WEBVTT - Paul Murray Live | 1 October

0:00:02.640 --> 0:00:08.190
<v Speaker 1>This is Paul Murray Live. It is indeed. Well done, Caleb.

0:00:08.210 --> 0:00:10.430
<v Speaker 1>We look forward to seeing you again tomorrow night and,

0:00:10.490 --> 0:00:11.650
<v Speaker 1>of course, next week.

0:00:11.810 --> 0:00:15.910
<v Speaker 2>Now, I've been showing you something for many years that

0:00:15.990 --> 0:00:20.919
<v Speaker 2>shows the reality of Australia under Jim Chalmers. I've focused

0:00:20.980 --> 0:00:22.860
<v Speaker 2>on it in the past few months and certainly I

0:00:22.880 --> 0:00:26.340
<v Speaker 2>highlighted it for you last night, which was the standard

0:00:26.600 --> 0:00:30.340
<v Speaker 2>to which Jim Chalmers, as the shadow treasurer, held the

0:00:30.380 --> 0:00:33.480
<v Speaker 2>then government when interest rates went up once.

0:00:34.880 --> 0:00:37.600
<v Speaker 3>This is a full blown cost of living crisis on

0:00:37.659 --> 0:00:41.300
<v Speaker 3>Scott Morrison's watch. This Prime Minister has an excuse for

0:00:41.380 --> 0:00:44.480
<v Speaker 3>everything and a plan for nothing. The issue that we

0:00:44.520 --> 0:00:48.180
<v Speaker 3>have with Scott Morrison is not that he doesn't take

0:00:48.240 --> 0:00:51.400
<v Speaker 3>responsibility for every aspect of this, it's that he takes

0:00:51.479 --> 0:00:55.340
<v Speaker 3>responsibility for none of this whatsoever. And when things are

0:00:55.380 --> 0:00:57.720
<v Speaker 3>going well, he's in front of the camera claiming all

0:00:57.740 --> 0:01:01.010
<v Speaker 3>the credit. When times are tough, he takes none of

0:01:01.050 --> 0:01:01.880
<v Speaker 3>the responsibility.

0:01:02.850 --> 0:01:04.270
<v Speaker 1>Now, obviously, he's a hypocrite.

0:01:04.290 --> 0:01:08.280
<v Speaker 2>We've known that since day one, or actually minus day one,

0:01:08.300 --> 0:01:10.980
<v Speaker 2>because we saw it in opposition. But, of course, the

0:01:11.020 --> 0:01:13.979
<v Speaker 2>point was that the entire political argument was that everything

0:01:14.020 --> 0:01:16.780
<v Speaker 2>in the Australian economy was personal. It was personal about

0:01:16.819 --> 0:01:21.310
<v Speaker 2>Scott Morrison. It was personal about the Liberal Party. Of course,

0:01:21.350 --> 0:01:23.569
<v Speaker 2>we had gone through COVID, and that's why inflation had

0:01:23.610 --> 0:01:26.209
<v Speaker 2>gone as high as it did. But the consequences of inflation,

0:01:26.310 --> 0:01:28.310
<v Speaker 2>as it was then, as it is now, is that

0:01:28.330 --> 0:01:31.420
<v Speaker 2>when everything costs more, on top of more last month,

0:01:31.580 --> 0:01:35.000
<v Speaker 2>more the month before, more the year before, there's only

0:01:35.060 --> 0:01:38.200
<v Speaker 2>so much people can take before they just stop listening

0:01:38.240 --> 0:01:38.700
<v Speaker 2>to governments.

0:01:38.720 --> 0:01:40.140
<v Speaker 1>They don't trust governments.

0:01:40.980 --> 0:01:42.890
<v Speaker 2>Now, it's the last part of that statement that I

0:01:42.940 --> 0:01:47.030
<v Speaker 2>think is particularly damning for the double standard that the

0:01:47.110 --> 0:01:49.550
<v Speaker 2>Treasurer takes to the Australian.

0:01:49.190 --> 0:01:52.320
<v Speaker 1>Economy when it has all got worse on his watch.

0:01:52.940 --> 0:01:53.700
<v Speaker 1>Remember what he said?

0:01:54.860 --> 0:01:56.940
<v Speaker 3>When things are going well, he's in front of the

0:01:56.980 --> 0:02:00.440
<v Speaker 3>camera claiming all the credit. When times are tough, he

0:02:00.500 --> 0:02:01.930
<v Speaker 3>takes none of the responsibility.

0:02:02.820 --> 0:02:04.740
<v Speaker 2>And those words apply to him because, as I showed

0:02:04.780 --> 0:02:09.680
<v Speaker 2>you 16 times last night, what does he say when

0:02:09.720 --> 0:02:13.360
<v Speaker 2>interest rates have gone up 16 times on his watch?

0:02:13.780 --> 0:02:15.340
<v Speaker 1>Well, there's an excuse for everything.

0:02:15.440 --> 0:02:18.359
<v Speaker 2>I'll save you going back through all 16, but here's

0:02:18.380 --> 0:02:21.280
<v Speaker 2>the highlights of every five months or so.

0:02:22.400 --> 0:02:26.310
<v Speaker 3>Ever since interest rates started rising before the election, It

0:02:26.370 --> 0:02:29.010
<v Speaker 3>was clear from the Independent Reserve Bank that there would

0:02:29.050 --> 0:02:32.810
<v Speaker 3>be a number of interest rate rises. Global economic uncertainty

0:02:33.130 --> 0:02:37.049
<v Speaker 3>that we've seen in recent times. Australians are already paying

0:02:37.090 --> 0:02:39.389
<v Speaker 3>a hefty price for this war in the Middle East

0:02:39.470 --> 0:02:42.350
<v Speaker 3>and this decision will make things harder for people. Our

0:02:42.370 --> 0:02:46.270
<v Speaker 3>inflation challenge is being turbocharged by a war on the

0:02:46.310 --> 0:02:47.570
<v Speaker 3>other side of the world.

0:02:49.610 --> 0:02:51.690
<v Speaker 2>I won't cut him any slack, but he would think

0:02:51.740 --> 0:02:54.400
<v Speaker 2>that there's some slack, that he has at times taken

0:02:54.440 --> 0:02:58.900
<v Speaker 2>responsibility for interest rate decisions, like when they went down

0:02:59.100 --> 0:03:02.760
<v Speaker 2>just conveniently in time for the government to sell the

0:03:02.820 --> 0:03:06.040
<v Speaker 2>lie that we'd turned the corner when rates fell in

0:03:06.180 --> 0:03:09.160
<v Speaker 2>February before the election last year.

0:03:10.540 --> 0:03:14.609
<v Speaker 3>Under this Labor government, inflation is down, wages are up,

0:03:15.110 --> 0:03:19.430
<v Speaker 3>unemployment is low, and now interest rates are falling as well.

0:03:20.690 --> 0:03:23.820
<v Speaker 2>Now, of course, none of that applies anymore because interest

0:03:23.880 --> 0:03:26.940
<v Speaker 2>rates have gone way back up to even above where

0:03:26.960 --> 0:03:30.299
<v Speaker 2>they were when things started to come down. Inflation now

0:03:30.400 --> 0:03:32.940
<v Speaker 2>has a four in front of it again, when the

0:03:32.980 --> 0:03:35.420
<v Speaker 2>entire reason for all of the interest rate rises has

0:03:35.440 --> 0:03:39.870
<v Speaker 2>been to push it down to between two and 3%.

0:03:39.870 --> 0:03:42.410
<v Speaker 2>So if 2% is where it needs to be, four

0:03:42.470 --> 0:03:44.230
<v Speaker 2>is obviously double where.

0:03:44.670 --> 0:03:45.150
<v Speaker 1>It needs to be.

0:03:45.150 --> 0:03:46.550
<v Speaker 2>And there's going to be a lot of pain between

0:03:46.610 --> 0:03:52.160
<v Speaker 2>now and then. Now, This has become a news story

0:03:52.320 --> 0:03:55.960
<v Speaker 2>today because people have obviously been watching, have been paying

0:03:56.000 --> 0:03:58.310
<v Speaker 2>attention to what we've been mentioning for a long time,

0:03:58.320 --> 0:04:01.170
<v Speaker 2>but particularly what we focused on last night. And a

0:04:01.190 --> 0:04:05.670
<v Speaker 2>question was fired to the Treasurer today based off the

0:04:05.710 --> 0:04:09.910
<v Speaker 2>hypocrisy of his position when it was somebody else in

0:04:09.950 --> 0:04:11.840
<v Speaker 2>charge versus him in charge.

0:04:11.880 --> 0:04:12.540
<v Speaker 1>Here's the question.

0:04:14.080 --> 0:04:16.540
<v Speaker 4>Back in 2022, just before he came into office.

0:04:17.080 --> 0:04:21.280
<v Speaker 5>Rates rose from 0.1% to 0.35% under Scott Morrison. You

0:04:21.320 --> 0:04:23.549
<v Speaker 5>accused him of having, quote, an excuse for everything and

0:04:23.560 --> 0:04:26.120
<v Speaker 5>a plan for nothing, and said he took, quote, all

0:04:26.140 --> 0:04:28.990
<v Speaker 5>the credit when things went well, but, quote, none of

0:04:29.029 --> 0:04:32.350
<v Speaker 5>the responsibility when they didn't. Rates are now 4.6%, yet

0:04:32.750 --> 0:04:33.990
<v Speaker 5>you're saying it's not your fault.

0:04:34.490 --> 0:04:36.770
<v Speaker 4>Aren't you doing the same thing? Why shouldn't you take

0:04:36.790 --> 0:04:38.289
<v Speaker 4>responsibility for the state of the economy?

0:04:39.270 --> 0:04:41.969
<v Speaker 1>Middle stump. As clean as a question can be.

0:04:42.670 --> 0:04:46.170
<v Speaker 2>Statement from before you became the Treasurer to what we

0:04:46.210 --> 0:04:49.510
<v Speaker 2>have been able to prove 16 times over when he

0:04:49.570 --> 0:04:52.659
<v Speaker 2>is the Treasurer. Well, of course, because the question came

0:04:52.740 --> 0:04:55.840
<v Speaker 2>from media sources that he doesn't like, watch him just

0:04:55.900 --> 0:04:58.660
<v Speaker 2>not engage with it at all. A little bit like

0:04:59.100 --> 0:05:01.000
<v Speaker 2>inflation or interest rate rises.

0:05:02.080 --> 0:05:05.799
<v Speaker 3>Well, I take responsibility for all aspects of my part

0:05:06.020 --> 0:05:10.169
<v Speaker 3>of the fight against inflation. and that means continuing to

0:05:10.230 --> 0:05:13.929
<v Speaker 3>manage the budget responsibly, rolling out cost of living relief

0:05:13.970 --> 0:05:16.130
<v Speaker 3>where we can afford to do that, and also dealing

0:05:16.170 --> 0:05:18.970
<v Speaker 3>with some of these longer-term challenges that Scott Morrison and

0:05:19.010 --> 0:05:23.010
<v Speaker 3>his colleagues left neglected for too long when they gathered

0:05:23.050 --> 0:05:26.270
<v Speaker 3>for that wasted decade of missed opportunities.

0:05:27.630 --> 0:05:29.550
<v Speaker 1>Rubbish. Just rubbish.

0:05:30.960 --> 0:05:32.600
<v Speaker 2>Now, I would have thought that this was slam dunk

0:05:32.640 --> 0:05:34.920
<v Speaker 2>and this was the angle that theoretically everyone on the

0:05:35.120 --> 0:05:36.919
<v Speaker 2>6pm news would have followed. But of course, that would

0:05:36.960 --> 0:05:38.580
<v Speaker 2>give credit to the person who's often critical of the

0:05:38.779 --> 0:05:42.280
<v Speaker 2>6pm news for keeping that piece of tape alive since

0:05:42.320 --> 0:05:45.100
<v Speaker 2>it was first set in 2022. So unsurprisingly, none of

0:05:45.120 --> 0:05:47.779
<v Speaker 2>that in the other news coverage around today. And again,

0:05:47.860 --> 0:05:50.820
<v Speaker 2>it's not about me pointing it out. It's that he

0:05:51.440 --> 0:05:55.020
<v Speaker 2>is a hypocrite. Now, sadly, to be a good politician,

0:05:55.060 --> 0:05:57.100
<v Speaker 2>you need to be shameless, which means even when this

0:05:57.140 --> 0:06:01.080
<v Speaker 2>stuff is pointed out, you never admit a mistake. But

0:06:01.200 --> 0:06:03.880
<v Speaker 2>when the whole point of the reason for your government

0:06:04.020 --> 0:06:07.080
<v Speaker 2>being in place was because the other guys were hypocrites

0:06:07.120 --> 0:06:08.800
<v Speaker 2>and we were going to do politics differently and we

0:06:08.820 --> 0:06:10.480
<v Speaker 2>were going to be transparent and we were going to

0:06:10.500 --> 0:06:11.980
<v Speaker 2>bring down cost of living and we were going to

0:06:12.020 --> 0:06:14.670
<v Speaker 2>change the world. Well, when you failed to do all

0:06:14.690 --> 0:06:16.890
<v Speaker 2>of it, in fact, it's all got worse. Literally the

0:06:17.070 --> 0:06:20.469
<v Speaker 2>opposite of what you were promising people at an election,

0:06:20.670 --> 0:06:22.110
<v Speaker 2>not just once but twice.

0:06:22.550 --> 0:06:22.990
<v Speaker 1>Well, guess what?

0:06:23.029 --> 0:06:25.580
<v Speaker 2>You need to be held accountable for it. not just

0:06:25.640 --> 0:06:28.940
<v Speaker 2>on programs like this, but obviously the Australian people. Now,

0:06:28.990 --> 0:06:31.669
<v Speaker 2>we know the Australian people are so annoyed right now.

0:06:31.750 --> 0:06:33.729
<v Speaker 2>Six out of 10 think the country's headed in.

0:06:33.710 --> 0:06:36.310
<v Speaker 1>The wrong direction. Higher numbers once.

0:06:36.210 --> 0:06:38.650
<v Speaker 2>You get to voters over the age of 35, even

0:06:38.770 --> 0:06:42.010
<v Speaker 2>higher for people who lived through 17% interest rate rises

0:06:42.310 --> 0:06:45.270
<v Speaker 2>that are now over the age of 55.

0:06:45.270 --> 0:06:48.550
<v Speaker 1>And it's all demographics. It is not a specific.

0:06:49.210 --> 0:06:53.299
<v Speaker 2>criticism that is coming from the corners of the media

0:06:53.440 --> 0:06:56.880
<v Speaker 2>that the government can't stand because they think that we'll

0:06:56.900 --> 0:07:00.020
<v Speaker 2>never give them credit for anything. But the truth is

0:07:00.620 --> 0:07:03.850
<v Speaker 2>that as it was when we saw it coming, it

0:07:03.880 --> 0:07:07.010
<v Speaker 2>has become true as the government and the government has

0:07:07.050 --> 0:07:09.670
<v Speaker 2>had the benefit of the doubt for too long. And

0:07:09.710 --> 0:07:13.790
<v Speaker 2>they play off that every time they get themselves into trouble.

0:07:14.530 --> 0:07:17.000
<v Speaker 1>But normal people will just start.

0:07:18.500 --> 0:07:22.140
<v Speaker 2>Throwing things at the television when you tell them that

0:07:22.180 --> 0:07:24.600
<v Speaker 2>down is up and that up is down and that

0:07:24.640 --> 0:07:28.820
<v Speaker 2>black is white and the Jedi mind trick. These are

0:07:28.840 --> 0:07:30.580
<v Speaker 2>not the droids you're looking for, as it was from

0:07:30.650 --> 0:07:34.790
<v Speaker 2>Obi-Wan Kenobi. But this is not the inflation crisis that

0:07:34.830 --> 0:07:37.950
<v Speaker 2>you know it to be. This is not the highest

0:07:38.010 --> 0:07:42.630
<v Speaker 2>interest rates have been in 15 years. But regardless of

0:07:42.670 --> 0:07:46.679
<v Speaker 2>the spin and regardless of what media people ingest.

0:07:48.130 --> 0:07:51.390
<v Speaker 1>Here's the reality of how much it costs extra.

0:07:51.170 --> 0:07:54.090
<v Speaker 2>Since this government came to power and 16 interest rate

0:07:54.150 --> 0:07:57.370
<v Speaker 2>rises have kicked in. Now, this is Reserve Bank data

0:07:57.490 --> 0:08:01.130
<v Speaker 2>as processed in a search I did today using ChatGPT.

0:08:01.370 --> 0:08:05.000
<v Speaker 2>So these are approximates, but still. A loan of $ 500, 000

0:08:04.870 --> 0:08:06.520
<v Speaker 2>costs you $ 890 extra a month. A loan of $ 750, 000

0:08:06.180 --> 0:08:06.820
<v Speaker 2>costs you $ 1, 300.

0:08:06.650 --> 0:08:06.940
<v Speaker 1>Extra a month.

0:08:16.780 --> 0:08:21.620
<v Speaker 2>If you owe a million dollars, it's just under $ 2, 000.

0:08:20.540 --> 0:08:22.840
<v Speaker 2>And if you owe one and a half million dollars,

0:08:23.220 --> 0:08:26.380
<v Speaker 2>it is almost $ 3, 000. When you look at that on

0:08:26.400 --> 0:08:28.710
<v Speaker 2>the far right of your screen per year, we're talking

0:08:28.770 --> 0:08:30.990
<v Speaker 2>about people who are trying to pay off $ 500, 000 needing

0:08:31.010 --> 0:08:33.310
<v Speaker 2>to find $ 10, 680 that they didn't need to find when

0:08:33.350 --> 0:08:46.720
<v Speaker 2>the government changed in 2022. Or $ 16, 000 or $ 21, 000 or $ 32, 000. Now,

0:08:46.740 --> 0:08:49.060
<v Speaker 2>the reality is that at some point there is no

0:08:49.280 --> 0:08:51.900
<v Speaker 2>fat to cut, there is no belt left to tighten

0:08:51.940 --> 0:08:55.809
<v Speaker 2>because there is no more tummy. The reality is that

0:08:55.850 --> 0:08:58.210
<v Speaker 2>is where a lot of people are. Mortgage stress is

0:08:58.250 --> 0:09:01.650
<v Speaker 2>at a very high level. Contributing to all of that

0:09:01.690 --> 0:09:03.750
<v Speaker 2>is something that, again, I've talked about for how long,

0:09:03.809 --> 0:09:06.439
<v Speaker 2>about the number of people who literally, according to charities,

0:09:06.480 --> 0:09:08.319
<v Speaker 2>will be running out of food each and every week.

0:09:08.340 --> 0:09:10.540
<v Speaker 1>It's close to four million households.

0:09:11.679 --> 0:09:14.000
<v Speaker 2>The last census, which was done during COVID, told us

0:09:14.020 --> 0:09:16.840
<v Speaker 2>that homelessness was the highest rating it has ever been.

0:09:17.000 --> 0:09:20.300
<v Speaker 2>You reckon it's any better by the time we see

0:09:20.400 --> 0:09:21.059
<v Speaker 2>the results of.

0:09:21.050 --> 0:09:22.190
<v Speaker 1>This year's census?

0:09:24.730 --> 0:09:27.790
<v Speaker 2>If nothing else, you want people to at least tell

0:09:27.850 --> 0:09:31.550
<v Speaker 2>you the truth, even if it is their version of

0:09:31.610 --> 0:09:36.800
<v Speaker 2>the truth. But the unavoidable truth, the unspinable truth, is

0:09:36.840 --> 0:09:42.330
<v Speaker 2>that life is harder with the best part of four

0:09:42.390 --> 0:09:46.100
<v Speaker 2>years after the Albanese government took over. The Reserve Bank

0:09:46.380 --> 0:09:49.280
<v Speaker 2>told us that two of the four interest rate rises

0:09:49.300 --> 0:09:52.470
<v Speaker 2>that have happened this year all had nothing to do

0:09:52.530 --> 0:09:56.890
<v Speaker 2>with the war. They were all before the war. They

0:09:56.910 --> 0:10:01.400
<v Speaker 2>were all to do with domestic inflation. But because our

0:10:01.480 --> 0:10:05.500
<v Speaker 2>politics has become one where votes are to be bought

0:10:06.140 --> 0:10:09.360
<v Speaker 2>and the demand from government is for it to solve

0:10:09.400 --> 0:10:10.360
<v Speaker 2>everyone's problems.

0:10:11.990 --> 0:10:15.709
<v Speaker 2>That this generation of politicians, who on the one hand

0:10:15.770 --> 0:10:17.969
<v Speaker 2>on climate change say we must do something about it

0:10:17.990 --> 0:10:20.840
<v Speaker 2>to save the next generation, do not believe the same

0:10:20.890 --> 0:10:24.260
<v Speaker 2>when it comes to debt. At a trillion dollars that

0:10:24.300 --> 0:10:29.939
<v Speaker 2>it is now, it'll of course become 1.2, 1.5 and eventually.

0:10:29.559 --> 0:10:30.420
<v Speaker 1>$ 2 trillion.

0:10:30.480 --> 0:10:30.760
<v Speaker 2>Why?

0:10:31.000 --> 0:10:32.820
<v Speaker 1>Because we're in a budget deficit for the next 40 years.

0:10:35.130 --> 0:10:36.530
<v Speaker 2>No matter how many people they want to bust into

0:10:36.550 --> 0:10:38.689
<v Speaker 2>the country, no matter how many people they think will

0:10:38.730 --> 0:10:41.989
<v Speaker 2>grow the tax base, the reality is that the baked-in,

0:10:42.330 --> 0:10:48.059
<v Speaker 2>designed spending of the Australian federal government will have us spending.

0:10:47.700 --> 0:10:51.620
<v Speaker 1>More than is coming in for the next 40 years.

0:10:53.059 --> 0:10:54.400
<v Speaker 2>The only way to fix that, of course, is to

0:10:54.440 --> 0:10:56.939
<v Speaker 2>increase taxes, and when people don't have any money, that's

0:10:56.980 --> 0:10:58.470
<v Speaker 2>not a great idea, so the only thing you can

0:10:58.500 --> 0:11:00.650
<v Speaker 2>do is to deal with spending. But, of course, if

0:11:00.690 --> 0:11:02.610
<v Speaker 2>you deal with spending, cuts, cuts, cuts, cuts, cuts, and

0:11:02.630 --> 0:11:07.630
<v Speaker 2>you're black-hearted and oh-so-evil At some point, the majority of

0:11:07.670 --> 0:11:10.750
<v Speaker 2>people will not care about the scare ads and the

0:11:10.790 --> 0:11:13.500
<v Speaker 2>scare tactics of the government because they are the custodians.

0:11:13.750 --> 0:11:16.760
<v Speaker 2>They are the captains of the ship. They are the navigators.

0:11:16.820 --> 0:11:19.660
<v Speaker 2>They are the people who have the ability to change

0:11:19.720 --> 0:11:20.420
<v Speaker 2>the settings.

0:11:21.260 --> 0:11:26.000
<v Speaker 1>But they don't. And that's dangerous for the country. People

0:11:26.040 --> 0:11:26.540
<v Speaker 1>are angry.

0:11:27.460 --> 0:11:29.680
<v Speaker 2>But very soon, if they have not already, they are

0:11:29.760 --> 0:11:32.770
<v Speaker 2>not going to fall for the spin. And that's where

0:11:32.790 --> 0:11:34.730
<v Speaker 2>we're going to see a change in our politics, hopefully.

0:11:35.150 --> 0:11:38.880
<v Speaker 2>between now and the next election. 16 interest rate rises.

0:11:39.429 --> 0:11:41.939
<v Speaker 2>One standard when it was somebody else, completely different standard

0:11:41.960 --> 0:11:48.740
<v Speaker 2>for himself, 16 times over. Now, also worth talking about

0:11:48.800 --> 0:11:53.210
<v Speaker 2>here is the issues in and around small business. Now,

0:11:53.250 --> 0:11:55.270
<v Speaker 2>as you know, the Prime Minister has been out and

0:11:55.309 --> 0:11:57.929
<v Speaker 2>about today championing a decision from the Reserve Bank, which

0:11:57.990 --> 0:12:01.730
<v Speaker 2>is that your tap-and-go surcharges can no longer be added

0:12:01.929 --> 0:12:02.530
<v Speaker 2>to a bill.

0:12:03.960 --> 0:12:07.110
<v Speaker 6>Every time you tap, those little surcharges add up. Right now,

0:12:07.160 --> 0:12:11.990
<v Speaker 6>they're costing Aussies $ 1. 6 billion each and every year. But

0:12:12.050 --> 0:12:15.809
<v Speaker 6>from today, they're banned, saving you money every time you tap.

0:12:15.830 --> 0:12:18.630
<v Speaker 6>So whether you're at the supermarket paying bills or buying

0:12:18.650 --> 0:12:20.730
<v Speaker 6>a cup of coffee, the price you see is the

0:12:20.770 --> 0:12:21.510
<v Speaker 6>price you pay.

0:12:22.490 --> 0:12:25.740
<v Speaker 2>Yes, that's the Prime Minister delivering a message from an alley,

0:12:25.800 --> 0:12:28.460
<v Speaker 2>probably somewhere a dumpster is just out of shot.

0:12:29.179 --> 0:12:30.040
<v Speaker 1>He's so one of us.

0:12:31.080 --> 0:12:33.459
<v Speaker 2>And yes, the decision was made by the Reserve Bank...

0:12:34.320 --> 0:12:38.900
<v Speaker 2>that these surcharges had to be effectively absorbed by business.

0:12:39.500 --> 0:12:42.140
<v Speaker 2>They couldn't be passed on as like a GST style

0:12:42.300 --> 0:12:45.600
<v Speaker 2>add-on to a bill. And that's one thing if you're

0:12:45.620 --> 0:12:48.979
<v Speaker 2>a massive mega company that's making hundreds of millions or

0:12:49.040 --> 0:12:53.059
<v Speaker 2>billions of dollars profit, but in small business, no such margin.

0:12:53.920 --> 0:12:56.860
<v Speaker 2>So the reality is, is that the charge has not disappeared.

0:12:56.880 --> 0:12:58.120
<v Speaker 2>I'm not the first and I won't be the last

0:12:58.160 --> 0:13:00.040
<v Speaker 2>to mention it, but how can I not make the

0:13:00.100 --> 0:13:04.920
<v Speaker 2>obvious point? that they are pretending that it has disappeared. No,

0:13:05.340 --> 0:13:09.010
<v Speaker 2>the banks still charge small businesses for what used to

0:13:09.040 --> 0:13:11.449
<v Speaker 2>be called the old FPOS machine, but now essentially the

0:13:11.550 --> 0:13:14.770
<v Speaker 2>tap-and-go technology that is the way that the extreme majority

0:13:14.809 --> 0:13:16.850
<v Speaker 2>of Australians pay for everything.

0:13:18.470 --> 0:13:19.489
<v Speaker 1>So who's going to pay for it?

0:13:20.190 --> 0:13:23.010
<v Speaker 2>Well, if the business has enough margin, they might find

0:13:23.050 --> 0:13:25.469
<v Speaker 2>a way to try to hold it in. But if

0:13:25.490 --> 0:13:27.730
<v Speaker 2>he's saying the total cost is more than a billion dollars, well,

0:13:27.770 --> 0:13:29.870
<v Speaker 2>guess what? For small business, they're not able to do

0:13:30.030 --> 0:13:33.980
<v Speaker 2>anything about it. which means plenty of people may have

0:13:34.420 --> 0:13:37.180
<v Speaker 2>seen a little change in the price of things that, yes,

0:13:37.300 --> 0:13:39.420
<v Speaker 2>it's not a huge amount of money all at once, but.

0:13:39.370 --> 0:13:40.900
<v Speaker 1>Over and over and over and over and over and

0:13:40.990 --> 0:13:42.070
<v Speaker 1>over and over, it.

0:13:42.090 --> 0:13:46.390
<v Speaker 2>Adds to the problem that exists, which means the price

0:13:46.429 --> 0:13:49.010
<v Speaker 2>of everything will go up because the price of being

0:13:49.110 --> 0:13:54.309
<v Speaker 2>able to pay for it, ding, still costs a business money.

0:13:55.050 --> 0:13:57.230
<v Speaker 2>Here's plenty of the small businesses we spoke to today.

0:13:58.150 --> 0:14:04.330
<v Speaker 3>It's $ 40, 000.

0:14:00.740 --> 0:14:02.020
<v Speaker 7>And.

0:14:13.330 --> 0:14:15.970
<v Speaker 2>Everyone tonight has shown you Peter Pappas, who runs a

0:14:16.070 --> 0:14:20.150
<v Speaker 2>Greek restaurant, because he was, well, so clear about.

0:14:19.970 --> 0:14:20.490
<v Speaker 1>What this is.

0:14:20.570 --> 0:14:23.770
<v Speaker 2>Again, to government that talks in hundreds of billions of dollars,

0:14:23.810 --> 0:14:25.990
<v Speaker 2>this doesn't matter. For people like the Prime Minister, who

0:14:26.030 --> 0:14:30.230
<v Speaker 2>had no experience in... business, let alone small business. And remember,

0:14:30.270 --> 0:14:33.250
<v Speaker 2>there's only two people around the entire cabinet table who

0:14:33.290 --> 0:14:36.860
<v Speaker 2>have any experience in small business. One supposedly is Tony Burke,

0:14:36.900 --> 0:14:38.960
<v Speaker 2>but I can't find what the evidence was. The other

0:14:39.360 --> 0:14:41.660
<v Speaker 2>is the Trade Minister, Don Farrell. And he, of course,

0:14:41.960 --> 0:14:44.900
<v Speaker 2>had his own wine label for a couple of years

0:14:45.220 --> 0:14:47.860
<v Speaker 2>in between runs in the Senate. Other than that, they

0:14:47.880 --> 0:14:51.890
<v Speaker 2>don't care. But people like Peter Pappas do. People like

0:14:52.150 --> 0:14:54.860
<v Speaker 2>my family do. People like your family do. Because there's

0:14:54.880 --> 0:14:57.820
<v Speaker 2>no margin in small business and now the cost goes up,

0:14:58.160 --> 0:15:00.360
<v Speaker 2>as well as the cost of everything going up.

0:15:00.860 --> 0:15:01.380
<v Speaker 1>So guess what?

0:15:01.540 --> 0:15:03.880
<v Speaker 2>They're not falling for the Prime Minister in a back

0:15:04.000 --> 0:15:05.950
<v Speaker 2>alley that everything got better today.

0:15:07.590 --> 0:15:09.750
<v Speaker 7>We seem to be the punching bag for the state

0:15:09.790 --> 0:15:12.530
<v Speaker 7>and federal government in terms of increasing taxes. A couple

0:15:12.570 --> 0:15:15.710
<v Speaker 7>of cents in our case, for example, adds up to

0:15:16.130 --> 0:15:17.510
<v Speaker 7>well over $ 100, 000 a year.

0:15:18.610 --> 0:15:21.190
<v Speaker 2>And again, the pressure on small business, and let's be

0:15:21.210 --> 0:15:24.890
<v Speaker 2>very clear... When I talk about the triangle of dependence,

0:15:25.610 --> 0:15:29.120
<v Speaker 2>the idea for governments like this federal government, like what

0:15:29.240 --> 0:15:32.680
<v Speaker 2>is existing in Victoria, what used to be there in Queensland,

0:15:33.160 --> 0:15:37.060
<v Speaker 2>is that they will eventually be able to get to 55, 60, 70%

0:15:37.060 --> 0:15:40.680
<v Speaker 2>of the vote. If everyone either works for the government,

0:15:41.360 --> 0:15:46.330
<v Speaker 2>gets welfare from the government, or in big business, the

0:15:46.370 --> 0:15:48.190
<v Speaker 2>biggest client is the government.

0:15:48.510 --> 0:15:49.750
<v Speaker 1>Therefore, nobody rocks the boat.

0:15:50.640 --> 0:15:52.380
<v Speaker 2>Now, despite the fact that the consequence of all of

0:15:52.420 --> 0:15:54.480
<v Speaker 2>this continues to be a budget deficit for the next

0:15:54.480 --> 0:15:57.240
<v Speaker 2>40 years, they don't care. Because if they can have

0:15:57.280 --> 0:15:59.160
<v Speaker 2>the majority of people on their side when it comes

0:15:59.200 --> 0:16:01.920
<v Speaker 2>to votes, well, no one ever rocks the boat. But

0:16:01.940 --> 0:16:05.380
<v Speaker 2>for the people who live outside of that triangle, the

0:16:05.400 --> 0:16:08.880
<v Speaker 2>people in small business, the people in medium business, the

0:16:08.900 --> 0:16:13.120
<v Speaker 2>people who do not have any interest in working anything

0:16:13.750 --> 0:16:16.510
<v Speaker 2>towards the government and are aggravated by the system of

0:16:16.570 --> 0:16:18.870
<v Speaker 2>government that we have and the way that there's so

0:16:18.930 --> 0:16:22.630
<v Speaker 2>many different ways to make things harder, this stuff can

0:16:22.670 --> 0:16:26.170
<v Speaker 2>be life and death. In fact, the Reserve Bank released

0:16:26.510 --> 0:16:29.960
<v Speaker 2>a pretty important look around the corner, which, yes, is

0:16:30.000 --> 0:16:31.520
<v Speaker 2>probably going to push us towards.

0:16:31.300 --> 0:16:33.440
<v Speaker 1>Another interest rate rise, because guess what?

0:16:33.810 --> 0:16:36.450
<v Speaker 2>If prices of everything go up because the charges to

0:16:36.470 --> 0:16:39.340
<v Speaker 2>the banks need to be paid for by the businesses, well,

0:16:39.360 --> 0:16:41.940
<v Speaker 2>that will, of course, add to inflation. Inflation already at

0:16:41.960 --> 0:16:44.580
<v Speaker 2>a four means there could be another interest rate rise

0:16:44.600 --> 0:16:46.300
<v Speaker 2>and it could be like half a percent as early

0:16:46.340 --> 0:16:46.960
<v Speaker 2>as November.

0:16:47.200 --> 0:16:48.460
<v Speaker 1>I hope not, but that's what could happen.

0:16:50.370 --> 0:16:53.190
<v Speaker 2>Financial pressures, this is from a note from the Reserve

0:16:53.230 --> 0:16:56.070
<v Speaker 2>Bank today, financial pressures are expected to increase over the

0:16:56.110 --> 0:16:59.210
<v Speaker 2>period ahead, especially for smaller businesses and those in more

0:16:59.330 --> 0:17:04.810
<v Speaker 2>energy-intensive or cyclic industries, the Reserve Bank's biannual report released

0:17:05.150 --> 0:17:09.710
<v Speaker 2>on Thursday. The incidents of financial stress are expected to

0:17:09.750 --> 0:17:13.629
<v Speaker 2>remain high in the period, ahead for smaller businesses, particularly

0:17:13.710 --> 0:17:17.859
<v Speaker 2>in construction, hospitality and retail industries, where uncertainty and weaker

0:17:17.880 --> 0:17:21.679
<v Speaker 2>demand could weigh on the discretionary spending. So unless you

0:17:21.700 --> 0:17:23.500
<v Speaker 2>have to spend it, you won't spend it, you won't

0:17:23.540 --> 0:17:25.540
<v Speaker 2>buy it, the business will have no revenue and the

0:17:25.560 --> 0:17:30.740
<v Speaker 2>business goes bust. The report says that insolvency rates, are currently, quote,

0:17:30.960 --> 0:17:36.000
<v Speaker 2>elevated in sectors including, guess what, hospitality, construction and transport,

0:17:36.020 --> 0:17:38.820
<v Speaker 2>where the operating environment remains challenging, particularly.

0:17:38.640 --> 0:17:43.330
<v Speaker 1>For smaller firms. It's all getting worse. You know it,

0:17:43.540 --> 0:17:43.980
<v Speaker 1>I know it.

0:17:44.080 --> 0:17:46.480
<v Speaker 2>They can spin, they can distract, they can say, look

0:17:46.540 --> 0:17:50.860
<v Speaker 2>over there, social media bans. But the reality of life

0:17:50.900 --> 0:17:53.080
<v Speaker 2>in Australia is that it has all got harder. Now,

0:17:53.100 --> 0:17:55.659
<v Speaker 2>it's not totally the government's fault, but certainly the government,

0:17:55.700 --> 0:17:58.330
<v Speaker 2>when it's had an opportunity to make things better or worse,

0:17:58.630 --> 0:18:05.639
<v Speaker 2>makes decisions... that always seem to end up with worse decisions. Now,

0:18:05.800 --> 0:18:08.300
<v Speaker 2>as we know, when it comes to migration, Australians couldn't

0:18:08.340 --> 0:18:10.939
<v Speaker 2>be clearer. Every single poll, including one that came out

0:18:11.040 --> 0:18:14.870
<v Speaker 2>this week in The Guardian, otherwise known as the Turnbull Times...

0:18:15.090 --> 0:18:17.109
<v Speaker 2>They've said that Australians want a massive reduction in the

0:18:17.150 --> 0:18:18.369
<v Speaker 2>number of people coming in.

0:18:18.590 --> 0:18:20.500
<v Speaker 1>Not about the type of people. It's not about the...

0:18:20.670 --> 0:18:23.970
<v Speaker 1>It's just literally every queue is already too long. Please

0:18:24.010 --> 0:18:24.990
<v Speaker 1>don't add to the queue.

0:18:25.390 --> 0:18:28.840
<v Speaker 2>But Tony Burke, of course, has made no change to

0:18:28.859 --> 0:18:30.820
<v Speaker 2>the overall number that are due to be coming in.

0:18:30.859 --> 0:18:32.680
<v Speaker 1>Instead, there's some smart-arse.

0:18:32.720 --> 0:18:37.590
<v Speaker 2>Political hits on things like the fruit-picking industry and the backpackers. Oh,

0:18:37.609 --> 0:18:38.750
<v Speaker 2>the backpackers are the problem.

0:18:38.950 --> 0:18:41.790
<v Speaker 1>Really? But, of course, there's housing.

0:18:42.310 --> 0:18:44.470
<v Speaker 2>Now, supposedly, one of the reasons why nobody has to

0:18:44.510 --> 0:18:46.890
<v Speaker 2>worry about migration and hundreds of thousands of people coming

0:18:46.930 --> 0:18:48.650
<v Speaker 2>in each and every year, a couple of million over

0:18:48.670 --> 0:18:51.000
<v Speaker 2>a couple of terms of this government is because, oh,

0:18:51.010 --> 0:18:53.710
<v Speaker 2>they're going to build 1.5 million new houses. Only problem

0:18:53.750 --> 0:18:56.950
<v Speaker 2>is they're not going to build 1.5 million new houses.

0:18:58.150 --> 0:18:59.600
<v Speaker 1>Instead, they're going to fall short by the best part

0:18:59.700 --> 0:19:02.580
<v Speaker 1>of a quarter of a million. Yet, of course, they

0:19:02.619 --> 0:19:04.080
<v Speaker 1>won't be cutting the number of people that are coming

0:19:04.100 --> 0:19:05.840
<v Speaker 1>into the country. Not at all.

0:19:06.780 --> 0:19:08.500
<v Speaker 2>Let alone, of course, the sheer idea that if you've

0:19:08.520 --> 0:19:10.659
<v Speaker 2>got one, two kids at home, eventually they will at

0:19:10.700 --> 0:19:14.050
<v Speaker 2>some point leave. That's the whole point about why you

0:19:14.070 --> 0:19:19.330
<v Speaker 2>need more housing supply. But then again, these geniuses, when

0:19:19.369 --> 0:19:20.930
<v Speaker 2>they have the chance to pull a lever, they pull

0:19:20.950 --> 0:19:23.840
<v Speaker 2>it in the wrong direction. Now, who knows where that

0:19:23.880 --> 0:19:26.560
<v Speaker 2>direction ends up in 10, 20 years' time, but the

0:19:26.600 --> 0:19:28.700
<v Speaker 2>reality is now matters.

0:19:29.359 --> 0:19:33.840
<v Speaker 1>Transition matters. The cost of transition matters.

0:19:35.240 --> 0:19:38.149
<v Speaker 2>Now, I don't hate the idea about the 5% deposit

0:19:38.609 --> 0:19:41.130
<v Speaker 2>for people if that's the way they can get into

0:19:41.150 --> 0:19:44.240
<v Speaker 2>the housing market. But, of course, the reality is the

0:19:44.359 --> 0:19:46.619
<v Speaker 2>size of the deposit and how little money there is

0:19:46.660 --> 0:19:50.960
<v Speaker 2>left over to save for a deposit is a big problem. Politically,

0:19:51.000 --> 0:19:53.060
<v Speaker 2>of course, this government thinks that, well, they can have

0:19:53.100 --> 0:19:55.770
<v Speaker 2>it both ways, right, which is have more demand for housing, i.e.

0:19:55.880 --> 0:20:00.850
<v Speaker 2>more people, at the same time as making it harder

0:20:01.090 --> 0:20:01.770
<v Speaker 2>for people to be able.

0:20:01.690 --> 0:20:04.270
<v Speaker 1>To save for a deposit... But.

0:20:04.210 --> 0:20:06.570
<v Speaker 2>Even if you are somebody who has actually bought one

0:20:06.730 --> 0:20:10.210
<v Speaker 2>of these houses, guess what? The value of the house,

0:20:10.690 --> 0:20:13.470
<v Speaker 2>because of the taxation policies that they put in place,

0:20:13.780 --> 0:20:16.219
<v Speaker 2>means what you bought for a million bucks right now,

0:20:16.260 --> 0:20:17.980
<v Speaker 2>if you had to resell it because, God forbid, people

0:20:18.000 --> 0:20:22.179
<v Speaker 2>get divorced, people lose their job, life happens, and it

0:20:22.200 --> 0:20:25.459
<v Speaker 2>might only happen to 1% of the overall borrowers, but

0:20:25.480 --> 0:20:28.780
<v Speaker 2>it's still potentially tens of thousands of people.

0:20:29.119 --> 0:20:29.580
<v Speaker 1>Guess what?

0:20:30.000 --> 0:20:32.100
<v Speaker 2>They've got to sell the joint for less than what

0:20:32.140 --> 0:20:37.170
<v Speaker 2>they actually bought. Story today, News 24, our home website,

0:20:37.190 --> 0:20:39.990
<v Speaker 2>of course, is that the home ownership dream is sour.

0:20:40.130 --> 0:20:40.390
<v Speaker 1>Why?

0:20:40.750 --> 0:20:43.710
<v Speaker 2>Because many who took advantage of the 5% deposit scheme, i.e.

0:20:43.770 --> 0:20:45.110
<v Speaker 2>people who have bought a house in the past couple

0:20:45.130 --> 0:20:48.060
<v Speaker 2>of years, that joint is worth less than what it

0:20:48.100 --> 0:20:50.459
<v Speaker 2>was before. Fine if you can ride it out for

0:20:50.460 --> 0:20:53.120
<v Speaker 2>10 years, but interest rates, they keep going up. They're

0:20:53.140 --> 0:20:56.480
<v Speaker 2>going to keep going up, let alone if, again, something

0:20:56.520 --> 0:20:59.680
<v Speaker 2>happens in your life. Now, despite the fact all of

0:20:59.720 --> 0:21:03.929
<v Speaker 2>this is happening, Clueless Clare O'Neill, the Housing Minister, is

0:21:03.990 --> 0:21:06.670
<v Speaker 2>out and about online today pretending nothing to see here,

0:21:07.070 --> 0:21:10.310
<v Speaker 2>that anyone who actually has made the most of the 5%

0:21:10.310 --> 0:21:13.230
<v Speaker 2>deposit scheme bought a house that is now worth less

0:21:13.690 --> 0:21:16.030
<v Speaker 2>because of the very same government that is still trying

0:21:16.050 --> 0:21:18.530
<v Speaker 2>to pretend nothing to see here.

0:21:18.950 --> 0:21:20.270
<v Speaker 1>Here she is on socials today.

0:21:21.690 --> 0:21:22.290
<v Speaker 8>Remember this.

0:21:22.750 --> 0:21:25.300
<v Speaker 6>Under a Labor government, you'll be able to buy your

0:21:25.359 --> 0:21:28.280
<v Speaker 6>first home with just a 5% deposit.

0:21:30.780 --> 0:21:31.380
<v Speaker 1>Five percent.

0:21:31.480 --> 0:21:32.200
<v Speaker 9>Five percent.

0:21:32.359 --> 0:21:32.980
<v Speaker 10>Five percent.

0:21:33.900 --> 0:21:36.200
<v Speaker 11>From today, every single first home buyer in the country

0:21:36.280 --> 0:21:38.160
<v Speaker 11>will be eligible to get into a home of their

0:21:38.240 --> 0:21:40.500
<v Speaker 11>own with just a five percent deposit and with our

0:21:40.520 --> 0:21:44.119
<v Speaker 11>government's backing. In Sydney, on average, it's taking 11 years

0:21:44.200 --> 0:21:46.660
<v Speaker 11>to save for their first home. We're bringing that back

0:21:46.680 --> 0:21:50.260
<v Speaker 11>to two or three years. One year on, we've already

0:21:50.320 --> 0:21:53.879
<v Speaker 11>helped 100,000 people across the country get the keys to

0:21:53.900 --> 0:21:55.580
<v Speaker 11>their own home and we're just getting started.

0:21:56.619 --> 0:21:59.100
<v Speaker 2>Shane Oliver is the AMP's chief economist. You see him

0:21:59.119 --> 0:22:00.679
<v Speaker 2>often on the news. He's been very kind to give

0:22:00.700 --> 0:22:03.180
<v Speaker 2>us a bit of his time tonight. Shane, of course,

0:22:03.200 --> 0:22:05.010
<v Speaker 2>you're way smarter than I would be. You may disagree

0:22:05.050 --> 0:22:07.169
<v Speaker 2>with many of what I've just had to say. But

0:22:07.490 --> 0:22:10.250
<v Speaker 2>what's your take on where we sit right now? Because, again,

0:22:11.150 --> 0:22:14.070
<v Speaker 2>the real-life version of this is pressure.

0:22:14.510 --> 0:22:14.670
<v Speaker 6>Right.

0:22:14.710 --> 0:22:17.600
<v Speaker 2>And it is a pressure that gets worse. And yes, theoretically,

0:22:17.640 --> 0:22:19.480
<v Speaker 2>when you look at the numbers, they don't have emotions.

0:22:19.560 --> 0:22:21.919
<v Speaker 2>But you know that emotion is a big part of

0:22:21.960 --> 0:22:25.369
<v Speaker 2>what's playing right now. Are things as good as the

0:22:25.410 --> 0:22:27.830
<v Speaker 2>government say? Are they as bad as I make out?

0:22:27.869 --> 0:22:30.609
<v Speaker 2>What's your sense about where the truth lies somewhere in

0:22:30.650 --> 0:22:30.950
<v Speaker 2>the middle?

0:22:31.890 --> 0:22:34.129
<v Speaker 8>Well, I won't pick sides here. I'll say it the

0:22:34.150 --> 0:22:36.199
<v Speaker 8>way I see it, and that is I think we're

0:22:36.240 --> 0:22:40.160
<v Speaker 8>in a difficult situation in Australia. We've benefited for many,

0:22:40.180 --> 0:22:45.960
<v Speaker 8>many years by the deregulation, the free market philosophy, the

0:22:45.980 --> 0:22:49.410
<v Speaker 8>good social safety net that Paul Keating and Bob Hawke introduced.

0:22:49.570 --> 0:22:53.970
<v Speaker 8>That effectively was continued under Howard and Costello with some tweaks,

0:22:54.030 --> 0:22:56.480
<v Speaker 8>of course. But since then, we've dropped the ball to

0:22:56.500 --> 0:22:59.429
<v Speaker 8>some degree, and that's meant lower productivity. And at the

0:22:59.450 --> 0:23:01.770
<v Speaker 8>end of the day, that means lower growth in our

0:23:01.810 --> 0:23:04.790
<v Speaker 8>living standards. And of course, right here, right now, that

0:23:04.830 --> 0:23:07.990
<v Speaker 8>is showing up. of course, in a higher cost of living.

0:23:08.050 --> 0:23:12.460
<v Speaker 8>That's how people are experiencing that deterioration. So I think

0:23:12.500 --> 0:23:16.359
<v Speaker 8>we are in a bit of a messy situation at present. Yes,

0:23:16.580 --> 0:23:20.820
<v Speaker 8>other countries also face an inflation problem globally. But if

0:23:20.840 --> 0:23:23.399
<v Speaker 8>you look at the underlying rates of inflation, even the

0:23:23.420 --> 0:23:27.050
<v Speaker 8>headline rates of inflation, we're at the high end. And that,

0:23:27.130 --> 0:23:30.189
<v Speaker 8>I think, reflects a bunch of things. Obviously, that productivity

0:23:30.230 --> 0:23:32.520
<v Speaker 8>issue is a big part of it. I think government

0:23:32.540 --> 0:23:35.100
<v Speaker 8>spending is a lot higher as a share of.

0:23:35.040 --> 0:23:36.460
<v Speaker 4>The economy that it used to be.

0:23:36.800 --> 0:23:39.639
<v Speaker 8>Yes, we want all those things that government can provide,

0:23:40.040 --> 0:23:43.740
<v Speaker 8>but it's coming with a cost because government spending obviously

0:23:43.800 --> 0:23:48.950
<v Speaker 8>squeezes out private spending. And one of the mechanisms through

0:23:48.970 --> 0:23:52.310
<v Speaker 8>which that happens is higher interest rates and higher inflation.

0:23:52.790 --> 0:23:55.090
<v Speaker 8>So to some degree, we're paying the price for that.

0:23:55.730 --> 0:23:59.090
<v Speaker 8>And of course, it just accentuates the basic problem. So

0:23:59.390 --> 0:24:02.310
<v Speaker 8>I think what should have happened, if I go back

0:24:02.350 --> 0:24:05.060
<v Speaker 8>to the budgets we saw across the federal government and

0:24:05.080 --> 0:24:08.300
<v Speaker 8>the state's earlier this year, we should have seen a

0:24:09.090 --> 0:24:11.810
<v Speaker 8>more aggressive move to cut spending. I mean, there was

0:24:11.830 --> 0:24:13.990
<v Speaker 8>some talk of cutting spending, but it's a fair way

0:24:14.010 --> 0:24:16.230
<v Speaker 8>down the track. But if we'd seen more spending cuts

0:24:16.310 --> 0:24:19.110
<v Speaker 8>back then, it would have taken pressure off, it would

0:24:19.150 --> 0:24:23.020
<v Speaker 8>have enabled household spending, business investment and so on to

0:24:23.080 --> 0:24:26.520
<v Speaker 8>pick up without bumping into this inflation problem that we

0:24:26.560 --> 0:24:30.100
<v Speaker 8>now have, and it would have meant probably lower interest

0:24:30.180 --> 0:24:32.460
<v Speaker 8>rates and less of a burden on those with a mortgage.

0:24:32.540 --> 0:24:34.820
<v Speaker 8>So I think that's the sort of problem we face today.

0:24:35.260 --> 0:24:37.869
<v Speaker 8>There's two problems with excessive levels of government spending. And

0:24:37.890 --> 0:24:40.030
<v Speaker 8>don't get me wrong, I think government spending is very important.

0:24:40.050 --> 0:24:42.170
<v Speaker 8>It plays a key role in the economy and public

0:24:42.190 --> 0:24:44.330
<v Speaker 8>servants do a great job for the most part. But

0:24:44.350 --> 0:24:46.409
<v Speaker 8>you can have too much of a good thing. And

0:24:46.550 --> 0:24:49.760
<v Speaker 8>I think that's what's happened in Australia. Public spending as

0:24:49.800 --> 0:24:52.480
<v Speaker 8>a share of the economy is around five percentage points

0:24:52.560 --> 0:24:57.379
<v Speaker 8>higher than it was in the decades prior to the pandemic.

0:24:57.859 --> 0:25:00.810
<v Speaker 8>And that, of course, is leading the problems we have

0:25:00.830 --> 0:25:02.350
<v Speaker 8>at present in terms of inflation.

0:25:02.670 --> 0:25:04.250
<v Speaker 4>But it also detracts from productivity.

0:25:04.530 --> 0:25:07.790
<v Speaker 8>If you allocate more of your resources to the public sector,

0:25:08.430 --> 0:25:11.560
<v Speaker 8>there's less left over for the somewhat more efficient, more

0:25:11.600 --> 0:25:13.020
<v Speaker 8>productive private sector.

0:25:13.420 --> 0:25:14.760
<v Speaker 4>And so it hits both ways.

0:25:15.140 --> 0:25:17.540
<v Speaker 8>It adds to costs in the short term, competes with

0:25:17.560 --> 0:25:20.060
<v Speaker 8>the private sector, but it also over the longer term

0:25:20.440 --> 0:25:22.820
<v Speaker 8>results in lower productivity growth.

0:25:23.340 --> 0:25:27.390
<v Speaker 2>Does it matter that in the intergenerational report they previewed

0:25:27.920 --> 0:25:32.820
<v Speaker 2>no budget surpluses between now and when the Jetsons were set. Literally,

0:25:32.880 --> 0:25:36.020
<v Speaker 2>the old 60s cartoon was in 2060, right?

0:25:36.020 --> 0:25:37.239
<v Speaker 1>40 years of.

0:25:37.200 --> 0:25:40.929
<v Speaker 2>Budget deficits, and obviously every one of those deficits is

0:25:40.990 --> 0:25:44.889
<v Speaker 2>added to existing debt. The Treasurer himself, because of the

0:25:44.970 --> 0:25:47.169
<v Speaker 2>cost of paying off debt, because interest rates apply to

0:25:47.210 --> 0:25:51.480
<v Speaker 2>governments as well, does it matter that the plan at

0:25:51.520 --> 0:25:54.180
<v Speaker 2>this point, the structure of the budget at this point,

0:25:54.619 --> 0:25:56.200
<v Speaker 2>is deficits for 40 years?

0:25:57.730 --> 0:26:01.210
<v Speaker 8>It certainly does. When I look at the budget numbers

0:26:01.230 --> 0:26:05.350
<v Speaker 8>in Australia, we don't have a revenue problem. Budget revenue

0:26:05.470 --> 0:26:09.210
<v Speaker 8>is sort of running around as high as it has

0:26:09.290 --> 0:26:12.820
<v Speaker 8>ever got. I think the previous slightly higher number, only

0:26:12.840 --> 0:26:16.159
<v Speaker 8>fractionally higher, was in the high point or the start

0:26:16.180 --> 0:26:19.360
<v Speaker 8>of the mining boom. back in the 2000s, and then

0:26:19.400 --> 0:26:21.680
<v Speaker 8>Howard Costello gave a lot of that back as tax

0:26:21.720 --> 0:26:24.810
<v Speaker 8>cuts when they realised that revenue was getting too high.

0:26:25.200 --> 0:26:28.530
<v Speaker 8>But now we've got similar revenue levels as a share

0:26:28.570 --> 0:26:32.030
<v Speaker 8>of the economy compared to back then, but government spending

0:26:32.310 --> 0:26:34.869
<v Speaker 8>is that much more, and that's why we have a

0:26:34.910 --> 0:26:38.449
<v Speaker 8>budget deficit, whereas back then we had a budget surplus,

0:26:38.490 --> 0:26:41.000
<v Speaker 8>and those budget surpluses grew in size and we paid

0:26:41.060 --> 0:26:41.620
<v Speaker 8>down debt.

0:26:41.920 --> 0:26:43.900
<v Speaker 4>Yes, it does matter that you've got budget.

0:26:43.619 --> 0:26:46.979
<v Speaker 8>Deficits now, indefinitely because as you say each time you

0:26:47.000 --> 0:26:50.540
<v Speaker 8>run a budget deficit you're spending more than you earn.

0:26:50.340 --> 0:26:52.399
<v Speaker 4>Basically it's like a household you add to.

0:26:52.380 --> 0:26:55.830
<v Speaker 8>Your debt and the problem with all of that is

0:26:55.869 --> 0:26:58.510
<v Speaker 8>that we're not putting money aside for a rainy day

0:26:58.810 --> 0:27:01.990
<v Speaker 8>when you add to debt you're exposed when interest rates

0:27:02.030 --> 0:27:04.770
<v Speaker 8>go up globally which is happening right here right now

0:27:04.830 --> 0:27:07.929
<v Speaker 8>we're seeing levels of interest rates globally, bond yields I'm

0:27:07.970 --> 0:27:12.500
<v Speaker 8>talking about here in Australia, not seen since 2011, I think, 2015,

0:27:12.500 --> 0:27:16.300
<v Speaker 8>in the US, not since 2002. That's a bit of

0:27:16.340 --> 0:27:19.919
<v Speaker 8>a backlash against public debt globally. Maybe the problem's not

0:27:19.980 --> 0:27:22.540
<v Speaker 8>as great in Australia, but by the same token, we

0:27:22.619 --> 0:27:25.350
<v Speaker 8>pay for it. We have to allocate more of our

0:27:25.410 --> 0:27:29.330
<v Speaker 8>tax revenue to paying interest on that debt. So, yes,

0:27:29.369 --> 0:27:29.870
<v Speaker 8>it does matter.

0:27:30.070 --> 0:27:31.530
<v Speaker 4>The other problem, I think, with.

0:27:31.450 --> 0:27:34.689
<v Speaker 8>The intergenerational report that we saw on Monday was that

0:27:34.760 --> 0:27:37.060
<v Speaker 8>the whole point of the intergenerational report when it was

0:27:37.359 --> 0:27:41.160
<v Speaker 8>introduced by Costello in 2002, I think it was, was

0:27:41.180 --> 0:27:43.340
<v Speaker 8>to highlight the stresses.

0:27:42.940 --> 0:27:46.929
<v Speaker 4>And strains on the budget from an ageing population... and ultimately, as.

0:27:47.750 --> 0:27:50.590
<v Speaker 8>A community, as a country, to work out ways to

0:27:50.690 --> 0:27:53.869
<v Speaker 8>budget for that. And, of course, the government at the day,

0:27:53.950 --> 0:27:57.209
<v Speaker 8>back then, they did that by running budget surpluses, we

0:27:57.230 --> 0:28:00.790
<v Speaker 8>set up the Future Fund and so on. That purpose

0:28:00.850 --> 0:28:04.810
<v Speaker 8>behind the IGR seems to have been forgotten. Yes, we

0:28:04.850 --> 0:28:07.169
<v Speaker 8>have the spending going on as a result of an

0:28:07.230 --> 0:28:10.449
<v Speaker 8>ageing population, but we're not cutting spending in other areas

0:28:10.490 --> 0:28:13.649
<v Speaker 8>to make way for it. And the other big problem, well,

0:28:13.690 --> 0:28:16.200
<v Speaker 8>I thought with the IGR is it assumes that there's

0:28:16.220 --> 0:28:20.200
<v Speaker 8>no major setback. If we have a setback like the GFC,

0:28:20.400 --> 0:28:24.300
<v Speaker 8>when a government of whatever persuasion is inclined to spend

0:28:24.340 --> 0:28:27.310
<v Speaker 8>their way out of it, like the pandemic, then we'll

0:28:27.609 --> 0:28:30.090
<v Speaker 8>leap up the budget deficit to a new higher level.

0:28:30.130 --> 0:28:32.410
<v Speaker 8>Government spending will jump up to a new higher level.

0:28:32.750 --> 0:28:35.850
<v Speaker 8>And the projections we see in the intergenerational report will

0:28:35.890 --> 0:28:37.010
<v Speaker 8>actually look optimistic.

0:28:37.390 --> 0:28:39.880
<v Speaker 4>So, yes, I agree. It is a problem that we've

0:28:39.890 --> 0:28:41.260
<v Speaker 4>got these ongoing deficits.

0:28:41.660 --> 0:28:43.000
<v Speaker 2>Last one here, and I don't want to get you

0:28:43.040 --> 0:28:45.860
<v Speaker 2>in trouble, but I know you're a skilled media performer

0:28:45.900 --> 0:28:47.719
<v Speaker 2>and won't go anywhere near it, but I just want

0:28:47.740 --> 0:28:51.860
<v Speaker 2>to ask, as an economist, right, what gets you shouting

0:28:51.880 --> 0:28:54.580
<v Speaker 2>at the television? Do you get shouting at the television

0:28:54.620 --> 0:28:58.840
<v Speaker 2>about politicians, about commentators, about the use of Vox Pops?

0:28:58.900 --> 0:29:00.720
<v Speaker 2>What is it as a bloke who sees the whole

0:29:00.780 --> 0:29:05.520
<v Speaker 2>picture where you just go, stop viewing the economy like that?

0:29:07.640 --> 0:29:10.690
<v Speaker 8>Look, to be honest with you, I grew up, I

0:29:10.730 --> 0:29:13.580
<v Speaker 8>started my career as an economist in the days of

0:29:13.660 --> 0:29:16.800
<v Speaker 8>Hawke and Keating and then Howard and Costello. I mean,

0:29:16.940 --> 0:29:20.860
<v Speaker 8>they're my heroes in terms of implementing good, sensible economics,

0:29:21.660 --> 0:29:26.080
<v Speaker 8>which was along the lines of that we can't just

0:29:26.140 --> 0:29:28.200
<v Speaker 8>focus on dividing the pie up.

0:29:28.640 --> 0:29:31.590
<v Speaker 4>We've got to grow the pie. So I get annoyed.

0:29:31.610 --> 0:29:34.750
<v Speaker 4>I don't shoot the TV. I'm not Elvis.

0:29:34.770 --> 0:29:36.810
<v Speaker 8>I've got some Elvis books over there, but I'm not

0:29:36.950 --> 0:29:38.730
<v Speaker 8>going to get my gun out and shoot the TV

0:29:38.750 --> 0:29:40.800
<v Speaker 8>because that'll probably end up shooting myself in the foot

0:29:40.820 --> 0:29:41.420
<v Speaker 8>because I've then got.

0:29:41.380 --> 0:29:42.440
<v Speaker 1>To buy a new TV.

0:29:43.520 --> 0:29:46.740
<v Speaker 8>But I do get upset when I hear this focus

0:29:46.830 --> 0:29:50.770
<v Speaker 8>constantly on how we divide the pie up rather than

0:29:50.990 --> 0:29:53.450
<v Speaker 8>growing the pie. You know, Hawke and Keating, and I'll

0:29:53.470 --> 0:29:54.890
<v Speaker 8>just go back. This was at the start of my...

0:29:55.010 --> 0:29:57.270
<v Speaker 8>They got it right because they said, yeah, we've got

0:29:57.290 --> 0:29:59.739
<v Speaker 8>to have a good social safety net. And people who

0:29:59.880 --> 0:30:03.190
<v Speaker 8>really need welfare, they should get it. We should help it.

0:30:03.240 --> 0:30:05.920
<v Speaker 8>That's the Australian way. But we also got to grow

0:30:05.960 --> 0:30:08.550
<v Speaker 8>the pie. Now I don't think there's enough focus on

0:30:08.590 --> 0:30:10.870
<v Speaker 8>growing the pie. There's just too much debate about how

0:30:10.910 --> 0:30:14.810
<v Speaker 8>to divide the pie up and associated with that. There's

0:30:14.830 --> 0:30:17.290
<v Speaker 8>too much debate about what sort of sugar hit can

0:30:17.330 --> 0:30:20.130
<v Speaker 8>we give the economy today? You know, what sort of

0:30:20.190 --> 0:30:21.430
<v Speaker 8>cost of living relief?

0:30:21.710 --> 0:30:22.730
<v Speaker 1>These things don't.

0:30:22.590 --> 0:30:24.210
<v Speaker 4>Solve the underlying problem.

0:30:24.430 --> 0:30:27.830
<v Speaker 8>We've got to focus more on growing the pie, make

0:30:27.890 --> 0:30:33.260
<v Speaker 8>it easier for business to employ people, invest more, do

0:30:33.340 --> 0:30:36.880
<v Speaker 8>so in Australia. And once you do that, that's how

0:30:36.900 --> 0:30:39.320
<v Speaker 8>we will grow the pie. And then, sure, you've got

0:30:39.360 --> 0:30:42.400
<v Speaker 8>more money to spend on helping fellow Australians.

0:30:42.640 --> 0:30:43.160
<v Speaker 10>Yeah, I'm with you.

0:30:43.240 --> 0:30:44.120
<v Speaker 1>Shane, lovely to talk to you.

0:30:44.120 --> 0:30:44.620
<v Speaker 10>All the best, mate.

0:30:45.330 --> 0:30:45.680
<v Speaker 1>Thanks, Paul.

0:30:45.720 --> 0:30:46.050
<v Speaker 4>Take care.

0:30:46.270 --> 0:30:48.930
<v Speaker 1>Shane Oliver there, the Chief Economist. Good bloke. With great

0:30:48.950 --> 0:30:51.210
<v Speaker 1>insight there from the AMP.

0:30:51.570 --> 0:30:54.170
<v Speaker 2>Now, the thing that always sends me a little bit crazy,

0:30:54.470 --> 0:30:56.110
<v Speaker 2>as you know, is every time the federal budget, and

0:30:56.130 --> 0:30:58.450
<v Speaker 2>this has gone on for like probably 30 years now,

0:30:58.970 --> 0:31:02.330
<v Speaker 2>is that stupid calculator that every single news website, every

0:31:02.370 --> 0:31:04.110
<v Speaker 2>single news website, right, from the ones you don't touch

0:31:04.130 --> 0:31:05.610
<v Speaker 2>to the ones that you go to every day, put

0:31:05.650 --> 0:31:06.550
<v Speaker 2>up that calculator.

0:31:06.610 --> 0:31:07.710
<v Speaker 1>What's in it for you?

0:31:07.910 --> 0:31:10.270
<v Speaker 2>It shouldn't be about that. But alas, that feeds into

0:31:10.310 --> 0:31:12.430
<v Speaker 2>our politics today. And again, it's part of our problem.

0:31:12.530 --> 0:31:13.190
<v Speaker 1>All right, quick break.

0:31:13.230 --> 0:31:15.760
<v Speaker 2>Let's get straight into debate this evening. We'll get to

0:31:15.800 --> 0:31:17.680
<v Speaker 2>a winner and loser of the week in a moment

0:31:17.700 --> 0:31:19.440
<v Speaker 2>or two's time. I want to talk about the new

0:31:19.500 --> 0:31:23.100
<v Speaker 2>Greens leader and a whole lot more. Thanks so much

0:31:23.120 --> 0:31:25.000
<v Speaker 2>for watching this Thursday night.

0:31:25.220 --> 0:31:25.640
<v Speaker 1>Go Knights!

0:31:30.430 --> 0:31:32.820
<v Speaker 2>Thank you so much for watching with the impossible job

0:31:32.860 --> 0:31:35.020
<v Speaker 2>of winners and losers this week, and I'm sure Jim

0:31:35.040 --> 0:31:37.100
<v Speaker 2>Chalmers will feature on either side of all of that

0:31:37.140 --> 0:31:37.960
<v Speaker 2>in a moment or two's time.

0:31:37.980 --> 0:31:39.460
<v Speaker 1>It's, of course, Michael Kroger, the former.

0:31:39.560 --> 0:31:42.780
<v Speaker 2>Liberal Party president, but our friend, of course, in beautiful Melbourne,

0:31:43.180 --> 0:31:45.640
<v Speaker 2>where spring will eventually get there and then it'll disappear

0:31:45.680 --> 0:31:46.350
<v Speaker 2>in the same day.

0:31:46.660 --> 0:31:48.750
<v Speaker 1>Linda Scott is, of course, a former.

0:31:49.930 --> 0:31:53.030
<v Speaker 2>Lead advocate of local government, sat around the National Cabinet table,

0:31:53.090 --> 0:31:55.010
<v Speaker 2>and she's so much more. Labor to her bootstraps, but

0:31:55.050 --> 0:31:56.890
<v Speaker 2>she's free to say whatever she wants each and every

0:31:56.910 --> 0:32:00.670
<v Speaker 2>time we get here. So, Linda, tell me... When Jim

0:32:00.710 --> 0:32:03.880
<v Speaker 2>Chalmers said this, the first time interest rates went up

0:32:04.100 --> 0:32:06.840
<v Speaker 2>in this cycle, and that was one interest rate rise

0:32:07.020 --> 0:32:09.220
<v Speaker 2>under the Morrison government, he said this.

0:32:13.940 --> 0:32:17.300
<v Speaker 3>When times are tough, he takes none of the responsibility.

0:32:20.600 --> 0:32:23.540
<v Speaker 1>The eighth time under his watch, he said this.

0:32:24.520 --> 0:32:28.400
<v Speaker 3>Our inflation challenge is being turbocharged by a war on

0:32:28.440 --> 0:32:29.830
<v Speaker 3>the other side of the world.

0:32:30.910 --> 0:32:33.950
<v Speaker 1>Let's start nice and easy. Do you notice a slightly

0:32:34.020 --> 0:32:35.630
<v Speaker 1>different approach to these issues?

0:32:36.280 --> 0:32:38.850
<v Speaker 7>Well, look, Paul Murray, it would be lovely, wouldn't it,

0:32:38.880 --> 0:32:41.620
<v Speaker 7>to think that we could sort of summarise the economy

0:32:41.660 --> 0:32:43.720
<v Speaker 7>in two grabs, but I know you are a very

0:32:43.760 --> 0:32:46.100
<v Speaker 7>clever person and you can't do that. I think it

0:32:46.160 --> 0:32:49.910
<v Speaker 7>is the case that there are huge, uncertain economic times,

0:32:50.030 --> 0:32:51.930
<v Speaker 7>not just here in Australia, but right across the world.

0:32:51.990 --> 0:32:54.410
<v Speaker 7>And I don't think any economist would deny that. We

0:32:54.430 --> 0:32:57.610
<v Speaker 7>can debate about the relativities, and I'm sure Michael Kroger

0:32:57.630 --> 0:33:00.520
<v Speaker 7>will jump in about that. But the reality is that

0:33:01.120 --> 0:33:04.900
<v Speaker 7>interest rates do hurt Australians, especially those with mortgages. And

0:33:04.940 --> 0:33:08.220
<v Speaker 7>that is a really important thing to consider for governments

0:33:08.680 --> 0:33:10.400
<v Speaker 7>to consider what they're going to do about it. It's

0:33:10.480 --> 0:33:13.640
<v Speaker 7>why they've announced, you know, the implementation today of things

0:33:13.680 --> 0:33:19.060
<v Speaker 7>like removing those sneaky credit card searches estimated... Well, estimated

0:33:19.120 --> 0:33:24.610
<v Speaker 7>to cost..... to give back, you know, $ 1. 6 billion to Australians.

0:33:24.930 --> 0:33:27.229
<v Speaker 7>These kinds of things add up. They make a difference

0:33:27.270 --> 0:33:30.310
<v Speaker 7>to people's cost of living when cost of living pressures

0:33:30.490 --> 0:33:33.810
<v Speaker 7>are real. And as much as the Prime Minister is

0:33:33.950 --> 0:33:37.590
<v Speaker 7>going to the UN, trying to work with our ally

0:33:37.630 --> 0:33:40.970
<v Speaker 7>nations to... calm down the world, to create peace, not

0:33:41.010 --> 0:33:45.090
<v Speaker 7>to have this huge problem that's happening in the Middle

0:33:45.170 --> 0:33:48.230
<v Speaker 7>East that is impacting our economy and the cost of

0:33:48.270 --> 0:33:51.230
<v Speaker 7>living here in Australia. There's only so many levers Australia

0:33:51.280 --> 0:33:55.340
<v Speaker 7>can pull. So, you know, I don't have an argument

0:33:55.480 --> 0:34:01.040
<v Speaker 7>about the RBA's increases. They hurt people. That's absolutely important

0:34:01.080 --> 0:34:04.660
<v Speaker 7>to acknowledge. But the government's doing what they can in

0:34:04.840 --> 0:34:06.660
<v Speaker 7>a very difficult set of circumstances.

0:34:06.780 --> 0:34:08.739
<v Speaker 2>Michael, I want this to be a difficult question for

0:34:08.820 --> 0:34:12.160
<v Speaker 2>both of you, right? So if interest rates have gone

0:34:12.200 --> 0:34:16.900
<v Speaker 2>up 16 times, if inflation is now hitting at 4%,

0:34:16.900 --> 0:34:20.070
<v Speaker 2>if the number one brand value of the Liberal Party

0:34:20.200 --> 0:34:21.070
<v Speaker 2>is the economy.

0:34:22.050 --> 0:34:22.670
<v Speaker 1>When does it.

0:34:22.670 --> 0:34:25.690
<v Speaker 2>Start to kick in that people would prefer voting for

0:34:25.730 --> 0:34:28.680
<v Speaker 2>the Liberal Party over the Labor Party? Because the reality

0:34:28.900 --> 0:34:32.719
<v Speaker 2>is that time is now and they've got to lift

0:34:32.780 --> 0:34:35.480
<v Speaker 2>their vote and surely you would think, with Tim Wilson

0:34:35.540 --> 0:34:39.400
<v Speaker 2>as their main economic voice, that that vote will happen.

0:34:41.040 --> 0:34:44.589
<v Speaker 10>Yeah, that is exactly what is going to happen. And

0:34:44.830 --> 0:34:46.310
<v Speaker 10>you look at it... I start by looking at it

0:34:46.330 --> 0:34:49.780
<v Speaker 10>this way, mate. Our friend the late Graeme... Great Graham

0:34:49.820 --> 0:34:51.919
<v Speaker 10>Richardson used to have this saying, one of his many

0:34:51.960 --> 0:34:56.219
<v Speaker 10>great sayings, the mob will always work you out. That

0:34:56.239 --> 0:34:59.450
<v Speaker 10>was his great saying, Richo. And I think this week

0:34:59.530 --> 0:35:03.010
<v Speaker 10>the mob worked out Jim Chalmers. They'd already worked out Albo.

0:35:03.950 --> 0:35:07.350
<v Speaker 10>They've worked out now, Paul, that Jim Chalmers is nothing

0:35:07.390 --> 0:35:10.770
<v Speaker 10>more than Robert Redford out of The Candidate, an actor

0:35:10.810 --> 0:35:13.810
<v Speaker 10>playing a part, reading the script that's given to him

0:35:13.989 --> 0:35:15.890
<v Speaker 10>with no real understanding of what he's doing.

0:35:16.010 --> 0:35:16.469
<v Speaker 1>Great line.

0:35:16.930 --> 0:35:20.370
<v Speaker 10>And he's promised so much. for so long, and it's

0:35:20.430 --> 0:35:24.469
<v Speaker 10>all bulldust. It's all rubbish. It's all nonsense. We have

0:35:24.510 --> 0:35:28.799
<v Speaker 10>the second highest interest rates in the developed world. Inflation

0:35:28.840 --> 0:35:32.660
<v Speaker 10>is 40% above the Reserve Bank's middle band. We have

0:35:32.719 --> 0:35:38.279
<v Speaker 10>government revenues at very high level, almost record levels. The

0:35:38.320 --> 0:35:41.779
<v Speaker 10>same with government expenditure. We have record debt. We have

0:35:41.860 --> 0:35:44.330
<v Speaker 10>deficits going for the next 40 years. We have a

0:35:44.370 --> 0:35:48.830
<v Speaker 10>collapsing housing market, which if the AMP are right, 15%,

0:35:48.830 --> 0:35:55.529
<v Speaker 10>wipes out $ 1. 5 to $ 2 trillion from homeowners' value. This is...

0:35:55.770 --> 0:36:00.359
<v Speaker 10>And then we have surging energy prices. Social cohesion has

0:36:00.420 --> 0:36:04.520
<v Speaker 10>been smashed. I mean, at every level, this has been

0:36:04.560 --> 0:36:08.830
<v Speaker 10>a catastrophic government who borrowed... Won the election by... Buying

0:36:08.930 --> 0:36:12.049
<v Speaker 10>votes by spending money they had to borrow, i.e. student debt,

0:36:12.050 --> 0:36:13.969
<v Speaker 10>$ 16 billion, which they borrowed.

0:36:14.090 --> 0:36:14.530
<v Speaker 1>Correct.

0:36:14.590 --> 0:36:17.200
<v Speaker 10>I mean, look, it goes on and on and on, Paul.

0:36:17.420 --> 0:36:21.080
<v Speaker 10>And the mob have worked these people out. They'll start

0:36:21.120 --> 0:36:23.820
<v Speaker 10>going back to Angus Taylor and Tim Wilson, Jane Hume,

0:36:24.300 --> 0:36:26.590
<v Speaker 10>James Patterson. It's a very solid, good team there at

0:36:26.620 --> 0:36:29.450
<v Speaker 10>the top. The Liberal vote will start increasing as people

0:36:29.489 --> 0:36:32.010
<v Speaker 10>realise this country is seriously broken.

0:36:32.489 --> 0:36:34.270
<v Speaker 2>Now, let's talk about something you both agree on, which

0:36:34.370 --> 0:36:37.070
<v Speaker 2>is that you can't stand the new Greens leader because

0:36:37.090 --> 0:36:39.840
<v Speaker 2>they're a Green, right? David Shoebridge, of course, he takes over.

0:36:39.860 --> 0:36:43.200
<v Speaker 2>Maureen Faruqi, who got four votes, including her own. So

0:36:43.420 --> 0:36:46.339
<v Speaker 2>three people in the entire Australian parliament agreed that she

0:36:46.360 --> 0:36:48.500
<v Speaker 2>should have been the Greens leader. Thankfully, that didn't end

0:36:48.560 --> 0:36:51.379
<v Speaker 2>up happening. But one line David Shoebridge got out there

0:36:51.440 --> 0:36:54.989
<v Speaker 2>in his first media appearance as leader was this about

0:36:55.030 --> 0:36:56.210
<v Speaker 2>changing Australian politics.

0:36:57.300 --> 0:36:59.739
<v Speaker 12>This is the moment for the Greens to fill the

0:36:59.780 --> 0:37:02.960
<v Speaker 12>vacuum that has been left by the Labor Party rushing

0:37:03.000 --> 0:37:06.460
<v Speaker 12>to the right. Labor has created the circumstances for One

0:37:06.520 --> 0:37:09.920
<v Speaker 12>Nation and Labor is not the answer. The Greens, the

0:37:09.960 --> 0:37:14.450
<v Speaker 12>progressive alternative, we're here to beat down One Nation and

0:37:14.469 --> 0:37:17.770
<v Speaker 12>we're here to replace Labor and return hope and faith

0:37:17.810 --> 0:37:18.410
<v Speaker 12>to politics.

0:37:19.370 --> 0:37:24.310
<v Speaker 2>Michael, new face, same party, same party that, of course,

0:37:24.550 --> 0:37:28.170
<v Speaker 2>couldn't be nastier about issues around the world, but let's

0:37:28.210 --> 0:37:31.970
<v Speaker 2>focus on their home game here. As a political operative,

0:37:32.010 --> 0:37:34.930
<v Speaker 2>do you think that somehow he's able to move to

0:37:34.950 --> 0:37:38.040
<v Speaker 2>the populist left like the Democrats are in the US?

0:37:39.700 --> 0:37:45.500
<v Speaker 10>I don't think so, because I think the angry, nasty, socialist,

0:37:45.660 --> 0:37:49.279
<v Speaker 10>anti-Semitic left in this country is about 15%. And a

0:37:49.320 --> 0:37:51.150
<v Speaker 10>lot of them vote for the Greens. They're on 12

0:37:51.150 --> 0:37:53.469
<v Speaker 10>or 13. I don't think there's many more extremists in

0:37:53.530 --> 0:37:56.969
<v Speaker 10>Australia that will swallow this. I mean, this guy... This

0:37:57.030 --> 0:37:59.590
<v Speaker 10>guy's in the angry extreme left. He was part of

0:37:59.630 --> 0:38:02.330
<v Speaker 10>the Lee Rhiannon faction in the New South Wales Greens,

0:38:02.390 --> 0:38:06.060
<v Speaker 10>so he's hard left. Don't you love it that he

0:38:06.100 --> 0:38:10.300
<v Speaker 10>beat the more extreme candidate in Farooqui and they couldn't

0:38:10.340 --> 0:38:13.080
<v Speaker 10>vote for Hanson Young, who I've always thought was very extreme,

0:38:13.280 --> 0:38:16.989
<v Speaker 10>because she was too moderate. So you've got the extreme,

0:38:17.010 --> 0:38:19.730
<v Speaker 10>the extreme, extreme, and to the left of that. The

0:38:19.790 --> 0:38:21.549
<v Speaker 10>best thing that came out of that press conference, and

0:38:21.590 --> 0:38:23.130
<v Speaker 10>no-one picked it up, mate, and it's a good thing

0:38:23.150 --> 0:38:26.089
<v Speaker 10>they're not running the economy... That guy, McKim, released all

0:38:26.110 --> 0:38:28.350
<v Speaker 10>the votes for the first time ever. Good on them. Transparency.

0:38:28.390 --> 0:38:29.950
<v Speaker 10>But when he read out the votes for deputy, he

0:38:30.010 --> 0:38:33.440
<v Speaker 10>said the one that went up from Victoria got six

0:38:34.060 --> 0:38:35.900
<v Speaker 10>and the second one got three and the third one

0:38:35.920 --> 0:38:36.480
<v Speaker 10>got two.

0:38:36.940 --> 0:38:37.200
<v Speaker 6>Right.

0:38:37.239 --> 0:38:37.520
<v Speaker 2>Eleven.

0:38:37.739 --> 0:38:40.219
<v Speaker 10>Six, three and two. And then he said they distributed

0:38:40.260 --> 0:38:40.940
<v Speaker 10>the preferences.

0:38:44.640 --> 0:38:45.140
<v Speaker 1>Wonderful.

0:38:45.239 --> 0:38:49.340
<v Speaker 10>They distributed the two preferences. Mr McKim, if you're on six,

0:38:49.800 --> 0:38:52.520
<v Speaker 10>you don't need to, out of 11, my friend, you

0:38:52.560 --> 0:38:55.610
<v Speaker 10>don't need to distribute the preferences.

0:38:55.670 --> 0:38:56.509
<v Speaker 1>I do love the favourite thing.

0:38:56.530 --> 0:38:58.410
<v Speaker 2>I couldn't believe when people said, oh, Sarah Hansen-Young should

0:38:58.430 --> 0:39:00.029
<v Speaker 2>be the better option of the two.

0:39:00.070 --> 0:39:00.550
<v Speaker 1>Seriously?

0:39:00.830 --> 0:39:03.830
<v Speaker 2>And obviously, Pat Malone, right, in terms of people who

0:39:03.850 --> 0:39:05.820
<v Speaker 2>have been around her for long enough inside the room.

0:39:06.320 --> 0:39:09.320
<v Speaker 2>Do you worry at all, Linda, that a new version

0:39:09.340 --> 0:39:12.160
<v Speaker 2>of the Greens can somehow... pick up some of the

0:39:12.200 --> 0:39:15.020
<v Speaker 2>energy that's existing, say, in the US. They can go

0:39:15.040 --> 0:39:18.420
<v Speaker 2>to the populist left, obviously. You're always worried about any competitor.

0:39:18.680 --> 0:39:20.580
<v Speaker 2>But do you see anything in that bloke that worries you?

0:39:21.410 --> 0:39:23.830
<v Speaker 7>Look, I think David Shoebridge has just told the truth,

0:39:23.910 --> 0:39:26.590
<v Speaker 7>that the Greens are out to attack Labor. I mean,

0:39:26.730 --> 0:39:28.230
<v Speaker 7>I think they always have been, but I think he's

0:39:28.270 --> 0:39:29.930
<v Speaker 7>just come out and said it at his opening speech.

0:39:30.160 --> 0:39:32.460
<v Speaker 7>press conference. And, you know, we all know what the

0:39:32.480 --> 0:39:36.620
<v Speaker 7>Greens are about is protest, not progress. The Greens have

0:39:36.700 --> 0:39:41.549
<v Speaker 7>always stood for shouting loudly outside of Parliament, but then

0:39:41.590 --> 0:39:44.510
<v Speaker 7>going back into Parliament and here in New South Wales,

0:39:44.530 --> 0:39:47.169
<v Speaker 7>you know, teaming up with the Liberal Party to knock

0:39:47.230 --> 0:39:51.509
<v Speaker 7>off workers' compensation reforms. in the federal parliament, knocking off

0:39:51.570 --> 0:39:54.950
<v Speaker 7>environmental reforms of the former Labor government and housing reforms

0:39:54.989 --> 0:39:57.860
<v Speaker 7>of the former Labor government. So, you know, we know

0:39:57.880 --> 0:40:01.299
<v Speaker 7>the Greens to be all about protest, not progress. But

0:40:01.980 --> 0:40:04.460
<v Speaker 7>this is just, I think, a new leader putting that

0:40:04.540 --> 0:40:08.299
<v Speaker 7>up transparently in lights and saying his number one job,

0:40:08.360 --> 0:40:12.089
<v Speaker 7>instead of attacking the far right, instead of calling out,

0:40:12.150 --> 0:40:15.170
<v Speaker 7>you know, the anti-worker policies of One Nation, is to

0:40:15.210 --> 0:40:18.290
<v Speaker 7>attack the only party in Australia fighting for workers, the

0:40:18.310 --> 0:40:21.830
<v Speaker 7>Labor Party. So, I mean, you know, to give him credit,

0:40:21.890 --> 0:40:25.750
<v Speaker 7>as Michael says, he's been transparent about his objective. I

0:40:25.790 --> 0:40:27.569
<v Speaker 7>don't think that's good for the nation. I think people

0:40:27.590 --> 0:40:28.140
<v Speaker 7>will see that.

0:40:28.390 --> 0:40:30.489
<v Speaker 2>I'm about to celebrate the Denny Ute Master, so I

0:40:30.530 --> 0:40:32.339
<v Speaker 2>need this to be as fast as possible. Your winner

0:40:32.400 --> 0:40:34.120
<v Speaker 2>or loser of the week, Linda, who.

0:40:34.020 --> 0:40:34.600
<v Speaker 1>Stood out for you?

0:40:34.860 --> 0:40:37.239
<v Speaker 7>Well, I mean, I love the Denny Ute master, so

0:40:37.260 --> 0:40:39.759
<v Speaker 7>don't get me wrong about that. But I do want

0:40:39.780 --> 0:40:42.160
<v Speaker 7>to say a big shout-out, and he won't be watching,

0:40:42.200 --> 0:40:45.060
<v Speaker 7>to my friend Raj. He's a beautiful little boy in Queensland.

0:40:45.360 --> 0:40:47.620
<v Speaker 7>He was camping all week during the school holidays and

0:40:47.640 --> 0:40:49.980
<v Speaker 7>he came home and he insisted on watching the Prime

0:40:50.000 --> 0:40:52.799
<v Speaker 7>Minister's speech at the UN because he missed it while

0:40:52.840 --> 0:40:55.140
<v Speaker 7>he was away camping. I sent a photo to the

0:40:55.180 --> 0:40:57.509
<v Speaker 7>Prime Minister who wrote back and just said, beautiful. So

0:40:57.890 --> 0:41:00.630
<v Speaker 7>no matter your politics, how gorgeous is it that our

0:41:00.690 --> 0:41:04.230
<v Speaker 7>little primary schoolers are so into world affairs and and

0:41:04.390 --> 0:41:06.529
<v Speaker 7>what's going on in our country that they come home

0:41:06.550 --> 0:41:07.570
<v Speaker 7>and they want to watch the news.

0:41:07.790 --> 0:41:10.810
<v Speaker 1>Michael, give me it in 10.

0:41:10.860 --> 0:41:12.900
<v Speaker 10>The Israelis on the plane last night are the winners,

0:41:13.260 --> 0:41:16.440
<v Speaker 10>and anyone that owns a property or a home in Australia,

0:41:16.620 --> 0:41:17.600
<v Speaker 10>we've had a shocking week.

0:41:17.960 --> 0:41:19.960
<v Speaker 1>Love you both. Thank you very much. Have a great weekend.

0:41:19.980 --> 0:41:22.759
<v Speaker 2>Hopefully it's a long one where you are around the country. So,

0:41:22.780 --> 0:41:25.250
<v Speaker 2>the Denny Ute Master. I've never been, but what's it like?

0:41:25.290 --> 0:41:27.670
<v Speaker 2>In fact, it is on as we speak. What a

0:41:27.690 --> 0:41:29.049
<v Speaker 2>weekend in Deniliquin.

0:41:29.430 --> 0:41:29.669
<v Speaker 13>Next.

0:41:34.180 --> 0:41:35.100
<v Speaker 1>Thanks so much for watching.

0:41:35.140 --> 0:41:37.319
<v Speaker 2>With our town, thanks to the good people of Harvey Norman,

0:41:37.340 --> 0:41:38.700
<v Speaker 2>I've been able to go all over the country and

0:41:38.739 --> 0:41:41.090
<v Speaker 2>see incredible things, which means I've been to lots of

0:41:41.200 --> 0:41:43.830
<v Speaker 2>iconic Australian events. There are two I desperately want to

0:41:43.870 --> 0:41:47.850
<v Speaker 2>get to. One is the rodeo in Mount Isa. The

0:41:47.910 --> 0:41:51.570
<v Speaker 2>second is happening this weekend in Deniliquin in New South Wales,

0:41:51.610 --> 0:41:54.580
<v Speaker 2>and it is the Denny Ute Muster. Vicky Lowry joins

0:41:54.620 --> 0:41:56.819
<v Speaker 2>us now. She's the general manager of the Muster, which

0:41:56.860 --> 0:41:59.419
<v Speaker 2>gets underway tomorrow. An awful lot of people are about

0:41:59.440 --> 0:42:01.480
<v Speaker 2>to roll into town, probably half already have.

0:42:01.500 --> 0:42:02.359
<v Speaker 1>How are you feeling, mate?

0:42:03.140 --> 0:42:05.239
<v Speaker 9>Oh, good, thanks. You're not wrong. More than half have

0:42:05.300 --> 0:42:06.080
<v Speaker 9>already arrived.

0:42:07.340 --> 0:42:09.520
<v Speaker 1>So give me an idea about what is involved in

0:42:09.540 --> 0:42:10.600
<v Speaker 1>the Denny Ute Master.

0:42:10.660 --> 0:42:13.020
<v Speaker 2>Let's talk about the cars that are going to turn

0:42:13.100 --> 0:42:15.140
<v Speaker 2>up first and then we'll get into the music and

0:42:15.160 --> 0:42:16.279
<v Speaker 2>the fun people are going to have.

0:42:16.300 --> 0:42:19.910
<v Speaker 13>Yeah, so the cars, it has changed over the years

0:42:19.969 --> 0:42:22.770
<v Speaker 13>to be more family orientated, but the Utes you'll see,

0:42:23.310 --> 0:42:27.190
<v Speaker 13>you know, all different mates and models within the camp

0:42:27.290 --> 0:42:31.859
<v Speaker 13>areas and then tomorrow the competition starts, circle work. We

0:42:31.900 --> 0:42:36.240
<v Speaker 13>have a whole sports arena of youth competition, show and shine,

0:42:36.260 --> 0:42:38.200
<v Speaker 13>and it just goes on.

0:42:38.960 --> 0:42:40.700
<v Speaker 2>I love the idea that you can get around and

0:42:40.719 --> 0:42:42.279
<v Speaker 2>have a look at these beautiful things. But as you

0:42:42.320 --> 0:42:44.359
<v Speaker 2>just said, there's some circle work about to be done.

0:42:44.380 --> 0:42:47.080
<v Speaker 2>It'd be a little bit like summer nats where people

0:42:47.120 --> 0:42:49.299
<v Speaker 2>line up to see that because there's nothing better than

0:42:49.360 --> 0:42:52.360
<v Speaker 2>seeing a beautiful, powerful car making a lot of noise

0:42:52.420 --> 0:42:53.600
<v Speaker 2>and creating a lot of dust.

0:42:54.280 --> 0:42:55.120
<v Speaker 9>That's correct.

0:42:55.400 --> 0:42:57.439
<v Speaker 13>And the entrants of the show and shine are very

0:42:57.500 --> 0:43:01.299
<v Speaker 13>passionate about their vehicles and about their competition.

0:43:01.960 --> 0:43:03.719
<v Speaker 2>All right, music has become a big part of it

0:43:03.780 --> 0:43:05.890
<v Speaker 2>as well. Give me an idea about what the bill

0:43:05.930 --> 0:43:07.230
<v Speaker 2>is like for people to.

0:43:07.190 --> 0:43:09.290
<v Speaker 1>Be able to be entertained. Is that mostly at night

0:43:09.310 --> 0:43:11.709
<v Speaker 1>or that's all day too? No, no, our.

0:43:11.650 --> 0:43:14.330
<v Speaker 13>Music starts at 8am in the morning with our day

0:43:14.350 --> 0:43:17.550
<v Speaker 13>stage where we support up and coming artists and local

0:43:17.660 --> 0:43:21.400
<v Speaker 13>artists and that finishes around 4 o'clock and then our

0:43:21.440 --> 0:43:25.779
<v Speaker 13>main stage starts at 4.30 right through to midnight. We've

0:43:25.820 --> 0:43:30.640
<v Speaker 13>got Tyler Braden from the US, great country artist, Yes, yes,

0:43:30.700 --> 0:43:34.680
<v Speaker 13>he's an amazing artist. Then we also have Turns An

0:43:34.700 --> 0:43:39.860
<v Speaker 13>Eye on Saturday night. Furnison The Fundamentals will be closing

0:43:39.940 --> 0:43:43.640
<v Speaker 13>on Saturday night with Fireworks on their last song.

0:43:43.700 --> 0:43:47.029
<v Speaker 9>They're a real popular band now here at the Muster.

0:43:48.050 --> 0:43:51.990
<v Speaker 9>Troy Cassidaly, Emos. We have Lee Kern again.

0:43:56.650 --> 0:44:00.640
<v Speaker 13>Shepherd, we've got artists of all different genres that cover

0:44:00.800 --> 0:44:01.680
<v Speaker 13>every age.

0:44:03.980 --> 0:44:06.020
<v Speaker 2>Now, as you say, it is a lot more family

0:44:06.080 --> 0:44:07.900
<v Speaker 2>friendly than it has been in the past. This is

0:44:07.940 --> 0:44:10.160
<v Speaker 2>an event, obviously, not just for people who love their cars,

0:44:10.380 --> 0:44:11.940
<v Speaker 2>but it's not wild like some of that. So I

0:44:11.960 --> 0:44:15.279
<v Speaker 2>shouldn't have made that comparison before. But the idea of

0:44:15.320 --> 0:44:16.800
<v Speaker 2>a little bit of dust, you know what I'm talking

0:44:16.820 --> 0:44:19.320
<v Speaker 2>about here? The people hitting me is drawn to it.

0:44:19.800 --> 0:44:22.500
<v Speaker 2>Do you have some crazy numbers from the past few years?

0:44:22.520 --> 0:44:25.640
<v Speaker 2>Like how much food do you sell? How much drinks

0:44:25.700 --> 0:44:28.720
<v Speaker 2>do you serve? I mean, when you've got, what, 22,000

0:44:28.719 --> 0:44:31.600
<v Speaker 2>people descending on the town? Yes, some locals, but it's

0:44:31.640 --> 0:44:35.009
<v Speaker 2>mostly people from out of town. What sort of stuff

0:44:35.030 --> 0:44:36.740
<v Speaker 2>do they eat and drink and how much of it?

0:44:37.750 --> 0:44:40.910
<v Speaker 9>They drink a lot of bungee and also a lot

0:44:40.930 --> 0:44:41.330
<v Speaker 9>of beer.

0:44:42.140 --> 0:44:46.520
<v Speaker 13>Yes, we have 30 food trade sites where they can,

0:44:46.719 --> 0:44:53.020
<v Speaker 13>of all different food, we cater for everyone. And then

0:44:53.160 --> 0:44:56.620
<v Speaker 13>we have five bars, so we cater for everyone there

0:44:56.680 --> 0:44:59.460
<v Speaker 13>as well. And then also, like you said, the families

0:44:59.540 --> 0:45:05.160
<v Speaker 13>are also catered for. within the festival arena. We're now 70%

0:45:05.160 --> 0:45:09.300
<v Speaker 13>families from when we started and it was all about.

0:45:09.330 --> 0:45:10.689
<v Speaker 9>The youths and young ones.

0:45:10.730 --> 0:45:13.210
<v Speaker 13>Those young ones are now coming and they're in the

0:45:13.250 --> 0:45:13.930
<v Speaker 13>family area.

0:45:15.370 --> 0:45:17.830
<v Speaker 2>Which is awesome because, again, if you've got fond memories

0:45:17.890 --> 0:45:19.529
<v Speaker 2>of something you did with your parents, there's a good

0:45:19.550 --> 0:45:21.230
<v Speaker 2>chance you're going to go back and do it when

0:45:21.610 --> 0:45:24.430
<v Speaker 2>you're on your Pat Malone, but then obviously you'll come

0:45:24.469 --> 0:45:27.109
<v Speaker 2>back with your kids as well. So making it what

0:45:27.160 --> 0:45:30.560
<v Speaker 2>it is right now is a sort of multi-generational connection

0:45:30.620 --> 0:45:31.220
<v Speaker 2>to the event.

0:45:31.820 --> 0:45:32.900
<v Speaker 9>Yeah.

0:45:33.040 --> 0:45:36.420
<v Speaker 13>We have over 30 music artists over the two days

0:45:37.219 --> 0:45:40.730
<v Speaker 13>and then also part of the ticket price are 40

0:45:40.730 --> 0:45:47.029
<v Speaker 13>around-the-ground activations. whether that's rock climbing wall, we've got an

0:45:47.150 --> 0:45:52.860
<v Speaker 13>animal farm, slot cars can assist. One of our local

0:45:52.890 --> 0:45:56.880
<v Speaker 13>charities are doing yabby races to raise money. Even tonight,

0:45:57.180 --> 0:46:00.360
<v Speaker 13>we open our gates now 24 hours prior to the

0:46:00.440 --> 0:46:03.759
<v Speaker 13>event and get up to 15,000 people come in a

0:46:03.800 --> 0:46:04.940
<v Speaker 13>day early to camp.

0:46:05.460 --> 0:46:09.560
<v Speaker 9>This year, for the first time, we've got a, a.

0:46:09.100 --> 0:46:12.820
<v Speaker 13>1,500-seated marquee, and we're putting on a ticketed tribute show,

0:46:12.900 --> 0:46:16.200
<v Speaker 13>and then a portion of every ticket goes to our

0:46:16.219 --> 0:46:20.520
<v Speaker 13>local PNC as one of our local charities. So that's

0:46:20.640 --> 0:46:24.300
<v Speaker 13>the first issue. We're always looking at ways to change

0:46:24.360 --> 0:46:28.799
<v Speaker 13>and improve the event and add to it so we

0:46:28.820 --> 0:46:29.720
<v Speaker 13>don't become stale.

0:46:29.800 --> 0:46:32.340
<v Speaker 9>But we look at our demographics.

0:46:32.800 --> 0:46:35.700
<v Speaker 13>And still, you know, the youths are the heart and

0:46:35.760 --> 0:46:39.030
<v Speaker 13>soul of the event. And that's still a big part

0:46:39.070 --> 0:46:42.810
<v Speaker 13>of the event. We haven't lost any focus on that,

0:46:43.270 --> 0:46:47.070
<v Speaker 13>as is our bull ride and whip cracking and wood chop.

0:46:47.450 --> 0:46:49.620
<v Speaker 9>They're our staples.

0:46:49.719 --> 0:46:52.060
<v Speaker 13>And then, you know, all the rest that we add

0:46:52.080 --> 0:46:56.160
<v Speaker 13>each year. Last year we had a full Wiggles stage show.

0:46:56.219 --> 0:46:56.540
<v Speaker 14>Yeah.

0:46:59.070 --> 0:47:01.509
<v Speaker 1>I love it. All right, well, it's full-on Australia. I

0:47:01.570 --> 0:47:01.930
<v Speaker 1>love it.

0:47:02.450 --> 0:47:05.850
<v Speaker 2>Look, of course, Tamworth's got country music. Parks has got Elvis. Well,

0:47:06.330 --> 0:47:09.870
<v Speaker 2>Deniliquin has its Ute Master. It's on this weekend. Seriously,

0:47:09.910 --> 0:47:12.230
<v Speaker 2>if you ever get the chance to go, I cannot

0:47:12.270 --> 0:47:13.640
<v Speaker 2>wait to get there one day myself.

0:47:14.260 --> 0:47:15.400
<v Speaker 1>Have a wonderful time, Vicky.

0:47:15.480 --> 0:47:17.359
<v Speaker 2>I know you're really busy tonight, but thanks for giving

0:47:17.400 --> 0:47:19.540
<v Speaker 2>us a couple of minutes to talk about, well, the

0:47:19.580 --> 0:47:20.339
<v Speaker 2>highlight of the year.

0:47:20.360 --> 0:47:21.860
<v Speaker 8>Pleasure.

0:47:21.940 --> 0:47:25.319
<v Speaker 13>It is the highlight of the year, and it's so

0:47:25.380 --> 0:47:29.049
<v Speaker 13>great to see so many people come together and and

0:47:29.170 --> 0:47:30.799
<v Speaker 13>catch up and make friends.

0:47:31.880 --> 0:47:32.620
<v Speaker 1>Good on you, Vicky.

0:47:32.760 --> 0:47:34.859
<v Speaker 2>Well done to everyone in Deniliquin. If you can't get there,

0:47:34.940 --> 0:47:38.450
<v Speaker 2>follow the Denny Ute Master on socials. You'll get lots

0:47:38.489 --> 0:47:40.709
<v Speaker 2>of photos, lots of FOMO, and hopefully make a plan

0:47:40.750 --> 0:47:44.470
<v Speaker 2>to go see them. The idiocy of politicians on social media.

0:47:44.650 --> 0:47:52.660
<v Speaker 2>That's how we'll end our week next. Everyone works too hard,

0:47:52.700 --> 0:47:55.260
<v Speaker 2>everyone pays too much tax, and where does it all go? Well,

0:47:55.300 --> 0:47:59.510
<v Speaker 2>the politicians and the staffers who make terrible social media videos.

0:47:59.870 --> 0:48:02.290
<v Speaker 2>We do this because, A, we like to laugh at them,

0:48:02.390 --> 0:48:05.710
<v Speaker 2>but B, a reminder about how patronising they can be,

0:48:05.750 --> 0:48:07.890
<v Speaker 2>including the Labor MP for Barton.

0:48:23.130 --> 0:48:27.470
<v Speaker 1>The coffee isn't cheaper. The coffee will cost more because

0:48:27.510 --> 0:48:31.310
<v Speaker 1>the surcharge still needs to be paid because the small

0:48:31.350 --> 0:48:33.739
<v Speaker 1>business still needs to access the bank. But who cares?

0:48:33.780 --> 0:48:36.800
<v Speaker 2>Social media, social media, right? What about the Labor MP

0:48:36.820 --> 0:48:49.680
<v Speaker 2>for Swan? And the brand-new leader of the Greens bringing

0:48:49.739 --> 0:48:51.580
<v Speaker 2>a new tone to Australian politics.

0:48:52.660 --> 0:48:55.540
<v Speaker 14>I was after a meme that had Darth Vader, Anthony

0:48:55.600 --> 0:48:58.340
<v Speaker 14>Albanese and Benjamin Netanyahu all together saying, what do they

0:48:58.360 --> 0:49:00.700
<v Speaker 14>have in common? They all love Palantir. But I was

0:49:00.719 --> 0:49:04.459
<v Speaker 14>told that was too abstract. And then I thought maybe

0:49:04.480 --> 0:49:09.290
<v Speaker 14>the eye of Sauron looking over the ALP logo saying

0:49:09.410 --> 0:49:14.110
<v Speaker 14>both love Palantir. That was too abstract apparently as well.

0:49:15.310 --> 0:49:16.990
<v Speaker 1>So what did you do? What did you show?

0:49:17.010 --> 0:49:20.200
<v Speaker 2>Anyway, that is our show for tonight and for the week.

0:49:20.219 --> 0:49:22.280
<v Speaker 2>Thank you very much for watching. Remember, all the highlights

0:49:22.320 --> 0:49:24.820
<v Speaker 2>are available at news24.

0:49:22.860 --> 0:49:26.819
<v Speaker 1>Com. au. Yes, of course, I'm on the bandwagon. I would

0:49:26.860 --> 0:49:28.200
<v Speaker 1>love to see the Newcastle Knights

0:49:28.580 --> 0:49:32.080
<v Speaker 2>Win in Rugby League, go Yankees as we start to

0:49:32.120 --> 0:49:36.669
<v Speaker 2>move towards post-season, go Jets in the NFL, and of course,

0:49:37.230 --> 0:49:37.910
<v Speaker 2>happy birthday, Chunk.