WEBVTT - The Bolt Report | 26 October

0:00:15.610 --> 0:00:19.430
<v Speaker 1>Better too late than never. It's when a politician is

0:00:19.489 --> 0:00:22.610
<v Speaker 1>mown down in this new culture of hate, it's then

0:00:22.630 --> 0:00:28.060
<v Speaker 1>that culture finally becomes the biggest issue in politics. Last week,

0:00:28.100 --> 0:00:30.880
<v Speaker 1>Federal Independent MP Helen Haynes flossed her legs when a

0:00:30.900 --> 0:00:34.780
<v Speaker 1>man allegedly ran his four-wheel drive into her at least twice.

0:00:35.310 --> 0:00:39.210
<v Speaker 1>And today Parliament paid tribute to her before cancelling a

0:00:39.270 --> 0:00:44.050
<v Speaker 1>lot of its usual business. And that's what happens when

0:00:44.070 --> 0:00:47.989
<v Speaker 1>a politician gets hurt and seriously hurt. But what of

0:00:48.570 --> 0:00:53.669
<v Speaker 1>ordinary Australians? For years, they have been terrified and hurt

0:00:53.730 --> 0:00:57.650
<v Speaker 1>and even killed in this culture. You've had shop assistants

0:00:58.070 --> 0:01:04.130
<v Speaker 1>getting smashed, hundreds of shops being firebombed by organised crime,

0:01:04.190 --> 0:01:08.600
<v Speaker 1>two more on the weekend. Shoppers in malls being terrified.

0:01:09.670 --> 0:01:11.010
<v Speaker 2>And then there's the home invasions.

0:01:11.830 --> 0:01:14.270
<v Speaker 1>And last week in Melbourne, a car was even shot

0:01:14.330 --> 0:01:17.730
<v Speaker 1>up in a road rage incident. Last year, two police

0:01:17.770 --> 0:01:22.640
<v Speaker 1>were murdered by a supposed sovereign citizen. Last Friday, three

0:01:22.690 --> 0:01:25.899
<v Speaker 1>men and an innocent teenage girl were shot by gunmen

0:01:25.959 --> 0:01:29.700
<v Speaker 1>spraying bullets into a crowd outside a Brisbane boxing event.

0:01:31.220 --> 0:01:34.530
<v Speaker 1>And of course, in December, 15 people were shot dead

0:01:34.670 --> 0:01:38.140
<v Speaker 1>in an Islamist attack on a Jewish festival at Bondi Beach.

0:01:39.260 --> 0:01:43.920
<v Speaker 1>So why hasn't this culture of hate been terrifying politicians?

0:01:44.840 --> 0:01:52.030
<v Speaker 1>Not just this month, not last December, but for years. Still,

0:01:52.330 --> 0:01:56.490
<v Speaker 1>now a politician is hurt and cruelly hurt. Politicians today

0:01:56.570 --> 0:02:00.670
<v Speaker 1>stopped work from the shock. And now they're demanding a

0:02:00.730 --> 0:02:01.570
<v Speaker 1>kinder culture.

0:02:02.730 --> 0:02:03.590
<v Speaker 2>Only now?

0:02:07.910 --> 0:02:12.810
<v Speaker 1>More the political opportunism today. Politicians, and not just them,

0:02:13.710 --> 0:02:17.650
<v Speaker 1>using this disgusting attack on Helen Haynes to play politics.

0:02:18.930 --> 0:02:22.709
<v Speaker 1>Now from the start, some in Labor and the ABC

0:02:22.750 --> 0:02:26.820
<v Speaker 1>have used this attack to smear One Nation. Now I've

0:02:26.840 --> 0:02:30.000
<v Speaker 1>mentioned this before, like Federal Labor MP Mike Freeland of Raging,

0:02:30.260 --> 0:02:33.700
<v Speaker 1>it has to stop, particularly the disparaging and hateful rhetoric

0:02:33.919 --> 0:02:38.100
<v Speaker 1>from French parties like One Nation, and ABC host Raph Epstein,

0:02:38.700 --> 0:02:42.060
<v Speaker 1>wondering aloud if blame could indeed be pinned on One Nation.

0:02:42.940 --> 0:02:47.270
<v Speaker 3>Does One Nation play a role in amplifying any dangerous rhetoric?

0:02:48.470 --> 0:02:51.609
<v Speaker 1>Yesterday, the ABC tried again, setting up Australian Federal Police

0:02:51.650 --> 0:02:54.950
<v Speaker 1>Commissioner Chrissie Barrett. She was asked on Insiders about a

0:02:54.970 --> 0:02:59.500
<v Speaker 1>Yahoo News report revealing another nasty One Nation cartoon, this

0:02:59.510 --> 0:03:03.769
<v Speaker 1>time two years ago, fantasising about running down former Victorian

0:03:03.810 --> 0:03:06.410
<v Speaker 1>Premier Daniel Andrews and the Prime Minister.

0:03:07.290 --> 0:03:08.390
<v Speaker 2>I got away with it all.

0:03:09.110 --> 0:03:12.370
<v Speaker 4>Oh, Bluey!

0:03:12.730 --> 0:03:13.390
<v Speaker 2>Thank goodness!

0:03:13.630 --> 0:03:15.570
<v Speaker 4>He was completely out of control, right?

0:03:17.530 --> 0:03:18.070
<v Speaker 2>Reverse?

0:03:18.150 --> 0:03:19.370
<v Speaker 5>No, he hates all labour.

0:03:19.610 --> 0:03:20.950
<v Speaker 6>Oh, no, Bluey!

0:03:21.950 --> 0:03:26.130
<v Speaker 1>That was after reports of Daniel Andrews' car hitting a cyclist.

0:03:26.190 --> 0:03:29.730
<v Speaker 1>But still, One Nation even fantasised about running over race-baiting

0:03:29.750 --> 0:03:30.790
<v Speaker 1>Senator Lydia Thorpe.

0:03:31.750 --> 0:03:33.190
<v Speaker 4>Lydia, get out of the way.

0:03:33.710 --> 0:03:33.790
<v Speaker 7>No!

0:03:33.810 --> 0:03:35.990
<v Speaker 4>How did you get Lydia to move out of the way?

0:03:36.490 --> 0:03:43.300
<v Speaker 1>Who? That was years before Haynes was attacked. But once again,

0:03:43.440 --> 0:03:46.540
<v Speaker 1>this was an excuse to link One Nation to the

0:03:46.600 --> 0:03:49.460
<v Speaker 1>attack on Haynes when Commissioner Barrett was trying to point

0:03:49.540 --> 0:03:52.380
<v Speaker 1>out what a personal experience of federal police statistics showed,

0:03:52.640 --> 0:03:57.140
<v Speaker 1>that any, any nasty political debate of any kind tended

0:03:57.160 --> 0:04:00.000
<v Speaker 1>to be followed by vicious abuse of politicians and threats

0:04:00.080 --> 0:04:00.380
<v Speaker 1>to them.

0:04:01.440 --> 0:04:04.640
<v Speaker 8>What about the tone of political discourse? We're obviously very

0:04:04.660 --> 0:04:06.620
<v Speaker 8>focused on it, we've been talking about it. What's your

0:04:06.640 --> 0:04:11.330
<v Speaker 8>perspective here? Does the language our politicians use influence this

0:04:11.350 --> 0:04:12.370
<v Speaker 8>sort of hate and violence?

0:04:12.450 --> 0:04:15.380
<v Speaker 9>It does have a direct correlation to what we see

0:04:15.420 --> 0:04:18.630
<v Speaker 9>in terms of threats and abuse and sometimes it's very immediate.

0:04:18.830 --> 0:04:22.630
<v Speaker 8>The things like a cartoon that suggests someone should be

0:04:22.650 --> 0:04:24.910
<v Speaker 8>hit by a car or something like that, does that

0:04:24.930 --> 0:04:26.430
<v Speaker 8>have a direct link? Is that what you're talking about?

0:04:26.650 --> 0:04:30.589
<v Speaker 9>We do see examples where there are particular announcements or,

0:04:30.790 --> 0:04:34.240
<v Speaker 9>you know, things like you've just described. There is a

0:04:34.300 --> 0:04:36.100
<v Speaker 9>reaction amongst the community.

0:04:36.130 --> 0:04:38.010
<v Speaker 8>So you think politicians should be dialling it down?

0:04:38.510 --> 0:04:40.600
<v Speaker 9>Again, I'm not here to tell politicians how to do

0:04:40.660 --> 0:04:42.820
<v Speaker 9>their job, and they have, you know, a very important

0:04:42.860 --> 0:04:45.740
<v Speaker 9>job to do. I'm here to describe what we see.

0:04:46.430 --> 0:04:49.150
<v Speaker 1>Heard in the full context, Barrett herself did not first

0:04:49.250 --> 0:04:53.630
<v Speaker 1>raise One Nation cartoon or blame it for the attack

0:04:53.690 --> 0:04:57.110
<v Speaker 1>on Haynes. She agreed only with a general proposition put

0:04:57.150 --> 0:05:00.640
<v Speaker 1>to her that, yes, things like that, not necessarily like

0:05:00.960 --> 0:05:05.339
<v Speaker 1>that clip itself, not necessarily that clip, added to the

0:05:05.400 --> 0:05:07.520
<v Speaker 1>abuse that politicians get. And who in their right mind

0:05:07.560 --> 0:05:11.270
<v Speaker 1>really could disagree with that? But why did the ABC

0:05:11.420 --> 0:05:15.720
<v Speaker 1>push for her to attack those One Nation cartoons specifically,

0:05:16.100 --> 0:05:20.380
<v Speaker 1>of all the hate speech that's out there? Now, it

0:05:20.440 --> 0:05:23.979
<v Speaker 1>is true, and I've said it before, One Nation is

0:05:24.100 --> 0:05:30.010
<v Speaker 1>trashing its brand with its vicious cartoon. It should stop

0:05:30.029 --> 0:05:33.310
<v Speaker 1>with the stupid stunts and get serious. But that has

0:05:33.510 --> 0:05:35.169
<v Speaker 1>nothing to do with the attack.

0:05:34.930 --> 0:05:38.010
<v Speaker 2>On Helen Haynes. The idea is idiotic.

0:05:38.050 --> 0:05:40.630
<v Speaker 1>I mean, the man charged with running Haynes down is,

0:05:41.050 --> 0:05:45.160
<v Speaker 1>we've heard, mentally disturbed. Neighbours have said he'd acted erratically

0:05:45.200 --> 0:05:48.720
<v Speaker 1>and had threatened them and acted strange, had raged at

0:05:48.760 --> 0:05:52.020
<v Speaker 1>his father, refused to speak to him, even through an

0:05:52.060 --> 0:05:55.640
<v Speaker 1>appointed intermediary. And Haynes, the woman who ran down, was

0:05:55.700 --> 0:05:59.609
<v Speaker 1>actually a friend of his father and stepmother. And what's more,

0:06:00.290 --> 0:06:03.030
<v Speaker 1>the guy was a One Nation hater who was a

0:06:03.050 --> 0:06:05.830
<v Speaker 1>global warming fanatic, so why would he then run down

0:06:05.870 --> 0:06:08.849
<v Speaker 1>a One Nation opponent who also fought against global warming?

0:06:09.700 --> 0:06:14.080
<v Speaker 1>Makes no sense because of a One Nation cartoon that

0:06:14.120 --> 0:06:17.909
<v Speaker 1>I guarantee you never saw. So why are the ABCs

0:06:17.970 --> 0:06:21.310
<v Speaker 1>focused on these cartoons and One Nation? Why, when the

0:06:21.410 --> 0:06:26.170
<v Speaker 1>biggest preachers of hatred, violence and physical confrontation are on

0:06:26.270 --> 0:06:31.060
<v Speaker 1>the left? They're not on the right at all. Now,

0:06:31.100 --> 0:06:34.620
<v Speaker 1>just this weekend, Victoria's emergency services minister proved that when

0:06:34.640 --> 0:06:37.719
<v Speaker 1>he found someone had followed him and put a bullet

0:06:37.820 --> 0:06:40.610
<v Speaker 1>on his car with the word rat scratched on it

0:06:41.390 --> 0:06:45.350
<v Speaker 1>and his old firefighter ID number. Who would know that?

0:06:45.550 --> 0:06:48.850
<v Speaker 1>And he blamed the hard left firefighters union for its

0:06:48.910 --> 0:06:50.050
<v Speaker 1>incitement to hate.

0:06:51.150 --> 0:06:54.990
<v Speaker 10>You can't stir up members and tell them so many

0:06:55.089 --> 0:06:57.919
<v Speaker 10>untruths and expect things like this not to happen.

0:06:58.540 --> 0:07:02.310
<v Speaker 5>Um, We want to give firefighters a pay rise. And

0:07:02.330 --> 0:07:04.370
<v Speaker 5>there's only one issue here, and that is that we

0:07:04.390 --> 0:07:06.650
<v Speaker 5>won't sign off on a slush fund for the union.

0:07:08.570 --> 0:07:14.410
<v Speaker 1>I'll give you more examples. The Marxist Socialist Alternative organises confrontations,

0:07:14.510 --> 0:07:17.950
<v Speaker 1>physical really, against One Nation and Pauline Hanson, which so

0:07:18.000 --> 0:07:23.040
<v Speaker 1>far have included protesters filmed calling for their death, like

0:07:23.080 --> 0:07:23.440
<v Speaker 1>this one.

0:07:24.410 --> 0:07:25.950
<v Speaker 4>Die, Nazi scum!

0:07:26.390 --> 0:07:28.260
<v Speaker 9>Shame, Pauline! Shame!

0:07:28.400 --> 0:07:31.200
<v Speaker 4>Death to Australia! Death to our nation!

0:07:32.460 --> 0:07:33.400
<v Speaker 2>Nope, not arrested.

0:07:33.940 --> 0:07:37.760
<v Speaker 1>Hard-left groups also staged violent protests at a Melbourne weapons expo,

0:07:38.160 --> 0:07:41.080
<v Speaker 1>attacking police and attacking people just trying to get in.

0:07:41.580 --> 0:07:44.930
<v Speaker 1>Another hard-left group associated with the socialist alternative attacked police

0:07:44.970 --> 0:07:49.130
<v Speaker 1>with these rocks at a Melbourne protest. A former volunteer

0:07:49.190 --> 0:07:53.380
<v Speaker 1>for the far-left GetUp told a parliamentary inquiry... GetUp had

0:07:53.420 --> 0:07:58.500
<v Speaker 1>trained him for the purpose of deliberately interrupting liberal political candidates' visits,

0:07:58.940 --> 0:08:02.660
<v Speaker 1>where security, he said, was not tight and maximum disruption

0:08:02.680 --> 0:08:05.700
<v Speaker 1>and embarrassment to the candidate could be caused, as well

0:08:05.880 --> 0:08:09.790
<v Speaker 1>as shirt-fronting the candidate in front of the press and

0:08:09.950 --> 0:08:13.670
<v Speaker 1>physically blocking the Liberal Party's candidate's walk while yelling abuse

0:08:13.710 --> 0:08:17.850
<v Speaker 1>at the candidate. Hard left influencer Hannah Ferguson only recently

0:08:17.910 --> 0:08:22.590
<v Speaker 1>justified some political violence, writing, Is violence sometimes necessary?

0:08:23.280 --> 0:08:24.380
<v Speaker 2>Answer? Yes.

0:08:25.220 --> 0:08:29.160
<v Speaker 1>And hard left pro-Palestine activist Grace Tame called for the

0:08:29.280 --> 0:08:35.620
<v Speaker 1>Interfather you now see in Palestine or in Gaza from

0:08:35.679 --> 0:08:40.390
<v Speaker 1>Palestinians fighting Israel and apparently if you ask Tame, it

0:08:40.429 --> 0:08:41.370
<v Speaker 1>should be brought here.

0:08:41.390 --> 0:08:46.990
<v Speaker 6>From Gadigal to Gaza, globalise the Interfather!

0:08:48.870 --> 0:08:51.230
<v Speaker 1>I could show you so much more footage of political

0:08:51.270 --> 0:08:53.439
<v Speaker 1>violence by the Australian left. I could fill up the

0:08:53.480 --> 0:08:56.880
<v Speaker 1>rest of the show with it, I'm sure. And it

0:08:56.900 --> 0:09:00.800
<v Speaker 1>could also show Labor Prime Minister forced by an anti-Australia

0:09:00.820 --> 0:09:05.890
<v Speaker 1>Day mob to flee for her safety, Julia Gillard. So

0:09:06.330 --> 0:09:10.350
<v Speaker 1>why is all this, another One Nation cartoon from two

0:09:10.410 --> 0:09:15.150
<v Speaker 1>years ago, the issue? How is this not an urgent

0:09:15.190 --> 0:09:18.770
<v Speaker 1>topic that it's the left that's become a menace to

0:09:18.860 --> 0:09:22.760
<v Speaker 1>our safety? some parts even joining forces with other groups

0:09:22.820 --> 0:09:28.340
<v Speaker 1>that celebrate political violence, like militant Muslim groups. Listen to

0:09:28.380 --> 0:09:31.850
<v Speaker 1>this socialist alternative member giving evidence this year to the

0:09:31.890 --> 0:09:36.530
<v Speaker 1>Royal Commission into Anti-Semitism, refusing to condemn Hamas terrorists.

0:09:37.650 --> 0:09:43.140
<v Speaker 11>I don't hold movements for the justice of the oppressed to.

0:09:43.080 --> 0:09:45.820
<v Speaker 4>A standard that says there can never be any violence.

0:09:46.920 --> 0:09:49.500
<v Speaker 2>And there's the ABC, and some in Labor.

0:09:50.160 --> 0:09:56.650
<v Speaker 1>Worried about one nation, while outside their studios and sometimes

0:09:56.730 --> 0:10:02.460
<v Speaker 1>even in them are leftists screaming for interference. defending political violence,

0:10:02.880 --> 0:10:07.260
<v Speaker 1>calling for death for Pauline Hanson, attacking police, attacking Jews,

0:10:07.540 --> 0:10:12.540
<v Speaker 1>attacking journalists like me, attacking conservatives and now allegedly running

0:10:12.679 --> 0:10:19.540
<v Speaker 1>down a politician. Ellen Haynes, how can the ABC and

0:10:19.580 --> 0:10:24.470
<v Speaker 1>Labor be so blind to all that and so silent

0:10:25.370 --> 0:10:35.360
<v Speaker 1>and so, so outraged by a One Nation cartoon instead. Now,

0:10:35.380 --> 0:10:39.380
<v Speaker 1>I'm also disgusted by politicians today misusing the brutal attack

0:10:39.440 --> 0:10:42.320
<v Speaker 1>on Helen Haynes to push their pet policies. We were

0:10:42.340 --> 0:10:46.390
<v Speaker 1>talking about an attack which I showed was... Well, no-one

0:10:46.429 --> 0:10:48.929
<v Speaker 1>knows the motive at all yet. All we know, as

0:10:49.330 --> 0:10:53.600
<v Speaker 1>I said, is that the alleged attacker, a left-winger, mentally ill,

0:10:54.059 --> 0:11:00.479
<v Speaker 1>acting erratically, yelling even at his father. And he runs down, allegedly,

0:11:00.520 --> 0:11:03.479
<v Speaker 1>the friend of his father and mother-in-law. Well, look, it

0:11:03.520 --> 0:11:06.460
<v Speaker 1>could be political. It could be personal. It could be

0:11:06.500 --> 0:11:09.730
<v Speaker 1>something triggered by some delusion or derangement.

0:11:10.130 --> 0:11:10.969
<v Speaker 2>No one knows.

0:11:11.510 --> 0:11:14.709
<v Speaker 1>Yet today you had Labor Minister Tanya Plibersek, the Prime

0:11:14.730 --> 0:11:18.010
<v Speaker 1>Minister too, by the way, but Labor Minister Tanya Plibersek

0:11:18.330 --> 0:11:22.640
<v Speaker 1>blaming social media. Very convenient because the government is just

0:11:22.700 --> 0:11:26.200
<v Speaker 1>pushing through this controversial digital duty of care bill.

0:11:27.630 --> 0:11:31.790
<v Speaker 11>I think the industrial scale of the abuse that all

0:11:31.830 --> 0:11:35.550
<v Speaker 11>of us receive, but I think particularly the women here receive,

0:11:35.630 --> 0:11:40.100
<v Speaker 11>that has changed. It's been supercharged by social media. We

0:11:40.160 --> 0:11:43.559
<v Speaker 11>have an opportunity, all of us as elected members, as

0:11:43.600 --> 0:11:48.620
<v Speaker 11>a collective, as a parliament, to resist the pernicious influence

0:11:49.260 --> 0:11:50.220
<v Speaker 11>of social media.

0:11:51.480 --> 0:11:52.400
<v Speaker 2>But no one.

0:11:53.300 --> 0:11:57.569
<v Speaker 1>No one was worse today than Greens leader David Shoebridge,

0:11:58.130 --> 0:12:02.170
<v Speaker 1>who said, look, it is, yes, terrible for politicians to

0:12:02.230 --> 0:12:07.370
<v Speaker 1>impose agendas on this tragedy. And then immediately himself said

0:12:07.670 --> 0:12:11.770
<v Speaker 1>how politicians had to change, for one, by abusing Israel.

0:12:12.740 --> 0:12:17.760
<v Speaker 10>Politics needs to not spin off into virulent personal attacks.

0:12:18.630 --> 0:12:21.200
<v Speaker 10>but actually address the real material needs that are happening

0:12:21.820 --> 0:12:25.959
<v Speaker 10>across this country and across the world. And I have

0:12:26.020 --> 0:12:31.620
<v Speaker 10>seen language from politicians that are deeply dehumanising of migrants,

0:12:32.100 --> 0:12:37.069
<v Speaker 10>deeply dehumanising of people because of their religion, deeply dehumanising.

0:12:37.270 --> 0:12:40.130
<v Speaker 10>If there is a genocide occurring, you need to do

0:12:40.150 --> 0:12:41.610
<v Speaker 10>everything you can to stop a genocide.

0:12:42.610 --> 0:12:48.010
<v Speaker 1>Shoebridge somehow links the shocking attack on Helen Haynes to.

0:12:49.130 --> 0:12:49.710
<v Speaker 2>People, you.

0:12:51.190 --> 0:12:55.489
<v Speaker 1>Know, criticising Islam and the war in Gaza, which Shoebridge

0:12:56.770 --> 0:13:01.190
<v Speaker 1>lies is actually a genocide. And in that way, his

0:13:01.270 --> 0:13:05.110
<v Speaker 1>inflaming hatred of Israel and of Jews with that lie.

0:13:05.410 --> 0:13:07.949
<v Speaker 1>Joining me is Michael Kroger, former president of the Victorian Liberals,

0:13:08.330 --> 0:13:12.090
<v Speaker 1>and Stephen Conroy, former Labor senator and cabinet minister. Michael Kroger,

0:13:12.570 --> 0:13:17.380
<v Speaker 1>why this rush to link agendas like the Greens' anti-Israel

0:13:17.500 --> 0:13:21.930
<v Speaker 1>one to a horrific attack like this when absolutely nobody

0:13:21.950 --> 0:13:24.390
<v Speaker 1>yet knows the motives or the causes?

0:13:25.890 --> 0:13:30.120
<v Speaker 5>Well, that's absolutely right, Andrew. But the Greens will take

0:13:30.280 --> 0:13:37.540
<v Speaker 5>every opportunity to spew forth this anti-Israel, anti-Jewish rhetoric. I mean,

0:13:38.260 --> 0:13:41.459
<v Speaker 5>in all seriousness, in all of the circumstances involving this

0:13:41.580 --> 0:13:46.430
<v Speaker 5>tragedy involving Helen Haynes, this clown has to invoke the

0:13:46.470 --> 0:13:50.570
<v Speaker 5>Middle East. I mean, but, you know, people thought this

0:13:50.650 --> 0:13:52.979
<v Speaker 5>guy might be a better Greens leader, a more moderate

0:13:53.000 --> 0:13:55.160
<v Speaker 5>Greens leader, a more sensible Greens leader. No, he's way

0:13:55.179 --> 0:13:58.000
<v Speaker 5>to the extreme left. This guy is right beyond Adam Bandt.

0:13:58.780 --> 0:14:01.100
<v Speaker 5>And for that reason, let's hope they don't do well

0:14:01.820 --> 0:14:04.740
<v Speaker 5>in the forthcoming Victorian election and let's hope their vote

0:14:04.820 --> 0:14:07.319
<v Speaker 5>continues to recede federally because this is the type of

0:14:07.380 --> 0:14:09.670
<v Speaker 5>rhetoric we do not want in this country today, Andrew.

0:14:10.730 --> 0:14:11.830
<v Speaker 2>Stephen, Michael is right.

0:14:11.890 --> 0:14:14.010
<v Speaker 1>I read all those pieces saying this is a, a

0:14:14.090 --> 0:14:17.370
<v Speaker 1>moderate Green, this is someone the government can do business with,

0:14:17.390 --> 0:14:19.850
<v Speaker 1>this is a pragmatic guy, and then he says something

0:14:19.870 --> 0:14:20.250
<v Speaker 1>like that.

0:14:20.310 --> 0:14:22.230
<v Speaker 2>That took my breath away.

0:14:23.330 --> 0:14:27.370
<v Speaker 3>Yeah, look, I didn't share anyone's optimism that Shoebridge was

0:14:27.390 --> 0:14:32.130
<v Speaker 3>going to be some sort of moderate, workable, doing deals

0:14:32.190 --> 0:14:36.410
<v Speaker 3>with his history, his background inside the Greens, never gave

0:14:36.460 --> 0:14:39.520
<v Speaker 3>me any hope at all that they'd have a more.

0:14:39.420 --> 0:14:41.760
<v Speaker 2>Reasonable centrist approach. approach.

0:14:41.990 --> 0:14:45.930
<v Speaker 3>I did take issue with you, Andrew, over Tanya's comments.

0:14:46.010 --> 0:14:48.630
<v Speaker 3>I don't think she was in any way trying to

0:14:48.690 --> 0:14:54.660
<v Speaker 3>draw the digital safety issues from the bill into this.

0:14:54.720 --> 0:14:58.440
<v Speaker 3>I think you yourself have tragically and unfortunately been attacked

0:14:58.480 --> 0:15:02.420
<v Speaker 3>in the street. I've never forgotten those images. And the

0:15:02.460 --> 0:15:09.390
<v Speaker 3>temperatures going up through the echo chambers of social media,

0:15:09.490 --> 0:15:16.870
<v Speaker 3>pushing algorithms, pushing material down people's throats. So I don't

0:15:16.910 --> 0:15:19.130
<v Speaker 3>agree with you that Tanya was trying to link a

0:15:19.170 --> 0:15:22.050
<v Speaker 3>political objective. I think she was just stating a fact

0:15:22.070 --> 0:15:29.250
<v Speaker 3>that particularly female MPs are targeted more and more viciously.

0:15:29.290 --> 0:15:29.950
<v Speaker 2>I mean, even.

0:15:31.630 --> 0:15:36.140
<v Speaker 3>Nicole, who was on Peter's program, has identified the sort

0:15:36.180 --> 0:15:39.990
<v Speaker 3>of vilification. All of that comes to the hard left,

0:15:40.030 --> 0:15:44.910
<v Speaker 3>particularly in Victoria, have always had a vicious and thuggish

0:15:45.070 --> 0:15:50.230
<v Speaker 3>approach to their politics. They've tragically, you could go back,

0:15:50.270 --> 0:15:53.740
<v Speaker 3>as you said, over 20 or 30 years and show

0:15:53.800 --> 0:15:58.320
<v Speaker 3>incidences where the so-called, you know, left, hard left have

0:15:58.380 --> 0:16:02.180
<v Speaker 3>committed these sorts of thuggish acts. It's just a tragedy

0:16:02.220 --> 0:16:04.960
<v Speaker 3>in Victoria that it's been like that. But it has

0:16:05.020 --> 0:16:07.000
<v Speaker 3>unfortunately been like that for many, many years.

0:16:07.820 --> 0:16:09.900
<v Speaker 2>Yeah, well, why isn't that the issue?

0:16:09.980 --> 0:16:12.160
<v Speaker 1>Why is there no talk in Parliament, we've got to

0:16:12.200 --> 0:16:14.680
<v Speaker 1>control the left, the socialist alternative?

0:16:15.700 --> 0:16:17.540
<v Speaker 2>Is it a terrorist outfit? I don't know.

0:16:17.860 --> 0:16:20.620
<v Speaker 1>Maybe we should talk about that. How about the education?

0:16:20.970 --> 0:16:24.430
<v Speaker 1>I never blamed my attackers, the internet for my attackers.

0:16:24.750 --> 0:16:27.490
<v Speaker 1>They're just idiots who do not know that socialism has

0:16:27.630 --> 0:16:30.360
<v Speaker 1>never worked. anywhere that they can look at the sort

0:16:30.380 --> 0:16:34.340
<v Speaker 1>of socialism they advocate. And their tactics that promote it

0:16:34.400 --> 0:16:38.320
<v Speaker 1>here are anti-democratic. I thought it was their ignorance and

0:16:38.360 --> 0:16:41.109
<v Speaker 1>their yen for violence, not the internet.

0:16:41.390 --> 0:16:43.470
<v Speaker 2>That should be a topic here. But it's not.

0:16:43.830 --> 0:16:47.670
<v Speaker 1>Michael, the Albanese government is, meanwhile, falling to record lows

0:16:47.730 --> 0:16:48.310
<v Speaker 1>in the polls.

0:16:48.710 --> 0:16:49.810
<v Speaker 2>It's quite extraordinary.

0:16:50.550 --> 0:16:53.390
<v Speaker 1>We've seen Treasurer Jim Chalmers being lined up as the

0:16:53.430 --> 0:16:57.450
<v Speaker 1>scapegoat by some in Labor and Labor-friendly media. And it

0:16:57.520 --> 0:17:00.570
<v Speaker 1>seems he is feeling that heat from his colleagues, given

0:17:00.630 --> 0:17:02.250
<v Speaker 1>this partial apology.

0:17:02.310 --> 0:17:02.609
<v Speaker 2>Listen.

0:17:03.610 --> 0:17:07.810
<v Speaker 12>I'm driving some really difficult reforms through the parliament. And

0:17:07.890 --> 0:17:11.410
<v Speaker 12>I know that that's playing out, makes life tougher for

0:17:11.790 --> 0:17:14.030
<v Speaker 12>some of my colleagues in particular. And I do care

0:17:14.050 --> 0:17:15.990
<v Speaker 12>about that. And I do care about them. I should

0:17:16.040 --> 0:17:18.020
<v Speaker 12>make more time for my colleagues. I see a lot

0:17:18.060 --> 0:17:19.800
<v Speaker 12>of them. They come around and talk to me about

0:17:19.820 --> 0:17:21.379
<v Speaker 12>the economy all the time. I do as much as

0:17:21.460 --> 0:17:23.260
<v Speaker 12>I can. But if the message is that I need

0:17:23.300 --> 0:17:26.500
<v Speaker 12>to do more of that, then I take that message seriously.

0:17:26.540 --> 0:17:27.980
<v Speaker 2>The government's lost some paint.

0:17:28.260 --> 0:17:30.380
<v Speaker 12>It's up to other ministers and the Prime Minister's how

0:17:30.420 --> 0:17:33.020
<v Speaker 12>they describe their part in that.

0:17:34.520 --> 0:17:37.139
<v Speaker 1>I did love the conga line of Labor MPs who

0:17:37.160 --> 0:17:40.530
<v Speaker 1>came through our studios today saying, oh, Jim is fabulous,

0:17:40.609 --> 0:17:42.290
<v Speaker 1>I don't know why he's so hard on himself.

0:17:42.550 --> 0:17:45.330
<v Speaker 2>He's a great guy. How much trouble is he in?

0:17:47.470 --> 0:17:50.730
<v Speaker 5>You know, Andrew, when Bill Sneddon was being challenged to

0:17:50.750 --> 0:17:53.710
<v Speaker 5>the leadership of the Liberal Party in 1974, five people

0:17:53.760 --> 0:17:54.129
<v Speaker 5>came to.

0:17:54.950 --> 0:17:55.609
<v Speaker 2>asking to resign.

0:17:55.630 --> 0:17:56.970
<v Speaker 5>And he said, you know, the problem is I haven't

0:17:57.010 --> 0:17:58.630
<v Speaker 5>had enough of you fellows in here for a drink.

0:17:58.990 --> 0:18:02.160
<v Speaker 5>I haven't socialised with you enough over the months and years.

0:18:02.200 --> 0:18:02.760
<v Speaker 2>That's why you.

0:18:04.020 --> 0:18:05.900
<v Speaker 5>So to hear Jim Chalmers say, I need to spend

0:18:05.940 --> 0:18:08.400
<v Speaker 5>more time with my colleagues to get these difficult reforms

0:18:08.440 --> 0:18:12.379
<v Speaker 5>through Parliament. No, Jim, you need to spend more time revoking,

0:18:12.820 --> 0:18:15.830
<v Speaker 5>repealing this legislation. Your colleagues are coming to speak to

0:18:15.850 --> 0:18:19.030
<v Speaker 5>you about how you've trashed the economy, trashed the budget,

0:18:19.350 --> 0:18:25.280
<v Speaker 5>trashed the housing market, trashed inflation, interest rates, the long-term debt,

0:18:25.390 --> 0:18:27.260
<v Speaker 5>et cetera, et cetera. That's what they're complaining about, Jim.

0:18:27.619 --> 0:18:30.340
<v Speaker 5>They're not complaining about how you're not... It's not that they,

0:18:30.400 --> 0:18:32.959
<v Speaker 5>you know, feel they're aggrieved because they're not socialising with

0:18:32.980 --> 0:18:35.070
<v Speaker 5>you enough. You're not having them in for enough drinks.

0:18:35.730 --> 0:18:38.949
<v Speaker 5>So if that's what he thinks, he's completely delusional. How

0:18:38.990 --> 0:18:39.650
<v Speaker 5>much trouble is he.

0:18:39.609 --> 0:18:40.010
<v Speaker 9>In, Andrew?

0:18:40.830 --> 0:18:43.850
<v Speaker 5>Look, when Keating resigned from the Hawke government in May 91,

0:18:43.850 --> 0:18:46.170
<v Speaker 5>it was the end of the Hawke government. I don't

0:18:46.210 --> 0:18:49.710
<v Speaker 5>think a prime minister can afford to lose his treasurer

0:18:49.830 --> 0:18:52.449
<v Speaker 5>without bringing the whole government down. And this government is

0:18:52.490 --> 0:18:56.930
<v Speaker 5>in enough trouble federally already, despite winning by a huge

0:18:56.990 --> 0:18:59.990
<v Speaker 5>margin in May last year. So I don't think Chalmers

0:19:00.020 --> 0:19:02.500
<v Speaker 5>can go unless he voluntarily resigns. And I don't think

0:19:02.520 --> 0:19:03.820
<v Speaker 5>he's going to do that because he doesn't want to

0:19:03.840 --> 0:19:07.160
<v Speaker 5>be the fall guy for Albanese. So I think they're

0:19:07.200 --> 0:19:09.100
<v Speaker 5>both on the plank together, arm in arm.

0:19:10.980 --> 0:19:13.800
<v Speaker 1>Stephen, because I'm so short of time and I really

0:19:13.820 --> 0:19:15.560
<v Speaker 1>want to get into this next topic, I'm going to

0:19:15.600 --> 0:19:17.810
<v Speaker 1>take it as read that you disagree with everything and

0:19:17.869 --> 0:19:19.439
<v Speaker 1>Jim Chalmers is as safe as houses.

0:19:19.900 --> 0:19:20.690
<v Speaker 2>And I'll move to this.

0:19:21.030 --> 0:19:23.690
<v Speaker 1>I'm wondering if the federal Liberals, and this is your

0:19:23.770 --> 0:19:26.369
<v Speaker 1>chance for a free kick, the federal Liberals have somehow

0:19:26.410 --> 0:19:29.770
<v Speaker 1>become electable again. I know I said that Angus Staley

0:19:29.790 --> 0:19:32.430
<v Speaker 1>was a dead man walking, but have they become electable again,

0:19:32.470 --> 0:19:36.870
<v Speaker 1>particularly with one Labor failing and One Nation saying some

0:19:37.270 --> 0:19:41.379
<v Speaker 1>stupid things? Federally, its voters now close the Labor's. And

0:19:41.420 --> 0:19:44.639
<v Speaker 1>in Victoria, the News Poll today tips the Liberals to

0:19:44.680 --> 0:19:48.050
<v Speaker 1>win next month's election and buy a lot now. 33%

0:19:48.050 --> 0:19:52.179
<v Speaker 1>of the primary voted. has, and after preferences, a massive

0:19:52.220 --> 0:19:57.000
<v Speaker 1>lead of 55% to Labor's 45%. And as I was

0:19:57.040 --> 0:20:00.820
<v Speaker 1>saying to Labor people at a function it was at.

0:20:00.859 --> 0:20:03.910
<v Speaker 2>Liberals at a function it was at yesterday....

0:20:04.810 --> 0:20:07.429
<v Speaker 1>Labor's vote is collapsing by the day, and I expect

0:20:07.770 --> 0:20:11.330
<v Speaker 1>before Election Day, a landslide. What do you think is

0:20:11.390 --> 0:20:11.790
<v Speaker 1>going on?

0:20:11.810 --> 0:20:16.970
<v Speaker 3>Well, I think there's no question that Jess Wilson is

0:20:17.210 --> 0:20:22.149
<v Speaker 3>the hot favourite to win the election. It's always a challenge,

0:20:22.210 --> 0:20:26.240
<v Speaker 3>and I think Michael has said this consistently for many years,

0:20:26.320 --> 0:20:29.520
<v Speaker 3>and I know I think, Andrew, you agree, that electing

0:20:30.070 --> 0:20:33.609
<v Speaker 3>A fourth term for any political party in any state

0:20:33.750 --> 0:20:39.050
<v Speaker 3>or federal is always enormously difficult. And I think Ben's

0:20:39.570 --> 0:20:44.550
<v Speaker 3>trying to change the direction of the government. But there's

0:20:44.590 --> 0:20:46.870
<v Speaker 3>a lot of barnacles. There's a lot of issues. There's

0:20:46.890 --> 0:20:50.649
<v Speaker 3>a lot of baggage for him, which clearly makes Jess

0:20:50.910 --> 0:20:53.869
<v Speaker 3>the absolute favourite. But all of the polls are roughly

0:20:53.910 --> 0:20:57.040
<v Speaker 3>now settled in the same rough band. You know, One

0:20:57.080 --> 0:21:04.570
<v Speaker 3>Nation in Victoria, I'm talking, you know, 20, 21, 22. Labor, 24, 25,

0:21:04.570 --> 0:21:11.250
<v Speaker 3>maybe 26. Liberals, 28, 29, 31. So that's... Yeah, it

0:21:11.270 --> 0:21:14.990
<v Speaker 3>puts Jess in the box seat. But Ben Carroll will keep,

0:21:15.710 --> 0:21:19.939
<v Speaker 3>you know, pushing Labor's messages, talking about the.

0:21:19.910 --> 0:21:22.600
<v Speaker 2>Possibilities that he will introduce. Yeah, I know, but, mate, mate,

0:21:22.660 --> 0:21:23.139
<v Speaker 2>it's not just his.

0:21:23.850 --> 0:21:25.889
<v Speaker 3>It's such as it is a fourth term.

0:21:25.970 --> 0:21:30.979
<v Speaker 1>It's also a government deeply marred in corruption, blown the

0:21:31.040 --> 0:21:37.020
<v Speaker 1>state's fortunes, got highest unemployment in Australia, made its performance through. Michael,

0:21:37.359 --> 0:21:40.280
<v Speaker 1>out of time, but can you give me a 20-second response?

0:21:41.790 --> 0:21:44.610
<v Speaker 5>Well, we're bankrupt, lawless and corrupt, so no wonder there's

0:21:44.650 --> 0:21:45.689
<v Speaker 5>a 10% swing in.

0:21:45.650 --> 0:21:46.450
<v Speaker 2>That poll this morning.

0:21:46.490 --> 0:21:48.410
<v Speaker 5>But the record in Victoria, by the way, Andrew, since

0:21:48.450 --> 0:21:51.290
<v Speaker 5>the Second World War is a 6% swing to the

0:21:51.330 --> 0:21:54.550
<v Speaker 5>Liberal Party. That poll this morning said 10%. If that happens,

0:21:54.609 --> 0:21:58.210
<v Speaker 5>Labor will lose 33 of their 56 seats. So I

0:21:58.250 --> 0:22:00.280
<v Speaker 5>don't know that that will happen. That seems to me

0:22:00.300 --> 0:22:04.080
<v Speaker 5>to be beyond the pale. 8% two-party preferred swing is

0:22:05.100 --> 0:22:08.480
<v Speaker 5>probably in the ballpark at the minute, which would just,

0:22:08.900 --> 0:22:11.239
<v Speaker 5>just give Jess Wilson a majority. But a lot can

0:22:11.280 --> 0:22:12.859
<v Speaker 5>happen in the last two weeks, Andrew, a hell of

0:22:12.900 --> 0:22:13.020
<v Speaker 5>a lot.

0:22:13.040 --> 0:22:15.179
<v Speaker 1>A lot can happen, but I also think sentiment is

0:22:15.240 --> 0:22:18.270
<v Speaker 1>shifting and it's all against Labor. It could be even worse.

0:22:18.750 --> 0:22:21.230
<v Speaker 1>Michael Kroger, Stephen Conroy, thank you very much to you both.

0:22:21.670 --> 0:22:24.420
<v Speaker 1>After the break, More riots in France over the weekend

0:22:24.780 --> 0:22:28.700
<v Speaker 1>now spreading to Italy with protesters invading the Colosseum. I

0:22:28.720 --> 0:22:30.220
<v Speaker 1>think we've seen this movie before.

0:22:30.290 --> 0:22:33.109
<v Speaker 2>Barbarians again attacking the West through Rome.

0:22:37.369 --> 0:22:40.909
<v Speaker 1>Another massive weekend of riots in France on the weekend,

0:22:40.970 --> 0:22:44.370
<v Speaker 1>although the crowds were down on the week before and

0:22:44.410 --> 0:22:48.310
<v Speaker 1>the damage was less, which perhaps is no wonder. Now

0:22:48.350 --> 0:22:54.390
<v Speaker 1>that 70,000 police and gendarmes were deployed this time against them,

0:22:54.609 --> 0:22:56.169
<v Speaker 1>backed up by the army.

0:22:56.990 --> 0:23:01.379
<v Speaker 2>But Italy was again invaded by barbarians.

0:23:00.940 --> 0:23:06.119
<v Speaker 1>Who this time, once more, broke into Rome's Colosseum before

0:23:06.140 --> 0:23:10.740
<v Speaker 1>they were beaten off. Now, once again, like the last time,

0:23:10.760 --> 0:23:15.040
<v Speaker 1>what was it in the 5th century? Italy's civilisation is

0:23:15.100 --> 0:23:22.540
<v Speaker 1>under attack by the untutored hordes. Again, many rioters last

0:23:22.600 --> 0:23:26.629
<v Speaker 1>weekend in France were a Muslim background, but the organisers

0:23:27.230 --> 0:23:29.190
<v Speaker 1>and a lot of the people on the streets were

0:23:29.270 --> 0:23:33.290
<v Speaker 1>clearly of the hard left. In fact, two politicians from

0:23:33.710 --> 0:23:40.500
<v Speaker 1>France's hard-left Ensemble Soumise party even confronted police physically. Joining

0:23:40.520 --> 0:23:43.240
<v Speaker 1>me is the country's top foreign affairs writer, Greg Sheridan

0:23:43.820 --> 0:23:49.210
<v Speaker 1>of The Australian. Greg, These riots are destroying France, especially

0:23:49.250 --> 0:23:52.320
<v Speaker 1>the tourism industry in Paris. The city of love is

0:23:52.380 --> 0:23:55.440
<v Speaker 1>now being advertised as the city of hate.

0:23:55.900 --> 0:23:59.000
<v Speaker 2>Where is this going? Well, Andrew, it's great to be

0:23:59.020 --> 0:23:59.340
<v Speaker 2>with you.

0:23:59.400 --> 0:24:02.700
<v Speaker 13>It's a very distressing story and it's becoming a Europe

0:24:02.760 --> 0:24:06.080
<v Speaker 13>wide story. It is the collapse of the European model,

0:24:06.540 --> 0:24:10.920
<v Speaker 13>the collapse of European social democracy. Your right to identify

0:24:10.960 --> 0:24:13.940
<v Speaker 13>the hard left and the Islamists. This is a very

0:24:14.070 --> 0:24:19.230
<v Speaker 13>deliberate action. of the so-called Red Green Alliance, who are

0:24:19.359 --> 0:24:22.840
<v Speaker 13>united in their common hatred of French society and the

0:24:22.900 --> 0:24:27.820
<v Speaker 13>West generally. The West generally is now reaping the consequence

0:24:28.140 --> 0:24:32.100
<v Speaker 13>of letting the hard left control the education system for

0:24:32.320 --> 0:24:33.120
<v Speaker 13>the last.

0:24:32.790 --> 0:24:33.939
<v Speaker 2>40 or 50 years.

0:24:34.350 --> 0:24:36.710
<v Speaker 13>French students are ignorant of their own history and in

0:24:37.010 --> 0:24:39.170
<v Speaker 13>so far as they know anything about it, they think

0:24:39.210 --> 0:24:43.229
<v Speaker 13>France is colonialist, racist, oppressive and wicked. They also have

0:24:43.290 --> 0:24:46.359
<v Speaker 13>no idea how the economy works. in the melange of

0:24:46.540 --> 0:24:49.300
<v Speaker 13>mad causes and everything they were demonstrating about last week,

0:24:49.619 --> 0:24:53.430
<v Speaker 13>they wanted more money for the Louvre Museum. Well, that's

0:24:53.470 --> 0:24:56.710
<v Speaker 13>a good cause, I suppose, but they've no idea where

0:24:56.730 --> 0:24:59.409
<v Speaker 13>the money is coming from or anything. The French state

0:24:59.470 --> 0:25:02.430
<v Speaker 13>can no longer spend money on this crisis as it

0:25:02.560 --> 0:25:06.320
<v Speaker 13>used to. Hundreds of thousands of demonstrators are motivated by

0:25:06.340 --> 0:25:11.730
<v Speaker 13>a hostility to the French state, and there are thousands,

0:25:11.990 --> 0:25:15.980
<v Speaker 13>tens of thousands of street thugs like the old Nazi,

0:25:16.040 --> 0:25:19.770
<v Speaker 13>fascist and communist street fighters of the 20s and 30s.

0:25:20.420 --> 0:25:24.020
<v Speaker 13>So this is a very, very bad moment for France.

0:25:24.240 --> 0:25:27.580
<v Speaker 13>You hope that it just runs out of steam. There's

0:25:27.619 --> 0:25:31.760
<v Speaker 13>no sign of any real leadership from President Macron or

0:25:31.820 --> 0:25:32.820
<v Speaker 13>indeed from anyone else.

0:25:34.180 --> 0:25:37.679
<v Speaker 1>Speaking of exactly that, Emmanuel Macron has You know, the

0:25:37.700 --> 0:25:40.200
<v Speaker 1>polls show, I can't think of the last time a

0:25:40.200 --> 0:25:41.869
<v Speaker 1>French president had polls this slow.

0:25:41.890 --> 0:25:43.310
<v Speaker 2>He is despised.

0:25:43.830 --> 0:25:46.050
<v Speaker 1>On Friday, it just made it even worse, Greg, with

0:25:46.090 --> 0:25:51.850
<v Speaker 1>his bizarre reaction to a white man allegedly and randomly

0:25:51.930 --> 0:25:55.899
<v Speaker 1>machine gunning black people, killing one, wounding five, including a

0:25:55.900 --> 0:26:00.719
<v Speaker 1>12-year-old girl in what police said seemed a terrorist attack.

0:26:01.000 --> 0:26:02.960
<v Speaker 1>But then Macron said this.

0:26:03.950 --> 0:26:05.600
<v Speaker 2>Because it is the first time there has been a

0:26:05.660 --> 0:26:09.820
<v Speaker 2>planned terrorist act to kill our compatriots, our children, on

0:26:09.859 --> 0:26:12.690
<v Speaker 2>the basis of their skin color or the religion attributed

0:26:12.730 --> 0:26:12.990
<v Speaker 2>to them.

0:26:13.990 --> 0:26:16.919
<v Speaker 1>The first time anyone killed someone in France on the

0:26:16.960 --> 0:26:21.220
<v Speaker 1>basis of race or religion. We've had jihadists, Muslim jihadists,

0:26:21.290 --> 0:26:24.670
<v Speaker 1>murdering a priest in his church. Worshippers in another Catholic

0:26:24.710 --> 0:26:27.270
<v Speaker 1>church also murdered by Muslim jihadists.

0:26:27.510 --> 0:26:28.730
<v Speaker 2>I think three.

0:26:29.150 --> 0:26:33.170
<v Speaker 1>Jews in a kosher deli, gunned down. Jewish children in

0:26:33.230 --> 0:26:34.690
<v Speaker 1>a school, gunned.

0:26:34.450 --> 0:26:37.580
<v Speaker 2>Down and more. How on earth could Macron have forgotten

0:26:38.140 --> 0:26:38.919
<v Speaker 2>all that?

0:26:40.260 --> 0:26:43.640
<v Speaker 13>Well, I think it just shows what a hollow, superficial

0:26:43.720 --> 0:26:46.919
<v Speaker 13>figure Macron really is. I mean, what has this presidency

0:26:46.980 --> 0:26:50.659
<v Speaker 13>added up to? beyond sort of, you know, fading movie

0:26:50.680 --> 0:26:57.460
<v Speaker 13>star good looks and ready patter. I mean, obviously, a

0:26:57.960 --> 0:27:01.190
<v Speaker 13>white person shooting black people is a shocking, terrible act

0:27:01.250 --> 0:27:05.310
<v Speaker 13>of racist terrorism, rightly to be condemned. But to suggest

0:27:05.350 --> 0:27:08.330
<v Speaker 13>that it's the first time anyone has been attacked on

0:27:08.350 --> 0:27:10.470
<v Speaker 13>the basis of their race or religion.

0:27:10.710 --> 0:27:12.230
<v Speaker 2>Is just bananas.

0:27:12.450 --> 0:27:15.190
<v Speaker 13>I mean, as you say, all those instances of Islamist

0:27:15.270 --> 0:27:20.119
<v Speaker 13>terror directed against Jews, directed against Christians, directed against innocent

0:27:20.180 --> 0:27:23.540
<v Speaker 13>French civilians. A lot of that was on the basis

0:27:23.600 --> 0:27:28.200
<v Speaker 13>of religion and race. So that's what I mean about

0:27:28.240 --> 0:27:31.399
<v Speaker 13>this absolute lack of leadership. I mean, Marine Le Pen

0:27:31.590 --> 0:27:35.050
<v Speaker 13>is doing very well because on the immigration stuff, she

0:27:35.470 --> 0:27:39.629
<v Speaker 13>speaks hard truths. My worry, though, is that even the

0:27:39.670 --> 0:27:41.330
<v Speaker 13>people on the right who want to crack down on

0:27:41.369 --> 0:27:43.210
<v Speaker 13>immigration and so on, they're not willing to tell the

0:27:43.270 --> 0:27:47.290
<v Speaker 13>French people the truth about the budgetary situation. So, you know,

0:27:47.490 --> 0:27:50.810
<v Speaker 13>different players will tell different bits of the truth, but

0:27:50.830 --> 0:27:55.490
<v Speaker 13>there's no Margaret Thatcher, Ronald Reagan, Bob Hawke, who's going

0:27:55.510 --> 0:27:56.250
<v Speaker 13>to tell.

0:27:55.970 --> 0:27:57.949
<v Speaker 2>Them the whole bad news.

0:27:58.790 --> 0:28:01.190
<v Speaker 13>You know, it's bad news on all fronts and they're

0:28:01.210 --> 0:28:05.330
<v Speaker 13>going to have to tighten their belts and behave themselves

0:28:05.369 --> 0:28:07.290
<v Speaker 13>for a good few years to get out of it.

0:28:08.119 --> 0:28:10.000
<v Speaker 1>Mind you, the same could be true here. So many

0:28:10.040 --> 0:28:12.400
<v Speaker 1>people have become, you know, got used to the welfare

0:28:12.440 --> 0:28:15.619
<v Speaker 1>in Europe and Australia that it's, now almost impossible for

0:28:15.700 --> 0:28:20.030
<v Speaker 1>any party seeking election as government to tell the truth,

0:28:20.090 --> 0:28:24.250
<v Speaker 1>that the benefits must stop, must be cut back. Greg,

0:28:24.750 --> 0:28:30.540
<v Speaker 1>a world history-changing poll tomorrow, potentially. Israel is going to

0:28:30.560 --> 0:28:33.879
<v Speaker 1>the polls. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his right-wing government

0:28:34.200 --> 0:28:37.060
<v Speaker 1>could be in trouble here. What's at stake? What could change?

0:28:38.280 --> 0:28:40.930
<v Speaker 13>Well, Andrew, oddly enough... I don't think much is going

0:28:40.950 --> 0:28:44.730
<v Speaker 13>to change. If he loses to Gabby Escalon, the main

0:28:45.110 --> 0:28:49.860
<v Speaker 13>opposition leader, former head of the Israel Defence Force, the

0:28:50.060 --> 0:28:55.060
<v Speaker 13>polarising figure of Netanyahu will be gone. But Israel's key

0:28:55.100 --> 0:29:00.460
<v Speaker 13>policies on most things won't change. The opposition, you know,

0:29:00.480 --> 0:29:03.570
<v Speaker 13>the things that the progressive left, the Albanese government and

0:29:03.630 --> 0:29:06.650
<v Speaker 13>all the others, hate Israel for are things which Israel

0:29:06.670 --> 0:29:11.170
<v Speaker 13>really has no choice about. It has to take continuing

0:29:11.260 --> 0:29:14.300
<v Speaker 13>action in Gaza to prevent a Hamas recurrence. It has

0:29:14.340 --> 0:29:18.100
<v Speaker 13>to take continuing action in Lebanon to prevent Hezbollah from

0:29:18.140 --> 0:29:21.860
<v Speaker 13>re-establishing on its border. Any Israeli government is going to

0:29:21.880 --> 0:29:24.780
<v Speaker 13>go with the Americans, whichever way they go, on Iran.

0:29:25.060 --> 0:29:28.600
<v Speaker 13>The one thing Eisencott is different from Netanyahu on, which

0:29:28.660 --> 0:29:32.200
<v Speaker 13>I think is a good thing, is that he will

0:29:32.240 --> 0:29:36.380
<v Speaker 13>be more vigorous in stopping this tiny minority of illegal

0:29:36.480 --> 0:29:41.560
<v Speaker 13>settlers who engage in you know, thuggery and violence against

0:29:41.940 --> 0:29:45.940
<v Speaker 13>Palestinian villages in the West Bank. Now, the Netanyahu government

0:29:45.980 --> 0:29:48.780
<v Speaker 13>does not endorse this violence, but it hasn't been very

0:29:48.840 --> 0:29:52.580
<v Speaker 13>vigorous in stopping it. This level of violence is nothing

0:29:52.620 --> 0:29:54.360
<v Speaker 13>compared to Hamas or anything like that.

0:29:54.800 --> 0:29:56.800
<v Speaker 2>But still, it's bad in itself. It's wrong.

0:29:57.220 --> 0:29:59.770
<v Speaker 13>The Palestinians are innocent victims and it's very bad for

0:30:00.320 --> 0:30:03.900
<v Speaker 13>Israel's standing. But that's really the only thing that's going

0:30:03.920 --> 0:30:06.800
<v Speaker 13>to change. Otherwise, Israel is going to be the same.

0:30:07.360 --> 0:30:09.940
<v Speaker 13>There is no plausible way you could have a Palestinian

0:30:09.980 --> 0:30:13.440
<v Speaker 13>state in these current circumstances. You'd need 20 years of

0:30:13.500 --> 0:30:17.570
<v Speaker 13>normalisation and convincing the Israelis that the Palestinian state won't

0:30:17.920 --> 0:30:21.750
<v Speaker 13>attack them in terrorism or military ways before you could

0:30:21.790 --> 0:30:25.010
<v Speaker 13>have a Palestinian state. So, you know, the big villain

0:30:25.030 --> 0:30:29.210
<v Speaker 13>will be gone, Netanyahu, But nothing will really change in

0:30:29.270 --> 0:30:30.070
<v Speaker 13>Israeli policy.

0:30:30.130 --> 0:30:31.050
<v Speaker 2>No, well, that's the thing.

0:30:32.030 --> 0:30:34.270
<v Speaker 1>Well, one thing will change is that people might have

0:30:34.290 --> 0:30:37.270
<v Speaker 1>to confront the fact that their favourite scapegoat, oh, it's

0:30:37.310 --> 0:30:40.550
<v Speaker 1>not Israel I'm against, it's just that wicked Netanyahu, they'll

0:30:40.570 --> 0:30:42.910
<v Speaker 1>have to confront that they don't actually want Israel to

0:30:42.950 --> 0:30:46.820
<v Speaker 1>defend itself. because almost every Israeli thinks it should be defended,

0:30:47.240 --> 0:30:51.080
<v Speaker 1>and they're going to find that, you know, just bashing

0:30:51.540 --> 0:30:55.790
<v Speaker 1>Netanyahu solves nothing. Greg Sheridan, thank you so much for

0:30:55.830 --> 0:31:00.910
<v Speaker 1>your time. After the break, hard-left protesters hijack Remembrance Day.

0:31:00.930 --> 0:31:08.840
<v Speaker 1>It's time to attack Pauline Hanson. Yesterday, I emceed the

0:31:08.940 --> 0:31:12.220
<v Speaker 1>Melbourne launch of the book that my colleague Shari Markson

0:31:12.240 --> 0:31:13.540
<v Speaker 1>and Jewish leader Alex Rifkin.

0:31:14.600 --> 0:31:18.240
<v Speaker 2>have written about the Bondi Massacre. It's called Bondi Terror.

0:31:18.260 --> 0:31:21.310
<v Speaker 1>The launch was held in a synagogue, the Caulfield Shul.

0:31:21.370 --> 0:31:24.090
<v Speaker 1>Hello to the people there that said they watch every night.

0:31:24.150 --> 0:31:30.410
<v Speaker 1>And it finished with our national anthem. And it struck me. Jews,

0:31:30.730 --> 0:31:33.510
<v Speaker 1>I've seen quite often, sing our national anthem, fly our

0:31:33.550 --> 0:31:38.300
<v Speaker 1>flags even at a number of gatherings. But do you

0:31:38.340 --> 0:31:41.680
<v Speaker 1>hear socialists here sing our national anthem or wave our flag?

0:31:42.950 --> 0:31:47.140
<v Speaker 1>Did the pro-Palestine protesters who blocked the Sydney Harbour Bridge

0:31:47.620 --> 0:31:50.840
<v Speaker 1>sing our anthem or fly the Australian flag? Or did

0:31:50.860 --> 0:31:53.680
<v Speaker 1>they just fly the Palestinian ones and that Aboriginal one

0:31:54.100 --> 0:31:58.540
<v Speaker 1>out the front? Do anti-Israel protesters fly our flag or

0:31:58.880 --> 0:32:00.880
<v Speaker 1>sing our anthem like Jews do?

0:32:02.120 --> 0:32:03.040
<v Speaker 2>Or do they damn them?

0:32:03.240 --> 0:32:08.140
<v Speaker 1>Here's Nasser Mashni, who heads the Australia-Palestine Advocacy Network. Here

0:32:08.160 --> 0:32:10.880
<v Speaker 1>he is addressing a Melbourne rally, his right.

0:32:10.720 --> 0:32:11.100
<v Speaker 2>At the back.

0:32:12.940 --> 0:32:15.360
<v Speaker 14>I'd see the Australian flag and I'd go up to

0:32:15.380 --> 0:32:18.620
<v Speaker 14>our community and say, look, I know you want to belong.

0:32:19.280 --> 0:32:22.770
<v Speaker 14>I know you feel that waving the Australian flag might

0:32:22.850 --> 0:32:26.350
<v Speaker 14>make a racist white person think that you're acceptable.

0:32:26.730 --> 0:32:30.730
<v Speaker 2>But that is the coloniser's flag. It does not belong here.

0:32:32.010 --> 0:32:35.910
<v Speaker 1>Joining me are Peter McGoran, former Federal Nationals Minister, and

0:32:35.930 --> 0:32:41.300
<v Speaker 1>News24 host Anika DiGiorgio. Peter, what does it say that

0:32:41.380 --> 0:32:45.920
<v Speaker 1>pro-Israel Australians tend to sing our anthem, but I have

0:32:46.040 --> 0:32:50.140
<v Speaker 1>not heard pro-Palestine protesters and socialists do the same?

0:32:50.460 --> 0:32:53.160
<v Speaker 2>Some might, but I don't hear them. What does that

0:32:53.200 --> 0:32:53.560
<v Speaker 2>tell you?

0:32:54.160 --> 0:32:57.010
<v Speaker 15>Well, one sector of the community has great pride and

0:32:57.070 --> 0:33:00.150
<v Speaker 15>belief in Australia and the other has little or none.

0:33:01.170 --> 0:33:03.750
<v Speaker 15>The Jewish community, as you well know, Andrew, have been

0:33:04.250 --> 0:33:11.540
<v Speaker 15>deeply integrated into every aspect of Australian life. commercial, legal, cultural, political,

0:33:12.000 --> 0:33:16.090
<v Speaker 15>born very much out of the refugee status following the

0:33:16.150 --> 0:33:19.170
<v Speaker 15>Holocaust and the Second World War, where they are eternally

0:33:19.210 --> 0:33:24.080
<v Speaker 15>grateful and their children and the next generation are similarly

0:33:24.160 --> 0:33:28.050
<v Speaker 15>grateful for all that Australia gave them. safety above all else,

0:33:28.110 --> 0:33:32.390
<v Speaker 15>and then opportunity. Sadly, with mass immigration, we are not

0:33:32.430 --> 0:33:35.810
<v Speaker 15>getting that same commitment to Australia as a country, as

0:33:35.850 --> 0:33:39.760
<v Speaker 15>a society. And, in fact, Islam will not allow its

0:33:39.860 --> 0:33:45.240
<v Speaker 15>believers or adherents to commit to a Western society with

0:33:45.300 --> 0:33:49.000
<v Speaker 15>its liberalism and its equality with women and so on.

0:33:49.280 --> 0:33:51.960
<v Speaker 2>They will only belong... They will.

0:33:51.910 --> 0:33:56.020
<v Speaker 15>Only commit to a state... that's under the caliphate. Otherwise,

0:33:56.220 --> 0:33:57.370
<v Speaker 15>the Qur'an doesn't allow it.

0:33:58.570 --> 0:34:01.770
<v Speaker 1>Danika, to me, the difference is there are friends of

0:34:01.790 --> 0:34:05.650
<v Speaker 1>Western civilisation and there are enemies of civilisation. And you

0:34:05.690 --> 0:34:07.770
<v Speaker 1>can tell by the honour they do or do not

0:34:07.830 --> 0:34:09.670
<v Speaker 1>give to our national symbols.

0:34:09.730 --> 0:34:11.319
<v Speaker 2>What do you make of it? Absolutely.

0:34:11.430 --> 0:34:13.860
<v Speaker 6>And we are facing a real crisis in this country.

0:34:13.900 --> 0:34:16.120
<v Speaker 6>We have seen our social fractures in the last couple

0:34:16.140 --> 0:34:19.600
<v Speaker 6>of years, in particular fracture, because of this issue. And

0:34:19.640 --> 0:34:22.540
<v Speaker 6>I don't think we can just say... You know, it's

0:34:22.620 --> 0:34:29.450
<v Speaker 6>with people who are the pro-Israel people that you just

0:34:29.489 --> 0:34:31.370
<v Speaker 6>mentioned before. I think this is broader than that. These

0:34:31.410 --> 0:34:33.549
<v Speaker 6>people are proud to be Australians. These people want to

0:34:33.570 --> 0:34:36.770
<v Speaker 6>be Australians. They want to assimilate into our culture. whereas

0:34:36.810 --> 0:34:39.030
<v Speaker 6>there have been some people we have brought in, welcomed

0:34:39.050 --> 0:34:41.670
<v Speaker 6>with open arms, who hate our culture, hate the way

0:34:41.710 --> 0:34:43.469
<v Speaker 6>we live and don't want to assimilate. And it does

0:34:43.510 --> 0:34:45.469
<v Speaker 6>come down to the fact that, in my view, not

0:34:45.590 --> 0:34:49.520
<v Speaker 6>all cultures are created equally and there are people whose

0:34:49.580 --> 0:34:52.940
<v Speaker 6>views are completely incompatible with a Western liberal democracy. And

0:34:52.960 --> 0:34:54.819
<v Speaker 6>there are a lot of people out there, Andrew, who

0:34:54.860 --> 0:34:57.580
<v Speaker 6>simply do not want to face up to this fact.

0:34:57.620 --> 0:35:00.100
<v Speaker 6>They get worried, don't say things like that because you're

0:35:00.120 --> 0:35:02.680
<v Speaker 6>a racist, you're a bigot. No, when the facts speak

0:35:02.739 --> 0:35:07.049
<v Speaker 6>for themselves... We are heading towards this mass immigration experiment

0:35:07.410 --> 0:35:11.710
<v Speaker 6>and we're trying this multicultural pot. And unfortunately, right now,

0:35:11.830 --> 0:35:14.430
<v Speaker 6>it's not working in this country. We should show pride

0:35:14.450 --> 0:35:16.509
<v Speaker 6>in this country. We should be able to sing the

0:35:16.530 --> 0:35:20.650
<v Speaker 6>national anthem or wave the flag. But I do worry

0:35:20.890 --> 0:35:22.750
<v Speaker 6>about where we are heading to. And a lot of

0:35:22.810 --> 0:35:24.730
<v Speaker 6>it is driven by mass migration.

0:35:26.150 --> 0:35:29.070
<v Speaker 2>Look, I tell you, absolutely true. Interesting.

0:35:29.160 --> 0:35:32.240
<v Speaker 1>I asked the audience how many felt safer in Australia

0:35:32.280 --> 0:35:33.200
<v Speaker 1>today than they did.

0:35:33.260 --> 0:35:35.900
<v Speaker 2>And you know, last January when.

0:35:35.780 --> 0:35:38.719
<v Speaker 1>We were saying, oh, we're going to really remember, take

0:35:38.760 --> 0:35:41.339
<v Speaker 1>some lessons from the Bondo massacre, not one put up

0:35:41.380 --> 0:35:46.450
<v Speaker 1>their hand that they felt safer. Peter, I warned last week,

0:35:46.700 --> 0:35:51.250
<v Speaker 1>I showed protesters selling what they called a Palestinian poppy,

0:35:51.790 --> 0:35:54.310
<v Speaker 1>and I did warn last week that protesters would try

0:35:54.330 --> 0:35:58.870
<v Speaker 1>to hijack symbols of Remembrance Day on October 11, when

0:35:58.890 --> 0:35:59.650
<v Speaker 1>we remember the.

0:35:59.610 --> 0:36:02.270
<v Speaker 2>Dead of World War I. And sure enough.

0:36:02.850 --> 0:36:06.290
<v Speaker 1>The Socialist Alternative, through a group that it's helped create,

0:36:06.350 --> 0:36:10.580
<v Speaker 1>it's really good at these front groups, is holding another

0:36:10.620 --> 0:36:16.359
<v Speaker 1>mass protest by students against Pauline Hanson on Remembrance Day. Now,

0:36:16.400 --> 0:36:18.390
<v Speaker 1>it says, oh, no, no, that's a coincidence, but it's

0:36:18.489 --> 0:36:21.650
<v Speaker 1>not changing the date. Do you think that's fair enough?

0:36:22.530 --> 0:36:26.650
<v Speaker 15>Well, the puppet masters and the organisers have found themselves

0:36:26.670 --> 0:36:31.450
<v Speaker 15>some very useful fools, immature, but they don't know the history.

0:36:31.750 --> 0:36:35.650
<v Speaker 15>There'd barely be a student there who'd know the importance

0:36:35.670 --> 0:36:37.890
<v Speaker 15>of the 11th of November. God knows they don't get

0:36:37.930 --> 0:36:41.009
<v Speaker 15>it in many schools and not many teachers themselves would

0:36:41.070 --> 0:36:46.219
<v Speaker 15>even know. So we have deep roots... problems in our

0:36:46.280 --> 0:36:48.960
<v Speaker 15>education system. Now, where are their parents on the day?

0:36:49.280 --> 0:36:51.960
<v Speaker 15>What parent would let your child protest in that way?

0:36:52.180 --> 0:36:55.720
<v Speaker 15>Are the schools taking disciplinary action? I'm not against protests,

0:36:55.760 --> 0:36:57.600
<v Speaker 15>of course. And in fact, Andrew, I have to confess,

0:36:58.340 --> 0:37:02.960
<v Speaker 15>I protested against the Springbok tour because of the apartheid.

0:37:03.000 --> 0:37:06.880
<v Speaker 15>And I've taken part in a number of farmer-based protests

0:37:06.960 --> 0:37:14.840
<v Speaker 15>over the years. But they were organised, permitted, and very civil. But, unfortunately,

0:37:15.120 --> 0:37:17.840
<v Speaker 15>we've got young people who are spoiled. They know nothing

0:37:17.880 --> 0:37:22.910
<v Speaker 15>about Australia. Democracy, we're only one of 32 functioning democracies

0:37:22.969 --> 0:37:25.370
<v Speaker 15>in the world, and they take it for granted.

0:37:26.570 --> 0:37:30.190
<v Speaker 1>And they don't know what the socialist alternative policy really

0:37:30.370 --> 0:37:33.859
<v Speaker 1>is and the fact that not one country has successfully

0:37:33.890 --> 0:37:37.640
<v Speaker 1>implemented what they are fighting for, and they don't believe

0:37:38.100 --> 0:37:43.259
<v Speaker 1>in democratic change but revolutionary change. like smash everything. Danika,

0:37:43.480 --> 0:37:47.219
<v Speaker 1>what do you think about hijacking Remembrance Day? I don't

0:37:47.239 --> 0:37:51.400
<v Speaker 1>think that's an accident. They're against the symbols of our society.

0:37:51.620 --> 0:37:53.200
<v Speaker 6>Of course they are. Not even one of our most

0:37:53.260 --> 0:37:55.569
<v Speaker 6>sacred days where we remember those who fought for us

0:37:55.620 --> 0:37:58.330
<v Speaker 6>and continue to do so. Not even that is safe

0:37:58.370 --> 0:38:01.530
<v Speaker 6>from this loony tune brigade. And I really despair, Andrew,

0:38:01.550 --> 0:38:04.710
<v Speaker 6>for this next generation because there's so much brainwashing out

0:38:04.750 --> 0:38:07.730
<v Speaker 6>there and it does begin in the classrooms. I mean,

0:38:07.790 --> 0:38:10.330
<v Speaker 6>we are seeing kids being taught all sorts of nonsense,

0:38:10.370 --> 0:38:14.330
<v Speaker 6>whether it be... Gender, gender content, or whether it be

0:38:14.370 --> 0:38:17.089
<v Speaker 6>when it comes to Aboriginal issues. I mean, you walk

0:38:17.110 --> 0:38:20.320
<v Speaker 6>into a classroom, you've got to apologise for what? Look

0:38:20.340 --> 0:38:23.280
<v Speaker 6>at what's happened in university campuses over the last couple

0:38:23.300 --> 0:38:26.900
<v Speaker 6>of years, brainwashing there on campuses. And this is why

0:38:27.020 --> 0:38:30.940
<v Speaker 6>culture wars matter, because it is teaching the next generation

0:38:31.000 --> 0:38:33.760
<v Speaker 6>to hate this country, to hate us, to hate the West.

0:38:34.100 --> 0:38:36.480
<v Speaker 6>And this is where the issues start. We look overseas,

0:38:36.520 --> 0:38:38.820
<v Speaker 6>for goodness sake. The protests that we're seeing in France

0:38:38.880 --> 0:38:41.419
<v Speaker 6>and now in Rome that you showed just before, they

0:38:41.460 --> 0:38:44.680
<v Speaker 6>were meant to be student protests. And look what happens.

0:38:44.800 --> 0:38:47.270
<v Speaker 6>It gets hijacked and now they are out of control.

0:38:47.570 --> 0:38:49.810
<v Speaker 6>That is not what we want to see here. But

0:38:49.850 --> 0:38:53.330
<v Speaker 6>I truly despair for this next generation. They don't understand.

0:38:53.370 --> 0:38:56.270
<v Speaker 6>And the other point I would make is where are

0:38:56.290 --> 0:38:58.810
<v Speaker 6>their parents? I know that Georgia Maloney last week said.

0:39:01.110 --> 0:39:03.930
<v Speaker 6>Any parent will be in trouble if their child is

0:39:03.969 --> 0:39:07.050
<v Speaker 6>found to be taking part in riots like this. Well,

0:39:07.239 --> 0:39:09.379
<v Speaker 6>good on her for standing her ground and we should

0:39:09.420 --> 0:39:10.340
<v Speaker 6>have more of that here.

0:39:11.900 --> 0:39:14.660
<v Speaker 1>Peter, talking about all this, you know, I think Australians

0:39:14.739 --> 0:39:17.880
<v Speaker 1>are now desperate for politicians to unite us, to stop,

0:39:18.600 --> 0:39:23.390
<v Speaker 1>you know, pushing policies that divide. Greens leader David Shoebridge

0:39:23.489 --> 0:39:26.069
<v Speaker 1>learned a loud lesson about that on the weekend when

0:39:26.090 --> 0:39:28.750
<v Speaker 1>he went to a protest against the Albanese government planning

0:39:28.790 --> 0:39:33.060
<v Speaker 1>to sell off the army historic Victoria barracks and tried

0:39:33.110 --> 0:39:37.170
<v Speaker 1>to do that acknowledgement of country that treats non-Aboriginal Australians

0:39:37.550 --> 0:39:38.890
<v Speaker 1>as strangers to their own home.

0:39:39.170 --> 0:39:40.069
<v Speaker 2>It didn't go well.

0:39:41.560 --> 0:39:44.560
<v Speaker 7>I've spoken about the military history and acknowledged the military history.

0:39:45.000 --> 0:39:45.799
<v Speaker 2>That's right to do.

0:39:46.360 --> 0:39:48.600
<v Speaker 7>But I'm also going to acknowledge the deep history of

0:39:48.640 --> 0:39:51.460
<v Speaker 7>this place and the Gadigal history of this place, because

0:39:51.520 --> 0:39:53.820
<v Speaker 7>that's important too.

0:39:53.920 --> 0:39:55.360
<v Speaker 2>And I'm not going to say.

0:39:56.800 --> 0:40:01.859
<v Speaker 2>And it's a fundamental thing. Now, what I'm now going to.

0:40:01.780 --> 0:40:05.090
<v Speaker 7>Talk about is what's in front of us here today.

0:40:05.310 --> 0:40:10.049
<v Speaker 2>How should that tell the Greens, Peter? You can't tell

0:40:10.090 --> 0:40:11.350
<v Speaker 2>them anything, Andrew.

0:40:12.410 --> 0:40:17.210
<v Speaker 15>It doesn't matter how obvious a rebuttal to your absurd

0:40:17.250 --> 0:40:20.430
<v Speaker 15>beliefs a Green presses on. And the thing, Andrew, is,

0:40:20.489 --> 0:40:25.299
<v Speaker 15>of course, the Victoria Barracks has been a military functioning

0:40:25.400 --> 0:40:32.700
<v Speaker 15>base since 1840. Countless young Australians began their journey from

0:40:32.780 --> 0:40:38.580
<v Speaker 15>that site in formation to their deaths or grave injuries.

0:40:39.180 --> 0:40:43.040
<v Speaker 15>And so it is hallowed ground. And we're being told

0:40:43.460 --> 0:40:46.040
<v Speaker 15>we can't have our hallowed ground, that it's just part

0:40:46.080 --> 0:40:51.280
<v Speaker 15>of the amorphous Gadigal country. And where does it stop?

0:40:51.660 --> 0:40:58.359
<v Speaker 15>The MCG is 173 years old. Flemington Racecourse is 180

0:40:58.360 --> 0:41:02.589
<v Speaker 15>years old. Randwick Racecourse is 195 years old. And yet

0:41:02.680 --> 0:41:05.529
<v Speaker 15>they all have welcoming ceremonies. At what point in our

0:41:05.550 --> 0:41:09.730
<v Speaker 15>history do we just come together and enjoy the event

0:41:09.790 --> 0:41:11.190
<v Speaker 15>and the importance of the site?

0:41:12.270 --> 0:41:14.390
<v Speaker 1>Danika DiGiorgio, I'm out of time, but I'd love to

0:41:14.430 --> 0:41:16.009
<v Speaker 1>hear your final comment on this.

0:41:16.310 --> 0:41:18.330
<v Speaker 6>Well, I just think I'm embarrassed for Shoebridge and the

0:41:18.370 --> 0:41:20.790
<v Speaker 6>Greens that are continuing to peddle this crap that clearly

0:41:20.910 --> 0:41:22.470
<v Speaker 6>nobody wants. Stop dividing us.

0:41:24.180 --> 0:41:27.859
<v Speaker 1>I think that's absolutely correct. Peter McGoran, Danika DiGiorgio, thank

0:41:27.900 --> 0:41:29.759
<v Speaker 1>you very much to you both. And in fact, I

0:41:29.800 --> 0:41:32.339
<v Speaker 1>do think you'll see more scenes like that as people

0:41:32.380 --> 0:41:35.090
<v Speaker 1>get more and more fed up with being divided. After

0:41:35.120 --> 0:41:37.630
<v Speaker 1>the break, have we been too hard on Meghan Markle?

0:41:37.650 --> 0:41:41.100
<v Speaker 1>Because there's Stunning allegations now against her father that make

0:41:41.140 --> 0:41:49.130
<v Speaker 1>her say, see. Shocking news from Britain that might change

0:41:49.170 --> 0:41:54.170
<v Speaker 1>how people see Meghan Markle, wife of Prince Harry. In 2019,

0:41:54.170 --> 0:41:56.489
<v Speaker 1>a letter was passed on to British police claiming that

0:41:56.510 --> 0:41:59.989
<v Speaker 1>her father had hundreds or even thousands of photographs of

0:42:00.010 --> 0:42:05.440
<v Speaker 1>children being sexually abusive presented. Some also showing her father allegedly.

0:42:07.060 --> 0:42:07.780
<v Speaker 2>With the children.

0:42:09.070 --> 0:42:13.489
<v Speaker 1>Now, Thomas Markle says, you know, it's all the fabrication.

0:42:14.170 --> 0:42:18.299
<v Speaker 1>But anyway, Meghan Markle says, his daughter says, police then

0:42:18.400 --> 0:42:21.540
<v Speaker 1>showed her the letter and this is why she broke

0:42:21.580 --> 0:42:24.160
<v Speaker 1>contact with her father, would not let her children see them.

0:42:24.200 --> 0:42:27.760
<v Speaker 1>It wasn't because she was a hard-hearted social climber. Joining

0:42:27.800 --> 0:42:30.760
<v Speaker 1>me from London is Samara Gill, now host of Unleashed

0:42:30.800 --> 0:42:35.560
<v Speaker 1>with Samara Gill on News 24, going great guns, look

0:42:35.600 --> 0:42:38.299
<v Speaker 1>it up, have a look at her, saying what she

0:42:38.340 --> 0:42:42.500
<v Speaker 1>really thinks. Samara, there are some strange things about this

0:42:42.540 --> 0:42:45.140
<v Speaker 1>development and one is why was this letter sent to

0:42:45.200 --> 0:42:49.390
<v Speaker 1>British police and not police in the Philippines where Meghan

0:42:49.410 --> 0:42:51.410
<v Speaker 1>Markle's father kept the photos where he lived for a

0:42:51.410 --> 0:42:53.710
<v Speaker 1>while or to the US as a US citizen, so

0:42:53.730 --> 0:42:55.390
<v Speaker 1>to Mexico where he's also lived?

0:42:55.690 --> 0:42:56.170
<v Speaker 2>And why did.

0:42:56.950 --> 0:43:01.550
<v Speaker 1>police allegedly not send this information on to other police?

0:43:03.310 --> 0:43:06.109
<v Speaker 16>Yeah, it's a really good question, Andrew, and I just

0:43:06.150 --> 0:43:08.989
<v Speaker 16>made about a thousand faces there because I think no

0:43:09.110 --> 0:43:12.219
<v Speaker 16>one really knows what to make of this. Every single

0:43:12.260 --> 0:43:15.120
<v Speaker 16>day we continue to get new lines from Meghan's side

0:43:16.000 --> 0:43:18.440
<v Speaker 16>and then fresh lines from Thomas Markle Jr.

0:43:18.440 --> 0:43:21.960
<v Speaker 4>'s side. Now, I knew Thomas Markle Jr. for quite

0:43:22.000 --> 0:43:22.480
<v Speaker 4>a while.

0:43:22.580 --> 0:43:26.000
<v Speaker 16>We had many discussions over the phone. We FaceTimed while

0:43:26.040 --> 0:43:27.820
<v Speaker 16>he was in the Philippines, of course, all in a

0:43:27.880 --> 0:43:31.910
<v Speaker 16>journalistic capacity. But it was quite interesting because he was

0:43:31.969 --> 0:43:33.910
<v Speaker 16>living very closely with his.

0:43:33.830 --> 0:43:35.330
<v Speaker 4>Dad over there.

0:43:35.650 --> 0:43:38.370
<v Speaker 16>And, you know, they were at the bars drinking, enjoying

0:43:38.430 --> 0:43:42.230
<v Speaker 16>their time in the Philippines because they were short of money.

0:43:42.969 --> 0:43:46.040
<v Speaker 16>And now to hear that Thomas Markle Jr. is the

0:43:46.100 --> 0:43:50.399
<v Speaker 16>one who obviously went to the police and allegedly found

0:43:50.460 --> 0:43:53.750
<v Speaker 16>these horrific photographs and dobbed his father in is a

0:43:53.790 --> 0:43:56.210
<v Speaker 16>really crazy turn of events if you knew how close

0:43:56.230 --> 0:44:00.870
<v Speaker 16>their relationship was. So in terms of the Met Police letter,

0:44:01.469 --> 0:44:06.420
<v Speaker 16>this is really interesting for me because absolutely it paints

0:44:06.480 --> 0:44:10.080
<v Speaker 16>Meghan in a much more sympathetic light to hear that

0:44:10.850 --> 0:44:14.239
<v Speaker 16>She knew about potentially these horrible things her father had done,

0:44:14.340 --> 0:44:17.860
<v Speaker 16>and that's why she stayed estranged from him. But it

0:44:17.940 --> 0:44:21.500
<v Speaker 16>is interesting, at least from the Met Police perspective, why

0:44:21.520 --> 0:44:24.180
<v Speaker 16>there was a failing here and why her team maybe

0:44:24.219 --> 0:44:27.259
<v Speaker 16>didn't reach out a couple of months after and say, hey,

0:44:27.300 --> 0:44:30.060
<v Speaker 16>have you looked into these allegations? Because it seems like

0:44:30.100 --> 0:44:33.069
<v Speaker 16>now there's going to be an internal investigation into why

0:44:33.130 --> 0:44:36.630
<v Speaker 16>nothing was done. But even a letter being sent to

0:44:36.650 --> 0:44:39.690
<v Speaker 16>the Met Police and not the American authorities.

0:44:40.500 --> 0:44:43.290
<v Speaker 4>It all is just, it's really a mess.

0:44:43.550 --> 0:44:47.169
<v Speaker 16>And, you know, Meghan has been dragged through the mud

0:44:47.250 --> 0:44:50.089
<v Speaker 16>publicly about not having a relationship with her father. Her

0:44:50.130 --> 0:44:53.200
<v Speaker 16>father is the one who paid for all her school fees,

0:44:53.400 --> 0:44:55.540
<v Speaker 16>brought her up, really. I mean, they spent a lot

0:44:55.560 --> 0:44:57.920
<v Speaker 16>of time together in their childhood. He was the primary

0:44:57.960 --> 0:45:01.460
<v Speaker 16>carer at one stage. And, of course, he wasn't present

0:45:01.500 --> 0:45:04.299
<v Speaker 16>at the wedding. Amal and George Clooney were. There's the

0:45:04.390 --> 0:45:07.689
<v Speaker 16>famous line in the Palace Papers where it was reported that,

0:45:08.550 --> 0:45:11.310
<v Speaker 16>you know, Oprah was asked and George and Amal Clooney

0:45:11.350 --> 0:45:13.650
<v Speaker 16>were asked, oh, how do you know Meghan? Oh, we

0:45:13.690 --> 0:45:16.210
<v Speaker 16>don't know her. This is the first time we've actually

0:45:16.370 --> 0:45:19.280
<v Speaker 16>ever been here. They were her guests. You know, there

0:45:19.320 --> 0:45:23.360
<v Speaker 16>was always so much controversy and drama around her estrangement

0:45:23.400 --> 0:45:25.900
<v Speaker 16>from her family, and I think this is giving us

0:45:25.940 --> 0:45:28.779
<v Speaker 16>a little bit of clarity as to why she did

0:45:28.860 --> 0:45:32.799
<v Speaker 16>keep that distance. But the whole thing just reeks of...

0:45:32.930 --> 0:45:34.989
<v Speaker 16>I mean, there's so much we still don't know. As

0:45:35.050 --> 0:45:37.250
<v Speaker 16>Tom Bower said to me in text message, who's a

0:45:37.290 --> 0:45:40.330
<v Speaker 16>royal reporter, I can't make my mind up because I

0:45:40.430 --> 0:45:42.510
<v Speaker 16>don't know what's actually gone on here, Andrew.

0:45:43.630 --> 0:45:47.920
<v Speaker 2>Yeah, apparently, you know, in that time, like this... Anyway.

0:45:48.219 --> 0:45:52.890
<v Speaker 1>There was footage of Thomas Markle Jr. who stopped him

0:45:54.360 --> 0:45:56.989
<v Speaker 1>going to the police. So what was that about? You know,

0:45:57.010 --> 0:45:59.710
<v Speaker 1>why did he have himself photographed doing it? And why

0:45:59.750 --> 0:46:01.850
<v Speaker 1>was he, how did he find the phones? He said

0:46:01.870 --> 0:46:04.190
<v Speaker 1>he was looking in these boxes that had been taped

0:46:04.230 --> 0:46:07.070
<v Speaker 1>since his father moved to the Philippines more than a

0:46:07.090 --> 0:46:09.890
<v Speaker 1>decade ago or something, looking for a phone for a

0:46:09.950 --> 0:46:10.930
<v Speaker 1>girlfriend or something.

0:46:10.989 --> 0:46:11.150
<v Speaker 13>I mean.

0:46:11.810 --> 0:46:15.500
<v Speaker 1>A mobile phone that's more than a decade old and

0:46:15.840 --> 0:46:16.660
<v Speaker 1>would it still work?

0:46:16.719 --> 0:46:19.620
<v Speaker 2>I mean, the whole thing's crazy. The King, by the way...

0:46:19.500 --> 0:46:20.279
<v Speaker 2>It really is.

0:46:21.000 --> 0:46:24.100
<v Speaker 1>is going to visit Commonwealth countries in the Caribbean next month.

0:46:24.560 --> 0:46:26.799
<v Speaker 1>And once again, he's got leaders there saying they want

0:46:26.820 --> 0:46:29.750
<v Speaker 1>to talk to him about Britain paying them reparations for slavery,

0:46:29.790 --> 0:46:32.350
<v Speaker 1>even though he has no say in government policy, of course.

0:46:32.989 --> 0:46:34.810
<v Speaker 2>Why these demands and on what grounds?

0:46:34.870 --> 0:46:38.310
<v Speaker 1>I'm puzzled because people in Britain today, they weren't responsible

0:46:38.330 --> 0:46:42.760
<v Speaker 1>for slavery... Britain actually ended slavery and not just for Britain.

0:46:43.180 --> 0:46:46.800
<v Speaker 1>Britain already sends aid to the Caribbean and no slavers

0:46:46.840 --> 0:46:49.850
<v Speaker 1>lived there in more than a century. So what is

0:46:49.890 --> 0:46:50.629
<v Speaker 1>the grounds here?

0:46:52.750 --> 0:46:54.330
<v Speaker 4>There are no grounds, Andrew.

0:46:54.390 --> 0:46:57.800
<v Speaker 16>There are no grounds for the Caribbean to be demanding this.

0:46:57.890 --> 0:47:01.620
<v Speaker 16>They're absolutely taking the opportunity of Charles Cumming and giving

0:47:01.980 --> 0:47:05.419
<v Speaker 16>their area good press to then ask him for these

0:47:05.500 --> 0:47:08.120
<v Speaker 16>reparations or sort of demand them. I mean, Charles is

0:47:08.180 --> 0:47:11.620
<v Speaker 16>a constitutional monarch, firstly. He can't just simply open the

0:47:11.640 --> 0:47:14.010
<v Speaker 16>British Treasury and start writing checks.

0:47:14.340 --> 0:47:15.610
<v Speaker 4>That's not how it works.

0:47:16.450 --> 0:47:20.190
<v Speaker 16>And honestly, no one alive today in Britain, as you said,

0:47:20.610 --> 0:47:23.649
<v Speaker 16>is responsible for what happened. And I don't understand why

0:47:23.790 --> 0:47:26.509
<v Speaker 16>Britain is the one that constantly gets dragged into these

0:47:26.570 --> 0:47:30.290
<v Speaker 16>reparation talks when there are countless other countries that are

0:47:30.330 --> 0:47:34.230
<v Speaker 16>guilty of enslaving their own people, enslaving those from other countries.

0:47:34.570 --> 0:47:40.920
<v Speaker 16>There are many African leaders that enslaved Africans. And of course, Britain,

0:47:40.960 --> 0:47:43.400
<v Speaker 16>which could be seen as the rich uncle, is the

0:47:43.500 --> 0:47:46.000
<v Speaker 16>one that's always asked to cough up and pay. And

0:47:46.200 --> 0:47:48.609
<v Speaker 16>I just don't understand it. You know, if campaigners want

0:47:48.620 --> 0:47:52.910
<v Speaker 16>a financial settlement from Britain, you know, surely the negotiations

0:47:53.230 --> 0:47:54.489
<v Speaker 16>should be with the ministers.

0:47:55.130 --> 0:47:56.150
<v Speaker 4>And not the king.

0:47:56.469 --> 0:47:59.480
<v Speaker 16>And I just think that it's such a misuse of

0:47:59.520 --> 0:48:00.120
<v Speaker 16>the time.

0:48:00.140 --> 0:48:02.800
<v Speaker 4>I just don't know why we keep dragging up this conversation.

0:48:02.880 --> 0:48:04.440
<v Speaker 4>The king's not going to budge, in my view.

0:48:04.460 --> 0:48:08.990
<v Speaker 1>Yeah, and particularly when the word slave comes from Slav

0:48:09.050 --> 0:48:11.900
<v Speaker 1>as in Slavic because of all the people from the

0:48:12.020 --> 0:48:16.259
<v Speaker 1>Balkans that the Ottomans, et cetera, and people before them

0:48:16.500 --> 0:48:21.020
<v Speaker 1>were taking over to what's now Turkey. I don't hear

0:48:21.040 --> 0:48:25.839
<v Speaker 1>people saying to Turkey, you know, reparations for Serbia, reparations

0:48:25.880 --> 0:48:29.190
<v Speaker 1>for Bosnia, reparations for Croatia.

0:48:29.230 --> 0:48:30.830
<v Speaker 2>I don't hear that. Why would that be?

0:48:33.280 --> 0:48:35.360
<v Speaker 4>Well, it's a great question.

0:48:36.290 --> 0:48:39.189
<v Speaker 16>Honestly, I mean, they enslaved their own, I guess. That's

0:48:39.230 --> 0:48:41.969
<v Speaker 16>really what happened there. They never took from any other country,

0:48:42.030 --> 0:48:44.670
<v Speaker 16>but maybe because those countries are doing okay financially.

0:48:44.730 --> 0:48:47.070
<v Speaker 4>It's always the countries that are not doing.

0:48:46.870 --> 0:48:49.170
<v Speaker 16>As well that then start to ask for, you know,

0:48:49.190 --> 0:48:52.340
<v Speaker 16>a bit of pocket change and go through the history books.

0:48:52.430 --> 0:48:53.779
<v Speaker 4>I just honestly don't think.

0:48:53.820 --> 0:48:55.580
<v Speaker 2>Samara, you hit on it right there.

0:48:56.020 --> 0:48:59.120
<v Speaker 1>Samara Gill, thank you so much for your time. Coming

0:48:59.180 --> 0:49:01.400
<v Speaker 1>up next is Shari Markson.

0:49:01.460 --> 0:49:01.819
<v Speaker 2>Good night.