1
00:00:15,436 --> 00:00:23,436
Speaker 1: Pushkin Tesla ceo Elon Musk offering to buy Twitter for

2
00:00:23,436 --> 00:00:27,076
Speaker 1: forty three billion dollars. Muscu has accused the social media

3
00:00:27,156 --> 00:00:29,556
Speaker 1: platform of limiting free speech analysis.

4
00:00:29,796 --> 00:00:33,236
Speaker 2: In April of twenty twenty two, Elon Musk launched his

5
00:00:33,316 --> 00:00:36,836
Speaker 2: takeover of Twitter, offering forty four billion dollars for it.

6
00:00:37,156 --> 00:00:39,556
Speaker 3: Why make that offer? Well, I think it's very important

7
00:00:39,596 --> 00:00:44,796
Speaker 3: for be it be an inclusive arena for free speech.

8
00:00:45,796 --> 00:00:46,076
Speaker 4: Yeah.

9
00:00:46,156 --> 00:00:50,036
Speaker 2: So, he'd also started talking a lot about something he

10
00:00:50,116 --> 00:00:54,756
Speaker 2: called the woke mind virus. Must didn't coin the term,

11
00:00:54,996 --> 00:00:58,236
Speaker 2: but he popularized it. Musk is a man of many

12
00:00:58,236 --> 00:01:02,036
Speaker 2: interests and many masks. There's the batman mask and then

13
00:01:02,076 --> 00:01:05,156
Speaker 2: there's the would be philosopher hat. And making his bid

14
00:01:05,196 --> 00:01:08,876
Speaker 2: for Twitter, Musk wore both of these so online, he

15
00:01:09,956 --> 00:01:13,356
Speaker 2: complaining that the science fiction on Netflix, for instance, had

16
00:01:13,356 --> 00:01:18,076
Speaker 2: gotten too woke. But in conversations with serious people at

17
00:01:18,116 --> 00:01:21,636
Speaker 2: a Ted Talks event in twenty twenty two, he talk

18
00:01:21,676 --> 00:01:24,476
Speaker 2: about the stakes of buying Twitter in grander terms.

19
00:01:24,836 --> 00:01:28,596
Speaker 3: It's important to the function of democracy. It's important to

20
00:01:28,596 --> 00:01:31,796
Speaker 3: the function of the United States as a free country

21
00:01:31,916 --> 00:01:34,436
Speaker 3: on many other countries, and help freedom in the world.

22
00:01:34,756 --> 00:01:39,156
Speaker 3: Civilizational risk is decreased, the more we can increase the

23
00:01:39,196 --> 00:01:42,276
Speaker 3: trust of Twitter as a public platform.

24
00:01:42,556 --> 00:01:44,996
Speaker 2: People in the media talk about Twitter all the time,

25
00:01:45,596 --> 00:01:49,036
Speaker 2: but that's because they're on it. Most other people aren't.

26
00:01:49,436 --> 00:01:52,076
Speaker 2: In the US, only about one in five American adults

27
00:01:52,116 --> 00:01:56,196
Speaker 2: even have accounts, and most posting about politics is done

28
00:01:56,236 --> 00:02:00,476
Speaker 2: by fewer than ten percent of users. Twitter isn't, and

29
00:02:00,596 --> 00:02:05,596
Speaker 2: never was, a town square. Musk buying it just put

30
00:02:05,596 --> 00:02:09,636
Speaker 2: a private platform into different private hands. As his purchase

31
00:02:09,676 --> 00:02:12,276
Speaker 2: went through in October of twenty twenty two.

32
00:02:12,396 --> 00:02:14,836
Speaker 5: Twitter users are waking up to find that that little

33
00:02:14,916 --> 00:02:18,796
Speaker 5: blue bird has flown. The coup owner Elon Musk, changed

34
00:02:18,836 --> 00:02:22,196
Speaker 5: the iconic bird logo to the letter X.

35
00:02:23,716 --> 00:02:27,996
Speaker 2: The way Musk talked about X got increasingly grandiose. He claimed,

36
00:02:28,356 --> 00:02:31,196
Speaker 2: the woke mind virus is either defeated or nothing else

37
00:02:31,276 --> 00:02:35,356
Speaker 2: matters a mind virus, as best I can tell. The

38
00:02:35,436 --> 00:02:40,836
Speaker 2: idea came from Richard Dawkins, evolutionary biologist and prominent atheist,

39
00:02:41,316 --> 00:02:44,876
Speaker 2: who wrote a tirade in nineteen ninety one, seemingly because

40
00:02:44,916 --> 00:02:47,716
Speaker 2: he was furious that one of his ex wives was

41
00:02:47,756 --> 00:02:52,036
Speaker 2: sending their six year old daughter to Catholic school. Dawkins

42
00:02:52,076 --> 00:02:57,916
Speaker 2: considered religion a mind virus. Computers can get viruses, he explained,

43
00:02:58,196 --> 00:03:01,676
Speaker 2: and so can the human mind. At the very least,

44
00:03:01,956 --> 00:03:06,156
Speaker 2: Dawkins wrote, the mind is a plausible candidate for infection.

45
00:03:07,356 --> 00:03:09,996
Speaker 2: But what even is the virus that Musk so worried about?

46
00:03:10,516 --> 00:03:12,476
Speaker 3: Lork bind myrus is communism rebranded?

47
00:03:12,836 --> 00:03:16,556
Speaker 2: Sometimes, though, must give a different definition using the expression

48
00:03:16,836 --> 00:03:20,076
Speaker 2: woke mind virus for something that had been a truly

49
00:03:20,116 --> 00:03:23,956
Speaker 2: horrible feature of Twitter and of much public discourse for years,

50
00:03:24,796 --> 00:03:28,636
Speaker 2: the suppression, especially on the left of political dissent.

51
00:03:31,716 --> 00:03:34,876
Speaker 3: You can't question things. Even the questioning is bad.

52
00:03:35,556 --> 00:03:40,116
Speaker 2: Questioning is good. Here we agree. So I've got some questions.

53
00:03:43,636 --> 00:03:46,796
Speaker 2: Welcome to x Men, the Elon Musk origin story. I'm

54
00:03:46,876 --> 00:03:49,516
Speaker 2: Jill Lapour. I'm a professor at Harvard. I'm a US

55
00:03:49,636 --> 00:03:52,676
Speaker 2: political historian, and for a long time I've been studying

56
00:03:52,676 --> 00:03:57,836
Speaker 2: the relationship between technological and political change. In this series,

57
00:03:58,116 --> 00:04:00,676
Speaker 2: I've been looking into how Musk is in many ways

58
00:04:00,716 --> 00:04:05,796
Speaker 2: an invention of science fiction, and so is Muskism, which

59
00:04:05,996 --> 00:04:09,676
Speaker 2: I've been arguing is less a form of futurism than

60
00:04:09,716 --> 00:04:13,556
Speaker 2: a throwback. I think that's true of Musk's concern about

61
00:04:13,556 --> 00:04:19,956
Speaker 2: a woke mind virus, too. First of all, let me

62
00:04:20,036 --> 00:04:22,276
Speaker 2: just say for the record that Musk has a point

63
00:04:22,316 --> 00:04:26,316
Speaker 2: about the assault on free speech, including in higher education,

64
00:04:27,076 --> 00:04:28,916
Speaker 2: and he has a point that there are indeed some

65
00:04:29,076 --> 00:04:34,116
Speaker 2: malign consequences of wokeness. Fair enough. But what I'm interested

66
00:04:34,196 --> 00:04:37,516
Speaker 2: in is the very idea of a mind virus. Where

67
00:04:37,516 --> 00:04:39,956
Speaker 2: a Musk got that language, what he means by it,

68
00:04:40,476 --> 00:04:43,676
Speaker 2: and what effect it has. Because other people might muse

69
00:04:43,716 --> 00:04:46,676
Speaker 2: about this kind of thing, but Musk, he spent forty

70
00:04:46,716 --> 00:04:50,356
Speaker 2: four billion dollars to buy Twitter to kill the virus.

71
00:04:53,836 --> 00:04:56,796
Speaker 2: This story doesn't really start with Richard Dawkins in the

72
00:04:56,876 --> 00:05:00,556
Speaker 2: nineteen nineties. It starts in the nineteen fifties.

73
00:05:01,076 --> 00:05:02,596
Speaker 6: What is it? What's going on?

74
00:05:03,076 --> 00:05:03,556
Speaker 3: I don't know.

75
00:05:03,676 --> 00:05:06,516
Speaker 6: A strange neurosis, evidently contagious.

76
00:05:06,756 --> 00:05:09,916
Speaker 2: In the nineteen fifties, a lot of people were very suddenly,

77
00:05:10,356 --> 00:05:12,676
Speaker 2: very worried about mind control.

78
00:05:13,036 --> 00:05:15,356
Speaker 6: It's an malignant disease spreading through the whole country.

79
00:05:15,916 --> 00:05:19,236
Speaker 2: Fear of communism and at the same time, fear of

80
00:05:19,276 --> 00:05:23,636
Speaker 2: anti communism in the form of McCarthyism. Both fears are

81
00:05:23,636 --> 00:05:27,036
Speaker 2: the subject of the nineteen fifty six film Invasion of

82
00:05:27,076 --> 00:05:32,116
Speaker 2: the Body Snatchers, where everyone seems suddenly not quite themselves anymore,

83
00:05:32,876 --> 00:05:33,716
Speaker 2: and what causes it.

84
00:05:34,276 --> 00:05:35,756
Speaker 3: Worry about what's going on in the world.

85
00:05:35,836 --> 00:05:41,636
Speaker 7: Probably this actually.

86
00:05:41,436 --> 00:05:45,316
Speaker 4: Was a panic of concern to the military in the

87
00:05:45,556 --> 00:05:48,796
Speaker 4: early years of the Korean War that American troops seem

88
00:05:48,876 --> 00:05:52,916
Speaker 4: to be succumbing to some sort of mysterious techniques.

89
00:05:53,156 --> 00:05:56,036
Speaker 2: Rebecca Lamov is a historian of science at Harvard a

90
00:05:56,076 --> 00:05:59,396
Speaker 2: colleague of mine. She's written a new book, The Instability

91
00:05:59,436 --> 00:06:04,516
Speaker 2: of Truth, A History of brainwashing, mind control, and hyper persuasion.

92
00:06:05,196 --> 00:06:08,556
Speaker 2: Beginning during the Korean War, when the Chinese government under

93
00:06:08,596 --> 00:06:12,796
Speaker 2: Chairman now held Americans as prisoners, they were.

94
00:06:12,676 --> 00:06:16,236
Speaker 4: Held in prison camps. Initially these camps were run by

95
00:06:16,236 --> 00:06:18,836
Speaker 4: the Koreans and later by the Chinese. The troops were

96
00:06:18,876 --> 00:06:22,316
Speaker 4: subjected to re education as a sort of experiment to

97
00:06:22,316 --> 00:06:24,836
Speaker 4: see if it would apply to westerners. One of the

98
00:06:24,876 --> 00:06:27,156
Speaker 4: soldiers had brought back his journal in which he had

99
00:06:27,196 --> 00:06:28,796
Speaker 4: been forced to confess.

100
00:06:29,156 --> 00:06:31,556
Speaker 2: Being an evil capitalist, basically.

101
00:06:31,116 --> 00:06:34,316
Speaker 4: Being an evil capitalist or having had a hand in oppression,

102
00:06:34,436 --> 00:06:38,076
Speaker 4: or in this case he was African Americans. So sometimes

103
00:06:38,076 --> 00:06:43,276
Speaker 4: they would actually incorporate a racial sort of liberation analysis

104
00:06:43,316 --> 00:06:45,476
Speaker 4: into it. But at any rate, ninety one percent of

105
00:06:45,516 --> 00:06:48,836
Speaker 4: the prisoners reported that they were forced to journal.

106
00:06:48,796 --> 00:06:50,476
Speaker 2: Because part of the re education is you have to

107
00:06:50,516 --> 00:06:52,196
Speaker 2: retell the story of your own life.

108
00:06:52,356 --> 00:06:55,916
Speaker 4: Exactly what the US military and then later the press

109
00:06:55,956 --> 00:07:00,116
Speaker 4: were seeing when these prisoners were returned was something they

110
00:07:00,676 --> 00:07:04,676
Speaker 4: felt was quite mysterious. They would appear vacant and sort

111
00:07:04,716 --> 00:07:10,236
Speaker 4: of dissociated, and would be quoting Communist propaganda, which used

112
00:07:10,276 --> 00:07:13,956
Speaker 4: that very formulaic language that their families wouldn't recognize. So

113
00:07:13,956 --> 00:07:17,796
Speaker 4: they seemed to be not themselves. And there was evidence that,

114
00:07:18,116 --> 00:07:21,036
Speaker 4: as a New Yorker reporter later put at, something new

115
00:07:21,076 --> 00:07:23,956
Speaker 4: in history was happening, and they called in troops of

116
00:07:23,956 --> 00:07:27,956
Speaker 4: psychiatrists and sociologists and any expert to see see if

117
00:07:27,956 --> 00:07:29,516
Speaker 4: they could break the spell.

118
00:07:29,836 --> 00:07:33,396
Speaker 2: I mean, it's terrifying. Is they're terrifying, terrifying prospect.

119
00:07:33,596 --> 00:07:33,796
Speaker 6: Yeah.

120
00:07:33,796 --> 00:07:37,236
Speaker 4: There were also American pilots who gave false confessions to

121
00:07:37,276 --> 00:07:40,716
Speaker 4: having dropped biological weapons over China, and there were American

122
00:07:40,716 --> 00:07:44,396
Speaker 4: businessmen who also seemed to be turning up having been brainwashed.

123
00:07:44,436 --> 00:07:47,636
Speaker 4: So it was quite terrifying that the Communists had something

124
00:07:47,636 --> 00:07:49,596
Speaker 4: that just was not understood.

125
00:07:52,596 --> 00:07:55,396
Speaker 3: New York. Well, American executive Robert bogla Is home with

126
00:07:55,476 --> 00:07:58,236
Speaker 3: his wife after confinement in a Hungarian Communist prison camp

127
00:07:58,276 --> 00:07:59,196
Speaker 3: for seventeen months.

128
00:07:59,636 --> 00:08:03,116
Speaker 4: So Robert Vogeler was an American businessman, an executive who

129
00:08:03,156 --> 00:08:07,316
Speaker 4: was working in Hungary for IT and T, the International

130
00:08:07,356 --> 00:08:10,996
Speaker 4: Telegraph and Telephone Company. He entered the headlines because he

131
00:08:11,316 --> 00:08:14,276
Speaker 4: was returned after being imprisoned by the secret police.

132
00:08:15,116 --> 00:08:19,396
Speaker 6: I was shoved into a sixth feet by nine feet cell,

133
00:08:20,676 --> 00:08:24,396
Speaker 6: and the cold was unbearable. The worst of it, however,

134
00:08:24,956 --> 00:08:29,156
Speaker 6: was the endless routine repeated every six minutes, of the

135
00:08:29,156 --> 00:08:33,596
Speaker 6: steel people being opened and clang shut.

136
00:08:34,196 --> 00:08:37,076
Speaker 4: He couldn't quite remember what had happened to him. He

137
00:08:37,156 --> 00:08:40,636
Speaker 4: had been converted to communism initially. When he came back

138
00:08:41,036 --> 00:08:44,436
Speaker 4: then he sort of decompressed and returned to himself. Later,

139
00:08:44,476 --> 00:08:46,796
Speaker 4: when he reflected on it, he said, the very body

140
00:08:46,916 --> 00:08:49,436
Speaker 4: is forced into league against one's personality.

141
00:08:50,076 --> 00:08:54,076
Speaker 6: The important thing to be learned from my experience is

142
00:08:54,116 --> 00:08:59,756
Speaker 6: that it can happen to anyone. It can happen to you.

143
00:09:00,996 --> 00:09:04,676
Speaker 2: Lamov says that the public learned about brainwashing from a

144
00:09:04,676 --> 00:09:06,036
Speaker 2: writer named Edward Hunter.

145
00:09:06,956 --> 00:09:10,756
Speaker 4: He actually was quite an experienced OSA agent Office of

146
00:09:10,796 --> 00:09:14,356
Speaker 4: Strategic Services, which was the precursor to the CIA essentially,

147
00:09:14,836 --> 00:09:17,476
Speaker 4: and he had been working in China for several decades

148
00:09:17,756 --> 00:09:20,996
Speaker 4: and had been an anti propaganda that was his beat,

149
00:09:21,116 --> 00:09:23,876
Speaker 4: and he had also worked as a journalist. He had

150
00:09:23,876 --> 00:09:26,996
Speaker 4: an extensive collection of propaganda. So he wrote an article

151
00:09:27,156 --> 00:09:30,556
Speaker 4: in nineteen fifty announcing that the Communist had developed a

152
00:09:30,596 --> 00:09:33,156
Speaker 4: new super weapon. He called it brainwashing.

153
00:09:33,756 --> 00:09:36,676
Speaker 2: But it's a very evocative phrase. So that becomes the

154
00:09:36,796 --> 00:09:40,276
Speaker 2: language with which Americans talk about this process of malist

155
00:09:40,316 --> 00:09:41,836
Speaker 2: indoctrination exactly.

156
00:09:41,876 --> 00:09:44,516
Speaker 4: It takes off, and he publishes a book. He goes

157
00:09:44,516 --> 00:09:47,436
Speaker 4: on a lecture circuit. He explains more deeply, and he

158
00:09:47,436 --> 00:09:53,116
Speaker 4: connects this brainwashing to Communist techniques and hypnosis, and also

159
00:09:53,236 --> 00:09:57,636
Speaker 4: to Soviet programs to build new types of human beings.

160
00:09:58,196 --> 00:10:01,156
Speaker 2: The US government was concerned enough that in nineteen fifty

161
00:10:01,156 --> 00:10:05,716
Speaker 2: three it started its own brainwashing program MK Ultra, led

162
00:10:05,716 --> 00:10:10,676
Speaker 2: by the CIA, horrifying human experiments. The public didn't know

163
00:10:10,716 --> 00:10:13,636
Speaker 2: about it for decades, but you can see the fear

164
00:10:13,676 --> 00:10:16,676
Speaker 2: of brainwashing reaching a kind of apex with the film

165
00:10:16,796 --> 00:10:21,236
Speaker 2: adaptation of the nineteen fifty nine novel Manchurian Candidate.

166
00:10:21,676 --> 00:10:25,596
Speaker 7: I have conditioned them or brainwashed them, which I understand

167
00:10:25,676 --> 00:10:26,916
Speaker 7: is the new American work.

168
00:10:27,476 --> 00:10:30,596
Speaker 2: It was as if these men had been made into machines.

169
00:10:30,956 --> 00:10:33,956
Speaker 7: His brain has not only been washed as they say,

170
00:10:34,236 --> 00:10:35,836
Speaker 7: it has been dry clean.

171
00:10:38,956 --> 00:10:42,076
Speaker 2: In the midst of all this, one man in Pretoria,

172
00:10:42,116 --> 00:10:44,396
Speaker 2: South Africa, was frantic.

173
00:10:45,156 --> 00:10:49,276
Speaker 7: Every day the brainwashers repeat and emphasize the things they

174
00:10:49,436 --> 00:10:50,636
Speaker 7: want us to believe.

175
00:10:51,396 --> 00:10:55,756
Speaker 2: Remember Elon Musk's maternal grandfather, J. N. Haldeman. I talked

176
00:10:55,756 --> 00:10:59,196
Speaker 2: about him in an earlier episode. That's an actor, reading

177
00:10:59,196 --> 00:11:03,356
Speaker 2: from a tract Haldeman published in South Africa in nineteen sixty.

178
00:11:03,476 --> 00:11:07,276
Speaker 2: In it, Haldeman described himself as having been a student

179
00:11:07,436 --> 00:11:12,476
Speaker 2: of social engineering who had directed a number of scientific, social, economic,

180
00:11:12,516 --> 00:11:16,356
Speaker 2: and political organizations. In the nineteen thirties, He'd been a

181
00:11:16,436 --> 00:11:20,196
Speaker 2: leader of the technocracy movement in Canada. Then he joined

182
00:11:20,236 --> 00:11:24,636
Speaker 2: the anti Semitic Social Credit Party, becoming its national chairman.

183
00:11:25,436 --> 00:11:28,076
Speaker 2: In nineteen forty nine, he began thinking about moving to

184
00:11:28,116 --> 00:11:32,836
Speaker 2: South Africa, attracted by its newly announced policy of apartheid.

185
00:11:33,196 --> 00:11:37,596
Speaker 2: He moved there in nineteen fifty. In May of nineteen sixty,

186
00:11:37,876 --> 00:11:42,596
Speaker 2: Haldeman wrote the International Conspiracy to establish a World Dictatorship

187
00:11:42,636 --> 00:11:46,236
Speaker 2: and its Menace to South Africa. The tract was a

188
00:11:46,276 --> 00:11:49,276
Speaker 2: response to a speech by the British Prime Minister.

189
00:11:50,196 --> 00:11:53,396
Speaker 7: The window Chaine is blowing through this continent.

190
00:11:54,716 --> 00:11:55,916
Speaker 3: Whether we like it or not.

191
00:11:56,516 --> 00:12:00,836
Speaker 6: This growth national consciousness is a political fact.

192
00:12:02,676 --> 00:12:06,956
Speaker 2: In February nineteen sixty, Harold McMillan, the PM, had addressed

193
00:12:06,996 --> 00:12:12,236
Speaker 2: the South African Parliament disc countenancing apartheid and urging acceptance

194
00:12:12,316 --> 00:12:14,516
Speaker 2: of the inevitability of independence.

195
00:12:15,316 --> 00:12:17,036
Speaker 8: We was all accepted as a fair.

196
00:12:18,396 --> 00:12:21,636
Speaker 2: Only weeks later, South African police opened fire on a

197
00:12:21,676 --> 00:12:25,316
Speaker 2: crowd of thousands of black South Africans protesting outside the

198
00:12:25,356 --> 00:12:30,196
Speaker 2: Sharpville police station. Police killed sixty nine people, including children,

199
00:12:30,596 --> 00:12:32,436
Speaker 2: and wounded nearly two hundred.

200
00:12:34,556 --> 00:12:38,516
Speaker 3: There was a rattle of machine gun and people started running.

201
00:12:38,556 --> 00:12:44,036
Speaker 6: Pocerta children were screaming around the street crying for the amadas,

202
00:12:44,396 --> 00:12:48,116
Speaker 6: and some other policemen's were busy shooting those children.

203
00:12:49,036 --> 00:12:52,676
Speaker 2: The killings were captured on television and the coverage reached

204
00:12:52,716 --> 00:12:57,116
Speaker 2: around the world. In the ensuing protests and state of emergency,

205
00:12:57,676 --> 00:13:02,276
Speaker 2: Nelson Mandela was among eighteen thousand people arrested and jailed.

206
00:13:03,156 --> 00:13:07,836
Speaker 2: Haldeman wrote this tract that spring, suggesting that the uprising

207
00:13:08,076 --> 00:13:09,036
Speaker 2: had been staged.

208
00:13:09,556 --> 00:13:12,836
Speaker 7: Questions to be asked who were the white leaders in

209
00:13:12,876 --> 00:13:16,956
Speaker 7: the Shopville Native riot? Who escaped. Who were the ones

210
00:13:16,996 --> 00:13:20,276
Speaker 7: who fired the shots at the police that would guarantee

211
00:13:20,276 --> 00:13:22,836
Speaker 7: that a major event would take place at that time?

212
00:13:23,436 --> 00:13:24,596
Speaker 7: What are their connections?

213
00:13:25,316 --> 00:13:28,796
Speaker 2: He believed apartheid had come under attack due to an

214
00:13:28,836 --> 00:13:33,076
Speaker 2: international conspiracy spreading dangerous ideas like these.

215
00:13:33,516 --> 00:13:42,476
Speaker 7: The natives are ill treated, underpaid, underprivileged. Separate development is wrong,

216
00:13:43,396 --> 00:13:46,356
Speaker 7: apartheid is un Christian.

217
00:13:46,436 --> 00:13:50,836
Speaker 2: And Heldemann believed that the media itself was doing the brainwashing.

218
00:13:51,516 --> 00:13:59,196
Speaker 7: Every day newspapers, magazines, commercial radio newscasters drip this into

219
00:13:59,236 --> 00:14:02,836
Speaker 7: the conscious and subconscious minds of the public.

220
00:14:03,396 --> 00:14:05,756
Speaker 2: He pledged to stop the spread of the virus.

221
00:14:06,196 --> 00:14:09,516
Speaker 7: People who know it is ninety nine percent un true,

222
00:14:09,956 --> 00:14:15,716
Speaker 7: repeat these lies emphatically and emotionally. The facts of history

223
00:14:15,796 --> 00:14:19,556
Speaker 7: show that the white man has always developed the country

224
00:14:19,676 --> 00:14:24,396
Speaker 7: he inhabits to the benefit of all concerned. The black

225
00:14:24,476 --> 00:14:28,396
Speaker 7: people of Africa have been in close contact with civilization

226
00:14:28,836 --> 00:14:35,356
Speaker 7: from the earliest times, but on their own built nothing, discovered, nothing,

227
00:14:35,956 --> 00:14:37,196
Speaker 7: not even the will.

228
00:14:39,116 --> 00:14:42,236
Speaker 2: Now, let me state again what I've said before. Elon

229
00:14:42,356 --> 00:14:45,716
Speaker 2: Musk is not responsible for the ideas or actions of

230
00:14:45,756 --> 00:14:49,036
Speaker 2: his grandfather, who died when Musk was only two years old.

231
00:14:49,996 --> 00:14:53,676
Speaker 2: I mentioned him here because he's an excellent illustration of

232
00:14:53,756 --> 00:14:56,796
Speaker 2: the persistence of fears of mind control.

233
00:14:57,396 --> 00:15:01,556
Speaker 7: People have become misled on the proven traditional attitudes of

234
00:15:01,636 --> 00:15:03,916
Speaker 7: what is right and wrong and what is good and

235
00:15:04,036 --> 00:15:07,836
Speaker 7: bad for themselves and for their country by an intensive

236
00:15:07,996 --> 00:15:14,476
Speaker 7: psycho political warfare which has been conducted to change people's minds.

237
00:15:13,636 --> 00:15:16,796
Speaker 2: For everything Heldeman blamed brainwashing.

238
00:15:17,436 --> 00:15:22,436
Speaker 7: Psychopolitics is now one of the chief weapons of the internationalists,

239
00:15:22,836 --> 00:15:25,276
Speaker 7: and it is in this field that they are having

240
00:15:25,396 --> 00:15:31,676
Speaker 7: so much success and practically no opposition. An intensive mass

241
00:15:31,876 --> 00:15:35,636
Speaker 7: mind conditioning has been going on for a century.

242
00:15:36,236 --> 00:15:39,436
Speaker 2: This was being done, he alleged, not only by the media,

243
00:15:39,516 --> 00:15:41,036
Speaker 2: but also by universities.

244
00:15:41,396 --> 00:15:45,196
Speaker 7: It is no wonder that so many university professors come

245
00:15:45,236 --> 00:15:50,276
Speaker 7: out with liberalistic, anti nationalist statements, although they may be

246
00:15:50,436 --> 00:15:56,676
Speaker 7: professing Christians and sincerely feel they are patriots. Throughout university

247
00:15:56,756 --> 00:16:00,436
Speaker 7: courses to get their degrees, they were subjected to a

248
00:16:00,516 --> 00:16:02,756
Speaker 7: materialistic inductrination.

249
00:16:03,556 --> 00:16:06,516
Speaker 2: While we're at it, it's curious that another of Heldeman's

250
00:16:06,556 --> 00:16:09,196
Speaker 2: big evils was government waste.

251
00:16:09,356 --> 00:16:12,116
Speaker 7: Most of this waste is a result of following the

252
00:16:12,276 --> 00:16:15,996
Speaker 7: tax and debt system of the Internationalists.

253
00:16:16,356 --> 00:16:20,076
Speaker 2: He wanted to set up a finance committee to combat inefficiency.

254
00:16:20,436 --> 00:16:24,356
Speaker 7: A watchdog financial agency is needed.

255
00:16:24,396 --> 00:16:26,676
Speaker 2: And he wanted one to combat brainwashing too.

256
00:16:27,196 --> 00:16:31,116
Speaker 7: Another watchdog committee must have power to counter erect the

257
00:16:31,156 --> 00:16:35,876
Speaker 7: psycho political warfare that is being directed against South Africa.

258
00:16:36,836 --> 00:16:40,476
Speaker 7: This must be done or the Finance Committee, which soon

259
00:16:40,556 --> 00:16:43,636
Speaker 7: find they had no public support for their efforts to

260
00:16:43,716 --> 00:16:47,996
Speaker 7: save the country. People must be warned and become fully

261
00:16:48,076 --> 00:16:52,476
Speaker 7: aware that when they read the international English language newspapers,

262
00:16:52,956 --> 00:16:56,756
Speaker 7: these are not really British or American. They are more

263
00:16:56,876 --> 00:17:01,076
Speaker 7: likely to be psychopolitical organs of Moscow and Wall Street.

264
00:17:01,916 --> 00:17:04,916
Speaker 2: Heldeman was writing in nineteen sixty just as the public

265
00:17:04,956 --> 00:17:09,036
Speaker 2: panic about brainwashing was beginning to wind down. After that,

266
00:17:09,236 --> 00:17:13,196
Speaker 2: people stopped talking about it so much. Rebecca Lamov says

267
00:17:13,316 --> 00:17:16,276
Speaker 2: the public fear about mind control didn't really start up

268
00:17:16,316 --> 00:17:19,476
Speaker 2: again until the nineteen nineties, the end of the Cold War,

269
00:17:19,916 --> 00:17:23,316
Speaker 2: the beginning of the Internet. That's when Richard Dawkins started

270
00:17:23,316 --> 00:17:27,996
Speaker 2: writing about viruses of the mind spreading like computer viruses,

271
00:17:28,916 --> 00:17:34,356
Speaker 2: and then the worry became those viruses are spreading by computer.

272
00:17:38,516 --> 00:17:41,796
Speaker 2: Full disclosure. I hate Twitter. I hated it when it

273
00:17:41,876 --> 00:17:45,116
Speaker 2: was leftier, and I still hate it now that it's rightier.

274
00:17:46,116 --> 00:17:48,516
Speaker 2: I hate all social media. I've never had an account

275
00:17:48,556 --> 00:17:50,676
Speaker 2: on any of these things. I think social media is

276
00:17:50,676 --> 00:17:55,276
Speaker 2: a disaster for democracy, for fairness, for decency, for humanity.

277
00:17:56,076 --> 00:17:59,276
Speaker 2: On the other hand, Musk's plan for fixing Twitter. It

278
00:17:59,276 --> 00:18:01,596
Speaker 2: brings to mind the adage that the cure is sometimes

279
00:18:01,636 --> 00:18:05,236
Speaker 2: worse than the disease. If history is any guide to

280
00:18:05,316 --> 00:18:08,556
Speaker 2: the fear of mind control, it is the backlash that

281
00:18:08,636 --> 00:18:11,316
Speaker 2: you have to work watch out for, which brings me

282
00:18:11,356 --> 00:18:16,196
Speaker 2: to Mosque's admiration for the writings of a Canadian marketing professor.

283
00:18:17,116 --> 00:18:19,676
Speaker 3: The Parasitic Mind Stray good book. It recommended to everyone.

284
00:18:19,676 --> 00:18:21,716
Speaker 3: In fact, I did recommend it to everyone. It really

285
00:18:21,756 --> 00:18:24,116
Speaker 3: does hit the nail on the head with respect to

286
00:18:24,916 --> 00:18:28,516
Speaker 3: the sort of ork mind virus that is damaging civilization.

287
00:18:29,116 --> 00:18:32,036
Speaker 2: That's Musk in twenty twenty four talking to the author

288
00:18:32,116 --> 00:18:36,716
Speaker 2: of The Parasitic Mind, how infectious ideas are killing common sense?

289
00:18:37,276 --> 00:18:40,796
Speaker 2: A man who's described his book as the mind vaccine

290
00:18:40,836 --> 00:18:44,396
Speaker 2: against all of the idea pathogens that have been destroying

291
00:18:44,596 --> 00:18:49,236
Speaker 2: the West. Name of Gad Sad. He's got a big

292
00:18:49,236 --> 00:18:53,236
Speaker 2: following on x and a YouTube show called The Sad Truth.

293
00:18:53,796 --> 00:18:56,476
Speaker 4: He was educated in the nineteen nineties interestingly in a

294
00:18:56,476 --> 00:19:00,956
Speaker 4: PhD program. He's an evolutionary behavioral scientist, but he's a

295
00:19:00,956 --> 00:19:05,276
Speaker 4: professor of marketing. So he basically spent the first twenty

296
00:19:05,476 --> 00:19:07,916
Speaker 4: or thirty years of his career applying the insights of

297
00:19:07,956 --> 00:19:11,796
Speaker 4: evolutionary behavioral science, or he would say, evolutionary science to

298
00:19:12,756 --> 00:19:16,876
Speaker 4: commerce and to marketing, and so basically, how do you

299
00:19:17,476 --> 00:19:20,596
Speaker 4: best sell you know, high heels to women when they're

300
00:19:20,796 --> 00:19:23,516
Speaker 4: its best when they're menstruating, or can you target these

301
00:19:23,556 --> 00:19:27,076
Speaker 4: particular moments because there's evidence that women are more receptive

302
00:19:27,116 --> 00:19:29,556
Speaker 4: to certain messages at certain times, or things like that.

303
00:19:29,956 --> 00:19:32,716
Speaker 2: And then he ran into a wall. Here's how Sad

304
00:19:32,836 --> 00:19:36,156
Speaker 2: tells it in a conversation with Musk last year on X.

305
00:19:36,676 --> 00:19:40,516
Speaker 8: I first noticed all of these mind viruses in my

306
00:19:40,676 --> 00:19:44,156
Speaker 8: academic work when I was trying to introduce, you know,

307
00:19:44,196 --> 00:19:48,276
Speaker 8: evolutionary psychology evolutionary biology in the business schools, and most

308
00:19:48,316 --> 00:19:51,516
Speaker 8: of my social science colleagues were so that set against

309
00:19:51,596 --> 00:19:54,516
Speaker 8: using biology to explain human phenomena. So that was my

310
00:19:54,756 --> 00:19:57,556
Speaker 8: original sort of at ha moment, we have a problem.

311
00:19:57,796 --> 00:19:59,636
Speaker 4: I think he had trouble in academia, and this is

312
00:19:59,636 --> 00:20:01,676
Speaker 4: what caused him to sort of move in the direction

313
00:20:01,756 --> 00:20:04,436
Speaker 4: he has is that people were resistant to listening to

314
00:20:04,476 --> 00:20:08,436
Speaker 4: his ideas at any moment. He identified sex differences between

315
00:20:08,476 --> 00:20:12,396
Speaker 4: men and women. If it happened to reflect poorly on women,

316
00:20:12,436 --> 00:20:14,556
Speaker 4: he said that people were just unwilling to listen to

317
00:20:14,556 --> 00:20:18,036
Speaker 4: his ideas, especially the smart people who are actually dumb.

318
00:20:18,156 --> 00:20:21,796
Speaker 2: Yeah, and he's not wrong that there's a tremendous rejection

319
00:20:21,956 --> 00:20:25,676
Speaker 2: of those ideas without inspection. And that's a common part

320
00:20:25,716 --> 00:20:27,836
Speaker 2: of academic life, Like I don't think in terms of

321
00:20:27,876 --> 00:20:32,556
Speaker 2: diagnosing the closed mindedness of a lot of academics, they're

322
00:20:32,556 --> 00:20:33,596
Speaker 2: not wrong about that.

323
00:20:33,796 --> 00:20:36,716
Speaker 4: Yeah, exactly. So then you could maybe say that because

324
00:20:36,796 --> 00:20:39,516
Speaker 4: these things are associated with what they would say the

325
00:20:39,516 --> 00:20:42,036
Speaker 4: far left, it is a form of communism be branded

326
00:20:42,036 --> 00:20:44,716
Speaker 4: and the way that we I suppose we can both

327
00:20:44,996 --> 00:20:47,996
Speaker 4: identify moments in academia where it does feel like there's

328
00:20:48,036 --> 00:20:49,036
Speaker 4: a kind of lockstep.

329
00:20:49,156 --> 00:20:52,276
Speaker 2: Absolutely, Yeah, I get it right.

330
00:20:52,476 --> 00:20:56,836
Speaker 4: I agree it's uncomfortable because I think I wouldn't want

331
00:20:56,876 --> 00:20:58,276
Speaker 4: to just say this is absurd.

332
00:20:58,756 --> 00:21:01,356
Speaker 2: Where I get off the train. Where I leap off

333
00:21:01,396 --> 00:21:05,916
Speaker 2: that train is when Sad's argument, Musk's argument runs this way.

334
00:21:06,476 --> 00:21:10,356
Speaker 2: I don't like these ideas. Therefore, these ideas are bad ideas. Therefore,

335
00:21:10,356 --> 00:21:13,276
Speaker 2: these ideas are mind viruses, and therefore I will kill

336
00:21:13,316 --> 00:21:14,996
Speaker 2: them in the name of free speech.

337
00:21:15,716 --> 00:21:20,396
Speaker 8: All of these parasitic ideas originated from the university ecosystem.

338
00:21:20,476 --> 00:21:24,396
Speaker 2: The parasitic mind is an argument against a collection of

339
00:21:24,476 --> 00:21:28,916
Speaker 2: bad ideas spawned on university campuses what Sad describes as

340
00:21:29,036 --> 00:21:34,836
Speaker 2: anti science, anti reason, and illiberal idea pathogens, including postmodernism,

341
00:21:35,156 --> 00:21:40,156
Speaker 2: radical feminism, and transgender activism. Musk read the book, loved it,

342
00:21:40,596 --> 00:21:43,596
Speaker 2: and started tweeting about it, said it gave him nightmares.

343
00:21:44,116 --> 00:21:46,356
Speaker 8: When was it for you that you noticed that something

344
00:21:46,476 --> 00:21:46,796
Speaker 8: was wrong?

345
00:21:46,916 --> 00:21:50,476
Speaker 3: I'd say about five years ago, come in in the climate,

346
00:21:50,596 --> 00:21:54,556
Speaker 3: just before COVID. The degree of panic over COVID was

347
00:21:54,596 --> 00:21:58,316
Speaker 3: exacerbated by this unwillingness to question science or question the

348
00:21:58,356 --> 00:21:59,076
Speaker 3: accepted view.

349
00:21:59,836 --> 00:22:03,276
Speaker 2: In his book, Sad argues that Google, YouTube, Facebook, and

350
00:22:03,316 --> 00:22:06,356
Speaker 2: Twitter have more global control over us than all other

351
00:22:06,436 --> 00:22:10,436
Speaker 2: companies combined. He writes, it is an hyperbole to say

352
00:22:10,636 --> 00:22:13,356
Speaker 2: that they have more collective power in terms of the

353
00:22:13,356 --> 00:22:17,036
Speaker 2: information they control than all of the rulers, priests, and

354
00:22:17,156 --> 00:22:22,956
Speaker 2: politicians in all of history. Hence, Musk is saving civilization.

355
00:22:23,716 --> 00:22:27,796
Speaker 8: In my view, your purchase of Twitter will go down

356
00:22:28,236 --> 00:22:31,996
Speaker 8: historically as the most important of all of your great initiatives.

357
00:22:32,156 --> 00:22:33,036
Speaker 7: Do you feel that.

358
00:22:33,316 --> 00:22:35,756
Speaker 8: Was that a right calculation on my part? Or was

359
00:22:35,836 --> 00:22:36,956
Speaker 8: I overstating the case?

360
00:22:37,076 --> 00:22:40,316
Speaker 3: Well, you might be right. It's possible. It's possible that

361
00:22:40,316 --> 00:22:42,876
Speaker 3: you're right. I mean, I didn't do the purchase because

362
00:22:42,916 --> 00:22:44,996
Speaker 3: I thought it was a great way to make money,

363
00:22:45,196 --> 00:22:47,836
Speaker 3: or because I thought it would improve by quality of living.

364
00:22:47,876 --> 00:22:51,636
Speaker 3: But it really felt like if it was a civilizational danger,

365
00:22:51,796 --> 00:22:53,996
Speaker 3: it was just no place to actually get the truth.

366
00:22:54,476 --> 00:22:57,236
Speaker 2: There ought to be some kind of watchdog committee, right,

367
00:22:57,476 --> 00:23:00,476
Speaker 2: And so Musk bought Twitter to stop the spread of

368
00:23:00,516 --> 00:23:04,036
Speaker 2: the woke mind virus. Musk, by no means shares all

369
00:23:04,076 --> 00:23:06,716
Speaker 2: of his grandfather's views, and in fact, many of his

370
00:23:06,836 --> 00:23:08,196
Speaker 2: views are of course very different.

371
00:23:09,196 --> 00:23:12,236
Speaker 3: Rice maybe the work bind virus. It consists of creating

372
00:23:12,396 --> 00:23:19,676
Speaker 3: very divisive identity politics. So it actually amplifies racism, amplifies sexism,

373
00:23:19,716 --> 00:23:23,076
Speaker 3: and only isms, and while claiming to do the opposite,

374
00:23:23,676 --> 00:23:28,076
Speaker 3: it actually divides people and makes them sort of hate

375
00:23:28,076 --> 00:23:30,516
Speaker 3: each other, and it makes people hate themselves.

376
00:23:31,356 --> 00:23:34,276
Speaker 2: Still, Musk also does echo a lot of his grandfather's

377
00:23:34,276 --> 00:23:38,916
Speaker 2: fears from decades ago. Last year, Musk warned that Christianity

378
00:23:39,156 --> 00:23:40,396
Speaker 2: might soon perish.

379
00:23:41,196 --> 00:23:44,556
Speaker 3: Also, the work Bindvirus is communism rebranded, and.

380
00:23:44,596 --> 00:23:47,476
Speaker 2: Musk has said he wanted to correct for Twitter's long

381
00:23:47,516 --> 00:23:49,236
Speaker 2: time leftward tilt.

382
00:23:49,276 --> 00:23:51,796
Speaker 3: And on the past Twitter was controlled by fall left

383
00:23:51,836 --> 00:23:56,116
Speaker 3: activists objectively, they would describe themselves as that, though what.

384
00:23:56,076 --> 00:23:59,356
Speaker 2: Musk actually did when he bought X was to limit

385
00:23:59,436 --> 00:24:02,916
Speaker 2: content moderation and restore the accounts of people who'd been

386
00:24:02,956 --> 00:24:08,156
Speaker 2: banned for extremism or for spreading misinformation. Musk also gave

387
00:24:08,196 --> 00:24:12,156
Speaker 2: another reason for by Twitter, a personal one. It involves

388
00:24:12,196 --> 00:24:15,516
Speaker 2: one of his kids, one of J. N. Haldeman's great grandchildren.

389
00:24:16,356 --> 00:24:19,676
Speaker 2: Musk spoke with Anguish about what he called child mutilation

390
00:24:20,036 --> 00:24:21,436
Speaker 2: and child sterilization.

391
00:24:22,196 --> 00:24:24,996
Speaker 3: It happened to one of my older boys. Where I was,

392
00:24:25,916 --> 00:24:30,036
Speaker 3: I was essentially tricked into signing documents for one of

393
00:24:30,076 --> 00:24:32,756
Speaker 3: my older boys, Xavier. This is before I had really

394
00:24:32,756 --> 00:24:34,596
Speaker 3: any understanding what was going on and that we had

395
00:24:34,636 --> 00:24:37,756
Speaker 3: COVID gone on, and so there was a lot of confusion,

396
00:24:38,676 --> 00:24:40,876
Speaker 3: you know. I was told, oh, you know, Savior might

397
00:24:40,876 --> 00:24:41,876
Speaker 3: commit suicide.

398
00:24:42,356 --> 00:24:45,116
Speaker 2: That was in twenty twenty, the year Musk and Grimes

399
00:24:45,156 --> 00:24:48,156
Speaker 2: had a son they named x. It was another child,

400
00:24:48,196 --> 00:24:51,676
Speaker 2: an older child from Musk's first marriage and now sixteen,

401
00:24:52,116 --> 00:24:55,956
Speaker 2: who transitioned that year and who disputes Musk's account of

402
00:24:55,996 --> 00:24:56,596
Speaker 2: what happened.

403
00:24:57,196 --> 00:24:59,636
Speaker 3: I lost my son. Essentially, they call it dead naming

404
00:24:59,676 --> 00:25:02,596
Speaker 3: for a reason. Yeah, all right, So the reason it's

405
00:25:02,636 --> 00:25:08,476
Speaker 3: called dead naming is because your son is dead, killed

406
00:25:08,516 --> 00:25:09,956
Speaker 3: by the walk line virus.

407
00:25:10,236 --> 00:25:13,916
Speaker 2: In twenty twenty two, this child turned eighteen, changed her

408
00:25:13,996 --> 00:25:17,636
Speaker 2: name to Vivian Wilson and cut off all contact with

409
00:25:17,716 --> 00:25:18,156
Speaker 2: her father.

410
00:25:18,756 --> 00:25:20,756
Speaker 3: So I vowed to destroy the my virus.

411
00:25:20,756 --> 00:25:25,556
Speaker 2: After that that year, Musk bought Twitter and renamed it x.

412
00:25:30,076 --> 00:25:33,996
Speaker 2: Rebecca Lamov, expert on the history of brainwashing, does think

413
00:25:34,156 --> 00:25:35,196
Speaker 2: there's something to fear.

414
00:25:35,676 --> 00:25:38,276
Speaker 4: I think that we live in an environment, including an

415
00:25:38,516 --> 00:25:42,356
Speaker 4: information environment, where you know, the stakes are quite high

416
00:25:42,436 --> 00:25:47,396
Speaker 4: and the tools are incredibly powerful, and therefore the countervailing

417
00:25:47,436 --> 00:25:51,156
Speaker 4: pressures are also very strong, so that we need to

418
00:25:51,156 --> 00:25:54,756
Speaker 4: be extremely aware of the possibilities that our minds are

419
00:25:54,796 --> 00:25:56,996
Speaker 4: being changed in tiny, tiny ways.

420
00:25:57,436 --> 00:26:00,236
Speaker 2: And here's what haunts me in this decade's long story

421
00:26:00,516 --> 00:26:05,036
Speaker 2: of the fear of mind control. Who is actually in control?

422
00:26:06,036 --> 00:26:10,356
Speaker 2: In nineteen sixty, when Elon Musk's grandfather wanted to warn

423
00:26:10,396 --> 00:26:14,596
Speaker 2: the world about the international conspiracy against white Christian civilization

424
00:26:14,956 --> 00:26:18,076
Speaker 2: that involved mind control through the media and the universities.

425
00:26:18,996 --> 00:26:21,716
Speaker 2: He got out a typewriter, typed up a tract or

426
00:26:21,756 --> 00:26:25,876
Speaker 2: two and a newsletter, and made a few dozen mimeographs.

427
00:26:26,636 --> 00:26:29,836
Speaker 2: He mailed them to a few friends, maybe I don't

428
00:26:29,876 --> 00:26:34,796
Speaker 2: know fifty copies, and then they mostly disappeared. In the

429
00:26:34,836 --> 00:26:38,076
Speaker 2: twenty twenties, when Elon Musk decided that he wanted to

430
00:26:38,076 --> 00:26:41,876
Speaker 2: warn the world about a woke mind virus, he bought Twitter.

431
00:26:42,276 --> 00:26:46,956
Speaker 2: Twitter is not a typewriter. Musk spent forty four billion

432
00:26:46,996 --> 00:26:49,636
Speaker 2: dollars on it. He could do that because he is

433
00:26:49,676 --> 00:26:51,356
Speaker 2: the richest man in the world, and he can do

434
00:26:51,436 --> 00:26:54,916
Speaker 2: things like that. Every time he wants to speak, he

435
00:26:54,956 --> 00:26:58,716
Speaker 2: reaches over two hundred million people. He runs a company

436
00:26:58,796 --> 00:27:03,036
Speaker 2: that feeds people information. And this is liberating us from

437
00:27:03,076 --> 00:27:09,076
Speaker 2: mind control. No, this is the dream of the brainwasher.

438
00:27:14,236 --> 00:27:17,396
Speaker 2: Next time on x Man Elon Musk's plan to save

439
00:27:17,516 --> 00:27:22,436
Speaker 2: humans from being destroyed by artificial intelligence Muskism and the

440
00:27:22,556 --> 00:27:24,076
Speaker 2: AI Apocalypse