WEBVTT - Paul Murray Live | 13 October

0:00:02.640 --> 0:00:08.140
<v Speaker 1>This is Paul Murray Live. Yes, you thought correctly, Shari.

0:00:08.160 --> 0:00:10.319
<v Speaker 1>It is Caleb Bond in for Paul this week here

0:00:10.380 --> 0:00:11.979
<v Speaker 1>in the Man Cave. Thank you for joining me. Here's

0:00:12.000 --> 0:00:14.480
<v Speaker 1>what's coming up. It's not looking good for the economy.

0:00:14.500 --> 0:00:18.390
<v Speaker 1>The Reserve Bank might raise rates again and the International

0:00:18.430 --> 0:00:21.610
<v Speaker 1>Monetary Fund is predicting a grim outlook. More on that soon.

0:00:21.970 --> 0:00:25.010
<v Speaker 1>Stephen Conroy and Carlos Caremba on the panel tonight. The

0:00:25.050 --> 0:00:28.210
<v Speaker 1>Coalition is reviving a plan to scrap the counting of

0:00:28.310 --> 0:00:31.110
<v Speaker 1>overseas emissions after the High Court struck down a coal

0:00:31.150 --> 0:00:33.909
<v Speaker 1>mine last week. And an Indigenous man was given a

0:00:34.010 --> 0:00:37.930
<v Speaker 1>sentencing discount for raping children because of his, quote, connection

0:00:38.250 --> 0:00:42.410
<v Speaker 1>to country. I'll talk to Chris Merritt about that. Now,

0:00:42.550 --> 0:00:54.760
<v Speaker 1>it was a fantastic day for the Treasurer, Jim Chalmers. Well, actually, no,

0:00:54.780 --> 0:00:58.380
<v Speaker 1>it wasn't, because it's not just within Australia now that

0:00:58.480 --> 0:01:01.090
<v Speaker 1>he and the Prime Minister are being warned about high

0:01:01.120 --> 0:01:04.390
<v Speaker 1>government spending being a problem. The warnings are coming from

0:01:04.550 --> 0:01:08.690
<v Speaker 1>overseas now too. The International Monetary Fund released its latest

0:01:08.750 --> 0:01:12.130
<v Speaker 1>World Economic Outlook report today and, look, the long and

0:01:12.150 --> 0:01:15.510
<v Speaker 1>the short of it is Australia is doing worse than

0:01:15.569 --> 0:01:19.450
<v Speaker 1>most comparable countries on many measures and the debt deficit

0:01:19.510 --> 0:01:22.839
<v Speaker 1>and spending is too high... and needs to be reined in.

0:01:22.880 --> 0:01:25.710
<v Speaker 1>This is how The Australian wrote it up today. In

0:01:25.770 --> 0:01:30.030
<v Speaker 1>its latest World Economic Outlook report, the IMF further downgraded

0:01:30.069 --> 0:01:35.180
<v Speaker 1>its forecasts for Australia's economic growth next year to just 1.6%,

0:01:35.180 --> 0:01:38.920
<v Speaker 1>while its projections for the current account deficit widened from 2.3%

0:01:38.920 --> 0:01:41.640
<v Speaker 1>in its last reading in April to 3.1% as a

0:01:41.640 --> 0:01:47.289
<v Speaker 1>share of GDP this year. The IMF also expects unemployment

0:01:47.310 --> 0:01:51.750
<v Speaker 1>to peak at 4.7% next year and upgrade from expectations

0:01:52.370 --> 0:01:55.830
<v Speaker 1>in April for the jobless rate to sit at just 4.3%

0:01:55.830 --> 0:02:00.440
<v Speaker 1>in 2027. Unemployment in the majority of other advanced economies

0:02:00.520 --> 0:02:05.320
<v Speaker 1>is expected to either fall or remain flat out to 2027.

0:02:05.320 --> 0:02:10.160
<v Speaker 1>The IMF downgraded its projections for inflation from its previous forecasts,

0:02:10.250 --> 0:02:15.440
<v Speaker 1>expecting price growth to fall from 3.9% this year to 3.1%

0:02:15.440 --> 0:02:20.410
<v Speaker 1>next year, despite the downgrade, Australia's inflation challenge ranks among

0:02:20.450 --> 0:02:25.030
<v Speaker 1>the worst in the developed world. So let's pull apart

0:02:25.050 --> 0:02:29.850
<v Speaker 1>a few of those things. Economic growth of just 1.6%. Now,

0:02:29.870 --> 0:02:32.890
<v Speaker 1>I know I've pointed this out before, but I cannot

0:02:32.950 --> 0:02:37.570
<v Speaker 1>be clearer. There is no real economic growth. There are

0:02:37.669 --> 0:02:40.970
<v Speaker 1>really only two things growing in this country, and that's

0:02:41.110 --> 0:02:45.320
<v Speaker 1>government spending and the jobs underpinned by government money, and migration.

0:02:46.100 --> 0:02:49.140
<v Speaker 1>If it were not for the great Ponzi scheme of

0:02:49.200 --> 0:02:52.570
<v Speaker 1>mass migration, we would have gone into an official recession

0:02:52.690 --> 0:02:57.149
<v Speaker 1>a long time ago, because there is no real natural

0:02:57.310 --> 0:03:00.810
<v Speaker 1>economic growth at all. We're not getting any better with productivity.

0:03:00.830 --> 0:03:03.470
<v Speaker 1>We're not making anything new. We are in a hole.

0:03:04.290 --> 0:03:07.400
<v Speaker 1>The only strategy for growth has been to bring in

0:03:07.639 --> 0:03:10.800
<v Speaker 1>lots of people, which then necessitates that you must find

0:03:10.840 --> 0:03:13.940
<v Speaker 1>them jobs and build them houses and have schools for

0:03:13.980 --> 0:03:16.320
<v Speaker 1>their kids to go to and doctors to treat them

0:03:16.340 --> 0:03:20.519
<v Speaker 1>etc so that creates a level of growth but you

0:03:20.540 --> 0:03:22.700
<v Speaker 1>just bring in lots of people and the government spends

0:03:22.740 --> 0:03:24.859
<v Speaker 1>lots of money making jobs for them and then they

0:03:24.900 --> 0:03:28.320
<v Speaker 1>go well have a look we have economic growth well

0:03:28.639 --> 0:03:32.100
<v Speaker 1>we don't not really that's why the number is so

0:03:32.160 --> 0:03:36.760
<v Speaker 1>low it's all a sham unemployment going up here despite

0:03:36.820 --> 0:03:38.960
<v Speaker 1>the fact that it will either go down or stay

0:03:39.060 --> 0:03:43.210
<v Speaker 1>steady in most other advanced economies now This is unfortunately

0:03:43.270 --> 0:03:46.230
<v Speaker 1>something that will probably need to happen in order to

0:03:46.310 --> 0:03:49.530
<v Speaker 1>rein in inflation a little. It'll be a response to

0:03:49.590 --> 0:03:53.500
<v Speaker 1>high inflation. But bear in mind that the government has

0:03:53.680 --> 0:03:56.620
<v Speaker 1>willed this to happen because it's not been able to

0:03:56.680 --> 0:04:00.880
<v Speaker 1>do anything about its own contribution to inflation in high

0:04:00.920 --> 0:04:03.200
<v Speaker 1>government spending, but I'll come back to that in a minute.

0:04:04.000 --> 0:04:06.340
<v Speaker 1>And the inflation rate, down from 3.9% to 3.1%, which, yes,

0:04:06.360 --> 0:04:13.030
<v Speaker 1>it's positive because it's going down, but it's still not

0:04:13.130 --> 0:04:15.590
<v Speaker 1>in the 2% to 3% area where the Reserve Bank

0:04:15.630 --> 0:04:18.130
<v Speaker 1>would like it to be, and it's still one of

0:04:18.190 --> 0:04:22.099
<v Speaker 1>the worst in the developed world. And the IMF has

0:04:22.160 --> 0:04:24.820
<v Speaker 1>warned that the government needs to look at its own

0:04:24.880 --> 0:04:27.320
<v Speaker 1>balance sheet as part of this. This is an excerpt

0:04:27.860 --> 0:04:32.140
<v Speaker 1>from the report. A renewed focus on rebuilding fiscal space

0:04:32.200 --> 0:04:37.089
<v Speaker 1>is urgent given elevated debt, higher borrowing costs, multiplying demands

0:04:37.150 --> 0:04:42.000
<v Speaker 1>on public budgets and heightened uncertainty. any new spending increases

0:04:42.060 --> 0:04:45.929
<v Speaker 1>or tax cuts should be well-funded to secure the necessary

0:04:46.020 --> 0:04:51.930
<v Speaker 1>fiscal adjustment paths. Now, well-funded, meaning you'd better have the

0:04:51.990 --> 0:04:54.550
<v Speaker 1>money to do it. And at the moment, we don't.

0:04:55.010 --> 0:04:57.650
<v Speaker 1>We don't have the sort of money to be spending

0:04:58.029 --> 0:05:01.230
<v Speaker 1>that the government is spending at the moment. But, of course,

0:05:01.830 --> 0:05:06.240
<v Speaker 1>the Treasurer just deflects it again today. And, again, he says, well,

0:05:06.800 --> 0:05:08.419
<v Speaker 1>it's all just because of what's happening overseas.

0:05:09.370 --> 0:05:12.310
<v Speaker 2>Global supply shocks are becoming more frequent and the war

0:05:12.330 --> 0:05:14.500
<v Speaker 2>in the Middle East is evidence of this. And thirdly,

0:05:15.100 --> 0:05:19.099
<v Speaker 2>the conflict is causing inflation to rise right around the world.

0:05:20.620 --> 0:05:24.830
<v Speaker 1>This government is so blind and so arrogant. that it

0:05:24.970 --> 0:05:29.029
<v Speaker 1>simply refuses to admit its role in inflation and therefore

0:05:29.170 --> 0:05:31.770
<v Speaker 1>its role in putting up interest rates, which is putting

0:05:31.830 --> 0:05:36.230
<v Speaker 1>pressure on families and small businesses across the country. I mean,

0:05:36.790 --> 0:05:39.010
<v Speaker 1>the Treasurer there said, oh, you know, inflation's bad across

0:05:39.050 --> 0:05:42.980
<v Speaker 1>the world. Well, as I just told you, direct from

0:05:43.010 --> 0:05:47.839
<v Speaker 1>the IMF's own numbers, we are one of the worst

0:05:47.880 --> 0:05:50.960
<v Speaker 1>in the developed world for inflation at the moment. So

0:05:51.060 --> 0:05:52.460
<v Speaker 1>we can't just point to the rest of the world

0:05:52.500 --> 0:05:54.000
<v Speaker 1>and say, ah, well, you know, it's not so bad

0:05:54.040 --> 0:05:58.480
<v Speaker 1>for us. The advice there from the IMF could not

0:05:58.600 --> 0:06:02.290
<v Speaker 1>be clearer. And to be fair, this is a commentary

0:06:02.310 --> 0:06:05.090
<v Speaker 1>to the whole of the world, not just to Australia,

0:06:05.630 --> 0:06:08.790
<v Speaker 1>but there is too much debt. There is too much deficit.

0:06:09.210 --> 0:06:13.289
<v Speaker 1>There is too much government spending. And governments are not taking,

0:06:13.670 --> 0:06:18.330
<v Speaker 1>not properly taking into account the fiscal damage caused by that.

0:06:18.990 --> 0:06:21.950
<v Speaker 1>And as I said before, Australia's markers are worse than

0:06:21.970 --> 0:06:24.950
<v Speaker 1>the rest of the developed world and comparable countries. So

0:06:24.980 --> 0:06:27.100
<v Speaker 1>if that's what the IMF is saying to the world

0:06:27.160 --> 0:06:31.260
<v Speaker 1>as a whole, it doubly applies to us. We have

0:06:31.300 --> 0:06:35.200
<v Speaker 1>the highest level of government spending to GDP in four

0:06:35.240 --> 0:06:38.839
<v Speaker 1>decades outside of the COVID years, and yet the government

0:06:38.980 --> 0:06:41.810
<v Speaker 1>wants you to believe that none of this is contributing

0:06:41.850 --> 0:06:46.250
<v Speaker 1>to inflation and it's all because of external things happening overseas. Well,

0:06:46.370 --> 0:06:50.370
<v Speaker 1>you're not buying it. We had the News24 YouGov Pulse

0:06:50.430 --> 0:06:53.170
<v Speaker 1>poll that I revealed here last week, showed that 63%

0:06:53.170 --> 0:06:53.510
<v Speaker 1>of people.

0:06:55.400 --> 0:06:58.680
<v Speaker 1>Don't believe the Treasurer when he says that inflation is

0:06:58.740 --> 0:07:01.140
<v Speaker 1>caused by what's happening in the Middle East. He had

0:07:01.160 --> 0:07:04.980
<v Speaker 1>a news poll yesterday saying that 55% of people believe

0:07:05.020 --> 0:07:09.940
<v Speaker 1>government spending should be cut. Now, cutting government spending is

0:07:10.000 --> 0:07:13.170
<v Speaker 1>traditionally very difficult to sell to the electorate because it

0:07:13.210 --> 0:07:16.970
<v Speaker 1>generally means taking something away from the electorate. And usually

0:07:16.990 --> 0:07:19.690
<v Speaker 1>when you give people something or you give people money,

0:07:20.150 --> 0:07:23.560
<v Speaker 1>they don't like losing it. But the economic conditions are

0:07:23.640 --> 0:07:26.679
<v Speaker 1>so bad and the cost of living is so bad,

0:07:27.200 --> 0:07:30.880
<v Speaker 1>people can see that government spending has to be cut

0:07:31.460 --> 0:07:34.080
<v Speaker 1>in order to rein in inflation and give some relief

0:07:34.120 --> 0:07:38.430
<v Speaker 1>to everyday Australians. And that relief doesn't come from government subsidies.

0:07:38.890 --> 0:07:42.010
<v Speaker 1>comes from the government running its budget like the rest

0:07:42.050 --> 0:07:46.350
<v Speaker 1>of us have to run our budgets. Because while you're

0:07:46.410 --> 0:07:50.070
<v Speaker 1>battling to get by, they're spending more than they ever have.

0:07:50.590 --> 0:07:53.680
<v Speaker 1>And that makes it harder for you to get by. Now,

0:07:54.150 --> 0:07:56.520
<v Speaker 1>there is no doubt that the government is under pressure

0:07:56.560 --> 0:07:59.320
<v Speaker 1>on this. But one of the great problems with the

0:07:59.400 --> 0:08:03.160
<v Speaker 1>Albanese government is its arrogance. The Prime Minister doesn't want

0:08:03.180 --> 0:08:06.640
<v Speaker 1>to admit when he gets things wrong, and the Treasurer

0:08:06.680 --> 0:08:09.440
<v Speaker 1>doesn't want to admit when he gets things wrong. And

0:08:09.480 --> 0:08:11.680
<v Speaker 1>the Prime Minister doesn't want to sack the Treasurer or

0:08:11.760 --> 0:08:15.380
<v Speaker 1>sacrifice the Treasurer in all of this because I think

0:08:15.400 --> 0:08:17.880
<v Speaker 1>he worries that that would be an admission of the

0:08:17.940 --> 0:08:21.860
<v Speaker 1>fact that they did get things wrong. All I can say,

0:08:21.940 --> 0:08:26.060
<v Speaker 1>Prime Minister, is that things will only get worse unless

0:08:26.110 --> 0:08:30.170
<v Speaker 1>you take decisive action. If you don't change course now,

0:08:30.670 --> 0:08:33.530
<v Speaker 1>the pressure is only going to get harder because the

0:08:33.570 --> 0:08:39.410
<v Speaker 1>electorate has woken up and they are turning. Just you watch. Now,

0:08:39.610 --> 0:08:42.410
<v Speaker 1>this is an uncomfortable story, but it's one that we

0:08:42.530 --> 0:08:45.059
<v Speaker 1>really need to talk about. And I think too often

0:08:45.600 --> 0:08:48.339
<v Speaker 1>the reason the things that I'm about to describe go

0:08:48.520 --> 0:08:51.860
<v Speaker 1>on and continue to happen is partly driven by the

0:08:51.920 --> 0:08:55.120
<v Speaker 1>fact that it's uncomfortable and no one really wants to

0:08:55.179 --> 0:08:58.710
<v Speaker 1>talk about it. But by not being honest about what's

0:08:58.750 --> 0:09:02.210
<v Speaker 1>happening in some Indigenous communities and the way that many

0:09:02.270 --> 0:09:05.550
<v Speaker 1>Aboriginal women and children are being treated, we are doing

0:09:05.590 --> 0:09:09.199
<v Speaker 1>them a massive disservice. Now, you might have been following...

0:09:09.450 --> 0:09:12.660
<v Speaker 1>Ros Thomas' great reporting in The Australian over the past

0:09:12.780 --> 0:09:17.140
<v Speaker 1>month or so about abuse in Indigenous communities and particularly

0:09:17.200 --> 0:09:21.059
<v Speaker 1>the behaviour of the child protection system in Western Australia.

0:09:21.540 --> 0:09:24.689
<v Speaker 1>And some of the stuff she has uncovered is just galling,

0:09:24.730 --> 0:09:29.990
<v Speaker 1>just awful, awful stories of children being neglected, and not

0:09:30.070 --> 0:09:31.950
<v Speaker 1>only by the people who are meant to care for them,

0:09:32.570 --> 0:09:35.390
<v Speaker 1>but by the system that is meant to protect them

0:09:36.040 --> 0:09:38.959
<v Speaker 1>from that very neglect. I mean, the one that really

0:09:39.030 --> 0:09:41.880
<v Speaker 1>sticks in my mind is the kid who was taken

0:09:41.940 --> 0:09:45.580
<v Speaker 1>from his grandparents and given to his mother before being returned,

0:09:45.780 --> 0:09:50.140
<v Speaker 1>but only after complaints were made. Child Protection Agency officials

0:09:50.200 --> 0:09:54.810
<v Speaker 1>removed a young Indigenous boy from his grandparents and gave

0:09:54.870 --> 0:09:59.010
<v Speaker 1>him to his meth-addicted and convicted drug dealer mother. And

0:09:59.030 --> 0:10:02.010
<v Speaker 1>they were only told about this via text message. They'd

0:10:02.030 --> 0:10:05.790
<v Speaker 1>been his sole carers since he was born. Taken from

0:10:05.860 --> 0:10:10.059
<v Speaker 1>his classroom on his second day of kindergarten and delivered

0:10:10.100 --> 0:10:12.900
<v Speaker 1>to his drug-addled mother, a woman he had not spent

0:10:13.020 --> 0:10:17.679
<v Speaker 1>a night with since birth. And the text simply read, Hi,

0:10:18.040 --> 0:10:23.010
<v Speaker 1>grandmother's name, Please be informed that grandson's name was reunified

0:10:23.090 --> 0:10:25.949
<v Speaker 1>into his mother's care today from the school, and the

0:10:25.990 --> 0:10:28.970
<v Speaker 1>school has been informed that the mum has full care

0:10:29.130 --> 0:10:35.630
<v Speaker 1>of the grandson from today. How does this stuff happen? Well,

0:10:35.970 --> 0:10:38.710
<v Speaker 1>Ms Thomas had another story in the Aus today that,

0:10:38.870 --> 0:10:42.689
<v Speaker 1>to be perfectly frank, made my skin crawl, and I'm

0:10:42.790 --> 0:10:45.870
<v Speaker 1>sure it'll make your skin crawl too. But that's kind

0:10:45.890 --> 0:10:48.760
<v Speaker 1>of the point. We have to listen to this stuff.

0:10:48.840 --> 0:10:51.440
<v Speaker 1>We have to read this stuff. We have to be

0:10:51.520 --> 0:10:55.640
<v Speaker 1>uncomfortable about this stuff because, by God, we have to

0:10:55.710 --> 0:10:58.449
<v Speaker 1>do something about it. This was her reporting in The

0:10:58.510 --> 0:11:03.730
<v Speaker 1>Australian today. A revered community leader who showed no remorse

0:11:03.770 --> 0:11:06.870
<v Speaker 1>for a campaign of rape and sexual abuse he wreaked

0:11:06.950 --> 0:11:11.200
<v Speaker 1>on four young Indigenous children had his sentence reduced because

0:11:11.240 --> 0:11:16.380
<v Speaker 1>of his significant connection to country, quote-unquote, and commendable attempts...

0:11:16.520 --> 0:11:20.300
<v Speaker 1>to keep his culture alive. Geoffrey Allen Brown was found

0:11:20.360 --> 0:11:23.930
<v Speaker 1>guilty of abusing the children aged 10, 11, 13 and

0:11:23.929 --> 0:11:27.170
<v Speaker 1>14 over six years in Port Hedland until one of

0:11:27.210 --> 0:11:30.330
<v Speaker 1>his victims, a small boy, found the courage to stand

0:11:30.429 --> 0:11:34.030
<v Speaker 1>up and declare him as his abuser. Until that day,

0:11:34.530 --> 0:11:37.459
<v Speaker 1>the Hedland Aboriginal community in Western Australia, which has been

0:11:37.480 --> 0:11:40.660
<v Speaker 1>the focus of a growing child protection scandal that has

0:11:40.700 --> 0:11:44.620
<v Speaker 1>gripped the nation, considered Brown a shining light in their towns.

0:11:45.390 --> 0:11:47.690
<v Speaker 1>The shocking case, which has only come to light now,

0:11:48.030 --> 0:11:52.110
<v Speaker 1>years after the sentencing in 2024, has raised new questions

0:11:52.170 --> 0:11:55.610
<v Speaker 1>about how sections of the Indigenous community and authorities are

0:11:55.650 --> 0:12:00.839
<v Speaker 1>dealing with the devastating prevalence of the sexual assault of children. Now,

0:12:01.429 --> 0:12:03.750
<v Speaker 1>this is a story that is not unfamiliar in many

0:12:03.820 --> 0:12:07.100
<v Speaker 1>respects when it comes to child abuse. You have someone

0:12:07.120 --> 0:12:09.920
<v Speaker 1>who is an upstanding member of the community, who is

0:12:10.059 --> 0:12:13.440
<v Speaker 1>well respected by the community, who people trust, who's believed

0:12:13.460 --> 0:12:16.500
<v Speaker 1>to be a good person, And then they use that trust,

0:12:16.980 --> 0:12:20.540
<v Speaker 1>abuse that trust that other people have in them to

0:12:20.580 --> 0:12:23.840
<v Speaker 1>do the most awful things to children. We've seen it

0:12:23.880 --> 0:12:27.059
<v Speaker 1>in schools. We've seen it in churches. We've seen it

0:12:27.080 --> 0:12:31.400
<v Speaker 1>in scalp groups. We see it in Indigenous communities too. Now,

0:12:31.640 --> 0:12:35.320
<v Speaker 1>what really makes me angry is that in the context

0:12:35.360 --> 0:12:38.940
<v Speaker 1>of knowing that child abuse and sexual abuse is a

0:12:39.120 --> 0:12:42.510
<v Speaker 1>major problem in some Indigenous communities, that the judge would

0:12:42.550 --> 0:12:48.260
<v Speaker 1>then take into account cultural work and cultural circumstances as

0:12:48.300 --> 0:12:53.040
<v Speaker 1>a mitigating factor in sentencing. I mean, so what? He

0:12:53.080 --> 0:12:57.080
<v Speaker 1>has a significant connection to country. We're talking about the country,

0:12:57.200 --> 0:13:01.429
<v Speaker 1>the Indigenous community, where he raped and abused four children.

0:13:02.390 --> 0:13:04.750
<v Speaker 1>How was his care and connection for his country then?

0:13:05.850 --> 0:13:09.189
<v Speaker 1>This is a bit more from Ms Thomas's story. A

0:13:09.230 --> 0:13:12.910
<v Speaker 1>district court judge... agreed that Brown's excellent standing in the

0:13:12.950 --> 0:13:17.110
<v Speaker 1>Port Hedland community, his, quote, significant connection to country, his

0:13:17.170 --> 0:13:22.130
<v Speaker 1>commendable attempts to keep his culture alive and his being

0:13:22.190 --> 0:13:25.770
<v Speaker 1>his late wife's full-time carer, which is a credit to you,

0:13:26.230 --> 0:13:30.699
<v Speaker 1>should be mitigating factors enlightening his sentence for sexual abuse.

0:13:31.620 --> 0:13:34.580
<v Speaker 1>While Brown stood in the dock awaiting sentence on 13

0:13:34.580 --> 0:13:38.080
<v Speaker 1>counts of raping and indecently dealing with four Aboriginal children,

0:13:38.780 --> 0:13:42.429
<v Speaker 1>Judge Gary Massey said to him... And I can't believe

0:13:42.490 --> 0:13:46.270
<v Speaker 1>I'm reading this. You've done it tough since being remanded

0:13:46.350 --> 0:13:50.610
<v Speaker 1>in custody awaiting trial. You are separated from your family

0:13:50.650 --> 0:13:53.950
<v Speaker 1>with whom you are close and your wife is deprived

0:13:53.990 --> 0:13:56.990
<v Speaker 1>of your role as her carer, which I'm sure weighs

0:13:57.050 --> 0:14:01.900
<v Speaker 1>heavily on you. Ultimately, the sentence I must impose must

0:14:01.940 --> 0:14:06.620
<v Speaker 1>be proportionate with the seriousness of your offending. I'm going

0:14:06.640 --> 0:14:09.740
<v Speaker 1>to treat you as a good person of prior good

0:14:09.800 --> 0:14:14.010
<v Speaker 1>character and and that is a mitigating factor. I mustn't

0:14:14.130 --> 0:14:18.990
<v Speaker 1>impose a crushing sentence on you, the judge said. That

0:14:19.110 --> 0:14:24.190
<v Speaker 1>is a sentence which destroys any reasonable expectation of a

0:14:24.330 --> 0:14:33.160
<v Speaker 1>useful life upon release. I mustn't impose a crushing sentence

0:14:33.240 --> 0:14:37.380
<v Speaker 1>upon you. Well, how crushed do you think those kids

0:14:37.500 --> 0:14:42.520
<v Speaker 1>feel after being raped and abused? And again, I know

0:14:42.560 --> 0:14:45.570
<v Speaker 1>it's shocking and it's disgusting and it would be much

0:14:45.680 --> 0:14:48.250
<v Speaker 1>easier to bury our heads in the sand, to pretend

0:14:48.290 --> 0:14:52.310
<v Speaker 1>that this isn't going on, but it is. And Ros

0:14:52.350 --> 0:14:54.710
<v Speaker 1>Thomas is doing the hard work in the Australian to

0:14:54.790 --> 0:14:57.700
<v Speaker 1>bring this stuff to light and we have to respond

0:14:57.740 --> 0:15:00.760
<v Speaker 1>to it. We have to do something about it because

0:15:00.780 --> 0:15:03.100
<v Speaker 1>the fact that this is going on in this country

0:15:03.660 --> 0:15:07.280
<v Speaker 1>that kids are basically being ignored and abandoned and that

0:15:07.300 --> 0:15:10.200
<v Speaker 1>we're too afraid to touch it because people are too

0:15:10.240 --> 0:15:13.210
<v Speaker 1>afraid to be seen as racist and that, in fact,

0:15:13.430 --> 0:15:16.630
<v Speaker 1>you can get a discount in court because you have

0:15:16.670 --> 0:15:20.470
<v Speaker 1>a cultural connection to the land where you raped and

0:15:20.550 --> 0:15:25.600
<v Speaker 1>abused children is an outrage. Who cares that he has

0:15:25.620 --> 0:15:27.860
<v Speaker 1>a strong connection to his country? I mean, I have

0:15:27.880 --> 0:15:30.460
<v Speaker 1>a strong connection to Adelaide because that's where I was born.

0:15:31.110 --> 0:15:32.890
<v Speaker 1>But I don't think that would ever be taken into

0:15:32.930 --> 0:15:36.720
<v Speaker 1>consideration in any kind of sentencing that I might have

0:15:36.760 --> 0:15:40.780
<v Speaker 1>to face in my life. Who cares that he's done

0:15:40.860 --> 0:15:45.200
<v Speaker 1>work to preserve Aboriginal culture in his community? I mean,

0:15:45.620 --> 0:15:49.250
<v Speaker 1>this monster is on one hand being given credit for

0:15:49.310 --> 0:15:52.750
<v Speaker 1>his work to preserve Aboriginal culture, and yet at the

0:15:52.870 --> 0:15:56.430
<v Speaker 1>very same time, we are faced by the major cultural

0:15:56.570 --> 0:16:00.910
<v Speaker 1>issues that exist in many of these Aboriginal communities. And

0:16:00.980 --> 0:16:04.540
<v Speaker 1>by that, I'm not saying that abuse is inherent to

0:16:04.600 --> 0:16:08.060
<v Speaker 1>Aboriginal culture, but I'm saying that there are high levels

0:16:08.100 --> 0:16:12.480
<v Speaker 1>of prevalence in Aboriginal communities, and that clearly points to

0:16:12.520 --> 0:16:16.920
<v Speaker 1>a cultural issue that needs to be dealt with. Indigenous

0:16:16.980 --> 0:16:21.170
<v Speaker 1>women and children are 34 times more likely to be

0:16:21.230 --> 0:16:28.370
<v Speaker 1>hospitalised due to domestic violence, and violence-related issues, and non-Indigenous women,

0:16:28.550 --> 0:16:31.570
<v Speaker 1>and six times more likely to die as a result

0:16:31.730 --> 0:16:36.520
<v Speaker 1>of family violence. Now, granted, these aren't the newest figures,

0:16:36.580 --> 0:16:38.640
<v Speaker 1>but they were the best I could find, published by

0:16:38.700 --> 0:16:44.120
<v Speaker 1>the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare. During 2011-12, Indigenous

0:16:44.180 --> 0:16:48.120
<v Speaker 1>children aged 0 to 17 were nearly eight times as

0:16:48.200 --> 0:16:53.080
<v Speaker 1>likely as non-Indigenous children to be the subject of substantiated

0:16:53.120 --> 0:16:57.260
<v Speaker 1>child abuse or neglect, That's 42 per 1,000 children compared

0:16:57.300 --> 0:17:01.400
<v Speaker 1>with five per 1,000. And in 2012, rates of sexual

0:17:01.420 --> 0:17:04.899
<v Speaker 1>assault reported to police among Indigenous children aged zero to

0:17:05.000 --> 0:17:08.889
<v Speaker 1>nine in New South Wales, Queensland, South Australia and the

0:17:08.950 --> 0:17:12.490
<v Speaker 1>Northern Territory were two to four times higher than rates

0:17:12.530 --> 0:17:17.050
<v Speaker 1>among non-Indigenous children in these jurisdictions. And part of that

0:17:17.109 --> 0:17:21.970
<v Speaker 1>is our fault, the rest of Australia, because again and again...

0:17:22.550 --> 0:17:25.060
<v Speaker 1>We see the statistics and again and again we see

0:17:25.119 --> 0:17:27.820
<v Speaker 1>cases like this and again and again we see the

0:17:27.920 --> 0:17:31.879
<v Speaker 1>squalor that people live in, in remote Aboriginal communities. And

0:17:31.900 --> 0:17:34.280
<v Speaker 1>we get angry about it for a while and then

0:17:34.300 --> 0:17:36.629
<v Speaker 1>we forget about it because it's out of sight, out

0:17:36.670 --> 0:17:40.330
<v Speaker 1>of mind. Or there is a reticence, even a fear

0:17:40.970 --> 0:17:43.570
<v Speaker 1>to do anything about it because that might be seen

0:17:43.609 --> 0:17:47.119
<v Speaker 1>as interfering in Aboriginal communities. You know, the evil white

0:17:47.190 --> 0:17:49.160
<v Speaker 1>man is going to go in and do more evil

0:17:49.220 --> 0:17:54.100
<v Speaker 1>colonial work with Aboriginal people. But this shouldn't be about race.

0:17:54.940 --> 0:17:59.119
<v Speaker 1>Race shouldn't come into it. The fundamental question should be

0:17:59.200 --> 0:18:02.619
<v Speaker 1>whether or not women and children are safe. And time

0:18:02.660 --> 0:18:05.639
<v Speaker 1>and again that is ignored. And time and again we

0:18:05.700 --> 0:18:09.030
<v Speaker 1>see that even the institutions that are meant to protect them,

0:18:09.550 --> 0:18:14.470
<v Speaker 1>the child protection authorities, the courts, often do the exact

0:18:14.570 --> 0:18:18.950
<v Speaker 1>opposite because they don't want to be seen to be racist. Well,

0:18:19.010 --> 0:18:24.850
<v Speaker 1>it's not racist. It's about basic human decency. It's about

0:18:24.950 --> 0:18:29.830
<v Speaker 1>caring for vulnerable people. And in this obsession about culture,

0:18:30.530 --> 0:18:35.209
<v Speaker 1>the powers that be are actually being racist, because seemingly

0:18:35.300 --> 0:18:40.060
<v Speaker 1>race and culture are too often being put above basic safety.

0:18:40.980 --> 0:18:44.810
<v Speaker 1>All of this is a national disgrace. The story that

0:18:44.830 --> 0:18:48.850
<v Speaker 1>I've told you about tonight underlines how bad things are.

0:18:49.750 --> 0:18:52.949
<v Speaker 1>And so I ask, how many more times do we

0:18:52.990 --> 0:18:56.190
<v Speaker 1>need to read stories like this before as a country

0:18:56.560 --> 0:19:00.030
<v Speaker 1>we knock our heads together and we do something about it?

0:19:00.720 --> 0:19:03.240
<v Speaker 1>Because continuing to do what we're doing at the moment,

0:19:03.600 --> 0:19:06.959
<v Speaker 1>continuing to worry more about culture and race than actually

0:19:07.000 --> 0:19:10.130
<v Speaker 1>keeping women and children safe, will just lead to more

0:19:10.250 --> 0:19:14.790
<v Speaker 1>Aboriginal women and children being abused. It'll simply deliver more

0:19:14.930 --> 0:19:19.470
<v Speaker 1>of the same. It is a stain on this country,

0:19:19.650 --> 0:19:23.760
<v Speaker 1>a national shame, and it's about time we draw a

0:19:23.800 --> 0:19:28.340
<v Speaker 1>line in the sand. Now, going back to the Albanese government,

0:19:28.359 --> 0:19:30.260
<v Speaker 1>of course, one of the other things that the Albanese

0:19:30.280 --> 0:19:32.520
<v Speaker 1>government is really under pressure on at the moment is

0:19:32.619 --> 0:19:36.629
<v Speaker 1>small business. The government just doesn't seem to understand small business.

0:19:36.670 --> 0:19:41.399
<v Speaker 1>They're absolutely flogging them between capital gains tax changes and

0:19:41.460 --> 0:19:44.550
<v Speaker 1>the trust tax changes. Of course, now there's huge bungled

0:19:44.640 --> 0:19:48.609
<v Speaker 1>card surcharge stuff and the embarrassment for the government of

0:19:48.650 --> 0:19:52.030
<v Speaker 1>the ATO refusing to absorb the surcharge and scrapping credit

0:19:52.050 --> 0:19:54.800
<v Speaker 1>card payments for tax bills, which the government then had

0:19:54.820 --> 0:19:56.680
<v Speaker 1>to go and intervene on and delay for a while,

0:19:57.200 --> 0:20:00.199
<v Speaker 1>even though the government, of course, expected small businesses to

0:20:00.240 --> 0:20:03.520
<v Speaker 1>absorb the surcharge. And as I've been saying since it happened,

0:20:04.520 --> 0:20:06.760
<v Speaker 1>I don't know how they managed to mess this one

0:20:06.840 --> 0:20:10.910
<v Speaker 1>up so badly. Like, they have just handled it so poorly.

0:20:11.550 --> 0:20:14.960
<v Speaker 1>But as I showed you last night, the Small Business Minister,

0:20:15.080 --> 0:20:17.820
<v Speaker 1>Anne Arley, who most people probably don't even know is

0:20:18.240 --> 0:20:23.780
<v Speaker 1>Small Business Minister, is insisting that this government understands small business.

0:20:25.340 --> 0:20:29.990
<v Speaker 4>This side of the house understands what small businesses are

0:20:30.070 --> 0:20:33.450
<v Speaker 4>dealing with as prices, as the cost of doing business increases,

0:20:33.530 --> 0:20:36.919
<v Speaker 4>as margins decrease. On this side of the house, we

0:20:36.980 --> 0:20:39.280
<v Speaker 4>actually get out there and talk to small businesses. I'm

0:20:39.340 --> 0:20:42.439
<v Speaker 4>proud of a government that has allocated so much in

0:20:42.480 --> 0:20:46.590
<v Speaker 4>the budget to assist small businesses. On the matter of

0:20:46.619 --> 0:20:48.970
<v Speaker 4>the credit card surcharge or the ban to the credit

0:20:48.990 --> 0:20:51.810
<v Speaker 4>card surcharge, it was a decision that was made by

0:20:51.869 --> 0:20:52.609
<v Speaker 4>the RBA.

0:20:53.130 --> 0:20:54.129
<v Speaker 1>I became aware of.

0:20:54.150 --> 0:20:56.969
<v Speaker 4>It, as did everyone else, when the RBA made that

0:20:57.010 --> 0:21:01.000
<v Speaker 4>decision and made it public. I think it's pretty clear

0:21:01.140 --> 0:21:05.179
<v Speaker 4>from the... statements that were made by the RBA, the

0:21:05.280 --> 0:21:09.479
<v Speaker 4>RBA made the decision to ban surcharges and the ATO responded.

0:21:10.440 --> 0:21:13.080
<v Speaker 1>You can see the cracks emerging and the government is

0:21:13.140 --> 0:21:16.460
<v Speaker 1>seriously under pressure on this. They are feeling the pressure

0:21:16.560 --> 0:21:18.840
<v Speaker 1>and they know it hasn't sold well in the public.

0:21:19.100 --> 0:21:21.880
<v Speaker 1>Because not only did they pay off small businesses by

0:21:21.940 --> 0:21:24.600
<v Speaker 1>saying that they basically expected them to absorb the cost

0:21:24.660 --> 0:21:27.320
<v Speaker 1>from the bank and not pass on the surcharge, thereby

0:21:27.380 --> 0:21:30.379
<v Speaker 1>making things cheaper for the consumer but more expensive for

0:21:30.420 --> 0:21:34.060
<v Speaker 1>small business. But they've also paid off the consumer because,

0:21:34.080 --> 0:21:36.859
<v Speaker 1>of course, small businesses can't afford to do that. And

0:21:36.900 --> 0:21:38.960
<v Speaker 1>so they're still passing on the surcharge, just in a

0:21:39.160 --> 0:21:40.980
<v Speaker 1>different way. It now reflects in the cost of a

0:21:41.020 --> 0:21:44.000
<v Speaker 1>product as opposed to being added to the cost later.

0:21:44.560 --> 0:21:47.520
<v Speaker 1>But the effect is still basically the same. You, the customer,

0:21:47.920 --> 0:21:51.480
<v Speaker 1>still pay. So they're feeling the heat. And now they're

0:21:51.550 --> 0:21:55.330
<v Speaker 1>upset with the line of questioning from the opposition in

0:21:55.390 --> 0:21:59.820
<v Speaker 1>question time. Ms Ali was most upset... that Liberal National

0:21:59.960 --> 0:22:03.280
<v Speaker 1>MP Angie Bell said in Question Time today that the

0:22:03.340 --> 0:22:06.639
<v Speaker 1>Small Business Minister and the Prime Minister ought to be

0:22:06.780 --> 0:22:09.290
<v Speaker 1>stoned in the square over this debacle.

0:22:10.330 --> 0:22:14.650
<v Speaker 5>This Minister and this Prime Minister should be absolutely shamed

0:22:14.810 --> 0:22:16.010
<v Speaker 5>and stoned.

0:22:15.570 --> 0:22:16.150
<v Speaker 1>In the square.

0:22:16.170 --> 0:22:22.010
<v Speaker 4>I don't usually comment about these things but.

0:22:21.910 --> 0:22:23.030
<v Speaker 6>I feel like I have to.

0:22:23.170 --> 0:22:26.040
<v Speaker 4>This past week alone I've had 19 death threats on

0:22:26.080 --> 0:22:28.970
<v Speaker 4>my social media. And in the past, I've had death

0:22:28.990 --> 0:22:32.610
<v Speaker 4>threats that are couched in that exact same language.

0:22:33.430 --> 0:22:34.030
<v Speaker 1>Stone her.

0:22:35.070 --> 0:22:37.899
<v Speaker 4>It's not just something that a parliamentarian shouldn't say in

0:22:37.940 --> 0:22:42.300
<v Speaker 4>terms of advocating violence against another parliamentarian. It is something

0:22:42.340 --> 0:22:46.220
<v Speaker 4>that stands against our Australian values. We are a country

0:22:46.260 --> 0:22:50.790
<v Speaker 4>that proudly stands against violence against women and against regimes

0:22:51.090 --> 0:22:55.810
<v Speaker 4>that use brutal methods like stoning against women. This is

0:22:55.850 --> 0:22:59.540
<v Speaker 4>not just something... that we should just turn away from.

0:23:00.100 --> 0:23:03.980
<v Speaker 4>It is racist, it is misogynistic and it should never

0:23:04.280 --> 0:23:05.020
<v Speaker 4>have been said.

0:23:06.560 --> 0:23:09.340
<v Speaker 1>Now, to be fair to Ms Ali, I do think

0:23:09.359 --> 0:23:11.840
<v Speaker 1>it was a poor choice of words. She obviously wasn't

0:23:12.369 --> 0:23:15.490
<v Speaker 1>advocating actual violence against the Prime Minister or the Small

0:23:15.530 --> 0:23:17.950
<v Speaker 1>Business Minister, but it was probably a poor choice of

0:23:18.050 --> 0:23:20.950
<v Speaker 1>words and it opened her up to criticism that there

0:23:20.970 --> 0:23:24.210
<v Speaker 1>otherwise would not be. But I don't think this was

0:23:24.270 --> 0:23:27.889
<v Speaker 1>in any way sexist, otherwise there would not be a

0:23:27.930 --> 0:23:31.410
<v Speaker 1>suggestion that the Prime Minister, who incidentally is a man,

0:23:32.010 --> 0:23:34.210
<v Speaker 1>would also be stoned in the square. It wasn't about

0:23:34.630 --> 0:23:37.109
<v Speaker 1>sex or gender at all. And so I think it's

0:23:37.130 --> 0:23:38.670
<v Speaker 1>a bit of a stretch, really, to say that it

0:23:38.710 --> 0:23:42.790
<v Speaker 1>was somehow specifically commentary on women being stoned. That's not

0:23:42.830 --> 0:23:46.649
<v Speaker 1>what it was. And she had to play the race card.

0:23:47.440 --> 0:23:51.080
<v Speaker 1>How did it have anything to do with race? The

0:23:51.300 --> 0:23:54.760
<v Speaker 1>only possible connection could be that Anne Arley was born

0:23:54.800 --> 0:23:58.040
<v Speaker 1>in Egypt and is a Muslim. and so somehow making

0:23:58.080 --> 0:24:02.480
<v Speaker 1>a comment about her is inherently racist. Well, that's just

0:24:02.540 --> 0:24:06.900
<v Speaker 1>a load of crap. It had nothing to do with race. Sure,

0:24:07.530 --> 0:24:10.330
<v Speaker 1>complain that she made a non-literal comment that you should

0:24:10.350 --> 0:24:13.390
<v Speaker 1>be stoned in the square, but it's getting really stupid

0:24:13.930 --> 0:24:16.490
<v Speaker 1>when you start trying to make it about race. And

0:24:16.570 --> 0:24:20.790
<v Speaker 1>by the way, where were you, Miss Ali, when Labor

0:24:20.810 --> 0:24:24.320
<v Speaker 1>Senator Glenn Stirl, one of your blokes, said this to

0:24:24.359 --> 0:24:28.250
<v Speaker 1>Bridget McKenzie earlier this year? Let's have that debate. On

0:24:28.450 --> 0:24:32.270
<v Speaker 1>any forum... Any forum, I will happily have that. Let's

0:24:32.310 --> 0:24:33.149
<v Speaker 1>go to the National Press Club.

0:24:33.170 --> 0:24:34.129
<v Speaker 6>Because I'll cut you up.

0:24:34.570 --> 0:24:40.990
<v Speaker 1>You'll cut me up. A Labor senator, a male Labor senator,

0:24:41.530 --> 0:24:43.990
<v Speaker 1>tells a female National senator that he's going to cut

0:24:44.030 --> 0:24:46.650
<v Speaker 1>her up. And what did you say about it? Were

0:24:46.670 --> 0:24:50.280
<v Speaker 1>you as angry then as you are angry now when

0:24:50.340 --> 0:24:53.520
<v Speaker 1>comments are made to you? Comments, in this case, made

0:24:53.560 --> 0:24:56.949
<v Speaker 1>by a woman, not by a man. that you call sexist.

0:24:57.470 --> 0:25:00.040
<v Speaker 1>And that wasn't the first time that he'd gone after Mackenzie.

0:25:00.080 --> 0:25:02.560
<v Speaker 1>Four years earlier, he'd called her a naughty little girl.

0:25:03.420 --> 0:25:05.640
<v Speaker 1>Senator Mackenzie, do you always have to have the last word?

0:25:05.660 --> 0:25:06.920
<v Speaker 1>I was going to defend you then.

0:25:07.720 --> 0:25:10.460
<v Speaker 3>Honestly, like a naughty little girl, can you just be

0:25:10.520 --> 0:25:11.770
<v Speaker 3>quiet while someone finishes?

0:25:13.170 --> 0:25:16.190
<v Speaker 1>What did you say then, Mazzali? Would you say that

0:25:16.230 --> 0:25:19.150
<v Speaker 1>that's a sexist comment? Did you speak out then?

0:25:20.250 --> 0:25:20.690
<v Speaker 6>I'll wait.

0:25:21.630 --> 0:25:24.710
<v Speaker 1>Now, I'll make it clear. I don't wish death threats

0:25:25.130 --> 0:25:29.030
<v Speaker 1>upon anybody and death threats sent to a politician should

0:25:29.070 --> 0:25:32.330
<v Speaker 1>never happen. That's the kind of thing that you do

0:25:32.910 --> 0:25:36.240
<v Speaker 1>or you're thinking about doing. Don't be an idiot and

0:25:36.300 --> 0:25:39.540
<v Speaker 1>put your head in a bucket of cold water. But

0:25:39.580 --> 0:25:42.859
<v Speaker 1>I find it really hard to have sympathy for Labor

0:25:42.900 --> 0:25:49.080
<v Speaker 1>complaining about how non-literal comments are sexist and condoning violence

0:25:49.180 --> 0:25:52.250
<v Speaker 1>and pulling the race card. when you failed to speak

0:25:52.369 --> 0:25:55.229
<v Speaker 1>up when men in your own party say a similar

0:25:55.290 --> 0:25:58.270
<v Speaker 1>thing to women in the coalition. The standard you walk

0:25:58.330 --> 0:26:01.770
<v Speaker 1>past is the standard you accept. And you walked past

0:26:01.810 --> 0:26:06.000
<v Speaker 1>it before, so why won't you accept it now? Except

0:26:06.020 --> 0:26:09.060
<v Speaker 1>that you know you're under pressure on this card surcharge

0:26:09.100 --> 0:26:13.100
<v Speaker 1>issue and you're trying to deflect it. And yes, I

0:26:13.140 --> 0:26:17.060
<v Speaker 1>know that's politics, but forgive me for not taking this

0:26:17.119 --> 0:26:21.600
<v Speaker 1>complaint entirely seriously. And quickly before we get to a break,

0:26:22.220 --> 0:26:25.980
<v Speaker 1>the Northern Territory announced today that their trial of pepper

0:26:26.000 --> 0:26:29.400
<v Speaker 1>spray being available to members of the public will be

0:26:29.520 --> 0:26:32.590
<v Speaker 1>made permanent. Here was the Chief Minister, Leah Finocchiaro.

0:26:33.640 --> 0:26:37.169
<v Speaker 7>In September last year, we commenced a 12-month trial into

0:26:37.210 --> 0:26:40.620
<v Speaker 7>the legal use of OC spray for self-defence. We put

0:26:40.660 --> 0:26:44.419
<v Speaker 7>a rigorous trial process around that to make sure that

0:26:44.480 --> 0:26:48.520
<v Speaker 7>our police could keep firm control over who has access

0:26:48.540 --> 0:26:51.720
<v Speaker 7>to OC spray, how it's used, and our response has

0:26:51.770 --> 0:26:55.310
<v Speaker 7>been fantastic, with a 99% success rate.

0:26:56.310 --> 0:26:59.530
<v Speaker 1>And they'll also allow now 16 and 17-year-olds to be

0:26:59.590 --> 0:27:01.290
<v Speaker 1>able to access it, but they'll have to do it

0:27:01.350 --> 0:27:04.350
<v Speaker 1>with permission from a parent in the presence of a parent.

0:27:05.230 --> 0:27:08.250
<v Speaker 1>This has worked in the Northern Territory. It already exists

0:27:08.290 --> 0:27:11.740
<v Speaker 1>in Western Australia. Why can't we just take it national?

0:27:12.560 --> 0:27:14.340
<v Speaker 1>I mean, when was the last time you heard of

0:27:14.380 --> 0:27:18.260
<v Speaker 1>big problems with people in Western Australia or the Northern Territory,

0:27:18.300 --> 0:27:22.419
<v Speaker 1>for that matter, being able to have access to pepper spray?

0:27:23.119 --> 0:27:27.910
<v Speaker 1>It's not lethal. It seems like a pretty sensible self-defence

0:27:27.970 --> 0:27:31.369
<v Speaker 1>measure to me, one that I can understand particularly women

0:27:31.770 --> 0:27:34.790
<v Speaker 1>might like to carry. But you think of places like

0:27:34.830 --> 0:27:37.850
<v Speaker 1>Victoria at the moment, where we know there are large

0:27:37.910 --> 0:27:41.379
<v Speaker 1>problems with youth crime and break and enter and car

0:27:41.410 --> 0:27:44.720
<v Speaker 1>theft and carjacking, et cetera. Would you feel a little

0:27:44.760 --> 0:27:48.760
<v Speaker 1>bit safer if you were able to have pepper spray?

0:27:49.100 --> 0:27:51.800
<v Speaker 1>And this was brought up by David Limbrick today down

0:27:51.840 --> 0:27:54.880
<v Speaker 1>in Victoria. And the response of many has been, oh, well,

0:27:54.900 --> 0:27:58.840
<v Speaker 1>you know, that's sort of sheeting the blame onto people themselves.

0:27:58.900 --> 0:28:00.840
<v Speaker 1>It's not the job of the government to fix this. Well,

0:28:01.180 --> 0:28:03.689
<v Speaker 1>two things can be true at once. I mean, if

0:28:03.970 --> 0:28:07.600
<v Speaker 1>there are crime problems, why should we not have a

0:28:08.400 --> 0:28:13.540
<v Speaker 1>non-lethal method of being able to defend ourselves? If you

0:28:13.560 --> 0:28:17.160
<v Speaker 1>have someone who abuses that right, well, they're never allowed

0:28:17.200 --> 0:28:20.380
<v Speaker 1>to buy it again. But I don't see why this

0:28:20.520 --> 0:28:25.040
<v Speaker 1>cannot and should not go national. It works in Western Australia.

0:28:25.500 --> 0:28:28.660
<v Speaker 1>It works in the Northern Territory. Why can't we let

0:28:28.760 --> 0:28:33.070
<v Speaker 1>people have a basic right non-lethal method of self-defence that

0:28:33.109 --> 0:28:36.470
<v Speaker 1>they can use if they need it. Coming up after

0:28:36.490 --> 0:28:39.070
<v Speaker 1>the break, the Prime Minister says he'll do whatever he

0:28:39.110 --> 0:28:41.430
<v Speaker 1>can to stop the live streaming of an execution in

0:28:41.490 --> 0:28:44.100
<v Speaker 1>America being watched here, but there mightn't be much he

0:28:44.150 --> 0:28:45.910
<v Speaker 1>can do. More on that with the panel in a minute.

0:28:45.950 --> 0:28:53.480
<v Speaker 1>Thanks for being here tonight. Caleb Bond in for Paul.

0:28:53.520 --> 0:28:56.200
<v Speaker 1>Joining me now is former Labor Minister Stephen Conroy and

0:28:56.260 --> 0:28:59.860
<v Speaker 1>South Australian One Nation MLC Carlos Carim before the panel tonight.

0:28:59.880 --> 0:29:03.340
<v Speaker 1>Thank you both for being here. Stories dropped on the

0:29:03.360 --> 0:29:07.500
<v Speaker 1>Aus this evening. The Coalition is now going to revive

0:29:07.600 --> 0:29:10.350
<v Speaker 1>a policy that it took to the last election to

0:29:10.410 --> 0:29:13.370
<v Speaker 1>scrap Scope 3 emissions. We talked a fair bit last

0:29:13.410 --> 0:29:16.830
<v Speaker 1>week about Scope 3 emissions because that's basically emissions that

0:29:16.870 --> 0:29:20.610
<v Speaker 1>happen overseas that are caused by things we do in

0:29:20.630 --> 0:29:23.990
<v Speaker 1>this country, i.e. we export coal and it gets burnt

0:29:24.040 --> 0:29:27.700
<v Speaker 1>somewhere else. that's considered a Scope 3 emission. That was

0:29:27.920 --> 0:29:30.410
<v Speaker 1>used in a case in the High Court to scupper

0:29:30.510 --> 0:29:33.010
<v Speaker 1>a coal mine in New South Wales because apparently they

0:29:33.050 --> 0:29:36.550
<v Speaker 1>had not taken into account the mitigation of those Scope

0:29:36.550 --> 0:29:40.580
<v Speaker 1>3 emissions. Stephen, I don't understand why we... should have

0:29:40.620 --> 0:29:44.460
<v Speaker 1>any responsibility for these so-called Scope 3 emissions in Australia

0:29:44.920 --> 0:29:47.350
<v Speaker 1>because if we're not causing them, we're not burning the

0:29:47.390 --> 0:29:52.610
<v Speaker 1>coal or doing anything with it, it's not really our problem,

0:29:52.650 --> 0:29:52.880
<v Speaker 1>is it?

0:29:55.770 --> 0:29:56.910
<v Speaker 6>I agree with you completely.

0:29:57.680 --> 0:29:59.200
<v Speaker 3>I mean, this is a piece of New South Wales

0:29:59.240 --> 0:30:04.440
<v Speaker 3>legislation that has been interpreted in a new way. And

0:30:04.860 --> 0:30:08.760
<v Speaker 3>the sooner that the New South Wales Parliament change it

0:30:08.820 --> 0:30:13.150
<v Speaker 3>so it's absolutely clear that scope three emissions shouldn't be

0:30:13.890 --> 0:30:17.530
<v Speaker 3>needed to be considered or if there's a federal alternative,

0:30:18.290 --> 0:30:19.790
<v Speaker 3>as I said, the sooner the better. But this is

0:30:19.850 --> 0:30:22.930
<v Speaker 3>essentially a New South Wales problem and they should fix it.

0:30:23.530 --> 0:30:28.180
<v Speaker 3>But it's dangerous because of the precedent it might set

0:30:28.270 --> 0:30:31.469
<v Speaker 3>for not just New South Wales but other jurisdictions. And

0:30:31.490 --> 0:30:33.330
<v Speaker 3>it may be that the best way to solve it

0:30:33.390 --> 0:30:37.570
<v Speaker 3>is through the federal parliament. But, you know, this is

0:30:37.710 --> 0:30:42.170
<v Speaker 3>a very poor decision that breaks new ground and I

0:30:42.210 --> 0:30:46.010
<v Speaker 3>think it's a very dangerous precedent.

0:30:46.410 --> 0:30:48.830
<v Speaker 1>And I think the thing, Carlos, is, of course, you know,

0:30:48.890 --> 0:30:51.570
<v Speaker 1>the federal parliament can't change New South Wales law. It's

0:30:51.630 --> 0:30:53.790
<v Speaker 1>a matter for the Minsk government. They've said they don't

0:30:53.810 --> 0:30:55.850
<v Speaker 1>want to change anything in New South Wales for some

0:30:55.890 --> 0:31:00.290
<v Speaker 1>reason or another. But having Scope 3 emissions counted at

0:31:00.350 --> 0:31:03.430
<v Speaker 1>a federal level certainly then trickles down into the way

0:31:03.470 --> 0:31:06.700
<v Speaker 1>that states treat these things. And so, effectively, what they

0:31:06.720 --> 0:31:10.020
<v Speaker 1>are saying is, well, Scope 3 emissions just shouldn't exist

0:31:10.080 --> 0:31:13.560
<v Speaker 1>as a concept. No, and that's right, Caleb.

0:31:14.060 --> 0:31:16.940
<v Speaker 8>Look, we have the same issue here in South Australia,

0:31:16.960 --> 0:31:19.680
<v Speaker 8>not necessarily with coal, but definitely with gas. So much

0:31:19.740 --> 0:31:22.620
<v Speaker 8>of the state relies on gas. Everything is firmed. We

0:31:22.640 --> 0:31:25.580
<v Speaker 8>have the highest concentration of renewables, so we need the gas.

0:31:26.260 --> 0:31:28.480
<v Speaker 8>And I'm posing a question to the government in the

0:31:28.510 --> 0:31:30.870
<v Speaker 8>next couple of days, exactly that. What is the government

0:31:30.890 --> 0:31:33.030
<v Speaker 8>going to do to make sure that this doesn't happen?

0:31:33.570 --> 0:31:36.590
<v Speaker 8>This is what happens when zealots are in charge. They

0:31:36.630 --> 0:31:39.990
<v Speaker 8>leave the door open for dangerous legislation, which essentially can

0:31:40.070 --> 0:31:42.710
<v Speaker 8>bankrupt the country, because we dig things out of the

0:31:42.770 --> 0:31:45.350
<v Speaker 8>ground and we ship them overseas to be burnt elsewhere,

0:31:45.750 --> 0:31:47.290
<v Speaker 8>and that is how we make our money. And if

0:31:47.330 --> 0:31:48.930
<v Speaker 8>we can't continue to do that, we're going to have

0:31:48.970 --> 0:31:50.610
<v Speaker 8>to find the money somewhere else, and I just don't

0:31:50.630 --> 0:31:51.590
<v Speaker 8>know where it's going to come from.

0:31:51.890 --> 0:31:55.040
<v Speaker 1>Well, indeed, and, of course, it provides cheap, reliable energy

0:31:55.060 --> 0:31:56.660
<v Speaker 1>to other parts of the world that really need it,

0:31:56.880 --> 0:32:00.020
<v Speaker 1>you know? There are a lot of countries, India, China, whatever,

0:32:00.040 --> 0:32:03.040
<v Speaker 1>have been able to build good economies on the back

0:32:03.100 --> 0:32:05.160
<v Speaker 1>of the sort of coal that we sell to them.

0:32:06.120 --> 0:32:08.120
<v Speaker 1>And if people don't agree with that, well, maybe they

0:32:08.140 --> 0:32:09.980
<v Speaker 1>should go and argue to people in poverty that they

0:32:10.000 --> 0:32:13.670
<v Speaker 1>should never be pulled out of poverty. And speaking of poverty,

0:32:13.950 --> 0:32:15.470
<v Speaker 1>a lot of people doing it tough at the moment,

0:32:15.510 --> 0:32:18.990
<v Speaker 1>of course, interest rates. Going up in the last couple

0:32:19.030 --> 0:32:22.690
<v Speaker 1>of weeks, we got the minutes from the RBA's meeting

0:32:22.830 --> 0:32:25.930
<v Speaker 1>today and they have foreshadowed that we may well be

0:32:25.970 --> 0:32:29.190
<v Speaker 1>in line for another interest rate rise. Not that that

0:32:29.250 --> 0:32:32.910
<v Speaker 1>necessarily comes as a surprise. That had already kind of

0:32:32.970 --> 0:32:38.170
<v Speaker 1>been mooted. But you also had the International Monetary Fund

0:32:38.330 --> 0:32:42.830
<v Speaker 1>hand down its report today that shows, Stephen, on most markers...

0:32:42.990 --> 0:32:48.420
<v Speaker 1>We are doing worse than comparable countries and most developed countries.

0:32:48.460 --> 0:32:52.680
<v Speaker 1>Things are getting slightly better. But a very clear warning

0:32:52.740 --> 0:32:57.740
<v Speaker 1>from the IMF that all countries, Australia included, need to

0:32:58.030 --> 0:33:02.430
<v Speaker 1>think very carefully about government spending right now because there's

0:33:02.470 --> 0:33:05.410
<v Speaker 1>too much debt and there's too much deficit and there's

0:33:05.450 --> 0:33:08.270
<v Speaker 1>too much spending and not enough concern for what that

0:33:08.350 --> 0:33:09.610
<v Speaker 1>means for the fiscal outlook.

0:33:12.450 --> 0:33:16.300
<v Speaker 3>Look, the IMF have had a long history of not

0:33:16.600 --> 0:33:19.860
<v Speaker 3>giving a stuff about how many people they make unemployed.

0:33:20.600 --> 0:33:21.220
<v Speaker 6>That's their job.

0:33:22.500 --> 0:33:26.820
<v Speaker 3>They just demand, you know, the hair shirt, government cuts,

0:33:27.510 --> 0:33:31.130
<v Speaker 3>and don't care if 200,000 extra people are put on

0:33:31.170 --> 0:33:34.510
<v Speaker 3>the unemployment scrapbook, just like Australia Reserve Bank. They've made

0:33:34.530 --> 0:33:36.490
<v Speaker 3>it very clear. Those minutes reinforce it. I mean, the

0:33:36.530 --> 0:33:40.600
<v Speaker 3>minutes are pretty much the basis for of the speech

0:33:40.980 --> 0:33:44.640
<v Speaker 3>that Michelle Bullock gave at her press conference, the notes

0:33:44.680 --> 0:33:46.920
<v Speaker 3>that were released at the time of her press conference.

0:33:46.940 --> 0:33:51.310
<v Speaker 3>So there's no great shock. But what's shocking is that

0:33:51.410 --> 0:33:54.890
<v Speaker 3>they just don't care if another 200,000 Australians lose their job.

0:33:56.020 --> 0:34:00.670
<v Speaker 3>And it's not even like they're hiding it. they're literally saying, oh, well,

0:34:00.710 --> 0:34:03.590
<v Speaker 3>we may need unemployment to rise because we've got to

0:34:03.630 --> 0:34:06.930
<v Speaker 3>deal with this inflation and it may have to rise

0:34:06.990 --> 0:34:11.239
<v Speaker 3>to approaching, you know, 5%. That's 200,000 Australians' lives destroyed

0:34:11.570 --> 0:34:15.700
<v Speaker 3>who will struggle to ever get work again because that's

0:34:15.739 --> 0:34:18.779
<v Speaker 3>the way, particularly if they're male over 50 and they

0:34:18.800 --> 0:34:22.299
<v Speaker 3>lose their job, they'll almost certainly never get another job

0:34:22.340 --> 0:34:25.540
<v Speaker 3>according to all of the statistics you look back over

0:34:25.580 --> 0:34:28.710
<v Speaker 3>the last 20 years. So I don't think the government's,

0:34:29.239 --> 0:34:32.819
<v Speaker 3>going to take the Reserve Bank's position at all. This

0:34:32.860 --> 0:34:37.600
<v Speaker 3>government is very proud of having seen through the global

0:34:37.640 --> 0:34:41.950
<v Speaker 3>financial crisis back when I was in Parliament and making

0:34:41.989 --> 0:34:45.890
<v Speaker 3>sure that 200,000 people didn't lose their jobs, supporting the

0:34:46.510 --> 0:34:49.290
<v Speaker 3>measures during COVID to make sure hundreds of thousands of

0:34:49.310 --> 0:34:52.009
<v Speaker 3>Australians didn't lose their jobs. And just because a bunch

0:34:52.050 --> 0:34:55.569
<v Speaker 3>of economists and and the Reserve Bank staff still are

0:34:55.590 --> 0:34:59.350
<v Speaker 3>getting all of their fundamental modelling wrong, the government aren't

0:34:59.370 --> 0:35:01.810
<v Speaker 3>going to suddenly decide 200,000 people should lose their jobs.

0:35:01.969 --> 0:35:03.370
<v Speaker 1>Well, I don't disagree with you that it's a bad

0:35:03.410 --> 0:35:05.550
<v Speaker 1>thing for people to lose their jobs, but surely baked

0:35:05.590 --> 0:35:08.770
<v Speaker 1>into this under this government would be a large number

0:35:08.790 --> 0:35:11.029
<v Speaker 1>of these backpackers who would no longer be working in

0:35:11.070 --> 0:35:15.430
<v Speaker 1>this country. And also, what lever do you pull? I mean,

0:35:15.950 --> 0:35:18.120
<v Speaker 1>something has to be done about inflation. There's no doubt

0:35:18.180 --> 0:35:21.779
<v Speaker 1>about that. There's only one lever the RBA can pull,

0:35:22.200 --> 0:35:23.890
<v Speaker 1>So what do you suggest is done instead?

0:35:26.410 --> 0:35:29.950
<v Speaker 3>Well, they should start by understanding that they've got their

0:35:29.969 --> 0:35:35.170
<v Speaker 3>modelling wrong. They keep using the same strategy based on

0:35:35.210 --> 0:35:40.500
<v Speaker 3>the same modelling as if it's a demand side inflation problem.

0:35:40.900 --> 0:35:45.880
<v Speaker 3>This is a supply side, a supply side. And if

0:35:45.960 --> 0:35:48.220
<v Speaker 3>you put up interest rates to deal with a supply

0:35:48.280 --> 0:35:51.730
<v Speaker 3>side problem, you are going to tank the economy. And

0:35:51.770 --> 0:35:55.509
<v Speaker 3>that's what they've now admitted. We want 200,000 people to

0:35:55.570 --> 0:35:58.910
<v Speaker 3>lose their jobs. Well, my invitation to Michelle Bullock and

0:35:58.930 --> 0:36:00.870
<v Speaker 3>the staff at the Reserve Bank is you go down

0:36:00.910 --> 0:36:04.650
<v Speaker 3>to the local CES, you stand out front of the CES,

0:36:04.690 --> 0:36:07.280
<v Speaker 3>and as that queue gets longer because of your policy,

0:36:07.640 --> 0:36:10.279
<v Speaker 3>you explain to them, this is good for you.

0:36:10.460 --> 0:36:12.600
<v Speaker 6>I know it hurts, but it's good for you.

0:36:13.300 --> 0:36:18.120
<v Speaker 3>And see how a response she gets, because they're wrong fundamentally.

0:36:18.969 --> 0:36:23.109
<v Speaker 3>on the diagnosis, which means they're wrong on the solution.

0:36:23.570 --> 0:36:28.670
<v Speaker 3>It's a supply-side issue and they're applying demand-side solutions in

0:36:28.710 --> 0:36:29.210
<v Speaker 3>their mind.

0:36:29.730 --> 0:36:30.610
<v Speaker 1>What do you say, Carlos?

0:36:32.450 --> 0:36:36.419
<v Speaker 8>Look, I've heard this argument before. The RBA only have

0:36:36.540 --> 0:36:40.340
<v Speaker 8>one lever and they're literally pleading with the government, stop spending,

0:36:40.500 --> 0:36:43.020
<v Speaker 8>slow down your spending. And it's been not only the

0:36:43.060 --> 0:36:45.759
<v Speaker 8>Labor Party, the Liberal Party were just as bad during COVID.

0:36:46.120 --> 0:36:49.009
<v Speaker 8>And so we get all these issues. Now, Stephen talks

0:36:49.070 --> 0:36:52.170
<v Speaker 8>about supply. Well, we can't increase supply if you keep

0:36:52.250 --> 0:36:55.370
<v Speaker 8>over-regulating the economy. You can't have the government be the

0:36:55.430 --> 0:36:58.609
<v Speaker 8>biggest builder, the biggest employer, the biggest everything. You've got

0:36:58.630 --> 0:37:01.690
<v Speaker 8>to let the private sector take over. But unfortunately, the

0:37:01.730 --> 0:37:04.050
<v Speaker 8>Labor Party is not about that. They just want more

0:37:04.110 --> 0:37:06.420
<v Speaker 8>people working for the government. And this is where we're

0:37:06.440 --> 0:37:07.700
<v Speaker 8>going to end up. And you only have to look

0:37:07.739 --> 0:37:10.279
<v Speaker 8>at countries around the world where this has gone drastically

0:37:10.340 --> 0:37:12.540
<v Speaker 8>wrong and this is where we're heading. And so I'm

0:37:12.640 --> 0:37:16.440
<v Speaker 8>pleading with the government to change their scopes and start

0:37:16.719 --> 0:37:20.120
<v Speaker 8>to reduce the spending, make the tough decisions. No-one wants

0:37:20.140 --> 0:37:22.850
<v Speaker 8>to see people unemployed, but no-one wants to see inflation

0:37:22.870 --> 0:37:25.390
<v Speaker 8>continue to rise because it will spiral out of control

0:37:25.630 --> 0:37:26.250
<v Speaker 8>pretty quickly.

0:37:27.030 --> 0:37:29.430
<v Speaker 1>Just changing tack for a minute, of course, there's been

0:37:29.450 --> 0:37:32.839
<v Speaker 1>a lot of talk today about the potential live streaming

0:37:32.880 --> 0:37:36.700
<v Speaker 1>of this execution in the United States of Nadal Malik Hassan.

0:37:37.900 --> 0:37:41.620
<v Speaker 1>And there's been a pretty strong reaction across the board

0:37:41.700 --> 0:37:43.839
<v Speaker 1>from Barnaby Joyce through to the Prime Minister. The Prime

0:37:43.860 --> 0:37:46.430
<v Speaker 1>Minister said today he will do everything he possibly can

0:37:46.469 --> 0:37:50.270
<v Speaker 1>to stop this. But the eSafety Commissioner has basically admitted

0:37:50.290 --> 0:37:55.030
<v Speaker 1>there's very little that can be done to stop it. Stephen,

0:37:55.070 --> 0:37:58.239
<v Speaker 1>do you think laws should be changed or things should

0:37:58.300 --> 0:38:01.520
<v Speaker 1>go further in order to stop this kind of thing

0:38:01.560 --> 0:38:05.120
<v Speaker 1>being shown online? Because effectively, you know, you can regulate

0:38:05.280 --> 0:38:07.660
<v Speaker 1>what social media companies do. But if you want to

0:38:07.680 --> 0:38:10.570
<v Speaker 1>go further than that, you'd basically be censoring the internet.

0:38:13.969 --> 0:38:17.010
<v Speaker 3>Well, look, I think this is just a disgusting decision.

0:38:17.989 --> 0:38:20.029
<v Speaker 3>I'm not a fan of capital punishment. I'm long on

0:38:20.050 --> 0:38:24.120
<v Speaker 3>the record. But this sort of barbaric attitude, whether we're

0:38:24.140 --> 0:38:28.050
<v Speaker 3>going to show a live execution, this is the same

0:38:28.090 --> 0:38:31.630
<v Speaker 3>as what ISIS were doing, beheading people on camera. And

0:38:31.710 --> 0:38:34.009
<v Speaker 3>everybody in the world, in the civilised world, said this

0:38:34.070 --> 0:38:36.089
<v Speaker 3>is abhorrent and we should do whatever we can to

0:38:36.130 --> 0:38:43.350
<v Speaker 3>try and minimise this. And suddenly, you know, the Trump administration,

0:38:43.370 --> 0:38:47.590
<v Speaker 3>there's a lunatic esgus, decide they're going to live stream

0:38:48.450 --> 0:38:51.930
<v Speaker 3>an execution. I mean, this is barbaric. Now, in terms

0:38:51.989 --> 0:38:54.960
<v Speaker 3>of the powers, I don't think when this is a

0:38:55.080 --> 0:39:02.080
<v Speaker 3>state streamed, you know, activity that it is easy or,

0:39:02.900 --> 0:39:06.060
<v Speaker 3>as the eSafety Minister said, possible. This will be all

0:39:06.160 --> 0:39:07.870
<v Speaker 3>over the dark internet, but it's going to be all

0:39:07.910 --> 0:39:12.120
<v Speaker 3>over the normal internet as well. And I think in

0:39:12.160 --> 0:39:14.700
<v Speaker 3>that circumstance, it's not like some child porn where they're

0:39:14.719 --> 0:39:17.560
<v Speaker 3>hiding and you've got to track them down. And it's

0:39:17.600 --> 0:39:21.609
<v Speaker 3>a challenge, but it's possible to minimise. You can make

0:39:21.640 --> 0:39:24.610
<v Speaker 3>sure the platforms don't allow it. But this is a

0:39:24.650 --> 0:39:28.330
<v Speaker 3>government website that they're planning on doing it through. So

0:39:28.350 --> 0:39:31.759
<v Speaker 3>I would agree with the... Safety Commissioner. Very hard to do,

0:39:31.860 --> 0:39:36.280
<v Speaker 3>but it's abhorrent that Trump wants to mimic ISIS.

0:39:36.820 --> 0:39:39.379
<v Speaker 1>Just very quickly, Carlos, I've only got 30 seconds, but

0:39:39.440 --> 0:39:40.279
<v Speaker 1>would you ban it?

0:39:40.300 --> 0:39:40.520
<v Speaker 5>Sure.

0:39:41.860 --> 0:39:43.950
<v Speaker 8>No, I wouldn't ban it. I just wouldn't watch it.

0:39:44.100 --> 0:39:46.110
<v Speaker 8>And that's the free choice and free will that we

0:39:46.140 --> 0:39:48.360
<v Speaker 8>have in this country. If you don't want to watch it,

0:39:48.370 --> 0:39:51.450
<v Speaker 8>don't watch it. I don't agree with it being broadcast,

0:39:51.469 --> 0:39:53.129
<v Speaker 8>but I'm not going to ban it because you start

0:39:53.170 --> 0:39:55.629
<v Speaker 8>banning this and you ban the other things. And we

0:39:55.650 --> 0:39:58.710
<v Speaker 8>know that the censorship laws that the Labor Party are

0:39:58.730 --> 0:40:01.690
<v Speaker 8>trying to bring in now, you know, the duty of care,

0:40:01.750 --> 0:40:05.190
<v Speaker 8>this is all about stopping people from watching things. Just

0:40:05.290 --> 0:40:08.210
<v Speaker 8>let them make their own decision. And I can tell

0:40:08.230 --> 0:40:11.569
<v Speaker 8>you now, though, just quickly, Caleb, your early discussion about

0:40:11.610 --> 0:40:14.100
<v Speaker 8>that gentleman, I think it was in WA, who raped

0:40:14.140 --> 0:40:16.859
<v Speaker 8>those four Aboriginal girls. I'll tell you what, I'd make

0:40:16.900 --> 0:40:19.219
<v Speaker 8>an exception for that gentleman, though, because that was just

0:40:19.320 --> 0:40:22.160
<v Speaker 8>absolutely disgusting and I'm tired about hearing about this sort

0:40:22.200 --> 0:40:23.219
<v Speaker 8>of stuff in those communities.

0:40:23.480 --> 0:40:25.200
<v Speaker 1>I don't think you'd be the Lone Ranger in that.

0:40:25.300 --> 0:40:28.310
<v Speaker 1>Good to have a chat, Jen. Stephen Conroy, Carlos Caremba.

0:40:28.469 --> 0:40:30.649
<v Speaker 1>All right, coming up after the break, more on that

0:40:30.810 --> 0:40:33.190
<v Speaker 1>awful case we were just talking about from WA of

0:40:33.230 --> 0:40:36.270
<v Speaker 1>this rapist who was given a discount on his sentence

0:40:36.390 --> 0:40:39.150
<v Speaker 1>because of his connection to Aboriginal land. Chris Merritt will

0:40:39.190 --> 0:40:45.609
<v Speaker 1>join me. Don't go away. Caleb Bond in for Paul

0:40:45.650 --> 0:40:47.430
<v Speaker 1>this week. Now, as I talked about at the top

0:40:47.450 --> 0:40:50.040
<v Speaker 1>of the show, there was this shocking story in the

0:40:50.100 --> 0:40:53.140
<v Speaker 1>Oz today about the sentencing of an Indigenous man, Geoffrey

0:40:53.239 --> 0:40:56.440
<v Speaker 1>Allen Brown, who was found guilty of raping and sexually

0:40:56.500 --> 0:41:00.819
<v Speaker 1>abusing four Aboriginal children. And the galling part is that

0:41:00.900 --> 0:41:04.650
<v Speaker 1>a court in Western Australia... gave him a reduced prison

0:41:04.690 --> 0:41:08.509
<v Speaker 1>sentence due to his significant connection to country and his

0:41:08.550 --> 0:41:12.210
<v Speaker 1>good standing in the community. Judge Gary Massey said, you've

0:41:12.230 --> 0:41:15.030
<v Speaker 1>done it tough since being remanded in custody awaiting trial.

0:41:15.070 --> 0:41:18.180
<v Speaker 1>You are separated from your family with whom you were close.

0:41:18.790 --> 0:41:21.510
<v Speaker 1>and your wife is deprived of your role as her carer,

0:41:21.570 --> 0:41:25.310
<v Speaker 1>which I'm sure weighs heavily on you. He went on, ultimately,

0:41:25.370 --> 0:41:28.509
<v Speaker 1>the sentence I must impose must be proportionate with the

0:41:28.570 --> 0:41:32.090
<v Speaker 1>seriousness of your offending. I'm going to treat you as

0:41:32.150 --> 0:41:34.870
<v Speaker 1>a person of prior good character, and that is a

0:41:34.989 --> 0:41:40.240
<v Speaker 1>mitigating factor. I mustn't impose a crushing sentence on you.

0:41:40.820 --> 0:41:44.040
<v Speaker 1>If that doesn't make you angry, Nothing will. For more,

0:41:44.100 --> 0:41:48.700
<v Speaker 1>the Australian's legal affairs contributor, Chris Merritt, joins me now. Chris,

0:41:49.420 --> 0:41:53.500
<v Speaker 1>I just can't get over that you have courts and

0:41:53.820 --> 0:41:59.540
<v Speaker 1>jurists taking into account such things despite the severity of

0:41:59.600 --> 0:42:01.700
<v Speaker 1>a crime like this. I mean, surely there is a

0:42:01.760 --> 0:42:06.420
<v Speaker 1>point at which good character or connection to country or

0:42:06.480 --> 0:42:10.900
<v Speaker 1>whatever doesn't count anymore because it certainly doesn't matter to

0:42:10.940 --> 0:42:12.540
<v Speaker 1>those poor kids who were abused.

0:42:13.930 --> 0:42:17.810
<v Speaker 2>Look, the really surprising thing about this is those views

0:42:17.850 --> 0:42:25.260
<v Speaker 2>you've just expressed perfectly encapsulate the law as enunciated in

0:42:25.260 --> 0:42:29.540
<v Speaker 2>2022 in a unanimous decision of the West Australian Court

0:42:29.560 --> 0:42:35.020
<v Speaker 2>of Appeal. Now, that decision, known as OTR, said the

0:42:35.160 --> 0:42:40.740
<v Speaker 2>primary consideration when it comes to sentencing in child sexual

0:42:40.800 --> 0:42:46.650
<v Speaker 2>offences is is punishment and deterrence and personal matters, personal

0:42:46.710 --> 0:42:52.319
<v Speaker 2>to the offender, are less important and good character should

0:42:52.360 --> 0:42:55.859
<v Speaker 2>have little weight at all. But when you consider the

0:42:55.940 --> 0:43:00.680
<v Speaker 2>sentencing remarks in this case, the Brown case, it's very

0:43:00.780 --> 0:43:05.660
<v Speaker 2>clear that the judge in question took into account personal

0:43:05.719 --> 0:43:10.450
<v Speaker 2>matters such as this man's role in the Indigenous community

0:43:10.590 --> 0:43:16.910
<v Speaker 2>and keeping Indigenous culture alive and looking after his unwell wife.

0:43:17.930 --> 0:43:22.180
<v Speaker 6>That should have less weight than deterrence.

0:43:21.760 --> 0:43:24.440
<v Speaker 2>And punishment, according to the Court of Appeal.

0:43:25.380 --> 0:43:30.800
<v Speaker 6>And the other factor, good character. The court was very

0:43:30.900 --> 0:43:31.440
<v Speaker 6>clear on.

0:43:31.380 --> 0:43:34.719
<v Speaker 2>This, that when it comes to dealing with pedophiles, of

0:43:34.840 --> 0:43:38.460
<v Speaker 2>course they would have good character because people would not

0:43:38.560 --> 0:43:43.299
<v Speaker 2>know about their sexual offending until it became apparent. Now,

0:43:43.360 --> 0:43:46.940
<v Speaker 2>that has been the law in Western Australia since 2022.

0:43:46.940 --> 0:43:53.719
<v Speaker 2>That's two years before the sentencing in this case. Now,

0:43:54.020 --> 0:43:58.460
<v Speaker 2>what that tells me is I'm startled that the Office

0:43:58.960 --> 0:44:03.240
<v Speaker 2>of the Director of Public Prosecutions in WA did not

0:44:03.489 --> 0:44:09.140
<v Speaker 2>use the 21-day period post-sentencing to seek leave or to

0:44:09.219 --> 0:44:14.000
<v Speaker 2>lodge notice of appeal that the sentence was, there was

0:44:14.040 --> 0:44:19.250
<v Speaker 2>something awry here. The report in The Australian by Ros

0:44:19.290 --> 0:44:25.170
<v Speaker 2>Thomas gives a very, very clear impression that those factors

0:44:25.210 --> 0:44:30.029
<v Speaker 2>that I mentioned, personal factors and good character, played a

0:44:30.110 --> 0:44:34.520
<v Speaker 2>large part in reducing this man's sentence from what could

0:44:34.540 --> 0:44:40.170
<v Speaker 2>have been a maximum of 20 years. And remember, he pleaded,

0:44:40.250 --> 0:44:45.390
<v Speaker 2>he was found guilty of six offences of sexual penetration

0:44:45.430 --> 0:44:49.569
<v Speaker 2>of a child. That was amongst the 13 offences he

0:44:49.610 --> 0:44:52.910
<v Speaker 2>was convicted of. Maximum penalty, 20 years.

0:44:52.969 --> 0:44:55.410
<v Speaker 6>What he got? Just over 10.

0:44:55.410 --> 0:44:58.750
<v Speaker 2>So it's far too late now for the DPP to

0:44:58.810 --> 0:44:59.669
<v Speaker 2>turn around and.

0:45:01.880 --> 0:45:04.719
<v Speaker 6>Take advantage of that 21-day period. That's years old.

0:45:05.390 --> 0:45:10.290
<v Speaker 2>It is possible to seek leave from the Supreme Court

0:45:10.950 --> 0:45:16.600
<v Speaker 2>to lodge a late appeal on sentencing, but it's years

0:45:16.780 --> 0:45:19.880
<v Speaker 2>in the past now. I think the Office of the

0:45:19.920 --> 0:45:24.140
<v Speaker 2>Director of Public Prosecutions has some serious questions to answer here.

0:45:24.160 --> 0:45:28.830
<v Speaker 2>I have every faith in the accuracy of the report

0:45:28.850 --> 0:45:33.200
<v Speaker 2>that in The Australian by Ros Thomas, of these sentencing remarks.

0:45:33.660 --> 0:45:38.210
<v Speaker 2>And based on those remarks, based on that report, it

0:45:38.330 --> 0:45:42.730
<v Speaker 2>looks to me as though this sentence has misfired and

0:45:42.790 --> 0:45:48.510
<v Speaker 2>there may well have been inadequate attention to the judgment

0:45:48.810 --> 0:45:51.770
<v Speaker 2>of the Court of Appeal in the OTR case.

0:45:52.770 --> 0:45:56.069
<v Speaker 1>And you raised the issue of it should have been appealed.

0:45:56.690 --> 0:46:00.219
<v Speaker 1>And I wonder, as with all of these cases, whether

0:46:00.239 --> 0:46:04.520
<v Speaker 1>there is a reticence to intervene in certain matters of

0:46:04.680 --> 0:46:08.040
<v Speaker 1>child abuse because there is a concern over the cultural element.

0:46:08.840 --> 0:46:13.120
<v Speaker 1>And this is the problem. Why should cultural considerations, like

0:46:13.180 --> 0:46:17.070
<v Speaker 1>someone's connection to country, as we say in Indigenous terms,

0:46:17.450 --> 0:46:20.489
<v Speaker 1>have any bearing on a sentence whatsoever? I mean, if

0:46:20.590 --> 0:46:22.850
<v Speaker 1>I were being sentenced for a crime, do you think

0:46:22.870 --> 0:46:24.770
<v Speaker 1>they'd take into account that I have a connection to

0:46:24.830 --> 0:46:26.169
<v Speaker 1>Adelaide because that's where I was born?

0:46:28.190 --> 0:46:31.180
<v Speaker 6>You're talking common sense. I think.

0:46:32.700 --> 0:46:36.259
<v Speaker 2>You're absolutely right. I think the sooner this is sorted out,

0:46:36.280 --> 0:46:40.940
<v Speaker 2>the better. But the reality is that judicial officers, not

0:46:40.980 --> 0:46:43.549
<v Speaker 2>just in Western Australia but right around the country, are

0:46:43.590 --> 0:46:51.670
<v Speaker 2>being deluged with advice and guidance on how it's really

0:46:51.710 --> 0:46:56.650
<v Speaker 2>desirable to reduce the Indigenous incarceration rate. and to take

0:46:56.690 --> 0:47:05.910
<v Speaker 2>into account cultural detriments that the Indigenous community suffers that

0:47:06.630 --> 0:47:09.540
<v Speaker 2>others in the community do not suffer. Now, that's all

0:47:09.600 --> 0:47:14.180
<v Speaker 2>very well, but the primary consideration for judicial officers is

0:47:14.280 --> 0:47:19.060
<v Speaker 2>the law. And the Court of Appeal of Western Australia...

0:47:19.130 --> 0:47:23.930
<v Speaker 2>has been very, very clear. Punishment and deterrence for sexual

0:47:24.469 --> 0:47:30.590
<v Speaker 2>offences is the primary consideration. Other matters such as connection

0:47:30.610 --> 0:47:34.450
<v Speaker 2>to country are personal and carry less weight.

0:47:34.610 --> 0:47:37.719
<v Speaker 6>That's not my view. That's the Court of Appeals view, unanimously.

0:47:38.020 --> 0:47:40.040
<v Speaker 1>Yep, as will it should be. And I'm not going

0:47:40.060 --> 0:47:42.020
<v Speaker 1>to let go of this one because it just, it

0:47:42.100 --> 0:47:44.860
<v Speaker 1>outrages me so much. And I know they're uncomfortable stories

0:47:44.900 --> 0:47:47.140
<v Speaker 1>to talk about, but we have to talk about them

0:47:47.180 --> 0:47:49.670
<v Speaker 1>because light needs to be shone on it. And something

0:47:49.710 --> 0:47:51.930
<v Speaker 1>has to change. And the work of Ros Thomas, as

0:47:51.950 --> 0:47:55.649
<v Speaker 1>you say, on this has just been sensational. Chris Merritt,

0:47:55.969 --> 0:47:57.650
<v Speaker 1>thank you for your time. Thank you for joining me tonight.

0:47:57.850 --> 0:47:59.870
<v Speaker 1>All right, after the break, the late debate not too

0:47:59.910 --> 0:48:01.790
<v Speaker 1>far away. Of course, I'm not on it at the moment,

0:48:01.810 --> 0:48:03.730
<v Speaker 1>but I'll be there. I'll be back there next week.

0:48:03.770 --> 0:48:05.530
<v Speaker 6>Don't go away.

0:48:08.710 --> 0:48:13.770
<v Speaker 1>Now, the Energy Market Commission has approved basically a $ 1

0:48:13.230 --> 0:48:16.420
<v Speaker 1>tax on your power bill every year. to build new

0:48:16.780 --> 0:48:20.540
<v Speaker 1>EV chargers. But Christy McBain, who was the emergency services minister,

0:48:20.560 --> 0:48:22.010
<v Speaker 1>says the government doesn't support it.

0:48:23.100 --> 0:48:27.310
<v Speaker 5>It's not something that the government is suggesting. I think that,

0:48:27.390 --> 0:48:30.029
<v Speaker 5>you know, if you're buying an EV, you do so

0:48:30.090 --> 0:48:32.350
<v Speaker 5>and you've got a range of incentives already out there

0:48:32.410 --> 0:48:35.990
<v Speaker 5>to do that. It shouldn't be, you know, agglomerised to

0:48:36.030 --> 0:48:36.810
<v Speaker 5>the rest of the country.

0:48:38.010 --> 0:48:41.700
<v Speaker 1>Only trouble is, Christy, the idea came from Chris Bowen's

0:48:41.890 --> 0:48:46.200
<v Speaker 1>Energy and Climate Change Department. Oh! Oh, no. Here's the

0:48:46.239 --> 0:48:46.670
<v Speaker 1>late debate.