1
00:00:09,093 --> 00:00:12,693
Speaker 1: You're listening to a podcast from News Talks B follow

2
00:00:12,773 --> 00:00:16,173
Speaker 1: this and our wide range of podcasts now on iHeartRadio

3
00:00:16,653 --> 00:00:17,053
Speaker 1: and land.

4
00:00:17,093 --> 00:00:21,053
Speaker 2: Revenue is setting at sites on taxing nine thousand club

5
00:00:21,173 --> 00:00:25,892
Speaker 2: societies and other not for profits under changes that could

6
00:00:25,973 --> 00:00:28,973
Speaker 2: be implemented. To chat about this further, we're joined by

7
00:00:29,013 --> 00:00:32,853
Speaker 2: independent tax specialists Jeff Nightingale, who's on the line now. Cheff,

8
00:00:32,933 --> 00:00:34,053
Speaker 2: very good afternoon to you.

9
00:00:34,853 --> 00:00:35,613
Speaker 3: Good afternoon.

10
00:00:36,213 --> 00:00:39,613
Speaker 4: Hey, So Jeff, how does tax on clubs and societies

11
00:00:39,653 --> 00:00:40,293
Speaker 4: currently work?

12
00:00:41,533 --> 00:00:45,492
Speaker 3: Yes, so, at the moment they have one thousand dollars

13
00:00:46,173 --> 00:00:50,452
Speaker 3: tax free threshold for interest income from investments and things.

14
00:00:50,893 --> 00:00:54,373
Speaker 3: But all of their transactions with their members, subscriptions in

15
00:00:54,493 --> 00:00:57,813
Speaker 3: any trading amongst the members that they generally have been

16
00:00:57,853 --> 00:01:00,892
Speaker 3: seen to be not taxable tax free because they are

17
00:01:00,973 --> 00:01:03,413
Speaker 3: mutual transactions. They're not about making a profit, but just

18
00:01:03,453 --> 00:01:08,653
Speaker 3: about sharing the costs around around the members. And it's

19
00:01:08,693 --> 00:01:12,093
Speaker 3: that that ideas suggesting might have to change.

20
00:01:12,373 --> 00:01:15,933
Speaker 4: So we're talking subs at a bowling club, for example.

21
00:01:17,413 --> 00:01:19,333
Speaker 3: Yeah, probably not a bowling club. So there is a

22
00:01:19,333 --> 00:01:24,693
Speaker 3: specific exemption for pure sporting amateur sporting bodies. We're talking

23
00:01:24,853 --> 00:01:29,213
Speaker 3: maybe subs at a bridge club. We're talking contributions to

24
00:01:29,253 --> 00:01:34,333
Speaker 3: your local residents association, body, corporate, you know, a myriad

25
00:01:34,453 --> 00:01:41,013
Speaker 3: of you know, non profit making mutual associations where people

26
00:01:41,093 --> 00:01:43,013
Speaker 3: organize themselves together and share the costs.

27
00:01:43,333 --> 00:01:46,652
Speaker 4: Right, so you could say, like on the most sort

28
00:01:46,652 --> 00:01:48,253
Speaker 4: of lowest level of it, even though they are a

29
00:01:48,293 --> 00:01:50,773
Speaker 4: great time, especially when they're up in a nightclub. But

30
00:01:50,933 --> 00:01:53,053
Speaker 4: say you're running a book club with your friends, and

31
00:01:53,093 --> 00:01:55,813
Speaker 4: you will put some money into the book club. The

32
00:01:55,853 --> 00:01:57,613
Speaker 4: ID thinks it should take some of that.

33
00:01:58,773 --> 00:02:03,013
Speaker 3: Well, yes, but a bit more confidence in that. What's

34
00:02:03,053 --> 00:02:06,853
Speaker 3: happened is that they have they've reached an interpretation internally

35
00:02:06,853 --> 00:02:10,973
Speaker 3: that changes their view of the law, and that changes

36
00:02:11,013 --> 00:02:14,933
Speaker 3: the view from those subscriptions or levees were non taxable,

37
00:02:15,213 --> 00:02:18,093
Speaker 3: and now they're saying it's possible that they're taxable, and

38
00:02:18,173 --> 00:02:21,853
Speaker 3: so now they're consulting on that before they change their view. Formally,

39
00:02:21,893 --> 00:02:23,853
Speaker 3: they're saying, hey, what does everyone think about this? And

40
00:02:23,893 --> 00:02:26,653
Speaker 3: I think the answer is we don't like change and

41
00:02:26,693 --> 00:02:30,933
Speaker 3: we want to stay the status quiet. I mean, I think,

42
00:02:31,013 --> 00:02:33,733
Speaker 3: to be fair, the subtext is they are collecting evidence

43
00:02:33,773 --> 00:02:35,933
Speaker 3: to go back to the Ministry of Revenue and say

44
00:02:36,093 --> 00:02:38,972
Speaker 3: we don't want to make this change. Here's a whole

45
00:02:39,013 --> 00:02:42,972
Speaker 3: bunch of reasons on our consultation, So let's tweak the

46
00:02:43,053 --> 00:02:44,733
Speaker 3: law so we don't have to make this change. I

47
00:02:44,733 --> 00:02:45,733
Speaker 3: think that's what's happening.

48
00:02:46,213 --> 00:02:51,093
Speaker 4: And is this looking at churches and businesses like sanitarium

49
00:02:51,133 --> 00:02:56,093
Speaker 4: for example, Is this under this whole scope of this investigation.

50
00:02:56,813 --> 00:03:02,293
Speaker 3: Yes, that's right. So we were expecting a discussion document

51
00:03:02,373 --> 00:03:06,972
Speaker 3: on the taxation of charitable businesses and that's the sanitariums

52
00:03:06,972 --> 00:03:10,173
Speaker 3: and others of this world tacked onto that was a

53
00:03:10,252 --> 00:03:13,213
Speaker 3: chapter dealing with this not for profit. So that bit

54
00:03:13,293 --> 00:03:16,493
Speaker 3: caught us by surprise. So we were expecting the government

55
00:03:16,532 --> 00:03:18,693
Speaker 3: to do some work on whether they should tax the

56
00:03:18,853 --> 00:03:20,573
Speaker 3: business operations of charities.

57
00:03:22,013 --> 00:03:26,453
Speaker 2: The unintended consequences of changes to text legislation, and it

58
00:03:26,493 --> 00:03:28,572
Speaker 2: worries me when they are, you know, they change their

59
00:03:28,613 --> 00:03:32,213
Speaker 2: interpretation of the law. For most people, you'd think the

60
00:03:32,293 --> 00:03:35,333
Speaker 2: law is the law and interpretation shouldn't come into it.

61
00:03:35,733 --> 00:03:39,493
Speaker 2: Is that just the complexity when there are changes to

62
00:03:39,733 --> 00:03:41,653
Speaker 2: these particular tax laws.

63
00:03:42,533 --> 00:03:45,773
Speaker 3: Yeah, you're absolutely right. Certainty of tax law is an

64
00:03:45,813 --> 00:03:50,973
Speaker 3: important thing and changes are very unsettling and to be avoided.

65
00:03:52,013 --> 00:03:56,093
Speaker 3: Sometimes it's unavoidable, and you know, I've advised many clubs

66
00:03:56,093 --> 00:03:59,133
Speaker 3: and associations over the years, and we've always dealt with

67
00:03:59,173 --> 00:04:02,933
Speaker 3: it in the way that IOD accepted, and so this

68
00:04:03,053 --> 00:04:08,053
Speaker 3: change is a surprise and creates uncertainty. I think IOD

69
00:04:08,413 --> 00:04:12,333
Speaker 3: in their own way attempting to cure it, but at

70
00:04:12,333 --> 00:04:14,893
Speaker 3: the moment we are left with uncertainty if you are

71
00:04:14,933 --> 00:04:18,373
Speaker 3: the treasurer of a club or a little association.

72
00:04:20,093 --> 00:04:22,293
Speaker 4: So just to make this clear, because I'm a little

73
00:04:22,293 --> 00:04:24,773
Speaker 4: bit confused on that. So they're planning to target around

74
00:04:24,853 --> 00:04:27,453
Speaker 4: nine thousand clubs. What's the difference between a club, a

75
00:04:27,453 --> 00:04:29,333
Speaker 4: society and a trade association.

76
00:04:30,773 --> 00:04:37,893
Speaker 3: Well, they might be formed under different laws like incorporated

77
00:04:37,933 --> 00:04:43,293
Speaker 3: societies or not. They might just be unincorporated. The unifying

78
00:04:43,333 --> 00:04:46,213
Speaker 3: factors they are not about making a profit. So if

79
00:04:46,253 --> 00:04:48,973
Speaker 3: you think of the Bridge Club, the Bridge Club is

80
00:04:49,013 --> 00:04:51,813
Speaker 3: about helping people play bridge. If you think about the

81
00:04:51,893 --> 00:04:54,693
Speaker 3: Residents Association, it's act as a voice for the residents.

82
00:04:54,693 --> 00:04:57,733
Speaker 3: So they're not about making profits, and they share their

83
00:04:57,773 --> 00:05:01,573
Speaker 3: costs amongst the members. That's how they operate. And so

84
00:05:01,613 --> 00:05:05,173
Speaker 3: that's the nine thousand and some of these very big

85
00:05:05,213 --> 00:05:06,933
Speaker 3: So if you think about a trade union, that's an

86
00:05:06,933 --> 00:05:09,773
Speaker 3: association that's not about MA a profit. It's about as

87
00:05:09,893 --> 00:05:16,413
Speaker 3: members and some of the professional association's trade associations could

88
00:05:16,413 --> 00:05:18,413
Speaker 3: be caught up in all of this. So this is

89
00:05:18,453 --> 00:05:21,853
Speaker 3: a big issue. It has up to now been a

90
00:05:21,933 --> 00:05:24,813
Speaker 3: very settled area of tax law, and they've kind of

91
00:05:25,653 --> 00:05:28,453
Speaker 3: thrown the cat amongst the pigeons. But I think the

92
00:05:28,493 --> 00:05:30,733
Speaker 3: purpose of the discussion document is to try and find

93
00:05:30,933 --> 00:05:32,573
Speaker 3: good reasons to fix the problems.

94
00:05:33,253 --> 00:05:36,773
Speaker 4: We're talking to independent tax specialists. Jeff Nightingale, So you

95
00:05:36,813 --> 00:05:40,253
Speaker 4: said before that there's different provisions for a sports club,

96
00:05:40,573 --> 00:05:43,613
Speaker 4: and you see it might be different from a sports

97
00:05:43,613 --> 00:05:46,573
Speaker 4: club as opposed to a bridge club. Is that correct?

98
00:05:47,173 --> 00:05:51,013
Speaker 3: Yes, yes, So there is a specific tax exemption for

99
00:05:51,293 --> 00:05:55,333
Speaker 3: the promotion of amateur sport and that's been there for

100
00:05:55,453 --> 00:06:00,613
Speaker 3: years and there's no suggestion that that's going to change.

101
00:06:00,653 --> 00:06:04,733
Speaker 3: That's not being mentioned. So that should take out all

102
00:06:04,773 --> 00:06:08,453
Speaker 3: of the sports clubs that the pure sports clubs. You

103
00:06:08,493 --> 00:06:12,853
Speaker 3: do get into definitional the challenges. What's the sport and

104
00:06:12,893 --> 00:06:13,493
Speaker 3: what I'm going to.

105
00:06:13,493 --> 00:06:16,933
Speaker 4: Say so because because someone might say bridge, you know,

106
00:06:17,413 --> 00:06:19,853
Speaker 4: is kind of a sport. Is chess considered a sport?

107
00:06:20,493 --> 00:06:21,693
Speaker 2: Bingo? That's on the.

108
00:06:21,653 --> 00:06:25,653
Speaker 3: Line exactly, Yeah, walking bingo yeah.

109
00:06:25,733 --> 00:06:27,733
Speaker 4: Yeah, well, I mean, well, I've got kids that try

110
00:06:27,773 --> 00:06:29,373
Speaker 4: and claim that Fortnite is a sport.

111
00:06:32,973 --> 00:06:35,693
Speaker 2: Jeff, thank you very much for having just.

112
00:06:35,653 --> 00:06:36,053
Speaker 1: Before we go.

113
00:06:36,293 --> 00:06:38,773
Speaker 4: Do you think that seriously in this in this look

114
00:06:38,853 --> 00:06:42,133
Speaker 4: that things like, I guess, musical clubs, you know, pastime clubs,

115
00:06:42,173 --> 00:06:46,813
Speaker 4: motor clubs, I'm just pulling clubs out of my oment court.

116
00:06:47,133 --> 00:06:49,253
Speaker 4: That would that would be that would seem terrible to me,

117
00:06:49,333 --> 00:06:52,452
Speaker 4: because because in my opinion that clubs. We need more clubs,

118
00:06:52,533 --> 00:06:54,413
Speaker 4: We need more people in the community getting out and

119
00:06:54,413 --> 00:06:58,013
Speaker 4: getting together. And I feel very sorry. I see club houses,

120
00:06:58,053 --> 00:07:00,893
Speaker 4: I see people trying to organize these things, and there's

121
00:07:00,933 --> 00:07:03,253
Speaker 4: a lot of stress on these people. Everyone's really really busy,

122
00:07:03,573 --> 00:07:05,773
Speaker 4: and they're trying to put these things together that are

123
00:07:05,773 --> 00:07:08,493
Speaker 4: good for the community, and I would just hate to

124
00:07:08,533 --> 00:07:12,893
Speaker 4: see another level of admin or another level of difficulty

125
00:07:12,893 --> 00:07:14,813
Speaker 4: put on these people to the point where they just

126
00:07:14,853 --> 00:07:16,133
Speaker 4: throw up the hands in the air and go, I

127
00:07:16,133 --> 00:07:17,413
Speaker 4: can't be bother doing this anymore.

128
00:07:18,253 --> 00:07:22,333
Speaker 3: I completely agree, but I also suspect that I do

129
00:07:22,453 --> 00:07:24,813
Speaker 3: agree with you, and they're trying to get enough feedback

130
00:07:24,853 --> 00:07:27,773
Speaker 3: to go back to the Minister of Revenue and say, hey,

131
00:07:27,813 --> 00:07:30,173
Speaker 3: this isn't a good idea to make this change?

132
00:07:30,213 --> 00:07:33,613
Speaker 4: Okay, so this is my feedback. It's not a good idea.

133
00:07:34,293 --> 00:07:38,253
Speaker 4: There's a feedback. Write your submission, yeah yeah, and look,

134
00:07:38,293 --> 00:07:40,053
Speaker 4: you can have your feedback on this on eight hundred

135
00:07:40,093 --> 00:07:43,333
Speaker 4: eighty ten eighty and nine two nine two, and also

136
00:07:43,333 --> 00:07:45,533
Speaker 4: write a submission. Hey, thank you so much. That was

137
00:07:46,133 --> 00:07:48,893
Speaker 4: independent tax specialist Jeff Nightingale.

138
00:07:49,533 --> 00:07:52,173
Speaker 1: For more from News Talks ed B listen live on

139
00:07:52,253 --> 00:07:55,213
Speaker 1: air or online, and keep our shows with you wherever

140
00:07:55,253 --> 00:07:57,813
Speaker 1: you go with our podcasts on iHeartRadio