WEBVTT - Parties submit single PR candidate lists

0:00:04.210 --> 0:00:09.729
<v Speaker 1>So, I'm asking this morning why some political parties have

0:00:09.840 --> 0:00:15.580
<v Speaker 1>submitted single PR candidate lists for the metros and what

0:00:15.620 --> 0:00:18.739
<v Speaker 1>the consequences of that could be. So, there are a

0:00:18.840 --> 0:00:22.599
<v Speaker 1>number of political parties that have submitted just one candidate

0:00:22.680 --> 0:00:28.000
<v Speaker 1>on their proportional representation lists for the upcoming municipal elections,

0:00:28.060 --> 0:00:35.370
<v Speaker 1>despite the potentially winning multiple PR seats. ActionSA, the EFF,

0:00:35.670 --> 0:00:41.449
<v Speaker 1>MK Party, Good and Co. are among those that have

0:00:41.470 --> 0:00:44.870
<v Speaker 1>submitted single names on some of their PR lists, which

0:00:44.950 --> 0:00:48.090
<v Speaker 1>means that voters will not see a full list of

0:00:48.150 --> 0:00:52.349
<v Speaker 1>potential candidates for any additional PR seats that the party

0:00:52.380 --> 0:00:56.580
<v Speaker 1>may secure. ActionSA has said that it deliberately submitted single

0:00:56.640 --> 0:01:01.390
<v Speaker 1>candidates because it wants to reward candidates after the election

0:01:01.430 --> 0:01:04.410
<v Speaker 1>results are known. But when you look at the Municipal

0:01:04.450 --> 0:01:08.850
<v Speaker 1>Structures Act, a party may not supplement or change its

0:01:08.930 --> 0:01:12.330
<v Speaker 1>list from the date of the closure of nomination of

0:01:12.410 --> 0:01:16.970
<v Speaker 1>candidates for an election until a day after the date

0:01:17.110 --> 0:01:19.789
<v Speaker 1>of the first council meeting, which means that even if

0:01:19.850 --> 0:01:23.090
<v Speaker 1>a party has won several PR seats, the first council

0:01:23.140 --> 0:01:26.780
<v Speaker 1>meeting will go ahead with vacant positions if the party

0:01:26.800 --> 0:01:29.900
<v Speaker 1>is has only named one candidate. And a scenario like

0:01:29.940 --> 0:01:33.080
<v Speaker 1>that could potentially affect a vote to form a coalition

0:01:33.580 --> 0:01:36.590
<v Speaker 1>in a council where no party has won an outright majority.

0:01:37.030 --> 0:01:40.190
<v Speaker 1>So we've invited now on the line Helen Ziller, who

0:01:40.209 --> 0:01:44.110
<v Speaker 1>is the DA mayoral candidate in Johannesburg, because they seem

0:01:44.130 --> 0:01:46.670
<v Speaker 1>to have picked this up and they may be threatening

0:01:46.709 --> 0:01:49.610
<v Speaker 1>some court action. She'll explain that to us. I've also

0:01:49.630 --> 0:01:54.500
<v Speaker 1>invited Terry Tselani, who is the executive chairman of the

0:01:54.580 --> 0:01:59.120
<v Speaker 1>Institute of election management services in Africa. So we'll start

0:01:59.160 --> 0:02:01.700
<v Speaker 1>this chat with Helen Ziller, who's joining us now on

0:02:01.740 --> 0:02:03.320
<v Speaker 1>the line. Helen, thanks for making time.

0:02:03.360 --> 0:02:06.000
<v Speaker 2>Good morning. It's always a pleasure, Clement. Good to be

0:02:06.040 --> 0:02:06.440
<v Speaker 2>with you.

0:02:06.980 --> 0:02:10.850
<v Speaker 1>What exactly is the DA's concern with this approach by

0:02:10.950 --> 0:02:14.049
<v Speaker 1>some of these parties, MK Party, EFF, and Action SA?

0:02:15.090 --> 0:02:18.690
<v Speaker 2>Well, in the past, parties used to submit one name

0:02:18.770 --> 0:02:21.780
<v Speaker 2>for their list and then supplement that list after the

0:02:21.840 --> 0:02:25.750
<v Speaker 2>election with and before the first council meeting where you

0:02:25.810 --> 0:02:29.609
<v Speaker 2>elect the mayor and the speaker. Now, the act was

0:02:29.669 --> 0:02:34.810
<v Speaker 2>amended in 2021 in part to prevent this kind of

0:02:34.930 --> 0:02:40.310
<v Speaker 2>undemocratic behavior because when voters are voting for a party

0:02:40.350 --> 0:02:44.880
<v Speaker 2>that is unlikely to win any ward seats but likely

0:02:44.940 --> 0:02:48.580
<v Speaker 2>to win quite a few proportional list seats, and Action

0:02:48.740 --> 0:02:51.940
<v Speaker 2>SA and EFF are two of those parties as an example,

0:02:52.370 --> 0:02:55.790
<v Speaker 2>they will win quite a number of list seats, but

0:02:55.950 --> 0:02:59.910
<v Speaker 2>probably no ward seats. Then their list becomes very important

0:02:59.990 --> 0:03:03.049
<v Speaker 2>because then people know who they're voting for. So the

0:03:03.130 --> 0:03:06.329
<v Speaker 2>idea of the amendment was to make it more democratic,

0:03:06.389 --> 0:03:09.890
<v Speaker 2>to say voters, and this is about voters, not rewarding

0:03:10.070 --> 0:03:14.160
<v Speaker 2>candidates who worked hard in the election. Voters have a

0:03:14.260 --> 0:03:18.220
<v Speaker 2>right to know who they are voting for. And that

0:03:18.280 --> 0:03:22.540
<v Speaker 2>is why the IEC publishes the list. So everyone knows

0:03:22.700 --> 0:03:25.799
<v Speaker 2>who they are voting for in order of precedence from

0:03:25.860 --> 0:03:29.440
<v Speaker 2>number one to number however many they put on. So

0:03:29.960 --> 0:03:32.799
<v Speaker 2>you're not allowed in our interpretation of the law to

0:03:33.600 --> 0:03:37.040
<v Speaker 2>only put forward one candidate if you know full well

0:03:37.080 --> 0:03:41.220
<v Speaker 2>you're not only going to win one list candidate. And

0:03:41.280 --> 0:03:44.510
<v Speaker 2>it's bad faith to do so. And in fact, it

0:03:44.550 --> 0:03:48.060
<v Speaker 2>could be seen as fraudulent. in certain interpretations of the

0:03:48.120 --> 0:03:51.360
<v Speaker 2>Constitution and the law as we read it. So we

0:03:51.460 --> 0:03:53.960
<v Speaker 2>are going to court today to ask for a declarator

0:03:54.140 --> 0:03:57.320
<v Speaker 2>on this. But this is a very bad indication of

0:03:57.340 --> 0:03:59.360
<v Speaker 2>the parties who know they're going to win quite a

0:03:59.440 --> 0:04:03.520
<v Speaker 2>few list seats, who only put down one person, because

0:04:03.660 --> 0:04:07.140
<v Speaker 2>it shows that they are deeply autocratic. They're saying to

0:04:07.160 --> 0:04:09.640
<v Speaker 2>the voters, we don't give you a chance to choose

0:04:10.000 --> 0:04:14.200
<v Speaker 2>who you want to be elected. Just vote for us, blind,

0:04:14.600 --> 0:04:18.370
<v Speaker 2>fly blind in good faith, And let us choose after

0:04:18.390 --> 0:04:21.589
<v Speaker 2>the election. Or let the leader choose who's going to

0:04:21.630 --> 0:04:24.510
<v Speaker 2>be on the list after the election. And the amendment

0:04:24.950 --> 0:04:28.000
<v Speaker 2>to the Act was in part to prevent that kind

0:04:28.020 --> 0:04:29.140
<v Speaker 2>of autocratic behavior.

0:04:29.839 --> 0:04:31.920
<v Speaker 1>So when you go to the courts today, do you

0:04:31.940 --> 0:04:35.200
<v Speaker 1>want the court to confirm that the parties cannot supplement

0:04:35.240 --> 0:04:38.700
<v Speaker 1>their peer lists before the first council meeting or an

0:04:38.740 --> 0:04:41.159
<v Speaker 1>interpretation of the Act? Or are you more concerned about

0:04:41.180 --> 0:04:45.770
<v Speaker 1>the quote-unquote undemocratic approach that these parties have taken?

0:04:46.920 --> 0:04:50.229
<v Speaker 2>Well, we are concerned about people abiding by the law

0:04:50.290 --> 0:04:52.969
<v Speaker 2>and the intention of the amendment to the Act in 2021.

0:04:52.970 --> 0:04:57.130
<v Speaker 2>So item 20 of Schedule 1 of the Structures Act

0:04:57.170 --> 0:05:02.770
<v Speaker 2>was amended. It gives a very clear prohibition of supplementing

0:05:02.870 --> 0:05:06.150
<v Speaker 2>or changing a list from the date of closure for

0:05:06.170 --> 0:05:10.890
<v Speaker 2>the nomination of candidates and then to after the date

0:05:11.070 --> 0:05:12.890
<v Speaker 2>of the first council meeting, which is when you can

0:05:12.940 --> 0:05:15.920
<v Speaker 2>start making changes. So the purpose of that is to say,

0:05:16.790 --> 0:05:20.090
<v Speaker 2>Voters have to know who they are voting for, and

0:05:20.110 --> 0:05:22.589
<v Speaker 2>they have to see your list. And if you only

0:05:22.630 --> 0:05:26.120
<v Speaker 2>publish one person on the list, you're not showing who

0:05:26.300 --> 0:05:29.080
<v Speaker 2>people are voting for, especially if you're not only going

0:05:29.100 --> 0:05:32.180
<v Speaker 2>to get one person. So that makes it a prohibition,

0:05:32.540 --> 0:05:36.580
<v Speaker 2>item 20 to schedule one. There is a possibility for

0:05:36.640 --> 0:05:41.040
<v Speaker 2>some exceptions to be made under item 17, which says

0:05:41.420 --> 0:05:44.810
<v Speaker 2>if you in good faith put forward a list of

0:05:44.820 --> 0:05:47.190
<v Speaker 2>the number of of list candidates you think you will

0:05:47.210 --> 0:05:49.830
<v Speaker 2>get elected, but you happen to get a few more,

0:05:50.430 --> 0:05:52.750
<v Speaker 2>maybe because you didn't win the awards that you expected

0:05:52.770 --> 0:05:55.930
<v Speaker 2>to win, so you get a few more list seats, well,

0:05:55.970 --> 0:05:58.630
<v Speaker 2>then we can supplement them for you. But the idea

0:05:58.750 --> 0:06:00.650
<v Speaker 2>is that you first have to be in good faith.

0:06:01.270 --> 0:06:05.410
<v Speaker 2>You first have to put forward a coherent list of

0:06:06.150 --> 0:06:10.450
<v Speaker 2>the candidates in ranked order, because you know, believe that

0:06:10.490 --> 0:06:12.070
<v Speaker 2>that is the number of seats you're going to be

0:06:12.089 --> 0:06:15.480
<v Speaker 2>able to fill from your list. You cannot, knowing very

0:06:15.560 --> 0:06:19.240
<v Speaker 2>well that you will get elected more than one seat,

0:06:19.680 --> 0:06:23.620
<v Speaker 2>you cannot therefore only put up a list on one person.

0:06:24.400 --> 0:06:27.600
<v Speaker 1>And if there are vacant PR seats, I mean, that

0:06:27.660 --> 0:06:30.460
<v Speaker 1>can change the balance of power at the first sitting

0:06:30.500 --> 0:06:34.700
<v Speaker 1>of council in your favor when it comes to forming

0:06:34.740 --> 0:06:38.110
<v Speaker 1>an administration or even negotiating a coalition. So this can

0:06:38.140 --> 0:06:42.349
<v Speaker 1>favor parties that have put, you know, have sort of

0:06:42.390 --> 0:06:45.910
<v Speaker 1>filled the list of the PR, that PR list, because

0:06:45.930 --> 0:06:48.150
<v Speaker 1>then you're going to have people in council that can

0:06:48.190 --> 0:06:48.830
<v Speaker 1>vote you in.

0:06:50.370 --> 0:06:52.890
<v Speaker 2>Well, the bottom line is that it favors the voters

0:06:53.710 --> 0:06:56.839
<v Speaker 2>because voters have to know who they are voting for.

0:06:57.480 --> 0:06:59.539
<v Speaker 2>And let's say you're a voter and you vote for

0:06:59.560 --> 0:07:04.710
<v Speaker 2>the EFF. You don't know who you're voting for. You

0:07:04.750 --> 0:07:09.299
<v Speaker 2>know that they will definitely get Dr. Mofokeng, their mayoral candidate, in,

0:07:09.360 --> 0:07:12.340
<v Speaker 2>but they've published nobody else. So who are you voting for?

0:07:13.420 --> 0:07:16.520
<v Speaker 2>The purpose of this amendment was to make sure that

0:07:16.620 --> 0:07:19.800
<v Speaker 2>voters are put first, which is right, and that they

0:07:19.880 --> 0:07:21.960
<v Speaker 2>know who they are voting for. They are not giving

0:07:21.990 --> 0:07:26.070
<v Speaker 2>a party leader like Herman Meshaba or Julius Malema the

0:07:26.110 --> 0:07:29.050
<v Speaker 2>right to invent a list after the election that they

0:07:29.090 --> 0:07:32.370
<v Speaker 2>didn't vote for. And that is the purpose of the amendment.

0:07:33.170 --> 0:07:35.910
<v Speaker 1>Yeah, and I'm asking now about the consequence on the

0:07:35.950 --> 0:07:38.910
<v Speaker 1>first day of the sitting of council. What's the consequence

0:07:38.950 --> 0:07:39.310
<v Speaker 1>of that?

0:07:40.210 --> 0:07:42.890
<v Speaker 2>So the consequence will be that the councillors who were

0:07:42.970 --> 0:07:45.910
<v Speaker 2>elected and who the voters knew they were voting for

0:07:46.510 --> 0:07:50.030
<v Speaker 2>will be in the council electing a speaker and electing

0:07:50.090 --> 0:07:54.810
<v Speaker 2>a mayor. The people who were just autocratically nominated by

0:07:54.880 --> 0:07:58.700
<v Speaker 2>party leaders after the election and were not voted for

0:07:59.440 --> 0:08:02.260
<v Speaker 2>by the voters won't be there. That's the consequence.

0:08:03.450 --> 0:08:06.370
<v Speaker 1>All right, Helen Ziller, thank you so much for coming

0:08:06.450 --> 0:08:11.070
<v Speaker 1>through and laying out what your concerns are. Action SA

0:08:11.510 --> 0:08:15.720
<v Speaker 1>sent us a written response saying that the IEC allows

0:08:15.860 --> 0:08:19.360
<v Speaker 1>all political parties to supplement their PR list based on

0:08:19.380 --> 0:08:22.220
<v Speaker 1>the number of seats they possess. There is a defined

0:08:22.300 --> 0:08:26.750
<v Speaker 1>window for this amendment following voting day. Action SA took

0:08:26.790 --> 0:08:30.410
<v Speaker 1>a deliberate decision to submit one name only, and that's

0:08:30.450 --> 0:08:33.520
<v Speaker 1>the name of Haman Mashabah, so that the party can

0:08:33.559 --> 0:08:36.720
<v Speaker 1>then supplement the list based on how many seats we

0:08:36.760 --> 0:08:40.920
<v Speaker 1>have won. This supplemented list is based on the outcomes

0:08:40.980 --> 0:08:46.300
<v Speaker 1>of award candidates where we are contesting across the city

0:08:46.340 --> 0:08:50.760
<v Speaker 1>of Johannesburg. Candidates were provided their KPIs by the regional

0:08:50.880 --> 0:08:54.610
<v Speaker 1>and provincial leadership, so the party will consider additional variables

0:08:55.090 --> 0:08:59.910
<v Speaker 1>like skills and representations as balancing factors of the supplemented list.

0:09:00.640 --> 0:09:04.040
<v Speaker 1>So that's the written response that came from Action SA's

0:09:04.120 --> 0:09:09.320
<v Speaker 1>Jobek campaign manager. I want to bring in now Terry Tselani,

0:09:10.140 --> 0:09:15.179
<v Speaker 1>who is the executive chairman of the Institute of Election

0:09:15.559 --> 0:09:17.260
<v Speaker 1>Management Services in Africa.

0:09:17.300 --> 0:09:17.449
<v Speaker 3>Mr.

0:09:17.470 --> 0:09:20.030
<v Speaker 1>Tselani, thank you so much for also making time for us.

0:09:20.030 --> 0:09:20.750
<v Speaker 1>Good morning. Good morning.

0:09:22.309 --> 0:09:24.010
<v Speaker 3>Good morning to you and to your listeners, and thank

0:09:24.030 --> 0:09:24.830
<v Speaker 3>you very much for having me.

0:09:25.130 --> 0:09:28.970
<v Speaker 1>So, are these political parties you've submitted, you know, the

0:09:29.010 --> 0:09:32.120
<v Speaker 1>name of one person for their peer list, are they

0:09:32.150 --> 0:09:36.660
<v Speaker 1>within their rights? What does this Municipal Structures Act say

0:09:36.720 --> 0:09:40.440
<v Speaker 1>about a party changing or supplementing its peer candidate list

0:09:40.480 --> 0:09:41.880
<v Speaker 1>after nominations have closed?

0:09:44.160 --> 0:09:50.630
<v Speaker 3>Well, in terms of Section 2 of the local government

0:09:50.690 --> 0:09:55.670
<v Speaker 3>municipal structure sect a party and then we can go

0:09:55.740 --> 0:10:04.100
<v Speaker 3>to sub section 10 a political party that receives more

0:10:04.160 --> 0:10:10.700
<v Speaker 3>seats than it has submitted the list will be asked

0:10:10.760 --> 0:10:14.760
<v Speaker 3>by the chief electoral officer to supplement that list. And therefore,

0:10:15.320 --> 0:10:21.790
<v Speaker 3>political parties that would have fewer seats would have, say

0:10:22.130 --> 0:10:26.510
<v Speaker 3>for instance, one representative in the PR list would be

0:10:26.570 --> 0:10:34.700
<v Speaker 3>entitled in terms of that section to supplement that list

0:10:34.900 --> 0:10:38.140
<v Speaker 3>even before the council meets. So immediately after the results

0:10:38.160 --> 0:10:42.219
<v Speaker 3>have been announced and the political party has got more seats,

0:10:42.280 --> 0:10:47.250
<v Speaker 3>it will be asked by the chief electoral officer to

0:10:47.309 --> 0:10:48.230
<v Speaker 3>supplement its list.

0:10:49.260 --> 0:10:53.179
<v Speaker 1>Okay, so then that takes away the risk of that

0:10:53.260 --> 0:10:57.660
<v Speaker 1>first sitting of council where you only have one person

0:10:57.700 --> 0:11:00.180
<v Speaker 1>who was on the PR list and if the voting

0:11:00.220 --> 0:11:04.160
<v Speaker 1>for the mayor happens, then your party may face some

0:11:04.200 --> 0:11:07.300
<v Speaker 1>consequences here. So you're saying immediately after the elections, that

0:11:07.320 --> 0:11:10.800
<v Speaker 1>opportunity to supplement the list exists even before the first

0:11:11.140 --> 0:11:11.860
<v Speaker 1>council sitting?

0:11:13.640 --> 0:11:18.400
<v Speaker 3>Absolutely. In fact, the amendment that Helen is referring to

0:11:19.309 --> 0:11:31.449
<v Speaker 3>when it comes to Section Schedule 2 and that particular section,

0:11:32.190 --> 0:11:37.200
<v Speaker 3>it emphasizes the fact that the chief electoral officer must

0:11:37.220 --> 0:11:41.680
<v Speaker 3>do this within two days. So the only insertion in

0:11:41.700 --> 0:11:45.579
<v Speaker 3>the amendment is that of saying this must be done

0:11:46.160 --> 0:11:50.740
<v Speaker 3>within two days of a notice of a list supplemented

0:11:50.800 --> 0:11:53.880
<v Speaker 3>by the name or names of one or more eligible candidates.

0:11:53.940 --> 0:11:58.110
<v Speaker 3>If I can just read the section for you. It says,

0:11:59.190 --> 0:12:03.270
<v Speaker 3>if a party list contains fewer candidates than the party

0:12:03.390 --> 0:12:07.690
<v Speaker 3>is entitled to, the chief electoral officer must, in writing,

0:12:08.350 --> 0:12:14.350
<v Speaker 3>immediately notify the party of the exact shortfall and request

0:12:14.370 --> 0:12:18.240
<v Speaker 3>the party to deliver within two days. of the notice,

0:12:18.420 --> 0:12:22.319
<v Speaker 3>a list supplemented by the name or names of one

0:12:22.600 --> 0:12:27.660
<v Speaker 3>or more eligible candidates. So this has got to happen.

0:12:27.780 --> 0:12:32.110
<v Speaker 3>Once a chief electoral officer announces the results of the

0:12:32.160 --> 0:12:37.929
<v Speaker 3>election and then finds that this particular party has fewer candidates,

0:12:38.870 --> 0:12:41.070
<v Speaker 3>the chief electoral officer will then send a notice to

0:12:41.090 --> 0:12:44.030
<v Speaker 3>that party in order for that party to supplement its

0:12:44.090 --> 0:12:48.420
<v Speaker 3>list And that party must do that within two days.

0:12:48.920 --> 0:12:54.970
<v Speaker 3>So that amendment for that particular section only indicates the

0:12:55.090 --> 0:12:59.689
<v Speaker 3>period within which a response must be given by the

0:13:00.550 --> 0:13:01.209
<v Speaker 3>said party.

0:13:01.470 --> 0:13:01.730
<v Speaker 2>Okay.

0:13:02.230 --> 0:13:06.319
<v Speaker 1>It appears the DA is, well, at least from my reading,

0:13:06.679 --> 0:13:12.640
<v Speaker 1>their priority is more about the democratic process that's being

0:13:12.840 --> 0:13:17.570
<v Speaker 1>affected here because Helen Zilla, as you heard, says the

0:13:17.610 --> 0:13:20.370
<v Speaker 1>people who are voting for these organizations don't know who

0:13:20.410 --> 0:13:23.630
<v Speaker 1>they are voting for. They see, yes, Hemant Mashaba is

0:13:23.650 --> 0:13:28.710
<v Speaker 1>the mayoral candidate or Dr. Taleng or, you know, Bongani

0:13:28.750 --> 0:13:32.080
<v Speaker 1>from the MK party, Mr. Baloi, but actually they don't

0:13:32.100 --> 0:13:34.500
<v Speaker 1>know who else is on the PR list. So is

0:13:34.620 --> 0:13:37.540
<v Speaker 1>that a democratic process? Because Helen says the reason that

0:13:37.800 --> 0:13:40.580
<v Speaker 1>the IEC in fact releases the list so that people

0:13:40.660 --> 0:13:42.939
<v Speaker 1>know who they are voting for. What do you make

0:13:42.980 --> 0:13:43.640
<v Speaker 1>of that argument?

0:13:45.210 --> 0:13:51.930
<v Speaker 3>Well, it's a different argument altogether because then we are

0:13:51.970 --> 0:13:55.240
<v Speaker 3>moving away from what the provision of the law says.

0:13:56.460 --> 0:14:01.300
<v Speaker 3>So they will actually be, if I understand it well,

0:14:02.380 --> 0:14:07.060
<v Speaker 3>they will actually be taking the provision that are there

0:14:07.120 --> 0:14:11.330
<v Speaker 3>on law to say this is undemocratic and therefore it

0:14:11.380 --> 0:14:16.700
<v Speaker 3>must be repealed. But it cannot work that way. So

0:14:17.740 --> 0:14:21.960
<v Speaker 3>for this period, for those people who, even if in

0:14:22.180 --> 0:14:30.220
<v Speaker 3>other ways this section were to be repealed, it will

0:14:30.240 --> 0:14:35.760
<v Speaker 3>not affect the current councillors. who are going to be

0:14:35.780 --> 0:14:39.820
<v Speaker 3>elected based on this particular aspect. The issue of whether

0:14:39.840 --> 0:14:43.040
<v Speaker 3>it is democratic or undemocratic, I think it's a completely

0:14:43.120 --> 0:14:44.320
<v Speaker 3>different debate altogether.

0:14:44.800 --> 0:14:46.760
<v Speaker 1>But what do you make of that debate? Is it

0:14:46.800 --> 0:14:52.660
<v Speaker 1>a strong debate? So, for instance, the IEC says voters

0:14:52.780 --> 0:14:57.190
<v Speaker 1>need to understand who they're voting for. And the reason

0:14:57.230 --> 0:14:59.970
<v Speaker 1>they released the list, which includes the list of, you know,

0:14:59.990 --> 0:15:04.200
<v Speaker 1>the PR list that political parties have, submit is because

0:15:04.240 --> 0:15:06.400
<v Speaker 1>they want voters to know who they are voting for.

0:15:06.440 --> 0:15:10.060
<v Speaker 1>But if, for instance, on the Action Essay or EFF

0:15:10.100 --> 0:15:12.380
<v Speaker 1>or MK Party, you've got one name, which is the

0:15:12.400 --> 0:15:16.350
<v Speaker 1>emerald candidate, and you don't have anyone on that PR list,

0:15:16.910 --> 0:15:20.750
<v Speaker 1>is that democratic? Does that help the voters know who

0:15:20.790 --> 0:15:21.580
<v Speaker 1>they are voting for?

0:15:23.210 --> 0:15:25.650
<v Speaker 3>Well, it is still democratic in the sense that if,

0:15:25.670 --> 0:15:33.640
<v Speaker 3>for instance, any of the people who are in the

0:15:33.700 --> 0:15:40.620
<v Speaker 3>list if any of the people who are in the

0:15:40.660 --> 0:15:45.120
<v Speaker 3>list are to be removed by a political party and

0:15:45.500 --> 0:15:48.830
<v Speaker 3>then inside or you know appoint other people it is

0:15:48.850 --> 0:15:53.050
<v Speaker 3>still within the democratic principles that the political party decides

0:15:53.290 --> 0:15:58.830
<v Speaker 3>yeah so it doesn't I think it is really a

0:16:00.350 --> 0:16:04.780
<v Speaker 3>place argument to say that when people vote for a party,

0:16:04.820 --> 0:16:07.660
<v Speaker 3>they are voting for the candidates that are in that

0:16:07.820 --> 0:16:10.980
<v Speaker 3>party because the party can always change the list and

0:16:11.160 --> 0:16:15.150
<v Speaker 3>have whoever. Other people vote for a party because they

0:16:15.250 --> 0:16:18.510
<v Speaker 3>trust that particular party that it will deliver on the

0:16:18.550 --> 0:16:23.330
<v Speaker 3>mandate that they have set for themselves. So I don't

0:16:23.390 --> 0:16:30.520
<v Speaker 3>buy the argument that if you are electing a party, necessarily...

0:16:30.800 --> 0:16:32.710
<v Speaker 3>you've got to know each and every person who is

0:16:32.850 --> 0:16:33.650
<v Speaker 3>actually in that list.

0:16:33.890 --> 0:16:36.810
<v Speaker 1>Yeah, I get your point because it's still the prerogative

0:16:37.370 --> 0:16:40.950
<v Speaker 1>of the party to change the list, whichever way they may.

0:16:41.010 --> 0:16:43.130
<v Speaker 1>So even the person that they put on the PR

0:16:43.170 --> 0:16:46.900
<v Speaker 1>list and you went and voted, it's still their prerogative

0:16:46.960 --> 0:16:53.180
<v Speaker 1>to update that list after the elections. So there's someone

0:16:53.200 --> 0:16:58.430
<v Speaker 1>who's asking about the item 5-2, the candidates' names must

0:16:58.490 --> 0:17:00.630
<v Speaker 1>appear on the list. So is there an expectation? There's

0:17:00.650 --> 0:17:03.360
<v Speaker 1>a question here from someone who wants to know if

0:17:04.040 --> 0:17:07.679
<v Speaker 1>there's an expectation that the candidates' names must appear on

0:17:07.720 --> 0:17:13.919
<v Speaker 1>the list. So these parties, are they not violating any

0:17:13.980 --> 0:17:17.480
<v Speaker 1>regulations by just putting one person? Is there any clause

0:17:17.520 --> 0:17:21.530
<v Speaker 1>that says every single party has to put the names

0:17:21.690 --> 0:17:25.830
<v Speaker 1>of their members who are part of the PR list?

0:17:26.090 --> 0:17:27.970
<v Speaker 1>Those names have to clearly appear.

0:17:29.820 --> 0:17:33.619
<v Speaker 3>No, there is no such provision. The provision only requires

0:17:33.700 --> 0:17:40.800
<v Speaker 3>a political party to submit the names not more than

0:17:41.480 --> 0:17:47.560
<v Speaker 3>the number of seats available in that particular municipality. So

0:17:48.200 --> 0:17:54.040
<v Speaker 3>if you submit a PR list but you only have

0:17:54.140 --> 0:17:58.680
<v Speaker 3>one candidate in there, the assumption is that you don't

0:17:58.840 --> 0:18:01.240
<v Speaker 3>know whether you're going to win more than one seat.

0:18:01.580 --> 0:18:04.310
<v Speaker 3>You believe that maybe you will only win one seat.

0:18:04.380 --> 0:18:07.830
<v Speaker 3>And therefore, the law still protects you if you win

0:18:07.869 --> 0:18:11.730
<v Speaker 3>more than one seat. To say that you, even though

0:18:11.750 --> 0:18:14.890
<v Speaker 3>you campaigned and then thought that you would only have

0:18:15.030 --> 0:18:24.300
<v Speaker 3>one seat, now you have been given a responsibility to

0:18:24.340 --> 0:18:27.899
<v Speaker 3>have more seats by the number of people who have

0:18:27.940 --> 0:18:31.200
<v Speaker 3>actually voted for you. And therefore, that has got to

0:18:31.240 --> 0:18:34.130
<v Speaker 3>be supplemented. And then you've got to be able to

0:18:34.670 --> 0:18:40.510
<v Speaker 3>supply the number, or rather the names of the candidates

0:18:40.550 --> 0:18:41.889
<v Speaker 3>who will fill those positions.

0:18:43.510 --> 0:18:46.170
<v Speaker 1>Well, Terry Tilanin, thank you so much for making time

0:18:46.210 --> 0:18:52.629
<v Speaker 1>for us, Executive Chairman. of the Institute of Election Management

0:18:52.850 --> 0:18:55.659
<v Speaker 1>Services in Africa. I guess what we do now is

0:18:55.700 --> 0:18:59.740
<v Speaker 1>wait for the DA as they head to court today.

0:18:59.760 --> 0:19:02.939
<v Speaker 1>I think they want a declaratory order because they are

0:19:02.960 --> 0:19:09.140
<v Speaker 1>raising issues of, you know, just the democratic nature with which,

0:19:09.500 --> 0:19:11.380
<v Speaker 1>you know, people are going to vote when they don't

0:19:11.440 --> 0:19:15.230
<v Speaker 1>know who they are voting for because on the PR lists,

0:19:15.650 --> 0:19:18.690
<v Speaker 1>some parties are only putting their mayoral candidates in Johannesburg

0:19:20.130 --> 0:19:23.860
<v Speaker 1>Is their concern valid? Well, we'll find out. Hopefully there's

0:19:23.880 --> 0:19:26.760
<v Speaker 1>going to be a constitutional clarity there.