WEBVTT - Palmer Luckey: “Steve Jobs Ruined Everything with the iPhone”

0:00:09.760 --> 0:00:14.100
<v Speaker 1>The Builders is a production of Kaleidoscope and iHeart, presented

0:00:14.260 --> 0:00:18.860
<v Speaker 1>by Ramp. Ramp is a financial operations platform that helps

0:00:18.960 --> 0:00:23.120
<v Speaker 1>ambitious companies manage their finances so their teams can spend

0:00:23.180 --> 0:00:26.980
<v Speaker 1>less time chasing receipts and approvals and more time bringing

0:00:27.120 --> 0:00:32.019
<v Speaker 1>extraordinary ideas to life. I'm Walter Isaacs, and welcome to

0:00:32.040 --> 0:00:36.280
<v Speaker 1>The Builders, my series of conversations with the most consequential

0:00:36.360 --> 0:00:41.080
<v Speaker 1>minds shaping our future. Today, I'm speaking with Palmer Luckey.

0:00:41.479 --> 0:00:44.120
<v Speaker 2>Andrel Industries founder, Palmer Luckey.

0:00:44.280 --> 0:00:47.520
<v Speaker 3>His name is Luckey, and he is worth a good fortune.

0:00:47.620 --> 0:00:49.840
<v Speaker 2>Who's this Palmer Luckey?

0:00:49.979 --> 0:00:51.260
<v Speaker 3>Who is Palmer Luckey?

0:00:52.659 --> 0:00:57.650
<v Speaker 1>Palmer Luckey is an old-school garage inventor. He has the

0:00:57.730 --> 0:01:02.030
<v Speaker 1>imagination of somebody raised on video games, and he takes

0:01:02.070 --> 0:01:07.020
<v Speaker 1>it almost childlike pleasure in making futuristic things real.

0:01:07.790 --> 0:01:09.429
<v Speaker 3>That spirit helped.

0:01:09.250 --> 0:01:13.450
<v Speaker 1>Him build the Oculus Rift, the virtual reality headset that

0:01:13.470 --> 0:01:16.450
<v Speaker 1>was bought by Facebook in 2014.

0:01:16.450 --> 0:01:17.000
<v Speaker 2>In the world of.

0:01:16.959 --> 0:01:20.360
<v Speaker 4>Silicon Valley, Palmer Luckey is known as a VR wonder kid,

0:01:20.800 --> 0:01:23.000
<v Speaker 4>the inventor of the Oculus, and he sold to Facebook

0:01:23.020 --> 0:01:25.399
<v Speaker 4>for $ 2 billion.

0:01:24.540 --> 0:01:25.980
<v Speaker 2>At the age of 21.

0:01:25.980 --> 0:01:29.580
<v Speaker 1>But a few years later, Palmer was ousted from Facebook,

0:01:29.920 --> 0:01:35.270
<v Speaker 1>and he turned his attention to something very different, military technology.

0:01:35.770 --> 0:01:39.770
<v Speaker 4>He has pivoted to an entirely different domain, founding Anduril,

0:01:40.230 --> 0:01:43.670
<v Speaker 4>arguably the most disruptive defense contracting company in.

0:01:43.630 --> 0:01:44.449
<v Speaker 1>The United States.

0:01:44.890 --> 0:01:47.110
<v Speaker 2>Some call his weapons killer robots.

0:01:47.390 --> 0:01:49.590
<v Speaker 4>He says they are the future of warfare.

0:01:50.660 --> 0:01:56.140
<v Speaker 1>Instead of creating virtual worlds, his company Anduril uses artificial

0:01:56.200 --> 0:02:01.060
<v Speaker 1>intelligence to decipher and act in the real world. Autonomous

0:02:01.160 --> 0:02:06.760
<v Speaker 1>drones and missiles, surveillance towers, fighter aircrafts. And recently, he's

0:02:06.920 --> 0:02:10.250
<v Speaker 1>teamed up with the Department of War in a new initiative.

0:02:10.820 --> 0:02:17.549
<v Speaker 5>Today, at my direction, I'm announcing Project Meridian, co-led by

0:02:17.650 --> 0:02:23.769
<v Speaker 5>three of our nation's best minds, Elon Musk, Palmer Luckey,

0:02:24.690 --> 0:02:25.410
<v Speaker 5>and Newt Gingrich.

0:02:26.820 --> 0:02:31.840
<v Speaker 1>Project Meridian aims to study the future of warfare. And

0:02:31.880 --> 0:02:36.350
<v Speaker 1>within a week of the announcement, Luckey's company, Andoril, announced

0:02:36.450 --> 0:02:39.930
<v Speaker 1>a $ 6. 6 billion partnership with the U.S.

0:02:40.010 --> 0:02:40.370
<v Speaker 6>Navy.

0:02:41.610 --> 0:02:45.769
<v Speaker 1>Palmer Luckey's work has gone from the virtual world to

0:02:45.810 --> 0:02:50.690
<v Speaker 1>the real world, and it raises critical questions. Can autonomous

0:02:50.810 --> 0:02:55.239
<v Speaker 1>weapons make war more precise and protect lives? Or will

0:02:55.290 --> 0:02:59.179
<v Speaker 1>it just make killing easier and more distant? If an

0:02:59.320 --> 0:03:04.570
<v Speaker 1>artificial intelligence system identifies a target, Who's responsible for the

0:03:04.610 --> 0:03:08.440
<v Speaker 1>decision to strike? And what happens when wars begin moving

0:03:08.540 --> 0:03:14.799
<v Speaker 1>faster than human beings can think? Here's my conversation with

0:03:14.900 --> 0:03:15.760
<v Speaker 1>Palmer Luckey.

0:03:18.919 --> 0:03:20.680
<v Speaker 3>Welcome to the builders. Thanks for being here.

0:03:20.780 --> 0:03:21.519
<v Speaker 2>Thank you for having me.

0:03:22.160 --> 0:03:25.780
<v Speaker 1>You were homeschooled by your mom. Tell me how that

0:03:25.840 --> 0:03:29.329
<v Speaker 1>affected your emotional and friendship education.

0:03:29.830 --> 0:03:32.880
<v Speaker 2>Oh, that's an interesting one. Um, I mean, friendship-wise, I

0:03:32.900 --> 0:03:35.140
<v Speaker 2>had a lot of friends who were homeschooled. I had

0:03:35.160 --> 0:03:37.240
<v Speaker 2>a lot of friends who were in the neighborhood. I

0:03:37.280 --> 0:03:42.080
<v Speaker 2>also did a lot of sports. And so I'd say friendship-wise,

0:03:42.100 --> 0:03:44.660
<v Speaker 2>it worked out perfectly fine. Education-wise, I also think it

0:03:44.680 --> 0:03:47.420
<v Speaker 2>worked out pretty well. When you're 14, 15 years old,

0:03:47.780 --> 0:03:50.220
<v Speaker 2>you're taking all your high school credits at the same

0:03:50.260 --> 0:03:52.700
<v Speaker 2>time as you're taking your college credits. All of a sudden,

0:03:52.740 --> 0:03:54.440
<v Speaker 2>you have the power to manage your own time. And

0:03:54.460 --> 0:03:57.200
<v Speaker 2>you realize if I can be efficient in learning what

0:03:57.260 --> 0:03:59.940
<v Speaker 2>I need to, efficient in passing my tests, efficient in

0:03:59.960 --> 0:04:01.980
<v Speaker 2>my homework, then I've got all the rest of my

0:04:02.040 --> 0:04:04.300
<v Speaker 2>time to work on what I'm passionate about. And in

0:04:04.720 --> 0:04:08.280
<v Speaker 2>my case, it was virtual reality technology. So it's very

0:04:08.460 --> 0:04:11.690
<v Speaker 2>obvious to me that Oculus, my first company, wouldn't exist

0:04:12.040 --> 0:04:13.170
<v Speaker 2>if I had not been homeschooled.

0:04:13.810 --> 0:04:16.710
<v Speaker 1>To what extent were your friends virtual friends and how

0:04:16.730 --> 0:04:17.710
<v Speaker 1>did that change things?

0:04:18.290 --> 0:04:21.350
<v Speaker 2>When I was younger, I had lots of in-person friends.

0:04:21.370 --> 0:04:23.290
<v Speaker 2>And then it was as I got older, probably the

0:04:23.850 --> 0:04:26.440
<v Speaker 2>people that I was closest to were people that I

0:04:26.500 --> 0:04:29.900
<v Speaker 2>knew through the internet and through my online community for

0:04:30.260 --> 0:04:35.580
<v Speaker 2>electronics enthusiasts called ModRetro, combining modern technology with vintage computers,

0:04:35.620 --> 0:04:39.320
<v Speaker 2>vintage game consoles, things like that. Interesting fact, when I

0:04:39.380 --> 0:04:43.460
<v Speaker 2>started Oculus, most of the early hardware engineers were the

0:04:43.640 --> 0:04:47.560
<v Speaker 2>other moderators and administrators of the ModRetro forums, which I started.

0:04:47.950 --> 0:04:49.470
<v Speaker 2>They were the people that I knew the best, that

0:04:49.510 --> 0:04:51.550
<v Speaker 2>I trusted the most, and I knew they knew their

0:04:51.610 --> 0:04:53.070
<v Speaker 2>stuff on the electronic side, too.

0:04:53.510 --> 0:04:56.790
<v Speaker 1>And you got this guy, Chris, right, who you'd never

0:04:56.870 --> 0:04:58.190
<v Speaker 1>really met before in person.

0:04:58.210 --> 0:04:58.570
<v Speaker 3>That's right.

0:04:59.150 --> 0:05:03.130
<v Speaker 2>Yeah, Chris Dykus was the first employee of Oculus. I

0:05:03.170 --> 0:05:06.940
<v Speaker 2>gave him a call on a Friday, and I said, hey, Chris,

0:05:07.510 --> 0:05:10.779
<v Speaker 2>what are you doing next month? He said, oh, I'm

0:05:10.839 --> 0:05:13.339
<v Speaker 2>getting a job at this local pizza place, and I'm

0:05:13.420 --> 0:05:15.060
<v Speaker 2>studying for these courses I'm going to take. I'm going

0:05:15.080 --> 0:05:17.659
<v Speaker 2>to start college in the fall. I said, no, you're not.

0:05:17.900 --> 0:05:19.340
<v Speaker 2>You're going to come work with me, and we're going

0:05:19.360 --> 0:05:22.550
<v Speaker 2>to build virtual reality headsets at Oculus. But, I mean,

0:05:22.950 --> 0:05:24.550
<v Speaker 2>that was what I was doing when I was a teenager,

0:05:24.650 --> 0:05:26.690
<v Speaker 2>and most kids would not get the opportunity to do that.

0:05:27.200 --> 0:05:31.920
<v Speaker 1>Elon Musk was really affected by reading sci-fi and certain

0:05:31.980 --> 0:05:33.460
<v Speaker 1>comic books, superhero comics.

0:05:33.870 --> 0:05:36.350
<v Speaker 3>What did you read as a kid that affected you

0:05:36.390 --> 0:05:36.770
<v Speaker 3>that way?

0:05:37.650 --> 0:05:40.870
<v Speaker 2>I was a big fan of science fiction that really

0:05:40.930 --> 0:05:44.810
<v Speaker 2>focused on the technology itself. I guess one good example

0:05:44.870 --> 0:05:47.830
<v Speaker 2>is Jules Verne wrote 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea. And

0:05:47.850 --> 0:05:52.270
<v Speaker 2>it's very obvious reading it that his goal was not

0:05:52.310 --> 0:05:54.620
<v Speaker 2>to tell a story about It was to create a

0:05:54.700 --> 0:05:57.260
<v Speaker 2>setting through which he could talk about what he thought

0:05:57.310 --> 0:06:00.510
<v Speaker 2>the future of maritime technology was. I mean, you're talking

0:06:00.990 --> 0:06:05.470
<v Speaker 2>a dozen pages in a row detailing the battery technology

0:06:05.529 --> 0:06:08.790
<v Speaker 2>of the Nautilus and how it was recharged by extracting

0:06:08.850 --> 0:06:11.390
<v Speaker 2>mineral elements from the seafloor and how Captain Nemo was

0:06:11.450 --> 0:06:14.270
<v Speaker 2>processing them. It was kind of a delivery vehicle for,

0:06:14.290 --> 0:06:17.980
<v Speaker 2>you know, maybe three dozen different ideas that he had

0:06:18.060 --> 0:06:21.060
<v Speaker 2>and he wove a narrative around them. I've always loved

0:06:21.100 --> 0:06:23.500
<v Speaker 2>that sort of story because it lets you think, What

0:06:23.560 --> 0:06:26.240
<v Speaker 2>would the world look like if we had things we

0:06:26.279 --> 0:06:29.040
<v Speaker 2>don't now? It was the same reason I liked Star Trek,

0:06:29.080 --> 0:06:29.980
<v Speaker 2>even though it's communist.

0:06:30.580 --> 0:06:33.680
<v Speaker 1>But was there anything in sci-fi that you said, that's cool,

0:06:33.720 --> 0:06:34.280
<v Speaker 1>let me do it?

0:06:34.760 --> 0:06:38.340
<v Speaker 2>I mean, I think it kind of goes without saying,

0:06:38.400 --> 0:06:41.020
<v Speaker 2>it was the concept of virtual reality. That was one

0:06:41.040 --> 0:06:44.620
<v Speaker 2>of the technologies where it really grabbed me. It was

0:06:44.690 --> 0:06:48.650
<v Speaker 2>so interesting because it was so clearly not realized. But

0:06:48.690 --> 0:06:52.140
<v Speaker 2>this idea that you could build technology that would trick

0:06:52.370 --> 0:06:56.130
<v Speaker 2>your own peripheral nervous system into believing that it was

0:06:56.290 --> 0:06:58.150
<v Speaker 2>in a place that it was not. And basically that

0:06:58.170 --> 0:07:00.010
<v Speaker 2>you could build a mirror image of a person where

0:07:00.050 --> 0:07:02.050
<v Speaker 2>a person is taking in data. If you could build

0:07:02.089 --> 0:07:05.410
<v Speaker 2>this perfect simulator of that data, so good that it

0:07:05.450 --> 0:07:08.370
<v Speaker 2>can convince your lizard brain that you've been transported into

0:07:08.430 --> 0:07:11.790
<v Speaker 2>a digital world of your own or someone else's creation.

0:07:12.240 --> 0:07:14.880
<v Speaker 2>That's a really entrancing idea for a technologist. And so

0:07:15.260 --> 0:07:17.880
<v Speaker 2>it is a lot of fun to be around at

0:07:17.920 --> 0:07:20.760
<v Speaker 2>that moment where technology advances to the point where you

0:07:20.810 --> 0:07:24.650
<v Speaker 2>can turn something that was science fiction into science fact.

0:07:25.090 --> 0:07:27.470
<v Speaker 2>And luckily, I was born at the right time for

0:07:27.530 --> 0:07:29.590
<v Speaker 2>that to be the case with virtual reality. I could

0:07:29.610 --> 0:07:32.600
<v Speaker 2>have been as passionate as I wanted, but had I

0:07:32.650 --> 0:07:34.800
<v Speaker 2>been born 20 years earlier, I never would have made

0:07:34.880 --> 0:07:35.440
<v Speaker 2>Oculus work.

0:07:36.020 --> 0:07:40.000
<v Speaker 1>I have a theory about advances in technology is that

0:07:40.060 --> 0:07:43.820
<v Speaker 1>the greatest advances are those that are the human computer

0:07:43.900 --> 0:07:47.680
<v Speaker 1>interface or the human machine, how it puts together. And

0:07:47.740 --> 0:07:52.470
<v Speaker 1>VR seems part of that process, maybe culminating with Neuralink and.

0:07:52.430 --> 0:07:53.430
<v Speaker 3>Chips in our brain.

0:07:53.900 --> 0:07:57.550
<v Speaker 1>Do you see that as part of the main goal

0:07:57.890 --> 0:08:00.730
<v Speaker 1>of technology is how to interface with humans? Or do

0:08:00.770 --> 0:08:02.650
<v Speaker 1>you see it as something that might run off without

0:08:02.750 --> 0:08:03.570
<v Speaker 1>us and not need us?

0:08:04.510 --> 0:08:07.150
<v Speaker 2>To be honest, I think the entire industry has gone

0:08:07.170 --> 0:08:11.710
<v Speaker 2>in completely the wrong direction. It's been a folly. And

0:08:12.090 --> 0:08:15.450
<v Speaker 2>Steve Jobs, love the guy, but it was the iPhone

0:08:15.470 --> 0:08:18.610
<v Speaker 2>that started all of this. Prior to the iPhone, there

0:08:18.650 --> 0:08:23.620
<v Speaker 2>was an understanding that technology was something that could multiply

0:08:23.680 --> 0:08:26.510
<v Speaker 2>your output, that you could leverage it to work in

0:08:26.630 --> 0:08:30.300
<v Speaker 2>superhuman ways. And Steve Jobs believed this. He famously called

0:08:30.320 --> 0:08:32.980
<v Speaker 2>a computer a bicycle for the mind, to allow you

0:08:33.000 --> 0:08:35.620
<v Speaker 2>to accomplish things much more efficiently, to cover much more

0:08:35.679 --> 0:08:39.309
<v Speaker 2>ground than you would unaided. The problem with the iPhone

0:08:40.090 --> 0:08:43.890
<v Speaker 2>is that it simplified everything to a degree where, yes,

0:08:44.470 --> 0:08:46.910
<v Speaker 2>you could learn to use it in less than a minute.

0:08:47.380 --> 0:08:50.040
<v Speaker 2>You could learn to use it to the fullest of

0:08:50.100 --> 0:08:53.800
<v Speaker 2>its capability in about 10 minutes. But then you reach

0:08:53.840 --> 0:08:56.640
<v Speaker 2>the ceiling, the skill ceiling for using it. And the

0:08:56.679 --> 0:08:59.240
<v Speaker 2>productivity ceiling was very, very low. You reached it very,

0:08:59.260 --> 0:09:03.170
<v Speaker 2>very quickly. Compare that with, for example, a keyboard. A

0:09:03.210 --> 0:09:08.670
<v Speaker 2>keyboard requires weeks or months of consistent focused training in

0:09:08.850 --> 0:09:10.880
<v Speaker 2>order to be able to achieve a high rate of speed,

0:09:11.120 --> 0:09:14.220
<v Speaker 2>a high rate of accuracy in order to be able to,

0:09:14.400 --> 0:09:18.079
<v Speaker 2>especially like to learn lots of key macros for running Excel,

0:09:18.100 --> 0:09:20.900
<v Speaker 2>you know, where I can learn to not just type words,

0:09:20.940 --> 0:09:25.610
<v Speaker 2>but even have complex mathematical interactions and notation input by

0:09:25.630 --> 0:09:28.260
<v Speaker 2>the same device. Now, Yes, I have to train for months,

0:09:28.300 --> 0:09:29.319
<v Speaker 2>but what do I get at the end of that?

0:09:29.700 --> 0:09:32.580
<v Speaker 2>I get a superhuman input device where I can put

0:09:32.940 --> 0:09:35.480
<v Speaker 2>words into the computer as fast as I can speak

0:09:35.940 --> 0:09:40.500
<v Speaker 2>wordlessly and with an extremely high level of accuracy, no ambiguity,

0:09:40.780 --> 0:09:43.980
<v Speaker 2>perfectly easy to reproduce. I can do a compact keyboard,

0:09:44.020 --> 0:09:46.980
<v Speaker 2>a full-size keyboard. I can do incredible things. I would

0:09:47.000 --> 0:09:49.599
<v Speaker 2>say the keyboard is the ultimate version of a superhuman

0:09:49.640 --> 0:09:52.420
<v Speaker 2>interface that allows you to do things far beyond a

0:09:52.460 --> 0:09:55.070
<v Speaker 2>level of performance that you'd expect from a person. And

0:09:55.210 --> 0:09:58.500
<v Speaker 2>a iPhone with a touchscreen is this very easy to

0:09:58.559 --> 0:10:00.300
<v Speaker 2>use device that does not have a high skill ceiling.

0:10:01.280 --> 0:10:04.540
<v Speaker 2>The problem is that everything has become the iPhone. Every

0:10:04.620 --> 0:10:08.100
<v Speaker 2>application is now the iPhone. Every product is the iPhone.

0:10:08.420 --> 0:10:11.480
<v Speaker 2>Every virtual reality headset is the iPhone. They are systems

0:10:11.500 --> 0:10:12.990
<v Speaker 2>that are made to be easy to learn in the

0:10:13.040 --> 0:10:18.120
<v Speaker 2>first minute, mastered within 10 minutes. And there's no provision

0:10:18.160 --> 0:10:21.090
<v Speaker 2>made for the man who will spend a thousand hours,

0:10:21.090 --> 0:10:26.550
<v Speaker 2>10,000 hours, 50,000 hours learning his art. There's nothing more

0:10:26.600 --> 0:10:29.300
<v Speaker 2>to be had. And so personally, what I would love

0:10:29.320 --> 0:10:33.060
<v Speaker 2>to see is a return to applications, and also input

0:10:33.100 --> 0:10:36.770
<v Speaker 2>devices and human to computer interaction schemes that combine the

0:10:36.809 --> 0:10:40.690
<v Speaker 2>two that say, you know what, this scheme, like a keyboard,

0:10:41.030 --> 0:10:46.190
<v Speaker 2>will require months, maybe years of training to become truly proficient.

0:10:46.429 --> 0:10:47.600
<v Speaker 2>But what you get out of it at the end

0:10:47.760 --> 0:10:51.140
<v Speaker 2>will be something that is superhuman to an ultimate degree.

0:10:51.300 --> 0:10:54.520
<v Speaker 2>What writing is to the keyboard, the keyboard will be

0:10:54.580 --> 0:10:57.340
<v Speaker 2>to this. And I've got some ideas around that, but

0:10:57.360 --> 0:11:00.500
<v Speaker 2>I'll even say things like Neuralink, certain brain to computer interfaces.

0:11:00.590 --> 0:11:02.110
<v Speaker 3>I see the same mistakes being made.

0:11:02.530 --> 0:11:06.190
<v Speaker 2>Everybody wants a magical human to computer interface where you

0:11:06.230 --> 0:11:08.490
<v Speaker 2>can use it and you don't have to train. You

0:11:08.510 --> 0:11:11.130
<v Speaker 2>don't have to learn. You can just use it immediately.

0:11:11.190 --> 0:11:13.480
<v Speaker 2>I put something on and I'm immediately controlling the computer

0:11:13.500 --> 0:11:15.760
<v Speaker 2>with it. But is that really what we need? Do

0:11:15.980 --> 0:11:19.059
<v Speaker 2>we need to use this wondrous technology to have a

0:11:19.200 --> 0:11:22.040
<v Speaker 2>different way of clicking a few buttons and operating an

0:11:22.140 --> 0:11:25.710
<v Speaker 2>iPhone interface? Or do we want to completely supplant that

0:11:25.970 --> 0:11:29.110
<v Speaker 2>and move into a next generation of interaction that surpasses

0:11:29.170 --> 0:11:32.770
<v Speaker 2>our wildest imagination. Unfortunately, like I said, Steve Jobs ruined

0:11:32.809 --> 0:11:35.830
<v Speaker 2>everything with the iPhone. We're still suffering the impacts of

0:11:35.890 --> 0:11:40.179
<v Speaker 2>his incredible product design. And I'm hoping it comes back

0:11:40.220 --> 0:11:40.960
<v Speaker 2>around someday.

0:11:41.580 --> 0:11:43.400
<v Speaker 1>Well, let me push back on you a little bit,

0:11:43.440 --> 0:11:47.930
<v Speaker 1>because when you created Oculus Rift, It was indeed in

0:11:47.950 --> 0:11:51.830
<v Speaker 1>the tradition of a Steve Jobs. It's totally intuitive and

0:11:51.890 --> 0:11:53.590
<v Speaker 1>you just interface with the computer.

0:11:54.150 --> 0:11:57.829
<v Speaker 2>Absolutely. I think it doesn't contradict what I'm saying. I

0:11:57.850 --> 0:12:00.130
<v Speaker 2>just realized I was part of the problem. I made

0:12:00.150 --> 0:12:04.490
<v Speaker 2>a product with a very low barrier to entry, very

0:12:04.590 --> 0:12:07.630
<v Speaker 2>low skill ceiling. Anyone could use it. And then I

0:12:07.670 --> 0:12:09.410
<v Speaker 2>sold a lot of them. And I think it's because

0:12:09.450 --> 0:12:12.820
<v Speaker 2>of that. What's the right way to put this? I

0:12:12.840 --> 0:12:16.020
<v Speaker 2>can recognize that it's easier to make a successful product

0:12:16.200 --> 0:12:18.400
<v Speaker 2>when you follow the iPhone model. And then I can

0:12:18.500 --> 0:12:22.939
<v Speaker 2>still lament the impact on humanity of that. Because what

0:12:22.960 --> 0:12:24.700
<v Speaker 2>a world we could live in if people were willing

0:12:24.740 --> 0:12:29.880
<v Speaker 2>to invest time into their computer interactivity skills the same

0:12:29.940 --> 0:12:35.520
<v Speaker 2>way they invest in, let's say, sport or dance or piano.

0:12:35.940 --> 0:12:37.730
<v Speaker 2>I think you'd see some incredible things come of it,

0:12:37.840 --> 0:12:38.960
<v Speaker 2>even if it wasn't for everybody.

0:12:39.730 --> 0:12:42.310
<v Speaker 1>When it came time to sell Oculus, I know you

0:12:42.350 --> 0:12:44.870
<v Speaker 1>want that, eager to do so, but you had a

0:12:44.890 --> 0:12:48.500
<v Speaker 1>few choices. You had Microsoft, you had Google, you had Facebook.

0:12:48.860 --> 0:12:51.300
<v Speaker 1>Why was Facebook the more obvious fit?

0:12:52.820 --> 0:12:58.179
<v Speaker 2>The thing you have to remember about 2014 when this

0:12:58.200 --> 0:13:02.699
<v Speaker 2>decision was going around is that all of these companies

0:13:02.740 --> 0:13:05.740
<v Speaker 2>were in very different places than they are today, strategically.

0:13:07.059 --> 0:13:11.550
<v Speaker 2>And at the time, companies like Google and Microsoft had

0:13:11.570 --> 0:13:15.870
<v Speaker 2>10-year plans that really didn't involve VR. In other words,

0:13:16.750 --> 0:13:20.199
<v Speaker 2>they were not betting that VR would succeed or certainly

0:13:20.220 --> 0:13:22.160
<v Speaker 2>not betting that it needed to succeed, right? It was

0:13:22.200 --> 0:13:25.699
<v Speaker 2>another part of a gigantic empire. But, you know, I

0:13:25.760 --> 0:13:29.140
<v Speaker 2>like Microsoft. I'm a huge Windows power user. But I

0:13:29.220 --> 0:13:33.729
<v Speaker 2>recognize that the thing Microsoft needs to succeed is Microsoft Office,

0:13:33.780 --> 0:13:38.110
<v Speaker 2>Microsoft Windows. It's not virtual reality as this new computing medium.

0:13:38.679 --> 0:13:40.460
<v Speaker 2>And the same was true of Google. Now, Facebook was

0:13:40.500 --> 0:13:44.340
<v Speaker 2>in a different position. Facebook didn't have their own operating system.

0:13:44.740 --> 0:13:47.520
<v Speaker 2>They didn't control their own hardware platform. They were completely

0:13:47.580 --> 0:13:50.920
<v Speaker 2>subservient to the people who did control these technology platforms.

0:13:51.330 --> 0:13:54.510
<v Speaker 2>And so the pitch from Facebook was, hey, if you

0:13:54.570 --> 0:13:57.870
<v Speaker 2>sell to these other companies, they're just going to use

0:13:57.890 --> 0:14:01.250
<v Speaker 2>you as another business line. And if you make money, great.

0:14:01.490 --> 0:14:05.790
<v Speaker 2>If not, they'll take you apart for pieces. Whereas Facebook

0:14:06.290 --> 0:14:09.400
<v Speaker 2>needs you to succeed. If we buy you, we are

0:14:09.440 --> 0:14:12.200
<v Speaker 2>going to invest as much money as it takes to

0:14:12.559 --> 0:14:16.260
<v Speaker 2>jump from this current computing paradigm into a future where

0:14:16.320 --> 0:14:19.390
<v Speaker 2>augmented reality and virtual reality are the future. And there's

0:14:19.430 --> 0:14:21.850
<v Speaker 2>also kind of this belief, if you've got Facebook on

0:14:21.870 --> 0:14:24.780
<v Speaker 2>the bottom of the ecosystems, and you kind of shake

0:14:24.860 --> 0:14:28.540
<v Speaker 2>up the whole ecosystem with a new computing revolution. Maybe

0:14:28.560 --> 0:14:30.840
<v Speaker 2>Facebook doesn't come out in first place, but they're probably

0:14:30.860 --> 0:14:32.740
<v Speaker 2>not on the bottom, right? They probably move up a

0:14:32.800 --> 0:14:36.980
<v Speaker 2>number of places in the process relative to Apple and

0:14:37.380 --> 0:14:40.340
<v Speaker 2>Google and Microsoft and the like. And so their pitch

0:14:40.380 --> 0:14:44.890
<v Speaker 2>was specifically, if you sell to us, we will put

0:14:44.890 --> 0:14:48.590
<v Speaker 2>$ 1 billion per year into research and development for the

0:14:48.630 --> 0:14:52.290
<v Speaker 2>next 10 years, guaranteed. And when you start running the

0:14:52.330 --> 0:14:55.380
<v Speaker 2>numbers on that, and how much of your company you

0:14:55.400 --> 0:14:58.620
<v Speaker 2>would need to sell to raise $ 10 billion to money

0:14:58.660 --> 0:15:01.420
<v Speaker 2>to R &amp; D, you realize that's a pretty incredible

0:15:01.440 --> 0:15:04.340
<v Speaker 2>deal as a technologist. And the funny thing is, over

0:15:04.400 --> 0:15:07.680
<v Speaker 2>the next 10 years, they didn't spend $ 10 billion. They

0:15:07.710 --> 0:15:12.610
<v Speaker 2>spent about $ 70 billion. And so the theory has proven out.

0:15:12.650 --> 0:15:15.130
<v Speaker 2>They really do believe in this. They do want it

0:15:15.170 --> 0:15:17.470
<v Speaker 2>to pan out. They need it to pan out. And

0:15:17.490 --> 0:15:19.890
<v Speaker 2>I think that if we had sold to Google... or Microsoft.

0:15:19.910 --> 0:15:21.190
<v Speaker 2>That isn't the case. I mean, I don't want to

0:15:21.210 --> 0:15:23.660
<v Speaker 2>throw Google under the bus here, but Google shut down

0:15:23.700 --> 0:15:26.740
<v Speaker 2>their VR program about a year and a half after

0:15:26.780 --> 0:15:29.040
<v Speaker 2>we were acquired, right? They were competing in VR. They

0:15:29.080 --> 0:15:31.770
<v Speaker 2>decided not to. Then they restarted again a few years later,

0:15:31.790 --> 0:15:34.450
<v Speaker 2>and then they killed that one too. And so it's,

0:15:34.930 --> 0:15:37.110
<v Speaker 2>I think that if Oculus had been purchased by Google,

0:15:38.490 --> 0:15:40.450
<v Speaker 2>nine times out of ten, we would have been shut

0:15:40.490 --> 0:15:41.570
<v Speaker 2>down and not gone anywhere.

0:15:41.690 --> 0:15:45.410
<v Speaker 1>Yeah, but Meta just recently laid off 10% of its

0:15:45.570 --> 0:15:48.910
<v Speaker 1>virtual augmented reality force, and they don't seem to be

0:15:48.950 --> 0:15:50.750
<v Speaker 1>making it into a great consumer product.

0:15:51.070 --> 0:15:53.530
<v Speaker 2>Well, so there's two things to unpack there. One is

0:15:54.270 --> 0:15:57.270
<v Speaker 2>great consumer product. And I think, first of all, most

0:15:57.290 --> 0:16:00.090
<v Speaker 2>of the money they're spending is on research and development

0:16:00.170 --> 0:16:03.790
<v Speaker 2>of next-gen AR, VR technologies that you don't necessarily get

0:16:03.840 --> 0:16:07.200
<v Speaker 2>to see the fruit of that until it eventually makes

0:16:07.240 --> 0:16:10.010
<v Speaker 2>it into products. They've spent many billions on things that

0:16:10.170 --> 0:16:13.790
<v Speaker 2>are important and will be important. Things like fundamental understanding

0:16:13.880 --> 0:16:16.119
<v Speaker 2>of how to build certain types of optics, how to

0:16:16.140 --> 0:16:18.880
<v Speaker 2>build certain types of cameras, build certain types of computing systems.

0:16:19.400 --> 0:16:21.560
<v Speaker 2>And you just don't get to see that until it

0:16:21.580 --> 0:16:23.880
<v Speaker 2>gets into a product. Now, like you look at things

0:16:23.900 --> 0:16:27.980
<v Speaker 2>like MetaHorizons, that's a terrible product. Everyone agrees. awful product.

0:16:28.000 --> 0:16:29.180
<v Speaker 2>I think even the people who work on it know

0:16:29.220 --> 0:16:31.940
<v Speaker 2>it's an awful product. And I'm teamed up with Meta,

0:16:31.980 --> 0:16:33.740
<v Speaker 2>and I don't think that they even mind me saying

0:16:33.820 --> 0:16:36.780
<v Speaker 2>it's a pretty bad product. But I don't think you

0:16:36.800 --> 0:16:38.980
<v Speaker 2>can look at that product and the mistakes that were

0:16:39.020 --> 0:16:41.160
<v Speaker 2>made there and see it as representative of the whole thing.

0:16:41.180 --> 0:16:43.700
<v Speaker 2>And you're right, they did just lay off about 10%

0:16:43.700 --> 0:16:46.650
<v Speaker 2>of Reality Labs. But I can't see that as an

0:16:46.690 --> 0:16:50.280
<v Speaker 2>indication that they're abandoning VR because, well, two things. One,

0:16:50.500 --> 0:16:53.760
<v Speaker 2>they've still got 90% of it. And that 90% is

0:16:53.840 --> 0:16:57.180
<v Speaker 2>literally 10 times bigger than the next biggest VR team.

0:16:57.410 --> 0:17:00.130
<v Speaker 2>I mean, so they are larger by an order of

0:17:00.250 --> 0:17:04.740
<v Speaker 2>magnitude post layoffs than the next closest competition. And so

0:17:04.760 --> 0:17:06.900
<v Speaker 2>what I've seen people say, oh, they've lost faith in VR.

0:17:06.940 --> 0:17:09.500
<v Speaker 2>They're moving on. My point is, how could you say that?

0:17:09.540 --> 0:17:11.860
<v Speaker 2>They clearly still believe in it more than anybody. They've

0:17:11.900 --> 0:17:15.280
<v Speaker 2>spent more than anybody. They've made an adjustment where they

0:17:15.300 --> 0:17:17.960
<v Speaker 2>laid off people. And remember that these jobs are focused

0:17:18.030 --> 0:17:21.189
<v Speaker 2>in a few specific areas. For example, they've decided that

0:17:21.210 --> 0:17:23.590
<v Speaker 2>they are not going to be in the business anymore

0:17:24.010 --> 0:17:28.730
<v Speaker 2>of building first party gaming applications that compete against other developers.

0:17:29.010 --> 0:17:30.649
<v Speaker 2>So they said, wait, OK, we're not going to be

0:17:30.670 --> 0:17:33.850
<v Speaker 2>in the business of competing with Ubisoft and and Rockstar

0:17:34.390 --> 0:17:37.330
<v Speaker 2>and Capcom. We're just going to work with them instead

0:17:37.369 --> 0:17:40.129
<v Speaker 2>of kind of being the platform we're trying to attract

0:17:40.150 --> 0:17:42.770
<v Speaker 2>them to and also competing with them on first party titles.

0:17:43.290 --> 0:17:45.490
<v Speaker 2>And I actually totally agree with that decision. When I

0:17:45.530 --> 0:17:48.790
<v Speaker 2>was at Oculus, that was actually my strong position. I

0:17:49.109 --> 0:17:52.330
<v Speaker 2>always said we can't afford to be the Nintendo of VR.

0:17:52.590 --> 0:17:54.470
<v Speaker 2>Like we can't bet that we are going to build

0:17:54.510 --> 0:17:56.790
<v Speaker 2>all the games people want. We need to work with everybody.

0:17:56.830 --> 0:17:59.190
<v Speaker 2>We need to build an ecosystem, a platform that helps

0:17:59.260 --> 0:18:03.300
<v Speaker 2>everyone succeed. We need a self-sustaining ecosystem, not one where

0:18:03.340 --> 0:18:06.300
<v Speaker 2>we just build everything ourselves. It was after I was

0:18:06.380 --> 0:18:09.570
<v Speaker 2>fired that that really changed. And so, yeah, all the

0:18:09.590 --> 0:18:11.169
<v Speaker 2>people who were doing that got laid off. And I

0:18:11.210 --> 0:18:13.889
<v Speaker 2>feel bad for people in that position because, you know,

0:18:13.930 --> 0:18:16.389
<v Speaker 2>it's their livelihood at stake. But at the same time,

0:18:17.070 --> 0:18:20.490
<v Speaker 2>recognizing it was the right decision for the virtual reality ecosystem,

0:18:20.710 --> 0:18:22.550
<v Speaker 2>I think it'll make it stronger in the long run

0:18:22.790 --> 0:18:27.280
<v Speaker 2>to not have the biggest VR company competing with the

0:18:27.320 --> 0:18:30.420
<v Speaker 2>video game developers that they need to attract to their platforms.

0:18:30.980 --> 0:18:33.439
<v Speaker 1>You seem pretty passionate about it. Let me ask you

0:18:33.480 --> 0:18:35.979
<v Speaker 1>to reflect. Do you kind of wish you were still

0:18:36.359 --> 0:18:36.899
<v Speaker 1>at Meta?

0:18:38.500 --> 0:18:40.879
<v Speaker 2>I think kind of wish is the right way to

0:18:40.920 --> 0:18:43.460
<v Speaker 2>put it. I really enjoy what I'm doing at Anduril.

0:18:43.740 --> 0:18:46.400
<v Speaker 2>I think that it's making a huge difference. I think

0:18:46.440 --> 0:18:49.040
<v Speaker 2>it's making a bigger difference than I would currently be

0:18:49.080 --> 0:18:52.869
<v Speaker 2>making in the VR industry. You also have to consider,

0:18:54.490 --> 0:18:56.270
<v Speaker 2>it's more than just do you wish you were still

0:18:56.310 --> 0:18:59.440
<v Speaker 2>at Oculus? Because If you were to put me into Oculus,

0:18:59.480 --> 0:19:02.720
<v Speaker 2>it wouldn't solve a lot of the underlying problems. For example,

0:19:03.200 --> 0:19:07.070
<v Speaker 2>most people in the Bay Area are very, very much

0:19:07.150 --> 0:19:09.810
<v Speaker 2>on the other side of me politically and they hate

0:19:09.850 --> 0:19:11.939
<v Speaker 2>me and they don't want to work with me. And

0:19:11.980 --> 0:19:14.400
<v Speaker 2>so there's an interesting– do I wish I were back? No,

0:19:14.420 --> 0:19:18.450
<v Speaker 2>I really wish the whole world were different, everything worked differently,

0:19:18.710 --> 0:19:21.130
<v Speaker 2>that we could rewind time and that I were back

0:19:21.170 --> 0:19:21.790
<v Speaker 2>at Oculus.

0:19:21.910 --> 0:19:22.390
<v Speaker 3>Well, wait a minute.

0:19:22.410 --> 0:19:24.709
<v Speaker 1>First of all, you say the whole tech community is

0:19:25.170 --> 0:19:27.830
<v Speaker 1>against you politically. It seems it's been quite a shift

0:19:27.910 --> 0:19:31.580
<v Speaker 1>and you're part of it and Peter Thiel and David Zak.

0:19:32.060 --> 0:19:34.639
<v Speaker 2>So that is fair. There has been a bit of

0:19:34.680 --> 0:19:36.540
<v Speaker 2>a shift. And so my whining is a little bit

0:19:36.619 --> 0:19:39.630
<v Speaker 2>out of date. But certainly for a long period of time,

0:19:39.650 --> 0:19:41.600
<v Speaker 2>you kind of have to ask yourself, do you want

0:19:41.619 --> 0:19:44.750
<v Speaker 2>to swim in a stream against the current or with it?

0:19:45.060 --> 0:19:47.690
<v Speaker 2>I mean, sometimes I like being contrarian, but I like

0:19:47.730 --> 0:19:49.909
<v Speaker 2>being in a stream where I can get as much.

0:19:50.020 --> 0:19:51.340
<v Speaker 2>much done as possible.

0:19:51.720 --> 0:19:53.419
<v Speaker 3>So let's go back to the firing.

0:19:54.380 --> 0:19:59.450
<v Speaker 1>You got fired basically because you contributed $ 9, 000 or $ 10, 000

0:19:59.320 --> 0:20:02.760
<v Speaker 1>to a Trump-supporting PAC. Then they said, oh, no, that

0:20:02.800 --> 0:20:06.449
<v Speaker 1>wasn't the reason. It wasn't political. But that was totally untrue.

0:20:06.869 --> 0:20:09.070
<v Speaker 1>Do you wish you had pushed back and fought for

0:20:09.109 --> 0:20:09.590
<v Speaker 1>your rights?

0:20:11.390 --> 0:20:15.420
<v Speaker 2>Um, the, the real answer is yes. Um, you gotta

0:20:15.440 --> 0:20:18.260
<v Speaker 2>remember I was 24. I was a young guy. I

0:20:18.280 --> 0:20:21.419
<v Speaker 2>didn't have experience in any of this. Um, I, I

0:20:21.460 --> 0:20:25.020
<v Speaker 2>think I probably, I probably should have fought harder, but

0:20:25.040 --> 0:20:28.740
<v Speaker 2>you also have to remember that once you've been fired,

0:20:29.880 --> 0:20:33.570
<v Speaker 2>you can't fight your way back into being in charge

0:20:33.740 --> 0:20:37.310
<v Speaker 2>of your company that you started as a teenager. You

0:20:37.330 --> 0:20:40.669
<v Speaker 2>can't sue them into making you the CEO, right? That

0:20:40.710 --> 0:20:44.750
<v Speaker 2>doesn't happen. What you're actually doing is just litigating the past,

0:20:45.330 --> 0:20:48.350
<v Speaker 2>maybe getting some money for the future. But then in

0:20:48.369 --> 0:20:51.010
<v Speaker 2>the process, you have to put so much time and

0:20:51.109 --> 0:20:55.890
<v Speaker 2>energy into that singular effort. You basically need to convert

0:20:55.930 --> 0:20:59.260
<v Speaker 2>your life to win these lawsuits into that of a

0:20:59.320 --> 0:21:03.580
<v Speaker 2>professional full-time victim. And so I had to make a choice.

0:21:03.600 --> 0:21:05.980
<v Speaker 2>Was I going to be a professional victim Or was

0:21:06.040 --> 0:21:08.640
<v Speaker 2>I going to start a new company and prove that

0:21:08.820 --> 0:21:11.200
<v Speaker 2>I'm not a one-hit wonder, that I'm not the dummy

0:21:11.240 --> 0:21:14.699
<v Speaker 2>that people said that I was? And I think with

0:21:14.720 --> 0:21:17.330
<v Speaker 2>the benefit of perfect hindsight, I made the right choice.

0:21:17.869 --> 0:21:19.670
<v Speaker 2>In a perfect world, I would love to have fought

0:21:19.730 --> 0:21:22.350
<v Speaker 2>for what's right and also started Andral. But it's hard

0:21:22.390 --> 0:21:24.629
<v Speaker 2>to imagine that I could have done both effectively.

0:21:24.650 --> 0:21:24.910
<v Speaker 5>Well, wait.

0:21:24.950 --> 0:21:27.669
<v Speaker 1>Could you imagine yourself being like an Elon Musk and

0:21:28.450 --> 0:21:32.970
<v Speaker 1>both running the augmented reality at Meta and also Andral?

0:21:33.390 --> 0:21:35.050
<v Speaker 1>Or do you think you have to focus on only

0:21:35.170 --> 0:21:35.590
<v Speaker 1>one thing?

0:21:36.630 --> 0:21:40.010
<v Speaker 2>I think Elon is a singular individual. I've never seen

0:21:40.150 --> 0:21:45.400
<v Speaker 2>anyone like him at all. He's the only person I've

0:21:45.440 --> 0:21:48.740
<v Speaker 2>seen effectively do it. What's the next best step? It's

0:21:48.760 --> 0:21:53.420
<v Speaker 2>like Jack Dorsey with Twitter and Square. Steve Jobs with

0:21:53.460 --> 0:21:57.530
<v Speaker 2>Pixar and Apple. That's pretty good, but he's dead. Fair enough.

0:22:00.310 --> 0:22:03.290
<v Speaker 2>But look at Elon. He's doing it with SpaceX and

0:22:03.350 --> 0:22:08.109
<v Speaker 2>with Tesla and with now X and XAI. He's a

0:22:08.210 --> 0:22:12.410
<v Speaker 2>truly singular individual. I don't know anyone who can do

0:22:12.450 --> 0:22:14.710
<v Speaker 2>it the way that he does it. I certainly don't

0:22:14.750 --> 0:22:17.690
<v Speaker 2>think that I can. I've given it some thought. You know,

0:22:17.770 --> 0:22:21.230
<v Speaker 2>I have a couple of these little side projects like ModRetro,

0:22:21.300 --> 0:22:25.510
<v Speaker 2>the online community is now manufacturing clones of vintage game

0:22:25.550 --> 0:22:28.430
<v Speaker 2>consoles and like we build a tribute to the Nintendo

0:22:28.470 --> 0:22:30.950
<v Speaker 2>Game Boy it's basically a super Game Boy with a

0:22:31.010 --> 0:22:36.000
<v Speaker 2>sapphire screen lens and a magnesium aluminum alloy shell but

0:22:36.060 --> 0:22:39.939
<v Speaker 2>like that's a tiny tiny slice of my time I

0:22:40.040 --> 0:22:43.280
<v Speaker 2>also am a major part owner of a niche ice

0:22:43.340 --> 0:22:46.870
<v Speaker 2>cream company that makes ice cream burritos I put very

0:22:46.920 --> 0:22:49.930
<v Speaker 2>very little time into it Anderle is taking up 99%

0:22:49.930 --> 0:22:50.730
<v Speaker 2>of my time.

0:22:53.770 --> 0:23:07.800
<v Speaker 1>Don't go anywhere There's a lot more right after this break. Well,

0:23:07.820 --> 0:23:11.500
<v Speaker 1>let's get to Andoril. You're sitting there, you're fired from Facebook.

0:23:12.280 --> 0:23:13.580
<v Speaker 3>You got a lot of options.

0:23:13.940 --> 0:23:16.060
<v Speaker 1>Tell me the path that gets you to be a

0:23:16.119 --> 0:23:18.070
<v Speaker 1>defense products company.

0:23:18.810 --> 0:23:20.790
<v Speaker 2>Well, this is something that I've been thinking about for

0:23:20.830 --> 0:23:22.310
<v Speaker 2>a while and a few of my friends have been

0:23:22.330 --> 0:23:24.830
<v Speaker 2>thinking about for a while. We've been talking about the

0:23:24.869 --> 0:23:27.629
<v Speaker 2>fact that the United States had been falling behind in

0:23:27.670 --> 0:23:30.750
<v Speaker 2>defense technology. We were no longer building the tools that

0:23:30.790 --> 0:23:34.169
<v Speaker 2>we really needed to deter or win the wars that

0:23:34.210 --> 0:23:37.129
<v Speaker 2>were likely to happen in the future. And the incentive

0:23:37.170 --> 0:23:41.189
<v Speaker 2>structure that the United States government had created for the

0:23:41.330 --> 0:23:45.430
<v Speaker 2>major defense companies clearly was not incentivizing them to invest

0:23:45.470 --> 0:23:49.480
<v Speaker 2>in this type of technology. Simultaneously, the big tech companies

0:23:49.960 --> 0:23:53.639
<v Speaker 2>were refusing to work with the national security apparatus. And

0:23:53.660 --> 0:23:55.580
<v Speaker 2>there'd never been a point in US history where that

0:23:55.600 --> 0:23:58.240
<v Speaker 2>was the case. There'd never been a point where the

0:23:58.320 --> 0:24:02.580
<v Speaker 2>most innovative technology companies refused to work with the United

0:24:02.600 --> 0:24:06.870
<v Speaker 2>States military. That's always been a hallmark of American technology

0:24:06.900 --> 0:24:08.790
<v Speaker 2>companies is that they did work hand in hand with

0:24:08.810 --> 0:24:13.510
<v Speaker 2>the government on this to safeguard the freedoms and structures

0:24:14.109 --> 0:24:17.230
<v Speaker 2>and even trade environment that made it possible for them

0:24:17.250 --> 0:24:20.670
<v Speaker 2>to operate here and internationally. And so I said, okay,

0:24:20.690 --> 0:24:22.359
<v Speaker 2>if the big tech guys aren't going to save us,

0:24:23.540 --> 0:24:27.280
<v Speaker 2>And then the defense companies aren't going to save us. Well,

0:24:27.380 --> 0:24:30.500
<v Speaker 2>maybe there are some defense startups out there that could

0:24:30.580 --> 0:24:33.439
<v Speaker 2>do something. And so me and I didn't start out

0:24:33.560 --> 0:24:36.020
<v Speaker 2>wanting to start a defense company. I started out wanting

0:24:36.080 --> 0:24:38.359
<v Speaker 2>to give money to other defense companies. I wanted to

0:24:38.400 --> 0:24:40.740
<v Speaker 2>invest in them. And I actually started doing this while

0:24:40.800 --> 0:24:43.460
<v Speaker 2>I was at Oculus. That was how I got connected

0:24:43.480 --> 0:24:46.290
<v Speaker 2>with Trey Stevens at Founders Fund because he was at

0:24:46.330 --> 0:24:50.139
<v Speaker 2>Founders Fund and tasked with finding the next SpaceX or Palantir,

0:24:50.180 --> 0:24:55.100
<v Speaker 2>the next company worth billions of dollars doing business with

0:24:55.119 --> 0:24:58.860
<v Speaker 2>the government. And he had met with, I think, about

0:24:58.859 --> 0:25:02.620
<v Speaker 2>2000 different companies. And how many investments do you think

0:25:02.640 --> 0:25:06.060
<v Speaker 2>that they had decided to make? Zero. It wasn't that

0:25:06.080 --> 0:25:09.760
<v Speaker 2>these were bad people. It wasn't that they weren't patriotic

0:25:09.820 --> 0:25:12.740
<v Speaker 2>or even smart. It's that it was very clear none

0:25:12.760 --> 0:25:17.359
<v Speaker 2>of them had the set or constellation of skills, ability, charisma,

0:25:17.420 --> 0:25:20.280
<v Speaker 2>whatever it was, to be able to build a company

0:25:20.300 --> 0:25:22.740
<v Speaker 2>that could go toe to toe with Lockheed or Northrop

0:25:22.760 --> 0:25:25.290
<v Speaker 2>or Boeing and actually win. In other words, to go

0:25:25.310 --> 0:25:27.590
<v Speaker 2>from being a little gizmo and gadget provider into being

0:25:27.650 --> 0:25:31.830
<v Speaker 2>a next generation defense prime. And so when I got fired,

0:25:32.130 --> 0:25:34.330
<v Speaker 2>Trey was one of the first people I called. I said, Trey,

0:25:35.130 --> 0:25:37.909
<v Speaker 2>I think we need to stop trying to invest in

0:25:37.950 --> 0:25:40.120
<v Speaker 2>a defense company. I think we need to start it ourselves.

0:25:40.850 --> 0:25:42.690
<v Speaker 2>And he says, but Palmer, I thought you were too

0:25:42.730 --> 0:25:45.430
<v Speaker 2>busy with Facebook. I said, oh, well, it's a sacrifice

0:25:45.490 --> 0:25:48.879
<v Speaker 2>I'm willing to make. And it worked out pretty well.

0:25:49.060 --> 0:25:51.480
<v Speaker 2>But the whole point of the company from the beginning

0:25:51.520 --> 0:25:54.580
<v Speaker 2>was to save taxpayers hundreds of billions of dollars a

0:25:54.619 --> 0:25:57.020
<v Speaker 2>year by making tens of billions of dollars a year.

0:25:57.060 --> 0:25:59.500
<v Speaker 2>So to build things that are much more efficient, much

0:25:59.540 --> 0:26:02.490
<v Speaker 2>more cost effective. And it was fantastic. quickly as we

0:26:02.530 --> 0:26:05.050
<v Speaker 2>can and get it out there as quickly as we can.

0:26:05.090 --> 0:26:05.840
<v Speaker 2>And we've done it.

0:26:06.250 --> 0:26:09.149
<v Speaker 1>Well, tell me what type of big systems that you

0:26:09.190 --> 0:26:11.220
<v Speaker 1>can do better than Boeing and Lockheed.

0:26:12.200 --> 0:26:15.220
<v Speaker 2>Well, I don't want to be too uncouth and, you know,

0:26:15.240 --> 0:26:18.140
<v Speaker 2>throw people under the bus. But I mean, one obvious example,

0:26:18.260 --> 0:26:21.119
<v Speaker 2>not judged by me, but judged by the U.S. Air Force,

0:26:21.220 --> 0:26:25.330
<v Speaker 2>was our recent success on the Air Force's CCA program,

0:26:25.350 --> 0:26:29.730
<v Speaker 2>the Collaborative Combat Aircraft Program, basically building AI-powered fighter jets

0:26:29.790 --> 0:26:33.420
<v Speaker 2>for the United States Air Force. Our aircraft, Fury, which

0:26:33.560 --> 0:26:38.520
<v Speaker 2>now has the Air Force designation FQ-44, we beat Northrop

0:26:38.760 --> 0:26:43.020
<v Speaker 2>and Boeing and Lockheed for the CCA Increment One contract.

0:26:43.640 --> 0:26:45.960
<v Speaker 2>I think that's going to be the first of many.

0:26:46.030 --> 0:26:48.180
<v Speaker 2>I think there's been other smaller things where we've won

0:26:48.220 --> 0:26:52.389
<v Speaker 2>here and there. You're going to see us winning major programs,

0:26:53.270 --> 0:26:55.970
<v Speaker 2>I think, on a regular cadence because investments that we've

0:26:55.990 --> 0:26:59.709
<v Speaker 2>made over the last eight years are finally– bearing out

0:27:00.030 --> 0:27:01.990
<v Speaker 2>and people are going to start to see the fruit

0:27:02.030 --> 0:27:02.609
<v Speaker 2>from those trees.

0:27:03.230 --> 0:27:06.720
<v Speaker 1>It seems that, you know, Alex Karp with Palantir, Elon

0:27:06.740 --> 0:27:10.980
<v Speaker 1>Musk with SpaceX, and you have this different model where

0:27:11.020 --> 0:27:14.460
<v Speaker 1>you're not getting commissioned by the government to do a

0:27:14.520 --> 0:27:18.620
<v Speaker 1>certain thing. You're creating a product and then saying this

0:27:18.660 --> 0:27:19.520
<v Speaker 1>would work for you.

0:27:19.600 --> 0:27:20.120
<v Speaker 3>Is that right?

0:27:20.540 --> 0:27:23.229
<v Speaker 2>That's right. So we use our money that we raise

0:27:24.150 --> 0:27:27.560
<v Speaker 2>and that we make to decide what products we're build them,

0:27:27.700 --> 0:27:29.880
<v Speaker 2>decide when they're done, and then sell them to the customer.

0:27:30.340 --> 0:27:32.899
<v Speaker 2>There's times where we're developing hand-in-hand with a customer. And

0:27:32.920 --> 0:27:35.540
<v Speaker 2>there's certainly times where the customers are helping with cost

0:27:35.619 --> 0:27:38.159
<v Speaker 2>because of some particular thing they want to do. But

0:27:38.240 --> 0:27:41.850
<v Speaker 2>generally speaking, Anduril is a products company, not a contractor.

0:27:41.930 --> 0:27:44.710
<v Speaker 2>And we put billions and billions of dollars into things

0:27:45.290 --> 0:27:48.590
<v Speaker 2>before the government ever gives us a dime. And we're

0:27:48.609 --> 0:27:50.030
<v Speaker 2>not talking about a few months here. I mean, we

0:27:50.050 --> 0:27:52.709
<v Speaker 2>have aircraft we've been developing for five years now that

0:27:52.730 --> 0:27:55.490
<v Speaker 2>we're just now, for the first time, getting any money

0:27:55.530 --> 0:27:59.770
<v Speaker 2>from the government for. And I think it's actually a

0:27:59.810 --> 0:28:02.429
<v Speaker 2>much healthier model. It keeps you a lot sharper. It

0:28:02.470 --> 0:28:04.760
<v Speaker 2>ensures that you skin your knees when you trip and fall,

0:28:04.800 --> 0:28:06.490
<v Speaker 2>and that's what keeps you on your toes.

0:28:06.960 --> 0:28:09.220
<v Speaker 1>Let's get to the name, Andoril, which, of course, from

0:28:09.280 --> 0:28:12.560
<v Speaker 1>Lord of the Rings, but it's the force for good sword.

0:28:13.020 --> 0:28:17.340
<v Speaker 1>Do you consider yourself having sort of a moral component

0:28:17.400 --> 0:28:20.619
<v Speaker 1>here that you're going to be fighting for, say, democracy

0:28:20.800 --> 0:28:22.020
<v Speaker 1>and American interests?

0:28:23.060 --> 0:28:23.280
<v Speaker 6>Yes.

0:28:24.200 --> 0:28:26.600
<v Speaker 2>Yes. One of the ideas with Anduril is we are

0:28:26.640 --> 0:28:30.619
<v Speaker 2>not a politically neutral company, a morally neutral company, an

0:28:30.660 --> 0:28:33.409
<v Speaker 2>ethically neutral company. We want to be building a company

0:28:33.710 --> 0:28:36.430
<v Speaker 2>that is working with the nations, that safeguard rights like

0:28:36.510 --> 0:28:41.010
<v Speaker 2>freedom of expression, freedom of self-governance. These kind of ideas

0:28:41.090 --> 0:28:44.300
<v Speaker 2>that maybe not every country perfectly agrees on. We're not

0:28:44.400 --> 0:28:46.520
<v Speaker 2>always going to be perfectly in sync with each other.

0:28:46.560 --> 0:28:49.780
<v Speaker 2>But we generally more or less agree on. that those

0:28:49.820 --> 0:28:51.570
<v Speaker 2>things are important. And there's a lot of nations in

0:28:51.590 --> 0:28:53.830
<v Speaker 2>the world that don't think those are important. At the

0:28:53.850 --> 0:28:56.310
<v Speaker 2>same time, I do recognize at the end of the day,

0:28:56.350 --> 0:28:58.570
<v Speaker 2>we're kind of beholden to the United States government. I

0:28:58.610 --> 0:29:00.950
<v Speaker 2>can't sell to any country the United States government doesn't

0:29:00.970 --> 0:29:03.590
<v Speaker 2>want me to sell to. And any ally that they

0:29:03.630 --> 0:29:05.390
<v Speaker 2>want to work with, we also have to work with

0:29:05.430 --> 0:29:08.060
<v Speaker 2>as well. I've decided that that kind of is the

0:29:08.080 --> 0:29:10.860
<v Speaker 2>way that it has to be. Regardless of my moral

0:29:10.900 --> 0:29:14.880
<v Speaker 2>position or ethical position, I live in a country where

0:29:14.900 --> 0:29:17.740
<v Speaker 2>we've decided that we are going to outsource responsibility for

0:29:17.780 --> 0:29:21.910
<v Speaker 2>those decisions to to our constitutional republic, to the elected

0:29:21.950 --> 0:29:24.820
<v Speaker 2>officials that we can all hold accountable for those decisions.

0:29:25.320 --> 0:29:27.040
<v Speaker 2>And so I sometimes get people saying, well, Palmer, does

0:29:27.060 --> 0:29:31.040
<v Speaker 2>your commitment to ethics extend to, for example, saying that

0:29:31.100 --> 0:29:34.100
<v Speaker 2>you will help one country or won't help another? The

0:29:34.120 --> 0:29:35.960
<v Speaker 2>point I have to make to people is you don't

0:29:35.980 --> 0:29:37.760
<v Speaker 2>want to live in a world where a handful of

0:29:37.860 --> 0:29:41.920
<v Speaker 2>corporate weapons executives get to have de facto control over U.S.

0:29:41.980 --> 0:29:46.810
<v Speaker 2>foreign policy. That should not be a decision that executives

0:29:46.830 --> 0:29:48.990
<v Speaker 2>like me are able to make. The only way to

0:29:49.030 --> 0:29:51.150
<v Speaker 2>keep us accountable is to make us an extension of

0:29:51.190 --> 0:29:55.390
<v Speaker 2>the United States government's policy. Otherwise, you end up with very,

0:29:55.450 --> 0:29:58.940
<v Speaker 2>very strange power dynamics where you can imagine a world

0:29:58.960 --> 0:30:01.420
<v Speaker 2>where the CEO of Lockheed Martin has more power than

0:30:01.440 --> 0:30:03.280
<v Speaker 2>the president of the United States. And that's probably not

0:30:03.320 --> 0:30:03.720
<v Speaker 2>a good thing.

0:30:04.180 --> 0:30:08.440
<v Speaker 1>Tell me about the software platform Lattice and how that

0:30:08.720 --> 0:30:10.840
<v Speaker 1>sort of underlies a lot of what you're doing.

0:30:11.560 --> 0:30:15.120
<v Speaker 2>So Lattice is the collection of software that we've built

0:30:15.160 --> 0:30:17.400
<v Speaker 2>that powers all of our different products. It's kind of

0:30:17.420 --> 0:30:20.620
<v Speaker 2>the AI brain that powers our missiles, our submarines, our

0:30:20.660 --> 0:30:23.980
<v Speaker 2>fighter jets, our sensor towers, all of the 25 plus

0:30:24.010 --> 0:30:27.740
<v Speaker 2>products that we make. And The really key thing about

0:30:27.800 --> 0:30:30.219
<v Speaker 2>it is that we can tie together all of these

0:30:30.280 --> 0:30:33.140
<v Speaker 2>systems so they can talk to each other, work together

0:30:33.240 --> 0:30:36.940
<v Speaker 2>very seamlessly so that every sensor is an eye for

0:30:37.080 --> 0:30:40.550
<v Speaker 2>every other system and every weapon is a system available

0:30:40.970 --> 0:30:44.030
<v Speaker 2>to every brain. It's a very different way of thinking

0:30:44.090 --> 0:30:46.790
<v Speaker 2>about autonomous systems to kind of tie them together in

0:30:46.830 --> 0:30:50.570
<v Speaker 2>this way. And it also is great in terms of

0:30:50.830 --> 0:30:54.010
<v Speaker 2>a return on investment perspective for me, because If I

0:30:54.030 --> 0:30:57.050
<v Speaker 2>put a dollar into making the wing of an aircraft better,

0:30:57.630 --> 0:30:59.210
<v Speaker 2>the only thing that gets better is the wing of

0:30:59.250 --> 0:31:01.910
<v Speaker 2>that one aircraft. If I put a dollar into making

0:31:01.950 --> 0:31:05.810
<v Speaker 2>Lattice better, everything that uses Lattice gets made better. And

0:31:05.830 --> 0:31:10.620
<v Speaker 2>so you have this multiplicative effect where putting billions of

0:31:10.650 --> 0:31:13.500
<v Speaker 2>dollars into it now turns into billions of dollars you've

0:31:13.520 --> 0:31:16.760
<v Speaker 2>invested across the dozens of products that use it. And

0:31:16.780 --> 0:31:19.620
<v Speaker 2>we actually have as many people working on Lattice as

0:31:19.660 --> 0:31:23.530
<v Speaker 2>we do every hardware product combined at Android. That's how

0:31:23.590 --> 0:31:24.140
<v Speaker 2>important it is.

0:31:24.890 --> 0:31:27.940
<v Speaker 1>And is the point to make autonomous weapons?

0:31:28.580 --> 0:31:28.840
<v Speaker 3>Yes.

0:31:29.540 --> 0:31:33.620
<v Speaker 1>And do you see there's any problem by having drones

0:31:33.740 --> 0:31:37.580
<v Speaker 1>or autonomous systems that'll make kill decisions without a human

0:31:37.620 --> 0:31:38.440
<v Speaker 1>being in the loop?

0:31:39.110 --> 0:31:42.790
<v Speaker 2>I think it is the only rational moral outcome or

0:31:42.830 --> 0:31:48.390
<v Speaker 2>decision to make. Life and death decisions are too morally

0:31:48.490 --> 0:31:51.900
<v Speaker 2>fraught and too important to not bring to bear the

0:31:52.020 --> 0:31:55.420
<v Speaker 2>most powerful technology that you have. And this isn't even

0:31:55.440 --> 0:31:58.740
<v Speaker 2>an argument about AI or not. AI happens to be

0:31:58.780 --> 0:32:01.010
<v Speaker 2>the thing that everyone's talking about right now because it's

0:32:01.030 --> 0:32:03.210
<v Speaker 2>hot and it's in the news. But what this really

0:32:03.250 --> 0:32:04.750
<v Speaker 2>comes down to is do you want to use the

0:32:04.810 --> 0:32:08.850
<v Speaker 2>best technology that can measurably and provably lead to the

0:32:08.970 --> 0:32:12.010
<v Speaker 2>lowest collateral damage, the lowest loss of civilian life, the

0:32:12.050 --> 0:32:14.730
<v Speaker 2>highest level of precision? There are people who would be

0:32:14.810 --> 0:32:18.700
<v Speaker 2>willing to accept more collateral damage, more civilian loss of

0:32:18.740 --> 0:32:24.420
<v Speaker 2>life in exchange for autonomous weapons not being allowed. If

0:32:24.460 --> 0:32:28.000
<v Speaker 2>you had an autonomous landmine that could differentiate between a

0:32:28.520 --> 0:32:31.570
<v Speaker 2>Russian tank and a school bus full of kids, there

0:32:31.610 --> 0:32:35.110
<v Speaker 2>are people in the world who seriously argue that it

0:32:35.170 --> 0:32:37.350
<v Speaker 2>is better to have a dumb mind that blows up

0:32:37.390 --> 0:32:39.430
<v Speaker 2>that school bus full of kids as long as it

0:32:39.470 --> 0:32:41.810
<v Speaker 2>wasn't a robot who decided who lived and who died.

0:32:42.130 --> 0:32:45.250
<v Speaker 2>I just can't abide by that. I cannot get on

0:32:45.290 --> 0:32:48.090
<v Speaker 2>that side. And people will point to problems like, Well,

0:32:48.330 --> 0:32:50.130
<v Speaker 2>what if it makes this type of mistake? What if

0:32:50.170 --> 0:32:51.430
<v Speaker 2>it does this? What if it does that? And my

0:32:51.450 --> 0:32:55.410
<v Speaker 2>point is, let's regulate that. Let's regulate the quality of

0:32:55.450 --> 0:32:58.590
<v Speaker 2>these algorithms. Let's regulate their output. Let's regulate how they're used.

0:32:58.870 --> 0:33:00.930
<v Speaker 2>Let's make sure that we're holding people accountable for when

0:33:00.950 --> 0:33:04.850
<v Speaker 2>they're used or misused. But when people in the United Nations,

0:33:04.950 --> 0:33:07.390
<v Speaker 2>for example, call for a ban on what they call

0:33:07.540 --> 0:33:11.220
<v Speaker 2>lethal autonomous weapon system laws, and they say things that

0:33:11.260 --> 0:33:14.340
<v Speaker 2>the soundbite sounds good. Well, don't you agree that a

0:33:14.420 --> 0:33:17.700
<v Speaker 2>robot should never decide who lives and dies? It sounds

0:33:17.740 --> 0:33:20.540
<v Speaker 2>great as a soundbite, but what it actually turns into

0:33:20.940 --> 0:33:24.900
<v Speaker 2>is that you're committing yourself to making dumb weapons that

0:33:25.020 --> 0:33:30.130
<v Speaker 2>cannot discriminate between actual combatants and civilians. It's weapons that

0:33:30.210 --> 0:33:33.810
<v Speaker 2>cannot differentiate between the right building and the wrong building.

0:33:33.890 --> 0:33:36.010
<v Speaker 1>Well, wait, correct me if I'm wrong, but what you've

0:33:36.070 --> 0:33:40.600
<v Speaker 1>just criticized is the U.S. military doctrine. I mean, places

0:33:40.630 --> 0:33:44.190
<v Speaker 1>like Creech Air Force Base, They got drones flying all

0:33:44.270 --> 0:33:47.010
<v Speaker 1>over the Middle East, but there are humans sitting there

0:33:47.090 --> 0:33:49.070
<v Speaker 1>watching it and they've got to be in the loop.

0:33:49.310 --> 0:33:51.390
<v Speaker 3>Do you think the U.S. military doctrine's wrong?

0:33:52.290 --> 0:33:54.730
<v Speaker 2>I think that their doctrine is formed by the limits

0:33:54.770 --> 0:33:57.300
<v Speaker 2>of the technology that they have. So I think that

0:33:57.380 --> 0:34:00.400
<v Speaker 2>right now it is good doctrine. Up until now, the

0:34:00.460 --> 0:34:02.500
<v Speaker 2>level of autonomy that we've had, the level for a

0:34:02.540 --> 0:34:06.180
<v Speaker 2>machine to make that decision has been so incredibly coarse

0:34:06.260 --> 0:34:08.299
<v Speaker 2>and poor quality that it would have been a really

0:34:08.360 --> 0:34:11.270
<v Speaker 2>bad idea to just generally hand it over. That's why

0:34:11.310 --> 0:34:13.310
<v Speaker 2>I said, this isn't really about AI. It's about, you know,

0:34:13.469 --> 0:34:15.989
<v Speaker 2>is it the right tool? You also got to remember

0:34:16.090 --> 0:34:18.550
<v Speaker 2>autonomy in many ways is getting rid of failure modes.

0:34:19.030 --> 0:34:20.810
<v Speaker 2>So like you, you've probably heard about some of the

0:34:20.830 --> 0:34:24.270
<v Speaker 2>people hacking into predator feeds that were unsecured. Think about

0:34:24.350 --> 0:34:26.110
<v Speaker 2>all the problems that go away when you have an

0:34:26.180 --> 0:34:28.840
<v Speaker 2>autonomous system that isn't even carrying a radio because it

0:34:28.860 --> 0:34:31.339
<v Speaker 2>doesn't need one or use one for the mission. Like you're,

0:34:31.380 --> 0:34:34.410
<v Speaker 2>you're getting rid of cyber vulnerability. in a lot of

0:34:34.430 --> 0:34:39.100
<v Speaker 2>remotely piloted systems, that same requirement to have somebody press

0:34:39.120 --> 0:34:42.100
<v Speaker 2>the final kill decision button can also turn into a

0:34:42.600 --> 0:34:45.920
<v Speaker 2>way for every weapon to be hijackable by an enemy

0:34:46.100 --> 0:34:47.799
<v Speaker 2>who will then tell it to do the wrong thing.

0:34:47.820 --> 0:34:49.980
<v Speaker 2>And so I think that doctrine is formed by the

0:34:50.000 --> 0:34:52.950
<v Speaker 2>weapons that they have. And what you said is mostly true.

0:34:52.989 --> 0:34:54.910
<v Speaker 2>Like it's true for a predator drone. A person has

0:34:54.930 --> 0:34:56.629
<v Speaker 2>to be in the loop. They have to see what's

0:34:56.650 --> 0:34:58.940
<v Speaker 2>going on. They have to push that button. But the

0:34:58.980 --> 0:35:02.510
<v Speaker 2>United States has been using radiation-seeking missiles since Vietnam, right?

0:35:02.640 --> 0:35:05.170
<v Speaker 2>You send a missile over the horizon, you never see

0:35:05.210 --> 0:35:07.970
<v Speaker 2>it again. It looks for a certain radio frequency emission,

0:35:08.590 --> 0:35:11.350
<v Speaker 2>and it flies into that thing. The United States has

0:35:11.370 --> 0:35:15.810
<v Speaker 2>a lot of weapon systems that already take kill decisions

0:35:15.850 --> 0:35:19.110
<v Speaker 2>into their own hands. It's just they're very specific kill decisions.

0:35:19.670 --> 0:35:21.250
<v Speaker 2>And so I think AI will be the same way.

0:35:21.610 --> 0:35:25.390
<v Speaker 3>Well, I mean, you're right. Landmines are completely autonomous. They're

0:35:25.410 --> 0:35:26.170
<v Speaker 3>just not smart.

0:35:26.810 --> 0:35:29.970
<v Speaker 2>Well, now you're getting into a whole other interesting debate.

0:35:30.050 --> 0:35:32.570
<v Speaker 2>I gave a talk a few years ago which argued

0:35:32.610 --> 0:35:36.270
<v Speaker 2>that autonomous weapons are actually thousands of years old. Again,

0:35:36.310 --> 0:35:39.770
<v Speaker 2>people are focusing on AI, but that's just the latest tool, right?

0:35:39.790 --> 0:35:42.690
<v Speaker 2>Like there's no difference between AI and, you know, like

0:35:43.469 --> 0:35:47.630
<v Speaker 2>an old school algorithm or honestly even like a clockwork

0:35:47.690 --> 0:35:50.850
<v Speaker 2>mechanism that accomplishes the same thing. The way it's accomplished

0:35:50.870 --> 0:35:53.629
<v Speaker 2>shouldn't matter. It's what actually comes out the other side.

0:35:53.650 --> 0:35:57.830
<v Speaker 2>So landmines, great example. They are an autonomous weapon. There

0:35:57.850 --> 0:36:00.469
<v Speaker 2>have been landmines for many years that ignore certain types

0:36:00.489 --> 0:36:03.390
<v Speaker 2>of targets and attack other types, mostly based on like

0:36:03.469 --> 0:36:05.950
<v Speaker 2>weight over a pressure plate or their magnetic signature. So

0:36:05.969 --> 0:36:08.730
<v Speaker 2>you have a system that is making decisions about who

0:36:08.750 --> 0:36:10.489
<v Speaker 2>to kill and who to not. They say, we're gonna

0:36:10.510 --> 0:36:13.220
<v Speaker 2>ignore cars, but then a big armored vehicle is gonna

0:36:13.239 --> 0:36:15.720
<v Speaker 2>have a larger mass. It's gonna have a larger magnetic

0:36:15.760 --> 0:36:17.580
<v Speaker 2>signature and I'm gonna blow that up. But if you

0:36:17.719 --> 0:36:20.200
<v Speaker 2>really wanna go back you can actually find things like

0:36:20.300 --> 0:36:22.940
<v Speaker 2>pit traps that were built the same way. Pit traps

0:36:22.980 --> 0:36:25.740
<v Speaker 2>that would allow people to walk over them, but horses

0:36:25.820 --> 0:36:28.299
<v Speaker 2>to suddenly break through and fall through so that they

0:36:28.340 --> 0:36:30.860
<v Speaker 2>wouldn't get the foot soldiers, but they would get the

0:36:30.960 --> 0:36:34.670
<v Speaker 2>higher echelon officers that were on horses behind them. So

0:36:35.390 --> 0:36:37.930
<v Speaker 2>people have been building weapons where they were designed by

0:36:37.950 --> 0:36:41.650
<v Speaker 2>a man using the power of technology to decide on

0:36:41.690 --> 0:36:43.810
<v Speaker 2>the battlefield who will live and who will die at

0:36:43.850 --> 0:36:46.550
<v Speaker 2>the point of that weapon. I don't think there's actually

0:36:46.590 --> 0:36:49.350
<v Speaker 2>an inherent difference between using AI to do it and

0:36:49.469 --> 0:36:52.380
<v Speaker 2>using how thick the bamboo over is over your pit trap.

0:36:52.620 --> 0:36:55.259
<v Speaker 2>They're both two sides of the same coin. The key

0:36:55.300 --> 0:36:56.960
<v Speaker 2>is that a person has to be accountable for the

0:36:57.040 --> 0:36:59.219
<v Speaker 2>use of force. A person has to be accountable when

0:36:59.239 --> 0:37:02.319
<v Speaker 2>they're misused. And the people who are building them and

0:37:02.430 --> 0:37:05.129
<v Speaker 2>using them have to be aware of the fact that

0:37:05.190 --> 0:37:07.290
<v Speaker 2>these things have problems. You know, like if you build

0:37:07.330 --> 0:37:08.970
<v Speaker 2>a pit trap in the middle of the wrong street,

0:37:10.170 --> 0:37:12.350
<v Speaker 2>you're going to be held accountable for what happens next.

0:37:12.370 --> 0:37:15.069
<v Speaker 2>You don't get to say, oh, well, I didn't mean

0:37:15.150 --> 0:37:17.029
<v Speaker 2>for the pit trap to kill the wrong person. I

0:37:17.050 --> 0:37:19.390
<v Speaker 2>think AI weapons will be the same way. People are

0:37:19.410 --> 0:37:21.799
<v Speaker 2>going to be trained on the limitations, and if they

0:37:22.140 --> 0:37:24.939
<v Speaker 2>use them in ways that cause loss of civilian life,

0:37:25.500 --> 0:37:28.100
<v Speaker 2>the people who use them will be held to account.

0:37:28.120 --> 0:37:30.580
<v Speaker 2>We're not just going to throw up our hands and say, oh, well,

0:37:31.440 --> 0:37:33.339
<v Speaker 2>what can you do? The robot decided to kill the guy.

0:37:35.500 --> 0:37:37.680
<v Speaker 3>We'll be right back after this quick break.

0:37:55.170 --> 0:37:58.529
<v Speaker 1>Can you, either in your science fiction brain or in

0:37:58.590 --> 0:38:03.310
<v Speaker 1>your endoral brain, imagine a war in the future that's

0:38:03.450 --> 0:38:08.419
<v Speaker 1>fought almost virtually by really smart machines in which very

0:38:08.460 --> 0:38:09.880
<v Speaker 1>few people, if any, die?

0:38:09.900 --> 0:38:13.739
<v Speaker 2>I mean, I've had a lot of discussions on this,

0:38:13.920 --> 0:38:16.440
<v Speaker 2>and it's hard to make the point I'm going to

0:38:16.480 --> 0:38:20.299
<v Speaker 2>make without people jumping down your throat and trying to

0:38:20.500 --> 0:38:23.219
<v Speaker 2>take it in the least charitable light. But I would

0:38:23.260 --> 0:38:26.460
<v Speaker 2>say we're basically already living in the early version of that.

0:38:28.060 --> 0:38:31.680
<v Speaker 2>You look at modern warfare and a lot of the

0:38:31.719 --> 0:38:35.660
<v Speaker 2>wars that have happened over the last, call it 30 years,

0:38:36.160 --> 0:38:39.020
<v Speaker 2>a lot fewer people are dying in war, generally speaking.

0:38:39.300 --> 0:38:42.969
<v Speaker 2>We have like the invention of precision guided bombs has

0:38:43.160 --> 0:38:45.830
<v Speaker 2>made a lot of old school bombing campaign techniques possible.

0:38:46.070 --> 0:38:49.509
<v Speaker 2>completely irrelevant and seemingly barbaric, right? The things that the

0:38:49.570 --> 0:38:52.489
<v Speaker 2>United States and our allies did during World War II

0:38:52.790 --> 0:38:56.440
<v Speaker 2>today would be considered war crimes because we've become so

0:38:56.540 --> 0:38:59.120
<v Speaker 2>good at precision targeted warfare. The reason people jump down

0:38:59.140 --> 0:39:01.259
<v Speaker 2>your throats, they say, Palmer, how can you say, you know,

0:39:01.300 --> 0:39:03.630
<v Speaker 2>a war is humane or that nobody dies when you're

0:39:03.650 --> 0:39:07.170
<v Speaker 2>talking about tens of thousands? Obviously, that's horrible. But remember

0:39:07.210 --> 0:39:10.029
<v Speaker 2>that in living memory, we have wars where tens of

0:39:10.270 --> 0:39:14.180
<v Speaker 2>millions died. I mean, like, look at Russian losses. Look

0:39:14.219 --> 0:39:18.440
<v Speaker 2>at Chinese losses. Look at German losses. Just An incredible

0:39:18.500 --> 0:39:21.300
<v Speaker 2>loss of life. And so I think we've actually already

0:39:21.400 --> 0:39:23.960
<v Speaker 2>moved about 90 percent of the way down the scale.

0:39:24.340 --> 0:39:27.520
<v Speaker 2>We're kind of fighting over the margins here. Will wars

0:39:27.560 --> 0:39:30.299
<v Speaker 2>go to where there's very few people involved and it's

0:39:30.340 --> 0:39:33.080
<v Speaker 2>mostly machines? I would actually argue we're already most of

0:39:33.140 --> 0:39:35.560
<v Speaker 2>the way there. This is why I don't think it's

0:39:35.620 --> 0:39:37.460
<v Speaker 2>actually going to make much of a difference. People say,

0:39:37.640 --> 0:39:40.660
<v Speaker 2>Paul Marino, the future of war, wouldn't that mean that

0:39:40.700 --> 0:39:43.009
<v Speaker 2>the barrier to war is going to go way down?

0:39:43.050 --> 0:39:46.910
<v Speaker 2>And my point is, guys, it's already there. Wars just

0:39:47.050 --> 0:39:49.750
<v Speaker 2>don't carry the same collateral damage that they used to.

0:39:50.190 --> 0:39:52.509
<v Speaker 2>And so I very much can imagine a world where

0:39:52.750 --> 0:39:55.799
<v Speaker 2>you won't get rid of all the human death. I

0:39:55.840 --> 0:39:59.000
<v Speaker 2>think we're going to get to a point where most

0:39:59.040 --> 0:40:02.799
<v Speaker 2>of the casualties are going to be robots and systems

0:40:02.920 --> 0:40:05.680
<v Speaker 2>and hardware rather than flesh and bone.

0:40:05.840 --> 0:40:09.420
<v Speaker 1>Well, don't you think your technology will end up deterring

0:40:09.440 --> 0:40:10.980
<v Speaker 1>more wars than it creates?

0:40:11.780 --> 0:40:14.799
<v Speaker 2>So that is certainly the hope. I believe that it's

0:40:14.820 --> 0:40:18.900
<v Speaker 2>an interesting thing where the more successful Andoril is– the

0:40:18.920 --> 0:40:21.779
<v Speaker 2>less credit we'll get for it. Already today, you have

0:40:21.800 --> 0:40:24.100
<v Speaker 2>people saying, Palmer thinks that we're gonna fight this war

0:40:24.120 --> 0:40:27.140
<v Speaker 2>with China. Well, sure doesn't seem like anything's happening yet.

0:40:27.580 --> 0:40:29.380
<v Speaker 2>And the funny thing is, let's say that we get

0:40:29.400 --> 0:40:30.950
<v Speaker 2>to 20 years from now and we haven't had a

0:40:30.989 --> 0:40:34.310
<v Speaker 2>fight with China, that's gonna be in large part because

0:40:34.489 --> 0:40:37.529
<v Speaker 2>of not just Anduril, but dozens of other companies that

0:40:37.550 --> 0:40:40.750
<v Speaker 2>have all contributed to this. The only reason that we

0:40:40.770 --> 0:40:44.130
<v Speaker 2>will avoid it is because we carefully build a world

0:40:44.370 --> 0:40:48.049
<v Speaker 2>where China doesn't feel that they can move. And the

0:40:48.090 --> 0:40:50.069
<v Speaker 2>annoying thing is that everyone will look at that and

0:40:50.110 --> 0:40:52.790
<v Speaker 2>assume it's just the natural state of things rather than

0:40:52.810 --> 0:40:56.860
<v Speaker 2>a carefully engineered, beautiful garden. On the other hand, if

0:40:56.900 --> 0:40:59.100
<v Speaker 2>we do end up in a war with China and

0:40:59.180 --> 0:41:02.279
<v Speaker 2>Anduril systems are getting used on the regular, all those

0:41:02.320 --> 0:41:05.650
<v Speaker 2>people say, wow, I was wrong. Good thing we have Anduril.

0:41:06.070 --> 0:41:09.150
<v Speaker 2>It's like at that point we've already lost, right? By

0:41:09.190 --> 0:41:12.330
<v Speaker 2>the time you're fighting a war, it means you didn't

0:41:12.530 --> 0:41:13.610
<v Speaker 2>build your garden correctly.

0:41:14.770 --> 0:41:18.460
<v Speaker 1>Speaking of creating new businesses and turning you into an

0:41:18.520 --> 0:41:21.780
<v Speaker 1>Elon Musk running a lot of them, you've started another

0:41:21.920 --> 0:41:24.819
<v Speaker 1>one that uses a Lord of the Rings name, Erebor,

0:41:25.360 --> 0:41:28.640
<v Speaker 1>for a boring bank. But it seems to be based

0:41:28.760 --> 0:41:32.989
<v Speaker 1>on the notion that crypto can make things a lot

0:41:33.030 --> 0:41:34.910
<v Speaker 1>more efficient in the banking system.

0:41:35.560 --> 0:41:37.460
<v Speaker 2>You know, I think people have indexed a lot on

0:41:37.520 --> 0:41:40.040
<v Speaker 2>it being a crypto bank, and that's what the early

0:41:40.080 --> 0:41:42.860
<v Speaker 2>reporting was saying. The reality is what we're doing with

0:41:42.900 --> 0:41:46.280
<v Speaker 2>crypto is quite boring compared to what most people are doing.

0:41:46.920 --> 0:41:51.360
<v Speaker 2>We support US dollar-backed stablecoins. There's a lot of boring

0:41:51.430 --> 0:41:53.970
<v Speaker 2>banks already that support crypto, but you wouldn't call JP

0:41:53.989 --> 0:41:57.630
<v Speaker 2>Morgan a crypto bank. You wouldn't call Goldman Sachs a

0:41:57.670 --> 0:42:00.970
<v Speaker 2>crypto bank. I think it's just going to become table stakes.

0:42:01.150 --> 0:42:03.810
<v Speaker 2>Everyone is going to, to a certain extent, support stablecoins.

0:42:04.160 --> 0:42:06.279
<v Speaker 2>It's an interesting thing to talk about right now, but

0:42:06.320 --> 0:42:08.320
<v Speaker 2>five years from now, people are going to look back

0:42:08.390 --> 0:42:11.770
<v Speaker 2>and say, wow, what was all the fuss about Arab

0:42:11.790 --> 0:42:13.730
<v Speaker 2>War being a crypto bank? They're just like everybody else.

0:42:15.010 --> 0:42:16.370
<v Speaker 1>One of the other people who will have it on

0:42:16.410 --> 0:42:19.009
<v Speaker 1>this show, the builders, is Fei-Fei Li, whom you know.

0:42:19.610 --> 0:42:21.390
<v Speaker 3>And she said AI.

0:42:21.090 --> 0:42:25.259
<v Speaker 1>Is a powerful tool that we're only beginning to understand,

0:42:25.450 --> 0:42:30.259
<v Speaker 1>and that's a profound responsibility. What are the responsibilities right

0:42:30.300 --> 0:42:33.400
<v Speaker 1>now we should figure out in this tool of AI?

0:42:34.620 --> 0:42:37.859
<v Speaker 2>I mean, the number one thing I'm most worried about

0:42:38.300 --> 0:42:40.910
<v Speaker 2>and thus I think has probably the biggest area of responsibility.

0:42:42.010 --> 0:42:44.790
<v Speaker 2>I'm not a pro-censorship guy. I'm not a fan of

0:42:44.870 --> 0:42:49.069
<v Speaker 2>limiting AI to not do certain things. But if I

0:42:49.090 --> 0:42:52.310
<v Speaker 2>were going to pick one area to have some level

0:42:52.350 --> 0:42:56.850
<v Speaker 2>of responsibility or regulation or censorship, it would be around

0:42:57.130 --> 0:43:01.250
<v Speaker 2>applications of artificial intelligence to create biological and chemological weapons.

0:43:02.270 --> 0:43:05.799
<v Speaker 2>There's so much low-hanging fruit that has been inaccessible to

0:43:05.820 --> 0:43:12.330
<v Speaker 2>people because it was buried in academic understanding that required

0:43:12.370 --> 0:43:16.670
<v Speaker 2>a certain bar to even be barely functionally literate in.

0:43:17.110 --> 0:43:20.570
<v Speaker 2>AI has made it possible for people to get much

0:43:20.700 --> 0:43:23.259
<v Speaker 2>further down the chain of doing very scary things. And

0:43:23.640 --> 0:43:25.540
<v Speaker 2>you've probably seen some of the things people have been

0:43:25.560 --> 0:43:29.700
<v Speaker 2>doing where they have labs that are doing new pharmacological

0:43:29.739 --> 0:43:33.280
<v Speaker 2>development where the AI is basically telling them which experiments

0:43:33.320 --> 0:43:36.180
<v Speaker 2>to run, which compounds to mix, exactly what their work

0:43:36.219 --> 0:43:40.029
<v Speaker 2>instructions for the lab are. You don't need like PhDs.

0:43:40.070 --> 0:43:42.450
<v Speaker 2>Like you just need like lab technicians who are reading

0:43:42.469 --> 0:43:44.770
<v Speaker 2>their work instructions and doing these things, running these tests,

0:43:45.010 --> 0:43:47.180
<v Speaker 2>feeding the results back into the AI. They're basically using

0:43:47.219 --> 0:43:49.700
<v Speaker 2>the people as meat robots to do everything for them.

0:43:50.260 --> 0:43:52.879
<v Speaker 2>We are not far away from, from a person being

0:43:52.980 --> 0:43:57.600
<v Speaker 2>able to create pretty scary biological weapons without any of

0:43:57.660 --> 0:44:00.160
<v Speaker 2>the people who are working in the lab knowing that

0:44:00.180 --> 0:44:03.060
<v Speaker 2>that's what they're doing, without any of the machines catching it.

0:44:03.700 --> 0:44:06.390
<v Speaker 2>And I think that there would be a very strong

0:44:06.469 --> 0:44:13.710
<v Speaker 2>argument to remove certain elements of data or specifically tamper

0:44:13.750 --> 0:44:16.489
<v Speaker 2>with the data in order to break it, unless you

0:44:16.570 --> 0:44:19.549
<v Speaker 2>are within institutions that are allowed access to these things.

0:44:19.590 --> 0:44:22.420
<v Speaker 2>And people say, but Palmer, you know, These tools are

0:44:22.480 --> 0:44:25.840
<v Speaker 2>also useful for developing medicine. I think that it's an

0:44:25.940 --> 0:44:29.360
<v Speaker 2>asymmetrical thing, though. I agree. This would mean that probably

0:44:29.719 --> 0:44:32.310
<v Speaker 2>you won't have a teenager in his garage able to

0:44:32.370 --> 0:44:37.110
<v Speaker 2>develop a new pharmaceutical compound without being part of a laboratory.

0:44:37.330 --> 0:44:39.170
<v Speaker 2>That is a loss that I'm willing to take if

0:44:39.190 --> 0:44:41.650
<v Speaker 2>you don't have people designing bioweapons designed to wipe out

0:44:41.690 --> 0:44:45.910
<v Speaker 2>people based on their ethnic line, race, other biological markers,

0:44:46.050 --> 0:44:49.200
<v Speaker 2>or thinking they're doing such and failing to do so.

0:44:49.620 --> 0:44:51.239
<v Speaker 2>I'm terrified of that. So if there's going to be

0:44:51.280 --> 0:44:54.339
<v Speaker 2>responsibility for AI, I think we should focus on things

0:44:54.400 --> 0:44:58.140
<v Speaker 2>that can self-replicate and live in the real world outside

0:44:58.160 --> 0:44:58.919
<v Speaker 2>of that data center.

0:44:58.940 --> 0:45:02.819
<v Speaker 1>All right, one last question. I'm going to ask you

0:45:02.840 --> 0:45:06.370
<v Speaker 1>to pick something that you think will be really cool

0:45:06.410 --> 0:45:08.710
<v Speaker 1>in the future that you'd like to be doing.

0:45:08.930 --> 0:45:10.110
<v Speaker 3>What's the next cool thing?

0:45:12.350 --> 0:45:14.150
<v Speaker 2>Oh, this is so difficult. I only get one? I

0:45:14.290 --> 0:45:15.049
<v Speaker 2>just get one pick?

0:45:15.310 --> 0:45:15.690
<v Speaker 3>Get two.

0:45:16.350 --> 0:45:19.969
<v Speaker 2>Oh, two. All right. I think... One of the things

0:45:20.010 --> 0:45:24.290
<v Speaker 2>that I'm very excited for is the vertical integration of

0:45:24.670 --> 0:45:30.069
<v Speaker 2>power generation, manufacturing capacity, processing capacity and recycling capacity where

0:45:30.310 --> 0:45:33.070
<v Speaker 2>you are going to make it, I think, ridiculously cheap

0:45:33.110 --> 0:45:35.589
<v Speaker 2>to build a lot of goods. The same mechanization you've

0:45:35.610 --> 0:45:39.170
<v Speaker 2>seen in textiles manufacturing where fabric is now roughly a

0:45:39.230 --> 0:45:42.730
<v Speaker 2>thousand times cheaper in terms of per unit earning cost

0:45:43.090 --> 0:45:44.630
<v Speaker 2>as it used to be. I think you're going to

0:45:44.650 --> 0:45:46.450
<v Speaker 2>see that applied to cars. You're going to see that

0:45:46.510 --> 0:45:49.450
<v Speaker 2>applied to consumer electronics. I think you're going to see

0:45:49.510 --> 0:45:54.230
<v Speaker 2>a lot of everyday goods because the extraction processing and

0:45:54.270 --> 0:45:58.200
<v Speaker 2>recycling costs, manufacturing costs, it'll all together be so low

0:45:58.570 --> 0:46:00.020
<v Speaker 2>that we're just gonna be able to crank out things

0:46:00.040 --> 0:46:03.080
<v Speaker 2>like TVs and cars as easily as we churn out

0:46:03.440 --> 0:46:06.020
<v Speaker 2>rolls of fabric. I think a world where you can

0:46:06.060 --> 0:46:08.739
<v Speaker 2>buy a car for a thousand dollars, I think that's

0:46:08.800 --> 0:46:11.520
<v Speaker 2>actually within our lifetime. So I'm very, very excited about that.

0:46:11.580 --> 0:46:15.220
<v Speaker 2>Just the basic necessities of life being driven way down

0:46:15.260 --> 0:46:19.399
<v Speaker 2>in cost through automation, vertical integration, and co-location. The second

0:46:19.420 --> 0:46:22.820
<v Speaker 2>would probably be settling the oceans. There's a lot of

0:46:22.920 --> 0:46:25.600
<v Speaker 2>ocean out there. There's a lot of space. There's a

0:46:25.660 --> 0:46:29.759
<v Speaker 2>lot of food and energy potential. And up till now,

0:46:29.800 --> 0:46:32.580
<v Speaker 2>the main reason we have not been settling the oceans,

0:46:33.000 --> 0:46:36.560
<v Speaker 2>it's been an engineering limitation. I think that new advances

0:46:36.600 --> 0:46:39.719
<v Speaker 2>in material science make that not so much of a

0:46:39.760 --> 0:46:41.890
<v Speaker 2>problem anymore. And so I think we're going to get

0:46:41.930 --> 0:46:44.810
<v Speaker 2>to the point where we're able to build megastructures at

0:46:44.910 --> 0:46:49.330
<v Speaker 2>sea that persist for thousands of years without any significant maintenance.

0:46:49.370 --> 0:46:53.090
<v Speaker 2>And that'll be a very, very interesting thing that'll reorder

0:46:53.110 --> 0:46:55.100
<v Speaker 2>the economy and politics in a lot of ways.

0:46:55.360 --> 0:46:58.180
<v Speaker 3>This coming from the kid who read Jules Verne, right?

0:46:59.460 --> 0:47:01.520
<v Speaker 2>Look, I got to say, the best way to predict

0:47:01.540 --> 0:47:04.120
<v Speaker 2>the future is to build it. But I think people

0:47:04.200 --> 0:47:06.609
<v Speaker 2>often end up building the future that was put right

0:47:06.620 --> 0:47:08.569
<v Speaker 2>in front of them by science fiction authors. And so

0:47:09.510 --> 0:47:11.380
<v Speaker 2>I can't say I've ever come up with an idea

0:47:11.390 --> 0:47:15.500
<v Speaker 2>that some science fiction author I've read hasn't come up

0:47:15.540 --> 0:47:18.660
<v Speaker 2>with better. But yeah, I'm a big believer in the

0:47:18.680 --> 0:47:21.500
<v Speaker 2>concept of seasteading. I think it's going to come back around.

0:47:21.540 --> 0:47:24.319
<v Speaker 2>It's out of vogue right now, but it'll come back.

0:47:25.180 --> 0:47:27.549
<v Speaker 3>Palmer Luckey, thank you for joining us.

0:47:28.110 --> 0:47:28.469
<v Speaker 2>Thank you.

0:47:32.850 --> 0:47:37.569
<v Speaker 1>Palmer Luckey represents a new generation in Silicon Valley. He

0:47:37.610 --> 0:47:41.600
<v Speaker 1>believes technologists have an obligation to help defend the United

0:47:41.660 --> 0:47:45.720
<v Speaker 1>States and that if America doesn't build these systems, somebody

0:47:45.800 --> 0:47:50.860
<v Speaker 1>else will. I find some of that argument persuasive. Democracies

0:47:51.239 --> 0:47:55.760
<v Speaker 1>do need defending. But competition can also be a justification

0:47:56.060 --> 0:48:00.980
<v Speaker 1>for moving faster than our judgment. After this interview, I

0:48:01.000 --> 0:48:05.060
<v Speaker 1>was left wondering, how seriously does Palmer take his new

0:48:05.120 --> 0:48:09.359
<v Speaker 1>power and responsibility? does he understand the gravitas of what

0:48:09.400 --> 0:48:12.580
<v Speaker 1>he's doing? This is the same kid who grew up

0:48:12.800 --> 0:48:18.239
<v Speaker 1>idolizing a character from Yu-Gi-Oh!, who, after building VR headsets

0:48:18.300 --> 0:48:22.460
<v Speaker 1>in his childhood bedroom, takes over a multi-billion dollar military

0:48:22.520 --> 0:48:27.569
<v Speaker 1>defense company. Whether or not Palmer sees the parallel, one

0:48:27.610 --> 0:48:32.010
<v Speaker 1>thing is true. He's moved past being inspired by anime

0:48:32.070 --> 0:48:36.280
<v Speaker 1>and Jules Verne, And today, he's building the science fiction

0:48:36.500 --> 0:48:42.600
<v Speaker 1>he once imagined. That's it for today's episode. I'm Walter Isaacson.

0:48:43.180 --> 0:48:45.640
<v Speaker 3>We'll see you next time on The Builders.

0:48:48.380 --> 0:48:51.600
<v Speaker 6>The Builders is a Kaleidoscope and iHeart production. This series

0:48:51.680 --> 0:48:55.040
<v Speaker 6>is hosted by Walter Isaacson. It's executive produced for Kaleidoscope

0:48:55.100 --> 0:48:59.780
<v Speaker 6>by Oswald Lishen, David Weisbord, and Mungish Hatikadu. Sheena Ozaki

0:48:59.820 --> 0:49:03.930
<v Speaker 6>is the producer. Julia Nutter is supervising producer. Eva Zorich

0:49:03.969 --> 0:49:08.480
<v Speaker 6>is our consultant producer. Fact-checking by Eamon Whalen. Research by

0:49:08.520 --> 0:49:12.520
<v Speaker 6>Gloria Teal. Maria Paz Mendez-Hodes is head of video. Marketing

0:49:12.580 --> 0:49:17.330
<v Speaker 6>by Christy Mirabal and Elle Liu. Production support by Dara-Luk Potts.

0:49:17.770 --> 0:49:10.390
<v Speaker 6>Music for the series was created by Spencer Steele. From iHeart,

0:49:10.410 --> 0:49:13.610
<v Speaker 6>this series is EP'd by Allie Perry and Katrina Norvell.

0:49:27.820 --> 0:49:32.140
<v Speaker 6>Special thanks to Bob Pittman, Conal Byrne, Will Pearson, John Sykes,

0:49:32.340 --> 0:49:37.180
<v Speaker 6>Nikki Etor, Carrie Lieberman, Binky Urban, Julia Prosser, Jeremy Blum,

0:49:37.430 --> 0:49:42.750
<v Speaker 6>Alison Goldberger, WYES, and ASL Studios. For more from Walter Isaacson,

0:49:42.830 --> 0:49:45.469
<v Speaker 6>be sure to check out his newest paperback, The Innovators,

0:49:45.650 --> 0:49:48.770
<v Speaker 6>how a group of hackers, geniuses, and geeks created the

0:49:48.830 --> 0:49:52.610
<v Speaker 6>digital revolution. It's available wherever fine books are sold. And

0:49:52.630 --> 0:49:55.510
<v Speaker 6>for more videos and podcasts from the Frontiers of Discovery,

0:49:55.920 --> 0:49:58.379
<v Speaker 6>be sure to check out kaleidoscope.nyc.