WEBVTT - The Bolt Report | 19 October

0:00:07.430 --> 0:00:10.560
<v Speaker 1>OK, straight to that breaking news, to that shocking news.

0:00:11.000 --> 0:00:14.560
<v Speaker 1>As you've heard, Federal Independent MP Helen Haynes has been

0:00:14.580 --> 0:00:18.420
<v Speaker 1>seriously injured outside her Wangaratta office in regional Victoria. We're

0:00:18.440 --> 0:00:22.360
<v Speaker 1>expecting a press conference from the Prime Minister shortly. What

0:00:22.390 --> 0:00:24.329
<v Speaker 1>we do know so far is that Haynes, who's the

0:00:24.350 --> 0:00:27.230
<v Speaker 1>mother of three, was unloading food or something from the

0:00:27.570 --> 0:00:30.010
<v Speaker 1>boot of her car when she was hit by a

0:00:30.410 --> 0:00:35.879
<v Speaker 1>white SUV. Apparently, it had done a U-turn... when the

0:00:35.920 --> 0:00:40.480
<v Speaker 1>driver allegedly saw her. Her legs, at least, are very

0:00:40.550 --> 0:00:45.849
<v Speaker 1>seriously injured. Passers-by reportedly jumped on the driver, pinned him down,

0:00:46.770 --> 0:00:50.430
<v Speaker 1>reportedly took a penknife from him, and police are investigating

0:00:50.470 --> 0:00:54.930
<v Speaker 1>if this was a targeted attack. And if so, how

0:00:54.970 --> 0:01:01.070
<v Speaker 1>that will shock politics today. We've had so much anger

0:01:01.270 --> 0:01:05.510
<v Speaker 1>in our polity that... Really, it's shocking. We've just got

0:01:05.530 --> 0:01:09.070
<v Speaker 1>to wind this back. And for Helen Haynes to be

0:01:09.130 --> 0:01:12.980
<v Speaker 1>the target of it, she's 53, she was first elected

0:01:13.040 --> 0:01:17.800
<v Speaker 1>in 2019. She's been re-elected twice. She's not a TLMP.

0:01:18.160 --> 0:01:22.220
<v Speaker 1>She hasn't been angry, one of these angry politicians, not

0:01:22.500 --> 0:01:26.660
<v Speaker 1>at all, not at all. But she, by the way,

0:01:26.700 --> 0:01:32.440
<v Speaker 1>she actually shares a lot of TLMP's concerns. It's terrible. Now,

0:01:32.459 --> 0:01:35.630
<v Speaker 1>the The Prime Minister, like I say, is going to

0:01:35.730 --> 0:01:38.710
<v Speaker 1>tell us more. It's significant that he's going to give

0:01:38.790 --> 0:01:42.250
<v Speaker 1>a press conference. I assume that he has something very

0:01:42.310 --> 0:01:44.390
<v Speaker 1>serious to tell us. But in the meantime, we've got

0:01:44.490 --> 0:01:49.880
<v Speaker 1>Cameron Redden, who's been covering all this. Cameron, thank you

0:01:49.920 --> 0:01:53.740
<v Speaker 1>so much for your time. Andrew Clunell has also said

0:01:53.780 --> 0:01:57.640
<v Speaker 1>that it is his understanding that it's a targeted attack.

0:01:57.720 --> 0:01:58.320
<v Speaker 1>What do you know?

0:01:59.670 --> 0:02:02.730
<v Speaker 2>Yeah, and that's the report coming through via Andrew. That

0:02:02.770 --> 0:02:06.730
<v Speaker 2>is a belief of senior Labor sources, Andrew. So we

0:02:06.790 --> 0:02:08.450
<v Speaker 2>are going to hear from the Prime Minister more. We'll

0:02:08.490 --> 0:02:11.549
<v Speaker 2>also hear from the Home Affairs Minister, Tony Burke, who

0:02:11.570 --> 0:02:14.029
<v Speaker 2>will be at this press conference as well. Now, that

0:02:14.070 --> 0:02:16.350
<v Speaker 2>potentially tells us something, what we can read into the

0:02:16.389 --> 0:02:18.680
<v Speaker 2>sort of language that we might expect and the way

0:02:18.720 --> 0:02:22.760
<v Speaker 2>that the government is viewing this incident. Andrew, this is shocking,

0:02:22.820 --> 0:02:25.200
<v Speaker 2>as you mentioned. It is unsettling. We have not, if

0:02:25.240 --> 0:02:27.500
<v Speaker 2>this is confirmed, to be a targeted attack. That is

0:02:27.540 --> 0:02:28.200
<v Speaker 2>the allegation.

0:02:28.240 --> 0:02:29.440
<v Speaker 3>That's the report at the moment.

0:02:30.110 --> 0:02:31.809
<v Speaker 2>We would not have seen something like this to this

0:02:31.870 --> 0:02:34.270
<v Speaker 2>scale in Australian politics, certainly not in my time and

0:02:34.310 --> 0:02:36.870
<v Speaker 2>maybe at all, not for a very long time. So

0:02:36.889 --> 0:02:39.429
<v Speaker 2>we'll hear from that. I don't anticipate that the Prime

0:02:39.450 --> 0:02:41.590
<v Speaker 2>Minister will be keeping us waiting long. He and Tony

0:02:41.610 --> 0:02:43.370
<v Speaker 2>Burke are going to be there in Sydney. They're not

0:02:43.410 --> 0:02:46.030
<v Speaker 2>in Canberra at the moment. My understanding is that there

0:02:46.050 --> 0:02:48.620
<v Speaker 2>have been meetings going on to try and ascertain exactly

0:02:48.660 --> 0:02:51.220
<v Speaker 2>what has happened over the last couple of hours. And

0:02:51.260 --> 0:02:52.940
<v Speaker 2>we'll be hearing now from the Prime Minister in the

0:02:52.980 --> 0:02:55.080
<v Speaker 2>next few minutes, Andrew. But this is, as you say,

0:02:55.100 --> 0:03:00.100
<v Speaker 2>a very unsettling moment in Australian politics and It's hard

0:03:00.160 --> 0:03:02.429
<v Speaker 2>not to, as Andrew Clennell reflected on a moment ago,

0:03:02.530 --> 0:03:04.590
<v Speaker 2>think of the incidents we've seen around the world, particularly

0:03:04.610 --> 0:03:08.450
<v Speaker 2>in the UK, and the impact that that has had where,

0:03:09.330 --> 0:03:13.530
<v Speaker 2>whether it's Joe Cox, David Amess and others, some terrible

0:03:13.570 --> 0:03:14.890
<v Speaker 2>incidents have taken place.

0:03:14.950 --> 0:03:16.910
<v Speaker 3>So, look, we will get more details.

0:03:17.290 --> 0:03:20.210
<v Speaker 2>All this coming to hand in the last three hours, really, Andrew,

0:03:20.310 --> 0:03:23.110
<v Speaker 2>but hopefully we will get something comprehensive from the Prime

0:03:23.130 --> 0:03:25.609
<v Speaker 2>Minister in the next few minutes. A terrible moment of

0:03:25.650 --> 0:03:27.470
<v Speaker 2>the year, but certainly in Australian politics.

0:03:29.470 --> 0:03:32.790
<v Speaker 1>No, we haven't seen something like this for many, many

0:03:32.870 --> 0:03:37.630
<v Speaker 1>decades since Labor leader Arthur Call was shot in the jaw. And,

0:03:37.850 --> 0:03:41.290
<v Speaker 1>of course, since then, well, recently, we've had the assassination

0:03:41.850 --> 0:03:46.860
<v Speaker 1>attempts on Donald Trump. We've had the assassination of Dutch leader,

0:03:47.600 --> 0:03:51.160
<v Speaker 1>political leader Pim Fortone. We've had those attacks you mentioned

0:03:51.200 --> 0:03:56.980
<v Speaker 1>on two MPs in fatal attacks in Britain. Really, the

0:03:57.020 --> 0:04:01.190
<v Speaker 1>world seems to be in extremely... dangerous place. And the

0:04:01.230 --> 0:04:06.030
<v Speaker 1>fact that Anthony Albanese is going to hold a press conference, Cameron, Cam,

0:04:06.210 --> 0:04:09.050
<v Speaker 1>what do you make of that? Oh, it elevates.

0:04:09.110 --> 0:04:11.730
<v Speaker 2>I mean, it's a serious incident. That goes without saying, Andrew.

0:04:11.750 --> 0:04:13.930
<v Speaker 2>But clearly the Prime Minister sees this as a moment

0:04:13.970 --> 0:04:16.550
<v Speaker 2>when people need to hear from him. I anticipate that

0:04:16.670 --> 0:04:19.940
<v Speaker 2>whatever programming was scheduled on every network in the country

0:04:19.980 --> 0:04:22.520
<v Speaker 2>will be paused to take this address, given the severity

0:04:22.600 --> 0:04:25.500
<v Speaker 2>of it. And we've been talking for, I think it's

0:04:25.520 --> 0:04:28.140
<v Speaker 2>fair to say, years, Andrew, about some of the fears

0:04:28.220 --> 0:04:30.750
<v Speaker 2>that people have had in this place in Parliament House

0:04:31.520 --> 0:04:35.330
<v Speaker 2>about attacks, about the safety of MPs. We've had other

0:04:35.710 --> 0:04:38.250
<v Speaker 2>members of Parliament have to bolster their own safety because

0:04:38.270 --> 0:04:41.640
<v Speaker 2>they receive threats online. We know what goes on social media,

0:04:41.680 --> 0:04:44.060
<v Speaker 2>but elsewhere too. And it's one of the great things

0:04:44.120 --> 0:04:47.030
<v Speaker 2>about our democracy when you travel around the world, that

0:04:47.110 --> 0:04:50.150
<v Speaker 2>MPs are so accessible. They hold open rallies. They hold

0:04:50.550 --> 0:04:53.290
<v Speaker 2>community stalls. They go to sport. They go for a run.

0:04:53.330 --> 0:04:56.030
<v Speaker 2>They take the dog for a walk, often without heavy

0:04:56.089 --> 0:04:59.940
<v Speaker 2>police security or without barricades around them, because that's how

0:05:00.000 --> 0:05:00.980
<v Speaker 2>our democracy works.

0:05:01.020 --> 0:05:01.680
<v Speaker 1>It's so open.

0:05:01.800 --> 0:05:04.200
<v Speaker 2>And Helen Haynes in this situation, we're told, was getting

0:05:04.560 --> 0:05:07.529
<v Speaker 2>something out of the boot of her car and And seemingly,

0:05:07.650 --> 0:05:09.589
<v Speaker 2>so the report goes, and so is the belief of

0:05:09.650 --> 0:05:12.500
<v Speaker 2>senior Labor sources talking to Andrew Clunell, has been targeted

0:05:12.620 --> 0:05:15.700
<v Speaker 2>in this attack. If that was to be the case, well,

0:05:15.920 --> 0:05:18.260
<v Speaker 2>that is going to cause a lot of pause for thought.

0:05:19.040 --> 0:05:22.170
<v Speaker 2>Going forward, Andrew, that door is opening, so the Prime

0:05:22.190 --> 0:05:24.270
<v Speaker 2>Minister can only be a few seconds away, you would think.

0:05:26.570 --> 0:05:29.890
<v Speaker 1>Now, we can't jump to conclusions. We don't know if

0:05:29.950 --> 0:05:33.230
<v Speaker 1>it was targeted. And if it was targeted, for what reasons?

0:05:33.270 --> 0:05:36.080
<v Speaker 1>Were they political? Were they personal? None of that we know.

0:05:36.100 --> 0:05:39.400
<v Speaker 1>We might be told soon. We do not know. But

0:05:40.240 --> 0:05:42.600
<v Speaker 1>it is true that the temperature has heated up. And

0:05:42.960 --> 0:05:46.990
<v Speaker 1>I think, Cameron, you will back me up in saying,

0:05:47.029 --> 0:05:52.680
<v Speaker 1>you know, if you... No politician deserves... Any violence? Absolutely none.

0:05:52.740 --> 0:05:55.780
<v Speaker 1>We cannot have that. But of all the people, I

0:05:55.779 --> 0:05:57.820
<v Speaker 1>wouldn't have thought Helen Haynes would be on the list.

0:05:58.100 --> 0:06:00.170
<v Speaker 1>Here's the Prime Minister now about to give us an update.

0:06:00.310 --> 0:06:00.630
<v Speaker 1>Here we go.

0:06:00.690 --> 0:06:06.510
<v Speaker 4>serious incident that has occurred in Victoria. This afternoon, Helen Haynes,

0:06:06.790 --> 0:06:10.930
<v Speaker 4>the member for Indi, was attacked outside her electorate.

0:06:10.410 --> 0:06:11.729
<v Speaker 5>Office in Wangaratta.

0:06:12.750 --> 0:06:16.780
<v Speaker 4>All of our thoughts are with Helen, her family, her friends,

0:06:16.920 --> 0:06:22.050
<v Speaker 4>her team and her community. at this extremely difficult time.

0:06:23.050 --> 0:06:27.030
<v Speaker 4>We are praying for her full recovery. I want to

0:06:27.110 --> 0:06:31.980
<v Speaker 4>thank the first responders for their extraordinary work. There is

0:06:32.000 --> 0:06:36.700
<v Speaker 4>a major police investigation underway and I can confirm that

0:06:36.779 --> 0:06:41.860
<v Speaker 4>a suspect is in custody. The Australian Federal Police, Victorian

0:06:41.920 --> 0:06:46.330
<v Speaker 4>Police and ASIA are working together on this. The Joint

0:06:46.410 --> 0:06:50.609
<v Speaker 4>Counter Terrorism Team has been activated but the motive is

0:06:50.690 --> 0:06:55.750
<v Speaker 4>not known. I've spoken with Victorian Premier Ben Carroll and

0:06:55.770 --> 0:06:59.830
<v Speaker 4>have been briefed by AFP Commissioner Chrissie Barrett. It is

0:06:59.890 --> 0:07:03.310
<v Speaker 4>too early in this investigation for me to provide you

0:07:03.350 --> 0:07:07.390
<v Speaker 4>with details of what the motivation is behind this attack.

0:07:08.450 --> 0:07:09.910
<v Speaker 5>My thoughts are also.

0:07:09.650 --> 0:07:14.300
<v Speaker 4>With those there who were there in Wangaratta today and

0:07:14.390 --> 0:07:20.790
<v Speaker 4>Helen's community more broadly. Helen Haynes is incredibly hardworking. She

0:07:20.870 --> 0:07:26.900
<v Speaker 4>is fiercely intelligent, but most importantly, she's just thoroughly decent

0:07:27.000 --> 0:07:32.620
<v Speaker 4>human being, full of integrity and respected right across the

0:07:32.680 --> 0:07:37.060
<v Speaker 4>Parliament and from everyone who comes into contact with her.

0:07:38.280 --> 0:07:42.480
<v Speaker 4>She is a well-loved member of her community, and this

0:07:42.520 --> 0:07:48.260
<v Speaker 4>will come as an incredible shock to that community. Our

0:07:48.320 --> 0:07:52.940
<v Speaker 4>thoughts remain with Helen Haynes at this very difficult time.

0:07:54.540 --> 0:07:58.240
<v Speaker 4>Minister Burke will make some short comments and then we'll

0:07:58.260 --> 0:07:58.880
<v Speaker 4>take just a.

0:07:58.900 --> 0:08:04.080
<v Speaker 5>Couple of questions. Thank you, Prime Minister. As the Prime

0:08:04.110 --> 0:08:06.450
<v Speaker 5>Minister said, we're still very early.

0:08:06.230 --> 0:08:10.510
<v Speaker 6>In the investigation, but importantly, someone is in custody and

0:08:10.550 --> 0:08:15.110
<v Speaker 6>acknowledges the family statement, has acknowledged the bystanders, the health

0:08:15.150 --> 0:08:16.030
<v Speaker 6>workers and the police.

0:08:18.640 --> 0:08:20.679
<v Speaker 5>Last year, or the year before last.

0:08:20.720 --> 0:08:25.980
<v Speaker 6>We had 951 reports of harassing and threatening behaviour against

0:08:26.020 --> 0:08:29.880
<v Speaker 6>various high office holders. The more recent financial year, that

0:08:29.880 --> 0:08:35.160
<v Speaker 6>951 has gone to 1,067. At this moment in time,

0:08:35.350 --> 0:08:38.309
<v Speaker 6>while it's still so early in the investigation, our thoughts

0:08:38.390 --> 0:08:41.470
<v Speaker 6>are all with Helen and her family and her community

0:08:41.510 --> 0:08:45.609
<v Speaker 6>and her friends. As the Prime Minister said, Helen is respected,

0:08:46.110 --> 0:08:47.290
<v Speaker 6>admired and loved.

0:08:47.920 --> 0:08:48.500
<v Speaker 2>Senator Morrison.

0:08:48.540 --> 0:08:53.120
<v Speaker 7>Senator Morrison, was the suspect known to any police body

0:08:53.260 --> 0:08:53.800
<v Speaker 7>or agency?

0:08:53.940 --> 0:08:59.100
<v Speaker 4>Look, I'm not about to go into comments about an investigation,

0:08:59.260 --> 0:09:02.660
<v Speaker 4>which is underway and has been underway for a matter

0:09:02.820 --> 0:09:03.880
<v Speaker 4>of just hours.

0:09:04.260 --> 0:09:08.100
<v Speaker 8>Did the government go with any threats made towards Helen

0:09:08.140 --> 0:09:10.260
<v Speaker 8>Haynes and was there any concern around.

0:09:10.440 --> 0:09:13.520
<v Speaker 1>Anything she'd be copying? Look, we have made.

0:09:15.550 --> 0:09:20.189
<v Speaker 4>a range of comments that I have made. Go look

0:09:20.290 --> 0:09:23.470
<v Speaker 4>up the interviews in which I've done and call for

0:09:23.490 --> 0:09:27.920
<v Speaker 4>the temperature to be turned down when it comes to

0:09:28.040 --> 0:09:32.820
<v Speaker 4>political discourse. It is too early though to speculate on

0:09:32.880 --> 0:09:34.660
<v Speaker 4>motivation and we won't be doing so.

0:09:34.720 --> 0:09:37.380
<v Speaker 5>We'll allow the authorities to do their work.

0:09:46.450 --> 0:09:55.800
<v Speaker 4>Obviously Helen Haynes has suffered serious this is a serious

0:09:55.880 --> 0:10:00.699
<v Speaker 4>incident and so our thoughts are with Helen and her

0:10:00.760 --> 0:10:03.120
<v Speaker 4>recovery at this time.

0:10:03.679 --> 0:10:04.360
<v Speaker 5>Can you say.

0:10:04.460 --> 0:10:07.380
<v Speaker 1>What security measures, if any, she was afforded ahead of

0:10:07.420 --> 0:10:08.560
<v Speaker 1>this attack by Parliament?

0:10:09.240 --> 0:10:14.330
<v Speaker 4>Look, we organise security arrangements based upon the.

0:10:16.230 --> 0:10:17.770
<v Speaker 5>Threat levels which are there.

0:10:18.710 --> 0:10:22.800
<v Speaker 4>But as Minister Burke has said, And as you would

0:10:22.840 --> 0:10:31.040
<v Speaker 4>be aware, and anyone who looks at comments made and

0:10:31.100 --> 0:10:36.160
<v Speaker 4>directed towards members of parliament and high office holders, there

0:10:36.260 --> 0:10:42.809
<v Speaker 4>is increased heightened risk has occurred. Our thoughts are just

0:10:42.830 --> 0:10:47.990
<v Speaker 4>very much with Helen, her family, her community at this time.

0:10:48.110 --> 0:10:48.770
<v Speaker 5>Thanks very much.

0:10:53.780 --> 0:10:57.230
<v Speaker 1>Well, I take one tiny bit of hope from that,

0:10:57.250 --> 0:11:01.550
<v Speaker 1>that the Prime Minister's talking about Helen Haynes' recovery. So,

0:11:03.130 --> 0:11:08.780
<v Speaker 1>prayers for her and her family. But, you know, the

0:11:08.800 --> 0:11:10.840
<v Speaker 1>Prime Minister's also right. He has called for the temperature

0:11:10.880 --> 0:11:13.900
<v Speaker 1>to be lowered. I think he's right in having done that,

0:11:14.740 --> 0:11:17.950
<v Speaker 1>and today bears out the wisdom of that. I always

0:11:17.990 --> 0:11:22.100
<v Speaker 1>thought that... The person in greatest danger in Parliament was

0:11:22.240 --> 0:11:25.380
<v Speaker 1>Pauline Hanson with the threats against her. In fact, as

0:11:25.420 --> 0:11:27.620
<v Speaker 1>you know, on this show, I've said her security should

0:11:27.640 --> 0:11:31.260
<v Speaker 1>be beefed up from what I'd seen, has been. But

0:11:31.340 --> 0:11:36.820
<v Speaker 1>political violence, unfortunately, is not that new to Australia. We

0:11:36.880 --> 0:11:40.679
<v Speaker 1>tend to forget. 1966, Arthur Caldwell, shot in the face,

0:11:40.850 --> 0:11:46.270
<v Speaker 1>Labor leader, federal Labor leader. In 1994, John Newman, the

0:11:46.350 --> 0:11:53.790
<v Speaker 1>state MP, Laborer, Cameramatta also assassinated. But this will come as...

0:11:53.910 --> 0:11:58.530
<v Speaker 1>This will really change things in Canberra. Politicians should not

0:11:58.650 --> 0:12:03.010
<v Speaker 1>have to fear walking among us. But this... Back to

0:12:03.090 --> 0:12:05.840
<v Speaker 1>our political reporter, Cam Redden. Cam, what did you take

0:12:05.910 --> 0:12:07.360
<v Speaker 1>out of the Prime Minister's comments?

0:12:08.380 --> 0:12:10.110
<v Speaker 3>Well, pretty clear from the language there, Andrew.

0:12:10.150 --> 0:12:12.890
<v Speaker 2>He believes this is very much a targeted attack, that

0:12:12.950 --> 0:12:14.690
<v Speaker 2>man in custody. I do just want to add that

0:12:15.450 --> 0:12:18.750
<v Speaker 2>sources for News24, our understanding at this stage is that

0:12:19.070 --> 0:12:22.459
<v Speaker 2>the person in custody has no immediate or obvious terror

0:12:22.500 --> 0:12:25.520
<v Speaker 2>links known. The Prime Minister said there that the AFP

0:12:25.559 --> 0:12:28.020
<v Speaker 2>and ASIO are involved in this as well. There are

0:12:28.040 --> 0:12:31.580
<v Speaker 2>no immediate known links to terror, is our understanding. But

0:12:31.640 --> 0:12:34.550
<v Speaker 2>clearly now a major police investigation going on. You mentioned

0:12:34.570 --> 0:12:37.530
<v Speaker 2>some of the history of... there, Andrew, but it goes

0:12:37.550 --> 0:12:39.550
<v Speaker 2>without saying. We're about to go into a state election

0:12:39.590 --> 0:12:41.589
<v Speaker 2>in Victoria. We've got a state election in New South

0:12:41.630 --> 0:12:44.179
<v Speaker 2>Wales early next year. We're going towards the end of

0:12:44.240 --> 0:12:48.699
<v Speaker 2>a parliamentary year, but this will absolutely rattle and unsettle

0:12:48.880 --> 0:12:52.140
<v Speaker 2>politicians across the country, I would say, because rare as

0:12:52.179 --> 0:12:54.080
<v Speaker 2>it is, you do have to go back several decades

0:12:54.120 --> 0:12:55.880
<v Speaker 2>for this to be the case in Australia. I also

0:12:55.920 --> 0:12:57.540
<v Speaker 2>want to point out one other thing that Tony Burke

0:12:57.600 --> 0:12:59.579
<v Speaker 2>mentioned there as well, Andrew, and we've covered this a

0:12:59.610 --> 0:13:01.929
<v Speaker 2>bit throughout the year. He noted there that in the

0:13:01.970 --> 0:13:05.920
<v Speaker 2>last financial year alone, there were more than 1,000 registered

0:13:06.080 --> 0:13:10.189
<v Speaker 2>threats to politicians. Now, that isn't just somebody sending an email.

0:13:10.230 --> 0:13:13.410
<v Speaker 2>That is somebody's office or the politician themselves taking it

0:13:13.490 --> 0:13:16.510
<v Speaker 2>seriously enough to refer that on to the Australian Federal

0:13:16.550 --> 0:13:19.490
<v Speaker 2>Police or to some sort of authority. So that's 1,000

0:13:19.490 --> 0:13:22.579
<v Speaker 2>that have been escalated in just the financial year gone,

0:13:23.020 --> 0:13:25.540
<v Speaker 2>and that has been escalating year on year. So that

0:13:25.559 --> 0:13:29.080
<v Speaker 2>investigation now ongoing, we didn't really get a clear health

0:13:29.160 --> 0:13:33.260
<v Speaker 2>update from the Prime Minister there on Helen Haynes, but

0:13:33.380 --> 0:13:36.650
<v Speaker 2>he did talk about her recovery there. So perhaps some

0:13:36.710 --> 0:13:38.770
<v Speaker 2>hope in amongst this terrible news, Andrew.

0:13:38.790 --> 0:13:39.250
<v Speaker 5>Perhaps.

0:13:39.309 --> 0:13:42.150
<v Speaker 2>But this break in tonight, we will clearly get more

0:13:42.190 --> 0:13:44.850
<v Speaker 2>reaction to this tomorrow and over the months ahead. And

0:13:44.890 --> 0:13:46.329
<v Speaker 2>as you can say, we can only hope that it

0:13:46.390 --> 0:13:48.410
<v Speaker 2>is a good and speedy recovery for her.

0:13:50.490 --> 0:13:53.929
<v Speaker 1>Yeah, but I come back to, I think you noticed

0:13:54.010 --> 0:13:56.490
<v Speaker 1>it too, the words of the Prime Minister who said

0:13:56.570 --> 0:13:59.530
<v Speaker 1>it's too early to speculate about motive. Motive is what

0:13:59.550 --> 0:14:02.870
<v Speaker 1>you speculate on when you think this was a targeted attack,

0:14:03.950 --> 0:14:06.010
<v Speaker 1>not if it was an accident. There's no motive for

0:14:06.030 --> 0:14:09.490
<v Speaker 1>an accident. I think that's a pretty clear hint that

0:14:10.530 --> 0:14:13.970
<v Speaker 1>something very serious has occurred and something that's very frightening

0:14:14.429 --> 0:14:16.410
<v Speaker 1>and that will frighten a lot of politicians and may

0:14:16.450 --> 0:14:19.250
<v Speaker 1>change the way they interact with the community. which will

0:14:19.270 --> 0:14:22.320
<v Speaker 1>be to the loss of us all. Cameron Redden, thank

0:14:22.360 --> 0:14:24.040
<v Speaker 1>you so much for your time. No doubt we'll be

0:14:24.080 --> 0:14:28.360
<v Speaker 1>talking to you during the night if we get more information.

0:14:28.440 --> 0:14:32.440
<v Speaker 1>Thank you so much. After the break, more on this

0:14:33.480 --> 0:14:44.140
<v Speaker 1>shocking Helen Haynes news. So to repeat, Federal Independent MP

0:14:44.180 --> 0:14:50.320
<v Speaker 1>Helen Haynes struck by a car outside her office Reportedly,

0:14:50.400 --> 0:14:54.420
<v Speaker 1>a car that turned around did a U-turn when the

0:14:54.470 --> 0:14:58.330
<v Speaker 1>driver saw her. Motive not known. As far as we

0:14:58.370 --> 0:15:01.890
<v Speaker 1>can tell, as far as we have heard, no terror

0:15:02.970 --> 0:15:07.490
<v Speaker 1>motive there. So we shall see. The Prime Minister wouldn't speculate.

0:15:07.710 --> 0:15:10.710
<v Speaker 1>But in saying that he wouldn't speculate on motive, he

0:15:10.750 --> 0:15:13.830
<v Speaker 1>made clear, I think, that he did believe this was

0:15:13.950 --> 0:15:18.420
<v Speaker 1>no accident. Joining me is the political panel, Cameron Milner,

0:15:18.440 --> 0:15:20.420
<v Speaker 1>former Chief of Staff to Labor leader Bill Shorten, now

0:15:20.460 --> 0:15:25.610
<v Speaker 1>Director of GXO Strategies, and Michael Kroger, former Victorian Liberal President.

0:15:25.670 --> 0:15:32.950
<v Speaker 1>Michael Kroger, this news will shock so many politicians and

0:15:32.990 --> 0:15:36.190
<v Speaker 1>make a lot of them afraid to walk in public.

0:15:37.910 --> 0:15:40.150
<v Speaker 9>Look, Andrew, as you said before, we've seen an increase

0:15:40.170 --> 0:15:45.220
<v Speaker 9>in violence against political figures across the world in recent years.

0:15:46.870 --> 0:15:50.550
<v Speaker 9>The question is, why is this happening? Well, I think

0:15:50.590 --> 0:15:53.470
<v Speaker 9>without reflecting on what's happened to Helen Haynes, that the

0:15:53.490 --> 0:15:59.530
<v Speaker 9>level of incitement around the world is increasing through demonstrations,

0:15:59.630 --> 0:16:00.500
<v Speaker 9>social media.

0:16:00.600 --> 0:16:01.270
<v Speaker 5>Whatever else.

0:16:01.390 --> 0:16:04.760
<v Speaker 9>So the level of hatred, anger in the world, in

0:16:04.800 --> 0:16:10.050
<v Speaker 9>Western countries is increasing. But specifically on that press conference,

0:16:11.250 --> 0:16:13.820
<v Speaker 9>and look, it's improper to speculate too much at this

0:16:13.880 --> 0:16:16.000
<v Speaker 9>stage for all the reasons we know, Andrew, but that

0:16:16.040 --> 0:16:19.340
<v Speaker 9>was a most unusual press conference. I don't think I've

0:16:19.380 --> 0:16:21.740
<v Speaker 9>ever seen a Prime Minister and Senior Minister give such

0:16:21.800 --> 0:16:29.810
<v Speaker 9>a press conference in my lifetime. Clearly, clearly something has

0:16:29.870 --> 0:16:33.730
<v Speaker 9>gone on here that they are aware of.

0:16:34.590 --> 0:16:34.920
<v Speaker 10>That is.

0:16:35.700 --> 0:16:37.900
<v Speaker 9>That is not a press conference given by a Prime

0:16:38.040 --> 0:16:41.970
<v Speaker 9>Minister at any time that I've seen in these circumstances.

0:16:43.070 --> 0:16:48.810
<v Speaker 9>So we, of course, wish Helen Haynes well. Everyone that

0:16:48.890 --> 0:16:52.590
<v Speaker 9>I know knows her, thinks the world of her. So

0:16:52.630 --> 0:16:57.490
<v Speaker 9>to her and her friends and family and supporters in India,

0:16:57.770 --> 0:17:00.550
<v Speaker 9>you know, our hearts go out to her and all

0:17:00.600 --> 0:17:01.460
<v Speaker 9>strength and love to her.

0:17:03.740 --> 0:17:06.109
<v Speaker 1>As I suggested earlier in the show, she'd be one

0:17:06.160 --> 0:17:08.530
<v Speaker 1>of the last people you'd think would be the target

0:17:08.550 --> 0:17:13.310
<v Speaker 1>of such hatred, that someone might, might, this is speculating,

0:17:13.530 --> 0:17:20.230
<v Speaker 1>might do something like this to her. But, my God. Cameron,

0:17:21.190 --> 0:17:23.689
<v Speaker 1>what do you make of this? Because, like I say,

0:17:24.100 --> 0:17:26.580
<v Speaker 1>this is not, Helen Haynes is not someone you would

0:17:26.740 --> 0:17:29.300
<v Speaker 1>imagine would be a target of an attack.

0:17:31.680 --> 0:17:33.369
<v Speaker 11>No, you don't, and I think tonight we've all got

0:17:33.380 --> 0:17:35.270
<v Speaker 11>to have our thoughts and prayers for Helen and for

0:17:35.310 --> 0:17:37.730
<v Speaker 11>her speedy recovery and for the family to actually have

0:17:38.090 --> 0:17:40.510
<v Speaker 11>lots of love around them tonight because they shouldn't be

0:17:40.550 --> 0:17:43.500
<v Speaker 11>going through this situation. No politician, no member of public

0:17:43.540 --> 0:17:45.540
<v Speaker 11>should be in a situation where they're doing their groceries

0:17:45.580 --> 0:17:47.720
<v Speaker 11>and get hit by a car has potentially done a

0:17:47.820 --> 0:17:50.600
<v Speaker 11>U-turn and might have motive for what they've done, Andrew.

0:17:50.619 --> 0:17:53.550
<v Speaker 11>So this is just a truly awful, shocking moment.

0:17:53.310 --> 0:17:54.010
<v Speaker 1>In Australian politics.

0:17:54.390 --> 0:17:57.310
<v Speaker 11>To your point, Michael, unprecedented in terms of a Prime

0:17:57.330 --> 0:18:00.330
<v Speaker 11>Minister coming to do a press conference so quickly. Obviously,

0:18:00.390 --> 0:18:02.270
<v Speaker 11>more will come to light, but we need to make

0:18:02.330 --> 0:18:04.260
<v Speaker 11>sure we get to the absolute root cause of this

0:18:04.619 --> 0:18:07.139
<v Speaker 11>and understand exactly what's happened, because the last thing we

0:18:07.180 --> 0:18:09.680
<v Speaker 11>need is our politicians to be less connected to the community.

0:18:09.960 --> 0:18:11.660
<v Speaker 11>We love the fact they go walking their dogs, going

0:18:11.680 --> 0:18:13.970
<v Speaker 11>to do the groceries. They want to be connected to

0:18:13.990 --> 0:18:16.410
<v Speaker 11>the community. They can't just be behind a security fence.

0:18:16.790 --> 0:18:18.650
<v Speaker 11>And this is what I think is the risk tonight, Andrew,

0:18:18.930 --> 0:18:21.410
<v Speaker 11>is that we can't have politicians withdraw at the very

0:18:21.450 --> 0:18:23.850
<v Speaker 11>moment we need them to connect, even more so than ever,

0:18:24.109 --> 0:18:24.729
<v Speaker 11>to our community.

0:18:26.980 --> 0:18:30.840
<v Speaker 1>That is so true, because, Michael, there's a real trust

0:18:30.880 --> 0:18:33.359
<v Speaker 1>deficit in our community at the moment, as well as

0:18:33.380 --> 0:18:37.300
<v Speaker 1>the hatred, a lack of trust in the political institutions,

0:18:37.359 --> 0:18:40.320
<v Speaker 1>as well as in journalism. We've got to say that too.

0:18:40.359 --> 0:18:40.609
<v Speaker 10>But....

0:18:42.520 --> 0:18:47.119
<v Speaker 1>Then to have at that moment politicians withdrawing from public

0:18:47.160 --> 0:18:49.940
<v Speaker 1>engagements that are deemed to be too risky. And we've

0:18:49.960 --> 0:18:53.080
<v Speaker 1>seen this build up. You might recall Julia Gillard as

0:18:53.140 --> 0:18:56.660
<v Speaker 1>Prime Minister had to be bustled into a car when

0:18:56.700 --> 0:19:01.210
<v Speaker 1>a demonstration looked like getting very dangerous. Police bundled her

0:19:01.270 --> 0:19:03.250
<v Speaker 1>into the car. She lost her shoe on the way.

0:19:04.170 --> 0:19:06.129
<v Speaker 1>You might remember, I mean, people laughed it off at

0:19:06.170 --> 0:19:09.609
<v Speaker 1>the time, but Tony Abbott got headbutted by some fool

0:19:10.190 --> 0:19:13.180
<v Speaker 1>in the streets of Hobart. He was also the target

0:19:13.260 --> 0:19:16.800
<v Speaker 1>of demonstrations. His sister had her jacket half ripped off

0:19:16.840 --> 0:19:21.179
<v Speaker 1>her back. But the hatred has built up and up

0:19:21.500 --> 0:19:25.159
<v Speaker 1>and up, and I wonder, Anthony Albanese has called this

0:19:25.240 --> 0:19:27.690
<v Speaker 1>out and said, you know, cool it down, but I

0:19:27.750 --> 0:19:29.869
<v Speaker 1>wonder if the genie's out of the bottle, whether it

0:19:29.910 --> 0:19:30.310
<v Speaker 1>can be.

0:19:32.070 --> 0:19:36.090
<v Speaker 5>Well, the genie's out of the bottle, you know, bigger

0:19:36.130 --> 0:19:37.990
<v Speaker 5>and brighter and worse than I've ever seen.

0:19:39.030 --> 0:19:41.389
<v Speaker 9>I was just actually at Monash University a couple of

0:19:41.410 --> 0:19:45.659
<v Speaker 9>hours ago and walked past the Krongold Centre, where in

0:19:45.660 --> 0:19:49.290
<v Speaker 9>1976 I stood on a grassy knoll as Malcolm Fraser,

0:19:49.350 --> 0:19:53.040
<v Speaker 9>the Prime Minister, had to run past with federal police

0:19:53.240 --> 0:19:56.280
<v Speaker 9>protecting him because he'd been locked in the basement of

0:19:56.340 --> 0:19:59.550
<v Speaker 9>this centre which he'd opened. And he'd been locked in

0:19:59.590 --> 0:20:02.710
<v Speaker 9>there for an hour by chanting rat-bag left-wing demonstrators.

0:20:03.790 --> 0:20:05.389
<v Speaker 5>And then there was a moment for him to escape

0:20:05.450 --> 0:20:05.890
<v Speaker 5>and he did.

0:20:05.910 --> 0:20:10.230
<v Speaker 9>This has been going on in Australia forever. for decades,

0:20:10.410 --> 0:20:13.250
<v Speaker 9>but I think it's getting worse now. I think, as

0:20:13.290 --> 0:20:16.510
<v Speaker 9>I said, I think the incitement through social media whips up,

0:20:17.730 --> 0:20:19.760
<v Speaker 9>let's call a spade a spade, it whips up the

0:20:19.820 --> 0:20:26.420
<v Speaker 9>extreme left more than we've ever seen before, Andrew, because

0:20:26.800 --> 0:20:30.000
<v Speaker 9>in the old days, you'd have to phone people, send

0:20:30.020 --> 0:20:33.119
<v Speaker 9>off a Gestetner machine or a fax or something. Now,

0:20:33.720 --> 0:20:37.260
<v Speaker 9>the ease with which communication can be passed amongst the

0:20:37.280 --> 0:20:40.179
<v Speaker 9>extremes of the left and right to organise functions and

0:20:40.220 --> 0:20:41.600
<v Speaker 9>demonstrations is so easy.

0:20:41.660 --> 0:20:45.320
<v Speaker 5>Encrypted messaging, these acts of violence, et cetera, et cetera.

0:20:45.340 --> 0:20:47.740
<v Speaker 5>The world has changed. It's a far more dangerous place.

0:20:48.500 --> 0:20:53.000
<v Speaker 9>That's why those inciting violence have a special low place

0:20:53.960 --> 0:20:58.460
<v Speaker 9>in Western civilisation, in Western societies, because of their capacity today,

0:20:58.510 --> 0:21:02.230
<v Speaker 9>which they never had before, to incite hatred and violence.

0:21:02.310 --> 0:21:05.629
<v Speaker 5>And violence has become their modus operandi, Andrew.

0:21:07.750 --> 0:21:07.910
<v Speaker 10>Look.

0:21:09.020 --> 0:21:11.320
<v Speaker 1>I know the chilling effect this can have. I mean,

0:21:11.440 --> 0:21:15.080
<v Speaker 1>I had to cut my own public appearances. I now

0:21:15.140 --> 0:21:18.560
<v Speaker 1>take much more care. I mean, there's been one Islamist

0:21:18.740 --> 0:21:23.540
<v Speaker 1>jailed for ordering me to be killed and got attacked

0:21:23.580 --> 0:21:26.179
<v Speaker 1>in the street by Antifa. And, you know, a lot

0:21:26.200 --> 0:21:28.590
<v Speaker 1>of people just think, oh, well, you know, but it's

0:21:28.640 --> 0:21:31.150
<v Speaker 1>not oh well. If you're always looking over your shoulder,

0:21:31.530 --> 0:21:36.110
<v Speaker 1>and now we know from Helen Haynes, you know, how

0:21:36.190 --> 0:21:39.620
<v Speaker 1>serious this can be. You can't just... do as I

0:21:39.900 --> 0:21:41.720
<v Speaker 1>too often have done and just thought, oh, well, I'll

0:21:41.760 --> 0:21:44.600
<v Speaker 1>go anyway, but, you know, don't care, won't happen. It

0:21:44.640 --> 0:21:49.360
<v Speaker 1>does happen. We just saw, perhaps we saw that happen today.

0:21:49.560 --> 0:21:52.070
<v Speaker 1>We have a grant from the Prime Minister just to

0:21:52.109 --> 0:21:53.510
<v Speaker 1>remind people of what he just said.

0:21:53.530 --> 0:21:58.510
<v Speaker 4>I can confirm that a suspect is in custody. The

0:21:58.530 --> 0:22:03.189
<v Speaker 4>Australian Federal Police, Victorian Police and Asia are working together

0:22:03.310 --> 0:22:06.560
<v Speaker 4>on this. It is too early in this investigation for

0:22:06.600 --> 0:22:10.450
<v Speaker 4>me to provide you with details. what the motivation is

0:22:10.690 --> 0:22:11.830
<v Speaker 4>behind this attack.

0:22:13.609 --> 0:22:18.050
<v Speaker 1>So there you go, Cameron. A suspect is in custody

0:22:18.570 --> 0:22:22.050
<v Speaker 1>with an accident that's not really a suspect. We can't

0:22:22.090 --> 0:22:25.560
<v Speaker 1>speculate a motive. There's not a motive if it's just

0:22:25.600 --> 0:22:30.180
<v Speaker 1>an accident. And security agencies are investigating. And, of course,

0:22:30.240 --> 0:22:34.300
<v Speaker 1>Tony Burke was there, who's overseas, some of those security agencies.

0:22:35.260 --> 0:22:39.230
<v Speaker 1>I'm afraid this is going to be Very bad news

0:22:39.320 --> 0:22:40.560
<v Speaker 1>when we get to the bottom of it.

0:22:42.840 --> 0:22:44.780
<v Speaker 11>Well, it may well be, but I also want to

0:22:44.800 --> 0:22:46.980
<v Speaker 11>be reminded by the fact that at moments like this,

0:22:47.060 --> 0:22:49.240
<v Speaker 11>Prime Ministers need to step up and lead the nation

0:22:49.280 --> 0:22:52.800
<v Speaker 11>with true courage. This is Albo's John Howard moment. I mean,

0:22:52.820 --> 0:22:55.139
<v Speaker 11>John Howard stood up after the Port Arthur massacre. He

0:22:55.180 --> 0:22:59.010
<v Speaker 11>went and publicly engaged even dangerous and difficult crowds. He

0:22:59.070 --> 0:23:01.550
<v Speaker 11>engaged and told people where the country needed to go.

0:23:01.570 --> 0:23:03.890
<v Speaker 11>And that's the moment that Albo needs to take now

0:23:04.270 --> 0:23:06.820
<v Speaker 11>if we're in such a serious situation that... A serving

0:23:06.859 --> 0:23:10.540
<v Speaker 11>member of parliament has been, you know, run down with

0:23:10.560 --> 0:23:13.910
<v Speaker 11>the intent, obviously, clearly, to cause severe injury, potentially worse.

0:23:16.770 --> 0:23:19.830
<v Speaker 1>Except I struggle to know what you can do, apart

0:23:19.850 --> 0:23:26.470
<v Speaker 1>from improve security. It behooves everyone, really, to tone it down,

0:23:26.550 --> 0:23:30.449
<v Speaker 1>tone down the hate, tone down the vicious mockery. And

0:23:30.470 --> 0:23:33.160
<v Speaker 1>I might have something to say about One Nation that

0:23:33.200 --> 0:23:35.820
<v Speaker 1>I was going to plan to say before all this.

0:23:36.380 --> 0:23:38.960
<v Speaker 1>later in this show. Michael Kroger, Cameron Milner, thank you

0:23:38.980 --> 0:23:42.200
<v Speaker 1>very much. Yeah, sorry, Michael, go ahead.

0:23:42.220 --> 0:23:44.600
<v Speaker 9>I was just going to say, not wanting to enter

0:23:44.640 --> 0:23:48.420
<v Speaker 9>into a discordant note, but Cameron, I think it's a

0:23:48.440 --> 0:23:53.060
<v Speaker 9>little late for Albo to have his Port Arthur moment

0:23:53.200 --> 0:23:56.460
<v Speaker 9>or Bali moment. I think it's a bit late for

0:23:56.500 --> 0:23:59.860
<v Speaker 9>him to be doing that, given the shocking state of social,

0:24:00.020 --> 0:24:02.520
<v Speaker 9>the lack of social cohesion in this country over the

0:24:02.560 --> 0:24:03.260
<v Speaker 9>last three years.

0:24:03.859 --> 0:24:07.450
<v Speaker 5>We know why it's happened. And I'll just leave it there.

0:24:07.490 --> 0:24:09.170
<v Speaker 5>People can draw their own conclusions.

0:24:11.810 --> 0:24:14.109
<v Speaker 1>I think you're right. I think we should have in

0:24:14.130 --> 0:24:17.629
<v Speaker 1>this context, and I feel terrible that you've had to

0:24:17.690 --> 0:24:21.110
<v Speaker 1>remind me of it, that we did just last December

0:24:21.150 --> 0:24:27.050
<v Speaker 1>have 15 people slaughtered at a Jewish festival. Now, what

0:24:27.090 --> 0:24:31.790
<v Speaker 1>was that other than the rising tide of intolerance and hatred,

0:24:32.190 --> 0:24:35.540
<v Speaker 1>lethal hatred in this country today? Thank you for reminding

0:24:35.580 --> 0:24:40.290
<v Speaker 1>me of that. After the break, Greg Sheridan and talking

0:24:40.310 --> 0:24:43.470
<v Speaker 1>about hatred in the riots in France, because they too

0:24:44.190 --> 0:24:53.600
<v Speaker 1>are a warning. More about Helen Haynes, the alleged attack

0:24:53.630 --> 0:24:57.780
<v Speaker 1>on her in a minute, but another warning, really, what

0:24:57.800 --> 0:25:01.460
<v Speaker 1>we saw in France on the weekend. Because these weren't

0:25:01.480 --> 0:25:04.050
<v Speaker 1>just protests, this was a, This is a civil war

0:25:04.190 --> 0:25:06.490
<v Speaker 1>and Australia's got to learn from that too before it

0:25:06.890 --> 0:25:09.659
<v Speaker 1>is too late for us as well. You look at

0:25:09.700 --> 0:25:13.860
<v Speaker 1>what France endured on the weekend, more than 550,000 protesters,

0:25:14.260 --> 0:25:19.810
<v Speaker 1>plus thugs and thieves and arsonists on the street in

0:25:19.890 --> 0:25:22.710
<v Speaker 1>dozens of French cities and towns. Many of the protests

0:25:22.770 --> 0:25:25.949
<v Speaker 1>were peaceful, of course, but many other protesters were fighting

0:25:26.010 --> 0:25:31.340
<v Speaker 1>police and Gendarmes hurting nearly 1,000 of them, plus, of course,

0:25:31.359 --> 0:25:35.199
<v Speaker 1>looting and burning cars and shops, burning even the historic

0:25:35.280 --> 0:25:39.430
<v Speaker 1>town hall of Limoges and cheering like animals, like an

0:25:39.470 --> 0:25:58.580
<v Speaker 1>invading army when the tower collapsed. French Prime Minister Sébastien

0:25:58.619 --> 0:26:01.880
<v Speaker 1>Le Corneau himself described this as a moment for people

0:26:01.920 --> 0:26:05.179
<v Speaker 1>to choose. Were they for the rioters who believed in

0:26:05.200 --> 0:26:08.000
<v Speaker 1>political violence or for France itself?

0:26:09.140 --> 0:26:12.129
<v Speaker 12>This is a political maneuver that embraces violence. Either you

0:26:12.190 --> 0:26:14.169
<v Speaker 12>are on the side of the rioters or you are

0:26:14.190 --> 0:26:16.310
<v Speaker 12>on the side of those who have a violent agenda

0:26:16.410 --> 0:26:18.190
<v Speaker 12>for the Republic and against the Republic.

0:26:19.910 --> 0:26:23.860
<v Speaker 1>President Emmanuel Macron was fiddling at a Celine Dion concert

0:26:23.900 --> 0:26:26.390
<v Speaker 1>on Friday night, which was hours before his country went

0:26:26.430 --> 0:26:29.330
<v Speaker 1>up in flames, went further implying that France was under

0:26:29.410 --> 0:26:32.429
<v Speaker 1>attack from people who could not call themselves French.

0:26:33.530 --> 0:26:36.010
<v Speaker 4>Watching these images we all asked ourselves what is in

0:26:36.050 --> 0:26:40.200
<v Speaker 4>their heads and how can French people do this to France?

0:26:42.440 --> 0:26:44.700
<v Speaker 1>But who are these people that the President and Prime

0:26:44.720 --> 0:26:49.619
<v Speaker 1>Minister say are at war with France? Let's make some

0:26:49.640 --> 0:26:52.619
<v Speaker 1>things clear because everyone looking at these riots just see the,

0:26:52.630 --> 0:26:55.970
<v Speaker 1>you know, sort of Rajash blot, just sees in them

0:26:55.990 --> 0:26:59.650
<v Speaker 1>what suits them politically to say. No, they weren't all Muslim.

0:27:00.130 --> 0:27:02.650
<v Speaker 1>The truth is worse and it's more dangerous and we've

0:27:02.670 --> 0:27:05.960
<v Speaker 1>got to learn from it. It is true, as I

0:27:05.980 --> 0:27:08.220
<v Speaker 1>said last week, that many of the rioters are clearly

0:27:08.240 --> 0:27:11.340
<v Speaker 1>of immigrant background, especially Muslim background, people who in general

0:27:11.500 --> 0:27:15.199
<v Speaker 1>have been hard to assimilate. And they include youths who

0:27:15.220 --> 0:27:17.960
<v Speaker 1>in the riots seem to love destroying the country that

0:27:18.000 --> 0:27:30.290
<v Speaker 1>took them or their parents in. But among them are

0:27:30.310 --> 0:27:33.710
<v Speaker 1>other students, not Muslim, just giddy with their power to destroy.

0:27:34.350 --> 0:27:37.510
<v Speaker 1>And then behind the scenes is the hard left, who

0:27:37.550 --> 0:27:39.910
<v Speaker 1>so often embrace violence to get what they can't win

0:27:40.380 --> 0:27:42.679
<v Speaker 1>in a vote. And above all that, of course, we

0:27:42.720 --> 0:27:46.180
<v Speaker 1>can't forget France's toxic love of revolutions. France to this

0:27:46.240 --> 0:27:50.070
<v Speaker 1>day still celebrates the incredibly violent and savage French Revolution,

0:27:50.550 --> 0:27:55.109
<v Speaker 1>celebrates it every Bastille Day, making that day in 1789

0:27:55.109 --> 0:27:58.970
<v Speaker 1>look supposedly heroic. You know, this heroic mob then attacked

0:27:59.010 --> 0:28:03.320
<v Speaker 1>the Bastille prison, in fact, slaughtering just slaughtering the seven

0:28:03.380 --> 0:28:07.139
<v Speaker 1>soldiers they took prisoner, beheading the commander, beheading another official,

0:28:07.460 --> 0:28:10.680
<v Speaker 1>sticking their heads on pikes and freeing just seven prisoners

0:28:11.200 --> 0:28:13.939
<v Speaker 1>that were held there, two madmen, four forgers and one

0:28:14.000 --> 0:28:18.300
<v Speaker 1>aristocrat jailed as a pervert. How stupid the French have

0:28:18.340 --> 0:28:22.570
<v Speaker 1>been to promote that barbarity as freedom, especially when it

0:28:22.590 --> 0:28:25.870
<v Speaker 1>led to civil war, dictatorship and Napoleonic wars that killed

0:28:25.910 --> 0:28:30.090
<v Speaker 1>some five million people. And now, here we are again.

0:28:30.910 --> 0:28:33.310
<v Speaker 1>Some journalists of the left, again, dressing up these violent

0:28:33.350 --> 0:28:37.620
<v Speaker 1>protests as, you know, also in a noble cause. Just

0:28:37.700 --> 0:28:41.180
<v Speaker 1>protests by students demanding more funding for schools. And that

0:28:41.240 --> 0:28:44.740
<v Speaker 1>president you just saw celebrating the bloody French Revolution is

0:28:44.760 --> 0:28:47.580
<v Speaker 1>now saying, well, this revolution, that is an attack on

0:28:47.640 --> 0:28:50.810
<v Speaker 1>France itself. But people aren't really French. We're a traitor

0:28:50.830 --> 0:28:53.330
<v Speaker 1>to this country. Let me repeat what you just heard.

0:28:54.350 --> 0:28:56.770
<v Speaker 1>How can French people do this to France?

0:28:57.170 --> 0:28:59.230
<v Speaker 12>Either you are on the side of the rioters, or

0:28:59.270 --> 0:29:00.690
<v Speaker 12>you are on the side of those who have a

0:29:00.750 --> 0:29:03.510
<v Speaker 12>violent agenda for the Republic and against the Republic.

0:29:05.430 --> 0:29:07.670
<v Speaker 1>But how many of these protesters on the weekend are

0:29:07.710 --> 0:29:10.240
<v Speaker 1>on the side of France, would choose France to defend?

0:29:11.620 --> 0:29:14.560
<v Speaker 1>Is it the children of Muslim immigrants who feature so

0:29:14.960 --> 0:29:20.240
<v Speaker 1>prominently in these riots? Are there protesters waving the flag

0:29:20.260 --> 0:29:24.860
<v Speaker 1>of Palestine, showing solidarity with a Muslim extremist who slaughtered

0:29:24.860 --> 0:29:29.280
<v Speaker 1>1,200 Jews on October 7th? carrying the Palestinian flag even

0:29:29.340 --> 0:29:32.400
<v Speaker 1>as they stormed the city hall in Marseilles, like some

0:29:32.520 --> 0:29:36.310
<v Speaker 1>foreign army? Or is the French government expecting France now

0:29:36.330 --> 0:29:38.510
<v Speaker 1>to be saved by protesters who fly flags of so

0:29:38.550 --> 0:29:43.010
<v Speaker 1>many other Muslim countries? Countries which follow a faith spread

0:29:43.070 --> 0:29:46.670
<v Speaker 1>by the sword? Will these protesters choose France, which has

0:29:47.100 --> 0:29:50.820
<v Speaker 1>so weakened itself with mass immigration? I've seen not just

0:29:51.210 --> 0:29:56.160
<v Speaker 1>Palestinian flags, but the flags of Morocco and Algeria, of Iraq,

0:29:56.520 --> 0:30:01.010
<v Speaker 1>of Egypt, all Muslim countries. Or do Francis Leder think

0:30:01.030 --> 0:30:04.670
<v Speaker 1>that France will be saved by the black-clad anarchists who

0:30:04.710 --> 0:30:08.020
<v Speaker 1>were causing so much havoc? Or by the street fighters

0:30:08.260 --> 0:30:10.080
<v Speaker 1>who chased and tripped a woman and then kicked her

0:30:10.160 --> 0:30:13.479
<v Speaker 1>again and again? Will France be saved by the hoods

0:30:14.380 --> 0:30:16.420
<v Speaker 1>that are so loving the power of violence that one

0:30:16.520 --> 0:30:18.830
<v Speaker 1>uses homemade flamethrower on the face of a woman who

0:30:18.870 --> 0:30:22.150
<v Speaker 1>tried to stop the vandalism? Or will France be saved

0:30:22.170 --> 0:30:23.850
<v Speaker 1>by the looters who bashed a man trying to save

0:30:23.890 --> 0:30:27.760
<v Speaker 1>his video store, kicked him to the ground? or by

0:30:27.800 --> 0:30:29.380
<v Speaker 1>the looters who have pushed aside the woman trying to

0:30:29.400 --> 0:30:33.469
<v Speaker 1>save another business from looters pleading with them, pleading with

0:30:33.530 --> 0:30:36.190
<v Speaker 1>them not to do this and just being pushed aside?

0:30:37.410 --> 0:30:39.870
<v Speaker 1>Or will France be saved by the hard-left Marxists of

0:30:39.890 --> 0:30:43.510
<v Speaker 1>La France Insoumise who, police say, whipped up the protests

0:30:43.530 --> 0:30:48.270
<v Speaker 1>with the party's mayor of Saint-Denis, Bali Bagayoko, filmed dancing

0:30:48.310 --> 0:30:50.750
<v Speaker 1>by a fire lit by protesters at a school?

0:30:51.880 --> 0:30:57.060
<v Speaker 13>So who exactly among this horrible mob of the hard left,

0:30:57.100 --> 0:31:01.380
<v Speaker 13>these Muslim immigrants, these anarchists and the greedy and the thieves,

0:31:01.400 --> 0:31:01.900
<v Speaker 13>does Le Corneau.

0:31:19.290 --> 0:31:22.550
<v Speaker 1>And Macron too. Do they expect these people to put

0:31:22.610 --> 0:31:27.090
<v Speaker 1>France first? Who are these people that Macron said aren't

0:31:27.130 --> 0:31:31.450
<v Speaker 1>really French? Maybe he's absolutely correct. People who are destroying

0:31:31.490 --> 0:31:34.190
<v Speaker 1>France instead. And don't we see that same alliance growing

0:31:34.250 --> 0:31:39.150
<v Speaker 1>right here? That alliance between Palestinian activists and the hard

0:31:39.170 --> 0:31:43.450
<v Speaker 1>left greens and the Aboriginal radicals and the Marxist groups

0:31:43.510 --> 0:31:46.960
<v Speaker 1>and the Jew haters and The hate preachers and the

0:31:47.020 --> 0:31:51.360
<v Speaker 1>climate extremists all joined by seeming loathing of Australia today,

0:31:51.460 --> 0:31:56.340
<v Speaker 1>telling you it's racist, it's genocidal. Now, I know we're

0:31:56.360 --> 0:31:58.660
<v Speaker 1>nothing like France. There's too few of these radicals to

0:31:58.680 --> 0:32:00.480
<v Speaker 1>worry about. But I tell you, it doesn't take long

0:32:01.620 --> 0:32:05.090
<v Speaker 1>before too few people to worry about become too many

0:32:05.120 --> 0:32:09.790
<v Speaker 1>to confront. And we see that right now in France. Now,

0:32:09.850 --> 0:32:11.830
<v Speaker 1>do we really want to wait until Australia looks like that?

0:32:12.690 --> 0:32:15.180
<v Speaker 1>Because right now, of course, we're seeing people say, oh, yes,

0:32:15.260 --> 0:32:18.920
<v Speaker 1>the cause is just. French schools are terrible. Schools go

0:32:18.960 --> 0:32:22.820
<v Speaker 1>to 6pm. Teachers are in short supply. But, oh, that's true,

0:32:22.860 --> 0:32:25.460
<v Speaker 1>of course, even though France spends more on education than

0:32:25.480 --> 0:32:29.210
<v Speaker 1>Germany and Britain. But you see, of course, socialism has

0:32:29.230 --> 0:32:33.290
<v Speaker 1>destroyed France. Those socialistic policies are destroying us because a

0:32:33.310 --> 0:32:35.650
<v Speaker 1>lot of their spending on schools goes to pay pensions

0:32:35.670 --> 0:32:40.240
<v Speaker 1>for retired teachers. And France is now dangerously broke. Massive debt.

0:32:40.780 --> 0:32:44.940
<v Speaker 1>Massive debt. and a retirement age still of just 62

0:32:44.940 --> 0:32:48.860
<v Speaker 1>for many. It is out of money, yet left us

0:32:48.900 --> 0:32:53.000
<v Speaker 1>demanding even more spending on everything from schools, hospitals and

0:32:53.100 --> 0:32:56.040
<v Speaker 1>pensions to God knows what, demanding other people's cash and

0:32:56.060 --> 0:32:59.200
<v Speaker 1>saying bugger to France. And if the protesters care so

0:32:59.220 --> 0:33:02.160
<v Speaker 1>much about schools, why burn down or severely damage 24

0:33:02.160 --> 0:33:05.110
<v Speaker 1>of them? Why burn buses and cars and shops and

0:33:05.990 --> 0:33:09.990
<v Speaker 1>why loot shops that are selling iPhones, Hermes and Jewelry

0:33:10.030 --> 0:33:14.250
<v Speaker 1>and sportswear, Wi-Fi flags in Muslim countries, that's not about

0:33:14.310 --> 0:33:18.030
<v Speaker 1>school funding. That's what you get when people think change

0:33:18.070 --> 0:33:23.290
<v Speaker 1>can be made by showing force or by burning things

0:33:23.870 --> 0:33:26.150
<v Speaker 1>or putting up barricades, when they think that's how you

0:33:26.190 --> 0:33:30.230
<v Speaker 1>get change, not by reason and the vote, calmly and peacefully.

0:33:31.300 --> 0:33:34.280
<v Speaker 1>And when you turn to violence, the violent will always

0:33:34.360 --> 0:33:37.900
<v Speaker 1>turn up, just for the fun of it, for the profits.

0:33:38.940 --> 0:33:42.540
<v Speaker 1>And who knows then who will win and where this goes.

0:33:43.220 --> 0:33:45.810
<v Speaker 1>So yes, this war in France is indeed a test

0:33:45.850 --> 0:33:49.070
<v Speaker 1>of people's loyalties. How many people in France are still

0:33:49.110 --> 0:33:53.030
<v Speaker 1>in the countryside? But ask how many people here will

0:33:53.050 --> 0:33:57.370
<v Speaker 1>be in our countryside when we too let ourselves become

0:33:57.430 --> 0:34:07.480
<v Speaker 1>that poor, that divided and that violent. I'm joined by

0:34:07.500 --> 0:34:10.219
<v Speaker 1>the country's top foreign affairs writer, Greg Sheridan of The Australian,

0:34:10.260 --> 0:34:12.360
<v Speaker 1>who wrote a great piece in The Australian on the

0:34:12.400 --> 0:34:15.480
<v Speaker 1>weekend about this war and France's democracy by the hard

0:34:15.540 --> 0:34:18.739
<v Speaker 1>left and by Islamists. Greg, thank you for your time.

0:34:18.840 --> 0:34:19.910
<v Speaker 1>What is at stake here?

0:34:21.070 --> 0:34:24.210
<v Speaker 14>Well, Andrew, it's good to be with you and I

0:34:24.510 --> 0:34:28.129
<v Speaker 14>share all your sentiments about Helen Haynes. I hope this

0:34:28.190 --> 0:34:30.390
<v Speaker 14>is not the terrible moment that we fear it is

0:34:30.469 --> 0:34:33.950
<v Speaker 14>and I hope she gets better soon. But France has

0:34:34.010 --> 0:34:38.680
<v Speaker 14>become ungovernable and We are nearer to that point than

0:34:38.719 --> 0:34:43.129
<v Speaker 14>we think. We suffer all the same pathologies. So there

0:34:43.190 --> 0:34:46.410
<v Speaker 14>is an alliance between the Islamists and the far left.

0:34:46.870 --> 0:34:49.970
<v Speaker 14>I would actually put more blame on the French far

0:34:50.030 --> 0:34:52.509
<v Speaker 14>left than I do on the Islamists, simply because there

0:34:52.550 --> 0:34:55.529
<v Speaker 14>are more of them. And they have an ideology of

0:34:55.630 --> 0:35:01.259
<v Speaker 14>hatred of France, which doesn't even arise from any conceivable experience.

0:35:02.000 --> 0:35:08.549
<v Speaker 14>The Anglo- or not Anglo, obviously the Caucasian French, like

0:35:08.610 --> 0:35:13.069
<v Speaker 14>all French, enjoy the most generous welfare state on the planet.

0:35:13.410 --> 0:35:18.120
<v Speaker 14>They are pampered from cradle to grave. They get free everything.

0:35:18.640 --> 0:35:21.920
<v Speaker 14>They have a retirement age at 62. They have the

0:35:22.040 --> 0:35:26.110
<v Speaker 14>slackest work conditions in the world. And yet, the minute

0:35:26.120 --> 0:35:30.649
<v Speaker 14>there is the slightest inconvenience, they want to have demonstrations

0:35:30.690 --> 0:35:31.230
<v Speaker 14>in the street.

0:35:31.370 --> 0:35:33.270
<v Speaker 1>It strikes me as absurd.

0:35:33.680 --> 0:35:37.399
<v Speaker 14>That anyone can claim that they are a nonviolent demonstrator

0:35:37.719 --> 0:35:41.520
<v Speaker 14>when they know that by having these massive demonstrations, they

0:35:41.580 --> 0:35:45.109
<v Speaker 14>will produce this massive violence. And I'll tell you some

0:35:45.150 --> 0:35:47.770
<v Speaker 14>of the innocent victims. Some of the innocent victims are

0:35:47.810 --> 0:35:50.730
<v Speaker 14>the thousand police who are injured because they're trying to

0:35:50.770 --> 0:35:56.379
<v Speaker 14>protect civilians from harm by these street fighting thugs. Now,

0:35:56.420 --> 0:35:59.000
<v Speaker 14>in democracy, you get fed up with the policies, you

0:35:59.020 --> 0:36:01.600
<v Speaker 14>change your government, you vote them out. But the far

0:36:01.680 --> 0:36:05.360
<v Speaker 14>left has an ideology which says democracy is a sham

0:36:05.739 --> 0:36:10.260
<v Speaker 14>and only direct action has validity. And the other factor

0:36:10.280 --> 0:36:14.920
<v Speaker 14>I'd mention is I'm sure that outside international actors, Russia,

0:36:14.980 --> 0:36:19.480
<v Speaker 14>Iran and probably China, are goading all this on social

0:36:19.540 --> 0:36:22.700
<v Speaker 14>media because we know that that's what they do. I'm

0:36:22.719 --> 0:36:25.600
<v Speaker 14>not saying they're a decisive factor, but so I think

0:36:25.640 --> 0:36:29.279
<v Speaker 14>there are three important actors, Islamists, the French far left,

0:36:30.070 --> 0:36:34.010
<v Speaker 14>and outside actors and the French public, especially its young people,

0:36:34.570 --> 0:36:38.080
<v Speaker 14>are so indoctrinated by left wing education that they think

0:36:38.160 --> 0:36:39.700
<v Speaker 14>somehow or other this.

0:36:39.600 --> 0:36:45.120
<v Speaker 1>Is morally righteous. Yeah, the same is happening right here,

0:36:45.219 --> 0:36:47.609
<v Speaker 1>as you know, Greg, and this is the thing, it's

0:36:47.680 --> 0:36:52.250
<v Speaker 1>not just Islamists attacking France, it's a lack of people

0:36:52.570 --> 0:36:57.540
<v Speaker 1>in France ethnically French, as it were, who are not

0:36:57.680 --> 0:37:00.660
<v Speaker 1>prepared to defend it. That is the problem. We have

0:37:00.680 --> 0:37:04.299
<v Speaker 1>the challenge, but we are too weak in responding. Now,

0:37:04.440 --> 0:37:10.640
<v Speaker 1>on that point, one problem is that Donald Trump, for instance,

0:37:10.719 --> 0:37:13.339
<v Speaker 1>I mentioned this in my columns last week, has been

0:37:13.390 --> 0:37:16.810
<v Speaker 1>a traitor to democracies himself. I'm sorry to To Trump fans,

0:37:16.850 --> 0:37:19.930
<v Speaker 1>to speak so bluntly, traitor is the word. He's been

0:37:20.010 --> 0:37:22.770
<v Speaker 1>selling out Ukraine. He's been blaming it for being invaded

0:37:22.810 --> 0:37:26.109
<v Speaker 1>by fascist Russia. He last week even bought Russian oil

0:37:26.130 --> 0:37:29.950
<v Speaker 1>or diesel. That's putting money in Putin's pocket to kill

0:37:30.030 --> 0:37:34.570
<v Speaker 1>Ukrainians and even crippled Ukraine satellite defences from Russian attack.

0:37:35.110 --> 0:37:37.870
<v Speaker 1>And now, Greg, there's a moment that could change history

0:37:37.989 --> 0:37:41.550
<v Speaker 1>even more for the very worse. Another Munich moment. Russian

0:37:41.570 --> 0:37:45.070
<v Speaker 1>war criminal Vladimir Putin today floating a plan to settle

0:37:45.180 --> 0:37:48.320
<v Speaker 1>Ukraine's fate with a summit next month just between him,

0:37:49.140 --> 0:37:53.280
<v Speaker 1>Putin and Trump and Chinese dictator Xi Jinping. No Ukraine.

0:37:54.340 --> 0:37:55.020
<v Speaker 1>What do you make of that?

0:37:56.239 --> 0:37:59.680
<v Speaker 14>Well, Andrew, just a footnote on the French stuff. I

0:37:59.700 --> 0:38:02.150
<v Speaker 14>don't think it's a question of ethnically French people coming

0:38:02.190 --> 0:38:03.070
<v Speaker 14>out to defend France.

0:38:03.170 --> 0:38:04.489
<v Speaker 1>I think every Democrat.

0:38:04.930 --> 0:38:08.670
<v Speaker 14>Whatever their ethnicity, including all the good Muslim Democrats in France,

0:38:09.180 --> 0:38:11.600
<v Speaker 14>would be wanting to defend France, but they don't want

0:38:11.620 --> 0:38:13.440
<v Speaker 14>to defend it physically. They don't want to go and

0:38:13.460 --> 0:38:17.870
<v Speaker 14>have a street fight with the maniacs in the protest.

0:38:17.950 --> 0:38:21.790
<v Speaker 14>They want to support parliamentary democracy and the institutions of France,

0:38:21.850 --> 0:38:25.070
<v Speaker 14>including the police. I agree with everything you said about Trump.

0:38:25.610 --> 0:38:29.390
<v Speaker 14>I can't believe even Trump would be outrageous enough to

0:38:29.530 --> 0:38:33.660
<v Speaker 14>settle the affairs of Ukraine by a three-power government. a

0:38:34.160 --> 0:38:38.120
<v Speaker 14>meeting with Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping. But one of

0:38:38.219 --> 0:38:42.520
<v Speaker 14>the deep elements of our civilizational crisis right now is

0:38:42.600 --> 0:38:46.460
<v Speaker 14>that the normal champion of Western civilization is the president

0:38:46.540 --> 0:38:49.420
<v Speaker 14>of the United States. That's part of the job description.

0:38:49.960 --> 0:38:54.279
<v Speaker 14>And Trump, for the moment, has betrayed Western civilization. He's

0:38:54.400 --> 0:38:58.220
<v Speaker 14>sold out Ukraine. He's pandered to Vladimir Putin. He's gone

0:38:58.330 --> 0:39:02.750
<v Speaker 14>soft on China. And he has no coherent direction at

0:39:02.790 --> 0:39:06.190
<v Speaker 14>the moment. The Democrats were terrible in office. Trump has

0:39:06.250 --> 0:39:10.520
<v Speaker 14>done some good things, but his own profound character flaws

0:39:10.880 --> 0:39:15.520
<v Speaker 14>have now seen him sell out every decent political value

0:39:16.460 --> 0:39:19.530
<v Speaker 14>he previously espoused. So hopefully after the.

0:39:19.700 --> 0:39:25.129
<v Speaker 1>Look, we're in a very dangerous position. The dangers are really...

0:39:24.670 --> 0:39:26.569
<v Speaker 1>I can't remember the last time we've been in so

0:39:26.610 --> 0:39:29.049
<v Speaker 1>much danger, Greg. Greg, I just want to show you...

0:39:29.800 --> 0:39:32.060
<v Speaker 1>Anthony Albanese. He's just sat down for an interview with

0:39:32.080 --> 0:39:34.080
<v Speaker 1>the ABC. Here's a little bit of it. Have a listen.

0:39:35.510 --> 0:39:40.950
<v Speaker 4>There was a deliberate act, it would appear. We don't

0:39:40.989 --> 0:39:45.779
<v Speaker 4>know what motivation is. So that is the work that's

0:39:45.820 --> 0:39:49.540
<v Speaker 4>being undertaken by the Victorian Police together with the Australian

0:39:49.600 --> 0:39:50.380
<v Speaker 4>Federal Police.

0:39:50.950 --> 0:39:54.570
<v Speaker 8>Were you aware of any previous threats of any kind

0:39:54.850 --> 0:39:56.090
<v Speaker 8>towards Helen Haynes?

0:39:56.969 --> 0:39:59.650
<v Speaker 4>I wasn't personally aware of any.

0:40:01.130 --> 0:40:02.910
<v Speaker 5>Threats to her personally.

0:40:03.370 --> 0:40:07.970
<v Speaker 4>What we do know is that the temperature has increased

0:40:08.450 --> 0:40:09.330
<v Speaker 4>in recent times.

0:40:11.360 --> 0:40:13.420
<v Speaker 1>I'm running out of time, Greg, but what do you

0:40:13.500 --> 0:40:18.219
<v Speaker 1>think this attack will do to Australia, alleged attack?

0:40:18.239 --> 0:40:21.040
<v Speaker 14>Well, I hate, like you, Andrew, I hate, I just

0:40:21.120 --> 0:40:25.360
<v Speaker 14>hate the incivility at the core of everything. Can't anybody

0:40:25.460 --> 0:40:29.190
<v Speaker 14>smile anymore? Can't you disagree? Can't you say that fellow's

0:40:29.230 --> 0:40:32.290
<v Speaker 14>a bit silly or a chook or something? You know,

0:40:32.390 --> 0:40:35.350
<v Speaker 14>Australian abuse used to be so friendly, you know, you'd

0:40:35.390 --> 0:40:38.160
<v Speaker 14>say it's a bit of a rat bag or something. I.

0:40:39.810 --> 0:40:43.509
<v Speaker 14>Fear if we are now getting to deadly attacks. We

0:40:43.550 --> 0:40:46.770
<v Speaker 14>don't know yet, but if we're getting to that, you know,

0:40:46.810 --> 0:40:48.410
<v Speaker 14>we've been on the brink of that for a long

0:40:48.450 --> 0:40:51.920
<v Speaker 14>time and you're right to reference the deadly attacks in Bondi.

0:40:52.219 --> 0:40:55.560
<v Speaker 14>That's why I say we have the same pathologies as France.

0:40:55.900 --> 0:40:58.540
<v Speaker 14>They're just not quite so intense at the moment. And

0:40:58.560 --> 0:41:01.660
<v Speaker 14>this might be a very bad moment in our national history.

0:41:05.050 --> 0:41:09.469
<v Speaker 1>Greg, this is an ugly day. Ugliness in Europe, ugliness here.

0:41:09.960 --> 0:41:11.740
<v Speaker 1>Thank you so much for your time.

0:41:12.200 --> 0:41:12.379
<v Speaker 12>Thanks.

0:41:12.600 --> 0:41:15.080
<v Speaker 1>Before the break, the Victoria Police have also had a

0:41:15.100 --> 0:41:19.930
<v Speaker 1>press conference on the alleged attack on Federal MP Helen Haynes.

0:41:20.050 --> 0:41:20.820
<v Speaker 1>Here's a little bit of it.

0:41:21.989 --> 0:41:25.930
<v Speaker 15>A 43-year-old male driver of the vehicle involved in this

0:41:25.969 --> 0:41:31.049
<v Speaker 15>collision was detained by civilians, witnesses to the incident, and

0:41:31.070 --> 0:41:34.680
<v Speaker 15>then arrested by police upon their arrival. That male is

0:41:34.719 --> 0:41:37.220
<v Speaker 15>currently at the Wangaratta Police Station. and will be interviewed

0:41:37.260 --> 0:41:40.759
<v Speaker 15>by investigators. We've got the Major Collision Investigation Unit, who

0:41:40.780 --> 0:41:43.029
<v Speaker 15>are currently en route from Melbourne. They are coming up

0:41:43.230 --> 0:41:45.370
<v Speaker 15>to assist with processing the crime scene.

0:41:45.630 --> 0:41:48.029
<v Speaker 1>Is the male a local resident?

0:41:48.070 --> 0:41:50.689
<v Speaker 15>The male that has been arrested is a 43-year-old male

0:41:50.710 --> 0:41:51.390
<v Speaker 15>from Tarrawindji.

0:41:52.050 --> 0:41:54.930
<v Speaker 3>Any reports that these two are known to each other?

0:41:55.250 --> 0:41:57.430
<v Speaker 15>Nothing to indicate at this stage that the parties are known,

0:41:57.469 --> 0:41:59.460
<v Speaker 15>but they will be subject to the investigation.

0:42:02.500 --> 0:42:06.040
<v Speaker 1>Well, after the break, some ugliness from One Nation that

0:42:06.100 --> 0:42:09.440
<v Speaker 1>in the circumstances, I think they should better, they had

0:42:09.460 --> 0:42:18.570
<v Speaker 1>better repent. Now, look, I don't, I want to be fair.

0:42:18.590 --> 0:42:22.390
<v Speaker 1>I don't want anyone to think that I'm blaming in

0:42:22.489 --> 0:42:24.710
<v Speaker 1>any way One Nation for what happened to Helen Haynes.

0:42:24.790 --> 0:42:29.450
<v Speaker 1>It's absolutely not my intention. And I'm sure that Pauline

0:42:29.469 --> 0:42:31.040
<v Speaker 1>Hanson would be as shocked as I am by what

0:42:31.080 --> 0:42:36.590
<v Speaker 1>happened and appalled I am going to say something I

0:42:36.650 --> 0:42:40.490
<v Speaker 1>planned to say before news of that attack, alleged attack,

0:42:40.710 --> 0:42:44.509
<v Speaker 1>actually happened, because I'm sick of the cultural destruction that

0:42:44.550 --> 0:42:47.660
<v Speaker 1>we face, the stridency and the meanness and all that.

0:42:48.050 --> 0:42:51.340
<v Speaker 1>And I'm afraid that One Nation has, in my opinion,

0:42:51.380 --> 0:42:54.640
<v Speaker 1>become disgusting now in how it's pandering to the cruel

0:42:54.739 --> 0:42:58.400
<v Speaker 1>and to the heartless and to the barbaric to win votes. Now,

0:42:58.420 --> 0:43:02.120
<v Speaker 1>you take as popular Please Explain cartoons, which trash Liberal

0:43:02.200 --> 0:43:06.759
<v Speaker 1>MPs Andrew Hastie, former SAS captain, as a traitor, a

0:43:06.969 --> 0:43:11.660
<v Speaker 1>traitor for speaking out against horrific alleged war crimes by

0:43:11.700 --> 0:43:16.719
<v Speaker 1>Ben Robert Smith. I mean, that's appalling enough, disgusting. But

0:43:16.800 --> 0:43:19.770
<v Speaker 1>now it's mocking Senator Jackie Lambie as well, after she

0:43:19.810 --> 0:43:22.630
<v Speaker 1>last week spoke out for a fellow veteran with a

0:43:22.670 --> 0:43:27.330
<v Speaker 1>distressing medical condition that Lambie also had, raising awareness of

0:43:27.390 --> 0:43:32.310
<v Speaker 1>pelvic organ prolapse. which One Nation turned into a cheap

0:43:32.730 --> 0:43:34.250
<v Speaker 1>and cruel smear.

0:43:34.270 --> 0:43:37.920
<v Speaker 12>I can't laugh because of me prolapsed vagina.

0:43:37.960 --> 0:43:40.439
<v Speaker 3>They ain't told me they've made fun of that, have they?

0:43:40.460 --> 0:43:42.739
<v Speaker 7>No, that'd be very distasteful.

0:43:46.350 --> 0:43:49.230
<v Speaker 1>Now, I'll show that not to mock Lambie one little bit.

0:43:49.910 --> 0:43:53.989
<v Speaker 1>but to show you exactly how cruel and disgusting One

0:43:54.050 --> 0:43:56.960
<v Speaker 1>Nation can be when it puts its mind to it.

0:43:57.330 --> 0:44:00.810
<v Speaker 1>But Pauline Hanson and her cartoonist today were shameless.

0:44:02.210 --> 0:44:05.250
<v Speaker 3>You know, Jackie Lambie, get over it, OK? It is

0:44:05.350 --> 0:44:09.589
<v Speaker 3>actually satirical and I think she's taken to heart, which

0:44:09.610 --> 0:44:11.640
<v Speaker 3>she shouldn't be, you know. Have a good look at it.

0:44:11.910 --> 0:44:12.739
<v Speaker 3>Have a bit of a.

0:44:12.719 --> 0:44:15.020
<v Speaker 11>Laugh, Jackie, and lighten up.

0:44:15.680 --> 0:44:18.700
<v Speaker 10>I woke up this morning not thinking about Jackie Lambie's

0:44:19.410 --> 0:44:21.450
<v Speaker 10>prolapse vagina, I woke up this morning thinking about the

0:44:21.489 --> 0:44:27.600
<v Speaker 10>problems facing Victoria. Not only do I not really care

0:44:27.620 --> 0:44:30.760
<v Speaker 10>about the political implications, I can't.

0:44:31.360 --> 0:44:37.700
<v Speaker 1>I physically can't care. It's called satire. That's what we do. Mark,

0:44:37.719 --> 0:44:39.250
<v Speaker 1>if that's your sense of humour, I don't want you

0:44:39.290 --> 0:44:43.710
<v Speaker 1>in Parliament. And, Pauline, was I supposed to laugh along?

0:44:43.730 --> 0:44:46.630
<v Speaker 1>Was Gina supposed to laugh along? Gina Reinhart, when the

0:44:46.670 --> 0:44:52.040
<v Speaker 1>ABC cruelly... told a joke about, well, I won't go

0:44:52.080 --> 0:44:55.360
<v Speaker 1>into it, a disgusting joke about mincing her guts to paste.

0:44:56.270 --> 0:44:58.969
<v Speaker 1>Was that supposed to be ha-ha-ha, just satire? Joining me

0:44:59.030 --> 0:45:01.770
<v Speaker 1>are Lisa Goddard, former foreign correspondent and founder of Adani

0:45:01.810 --> 0:45:05.530
<v Speaker 1>Media and News24 host of The Nika to Georgia. Lisa,

0:45:05.610 --> 0:45:06.230
<v Speaker 1>your response.

0:45:08.450 --> 0:45:10.630
<v Speaker 8>Yeah, Andrew, look, you won't hear me side with Jackie

0:45:10.670 --> 0:45:13.730
<v Speaker 8>Lambie very often, but on this one I do think

0:45:13.810 --> 0:45:17.170
<v Speaker 8>that her health issues should have been off limits. I

0:45:17.210 --> 0:45:20.049
<v Speaker 8>think satire, it can't be a cover for. It was

0:45:20.090 --> 0:45:23.049
<v Speaker 8>basically humiliating her. I think it's fair game when you're

0:45:23.090 --> 0:45:26.330
<v Speaker 8>discussing policy or conduct when they're a politician and in

0:45:26.370 --> 0:45:28.469
<v Speaker 8>the public eye. But on this one, I think it

0:45:28.510 --> 0:45:32.370
<v Speaker 8>went a bit too far. The issue is, though, right,

0:45:32.430 --> 0:45:34.900
<v Speaker 8>we're sitting here tonight talking about it. I've looked at

0:45:34.930 --> 0:45:37.480
<v Speaker 8>the number of views. This has served the exact purpose

0:45:37.500 --> 0:45:39.620
<v Speaker 8>that One Nation wants it to serve, which is it's

0:45:39.660 --> 0:45:43.100
<v Speaker 8>getting more and more eyeballs. So that's the problem you've got.

0:45:43.140 --> 0:45:44.600
<v Speaker 8>The more we talk about it, the more people are

0:45:44.620 --> 0:45:46.279
<v Speaker 8>going to watch it, which is more it's going to

0:45:46.340 --> 0:45:49.280
<v Speaker 8>do exactly what it was designed to do. So Jackie

0:45:49.320 --> 0:45:50.660
<v Speaker 8>Lambie did put it out there. I think she was

0:45:50.680 --> 0:45:53.640
<v Speaker 8>incredibly brave and very vulnerable to say that on the

0:45:53.680 --> 0:45:55.700
<v Speaker 8>floor of Parliament, as she did about 10 days ago.

0:45:55.719 --> 0:45:57.839
<v Speaker 8>And like I said, very rarely will you hear me

0:45:57.890 --> 0:46:01.609
<v Speaker 8>defend her publicly You're right, it was pretty ugly.

0:46:01.630 --> 0:46:07.420
<v Speaker 1>Danika, is there a defence you can mount on what

0:46:07.460 --> 0:46:09.420
<v Speaker 1>was done to Jackie Lambie there?

0:46:10.360 --> 0:46:13.820
<v Speaker 3>No, it was a low blow and it was completely disrespectful.

0:46:14.200 --> 0:46:16.930
<v Speaker 7>And Jackie Lambie was actually quite brave to come out

0:46:16.969 --> 0:46:19.270
<v Speaker 7>and talk about that because there is a stigma in

0:46:19.330 --> 0:46:21.430
<v Speaker 7>Australia and around the world around that condition.

0:46:21.510 --> 0:46:23.370
<v Speaker 3>And it's actually more common than what you think. A

0:46:23.410 --> 0:46:24.250
<v Speaker 3>lot of women do.

0:46:24.190 --> 0:46:27.460
<v Speaker 7>Suffer it through childbirth. And to have more women like

0:46:27.500 --> 0:46:29.420
<v Speaker 7>Jackie Lambie come out and talk about it, I actually

0:46:29.440 --> 0:46:31.960
<v Speaker 7>think it helps the situation. And like Lisa, you will

0:46:32.000 --> 0:46:34.780
<v Speaker 7>never really find me coming out and defending Jackie Lambie.

0:46:34.840 --> 0:46:37.100
<v Speaker 3>But in this case, it would. Now, One Nation has

0:46:37.140 --> 0:46:39.520
<v Speaker 3>got to be very, very careful here.

0:46:39.760 --> 0:46:43.880
<v Speaker 7>It certainly has the upper hand across Australian political spectrum.

0:46:44.660 --> 0:46:47.060
<v Speaker 7>But the problem is when you make comments like this

0:46:47.180 --> 0:46:48.259
<v Speaker 7>or you think it's so funny.

0:46:48.640 --> 0:46:50.390
<v Speaker 3>You actually alienate women.

0:46:51.210 --> 0:46:53.989
<v Speaker 7>And given that women make up quite a significant number

0:46:54.010 --> 0:46:57.910
<v Speaker 7>of the voting population, you ought to be very, very careful.

0:46:57.969 --> 0:47:00.009
<v Speaker 7>And I think that the analogy you use with the

0:47:00.050 --> 0:47:03.670
<v Speaker 7>Gina Reinhart incident, you know, none of us thought that

0:47:03.710 --> 0:47:04.370
<v Speaker 7>that was funny.

0:47:04.489 --> 0:47:07.109
<v Speaker 3>Are we really seriously supposed to think this is funny?

0:47:07.290 --> 0:47:07.760
<v Speaker 3>It's sick.

0:47:08.239 --> 0:47:10.860
<v Speaker 7>And quite frankly, even just watching that just then, I

0:47:11.780 --> 0:47:13.620
<v Speaker 7>felt disturbed. I didn't like it at all.

0:47:15.969 --> 0:47:18.690
<v Speaker 1>If you only apply your principles to your friends and

0:47:18.710 --> 0:47:21.650
<v Speaker 1>not to your enemies, then you have no principles at all.

0:47:22.270 --> 0:47:25.089
<v Speaker 1>Just by the way, Lisa, I'm sorry this segment's really

0:47:25.110 --> 0:47:27.110
<v Speaker 1>short because of the distressing news at the top of

0:47:27.130 --> 0:47:33.630
<v Speaker 1>the show. We've shown you the people the horrible scenes

0:47:33.710 --> 0:47:36.050
<v Speaker 1>in France. I would have thought that would frighten Australians

0:47:36.130 --> 0:47:39.390
<v Speaker 1>stupid and make them resolve not to repeat them here.

0:47:39.690 --> 0:47:43.239
<v Speaker 1>Here are students at Sydney University's hard-lift Students' Representative Council

0:47:43.280 --> 0:47:44.470
<v Speaker 1>on the way, sending their love.

0:47:45.610 --> 0:47:48.469
<v Speaker 12>From the Union of Students of the University of Sydney,

0:47:48.489 --> 0:47:51.050
<v Speaker 12>we bring all our support to high school.

0:47:50.750 --> 0:47:53.150
<v Speaker 5>Students who block their high school with a lot of

0:47:53.190 --> 0:47:56.540
<v Speaker 5>courage and face systemic injustice. The movement must continue.

0:48:03.820 --> 0:48:06.960
<v Speaker 1>They made clear they were supporting students, but still, I

0:48:07.000 --> 0:48:09.399
<v Speaker 1>thought that was ill-advised. Your thoughts, Lisa?

0:48:11.190 --> 0:48:12.950
<v Speaker 8>Yeah, completely agree. And I can tell you what, I

0:48:12.969 --> 0:48:14.890
<v Speaker 8>don't know about you, but I didn't see many French

0:48:14.989 --> 0:48:18.509
<v Speaker 8>students in their French school uniforms out there looting Louis

0:48:18.530 --> 0:48:23.560
<v Speaker 8>Vuitton or stores or burning down historic buildings in France

0:48:23.700 --> 0:48:26.880
<v Speaker 8>over the weekend. So, no, completely outrageous. And it's frightening

0:48:26.920 --> 0:48:29.260
<v Speaker 8>because you watch the protests that happen in the streets

0:48:29.300 --> 0:48:31.180
<v Speaker 8>here in this country and the flags that are being

0:48:31.239 --> 0:48:33.700
<v Speaker 8>flown there, very similar to what we're seeing in France

0:48:33.800 --> 0:48:34.779
<v Speaker 8>and other parts of Europe. Same thing.

0:48:36.710 --> 0:48:39.990
<v Speaker 1>Lisa Goddard, Danica DiGiorgio again. Sorry it's so short. Thank

0:48:40.010 --> 0:48:43.120
<v Speaker 1>you for your time. Coming up next, Shari Markson. Good night.