WEBVTT - The Embalmed Beef Scandal

0:00:08.285 --> 0:00:13.485
<v Speaker 1>School of Humans. If you haven't had the pleasure of

0:00:13.525 --> 0:00:18.645
<v Speaker 1>eating old, rotten, contaminated beef before, it's not great. Spoiler.

0:00:19.965 --> 0:00:21.845
<v Speaker 1>I recently went to a waffle house with one of

0:00:21.885 --> 0:00:24.925
<v Speaker 1>my friends, and while she did not realize at the time,

0:00:25.165 --> 0:00:30.325
<v Speaker 1>she indeed was eating some gross, nasty meat and she

0:00:30.485 --> 0:00:35.125
<v Speaker 1>suffered accordingly. Here is her historical account.

0:00:35.525 --> 0:00:40.765
<v Speaker 2>When I took my first bite, it tasted oddly sweet,

0:00:41.285 --> 0:00:45.685
<v Speaker 2>and I thought, gosh, this dinerlike establishment is way fancier

0:00:45.685 --> 0:00:47.685
<v Speaker 2>than I thought, because they must have some sort of

0:00:48.325 --> 0:00:56.965
<v Speaker 2>tomato jam or something that's making this burger taste really sweet,

0:00:56.485 --> 0:01:01.285
<v Speaker 2>kind of sickly sweet, like nothing I had ever tasted before.

0:01:02.725 --> 0:01:06.765
<v Speaker 2>And when did I realize that something was wrong, I

0:01:06.805 --> 0:01:12.925
<v Speaker 2>would say within seventy five seconds, when my stomach started

0:01:13.125 --> 0:01:20.045
<v Speaker 2>digesting in a violent manner, and I realized that no

0:01:20.085 --> 0:01:24.925
<v Speaker 2>one's stomach should make those sounds. I eat the whole burger.

0:01:24.965 --> 0:01:28.565
<v Speaker 2>I'm not gonna lie. I thought, maybe if I keep going,

0:01:28.925 --> 0:01:33.845
<v Speaker 2>this will get better. And then I felt the sensation

0:01:34.085 --> 0:01:37.405
<v Speaker 2>of everything I've ever eaten rising up into my thoat,

0:01:37.525 --> 0:01:40.805
<v Speaker 2>and I said, I'm gonna throw up. So I stood

0:01:40.885 --> 0:01:44.845
<v Speaker 2>up and walked into the bathroom and put my face

0:01:44.925 --> 0:01:47.445
<v Speaker 2>closer into the toilet than I ever thought I would

0:01:47.525 --> 0:01:50.285
<v Speaker 2>as such an establishment, and I threw that bad boy

0:01:50.365 --> 0:01:50.805
<v Speaker 2>right up.

0:01:53.205 --> 0:01:56.725
<v Speaker 1>Don't worry, she is healed today and she, you know, luckily,

0:01:56.805 --> 0:01:59.285
<v Speaker 1>has had the courage to return to waffle House since

0:01:59.365 --> 0:02:02.685
<v Speaker 1>the incident. But it's crazy that I mentioned that, because

0:02:03.085 --> 0:02:05.645
<v Speaker 1>that's what I want to talk about today, because as

0:02:05.685 --> 0:02:09.285
<v Speaker 1>the thing is, tomorrow, we Americans all across the land

0:02:09.325 --> 0:02:12.845
<v Speaker 1>will gather and gorge ourselves on various food items to

0:02:12.925 --> 0:02:17.725
<v Speaker 1>celebrate Thanksgiving, the holiday that commemorates when Pilgrims and Indigenous

0:02:17.725 --> 0:02:21.885
<v Speaker 1>Americans sat down and feasted together in the ongoing crisis

0:02:21.925 --> 0:02:25.805
<v Speaker 1>of a European colonialism that had already wiped out about

0:02:25.885 --> 0:02:28.885
<v Speaker 1>ninety seven percent of the Native Americans in New England

0:02:29.285 --> 0:02:33.285
<v Speaker 1>from you know, white people introducing disease and other various

0:02:33.325 --> 0:02:37.565
<v Speaker 1>acts of genocide. As a little treat, I just wanted

0:02:37.565 --> 0:02:40.005
<v Speaker 1>to give you something to ruminate on that will just

0:02:40.045 --> 0:02:44.725
<v Speaker 1>really enhance your experience of eating turkey, ham and other meats.

0:02:45.565 --> 0:02:49.725
<v Speaker 1>Today's episode is about a rotten beef scandal, yes, and

0:02:49.925 --> 0:02:53.085
<v Speaker 1>what it took to stop having so much poisonous meat

0:02:53.365 --> 0:03:03.085
<v Speaker 1>on grocery store shelves. Theme song This is American filth.

0:03:03.125 --> 0:03:05.445
<v Speaker 1>I'm Gabby Watts. Every week I tell you a film

0:03:05.645 --> 0:03:12.045
<v Speaker 1>the story from American history. Today's episode the Embalmed Beef Scandal.

0:03:23.525 --> 0:03:26.445
<v Speaker 1>So let's go back in our fifth time machine to

0:03:26.485 --> 0:03:32.805
<v Speaker 1>the Spanish American War. So Cuba had been trying to

0:03:32.845 --> 0:03:36.045
<v Speaker 1>get independence from Spain for a while. You know. First

0:03:36.085 --> 0:03:38.285
<v Speaker 1>of all, there was the Ten Years War in eighteen

0:03:38.365 --> 0:03:41.725
<v Speaker 1>sixty eight, which ended, can you believe it in eighteen

0:03:41.845 --> 0:03:47.205
<v Speaker 1>seventy eight, exactly ten years later, But they continue fighting,

0:03:47.245 --> 0:03:50.645
<v Speaker 1>and eventually the United States was like, hmmm, we should

0:03:50.645 --> 0:03:54.005
<v Speaker 1>get involved in this conflict because you know, we love

0:03:54.045 --> 0:03:57.045
<v Speaker 1>it when people fight for independence. That's what we did.

0:03:57.165 --> 0:04:05.085
<v Speaker 1>Let's help you Just kidding. That was not our motivation.

0:04:06.285 --> 0:04:10.125
<v Speaker 1>The US got involved for its own political and economic interest.

0:04:11.285 --> 0:04:14.965
<v Speaker 1>The US wanted to get Spain aka European mega powers

0:04:15.005 --> 0:04:20.245
<v Speaker 1>out of the America region. Also, some historians have hypothesized

0:04:20.245 --> 0:04:23.365
<v Speaker 1>another reason that the US might have gotten involved was

0:04:23.405 --> 0:04:26.045
<v Speaker 1>that the US wanted to make sure that the black people,

0:04:26.085 --> 0:04:28.525
<v Speaker 1>who made up two fits of the population of Cuba

0:04:28.565 --> 0:04:32.325
<v Speaker 1>would not make their own nation state on the island. So,

0:04:32.605 --> 0:04:36.365
<v Speaker 1>to summarize, the US got involved for the usual reasons

0:04:36.805 --> 0:04:46.565
<v Speaker 1>White supremacy and capitalism. At least we are consistent. What

0:04:46.725 --> 0:04:50.165
<v Speaker 1>really escalated the war zeal in the public was in

0:04:50.205 --> 0:04:54.005
<v Speaker 1>February of eighteen ninety eight, one of the US's battleships

0:04:54.085 --> 0:04:58.365
<v Speaker 1>was destroyed in Havana by a mysterious explosion that killed

0:04:58.405 --> 0:05:04.045
<v Speaker 1>two hundred and sixty eight men. And what's really fun

0:05:04.085 --> 0:05:06.405
<v Speaker 1>about that was that it was it's never proven what

0:05:06.605 --> 0:05:10.245
<v Speaker 1>caused the explosion, but the US was like, whoops, I

0:05:10.325 --> 0:05:13.285
<v Speaker 1>guess this proves we for sure need to get involved.

0:05:15.765 --> 0:05:19.245
<v Speaker 1>So the US entered the war in April eighteen ninety eight,

0:05:20.605 --> 0:05:23.605
<v Speaker 1>and it only lasted a few months. The United States

0:05:23.605 --> 0:05:28.765
<v Speaker 1>emerged victorious. By August eighteen ninety eight, Cuba was independent,

0:05:29.045 --> 0:05:32.165
<v Speaker 1>but somehow the US had acquired Puerto Rico Guam in

0:05:32.205 --> 0:05:35.085
<v Speaker 1>the Philippines. And the cool thing about all of this

0:05:35.485 --> 0:05:39.405
<v Speaker 1>is that no Cuban representatives were invited to the peace talks.

0:05:41.885 --> 0:05:45.365
<v Speaker 1>During the Spanish American War, the United States deployed about

0:05:45.405 --> 0:05:49.525
<v Speaker 1>two hundred and seventy four thousand soldiers and about three

0:05:49.565 --> 0:05:53.645
<v Speaker 1>thousand men died. But the thing is only two hundred

0:05:53.645 --> 0:05:56.485
<v Speaker 1>and eighty got killed in battle. The rest two thousand,

0:05:56.605 --> 0:05:59.965
<v Speaker 1>six hundred and thirty died from other stuff, and some

0:06:00.005 --> 0:06:03.765
<v Speaker 1>people suspected that some of the soldiers were dying from

0:06:03.845 --> 0:06:06.965
<v Speaker 1>the food that the army had provided to them, specifically

0:06:07.605 --> 0:06:12.725
<v Speaker 1>the beef. Apparently, this beef was so good that everyone

0:06:12.805 --> 0:06:19.885
<v Speaker 1>was calling it red horse mm horse. Once older described

0:06:19.885 --> 0:06:22.925
<v Speaker 1>the canned beef that they had gotten. Here's what he said.

0:06:24.525 --> 0:06:26.805
<v Speaker 1>A tin of red horse would be handed to one

0:06:26.845 --> 0:06:29.445
<v Speaker 1>man who opened it. He put it to his nose,

0:06:29.645 --> 0:06:32.565
<v Speaker 1>smelled of it, wrinkled up his face, and took a spit.

0:06:33.205 --> 0:06:35.805
<v Speaker 1>The next man did the same, and the next till

0:06:35.845 --> 0:06:39.125
<v Speaker 1>the eight men of the mess had smelled, grimaced, and spit.

0:06:39.965 --> 0:06:43.325
<v Speaker 1>Then that tin of red horse was thrown overboard for

0:06:43.485 --> 0:06:46.245
<v Speaker 1>any of the fishes of the Atlantic Ocean who might

0:06:46.445 --> 0:06:49.725
<v Speaker 1>like it. What we called red horse soon had all

0:06:49.725 --> 0:06:58.165
<v Speaker 1>our country scandalized with its new name of embalmed beef. Yuma,

0:06:58.885 --> 0:07:05.085
<v Speaker 1>embalmed beef. Doesn't that sound appetizing? What do you guys

0:07:05.125 --> 0:07:07.805
<v Speaker 1>think that the taste palette of this embalmed beef was?

0:07:07.965 --> 0:07:14.525
<v Speaker 1>I'm thinking a rancid acid with undertones of dead grandma yummy.

0:07:15.365 --> 0:07:19.285
<v Speaker 1>The soldier continued, It was so embalmed with all flavor

0:07:19.325 --> 0:07:22.565
<v Speaker 1>of life and every suck of nourishment gone from it

0:07:22.805 --> 0:07:27.565
<v Speaker 1>through having nevertheless a putridity of odor, more pungent than

0:07:27.645 --> 0:07:34.005
<v Speaker 1>ever reaches the nostrils from a properly embalmed cadaver. They

0:07:34.085 --> 0:07:41.485
<v Speaker 1>used to talk different. Anyway, this soldier had the wisdom

0:07:41.605 --> 0:07:45.845
<v Speaker 1>to not actually eat this beef, but a lot of

0:07:45.885 --> 0:07:49.365
<v Speaker 1>soldiers were getting sick. So the news of this nasty

0:07:49.405 --> 0:07:52.245
<v Speaker 1>meat reached the public and they were upset. They were like, oh,

0:07:52.285 --> 0:07:54.045
<v Speaker 1>you send their boys to war and then you give

0:07:54.085 --> 0:07:58.365
<v Speaker 1>them nasty beef. That's horrible. One concerned mom complained to

0:07:58.405 --> 0:08:02.085
<v Speaker 1>the president, President William McKinley, and was like, we are

0:08:02.125 --> 0:08:05.125
<v Speaker 1>living under a generous government with a good kind man

0:08:05.165 --> 0:08:08.325
<v Speaker 1>at an head, willing to give the army the best possible,

0:08:08.725 --> 0:08:12.205
<v Speaker 1>and yet thieving corporations will give the boys the worst.

0:08:14.285 --> 0:08:18.725
<v Speaker 1>So where did all this nasty embalmed beef come from?

0:08:18.845 --> 0:08:21.685
<v Speaker 1>Most of the meat contracts that the army had were

0:08:21.685 --> 0:08:24.765
<v Speaker 1>with these meat packers based out of Chicago, the land

0:08:24.805 --> 0:08:33.525
<v Speaker 1>of wind and poorly constructed pizza. Chicago became the place

0:08:33.565 --> 0:08:37.445
<v Speaker 1>for meatpacking in the eighteen sixties. There are five main

0:08:37.565 --> 0:08:41.165
<v Speaker 1>meat packing companies, and the men who ran these companies

0:08:41.245 --> 0:08:45.245
<v Speaker 1>developed a lot of innovations that solidified their meat packing prowess.

0:08:45.485 --> 0:08:48.605
<v Speaker 1>They came up with assembly lines, ice cold rooms so

0:08:48.645 --> 0:08:52.765
<v Speaker 1>you could process year round refrigerated freight cars. At first,

0:08:52.805 --> 0:08:56.605
<v Speaker 1>people were very suspicious of refrigerated beef. It was like,

0:08:56.925 --> 0:08:59.005
<v Speaker 1>what you want me to eat meat that has been

0:08:59.045 --> 0:09:01.245
<v Speaker 1>out for more than a week after it has been killed.

0:09:01.365 --> 0:09:06.885
<v Speaker 1>That's crazy. But the thing is money. The refrigerated beef

0:09:07.005 --> 0:09:10.205
<v Speaker 1>was a lot cheaper than fresh meat, so people were like,

0:09:10.605 --> 0:09:15.525
<v Speaker 1>never mind, give me that Old Meat. Side note, I

0:09:15.565 --> 0:09:17.925
<v Speaker 1>did briefly have a country band called Old Meat, but

0:09:17.965 --> 0:09:20.565
<v Speaker 1>it never took off. Here are some of the song

0:09:20.685 --> 0:09:24.925
<v Speaker 1>titles Highway sixty nine, fat Boys in big trucks, road Headache,

0:09:25.085 --> 0:09:27.765
<v Speaker 1>drinking whiskey on the Lord's Day, and of course big

0:09:27.765 --> 0:09:30.405
<v Speaker 1>old Pussy. So yeah, I have no idea why nobody

0:09:30.445 --> 0:09:35.605
<v Speaker 1>liked us anyway. Not only was their refrigerated meat, canned

0:09:35.645 --> 0:09:38.605
<v Speaker 1>meat was also on the up and up, and canned

0:09:38.645 --> 0:09:41.605
<v Speaker 1>meat was generally the worst meat out there, just very

0:09:41.645 --> 0:09:45.245
<v Speaker 1>low grade. It was boiled, packed into cans and broth

0:09:46.005 --> 0:09:53.085
<v Speaker 1>and then sterilized technically. And if you can believe it,

0:09:53.125 --> 0:09:56.925
<v Speaker 1>the meatpacker bosses didn't really give a fuck about their workers.

0:09:57.525 --> 0:10:01.925
<v Speaker 1>They were all about doing it fast. All the meatpacking

0:10:02.005 --> 0:10:05.165
<v Speaker 1>plants weren't a part of Chicago that everyone called packing town.

0:10:05.965 --> 0:10:09.285
<v Speaker 1>The plants were these huge, sprawling yards, and most of

0:10:09.325 --> 0:10:12.925
<v Speaker 1>the laborers were immigrants working in these very dangerous and

0:10:13.005 --> 0:10:17.445
<v Speaker 1>crowded conditions. The rooms were dark and unventilated, and they

0:10:17.445 --> 0:10:22.165
<v Speaker 1>were paid atrociously mere pennies an hour. The only people

0:10:22.165 --> 0:10:24.325
<v Speaker 1>who got a better wage were the people who did

0:10:24.365 --> 0:10:28.165
<v Speaker 1>the pace setting, basically the managers on the floor who

0:10:28.165 --> 0:10:30.525
<v Speaker 1>had just speed up the assembly lines so they had

0:10:30.565 --> 0:10:35.845
<v Speaker 1>to work at a faster and faster rate. And because

0:10:35.885 --> 0:10:38.965
<v Speaker 1>these meat packer dudes controlled so much of the production,

0:10:39.445 --> 0:10:42.885
<v Speaker 1>they were able to set their own prices. A lot

0:10:42.925 --> 0:10:45.845
<v Speaker 1>of muckraking journalists at the time were doing stories on

0:10:45.885 --> 0:10:49.445
<v Speaker 1>them and called them the Beef Trust. I would have

0:10:49.525 --> 0:10:52.005
<v Speaker 1>called them the Beefy and the piggy Boys, but that's

0:10:52.125 --> 0:10:56.685
<v Speaker 1>just me. But yeah, as you can imagine, in these

0:10:56.765 --> 0:11:00.285
<v Speaker 1>working conditions, nothing bad could ever happen with the meats.

0:11:01.285 --> 0:11:04.885
<v Speaker 1>But anyway, back to the embalmed beef in the Spanish

0:11:04.885 --> 0:11:10.565
<v Speaker 1>American Wars. President McKinley was taking these embalmed beef accusations

0:11:10.725 --> 0:11:14.485
<v Speaker 1>very seriously, you know, because he was concerned about the

0:11:14.565 --> 0:11:17.485
<v Speaker 1>quality of beef in his soldier's health. He was definitely

0:11:17.565 --> 0:11:20.085
<v Speaker 1>not concerned about the fact that Congress might lose its

0:11:20.085 --> 0:11:23.085
<v Speaker 1>Republican lead in the upcoming election if he didn't do

0:11:23.165 --> 0:11:27.365
<v Speaker 1>anything about it. Anyway, McKinley set up a commission to investigate.

0:11:29.285 --> 0:11:33.005
<v Speaker 1>They found a witness, Major General Nelson A. Miles, who

0:11:33.085 --> 0:11:36.285
<v Speaker 1>was convinced that the beef had something injected into it

0:11:36.325 --> 0:11:39.405
<v Speaker 1>that was making all the soldiers sick, and that the

0:11:39.405 --> 0:11:45.685
<v Speaker 1>beef was being preserved with secret evil chemicals. Miles talked

0:11:45.685 --> 0:11:48.085
<v Speaker 1>about the accounts of a doctor who was a chief

0:11:48.085 --> 0:11:51.605
<v Speaker 1>surgeon with the army in Tampa. The doctor had seen

0:11:51.645 --> 0:11:54.365
<v Speaker 1>a large hunk of meat hanging on the deck of

0:11:54.405 --> 0:11:57.005
<v Speaker 1>a boat in the sun, and he said that after

0:11:57.165 --> 0:12:02.325
<v Speaker 1>sixty hours, instead of it being brotten and decomposing, the

0:12:02.405 --> 0:12:05.325
<v Speaker 1>meat looked fine, and he was like, that would have

0:12:05.325 --> 0:12:09.685
<v Speaker 1>been impossible without the use of dangerous chemicals. The doctor

0:12:09.765 --> 0:12:12.925
<v Speaker 1>also observed some other beef that had an odor similar

0:12:13.005 --> 0:12:17.525
<v Speaker 1>to an involved human body, and when cooked, it tasted

0:12:17.605 --> 0:12:22.125
<v Speaker 1>like decomposed boric acid, and some of the soldiers said

0:12:22.525 --> 0:12:32.965
<v Speaker 1>it smelt like a bouquet of cesspools. Mmm. Miles report

0:12:33.165 --> 0:12:36.605
<v Speaker 1>about what this doctor had seen made the Commissary General

0:12:36.725 --> 0:12:40.685
<v Speaker 1>Charles Patrick Egan pissed because he was like, Wow, are

0:12:40.725 --> 0:12:44.125
<v Speaker 1>you accusing me of buying poisoned beef for the army?

0:12:44.485 --> 0:12:47.645
<v Speaker 1>Fuck you, Miles, you bitch ass cook. You're a goddang

0:12:47.725 --> 0:12:52.045
<v Speaker 1>stupid ass liar. He didn't say that exactly, but he

0:12:52.165 --> 0:12:56.125
<v Speaker 1>did use such foul language against Smiles that Egan got

0:12:56.205 --> 0:13:00.405
<v Speaker 1>court martialed for conduct unbecoming of an officer and was

0:13:00.445 --> 0:13:05.445
<v Speaker 1>suspended from the Army for six years. Whoopsies. Anyway, most

0:13:05.685 --> 0:13:08.325
<v Speaker 1>of this meat had been provided by one of the

0:13:08.365 --> 0:13:14.005
<v Speaker 1>beefy and piggy boys, Philip Armor, whose company was called

0:13:14.165 --> 0:13:16.885
<v Speaker 1>Armor and Company. Can you believe it? He had sold

0:13:16.925 --> 0:13:19.245
<v Speaker 1>five hundred thousand pounds of beef to the army in

0:13:19.285 --> 0:13:23.685
<v Speaker 1>May eighteen ninety eight, and an Army inspector tested this

0:13:23.805 --> 0:13:26.925
<v Speaker 1>meat specifically, and he found that there were seven hundred

0:13:26.965 --> 0:13:29.725
<v Speaker 1>and fifty one cases of rotten meat. And then in

0:13:29.765 --> 0:13:32.285
<v Speaker 1>the canned meat he found several tins that had been

0:13:32.325 --> 0:13:37.165
<v Speaker 1>busted open and quote the effervescent futrid contents of which

0:13:37.205 --> 0:13:42.605
<v Speaker 1>were distributed all over the cases. So, anyway, there is

0:13:42.605 --> 0:13:46.165
<v Speaker 1>a bunch of various cases from soldiers to generals who

0:13:46.165 --> 0:13:49.405
<v Speaker 1>were like, yeah, this beef was nasty, it smelled bad.

0:13:49.445 --> 0:13:53.725
<v Speaker 1>There was probably something evil injected into it. Also, it's rotten.

0:13:53.805 --> 0:13:58.205
<v Speaker 1>You gave us bad meat. But the meatpackers were like, actually,

0:13:58.285 --> 0:14:02.645
<v Speaker 1>the refrigerator beef was fine. Y'all just didn't handle it properly. Yeah,

0:14:02.725 --> 0:14:05.885
<v Speaker 1>y'all didn't have enough ice for the refrigeration. I heard

0:14:05.925 --> 0:14:08.805
<v Speaker 1>that y'all transported the meat in wagons that had also

0:14:08.885 --> 0:14:12.765
<v Speaker 1>transported manure and garbage and was crawling with maggots. So

0:14:12.845 --> 0:14:16.645
<v Speaker 1>that's not our fault. You guys are dumb. Also, no,

0:14:16.845 --> 0:14:19.925
<v Speaker 1>we didn't put dangerous chemicals in the canned meat. Who

0:14:19.925 --> 0:14:23.565
<v Speaker 1>do you think we are? And actually, the meat packers

0:14:23.565 --> 0:14:26.605
<v Speaker 1>did directly address that beef that was hanging up on

0:14:26.645 --> 0:14:28.885
<v Speaker 1>the deck of the boat. They were like, yeah, we

0:14:28.965 --> 0:14:31.405
<v Speaker 1>sent some cows that had some preservatives in them, but

0:14:31.485 --> 0:14:33.805
<v Speaker 1>we were just doing an experiment. We weren't meaning for

0:14:33.805 --> 0:14:36.605
<v Speaker 1>anyone to eat those beefs. We were just seeing what

0:14:36.605 --> 0:14:42.045
<v Speaker 1>would happen. Okay. So, yet, no one can prove that

0:14:42.125 --> 0:14:45.485
<v Speaker 1>harmful chemicals had been used to preserve the beef that

0:14:45.565 --> 0:14:48.885
<v Speaker 1>were making the soldiers sick and die. What the studies

0:14:48.925 --> 0:14:52.685
<v Speaker 1>did conclude was that maybe the beef wasn't poison it

0:14:52.725 --> 0:14:57.485
<v Speaker 1>was just normal gross meat. You're getting nauseated not because

0:14:57.485 --> 0:15:02.285
<v Speaker 1>it's poisoned, but because it tastes bad. Easy mistake. Also,

0:15:02.405 --> 0:15:05.085
<v Speaker 1>through these investigations, it was becoming clear that a lot

0:15:05.125 --> 0:15:07.525
<v Speaker 1>of the death and sickness during the war was due

0:15:07.565 --> 0:15:10.925
<v Speaker 1>to unsanitary conditions at the army camps, which led to

0:15:11.005 --> 0:15:15.325
<v Speaker 1>a lot of people getting typhoid fever. Like, for example,

0:15:15.325 --> 0:15:18.965
<v Speaker 1>a one camp, all the soldiers were drinking well water

0:15:19.365 --> 0:15:22.245
<v Speaker 1>that hadn't been boiled. But this well was within three

0:15:22.285 --> 0:15:25.725
<v Speaker 1>feet of an outhouse. So basically people were getting sick

0:15:25.765 --> 0:15:28.485
<v Speaker 1>not from beef, but from drinking their own shit. Aha,

0:15:28.525 --> 0:15:35.125
<v Speaker 1>we love to hear it. So even despite these findings,

0:15:35.125 --> 0:15:36.765
<v Speaker 1>a lot of people were still like, I don't trust

0:15:36.805 --> 0:15:39.205
<v Speaker 1>the beefy and the piggy boys. I think something suspicious

0:15:39.245 --> 0:15:42.445
<v Speaker 1>is going on. In nineteen oh three, a New York

0:15:42.445 --> 0:15:46.365
<v Speaker 1>Times article quoted an official from the Association of Manufacturers

0:15:46.365 --> 0:15:49.725
<v Speaker 1>and Distributors of Food Products that said quote, since the

0:15:49.765 --> 0:15:53.565
<v Speaker 1>embalmed beef scandal after the Spanish American War, everyone has

0:15:53.645 --> 0:15:56.085
<v Speaker 1>looked with doubt on any food which has been known

0:15:56.125 --> 0:15:59.405
<v Speaker 1>to contain preservatives, and in general, at the turn of

0:15:59.405 --> 0:16:02.205
<v Speaker 1>the twentieth century, people were more and more concerned about

0:16:02.205 --> 0:16:05.885
<v Speaker 1>adultery in food. There was the pure foods movement. It

0:16:05.965 --> 0:16:08.845
<v Speaker 1>was a hot button issue because you know, as cities

0:16:08.925 --> 0:16:12.445
<v Speaker 1>populations were dramatically increasing, that meant that I was taking

0:16:12.485 --> 0:16:15.765
<v Speaker 1>longer to transport enough food from farms to markets, so

0:16:15.845 --> 0:16:19.925
<v Speaker 1>they needed solutions, hence preservatives. One of the main purveyers

0:16:19.925 --> 0:16:23.445
<v Speaker 1>of the clean food movement was Harvey Washington Wiley, who

0:16:23.445 --> 0:16:26.445
<v Speaker 1>became the chemist for the Secretary of Agriculture and eventually

0:16:26.485 --> 0:16:28.965
<v Speaker 1>became the first Commissioner of the Food and Drug Administration.

0:16:29.445 --> 0:16:33.165
<v Speaker 1>So interesting, but that's all later. But even Wiley had

0:16:33.205 --> 0:16:36.165
<v Speaker 1>participated in the involved beef studies and he hadn't found

0:16:36.205 --> 0:16:39.765
<v Speaker 1>any dangerous preservatives inside of the meat. So in the end,

0:16:39.845 --> 0:16:41.565
<v Speaker 1>the meat packers were not at fault at all, and

0:16:41.605 --> 0:16:44.045
<v Speaker 1>nothing bad has ever happened with American food. Everything is

0:16:44.085 --> 0:16:49.685
<v Speaker 1>great haha. So yeah, the embalmed beef scandal, it does

0:16:49.725 --> 0:16:52.285
<v Speaker 1>have a bit of an anti climactic ending, but that's

0:16:52.325 --> 0:16:55.605
<v Speaker 1>not the end of the episode. People were still going

0:16:55.645 --> 0:17:00.725
<v Speaker 1>after the meat packers, but it would take the work

0:17:00.765 --> 0:17:11.205
<v Speaker 1>of an unsuccessful socialist writer to really make things change. Okay,

0:17:11.245 --> 0:17:12.685
<v Speaker 1>I feel like probably most of you had to read

0:17:12.725 --> 0:17:15.405
<v Speaker 1>The Jungle in high school, right right. It was written

0:17:15.405 --> 0:17:19.085
<v Speaker 1>by Upton Sinclair, who later went on to write almost

0:17:19.125 --> 0:17:21.925
<v Speaker 1>one hundred books, won the Pulitzer Prize YadA, YadA, YadA,

0:17:22.285 --> 0:17:25.685
<v Speaker 1>but before that he was an unsuccessful loser like the

0:17:25.685 --> 0:17:29.165
<v Speaker 1>rest of us. Sinclair was also getting into socialism at

0:17:29.165 --> 0:17:31.645
<v Speaker 1>the time. He had joined the Socialist Party in nineteen

0:17:31.685 --> 0:17:35.205
<v Speaker 1>oh three. He was like, yep, big corporations are evil.

0:17:35.445 --> 0:17:38.205
<v Speaker 1>The government should take over the ownership of big business.

0:17:38.285 --> 0:17:41.725
<v Speaker 1>I'm sick of this shit. He was inspired to go

0:17:41.725 --> 0:17:44.685
<v Speaker 1>to Chicago when meat packing workers were on strike in

0:17:44.765 --> 0:17:48.885
<v Speaker 1>nineteen oh four. But the big corporations, the Beefy and

0:17:48.925 --> 0:17:52.805
<v Speaker 1>the piggy Boys, they just hired replacement workers who kept

0:17:52.805 --> 0:17:56.525
<v Speaker 1>the businesses going, and so the strikers fell into poverty

0:17:56.565 --> 0:18:02.565
<v Speaker 1>and lost everything. Sinclair went to Chicago incognito at the

0:18:02.605 --> 0:18:05.645
<v Speaker 1>meat packing factories to see what was going on, and

0:18:05.685 --> 0:18:07.685
<v Speaker 1>what he found was that it was nasty and gross,

0:18:08.165 --> 0:18:10.805
<v Speaker 1>and the workers were treated terribly. What can you believe

0:18:10.845 --> 0:18:14.485
<v Speaker 1>it a corporation treating its employees badly? Uh huh. Luckily

0:18:14.525 --> 0:18:17.765
<v Speaker 1>it's nothing like that today. And here are some of

0:18:17.805 --> 0:18:20.565
<v Speaker 1>the terrible things he observed at the meat packing plants

0:18:20.605 --> 0:18:23.205
<v Speaker 1>that he included in the book. He found that the

0:18:23.205 --> 0:18:25.845
<v Speaker 1>meat packing workers worked on assembly lines and moved at

0:18:25.845 --> 0:18:29.645
<v Speaker 1>a dangerous pace, leading to bodily injuries like lost fingers

0:18:29.645 --> 0:18:33.085
<v Speaker 1>and limbs. Men had to haul one hundred pound hunks

0:18:33.085 --> 0:18:36.365
<v Speaker 1>of meat on their backs, which would lead to debilitating injuries.

0:18:37.245 --> 0:18:40.245
<v Speaker 1>They are often sick. Sometimes they even had tuberculosis and

0:18:40.285 --> 0:18:43.485
<v Speaker 1>would cough constantly and spit blood on the floor. And

0:18:43.565 --> 0:18:45.685
<v Speaker 1>the thing is, if you got injured or sick on

0:18:45.765 --> 0:18:48.605
<v Speaker 1>the job, the beeping the piggy boys didn't give a toot.

0:18:49.285 --> 0:18:53.845
<v Speaker 1>No workers comped for you. And besides these grueling and

0:18:53.885 --> 0:18:57.245
<v Speaker 1>hazardous work conditions, the sanitation and the meat packing plants

0:18:57.405 --> 0:19:01.685
<v Speaker 1>was abysmal. There weren't enough toilets, so sometimes workers would

0:19:01.725 --> 0:19:04.365
<v Speaker 1>just pee on the ground, and there was no soap

0:19:04.405 --> 0:19:08.565
<v Speaker 1>or water to clean your hand ants anyway. Sinclair also

0:19:08.565 --> 0:19:12.685
<v Speaker 1>wrote about how disease rotten and contaminated meat was still

0:19:12.765 --> 0:19:17.565
<v Speaker 1>processed and then filled with harmful chemicals for preservation and

0:19:17.605 --> 0:19:23.165
<v Speaker 1>then mislabeled when sold to the public. Mmmm. And after

0:19:23.165 --> 0:19:26.565
<v Speaker 1>the meat was slaughtered, they just put it on the ground.

0:19:26.645 --> 0:19:29.405
<v Speaker 1>And on the ground, remember there was urine and blood

0:19:29.565 --> 0:19:31.845
<v Speaker 1>spit all over the floor, and then it would be

0:19:31.885 --> 0:19:35.965
<v Speaker 1>transported around the plants and these carts that also had sawdust, rat,

0:19:36.045 --> 0:19:38.925
<v Speaker 1>dung rat poison, and sometimes even dead rats in them,

0:19:39.845 --> 0:19:41.685
<v Speaker 1>and then all of that was just tipped into the

0:19:41.685 --> 0:19:47.405
<v Speaker 1>hoppers to make a canned meat and sausage yummy. And finally,

0:19:47.405 --> 0:19:51.325
<v Speaker 1>the most disserving thing was sometimes workers would fall into

0:19:51.325 --> 0:19:55.285
<v Speaker 1>the vats and when this happened, quote when they were

0:19:55.325 --> 0:19:57.845
<v Speaker 1>fished out, there was never enough of them to be

0:19:58.045 --> 0:20:02.765
<v Speaker 1>worth exhibiting. Sometimes they would be overlooked for days till

0:20:02.845 --> 0:20:05.325
<v Speaker 1>all but the bones of them had gone out to

0:20:05.605 --> 0:20:13.725
<v Speaker 1>the world as Durham's pure leaf lard. Anyway, Sinclair faced

0:20:13.765 --> 0:20:15.885
<v Speaker 1>a lot of challenges when trying to publish The Jungle.

0:20:17.045 --> 0:20:20.365
<v Speaker 1>At first, it was distributed as a serialized version that

0:20:20.485 --> 0:20:24.165
<v Speaker 1>circulated in a socialist newspaper, and he had found a

0:20:24.165 --> 0:20:26.165
<v Speaker 1>publisher who was going to print the whole thing as

0:20:26.165 --> 0:20:29.165
<v Speaker 1>a novel, but then the company backed out because some

0:20:29.245 --> 0:20:31.645
<v Speaker 1>of the claims in the novel were so salacious that

0:20:31.685 --> 0:20:33.445
<v Speaker 1>they were like, uh, I don't want to put the

0:20:33.445 --> 0:20:36.045
<v Speaker 1>bill for a lawsuit against the Beefy and the piggy boys.

0:20:38.165 --> 0:20:40.725
<v Speaker 1>So Saint Clair started looking around for other publishers. He

0:20:40.805 --> 0:20:43.605
<v Speaker 1>mostly got rejections, but then had a meeting with a

0:20:43.605 --> 0:20:47.965
<v Speaker 1>publishing house called Doubleday, Page and Company. One of their

0:20:48.085 --> 0:20:51.245
<v Speaker 1>editors had the book was fabuloso but also cuckoo crazy,

0:20:51.605 --> 0:20:53.805
<v Speaker 1>so they wanted to get fact checked. They sent the

0:20:53.805 --> 0:20:57.045
<v Speaker 1>manuscript to the Chicago Tribune and they were like, does

0:20:57.085 --> 0:21:00.405
<v Speaker 1>this sound like it's for real. A representative from the

0:21:00.405 --> 0:21:03.285
<v Speaker 1>Tribune wrote back and was like, this book is definitely

0:21:03.365 --> 0:21:07.445
<v Speaker 1>cuckoo crazy and definitely not for real. But Saint Clair

0:21:07.525 --> 0:21:10.725
<v Speaker 1>was like, h that's dumb. This is for real, And

0:21:10.765 --> 0:21:13.365
<v Speaker 1>even the editors at the publishing house were like, yeah,

0:21:13.405 --> 0:21:16.325
<v Speaker 1>it is kind of sus how much they are denying

0:21:16.365 --> 0:21:21.365
<v Speaker 1>these claims. They sent like a multi page document. So

0:21:21.445 --> 0:21:23.885
<v Speaker 1>then the publishing house had their own investigation into the

0:21:23.925 --> 0:21:26.885
<v Speaker 1>Tribune and found that a publicist at the paper had

0:21:26.925 --> 0:21:30.245
<v Speaker 1>written the critique and that that publicist worked for the

0:21:30.285 --> 0:21:36.125
<v Speaker 1>meat packers. Uh, whoopsies. They decided to publish the book,

0:21:36.165 --> 0:21:39.165
<v Speaker 1>but they also wanted Sinclair to make it less preachy

0:21:39.205 --> 0:21:42.925
<v Speaker 1>about socialism, and Saint Clair, being so desperate at this point,

0:21:43.005 --> 0:21:44.845
<v Speaker 1>was like, fine, I'll do it. So he cut about

0:21:44.885 --> 0:21:48.085
<v Speaker 1>thirty thousand words like can you imagine how many social speeches?

0:21:48.125 --> 0:21:51.325
<v Speaker 1>That was? And the book finally came out as a

0:21:51.365 --> 0:21:55.965
<v Speaker 1>novel on February twenty six, nineteen oh six. In its

0:21:55.965 --> 0:21:58.605
<v Speaker 1>first year alone, it sold more than one hundred and

0:21:58.645 --> 0:22:02.805
<v Speaker 1>fifty thousand copies and was translated into seventeen languages and

0:22:02.925 --> 0:22:09.805
<v Speaker 1>has since been forced upon every American high schooler. Saint

0:22:09.845 --> 0:22:12.005
<v Speaker 1>Clair was stoked. He was like, hell, yeah, people are

0:22:12.045 --> 0:22:15.525
<v Speaker 1>reading it. But he was also kind of upset because

0:22:15.525 --> 0:22:18.605
<v Speaker 1>in the book, the main character loses everything because of

0:22:18.605 --> 0:22:21.125
<v Speaker 1>the meat processing plant, but he finds hope at the

0:22:21.245 --> 0:22:24.645
<v Speaker 1>end because of socialism, and that was Sinclair's main reason

0:22:24.645 --> 0:22:28.685
<v Speaker 1>for writing it. But what the public latched onto wasn't socialism,

0:22:29.125 --> 0:22:32.445
<v Speaker 1>but how all the meat was icky. Saint Clair was like,

0:22:32.525 --> 0:22:35.205
<v Speaker 1>I aimed at the public's heart, and by accident, I

0:22:35.365 --> 0:22:40.445
<v Speaker 1>hid it in the stomach. Sinclair's publishers and several other

0:22:40.485 --> 0:22:43.085
<v Speaker 1>people send the novel to the President, who was now

0:22:43.165 --> 0:22:47.965
<v Speaker 1>Theodore Roosevelt. Roosevelt had actually been in the Spanish American

0:22:48.005 --> 0:22:51.525
<v Speaker 1>War and really did think that beef was embalmed. He'd

0:22:51.565 --> 0:22:54.525
<v Speaker 1>been a colonel in Cuba and he had testified about

0:22:54.525 --> 0:22:57.645
<v Speaker 1>how gross the meat was. He said that he would

0:22:57.645 --> 0:22:59.765
<v Speaker 1>have eaten his old hat as soon as he would

0:22:59.765 --> 0:23:03.445
<v Speaker 1>have eaten embalmed the beef. So Roosevelt, like so much

0:23:03.525 --> 0:23:05.965
<v Speaker 1>with the public, was like, yeah, that meat was trash.

0:23:06.245 --> 0:23:08.205
<v Speaker 1>I don't care if you think it wasn't poisoned. There

0:23:08.245 --> 0:23:11.445
<v Speaker 1>was something wrong with it. Roosevelt was far from being

0:23:11.485 --> 0:23:14.845
<v Speaker 1>a socialist, but he was also anti trust. And at

0:23:14.885 --> 0:23:17.525
<v Speaker 1>this point, the beef and piggy boys had created their

0:23:17.525 --> 0:23:21.525
<v Speaker 1>own meat oligarchy, just reigning supreme, and Roosevelt thought it

0:23:21.605 --> 0:23:24.085
<v Speaker 1>was sus because as the cost of labor and production

0:23:24.245 --> 0:23:28.405
<v Speaker 1>was going down, the consumer price was going up. Roosevelt

0:23:28.405 --> 0:23:30.445
<v Speaker 1>was like, no, no, no, I don't like that. I want

0:23:30.445 --> 0:23:35.365
<v Speaker 1>to bust up this trust. So Roosevelt read The Jungle,

0:23:36.805 --> 0:23:39.685
<v Speaker 1>or had someone at least summarize it for him, and

0:23:39.725 --> 0:23:42.085
<v Speaker 1>at first he was like, yeah, okay, things might be

0:23:42.125 --> 0:23:44.605
<v Speaker 1>bad at the meat packing plants, but this is a novel,

0:23:44.645 --> 0:23:47.045
<v Speaker 1>not an article. We need to verify some of this info.

0:23:47.845 --> 0:23:51.165
<v Speaker 1>So he also sent some investigators to the plants and

0:23:51.205 --> 0:23:54.285
<v Speaker 1>they're like, hey, President, it's actually kind of worse than

0:23:54.285 --> 0:23:57.525
<v Speaker 1>what the book says. One of the investigators saw a

0:23:57.565 --> 0:24:01.565
<v Speaker 1>slaughtered hog fall into a toilet and then the workers

0:24:01.605 --> 0:24:04.285
<v Speaker 1>just pulled the carcass out and without cleaning it, hung

0:24:04.325 --> 0:24:07.605
<v Speaker 1>it back on the rack. Yum yam a diarrhea bacon.

0:24:12.965 --> 0:24:16.925
<v Speaker 1>This book was exactly what Roosevelt wanted. It proved that

0:24:17.045 --> 0:24:20.725
<v Speaker 1>legislation was necessary. Also, at this point in time, Europe

0:24:20.765 --> 0:24:23.765
<v Speaker 1>was already like, we don't want this American meat. It's gross.

0:24:24.165 --> 0:24:26.125
<v Speaker 1>And then once the Judgle came out, meat sales in

0:24:26.165 --> 0:24:30.085
<v Speaker 1>the US were dropping. All around the country. People were

0:24:30.085 --> 0:24:32.805
<v Speaker 1>writing to the White House and their legislators being like,

0:24:32.845 --> 0:24:35.165
<v Speaker 1>there needs to be reformed, We need things to change.

0:24:36.125 --> 0:24:37.925
<v Speaker 1>The meat needs to be inspected at every step of

0:24:37.965 --> 0:24:41.845
<v Speaker 1>the process. So Roosevelt was like, brus, look how bad

0:24:41.845 --> 0:24:44.685
<v Speaker 1>it is. We got to pass this legislation. And so

0:24:44.765 --> 0:24:48.485
<v Speaker 1>in June nineteen oh six, Congress passed the Meat Inspection Act.

0:24:51.005 --> 0:24:54.685
<v Speaker 1>This law authorized inspectors from the US Department of Agriculture

0:24:54.725 --> 0:24:57.765
<v Speaker 1>to make sure that the meats weren't contaminated or mislabeled

0:24:57.765 --> 0:25:01.205
<v Speaker 1>in any way. And the law also expanded federal government

0:25:01.285 --> 0:25:05.005
<v Speaker 1>regulation of corporations and other private businesses. And then the

0:25:05.045 --> 0:25:07.445
<v Speaker 1>same day that the Meat bill was passed, Congress also

0:25:07.485 --> 0:25:10.845
<v Speaker 1>passed the Pure Food and Drug Act, which regulates food

0:25:10.845 --> 0:25:14.805
<v Speaker 1>additives and prohibits misleading labels of food and drugs. And

0:25:14.845 --> 0:25:16.965
<v Speaker 1>then this Act eventually led to the creation of the

0:25:16.965 --> 0:25:20.325
<v Speaker 1>Food and Drug Administration and all this this was a

0:25:20.405 --> 0:25:23.045
<v Speaker 1>huge deal because this was the first time that food

0:25:23.165 --> 0:25:27.285
<v Speaker 1>was being regulated in the US. And so, yeah, today

0:25:27.765 --> 0:25:29.805
<v Speaker 1>all of our food is safe to eat now and

0:25:29.845 --> 0:25:34.605
<v Speaker 1>nothing ever goes wrong. Sure, according to the CDC, every

0:25:34.645 --> 0:25:36.885
<v Speaker 1>year about forty eight million people in the US get

0:25:36.925 --> 0:25:40.245
<v Speaker 1>sick from food born illnesses. But that's just like a

0:25:40.325 --> 0:25:45.285
<v Speaker 1>six of Americans. We're fine anyway. What about the beefy

0:25:45.285 --> 0:25:49.845
<v Speaker 1>and the pay boys, Well, obviously they weren't pleased with

0:25:49.845 --> 0:25:52.605
<v Speaker 1>this shit. But when the Meat Inspection Act was being

0:25:52.645 --> 0:25:55.965
<v Speaker 1>passed at nineteen oh six, the meat packing lobbyists, they

0:25:55.965 --> 0:25:59.285
<v Speaker 1>were actually able to persuade legislators to water down some

0:25:59.325 --> 0:26:03.205
<v Speaker 1>of the requirements. One of them was that it would

0:26:03.205 --> 0:26:05.885
<v Speaker 1>be the federal government, not the meat packer, who would

0:26:05.885 --> 0:26:09.445
<v Speaker 1>have to pay for all these additional inspections. And the

0:26:09.485 --> 0:26:13.525
<v Speaker 1>thing about these lobbyists, while they're still active today, they're like,

0:26:13.605 --> 0:26:16.845
<v Speaker 1>this is still too much regulation. I want to sell old, nasty,

0:26:16.885 --> 0:26:20.765
<v Speaker 1>poisoned meat, please, And in fact, under sith Lord Trump,

0:26:21.045 --> 0:26:23.045
<v Speaker 1>he did roll back some of the key elements of

0:26:23.085 --> 0:26:26.565
<v Speaker 1>the Meat Inspection Act for pork processors, So now in

0:26:26.685 --> 0:26:30.325
<v Speaker 1>pork processing plants, the duty of inspecting the meats has

0:26:30.365 --> 0:26:36.845
<v Speaker 1>gone back to the pork processors, not Federal safety inspectors. Cool.

0:26:36.965 --> 0:26:39.285
<v Speaker 1>So it's basically the same way it was before The

0:26:39.365 --> 0:26:42.405
<v Speaker 1>Jungle was published. H huh. And the beef boys, they're

0:26:42.405 --> 0:26:44.965
<v Speaker 1>trying to get the same thing passed for them. The

0:26:45.085 --> 0:26:48.605
<v Speaker 1>end is nigh. Ha ha. I don't know why I'm

0:26:48.645 --> 0:26:59.445
<v Speaker 1>still not a vegetarian after doing this episode. And Saint Clair, well,

0:26:59.525 --> 0:27:01.125
<v Speaker 1>you know, he was still a little better about how

0:27:01.165 --> 0:27:04.685
<v Speaker 1>people didn't suddenly become socialist, but after the Jungle came

0:27:04.685 --> 0:27:06.645
<v Speaker 1>out he did become. I'm very rich and famous, so

0:27:06.725 --> 0:27:10.365
<v Speaker 1>how socialist is that? Really? As always, we learn a

0:27:10.445 --> 0:27:12.525
<v Speaker 1>lesson from American filth, and the lesson here is that

0:27:12.565 --> 0:27:14.725
<v Speaker 1>if you drop a hog in a toilet, wash it off.

0:27:15.325 --> 0:27:19.405
<v Speaker 1>Wash off your hogs. Anyway, Happy Thanksgiving, I hope you

0:27:19.485 --> 0:27:23.285
<v Speaker 1>enjoy all your meats. American Film is a production of

0:27:23.285 --> 0:27:26.005
<v Speaker 1>School of Humans and iHeart Podcast. This episode was written

0:27:26.085 --> 0:27:29.725
<v Speaker 1>hosted by me Gabby Watts. Our senior producer is Amelia Brock,

0:27:29.805 --> 0:27:32.645
<v Speaker 1>and our executive producers are Virginia Prescott, Chide Poli, and

0:27:32.645 --> 0:27:37.125
<v Speaker 1>Brandon Barr. If you liked this episode, leave us a review, subscribe,

0:27:37.205 --> 0:27:39.965
<v Speaker 1>Do All the Things. Also, you can find the podcast

0:27:40.085 --> 0:27:57.245
<v Speaker 1>on Instagram at American Filth Pod. Follow me please, School

0:27:57.245 --> 0:27:59.125
<v Speaker 1>of Humans