack

116
00:08:14,596 --> 00:08:17,756
Speaker 1: in the middle of Gotham, nine days before the election.

117
00:08:18,476 --> 00:08:21,636
Speaker 1: The arena was sold out. Twenty thousand seats were filled

118
00:08:21,876 --> 00:08:25,236
Speaker 1: with Trump supporters dressed in red, white and blue, caring

119
00:08:25,276 --> 00:08:29,356
Speaker 1: signs that read Fight, Fight, Fight, and Trump can Fix It.

120
00:08:30,036 --> 00:08:33,436
Speaker 1: They had a lot to celebrate Trump was making the

121
00:08:33,476 --> 00:08:38,276
Speaker 1: most impressive comeback in American political history. Critics had been

122
00:08:38,316 --> 00:08:43,596
Speaker 1: calling Trump a fascist Hulk Hogan, the flamboyant former wrestler,

123
00:08:44,156 --> 00:08:45,236
Speaker 1: had an answer to that.

124
00:08:45,876 --> 00:08:52,636
Speaker 8: This is Donald Trump's house, brother Ilesino staking Nazis in here.

125
00:08:53,356 --> 00:08:58,236
Speaker 1: Musk didn't speak for long. Mainly he rallied Trump's troops.

126
00:08:58,316 --> 00:09:03,236
Speaker 4: USA, USA, USA.

127
00:09:02,556 --> 00:09:05,756
Speaker 1: And then Donald Trump. In a preview of his inauguration

128
00:09:05,956 --> 00:09:10,276
Speaker 1: rally promised to usher in a new golden age.

129
00:09:10,956 --> 00:09:14,876
Speaker 8: I'm here today with a message of hope for all Americans.

130
00:09:15,556 --> 00:09:19,316
Speaker 1: Trump spoke for more than an hour. He mocked journalists,

131
00:09:19,756 --> 00:09:23,556
Speaker 1: talked about fake news, made a promise about immigration.

132
00:09:24,276 --> 00:09:27,916
Speaker 8: On day one, I will launch the largest deportation program

133
00:09:27,996 --> 00:09:29,156
Speaker 8: in American history.

134
00:09:29,276 --> 00:09:32,076
Speaker 3: But to get the criminals out, I.

135
00:09:32,076 --> 00:09:35,236
Speaker 8: Will rescue every city in town that has been invaded.

136
00:09:35,316 --> 00:09:38,276
Speaker 1: In concorde, he denounced in doctrination, we.

137
00:09:38,276 --> 00:09:42,996
Speaker 8: Will get critical race theory and transgender insanity the hell out.

138
00:09:42,796 --> 00:09:43,476
Speaker 9: Of our school.

139
00:09:44,316 --> 00:09:48,116
Speaker 1: And he pledged himself to a policy of isolationism.

140
00:09:48,356 --> 00:09:51,156
Speaker 8: It's called America First.

141
00:09:51,436 --> 00:09:55,836
Speaker 1: When Trump finished, a crooner in a black tux sang Sinatra,

142
00:09:56,516 --> 00:10:08,036
Speaker 1: but it was a big, bold, glamy, star studded night

143
00:10:08,156 --> 00:10:11,156
Speaker 1: in Gotham with a lot of talk about crime, and

144
00:10:11,196 --> 00:10:13,876
Speaker 1: Elon Musk dressed as if he were Batman on a

145
00:10:14,036 --> 00:10:18,436
Speaker 1: casual Friday. But it all reminded me of a very

146
00:10:18,476 --> 00:10:20,596
Speaker 1: different night at Madison Square Garden.

147
00:10:21,756 --> 00:10:27,876
Speaker 10: Ladies and gentlemen, fellow American American patriots. I'm sure I

148
00:10:28,036 --> 00:10:32,356
Speaker 10: do not come before you tonight as a complete strange shot.

149
00:10:33,636 --> 00:10:38,436
Speaker 10: You all have heard of me through a Jewish control press.

150
00:10:39,516 --> 00:10:43,956
Speaker 1: In nineteen thirty nine, the German American bund An organization

151
00:10:44,156 --> 00:10:48,036
Speaker 1: of American Nazis held a sold out rally in Madison

152
00:10:48,076 --> 00:10:53,356
Speaker 1: Square Garden. They wore swastikas as armbands, raised their arms

153
00:10:53,356 --> 00:10:56,476
Speaker 1: to Hyle Hitler, and in front of a giant portrait

154
00:10:56,556 --> 00:11:03,116
Speaker 1: of George Washington, celebrated him as America's first fascist. Here's

155
00:11:03,156 --> 00:11:07,596
Speaker 1: Fritz Kuhnn, the bund Feurer, warning about a Jewish conspiracy

156
00:11:07,916 --> 00:11:09,116
Speaker 1: against the United States.

157
00:11:09,316 --> 00:11:15,196
Speaker 2: Unless you Aliens nor the ten Christians wigap and speak

158
00:11:15,236 --> 00:11:18,356
Speaker 2: out to the men that our go women, how be

159
00:11:18,556 --> 00:11:21,316
Speaker 2: returned to the American people who founded it.

160
00:11:21,956 --> 00:11:25,236
Speaker 1: These American Nazis were searching for someone to blame.

161
00:11:25,596 --> 00:11:29,916
Speaker 5: The people far and wide feel that somebody must have

162
00:11:30,156 --> 00:11:31,116
Speaker 5: fallen down.

163
00:11:30,956 --> 00:11:31,516
Speaker 4: On the job.

164
00:11:32,036 --> 00:11:33,956
Speaker 1: They were denouncing the press.

165
00:11:34,276 --> 00:11:36,836
Speaker 5: The whole country now must see that there is no

166
00:11:37,036 --> 00:11:38,556
Speaker 5: free radio for white.

167
00:11:38,356 --> 00:11:41,876
Speaker 1: Men campaigning to cut government spending.

168
00:11:42,036 --> 00:11:46,716
Speaker 5: Who is not familiar with a billion dollar yardstick that

169
00:11:46,876 --> 00:11:51,716
Speaker 5: is required to measure this stupendous total of our national

170
00:11:51,836 --> 00:11:52,596
Speaker 5: public debt.

171
00:11:53,116 --> 00:11:54,876
Speaker 1: They're demonizing immigrants.

172
00:11:55,156 --> 00:11:58,236
Speaker 7: Great bloods of tears were a few hundred thousand job

173
00:11:58,356 --> 00:12:00,716
Speaker 7: taking so called poor Jewish refugees.

174
00:12:02,076 --> 00:12:06,956
Speaker 1: And here's Fritzkun again. They were fighting in doctrination weed

175
00:12:07,796 --> 00:12:08,836
Speaker 1: I see, will.

176
00:12:08,636 --> 00:12:13,876
Speaker 7: Not you when called upon the gate ed will law

177
00:12:13,996 --> 00:12:17,196
Speaker 7: all support in our power in the fire to break

178
00:12:17,316 --> 00:12:20,676
Speaker 7: the trip and the power size ten of Jewish communism

179
00:12:20,836 --> 00:12:24,956
Speaker 7: in our schools, our university is our very homes.

180
00:12:27,556 --> 00:12:30,916
Speaker 1: History often sounds like a broken record, but it would

181
00:12:30,916 --> 00:12:33,276
Speaker 1: be easy to make too much of the echoes between

182
00:12:33,316 --> 00:12:38,116
Speaker 1: these two Madison Square Garden rallies, separated by decades, the

183
00:12:38,156 --> 00:12:42,076
Speaker 1: whole calling people Nazis because you disagree with them. I'm

184
00:12:42,116 --> 00:12:44,796
Speaker 1: sick of it, You're sick of it. So let me

185
00:12:44,796 --> 00:12:47,636
Speaker 1: be clear. The nearly eighty million Americans who voted for

186
00:12:47,676 --> 00:12:51,276
Speaker 1: Trump in twenty twenty four were sick of Democrats, unhappy

187
00:12:51,276 --> 00:12:55,996
Speaker 1: about inflation, annoyed by progressive purity crusades and unimpressed by

188
00:12:56,036 --> 00:12:59,476
Speaker 1: Kamala Harris, I get at Hull Kogan. I don't see

189
00:12:59,516 --> 00:13:05,716
Speaker 1: no stinking Nazis here. Still. Look, I'm a historian, and

190
00:13:05,796 --> 00:13:10,156
Speaker 1: there is history here. Fascism has a history, and it

191
00:13:10,316 --> 00:13:15,436
Speaker 1: casts a very long shadow. And there's another, very particular

192
00:13:15,476 --> 00:13:18,916
Speaker 1: reason to spend a little time thinking about the year

193
00:13:19,436 --> 00:13:25,916
Speaker 1: nineteen thirty nine. Right after that Boone rally, maybe even

194
00:13:25,956 --> 00:13:29,196
Speaker 1: the very next day, in an office building just a

195
00:13:29,316 --> 00:13:33,236
Speaker 1: few blocks away, and out of the same political tensions,

196
00:13:33,316 --> 00:13:37,276
Speaker 1: the rise of fascism, the fear of fascism, some guys

197
00:13:37,556 --> 00:13:40,836
Speaker 1: at a little New York comic book publishing house decided

198
00:13:40,876 --> 00:13:44,076
Speaker 1: to create a new superhero Atman.

199
00:13:44,596 --> 00:13:45,396
Speaker 3: What are you doing here?

200
00:13:45,676 --> 00:13:53,116
Speaker 1: I enter the caped crusader. Superman had only just made

201
00:13:53,116 --> 00:13:56,436
Speaker 1: his debut, a wild success. Pretty soon he was on

202
00:13:56,476 --> 00:13:56,956
Speaker 1: the radio.

203
00:13:57,236 --> 00:13:59,276
Speaker 5: I still on a bullet.

204
00:14:00,436 --> 00:14:02,236
Speaker 1: It took the writers a few weeks to come up

205
00:14:02,276 --> 00:14:05,676
Speaker 1: with a new superhero, but he made his debut that

206
00:14:05,836 --> 00:14:10,356
Speaker 1: spring nineteen thirty nine, and now it is my brand.

207
00:14:10,396 --> 00:14:12,156
Speaker 3: Bruce Wayne of a wide.

208
00:14:11,956 --> 00:14:16,916
Speaker 1: Known as the Batman. Superman comes from another planet. Batman's

209
00:14:17,036 --> 00:14:19,636
Speaker 1: just a guy with a cape, but he does have

210
00:14:19,716 --> 00:14:23,036
Speaker 1: a lot of money. Bruce Wayne is a millionaire head

211
00:14:23,076 --> 00:14:27,316
Speaker 1: of Wayne Enterprises. He's also pretty nifty with a pistol,

212
00:14:27,796 --> 00:14:32,556
Speaker 1: which soon became a problem. At the time, the publishers

213
00:14:32,596 --> 00:14:35,036
Speaker 1: of comic books were taking a lot of heat for

214
00:14:35,116 --> 00:14:39,156
Speaker 1: glorifying violence. The month that Batman made his debut, the

215
00:14:39,276 --> 00:14:43,916
Speaker 1: US Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of two new firearms

216
00:14:43,996 --> 00:14:48,836
Speaker 1: laws that, among other things, outlawed machine guns. Then that

217
00:14:48,956 --> 00:14:51,556
Speaker 1: September Hitler advanced.

218
00:14:51,876 --> 00:14:53,676
Speaker 10: Germany has invaded Poland.

219
00:14:54,156 --> 00:14:57,236
Speaker 7: France has decreed general mobilization and martial law.

220
00:14:57,716 --> 00:15:01,836
Speaker 1: Europe was going to war and Americans were sick of guns.

221
00:15:02,556 --> 00:15:05,316
Speaker 1: The publisher of DC Comics told the guy who wrote

222
00:15:05,356 --> 00:15:09,996
Speaker 1: Batman to lay off the guns. Batman on mister Cannon,

223
00:15:10,956 --> 00:15:15,476
Speaker 1: and I'm afraid we'll never see him again. Well, only

224
00:15:15,516 --> 00:15:19,156
Speaker 1: the original Batman was gone, replaced with a new one.

225
00:15:19,316 --> 00:15:22,276
Speaker 1: This Batman hates guns, and you know what, he also

226
00:15:22,356 --> 00:15:27,876
Speaker 1: hates fascists. Right after Germany invaded Poland, Batman got an

227
00:15:27,916 --> 00:15:31,516
Speaker 1: origin story. As a kid, Bruce Wayne had watched his

228
00:15:31,636 --> 00:15:34,756
Speaker 1: parents get gunned down on the streets, and so now

229
00:15:34,796 --> 00:15:38,116
Speaker 1: here he was in nineteen thirty nine fighting an organization

230
00:15:38,196 --> 00:15:43,876
Speaker 1: of American fascists, a thinly disguised American bund known as

231
00:15:43,916 --> 00:15:45,036
Speaker 1: the Scarlet Horde.

232
00:15:45,276 --> 00:15:48,916
Speaker 3: I must stop the Scarlet Hoard before they become dictators

233
00:15:49,036 --> 00:15:49,716
Speaker 3: of the world.

234
00:15:50,196 --> 00:15:52,956
Speaker 1: At the time and over the next few years, critics

235
00:15:52,956 --> 00:15:55,876
Speaker 1: of the comics would argue that they glorified strong men.

236
00:15:56,756 --> 00:16:01,676
Speaker 1: Time Magazine published a story called are Comics Fascist? To

237
00:16:01,676 --> 00:16:05,116
Speaker 1: defeat the argument that comics were too violent? Batman gave

238
00:16:05,196 --> 00:16:08,836
Speaker 1: up his gun. To defeat the argument that comics were fascist.

239
00:16:09,476 --> 00:16:12,876
Speaker 1: Batman took on this new enemy, the Scarlet Horde.

240
00:16:13,396 --> 00:16:17,636
Speaker 6: American nazis Hi Karl Kruger will be dictatle of the world.

241
00:16:18,116 --> 00:16:21,836
Speaker 1: The Scarlet Hords leader is pretty recognizably Fritz Kuhn, the

242
00:16:21,916 --> 00:16:24,636
Speaker 1: leader of the Bund, America's top Nazi.

243
00:16:25,156 --> 00:16:29,876
Speaker 7: Tell me, is our army ready, two thousand strong, waiting

244
00:16:29,996 --> 00:16:31,036
Speaker 7: for your command.

245
00:16:31,836 --> 00:16:39,156
Speaker 1: Batman defeats him, and without a gun, saves Gotham from fascism.

246
00:16:39,476 --> 00:16:42,076
Speaker 1: During the twenty twenty four election, there was a lot

247
00:16:42,116 --> 00:16:44,756
Speaker 1: of talk about fascism in the United States.

248
00:16:44,916 --> 00:16:47,196
Speaker 9: Let me ask you tonight, do you think Donald Trump

249
00:16:47,396 --> 00:16:48,036
Speaker 9: is a fascist?

250
00:16:48,076 --> 00:16:48,236
Speaker 10: Yes?

251
00:16:48,276 --> 00:16:49,676
Speaker 1: I do, Yes, I do.

252
00:16:50,116 --> 00:16:54,956
Speaker 8: Joe is surrounded by fascists surround the ovalas I've said.

253
00:16:54,836 --> 00:16:57,996
Speaker 1: It before, but I'll say it again. Everyone's tired of

254
00:16:58,036 --> 00:17:01,996
Speaker 1: everyone calling everyone else a fascist. But with everything that's

255
00:17:02,036 --> 00:17:05,076
Speaker 1: going on the rise of far right parties across Europe,

256
00:17:05,356 --> 00:17:09,516
Speaker 1: including one in Germany endorsed by Elon Musk, I can't

257
00:17:09,516 --> 00:17:13,476
Speaker 1: not talk about fascism, and Batman's whole origin story is

258
00:17:13,556 --> 00:17:17,716
Speaker 1: bound up with fascism. Every time Musk is compared to Batman,

259
00:17:18,316 --> 00:17:23,316
Speaker 1: it raises an old question, is Batman fighting fascism? Where

260
00:17:23,396 --> 00:17:28,796
Speaker 1: is Batman somehow himself a fascist? That was actually a

261
00:17:28,876 --> 00:17:31,676
Speaker 1: question in the nineteen thirties, and over the last decades

262
00:17:31,716 --> 00:17:34,436
Speaker 1: it's been a question again ever since a trilogy of

263
00:17:34,556 --> 00:17:38,756
Speaker 1: Dark Night films came out, directed by Christopher Nolan, the

264
00:17:38,756 --> 00:17:41,156
Speaker 1: movies that shaped Musk's view of Batman.

265
00:17:41,556 --> 00:17:46,436
Speaker 6: I did think that there is a strong fascist current,

266
00:17:46,796 --> 00:17:50,516
Speaker 6: certainly in the look and mood and the sort of

267
00:17:50,596 --> 00:17:53,836
Speaker 6: just Wagnerian atmosphere of those movies.

268
00:17:54,356 --> 00:17:58,236
Speaker 1: That's Ao Scott, longtime critic from the New York Times,

269
00:17:58,596 --> 00:18:02,796
Speaker 1: talking about those Nolan films from Warner Brothers Pictures, the

270
00:18:03,036 --> 00:18:07,556
Speaker 1: very very dark Dark Night series. It starts with Batman

271
00:18:07,676 --> 00:18:09,796
Speaker 1: begins in two thousand and five.

272
00:18:10,676 --> 00:18:11,996
Speaker 8: What are you?

273
00:18:12,596 --> 00:18:13,356
Speaker 6: I'm Batman?

274
00:18:15,476 --> 00:18:18,876
Speaker 1: Nolan's films brought forward in time the fascist themes and

275
00:18:18,916 --> 00:18:21,956
Speaker 1: concerns of the original nineteen thirties Batman.

276
00:18:22,516 --> 00:18:28,836
Speaker 6: There is a very not entirely coherent, but strongly kind

277
00:18:28,876 --> 00:18:35,716
Speaker 6: of authoritarian political bent, and one that takes some interesting forms.

278
00:18:36,036 --> 00:18:38,356
Speaker 1: A lot of characters in these movies say a version

279
00:18:38,396 --> 00:18:43,116
Speaker 1: of democracy has failed. We need a strong man. Take

280
00:18:43,156 --> 00:18:45,876
Speaker 1: this scene from the two thousand and eight film The

281
00:18:45,996 --> 00:18:46,756
Speaker 1: Dark Night.

282
00:18:46,956 --> 00:18:49,476
Speaker 9: When their enemies were at the gates, the Romans would

283
00:18:49,476 --> 00:18:52,476
Speaker 9: suspend democracy in a point one man to protect the city,

284
00:18:52,716 --> 00:18:54,636
Speaker 9: and it wasn't considered an honor, it was considered a

285
00:18:54,636 --> 00:18:55,396
Speaker 9: public service.

286
00:18:55,636 --> 00:18:55,996
Speaker 6: Harvey.

287
00:18:56,116 --> 00:18:58,716
Speaker 1: The last man that they appointed to protect the republic

288
00:18:58,756 --> 00:19:01,356
Speaker 1: was named Caesar, and he never gave up his power.

289
00:19:01,596 --> 00:19:05,516
Speaker 9: Okay, fine, you either die a hero or you live

290
00:19:05,636 --> 00:19:07,236
Speaker 9: long enough to see yourself become the villain.

291
00:19:08,076 --> 00:19:10,316
Speaker 6: The people need a he. The people need here that

292
00:19:10,356 --> 00:19:12,756
Speaker 6: the people can't take care of themselves. That in a way,

293
00:19:12,756 --> 00:19:16,676
Speaker 6: the sort of the democratic institutions that might have met

294
00:19:16,716 --> 00:19:20,556
Speaker 6: the people's needs and kept them safe have failed, and

295
00:19:20,756 --> 00:19:24,076
Speaker 6: what they need is a strong figure from outside of

296
00:19:24,076 --> 00:19:27,196
Speaker 6: the political system. There's no sense of any kind of

297
00:19:27,236 --> 00:19:30,116
Speaker 6: democratic participation in the Batman world.

298
00:19:30,196 --> 00:19:32,396
Speaker 1: Oh my god, No, they're all dupes. Everybody's a dupe.

299
00:19:32,396 --> 00:19:36,396
Speaker 1: Every Gothamite is a dupe, right Aoscott has a theory that,

300
00:19:36,516 --> 00:19:40,916
Speaker 1: unlike the Dark Knight films, the Marvel Universe films, Iron Man,

301
00:19:41,156 --> 00:19:45,596
Speaker 1: Captain America, ant Man, the Avengers, a team of do gooders,

302
00:19:46,356 --> 00:19:49,956
Speaker 1: these films represent an Obama Biden view of the world.

303
00:19:50,036 --> 00:19:53,716
Speaker 6: He says, It's just like this kind of weird global

304
00:19:53,836 --> 00:19:57,916
Speaker 6: committee of superheroes who are going to go around solving problems,

305
00:19:58,396 --> 00:20:02,556
Speaker 6: who put their own kind of personal feelings and motives

306
00:20:02,596 --> 00:20:06,276
Speaker 6: and vendettas aside to kind of to work for the

307
00:20:06,316 --> 00:20:08,916
Speaker 6: common good in a way that like a committee of

308
00:20:08,956 --> 00:20:13,196
Speaker 6: the in Brussels might try to solve supply chain issues.

309
00:20:13,516 --> 00:20:17,236
Speaker 6: That's a bureaucratic, technocratic idea of heroism.

310
00:20:17,596 --> 00:20:20,756
Speaker 1: But the Dark Knight films, which come not from Marvel

311
00:20:20,956 --> 00:20:25,516
Speaker 1: but from DC, those movies are about the failure of

312
00:20:25,596 --> 00:20:30,156
Speaker 1: Obama Biden politics, the failure of the liberal democratic state,

313
00:20:30,556 --> 00:20:34,836
Speaker 1: the failure of liberalism itself. And this is true most

314
00:20:34,876 --> 00:20:36,596
Speaker 1: of all of Batman.

315
00:20:37,316 --> 00:20:43,836
Speaker 6: His own personal story, his own kind of grievance and grief,

316
00:20:44,236 --> 00:20:48,356
Speaker 6: gets mapped on to the political situation and becomes kind

317
00:20:48,396 --> 00:20:51,676
Speaker 6: of evidence of just the rottenness and untenability and corruption.

318
00:20:51,796 --> 00:20:57,316
Speaker 6: So he doesn't assume power, but he represents a non democratic,

319
00:20:57,396 --> 00:21:01,196
Speaker 6: non state, extra legal, extra judicial form of power.

320
00:21:01,556 --> 00:21:09,316
Speaker 1: Nolan's Gotham is how the right understands San Francisco, Go

321
00:21:09,436 --> 00:21:14,716
Speaker 1: or Portlands seeah, Right, it's always a nighttime in Gotham,

322
00:21:15,076 --> 00:21:21,956
Speaker 1: people marching to their doom, being beaten up on the streets, homeless, bedraggled.

323
00:21:23,116 --> 00:21:26,556
Speaker 1: Because in all of the DC movies, right, Gotham is America.

324
00:21:26,716 --> 00:21:29,516
Speaker 6: Right, there's predators and prey, and then there are some

325
00:21:29,556 --> 00:21:33,236
Speaker 6: people who might, for their own reasons or motives, you know,

326
00:21:33,516 --> 00:21:36,596
Speaker 6: protect some of the prey from the from the predators.

327
00:21:37,356 --> 00:21:41,636
Speaker 6: But there is strength and there is power, and to

328
00:21:41,716 --> 00:21:45,076
Speaker 6: be a hero, to be kind of righteous, is to

329
00:21:45,236 --> 00:21:47,316
Speaker 6: understand that and to be able to use it.

330
00:21:47,596 --> 00:21:50,596
Speaker 1: For Scott, this view is maybe Musk's view of Twitter,

331
00:21:51,076 --> 00:21:53,036
Speaker 1: of politics of everything.

332
00:21:53,596 --> 00:21:56,676
Speaker 6: So you know, you could see like getting rid of

333
00:21:57,316 --> 00:22:00,036
Speaker 6: content moderate sort of opening up Twitter to what he

334
00:22:00,156 --> 00:22:02,956
Speaker 6: likes to call free speech, is a way of saying, look,

335
00:22:03,156 --> 00:22:06,436
Speaker 6: you know, stop kidding yourself that people are going to

336
00:22:06,476 --> 00:22:09,596
Speaker 6: come here and be nice and behave themselves. Nobody does that.

337
00:22:09,836 --> 00:22:12,756
Speaker 6: Nobody believes that we'd be better off if we got

338
00:22:12,916 --> 00:22:14,756
Speaker 6: rid of the idea that people.

339
00:22:14,596 --> 00:22:18,156
Speaker 1: Would Batman might have given up guns.

340
00:22:18,196 --> 00:22:19,436
Speaker 10: No guns, no killing.

341
00:22:19,476 --> 00:22:24,396
Speaker 1: Where's the fun in that? But deranged Dark Knight fans

342
00:22:24,556 --> 00:22:28,676
Speaker 1: have used guns, and they have killed. In twenty twelve,

343
00:22:28,876 --> 00:22:31,996
Speaker 1: a twenty four year old PhD student named James Holmes

344
00:22:32,316 --> 00:22:34,516
Speaker 1: went to a showing of a Batman movie at a

345
00:22:34,556 --> 00:22:36,356
Speaker 1: theater in Colorado.

346
00:22:36,196 --> 00:22:38,996
Speaker 3: As though re enacting a scene from a Dark Knight comic.

347
00:22:39,276 --> 00:22:43,076
Speaker 3: Witnesses say Holmes fired into the air and then started

348
00:22:43,076 --> 00:22:44,236
Speaker 3: shooting into the crowd.

349
00:22:44,356 --> 00:22:48,716
Speaker 1: He killed twelve people. At his apartment, police found more

350
00:22:48,756 --> 00:22:51,276
Speaker 1: guns and Batman masks.

351
00:22:51,716 --> 00:22:56,956
Speaker 3: Holmes immediately surrendered. Police observed his hair was dyed orange.

352
00:22:57,156 --> 00:22:59,556
Speaker 3: He told them I am the joker.

353
00:23:00,196 --> 00:23:02,996
Speaker 1: The Dark Knight might not have guns. But in twenty

354
00:23:03,036 --> 00:23:08,236
Speaker 1: twenty four, campaigning for Donald Trump, Elon Musk Dark Maga

355
00:23:08,476 --> 00:23:11,436
Speaker 1: became an advocate for an armed citizenry.

356
00:23:11,676 --> 00:23:14,156
Speaker 4: The other side wants to take away your freedom of speech.

357
00:23:15,196 --> 00:23:17,236
Speaker 4: They want to take away your right to bear arms.

358
00:23:17,596 --> 00:23:21,636
Speaker 1: He'd begun defending the Second Amendment of the US Constitution.

359
00:23:21,916 --> 00:23:27,316
Speaker 4: Free speech is the bedrock of democracy. That's why it's

360
00:23:27,356 --> 00:23:32,916
Speaker 4: the first Amendment and the second Amendment is there to

361
00:23:33,036 --> 00:23:36,636
Speaker 4: ensure that we have the First Amendment Free speech.

362
00:23:37,076 --> 00:23:41,236
Speaker 1: Musk seem to be saying must be defended if necessary

363
00:23:41,516 --> 00:23:46,716
Speaker 1: by force. Some people think of Elon Musk as a superhero.

364
00:23:47,556 --> 00:23:50,636
Speaker 1: Some people think of him as a super villain trying

365
00:23:50,676 --> 00:23:53,756
Speaker 1: to take over the whole planet with a style that

366
00:23:53,916 --> 00:23:55,236
Speaker 1: comes from the movies.

367
00:23:55,716 --> 00:23:58,116
Speaker 6: You can have ambition without limits, and you can do

368
00:23:58,196 --> 00:24:01,316
Speaker 6: whatever you want. There's a kind of freedom and glee,

369
00:24:01,356 --> 00:24:04,156
Speaker 6: and like, I'll say anything to anyone, I'll do anything.

370
00:24:04,236 --> 00:24:06,636
Speaker 6: I'll say, you know, we're going to invade Greenland. I'm

371
00:24:06,676 --> 00:24:10,396
Speaker 6: gonna mess with everybody's elections. Just this is the behavior

372
00:24:10,436 --> 00:24:12,156
Speaker 6: that we've seen before in movies.

373
00:24:12,396 --> 00:24:16,156
Speaker 1: Aoscott has another theory, a theory about how, in both

374
00:24:16,156 --> 00:24:19,716
Speaker 1: the movies and in American politics, a lot of people

375
00:24:19,716 --> 00:24:23,956
Speaker 1: have started rooting for politicians of all political stripes who

376
00:24:23,956 --> 00:24:27,876
Speaker 1: seemed to style themselves as the bad guys. You wrote

377
00:24:27,916 --> 00:24:31,116
Speaker 1: this long piece called the Supervillain is the Hero Now

378
00:24:31,196 --> 00:24:34,436
Speaker 1: and it had a tagline how Americans learned to root

379
00:24:34,476 --> 00:24:37,196
Speaker 1: for the dark side from the Joker and Wicked to

380
00:24:37,276 --> 00:24:40,036
Speaker 1: Elon Musk. So how did they?

381
00:24:40,756 --> 00:24:42,716
Speaker 6: I mean, the way the piece came about was sort

382
00:24:42,716 --> 00:24:46,916
Speaker 6: of just noticing that something had shifted, and Musk was

383
00:24:46,956 --> 00:24:50,596
Speaker 6: an important case study that he and Trump, the way

384
00:24:50,636 --> 00:24:55,996
Speaker 6: that they were acting, the sort of transgressive, aggressive energy

385
00:24:56,076 --> 00:24:58,796
Speaker 6: that they were projecting and that their followers seemed to love,

386
00:24:59,436 --> 00:25:02,636
Speaker 6: seemed like a supervillain vibe. You could say, and I

387
00:25:02,676 --> 00:25:05,556
Speaker 6: didn't mean that people who don't like them think of

388
00:25:05,596 --> 00:25:08,076
Speaker 6: them as supervillains, you know, because they're so bad, but

389
00:25:08,196 --> 00:25:11,276
Speaker 6: rather that the people who do like them are kind

390
00:25:11,356 --> 00:25:15,556
Speaker 6: of intrigued and seduced and excited by the villainy.

391
00:25:15,596 --> 00:25:18,996
Speaker 1: This is the logic of the Dark Night movies. Batman

392
00:25:19,236 --> 00:25:21,996
Speaker 1: is the bad man, but you should root for him.

393
00:25:22,276 --> 00:25:27,796
Speaker 1: Don't trust the state, liberalism democracy. You need Batman, the

394
00:25:27,836 --> 00:25:32,236
Speaker 1: brooding vigilante and his batmobile, a character who's so unhinged

395
00:25:32,276 --> 00:25:36,316
Speaker 1: and tormented that he essentially collapses into his arch nemesis,

396
00:25:36,436 --> 00:25:40,596
Speaker 1: the Joker. Late last year, a delusional version of this

397
00:25:40,676 --> 00:25:44,556
Speaker 1: plot took form in the mind of a decorated American serviceman.

398
00:25:45,316 --> 00:25:48,716
Speaker 1: He rented a Tesla cyber truck and texted his girlfriend

399
00:25:49,036 --> 00:25:53,236
Speaker 1: that driving it made him feel like Batman. He parked

400
00:25:53,236 --> 00:25:55,836
Speaker 1: it in front of the Trump Hotel in Las Vegas

401
00:25:56,276 --> 00:25:59,436
Speaker 1: and shot himself in the head. Just before a bomb

402
00:25:59,436 --> 00:26:03,956
Speaker 1: that he'd planted blew up. He loved a note saying

403
00:26:04,036 --> 00:26:11,716
Speaker 1: only Trump and Musk can save America. After the election,

404
00:26:12,076 --> 00:26:15,996
Speaker 1: in his victory speech, Trump called his comeback the greatest

405
00:26:16,076 --> 00:26:20,756
Speaker 1: political movement of all time. He credited Musk.

406
00:26:21,356 --> 00:26:22,916
Speaker 3: Let me tell you, we have a new star.

407
00:26:23,756 --> 00:26:25,756
Speaker 1: Trump had a lot of people to think, but the

408
00:26:25,756 --> 00:26:29,716
Speaker 1: person he talked about the longest was his own personal Batman.

409
00:26:29,996 --> 00:26:31,476
Speaker 3: The star is born Elan.

410
00:26:32,316 --> 00:26:35,076
Speaker 1: Trump told the story of watching a SpaceX rocket land

411
00:26:35,476 --> 00:26:39,636
Speaker 1: an amazing feat of engineering. Said he'd called Musk afterward.

412
00:26:40,076 --> 00:26:41,876
Speaker 3: I said, that's why I love you, Elon.

413
00:26:42,036 --> 00:26:44,956
Speaker 1: That's grab He talked about calling On Musk the way

414
00:26:45,036 --> 00:26:48,036
Speaker 1: Gotham's police commissioner uses the bat signal.

415
00:26:48,276 --> 00:26:53,676
Speaker 8: I said, Elon, you have something called starlink? Is that right?

416
00:26:54,396 --> 00:26:57,036
Speaker 3: He had that there so fast, it was incredible.

417
00:26:57,316 --> 00:27:00,396
Speaker 8: What is the characters especial guy as a super genius,

418
00:27:00,396 --> 00:27:00,876
Speaker 8: we have to.

419
00:27:00,836 --> 00:27:05,516
Speaker 1: Bring Elon Musk, the Dark Knight, head of Wayne enterprises

420
00:27:05,996 --> 00:27:10,076
Speaker 1: a super intelligence and quite possibly the only person on

421
00:27:10,156 --> 00:27:14,076
Speaker 1: the planet more powerful than the President of the United States.

422
00:27:18,316 --> 00:27:21,996
Speaker 1: Batman is the creation of a world that witnessed the

423
00:27:22,076 --> 00:27:25,836
Speaker 1: rise of fascism. The way I read it and you

424
00:27:25,876 --> 00:27:30,916
Speaker 1: can read it differently. Whatever Batman intends, he can't ever

425
00:27:30,996 --> 00:27:36,196
Speaker 1: really save Gotham because as a vigilante, Batman is part

426
00:27:36,196 --> 00:27:42,876
Speaker 1: of what went wrong with Gotham. But Batman's only one

427
00:27:42,916 --> 00:27:47,356
Speaker 1: of Muskism's touchstones. What came before the Dark Knight and

428
00:27:47,396 --> 00:27:51,316
Speaker 1: the rise of Dark Maga. To answer that question, we've

429
00:27:51,316 --> 00:27:54,716
Speaker 1: got to go back to the beginning of Elon Musk's life, when,

430
00:27:55,116 --> 00:27:58,756
Speaker 1: as a boy in South Africa under apartheid, he read

431
00:27:58,916 --> 00:28:03,036
Speaker 1: The Hitchaker's Guide to the Galaxy had discovered an origin story.

432
00:28:03,716 --> 00:28:05,876
Speaker 1: That's the next time on x Man