WEBVTT - The Bolt Report | 7 October

0:00:15.970 --> 0:00:20.710
<v Speaker 1>Tonight, the October 7th anniversary, today, the murder of 1,200

0:00:20.710 --> 0:00:25.360
<v Speaker 1>Israelis that day was bad enough and the three years

0:00:25.420 --> 0:00:29.420
<v Speaker 1>since have been actually terrifying. Also tonight, a shock poll

0:00:29.440 --> 0:00:31.700
<v Speaker 1>for Labor. There's time running out for the Prime Minister

0:00:31.740 --> 0:00:34.880
<v Speaker 1>and his failed Treasurer. And the French Civil War just

0:00:34.920 --> 0:00:38.040
<v Speaker 1>gets worse, with the hard left again joining with other

0:00:38.100 --> 0:00:44.990
<v Speaker 1>enemies of our civilisation. Plenty more tonight. But first, today

0:00:45.030 --> 0:00:48.449
<v Speaker 1>came another mad attack on our wealth. The High Court said,

0:00:48.470 --> 0:00:53.120
<v Speaker 1>hang on, a New South Wales coal mine... Wicked coal,

0:00:53.700 --> 0:00:57.540
<v Speaker 1>a mine at Mount Pleasant, can't extend operations unless it

0:00:57.600 --> 0:01:00.680
<v Speaker 1>proves it's tried as much as possible to stop emissions

0:01:00.760 --> 0:01:06.370
<v Speaker 1>caused by the coal it sends overseas. Global warming, you

0:01:06.390 --> 0:01:09.230
<v Speaker 1>got it. Now, if this becomes the new rule and

0:01:09.270 --> 0:01:11.649
<v Speaker 1>not just the New South Wales, our coal exports could

0:01:11.690 --> 0:01:16.010
<v Speaker 1>be destroyed by activists, including, of course, activist judges. That's

0:01:16.050 --> 0:01:19.750
<v Speaker 1>our second biggest export now under threat. $ 70 billion a year.

0:01:21.980 --> 0:01:24.500
<v Speaker 1>when we're buried in debt, when our standard of living

0:01:24.560 --> 0:01:28.730
<v Speaker 1>is already falling. Honestly, let me repeat a great truth

0:01:28.770 --> 0:01:31.790
<v Speaker 1>that our governments still don't get. It's not global warming

0:01:32.650 --> 0:01:38.350
<v Speaker 1>that could destroy Australia. It's global warming policies. That's what's

0:01:38.390 --> 0:01:42.550
<v Speaker 1>making us poorer and making life harder. And where has

0:01:42.670 --> 0:01:45.790
<v Speaker 1>our climate change and energy minister been while the High

0:01:45.850 --> 0:01:50.610
<v Speaker 1>Court puts a torpedo through our coal exports? Well, Chris

0:01:50.650 --> 0:01:55.830
<v Speaker 1>Bowen was... at his farcical climate conference in Tuvalu, a

0:01:55.950 --> 0:01:59.670
<v Speaker 1>conference which cost us more than $ 20 million, designed to

0:02:00.390 --> 0:02:04.110
<v Speaker 1>scare us and our judges and everyone else into a

0:02:04.310 --> 0:02:07.830
<v Speaker 1>frenzy about coal. But there he was actually nodding off,

0:02:07.920 --> 0:02:10.980
<v Speaker 1>couldn't keep his eyes open, which says it all. I mean,

0:02:11.000 --> 0:02:12.940
<v Speaker 1>if Bowen really thought his conference had to save the

0:02:12.960 --> 0:02:15.860
<v Speaker 1>planet from a climate apocalypse that could kill us all,

0:02:16.480 --> 0:02:23.570
<v Speaker 1>wouldn't he be wide awake with urgency, not closed-eyed with boredom? Now,

0:02:23.600 --> 0:02:27.710
<v Speaker 1>it's true, Prime Minister Anthony Albanese, who foolishly joined Bowen's circus,

0:02:27.750 --> 0:02:31.690
<v Speaker 1>did yesterday try to give a big wakey-wakey to the

0:02:31.770 --> 0:02:35.750
<v Speaker 1>embarrassingly few world leaders and Chris Bowen, who accepted Bowen's

0:02:35.790 --> 0:02:40.750
<v Speaker 1>invitation to come watch him play Planet Saver. But Albanese

0:02:40.770 --> 0:02:41.880
<v Speaker 1>just made a fool of himself.

0:02:42.940 --> 0:02:47.400
<v Speaker 2>The forecast of Super El Nino may test us all.

0:02:48.600 --> 0:02:54.800
<v Speaker 2>In Australia, we're expecting a summer of floods... of cyclones

0:02:55.860 --> 0:03:01.340
<v Speaker 2>of extreme heat and extreme behaviour. Because the science told

0:03:01.419 --> 0:03:05.700
<v Speaker 2>us that if we didn't act to address global emissions,

0:03:06.139 --> 0:03:08.900
<v Speaker 2>this is precisely what would occur.

0:03:11.320 --> 0:03:15.590
<v Speaker 1>Yet again, more alarmist bull from a scientific ignoramus. But

0:03:15.750 --> 0:03:19.930
<v Speaker 1>did you hear one journalist there, you know, question him,

0:03:20.410 --> 0:03:25.470
<v Speaker 1>correct him? One, does Albanese really think there's been no

0:03:25.630 --> 0:03:31.179
<v Speaker 1>El Nino before? It happened every few years. Two, does

0:03:31.240 --> 0:03:35.180
<v Speaker 1>Albanese seriously think that Australia could stop cyclones or floods

0:03:35.280 --> 0:03:39.840
<v Speaker 1>or an El Nino by cutting our tiny emissions? Come

0:03:39.880 --> 0:03:44.330
<v Speaker 1>off it. And three, does Albanese really not know that

0:03:44.940 --> 0:03:49.140
<v Speaker 1>Australia and Tuvalu have in fact both had fewer cyclones

0:03:49.540 --> 0:03:53.540
<v Speaker 1>over the past four decades of global warming, and fewer

0:03:53.580 --> 0:04:00.270
<v Speaker 1>severe ones? Not more cyclones, Prime Minister, but fewer. For instance,

0:04:00.590 --> 0:04:03.930
<v Speaker 1>the Australian-funded Climate and Ocean Support Programme in the Pacific

0:04:04.610 --> 0:04:07.650
<v Speaker 1>said four years ago, in the Greater South West Pacific...

0:04:08.300 --> 0:04:13.340
<v Speaker 1>which includes Tuvalu, the total number of severe tropical cyclones

0:04:13.380 --> 0:04:19.050
<v Speaker 1>has decreased over the last 40 seasons. And the number

0:04:19.070 --> 0:04:22.630
<v Speaker 1>of tropical cyclones that became severe events has marginally declined.

0:04:23.190 --> 0:04:28.860
<v Speaker 1>Fewer cyclones, not more. The opposite of what Albanese was saying.

0:04:29.140 --> 0:04:33.339
<v Speaker 1>And that's thanks to global warming. Same with Australia. Nor

0:04:33.400 --> 0:04:35.960
<v Speaker 1>is that the end of the good news that global

0:04:36.000 --> 0:04:40.669
<v Speaker 1>warming has brought. As our CSIRO admits, the earth is

0:04:40.710 --> 0:04:45.890
<v Speaker 1>now getting greener, especially in Australia, thanks in part to

0:04:45.950 --> 0:04:49.650
<v Speaker 1>our emissions. And we're getting more rain than a century ago.

0:04:50.000 --> 0:04:53.700
<v Speaker 1>Fewer cyclones, more rain, more greening. Should Albanese and Bowen

0:04:53.779 --> 0:04:58.440
<v Speaker 1>really be trying to stop all that? So let me

0:04:58.480 --> 0:05:01.700
<v Speaker 1>sum up the madness of their global warming crusade. Albanese

0:05:01.740 --> 0:05:04.289
<v Speaker 1>and Bowen want to spend billions we do not have

0:05:05.010 --> 0:05:08.010
<v Speaker 1>on green schemes that do not work. to stop a

0:05:08.050 --> 0:05:12.580
<v Speaker 1>climate catastrophe that does not exist. And I think many

0:05:12.620 --> 0:05:17.520
<v Speaker 1>people are now waking up to this incredible reality. They're

0:05:17.540 --> 0:05:20.200
<v Speaker 1>now counting the horrendous cost of this con of pretending

0:05:20.240 --> 0:05:24.480
<v Speaker 1>to stop global warming. I reckon that's why this pre-conference

0:05:24.560 --> 0:05:28.610
<v Speaker 1>conference over there in Fiji and Tuvalu has been such

0:05:28.650 --> 0:05:32.770
<v Speaker 1>a flop. This specific frolic organised by Chris Bowen as

0:05:33.130 --> 0:05:36.770
<v Speaker 1>President of Negotiations at next month's United Nations Climate Conference

0:05:36.790 --> 0:05:41.540
<v Speaker 1>conference in Turkey. Bowen asked world leaders to join him

0:05:42.300 --> 0:05:45.339
<v Speaker 1>in this pre-conference conference to work up a joint agenda

0:05:45.360 --> 0:05:49.539
<v Speaker 1>for the Turkey meeting. But just two non-Pacific leaders turned up.

0:05:51.000 --> 0:05:54.880
<v Speaker 1>They were from Minos. I mean, East Timor, the Maldives.

0:05:56.560 --> 0:05:59.020
<v Speaker 1>The turnout was so thin that Bowen had to get

0:05:59.100 --> 0:06:02.860
<v Speaker 1>two failed Labor leaders, New Zealand's Jacinda Ardern and Australia's

0:06:03.180 --> 0:06:07.500
<v Speaker 1>Julia Gillard, to come be the guest speakers, despite neither

0:06:07.540 --> 0:06:11.640
<v Speaker 1>being remotely a global warming expert. They were just there

0:06:11.660 --> 0:06:15.359
<v Speaker 1>to say, go Chris, you know, you beaut. It was

0:06:15.400 --> 0:06:19.640
<v Speaker 1>also embarrassing that Albanese seemed to be hiding from reporters.

0:06:19.839 --> 0:06:23.920
<v Speaker 1>He didn't answer a single question before flying back home,

0:06:23.960 --> 0:06:25.340
<v Speaker 1>leaving Bowen to carry the can.

0:06:26.339 --> 0:06:27.900
<v Speaker 3>If you want to talk about scrutiny, this is my

0:06:27.960 --> 0:06:30.680
<v Speaker 3>second press conference of pre-cop. The only reason I didn't

0:06:30.700 --> 0:06:32.610
<v Speaker 3>hold a press conference yesterday is because I was coming

0:06:32.640 --> 0:06:35.450
<v Speaker 3>and going to Tuvalu and didn't get back until well

0:06:35.470 --> 0:06:40.790
<v Speaker 3>into the evening. I'm here as the ministerial counterpart of Linda.

0:06:40.890 --> 0:06:44.630
<v Speaker 3>I'm holding a press conference today. Linda, unfortunately, the Prime

0:06:44.650 --> 0:06:46.820
<v Speaker 3>Minister of Fiji hasn't held a press conference either. Leaders

0:06:47.180 --> 0:06:49.960
<v Speaker 3>are engaged with each other. I'm here answering questions and

0:06:50.000 --> 0:06:50.800
<v Speaker 3>will do again tomorrow.

0:06:54.880 --> 0:06:58.040
<v Speaker 1>I mean, really, I'm guessing even Albanese actually now realises

0:06:58.080 --> 0:07:00.480
<v Speaker 1>there are a few votes left in pretending to stop

0:07:00.520 --> 0:07:04.060
<v Speaker 1>global warming when Australians are now counting the price of

0:07:04.080 --> 0:07:08.890
<v Speaker 1>just trying from paying huge prices for electricity to wasting

0:07:09.070 --> 0:07:14.620
<v Speaker 1>billions on dud green schemes like... Chris Bone's green hydrogen projects,

0:07:14.800 --> 0:07:17.960
<v Speaker 1>what a flop that was too. But from frying pan

0:07:18.000 --> 0:07:21.620
<v Speaker 1>to the fire, because Albanese has flown back to another

0:07:21.670 --> 0:07:26.870
<v Speaker 1>disastrous fallout from his global warming religion, this High Court decision.

0:07:28.890 --> 0:07:31.150
<v Speaker 1>For the first time, the High Court has ruled that

0:07:31.290 --> 0:07:34.930
<v Speaker 1>Australia is not just responsible for its own emissions, we're

0:07:34.970 --> 0:07:39.450
<v Speaker 1>also responsible for the emissions from countries which burn the

0:07:39.530 --> 0:07:44.350
<v Speaker 1>coal they buy from us. It says New South Wales

0:07:44.430 --> 0:07:46.830
<v Speaker 1>law demands that those emissions have to be considered before

0:07:46.880 --> 0:07:50.540
<v Speaker 1>approving mines or mine extensions, even though one mine cannot

0:07:50.600 --> 0:07:56.090
<v Speaker 1>make any difference to global warming that anyone could possibly notice.

0:07:57.830 --> 0:08:02.950
<v Speaker 1>And another telling thing. Environment Minister Murray Watt today didn't

0:08:03.330 --> 0:08:07.270
<v Speaker 1>thank the court for saving the world from dangerous heating,

0:08:07.390 --> 0:08:10.830
<v Speaker 1>for socking it to those wicked coal mines. He instead stressed,

0:08:11.130 --> 0:08:13.120
<v Speaker 1>oh no, this wasn't the government's fault.

0:08:14.070 --> 0:08:16.220
<v Speaker 4>I would make the point that the decision from the

0:08:16.260 --> 0:08:19.020
<v Speaker 4>High Court is in relation to a New South Wales

0:08:19.060 --> 0:08:22.780
<v Speaker 4>government decision based on New South Wales legislation, so it

0:08:22.820 --> 0:08:27.310
<v Speaker 4>doesn't automatically transfer to Commonwealth decisions in or Commonwealth legislation.

0:08:27.360 --> 0:08:30.280
<v Speaker 4>That was a very specific requirement under New South Wales

0:08:30.320 --> 0:08:34.580
<v Speaker 4>law that doesn't exist in Commonwealth law. So at this

0:08:34.660 --> 0:08:37.400
<v Speaker 4>early stage, I wouldn't necessarily say that it will flow

0:08:37.460 --> 0:08:38.860
<v Speaker 4>onto Commonwealth decisions as well.

0:08:40.220 --> 0:08:44.450
<v Speaker 1>Honestly, when even the Environment Minister of this government washes

0:08:44.490 --> 0:08:48.309
<v Speaker 1>his hands of an attack on alcohol, it is clear

0:08:48.350 --> 0:08:52.809
<v Speaker 1>that even Labor hardheads know that this climate religion has

0:08:52.890 --> 0:09:02.079
<v Speaker 1>become a curse. I was joined a short while ago

0:09:02.120 --> 0:09:04.860
<v Speaker 1>by Federal Opposition Leader Angus Taylor because he's about to

0:09:04.880 --> 0:09:11.349
<v Speaker 1>go to a memorial service to mark the October 7 massacre.

0:09:11.410 --> 0:09:11.910
<v Speaker 5>Good on him.

0:09:11.970 --> 0:09:15.770
<v Speaker 1>But this is our discussion. Angus Taylor, thank you so

0:09:15.809 --> 0:09:17.290
<v Speaker 1>much for your time. I want to talk to you

0:09:17.350 --> 0:09:21.689
<v Speaker 1>about the big immigration policy you released yesterday, which I

0:09:21.730 --> 0:09:25.050
<v Speaker 1>think is a good move. But first, this High Court decision.

0:09:25.850 --> 0:09:28.929
<v Speaker 1>that says a coal mine in New South Wales has

0:09:28.960 --> 0:09:32.840
<v Speaker 1>to account for emissions caused when its coal is burnt

0:09:32.880 --> 0:09:37.420
<v Speaker 1>by customers overseas for their power or for their smelting.

0:09:37.860 --> 0:09:39.380
<v Speaker 1>How serious is this?

0:09:39.980 --> 0:09:43.459
<v Speaker 6>It's very serious, Andrew, and thank you for having me.

0:09:43.540 --> 0:09:47.970
<v Speaker 6>This is activist lawfare and this is legislation from the

0:09:48.010 --> 0:09:50.890
<v Speaker 6>New South Wales government which is enabling it and what

0:09:50.929 --> 0:09:54.390
<v Speaker 6>it effectively means is is this mine is accountable for

0:09:54.410 --> 0:09:57.420
<v Speaker 6>the emissions of its customers. Now, that's never been a

0:09:58.040 --> 0:10:03.360
<v Speaker 6>principle that is... is usable or makes any sense at all, Andrew.

0:10:03.540 --> 0:10:07.929
<v Speaker 6>And the Minsk government should eliminate this legislation, should abolish it.

0:10:08.830 --> 0:10:11.390
<v Speaker 5>And if they don't and they should and if they.

0:10:11.309 --> 0:10:14.890
<v Speaker 6>Don't, then the Albanese government should do the same thing

0:10:15.070 --> 0:10:15.910
<v Speaker 6>at the federal level.

0:10:16.510 --> 0:10:18.250
<v Speaker 5>This is completely unacceptable.

0:10:18.309 --> 0:10:20.770
<v Speaker 6>The idea that a mine should be accountable for its

0:10:20.840 --> 0:10:23.500
<v Speaker 6>emissions and that should be taken into account for its

0:10:23.559 --> 0:10:27.180
<v Speaker 6>customers emissions and that should be taken into account is

0:10:27.340 --> 0:10:30.859
<v Speaker 6>total madness. And it will lead to the death of

0:10:30.960 --> 0:10:33.000
<v Speaker 6>our mining industry if it is to continue.

0:10:35.280 --> 0:10:37.480
<v Speaker 1>Now, I know the three of the five judges ruled

0:10:37.500 --> 0:10:40.210
<v Speaker 1>for this, and they're looking at New South Wales legislation,

0:10:40.570 --> 0:10:45.729
<v Speaker 1>what it allegedly obliges companies and planning authorities to do

0:10:45.910 --> 0:10:49.360
<v Speaker 1>in New South Wales. But I wonder whether this means

0:10:49.410 --> 0:10:53.300
<v Speaker 1>we should pull out of legal obligations overseas, like the

0:10:53.640 --> 0:10:57.540
<v Speaker 1>Paris Treaty, which would encourage judges to say, well, this

0:10:57.610 --> 0:11:00.550
<v Speaker 1>is international law or we sign these treaties and this

0:11:00.590 --> 0:11:03.510
<v Speaker 1>is our obligation. Do you think that you would you

0:11:03.550 --> 0:11:05.770
<v Speaker 1>have another look at that pulling out of the Paris Treaty?

0:11:05.809 --> 0:11:10.130
<v Speaker 6>Well, can I say there is absolutely nothing that requires this.

0:11:11.010 --> 0:11:13.319
<v Speaker 5>This is on the New South Wales government.

0:11:13.520 --> 0:11:17.339
<v Speaker 6>It's chosen to put this legislation in place and it

0:11:17.420 --> 0:11:20.949
<v Speaker 6>makes no sense whatsoever to And so they should just

0:11:20.970 --> 0:11:22.490
<v Speaker 6>get rid of it. It's got nothing to do with

0:11:22.530 --> 0:11:27.100
<v Speaker 6>international treaties. Andrew, that's another question and a reasonable question

0:11:27.130 --> 0:11:30.059
<v Speaker 6>you ask, but this has got nothing to do with that.

0:11:30.460 --> 0:11:33.100
<v Speaker 6>So the men's government should get rid of it. And

0:11:33.179 --> 0:11:37.760
<v Speaker 6>if they don't, then the Albanese government should enact legislation

0:11:38.090 --> 0:11:38.780
<v Speaker 6>to override it.

0:11:40.750 --> 0:11:43.870
<v Speaker 1>Now, that said, the International Court of Justice has already

0:11:43.890 --> 0:11:47.210
<v Speaker 1>been saying that perhaps that should be that should be

0:11:47.230 --> 0:11:50.050
<v Speaker 1>made obligatory in other countries too. I mean, the fact

0:11:50.190 --> 0:11:52.390
<v Speaker 1>is you sign up to a treaty like that and

0:11:52.429 --> 0:11:55.870
<v Speaker 1>you do, you know, judges do look at it as

0:11:55.929 --> 0:11:57.790
<v Speaker 1>a sign of what we should be doing. This is

0:11:57.809 --> 0:12:02.319
<v Speaker 1>the problem. Your immigration plan, though, to me it seems

0:12:02.860 --> 0:12:05.420
<v Speaker 1>the most considered attempt I've seen from any party for

0:12:05.440 --> 0:12:08.480
<v Speaker 1>a long, long, long time to slash immigration numbers. In fact,

0:12:08.500 --> 0:12:11.300
<v Speaker 1>I haven't seen them slash them. Whether it will work

0:12:11.360 --> 0:12:14.780
<v Speaker 1>or not, there's a debate. It's hard to tell. You know,

0:12:14.860 --> 0:12:17.000
<v Speaker 1>I guess you'll have to live with it if you

0:12:17.059 --> 0:12:19.980
<v Speaker 1>form government and we'll see. But can I ask this?

0:12:22.020 --> 0:12:27.960
<v Speaker 1>What's really made this issue so potent and has driven

0:12:28.100 --> 0:12:32.140
<v Speaker 1>One Nation's vote in particular is the idea that we're

0:12:32.160 --> 0:12:36.740
<v Speaker 1>losing control, that mass immigration is causing us to feel

0:12:36.820 --> 0:12:39.140
<v Speaker 1>strangers in our own home, more danger.

0:12:39.160 --> 0:12:39.600
<v Speaker 5>Less safe.

0:12:42.590 --> 0:12:45.809
<v Speaker 1>What drives you most in proposing these cuts? Is it

0:12:45.830 --> 0:12:49.910
<v Speaker 1>the economics of mass immigration or the social damage that

0:12:50.250 --> 0:12:53.630
<v Speaker 1>mass immigration has done? Is it about the economy or

0:12:53.730 --> 0:12:54.290
<v Speaker 1>our culture?

0:12:54.590 --> 0:12:57.650
<v Speaker 5>Well, it's both, Andrew. It absolutely is both.

0:12:57.770 --> 0:13:01.920
<v Speaker 6>We've seen people come to this country and get visas

0:13:02.640 --> 0:13:04.780
<v Speaker 6>who should never have come to this country and should

0:13:04.820 --> 0:13:08.640
<v Speaker 6>never have been issued visas. One of them was one

0:13:08.679 --> 0:13:12.699
<v Speaker 6>of the shooters at North Bondi just before Christmas last year.

0:13:14.160 --> 0:13:16.720
<v Speaker 6>But it is also true that we have seen record

0:13:17.120 --> 0:13:21.929
<v Speaker 6>levels of immigration under this Labor government, 1.6 million people

0:13:22.850 --> 0:13:25.690
<v Speaker 6>in just over four years. That's more than the population

0:13:25.809 --> 0:13:31.170
<v Speaker 6>of Adelaide. And that is completely unacceptable. It cannot be absorbed.

0:13:31.490 --> 0:13:34.210
<v Speaker 6>It's too big a number, whether it's cultural or economic.

0:13:35.200 --> 0:13:38.680
<v Speaker 6>Our housing, our infrastructure, our services haven't been able to

0:13:38.730 --> 0:13:42.489
<v Speaker 6>keep up. And I said from the moment I came

0:13:42.530 --> 0:13:46.590
<v Speaker 6>into this job that the numbers were too high, the

0:13:46.630 --> 0:13:50.550
<v Speaker 6>standards were too low and both must change. And that's

0:13:50.610 --> 0:13:54.170
<v Speaker 6>a reflection of both the economics and, of course, the

0:13:54.200 --> 0:13:56.340
<v Speaker 6>cultural impact that those kind of numbers have had.

0:13:58.490 --> 0:14:00.550
<v Speaker 1>Yeah, but you get business now saying, well, look, it's

0:14:00.570 --> 0:14:05.750
<v Speaker 1>going to hurt us, you know, making our workers, the

0:14:05.790 --> 0:14:10.439
<v Speaker 1>foreign workers they've sponsored, go back overseas to get an

0:14:10.500 --> 0:14:13.940
<v Speaker 1>extension of their contracts or whatever, of their visas, all

0:14:13.960 --> 0:14:17.300
<v Speaker 1>that kind of stuff. If it actually costs money, if

0:14:17.380 --> 0:14:21.010
<v Speaker 1>it hurts business, is that a small price to pay?

0:14:21.970 --> 0:14:25.530
<v Speaker 1>for the effect on our culture in making sure that

0:14:25.550 --> 0:14:28.210
<v Speaker 1>immigration numbers are brought down?

0:14:28.690 --> 0:14:30.050
<v Speaker 5>Well, I actually don't believe that.

0:14:30.190 --> 0:14:33.330
<v Speaker 6>I mean, any economy or business that is built on

0:14:33.370 --> 0:14:37.620
<v Speaker 6>a guest worker economy has got it wrong. And that's

0:14:37.660 --> 0:14:39.720
<v Speaker 6>exactly what we've seen under this government. We've got up

0:14:39.760 --> 0:14:45.380
<v Speaker 6>to almost 3 million temporary visas. That's over 10% of

0:14:45.400 --> 0:14:50.460
<v Speaker 6>the population now, Andrew. An economy and businesses can't thrive

0:14:50.640 --> 0:14:54.090
<v Speaker 6>on that. And so we're not going to be lectured

0:14:54.390 --> 0:14:57.670
<v Speaker 6>to by vested interests on this. We'll do what's right

0:14:57.710 --> 0:15:00.550
<v Speaker 6>for our nation. And what's right for our nation right now,

0:15:00.690 --> 0:15:04.090
<v Speaker 6>after a record surge of inflation, is a record cut

0:15:04.670 --> 0:15:09.420
<v Speaker 6>in inflation numbers to cut back that guest worker economy,

0:15:09.480 --> 0:15:12.880
<v Speaker 6>to take control of our borders again. You said up

0:15:12.960 --> 0:15:15.340
<v Speaker 6>front it remains to be seen whether this can be done. Well,

0:15:15.360 --> 0:15:19.520
<v Speaker 6>the same was said back in 2012, 2013, of stopping

0:15:19.560 --> 0:15:21.300
<v Speaker 6>the boats and we stopped the boats.

0:15:22.120 --> 0:15:23.260
<v Speaker 5>We've done this before.

0:15:23.420 --> 0:15:26.310
<v Speaker 6>We've regained control of our borders before and we will

0:15:26.370 --> 0:15:28.430
<v Speaker 6>regain control of our borders again.

0:15:31.010 --> 0:15:35.490
<v Speaker 1>Now, you did release your policy yesterday. Today is October

0:15:35.510 --> 0:15:42.810
<v Speaker 1>7th anniversary. As you mentioned, Two, well, the ceremonies are

0:15:42.830 --> 0:15:46.030
<v Speaker 1>being held at Bondi Beach, one of the main ceremonies today,

0:15:46.330 --> 0:15:52.010
<v Speaker 1>which is where we had that slaughter of Jews. One

0:15:52.030 --> 0:15:58.860
<v Speaker 1>of the gunmen being an immigrant, a Muslim immigrant. Is

0:15:58.910 --> 0:16:03.300
<v Speaker 1>the timing here of this a coincidence or did you

0:16:03.320 --> 0:16:08.780
<v Speaker 1>have in mind that, Yes, we will be looking today

0:16:08.900 --> 0:16:13.160
<v Speaker 1>in particular at the threat of Islam, maybe Muslim immigration,

0:16:13.560 --> 0:16:17.340
<v Speaker 1>and your immigration crackdown is part of that.

0:16:18.220 --> 0:16:22.050
<v Speaker 6>Well, there was an absolutely barbaric event on October 7

0:16:22.050 --> 0:16:24.890
<v Speaker 6>and also a barbaric event just before Christmas last year

0:16:25.030 --> 0:16:26.530
<v Speaker 6>at North Bondi.

0:16:26.890 --> 0:16:28.490
<v Speaker 5>I went to Israel.

0:16:28.570 --> 0:16:33.000
<v Speaker 6>I visited the Nova Music Festival site and kibbutz nearby.

0:16:33.000 --> 0:16:39.109
<v Speaker 6>1,200 people slaughtered, slaughtered. by Islamist extremists, Hamas inspired, of course.

0:16:40.350 --> 0:16:43.670
<v Speaker 6>And I saw much of the footage from body cams

0:16:43.850 --> 0:16:46.490
<v Speaker 6>and head cams. I never want to see that again, Andrew.

0:16:46.530 --> 0:16:49.070
<v Speaker 6>It's like nothing I have ever seen before. And it

0:16:49.090 --> 0:16:53.670
<v Speaker 6>was an atrocity. And so absolutely central to our immigration policy.

0:16:54.390 --> 0:16:55.380
<v Speaker 5>Is Australian values.

0:16:55.480 --> 0:16:57.960
<v Speaker 6>We do not want people coming to our country who

0:16:58.000 --> 0:17:01.480
<v Speaker 6>do not share our values. And Islamist extremists do not

0:17:01.540 --> 0:17:04.460
<v Speaker 6>share our values. It is simple as that. And so

0:17:04.480 --> 0:17:09.919
<v Speaker 6>it's so important this evening on today, on October 7,

0:17:09.920 --> 0:17:14.210
<v Speaker 6>that we we remember this. We remember this because this

0:17:14.250 --> 0:17:16.150
<v Speaker 6>should never, ever happen again.

0:17:16.170 --> 0:17:20.149
<v Speaker 1>Now, I totally agree with you that this government has

0:17:20.210 --> 0:17:26.240
<v Speaker 1>lost control over the immigration process. Intake, unbelievable. I mean,

0:17:26.420 --> 0:17:31.679
<v Speaker 1>how could we possibly have more than 400,000 people on

0:17:31.720 --> 0:17:34.570
<v Speaker 1>bridging visas trying to, you know, swap to another visa?

0:17:35.109 --> 0:17:39.949
<v Speaker 1>You say you want to slash that to just 20,000,

0:17:39.950 --> 0:17:42.629
<v Speaker 1>mostly by doing, you know, telling people if you want

0:17:42.650 --> 0:17:44.500
<v Speaker 1>a new visa, go back home and apply for it there.

0:17:45.369 --> 0:17:49.169
<v Speaker 1>Problem is that nearly 90,000 of those bridging visas are

0:17:49.190 --> 0:17:53.430
<v Speaker 1>held by relatives, parents, partners, et cetera, who are already here.

0:17:53.840 --> 0:17:56.459
<v Speaker 1>Are you telling them to leave before applying for visas

0:17:56.500 --> 0:18:00.440
<v Speaker 1>as well? Because, you know, there's the Labor will run

0:18:00.480 --> 0:18:03.900
<v Speaker 1>a scare campaign in migrant communities saying, oh, look, look

0:18:03.940 --> 0:18:06.480
<v Speaker 1>at you. You're being heartless. The people already here.

0:18:06.790 --> 0:18:09.450
<v Speaker 6>Well, we are saying that anyone whose visa has expired

0:18:09.970 --> 0:18:12.570
<v Speaker 6>must go and we will deport them if they don't.

0:18:13.220 --> 0:18:15.639
<v Speaker 6>But in the case you're just talking about, those bridging

0:18:15.660 --> 0:18:19.810
<v Speaker 6>visas will grandfather existing visas. We just won't issue new ones.

0:18:20.570 --> 0:18:23.869
<v Speaker 6>It's as simple as that, Andrew. And that's been taken

0:18:23.930 --> 0:18:27.810
<v Speaker 6>account of in our numbers. And that's going to give

0:18:27.830 --> 0:18:30.610
<v Speaker 6>us those outcomes that I talked about a moment ago.

0:18:31.450 --> 0:18:34.730
<v Speaker 6>Those bridging visas have been abused. Look, we had bridging

0:18:34.750 --> 0:18:36.040
<v Speaker 6>visas at well below 100,000 10 years ago.

0:18:38.130 --> 0:18:41.970
<v Speaker 5>They're now 400,000. It is very clear this is being abused.

0:18:41.990 --> 0:18:43.270
<v Speaker 5>So if someone wants.

0:18:44.570 --> 0:18:46.470
<v Speaker 6>To get a secondary visa, if they're on a visa

0:18:46.490 --> 0:18:48.770
<v Speaker 6>and it expires and they want another one, they should

0:18:48.810 --> 0:18:52.760
<v Speaker 6>go back offshore, apply. And if they qualify, they can

0:18:52.800 --> 0:18:55.680
<v Speaker 6>come back. But they should be the people we want.

0:18:55.840 --> 0:18:58.619
<v Speaker 6>We need to put Australia first and we need to

0:18:58.660 --> 0:19:00.760
<v Speaker 6>get the skills that are right for our country.

0:19:00.840 --> 0:19:02.840
<v Speaker 5>And that has not been happening under Labor.

0:19:03.660 --> 0:19:05.440
<v Speaker 1>Angus Thaler, thank you so much for your time.

0:19:05.900 --> 0:19:06.600
<v Speaker 5>Good to be with you, Andrew.

0:19:09.690 --> 0:19:14.090
<v Speaker 1>After the break, Labor's vote falls to the worst ever recorded.

0:19:14.690 --> 0:19:18.590
<v Speaker 1>Is the game over for Anthony Albanese and his failed treasurer?

0:19:24.520 --> 0:19:27.520
<v Speaker 1>The wheels really are falling off the Albanese government. I mean,

0:19:27.540 --> 0:19:31.300
<v Speaker 1>you just look at this week so far. You've got

0:19:31.340 --> 0:19:34.460
<v Speaker 1>coal exports being attacked by global warming policies of the kind,

0:19:34.520 --> 0:19:37.340
<v Speaker 1>you know, this government promotes. And you've got business in

0:19:37.380 --> 0:19:42.050
<v Speaker 1>revolt over the credit card surcharge ban that Albanese falsely

0:19:42.109 --> 0:19:46.190
<v Speaker 1>claimed would cut prices. Another terrible week, of course, for

0:19:46.609 --> 0:19:50.980
<v Speaker 1>home auctions last weekend after Albanese's tax hits on negative

0:19:51.020 --> 0:19:53.500
<v Speaker 1>gearing and capital gains. When I say Albanese, I include,

0:19:53.880 --> 0:19:58.330
<v Speaker 1>of course, Treasurer Jim Chalmers. The Prime Minister, meanwhile, faffing

0:19:58.390 --> 0:20:02.290
<v Speaker 1>around at that farce of his $ 20 million climate conference.

0:20:02.350 --> 0:20:06.030
<v Speaker 1>And when the opposition yesterday unveiled this big new immigration plan...

0:20:06.619 --> 0:20:09.300
<v Speaker 1>The government couldn't come up with a word of criticism,

0:20:09.359 --> 0:20:11.879
<v Speaker 1>like it was distracted or I don't know what it is.

0:20:12.500 --> 0:20:17.040
<v Speaker 1>So no wonder today's News 24 Pulse poll shows Labor

0:20:17.160 --> 0:20:21.910
<v Speaker 1>falling to the lowest primary vote support that is ever recorded,

0:20:21.950 --> 0:20:26.209
<v Speaker 1>just 25% of voters, 25%. That's three points behind One

0:20:26.250 --> 0:20:29.090
<v Speaker 1>Nation now. Nearly a million and a half fewer Labor

0:20:29.130 --> 0:20:33.750
<v Speaker 1>voters today than at last year's elections. The coalition, though,

0:20:33.770 --> 0:20:36.960
<v Speaker 1>of course, still trails at 21%. Joining me are Cameron Milner,

0:20:37.000 --> 0:20:39.200
<v Speaker 1>former Chief of Staff to Labor leader Bill Shorten, now

0:20:39.260 --> 0:20:43.280
<v Speaker 1>Director of GXO Strategies. If you're in the shtook, go

0:20:43.320 --> 0:20:46.739
<v Speaker 1>to Cameron. And Holly Hughes, former Liberal Senator, now with

0:20:46.820 --> 0:20:50.960
<v Speaker 1>One Nation. Cameron, things are so bad that Sherry Markson

0:20:51.000 --> 0:20:52.760
<v Speaker 1>on a show last night said some in New South

0:20:52.800 --> 0:20:56.140
<v Speaker 1>Wales Labor want Anthony Albany's sack. Sack, Jim Chalmers. You

0:20:56.160 --> 0:21:01.350
<v Speaker 1>yourself wrote something very similar yesterday, that it could be defenested,

0:21:01.730 --> 0:21:05.530
<v Speaker 1>although I... Think the chances of Albanese sacking Chalmers are

0:21:05.590 --> 0:21:09.990
<v Speaker 1>quite low, or am I wrong? Well, I think we're

0:21:10.030 --> 0:21:11.290
<v Speaker 1>in uncharted waters, Andrew.

0:21:11.350 --> 0:21:13.510
<v Speaker 7>I mean, this is a situation where Labor's primary is

0:21:13.530 --> 0:21:16.649
<v Speaker 7>the worst since Federation, worst in 125 years.

0:21:16.990 --> 0:21:18.510
<v Speaker 1>So this is in uncharted territory.

0:21:18.869 --> 0:21:21.090
<v Speaker 7>And, you know, Jim Chalmers and Anthony Albanese are the

0:21:21.150 --> 0:21:24.280
<v Speaker 7>Thelma and Louise, Thelma and Louise of Australian politics right now,

0:21:24.540 --> 0:21:27.040
<v Speaker 7>driving Labor across the cliff because the Labor primary hasn't

0:21:27.080 --> 0:21:27.580
<v Speaker 7>found a floor.

0:21:27.960 --> 0:21:29.580
<v Speaker 5>It's in freefall, Andrew, freefall.

0:21:29.940 --> 0:21:34.100
<v Speaker 7>And in uncharted times and unprecedented times, you know, extreme

0:21:34.140 --> 0:21:35.859
<v Speaker 7>action needs to be taken. And if they can't get

0:21:35.900 --> 0:21:37.940
<v Speaker 7>rid of Albo, the New South Wales right is coming

0:21:37.980 --> 0:21:38.720
<v Speaker 7>after Jim Chalmers.

0:21:40.920 --> 0:21:44.000
<v Speaker 1>Yeah, but Thelma and Louise went over the cliff together.

0:21:44.280 --> 0:21:47.220
<v Speaker 1>They were inseparable. I don't know that Albanese can separate

0:21:47.240 --> 0:21:49.000
<v Speaker 1>himself from Jim Chalmers, Holly.

0:21:49.970 --> 0:21:52.290
<v Speaker 8>I'm not sure they could pick up Brad Pitt either, but,

0:21:52.350 --> 0:21:56.170
<v Speaker 8>you know, hey, what would I know? But honestly, I mean,

0:21:56.730 --> 0:21:59.670
<v Speaker 8>these two are just a clown act and they are

0:21:59.770 --> 0:22:04.310
<v Speaker 8>completely destroying this country. Someone in the Labor Party has

0:22:04.369 --> 0:22:07.090
<v Speaker 8>to stand up. I mean, Cameron, there are good people

0:22:07.170 --> 0:22:10.170
<v Speaker 8>in there. How can they be letting these two socialist

0:22:10.340 --> 0:22:13.840
<v Speaker 8>nutjobs destroy this country at a rate of knots? And

0:22:13.859 --> 0:22:16.159
<v Speaker 8>that's what they're doing. But the fact of the matter

0:22:16.180 --> 0:22:19.720
<v Speaker 8>is Australians deserve the opportunity to vote these people out.

0:22:20.119 --> 0:22:22.159
<v Speaker 8>And the earliest we can go to an election is

0:22:22.300 --> 0:22:26.479
<v Speaker 8>August next year. So with any luck, we can actually

0:22:26.619 --> 0:22:30.139
<v Speaker 8>get an election and get rid of these clowns before

0:22:30.180 --> 0:22:33.400
<v Speaker 8>they do any more damage. However, either way, they've got

0:22:33.440 --> 0:22:35.640
<v Speaker 8>seven or eight months, nine months that they can still

0:22:35.660 --> 0:22:36.320
<v Speaker 8>wreak havoc in.

0:22:38.640 --> 0:22:45.209
<v Speaker 1>Now, but Cameron, what could Labor do to get out

0:22:45.230 --> 0:22:48.750
<v Speaker 1>of this absolute mess? It seems to me at the moment,

0:22:49.410 --> 0:22:52.659
<v Speaker 1>They've been frozen with a strategy that is, well, you know,

0:22:52.760 --> 0:22:54.860
<v Speaker 1>One Nation is going to implode at some stage, which

0:22:54.900 --> 0:22:58.720
<v Speaker 1>it still hasn't done, or that, you know, One Nation

0:22:58.740 --> 0:23:01.080
<v Speaker 1>will take so many votes away from the Liberals and

0:23:01.119 --> 0:23:03.720
<v Speaker 1>vice versa and blah, blah, and we'll come through the

0:23:03.740 --> 0:23:08.340
<v Speaker 1>middle like Stephen Bradbury. Those seem to be its two

0:23:08.680 --> 0:23:11.000
<v Speaker 1>big hopes, but I'm not sure that it could count

0:23:11.060 --> 0:23:12.919
<v Speaker 1>on that for much longer. What does it need to

0:23:12.960 --> 0:23:13.520
<v Speaker 1>do itself?

0:23:15.080 --> 0:23:17.300
<v Speaker 7>Well, it needs to stop having false hope, false hope

0:23:17.320 --> 0:23:20.060
<v Speaker 7>that the two-party preferred is actually covering up their disaster.

0:23:20.080 --> 0:23:22.500
<v Speaker 7>I mean, you can't have one in four Australians voting

0:23:22.520 --> 0:23:25.160
<v Speaker 7>for the major party, one in four Australians voting for Labor.

0:23:25.359 --> 0:23:28.730
<v Speaker 7>That's a disaster, Andrew, total disaster. So, no, and Labor's

0:23:28.750 --> 0:23:30.470
<v Speaker 7>problem is that they haven't worked out that the May

0:23:30.510 --> 0:23:33.190
<v Speaker 7>budget was the icing on the cake of this disaster,

0:23:33.430 --> 0:23:35.570
<v Speaker 7>the icing on the cake, and that's the problem. They've

0:23:35.590 --> 0:23:37.990
<v Speaker 7>been in freefall ever since the May budget as they've

0:23:38.040 --> 0:23:40.620
<v Speaker 7>gone and had a war on aspiration, a war on wealth,

0:23:40.980 --> 0:23:44.000
<v Speaker 7>and unfortunately... destroying our economy in terms of what they're

0:23:44.020 --> 0:23:47.560
<v Speaker 7>doing both for small businesses, households and the wider economy

0:23:47.580 --> 0:23:47.840
<v Speaker 7>as well.

0:23:48.119 --> 0:23:49.930
<v Speaker 5>To your point, Holly, something has to give.

0:23:51.050 --> 0:23:51.669
<v Speaker 8>Absolutely.

0:23:52.550 --> 0:23:56.320
<v Speaker 1>Well, it's interesting. Holly, you know, you've got One nation

0:23:56.359 --> 0:23:59.020
<v Speaker 1>going from strength to strength. People still, you know, like

0:23:59.060 --> 0:24:01.379
<v Speaker 1>I said, they keep predicting it's going to fail. It

0:24:01.440 --> 0:24:03.730
<v Speaker 1>hasn't yet. I still think there's, you know, a lot

0:24:03.770 --> 0:24:07.389
<v Speaker 1>of potential things that can go wrong. And the coalition

0:24:07.430 --> 0:24:11.770
<v Speaker 1>is still way behind them and both parties on just 21%

0:24:11.770 --> 0:24:16.369
<v Speaker 1>in this poll. Do you think the coalition might gain

0:24:16.430 --> 0:24:18.330
<v Speaker 1>ground with its new immigration policy?

0:24:19.170 --> 0:24:20.020
<v Speaker 9>I don't think so.

0:24:20.100 --> 0:24:22.260
<v Speaker 8>I think it's like turning up to the grand final

0:24:22.320 --> 0:24:25.780
<v Speaker 8>after everyone's already left and gone home. Everyone else has

0:24:25.820 --> 0:24:28.480
<v Speaker 8>announced a policy. They look like they're just trying to

0:24:28.520 --> 0:24:32.300
<v Speaker 8>copy One Nation and haven't done it even as successfully there.

0:24:32.380 --> 0:24:34.940
<v Speaker 8>I mean, who is going to sell it? I mean,

0:24:34.980 --> 0:24:37.310
<v Speaker 8>if you saw the press conference trying to announce it,

0:24:37.340 --> 0:24:39.860
<v Speaker 8>it was just an embarrassment. And the only one who

0:24:40.220 --> 0:24:41.980
<v Speaker 8>I would have put any faith in trying to sell

0:24:42.020 --> 0:24:45.609
<v Speaker 8>this message is John O'Donoghue, and he's eyeing the door

0:24:45.660 --> 0:24:49.730
<v Speaker 8>as quickly as possible. So, look, I found the whole

0:24:49.770 --> 0:24:53.379
<v Speaker 8>thing incredibly strange. I think the fact the NOM is

0:24:53.400 --> 0:24:55.800
<v Speaker 8>a very tricky thing to do. If you listen to

0:24:55.840 --> 0:24:59.399
<v Speaker 8>what the Coalition shadow ministers have been saying throughout this

0:24:59.460 --> 0:25:02.160
<v Speaker 8>whole debate is that the NOM is a tricky number

0:25:02.180 --> 0:25:05.580
<v Speaker 8>to predict, and yet they came out with this absolute

0:25:06.460 --> 0:25:09.520
<v Speaker 8>declaration of what their NOM would be, and I just

0:25:09.619 --> 0:25:13.750
<v Speaker 8>don't think it's rinsing with anybody. I think it's too little,

0:25:13.810 --> 0:25:15.429
<v Speaker 8>too late, and no-one believes them anyway.

0:25:17.170 --> 0:25:19.770
<v Speaker 1>When you say NOM, you mean the net overseas migration numbers?

0:25:19.790 --> 0:25:20.690
<v Speaker 8>Net overseas migration.

0:25:21.290 --> 0:25:24.730
<v Speaker 1>I don't know. I'm not that damning, to be honest, Cameron.

0:25:24.950 --> 0:25:31.700
<v Speaker 1>I thought Angus Taylor yesterday and on the interview just

0:25:31.740 --> 0:25:37.220
<v Speaker 1>then spoke with more conviction than I normally hear and

0:25:37.560 --> 0:25:42.750
<v Speaker 1>also he's thought through the numbers, he's got economic arguments

0:25:42.810 --> 0:25:45.730
<v Speaker 1>for everything that's thrown at him. It seems well rehearsed,

0:25:45.970 --> 0:25:51.800
<v Speaker 1>which you can't say Pauline Hanson's immigration... It was, you know, yes, no, this, no,

0:25:51.820 --> 0:25:54.540
<v Speaker 1>we mean that, or the definition, all that kind of thing.

0:25:54.660 --> 0:25:59.310
<v Speaker 1>It was not thought through, even though, you know, it's tough.

0:25:59.590 --> 0:26:00.530
<v Speaker 1>What did you make of it?

0:26:02.180 --> 0:26:03.770
<v Speaker 7>Well, I think, going back to the point before, I mean,

0:26:03.850 --> 0:26:05.730
<v Speaker 7>Angus Taylor and the Liberal Party have got a huge problem.

0:26:06.170 --> 0:26:08.090
<v Speaker 7>You know, six months ago they were losing votes to

0:26:08.150 --> 0:26:10.889
<v Speaker 7>One Nation. Now One Nation's picking up Labor votes. And

0:26:10.910 --> 0:26:12.610
<v Speaker 7>this is the problem for the coalition. It doesn't matter

0:26:12.630 --> 0:26:15.190
<v Speaker 7>what their policy is. They're coming third, Andrew. They're coming

0:26:15.250 --> 0:26:17.930
<v Speaker 7>third and a bad third because Labor's lost the working

0:26:17.970 --> 0:26:19.270
<v Speaker 7>class to One Nation now.

0:26:19.550 --> 0:26:20.490
<v Speaker 1>Votes are shifting across.

0:26:20.770 --> 0:26:22.889
<v Speaker 7>The Labor Party's basically a bunch of latte sippers and

0:26:22.950 --> 0:26:23.590
<v Speaker 7>social elites.

0:26:23.950 --> 0:26:25.850
<v Speaker 1>The Liberal Party, you know, maybe.

0:26:25.560 --> 0:26:26.280
<v Speaker 5>A few business people.

0:26:26.619 --> 0:26:29.040
<v Speaker 7>The One Nation is this juggernaut, and that's the problem.

0:26:29.080 --> 0:26:31.780
<v Speaker 7>You won't stop One Nation's juggernaut with a simple policy.

0:26:32.180 --> 0:26:33.980
<v Speaker 7>To your point, though, I think it was a good

0:26:34.020 --> 0:26:35.660
<v Speaker 7>policy in terms of what Angus Taylor had to say.

0:26:35.940 --> 0:26:36.960
<v Speaker 1>He's actually set out a number.

0:26:37.200 --> 0:26:39.290
<v Speaker 7>He set out a policy and a platform to achieve

0:26:39.330 --> 0:26:42.109
<v Speaker 7>that number, which is probably a first for what we

0:26:42.150 --> 0:26:43.710
<v Speaker 7>expect from Angus in terms of what he's done in

0:26:43.730 --> 0:26:45.669
<v Speaker 7>the past. So, yeah, credit to the fact that he's

0:26:45.930 --> 0:26:48.350
<v Speaker 7>done the work, but the One Nation juggernaut is well

0:26:48.369 --> 0:26:48.949
<v Speaker 7>and truly on the way.

0:26:51.460 --> 0:26:53.910
<v Speaker 1>Well, it's a hell of a contrast to the Labor

0:26:54.369 --> 0:26:57.389
<v Speaker 1>immigration policy, which turned out to be, we're going to

0:26:57.450 --> 0:27:01.280
<v Speaker 1>cut people on working holiday visas who are mainly Europeans

0:27:01.300 --> 0:27:04.420
<v Speaker 1>or Japanese, no one we worry about, but we are

0:27:04.480 --> 0:27:08.379
<v Speaker 1>going to keep that doubling of the refugee and humanitarian intake,

0:27:08.400 --> 0:27:11.169
<v Speaker 1>which is mainly people from Syria and Afghanistan.

0:27:11.570 --> 0:27:11.970
<v Speaker 6>Hmm.

0:27:12.350 --> 0:27:14.330
<v Speaker 1>Yes, I'm not quite sure that answers what the public's

0:27:14.390 --> 0:27:18.810
<v Speaker 1>up to. Holly, today we've got another example of Labor's

0:27:18.890 --> 0:27:22.910
<v Speaker 1>disastrous political strategy, which apparently is, you know, let's first

0:27:22.970 --> 0:27:28.939
<v Speaker 1>make a business, you know, really struggle for ideological reasons,

0:27:29.200 --> 0:27:32.060
<v Speaker 1>and then we'll throw taxpayers' money to bail some out

0:27:32.260 --> 0:27:38.480
<v Speaker 1>that we actually like. example today was, we've got a

0:27:38.920 --> 0:27:42.200
<v Speaker 1>water buyback scheme that has made it really hard for

0:27:42.240 --> 0:27:45.450
<v Speaker 1>a rice factory that's now going broke. Oh, let's throw

0:27:45.510 --> 0:27:48.530
<v Speaker 1>its $ 14 million of taxpayers' money to keep going, just

0:27:48.570 --> 0:27:51.670
<v Speaker 1>like it throws money at smelters to deal with the

0:27:51.790 --> 0:27:56.109
<v Speaker 1>power prices driven by its green policies. I mean, what

0:27:56.190 --> 0:27:57.030
<v Speaker 1>the hell is this?

0:27:57.740 --> 0:27:59.600
<v Speaker 8>Well, you couldn't make this stuff up. I mean, this

0:27:59.700 --> 0:28:02.860
<v Speaker 8>is literally their own policy agenda that is causing these problems.

0:28:03.220 --> 0:28:06.850
<v Speaker 8>Water buybacks are a disaster and the way that they've

0:28:06.880 --> 0:28:09.330
<v Speaker 8>separated from the farms. I mean, remember when Penny Wong

0:28:09.350 --> 0:28:13.010
<v Speaker 8>was Water Minister, she bought the wrong farm. I mean,

0:28:13.070 --> 0:28:14.510
<v Speaker 8>these guys have got no.

0:28:14.390 --> 0:28:16.649
<v Speaker 9>Idea what they are doing.

0:28:16.690 --> 0:28:19.550
<v Speaker 8>They don't understand agriculture. The fact that they want to

0:28:19.609 --> 0:28:22.470
<v Speaker 8>cut backpacker visas just shows how out of touch they

0:28:22.530 --> 0:28:24.909
<v Speaker 8>are with rural and regional Australia and how we can

0:28:24.930 --> 0:28:27.989
<v Speaker 8>get a workforce out there. But it is impossible to

0:28:28.070 --> 0:28:30.919
<v Speaker 8>do business, whether you're big business or small business, and

0:28:31.080 --> 0:28:34.800
<v Speaker 8>everything this government does makes it harder, whether it's the

0:28:35.040 --> 0:28:39.469
<v Speaker 8>bailouts for Tomago. or whether it's now for Sunrise, it's

0:28:39.590 --> 0:28:42.910
<v Speaker 8>all because of their own failed policies. And don't forget,

0:28:42.970 --> 0:28:45.710
<v Speaker 8>Chris Mintz has got legislation in his upper house at

0:28:45.750 --> 0:28:48.690
<v Speaker 8>the moment trying to push through more powers for the

0:28:48.750 --> 0:28:53.570
<v Speaker 8>planning minister so they can turn the landscape of rural

0:28:53.590 --> 0:28:56.430
<v Speaker 8>and regional New South Wales into an absolute behemoth of

0:28:56.540 --> 0:28:59.900
<v Speaker 8>wind turbines whilst they can't find a dollar to fix

0:29:00.000 --> 0:29:03.540
<v Speaker 8>our roads or our health systems. So, you know, they're

0:29:03.560 --> 0:29:06.160
<v Speaker 8>a disgrace from woe to God and all of their

0:29:06.180 --> 0:29:07.959
<v Speaker 8>policies are destroying our country.

0:29:09.760 --> 0:29:12.560
<v Speaker 1>Well, I think the Sunrise decision is just pure labour.

0:29:12.640 --> 0:29:16.100
<v Speaker 1>Pure labour. It really is. Like all those other bailouts

0:29:16.180 --> 0:29:20.260
<v Speaker 1>of the Tomago or other smelters or the way alloy

0:29:20.300 --> 0:29:24.020
<v Speaker 1>steel works. I mean, honestly, if that's our future, we

0:29:24.260 --> 0:29:27.040
<v Speaker 1>are stuffed. Cameron Milner, Holly Hughes, thank you very much

0:29:27.080 --> 0:29:30.180
<v Speaker 1>to you both. After the break, three years since the

0:29:30.240 --> 0:29:34.360
<v Speaker 1>October 7 massacre, why those three years since have been

0:29:34.440 --> 0:29:42.680
<v Speaker 1>even more terrifying? This might seem a digression before I

0:29:43.020 --> 0:29:46.460
<v Speaker 1>get to my guests, but looking at the riots in France,

0:29:47.100 --> 0:29:50.820
<v Speaker 1>I'm seeing a telling truth about the pro-Palestine protests that

0:29:50.840 --> 0:29:54.100
<v Speaker 1>have ripped through the West since the October 7 massacre

0:29:54.620 --> 0:29:59.300
<v Speaker 1>of Jews three years ago today. These riots, more like

0:29:59.700 --> 0:30:02.420
<v Speaker 1>A civil war, really. Quarter of a million protesters yesterday

0:30:02.460 --> 0:30:07.310
<v Speaker 1>confronting police. They're supposedly by students demanding better schools, yet

0:30:07.350 --> 0:30:09.680
<v Speaker 1>at the same time they're burning and looting them and

0:30:09.980 --> 0:30:12.870
<v Speaker 1>attacking dozens of teachers. But see how many of the

0:30:12.910 --> 0:30:17.630
<v Speaker 1>students are of Middle Eastern or African background. Muslims, many

0:30:18.010 --> 0:30:21.690
<v Speaker 1>carrying the Palestinian flag as well. Some attacking white people

0:30:21.770 --> 0:30:26.010
<v Speaker 1>like this mother, father and their son. one even reportedly

0:30:26.090 --> 0:30:29.420
<v Speaker 1>threatening to kill police in the name of Allah. To

0:30:29.440 --> 0:30:40.080
<v Speaker 1>the cheers of the crowd. Now, you're seeing here a

0:30:40.220 --> 0:30:43.150
<v Speaker 1>merging of enemies of the freedoms of the West. You've

0:30:43.170 --> 0:30:47.030
<v Speaker 1>got the Marxist left whipping up the right's, And Muslims

0:30:47.070 --> 0:30:50.660
<v Speaker 1>who have also joined together these two forces in vilifying

0:30:50.720 --> 0:30:54.560
<v Speaker 1>Jewish Israel so viciously that Jews around the world do

0:30:54.660 --> 0:30:59.310
<v Speaker 1>not feel safe. And we see exactly the same merging

0:30:59.370 --> 0:31:03.130
<v Speaker 1>here as well. Last month's socialism conference at Sydney University

0:31:03.710 --> 0:31:07.430
<v Speaker 1>didn't just preach Marxism, communism, revolution and love of Lenin.

0:31:08.410 --> 0:31:12.070
<v Speaker 1>didn't just preach against our democracy, but covered the lectern

0:31:12.090 --> 0:31:15.710
<v Speaker 1>with a Palestinian flag while the young idiots sang the Internationale,

0:31:15.750 --> 0:31:33.150
<v Speaker 1>the hymn of communists everywhere. Yep, totalitarians everywhere, pro-Palestinian movement,

0:31:33.190 --> 0:31:36.570
<v Speaker 1>haters of Israel, they're all merging with our far left,

0:31:37.030 --> 0:31:42.160
<v Speaker 1>all enemies of the West. But to today's October 7th anniversary,

0:31:42.200 --> 0:31:45.840
<v Speaker 1>when we remember that horror in Israel, the day started

0:31:45.860 --> 0:31:48.650
<v Speaker 1>here with the Jews and others gathering at Bondi to

0:31:48.690 --> 0:31:52.030
<v Speaker 1>commemorate not just October 7th, but the Australian version of

0:31:52.070 --> 0:31:55.830
<v Speaker 1>it at Bondi last December. There are more ceremonies tonight,

0:31:56.430 --> 0:32:00.170
<v Speaker 1>but the haters are out as well. The anti-Israel ones

0:32:00.630 --> 0:32:03.880
<v Speaker 1>who once again couldn't let Jews mourn in peace. There

0:32:03.900 --> 0:32:06.770
<v Speaker 1>was a mercifully small such vigil in Melbourne for the

0:32:06.810 --> 0:32:09.910
<v Speaker 1>Palestinians killed in the war that Hamas terrorists in Gaza

0:32:10.170 --> 0:32:13.550
<v Speaker 1>actually started on October 7. A small one, but heated

0:32:13.590 --> 0:32:16.430
<v Speaker 1>with protesters shoving away a man with an Israeli flag

0:32:16.710 --> 0:32:19.030
<v Speaker 1>and then scuffling with the rebel news journalist Avi Yemeni,

0:32:19.490 --> 0:32:22.840
<v Speaker 1>who's also Jewish, when he tried to interview them. There

0:32:22.880 --> 0:32:27.560
<v Speaker 1>were bigger pro-Palestinian events today by equally shameless protesters in Sydney.

0:32:28.100 --> 0:32:31.160
<v Speaker 1>And around the world, we've seen this perversion of pro-Palestinian

0:32:31.220 --> 0:32:34.620
<v Speaker 1>protesters not wanting Jews to be seen as the victims

0:32:34.680 --> 0:32:37.740
<v Speaker 1>of a terrible slaughter, but essentially as people we should

0:32:37.780 --> 0:32:41.280
<v Speaker 1>actually blame for being so evil that nice Palestinians on

0:32:41.300 --> 0:32:45.120
<v Speaker 1>that October 7 were forced to slaughter them. It really

0:32:45.180 --> 0:32:48.170
<v Speaker 1>is that sick. Joining me is Mark Sofer, the best

0:32:48.230 --> 0:32:51.300
<v Speaker 1>ambassador Israel has ever sent to Australia. He was also

0:32:51.400 --> 0:32:54.700
<v Speaker 1>Deputy Director General of Israel's Ministry of Foreign Affairs. Mark,

0:32:54.720 --> 0:32:57.930
<v Speaker 1>great to talk to you again. Three years since October 7.

0:32:57.920 --> 0:33:03.910
<v Speaker 1>Since then, Israel has essentially destroyed its terrorist enemies militarily,

0:33:04.510 --> 0:33:06.830
<v Speaker 1>but seems to have lost the propaganda war, with Jew

0:33:06.870 --> 0:33:09.390
<v Speaker 1>hatred now becoming mainstream in the Western left.

0:33:11.260 --> 0:33:16.140
<v Speaker 9>Well, I wouldn't say destroyed, but certainly significantly weakened. The enemies, unfortunately,

0:33:16.500 --> 0:33:21.220
<v Speaker 9>they're still there. Hamas, Hezbollah, the Iranian regime, etc. But

0:33:21.260 --> 0:33:23.830
<v Speaker 9>I think you're correct on the on the propaganda part,

0:33:23.850 --> 0:33:28.450
<v Speaker 9>but also the movement from what we have seen for

0:33:28.490 --> 0:33:31.010
<v Speaker 9>so many years has been the purview of the extreme right.

0:33:31.110 --> 0:33:35.210
<v Speaker 9>I'm talking of anti-Semitic bigotry of hatred of Jews has

0:33:35.280 --> 0:33:37.240
<v Speaker 9>now what we are seeing over the past few years

0:33:37.320 --> 0:33:40.360
<v Speaker 9>is now quite clearly and quite palpably part of the

0:33:40.420 --> 0:33:43.520
<v Speaker 9>extreme left as well. It's come out of the woodwork.

0:33:43.560 --> 0:33:45.620
<v Speaker 9>And we saw this just a couple of days ago

0:33:45.660 --> 0:33:49.740
<v Speaker 9>in the UK with the Greens party passing, which cannot

0:33:49.920 --> 0:33:55.140
<v Speaker 9>only be considered a massively anti-Semitic decision in its annual conference,

0:33:55.260 --> 0:33:58.280
<v Speaker 9>basically saying that every country and every people have the

0:33:58.320 --> 0:34:01.580
<v Speaker 9>right to self-determination except for the Jews, and that when

0:34:01.600 --> 0:34:05.020
<v Speaker 9>the Jews do it, it's racism. And so, therefore, we

0:34:05.120 --> 0:34:09.000
<v Speaker 9>are seeing unfortunately, last swaths of the parts of population

0:34:09.040 --> 0:34:12.820
<v Speaker 9>of the extreme left joining hands, joining forces with the

0:34:12.900 --> 0:34:15.799
<v Speaker 9>extreme right in this massive Jew hatred. And it's come

0:34:15.820 --> 0:34:18.020
<v Speaker 9>to the fore in the past few years, sadly.

0:34:20.560 --> 0:34:23.350
<v Speaker 1>I find it absolutely sickening. I did try to warn

0:34:24.170 --> 0:34:28.969
<v Speaker 1>about this development for many years, but not much luck.

0:34:29.010 --> 0:34:32.629
<v Speaker 1>And now look at this. Now, as you know, the

0:34:32.690 --> 0:34:37.200
<v Speaker 1>very same phenomenon has happened right here in Australia. Did

0:34:37.239 --> 0:34:39.489
<v Speaker 1>you see this Jew hatred coming?

0:34:41.489 --> 0:34:45.750
<v Speaker 9>Well, I don't think that anybody saw the developments or

0:34:45.770 --> 0:34:49.569
<v Speaker 9>the horrors of what happened in Australia over the past

0:34:49.610 --> 0:34:53.870
<v Speaker 9>few years, manifested first and foremost, of course, by the tragedy,

0:34:54.590 --> 0:34:58.029
<v Speaker 9>the horrific terrorist attack in Bondi, but it wasn't the

0:34:58.150 --> 0:35:01.950
<v Speaker 9>only one. Now, nobody really saw it coming to such

0:35:01.989 --> 0:35:08.160
<v Speaker 9>an extent. People knew that there was a undercurrent of people,

0:35:08.950 --> 0:35:13.430
<v Speaker 9>of some people who were basically anti-Jewish, but nobody believed

0:35:13.450 --> 0:35:15.690
<v Speaker 9>anything of this nature, I think, not in the Jewish community,

0:35:16.110 --> 0:35:18.130
<v Speaker 9>not in the body politic, and certainly not here in

0:35:18.210 --> 0:35:21.570
<v Speaker 9>Israel either. And I think that when Prime Minister Albanese

0:35:21.610 --> 0:35:26.770
<v Speaker 9>says that these acts are very un-Australian, of course, he's correct.

0:35:26.890 --> 0:35:29.190
<v Speaker 9>They are un-Australian. It's not part and parcel of the

0:35:29.230 --> 0:35:34.340
<v Speaker 9>Australian civilized society, which is the vast, vast majority. But unfortunately,

0:35:34.360 --> 0:35:36.480
<v Speaker 9>there are far too numerous a number of people in

0:35:36.560 --> 0:35:40.700
<v Speaker 9>Australia that don't hold Australian values. And so calling them

0:35:40.739 --> 0:35:45.330
<v Speaker 9>un-Australian is basically calling for what they actually are. They

0:35:45.910 --> 0:35:48.690
<v Speaker 9>don't hold the values, and they do hold values of hatred,

0:35:48.730 --> 0:35:56.720
<v Speaker 9>of terrorism. You mentioned earlier, Andrew, the demonstrations taking place

0:35:56.780 --> 0:36:00.279
<v Speaker 9>today in Australia, but not only in Australia, the 7th

0:36:00.300 --> 0:36:07.850
<v Speaker 9>of October protests. on certain parts of Australia and elsewhere.

0:36:07.870 --> 0:36:12.009
<v Speaker 9>And I really must say that, and I'm usually very diplomatic,

0:36:12.050 --> 0:36:16.710
<v Speaker 9>but the people demonstrating today, when Israelis were massacred in

0:36:16.770 --> 0:36:21.710
<v Speaker 9>massive numbers, raped, tortured, pillaged, taken hostage, those who are

0:36:21.750 --> 0:36:24.509
<v Speaker 9>demonstrating today in favor of the Hamas are really, I

0:36:24.590 --> 0:36:27.069
<v Speaker 9>must say, the dregs of society. I have no other

0:36:27.110 --> 0:36:30.810
<v Speaker 9>word for them. They could have demonstrated on any other day, tomorrow,

0:36:30.830 --> 0:36:32.150
<v Speaker 9>the next day, but the fact that they're doing it

0:36:32.210 --> 0:36:36.609
<v Speaker 9>today is proof that they actually support this massacre, they

0:36:36.650 --> 0:36:40.890
<v Speaker 9>support the hatred, and unfortunately these people exist. It's a

0:36:40.930 --> 0:36:42.529
<v Speaker 9>tragedy and a travesty that they do.

0:36:44.840 --> 0:36:48.680
<v Speaker 1>Yeah, look, I think it is deliberate as an attempt

0:36:48.860 --> 0:36:52.600
<v Speaker 1>or maybe as a betrayal of their thinking that Jews

0:36:52.680 --> 0:36:56.740
<v Speaker 1>had only themselves to blame for being massacred, raped, beheaded

0:36:57.120 --> 0:37:03.299
<v Speaker 1>and kidnapped. It's just, to me, morally incorrect. disgusting. I mean,

0:37:03.320 --> 0:37:05.339
<v Speaker 1>I know I'm supposed to reach out to people who

0:37:05.380 --> 0:37:08.420
<v Speaker 1>don't agree with me and, you know, try sweet reason,

0:37:08.460 --> 0:37:11.379
<v Speaker 1>but this is beyond the pale. But what does this

0:37:11.460 --> 0:37:15.200
<v Speaker 1>tell you? Does it tell you that so many in

0:37:15.239 --> 0:37:18.279
<v Speaker 1>the West only like Jews when they suffered, when they

0:37:18.969 --> 0:37:21.750
<v Speaker 1>ran to the execution pits and to be gunned down

0:37:21.790 --> 0:37:24.570
<v Speaker 1>by Nazis, not when they now defend themselves?

0:37:26.450 --> 0:37:28.739
<v Speaker 9>Well, the West is a very broad concept, and I

0:37:28.760 --> 0:37:31.640
<v Speaker 9>think we have to be very careful to distinguish between

0:37:31.680 --> 0:37:35.140
<v Speaker 9>the West or even and especially criticism of Israel. Many

0:37:35.160 --> 0:37:37.200
<v Speaker 9>of us here are very critical of the current Israeli

0:37:37.239 --> 0:37:42.759
<v Speaker 9>government and anti-Semitic. And not every act of criticism towards

0:37:43.160 --> 0:37:47.350
<v Speaker 9>Israel is anti-Semitic. However, as we say, you know, paranoiacs

0:37:47.430 --> 0:37:51.930
<v Speaker 9>also have enemies. And unfortunately, in the anti-Israel brigade, there

0:37:51.969 --> 0:37:56.379
<v Speaker 9>are not small amounts of anti-Semites as well. So yes,

0:37:56.460 --> 0:38:00.060
<v Speaker 9>I think that we do see here a hatred of Jews.

0:38:00.100 --> 0:38:02.540
<v Speaker 9>We're seeing it across the world. And I think it

0:38:02.580 --> 0:38:05.440
<v Speaker 9>has to be tackled. It has to be tackled by education.

0:38:05.460 --> 0:38:08.790
<v Speaker 9>It has to be tackled by measures of defense. Jews

0:38:08.830 --> 0:38:11.730
<v Speaker 9>will continue to defend themselves and Israel will continue to

0:38:11.770 --> 0:38:16.090
<v Speaker 9>defend itself wherever and however and wherever is necessary. However,

0:38:16.790 --> 0:38:18.879
<v Speaker 9>it must be tackled and we cannot, we will not,

0:38:19.160 --> 0:38:22.680
<v Speaker 9>cannot and must not sit idly by when we see

0:38:22.719 --> 0:38:25.969
<v Speaker 9>such things as demonstrations taking place today of all days

0:38:26.030 --> 0:38:30.010
<v Speaker 9>on the 7th of October, celebration of death, killing and terror.

0:38:32.670 --> 0:38:34.870
<v Speaker 1>Now, I think it's a wider project that we have

0:38:34.890 --> 0:38:38.549
<v Speaker 1>to actually stop demonising Western civilisation, of which Jews have

0:38:38.570 --> 0:38:42.919
<v Speaker 1>been such a key part, in fact, progenitors of Western civilisation.

0:38:43.280 --> 0:38:46.339
<v Speaker 1>That is a sickness that's underlying it all as well.

0:38:46.680 --> 0:38:50.759
<v Speaker 1>Mark Sofer, thank you so much for your time. After

0:38:50.800 --> 0:38:55.270
<v Speaker 1>the break, Gemma and Caroline, I'm really looking forward to that.

0:39:00.989 --> 0:39:05.750
<v Speaker 1>This Albanese government seems so dangerously naive, you know, blind

0:39:05.790 --> 0:39:12.049
<v Speaker 1>to dangers. The Daily Telegraph editor, Daily Telegraph, earlier this

0:39:12.090 --> 0:39:15.930
<v Speaker 1>year warned that some of our most sensitive military bases

0:39:15.969 --> 0:39:19.700
<v Speaker 1>have drones buzzing them nearly 150 times in one year.

0:39:21.430 --> 0:39:22.549
<v Speaker 1>and didn't shoot down one.

0:39:22.989 --> 0:39:23.279
<v Speaker 5>Couldn't.

0:39:23.760 --> 0:39:28.029
<v Speaker 1>Just said to people, pull down the curtains. Now this

0:39:28.170 --> 0:39:33.880
<v Speaker 1>same Daily Telegraph report... says, hey, the Pentagon has ordered

0:39:34.840 --> 0:39:38.759
<v Speaker 1>undercover US agents to check if they could penetrate Australia's

0:39:38.960 --> 0:39:41.990
<v Speaker 1>naval bases. In a test of our security, given that

0:39:42.010 --> 0:39:45.030
<v Speaker 1>they've got this submarines deal and all these top secrets

0:39:45.090 --> 0:39:47.230
<v Speaker 1>and all this kind of stuff coming our way, it

0:39:48.070 --> 0:39:49.310
<v Speaker 1>turned out to be a piece of cake.

0:39:50.280 --> 0:39:54.090
<v Speaker 10>A defence source with detailed knowledge of the operation told

0:39:54.130 --> 0:39:59.150
<v Speaker 10>me that agents move through restricted areas, undetected and unchallenged,

0:39:59.690 --> 0:40:05.170
<v Speaker 10>and recorded areas under strict security controls. Nobody stopped them.

0:40:07.780 --> 0:40:09.899
<v Speaker 1>Oh no, said our defence minister, she'll be right.

0:40:10.950 --> 0:40:13.969
<v Speaker 11>I can assure you that we have been increasing our

0:40:14.010 --> 0:40:17.100
<v Speaker 11>base security across the entirety of the footprint of defence

0:40:17.920 --> 0:40:20.600
<v Speaker 11>and we work very closely with our friends and partners

0:40:20.900 --> 0:40:24.340
<v Speaker 11>who operate from our bases and that very much includes

0:40:24.380 --> 0:40:26.299
<v Speaker 11>the United States but not just the United States.

0:40:28.770 --> 0:40:31.770
<v Speaker 1>Joining me are Gemma Tonini, columnist and communications consultant, and

0:40:31.790 --> 0:40:35.690
<v Speaker 1>Caroline de Russo, commentator and president of the West Australian Liberals. Gemma,

0:40:35.750 --> 0:40:38.170
<v Speaker 1>this naivety again. I mean, you've got the government going

0:40:38.230 --> 0:40:40.820
<v Speaker 1>so soft on China. It's not building up our military.

0:40:41.100 --> 0:40:43.500
<v Speaker 1>It's not tackling the explosion of Jew hatred, or didn't

0:40:43.780 --> 0:40:46.739
<v Speaker 1>until far too late. Not cracking down on mass immigration.

0:40:46.800 --> 0:40:51.600
<v Speaker 1>It's given 3,000 Palestinians from terrorists around Gaza tourism visas

0:40:51.640 --> 0:40:54.520
<v Speaker 1>before any thorough vetting. On and on. There seems to

0:40:54.580 --> 0:40:58.089
<v Speaker 1>be a total lack of seriousness with this government.

0:40:58.780 --> 0:41:00.610
<v Speaker 12>Well, of course there is, Andrew, and I'd like to

0:41:00.660 --> 0:41:05.689
<v Speaker 12>congratulate Mr Miles on a spectacularly delivered word salad there

0:41:05.730 --> 0:41:09.810
<v Speaker 12>that just said absolutely nothing. I mean, well done to

0:41:09.870 --> 0:41:13.920
<v Speaker 12>whoever media trained him, but he said nothing. He didn't

0:41:13.960 --> 0:41:17.340
<v Speaker 12>address the substantive claims in that report, which I personally

0:41:17.400 --> 0:41:21.410
<v Speaker 12>believe without hesitation, because You need to take a step back, Andrew,

0:41:21.570 --> 0:41:26.690
<v Speaker 12>and understand that ideologically this government is anti-war, doesn't believe

0:41:26.750 --> 0:41:29.890
<v Speaker 12>in war, doesn't believe we should be prepared for anything, has,

0:41:30.070 --> 0:41:34.870
<v Speaker 12>as you rightly pointed out, been so flippant with our sovereignty,

0:41:35.090 --> 0:41:43.299
<v Speaker 12>our security. on every iteration, defence underspending, all of the things. So,

0:41:43.719 --> 0:41:45.990
<v Speaker 12>you know, I was reflecting today, and I know we'll

0:41:46.010 --> 0:41:48.130
<v Speaker 12>talk about it in a minute, but the October 7th

0:41:48.170 --> 0:41:50.969
<v Speaker 12>anniversary and what would happen to this country if we

0:41:51.010 --> 0:41:54.590
<v Speaker 12>were subjected to the same kind of onslaught as Israel

0:41:55.050 --> 0:41:59.150
<v Speaker 12>was on October 7 and has been consistently since. The

0:41:59.250 --> 0:42:01.930
<v Speaker 12>only thing that we can be assured of is how

0:42:02.050 --> 0:42:05.310
<v Speaker 12>quickly this government would wet the bed. So when it

0:42:05.370 --> 0:42:09.910
<v Speaker 12>comes to defence, we are not in good hands. We

0:42:09.969 --> 0:42:12.780
<v Speaker 12>are more vulnerable than we were when the Albanese regime

0:42:12.820 --> 0:42:15.400
<v Speaker 12>took over. And I think that they deserve to be

0:42:15.480 --> 0:42:18.940
<v Speaker 12>continually pressured on this issue because it's a serious one.

0:42:18.960 --> 0:42:23.560
<v Speaker 1>It seems to me, Caroline, sometimes that the government's living

0:42:23.600 --> 0:42:26.950
<v Speaker 1>in sort of la-la land, you know. Imagine that we

0:42:26.989 --> 0:42:29.690
<v Speaker 1>can change the climate when it can't, you know. Imagine

0:42:29.730 --> 0:42:32.370
<v Speaker 1>that China's not the threat that it is, which it

0:42:32.810 --> 0:42:35.350
<v Speaker 1>certainly is. I mean, what is going on, do you think?

0:42:38.500 --> 0:42:41.989
<v Speaker 13>Well, I think you're being a bit kind to say

0:42:42.050 --> 0:42:46.069
<v Speaker 13>it's just naivety because if you're naive to something, that's

0:42:46.190 --> 0:42:48.410
<v Speaker 13>one thing. But when people give you information and you

0:42:48.930 --> 0:42:50.810
<v Speaker 13>turn a blind eye to it or you don't action

0:42:50.830 --> 0:42:52.870
<v Speaker 13>it or whatever, that's a little bit more than naivety.

0:42:53.200 --> 0:42:55.960
<v Speaker 13>You know what it reminds me of, Andrew? You know when, like,

0:42:56.000 --> 0:42:57.980
<v Speaker 13>a toddler wants to play hide and seek and they

0:42:58.020 --> 0:43:00.399
<v Speaker 13>think that if they cover their own eyes that you

0:43:00.460 --> 0:43:03.700
<v Speaker 13>can't see them? That's what I think that this government.

0:43:04.780 --> 0:43:05.799
<v Speaker 5>Right? That's what I.

0:43:05.780 --> 0:43:09.700
<v Speaker 13>Think that this government thinks. They think that if they just...

0:43:09.180 --> 0:43:11.930
<v Speaker 13>If they pretend that it's all going to be OK,

0:43:12.270 --> 0:43:14.610
<v Speaker 13>then it will be OK. They'll just will it to

0:43:14.650 --> 0:43:18.470
<v Speaker 13>be OK. And this is maybe one thing in Australian

0:43:18.510 --> 0:43:22.290
<v Speaker 13>culture that I think sometimes is great in some senses,

0:43:22.310 --> 0:43:23.950
<v Speaker 13>but we let ourselves down a little bit.

0:43:23.989 --> 0:43:24.689
<v Speaker 5>And it's this whole.

0:43:25.210 --> 0:43:28.330
<v Speaker 13>she'll be right mentality. And we've been a very, very

0:43:28.390 --> 0:43:31.800
<v Speaker 13>lucky country for a very, very long time. But like

0:43:31.840 --> 0:43:35.840
<v Speaker 13>with your superannuation, past performance isn't always an indicator of

0:43:35.980 --> 0:43:40.259
<v Speaker 13>future performance, Andrew. And I think you have to be

0:43:40.380 --> 0:43:44.140
<v Speaker 13>prepared for things to go wrong, even if, you know,

0:43:44.380 --> 0:43:48.270
<v Speaker 13>so far we've done OK. And this government, I think,

0:43:48.370 --> 0:43:51.410
<v Speaker 13>is getting to the point of being careless and and

0:43:51.690 --> 0:43:56.609
<v Speaker 13>reckless with our security and our future security, not just

0:43:56.670 --> 0:43:59.259
<v Speaker 13>our present security, you know, well into the future. Obviously,

0:43:59.300 --> 0:44:00.420
<v Speaker 13>defence things need.

0:44:00.239 --> 0:44:00.920
<v Speaker 5>To be planned.

0:44:01.020 --> 0:44:01.580
<v Speaker 1>No, it's true.

0:44:01.600 --> 0:44:04.180
<v Speaker 13>Because it's been all right so far, so why should

0:44:04.219 --> 0:44:07.000
<v Speaker 13>we lift a finger? Like Gemma said, word salad, knock

0:44:07.020 --> 0:44:10.180
<v Speaker 13>the question off, move on to our next, you know, whatever.

0:44:12.130 --> 0:44:17.650
<v Speaker 1>Well, it's three years since Israel got caught out horribly

0:44:18.070 --> 0:44:22.930
<v Speaker 1>with complacency. ignoring some warnings that Hamas was building up

0:44:23.010 --> 0:44:28.580
<v Speaker 1>to something spectacular, which then unveiled itself on October 7

0:44:28.580 --> 0:44:33.300
<v Speaker 1>in horrific detail, the massacre of 1,200 Israelis, the kidnaps,

0:44:33.360 --> 0:44:39.960
<v Speaker 1>the beheadings, the rapes, all that kind of stuff. Gemma,

0:44:40.160 --> 0:44:44.920
<v Speaker 1>the three years since, though, to me, have been equally terrifying.

0:44:46.440 --> 0:44:49.860
<v Speaker 1>The Jew hatred that we've that has just gone around

0:44:49.890 --> 0:44:53.060
<v Speaker 1>the West and particularly here in Australia. You saw the

0:44:53.100 --> 0:44:57.640
<v Speaker 1>Bondi massacre, of course. What should we have learned from

0:44:57.680 --> 0:44:58.580
<v Speaker 1>these three years?

0:44:59.520 --> 0:45:02.800
<v Speaker 12>Well, thank you for pre-empting my weekend column, Andrew, so beautifully,

0:45:03.739 --> 0:45:07.419
<v Speaker 12>the one that's to come this Saturday. Look, I found

0:45:07.460 --> 0:45:10.700
<v Speaker 12>today I'm not often lost for words. Today I've been

0:45:10.719 --> 0:45:13.940
<v Speaker 12>lost for words. It felt like part of my heart

0:45:13.960 --> 0:45:16.239
<v Speaker 12>is like a hose with a kink in it. to

0:45:16.280 --> 0:45:18.819
<v Speaker 12>be honest, because like you, I sit here and say,

0:45:18.900 --> 0:45:20.920
<v Speaker 12>how are we still here? How are we still having

0:45:20.960 --> 0:45:25.930
<v Speaker 12>conversations in Australia about the safety of our Jewish neighbours

0:45:25.969 --> 0:45:28.250
<v Speaker 12>and friends and colleagues and brothers and sisters? And I

0:45:28.330 --> 0:45:31.890
<v Speaker 12>simply offer the same analogy that I have done all along,

0:45:31.950 --> 0:45:35.690
<v Speaker 12>like insert, take the word Jewish out and put Indigenous

0:45:35.750 --> 0:45:37.880
<v Speaker 12>in there and we wouldn't be having these conversations or

0:45:37.890 --> 0:45:40.850
<v Speaker 12>put any other ethnicity. It is an ancient hatred. It

0:45:41.330 --> 0:45:44.210
<v Speaker 12>is a vile, repugnant hatred. And I cannot believe we're

0:45:44.230 --> 0:45:47.609
<v Speaker 12>still here. But I also can currently know why we're here,

0:45:47.630 --> 0:45:50.029
<v Speaker 12>because we have a flaccid government that doesn't want to

0:45:50.090 --> 0:45:52.830
<v Speaker 12>confront anything that might involve any kind of strength or

0:45:53.190 --> 0:45:55.490
<v Speaker 12>losing some political bark. And I think the other thing

0:45:55.510 --> 0:45:58.980
<v Speaker 12>that Australians need to understand is we call it October 7,

0:45:58.980 --> 0:46:01.960
<v Speaker 12>but what Hamas have called it and what the Iranian

0:46:02.000 --> 0:46:04.540
<v Speaker 12>regime call it is Operation Al-Aqsa Flood. And it was

0:46:04.540 --> 0:46:07.700
<v Speaker 12>10 years in the making. 10 years in the making,

0:46:07.700 --> 0:46:10.189
<v Speaker 12>10 years in the preparation, funded at least in part

0:46:10.230 --> 0:46:12.890
<v Speaker 12>by foreign aid, your tax dollars and mine, as well

0:46:12.930 --> 0:46:15.830
<v Speaker 12>as funding from other state actors in the Middle East.

0:46:15.930 --> 0:46:18.650
<v Speaker 12>And so we sit here in our naivety and our

0:46:18.730 --> 0:46:22.509
<v Speaker 12>safety at a distance and the absolute audacity of this

0:46:22.590 --> 0:46:26.420
<v Speaker 12>government to lecture the Israelis on how best to protect themselves.

0:46:26.480 --> 0:46:30.320
<v Speaker 12>I will never pardon the foreign minister for saying show

0:46:30.380 --> 0:46:34.060
<v Speaker 12>restraint as Israeli women were being dragged into Gaza, gang-raped.

0:46:34.400 --> 0:46:36.890
<v Speaker 12>as little children were being shot dead in their beds,

0:46:36.950 --> 0:46:39.630
<v Speaker 12>families burned alive. I will never pardon that. And I

0:46:39.710 --> 0:46:41.930
<v Speaker 12>hope with all my heart that that ends up being

0:46:41.989 --> 0:46:45.330
<v Speaker 12>her legacy because it is a disgrace and it tarnishes us.

0:46:45.710 --> 0:46:48.270
<v Speaker 12>And even now, when our foreign policy as a country

0:46:48.610 --> 0:46:52.930
<v Speaker 12>in recognising a Palestinian state is applauded by the IRGC

0:46:53.010 --> 0:46:57.160
<v Speaker 12>and applauded by Hamas, a terrorist organisation, we should hang

0:46:57.440 --> 0:46:58.300
<v Speaker 12>our heads in shame.

0:47:00.000 --> 0:47:03.779
<v Speaker 1>Too true. But, Caroline, I think it goes far beyond...

0:47:04.520 --> 0:47:08.759
<v Speaker 1>an errant government, to say the least. We have a

0:47:08.820 --> 0:47:13.890
<v Speaker 1>whole generation of children now who seem programmed to hate Israel,

0:47:14.770 --> 0:47:18.670
<v Speaker 1>to despise the West, to turn a blind eye to

0:47:18.710 --> 0:47:23.740
<v Speaker 1>Hamas terrorism, to march in our streets scaring Jews. I mean,

0:47:23.780 --> 0:47:24.780
<v Speaker 1>it's really frightening.

0:47:27.219 --> 0:47:30.290
<v Speaker 13>It is really frightening. And to what Gemma said, and

0:47:30.330 --> 0:47:34.590
<v Speaker 13>I suppose an overall point that goes to your remarks

0:47:34.650 --> 0:47:38.690
<v Speaker 13>just now, the best time to solve a problem is

0:47:38.890 --> 0:47:41.270
<v Speaker 13>as soon as you first become aware of it. And

0:47:41.330 --> 0:47:43.049
<v Speaker 13>if you don't do it as soon as you become

0:47:43.110 --> 0:47:46.230
<v Speaker 13>aware of it, the next best time is now. And

0:47:46.270 --> 0:47:48.370
<v Speaker 13>the problem is there has been a total failure of

0:47:48.469 --> 0:47:52.730
<v Speaker 13>leadership in this country to call out the BS when

0:47:52.790 --> 0:47:57.180
<v Speaker 13>it needed to be called out. at the Opera House steps,

0:47:57.719 --> 0:48:02.660
<v Speaker 13>across the bridge, at our university campuses, and then ultimately

0:48:02.860 --> 0:48:08.760
<v Speaker 13>with the catastrophic terrorist attack on Bondi Beach last year. Now,

0:48:09.300 --> 0:48:11.770
<v Speaker 13>you know, it's very, very difficult to say, had this

0:48:11.830 --> 0:48:15.509
<v Speaker 13>been done, this wouldn't have happened or whatever. We don't

0:48:15.570 --> 0:48:19.259
<v Speaker 13>know that. But we can always mitigate risks. And there

0:48:19.300 --> 0:48:24.230
<v Speaker 13>have been risks. Those risks have been obvious. Government has

0:48:24.290 --> 0:48:26.509
<v Speaker 13>known about them and the government has chosen not to

0:48:26.570 --> 0:48:30.370
<v Speaker 13>mitigate those risks. The people who should be showing leadership

0:48:30.550 --> 0:48:35.350
<v Speaker 13>have absolutely failed to show any leadership on this issue.

0:48:35.670 --> 0:48:36.870
<v Speaker 10>And that's why you have.

0:48:36.890 --> 0:48:39.890
<v Speaker 13>The problem with the generation of kids that hates Israel.

0:48:40.290 --> 0:48:42.469
<v Speaker 1>Fix the problem. You are so correct, but I would

0:48:42.530 --> 0:48:46.040
<v Speaker 1>add the vice chancellors of some universities, I would add

0:48:46.080 --> 0:48:49.640
<v Speaker 1>them as well, and the educators, all that kind of stuff.

0:48:50.140 --> 0:48:55.740
<v Speaker 1>I've got to go. Carolyn DiRusso and the lovely Gemma Tonini,

0:48:55.800 --> 0:48:58.080
<v Speaker 1>thank you very much to you both. Coming up now

0:48:58.100 --> 0:48:59.350
<v Speaker 1>is Shari Markson. Good night.