WEBVTT - Your AM Headlines + Are Bots Are Hijacking Your Feed?

0:00:06.355 --> 0:00:14.475
<v Speaker 1>You're listening to a Mamma Mia podcast. Hello, I'm Charlotte

0:00:14.495 --> 0:00:19.725
<v Speaker 1>Mortlock with the latest from the Quickie Newsroom. Politics used

0:00:19.765 --> 0:00:22.785
<v Speaker 1>to be one of those topics you could largely avoid

0:00:22.865 --> 0:00:27.645
<v Speaker 1>speaking about, like money and religion. Oh, how things have changed.

0:00:28.325 --> 0:00:32.555
<v Speaker 1>Now it's completely unavoidable. It's in your feed whether you

0:00:32.655 --> 0:00:33.254
<v Speaker 1>ask for.

0:00:33.095 --> 0:00:33.614
<v Speaker 2>It or not.

0:00:34.405 --> 0:00:38.104
<v Speaker 1>So who's behind the content? Who exactly is creating the

0:00:38.165 --> 0:00:40.755
<v Speaker 1>memes or the tiles that are fanning the flames of

0:00:40.875 --> 0:00:45.794
<v Speaker 1>fury online? New investigations have revealed how foreign bot farms

0:00:45.835 --> 0:00:50.495
<v Speaker 1>have been used to influence and direct narratives online. Today,

0:00:50.754 --> 0:00:54.835
<v Speaker 1>we look at foreign influences on Australian politics. But first,

0:00:55.035 --> 0:00:56.915
<v Speaker 1>here's Tamsin Rose with your headlines.

0:01:00.535 --> 0:01:04.235
<v Speaker 2>Thanks, Charlotte. Former Bachelor star Sam Wood will be back

0:01:04.335 --> 0:01:07.495
<v Speaker 2>in court on Thursday to apply for bail after being

0:01:07.555 --> 0:01:12.095
<v Speaker 2>charged with domestic violence offences. The 46-year-old was arrested on

0:01:12.135 --> 0:01:15.835
<v Speaker 2>the Sunshine Coast on Saturday night after police received reports

0:01:15.995 --> 0:01:19.515
<v Speaker 2>of alleged domestic violence at a Noosa property. He's been

0:01:19.535 --> 0:01:23.215
<v Speaker 2>charged with assault, occasioning bodily harm and strangulation in a

0:01:23.335 --> 0:01:27.395
<v Speaker 2>domestic setting, and is expected to spend several nights in custody.

0:01:28.285 --> 0:01:31.745
<v Speaker 2>His lawyer, Matthew Caskelley, told the AAP that the charges

0:01:31.845 --> 0:01:35.255
<v Speaker 2>will be defended and that Wood is simply worried about

0:01:35.295 --> 0:01:38.815
<v Speaker 2>his family. The fitness influencer has been stood down indefinitely

0:01:38.955 --> 0:01:42.194
<v Speaker 2>from the online fitness business he fronts. In a statement

0:01:42.235 --> 0:01:45.215
<v Speaker 2>posted on social media, the Wood family said they're working

0:01:45.255 --> 0:01:50.645
<v Speaker 2>through this together and cooperating with authorities. One Nation is

0:01:50.685 --> 0:01:54.125
<v Speaker 2>moving into a new Brisbane office and its new landlord

0:01:54.145 --> 0:01:57.415
<v Speaker 2>is Gina Reinhart. The party will soon set up its

0:01:57.675 --> 0:02:01.735
<v Speaker 2>national and Queensland headquarters at 160 Wharf Street, a building

0:02:01.915 --> 0:02:06.225
<v Speaker 2>recently bought by a company owned by mining billionaire Gina Reinhart.

0:02:06.945 --> 0:02:10.785
<v Speaker 2>One Nation says it'll pay Reinhart's Hancock prospecting the market

0:02:10.865 --> 0:02:14.305
<v Speaker 2>rate for the space. Hancock says it isn't offering free

0:02:14.405 --> 0:02:18.575
<v Speaker 2>or discounted rent to any tenant, political or otherwise. One

0:02:18.615 --> 0:02:21.935
<v Speaker 2>Nation MP Barnaby Joyce says the deal is entirely above board,

0:02:22.335 --> 0:02:26.865
<v Speaker 2>telling News24 it's her building, it's her lease. Reinhardt, Australia's

0:02:27.005 --> 0:02:30.045
<v Speaker 2>richest person, has previously gifted the party a private plane

0:02:30.125 --> 0:02:36.065
<v Speaker 2>worth more than $ 1. 3 million. Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor is taking the

0:02:36.145 --> 0:02:39.585
<v Speaker 2>Thames Valley Police to court over his arrest in relation

0:02:39.675 --> 0:02:42.835
<v Speaker 2>to the Epstein files. The former prince has lodged a

0:02:42.915 --> 0:02:46.335
<v Speaker 2>judicial review asking a judge to rule whether the search

0:02:46.355 --> 0:02:49.454
<v Speaker 2>warrants used to raid his home on the Sandringham Estate

0:02:49.875 --> 0:02:53.125
<v Speaker 2>and his former residence at Royal Lodge were lawful. He

0:02:53.145 --> 0:02:56.285
<v Speaker 2>was arrested in February at Marsh Farm in Norfolk on

0:02:56.325 --> 0:03:00.484
<v Speaker 2>his 66th birthday. According to the London Telegraph, it's the

0:03:00.565 --> 0:03:03.955
<v Speaker 2>first time a royal has challenged the lawfulness of criminal

0:03:03.995 --> 0:03:08.915
<v Speaker 2>proceedings against them since the trial of King Charles I

0:03:09.615 --> 0:03:13.635
<v Speaker 2>in 1649. Coming up, a very rare tree is being saved,

0:03:14.155 --> 0:03:16.515
<v Speaker 2>and we're looking at what foreign bot farms have to

0:03:16.555 --> 0:03:27.125
<v Speaker 2>do with Australian politics. Japan could soon have its own

0:03:27.205 --> 0:03:30.765
<v Speaker 2>version of the CIA. The country is working to set

0:03:30.825 --> 0:03:34.505
<v Speaker 2>up its first centralized intelligence network since World War II,

0:03:34.905 --> 0:03:38.445
<v Speaker 2>driven by concerns about China's military buildup and threats of

0:03:38.545 --> 0:03:42.945
<v Speaker 2>foreign interference. Right now, Japan's police, defense and foreign affairs

0:03:42.985 --> 0:03:45.975
<v Speaker 2>departments all gather intelligence, but they don't always share it

0:03:45.995 --> 0:03:50.405
<v Speaker 2>with each other. Prime Minister Sane Takeuchi says strengthening intelligence

0:03:50.545 --> 0:03:54.185
<v Speaker 2>is a matter of the utmost urgency, pointing to growing

0:03:54.225 --> 0:03:57.985
<v Speaker 2>military power in China, North Korea and closer ties between China,

0:03:58.085 --> 0:04:02.005
<v Speaker 2>Russia and North Korea. And there's a gum tree so

0:04:02.085 --> 0:04:05.405
<v Speaker 2>rare that only six have ever been found in the wild.

0:04:06.145 --> 0:04:09.265
<v Speaker 2>The Eucalyptus recurva, known as the Ice Age gum, grows

0:04:09.405 --> 0:04:13.035
<v Speaker 2>just south of Canberra. Experts told the ABC the trees

0:04:13.175 --> 0:04:16.464
<v Speaker 2>are likely the last survivors of an ancient species from

0:04:16.495 --> 0:04:20.305
<v Speaker 2>the Ice Age, making it probably Australia's rarest and most

0:04:20.325 --> 0:04:24.025
<v Speaker 2>threatened eucalypt. The good news is that scientists at the

0:04:24.085 --> 0:04:28.185
<v Speaker 2>Australian National Botanic Gardens have spent decades cloning them and

0:04:28.225 --> 0:04:31.095
<v Speaker 2>now have multiple copies of four of the six wild

0:04:31.155 --> 0:04:35.115
<v Speaker 2>trees as an insurance population. If you or anyone you

0:04:35.175 --> 0:04:37.995
<v Speaker 2>know needs to speak with an expert, please contact 1800RESPECT.

0:04:39.625 --> 0:04:43.835
<v Speaker 2>That's the National Sexual Assault, Domestic and Family Violence Counselling Service.

0:04:44.015 --> 0:04:46.075
<v Speaker 2>We'll include those details in the show notes.

0:04:48.155 --> 0:04:48.875
<v Speaker 3>Thanks, Tamsin.

0:04:49.155 --> 0:04:51.635
<v Speaker 1>Thanks for a new data centre in Lane Cove have

0:04:51.675 --> 0:04:55.555
<v Speaker 1>been scrapped following backlash from the community. If you feel

0:04:55.715 --> 0:04:59.535
<v Speaker 1>like all Australia is talking about right now is AI

0:04:59.575 --> 0:05:03.615
<v Speaker 1>data centres, it's even more intense in the United States.

0:05:04.225 --> 0:05:07.705
<v Speaker 1>Consuming most of the conversation in the US is fear.

0:05:08.685 --> 0:05:12.265
<v Speaker 1>Australia hasn't quite reached that fever pitch yet, but it's

0:05:12.365 --> 0:05:15.865
<v Speaker 1>likely a preview of what's to come ahead of our

0:05:15.865 --> 0:05:20.745
<v Speaker 1>2028 election. There are debates about water usage, noise, health,

0:05:21.065 --> 0:05:24.825
<v Speaker 1>big tech. But is this a natural conversation or has

0:05:24.865 --> 0:05:27.164
<v Speaker 1>it been hyped up by foreign actors?

0:05:27.365 --> 0:05:29.265
<v Speaker 3>So why do people don't want them in their backyard?

0:05:29.325 --> 0:05:31.654
<v Speaker 4>Because somehow they've got, I mean, a lot of people

0:05:31.675 --> 0:05:32.415
<v Speaker 4>say it's China.

0:05:32.715 --> 0:05:34.075
<v Speaker 2>You know, a lot of people say that it's a

0:05:34.095 --> 0:05:35.095
<v Speaker 2>China PR thing.

0:05:35.375 --> 0:05:36.675
<v Speaker 3>That's President Donald Trump.

0:05:37.265 --> 0:05:41.005
<v Speaker 1>He's insinuating the debate about data centres is being manufactured

0:05:41.085 --> 0:05:44.205
<v Speaker 1>by the Chinese government because they want to slow down

0:05:44.265 --> 0:05:47.925
<v Speaker 1>America's scale-up of data centres, which would be beneficial to

0:05:47.965 --> 0:05:49.984
<v Speaker 1>China in the race to see who can.

0:05:49.855 --> 0:05:54.195
<v Speaker 3>Build and develop AI fastest. It's the new arms race.

0:05:55.355 --> 0:05:59.615
<v Speaker 1>Here in Australia, we're also seeing concerns about foreign influence.

0:06:00.255 --> 0:06:03.645
<v Speaker 1>An investigation by The Guardian this year revealed that some

0:06:03.725 --> 0:06:07.905
<v Speaker 1>popular Facebook groups supporting One Nation are were run from overseas,

0:06:08.245 --> 0:06:12.925
<v Speaker 1>in places like Indonesia. And just this month, ABC News

0:06:12.965 --> 0:06:18.145
<v Speaker 1>Verify uncovered a YouTube channel called Oceana Unfiltered, pushing One

0:06:18.205 --> 0:06:21.235
<v Speaker 1>Nation content to tens of thousands of people in an

0:06:21.255 --> 0:06:22.135
<v Speaker 1>Aussie accent.

0:06:22.895 --> 0:06:24.095
<v Speaker 3>But the accent was.

0:06:24.055 --> 0:06:28.015
<v Speaker 1>Generated by AI, and the man behind it was traced

0:06:28.175 --> 0:06:32.335
<v Speaker 1>to Brazil. So, is this a foreign plot to get

0:06:32.575 --> 0:06:36.805
<v Speaker 1>One Nation elected? Timothy Graham is an associate professor in

0:06:36.845 --> 0:06:40.045
<v Speaker 1>digital media at the Queensland University of Technology.

0:06:40.735 --> 0:06:42.295
<v Speaker 3>Graham says probably not.

0:06:42.765 --> 0:06:45.735
<v Speaker 1>In fact, it's more likely that these foreign accounts aren't

0:06:45.795 --> 0:06:49.015
<v Speaker 1>trying to create a narrative. They're just trying to exploit

0:06:49.135 --> 0:06:50.495
<v Speaker 1>one that already exists.

0:06:51.015 --> 0:06:54.495
<v Speaker 4>They look like automation. They look like AI slop and

0:06:54.515 --> 0:06:57.775
<v Speaker 4>things like that. But often it is just people or

0:06:57.855 --> 0:07:01.435
<v Speaker 4>small start-ups in other countries that don't have as high

0:07:01.515 --> 0:07:04.214
<v Speaker 4>of a GDP rate as Australia. They're not as wealthy

0:07:04.275 --> 0:07:07.735
<v Speaker 4>as Australia. They're using One Nation as a vehicle to

0:07:07.755 --> 0:07:11.455
<v Speaker 4>be able to jump onto and to target the kinds

0:07:11.495 --> 0:07:14.155
<v Speaker 4>of people that One Nation targets. Because we as Australians

0:07:14.195 --> 0:07:16.895
<v Speaker 4>are lucrative. If you serve ads to us and you're

0:07:16.915 --> 0:07:19.215
<v Speaker 4>a content creator and you're getting a revenue share of

0:07:19.255 --> 0:07:22.675
<v Speaker 4>those ads, we pay out 20 times more on average than, say,

0:07:23.135 --> 0:07:25.575
<v Speaker 4>somebody living in Indonesia or in Pakistan.

0:07:25.895 --> 0:07:29.975
<v Speaker 1>So then Australian users are just basically being used as fodder.

0:07:31.855 --> 0:07:32.835
<v Speaker 4>You couldn't have put it better.

0:07:33.455 --> 0:07:37.075
<v Speaker 1>Regardless of their intention, these bot farms and their outputs

0:07:37.415 --> 0:07:42.155
<v Speaker 1>are influencing individuals and swinging voters. So while Trump argues

0:07:42.235 --> 0:07:45.755
<v Speaker 1>the US data centre's debate is actually being manufactured for

0:07:45.815 --> 0:07:50.015
<v Speaker 1>political reasons, Tim believes ours is just a by-product of

0:07:50.095 --> 0:07:53.435
<v Speaker 1>people trying to make a buck. The Guardian spoke to

0:07:53.485 --> 0:07:56.545
<v Speaker 1>foreign content creators who didn't even know who our Prime

0:07:56.575 --> 0:08:00.725
<v Speaker 1>Minister was. The flaw here is that politics outrages people.

0:08:01.155 --> 0:08:06.495
<v Speaker 1>and outrage pays bills. Platforms like Facebook will pay creators

0:08:06.635 --> 0:08:10.305
<v Speaker 1>if their posts get enough views and engagement. That money

0:08:10.435 --> 0:08:13.805
<v Speaker 1>comes from ads shown next to their content. And the

0:08:13.925 --> 0:08:17.465
<v Speaker 1>ads shown to Australians are worth more than ads shown

0:08:17.505 --> 0:08:19.185
<v Speaker 1>to people in poorer countries.

0:08:19.865 --> 0:08:21.485
<v Speaker 3>So if you're a creator.

0:08:21.245 --> 0:08:25.005
<v Speaker 1>In Indonesia trying to make a living, it's a smarter

0:08:25.065 --> 0:08:28.795
<v Speaker 1>financial decision to weigh into foreign politics than your own.

0:08:29.825 --> 0:08:35.255
<v Speaker 1>Facebook's creator monetisation program paid out nearly $ 3 billion to

0:08:35.295 --> 0:08:38.835
<v Speaker 1>an estimated 16.2 million accounts last year.

0:08:39.635 --> 0:08:42.175
<v Speaker 3>Graham says platforms are part of the issue.

0:08:42.895 --> 0:08:46.675
<v Speaker 4>They incentivise people to create this content, to target people

0:08:46.715 --> 0:08:50.215
<v Speaker 4>in this way, because the platforms take a cut as well.

0:08:50.715 --> 0:08:53.275
<v Speaker 4>The platform makes money. The bot farms, if you want

0:08:53.315 --> 0:08:55.125
<v Speaker 4>to call them that, some of them are bots, but

0:08:55.185 --> 0:08:58.025
<v Speaker 4>mostly it's like people who kind of just behave robotically,

0:08:58.125 --> 0:09:00.084
<v Speaker 4>you know, go from one phone to the next or whatever.

0:09:00.645 --> 0:09:02.765
<v Speaker 4>They make money off it. So they are they're using

0:09:02.804 --> 0:09:06.334
<v Speaker 4>us as fodder because we are like really lucrative cash cows.

0:09:06.675 --> 0:09:08.515
<v Speaker 3>So that raises a deeper question.

0:09:09.155 --> 0:09:12.535
<v Speaker 1>If this is how social media influences politics, is it

0:09:12.615 --> 0:09:13.865
<v Speaker 1>causing more harm than good?

0:09:14.475 --> 0:09:18.765
<v Speaker 4>There's been a really massive shift in political communication, in

0:09:18.785 --> 0:09:22.785
<v Speaker 4>the styles and in the content of how politics is

0:09:22.804 --> 0:09:25.405
<v Speaker 4>talked about, like at a civic level, just like regular

0:09:25.605 --> 0:09:28.345
<v Speaker 4>people and how they talk to each other and discuss politics,

0:09:28.865 --> 0:09:31.185
<v Speaker 4>but also at the sort of elite level, at the

0:09:31.225 --> 0:09:35.905
<v Speaker 4>level of politicians, lobbyists. I think that social media and

0:09:36.304 --> 0:09:40.925
<v Speaker 4>the web before that have really had a seismic impact

0:09:40.945 --> 0:09:44.375
<v Speaker 4>on what it means to discuss politics and Part of

0:09:44.415 --> 0:09:47.555
<v Speaker 4>that reason, I think, is just the way that social

0:09:47.615 --> 0:09:52.054
<v Speaker 4>media is designed around attention, around trying to get engagement.

0:09:52.075 --> 0:09:54.755
<v Speaker 4>It's kind of meant that in order to be able

0:09:54.835 --> 0:09:58.135
<v Speaker 4>to be political, you have to kind of be heard

0:09:58.395 --> 0:10:00.325
<v Speaker 4>and you have to be connected in the right ways.

0:10:01.545 --> 0:10:04.765
<v Speaker 1>One party in Australia has understood the power of engagement

0:10:04.965 --> 0:10:05.355
<v Speaker 1>better now.

0:10:05.835 --> 0:10:06.355
<v Speaker 3>Any other.

0:10:07.175 --> 0:10:11.075
<v Speaker 4>One Nation has been very effective at utilising social media

0:10:11.175 --> 0:10:15.745
<v Speaker 4>and understanding that politics now is participatory, right? Politics is

0:10:15.775 --> 0:10:19.725
<v Speaker 4>not about reaching out to demographics or reaching audiences. It's

0:10:19.765 --> 0:10:21.965
<v Speaker 4>being able to get people to pay attention to you

0:10:22.445 --> 0:10:25.025
<v Speaker 4>and to your content. So they're not paying attention to

0:10:25.065 --> 0:10:27.984
<v Speaker 4>the other stuff, to Labor or to the Greens or

0:10:28.025 --> 0:10:30.905
<v Speaker 4>whoever the case might be. The cartoon series that they

0:10:31.125 --> 0:10:34.975
<v Speaker 4>generated is custom made for social media. Short clips developed

0:10:34.995 --> 0:10:38.495
<v Speaker 4>in a style that doesn't appear political is highly drenched

0:10:38.554 --> 0:10:41.734
<v Speaker 4>in parody. It's highly effective. People like to share it

0:10:41.915 --> 0:10:45.055
<v Speaker 4>whether they are interested. for those opinions or whether they're

0:10:45.135 --> 0:10:47.434
<v Speaker 4>outraged by it. You see it go everywhere.

0:10:47.975 --> 0:10:51.605
<v Speaker 1>If politicians' posts are focusing purely on engagement and not

0:10:51.745 --> 0:10:56.405
<v Speaker 1>an actual constructive policy agenda, are they themselves contributing to

0:10:56.425 --> 0:11:00.145
<v Speaker 1>the problem? Of course, the other option is that everyone

0:11:00.205 --> 0:11:01.985
<v Speaker 1>else just starts playing the same game.

0:11:02.465 --> 0:11:03.955
<v Speaker 3>And there's evidence it works.

0:11:04.735 --> 0:11:08.095
<v Speaker 4>Gavin Newsom, governor of California, for example, just decided, I think,

0:11:08.135 --> 0:11:11.085
<v Speaker 4>about 18 months ago to start shouting like Trump from

0:11:11.155 --> 0:11:15.365
<v Speaker 4>his social media accounts, in all caps, just trolling, basically.

0:11:15.845 --> 0:11:18.665
<v Speaker 4>And a colleague and I here, Stephen Harrington, had been

0:11:18.725 --> 0:11:21.025
<v Speaker 4>tracking Gavin Newsom's engagement metrics, and they.

0:11:20.925 --> 0:11:21.985
<v Speaker 3>Just shoot through the roof.

0:11:22.325 --> 0:11:25.025
<v Speaker 4>So it works. Like, I'm sorry to say, if you

0:11:25.065 --> 0:11:27.885
<v Speaker 4>start acting like a troll a little bit, even, it

0:11:27.985 --> 0:11:31.245
<v Speaker 4>really can help your engagement. But like, how far do

0:11:31.285 --> 0:11:31.985
<v Speaker 4>we want to take that?

0:11:32.554 --> 0:11:35.255
<v Speaker 1>All of this shouting could come at the detriment of

0:11:35.355 --> 0:11:40.195
<v Speaker 1>our democracy. But there has been some benefit. Social media

0:11:40.235 --> 0:11:43.585
<v Speaker 1>has made it much easier to get involved. You don't

0:11:43.615 --> 0:11:46.064
<v Speaker 1>have to join a party or knock on doors.

0:11:46.585 --> 0:11:49.185
<v Speaker 4>It's a lot easier to get online and jump on

0:11:49.205 --> 0:11:54.405
<v Speaker 4>a hashtag or even discover things serendipitously. As you're searching

0:11:54.785 --> 0:11:56.785
<v Speaker 4>or as you're looking in your feed, you might see

0:11:57.485 --> 0:12:00.605
<v Speaker 4>hashtag trending and be unsure what that is and then

0:12:00.625 --> 0:12:04.155
<v Speaker 4>just sort of be drawn into collective action just because

0:12:04.415 --> 0:12:06.695
<v Speaker 4>you're in that space. And I think that I don't

0:12:06.715 --> 0:12:09.295
<v Speaker 4>think you could really go on Twitter in Australia without

0:12:09.395 --> 0:12:13.735
<v Speaker 4>coming across politics with the Auspol hashtag. It has lowered

0:12:13.815 --> 0:12:14.755
<v Speaker 4>the barrier of entry.

0:12:15.925 --> 0:12:19.535
<v Speaker 1>There is movement in this space. The Albanese government has

0:12:19.595 --> 0:12:22.275
<v Speaker 1>vowed to turn off the algorithm under its My Feed,

0:12:22.415 --> 0:12:26.755
<v Speaker 1>My Way legislation. This could reduce the way content creators

0:12:26.995 --> 0:12:31.795
<v Speaker 1>utilise outrage for engagement. It's a heavily contested and rapidly

0:12:31.835 --> 0:12:36.045
<v Speaker 1>evolving space. We'll keep you across it. Thanks for listening today.

0:12:36.405 --> 0:12:38.864
<v Speaker 1>For more news like this, please click follow on the

0:12:38.925 --> 0:12:41.844
<v Speaker 1>quickie wherever you get your podcast and please leave a

0:12:41.985 --> 0:12:42.865
<v Speaker 1>rating and review.

0:12:43.325 --> 0:12:44.815
<v Speaker 3>It helps other people find us.

0:12:49.855 --> 0:12:52.724
<v Speaker 1>Mamma Mia acknowledges the traditional owners of the land on

0:12:52.765 --> 0:12:54.295
<v Speaker 1>which we have recorded this podcast.