WEBVTT - Paul Murray Live | 19 October

0:00:02.220 --> 0:00:07.640
<v Speaker 1>This is Paul Murray Live. Thank you, Shari. Good evening, everyone.

0:00:07.660 --> 0:00:10.070
<v Speaker 1>What a terrible couple of hours it has been as

0:00:10.130 --> 0:00:12.890
<v Speaker 1>we have been dealing with the enormity of a new

0:00:13.030 --> 0:00:16.810
<v Speaker 1>low in Australia. Now, we know that for too long

0:00:16.850 --> 0:00:20.950
<v Speaker 1>there have been many threats... against politicians. Well, now, tonight,

0:00:21.010 --> 0:00:25.060
<v Speaker 1>we are dealing with what police are investigating as a

0:00:25.120 --> 0:00:29.180
<v Speaker 1>possible targeted attack on a member of parliament. Helen Haynes,

0:00:29.200 --> 0:00:31.580
<v Speaker 1>you know the story by now, but if you happen

0:00:31.600 --> 0:00:33.320
<v Speaker 1>to be floating by the television and this is your

0:00:33.340 --> 0:00:34.739
<v Speaker 1>first chance to have a look, let me tell you

0:00:34.760 --> 0:00:38.740
<v Speaker 1>the story thus far. Helen Haynes is the independent member

0:00:38.840 --> 0:00:41.700
<v Speaker 1>for Indi. This is her electorate office via Google Maps

0:00:41.780 --> 0:00:46.000
<v Speaker 1>in Wangaratta. Now, there was an incident that took place

0:00:46.020 --> 0:00:50.720
<v Speaker 1>at about 3.30 this afternoon in when allegedly, apparently, we've

0:00:50.740 --> 0:00:53.480
<v Speaker 1>got to be careful here because somebody is with police

0:00:53.540 --> 0:00:57.380
<v Speaker 1>right now, but a charge has not been made public,

0:00:58.840 --> 0:01:04.000
<v Speaker 1>when apparently a car made a direct line for the

0:01:04.030 --> 0:01:08.789
<v Speaker 1>member for Indi. Her injuries are considered to be serious.

0:01:09.560 --> 0:01:11.199
<v Speaker 1>As you can see to the left of that image,

0:01:11.240 --> 0:01:13.619
<v Speaker 1>which is from Google Images, and that, of course, is

0:01:13.670 --> 0:01:15.930
<v Speaker 1>a photo not taken today, so we're not talking about

0:01:15.970 --> 0:01:18.010
<v Speaker 1>any of the cars that you can see there, but

0:01:18.030 --> 0:01:21.470
<v Speaker 1>that is a photo of her office on the main

0:01:21.490 --> 0:01:25.810
<v Speaker 1>drag there in Wangaratta. To the left of it is

0:01:26.150 --> 0:01:32.170
<v Speaker 1>a barbershop. Local news reporting suggested that after Ms Haynes

0:01:32.250 --> 0:01:35.890
<v Speaker 1>had been hit by the car, people from that barbershop

0:01:36.069 --> 0:01:41.110
<v Speaker 1>and others were critical in being able to restrain the

0:01:41.150 --> 0:01:45.590
<v Speaker 1>person who is currently speaking to police. There has been

0:01:45.709 --> 0:01:50.010
<v Speaker 1>quite the police operation for obvious reasons. Remember, of course, Wangaratta,

0:01:50.110 --> 0:01:53.290
<v Speaker 1>a beautiful regional city, but again, a country town, where

0:01:53.330 --> 0:01:55.420
<v Speaker 1>things like this are not supposed to happen in a

0:01:55.560 --> 0:01:57.580
<v Speaker 1>state of Victoria, where these things are not supposed to

0:01:57.600 --> 0:01:59.980
<v Speaker 1>happen in a country like Australia, where these things are

0:02:00.340 --> 0:02:03.500
<v Speaker 1>not supposed to happen but happen. They have and they did.

0:02:03.980 --> 0:02:07.120
<v Speaker 1>This witness's name is Chris and he called in to

0:02:07.160 --> 0:02:11.850
<v Speaker 1>Radio 3AW in Melbourne within the first hour of what

0:02:11.889 --> 0:02:15.030
<v Speaker 1>has taken place here, a scenario where we are talking

0:02:15.070 --> 0:02:19.510
<v Speaker 1>about critical injuries. Of course, nothing but strength and love

0:02:19.950 --> 0:02:23.399
<v Speaker 1>to her family. for her to be able to pull

0:02:23.440 --> 0:02:27.079
<v Speaker 1>through here, but we're dealing with something massive, massive here tonight.

0:02:27.520 --> 0:02:29.899
<v Speaker 1>Here was the witness, Chris, on 3RW, talking to Jackie

0:02:29.980 --> 0:02:30.980
<v Speaker 1>Felgate on drive.

0:02:31.000 --> 0:02:33.799
<v Speaker 2>About an hour or so ago, an hour and a

0:02:33.810 --> 0:02:38.530
<v Speaker 2>half ago, there was a strong police emergency services turnout

0:02:39.590 --> 0:02:42.609
<v Speaker 2>from South Wang heading towards North Wang. Incredible amount of

0:02:42.630 --> 0:02:49.380
<v Speaker 2>emergency services, police, fireys, the works. At the corner here,

0:02:49.419 --> 0:02:51.680
<v Speaker 2>Murphy Street is blocked off in Wang between Faithful Street.

0:02:52.590 --> 0:02:56.980
<v Speaker 2>and to reach streets completely blocked off. There appears to

0:02:57.000 --> 0:03:01.380
<v Speaker 2>be an incident has happened outside Helen Haynes' office. The

0:03:01.419 --> 0:03:04.740
<v Speaker 2>ambulances have now left. The police have set up cordon

0:03:04.800 --> 0:03:08.980
<v Speaker 2>tapes in about three stages outside that office. The road

0:03:09.020 --> 0:03:14.989
<v Speaker 2>is there completely blocked. Anyway, there appears to be a

0:03:15.110 --> 0:03:16.950
<v Speaker 2>lot of medical equipment on the ground.

0:03:17.980 --> 0:03:21.320
<v Speaker 1>Now, of course, this happened in and around 3.30. This

0:03:21.380 --> 0:03:24.650
<v Speaker 1>first became news late this afternoon. Peter Credlin with it

0:03:24.790 --> 0:03:27.950
<v Speaker 1>on air this evening. The information has been building over

0:03:27.970 --> 0:03:30.330
<v Speaker 1>the past couple of hours through Andrew Bolt's hour at

0:03:30.330 --> 0:03:33.350
<v Speaker 1>7 o'clock Australian Eastern Daylight Time into Shari in the

0:03:33.389 --> 0:03:36.750
<v Speaker 1>past hour and then us right here. Again, for those

0:03:36.790 --> 0:03:38.920
<v Speaker 1>that are passing by the television, the latest on all

0:03:38.940 --> 0:03:42.040
<v Speaker 1>of this is the police... have given a statement this evening,

0:03:42.060 --> 0:03:45.820
<v Speaker 1>they did so in Wangaratta, about exactly what happened. Remember,

0:03:46.020 --> 0:03:49.120
<v Speaker 1>limited information because they're still investigating it. A little later

0:03:49.140 --> 0:03:51.220
<v Speaker 1>in the show, we'll talk to a veteran of the

0:03:51.260 --> 0:03:53.720
<v Speaker 1>Victorian Police Force about what they'll be doing right now

0:03:53.760 --> 0:03:54.980
<v Speaker 1>to work out what the heck happened.

0:03:56.620 --> 0:04:00.590
<v Speaker 3>Where a 65-year-old female has been struck by a motor

0:04:00.620 --> 0:04:04.089
<v Speaker 3>vehicle that was travelling along Murphy Street, outside some offices

0:04:04.510 --> 0:04:06.230
<v Speaker 3>further up the street that you can see in the background.

0:04:07.190 --> 0:04:10.510
<v Speaker 3>That female has suffered what has been described as critical

0:04:10.550 --> 0:04:14.540
<v Speaker 3>injuries conveyed via road ambulance to North East Health Wangaratta

0:04:15.100 --> 0:04:18.880
<v Speaker 3>and likely to be airlifted to Melbourne for further medical treatment.

0:04:19.680 --> 0:04:22.940
<v Speaker 1>Now, that woman is Helen Haynes. She's an independent member

0:04:23.000 --> 0:04:26.000
<v Speaker 1>of the Federal Parliament. She has been elected, re-elected. I

0:04:26.040 --> 0:04:29.810
<v Speaker 1>think this is now her fourth term in the Parliament. She,

0:04:29.820 --> 0:04:33.690
<v Speaker 1>of course, replaced Kath McGowan. Let's be very clear here.

0:04:34.560 --> 0:04:38.200
<v Speaker 1>The police allegation, the Prime Minister's statement, which I'll get

0:04:38.240 --> 0:04:40.080
<v Speaker 1>to in a moment or two's time here, is that

0:04:40.100 --> 0:04:43.360
<v Speaker 1>a member of the Australian Parliament has been physically targeted.

0:04:44.620 --> 0:04:49.420
<v Speaker 1>Her injuries are considered to be critical. At some time

0:04:49.660 --> 0:04:51.460
<v Speaker 1>within the next hour, we will get more of an

0:04:51.520 --> 0:04:54.860
<v Speaker 1>update as to exactly her condition and exactly where she is.

0:04:54.900 --> 0:04:58.680
<v Speaker 1>There was an expectation of her being airlifted from Wangaratta

0:04:58.820 --> 0:05:03.250
<v Speaker 1>to Melbourne, where, of course, medical facilities are are even

0:05:03.410 --> 0:05:08.510
<v Speaker 1>more complicated, more specialists there. Again, I showed you that barbershop,

0:05:08.550 --> 0:05:11.029
<v Speaker 1>which was just to the left of the image of

0:05:11.070 --> 0:05:15.130
<v Speaker 1>Helen Haynes' office in Wangaratta, being a big regional place.

0:05:15.240 --> 0:05:17.020
<v Speaker 1>Of course, she's got a couple of offices around, but

0:05:17.080 --> 0:05:19.739
<v Speaker 1>as the locals call it, Wang, as you heard, there

0:05:19.920 --> 0:05:25.320
<v Speaker 1>on High Street. Apparently, the person who is currently talking

0:05:25.339 --> 0:05:28.980
<v Speaker 1>to police, helping police with their inquiries, arrested on the spot, 43-year-old,

0:05:29.300 --> 0:05:34.150
<v Speaker 1>restrained by people who came from that barbershop. This is

0:05:34.190 --> 0:05:36.230
<v Speaker 1>what police said about the person who they are currently

0:05:36.370 --> 0:05:39.250
<v Speaker 1>talking to. Again, no charges, but we'll all find out

0:05:39.290 --> 0:05:41.350
<v Speaker 1>together if this takes it to the next level.

0:05:42.490 --> 0:05:46.450
<v Speaker 3>A 43-year-old male driver of the vehicle involved in this

0:05:46.490 --> 0:05:51.550
<v Speaker 3>collision was detained by civilians, witnesses to the incident. and

0:05:51.589 --> 0:05:55.170
<v Speaker 3>then arrested by police upon their arrival. That male is

0:05:55.210 --> 0:05:57.730
<v Speaker 3>currently at the Wangaratta Police Station and will be interviewed

0:05:57.770 --> 0:06:01.300
<v Speaker 3>by investigators. We've got the Major Collision Investigation Unit, who

0:06:01.330 --> 0:06:03.539
<v Speaker 3>are currently en route from Melbourne. They are coming up

0:06:03.740 --> 0:06:05.880
<v Speaker 3>to assist with processing the crime scene.

0:06:06.160 --> 0:06:08.560
<v Speaker 4>Is the male a local resident?

0:06:08.600 --> 0:06:11.200
<v Speaker 3>The male that has been arrested is a 43-year-old male

0:06:11.220 --> 0:06:11.900
<v Speaker 3>from Tarrawindji.

0:06:12.560 --> 0:06:14.900
<v Speaker 5>Any reports that these two are known.

0:06:14.640 --> 0:06:15.460
<v Speaker 6>To each other?

0:06:15.779 --> 0:06:17.960
<v Speaker 3>Nothing to indicate at this stage that the parties are known,

0:06:17.980 --> 0:06:19.960
<v Speaker 3>but that will be subject to the investigations.

0:06:21.230 --> 0:06:23.190
<v Speaker 1>So, again, that's as much information as we have about

0:06:23.210 --> 0:06:26.469
<v Speaker 1>the person who police believe has at least the case

0:06:26.490 --> 0:06:29.450
<v Speaker 1>to answer before they can work out about responsibility here.

0:06:29.770 --> 0:06:31.710
<v Speaker 1>Hence all of the careful language. Of course, the difference

0:06:31.750 --> 0:06:34.270
<v Speaker 1>between the madness of the internet and going through these

0:06:34.330 --> 0:06:36.310
<v Speaker 1>moments in real time is that we will tell you

0:06:36.350 --> 0:06:38.250
<v Speaker 1>things as they are confirmed, not as they are to

0:06:38.310 --> 0:06:41.630
<v Speaker 1>be speculated. Now, this took a whole new level just

0:06:41.690 --> 0:06:45.890
<v Speaker 1>after 7pm local time when the Prime Minister spoke to

0:06:45.940 --> 0:06:49.779
<v Speaker 1>this because, again... The allegation here is that this is

0:06:49.839 --> 0:06:52.659
<v Speaker 1>not a random traffic accident. This is the targeting of

0:06:52.760 --> 0:06:56.660
<v Speaker 1>a federal politician, a new low for Australia.

0:06:57.980 --> 0:07:02.090
<v Speaker 7>Helen Haynes, the member for Indi, was attacked outside her

0:07:02.150 --> 0:07:06.450
<v Speaker 7>electorate office in Wangaratta. All of our thoughts are with Helen,

0:07:07.190 --> 0:07:12.130
<v Speaker 7>her family, her friends, her team and her community at

0:07:12.170 --> 0:07:17.800
<v Speaker 7>this extremely difficult time. We are praying for her full recovery.

0:07:18.940 --> 0:07:22.620
<v Speaker 7>I want to thank the first responders for their extraordinary work.

0:07:23.820 --> 0:07:28.200
<v Speaker 7>There is a major police investigation underway and I can

0:07:28.240 --> 0:07:33.010
<v Speaker 7>confirm that a suspect is in custody. The Australian Federal Police,

0:07:33.510 --> 0:07:38.170
<v Speaker 7>Victorian Police and ASIO are working together on this. The

0:07:38.210 --> 0:07:42.510
<v Speaker 7>Joint Counter Terrorism Team has been activated but the motive

0:07:42.710 --> 0:07:43.390
<v Speaker 7>is not known.

0:07:44.720 --> 0:07:46.940
<v Speaker 1>The Prime Minister then made his way to the studios

0:07:47.140 --> 0:07:50.190
<v Speaker 1>of the ABC and the 7.30 program, where again he

0:07:50.250 --> 0:07:54.790
<v Speaker 1>is further highlighted here that this is not a random act. Instead,

0:07:54.810 --> 0:07:58.890
<v Speaker 1>Helen Haynes, a federal politician, was targeted today.

0:07:59.890 --> 0:08:06.190
<v Speaker 7>This was a serious incident and her health issues are serious.

0:08:06.450 --> 0:08:14.470
<v Speaker 7>This wasn't an accident. There was a deliberate act, it

0:08:14.490 --> 0:08:19.470
<v Speaker 7>would appear. We don't know what motivation is. Now, of course,

0:08:19.490 --> 0:08:20.870
<v Speaker 7>we'll all find out by police.

0:08:21.410 --> 0:08:24.600
<v Speaker 1>Again, with the questioning process taking place right now, whether

0:08:24.620 --> 0:08:26.940
<v Speaker 1>we move to charges or not, we'll all find out together.

0:08:27.240 --> 0:08:29.000
<v Speaker 1>Just a little more about the 43-year-old man. The smaller.

0:08:32.330 --> 0:08:35.310
<v Speaker 1>Town that he is from, from Wangaratta, is only about, well,

0:08:35.330 --> 0:08:38.200
<v Speaker 1>it's less than a 15-minute drive, so he's very much

0:08:38.360 --> 0:08:41.040
<v Speaker 1>a local. Whether he's known to police or not, again,

0:08:41.080 --> 0:08:43.099
<v Speaker 1>we'll all find out together. Now, I know for a

0:08:43.120 --> 0:08:44.720
<v Speaker 1>lot of people that have been glued to their television

0:08:44.740 --> 0:08:47.520
<v Speaker 1>since you first heard about this, some of this information

0:08:47.540 --> 0:08:49.630
<v Speaker 1>is what you've heard before, but again, there are lots

0:08:49.670 --> 0:08:52.290
<v Speaker 1>of people right around the country, different times, different time zones,

0:08:52.750 --> 0:08:54.929
<v Speaker 1>that are hearing either this for the first time or

0:08:54.950 --> 0:08:56.890
<v Speaker 1>I'm trying to pull it all together for you in

0:08:57.130 --> 0:09:00.870
<v Speaker 1>one place. Now, I've talked on this program about the

0:09:00.910 --> 0:09:04.510
<v Speaker 1>many reports, the endless reports, the frightening reports about the

0:09:04.550 --> 0:09:09.720
<v Speaker 1>number of people who make violent threats against politicians. Now,

0:09:09.760 --> 0:09:11.780
<v Speaker 1>I couldn't be the hardest, I am the hardest marker

0:09:11.920 --> 0:09:13.660
<v Speaker 1>when it comes to the politicians that I don't like,

0:09:13.679 --> 0:09:17.620
<v Speaker 1>but the idea, the idea of anyone stepping towards violence,

0:09:17.679 --> 0:09:24.600
<v Speaker 1>it is totally, totally abhorrent, totally, totally unacceptable. Now, inevitably,

0:09:24.630 --> 0:09:26.720
<v Speaker 1>there will be plenty of people that will try to

0:09:26.860 --> 0:09:30.600
<v Speaker 1>get into motivation faster than we know what has actually

0:09:30.800 --> 0:09:34.540
<v Speaker 1>happened here. But again, you can have a passionate discourse.

0:09:34.559 --> 0:09:37.900
<v Speaker 1>You can even have a loud argument from time to time.

0:09:38.300 --> 0:09:40.060
<v Speaker 1>Helen Hayne's not known to be a person who is

0:09:40.520 --> 0:09:42.900
<v Speaker 1>either of those things apply to. Remember, she's been on

0:09:42.940 --> 0:09:44.699
<v Speaker 1>this show. We spoke to her just a couple of

0:09:44.720 --> 0:09:47.220
<v Speaker 1>weeks ago. That was when she was having a go

0:09:47.460 --> 0:09:52.179
<v Speaker 1>at the government about that slush fund. payment, the best

0:09:52.200 --> 0:09:55.910
<v Speaker 1>part of half a billion dollars, which is being spent

0:09:55.950 --> 0:09:58.730
<v Speaker 1>by the government, amongst other things, on the golf course, right? Yes,

0:09:58.770 --> 0:10:01.310
<v Speaker 1>she's of the left. Yes, she's of the centre-left. Yes,

0:10:01.490 --> 0:10:04.790
<v Speaker 1>she is closer to Teal than she is Liberal, National

0:10:04.890 --> 0:10:08.650
<v Speaker 1>or anyone else. But whether you agree or disagree with politicians,

0:10:08.700 --> 0:10:11.240
<v Speaker 1>this stuff is not OK. And sadly, the Home Affairs

0:10:11.280 --> 0:10:14.740
<v Speaker 1>Minister confirmed to us tonight just how many people have

0:10:14.800 --> 0:10:18.380
<v Speaker 1>absolutely lost the plot that they are threatening politicians or

0:10:18.540 --> 0:10:20.100
<v Speaker 1>senior people in the country.

0:10:21.670 --> 0:10:25.600
<v Speaker 9>Last year, or the year before last, we had 951

0:10:25.600 --> 0:10:30.280
<v Speaker 9>reports of harassing and threatening behaviour against various high office holders.

0:10:31.480 --> 0:10:35.040
<v Speaker 9>The more recent financial year, that 951 has gone to 1,067.

0:10:35.040 --> 0:10:39.490
<v Speaker 9>At this moment in time, while it's still so early

0:10:39.500 --> 0:10:42.750
<v Speaker 9>in the investigation, our thoughts are all with Helen and

0:10:42.770 --> 0:10:46.190
<v Speaker 9>her family and her community and her friends. As the

0:10:46.230 --> 0:10:50.330
<v Speaker 9>Prime Minister said, Helen is respected, admired and loved.

0:10:51.750 --> 0:10:54.310
<v Speaker 1>Cam Redden is one of our political reporters in Canberra.

0:10:54.330 --> 0:10:57.210
<v Speaker 1>He's been across this, along with Andrew Clennell, as all

0:10:57.230 --> 0:10:58.709
<v Speaker 1>of the information has been coming to hand to us

0:10:58.750 --> 0:11:03.270
<v Speaker 1>here at News24, both online at news24. com. au and here on air.

0:11:03.290 --> 0:11:06.540
<v Speaker 1>Allegra Spender is a fellow independent. She too spoke on

0:11:06.559 --> 0:11:08.940
<v Speaker 1>the 7.30 report this evening. Let's see what she had

0:11:08.980 --> 0:11:10.599
<v Speaker 1>to say about her friend, because at the end of

0:11:10.640 --> 0:11:12.460
<v Speaker 1>the day, this is it. As much as it's all

0:11:12.500 --> 0:11:15.060
<v Speaker 1>about politics, the reality is we are talking about human beings,

0:11:15.080 --> 0:11:17.920
<v Speaker 1>we're talking about wives, we're talking about mothers, we're talking

0:11:17.960 --> 0:11:20.730
<v Speaker 1>about friends here. And regardless of whether we agree or

0:11:20.770 --> 0:11:24.310
<v Speaker 1>disagree with people politically, we think the best of people.

0:11:25.770 --> 0:11:27.939
<v Speaker 1>And of course, no one deserves what is happening right now.

0:11:28.000 --> 0:11:30.360
<v Speaker 1>Here is what Allegra Spender had to say about her

0:11:30.460 --> 0:11:31.220
<v Speaker 1>friend and colleague.

0:11:32.280 --> 0:11:35.699
<v Speaker 8>She's really an inspiration. I often, I'll go and talk

0:11:35.720 --> 0:11:38.410
<v Speaker 8>to her, particularly if I'm looking at regional, rural issues

0:11:38.570 --> 0:11:41.469
<v Speaker 8>and and get her perspective on what her community thinks.

0:11:42.350 --> 0:11:46.689
<v Speaker 8>But also, she's got, you see her with ministers, for instance,

0:11:47.470 --> 0:11:52.180
<v Speaker 8>she takes the work incredibly seriously. She interrogates the issues

0:11:52.220 --> 0:11:55.920
<v Speaker 8>very seriously, but with enormous respect and with a very

0:11:56.000 --> 0:11:58.540
<v Speaker 8>civilised approach. And I think this is something that we

0:11:58.580 --> 0:12:01.220
<v Speaker 8>need to see actually, frankly, much more of. She doesn't

0:12:01.240 --> 0:12:04.960
<v Speaker 8>play politics. She's actually just really interested in what is

0:12:05.370 --> 0:12:07.089
<v Speaker 8>best for her community and best for the country.

0:12:08.090 --> 0:12:10.730
<v Speaker 1>Cam, again, the enormity of what we're talking about here

0:12:10.809 --> 0:12:13.489
<v Speaker 1>is why we are talking about it with such specificity

0:12:13.590 --> 0:12:15.810
<v Speaker 1>and detail. We need to know what's happening in these

0:12:15.830 --> 0:12:18.250
<v Speaker 1>the early hours before we move into, as I've heard

0:12:18.290 --> 0:12:21.910
<v Speaker 1>you say throughout the evening, the inevitable bigger consequences of

0:12:21.929 --> 0:12:24.780
<v Speaker 1>the next days and weeks to come. Something has changed

0:12:24.820 --> 0:12:28.480
<v Speaker 1>in Australia and that has happened, well, in a terrible

0:12:28.520 --> 0:12:31.000
<v Speaker 1>way this evening. You've got some of the reaction from

0:12:31.059 --> 0:12:32.560
<v Speaker 1>other political figures around the country.

0:12:33.740 --> 0:12:35.560
<v Speaker 10>Yeah, let's show you some of these coming through, Paul,

0:12:35.580 --> 0:12:38.819
<v Speaker 10>from the Prime Minister down. People who make the observation

0:12:38.860 --> 0:12:41.140
<v Speaker 10>you just have that Helen Haynes talks to everyone. She's

0:12:41.179 --> 0:12:44.110
<v Speaker 10>a decent person and it's such a rare thing in

0:12:44.160 --> 0:12:47.110
<v Speaker 10>politics where she'll talk to someone and even if it's

0:12:47.150 --> 0:12:49.270
<v Speaker 10>a heated press conference or a full on interview, she'll

0:12:49.309 --> 0:12:51.310
<v Speaker 10>come up to you afterwards and have a laugh or

0:12:51.350 --> 0:12:53.650
<v Speaker 10>talk about the footy or something. She's just a decent person.

0:12:53.750 --> 0:12:56.230
<v Speaker 10>I do want to give you viewers a sense as well, Paul,

0:12:56.290 --> 0:12:59.630
<v Speaker 10>of The reaction that's already happening behind the scenes here,

0:12:59.650 --> 0:13:02.650
<v Speaker 10>I've been talking with several MPs and chiefs of staff

0:13:02.690 --> 0:13:05.660
<v Speaker 10>to senior high profile politicians over the last couple of

0:13:05.720 --> 0:13:09.460
<v Speaker 10>hours that are already reviewing their own security. They're reviewing

0:13:09.500 --> 0:13:12.700
<v Speaker 10>their processes. They're reviewing their access to staff and access

0:13:12.740 --> 0:13:16.300
<v Speaker 10>to police protection. My understanding is that the Home Affairs Minister,

0:13:16.340 --> 0:13:20.220
<v Speaker 10>Tony Burke, has even offered some MPs briefings about how

0:13:20.260 --> 0:13:22.640
<v Speaker 10>to improve their security or things they can do, that

0:13:22.660 --> 0:13:25.860
<v Speaker 10>there is support. for MPs that are concerned about this

0:13:25.890 --> 0:13:28.260
<v Speaker 10>that is now being offered, even in these first few

0:13:28.320 --> 0:13:31.640
<v Speaker 10>hours since. So as we still wait to hear hopefully

0:13:31.679 --> 0:13:33.820
<v Speaker 10>some good news on the medical front, I don't think

0:13:33.840 --> 0:13:36.140
<v Speaker 10>we'll get any more on that front until tomorrow morning, Paul.

0:13:36.179 --> 0:13:38.880
<v Speaker 10>But there is an instant reaction here. And of course,

0:13:38.900 --> 0:13:41.100
<v Speaker 10>in just a few weeks, Victorians everywhere will be out

0:13:41.120 --> 0:13:41.600
<v Speaker 10>at the polls.

0:13:42.300 --> 0:13:45.000
<v Speaker 1>Yeah, absolutely. I mean, Pauline Hanson has had plenty to

0:13:45.040 --> 0:13:46.829
<v Speaker 1>say about this. Of course, we know about the many

0:13:46.870 --> 0:13:49.890
<v Speaker 1>threats that she has received here. She says she's horrified

0:13:49.910 --> 0:13:54.900
<v Speaker 1>and saddened about Helen Haynes being seriously injured. I know

0:13:54.940 --> 0:13:57.420
<v Speaker 1>Australians everywhere are wishing her the same. Police are investigating.

0:13:57.440 --> 0:13:59.660
<v Speaker 1>We should let them do their work. Violence against any

0:13:59.740 --> 0:14:02.959
<v Speaker 1>elected representative, whoever they are and whatever they stand for,

0:14:03.040 --> 0:14:07.640
<v Speaker 1>is never acceptable. Again, Angus Taylor in his statement, David

0:14:07.710 --> 0:14:11.570
<v Speaker 1>Shoebridge too. Again, all of the leaders are coming forward

0:14:11.610 --> 0:14:16.309
<v Speaker 1>and saying what they should because of what has happened here. Cam,

0:14:16.650 --> 0:14:18.929
<v Speaker 1>we saw the Home Affairs Minister talk about this today.

0:14:18.990 --> 0:14:23.370
<v Speaker 1>We saw Anne Arleigh last week talking about this. And sometimes, sometimes...

0:14:23.590 --> 0:14:26.430
<v Speaker 1>Let's be honest, some people can roll their eyes when

0:14:26.450 --> 0:14:29.830
<v Speaker 1>you hear about a threat. Well, are they... is it real?

0:14:29.870 --> 0:14:32.030
<v Speaker 1>How many of these things are real? Well, the reality

0:14:32.100 --> 0:14:35.400
<v Speaker 1>here is we don't know what the precursors were to

0:14:35.440 --> 0:14:39.040
<v Speaker 1>what has happened today, but the reality is, is that

0:14:39.180 --> 0:14:42.420
<v Speaker 1>one of the things that has given many people safety

0:14:43.100 --> 0:14:46.900
<v Speaker 1>is threats have never been carried out in the past. Again,

0:14:47.020 --> 0:14:49.200
<v Speaker 1>I don't know if there is any precursor going into

0:14:49.260 --> 0:14:53.950
<v Speaker 1>all of this, but now that somebody has been targeted... Obviously,

0:14:54.110 --> 0:14:57.390
<v Speaker 1>the Prime Minister, again, suggesting that we have hit some

0:14:57.430 --> 0:14:59.960
<v Speaker 1>new threshold here. I was doing some research before the

0:15:00.000 --> 0:15:02.680
<v Speaker 1>program and it was unbelievable about the amount of money,

0:15:02.900 --> 0:15:07.760
<v Speaker 1>manpower and time the AFP is putting into chasing down

0:15:07.780 --> 0:15:09.980
<v Speaker 1>so many of these leads. We are talking about hundreds

0:15:10.020 --> 0:15:12.820
<v Speaker 1>and hundreds and hundreds of them. And, in fact, the

0:15:12.840 --> 0:15:16.430
<v Speaker 1>actual amount of money going into protecting significant Australians, it

0:15:16.470 --> 0:15:18.050
<v Speaker 1>is right up there with the total amount they are

0:15:18.070 --> 0:15:19.950
<v Speaker 1>spending on terrorism right now.

0:15:21.460 --> 0:15:23.710
<v Speaker 10>Yeah, and it does have an impact on our democracy, Paul.

0:15:23.770 --> 0:15:27.060
<v Speaker 10>I remember running around the election campaign last year following

0:15:27.100 --> 0:15:30.630
<v Speaker 10>Peter Dutton, who... had to, because of the extent of

0:15:30.690 --> 0:15:33.290
<v Speaker 10>threats that he has faced over many years in public life,

0:15:33.770 --> 0:15:36.890
<v Speaker 10>go everywhere with an AFP protection brigade. And not only

0:15:36.930 --> 0:15:39.220
<v Speaker 10>did that limit his ability to campaign, but I would

0:15:39.240 --> 0:15:41.700
<v Speaker 10>even go as far to say that it really limited

0:15:41.740 --> 0:15:44.580
<v Speaker 10>his impact of being able to engage with the community,

0:15:44.660 --> 0:15:47.180
<v Speaker 10>to do what's so good about our democracy that doesn't

0:15:47.220 --> 0:15:49.840
<v Speaker 10>happen so much overseas, that you go to barbecues, that

0:15:49.860 --> 0:15:53.060
<v Speaker 10>you catch a bus with people, you hold a community stall.

0:15:53.680 --> 0:15:55.980
<v Speaker 10>And you would hate to think that the end point

0:15:56.020 --> 0:15:59.170
<v Speaker 10>of events like this, Paul, is attack on democracy to

0:15:59.210 --> 0:16:01.490
<v Speaker 10>the point that people aren't able to engage with their

0:16:01.570 --> 0:16:03.850
<v Speaker 10>MPs that way because it's kind of the whole point

0:16:03.930 --> 0:16:06.960
<v Speaker 10>and we've been an outlier globally for so long. You

0:16:07.000 --> 0:16:09.720
<v Speaker 10>can only hope that obviously the police will do their

0:16:09.780 --> 0:16:13.240
<v Speaker 10>work and there will be political fallout to this too

0:16:13.300 --> 0:16:15.350
<v Speaker 10>but At the moment, as the Prime Minister said, as

0:16:15.390 --> 0:16:17.390
<v Speaker 10>you've alluded to, we can only hope and pray that

0:16:17.410 --> 0:16:20.120
<v Speaker 10>there is good medical news for Helen Haynes as she

0:16:20.170 --> 0:16:21.400
<v Speaker 10>is in the fight of her life tonight.

0:16:21.580 --> 0:16:23.500
<v Speaker 1>Absolutely, mate. Thank you, Cam. Cam Redden, of course, has

0:16:23.520 --> 0:16:26.060
<v Speaker 1>been across it all evening for us. No doubt more

0:16:26.080 --> 0:16:29.300
<v Speaker 1>information at News24. Again, in the morning, Di Lee is

0:16:29.320 --> 0:16:32.979
<v Speaker 1>the independent member for Fowler. She has sat in the

0:16:33.020 --> 0:16:36.200
<v Speaker 1>parliament for, well, a couple of terms now with Helen Haynes.

0:16:36.300 --> 0:16:38.060
<v Speaker 1>I'm sorry that this has happened to your friend, Di.

0:16:39.140 --> 0:16:40.860
<v Speaker 5>Oh, it's shocking news, Paul.

0:16:41.460 --> 0:16:43.840
<v Speaker 11>We just, you know, Helen and I sort of sat

0:16:43.980 --> 0:16:48.280
<v Speaker 11>and chatted just the last sitting talking about, you know,

0:16:48.850 --> 0:16:52.730
<v Speaker 11>our lives and how, you know, politics really takes a

0:16:52.770 --> 0:16:56.510
<v Speaker 11>lot out of our personal life and we were just

0:16:56.550 --> 0:17:00.270
<v Speaker 11>trying to organise a birthday, you know, for one of

0:17:00.290 --> 0:17:05.969
<v Speaker 11>the other crossbenchers. So she's very well respected. It is

0:17:06.090 --> 0:17:09.570
<v Speaker 11>a huge shock to hear her. Um, you know, obviously

0:17:09.590 --> 0:17:12.129
<v Speaker 11>I've been listening to reports and hearing what people are

0:17:12.190 --> 0:17:14.750
<v Speaker 11>saying that it was actual, an actual attack. And that

0:17:14.790 --> 0:17:19.129
<v Speaker 11>is a real shocking, um, description of what actually happened

0:17:19.250 --> 0:17:22.430
<v Speaker 11>to Helen. Um, her family obviously has put out a statement.

0:17:22.470 --> 0:17:26.330
<v Speaker 11>Her staff has put out a safe statement requesting respect

0:17:26.790 --> 0:17:29.010
<v Speaker 11>at this time for her. And as, as you said,

0:17:29.030 --> 0:17:32.590
<v Speaker 11>and as Cam said, we do pray for her, uh.

0:17:32.630 --> 0:17:38.669
<v Speaker 5>You know, health recovery. Um, and, uh, it is, um, It's,

0:17:38.990 --> 0:17:40.850
<v Speaker 5>you know, what can I say?

0:17:41.210 --> 0:17:45.110
<v Speaker 11>We here in Australia, as members of parliament, especially as independents,

0:17:45.130 --> 0:17:50.860
<v Speaker 11>we're out there constantly, constantly engaging with our community, especially

0:17:50.890 --> 0:17:51.880
<v Speaker 11>for the independents.

0:17:52.480 --> 0:17:54.400
<v Speaker 5>We do a lot of community engagement. I mean, I'm

0:17:54.460 --> 0:17:55.060
<v Speaker 5>having a.

0:17:55.500 --> 0:17:59.900
<v Speaker 11>Bring Your Bill Day tomorrow in Liverpool in order to

0:18:00.060 --> 0:18:06.169
<v Speaker 11>ensure that my community have access to information services that

0:18:06.190 --> 0:18:09.480
<v Speaker 11>will assist them through this very difficult time of cost

0:18:09.520 --> 0:18:10.400
<v Speaker 11>of living crisis.

0:18:11.300 --> 0:18:16.640
<v Speaker 5>So I will continue that role. It is shocking. We

0:18:16.680 --> 0:18:17.400
<v Speaker 5>all pray for.

0:18:17.320 --> 0:18:22.560
<v Speaker 11>Helen and we hope that the police investigation will yield

0:18:23.240 --> 0:18:29.240
<v Speaker 11>something that will hopefully ensure that, you know, members of

0:18:29.260 --> 0:18:33.110
<v Speaker 11>parliament feel safe to do their job. And I think

0:18:33.140 --> 0:18:39.170
<v Speaker 11>at this point in time, I think the heat, the

0:18:39.270 --> 0:18:42.830
<v Speaker 11>conversation that we have seen and we observe, I think

0:18:43.250 --> 0:18:45.730
<v Speaker 11>there's more anger, I feel there's more anger out there

0:18:45.760 --> 0:18:49.240
<v Speaker 11>in the community and I suppose because they're living in

0:18:49.320 --> 0:18:56.500
<v Speaker 11>very challenging times now, people are angry and it's quite concerning.

0:18:56.840 --> 0:18:59.199
<v Speaker 1>So, Di, and again, I don't want to tip off

0:18:59.420 --> 0:19:02.090
<v Speaker 1>the crazies but I want to try to get the

0:19:02.119 --> 0:19:05.100
<v Speaker 1>inside view on things here, right, that we... hear and

0:19:05.140 --> 0:19:07.660
<v Speaker 1>read and see all sorts of reports about the number

0:19:07.680 --> 0:19:11.410
<v Speaker 1>of threats that are coming towards politicians. Since you entered

0:19:11.450 --> 0:19:15.540
<v Speaker 1>the parliament, got re-elected and are sitting here tonight, are

0:19:15.580 --> 0:19:19.060
<v Speaker 1>there more... Is there sort of a bigger red button

0:19:19.100 --> 0:19:23.620
<v Speaker 1>that's available to MPs to call for help when it's needed?

0:19:23.980 --> 0:19:27.070
<v Speaker 1>Are there more patrols? Is there, you know, literally a

0:19:27.270 --> 0:19:31.109
<v Speaker 1>security guard that sits inside offices now? Have you seen

0:19:31.210 --> 0:19:34.910
<v Speaker 1>that bubble change or you're just as vulnerable or open

0:19:34.950 --> 0:19:36.270
<v Speaker 1>as you were six years ago?

0:19:37.750 --> 0:19:39.110
<v Speaker 5>I'm pretty open in my office.

0:19:39.670 --> 0:19:42.520
<v Speaker 11>You know, of course, every MP officer's got the red

0:19:42.580 --> 0:19:46.740
<v Speaker 11>button to press if there's any danger. You know, this

0:19:46.760 --> 0:19:51.620
<v Speaker 11>is my second term. My community here... I feel very

0:19:51.720 --> 0:19:54.170
<v Speaker 11>safe with the community. I mean, actually, in the last

0:19:54.210 --> 0:19:57.510
<v Speaker 11>few months, I've had a couple of calls from very

0:19:57.770 --> 0:20:03.270
<v Speaker 11>angry men, but just angry, but, you know, just very

0:20:03.350 --> 0:20:07.010
<v Speaker 11>abusive towards some of my staff when they speak on

0:20:07.030 --> 0:20:07.410
<v Speaker 11>the phone.

0:20:07.450 --> 0:20:09.909
<v Speaker 5>But there's nothing that wasn't threatening.

0:20:10.230 --> 0:20:13.710
<v Speaker 11>I mean, we reported those calls to the AFP to

0:20:13.770 --> 0:20:15.770
<v Speaker 11>ensure that, you know, that this.

0:20:16.600 --> 0:20:18.780
<v Speaker 5>you know, we're doing the right thing as well.

0:20:19.100 --> 0:20:24.610
<v Speaker 11>But my touch wood, my personal safety has not been

0:20:24.630 --> 0:20:25.490
<v Speaker 11>an issue.

0:20:25.510 --> 0:20:29.850
<v Speaker 5>I have not received any threats at all.

0:20:31.770 --> 0:20:34.390
<v Speaker 11>So, you know, my community is a beautiful community.

0:20:34.450 --> 0:20:37.720
<v Speaker 5>We're very multicultural. We're very diverse. You know, the people

0:20:37.760 --> 0:20:38.740
<v Speaker 5>here are very hardworking.

0:20:40.480 --> 0:20:44.060
<v Speaker 11>And, you know, people are struggling as well, door knocking,

0:20:44.080 --> 0:20:45.260
<v Speaker 11>and they tell me that.

0:20:45.840 --> 0:20:46.060
<v Speaker 5>So.

0:20:47.119 --> 0:20:50.320
<v Speaker 11>So look, at this point in time, I have no

0:20:50.380 --> 0:20:53.050
<v Speaker 11>doubt that is a concern for a lot of members

0:20:53.090 --> 0:20:56.010
<v Speaker 11>of parliament, but we will all have to carry on

0:20:56.270 --> 0:21:01.169
<v Speaker 11>our role as elected representative to represent the community. And

0:21:01.630 --> 0:21:03.770
<v Speaker 11>for me, I'll continue to engage with my community.

0:21:04.130 --> 0:21:05.730
<v Speaker 1>Good on you, Di. All the best for tomorrow. And

0:21:05.780 --> 0:21:08.379
<v Speaker 1>thanks for chatting to us tonight about your friend and colleague,

0:21:08.400 --> 0:21:11.230
<v Speaker 1>Helen Haynes, who of course, as we all know, is, well,

0:21:11.470 --> 0:21:13.270
<v Speaker 1>in hospital as we speak.

0:21:13.390 --> 0:21:13.649
<v Speaker 12>All right.

0:21:13.950 --> 0:21:15.150
<v Speaker 1>Now, we're going to bounce in and out of this

0:21:15.210 --> 0:21:17.570
<v Speaker 1>throughout the program for obvious reasons. This is one of

0:21:17.630 --> 0:21:20.330
<v Speaker 1>those days that is a big change. It is a

0:21:20.369 --> 0:21:23.689
<v Speaker 1>big change in how we interact. We don't know what

0:21:23.710 --> 0:21:25.850
<v Speaker 1>the consequences are going to be from here. A little

0:21:25.869 --> 0:21:28.120
<v Speaker 1>later in the show, we're going to talk to Matt Canavan,

0:21:28.140 --> 0:21:30.520
<v Speaker 1>of course, the leader of the Nationals, again, for that

0:21:31.300 --> 0:21:33.659
<v Speaker 1>insight about what it is like to be on the

0:21:33.700 --> 0:21:35.480
<v Speaker 1>front line, about how you have to keep your head

0:21:35.910 --> 0:21:37.670
<v Speaker 1>on a swivel. A little later in the show, we'll

0:21:37.690 --> 0:21:40.440
<v Speaker 1>talk to a former Victorian detective about what police would

0:21:40.460 --> 0:21:42.480
<v Speaker 1>be doing right now. But we are going to try

0:21:42.500 --> 0:21:44.320
<v Speaker 1>and weave in with what was planned for the show

0:21:44.960 --> 0:21:49.980
<v Speaker 1>this evening. including this conversation about the Victorian election. We

0:21:50.090 --> 0:21:53.470
<v Speaker 1>are closing in on that Victorian election. The last Saturday

0:21:53.590 --> 0:21:57.550
<v Speaker 1>in November, we are, of course, halfway through October, so

0:21:57.990 --> 0:22:01.119
<v Speaker 1>there is not long to go before the state election. Now,

0:22:01.140 --> 0:22:04.760
<v Speaker 1>there is some confusing pictures in the past seven days. Now,

0:22:04.780 --> 0:22:07.619
<v Speaker 1>as you know, I love Cos Samaras and Redbridge. Their

0:22:07.660 --> 0:22:09.699
<v Speaker 1>headline was, was that the Liberal Party is starting to

0:22:09.740 --> 0:22:13.189
<v Speaker 1>close in on a potential majority election. in Victoria, and

0:22:13.210 --> 0:22:17.990
<v Speaker 1>then from nowhere was a 50-50 call that came from

0:22:18.130 --> 0:22:21.130
<v Speaker 1>the Roy Morgan organisation suggesting that there is a way

0:22:21.450 --> 0:22:23.590
<v Speaker 1>for Labor and the Greens to be able to hold

0:22:23.830 --> 0:22:26.880
<v Speaker 1>on to power. Let's get to Cos, who's standing by

0:22:26.940 --> 0:22:31.159
<v Speaker 1>right now. Cos, again, I know the circumstances are bigger

0:22:31.200 --> 0:22:33.780
<v Speaker 1>than polls and data and elections and all the rest

0:22:33.800 --> 0:22:35.900
<v Speaker 1>of it, right? But let's get to this here, where

0:22:36.320 --> 0:22:37.920
<v Speaker 1>how can two things be right at the same time?

0:22:39.190 --> 0:22:40.540
<v Speaker 4>They're not. Simple as that.

0:22:40.900 --> 0:22:44.480
<v Speaker 13>I mean, as it stands right now, coalition looks like

0:22:44.850 --> 0:22:48.090
<v Speaker 13>it's going to win the majority of seats. It's more

0:22:48.109 --> 0:22:51.869
<v Speaker 13>than likely to secure close to 50 seats, possibly than higher.

0:22:52.670 --> 0:22:56.130
<v Speaker 13>So for your viewers, why is that the case? Why

0:22:56.170 --> 0:22:59.570
<v Speaker 13>can they win so many seats with a 30% primary vote?

0:23:00.450 --> 0:23:03.110
<v Speaker 13>So earlier this year, One Nation was polling in Victoria

0:23:03.150 --> 0:23:05.350
<v Speaker 13>in the high 20s. It's now polling somewhere in the

0:23:05.470 --> 0:23:07.930
<v Speaker 13>mid to low 20s. Most of that vote's gone to

0:23:07.970 --> 0:23:10.890
<v Speaker 13>the coalition. So what that means is that The coalition

0:23:10.930 --> 0:23:13.630
<v Speaker 13>wins a lot of three-way contests in Victoria.

0:23:13.670 --> 0:23:15.890
<v Speaker 6>So a lot of electorates, there are.

0:23:15.890 --> 0:23:19.810
<v Speaker 13>Genuine three-way contests. So One Nation, Labor and the coalition

0:23:20.150 --> 0:23:24.209
<v Speaker 13>competed for that one seat. Because the coalition now has

0:23:24.250 --> 0:23:27.210
<v Speaker 13>a much healthier primary, it starts to clean the deck.

0:23:28.410 --> 0:23:29.280
<v Speaker 1>And that's what's going on.

0:23:29.410 --> 0:23:31.840
<v Speaker 13>And the other thing, which is very important, they are

0:23:32.100 --> 0:23:36.300
<v Speaker 13>in a very strategically advantageous position. They will get preferences

0:23:36.400 --> 0:23:39.620
<v Speaker 13>from Labor in coalition versus One Nation contests.

0:23:40.200 --> 0:23:40.720
<v Speaker 4>And they'll get.

0:23:40.680 --> 0:23:47.610
<v Speaker 13>Preferences from, and of course, One Nation will get preferences

0:23:47.750 --> 0:23:50.129
<v Speaker 13>from the Liberal Party, but not to the same extent.

0:23:50.430 --> 0:23:53.230
<v Speaker 13>Depends where you are geographically. And the flip side, of course,

0:23:53.850 --> 0:23:56.350
<v Speaker 13>in seats where the coalition is trying to win seats

0:23:56.390 --> 0:23:59.040
<v Speaker 13>off the Labor Party, One Nation preferences will help them

0:23:59.190 --> 0:23:59.740
<v Speaker 13>there as well.

0:23:59.800 --> 0:24:02.060
<v Speaker 6>So they're getting the benefit from both sides.

0:24:02.520 --> 0:24:04.920
<v Speaker 1>Now, something I was, again, studying during the couple of

0:24:04.940 --> 0:24:07.879
<v Speaker 1>weeks off was having a look every now and then about, OK,

0:24:08.140 --> 0:24:11.350
<v Speaker 1>what's been the frame for 2026? Essentially, it has been

0:24:11.710 --> 0:24:14.409
<v Speaker 1>Labor down, Libs up, and as you say, One Nation

0:24:14.430 --> 0:24:16.710
<v Speaker 1>sort of grows throughout the year, as it has been

0:24:16.730 --> 0:24:20.170
<v Speaker 1>at the federal level. Then, of course, there was a

0:24:20.190 --> 0:24:22.710
<v Speaker 1>change of leader. Now, the Hail Mary that was either

0:24:22.730 --> 0:24:25.270
<v Speaker 1>supposed to save the furniture. Now, again, this is how

0:24:25.330 --> 0:24:27.390
<v Speaker 1>it all works, right? If they get done and actually

0:24:27.460 --> 0:24:30.220
<v Speaker 1>lose a majority... Well, then Ben Carroll and his mates

0:24:30.260 --> 0:24:32.220
<v Speaker 1>get to turn around and say, well, if we didn't

0:24:32.260 --> 0:24:34.660
<v Speaker 1>make the change... And then, of course, if they lose,

0:24:35.540 --> 0:24:37.840
<v Speaker 1>Jacinta Allen and her mates say, well, because you made

0:24:37.900 --> 0:24:42.050
<v Speaker 1>the change. That said, nothing has really happened since the change.

0:24:42.450 --> 0:24:45.950
<v Speaker 1>I remember talking on air about September, that while everyone

0:24:45.970 --> 0:24:48.389
<v Speaker 1>was looking at the footy, maybe that was an opportunity

0:24:48.470 --> 0:24:52.210
<v Speaker 1>for the slight reposition, the slight re-messaging, the slight sort

0:24:52.250 --> 0:24:57.040
<v Speaker 1>of testing of things. Well, all of that hasn't swung. Again,

0:24:57.300 --> 0:25:01.119
<v Speaker 1>nothing is inevitable, but nothing has changed since they dumped

0:25:01.200 --> 0:25:02.210
<v Speaker 1>Jacinta Allen, has it?

0:25:03.240 --> 0:25:07.620
<v Speaker 13>Well, people's living circumstances are still the same. We're talking

0:25:07.660 --> 0:25:10.430
<v Speaker 13>about 11 years of a deliberate strategy by the Labor

0:25:10.490 --> 0:25:13.190
<v Speaker 13>Party in Victoria to turn their backs away from outer

0:25:13.210 --> 0:25:17.390
<v Speaker 13>suburban regional Victorians, and the consequences are now writ large

0:25:17.410 --> 0:25:20.470
<v Speaker 13>in the polls. So you can't fix.

0:25:20.270 --> 0:25:22.690
<v Speaker 4>The road in two months. Ben Carroll doesn't have.

0:25:22.609 --> 0:25:24.869
<v Speaker 13>That time, and he has to now loan.

0:25:27.000 --> 0:25:30.119
<v Speaker 13>You know, on his reputation of not being attached to

0:25:30.140 --> 0:25:34.350
<v Speaker 13>the previous administrations in trying to convince Victorians that he's different.

0:25:34.390 --> 0:25:36.210
<v Speaker 6>That's a really long stretch of the boat.

0:25:37.410 --> 0:25:40.129
<v Speaker 1>Is there any question mark over Jess Wilson and the

0:25:40.190 --> 0:25:42.710
<v Speaker 1>Libs in those focus groups when voters start to say,

0:25:42.830 --> 0:25:45.190
<v Speaker 1>because I know, you know, generally speaking, let's be honest

0:25:45.230 --> 0:25:47.370
<v Speaker 1>about the way that it works, is that governments get

0:25:47.450 --> 0:25:50.830
<v Speaker 1>booted rather than oppositions get embraced. But there is a

0:25:50.869 --> 0:25:52.810
<v Speaker 1>moment where you start to realise, well, can I hang

0:25:52.850 --> 0:25:55.929
<v Speaker 1>out with this person for the next four years? And

0:25:56.730 --> 0:26:01.090
<v Speaker 1>Is there any soft area for Jess Wilson or have

0:26:01.109 --> 0:26:03.410
<v Speaker 1>they done a pretty good job of being able to

0:26:03.780 --> 0:26:06.200
<v Speaker 1>have a clear identity about who she is and people

0:26:06.300 --> 0:26:08.660
<v Speaker 1>know who she is? And even if they can't name

0:26:08.720 --> 0:26:11.560
<v Speaker 1>everyone else, they know, yep, Jess can run the joint

0:26:11.580 --> 0:26:12.960
<v Speaker 1>because this mob, they've got to go.

0:26:14.080 --> 0:26:16.040
<v Speaker 13>Yeah, I think they've done a pretty good job. I mean,

0:26:16.260 --> 0:26:18.580
<v Speaker 13>all they had to do was basically paint a picture

0:26:18.600 --> 0:26:21.159
<v Speaker 13>that she is a safe variance to go to as

0:26:21.200 --> 0:26:24.750
<v Speaker 13>an alternative to the Labor government. The one thing that

0:26:24.790 --> 0:26:27.210
<v Speaker 13>we are seeing changing in Victoria is that a lot

0:26:27.230 --> 0:26:30.030
<v Speaker 13>of people that went to One Nation off the Labor

0:26:30.070 --> 0:26:33.550
<v Speaker 13>Party are now going over to the coalition after expressing

0:26:33.590 --> 0:26:35.409
<v Speaker 13>concerns to us that they're not really happy with what

0:26:35.430 --> 0:26:37.780
<v Speaker 13>they're hearing from One Nation. So there is a change

0:26:37.800 --> 0:26:41.139
<v Speaker 13>in Victoria, and that is One Nation's vote softening. And

0:26:41.359 --> 0:26:43.880
<v Speaker 13>that could accelerate or we could see a bounce back.

0:26:43.900 --> 0:26:44.359
<v Speaker 4>We don't know.

0:26:44.380 --> 0:26:46.420
<v Speaker 1>We're living for a transformative period as well.

0:26:46.480 --> 0:26:50.090
<v Speaker 13>So as a pollster, I can only report on what

0:26:50.350 --> 0:26:52.909
<v Speaker 13>is occurring right now because it could be totally different.

0:26:52.650 --> 0:26:54.760
<v Speaker 6>When you and I are having a conversation three weeks' time.

0:26:54.930 --> 0:26:56.939
<v Speaker 1>Well, 100%. I always love when people say this. This

0:26:57.000 --> 0:26:58.480
<v Speaker 1>is not about a bet the house moment. This is

0:26:58.500 --> 0:27:00.880
<v Speaker 1>a temperature check, right? This is just a quick little, okay,

0:27:00.920 --> 0:27:04.220
<v Speaker 1>where are we right now? And guess what? Remember where,

0:27:04.240 --> 0:27:08.459
<v Speaker 1>of course, the Libs were, November 2024 versus May of 2025.

0:27:08.460 --> 0:27:13.080
<v Speaker 1>Circumstances matter. Campaigns matter. All of that will happen. Last

0:27:13.160 --> 0:27:16.480
<v Speaker 1>one before you go. I couldn't believe that I was

0:27:16.540 --> 0:27:19.950
<v Speaker 1>noticing in conversations some people that may well be a

0:27:19.970 --> 0:27:23.209
<v Speaker 1>little more of the, not the full lefty cloth, but

0:27:23.250 --> 0:27:26.250
<v Speaker 1>maybe the right wing of the lefty cloth, that are

0:27:26.369 --> 0:27:31.430
<v Speaker 1>starting to, starting to just kind of mention the technical

0:27:31.630 --> 0:27:35.320
<v Speaker 1>possibility of somebody other than Anthony Albanese being the leader

0:27:35.380 --> 0:27:37.639
<v Speaker 1>at the next federal election. I just want to ask

0:27:37.680 --> 0:27:43.240
<v Speaker 1>you this question, which is how personal have the problems

0:27:43.280 --> 0:27:46.790
<v Speaker 1>for the government become about the person who leads it

0:27:46.910 --> 0:27:50.710
<v Speaker 1>and the treasurer. Because to me, it's pretty obvious, right,

0:27:50.920 --> 0:27:54.060
<v Speaker 1>that interest rates, interest rates, interest rates put weight in

0:27:54.100 --> 0:27:57.619
<v Speaker 1>the saddlebags of the Prime Minister and the treasurer. But

0:27:57.640 --> 0:27:59.660
<v Speaker 1>are people saying in any of these groups, you know what,

0:27:59.880 --> 0:28:02.639
<v Speaker 1>I'm done with him? Not really.

0:28:02.680 --> 0:28:05.510
<v Speaker 13>And I would probably caution some of those on the

0:28:05.530 --> 0:28:08.650
<v Speaker 13>Labor side to take a lesson out of Victoria or

0:28:08.710 --> 0:28:11.609
<v Speaker 13>Queensland for that matter. You know, they changed leaders thinking

0:28:11.630 --> 0:28:13.890
<v Speaker 13>that was going to fix their problem. No, if you've

0:28:13.930 --> 0:28:16.889
<v Speaker 13>got a problem with the electorate, And that's because of

0:28:16.910 --> 0:28:20.230
<v Speaker 13>the economic situation that people are living in. You probably

0:28:20.260 --> 0:28:22.580
<v Speaker 13>need to focus on fixing that problem. It's a really,

0:28:22.600 --> 0:28:24.719
<v Speaker 13>you know, I was interviewed at the time when they

0:28:24.740 --> 0:28:26.800
<v Speaker 13>switched to Ben Caron. I said, well, in the past,

0:28:26.859 --> 0:28:27.460
<v Speaker 13>it's never worked.

0:28:27.960 --> 0:28:32.180
<v Speaker 1>Well, here we are, right? Yeah, correct. Again, I think

0:28:32.200 --> 0:28:36.380
<v Speaker 1>that it is situational right now. I do think that

0:28:36.400 --> 0:28:38.310
<v Speaker 1>sort of the previous benefit of the doubt the Prime

0:28:38.330 --> 0:28:41.550
<v Speaker 1>Minister's got, he's not really holding on to. Again, In

0:28:41.570 --> 0:28:43.890
<v Speaker 1>the News 24 Pulse tomorrow, we'll see another version of

0:28:43.950 --> 0:28:46.100
<v Speaker 1>that number, which has generally been in and around six

0:28:46.140 --> 0:28:48.960
<v Speaker 1>out of ten dissatisfied. Now, of course, that isn't just

0:28:49.100 --> 0:28:52.180
<v Speaker 1>all centre-right people. It's not centre-left people either, but we'll

0:28:52.680 --> 0:28:55.140
<v Speaker 1>deal with it all together. Coz, I always want people

0:28:55.160 --> 0:28:56.670
<v Speaker 1>to follow what you have to say. He writes in

0:28:56.690 --> 0:28:59.330
<v Speaker 1>the Financial Review. He's got a great podcast with the

0:28:59.370 --> 0:29:02.170
<v Speaker 1>John Curtin Centre. And get his sub-stack as well. Lots

0:29:02.190 --> 0:29:03.750
<v Speaker 1>of ways to get Coz. Thank you, mate. Appreciate it.

0:29:04.450 --> 0:29:04.630
<v Speaker 4>Cheers.

0:29:05.040 --> 0:29:05.750
<v Speaker 1>He's a good man, isn't he?

0:29:06.060 --> 0:29:06.320
<v Speaker 14>All right.

0:29:06.780 --> 0:29:08.060
<v Speaker 1>Now, let us take a break in a moment or

0:29:08.080 --> 0:29:10.180
<v Speaker 1>two's time. We're going to have Matt Canavan on because

0:29:10.200 --> 0:29:12.680
<v Speaker 1>there's plenty to talk about, including the Nats are now

0:29:12.760 --> 0:29:16.570
<v Speaker 1>seriously talking about pushing back on the EU trade deal.

0:29:17.190 --> 0:29:19.030
<v Speaker 1>A little later, we'll talk to a veteran of the

0:29:19.050 --> 0:29:22.110
<v Speaker 1>Victoria Police about what is the investigation that would be

0:29:22.130 --> 0:29:24.370
<v Speaker 1>happening right now in the breaking news. The big news

0:29:24.410 --> 0:29:26.910
<v Speaker 1>of the evening here is that an Australian politician has

0:29:26.950 --> 0:29:31.720
<v Speaker 1>been targeted and has been very seriously injured. An attack

0:29:31.760 --> 0:29:34.719
<v Speaker 1>that the Prime Minister says was not an accident. More

0:29:34.740 --> 0:29:40.380
<v Speaker 1>in a second. Hey, thank you very much for watching.

0:29:40.420 --> 0:29:42.400
<v Speaker 1>I should also say thank you very much to Caleb

0:29:42.420 --> 0:29:44.420
<v Speaker 1>Bond for taking care of the man cave for the

0:29:44.460 --> 0:29:46.800
<v Speaker 1>past couple of weeks. I had a whole funny thing

0:29:46.900 --> 0:29:49.560
<v Speaker 1>planned about how sort of the more things change, the

0:29:49.580 --> 0:29:52.140
<v Speaker 1>more they stay the same, about all sorts of stuff.

0:29:52.220 --> 0:29:54.360
<v Speaker 1>But of course, the tone of the evening is ever

0:29:54.380 --> 0:29:56.970
<v Speaker 1>so slightly different. But I had a wonderful break. It

0:29:57.010 --> 0:30:00.250
<v Speaker 1>was a wonderful time. Friends, family and motor racing. Oh,

0:30:00.330 --> 0:30:02.550
<v Speaker 1>how good. What about that car running out of fuel

0:30:02.590 --> 0:30:04.830
<v Speaker 1>at Bathurst? Could you believe it? We didn't when we

0:30:04.850 --> 0:30:06.390
<v Speaker 1>were watching it with our very own eyes.

0:30:06.710 --> 0:30:06.950
<v Speaker 4>All right.

0:30:07.060 --> 0:30:09.360
<v Speaker 1>Of course, the main story this evening is Helen Haynes,

0:30:09.420 --> 0:30:13.380
<v Speaker 1>the member for Indi, being critically injured. I mentioned before

0:30:13.420 --> 0:30:17.380
<v Speaker 1>High Street in Wangaratta. I apologise. It's Murphy Street in Wangaratta.

0:30:17.440 --> 0:30:20.590
<v Speaker 1>It's still an active crime scene, according to news reporters

0:30:20.630 --> 0:30:23.430
<v Speaker 1>who are on the location as we speak. Two blokes

0:30:23.470 --> 0:30:25.560
<v Speaker 1>who know what it's like to be on the front lines,

0:30:25.580 --> 0:30:28.020
<v Speaker 1>to interact as openly, yes, sometimes to keep your head

0:30:28.060 --> 0:30:31.420
<v Speaker 1>on a swivel, but always operate under an assumption that, well,

0:30:31.440 --> 0:30:33.820
<v Speaker 1>the worst you're ever going to cop is verbal abuse,

0:30:34.340 --> 0:30:36.440
<v Speaker 1>not something like this, is Matt Canavan, of course, the

0:30:36.480 --> 0:30:39.640
<v Speaker 1>Nationals leader. He joins us now. From Queensland, lovely to

0:30:39.680 --> 0:30:41.870
<v Speaker 1>see you, mate. Nicholas Rees, of course, the Lord Mayor

0:30:42.070 --> 0:30:44.450
<v Speaker 1>in Melbourne as well. Lads, I want to get to

0:30:44.490 --> 0:30:46.350
<v Speaker 1>the rest of the day's news because we have spent

0:30:46.690 --> 0:30:49.530
<v Speaker 1>so much time understandably talking about this, but it would

0:30:49.550 --> 0:30:51.330
<v Speaker 1>be remiss of me not to give you the opportunity

0:30:51.370 --> 0:30:54.330
<v Speaker 1>to speak about how you're feeling tonight about what is

0:30:54.370 --> 0:30:57.980
<v Speaker 1>happening and the threshold that we have now broken through here, Matt,

0:30:58.060 --> 0:31:01.459
<v Speaker 1>where a politician has been deliberately targeted, as a result,

0:31:01.580 --> 0:31:02.300
<v Speaker 1>critically injured.

0:31:04.750 --> 0:31:07.070
<v Speaker 4>Look, I'm extremely shocked and saddened.

0:31:07.490 --> 0:31:10.380
<v Speaker 15>I suppose perhaps not as shocked as I would be

0:31:10.450 --> 0:31:14.460
<v Speaker 15>because we have seen increasing threats, unfortunately, and it is, though,

0:31:14.480 --> 0:31:18.200
<v Speaker 15>shocking to see it manifest on Australia's streets. Not something

0:31:18.340 --> 0:31:20.800
<v Speaker 15>I would have thought. Look, I tonight just want to

0:31:21.160 --> 0:31:26.440
<v Speaker 15>express my heartfelt consideration to Helen Haynes and her family.

0:31:26.920 --> 0:31:30.040
<v Speaker 15>Hope everything can be as good as possible, given the

0:31:30.080 --> 0:31:33.530
<v Speaker 15>nature of what we're hearing today. We just hope and

0:31:33.570 --> 0:31:36.090
<v Speaker 15>pray for her at this stage. We don't, of course,

0:31:36.130 --> 0:31:38.910
<v Speaker 15>know all of the details here, so don't want to

0:31:38.970 --> 0:31:41.870
<v Speaker 15>rush to conclusions. But, yeah, I also hope that we

0:31:41.910 --> 0:31:44.890
<v Speaker 15>can maintain our open and free society. And, you know,

0:31:44.930 --> 0:31:47.950
<v Speaker 15>it's great to interact with people. I was doing that

0:31:47.990 --> 0:31:52.630
<v Speaker 15>just this afternoon in Yipoon and door knocking around the

0:31:52.750 --> 0:31:56.450
<v Speaker 15>area as well. Great people and we've got a great country.

0:31:56.550 --> 0:31:59.310
<v Speaker 15>So let's just hope for the best here for now.

0:31:59.630 --> 0:32:00.770
<v Speaker 1>Yeah, it is. Nicholas?

0:32:01.930 --> 0:32:04.610
<v Speaker 6>Oh, look, it's an absolutely shocking day for the nation,

0:32:04.710 --> 0:32:05.010
<v Speaker 6>isn't it?

0:32:05.100 --> 0:32:10.100
<v Speaker 16>Helen Haynes was just such a good human, you know,

0:32:10.300 --> 0:32:16.940
<v Speaker 16>mother of three, midwife, medical researcher, really hard-working woman. parliamentarian,

0:32:17.180 --> 0:32:21.740
<v Speaker 16>thoroughly decent person who I believe was respected by all

0:32:21.860 --> 0:32:26.870
<v Speaker 16>for someone like this to be attacked in a targeted way.

0:32:26.880 --> 0:32:32.470
<v Speaker 16>I know the details are still coming in. Let's hope

0:32:32.530 --> 0:32:35.730
<v Speaker 16>this isn't a turning point for our nation. I have

0:32:35.750 --> 0:32:39.860
<v Speaker 16>been worrying for some time that You know, our politics

0:32:39.940 --> 0:32:41.480
<v Speaker 16>has been becoming.

0:32:42.680 --> 0:32:44.620
<v Speaker 6>More coarse, dare I say more.

0:32:44.760 --> 0:32:50.810
<v Speaker 16>Violent in its language, you know, the US disease coming here. So, yeah,

0:32:51.310 --> 0:32:54.690
<v Speaker 16>I really right now thinking about Helen and her family

0:32:54.710 --> 0:32:57.130
<v Speaker 16>and I guess the analysis of some of these bigger

0:32:57.190 --> 0:32:59.090
<v Speaker 16>issues will come in the days to come.

0:32:59.150 --> 0:33:02.170
<v Speaker 1>Correct. Correct. Right. And again, you know, ASIO has told

0:33:02.210 --> 0:33:03.610
<v Speaker 1>us about all sorts of things, that it is the

0:33:03.630 --> 0:33:06.280
<v Speaker 1>far left, it is the far right. We've spoken about

0:33:06.340 --> 0:33:08.620
<v Speaker 1>all of the threats that are constantly there. To those

0:33:08.640 --> 0:33:09.960
<v Speaker 1>of you that are brave enough to put your name

0:33:10.100 --> 0:33:12.020
<v Speaker 1>on a ballot paper, I admire you. To those that

0:33:12.060 --> 0:33:14.800
<v Speaker 1>get elected, I admire and respect you. As hard as

0:33:14.860 --> 0:33:17.680
<v Speaker 1>I mark people's homework, again, you're out and about in

0:33:17.700 --> 0:33:21.080
<v Speaker 1>a way that is incredibly exposed. And on days like this, Yeah,

0:33:21.120 --> 0:33:23.760
<v Speaker 1>we're reminded about just how vulnerable that can be. All right, so, Matt,

0:33:23.780 --> 0:33:25.700
<v Speaker 1>I want to talk about the EU trade deal because

0:33:25.760 --> 0:33:28.660
<v Speaker 1>I've noticed Don Farrell running around, you know, it's taken

0:33:28.680 --> 0:33:30.690
<v Speaker 1>eight years to negotiate this and it's the best possible

0:33:30.710 --> 0:33:34.870
<v Speaker 1>deal we've ever had. Like, he had full Trump salesman pitch, right? Oh, yeah,

0:33:34.910 --> 0:33:36.990
<v Speaker 1>nobody else could do it, everyone else has tried. Matt

0:33:37.010 --> 0:33:39.970
<v Speaker 1>Canvan couldn't possibly negotiate this. Can you explain to normal

0:33:40.010 --> 0:33:41.450
<v Speaker 1>people who are sitting on a couch right now on

0:33:41.470 --> 0:33:45.330
<v Speaker 1>a Monday night? Tide, what is the downside of an

0:33:45.470 --> 0:33:48.400
<v Speaker 1>EU trade deal and how do Australians get screwed? What

0:33:48.440 --> 0:33:50.240
<v Speaker 1>is the minister not mentioning?

0:33:52.340 --> 0:33:55.300
<v Speaker 15>Well, this deal is going to hurt some Australian farmers.

0:33:55.360 --> 0:33:58.260
<v Speaker 15>It's going to sell out our nation's independence and sovereignty,

0:33:58.320 --> 0:34:02.120
<v Speaker 15>and it undermines the strong bargaining position we've taken for

0:34:02.160 --> 0:34:05.210
<v Speaker 15>years to only sign a free trade agreement which lives

0:34:05.370 --> 0:34:08.790
<v Speaker 15>up to that name. Now, indeed, just three years ago,

0:34:09.430 --> 0:34:11.550
<v Speaker 15>the guy out there selling this today, Don Farrell, walked

0:34:11.630 --> 0:34:15.589
<v Speaker 15>away from effectively the same deal. And he's never coherently

0:34:15.730 --> 0:34:19.160
<v Speaker 15>or cogently explained why he turned around and then walked

0:34:19.219 --> 0:34:21.719
<v Speaker 15>back to the negotiating table he walked away from and signed.

0:34:21.940 --> 0:34:23.759
<v Speaker 4>Well, in fact, it got worse. He actually signed a

0:34:23.780 --> 0:34:24.420
<v Speaker 4>worse deal.

0:34:24.260 --> 0:34:27.060
<v Speaker 15>Because in the interim, the EU had lifted, almost doubled

0:34:27.100 --> 0:34:30.840
<v Speaker 15>its tariffs on our steel and they stay. So he

0:34:30.860 --> 0:34:34.020
<v Speaker 15>signed a free trade agreement, but steel tariffs, Australian steel

0:34:34.040 --> 0:34:37.200
<v Speaker 15>will only enter the EU on a 50% tariff under

0:34:37.239 --> 0:34:38.000
<v Speaker 15>a free trade deal.

0:34:38.020 --> 0:34:38.540
<v Speaker 4>How does that work?

0:34:38.780 --> 0:34:41.470
<v Speaker 15>Down there in Victoria, where Nick Rees is from, this

0:34:41.550 --> 0:34:46.010
<v Speaker 15>is my biggest concern with the deal. This deal sacrifices

0:34:46.150 --> 0:34:48.860
<v Speaker 15>and sells out our dairy farmers. Dairy farmers in the

0:34:48.960 --> 0:34:52.819
<v Speaker 15>EU get about 30% of their income from government subsidies

0:34:52.860 --> 0:34:56.630
<v Speaker 15>and support. It's unfair. It tips the balance of trade

0:34:56.790 --> 0:34:59.529
<v Speaker 15>against our exporters. And because of that, we've always had

0:34:59.610 --> 0:35:02.290
<v Speaker 15>a reciprocal tariff which seeks to level the playing field

0:35:02.410 --> 0:35:03.250
<v Speaker 15>on EU cheese.

0:35:03.810 --> 0:35:05.750
<v Speaker 4>That tariff will be removed under this deal.

0:35:05.790 --> 0:35:09.730
<v Speaker 15>But again, given the lopsided nature of these arrangements, the

0:35:09.810 --> 0:35:13.180
<v Speaker 15>EU subsidies will remain and continue to that will expose

0:35:13.200 --> 0:35:15.760
<v Speaker 15>their dairy industry to massively unfair competitions.

0:35:15.820 --> 0:35:16.060
<v Speaker 5>Why?

0:35:16.080 --> 0:35:18.219
<v Speaker 15>The dairy industry, along with lots of other farmers for

0:35:18.280 --> 0:35:21.200
<v Speaker 15>lots of other reasons, have come out and panned this deal.

0:35:21.640 --> 0:35:23.840
<v Speaker 15>And as I say, it sells out of independence because

0:35:24.160 --> 0:35:26.580
<v Speaker 15>for the first time, this would make the Paris Agreement

0:35:26.700 --> 0:35:29.620
<v Speaker 15>legally binding. Again, the government hasn't really explained why we

0:35:29.680 --> 0:35:31.950
<v Speaker 15>need to do that when us and the EU account

0:35:31.969 --> 0:35:33.550
<v Speaker 15>for just 7% of world emissions.

0:35:34.410 --> 0:35:36.290
<v Speaker 4>This seems ridiculous and absurd.

0:35:37.170 --> 0:35:38.989
<v Speaker 15>And as I say, You know, we've had a strong

0:35:39.030 --> 0:35:41.930
<v Speaker 15>position as a country in only signing up to good

0:35:42.010 --> 0:35:44.650
<v Speaker 15>free trade agreements. It strengthens our bargaining position because it

0:35:44.870 --> 0:35:47.950
<v Speaker 15>makes countries know that, hey, we're no pushover. You've got

0:35:47.969 --> 0:35:50.939
<v Speaker 15>to strive to do a deal with us. This deal,

0:35:50.960 --> 0:35:53.040
<v Speaker 15>if we signed up to it, would undermine that because

0:35:53.080 --> 0:35:55.260
<v Speaker 15>it does show that Don Farrell is certainly a pushover.

0:35:55.280 --> 0:35:56.880
<v Speaker 4>It shows in his own negotiating tactics.

0:35:57.260 --> 0:36:00.299
<v Speaker 15>The EU only had held out for three years and then, bang,

0:36:00.320 --> 0:36:01.890
<v Speaker 15>he was back at the table signing the same thing.

0:36:02.300 --> 0:36:04.050
<v Speaker 15>So that's not a good example for the future of

0:36:04.110 --> 0:36:05.570
<v Speaker 15>our country and that's why we should reject it.

0:36:05.930 --> 0:36:09.890
<v Speaker 1>Yeah, Nick, again, I am personally always, just I always

0:36:09.910 --> 0:36:11.290
<v Speaker 1>tap the brakes a little bit when I hear about

0:36:11.310 --> 0:36:14.230
<v Speaker 1>how amazing these free trade deals are. I've said it

0:36:14.270 --> 0:36:16.009
<v Speaker 1>about the United States one. I've said it about the

0:36:16.030 --> 0:36:18.390
<v Speaker 1>Chinese one. And I say it now about the EU one, right?

0:36:19.410 --> 0:36:21.930
<v Speaker 1>And yes, politically, there is always the ones who aren't

0:36:21.969 --> 0:36:24.790
<v Speaker 1>in government who are the ones raising questions about it.

0:36:25.190 --> 0:36:28.950
<v Speaker 1>But they are significant to me. And I'm a person

0:36:28.969 --> 0:36:31.049
<v Speaker 1>who is Australia first. I'm a person who says what's

0:36:31.070 --> 0:36:34.969
<v Speaker 1>good for us, not what's good for Europe. But you,

0:36:35.050 --> 0:36:37.489
<v Speaker 1>I'm imagining, would be somebody that would sign up to this?

0:36:39.160 --> 0:36:42.600
<v Speaker 6>Well, look, I'm not across every single detail.

0:36:42.640 --> 0:36:45.180
<v Speaker 16>So I was listening to what Matt was saying there

0:36:45.340 --> 0:36:48.950
<v Speaker 16>very carefully and I Certainly love Victorian dairy farmers. I

0:36:48.989 --> 0:36:54.410
<v Speaker 16>consume plenty of their product every single week. I would

0:36:54.489 --> 0:36:58.660
<v Speaker 16>say across the board, this does seem to be quite

0:36:58.700 --> 0:37:02.180
<v Speaker 16>an attractive deal for Australia. You know, the Australian Industry Group,

0:37:02.200 --> 0:37:05.759
<v Speaker 16>Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry have both come out

0:37:05.960 --> 0:37:09.410
<v Speaker 16>and said they strongly support it. I'm aware that the

0:37:09.489 --> 0:37:13.069
<v Speaker 16>Farmers Federation, the NFF, has raised some concerns, particularly for farmers,

0:37:13.510 --> 0:37:18.330
<v Speaker 16>sheep and beef meat exporters. I believe the beef industry

0:37:18.370 --> 0:37:22.310
<v Speaker 16>was looking for a quota of 50,000 tonnes. They've got

0:37:22.310 --> 0:37:26.630
<v Speaker 16>35,000 tonnes. That's eight times what they're currently exporting. So

0:37:26.650 --> 0:37:29.800
<v Speaker 16>it's not everything they wanted, but gee whiz, it's a

0:37:29.840 --> 0:37:33.520
<v Speaker 16>significant improvement. Perhaps if there's some way they can agree

0:37:33.540 --> 0:37:36.840
<v Speaker 16>to review the deal in one year on some of

0:37:36.860 --> 0:37:40.779
<v Speaker 16>these specific areas where Matt has raised some concerns. That

0:37:40.840 --> 0:37:43.940
<v Speaker 16>might be a way forward, allows us to revisit the

0:37:44.020 --> 0:37:47.140
<v Speaker 16>specific areas of concern in a fairly short period of

0:37:47.160 --> 0:37:50.779
<v Speaker 16>time and get a deal, which overall seems to be

0:37:50.820 --> 0:37:51.910
<v Speaker 16>a good thing for Australia.

0:37:52.140 --> 0:37:53.689
<v Speaker 1>It always does my head in how there's not enough

0:37:53.730 --> 0:37:54.870
<v Speaker 1>sunset clauses in legislation.

0:37:54.890 --> 0:37:58.029
<v Speaker 4>Can I just raise the beef, Paul? Go for it, Matt.

0:37:58.610 --> 0:38:00.470
<v Speaker 4>I know we're taking a bit of time. It's important.

0:38:00.770 --> 0:38:03.850
<v Speaker 15>Of course, the beef access for Australia increases by eight times,

0:38:03.890 --> 0:38:06.279
<v Speaker 15>but The key point to make here is we did

0:38:06.360 --> 0:38:08.930
<v Speaker 15>export around this amount, 29,000 tonnes of beef to the

0:38:09.030 --> 0:38:11.590
<v Speaker 15>EU just 10 years ago. Then in the first Trump administration,

0:38:11.630 --> 0:38:14.110
<v Speaker 15>the EU sold us out. They did a side deal

0:38:14.190 --> 0:38:17.930
<v Speaker 15>with Donald Trump to get them off his back and

0:38:18.030 --> 0:38:21.919
<v Speaker 15>reduced our quota from 30,000 to 4,000 tonnes, just over

0:38:21.920 --> 0:38:24.779
<v Speaker 15>4,000 tonnes. Now under this deal, they're giving it back

0:38:24.840 --> 0:38:26.420
<v Speaker 15>up to what we had just 10 years ago and

0:38:26.840 --> 0:38:28.020
<v Speaker 15>expecting our beef industry to.

0:38:28.900 --> 0:38:30.819
<v Speaker 4>lured them to the hilltops.

0:38:30.260 --> 0:38:32.859
<v Speaker 15>That's why beef producers I speak to are so angry

0:38:32.880 --> 0:38:34.400
<v Speaker 15>it's a pattern of behaviour from this government where they

0:38:34.440 --> 0:38:37.410
<v Speaker 15>gaslight people where they try and say how great it

0:38:37.489 --> 0:38:40.989
<v Speaker 15>is but you know the beef producers actually know they

0:38:41.290 --> 0:38:43.149
<v Speaker 15>people like Josie Angus who I talked to up here

0:38:43.190 --> 0:38:45.569
<v Speaker 15>in North Queensland she knows that they're trying to pull

0:38:45.590 --> 0:38:47.569
<v Speaker 15>the wool over their eyes but our beef producers didn't

0:38:47.610 --> 0:38:49.620
<v Speaker 15>come down the last shower like Don Farrell thinks and

0:38:50.070 --> 0:38:53.150
<v Speaker 15>should stop trying to oversell something which is not as

0:38:53.210 --> 0:38:54.049
<v Speaker 15>great as they make out.

0:38:54.210 --> 0:38:56.210
<v Speaker 1>Geez, if your last name's Angus and you're involved in

0:38:56.250 --> 0:38:58.210
<v Speaker 1>the beef trade, like this is... You were born to

0:38:58.250 --> 0:39:00.759
<v Speaker 1>do it, were you? Literally born to do it.

0:39:00.760 --> 0:39:03.319
<v Speaker 4>Blair and Josie, they're a team. They're wonderful.

0:39:03.640 --> 0:39:03.899
<v Speaker 14>Oh, hey.

0:39:03.960 --> 0:39:05.219
<v Speaker 4>It's a beef. It's fantastic.

0:39:05.320 --> 0:39:07.160
<v Speaker 1>I'm all in. G'day to all of them. All right,

0:39:07.180 --> 0:39:08.980
<v Speaker 1>don't forget to send some product here. Just address it

0:39:09.000 --> 0:39:12.080
<v Speaker 1>Man Cave. It'll eventually get here. Now, 30 seconds to

0:39:12.100 --> 0:39:15.020
<v Speaker 1>both of you here before we move on to other things. Nicholas...

0:39:15.340 --> 0:39:16.420
<v Speaker 1>How the heck are you going to be able to

0:39:16.460 --> 0:39:18.549
<v Speaker 1>get to the point when people can swim again in

0:39:18.590 --> 0:39:20.589
<v Speaker 1>the Yarra River? How are you going to do this?

0:39:20.610 --> 0:39:23.170
<v Speaker 1>Are you personally going to be there with the pool scoop?

0:39:23.190 --> 0:39:24.110
<v Speaker 1>What are you going to be doing?

0:39:24.450 --> 0:39:27.410
<v Speaker 16>Well, I did just that today. Paul went for a

0:39:27.450 --> 0:39:29.969
<v Speaker 16>swim in the Yarra River and it was a fantastic experience.

0:39:30.140 --> 0:39:33.359
<v Speaker 16>way to start the working week. It was a little

0:39:33.480 --> 0:39:37.730
<v Speaker 16>chilly in there, but the water was beautiful overall, I've

0:39:37.770 --> 0:39:40.490
<v Speaker 16>got to say. And look, I was there today going

0:39:40.550 --> 0:39:44.029
<v Speaker 16>for a swim, as you can see. because we've brought

0:39:44.070 --> 0:39:47.489
<v Speaker 16>together a coalition for the swimmable Yarra. We've got the

0:39:47.550 --> 0:39:51.700
<v Speaker 16>councils across metropolitan Melbourne signed on. We've got Melbourne Water

0:39:52.160 --> 0:39:55.799
<v Speaker 16>signed on. There's a complexity of bureaucracy that we need

0:39:55.840 --> 0:39:57.420
<v Speaker 16>to work through.

0:39:57.460 --> 0:40:00.359
<v Speaker 6>But getting everyone together and saying, we want to do this.

0:40:00.520 --> 0:40:01.060
<v Speaker 1>Is a really.

0:40:01.520 --> 0:40:04.259
<v Speaker 16>And, of course, for well over 100 years, swimming in

0:40:04.280 --> 0:40:06.630
<v Speaker 16>the Yarra was a very popular pastime in Melbourne.

0:40:06.710 --> 0:40:08.750
<v Speaker 6>Thousands of people used to do it every summer. There

0:40:08.770 --> 0:40:11.570
<v Speaker 6>used to be big swimming races. It was all the rage.

0:40:11.640 --> 0:40:13.520
<v Speaker 16>So we want to bring that back and we're just

0:40:13.940 --> 0:40:15.879
<v Speaker 16>going to clean up the river in order to do so.

0:40:16.280 --> 0:40:18.600
<v Speaker 16>It is going to be a big job. We've got to,

0:40:18.680 --> 0:40:23.969
<v Speaker 16>you know, improve the stormwater, filtration, all of that. But Paris, Berlin, London,

0:40:24.160 --> 0:40:27.210
<v Speaker 16>they're all doing it. And if they can, we can too.

0:40:27.230 --> 0:40:30.209
<v Speaker 1>All right. Well, look, the brown snake eventually, one day,

0:40:30.370 --> 0:40:32.070
<v Speaker 1>if they can do something with that in Brisbane too,

0:40:32.390 --> 0:40:34.930
<v Speaker 1>why not? Let's all see what happens here. By the way,

0:40:35.390 --> 0:40:37.970
<v Speaker 1>you can see, Matt, see again, not just the politician,

0:40:37.989 --> 0:40:40.029
<v Speaker 1>but the man who used to advise politicians, right, as

0:40:40.070 --> 0:40:42.410
<v Speaker 1>both of you remember behind the scenes as well. He

0:40:42.489 --> 0:40:44.739
<v Speaker 1>knew you can get in the water, just don't get

0:40:44.780 --> 0:40:47.000
<v Speaker 1>your hair wet, right? That's going to look garbage on television,

0:40:47.040 --> 0:40:50.040
<v Speaker 1>so keep the head above the water. Well played, Vic.

0:40:50.180 --> 0:40:52.359
<v Speaker 6>Look, now, Paul, I'm going to have to fact check

0:40:52.400 --> 0:40:52.719
<v Speaker 6>you there.

0:40:52.820 --> 0:40:55.290
<v Speaker 16>I actually had the team tell me, look, just keep

0:40:55.350 --> 0:40:57.570
<v Speaker 16>your head above water that particular stretch.

0:40:58.110 --> 0:40:58.629
<v Speaker 4>Of the era.

0:40:58.670 --> 0:41:00.150
<v Speaker 6>So that was actually on health advice.

0:41:01.690 --> 0:41:03.529
<v Speaker 1>But everyone should jump in the water.

0:41:03.570 --> 0:41:03.969
<v Speaker 4>I love it.

0:41:04.210 --> 0:41:05.730
<v Speaker 1>I love it. Anyway, good luck with the project.

0:41:05.790 --> 0:41:05.989
<v Speaker 4>All right.

0:41:06.030 --> 0:41:08.370
<v Speaker 1>And finally, we can all read it behind you there. Matt,

0:41:08.430 --> 0:41:11.410
<v Speaker 1>what is it about backing in Aussie pineapples that you

0:41:11.430 --> 0:41:12.300
<v Speaker 1>want people to know?

0:41:14.340 --> 0:41:17.279
<v Speaker 15>Well, I just want to stop this crazy idea that

0:41:17.300 --> 0:41:20.220
<v Speaker 15>we would import pineapples from India and Indonesia. It's currently

0:41:20.239 --> 0:41:23.660
<v Speaker 15>a draft report from the Government Department of Agriculture. Go

0:41:23.680 --> 0:41:26.200
<v Speaker 15>to protectourpineapples.com.au if you want to sign up to stop

0:41:26.219 --> 0:41:28.589
<v Speaker 15>this madness because there's a lot of diseases over there,

0:41:28.610 --> 0:41:30.529
<v Speaker 15>a lot of bugs that we don't have and it

0:41:30.550 --> 0:41:33.390
<v Speaker 15>would devastate our pineapple industry and I'm here in Yippoon,

0:41:33.410 --> 0:41:35.890
<v Speaker 15>the centre of that. We don't want it. We don't

0:41:35.910 --> 0:41:38.529
<v Speaker 15>want those diseases here. We've got enough great Australian pineapples here.

0:41:38.570 --> 0:41:38.910
<v Speaker 4>Bye then.

0:41:39.719 --> 0:41:42.380
<v Speaker 1>Protectourpineapples.com.au or. org. au?

0:41:44.239 --> 0:41:46.180
<v Speaker 4>Dot com. Dot au. There you go.

0:41:46.280 --> 0:41:49.759
<v Speaker 1>Protectourpineapples.com.au. Thank you, lads. Do appreciate it. Look forward to

0:41:49.800 --> 0:41:51.520
<v Speaker 1>seeing you again next week. All right, in a moment

0:41:51.560 --> 0:41:55.359
<v Speaker 1>or two's time, an insider from the Victorian Police. How

0:41:55.400 --> 0:41:58.180
<v Speaker 1>would an investigation work about what has happened this evening

0:41:58.310 --> 0:42:01.150
<v Speaker 1>with the breaking news about Helen Haynes, a politician being

0:42:01.530 --> 0:42:07.110
<v Speaker 1>directly targeted, the results critical injuries and a change potentially

0:42:07.150 --> 0:42:12.029
<v Speaker 1>to our politics forever? The moment by moment matters and

0:42:12.070 --> 0:42:18.820
<v Speaker 1>a person who's lived it will join us next. Charlie

0:42:18.840 --> 0:42:22.900
<v Speaker 1>Benzina is a former detective with the Victoria Police. I

0:42:22.940 --> 0:42:25.780
<v Speaker 1>wanted to talk to him tonight because there are many

0:42:25.880 --> 0:42:29.379
<v Speaker 1>elements to what is being investigated right now. This, of course,

0:42:29.420 --> 0:42:32.600
<v Speaker 1>is the situation of Helen Haynes. The front pages are

0:42:32.660 --> 0:42:36.360
<v Speaker 1>dominated by this around the country. Of course, the local

0:42:37.160 --> 0:42:41.930
<v Speaker 1>paper in Victoria, the Herald Sun, targeted hit on Victorian

0:42:42.090 --> 0:42:44.920
<v Speaker 1>MP with a picture of Helen Haynes on the front page. cover.

0:42:44.980 --> 0:42:49.080
<v Speaker 1>The same headline is there for the advertiser in Adelaide.

0:42:49.660 --> 0:42:54.560
<v Speaker 1>The national paper, the Australian, is car attack on MP. Again,

0:42:54.739 --> 0:42:57.960
<v Speaker 1>Prime Minister has said here that this was targeted. This

0:42:58.040 --> 0:43:01.750
<v Speaker 1>is not an accident. The exact political motivation, of course,

0:43:01.770 --> 0:43:04.089
<v Speaker 1>we do not know. right now. But as I said,

0:43:04.350 --> 0:43:06.410
<v Speaker 1>Charlie joins us now to talk about what might be

0:43:06.450 --> 0:43:09.450
<v Speaker 1>happening on the inside of the situation right now. Charlie,

0:43:09.489 --> 0:43:11.649
<v Speaker 1>nice to talk to you. I'm sorry, these are the circumstances.

0:43:12.070 --> 0:43:13.750
<v Speaker 1>So give us an idea. We're in a period of

0:43:13.770 --> 0:43:16.290
<v Speaker 1>time when there is a person who is sitting with

0:43:16.350 --> 0:43:19.530
<v Speaker 1>police right now, but there is no further statement, no charges,

0:43:19.610 --> 0:43:22.149
<v Speaker 1>nothing else that's going on right now. What do you

0:43:22.430 --> 0:43:25.609
<v Speaker 1>know would be happening in an investigation like this?

0:43:26.930 --> 0:43:30.910
<v Speaker 14>Well, I see Albanese is thrown behind at the Federal

0:43:30.989 --> 0:43:35.280
<v Speaker 14>Police ASIO and the other anti-terrorist agents.

0:43:35.360 --> 0:43:38.839
<v Speaker 12>And they're obviously going for a worst-case scenario.

0:43:39.480 --> 0:43:42.870
<v Speaker 14>I don't really know, and I'm not heard officially, that

0:43:42.890 --> 0:43:46.950
<v Speaker 14>this has been a targeted attack. So are they just speculating,

0:43:47.010 --> 0:43:49.049
<v Speaker 14>as the media happen to do, and put fear into

0:43:49.090 --> 0:43:51.890
<v Speaker 14>the community? You know, let's just wait for the investigation

0:43:51.910 --> 0:43:54.739
<v Speaker 14>to proceed. The promise of the investigation will remain with

0:43:54.780 --> 0:43:58.000
<v Speaker 14>Victoria Police, whilst the federal agencies will be in support

0:43:58.020 --> 0:44:01.379
<v Speaker 14>of that. Sure, she is a political figure, and they've

0:44:01.400 --> 0:44:03.440
<v Speaker 14>got to look at it quite seriously in relation to that.

0:44:03.820 --> 0:44:06.380
<v Speaker 14>What would be happening now is, apart from any interview,

0:44:07.200 --> 0:44:09.440
<v Speaker 14>a thorough search of his motor car, they'd be taking

0:44:09.480 --> 0:44:12.799
<v Speaker 14>out warrants in relation to his premises to look at

0:44:12.840 --> 0:44:17.020
<v Speaker 14>his computers, et cetera, et cetera, and his social media

0:44:17.440 --> 0:44:19.800
<v Speaker 14>and see if there's any particular motivation one way or

0:44:19.820 --> 0:44:21.970
<v Speaker 14>the other. But they've got to sift through all this

0:44:22.030 --> 0:44:24.689
<v Speaker 14>information to just see what the situation was.

0:44:24.969 --> 0:44:26.870
<v Speaker 12>And the fact that a knife was found in the

0:44:26.910 --> 0:44:27.830
<v Speaker 12>car wouldn't put too.

0:44:27.730 --> 0:44:30.870
<v Speaker 14>Much weight on that either because it's a country area

0:44:31.710 --> 0:44:34.230
<v Speaker 14>and probably every second car's got a knife of some sort,

0:44:34.270 --> 0:44:36.790
<v Speaker 14>a pocket knife or whatever the case may be. Let

0:44:36.950 --> 0:44:40.180
<v Speaker 14>the investigation take its course and then let's wait for

0:44:40.200 --> 0:44:43.160
<v Speaker 14>the police to make an official announcement to see if

0:44:43.180 --> 0:44:45.759
<v Speaker 14>it was targeted. You know, she's at the back of

0:44:45.800 --> 0:44:48.920
<v Speaker 14>a motor car taking things out and the car has

0:44:48.940 --> 0:44:52.379
<v Speaker 14>driven into her somehow. And then he's been apprehended by

0:44:52.400 --> 0:44:56.420
<v Speaker 14>the local community, which is a great result for the

0:44:56.460 --> 0:44:59.950
<v Speaker 14>police to start sorting things out. So it's a step-by-step,

0:45:00.090 --> 0:45:04.450
<v Speaker 14>a thorough investigation simply because of her status in our community.

0:45:04.830 --> 0:45:06.950
<v Speaker 1>Yeah, a really good point about caution. And again, the

0:45:06.989 --> 0:45:10.509
<v Speaker 1>little chunks of information that we hear as we go along, right?

0:45:10.969 --> 0:45:12.469
<v Speaker 1>And again, that's why I wanted to get you on

0:45:12.790 --> 0:45:17.520
<v Speaker 1>to help calm the situation and tell us... the step-by-step here. Again,

0:45:17.600 --> 0:45:23.040
<v Speaker 1>in terms of the investigation, obviously the Wangaratta Police closest

0:45:23.100 --> 0:45:26.110
<v Speaker 1>to it, but you've got, as you said, the AFP,

0:45:26.120 --> 0:45:28.569
<v Speaker 1>you've got the Premier, so you've got a whole bunch

0:45:28.610 --> 0:45:31.710
<v Speaker 1>of people taking an interest from Canberra or from Melbourne.

0:45:32.410 --> 0:45:35.089
<v Speaker 1>This thing happened at 3.30 this afternoon. Would this still

0:45:35.150 --> 0:45:38.230
<v Speaker 1>be something that is being investigated by a detective in

0:45:38.330 --> 0:45:41.230
<v Speaker 1>Wangaratta or they've been told to stand aside and the

0:45:41.250 --> 0:45:43.630
<v Speaker 1>physical time it took for somebody to fly or drive

0:45:43.750 --> 0:45:46.620
<v Speaker 1>to get there is the difference between the D being

0:45:46.960 --> 0:45:48.020
<v Speaker 1>on the ground or not?

0:45:49.080 --> 0:45:51.500
<v Speaker 12>Well, I think the primacy would be certainly initially with

0:45:51.540 --> 0:45:54.240
<v Speaker 12>the Wangaratta detectives and then it would be up to

0:45:54.320 --> 0:45:57.290
<v Speaker 12>either police command here in Victoria to ascertain whether to

0:45:57.310 --> 0:46:01.330
<v Speaker 12>give it to their specialist units, the counter-terrorism units within Melbourne,

0:46:01.590 --> 0:46:02.029
<v Speaker 12>because they are.

0:46:01.989 --> 0:46:04.569
<v Speaker 14>The specialist groups. Who knows what the background of this

0:46:04.630 --> 0:46:07.220
<v Speaker 14>particular person is? He might be a sovereign citizen, he

0:46:07.260 --> 0:46:10.580
<v Speaker 14>might be religiously a fanatic. Who knows what the case

0:46:10.620 --> 0:46:13.460
<v Speaker 14>may be? They'd be looking at all their intelligence holdings

0:46:13.480 --> 0:46:14.880
<v Speaker 14>to see if this person's been.

0:46:14.739 --> 0:46:17.719
<v Speaker 12>On their radar, who are his associates and so forth

0:46:17.760 --> 0:46:18.219
<v Speaker 12>and so on.

0:46:18.239 --> 0:46:21.460
<v Speaker 14>What's his background? Is he actually an Australian citizen? Is

0:46:21.500 --> 0:46:25.410
<v Speaker 14>he of an ethnic background? All these things have to

0:46:25.489 --> 0:46:29.950
<v Speaker 14>play a particular role. You go where the evidence takes

0:46:29.969 --> 0:46:32.089
<v Speaker 14>you in relation to this. And I think it's been

0:46:32.130 --> 0:46:35.580
<v Speaker 14>a knee-jerk reaction by the media to start making this.

0:46:35.510 --> 0:46:37.580
<v Speaker 12>A targeted attack, a targeted attack.

0:46:37.860 --> 0:46:40.600
<v Speaker 14>You know, let's just wait, let the waters calm, but

0:46:40.640 --> 0:46:42.580
<v Speaker 14>I think they'd have the right people on the ground.

0:46:42.800 --> 0:46:46.100
<v Speaker 14>And as I said earlier, all these federal agencies assisting

0:46:46.140 --> 0:46:50.000
<v Speaker 14>Victoria Police, the promise will remain with the Victoria Police,

0:46:50.640 --> 0:46:53.759
<v Speaker 14>assisting the Wangaratta ones who are on the ground, but

0:46:53.900 --> 0:46:56.640
<v Speaker 14>I think ones from Melbourne would be travelling up there, absolutely.

0:46:57.110 --> 0:46:58.930
<v Speaker 1>Do you think that it was a mistake from the

0:46:58.950 --> 0:47:01.160
<v Speaker 1>Prime Minister to go as early as he did with

0:47:01.480 --> 0:47:05.000
<v Speaker 1>what he has said tonight? Because it was his intervention

0:47:05.040 --> 0:47:07.879
<v Speaker 1>at 7pm, which has been the lead that we've been

0:47:07.920 --> 0:47:11.350
<v Speaker 1>following here, about targeted, about not being an accident, in

0:47:11.370 --> 0:47:13.469
<v Speaker 1>that I understand why any leader wants to get out

0:47:13.510 --> 0:47:16.610
<v Speaker 1>and say, hey, this is what I know, but police

0:47:16.650 --> 0:47:19.009
<v Speaker 1>have to prove something. In fact, I just want to

0:47:19.200 --> 0:47:22.240
<v Speaker 1>play the Prime Minister and then get your to whether

0:47:22.260 --> 0:47:26.509
<v Speaker 1>this is, again, these are finite calls, 50-50 calls, but

0:47:26.570 --> 0:47:29.230
<v Speaker 1>what you thought of this information coming out tonight. Here

0:47:29.290 --> 0:47:29.790
<v Speaker 1>is the PM.

0:47:30.770 --> 0:47:37.070
<v Speaker 7>This was a serious incident and her health issues are serious.

0:47:37.330 --> 0:47:45.360
<v Speaker 7>This wasn't an accident. There was a deliberate act, it

0:47:45.400 --> 0:47:48.640
<v Speaker 7>would appear. We don't know what motivation is.

0:47:49.960 --> 0:47:50.220
<v Speaker 4>Charlie?

0:47:51.510 --> 0:47:54.290
<v Speaker 14>Well, again, I hate to say it, but sometimes we

0:47:54.310 --> 0:47:56.430
<v Speaker 14>know that Albo's a bit of a train wreck in

0:47:56.489 --> 0:47:59.109
<v Speaker 14>relation to coming out with statements that he does make.

0:47:59.130 --> 0:48:02.430
<v Speaker 14>You know, the people on the ground are the appropriate people.

0:48:02.530 --> 0:48:05.950
<v Speaker 14>I can see that the police in Victoria would be

0:48:06.020 --> 0:48:09.360
<v Speaker 14>briefing the Prime Minister and allowing him then to make

0:48:09.700 --> 0:48:12.180
<v Speaker 14>that accusation. And that's all it is, is an accusation

0:48:12.760 --> 0:48:14.899
<v Speaker 14>based on what I don't know. And then the police

0:48:14.920 --> 0:48:17.740
<v Speaker 14>not coming out. It's an embarrassment to the Victoria Police

0:48:17.760 --> 0:48:20.719
<v Speaker 14>if that was the case. So I think he's gone premature...

0:48:20.910 --> 0:48:23.430
<v Speaker 14>and there's things he probably doesn't know. But at the

0:48:23.450 --> 0:48:25.109
<v Speaker 14>end of the day, I think he wants to put

0:48:25.150 --> 0:48:27.350
<v Speaker 14>himself out there, but I think inappropriately.

0:48:27.870 --> 0:48:29.930
<v Speaker 1>Good on you, Charlie. Really appreciate the conversation. Look forward

0:48:29.950 --> 0:48:30.720
<v Speaker 1>to having another one soon.

0:48:31.320 --> 0:48:31.680
<v Speaker 12>Thanks, Paul.

0:48:31.820 --> 0:48:33.380
<v Speaker 1>Good on you. Thank you very much. Charlie Bezzina is

0:48:33.420 --> 0:48:36.040
<v Speaker 1>his name, former detective with the Victoria Police. He's also

0:48:36.060 --> 0:48:38.500
<v Speaker 1>a great author. Speaker as well. Go find him online.

0:48:38.640 --> 0:48:40.480
<v Speaker 1>Quick break. Back with more here on Paul Murray Live.

0:48:40.820 --> 0:48:42.590
<v Speaker 1>Plenty more coverage on this, but the rest of the

0:48:42.620 --> 0:48:44.430
<v Speaker 1>day and a look around the corner about what's happening

0:48:44.510 --> 0:48:50.400
<v Speaker 1>tomorrow with the late debate. That's it. We're done. The

0:48:50.440 --> 0:48:52.360
<v Speaker 1>Late Debate is next. We'll see you again tomorrow.