WEBVTT - Paul Murray Live | 6 October

0:00:05.510 --> 0:00:08.150
<v Speaker 1>Good evening, Australia. Caleb Bond in for Paul Murray. And

0:00:08.190 --> 0:00:10.489
<v Speaker 1>thank you to Jonathan Lee for that fascinating interview with

0:00:10.550 --> 0:00:13.230
<v Speaker 1>Geoffrey Archer, who died overnight at the age of 86.

0:00:13.210 --> 0:00:16.259
<v Speaker 1>He lived what I think you could describe as a

0:00:16.620 --> 0:00:20.220
<v Speaker 1>colourful life, from living in John Cleese's childhood home to

0:00:20.239 --> 0:00:23.840
<v Speaker 1>a scholarship that kicked off his life, basically, to being

0:00:23.880 --> 0:00:27.270
<v Speaker 1>an MP and a Conservative Party official, to writing his

0:00:27.330 --> 0:00:29.750
<v Speaker 1>first book in 1976, because, as you heard, he was

0:00:29.810 --> 0:00:32.409
<v Speaker 1>on the verge of bankruptcy after being caught... In a

0:00:32.450 --> 0:00:36.570
<v Speaker 1>dodgy investment scheme to entering the House of Lords in

0:00:36.570 --> 0:00:40.089
<v Speaker 1>1992 and later being jailed in 2001 for perjury in

0:00:40.110 --> 0:00:42.650
<v Speaker 1>a libel case, he ran against the Daily Star for

0:00:42.710 --> 0:00:45.900
<v Speaker 1>publishing that he had paid a prostitute for sex. And

0:00:45.960 --> 0:00:49.519
<v Speaker 1>dozens of books written and more than 300 million copies

0:00:50.220 --> 0:00:52.120
<v Speaker 1>sold along the way. It makes him one of the

0:00:52.159 --> 0:00:55.210
<v Speaker 1>best-selling authors of all time. If you missed any of

0:00:55.250 --> 0:00:57.290
<v Speaker 1>that interview, you can watch it again at 8pm here

0:00:57.790 --> 0:01:01.130
<v Speaker 1>on News 24 this Friday. Now, let's turn to today's news.

0:01:01.230 --> 0:01:03.990
<v Speaker 1>Coming up tonight, Jonathan Dunham will join me shortly to

0:01:04.030 --> 0:01:07.030
<v Speaker 1>talk about the Coalition's new migration strategy and plenty to

0:01:07.080 --> 0:01:11.000
<v Speaker 1>discuss with Carlos Caremba and Stephen Conroy on the panel tonight,

0:01:11.060 --> 0:01:15.900
<v Speaker 1>including One Nation's plan to ban burqas in schools. But first,

0:01:15.959 --> 0:01:18.980
<v Speaker 1>every fortnight on this program, we get a new News

0:01:18.980 --> 0:01:21.900
<v Speaker 1>24 YouGov Pulse poll to measure the mood of the nation...

0:01:22.030 --> 0:01:24.570
<v Speaker 1>and I have the latest edition right here in my

0:01:24.630 --> 0:01:33.160
<v Speaker 1>hands tonight. So let's see what you're thinking. So the

0:01:33.180 --> 0:01:35.880
<v Speaker 1>headline out of this is that Labor has recorded its

0:01:36.040 --> 0:01:40.119
<v Speaker 1>lowest primary result in history. Let's look at the primary votes.

0:01:40.280 --> 0:01:43.200
<v Speaker 1>One Nation is still on top, up 1.28%. The government

0:01:43.220 --> 0:01:44.830
<v Speaker 1>is down 1.25%, its lowest result ever. I'll come back

0:01:44.890 --> 0:01:52.890
<v Speaker 1>to that in a moment. The coalition is steady at 21%.

0:01:52.890 --> 0:01:57.110
<v Speaker 1>The Greens are up 1.15%, so slight uptick after changing

0:01:57.170 --> 0:02:00.540
<v Speaker 1>leaders from Larissa Waters to David Shoebridge. And the Greens

0:02:00.580 --> 0:02:02.860
<v Speaker 1>have probably had a bit more coverage in the past

0:02:02.920 --> 0:02:05.680
<v Speaker 1>week because of that, so probably not a huge surprise.

0:02:06.170 --> 0:02:10.540
<v Speaker 1>and others, independents, et cetera, at 11%. So, as I said,

0:02:11.260 --> 0:02:15.320
<v Speaker 1>that is Labor's worst primary result ever. It's the lowest

0:02:15.340 --> 0:02:17.880
<v Speaker 1>they've ever been in a YouGov poll. If they went

0:02:17.919 --> 0:02:20.320
<v Speaker 1>to an election today and that was the result, it

0:02:20.419 --> 0:02:24.109
<v Speaker 1>would be their worst on record. Now, of course, this

0:02:24.190 --> 0:02:27.130
<v Speaker 1>polling was done while interest rates went up, and there's

0:02:27.169 --> 0:02:29.690
<v Speaker 1>been a lot of pressure on the government about its spending,

0:02:30.070 --> 0:02:32.130
<v Speaker 1>and it would seem that it is now starting to

0:02:32.169 --> 0:02:35.740
<v Speaker 1>cut through. The fact that inflation... is still too high

0:02:35.760 --> 0:02:37.639
<v Speaker 1>and that's why you have to pay more on your mortgage,

0:02:38.020 --> 0:02:40.440
<v Speaker 1>people are waking up to the fact that the government

0:02:40.560 --> 0:02:43.380
<v Speaker 1>is a big driver of that. And they don't believe

0:02:43.440 --> 0:02:45.739
<v Speaker 1>this line, that it's all because of the war in

0:02:45.760 --> 0:02:50.059
<v Speaker 1>the Middle East. 63% of people disagree with the Treasurer

0:02:50.240 --> 0:02:53.180
<v Speaker 1>that interest rate rises are due to the war in

0:02:53.220 --> 0:02:55.800
<v Speaker 1>the Middle East, need I say any more. I think

0:02:55.840 --> 0:02:59.350
<v Speaker 1>this is cutting through more and more, that the government... expected,

0:02:59.400 --> 0:03:02.100
<v Speaker 1>more than they expected, I should say, and voters aren't

0:03:02.160 --> 0:03:06.359
<v Speaker 1>taking kindly to the responsibility being shunted onto someone else.

0:03:06.400 --> 0:03:08.900
<v Speaker 1>They want someone to fix the problem, not to tell

0:03:08.960 --> 0:03:12.120
<v Speaker 1>them that it's someone else's fault. At the end of

0:03:12.160 --> 0:03:14.360
<v Speaker 1>the day, it doesn't really matter whose fault it is.

0:03:14.400 --> 0:03:17.519
<v Speaker 1>You're the government. You're in charge. People are watching their

0:03:17.560 --> 0:03:21.200
<v Speaker 1>mortgages go up and their real wages go down, and

0:03:21.220 --> 0:03:23.360
<v Speaker 1>they're crying out for something to be done about it.

0:03:24.000 --> 0:03:27.139
<v Speaker 1>And it's working class voters, the battlers, that Labor has

0:03:27.180 --> 0:03:31.669
<v Speaker 1>a real problem with. Only 22% of working class voters

0:03:31.710 --> 0:03:36.010
<v Speaker 1>support Labor in this pulse poll versus 36% for One Nation.

0:03:36.490 --> 0:03:39.990
<v Speaker 1>So they're bleeding votes big time from what should really

0:03:40.070 --> 0:03:42.970
<v Speaker 1>be their bread and butter demographic. And if you look

0:03:42.990 --> 0:03:45.570
<v Speaker 1>at this, this is the change in the primary vote.

0:03:45.980 --> 0:03:48.780
<v Speaker 1>from the election last year to now, it makes it

0:03:48.840 --> 0:03:51.720
<v Speaker 1>clear that the rise of One Nation has not just

0:03:51.780 --> 0:03:55.760
<v Speaker 1>been driven by disaffected coalition voters. The turn away from

0:03:55.800 --> 0:03:59.860
<v Speaker 1>the coalition and Labor are pretty similar. They're down 10.8%

0:03:59.860 --> 0:04:03.400
<v Speaker 1>for the coalition and 9.6% for Labor. Of course, One

0:04:03.460 --> 0:04:08.120
<v Speaker 1>Nation up by 21.6%. But if they're in election today,

0:04:08.700 --> 0:04:11.720
<v Speaker 1>the government would still be winning the two-party preferred vote.

0:04:12.290 --> 0:04:16.300
<v Speaker 1>is 52-48 Labor's way when it's calculated against the Coalition,

0:04:16.770 --> 0:04:20.440
<v Speaker 1>and to One Nation, it's 53-47 Labor's way, which is

0:04:20.460 --> 0:04:22.820
<v Speaker 1>a small bump for One Nation from a fortnight ago.

0:04:23.320 --> 0:04:27.250
<v Speaker 1>But still, on two-party preferred, Labor is ahead, and that

0:04:27.320 --> 0:04:30.710
<v Speaker 1>could well still give them the numbers to form government

0:04:30.870 --> 0:04:34.580
<v Speaker 1>if there were an election. In the preferred Prime Minister stakes,

0:04:35.140 --> 0:04:38.350
<v Speaker 1>Angus Taylor has closed the gap. Anthony Albanese is now

0:04:38.410 --> 0:04:41.130
<v Speaker 1>only one point ahead of Mr Taylor, which is his

0:04:41.150 --> 0:04:43.450
<v Speaker 1>best result in a while. The gap was down to

0:04:43.510 --> 0:04:45.790
<v Speaker 1>three points in June, but it blew out to 11

0:04:45.790 --> 0:04:50.060
<v Speaker 1>points in July. Against Pauline Hanson, the PM is ahead

0:04:50.120 --> 0:04:53.570
<v Speaker 1>by 10 points. so people are more certain of who

0:04:53.589 --> 0:04:57.460
<v Speaker 1>they'd prefer as Prime Minister, but Mr Albanese is more popular.

0:04:57.800 --> 0:05:01.000
<v Speaker 1>But interestingly for Mr Taylor, he might have closed the

0:05:01.040 --> 0:05:04.830
<v Speaker 1>gap a bit on preferred PM, but his net satisfaction

0:05:04.910 --> 0:05:09.470
<v Speaker 1>rating is down four points to minus 16. Now, some

0:05:09.490 --> 0:05:12.349
<v Speaker 1>of the more interesting policy questions, of course, I showed

0:05:12.370 --> 0:05:14.640
<v Speaker 1>you before that People don't believe the war in the

0:05:14.680 --> 0:05:17.220
<v Speaker 1>Middle East is to blame for interest rate rises, but

0:05:17.680 --> 0:05:20.520
<v Speaker 1>on the question of the war itself, people were asked

0:05:20.600 --> 0:05:26.500
<v Speaker 1>how secure they feel Australia is from external threats. Only 11%,

0:05:26.500 --> 0:05:29.020
<v Speaker 1>as you can see there, said that they felt we

0:05:29.100 --> 0:05:34.919
<v Speaker 1>were secure from realistic external threats. The majority, 56%, said

0:05:34.940 --> 0:05:38.250
<v Speaker 1>they felt Australia was fairly secure now but were concerned

0:05:38.290 --> 0:05:42.900
<v Speaker 1>that we may not be in the future. And a third, 33%,

0:05:42.900 --> 0:05:46.240
<v Speaker 1>said Australia wasn't secure and that we urgently need to

0:05:46.300 --> 0:05:49.260
<v Speaker 1>do more to protect ourselves. That's a lot of people

0:05:49.520 --> 0:05:53.610
<v Speaker 1>worried about the safety of Australia, and rightly so. People

0:05:53.620 --> 0:05:57.290
<v Speaker 1>are looking at an unstable world, and I suspect thinking that,

0:05:57.390 --> 0:06:00.550
<v Speaker 1>you know, up against China, we would be in big trouble.

0:06:01.089 --> 0:06:03.589
<v Speaker 1>And on migration, which is, of course, the flavour of

0:06:03.630 --> 0:06:06.909
<v Speaker 1>the day, people were asked about the Albanese government's cuts

0:06:06.970 --> 0:06:10.549
<v Speaker 1>to backpacker visas. Now, Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke announced

0:06:10.589 --> 0:06:14.010
<v Speaker 1>last month that there'd be a cap of 45,000 on

0:06:14.310 --> 0:06:16.650
<v Speaker 1>the number of temporary workers who could stay for a

0:06:16.710 --> 0:06:20.630
<v Speaker 1>second year, which would be down from 57,000 who qualified

0:06:20.650 --> 0:06:23.160
<v Speaker 1>this year. And the number allowed to stay for a

0:06:23.300 --> 0:06:26.660
<v Speaker 1>third year would be cut to 5,000 compared to 31,000

0:06:26.660 --> 0:06:31.940
<v Speaker 1>this year. So a significant cut. 62% of people said

0:06:31.980 --> 0:06:34.670
<v Speaker 1>in this poll that it shouldn't be cut. 20% said

0:06:34.690 --> 0:06:39.719
<v Speaker 1>it should be and 18% didn't know. Now, of course,

0:06:39.760 --> 0:06:42.380
<v Speaker 1>there's been a lot of blowback from farmers and regional

0:06:42.460 --> 0:06:45.200
<v Speaker 1>areas because they rely on backpacker work to pick the

0:06:45.240 --> 0:06:47.640
<v Speaker 1>fruit and the veg and staff the pubs and stuff

0:06:47.680 --> 0:06:51.150
<v Speaker 1>like that. I think people are worried about migration and

0:06:51.190 --> 0:06:53.490
<v Speaker 1>they want it cut, but they want it cut in

0:06:53.510 --> 0:06:56.610
<v Speaker 1>the right areas. And to be honest, you don't hear

0:06:56.670 --> 0:07:00.150
<v Speaker 1>too many people complaining about backpackers, do you? So that's

0:07:00.190 --> 0:07:03.390
<v Speaker 1>the nuts and bolts of tonight's News24 YouGov Pulse poll.

0:07:03.470 --> 0:07:05.390
<v Speaker 1>And if you want more details and data, you can

0:07:05.450 --> 0:07:10.310
<v Speaker 1>go to news24. com. au. The data is dropping online right now.

0:07:10.380 --> 0:07:12.160
<v Speaker 1>But of course, the big story out of all of

0:07:12.200 --> 0:07:16.120
<v Speaker 1>that is that Labor has recorded its lowest primary result

0:07:16.460 --> 0:07:19.880
<v Speaker 1>in a YouGov poll ever. It's not good news for

0:07:19.900 --> 0:07:23.470
<v Speaker 1>the Prime Minister or the Treasurer after a pretty galling

0:07:23.570 --> 0:07:26.030
<v Speaker 1>week when it came to interest rates and their denial

0:07:26.090 --> 0:07:29.470
<v Speaker 1>that it has anything to do with inflation being caused

0:07:29.550 --> 0:07:32.230
<v Speaker 1>by the federal government. Now, moving to the big story

0:07:32.250 --> 0:07:35.400
<v Speaker 1>of the day, the Coalition's migration policy. A little earlier,

0:07:35.460 --> 0:07:40.480
<v Speaker 1>I spoke to Shadow Home Affairs and Immigration Minister Jonathan Duniam. Jonathan,

0:07:40.520 --> 0:07:44.550
<v Speaker 1>thank you for joining me. Obviously, a significant policy that

0:07:44.610 --> 0:07:48.210
<v Speaker 1>has been announced today. As your leader put it, Angus Taylor,

0:07:48.370 --> 0:07:52.650
<v Speaker 1>the biggest cuts to migration in Australian history is what

0:07:52.690 --> 0:07:53.880
<v Speaker 1>you are proposing.

0:07:54.440 --> 0:07:55.820
<v Speaker 2>We've seen Labor talk.

0:07:55.640 --> 0:07:58.180
<v Speaker 1>About the fact that they want to cut migration. They

0:07:58.240 --> 0:08:01.260
<v Speaker 1>failed to do it. How do you actually do it?

0:08:02.300 --> 0:08:05.180
<v Speaker 3>Well, it's not rocket science, Caleb, and this is the thing.

0:08:05.280 --> 0:08:08.790
<v Speaker 4>The wringing the hands approach, the tinkering around the edges

0:08:08.850 --> 0:08:11.310
<v Speaker 4>that Labor have done has got us to where we

0:08:11.430 --> 0:08:12.150
<v Speaker 4>are today.

0:08:12.170 --> 0:08:13.810
<v Speaker 3>I mean, they've been in government for.

0:08:13.750 --> 0:08:17.930
<v Speaker 4>Nearly half a decade and they're talking tough on migration,

0:08:17.970 --> 0:08:21.310
<v Speaker 4>but the numbers that Tony Burke announced at his press

0:08:21.350 --> 0:08:24.710
<v Speaker 4>club address today just a few weeks ago, virtually where

0:08:24.750 --> 0:08:27.680
<v Speaker 4>they were when they last let their numbers out at

0:08:27.920 --> 0:08:30.520
<v Speaker 4>the budget. So they're really doing nothing about it. Now,

0:08:30.560 --> 0:08:33.040
<v Speaker 4>how do you actually bring numbers down? Well, you meaningfully

0:08:33.100 --> 0:08:37.060
<v Speaker 4>target the pipelines that are bringing these people in, in

0:08:37.179 --> 0:08:41.100
<v Speaker 4>the huge numbers they're coming in. We've targeted temporary graduate

0:08:41.140 --> 0:08:44.230
<v Speaker 4>visa holders. Those are those people who, international students who

0:08:44.270 --> 0:08:47.110
<v Speaker 4>have completed their study and have then taken up the

0:08:47.170 --> 0:08:50.069
<v Speaker 4>option of being able to, as they're entitled to do

0:08:50.250 --> 0:08:54.250
<v Speaker 4>under current arrangements, get a visa as a temporary graduate. Now,

0:08:54.270 --> 0:08:56.110
<v Speaker 4>that doesn't mean you have to work in the field

0:08:56.150 --> 0:08:58.890
<v Speaker 4>that you studied in. And in fact, it's often the

0:08:58.929 --> 0:09:01.319
<v Speaker 4>case they don't. There are a huge number of the

0:09:01.380 --> 0:09:04.220
<v Speaker 4>people existing in our temporary visa population at the moment,

0:09:04.240 --> 0:09:06.640
<v Speaker 4>and they need to be cleared out. We would abolish

0:09:06.679 --> 0:09:09.730
<v Speaker 4>the temporary graduate visa. Similarly, 414,000 people on bridging visas

0:09:09.780 --> 0:09:16.970
<v Speaker 4>in this country. waiting to have their applications processed. That's madness.

0:09:16.970 --> 0:09:20.800
<v Speaker 4>414,000 people who probably, many of them shouldn't be here.

0:09:21.100 --> 0:09:25.420
<v Speaker 4>We need to process them expeditiously and remove them. There will,

0:09:25.460 --> 0:09:28.920
<v Speaker 4>of course, be a halving of the humanitarian intake. Labor

0:09:29.000 --> 0:09:32.179
<v Speaker 4>want 20,000 people here under the humanitarian intake. We think

0:09:32.220 --> 0:09:34.500
<v Speaker 4>we can halve that down to 10,000. We should always

0:09:34.559 --> 0:09:37.470
<v Speaker 4>do our bit for those in need, but the numbers

0:09:37.510 --> 0:09:39.290
<v Speaker 4>have to come down and they're some of the areas

0:09:39.330 --> 0:09:39.870
<v Speaker 4>we're targeting.

0:09:40.420 --> 0:09:42.720
<v Speaker 1>I'll start with the students and I'll come back to

0:09:43.380 --> 0:09:47.400
<v Speaker 1>the temporary protection visas. So you cut the numbers there,

0:09:47.540 --> 0:09:49.679
<v Speaker 1>as you say, by getting rid of these graduate visas.

0:09:49.730 --> 0:09:52.290
<v Speaker 1>You will also get rid of, in most cases, a

0:09:52.390 --> 0:09:54.930
<v Speaker 1>secondary partner visa for students when they come out. So

0:09:54.950 --> 0:09:58.130
<v Speaker 1>they wouldn't be able to bring someone with them. What

0:09:58.170 --> 0:10:00.630
<v Speaker 1>effect does that have on housing? Because, of course, some

0:10:00.670 --> 0:10:04.580
<v Speaker 1>of these students would be living in specific student accommodation.

0:10:04.820 --> 0:10:06.780
<v Speaker 1>What does that do to actually open up the housing market?

0:10:07.340 --> 0:10:10.640
<v Speaker 4>Yeah, well, we know that half of international students actually

0:10:10.679 --> 0:10:13.620
<v Speaker 4>do live in the private rental market. Now, often they're

0:10:13.640 --> 0:10:18.339
<v Speaker 4>in share houses, but when you're talking about a population.

0:10:17.740 --> 0:10:19.400
<v Speaker 3>Across the country under Labor's numbers.

0:10:20.120 --> 0:10:24.720
<v Speaker 4>of 290,000 international students in any given academic year. That's

0:10:24.760 --> 0:10:27.080
<v Speaker 4>a lot of people in the private rental market, predominantly

0:10:27.120 --> 0:10:30.660
<v Speaker 4>in Melbourne, Sydney, Brisbane, perhaps even Perth and let's say

0:10:30.679 --> 0:10:35.010
<v Speaker 4>Hobart and Adelaide as well. Yes, there's university accommodation, but

0:10:35.050 --> 0:10:37.290
<v Speaker 4>it is part of the pressure that we need to alleviate.

0:10:38.220 --> 0:10:40.599
<v Speaker 4>as a government, and that's why we've decided that it

0:10:40.660 --> 0:10:41.500
<v Speaker 4>would be.

0:10:41.380 --> 0:10:42.230
<v Speaker 3>A positive impact.

0:10:42.260 --> 0:10:45.330
<v Speaker 4>Now, we brought, under these measures, we believe the number

0:10:45.350 --> 0:10:48.949
<v Speaker 4>will come down to 240,000, and we are prepared to

0:10:48.990 --> 0:10:51.150
<v Speaker 4>put in a hard cap on the number of international

0:10:51.200 --> 0:10:55.400
<v Speaker 4>students we bring into this country at that level as well.

0:10:56.140 --> 0:10:59.630
<v Speaker 4>But Just on housing, I might also point out that

0:10:59.750 --> 0:11:03.390
<v Speaker 4>with our approach to getting rid of the temporary graduate visas,

0:11:03.410 --> 0:11:05.209
<v Speaker 4>which I'm sure we'll talk more about, we want to

0:11:05.250 --> 0:11:07.570
<v Speaker 4>focus on skilled visas, bringing in people with skills we

0:11:07.590 --> 0:11:10.960
<v Speaker 4>actually need, starting first with people in the construction and

0:11:11.000 --> 0:11:13.860
<v Speaker 4>building sector so we can build the houses Labor is not.

0:11:14.270 --> 0:11:16.740
<v Speaker 4>That's a big part of what we announced today and

0:11:16.760 --> 0:11:18.640
<v Speaker 4>will go a long way to resolving the issue that

0:11:19.020 --> 0:11:21.859
<v Speaker 4>Labor have left us with, with not enough homes built

0:11:21.880 --> 0:11:23.380
<v Speaker 4>for the people that live here today, let alone the

0:11:23.480 --> 0:11:24.719
<v Speaker 4>ones they want to bring in.

0:11:25.230 --> 0:11:28.130
<v Speaker 1>So with the bridging and temporary protection visas, as you say,

0:11:28.770 --> 0:11:32.059
<v Speaker 1>more than 414,000 of them now. You want that down

0:11:32.120 --> 0:11:37.420
<v Speaker 1>to 20,000. How do you achieve that? Is this effectively

0:11:37.580 --> 0:11:40.229
<v Speaker 1>mass deportations? No.

0:11:40.510 --> 0:11:43.510
<v Speaker 4>Look, what it is is getting government agencies to do

0:11:43.570 --> 0:11:45.790
<v Speaker 4>their job and resourcing them to be able to do so.

0:11:46.910 --> 0:11:48.920
<v Speaker 3>The fact that government goes slow.

0:11:48.760 --> 0:11:50.900
<v Speaker 4>On applications, which is often the case, we heard the

0:11:50.940 --> 0:11:53.720
<v Speaker 4>Minister himself admit to the Press Club a few weeks

0:11:53.780 --> 0:11:57.220
<v Speaker 4>ago that with working holidaymakers, for example, they basically just

0:11:57.240 --> 0:12:01.140
<v Speaker 4>stopped processing the applications for visas for that cohort. That's

0:12:01.179 --> 0:12:03.230
<v Speaker 4>a group of people farmers need to pick their fruit

0:12:03.790 --> 0:12:06.830
<v Speaker 4>this harvest season. That's a group of people that, of course,

0:12:07.090 --> 0:12:10.810
<v Speaker 4>tourism and hospitality businesses need to serve drinks, make beds,

0:12:10.870 --> 0:12:14.740
<v Speaker 4>cook meals. They just stop processing them. They can speed

0:12:14.800 --> 0:12:17.380
<v Speaker 4>these things up and they should. With the use of

0:12:17.440 --> 0:12:21.840
<v Speaker 4>technology and additional resources and allocating staff from within the

0:12:21.860 --> 0:12:25.320
<v Speaker 4>Department of Home Affairs, we will absolutely be able to

0:12:25.480 --> 0:12:28.949
<v Speaker 4>use the resources available to us to expedite the dealing

0:12:28.990 --> 0:12:32.270
<v Speaker 4>with the backlog of bridging visas. That needs to be

0:12:32.309 --> 0:12:33.670
<v Speaker 4>dealt with as a matter of urgency.

0:12:34.250 --> 0:12:37.670
<v Speaker 1>So net overseas migration would be cut to 100,000 in

0:12:37.690 --> 0:12:39.550
<v Speaker 1>the first two years of a coalition government, 130,000 in

0:12:39.570 --> 0:12:41.230
<v Speaker 1>the third year and then 160,000 in the fourth year.

0:12:41.250 --> 0:12:41.990
<v Speaker 1>What's the plan beyond that?

0:12:45.720 --> 0:12:48.570
<v Speaker 4>Well, obviously, the world in the early 2030s is going

0:12:48.590 --> 0:12:50.110
<v Speaker 4>to be a little different to the world we live

0:12:50.170 --> 0:12:52.349
<v Speaker 4>in today. Now, all things going well, there'll be a

0:12:52.350 --> 0:12:56.160
<v Speaker 4>coalition government elected. We'll have addressed the housing crisis and,

0:12:56.340 --> 0:12:58.920
<v Speaker 4>of course, been able to add to the housing stock,

0:12:58.960 --> 0:13:02.890
<v Speaker 4>which means we could start look at... looking at rather

0:13:03.690 --> 0:13:06.290
<v Speaker 4>immigration intakes that might be increased. But again, we won't

0:13:06.410 --> 0:13:09.090
<v Speaker 4>know until we get to that point in time. If

0:13:09.130 --> 0:13:11.390
<v Speaker 4>we've caught up, and this is the point of cutting

0:13:11.530 --> 0:13:14.790
<v Speaker 4>immigration to the levels we're talking about here, 100,000 in

0:13:14.830 --> 0:13:17.250
<v Speaker 4>the first year, that's a third of where Labor are

0:13:17.410 --> 0:13:21.330
<v Speaker 4>at now. 100,000 in the second is about catching up.

0:13:21.790 --> 0:13:24.290
<v Speaker 4>We need to address the problems we face today when

0:13:24.340 --> 0:13:28.520
<v Speaker 4>it comes to housing, health, other essential services like education,

0:13:28.640 --> 0:13:29.640
<v Speaker 4>public infrastructure.

0:13:30.420 --> 0:13:33.219
<v Speaker 3>There is pressure on those services now, today.

0:13:34.240 --> 0:13:38.210
<v Speaker 4>Our temporary visa population in Australia is at 3 million.

0:13:38.330 --> 0:13:40.770
<v Speaker 4>Before COVID, it was at 2 million. We need to

0:13:40.830 --> 0:13:45.230
<v Speaker 4>reduce that population. We'll bring it down by 650,000. As

0:13:45.270 --> 0:13:47.510
<v Speaker 4>a result of our work in those four years, at

0:13:47.530 --> 0:13:49.990
<v Speaker 4>the end of those four years, or at least leading

0:13:50.030 --> 0:13:52.490
<v Speaker 4>into it, we will be able to tell Australians what

0:13:52.590 --> 0:13:55.050
<v Speaker 4>we would do for the next four so they can plan,

0:13:55.370 --> 0:13:58.030
<v Speaker 4>so businesses can plan, so our economy has a plan

0:13:58.050 --> 0:14:00.660
<v Speaker 4>to grow. It's not rocket science, as I said before,

0:14:00.720 --> 0:14:02.860
<v Speaker 4>but Labor seem to stuff it up at every chance.

0:14:03.660 --> 0:14:05.820
<v Speaker 4>We want to get this right and we've demonstrated today

0:14:05.860 --> 0:14:08.939
<v Speaker 4>with this detailed policy that we have what it takes.

0:14:09.420 --> 0:14:11.460
<v Speaker 1>And I think there are incentives built into that to

0:14:11.500 --> 0:14:13.740
<v Speaker 1>get the right people and send the right people to

0:14:13.760 --> 0:14:16.390
<v Speaker 1>the right places as well. which is also so important

0:14:16.429 --> 0:14:19.320
<v Speaker 1>to the mix of migration in this country. Jonathan Dunnian,

0:14:19.340 --> 0:14:20.300
<v Speaker 1>thank you for joining me tonight.

0:14:20.880 --> 0:14:21.500
<v Speaker 3>Thank you, Caleb.

0:14:21.520 --> 0:14:25.360
<v Speaker 1>All right, plenty more to discuss, including that issue. Joining

0:14:25.380 --> 0:14:28.660
<v Speaker 1>me now, South Australian One Nation MP Carlos Caremba and

0:14:28.740 --> 0:14:32.440
<v Speaker 1>former Labor Minister Stephen Conroy. Good to see you both, gents.

0:14:32.540 --> 0:14:36.810
<v Speaker 1>We'll start with that migration policy. Carlos, how do you

0:14:36.830 --> 0:14:39.110
<v Speaker 1>think it compares to the One Nation policy?

0:14:40.610 --> 0:14:43.530
<v Speaker 5>Well, I think, Caleb, the interesting thing here is, I mean,

0:14:43.550 --> 0:14:45.770
<v Speaker 5>a bit late to the party, but can you really

0:14:45.830 --> 0:14:48.100
<v Speaker 5>trust the Liberal Party to go through with what they've said?

0:14:48.540 --> 0:14:50.800
<v Speaker 5>I mean, it's been both parties that have worked together

0:14:50.820 --> 0:14:53.100
<v Speaker 5>to get us into this disaster, and I just don't

0:14:53.160 --> 0:14:55.160
<v Speaker 5>trust them to come through on their goods. And I

0:14:55.200 --> 0:14:57.230
<v Speaker 5>only heard before in that brief you had there with

0:14:58.210 --> 0:15:00.570
<v Speaker 5>the other member that after four years, well, we'll see

0:15:00.610 --> 0:15:02.930
<v Speaker 5>what happens and we might just ramp it up. look,

0:15:03.370 --> 0:15:05.360
<v Speaker 5>we need to have these discussions and they wouldn't be

0:15:05.400 --> 0:15:06.940
<v Speaker 5>happening if it wasn't for One Nation.

0:15:06.960 --> 0:15:09.280
<v Speaker 2>So I'm just glad we're here. The people are listening.

0:15:09.400 --> 0:15:11.140
<v Speaker 2>They're showing that in the polls.

0:15:11.560 --> 0:15:13.180
<v Speaker 5>And only One Nation is actually going to do what

0:15:13.220 --> 0:15:14.760
<v Speaker 5>needs to be done to get this country back on

0:15:14.800 --> 0:15:17.620
<v Speaker 5>track when it comes to immigration.

0:15:17.620 --> 0:15:21.210
<v Speaker 1>$ 100, 000 for two years, Stephen, is a pretty significant cut,

0:15:21.290 --> 0:15:26.170
<v Speaker 1>as it was put today by Angus Taylor. And it

0:15:26.210 --> 0:15:28.590
<v Speaker 1>would be the biggest in history. This is a little

0:15:28.790 --> 0:15:30.070
<v Speaker 1>of what he had to say this afternoon.

0:15:31.420 --> 0:15:34.780
<v Speaker 6>And what we are proposing today is the biggest cut

0:15:34.880 --> 0:15:39.380
<v Speaker 6>to immigration in the history of this country. That is

0:15:39.420 --> 0:15:43.420
<v Speaker 6>what is necessary right now, given the failures of the

0:15:43.460 --> 0:15:47.940
<v Speaker 6>Labor government. It will bring what we're announcing today, will

0:15:47.960 --> 0:15:50.260
<v Speaker 6>bring the numbers down to below the levels they were

0:15:50.360 --> 0:15:55.680
<v Speaker 6>at under the Howard Liberal National Government. It will be

0:15:55.760 --> 0:16:00.010
<v Speaker 6>putting Australia first and it will be putting our national

0:16:00.190 --> 0:16:00.930
<v Speaker 6>interest first.

0:16:02.070 --> 0:16:04.510
<v Speaker 1>I know the numbers seem dramatic, Stephen, but I don't

0:16:04.530 --> 0:16:06.210
<v Speaker 1>think it's unfair to say that we need a bit

0:16:06.250 --> 0:16:09.030
<v Speaker 1>of a reset after a few years of high migration.

0:16:12.370 --> 0:16:16.170
<v Speaker 7>Well, I think the, you know, trying to outdo One Nation,

0:16:16.370 --> 0:16:19.680
<v Speaker 7>I'm with Colas. Like, if you want the sort of

0:16:19.720 --> 0:16:23.920
<v Speaker 7>flat earth immigration policy, just vote One Nation. Don't try

0:16:23.940 --> 0:16:26.960
<v Speaker 7>and pretend you're being tougher than One Nation, Angus, because

0:16:27.600 --> 0:16:28.900
<v Speaker 7>in the end, you're not going to be able to

0:16:28.940 --> 0:16:29.280
<v Speaker 7>prove it.

0:16:29.690 --> 0:16:31.720
<v Speaker 8>And people won't believe you for the very reasons Carlos

0:16:31.740 --> 0:16:32.510
<v Speaker 8>just described.

0:16:33.380 --> 0:16:35.100
<v Speaker 7>But the problem that the Libs have got is they're

0:16:35.140 --> 0:16:38.560
<v Speaker 7>so confident, so confident in their policy, they won't release

0:16:38.580 --> 0:16:43.540
<v Speaker 7>the costings. And they've made this comical assertion that it's

0:16:43.920 --> 0:16:48.440
<v Speaker 7>revenue neutral. The budget, the economy won't be affected because

0:16:48.880 --> 0:16:52.750
<v Speaker 7>the higher skilled migrants, will pay more tax and that

0:16:52.770 --> 0:16:58.310
<v Speaker 7>will make up for the overall reduction caused by dropping

0:16:58.350 --> 0:17:01.940
<v Speaker 7>to 100,000. I mean, that is just a comical assumption

0:17:02.260 --> 0:17:06.840
<v Speaker 7>that you may as well just say, you know, there's

0:17:06.859 --> 0:17:08.619
<v Speaker 7>going to be a net increase in the economy because

0:17:08.660 --> 0:17:08.840
<v Speaker 7>of it.

0:17:08.900 --> 0:17:10.820
<v Speaker 8>I mean, it's just a farcical assertion.

0:17:11.880 --> 0:17:16.119
<v Speaker 7>And one of the biggest slabs of the reductions is

0:17:16.140 --> 0:17:20.140
<v Speaker 7>that we can process them faster. This, again, is just

0:17:20.320 --> 0:17:25.070
<v Speaker 7>a mythical assertion. The department has been struggling for many

0:17:25.130 --> 0:17:27.410
<v Speaker 7>years to be able to process visas. It's got an old,

0:17:27.670 --> 0:17:33.629
<v Speaker 7>decrepit IT system, which is almost impossible to make work

0:17:33.710 --> 0:17:36.670
<v Speaker 7>faster because it's so old, so underspend, goes back under

0:17:36.710 --> 0:17:41.939
<v Speaker 7>the Liberals under, you know, many, many, many years. The

0:17:42.000 --> 0:17:44.980
<v Speaker 7>IT system can't work faster. They'd have to, you know,

0:17:45.020 --> 0:17:46.960
<v Speaker 7>put 10 times the public servants on who work in

0:17:47.000 --> 0:17:49.199
<v Speaker 7>this section just to try and make it work faster.

0:17:49.640 --> 0:17:51.380
<v Speaker 8>And even then the IT just will hold them back.

0:17:51.859 --> 0:17:55.790
<v Speaker 7>So there's some very, very courageous assumptions to try and

0:17:55.810 --> 0:17:58.210
<v Speaker 7>make the numbers add up and they won't and they don't.

0:17:58.330 --> 0:18:00.649
<v Speaker 1>But just on that point, Stephen, the government's been in

0:18:00.730 --> 0:18:03.820
<v Speaker 1>power since 2022. What have they done about it?

0:18:06.710 --> 0:18:07.650
<v Speaker 8>In terms of the processing?

0:18:07.980 --> 0:18:08.400
<v Speaker 1>Yeah.

0:18:09.280 --> 0:18:12.040
<v Speaker 7>You know, in terms of the priorities, Labor's not trying

0:18:12.060 --> 0:18:15.460
<v Speaker 7>to pretend that it's going to process them faster. Labor's

0:18:15.480 --> 0:18:18.919
<v Speaker 7>not pretending that. They're pretending that they can reduce the

0:18:18.960 --> 0:18:21.810
<v Speaker 7>numbers just magically, and.

0:18:21.750 --> 0:18:23.590
<v Speaker 8>They won't be able to, which means they won't be

0:18:23.609 --> 0:18:25.850
<v Speaker 8>able to reach their targets. I'm agreeing with Carlos. They

0:18:25.890 --> 0:18:26.990
<v Speaker 8>won't reach their targets.

0:18:27.010 --> 0:18:29.650
<v Speaker 7>This is a practical reason that they won't be able

0:18:29.690 --> 0:18:32.379
<v Speaker 7>to reach their targets. Put aside their mythical, there'll be

0:18:32.390 --> 0:18:35.280
<v Speaker 7>just as much taxes with the other migrants coming in,

0:18:35.320 --> 0:18:38.760
<v Speaker 7>which is just a comical assertion. The practical assertion is

0:18:38.800 --> 0:18:42.399
<v Speaker 7>they won't be able to meet their target, and it

0:18:42.520 --> 0:18:44.760
<v Speaker 7>will not be possible in the real world.

0:18:45.300 --> 0:18:48.199
<v Speaker 1>You see, the thing that irks me, Carlos, about the

0:18:48.260 --> 0:18:51.700
<v Speaker 1>economic argument is that if you took away the migration

0:18:51.740 --> 0:18:56.080
<v Speaker 1>that we've had post-COVID, we would have gone into a

0:18:56.100 --> 0:18:58.820
<v Speaker 1>recession a long time ago, but we have not in

0:18:58.900 --> 0:19:04.280
<v Speaker 1>that time actually had any improvement in productivity. We've not

0:19:04.500 --> 0:19:08.080
<v Speaker 1>really had any real growth in the private sector. I mean,

0:19:08.220 --> 0:19:09.840
<v Speaker 1>in recent years, something like 75% of jobs.

0:19:11.859 --> 0:19:14.400
<v Speaker 1>Were in industries that were in some way funded by

0:19:14.440 --> 0:19:18.320
<v Speaker 1>the federal government. So it's effectively, the federal government allows

0:19:18.340 --> 0:19:20.080
<v Speaker 1>a lot of people to come to the country. It

0:19:20.100 --> 0:19:22.080
<v Speaker 1>then spends a lot of money giving them jobs. So

0:19:22.119 --> 0:19:25.119
<v Speaker 1>it looks on paper like we have a level of

0:19:25.180 --> 0:19:27.790
<v Speaker 1>economic growth and that prevents us from going into an

0:19:27.830 --> 0:19:30.530
<v Speaker 1>official recession. But at the same time, we've had a

0:19:30.730 --> 0:19:33.430
<v Speaker 1>per capita recession. because the money you've got in your

0:19:33.470 --> 0:19:37.409
<v Speaker 1>pocket versus GDP has been going backwards. So effectively, we

0:19:37.600 --> 0:19:41.760
<v Speaker 1>are in recession. So maybe do we have to accept that, yeah,

0:19:42.020 --> 0:19:45.369
<v Speaker 1>cutting migration to some degree is going to hurt the economy,

0:19:45.869 --> 0:19:47.930
<v Speaker 1>but that has to happen in some way.

0:19:49.670 --> 0:19:51.880
<v Speaker 5>And look, you're right Caleb and I would just say

0:19:51.940 --> 0:19:55.840
<v Speaker 5>also that If your economy is based on mass migration,

0:19:55.880 --> 0:19:58.179
<v Speaker 5>you don't have an economy, you've got a Ponzi scheme.

0:19:58.619 --> 0:20:00.820
<v Speaker 5>And that's not in the best interest, the long-term best

0:20:00.880 --> 0:20:04.050
<v Speaker 5>interest of this country. We all know that we need migrants.

0:20:04.290 --> 0:20:07.470
<v Speaker 5>But I'd also say that if mass migration was a

0:20:07.510 --> 0:20:10.270
<v Speaker 5>solution to our skills shortage, why after bringing in over

0:20:10.270 --> 0:20:12.990
<v Speaker 5>1.5 million people in the last five years do we

0:20:13.030 --> 0:20:16.140
<v Speaker 5>still have a skills shortage? Nothing is adding up. People

0:20:16.180 --> 0:20:18.879
<v Speaker 5>are seeing that their economic pie is getting smaller. and

0:20:18.920 --> 0:20:21.700
<v Speaker 5>the solution is just to bring in more people? Like,

0:20:21.720 --> 0:20:23.240
<v Speaker 5>at what point are we going to make the tough

0:20:23.280 --> 0:20:25.899
<v Speaker 5>decision and put this country back on track? And I'm

0:20:25.920 --> 0:20:27.520
<v Speaker 5>telling you now, it ain't going to be the Liberal

0:20:27.560 --> 0:20:29.859
<v Speaker 5>Party or the Labor Party, because they're so wedded to

0:20:29.900 --> 0:20:32.990
<v Speaker 5>this philosophy of just bringing more people in, because, as

0:20:33.050 --> 0:20:35.129
<v Speaker 5>our Premier said in South Australia, it's cheaper to make

0:20:35.150 --> 0:20:35.950
<v Speaker 5>them overseas and.

0:20:35.910 --> 0:20:38.690
<v Speaker 2>Bring them in than it is to breed them here. Well,

0:20:38.710 --> 0:20:40.690
<v Speaker 2>we're going to end up... We're going to end up...

0:20:40.750 --> 0:20:42.960
<v Speaker 2>And the country's going backwards and everybody's feeling it.

0:20:43.210 --> 0:20:45.390
<v Speaker 5>The polling is showing that. The sooner One Nation gets

0:20:45.430 --> 0:20:47.930
<v Speaker 5>hold of that immigration policy... Sure, there might be a

0:20:47.950 --> 0:20:49.680
<v Speaker 5>bit of short-term pain, but I tell you now there's

0:20:49.700 --> 0:20:51.800
<v Speaker 5>going to be a hell of a long-term gain for

0:20:51.820 --> 0:20:52.740
<v Speaker 5>the Australian people.

0:20:53.140 --> 0:20:55.040
<v Speaker 1>Well, you mentioned the polling, of course, so I went

0:20:55.060 --> 0:20:57.610
<v Speaker 1>through at the top of the show the new News24

0:20:57.850 --> 0:21:00.590
<v Speaker 1>YouGov Pulse poll that has dropped tonight. You can get

0:21:00.609 --> 0:21:04.530
<v Speaker 1>all the details at news24. com. au. But two of the most

0:21:04.590 --> 0:21:07.520
<v Speaker 1>interesting things out of it, Stephen, you've got Labor now

0:21:07.580 --> 0:21:14.680
<v Speaker 1>hitting its lowest... primary vote ever in any YouGov poll, 25%,

0:21:14.680 --> 0:21:19.290
<v Speaker 1>which is pretty extraordinary, and also 63% of people saying

0:21:19.330 --> 0:21:22.810
<v Speaker 1>that they don't buy this argument from the Treasurer that

0:21:22.910 --> 0:21:26.070
<v Speaker 1>interest rates are going up and inflation is going up

0:21:26.150 --> 0:21:28.990
<v Speaker 1>or is not being fixed because of the war in

0:21:29.030 --> 0:21:32.690
<v Speaker 1>the Middle East. It doesn't look terribly positive for the government, Stephen.

0:21:35.240 --> 0:21:39.450
<v Speaker 7>Look, I think the overall reaction is... to the Reserve

0:21:39.510 --> 0:21:42.730
<v Speaker 7>Bank increasing interest rates and threatening to do it again

0:21:42.780 --> 0:21:47.080
<v Speaker 7>going forward would be bad for any incumbent government. So

0:21:47.560 --> 0:21:51.120
<v Speaker 7>it's not a surprise to see that poll out, given

0:21:51.160 --> 0:21:55.780
<v Speaker 7>it was taken last week. But again, it underlines the

0:21:55.820 --> 0:22:00.970
<v Speaker 7>fundamental challenge for the Labor government, and that is not

0:22:00.990 --> 0:22:06.149
<v Speaker 7>to underestimate Carlos and One Nation. They're not some aberration

0:22:06.170 --> 0:22:09.460
<v Speaker 7>that's going to vanish in six months or 12 months.

0:22:10.520 --> 0:22:14.580
<v Speaker 7>The punters out there are filthy with governments over the

0:22:14.600 --> 0:22:17.899
<v Speaker 7>last 40 years, which is basically Labor and Liberal. I

0:22:17.940 --> 0:22:20.430
<v Speaker 7>don't believe, and we could argue with Carlos all night,

0:22:20.670 --> 0:22:23.570
<v Speaker 7>that the One Nation have a policy solution. They've got

0:22:23.609 --> 0:22:26.750
<v Speaker 7>a very good at expressing the anger and frustration that

0:22:26.790 --> 0:22:29.410
<v Speaker 7>people are feeling because at the end of the day,

0:22:29.450 --> 0:22:34.419
<v Speaker 7>the fundamental social contract between people and the government is

0:22:35.000 --> 0:22:37.280
<v Speaker 7>that our kids are going to be better off or

0:22:37.320 --> 0:22:38.800
<v Speaker 7>have a chance to be better.

0:22:38.640 --> 0:22:39.600
<v Speaker 8>Off than we are.

0:22:40.140 --> 0:22:43.380
<v Speaker 7>And what we've seen over the last five or six years,

0:22:43.800 --> 0:22:46.400
<v Speaker 7>or probably 10 years, is kids have worked out they're

0:22:46.440 --> 0:22:48.760
<v Speaker 7>not going to be better off and their parents have

0:22:48.800 --> 0:22:51.239
<v Speaker 7>worked out that kids aren't going to be better off.

0:22:52.060 --> 0:22:56.680
<v Speaker 7>And people are filthy. They're angry and they're expressing that anger.

0:22:58.060 --> 0:22:59.980
<v Speaker 7>And when interest rates then pile on top of that,

0:23:00.890 --> 0:23:03.890
<v Speaker 7>They are just filthy with, you know, both political parties.

0:23:03.950 --> 0:23:06.680
<v Speaker 7>And this is a challenge for Labor. They cannot afford

0:23:06.700 --> 0:23:09.720
<v Speaker 7>to underestimate this. I don't believe anyone in government is

0:23:09.740 --> 0:23:11.660
<v Speaker 7>sitting there going, oh, no, another interest rate increase.

0:23:11.680 --> 0:23:13.159
<v Speaker 8>That's a good thing.

0:23:13.540 --> 0:23:18.389
<v Speaker 7>But for the moment, for the moment, you know, the

0:23:18.430 --> 0:23:20.629
<v Speaker 7>average Australian is absolutely filthy on governments.

0:23:21.270 --> 0:23:24.369
<v Speaker 1>And I think it's really interesting as well, Carlos, you know,

0:23:24.390 --> 0:23:28.050
<v Speaker 1>coming from your angle in One Nation... If you look

0:23:28.090 --> 0:23:31.210
<v Speaker 1>at the comparison between the numbers that you see now

0:23:31.380 --> 0:23:35.859
<v Speaker 1>versus what they were at the federal election in 2025,

0:23:35.859 --> 0:23:40.919
<v Speaker 1>the split away from the coalition and Labor is pretty similar. Like,

0:23:41.000 --> 0:23:42.720
<v Speaker 1>as you can see, Labor is down 9.6% and the

0:23:42.740 --> 0:23:48.639
<v Speaker 1>coalition's down 10.8%. Labor has lost a little less than

0:23:48.660 --> 0:23:50.800
<v Speaker 1>the Coalition. But, you know, the talk for a long

0:23:50.840 --> 0:23:54.200
<v Speaker 1>time has been, well, it's basically disaffected Coalition people going

0:23:54.240 --> 0:23:56.420
<v Speaker 1>over to One Nation, maybe there's a bit of Labor

0:23:56.440 --> 0:23:58.770
<v Speaker 1>going with them as well. But you look at that

0:23:59.310 --> 0:24:01.930
<v Speaker 1>and it looks pretty clear that the split is quite even.

0:24:02.890 --> 0:24:06.850
<v Speaker 1>And also these numbers that, you know, 36% of working-class

0:24:06.930 --> 0:24:09.950
<v Speaker 1>people saying they support Labor versus 20..... for One Nation,

0:24:09.970 --> 0:24:14.470
<v Speaker 1>that is, 36% for One Nation versus 22%. for Labor.

0:24:14.869 --> 0:24:18.129
<v Speaker 1>So you are having a great deal of cut through

0:24:18.150 --> 0:24:20.530
<v Speaker 1>with working class Labor voters.

0:24:22.030 --> 0:24:23.050
<v Speaker 2>Well, that's right, Caleb.

0:24:23.090 --> 0:24:25.630
<v Speaker 5>And here in South Australia, we were only probably, I think,

0:24:25.710 --> 0:24:27.820
<v Speaker 5>if the election had been held three months later, we

0:24:27.859 --> 0:24:28.859
<v Speaker 5>would be in opposition.

0:24:29.440 --> 0:24:31.120
<v Speaker 2>We were 800 votes away.

0:24:30.980 --> 0:24:33.939
<v Speaker 5>From picking up a seat in the working class area

0:24:34.280 --> 0:24:37.040
<v Speaker 5>in the north of Adelaide. And we see the swing

0:24:37.100 --> 0:24:39.480
<v Speaker 5>against Labor in those blue collar seats. It used to

0:24:39.540 --> 0:24:43.300
<v Speaker 5>be really Labor centric, like Elizabeth and places like that.

0:24:43.800 --> 0:24:45.500
<v Speaker 2>Now swinging towards One Nation.

0:24:45.960 --> 0:24:48.950
<v Speaker 5>One of our largest voter increases has been in people

0:24:48.990 --> 0:24:53.629
<v Speaker 5>that are earning between zero and $ 50, 000. The Labor Party

0:24:53.650 --> 0:24:57.450
<v Speaker 5>has left the Labor version of their voter. They've now

0:24:57.510 --> 0:25:00.760
<v Speaker 5>moved to the, you know, to the more affluent areas

0:25:00.820 --> 0:25:02.760
<v Speaker 5>of Adelaide, and we're seeing that around the country, and

0:25:02.780 --> 0:25:03.600
<v Speaker 5>they've forgotten what.

0:25:03.900 --> 0:25:05.719
<v Speaker 2>It used to be to be a Labor voter.

0:25:05.840 --> 0:25:07.879
<v Speaker 5>And, you know, I think I would say to Stephen is,

0:25:08.200 --> 0:25:11.460
<v Speaker 5>has anybody in the Labor Party asked themselves a simple question?

0:25:11.800 --> 0:25:14.120
<v Speaker 5>Why would someone like me, who was a builder, had

0:25:14.140 --> 0:25:17.300
<v Speaker 5>a good life, decide to get into politics? And I

0:25:17.320 --> 0:25:18.580
<v Speaker 5>can tell you now, if you don't know the answer,

0:25:18.600 --> 0:25:20.320
<v Speaker 5>I'll give it to you, mate, is because I'm sick

0:25:20.340 --> 0:25:22.680
<v Speaker 5>and tired of listening to the Liberal Party and Labor

0:25:22.720 --> 0:25:23.840
<v Speaker 5>Party telling me about how.

0:25:23.740 --> 0:25:24.260
<v Speaker 2>Good it is.

0:25:24.540 --> 0:25:26.719
<v Speaker 5>And so I decided to do what a lot of Australians,

0:25:26.920 --> 0:25:29.080
<v Speaker 5>you know, a fair few are now standing up and going,

0:25:29.100 --> 0:25:30.980
<v Speaker 5>you know what, we want to take control of our country.

0:25:31.200 --> 0:25:33.300
<v Speaker 5>And if that means getting involved in politics, whether it's

0:25:33.540 --> 0:25:36.240
<v Speaker 5>becoming a member, getting into local government, or actually just,

0:25:36.270 --> 0:25:38.830
<v Speaker 5>you know what, voting away from the uni party, then

0:25:38.890 --> 0:25:39.350
<v Speaker 5>so be it.

0:25:39.550 --> 0:25:41.330
<v Speaker 2>And I think those numbers are going to get stronger.

0:25:41.710 --> 0:25:43.150
<v Speaker 5>And it's going to be interesting to see at what

0:25:43.210 --> 0:25:45.350
<v Speaker 5>point do they decide to course correct or do they

0:25:45.390 --> 0:25:46.790
<v Speaker 5>run their ship into the bottom of the ocean?

0:25:46.830 --> 0:25:47.230
<v Speaker 2>Who knows?

0:25:47.590 --> 0:25:49.510
<v Speaker 1>Are you increasingly worried about that, Stephen?

0:25:51.790 --> 0:25:55.429
<v Speaker 7>Well, look, firstly, I think you just didn't notice the

0:25:55.450 --> 0:25:58.210
<v Speaker 7>Greens vote went up by nearly 3%. Now, I'm willing

0:25:58.230 --> 0:26:01.139
<v Speaker 7>to bet a bunch of Liberal voters didn't affect to

0:26:01.160 --> 0:26:02.619
<v Speaker 7>the Greens, and I'm willing to bet a bunch of

0:26:02.720 --> 0:26:07.640
<v Speaker 7>One Nation voters didn't defect to the Greens. So the 9%

0:26:07.640 --> 0:26:10.510
<v Speaker 7>needs to take into account, but about 3% of that

0:26:10.609 --> 0:26:13.669
<v Speaker 7>clearly is Labor voters who've gone to the Greens.

0:26:13.730 --> 0:26:16.150
<v Speaker 1>There'd also be some in the sort of others category

0:26:16.210 --> 0:26:19.470
<v Speaker 1>as well, I think, too. You know, the independents and whatever.

0:26:19.530 --> 0:26:22.490
<v Speaker 7>Sorry, the point I'm making... Yeah, no, the point I'm

0:26:22.530 --> 0:26:24.590
<v Speaker 7>making is... I mean, their vote went down, but the

0:26:24.630 --> 0:26:28.160
<v Speaker 7>point I'm making is that the 9% number saying.

0:26:28.320 --> 0:26:29.639
<v Speaker 8>Oh, it's close to Liberals.

0:26:29.940 --> 0:26:32.600
<v Speaker 7>But if you take into account that green vote, then

0:26:33.000 --> 0:26:35.139
<v Speaker 7>we're down at six. None of this, I want to

0:26:35.160 --> 0:26:39.790
<v Speaker 7>be very clear, is good news for the government. But

0:26:39.970 --> 0:26:42.050
<v Speaker 7>I don't think it's as dramatic a shift to one

0:26:42.090 --> 0:26:45.950
<v Speaker 7>nation as Carlos would like to claim. Tragically for Labor,

0:26:46.650 --> 0:26:51.730
<v Speaker 7>the tradie community, you know, left voting Labor a long

0:26:51.810 --> 0:26:52.389
<v Speaker 7>time ago.

0:26:52.710 --> 0:26:55.240
<v Speaker 8>What they've traditionally done is left Labor. and gone to

0:26:55.260 --> 0:26:55.720
<v Speaker 8>the Liberals.

0:26:55.760 --> 0:26:57.459
<v Speaker 7>The problem the Liberals have got is when votes have

0:26:57.510 --> 0:27:00.250
<v Speaker 7>left us, they've gone right through to One Nation and

0:27:00.310 --> 0:27:03.450
<v Speaker 7>that tradie community that have been voting for the Liberals

0:27:03.570 --> 0:27:05.270
<v Speaker 7>have deserted them to go.

0:27:05.190 --> 0:27:05.830
<v Speaker 8>To One Nation.

0:27:06.090 --> 0:27:08.670
<v Speaker 7>I think that's, I would analyse it like that rather

0:27:08.750 --> 0:27:11.590
<v Speaker 7>than just the straight, oh, suddenly we've lost tradie votes.

0:27:12.270 --> 0:27:13.910
<v Speaker 7>I can't tell you how many times in the last

0:27:13.910 --> 0:27:15.780
<v Speaker 7>20 years people have said, you know, when we were

0:27:15.800 --> 0:27:18.540
<v Speaker 7>talking about what happened on the polling booth day, the tradies,

0:27:18.560 --> 0:27:20.139
<v Speaker 7>the people turning up in their tradie outfits, they were

0:27:20.160 --> 0:27:23.000
<v Speaker 7>just walking past, not wanting our tickets, not wanting the

0:27:23.040 --> 0:27:25.380
<v Speaker 7>how to vote cards. That's gone on for over 20 years.

0:27:26.050 --> 0:27:28.490
<v Speaker 7>I'm not saying I like that. I'm just saying, observably,

0:27:28.650 --> 0:27:29.450
<v Speaker 7>that's been the case.

0:27:29.869 --> 0:27:31.530
<v Speaker 1>Now, I've got a couple of minutes before we need

0:27:31.550 --> 0:27:32.770
<v Speaker 1>to go, and I both want you to be able

0:27:32.790 --> 0:27:35.770
<v Speaker 1>to have a go at this one. Carlos, One Nation

0:27:35.830 --> 0:27:39.540
<v Speaker 1>now suggesting a ban on face coverings in schools, and

0:27:39.580 --> 0:27:45.020
<v Speaker 1>that would include burqas and would also apply to Islamic schools.

0:27:45.100 --> 0:27:45.580
<v Speaker 1>Good policy?

0:27:47.200 --> 0:27:49.139
<v Speaker 5>Yeah, I think so. I think kids are there to learn.

0:27:49.160 --> 0:27:50.980
<v Speaker 5>I think we need to keep the religion out of

0:27:51.460 --> 0:27:55.420
<v Speaker 5>these schools. And I 100% agree with Barnaby. The burqa

0:27:55.460 --> 0:27:58.310
<v Speaker 5>has no place in Australia. We're talking, I think, somewhere

0:27:58.330 --> 0:28:01.590
<v Speaker 5>over 20 countries have done this around the world. I

0:28:01.609 --> 0:28:03.850
<v Speaker 5>have no issue with it. I think we should ban

0:28:04.070 --> 0:28:04.650
<v Speaker 5>it 100%.

0:28:04.650 --> 0:28:05.450
<v Speaker 1>What do you think, Stephen?

0:28:08.109 --> 0:28:10.050
<v Speaker 7>I think it's a little bit of an overreaction to

0:28:10.869 --> 0:28:14.820
<v Speaker 7>a very tiny problem. I think it's the usual sledgehammer

0:28:15.580 --> 0:28:19.469
<v Speaker 7>to address... you know, a claimed issue. I mean, no

0:28:19.530 --> 0:28:22.209
<v Speaker 7>one tells the Jewish community how to dress. No one

0:28:22.230 --> 0:28:24.770
<v Speaker 7>tells the Greek community how to dress. No one tells the,

0:28:25.230 --> 0:28:28.530
<v Speaker 7>you know, Orthodox Christians how to dress. No one tells

0:28:28.590 --> 0:28:30.649
<v Speaker 7>Catholics how to dress. And all of a sudden we

0:28:30.670 --> 0:28:33.090
<v Speaker 7>want to tell the Muslim community how they should dress.

0:28:33.230 --> 0:28:37.760
<v Speaker 7>I think you should just be honest about your policy intent,

0:28:38.400 --> 0:28:42.860
<v Speaker 7>and that is just to try and divide Australians. The

0:28:43.680 --> 0:28:48.120
<v Speaker 7>Muslim community, you know, within the bounds of security, safety,

0:28:48.280 --> 0:28:50.820
<v Speaker 7>all of those sorts of things, should be entitled to

0:28:50.920 --> 0:28:53.660
<v Speaker 7>dress in the way they want. Do I agree with

0:28:54.600 --> 0:28:58.920
<v Speaker 7>some of the Muslim community religious practices in this sense? No,

0:28:58.940 --> 0:29:02.780
<v Speaker 7>I don't believe in female circumcision. But in terms of

0:29:02.860 --> 0:29:07.610
<v Speaker 7>going this far, that we're going to ban this in schools,

0:29:07.870 --> 0:29:11.830
<v Speaker 7>I think it's just an overreaction. But a typical, you know,

0:29:12.430 --> 0:29:15.210
<v Speaker 7>divisive point by One Nation to try and maintain their base.

0:29:15.660 --> 0:29:17.220
<v Speaker 1>I wish I could give you some time to hit

0:29:17.260 --> 0:29:19.030
<v Speaker 1>back at that one, Carlos, but we have run out

0:29:19.050 --> 0:29:21.290
<v Speaker 1>of it. Good to see you, both Carlos Carimba and

0:29:21.430 --> 0:29:23.870
<v Speaker 1>Stephen Conroy. Thank you for joining me tonight. Thank you

0:29:23.890 --> 0:29:25.950
<v Speaker 1>for joining me at home as well. Of course, if

0:29:25.970 --> 0:29:28.470
<v Speaker 1>you want to get any more information on that latest

0:29:28.510 --> 0:29:32.590
<v Speaker 1>News24 YouGov Pulse poll, you just go to news24. com. au. If

0:29:32.610 --> 0:29:36.120
<v Speaker 1>you're not a subscriber, become one now and join the family.

0:29:36.160 --> 0:29:37.670
<v Speaker 1>Thank you for joining me. Late Debates up next.