00:00:01 Speaker 1: Congress is gonna hold a Senate antitrust hearing on Tuesday focused on the proposed acquisition of Warner Brothers Discovery by Netflix. Now, it's a blockbuster media deal, and that's why there's a lot of attention around it. And it's roughly seventy plus billion, all right. Lawmakers want to examine whether the deal could reduce competition in the entertainment and streaming markets and if there could be quote harm to consumers. Now you may be saying, wait, what, how is this all happening? 00:00:32 Speaker 2: What's this? Why is this happening? The world that we are living in now. 00:00:37 Speaker 1: Has changed drastically because of streaming and how we consume things. So you're gonna have the Netflix at co CEO. He's scheduled to testify before the Senate Judiciary Committee an anti trust subcommittee, and answer lawmakers questions about the merger. 00:00:51 Speaker 2: Then you're gonna have Warner brother. 00:00:53 Speaker 1: Executives who are also expected to participate and explain their perspective on the deal. And what lawmakers are focused on is antitrust and competition. So to break some of this down, I decided I'd call a man that deals with us every day, Rich Greenfeld is a partner and TMT analysts at light Shed Partners the GP, light Shed Ventures, Media Futurists and cohs so the light Shed podcast and grab it wherever you get your podcasts, and I decided we'd have him on to talk about what this means for the average American. So let's just start with the overall bigger picture here, Rich and I appreciate you coming on. The way that we consume things has changed drastically. YouTube is a great example of that. It is an entertainment marketplace. It's evolving right now into literally TV and streaming. You've got social media platforms that are also vying for all of our attention with reels and stories and shows that are up there as well. So you look at the current landscape, why is this relevant in context of the acquisition with Warner brought there's discovery by Netflix and what question should consumers be asking? 00:02:05 Speaker 3: No, look that big from first of all, to keep having me. It's a fascinating time in the media landscape. I'm sure all of your listeners around the country are realizing. 00:02:17 Speaker 4: The way we consume. 00:02:18 Speaker 3: Entertainment has changed pretty dramatically. I mean the fact that the single largest platform. You know, when you look at what people are watching on a TV screen, so like this is actually on the big screen TV in your living room. The number one place or piece of content that people are turning to on that big screen television in twenty twenty sixes YouTube. 00:02:41 Speaker 4: That's pretty crazy, Ben, because I think if we were to. 00:02:43 Speaker 3: Go back twenty years ago, obviously that was zero, you know, ten years ago, that was tiny. And the fact that it is literally exploded really over the last five or six years to become the dominant place. You know, there's more times watching new to the TV than editing together. AVC, ESPN, Disney plus Hulu is the entire Disney Armada. 00:03:08 Speaker 4: YouTube is bigger. 00:03:09 Speaker 3: And so that's a tremendous change in how can I have three kids myself. I look at their media behavior. I look at what they turn on when they get home from school. Like the way that we are consuming content has traumatically changed. And that's part of the challenge. You know, I think what Congress on Tuesday and what regulars were looking at this transaction to the Department of Justice and even the court system if it ends up there. The challenge that they all have to think about is what is. 00:03:41 Speaker 4: The relevant market? 00:03:43 Speaker 3: Is the market streaming meaning preemium streaming, So a Netflix or a Hulu is the market all of TV, which includes broadcast TV, where the Grammys are tonight, where the Oscars are going to be on YouTube eventually. So do you include YouTube? You know, you can watch the NFL now on YouTube. There was a game out of Brazil someday. Ticket is on YouTube? So do you include streaming free television? Do you include broadcast TV? Do you include ESPN and all of able TV? Do you include things like TikTok which are not really things you watch on the TV, but are where you consume entertainment. So the challenge for everyone is what is the actual market that we're analyzing. 00:04:24 Speaker 4: Who competes with who? 00:04:26 Speaker 3: Obviously there's going to be some people in Congress and regulators who want to define this really narrowly, like this is just Netflix versus Hulu or Netflix versus Amazon Prime Video. That seems like a very primitive way or a very overly simplified way of looking at it, and certainly not the way your listeners think about their choices when they get home from a hard day at work. I think they're literally thinking about YouTube in the same breath that they're thinking about turning on Netflix or CBS. They're all competing for time. 00:05:00 Speaker 1: Yeah, they're all commuting for time and eyeballs. Which look, when I looked at this deal in general, my first question was, Okay, are Americans gonna get hurt? 00:05:09 Speaker 2: And I'm talking about jobs. 00:05:11 Speaker 1: Are they gonna be lost if one in a big way, if one side gets it or the other. I look at Netflix, I'm like, all right, well that's American. They're gonna do a lot in America. They also are in a studio, but this would make them into one, which would mean I would assume more job creation here. That was obviously a big perk for me. There's also questions that I've asked about, all right, well, where's the money coming from to buy this, because this is a big price tag. Talk to me and break that down a little bit. 00:05:37 Speaker 3: Well, okay, so John's interesting, right, because you know, if you look, first of all, we should step back and say, for your listeners, part of the reason we're having this conversation is not there's not just one person that wants to buy Warner Brothers in Netflix. There's another company, Paramount, that's very interested and has made a hostile bid. After their first or after the first several offers were rejected, they are still trying to buy company. But if we're simply going to look at job creation or even job status flow, you know, Netflix is not in the theatrical business. They are not in the syndication. They don't take TV shows and license them around the world. As you said, While they are building a studio, and they've been building a studio for many years, they don't have a studio the scale and the size of the studio, depth and catalog that Warner Brothers does. And so I think if you look at this, you can say that Netflix has probably put more money into the entertainment business on an manual basis securely into entertainment in any other company, not. 00:06:35 Speaker 4: Just in America but around the world. 00:06:36 Speaker 3: And so I think you can very much point to this and say Netflix, from a job standpoint, will be good for the entertainment industry. They are not looking to This is not about cost cutting. I don't think any part of the Netflix acquisition has been built around cost cutting. Now, Paramount is also trying to buy Warner Brothers. They have said they're going to keep both studios running fully independently. I'll tell you they're also talking about, you know, billions upon billions of dollars of cost savings. And I'll just be honest with you. I remember back when Disney bought Fox and the whole fact with you know, this was one during the first Trump administration, if you remember, a big part of that was we're going to keep Fox fully independent. Well, i'll tell you now what is. It's seven years later. Fox is a shell of itself, and yes it does release some movies, but you've seen dramatically, a dramatic strength and a tremendous amount of the overhead, meaning jobs of the two studios was eliminated. Like there's a tremendous amount of duplicative jobs between Paramount and Warner Brothers that certainly doesn't exist in Netflix. Now there's a Netflix skeptic out there that says, oh, Netflix won't release movies and movie theaters. 00:07:46 Speaker 4: They're just saying that to get approval. 00:07:49 Speaker 3: You know, obviously there's no way to know what Netflix ultimately does. But I will say they seem more committed to being in the theatrical business than I ever expected them to be. If you were to have asked me about this transaction on your show. Six months ago, I would have said there's no way they're going to do theatrical. They seem pretty committed to getting into this theastical business, which surprises me but is also to your point, good for jobs. 00:08:12 Speaker 1: For the next sixty seconds, can you hit pause on your life and just think about this. 00:08:17 Speaker 2: In communities around the world, millions. 00:08:20 Speaker 1: Of children like Lucy faced the crushing weight of poverty, hunger, illness, and a lack of opportunity dim their bright futures. But through Compassion International and local churches, everything is changing. Lucy receives nourishing food, vital medical care, and the chance to go to school. She learns life skills, develops God given talents, and builds a loving relationship with Jesus. It's a journey from vulnerability to empowerment, and it's sparked literally by your love. This transformation echoes far beyond Lucy, impacting her family, the community, and shaping the future of her nation. And you can make this profound difference right now. So join me in sponsoring a child. Visit Compassion dot com today, you'll empower life and change the world. That's Compassion dot com to learn more, there is a concern I'm one of them, about foreign influence, and I want American made movies and entertainment to be made here without outside influence. A great example of some of that outside influence we've witnessed was uh when Todd Gren Maverick was not even allowed to be shown over in China because of a patch that was on his bomber jacket that that was in favor of, you know, supporting Taiwan. Like, I see things like that, and I'm like, all right, I want to make sure those movies still get made without foreign influence. So break that down for me. Where's the money coming from the for for all this to get done? 00:09:54 Speaker 4: Well? 00:09:54 Speaker 3: I mean, look, you know, the reality is, you know, when you look at private equity broadly defined, more and more of it has certainly come from overseas. Certainly the Middle East has been the huge driver of major transactions in the US. I mean then, I don't know if you're folks how much you focus on it. But EA, which you know, makes big games, like you know, the the games that your listeners play, that is being acquired, you know, by sovereign wealth. You know, it's being acquired by Saudi Arabia's you know, public investment fun so if and so Middle East is not just targeting you know, Sollywood. They are really looking across the entertainment ecosystem and making big acquisitions. 00:10:41 Speaker 4: Now, you know, we'll. 00:10:42 Speaker 3: See, obviously, from a regulatory standpoint, whether all of these things are quote unquote allowed. 00:10:48 Speaker 4: You know, I think there are certainly going to be. 00:10:50 Speaker 3: Challenges and questions of whether this is good and what's the longer term impact. Obviously, we saw what happened to Pitcock and how much the government did not want something that, forget about even the spying, that there was a fear that China could influence the algorithm, China could manipulate, and whether it was true or not, there was enough fear regulatory wise to force a sale of the algorithm and. 00:11:14 Speaker 4: Of the US business to US investors. 00:11:17 Speaker 3: And so this is clearly, in the government's mind, a clear and present danger. We'll see whether what happens with TikTok, what happened with EA. And then obviously there's no issue with foreign money for the Netflix Warner Brothers transaction because Netflix is obviously a US company. They are funding this transaction entirely themselves. But the bidder against them paramount. While Larry Nelson is putting up some of the capital from his family's wealth, the majority of the actually of the equity of the transaction is being financed from three sovereign wealth funds in the Middle East. And while they are quote unquote giving up all governance in control, they certainly are investing the single largest dollar amount in this transaction. And so look at you know, whether there is a Siffiist regulatory concern TVD. 00:12:06 Speaker 4: They've obviously said there is not. 00:12:08 Speaker 3: I assume that will take time to actually ascertain if in fact they end up winning the bidding for this transaction. But look, I think you're actually raising a really important point of forget about whether we're talking about Hollywood and movie or TV broadenness to whether it's video games, things like TikTok social media feeds. Do we want any of these things that have such an impact on culture, especially on young people and the culture they grow up on. How much do they do we want outside foreign influence in the control of these things. And it's a great and important question that everyone should be asking. 00:12:43 Speaker 1: Yeah, it's it's an important one, and you talk about I mean, even with live golf and the PGA Tour. We've seen that battle play out with outside influence be like, wait, what do you why are there certain people trying to throw so much money getting into American households and American you know, different products or Europe. I mean, golf's a great example of that. There's been a lot of debate over that one, and it's certainly on this one as well. Let me let me go back to the jobs question and expand on that just a little bit. Paramount, by the way, they're relatively small for a media company, uh as was by the way, Skydance when it acquired it. So is there a concern should there be a concern about Paramount being able to operate a business that is of Warner Brothers Discovery size, especially when they're already so leveraged. 00:13:28 Speaker 3: Look, we have a we have We are very excited by David Ellison coming in. Paramount has been a company I don't know how long you follow sort of the Redstone family struggles and the challenges that this has been a trouble company for a long time and bringing in someone like David Ellison, who not just has a tremendous amount of family wealth, but also has a love of content, really wants to build and leverage technology. This has been great thing for Paramount, you know how a fresh start to life. And I think you know you mentioned the word leverage. The beauty of the Paramount's guidance transaction is that leverage was brought down. They actually gave it a point where they could be aggressive investors. I don't know if you watched the UFC either of the last two Saturday nights, but they went out and they spent a billion dollars plus on the UFC rights. Like, they are aggressively investing in their business. Really for the first time in probably a decade. Look, you are seeing Paramount actually in the you know, take control and actually be an aggressive investor. 00:14:32 Speaker 4: That is great. 00:14:33 Speaker 3: The challenge with Warner Brothers is that they're then trying to because they don't have enough cash because they are a smaller company. As you point out, they're levering up aggressively. And that's what worries me is I don't like in a business of TV with so much is changing. We talked about it at the top of the segment, how behavior, consumer behavior is shifting. Levering up is not you know, having a tremendous amount of debt is not really where you want to be as a media being twenty twenty six, and so I actually think Paramount would be better off not buying Warner Brothers and simply investing in itself, you know, if it doesn't have more capital from Larry directly. I actually think going to solo paths would actually be a better outcome for investors than over levering the company. But you know, we'll see, obviously, you know, it all comes down to money, and if they can raise enough money, I am sure there is some price where they could beat Netflix or Warner Brothers, but it's going to take a lot of firepower to convince the board to switch from Netflix over to Paramount. 00:15:36 Speaker 1: Final question for you, if you could be at this hearing on Tuesday, what's the number one question you'd want to ask? 00:15:42 Speaker 3: Well, I mean, I think it's funny. I think I would literally start off by just saying to each senator who's interviewing, I'd love for them to answer the question, what is the number one use in terms of content consumption of television? 00:16:02 Speaker 4: Like do they even realize? 00:16:03 Speaker 3: I'm actually curious how many senators in the hearing actually realize that there's more time spent watching YouTube than everything that the Walt Disney Company creates than everything that Netflix and Amazon create, Like. 00:16:17 Speaker 4: Are they aware of that? I think that would be a big one. 00:16:21 Speaker 3: And then the second piece bend that I think is important is I do think I would question them on are they aware of what happened with Disney Plus and Hulu? Because remember Disney brought Fox and by getting Fox, Disney got control of Hulu. And if you look at what's happened with Disney Plus and Hulu, So right now, if your listeners have either Disney Plus or Hulu individually, and they kick it with ad so they take the cheapest plan possible for Disney Plus, your listeners are paying eleven ninety nine. For Hulu, your listeners are paying eleven ninety nine, but the bundle of Disney Plus and Hulu is twelve ninety nine. So when you think about the consumer value of bundling and how much bundling channels creates really cost savings for consumers, the Hulu Disney Plus a study is a great example of how Netflix plus Hbo would be a great thing for consumers because you may end up with a lot more content for a very slight increase in price relative to what you're paying for each of these. 00:17:26 Speaker 2: Individually depends on the dollars. 00:17:28 Speaker 1: Basically what you're saying, it's like, it's almost like a buy one, get a huge. It's a bogo, right, you buy one, you get one at dirt cheap er. 00:17:35 Speaker 3: I mean, that's what it is with Disney and Hulu, Like you're basically getting If you buy Disney Plus, you get Hulu for a dollar. 00:17:40 Speaker 4: If you get Hulu, you get Disney Plus for a dollar. 00:17:42 Speaker 3: Like that is a pretty tremendous deal for consumers. I don't know that that's what Hbo and Netflix. It would be a good question to ask them to think about how they're thinking about pricing the combined services. But if you certainly look at Disney Plus and Hulu, the end result has been a tremendous win for consumer. 00:18:00 Speaker 4: There's no doubt about it. 00:18:01 Speaker 2: Rich. 00:18:01 Speaker 1: I appreciate your time, Rich Greenfield. Don't forget grab the podcast the Light Shed podcasts. Wherever you get your podcasts, they dive into a lot of this type of stuff. I hope this helped answer a lot of questions. You've heard me talking a lot about protecting American jobs and also talking about there was the big hearing in Washington, the dealt with Netflix and Warner Brothers and Discovery in all of this, and I want to continue that conversation now and really dive into what you can expect moving forward and what's going to be happening. Join me now talk about this is Cleete Williams. He's the chief Global Affairs officer with Netflix. Include I appreciate you coming on to talk even more about this. I want to get into the American job aspect of this first and foremost, because I don't think people realize, number one, how many jobs are being created in this country and directly with Netflix, but also indirectly with others that are making content that you guys are then buying and that supports the development of it as well. 00:19:03 Speaker 5: Yeah. No, thanks so much. Done for having me on, And obviously I'm I'm thrilled to talk about this because this is one of the reasons I was so excited to join Netflix in the first place, because Netflix is a company that is really committed to growing investment and growing jobs in the United States. And just to give you a little bit of detail on that, you know, Netflix is a company who has you know, we started mailing DVDs around, we got into streaming, and recently we've been getting into content. Right, it's really this classic American story, something that only could have happened in the United States. But as we've been getting into content, what we've done is we've tripled our workforce in the last couple of years and we are now filming in all fifty states in the United States. We've got a total of twelve hundred locations that we filmed in. And what this has done, it's supported one hundred and forty thousand production jobs in the country. It's supported two hundred and twenty five billion of economic output. And we're trying to do even more. You know, we're investing more into content as others in the industry are pulling back. And one of the really exciting stories is up in New Jersey where the Fort Monmouth base used to be. This base was closed down and now we're building a world class studio there. One point two billion dollars into that economy. And so look, it's a really exciting story for what's going on at Netflix. 00:20:23 Speaker 1: You know, for people that again and I go back to this is for me America first, American jobs. 00:20:28 Speaker 2: I also wrote an op at Fox News dot Com. 00:20:31 Speaker 1: You can grab it there talking about why I believe that Ron Reagan would be in favor of this merger between Netflix and Warner Brothers because of it doing so much to keep production and American interests first and foremost. He understood the value of exporting American ideals and American movies is an amazing way to have influence. 00:20:52 Speaker 2: All over the world. 00:20:54 Speaker 1: You look at the other side of this, so people understand just the context that there has been a re pedd hostile attempt to acquire from Paramount and skuideiance. What worries me about that side is a lot of outside of. 00:21:09 Speaker 2: The US money that can come in. 00:21:11 Speaker 1: I as a as a look, I want America to be shown in the best slide. I don't want there to be outside influenced. I worry about that. And you guys, to be very clear, your core is the United States of America. I want to make sure everybody understands that. 00:21:26 Speaker 5: Yeah know, look, that's absolutely right. And you know I just mentioned this studio in New Jersey. What we're hoping to do with this studio in New Jersey is do a bunch of filming in the United States that would have otherwise been done in other places like the United Kingdom. And so this really is about strengthening the American industry, making sure that America remains number one in the world for production. And look, you brought out the situation with Paramount, who is making the hostile bid, And I think one of the points that you raise in some of the things that you've written is is that there's really a clear contrast here, right. I mean, there's the job story and the fact that we've been creating jobs and they've been cutting them. Right, they had three and thirty five hundred jobs cut with their Skydance merger. Just yesterday they announced they were going to reduce their workforce at CBS by fifteen percent. They've they've identified six billion in synergies, which is code for job cuts. You know, that's actually probably going to be higher because this is the largest leverage buyout in history. But you know, speaking of the leverage buyout and speaking of the financing, here's where here's a big difference, and I think you know you will find very important, which is Netflix is an American deal with American dollars. Yeah, and the Paramount deal. Paramount has more equity from the Middle East than the United States. 00:22:43 Speaker 1: Hold on to say that again, because that's what that is my biggest warning. And when I was looking at this, I was I was one of those full disclosure. I've I've been critical of Netflix in the past on certain things I did, I did, I like or don't like you. 00:22:56 Speaker 2: It's a big company. 00:22:57 Speaker 1: That would be normal, but my big red flag here with hold on a second, we're talking about major influence that would come into a collection flash studio and production from the Middle East. I do not like that or feel comfortable with it at all. 00:23:14 Speaker 5: No, I mean I understand the concerns you're raising, right, I think you've written about that very eloquently, and just the difference here American deal with American dollars versus something that has the majority of its equity from the Middle East. And look, there are concerns about what that would do on influence and what it would do for American soft power. But I think you know, the interesting thing that a lot of people haven't focused on is that this also causes regulatory problems for Paramount that we don't have. Right And in the US, you've got the Trophy Department and their scithious review process, you know, which is going to have to look into whether this is you know, problematic foreign control. You've also got the European Union, you know, who may be concerned about you know, Middle East ownership of CNN and some of these other networks. And so, you know, I think that's a clear contrast between these two deals. 00:24:04 Speaker 1: Let's also talk about some of the misconceptions and we saw I think some of this come out and that antitrust hearing that was in Washington, d C. There are a lot of people that just assume that Netflix is a company that has a massive studio and you guys are creating a lot of this content in your own studios. That is not the case at all. That is exactly the reason why this paramount Warner Brothers Discovery deal is what you guys are wanting to do, because you do want to get into that as well. 00:24:34 Speaker 5: Yeah, that's absolutely right, and the contrast here is clear as well. You know, the Netflix deal is primarily a vertical merger, and what I mean by that is that, you know, we're proud of what we've done in the content production business in the last couple of years, but we've only been making our own stuff for around a decade. And you know, you contrast that with Warner Brothers, who has one hundred years of production in this business, who has all that iconic intellectual property, and so this is complementary. We're going to be able to bring that into the network Netflix platform. You know, you also have this legacy studio out in Hollywood that that Warner Brothers has. You know, we're building this new, world class studio in New Jersey, but we haven't had that kind of thing yet, so we're bringing that together. Then there's this theatrical distribution business, another area where we have not been active, and we're going to bring that together. And so that's a vertical merger with complementary assets where we're going to be able to get more content to consumers for less and we're going to keep all these major players and major buyers in the market. And then the Paramount deal is your classic horizontal merger with the Noah's Ark problem. You know, they're going to have two of everything, right, they already have one of those big legacy studios out in Hollywood, so they're going to have to cut one there. Already have a major theatrical distribution business, so that's going to get cut and consolidated. And then look, you can also look at the news and the sports and all these other things where they're going to double up as well. And so I think, you know, if you look at these vertical mergers which have traditionally been treated very favorably by competition authorities versus a horizontal merger which traditionally has not been Again, I think on the regulatory front, it's pretty clear, you know that the Netflix deal has a clearer path, and I do think that's a misconception that the other side has tried to perpetuate. 00:26:24 Speaker 2: Let me ask you one question. 00:26:25 Speaker 1: It's a concern that I and many others have had that are conservatives, and that is that Netflix has been seen through many conservatives as an advocate for more of the left and woke type programming. Without going into you know, exact details, in general, that has been a major concern and there has been a real concern that, look, if you guys get even more powerful, bigger than what you are now, that that is going to explode in some way. And then the choice of hey are our conservative stories, our traditional stories are historically traditional you know, context stories not going to be told because of quote propaganda. How would you answer and respond to that? Because that is a question. At Center, Holly talked about the hearing some of those clips people saw. 00:27:09 Speaker 2: I think it's a fair question ask. 00:27:11 Speaker 5: Well, Look, I appreciate you asking it, and I appreciate the opportunity to clear up what I think is a misconception here. Look, our mission at Netflix is to entertain the world and to run a profitable business. And in order to do that, you know, we need to provide something for everyone all across the spectrum, whether you're left, right, center, And look at the content we have. Right, We've got action movies, We've got rom coms, we got faith based shows, we've got documentaries about the military, westerns, you name it. And look, one of my favorite shows, not one that you would traditionally think of as conservative, but I think it really is, is Cobra Kai, Right, And the main character there, Johnny Lawrence, not only does he kick bud at Karate, but this is a blue collar guy who's set up that American has gotten too soft, too politically correct, and throughout the show he pushes back on that. And I think it's great Look, I'm a conservative. I worked in the Trump White House, and I'm look, Ben, I'm not going to deny that there are shows I don't like, right, but I can just turn those off, right, I can just put on something else, because we have a lot of content on our platform. And I will say, as a conservative, what I'm proud of at Netflix is that we stand up for the First Amendment and we stand up for free speech. And there have been times in the past where we have had folks on the left who have wanted to cancel us and to cancel our programming because it was offensive to them. There was a very famous example a couple of years ago with Dave Chappelle made some jokes that they didn't like, and we stood up for it and we said, no, we're not going to pull that down. We don't censor. And look, that's the same reason we're not in China. You know, we're not in China. We're not going to do that. 00:28:49 Speaker 1: Yeah, it's a great point and we're going to keep following this. Clett Williams, I appreciate you so much coming on chief Global Affairs Officer with Netflix, and I appreciate you answering that question what you did. I also so I think it's great to know that there are people like you that, by the way, came out of the Trump White House that are now high up at Netflix. I find that comforting to know I have an ally or a friend there that's looking out for my interests, in my family's interests as well. So I appreciate you coming on and talking about that. Don't forget. Share this podcast with your family and friends, share it on social media, please, and I'll see you back here tomorrow.