WEBVTT - Paul Murray Live | 21 September

0:00:02.640 --> 0:00:07.380
<v Speaker 1>This is Paul Murray Live. Thank you, Dee.

0:00:07.420 --> 0:00:10.840
<v Speaker 2>I never get enough of the opportunity to praise Danika DiGiorgio.

0:00:10.960 --> 0:00:13.500
<v Speaker 2>She is a spectacular presenter, isn't she? You can see

0:00:13.540 --> 0:00:16.530
<v Speaker 2>her digital show, Danika Goes Global, on our YouTube channel, and,

0:00:16.540 --> 0:00:18.340
<v Speaker 2>of course, you can see her with The Late Debate

0:00:18.430 --> 0:00:21.120
<v Speaker 2>each and every evening straight after us. So I'm pleased

0:00:21.140 --> 0:00:22.669
<v Speaker 2>we got to see her before, but, of course, you

0:00:22.690 --> 0:00:24.650
<v Speaker 2>get to see the full team each and every night

0:00:24.810 --> 0:00:27.190
<v Speaker 2>after us here on News 24.

0:00:27.190 --> 0:00:30.110
<v Speaker 1>Now, tonight, what are we going to talk about? Petrol prices.

0:00:30.390 --> 0:00:30.590
<v Speaker 2>Why?

0:00:30.610 --> 0:00:30.680
<v Speaker 3>Why?

0:00:30.930 --> 0:00:33.709
<v Speaker 2>Because it cost me literally almost $ 200 to film my car.

0:00:34.350 --> 0:00:36.269
<v Speaker 2>But where's the Prime Minister? Well, he's about to go

0:00:36.290 --> 0:00:38.840
<v Speaker 2>and accept an award for being a great global citizen, because,

0:00:38.880 --> 0:00:41.360
<v Speaker 2>you know, when Australian Prime Ministers start to care about

0:00:41.380 --> 0:00:44.339
<v Speaker 2>the world more than what's happening here, it never ends well.

0:00:44.780 --> 0:00:47.300
<v Speaker 2>The Intergenerational Report came out today. This is sort of

0:00:47.479 --> 0:00:50.220
<v Speaker 2>Christmas for nerds. It happens every couple of years. It

0:00:50.260 --> 0:00:52.330
<v Speaker 2>gives us an insight into where our country is headed.

0:00:52.390 --> 0:00:53.129
<v Speaker 2>It is not good news.

0:00:53.170 --> 0:00:53.650
<v Speaker 1>Tim Wilson.

0:00:54.080 --> 0:00:56.360
<v Speaker 2>is the shadow treasurer. He will give us his opinion

0:00:56.500 --> 0:00:59.240
<v Speaker 2>in a couple of minutes' time. A reminder, this weekend

0:00:59.260 --> 0:01:01.160
<v Speaker 2>we're going to be in Bathurst for Our Town. It

0:01:01.220 --> 0:01:03.800
<v Speaker 2>is a massive room, so we need the biggest crowd

0:01:03.840 --> 0:01:06.250
<v Speaker 2>we have ever had. If you are a fan of

0:01:06.270 --> 0:01:08.550
<v Speaker 2>Paul Murray Live or News 24, if you can get

0:01:08.950 --> 0:01:11.950
<v Speaker 2>to Bathurst, the Motor Museum, on Sunday night, send us

0:01:11.990 --> 0:01:14.170
<v Speaker 2>an email right now. I need to fill the room, OK?

0:01:14.569 --> 0:01:19.390
<v Speaker 2>Ourtown at news24. com. au.

0:01:16.650 --> 0:01:18.950
<v Speaker 1>Thanks to the good people of Harvey Norman. We are there.

0:01:19.069 --> 0:01:20.710
<v Speaker 2>Bathurst, a couple of weeks out from the race, but

0:01:20.750 --> 0:01:24.929
<v Speaker 2>I promise it's a whole lot more than just broom-brooms. Now,

0:01:24.950 --> 0:01:27.610
<v Speaker 2>we have a Prime Minister and a Treasurer who would

0:01:27.650 --> 0:01:30.360
<v Speaker 2>like to think that economic management is one of their

0:01:30.390 --> 0:01:34.920
<v Speaker 2>strong suits. The reality is it is anything but. And

0:01:34.940 --> 0:01:39.680
<v Speaker 2>Australian politics is often about distracting from the reality of

0:01:39.740 --> 0:01:43.120
<v Speaker 2>our circumstances and we fall for the distractions, like a

0:01:43.140 --> 0:01:46.010
<v Speaker 2>Prime Minister who campaigns on an issue that no one

0:01:46.270 --> 0:01:48.270
<v Speaker 2>was going to change, and that, of course, was Medicare.

0:01:48.620 --> 0:01:51.230
<v Speaker 2>You've got political figures like Jackie Lambie who, well, if

0:01:51.310 --> 0:01:54.530
<v Speaker 2>she yells louder than whatever the boring report is that day,

0:01:54.870 --> 0:01:58.930
<v Speaker 2>that's where the coverage goes. But the intergenerational report is

0:01:58.970 --> 0:02:03.010
<v Speaker 2>something that's been around since the Costello-Howard years in terms

0:02:03.050 --> 0:02:05.650
<v Speaker 2>of economic management. I know that it was the Howard-Costello years.

0:02:06.550 --> 0:02:08.850
<v Speaker 2>And there is one graphic that I've shown you now

0:02:08.950 --> 0:02:11.850
<v Speaker 2>since the last intergenerational report almost every week.

0:02:12.830 --> 0:02:13.370
<v Speaker 1>It's this one.

0:02:14.050 --> 0:02:16.549
<v Speaker 2>This is the one that shows that inside that red

0:02:16.610 --> 0:02:22.480
<v Speaker 2>box is every expected budget deficit between now and the 2060s.

0:02:23.600 --> 0:02:26.820
<v Speaker 2>That number, and every one of those lines, of course,

0:02:27.000 --> 0:02:29.660
<v Speaker 2>adds up. The deeper the deficit, the deeper the debt.

0:02:30.690 --> 0:02:34.049
<v Speaker 2>A trillion dollars of debt is what we're in right now,

0:02:34.169 --> 0:02:36.930
<v Speaker 2>and if all of that's true, then we're on our

0:02:36.970 --> 0:02:42.850
<v Speaker 2>way towards 1.2 and 1.5 T4 trillion dollars debt. Now,

0:02:42.889 --> 0:02:45.310
<v Speaker 2>Jim Chalmers thinks the politics doesn't matter about all of

0:02:45.350 --> 0:02:49.760
<v Speaker 2>this because, well... There's other things to distract you. But

0:02:49.780 --> 0:02:52.610
<v Speaker 2>the reality is, be it a house, a business or

0:02:52.650 --> 0:02:56.830
<v Speaker 2>a country, if you constantly spend more than you get in,

0:02:56.889 --> 0:02:58.970
<v Speaker 2>then guess what? You get into a world of trouble.

0:03:00.060 --> 0:03:03.820
<v Speaker 2>And confirmed yet again today by the Intergenerational Report is

0:03:03.840 --> 0:03:07.960
<v Speaker 2>something that cuts through the distraction, the spin, and a

0:03:08.020 --> 0:03:10.940
<v Speaker 2>sobering reality of our country is now upon us.

0:03:12.700 --> 0:03:16.540
<v Speaker 4>Across the whole 40 years, the federal budget is tipped

0:03:16.700 --> 0:03:18.140
<v Speaker 4>to stay in the red.

0:03:20.060 --> 0:03:26.450
<v Speaker 2>For the next 40 years, Australia has budget deficits. Now,

0:03:26.470 --> 0:03:27.990
<v Speaker 2>tonight I want to talk about what is a very

0:03:28.050 --> 0:03:31.169
<v Speaker 2>provocative proposal, but it is one that I truly believe.

0:03:32.450 --> 0:03:38.670
<v Speaker 2>Australia is broke and is broken. This report tells us

0:03:38.750 --> 0:03:43.420
<v Speaker 2>three big things that really matter. We'll get to all

0:03:43.440 --> 0:03:46.680
<v Speaker 2>of these things. But first, no light at the end

0:03:46.900 --> 0:03:48.120
<v Speaker 2>of that deficit tunnel.

0:03:48.160 --> 0:03:48.800
<v Speaker 1>It really matters.

0:03:50.470 --> 0:03:58.010
<v Speaker 2>Because, of course, it all started way back when, when

0:03:58.030 --> 0:03:59.670
<v Speaker 2>we decided to get rid of the Howard government and

0:03:59.710 --> 0:04:02.750
<v Speaker 2>we went from money in the bank to owing the

0:04:02.770 --> 0:04:06.770
<v Speaker 2>world an awful lot of money. Then COVID happened and

0:04:06.790 --> 0:04:10.240
<v Speaker 2>we owed the world an awful lot more. then this

0:04:10.300 --> 0:04:13.740
<v Speaker 2>government happened and we owe the world even more money

0:04:13.810 --> 0:04:18.349
<v Speaker 2>because the government is obsessed with taking $ 1 from here

0:04:18.430 --> 0:04:22.570
<v Speaker 2>and spending $ 2 over there. They want to say that

0:04:22.610 --> 0:04:24.610
<v Speaker 2>we've clipped the ticket a little bit here and we've

0:04:24.670 --> 0:04:26.630
<v Speaker 2>changed this there and we've raised a little bit of

0:04:26.670 --> 0:04:28.470
<v Speaker 2>tax there and we've pulled a bit of spending down,

0:04:28.529 --> 0:04:32.820
<v Speaker 2>but fundamentally what was the case three years ago is

0:04:33.260 --> 0:04:37.640
<v Speaker 2>even more the case today. And when confronted about this fact,

0:04:38.089 --> 0:04:41.650
<v Speaker 2>Jim Chalmers, who is a great believer in modern monetary theory.

0:04:41.690 --> 0:04:43.590
<v Speaker 2>This is the idea that you can run up debt

0:04:43.670 --> 0:04:46.330
<v Speaker 2>if you're a government because nobody will ever call it in.

0:04:47.000 --> 0:04:48.760
<v Speaker 2>This is what he had to say when he couldn't hide,

0:04:48.800 --> 0:04:52.240
<v Speaker 2>when he couldn't distract, when the reality was that the

0:04:52.279 --> 0:04:54.380
<v Speaker 2>same people who put the budget together every year are

0:04:54.420 --> 0:04:57.299
<v Speaker 2>telling us that there will be a deficit every year

0:04:58.180 --> 0:05:01.500
<v Speaker 2>until the time of the Jetsons. Remember that cartoon series

0:05:01.520 --> 0:05:06.010
<v Speaker 2>from the 1960s, Bubble Cars and Robot Maids? Well, that

0:05:06.050 --> 0:05:11.720
<v Speaker 2>was set in 2062. These deficits now go till 2065.

0:05:12.700 --> 0:05:16.310
<v Speaker 5>We shouldn't assume that the risks to that 1.2 productivity

0:05:16.370 --> 0:05:19.510
<v Speaker 5>number are all to the downside. As you can see

0:05:19.550 --> 0:05:22.290
<v Speaker 5>in that scenario we presented for AI in particular, there

0:05:22.330 --> 0:05:24.770
<v Speaker 5>are upside risks as well to that productivity number. And

0:05:24.790 --> 0:05:27.870
<v Speaker 5>so we think the 1.2 strikes.

0:05:27.529 --> 0:05:28.690
<v Speaker 1>A pretty effective balance.

0:05:30.110 --> 0:05:32.650
<v Speaker 2>Now, what he's talking about is percentage of GDP. Rather

0:05:32.860 --> 0:05:34.940
<v Speaker 2>than talking about raw dollars, right?

0:05:35.839 --> 0:05:38.419
<v Speaker 1>If you... Percentage of GDP, normal people go.

0:05:40.960 --> 0:05:42.820
<v Speaker 2>But the graph that was so clear that I've been

0:05:42.839 --> 0:05:44.839
<v Speaker 2>able to show you for the past three years is

0:05:44.900 --> 0:05:47.479
<v Speaker 2>one that does immense political damage to the government that

0:05:47.500 --> 0:05:50.190
<v Speaker 2>wants to distract from the reality of its choices. It

0:05:50.250 --> 0:05:52.290
<v Speaker 2>makes the choices for the settings as to whether we

0:05:52.350 --> 0:05:55.310
<v Speaker 2>are anywhere near a surplus or whether we go into deficit. And, OK,

0:05:55.350 --> 0:05:57.010
<v Speaker 2>a little bit up here, a little bit down there,

0:05:57.029 --> 0:05:59.350
<v Speaker 2>but when it's all down, for the next 40 years,

0:05:59.370 --> 0:06:00.210
<v Speaker 2>we're in a world of trouble.

0:06:01.750 --> 0:06:03.190
<v Speaker 1>So, of course, eagerly, I was.

0:06:03.700 --> 0:06:06.659
<v Speaker 2>running through the pages of the Intergenerational Report looking for

0:06:06.700 --> 0:06:09.440
<v Speaker 2>whatever the latest version of this was. Do you think

0:06:09.460 --> 0:06:11.350
<v Speaker 2>there's a chance they were trying to present what is

0:06:11.380 --> 0:06:14.770
<v Speaker 2>called statistical noise because this was the version of the

0:06:14.810 --> 0:06:21.230
<v Speaker 2>graph that existed in today's? No one can obviously easily

0:06:21.350 --> 0:06:24.870
<v Speaker 2>see that scribble. So I'll take away the scribble and

0:06:24.910 --> 0:06:29.040
<v Speaker 2>I'll show you what it actually looks like. It still

0:06:29.080 --> 0:06:33.550
<v Speaker 2>looks like budget deficits for the next 40 years. So

0:06:33.589 --> 0:06:36.720
<v Speaker 2>nice try, Jim, of course, whose doctorate is in the

0:06:36.860 --> 0:06:41.820
<v Speaker 2>spin of the economy of Paul Keating. But the document

0:06:42.120 --> 0:06:44.779
<v Speaker 2>still tells the story. The graph is still there to

0:06:44.820 --> 0:06:48.520
<v Speaker 2>be seen. And if Australia is spending more money than

0:06:48.580 --> 0:06:50.870
<v Speaker 2>it is taking in for the next 40 years and

0:06:50.910 --> 0:06:52.429
<v Speaker 2>we owe more than a trillion dollars.

0:06:53.110 --> 0:06:53.850
<v Speaker 1>We're broke.

0:06:55.490 --> 0:06:59.430
<v Speaker 2>Second point here. Australians are going to have fewer babies,

0:06:59.990 --> 0:07:02.150
<v Speaker 2>which means less tax for the government. So how do

0:07:02.180 --> 0:07:06.960
<v Speaker 2>they fill the tax hole? Well, more migration. If people

0:07:07.000 --> 0:07:09.060
<v Speaker 2>are old enough to remember what a street directory is,

0:07:09.920 --> 0:07:11.460
<v Speaker 2>then you will understand this metaphor.

0:07:11.540 --> 0:07:14.860
<v Speaker 1>If not, think of it as your Google Maps. This

0:07:14.940 --> 0:07:16.180
<v Speaker 1>is both the.

0:07:16.160 --> 0:07:19.760
<v Speaker 2>Street directory for where we're going and the receipt book

0:07:20.020 --> 0:07:22.060
<v Speaker 2>of where we have been. And all of it results

0:07:22.140 --> 0:07:25.000
<v Speaker 2>in a bigger Australia as a result not of people

0:07:25.040 --> 0:07:27.520
<v Speaker 2>having babies. And the single biggest reason why people don't

0:07:27.540 --> 0:07:30.730
<v Speaker 2>have babies in Australia is because it's too damn expensive.

0:07:32.120 --> 0:07:34.180
<v Speaker 2>The blue at the bottom of that graph is the

0:07:34.220 --> 0:07:36.040
<v Speaker 2>number of people that are having babies. See how that

0:07:36.080 --> 0:07:41.720
<v Speaker 2>gets replaced by the green, which is migration. Governments don't

0:07:41.800 --> 0:07:46.560
<v Speaker 2>want babies because, of course, babies cost money, not just

0:07:46.580 --> 0:07:48.610
<v Speaker 2>for the citizen but, of course, for the government too.

0:07:49.110 --> 0:07:52.390
<v Speaker 2>You see, when you were born, there's childcare, then there's

0:07:52.430 --> 0:07:54.950
<v Speaker 2>primary school, then there's high school, then there's university or

0:07:54.990 --> 0:07:55.490
<v Speaker 2>there's TAFE.

0:07:56.230 --> 0:07:58.430
<v Speaker 1>So they want... People who are.

0:07:58.390 --> 0:08:01.770
<v Speaker 2>Over the age of 18, theoretically skilled, theoretically able to

0:08:01.810 --> 0:08:06.680
<v Speaker 2>work from day one and therefore pay tax. So this

0:08:06.760 --> 0:08:11.920
<v Speaker 2>is by design that the system works by just bringing

0:08:11.940 --> 0:08:16.920
<v Speaker 2>more people in. We're still heading to 40 million people.

0:08:17.720 --> 0:08:19.420
<v Speaker 2>They're saying today, well, it won't be as fast as

0:08:19.440 --> 0:08:22.650
<v Speaker 2>it was in the past. No, that's the trajectory. Again,

0:08:22.890 --> 0:08:24.750
<v Speaker 2>they haven't just put in a line saying what this

0:08:24.830 --> 0:08:26.440
<v Speaker 2>report says. They put in a whole bunch of other

0:08:26.540 --> 0:08:28.220
<v Speaker 2>ones of, well, what we said three years ago, what

0:08:28.240 --> 0:08:29.260
<v Speaker 2>we said six years ago, what we.

0:08:29.240 --> 0:08:29.940
<v Speaker 1>Said nine years ago.

0:08:30.300 --> 0:08:33.280
<v Speaker 2>The line is still clear, uppity up, up, up, until

0:08:33.300 --> 0:08:39.420
<v Speaker 2>you're past 40 to 45 million people. And again, you

0:08:39.440 --> 0:08:44.390
<v Speaker 2>get there not through babies, but you get there through migration.

0:08:48.490 --> 0:08:53.680
<v Speaker 2>The third point about all of this. is that people

0:08:53.700 --> 0:08:56.540
<v Speaker 2>are living longer. Great, awesome, all of us wanna live forever,

0:08:57.260 --> 0:09:00.520
<v Speaker 2>but of course we can't. And the reality is, is

0:09:00.540 --> 0:09:03.860
<v Speaker 2>that retirement is in and around your mid 60s. Theoretically

0:09:03.900 --> 0:09:07.040
<v Speaker 2>superannuation pays for your retirement, right? No, it'll pay for

0:09:07.070 --> 0:09:10.349
<v Speaker 2>a comfortable five, maybe seven, maybe 10 years, depending on

0:09:10.410 --> 0:09:14.410
<v Speaker 2>how you were able to play the system. But of course,

0:09:15.550 --> 0:09:17.050
<v Speaker 2>the whole way that you're able to pay for your

0:09:17.190 --> 0:09:22.060
<v Speaker 2>aged care, either at home or in a facility, It's

0:09:22.100 --> 0:09:25.020
<v Speaker 2>because you bought a house, you paid off a house,

0:09:25.440 --> 0:09:26.590
<v Speaker 2>and the house is worth a whole lot more than

0:09:26.610 --> 0:09:28.730
<v Speaker 2>when you bought it, so you can sell the house

0:09:28.830 --> 0:09:31.550
<v Speaker 2>and the money left over goes into your aged care.

0:09:33.470 --> 0:09:36.270
<v Speaker 2>But of course, this government has made a series of

0:09:36.340 --> 0:09:40.480
<v Speaker 2>choices in the last budget that are deliberately about breaking

0:09:40.740 --> 0:09:45.460
<v Speaker 2>that nexus. So you're going to live longer, but you're

0:09:45.480 --> 0:09:49.120
<v Speaker 2>going to run out of money. Now, if you're somebody

0:09:49.160 --> 0:09:51.120
<v Speaker 2>who that won't affect in the next 10 years or

0:09:51.120 --> 0:09:53.720
<v Speaker 2>20 years, great. You've lived your life. You've worked damn

0:09:53.760 --> 0:09:57.030
<v Speaker 2>hard to be able to pay your house off, to

0:09:57.050 --> 0:09:59.150
<v Speaker 2>be able to one day sell your house, to be

0:09:59.210 --> 0:10:02.260
<v Speaker 2>able to pay for that aged care. But for the

0:10:02.300 --> 0:10:05.360
<v Speaker 2>kids and for the grandkids, the picture is pretty damn bleak,

0:10:07.360 --> 0:10:10.110
<v Speaker 2>which is why I say that the country is broke

0:10:10.890 --> 0:10:17.510
<v Speaker 2>and broken, because you have a scenario where mass immigration

0:10:17.530 --> 0:10:20.959
<v Speaker 2>is constantly adding to every queue. There is nothing in

0:10:20.980 --> 0:10:23.380
<v Speaker 2>the intergenerational report about how many new hospitals need to

0:10:23.420 --> 0:10:25.880
<v Speaker 2>be built. There's no suggestion about how many new roads

0:10:25.900 --> 0:10:27.500
<v Speaker 2>are going to be built. There's no suggestion about how

0:10:27.520 --> 0:10:34.250
<v Speaker 2>many schools have to be built. Instead, debt forever, migration

0:10:34.290 --> 0:10:36.770
<v Speaker 2>replaces babies because they pay tax from day one, not

0:10:36.770 --> 0:10:40.630
<v Speaker 2>18 years after. And despite the fact that you need

0:10:40.650 --> 0:10:42.650
<v Speaker 2>more money for your retirement, they've made a decision to

0:10:42.690 --> 0:10:46.490
<v Speaker 2>make your house to be sold for less, meaning you're

0:10:46.510 --> 0:10:46.750
<v Speaker 2>going to.

0:10:46.710 --> 0:10:51.410
<v Speaker 1>Struggle with your retirement. But, of course, we get back

0:10:51.450 --> 0:10:52.670
<v Speaker 1>to distraction politics.

0:10:53.940 --> 0:10:56.800
<v Speaker 2>And Jim Chalmers was very keen to, of course, blame

0:10:56.840 --> 0:10:59.120
<v Speaker 2>everything on Donald Trump because he'll be around forever, right?

0:10:59.420 --> 0:10:59.660
<v Speaker 7>No.

0:10:59.960 --> 0:11:03.900
<v Speaker 2>Remember, he leaves office in 2029. We're talking about problems

0:11:03.920 --> 0:11:06.420
<v Speaker 2>that go all the way through the 2030s, the 2040s,

0:11:06.470 --> 0:11:08.490
<v Speaker 2>the 2050s, the 2060s.

0:11:10.150 --> 0:11:10.689
<v Speaker 1>But don't worry.

0:11:10.929 --> 0:11:13.350
<v Speaker 2>Jim had a lovely thing to distract the media today.

0:11:13.750 --> 0:11:16.229
<v Speaker 2>Don't worry about the structural deficit. Don't worry about the

0:11:16.290 --> 0:11:18.429
<v Speaker 2>lack of retirement. Don't worry about migration.

0:11:18.580 --> 0:11:19.630
<v Speaker 1>Instead....

0:11:29.720 --> 0:11:31.360
<v Speaker 2>And do you think there's a chance that that trick

0:11:31.420 --> 0:11:33.319
<v Speaker 2>worked on the media? Did they talk about any of

0:11:33.360 --> 0:11:35.740
<v Speaker 2>the three things that I just talked about? Or did

0:11:35.760 --> 0:11:36.439
<v Speaker 2>they talk about.

0:11:37.540 --> 0:11:38.280
<v Speaker 1>You know the answer.

0:11:39.540 --> 0:11:44.830
<v Speaker 8>The Treasurer's 40-year forecast points to superannuation gains and service

0:11:44.870 --> 0:11:49.229
<v Speaker 8>sector growth, but acknowledges the rapid push into AI... will

0:11:49.270 --> 0:11:51.589
<v Speaker 8>force significant workplace shifts.

0:11:52.150 --> 0:11:55.819
<v Speaker 4>But artificial intelligence is cast as profound.

0:11:56.030 --> 0:11:59.559
<v Speaker 5>And the biggest economic transformation of our lifetime.

0:12:01.120 --> 0:12:02.640
<v Speaker 2>Now, the Prime Minister, of course, is in the United

0:12:02.660 --> 0:12:04.060
<v Speaker 2>States right now. And, you know, I don't talk about

0:12:04.080 --> 0:12:06.360
<v Speaker 2>domestic murders while I'm overseas, unless, of course, I'm finding

0:12:06.400 --> 0:12:08.240
<v Speaker 2>some way to bag One Nation. But whatever, that rule

0:12:08.260 --> 0:12:11.680
<v Speaker 2>doesn't apply. There was the absurdity of him hanging out

0:12:11.720 --> 0:12:14.820
<v Speaker 2>with the Apple executives on a weekend where clearly no-one's

0:12:14.840 --> 0:12:18.189
<v Speaker 2>doing work at Apple Park on a Saturday. And just conveniently,

0:12:18.210 --> 0:12:19.750
<v Speaker 2>he happened to turn out when they've got brand new

0:12:19.790 --> 0:12:21.350
<v Speaker 2>phones and the flip phone coming out in the next

0:12:21.390 --> 0:12:23.439
<v Speaker 2>couple of days because there's no reason that Apple would

0:12:23.460 --> 0:12:25.819
<v Speaker 2>want the free publicity, gladly given here by a prime

0:12:25.840 --> 0:12:29.700
<v Speaker 2>minister who's apparently learning about parental controls, that anyone would

0:12:29.720 --> 0:12:31.210
<v Speaker 2>have been able to show him in his office. But

0:12:31.330 --> 0:12:33.690
<v Speaker 2>nobody can film that, right? And now he's off to

0:12:33.730 --> 0:12:35.560
<v Speaker 2>New York where, of course, he's about to become a...

0:12:36.340 --> 0:12:38.850
<v Speaker 2>awarded global citizen. Reminds me a little bit of when

0:12:38.880 --> 0:12:41.690
<v Speaker 2>Wayne Swan was the world's best treasurer. Who was working

0:12:41.730 --> 0:12:44.630
<v Speaker 2>for him then? That's right, Jim Chalmers. See, it pays

0:12:44.670 --> 0:12:46.530
<v Speaker 2>to pay attention. That's why I'm glad you're here each

0:12:46.550 --> 0:12:49.790
<v Speaker 2>and every night. And despite the fact that petrol is

0:12:49.990 --> 0:12:52.370
<v Speaker 2>through the roof, I mentioned almost 200 bucks to fill

0:12:53.670 --> 0:12:55.530
<v Speaker 2>a 10-year-old car that runs on diesel. Because, you know,

0:12:55.530 --> 0:12:56.960
<v Speaker 2>10 years ago, that was what you did, right? You

0:12:56.980 --> 0:12:59.640
<v Speaker 2>bought the diesel car because in the end it'll end

0:12:59.679 --> 0:13:03.780
<v Speaker 2>up working. Well, no, of course, petrol prices through the roof. Here's...

0:13:04.740 --> 0:13:07.560
<v Speaker 2>The past couple of weeks in Sydney, when it comes

0:13:07.620 --> 0:13:11.810
<v Speaker 2>to normal unleaded petrol, the same in Melbourne and the

0:13:11.830 --> 0:13:14.150
<v Speaker 2>same in Brisbane, where it's now $ 2.

0:13:13.470 --> 0:13:17.850
<v Speaker 1>40 a litre. It's close to or over $ 3 for

0:13:17.970 --> 0:13:20.150
<v Speaker 1>diesel right now, but shh, nothing to see here.

0:13:20.850 --> 0:13:22.350
<v Speaker 2>And again, because we've been around for a while, we

0:13:22.390 --> 0:13:26.020
<v Speaker 2>remember what they promised, what they said, the each-way elbow

0:13:26.140 --> 0:13:29.140
<v Speaker 2>of it all. And I remind myself of a tweet,

0:13:30.340 --> 0:13:34.230
<v Speaker 2>November 16, 2021. Do you reckon Scott Morrison has been

0:13:34.250 --> 0:13:36.949
<v Speaker 2>to a petrol station lately? Petrol prices are surging on

0:13:36.990 --> 0:13:38.770
<v Speaker 2>his watch. He was complaining when.

0:13:38.690 --> 0:13:39.189
<v Speaker 1>It was $ 1.

0:13:38.890 --> 0:13:39.040
<v Speaker 6>79.

0:13:39.040 --> 0:13:39.360
<v Speaker 1>$ 1.

0:13:39.040 --> 0:13:39.199
<v Speaker 9>79.

0:13:39.200 --> 0:13:43.620
<v Speaker 1>Right now, $ 2. 39 in Sydney. Right now, $ 2. 32 in Melbourne.

0:13:43.620 --> 0:13:55.860
<v Speaker 2>$ 2. 31 right now in Brisbane.

0:13:55.900 --> 0:13:56.540
<v Speaker 1>But, you know, whatever.

0:13:56.880 --> 0:13:58.810
<v Speaker 2>We can't hold them to account for that. I'm overseas

0:13:58.830 --> 0:14:01.650
<v Speaker 2>doing international stuff. I'm saving the world. I'm dealing with

0:14:01.670 --> 0:14:03.689
<v Speaker 2>climate change. What about China? Don't worry about it.

0:14:04.130 --> 0:14:06.290
<v Speaker 1>I'm fixing the world of social media. Hang on.

0:14:06.309 --> 0:14:08.089
<v Speaker 2>By giving the minister the power to get rid of

0:14:08.130 --> 0:14:11.190
<v Speaker 2>the things that she thinks is harmful without checking with

0:14:11.230 --> 0:14:11.810
<v Speaker 2>anyone else?

0:14:12.130 --> 0:14:13.630
<v Speaker 1>No, nothing to see here. Nothing to see here.

0:14:14.940 --> 0:14:16.679
<v Speaker 2>And, of course, this government that claims to be all

0:14:16.720 --> 0:14:20.320
<v Speaker 2>about cost of living. Well, they're doing something about this. Oh, no,

0:14:20.400 --> 0:14:20.820
<v Speaker 2>that's right.

0:14:20.840 --> 0:14:21.520
<v Speaker 1>Nothing. Nothing.

0:14:22.330 --> 0:14:24.770
<v Speaker 2>Because they have to take 52 cents per litre of

0:14:24.870 --> 0:14:27.930
<v Speaker 2>every litre of petrol that is purchased, no matter the price,

0:14:28.330 --> 0:14:32.990
<v Speaker 2>in Australia right now. So blow me down with the

0:14:33.270 --> 0:14:37.410
<v Speaker 2>feather that supposedly last week was this horrible week for

0:14:37.490 --> 0:14:40.290
<v Speaker 2>Pauline Hanson and One Nation. This from a podcast, that

0:14:40.340 --> 0:14:43.200
<v Speaker 2>from a podcast. Did you hear what she said about the.

0:14:43.140 --> 0:14:45.080
<v Speaker 1>Prime Minister's mum? Well, guess what?

0:14:45.120 --> 0:14:48.700
<v Speaker 2>The reality of people who are paying that much for petrol,

0:14:48.960 --> 0:14:53.330
<v Speaker 2>they don't care. The latest news poll, and you've heard

0:14:53.350 --> 0:14:56.730
<v Speaker 2>this all night, has shown that Labor is down the

0:14:56.750 --> 0:14:59.880
<v Speaker 2>best part of 10 points in the past year in

0:14:59.940 --> 0:15:03.180
<v Speaker 2>news poll. But let's go back to the election. Labor

0:15:03.300 --> 0:15:07.360
<v Speaker 2>is down 7.6%. The coalition is down 12.8%. One Nation's

0:15:07.400 --> 0:15:11.350
<v Speaker 2>up 23%. The Greens are up almost a point. And

0:15:11.370 --> 0:15:15.400
<v Speaker 2>the independent and others category is down four. One Nation

0:15:15.440 --> 0:15:17.940
<v Speaker 2>back as the number one most popular political party in

0:15:17.980 --> 0:15:20.760
<v Speaker 2>the country, confirmed we will find out or not tomorrow

0:15:20.780 --> 0:15:22.500
<v Speaker 2>night in the News 24 Pulse.

0:15:23.000 --> 0:15:26.260
<v Speaker 1>Then Labor, then Daylight, then the Libs, then the Greens,

0:15:26.420 --> 0:15:26.950
<v Speaker 1>then others.

0:15:28.850 --> 0:15:32.170
<v Speaker 2>So while the question was a little bit mean, I

0:15:32.290 --> 0:15:34.730
<v Speaker 2>did enjoy it like everyone else did, that the man

0:15:34.750 --> 0:15:39.410
<v Speaker 2>who's about to be a globally awarded citizen is actually

0:15:39.710 --> 0:15:41.610
<v Speaker 2>not running the joint that well for those of us

0:15:41.850 --> 0:15:43.090
<v Speaker 2>who pay his wage.

0:15:44.640 --> 0:15:44.950
<v Speaker 10>Now, Mr.

0:15:45.000 --> 0:15:47.410
<v Speaker 3>Here in New York, on Wednesday night, you will receive

0:15:47.430 --> 0:15:50.890
<v Speaker 3>an award for being a global citizen. Don't you feel

0:15:50.910 --> 0:15:53.310
<v Speaker 3>like a bit of a fraud accepting this award when,

0:15:53.530 --> 0:15:56.690
<v Speaker 3>at home, you screwed up the response to the worst

0:15:56.730 --> 0:16:00.150
<v Speaker 3>massacre since Port Arthur? In the polls, you are taking

0:16:00.250 --> 0:16:03.130
<v Speaker 3>later to one point shy of Julie Gillard when.

0:16:02.990 --> 0:16:03.650
<v Speaker 6>You trolled her.

0:16:04.430 --> 0:16:06.860
<v Speaker 3>And your net negatives are worse than Scott Morrison.

0:16:07.410 --> 0:16:07.550
<v Speaker 11>No.

0:16:12.950 --> 0:16:15.910
<v Speaker 2>Now, because of preferences, there's still a chance that if

0:16:15.930 --> 0:16:18.330
<v Speaker 2>there was an election, he ends up falling to a minority,

0:16:18.370 --> 0:16:21.750
<v Speaker 2>so going from the 90s into the 70s, and he

0:16:21.790 --> 0:16:23.370
<v Speaker 2>can take his pick of a couple of greens, a

0:16:23.390 --> 0:16:25.729
<v Speaker 2>couple of teals. So the chance of a change of government, sadly,

0:16:26.050 --> 0:16:28.150
<v Speaker 2>not there, but it ain't heading in the right direction.

0:16:29.290 --> 0:16:31.750
<v Speaker 2>Can we talk about the behaviour of footy fans over

0:16:31.770 --> 0:16:35.470
<v Speaker 2>the weekend? Now, I'm a fully card-carrying bogan, but I

0:16:35.510 --> 0:16:37.750
<v Speaker 2>tell you where it stops, and that's physically hurting other

0:16:37.790 --> 0:16:40.490
<v Speaker 2>people or picking stuff up and throwing it at people.

0:16:41.540 --> 0:16:44.110
<v Speaker 2>I don't know why people do this and I understand

0:16:44.150 --> 0:16:46.130
<v Speaker 2>how passionate we can get and I understand how fired

0:16:46.170 --> 0:16:48.450
<v Speaker 2>up we can get and I get how metaphorically, you know,

0:16:48.990 --> 0:16:51.550
<v Speaker 2>you're throwing things at the telly but throwing stuff at

0:16:51.570 --> 0:16:54.410
<v Speaker 2>the ref, well, that's a whole new game. Now, yes,

0:16:54.950 --> 0:16:57.489
<v Speaker 2>Orias fans or Waz fans, of course, as they should

0:16:57.510 --> 0:17:00.510
<v Speaker 2>be known, disappointed because they were expecting to make their

0:17:00.530 --> 0:17:02.790
<v Speaker 2>way towards a grand final and I think many people

0:17:03.390 --> 0:17:05.350
<v Speaker 2>were hoping that they'd win the comp because they've never

0:17:05.410 --> 0:17:09.729
<v Speaker 2>won the comp. But at Eden Park where they had

0:17:09.780 --> 0:17:13.820
<v Speaker 2>their journey finished, Some of the reactions towards the referees

0:17:13.880 --> 0:17:25.250
<v Speaker 2>was outrageous. You can be pissed off, but you can't

0:17:25.410 --> 0:17:29.090
<v Speaker 2>start getting physical. It was way worse in the AFL. Hawthorne,

0:17:29.130 --> 0:17:31.250
<v Speaker 2>of course, lost their chance to make it to a

0:17:31.290 --> 0:17:34.700
<v Speaker 2>grand final. They too blamed the refs in all directions

0:17:35.220 --> 0:17:47.210
<v Speaker 2>and things got really out of hand there. of course,

0:17:47.250 --> 0:17:52.590
<v Speaker 2>the Lions on their way to another grand final. And

0:17:52.609 --> 0:17:56.430
<v Speaker 2>the Hawthorne coach was not very subtle about, well, not

0:17:56.510 --> 0:17:59.510
<v Speaker 2>really disagreeing with the fans, not agreeing with the fans

0:17:59.530 --> 0:18:01.629
<v Speaker 2>who threw the stuff, but not disagreeing with the fans

0:18:01.650 --> 0:18:03.730
<v Speaker 2>who were angry enough to want to throw stuff.

0:18:04.960 --> 0:18:06.660
<v Speaker 6>I don't mean the umpires have got a very difficult job.

0:18:08.340 --> 0:18:11.179
<v Speaker 6>I mean, how they performed in key moments will be reviewed.

0:18:12.460 --> 0:18:15.520
<v Speaker 2>Ah, how they performed in key moments, rather than, oh,

0:18:15.560 --> 0:18:18.150
<v Speaker 2>that's the game, that's the way it is. Well, unsurprisingly,

0:18:18.210 --> 0:18:19.880
<v Speaker 2>there has been quite the pile on, and I think

0:18:19.900 --> 0:18:22.480
<v Speaker 2>rightly so, about the coach and about his reaction here.

0:18:22.520 --> 0:18:25.140
<v Speaker 2>So he was on SEN this afternoon and said the

0:18:25.220 --> 0:18:28.379
<v Speaker 2>umpires have got an enormously difficult job. I go and

0:18:28.420 --> 0:18:30.550
<v Speaker 2>watch kids play sport. The way people treat the umpires

0:18:30.590 --> 0:18:32.709
<v Speaker 2>is very important all the way through. We have to

0:18:32.730 --> 0:18:35.149
<v Speaker 2>set a very high bar for what we expect in

0:18:35.210 --> 0:18:38.770
<v Speaker 2>that area. I wouldn't call it a pattern of behaviour.

0:18:38.810 --> 0:18:40.710
<v Speaker 2>We need to make sure our umpires are respected and

0:18:40.750 --> 0:18:41.390
<v Speaker 2>treated that way.

0:18:41.410 --> 0:18:42.040
<v Speaker 1>Well, of course.

0:18:42.700 --> 0:18:45.159
<v Speaker 2>Hence why, even when it doesn't go your way, you

0:18:45.180 --> 0:18:46.840
<v Speaker 2>can't turn around and say, well, you know, they will

0:18:46.980 --> 0:18:51.619
<v Speaker 2>review their decisions. So there is yet another grand final,

0:18:51.640 --> 0:18:53.530
<v Speaker 2>which will all involve a Melbourne team.

0:18:53.550 --> 0:18:53.950
<v Speaker 1>And that's fine.

0:18:53.970 --> 0:18:55.690
<v Speaker 2>It's a national comp and it's good to see. It'll

0:18:55.710 --> 0:18:59.869
<v Speaker 2>be Frio versus Brisbane. So could somebody please explain to

0:18:59.910 --> 0:19:03.330
<v Speaker 2>me how the Victorian government justifies a public holiday on Friday,

0:19:03.790 --> 0:19:05.770
<v Speaker 2>presumably for everyone to turn up to cheer on their

0:19:05.810 --> 0:19:10.200
<v Speaker 2>local team, in the AFL parade, the grand final parade,

0:19:10.240 --> 0:19:12.800
<v Speaker 2>which happens the day before the game on Saturday.

0:19:13.920 --> 0:19:16.040
<v Speaker 1>I'm not sure how that's going to go.

0:19:16.980 --> 0:19:18.740
<v Speaker 2>So you just get a public holiday even though no

0:19:19.140 --> 0:19:23.130
<v Speaker 2>Victorian teams are in the grand final, of course.

0:19:23.570 --> 0:19:24.899
<v Speaker 1>And, of course, nobody will promise to change it.

0:19:24.930 --> 0:19:25.110
<v Speaker 7>Why?

0:19:25.130 --> 0:19:28.710
<v Speaker 2>Because, you know, election, November. Nicholas Rees is the Melbourne

0:19:28.730 --> 0:19:30.090
<v Speaker 2>Lord Mayor. I'll ask him about it in a couple

0:19:30.109 --> 0:19:34.170
<v Speaker 2>of minutes' time, along with Matt Canavan. Now, as you know,

0:19:34.270 --> 0:19:37.680
<v Speaker 2>plenty of hand-wringing when Pauline Hanson boots out members of

0:19:37.720 --> 0:19:40.899
<v Speaker 2>the Australian media from press conferences. Now, we know that

0:19:40.920 --> 0:19:42.939
<v Speaker 2>the reason this happens for the ABC is because the

0:19:43.000 --> 0:19:47.969
<v Speaker 2>ABC publicly named a staffer from One Nation who was

0:19:48.000 --> 0:19:50.160
<v Speaker 2>low level, not a decision maker, but because they work

0:19:50.180 --> 0:19:53.619
<v Speaker 2>for One Nation, let's effectively dox them. That's why the

0:19:53.680 --> 0:19:57.300
<v Speaker 2>ABC is constantly banned from One Nation events. They've also

0:19:57.790 --> 0:19:59.950
<v Speaker 2>decided to ban The Guardian because, of course, The Guardian

0:19:59.990 --> 0:20:02.670
<v Speaker 2>does nothing other than try to dig as much dirt

0:20:02.690 --> 0:20:06.470
<v Speaker 2>as they possibly can on Pauline Hanson. Well, then there's

0:20:06.490 --> 0:20:08.910
<v Speaker 2>the situation that's happening in the United States that is

0:20:09.190 --> 0:20:12.370
<v Speaker 2>way worse than what is playing out here in Australia,

0:20:12.410 --> 0:20:15.210
<v Speaker 2>because the government is running out of the White House.

0:20:15.290 --> 0:20:18.250
<v Speaker 2>Donald Trump, of course, is the president. And they literally

0:20:18.270 --> 0:20:23.060
<v Speaker 2>have written into their Bill of Rights the freedom of

0:20:23.080 --> 0:20:31.919
<v Speaker 2>the press. So a whole collection from MSNOW, the former MSNBC, CNN, Politico,

0:20:31.960 --> 0:20:34.810
<v Speaker 2>which is a sort of insider Washington, very lefty but

0:20:34.850 --> 0:20:38.250
<v Speaker 2>still inside Washington media organisation, and the Associated.

0:20:37.830 --> 0:20:40.710
<v Speaker 1>Press have all been banned, not allowed to walk onto

0:20:40.730 --> 0:20:42.080
<v Speaker 1>the grounds of the White House.

0:20:43.380 --> 0:20:45.320
<v Speaker 2>Now, I do think part of the theory here may

0:20:45.400 --> 0:20:48.220
<v Speaker 2>well have been that all of the press then turn

0:20:48.240 --> 0:20:49.840
<v Speaker 2>around and they also decide, well, that's it, if you're

0:20:49.859 --> 0:20:51.040
<v Speaker 2>going to treat one like that, you're going to treat

0:20:51.060 --> 0:20:52.460
<v Speaker 2>like all like that, so we're all going out in

0:20:52.480 --> 0:20:54.570
<v Speaker 2>solidarity and we think we all know what the Trumpster

0:20:54.590 --> 0:20:56.689
<v Speaker 2>would do, which is lock the door behind them and

0:20:56.710 --> 0:20:59.149
<v Speaker 2>probably reopen the swimming pool, which is what the.

0:20:59.510 --> 0:21:02.670
<v Speaker 1>Press room used to be. He does know how to renovate.

0:21:04.050 --> 0:21:06.629
<v Speaker 2>But to show how the left has been reacting to it,

0:21:06.710 --> 0:21:09.409
<v Speaker 2>let's go to the most reasonable voice we could find.

0:21:10.070 --> 0:21:11.330
<v Speaker 1>And by that I'm taking the piss.

0:21:11.430 --> 0:21:15.640
<v Speaker 2>Here's Rachel Maddow reacting, of course, the hard left cable

0:21:15.660 --> 0:21:16.560
<v Speaker 2>TV host in the US.

0:21:19.430 --> 0:21:24.670
<v Speaker 12>What he's doing is just blatantly, plainly, on its face, illegal.

0:21:24.690 --> 0:21:26.830
<v Speaker 1>It'll be struck down by the courts and then we'll

0:21:26.869 --> 0:21:28.689
<v Speaker 1>have to have a big fight about him obeying the

0:21:28.730 --> 0:21:31.870
<v Speaker 1>court order that inevitably tells him to let our reporters

0:21:31.910 --> 0:21:34.530
<v Speaker 1>back in. And I love.

0:21:34.830 --> 0:21:37.760
<v Speaker 2>Let's go over here to four. I love the NFL.

0:21:37.890 --> 0:21:40.260
<v Speaker 2>National Football League, the New York Jets is my team.

0:21:40.280 --> 0:21:42.879
<v Speaker 1>They're terrible. They're 1-1, start of the season. I'm in

0:21:42.920 --> 0:21:44.619
<v Speaker 1>a tipping comp with my mates. It's going well. It's

0:21:44.640 --> 0:21:45.060
<v Speaker 1>going well.

0:21:46.430 --> 0:21:48.090
<v Speaker 2>And I love the National Football League. I know it's

0:21:48.109 --> 0:21:49.649
<v Speaker 2>not the biggest for everyone, but we certainly know they

0:21:49.670 --> 0:21:51.580
<v Speaker 2>could pack out the MCG. So there's plenty of NFL

0:21:51.600 --> 0:21:54.460
<v Speaker 2>fans in Australia. But even if you don't like the NFL,

0:21:54.540 --> 0:21:57.160
<v Speaker 2>what about what happened in the game between the Tennessee

0:21:57.260 --> 0:22:01.780
<v Speaker 2>Titans and the Philadelphia Eagles? They were playing today and

0:22:01.840 --> 0:22:04.730
<v Speaker 2>it was hot. And I mean damn hot. And for

0:22:04.770 --> 0:22:08.690
<v Speaker 2>some stupid reason, they still play this game on fake turf.

0:22:09.369 --> 0:22:15.560
<v Speaker 2>So the blasting sun meant... 69.4 degrees was the surface

0:22:15.600 --> 0:22:19.419
<v Speaker 2>temperature of the field. Now, this game was played in

0:22:19.460 --> 0:22:21.100
<v Speaker 2>the 1 o'clock zone. It should have been played in

0:22:21.119 --> 0:22:26.460
<v Speaker 2>the 4 o'clock zone to drop the temperature. Unsurprisingly, one

0:22:26.480 --> 0:22:30.060
<v Speaker 2>of the players from the winning team, well, just started

0:22:30.100 --> 0:22:31.200
<v Speaker 2>dropping swear words.

0:22:31.260 --> 0:22:31.500
<v Speaker 9>Why?

0:22:31.859 --> 0:22:37.800
<v Speaker 1>Because it was hot. It was damn hot. It was hot.

0:22:38.640 --> 0:22:39.859
<v Speaker 9>And everybody was hot.

0:22:39.920 --> 0:22:40.379
<v Speaker 7>You know, and.

0:22:41.720 --> 0:22:43.119
<v Speaker 1>Like I said, I didn't play Snap and I had

0:22:43.160 --> 0:22:48.379
<v Speaker 1>to get an IV. 69 degrees Celsius. Okay, by the way,

0:22:48.400 --> 0:22:53.199
<v Speaker 1>that's not the Fahrenheit. 66 degrees. Sorry, 69 degrees. That

0:22:53.260 --> 0:22:53.960
<v Speaker 1>is crazy.

0:22:55.000 --> 0:22:57.830
<v Speaker 2>That, by the way, is the temperature inside a V8

0:22:57.850 --> 0:22:59.570
<v Speaker 2>supercar when they're running around in Bathurst.

0:22:59.720 --> 0:23:00.570
<v Speaker 1>So for those who don't.

0:23:00.450 --> 0:23:02.830
<v Speaker 2>Think motorsport is a sport, how do you feel sitting

0:23:02.890 --> 0:23:05.190
<v Speaker 2>in front of something that's heading towards concrete at 200

0:23:05.190 --> 0:23:09.550
<v Speaker 2>kilometres an hour at 70 degrees inside? Shout out to

0:23:09.570 --> 0:23:12.510
<v Speaker 2>the non-motorsport fans. For those that are, it's Christmas, right?

0:23:12.530 --> 0:23:13.609
<v Speaker 1>We're on our way towards Bathurst.

0:23:13.930 --> 0:23:15.879
<v Speaker 2>Please join us this weekend for Our Town of Bathurst.

0:23:15.900 --> 0:23:17.590
<v Speaker 2>Thanks to the good people of Harvey Norman. It is

0:23:17.609 --> 0:23:25.939
<v Speaker 2>pretty simple. It is ourtownatnews24. com. au, ourtownatnews24. com. au.

0:23:22.480 --> 0:23:24.560
<v Speaker 1>All right, quick break. Let's get straight into it right now.

0:23:24.640 --> 0:23:27.640
<v Speaker 2>Lots to debate, lots to discuss, including, you know those

0:23:27.700 --> 0:23:30.159
<v Speaker 2>cameras that had a link back to China that meant

0:23:30.180 --> 0:23:32.720
<v Speaker 2>they had to be banned in all government buildings? Well,

0:23:32.920 --> 0:23:37.889
<v Speaker 2>guess which type of car uses the same cameras? More

0:23:37.910 --> 0:23:39.830
<v Speaker 2>in a sec here on Port Marie Live. Thanks for

0:23:39.850 --> 0:23:42.190
<v Speaker 2>joining us this Monday night. Lots to talk about tonight.

0:23:47.280 --> 0:23:49.210
<v Speaker 2>My mum just texted me and said, too much chest hair.

0:23:49.250 --> 0:23:51.350
<v Speaker 2>So I apologise to those that were thrown off by

0:23:51.390 --> 0:23:53.050
<v Speaker 2>the 70s. Look, but, you know, why not? A little

0:23:53.070 --> 0:23:55.210
<v Speaker 2>bit winter, a little bit summer. We're sort of beginning

0:23:55.310 --> 0:23:58.080
<v Speaker 2>the turn through spring. Glad she's paying attention, as always.

0:23:58.119 --> 0:23:58.500
<v Speaker 1>Love you, Mum.

0:23:58.859 --> 0:24:00.639
<v Speaker 2>All right, joining us now, two blokes who always love

0:24:00.660 --> 0:24:02.510
<v Speaker 2>their mums, none other than the great Matt Canavan and,

0:24:02.550 --> 0:24:04.630
<v Speaker 2>of course, Nicholas Rees, both joining us now because they're

0:24:04.650 --> 0:24:08.770
<v Speaker 2>going to agree on everything. So, Matt, what a surprise

0:24:08.790 --> 0:24:11.129
<v Speaker 2>that the government that's off playing games around the world

0:24:11.350 --> 0:24:13.750
<v Speaker 2>as petrol prices go through the roof here at home,

0:24:14.130 --> 0:24:16.129
<v Speaker 2>let alone get ready for two more interest rate rises,

0:24:16.490 --> 0:24:18.500
<v Speaker 2>is having the worst run they've had since Gillard was

0:24:18.540 --> 0:24:19.020
<v Speaker 2>in charge.

0:24:21.580 --> 0:24:25.379
<v Speaker 10>Well, look, maybe it is a surprise to the Labor government,

0:24:25.400 --> 0:24:28.050
<v Speaker 10>because all I hear in Canberra from Labor ministers is

0:24:28.609 --> 0:24:31.850
<v Speaker 10>how great things are. We hear speech after speech in

0:24:31.869 --> 0:24:34.490
<v Speaker 10>the Parliament about how people have never had it better, effectively.

0:24:35.530 --> 0:24:40.060
<v Speaker 10>GDP growth is up, unemployment is low, and people think,

0:24:40.340 --> 0:24:44.080
<v Speaker 10>or the Labor Party think people have it fantastic right now. Now, Obviously,

0:24:44.100 --> 0:24:46.560
<v Speaker 10>that's not the lived experience of people right now because

0:24:47.140 --> 0:24:50.149
<v Speaker 10>what the Labor Party doesn't say is that, well, GDP's up,

0:24:50.210 --> 0:24:53.649
<v Speaker 10>it's only going up because it's been artificially primed up

0:24:53.710 --> 0:24:57.490
<v Speaker 10>with massive migration numbers on a per-person basis. Of course,

0:24:57.630 --> 0:25:01.570
<v Speaker 10>under this government, incomes have been going down. Likewise, the

0:25:01.590 --> 0:25:04.090
<v Speaker 10>government likes to spruik the fact that wage growth has

0:25:04.130 --> 0:25:07.949
<v Speaker 10>been high. They never mention the thing underlying that, that

0:25:08.020 --> 0:25:10.820
<v Speaker 10>inflation has been very, very high. Indeed, it's been higher.

0:25:11.520 --> 0:25:13.400
<v Speaker 10>than wages have gone up over the life of this government.

0:25:13.420 --> 0:25:16.830
<v Speaker 10>So your real wage, the actual things your money can buy,

0:25:17.770 --> 0:25:20.650
<v Speaker 10>has gone down in the term of this government. So

0:25:21.170 --> 0:25:23.530
<v Speaker 10>I'm not sure maybe it is a shock to them

0:25:23.770 --> 0:25:27.609
<v Speaker 10>or maybe they know it's spin and they don't know

0:25:27.630 --> 0:25:29.449
<v Speaker 10>any different. But all I do know is when you

0:25:29.490 --> 0:25:32.330
<v Speaker 10>constantly tell people it's sunny outside and they open the

0:25:32.369 --> 0:25:35.149
<v Speaker 10>door and walk outside and actually it's pouring rain and

0:25:35.190 --> 0:25:37.690
<v Speaker 10>it's not very nice, they're going to get pretty angry

0:25:38.270 --> 0:25:38.910
<v Speaker 10>with you pretty soon.

0:25:39.500 --> 0:25:43.380
<v Speaker 2>Yeah, I mean, Nicholas, the truth here is that, you know,

0:25:43.440 --> 0:25:44.820
<v Speaker 2>I would have thought that, say, there would have been

0:25:44.840 --> 0:25:46.320
<v Speaker 2>a bit more of an explosion in the vote for

0:25:46.340 --> 0:25:48.200
<v Speaker 2>the Greens, but it is worth noting that they are

0:25:48.240 --> 0:25:50.949
<v Speaker 2>up on where they were at the election. Yes, we

0:25:50.990 --> 0:25:53.770
<v Speaker 2>know about One Nation and the coalition side of things, right?

0:25:53.790 --> 0:25:58.129
<v Speaker 2>You're not a Labor man anymore, but still. At some point,

0:25:58.230 --> 0:26:00.530
<v Speaker 2>they can't just believe this idea that, look, the primary

0:26:00.590 --> 0:26:02.800
<v Speaker 2>vote can be two, but all the preferences will get

0:26:02.859 --> 0:26:05.600
<v Speaker 2>us there. because eventually they'll fall to a position where,

0:26:05.720 --> 0:26:09.680
<v Speaker 2>in some contests, it's not going to be 2PP between

0:26:09.920 --> 0:26:12.570
<v Speaker 2>them and the Coalition. It's going to end up being

0:26:12.850 --> 0:26:15.730
<v Speaker 2>One Nation versus the Coalition, meaning some Labor seats, and

0:26:15.750 --> 0:26:17.990
<v Speaker 2>we're going to see that in Victoria, will be gone

0:26:18.170 --> 0:26:20.010
<v Speaker 2>early in the night because they can't get to the

0:26:20.050 --> 0:26:20.590
<v Speaker 2>final two.

0:26:21.359 --> 0:26:23.719
<v Speaker 4>Yeah, well, I mean, that is the political calculation that

0:26:23.780 --> 0:26:27.210
<v Speaker 4>hardheads in Victoria are looking at very closely with the

0:26:27.369 --> 0:26:31.170
<v Speaker 4>November state election looming here in Victoria. Look, I should

0:26:31.190 --> 0:26:33.570
<v Speaker 4>probably do a Mia Culper off the top here and

0:26:33.590 --> 0:26:36.669
<v Speaker 4>disclose that I was, of course, working for a Labor

0:26:36.710 --> 0:26:41.369
<v Speaker 4>government in Canberra the last time NewsPoll had Labor down

0:26:41.590 --> 0:26:42.950
<v Speaker 4>around 27%.

0:26:42.950 --> 0:26:45.439
<v Speaker 2>I think we all know, but thank you for reminding

0:26:45.500 --> 0:26:47.280
<v Speaker 2>us that you were in the brain stress that took

0:26:47.300 --> 0:26:48.800
<v Speaker 2>them right down into this ditch.

0:26:49.420 --> 0:26:54.780
<v Speaker 4>Well, we went lower, actually, 26%, which was 13 years ago,

0:26:54.840 --> 0:26:57.550
<v Speaker 4>which makes me feel very old, I've got to say.

0:26:57.570 --> 0:27:02.370
<v Speaker 4>So having lived through news poll numbers for Labor, even

0:27:02.410 --> 0:27:06.230
<v Speaker 4>lower than what we're seeing here today, I do have

0:27:06.250 --> 0:27:08.990
<v Speaker 4>to say it does feel a little bit different this

0:27:09.050 --> 0:27:09.850
<v Speaker 4>time around.

0:27:09.890 --> 0:27:10.730
<v Speaker 1>Let's not forget.

0:27:11.260 --> 0:27:16.720
<v Speaker 4>That Anthony Albanese absolutely smashed last year's election in 2025,

0:27:16.720 --> 0:27:20.419
<v Speaker 4>and it was the second election that he had won.

0:27:20.460 --> 0:27:22.040
<v Speaker 9>So he's a proven.

0:27:21.760 --> 0:27:27.300
<v Speaker 4>Election winner for Labor. And we are still, you know,

0:27:27.580 --> 0:27:29.980
<v Speaker 4>two years at least away from an election.

0:27:30.000 --> 0:27:32.540
<v Speaker 9>We're not going to face... go to the polls till 2028.

0:27:32.540 --> 0:27:35.320
<v Speaker 4>So this government has a long way to go yet,

0:27:35.380 --> 0:27:37.899
<v Speaker 4>which was very different to the situation we were in

0:27:37.940 --> 0:27:41.109
<v Speaker 4>back there in 2012 with Julia.

0:27:41.910 --> 0:27:43.570
<v Speaker 9>That said, I do think there.

0:27:43.490 --> 0:27:45.970
<v Speaker 4>Are plenty of warning signs there and plenty of things

0:27:46.290 --> 0:27:48.669
<v Speaker 4>that Labor needs to be paying attention to. Like if

0:27:48.710 --> 0:27:52.490
<v Speaker 4>we have another two interest rate rises... before Christmas, petrol

0:27:52.540 --> 0:27:56.280
<v Speaker 4>prices don't come off, then I think you're going to

0:27:56.300 --> 0:27:58.980
<v Speaker 4>have to see some more action from this Labor government

0:27:59.440 --> 0:28:00.400
<v Speaker 4>around cost of living.

0:28:00.510 --> 0:28:01.480
<v Speaker 9>I do think Angus.

0:28:01.230 --> 0:28:05.530
<v Speaker 4>Taylor's move in the last week on petrol was one

0:28:05.550 --> 0:28:09.470
<v Speaker 4>of the best things he's done since he became leader.

0:28:10.109 --> 0:28:12.780
<v Speaker 4>And yeah, a Labor government has always got to stay

0:28:12.859 --> 0:28:16.179
<v Speaker 4>very close to cost of living pressures, family budgets, and

0:28:16.200 --> 0:28:17.740
<v Speaker 4>they're under a lot of pressure at the moment.

0:28:17.900 --> 0:28:21.119
<v Speaker 2>Yeah, so hanging out, learning parental features at Apple or

0:28:21.140 --> 0:28:23.240
<v Speaker 2>heading off to the UN, not exactly the priority when

0:28:23.280 --> 0:28:24.679
<v Speaker 2>things are here at home. By the way, credit to

0:28:24.720 --> 0:28:28.100
<v Speaker 2>you too, Matt, obviously, for being the deputy leader or

0:28:28.119 --> 0:28:31.160
<v Speaker 2>the co-leader of the coalition, right? And this idea, right,

0:28:31.180 --> 0:28:34.270
<v Speaker 2>so when global oil prices get to $ 100 a barrel,

0:28:34.310 --> 0:28:37.149
<v Speaker 2>and we're getting very close there, that is when there

0:28:37.170 --> 0:28:40.470
<v Speaker 2>would be the automatic tax drop under a coalition government.

0:28:42.610 --> 0:28:44.350
<v Speaker 6>Look, that's right, Paul. We are actually there.

0:28:44.930 --> 0:28:49.370
<v Speaker 10>The formal rule we're establishing is that if the Brent

0:28:49.410 --> 0:28:53.020
<v Speaker 10>price for crude oil is over $ 100 a barrel, averaging

0:28:53.060 --> 0:28:57.440
<v Speaker 10>over two weeks, then we'd trigger this support. So that

0:28:57.480 --> 0:28:58.800
<v Speaker 10>has occurred in the last.

0:29:00.270 --> 0:29:03.750
<v Speaker 10>In the last five years, it's only occurred two other times.

0:29:03.810 --> 0:29:05.990
<v Speaker 10>That would be earlier this year when the war kicked

0:29:06.050 --> 0:29:09.970
<v Speaker 10>off in Iran and back in 2022 when the Ukraine

0:29:09.990 --> 0:29:14.630
<v Speaker 10>war kicked off. In both of those times, the government

0:29:14.650 --> 0:29:19.620
<v Speaker 10>stepped in and provided a 50% discount on the fuel excise.

0:29:20.110 --> 0:29:21.930
<v Speaker 10>And so it just makes sense. I think we established

0:29:21.950 --> 0:29:24.280
<v Speaker 10>this rule so people know. People know we've got your back.

0:29:25.280 --> 0:29:27.200
<v Speaker 10>And we don't have to go through these parlor games

0:29:27.260 --> 0:29:29.620
<v Speaker 10>every month or two about whether it should happen or not.

0:29:29.680 --> 0:29:32.240
<v Speaker 10>We just set a rule that when you get diesel

0:29:32.260 --> 0:29:34.930
<v Speaker 10>prices now, and I have seen it at $ 3 or

0:29:34.970 --> 0:29:38.030
<v Speaker 10>above at some service stations, a little bit below that.

0:29:37.950 --> 0:29:39.970
<v Speaker 6>Where I am here, but still very, very high.

0:29:40.500 --> 0:29:42.420
<v Speaker 10>When prices are at those sort of levels, then you

0:29:42.460 --> 0:29:45.640
<v Speaker 10>provide some automatic relief to people because it's just too tough,

0:29:45.720 --> 0:29:49.610
<v Speaker 10>especially for families who are struggling and can't scrimp on petrol.

0:29:49.630 --> 0:29:51.890
<v Speaker 10>We don't want them scrimping on groceries or other essentials.

0:29:52.450 --> 0:29:54.270
<v Speaker 10>And so there's some flex here for the government to

0:29:54.290 --> 0:29:56.370
<v Speaker 10>do that. We then have a rule where it comes

0:29:56.450 --> 0:29:59.110
<v Speaker 10>off when it averages below that level over an eight-week

0:29:59.150 --> 0:30:02.530
<v Speaker 10>period or two months. And so you see that sort

0:30:02.570 --> 0:30:05.200
<v Speaker 10>of coming on and off just like it has with

0:30:05.220 --> 0:30:07.500
<v Speaker 10>the political decisions we've had in the past. And so, look,

0:30:07.540 --> 0:30:09.080
<v Speaker 10>we think it's sensible for the government to do this now.

0:30:09.280 --> 0:30:10.020
<v Speaker 10>They should do this now.

0:30:10.020 --> 0:30:10.800
<v Speaker 1>100%.

0:30:10.800 --> 0:30:12.460
<v Speaker 6>Sooner rather than better now. Get it on with it

0:30:12.700 --> 0:30:14.320
<v Speaker 6>and provide some relief to families.

0:30:15.120 --> 0:30:18.170
<v Speaker 1>Yeah, Brent, right now, $ 1. 01 or $ 1. 02 right now. So, yeah,

0:30:18.190 --> 0:30:19.670
<v Speaker 1>we're well and truly past that threshold.

0:30:19.690 --> 0:30:19.930
<v Speaker 9>Sorry, Nick.

0:30:20.810 --> 0:30:23.130
<v Speaker 4>Oh, look, just one other thing for the electoral nerds

0:30:23.170 --> 0:30:28.090
<v Speaker 4>still with us. The fact that NewsPoll today had the

0:30:28.290 --> 0:30:35.200
<v Speaker 4>major party vote down at 46%, that is absolutely extraordinary.

0:30:35.220 --> 0:30:37.760
<v Speaker 4>To put this in perspective for people, you know, last

0:30:37.800 --> 0:30:41.020
<v Speaker 4>year's federal election, the major party vote, Labor, Liberal, was

0:30:41.060 --> 0:30:45.580
<v Speaker 4>at 66%. So that is off 20% in over a year.

0:30:46.020 --> 0:30:49.640
<v Speaker 9>And I think that might be its lowest point ever today.

0:30:49.900 --> 0:30:52.610
<v Speaker 9>since New Year's polls started. Now, the really interesting thing

0:30:52.690 --> 0:30:53.470
<v Speaker 9>here is if you.

0:30:53.390 --> 0:30:57.810
<v Speaker 4>Look back across Australian political history, when the major party

0:30:57.850 --> 0:31:01.970
<v Speaker 4>vote drops to those sort of low levels, it usually

0:31:02.190 --> 0:31:06.090
<v Speaker 4>is the harbinger of great instability and.

0:31:06.190 --> 0:31:08.030
<v Speaker 9>Major change in Australian politics.

0:31:08.070 --> 0:31:10.570
<v Speaker 4>So that is a very interesting number there today.

0:31:10.730 --> 0:31:14.420
<v Speaker 2>Yet another reason why laser-like focus about to Victoria, what happens,

0:31:14.460 --> 0:31:16.200
<v Speaker 2>and then, of course, we move to New South Wales, then,

0:31:16.220 --> 0:31:18.660
<v Speaker 2>of course, we see what happens, well... sooner rather than

0:31:18.680 --> 0:31:20.690
<v Speaker 2>later maybe when it comes to the federal election because,

0:31:20.710 --> 0:31:22.500
<v Speaker 2>of course, there's deficits for the next 40 years.

0:31:22.540 --> 0:31:25.900
<v Speaker 1>But who cares? Aye, aye, aye, aye, aye, aye, aye, aye, aye. today.

0:31:26.240 --> 0:31:28.640
<v Speaker 2>Now, also inside that intergenerational report, and again, it was

0:31:28.700 --> 0:31:29.700
<v Speaker 2>grim reading, right?

0:31:30.080 --> 0:31:31.540
<v Speaker 1>Because we always.

0:31:31.380 --> 0:31:33.240
<v Speaker 2>Talk about our government doesn't focus enough on the long,

0:31:33.280 --> 0:31:36.270
<v Speaker 2>this is the long-term picture. And the long-term picture shows

0:31:36.290 --> 0:31:40.570
<v Speaker 2>that the only way that Australia grows its tax base

0:31:40.730 --> 0:31:42.890
<v Speaker 2>is by bringing in people who start paying tax from

0:31:42.930 --> 0:31:45.690
<v Speaker 2>day one, rather than people who are born and cost

0:31:45.710 --> 0:31:48.650
<v Speaker 2>the system money all the way until they are 18.

0:31:48.650 --> 0:31:52.090
<v Speaker 2>So one of the reasons why people are, well, stating

0:31:52.110 --> 0:31:53.780
<v Speaker 2>there's lots of different reasons why people are saying they're

0:31:53.800 --> 0:31:56.220
<v Speaker 2>not having kids but apart from all the ideological or

0:31:56.260 --> 0:31:59.940
<v Speaker 2>the climate change it's about how expensive things are so

0:32:00.000 --> 0:32:02.380
<v Speaker 2>matt how do we deal with this because again it's

0:32:02.400 --> 0:32:05.160
<v Speaker 2>not about baby bonuses it's about the ongoing cost and

0:32:05.180 --> 0:32:07.700
<v Speaker 2>about people knowing that this is a decision which is

0:32:07.740 --> 0:32:10.510
<v Speaker 2>not about this summer next summer it's one that goes

0:32:10.590 --> 0:32:14.209
<v Speaker 2>on of course for 20 and increasingly 30 years where

0:32:14.230 --> 0:32:15.210
<v Speaker 2>they're under your roof.

0:32:17.570 --> 0:32:20.050
<v Speaker 10>Well, the last time we did see an increase in

0:32:20.430 --> 0:32:24.510
<v Speaker 10>the fertility rate in Australia was in the 2000s, where

0:32:24.550 --> 0:32:29.610
<v Speaker 10>the Howard government did provide substantial support for families, mainly

0:32:29.650 --> 0:32:32.150
<v Speaker 10>through the family tax benefit system. There's a lot of

0:32:32.230 --> 0:32:36.969
<v Speaker 10>focus and attention given to the baby bonus, but the

0:32:37.010 --> 0:32:39.770
<v Speaker 10>more substantive support was through the generic system of family

0:32:39.810 --> 0:32:42.930
<v Speaker 10>tax benefits. Now, when Kevin Rudd was elected, that was

0:32:42.990 --> 0:32:46.390
<v Speaker 10>first clawed back and Admittedly, Joe Hockey did some more

0:32:46.410 --> 0:32:49.570
<v Speaker 10>when we were trying to balance the budget. And look,

0:32:49.590 --> 0:32:52.570
<v Speaker 10>we've got a much lower percentage of our national income

0:32:52.610 --> 0:32:54.970
<v Speaker 10>going to support families now. And so I don't think

0:32:55.310 --> 0:32:58.610
<v Speaker 10>it's surprising to see the birth rate fall alongside that.

0:32:59.130 --> 0:33:00.450
<v Speaker 6>And we're working very hard to see.

0:33:00.370 --> 0:33:03.410
<v Speaker 10>What we can do with the stricter financial times we

0:33:03.470 --> 0:33:04.580
<v Speaker 10>have compared to the early 2000s.

0:33:05.640 --> 0:33:06.490
<v Speaker 6>Support families.

0:33:07.130 --> 0:33:09.690
<v Speaker 10>Again, I think it should be focused on through the

0:33:09.730 --> 0:33:13.730
<v Speaker 10>tax system, supporting people who work and pay tax and

0:33:13.950 --> 0:33:16.130
<v Speaker 10>helping them out too, because it is very, very expensive,

0:33:16.150 --> 0:33:20.020
<v Speaker 10>particularly in those early years of a newborn's life, especially

0:33:20.060 --> 0:33:22.240
<v Speaker 10>when a lot of parents like to spend some time

0:33:22.260 --> 0:33:24.980
<v Speaker 10>out of the workforce to look after their newborn children.

0:33:25.720 --> 0:33:27.560
<v Speaker 10>And when you can have two or three kids, it

0:33:27.920 --> 0:33:30.480
<v Speaker 10>adds up, it's many, many years potentially out of that

0:33:30.570 --> 0:33:34.560
<v Speaker 10>high income lifestyle you might be used to so we're

0:33:34.580 --> 0:33:36.120
<v Speaker 10>going to have more to say on this because I

0:33:36.160 --> 0:33:37.810
<v Speaker 10>think it is a national priority to lift our birth

0:33:37.850 --> 0:33:41.229
<v Speaker 10>rate at current levels and this report prediction will go

0:33:41.310 --> 0:33:44.750
<v Speaker 10>lower than current levels at current levels even in 100

0:33:44.750 --> 0:33:47.310
<v Speaker 10>years or so there'll just be a third the size

0:33:47.330 --> 0:33:50.100
<v Speaker 10>of our population descended from those alive today So we'll

0:33:50.120 --> 0:33:52.900
<v Speaker 10>be down about 11 million people descended from those alive

0:33:52.940 --> 0:33:55.020
<v Speaker 10>today at this birth rate.

0:33:55.500 --> 0:33:56.660
<v Speaker 6>It happens very, very fast.

0:33:56.880 --> 0:33:58.680
<v Speaker 2>And again, I mean, let's be clear here. I'm talking

0:33:58.740 --> 0:34:01.760
<v Speaker 2>about instant Aussies from lots of different backgrounds, fine and

0:34:01.780 --> 0:34:03.860
<v Speaker 2>fair enough, from parents and grandparents. But I love the

0:34:03.920 --> 0:34:06.650
<v Speaker 2>idea of more instant Aussies, the idea of fewer. In fact,

0:34:06.670 --> 0:34:09.170
<v Speaker 2>can we show that intergenerational report graphic that shows the

0:34:09.210 --> 0:34:11.810
<v Speaker 2>difference between the migration and the birth rate, right? where

0:34:11.850 --> 0:34:13.270
<v Speaker 2>you see the blue at the bottom of that, which

0:34:13.350 --> 0:34:17.250
<v Speaker 2>is the natural birth rate just essentially disappearing, meaning the

0:34:17.270 --> 0:34:21.130
<v Speaker 2>population growth, which is going to be another 10 million people, apparently,

0:34:21.210 --> 0:34:24.950
<v Speaker 2>between 11 million between now and the 2060s, where they're

0:34:25.010 --> 0:34:27.910
<v Speaker 2>still running a budget deficit every year of those. So

0:34:27.930 --> 0:34:30.170
<v Speaker 2>they're not even replacing and not even able to find

0:34:30.210 --> 0:34:32.460
<v Speaker 2>ways to get the revenue. The spending keeps going up.

0:34:32.969 --> 0:34:37.799
<v Speaker 2>And essentially, the system wants the ready-made taxpayer rather than

0:34:37.840 --> 0:34:38.899
<v Speaker 2>the inconvenient ones that.

0:34:38.820 --> 0:34:40.040
<v Speaker 1>Take 18 years to get there.

0:34:40.300 --> 0:34:42.790
<v Speaker 2>Nicholas, I get it, it's three blokes talking on telly,

0:34:42.810 --> 0:34:45.030
<v Speaker 2>but last time I checked, until they've worked out the science,

0:34:45.070 --> 0:34:47.530
<v Speaker 2>they still need us to be involved in the process

0:34:47.590 --> 0:34:50.430
<v Speaker 2>at some point for a moment, but still it matters.

0:34:50.680 --> 0:34:52.779
<v Speaker 6>Not just us, though, Paul.

0:34:52.800 --> 0:34:53.700
<v Speaker 9>We do have a.

0:34:53.860 --> 0:34:55.719
<v Speaker 1>Not just the three of us. That's a lot of work.

0:34:56.120 --> 0:34:58.610
<v Speaker 1>It's a lot of work. It's a young man's game.

0:34:59.280 --> 0:35:01.270
<v Speaker 4>Pleased to say that the men of Australia still have

0:35:01.290 --> 0:35:03.290
<v Speaker 4>a role to play in the birth rate and long

0:35:03.330 --> 0:35:07.089
<v Speaker 4>may it remain so. I mean, look, Matt makes some

0:35:07.190 --> 0:35:10.020
<v Speaker 4>interesting points there about trying to lift the birth rate

0:35:10.140 --> 0:35:10.520
<v Speaker 4>in Australia.

0:35:10.560 --> 0:35:12.940
<v Speaker 9>And good luck to him and the Nationals. Knock yourselves

0:35:13.040 --> 0:35:14.640
<v Speaker 9>out 100%. supportive.

0:35:14.660 --> 0:35:18.920
<v Speaker 4>But there is a global trend happening here, like go

0:35:18.960 --> 0:35:21.610
<v Speaker 4>to Italy, go to England, the birth rate is falling.

0:35:21.700 --> 0:35:25.350
<v Speaker 9>Go to China, go to Japan, the birth rate is falling.

0:35:25.650 --> 0:35:29.110
<v Speaker 4>This is a global phenomenon, and it's to do with

0:35:29.310 --> 0:35:34.190
<v Speaker 4>technological advancement, costs of living, and a whole bunch of

0:35:34.310 --> 0:35:39.520
<v Speaker 4>very big factors. Family planning, Women, you know, and families

0:35:39.540 --> 0:35:41.390
<v Speaker 4>are deciding not to have the same number of children.

0:35:41.860 --> 0:35:43.450
<v Speaker 9>This is a big trend for Australia.

0:35:43.530 --> 0:35:45.049
<v Speaker 4>I mean, one of the things that numbers have jumped

0:35:45.090 --> 0:35:47.250
<v Speaker 4>out at me today is, you know, we're still forecasting

0:35:47.350 --> 0:35:51.470
<v Speaker 4>a population growth rate of 1.5%. That's a blistering growth

0:35:51.510 --> 0:35:54.310
<v Speaker 4>rate compared to the rest of the world. And the

0:35:54.370 --> 0:35:56.110
<v Speaker 4>truth is we go in the same direction as the

0:35:56.160 --> 0:35:57.840
<v Speaker 4>rest of the world. We're going to see that drop

0:35:57.900 --> 0:36:03.340
<v Speaker 4>away quite significantly. effects for our future economy, future quality

0:36:03.360 --> 0:36:06.040
<v Speaker 4>of life. I here tonight do not have all the

0:36:06.140 --> 0:36:08.759
<v Speaker 4>answers to that, but that is the big story out

0:36:08.780 --> 0:36:09.200
<v Speaker 4>of today.

0:36:09.580 --> 0:36:12.020
<v Speaker 2>All right, Matt, let us talk about crocodiles because people

0:36:12.060 --> 0:36:14.720
<v Speaker 2>love talking crocodiles and they know how much that you

0:36:14.739 --> 0:36:17.209
<v Speaker 2>love Rockhampton and we know that Rocky's going to be

0:36:17.830 --> 0:36:21.049
<v Speaker 2>an Olympic city in 2032 along with so many other

0:36:21.450 --> 0:36:23.350
<v Speaker 2>in regional Queensland and, of course, the main game being

0:36:23.410 --> 0:36:26.469
<v Speaker 2>in Brisbane. But you want an apology from the BBC.

0:36:26.530 --> 0:36:29.090
<v Speaker 2>What have they done and how have they misrepresented Crocs?

0:36:30.730 --> 0:36:32.640
<v Speaker 2>In fact, let's show that and then I'll get your reaction.

0:36:32.680 --> 0:36:32.950
<v Speaker 9>Sorry.

0:36:32.969 --> 0:36:35.040
<v Speaker 1>This is the BBC. Roll that tape and then here

0:36:35.060 --> 0:36:35.299
<v Speaker 1>we go.

0:36:36.400 --> 0:36:39.739
<v Speaker 13>A river home to 500 crocodiles has been chosen as

0:36:39.780 --> 0:36:44.040
<v Speaker 13>an Olympic rowing venue. The Fitzroy River in Rockhampton, Queensland,

0:36:44.160 --> 0:36:46.540
<v Speaker 13>has been given the OK to host the Olympic and

0:36:46.580 --> 0:36:50.960
<v Speaker 13>Paralympic rowing and canoeing events at the 2032 Brisbane Games

0:36:51.040 --> 0:36:54.359
<v Speaker 13>in Australia. There's been lots of opposition with concerns over

0:36:54.450 --> 0:36:58.310
<v Speaker 13>flood risk, strong currents and, of course, the crocodiles, which

0:36:58.350 --> 0:37:00.290
<v Speaker 13>can grow to up to six metres long.

0:37:01.390 --> 0:37:02.710
<v Speaker 1>Well, yes, there should be an apology.

0:37:02.750 --> 0:37:05.630
<v Speaker 2>The idea that there are just crocks absolutely everywhere, I

0:37:05.650 --> 0:37:08.089
<v Speaker 2>know it's great for selling T-shirts, but come on, I'm

0:37:08.130 --> 0:37:11.330
<v Speaker 2>with you. National apology. Bring them for a booting like

0:37:11.350 --> 0:37:14.160
<v Speaker 2>they wanted Bart Simpson to cop.

0:37:14.219 --> 0:37:15.140
<v Speaker 6>Exactly right, Paul.

0:37:15.160 --> 0:37:19.020
<v Speaker 10>Well, one particular error there in that video, the video

0:37:19.060 --> 0:37:23.319
<v Speaker 10>that the BBC showed, I suppose they thought they had

0:37:23.340 --> 0:37:27.230
<v Speaker 10>us when the footage, when they Googled it, came from

0:37:27.250 --> 0:37:28.170
<v Speaker 10>the Fitzroy River.

0:37:28.650 --> 0:37:29.950
<v Speaker 6>Just a bit of a problem for them.

0:37:30.300 --> 0:37:33.080
<v Speaker 10>There are two Fitzroy Rivers in Australia and they've chosen

0:37:33.100 --> 0:37:37.230
<v Speaker 10>a Fitzroy River near a place called Kingsound in Western Australia.

0:37:37.250 --> 0:37:39.310
<v Speaker 6>I didn't think the crocs looked like ours. It didn't

0:37:39.330 --> 0:37:40.330
<v Speaker 6>look like our river.

0:37:40.830 --> 0:37:43.420
<v Speaker 10>And so when I looked at it, and saw that

0:37:43.480 --> 0:37:45.100
<v Speaker 10>they were just a little bit off the BBC.

0:37:45.239 --> 0:37:46.900
<v Speaker 6>They were 3,500 kilometres off.

0:37:48.620 --> 0:37:51.300
<v Speaker 10>That's how far away the Fitzroy River is in WA

0:37:51.340 --> 0:37:53.609
<v Speaker 10>compared to the Fitzroy River here, where we've just had

0:37:53.650 --> 0:37:55.430
<v Speaker 10>the state school rowing championships.

0:37:55.469 --> 0:37:57.290
<v Speaker 6>I've just been there the last three days. My son

0:37:57.330 --> 0:37:59.589
<v Speaker 6>competed in it. Not a croc.

0:37:59.630 --> 0:38:01.730
<v Speaker 10>Well, the only crocs in sight, Paul, were those on

0:38:01.750 --> 0:38:05.400
<v Speaker 10>your feet, and now good on the kids. Everyone's adopted

0:38:05.420 --> 0:38:07.780
<v Speaker 10>the crocs, and they've all got inflatable crocs on their tents,

0:38:07.840 --> 0:38:09.880
<v Speaker 10>and everyone loves it, and everyone's talking about rowing, so.

0:38:10.330 --> 0:38:11.050
<v Speaker 6>It's a great thing.

0:38:11.090 --> 0:38:12.799
<v Speaker 10>It was a great event, and the Olympics is going

0:38:12.820 --> 0:38:13.950
<v Speaker 10>to look fantastic up here.

0:38:14.239 --> 0:38:15.879
<v Speaker 2>Please tell me, Senator, that you don't own a pair

0:38:15.920 --> 0:38:19.420
<v Speaker 2>of Crocs and you wear socks with them as well, though.

0:38:19.880 --> 0:38:21.960
<v Speaker 10>I just got a photo with my Crocs on with

0:38:21.980 --> 0:38:23.640
<v Speaker 10>the Curio Mail this afternoon, Paul.

0:38:23.820 --> 0:38:24.360
<v Speaker 9>I'm sorry.

0:38:24.400 --> 0:38:26.160
<v Speaker 6>Now, look, can I just jump in?

0:38:26.239 --> 0:38:29.660
<v Speaker 10>And they're very handy when you're doing rowing and things

0:38:29.700 --> 0:38:30.609
<v Speaker 10>like that near a river.

0:38:31.590 --> 0:38:33.950
<v Speaker 9>So you do see quite a few pairs of Crocs.

0:38:34.410 --> 0:38:34.630
<v Speaker 6>No socks.

0:38:34.650 --> 0:38:37.049
<v Speaker 9>Crocs and socks in my part of the world.

0:38:37.130 --> 0:38:37.430
<v Speaker 6>No socks.

0:38:37.489 --> 0:38:38.110
<v Speaker 9>I do admit that.

0:38:38.130 --> 0:38:39.549
<v Speaker 1>You love those with no socks.

0:38:39.610 --> 0:38:41.190
<v Speaker 4>But we're on the same page on this one, Matt,

0:38:41.250 --> 0:38:43.670
<v Speaker 4>because we had the big NFL game here in Melbourne

0:38:44.150 --> 0:38:46.890
<v Speaker 4>last week. We had the biggest influx of Americans since

0:38:46.910 --> 0:38:50.630
<v Speaker 4>World War II in the city. It was amazing. But

0:38:50.690 --> 0:38:54.549
<v Speaker 4>I did find myself explaining to Americans that, no, there

0:38:54.590 --> 0:38:56.469
<v Speaker 4>aren't as spiders that are as big as your head

0:38:56.489 --> 0:38:58.700
<v Speaker 4>about to drop out of the trees. Look, we don't

0:38:58.719 --> 0:39:01.880
<v Speaker 4>have crocodiles on the streets here in Melbourne.

0:39:01.920 --> 0:39:03.140
<v Speaker 1>And I just feel like, you.

0:39:03.060 --> 0:39:07.000
<v Speaker 4>Know, 30 years of advertising, come and visit Australia with

0:39:07.040 --> 0:39:10.279
<v Speaker 4>crocodiles and all these big crazy creatures have just kind

0:39:10.320 --> 0:39:12.960
<v Speaker 4>of made the world think that we're a very, very

0:39:13.000 --> 0:39:13.680
<v Speaker 4>dangerous place to visit.

0:39:13.700 --> 0:39:14.560
<v Speaker 1>Mate, I'll give you the tip.

0:39:14.600 --> 0:39:16.060
<v Speaker 2>When I was in the US, I would sort of

0:39:16.200 --> 0:39:17.700
<v Speaker 2>for the first couple of days I'd do that and

0:39:17.719 --> 0:39:19.660
<v Speaker 2>then for the rest of us, oh, yeah, absolutely, mate.

0:39:19.800 --> 0:39:22.730
<v Speaker 1>Oh, yeah, whatever, we're bred tough. I'm not fat, I'm just.

0:39:22.690 --> 0:39:24.950
<v Speaker 6>A little skinny. We're the worst offenders at this.

0:39:25.489 --> 0:39:28.570
<v Speaker 1>Correct. Now, Lord Mayor of Melbourne, again, well done on

0:39:28.590 --> 0:39:29.930
<v Speaker 1>that NFL thing. I thought that was awesome.

0:39:30.010 --> 0:39:30.170
<v Speaker 9>Right?

0:39:30.510 --> 0:39:33.250
<v Speaker 2>Why is this a public holiday when there's no Victorian

0:39:33.310 --> 0:39:36.760
<v Speaker 2>teams in the grand final? This, I know, was some

0:39:36.800 --> 0:39:39.640
<v Speaker 2>little sort of pre-election nonsense. Fine, have another public holiday,

0:39:39.989 --> 0:39:42.020
<v Speaker 2>but do it on a Monday, do it about something else,

0:39:42.060 --> 0:39:43.339
<v Speaker 2>but come on, what do you think about this?

0:39:44.340 --> 0:39:46.440
<v Speaker 9>Ah, yes. Now, this is an issue raging in Melbourne

0:39:46.480 --> 0:39:46.959
<v Speaker 9>this week.

0:39:47.000 --> 0:39:50.259
<v Speaker 4>So we have the public holiday on Friday, which is

0:39:50.320 --> 0:39:51.880
<v Speaker 4>Grand Final Eve.

0:39:52.480 --> 0:39:53.219
<v Speaker 9>It's in about.

0:39:53.280 --> 0:39:55.299
<v Speaker 4>Oh, it's got to be coming up seven or eight

0:39:55.340 --> 0:39:58.620
<v Speaker 4>years now at least. It has become very popular, but

0:39:59.070 --> 0:40:01.489
<v Speaker 4>the debate has fired up again because a lot of

0:40:01.510 --> 0:40:04.330
<v Speaker 4>the industry business groups are saying now that there's two

0:40:04.370 --> 0:40:07.670
<v Speaker 4>interstate teams playing, we should cancel the public holiday. From

0:40:07.710 --> 0:40:10.590
<v Speaker 4>a Melbourne perspective, City of Melbourne perspective, It's actually a

0:40:10.610 --> 0:40:14.370
<v Speaker 4>great day. We have more people in the central city

0:40:14.989 --> 0:40:17.049
<v Speaker 4>on the Friday before grand final than we'd have on

0:40:17.090 --> 0:40:18.029
<v Speaker 4>an ordinary.

0:40:17.750 --> 0:40:22.270
<v Speaker 9>Friday because everybody comes in today. Because all the work.

0:40:22.070 --> 0:40:25.069
<v Speaker 1>From home blood just turned up. They finally turn up

0:40:25.150 --> 0:40:27.070
<v Speaker 1>in the city when they don't have to work.

0:40:27.170 --> 0:40:30.590
<v Speaker 12>I mean, look, you might be against people having fun, Paul,

0:40:30.640 --> 0:40:34.859
<v Speaker 12>but here in Melbourne, we love it. And that AFL

0:40:34.900 --> 0:40:37.839
<v Speaker 12>grand final, a public holiday, has turned out to be

0:40:37.860 --> 0:40:38.759
<v Speaker 12>an absolute ripper.

0:40:39.080 --> 0:40:41.120
<v Speaker 2>Of all the verbling we've done of each other on

0:40:41.160 --> 0:40:42.900
<v Speaker 2>this show, to claim I'm anti-fun.

0:40:42.940 --> 0:40:43.700
<v Speaker 1>I've heard it all now.

0:40:44.060 --> 0:40:46.540
<v Speaker 2>Thank you, Senator. Thank you, Mr Mayor. I do appreciate it.

0:40:46.680 --> 0:40:48.430
<v Speaker 2>We'll talk to you again very soon. All right, quick break.

0:40:48.710 --> 0:40:51.150
<v Speaker 2>Let's get back into this intergenerational report. It is grim,

0:40:51.190 --> 0:40:54.190
<v Speaker 2>but it's important reading, right? It is the roadmap and

0:40:54.210 --> 0:40:57.090
<v Speaker 2>it is the receipt book. And it is nothing but, again,

0:40:57.170 --> 0:41:00.200
<v Speaker 2>the replacement of the population with migration.

0:41:01.200 --> 0:41:03.740
<v Speaker 1>But what about 40 years of budget deficits? Tim Wilson,

0:41:03.760 --> 0:41:05.180
<v Speaker 1>of course, wants to be the Treasurer. He'd have to

0:41:05.280 --> 0:41:06.460
<v Speaker 1>deal with this. How would he?

0:41:06.460 --> 0:41:06.540
<v Speaker 4>Next.

0:41:06.880 --> 0:41:07.120
<v Speaker 11>Next.

0:41:12.969 --> 0:41:15.859
<v Speaker 2>The theme of the night tonight has been the intergenerational report.

0:41:15.910 --> 0:41:17.380
<v Speaker 1>Yes, I know, isn't it exciting?

0:41:17.420 --> 0:41:20.299
<v Speaker 2>But the reality is, is that it is both the

0:41:20.440 --> 0:41:23.239
<v Speaker 2>street directory and the receipt book when it comes to

0:41:23.280 --> 0:41:26.850
<v Speaker 2>mass migration. It's telling us that is the trajectory and

0:41:27.350 --> 0:41:30.370
<v Speaker 2>financially why we have to get there. Tim Wilson is

0:41:30.410 --> 0:41:32.700
<v Speaker 2>the shadow treasurer. At some point, it'll be his job

0:41:32.719 --> 0:41:35.880
<v Speaker 2>to have to deal with the Australian economy and its future.

0:41:35.900 --> 0:41:38.299
<v Speaker 2>And he joins us now from beautiful Melbourne. Lovely to

0:41:38.340 --> 0:41:41.200
<v Speaker 2>see you, Tim. What concerns you most about some of

0:41:41.219 --> 0:41:44.630
<v Speaker 2>the stuff that's buried deep, deep inside this today that

0:41:44.650 --> 0:41:46.090
<v Speaker 2>the treasurer wasn't pointing at?

0:41:47.600 --> 0:41:50.620
<v Speaker 7>Well, the objective of the intergenerational report has always been

0:41:50.660 --> 0:41:53.339
<v Speaker 7>to set the nation up so that we don't hand

0:41:53.420 --> 0:41:56.779
<v Speaker 7>a nation on to future generations where they'll end up

0:41:56.820 --> 0:42:02.070
<v Speaker 7>being poorer and carrying the cost of today. And instead

0:42:02.130 --> 0:42:05.250
<v Speaker 7>what it's projected out is 40 years of deficits into

0:42:05.290 --> 0:42:08.729
<v Speaker 7>the future. But even more distressingly, if you actually look

0:42:08.830 --> 0:42:12.170
<v Speaker 7>at the productivity assumptions, which are the basis of economic

0:42:12.210 --> 0:42:15.330
<v Speaker 7>growth in the economy today, They've cooked the books. They've

0:42:15.370 --> 0:42:18.590
<v Speaker 7>used a very rosy assessment, which isn't consistent with the

0:42:18.630 --> 0:42:22.190
<v Speaker 7>Reserve Bank. And if we use the Reserve Bank's numbers,

0:42:22.530 --> 0:42:25.489
<v Speaker 7>we would basically have a doubling of public debt and

0:42:25.510 --> 0:42:28.609
<v Speaker 7>nearly a doubling of the liability that Australians will take

0:42:28.710 --> 0:42:32.219
<v Speaker 7>into the future on, frankly, people who are less likely

0:42:32.239 --> 0:42:32.900
<v Speaker 7>to be able to afford it.

0:42:33.530 --> 0:42:35.730
<v Speaker 2>Now, bear with me here, but I want people to

0:42:35.750 --> 0:42:39.930
<v Speaker 2>think about Australia as if it was a pub, right? Now, obviously,

0:42:40.210 --> 0:42:42.410
<v Speaker 2>you can take the kids to a pub, but they

0:42:42.430 --> 0:42:44.259
<v Speaker 2>can't walk up and buy anything from the bar.

0:42:44.590 --> 0:42:46.879
<v Speaker 1>But you know who can? An 18-year-old.

0:42:46.910 --> 0:42:50.180
<v Speaker 2>Nobody's born an 18-year-old, but mass migration means that when

0:42:50.219 --> 0:42:52.299
<v Speaker 2>they come to the country, as long as they're over

0:42:52.320 --> 0:42:55.779
<v Speaker 2>the age of 18, they're an immediate taxpayer. This is

0:42:55.880 --> 0:42:59.739
<v Speaker 2>part of what I point out to be One of

0:42:59.800 --> 0:43:02.859
<v Speaker 2>the many structural things that are inside this document, right,

0:43:03.080 --> 0:43:06.069
<v Speaker 2>that are telling us what the path is and that

0:43:06.340 --> 0:43:08.770
<v Speaker 2>for us to work and not even to make a profit,

0:43:08.790 --> 0:43:11.630
<v Speaker 2>to make a loss every year for the next 40 years.

0:43:12.130 --> 0:43:13.210
<v Speaker 1>But we can't wait.

0:43:13.050 --> 0:43:16.010
<v Speaker 2>For people to have children, to go through early childhood,

0:43:16.239 --> 0:43:17.819
<v Speaker 2>to go through school, to go through high school.

0:43:18.020 --> 0:43:18.799
<v Speaker 1>We need to.

0:43:19.640 --> 0:43:23.040
<v Speaker 2>According to this document, continue at a start at 18 level.

0:43:23.560 --> 0:43:27.370
<v Speaker 1>What does that say about the type of society that

0:43:27.410 --> 0:43:29.450
<v Speaker 1>they want to build? Because we all understand migration.

0:43:29.469 --> 0:43:34.299
<v Speaker 2>We understand its history and its necessary future. But to me,

0:43:34.360 --> 0:43:37.140
<v Speaker 2>it screams that the government doesn't want kids. They want

0:43:37.140 --> 0:43:39.279
<v Speaker 2>18 year olds because they pay tax from day one.

0:43:40.830 --> 0:43:43.380
<v Speaker 7>Well, the problem is the economic model that the government

0:43:43.420 --> 0:43:46.560
<v Speaker 7>is engaging with, where the only way they can address

0:43:46.780 --> 0:43:50.660
<v Speaker 7>the tax base problem is to continue to pump people in.

0:43:51.140 --> 0:43:54.750
<v Speaker 7>It's unsustainable and it's been unsustainable, frankly, for a while.

0:43:55.150 --> 0:43:57.530
<v Speaker 7>What we actually need to do is have more Australians

0:43:57.610 --> 0:44:02.239
<v Speaker 7>working We need more Australians being financially independent, so they're taxpayers,

0:44:02.380 --> 0:44:05.120
<v Speaker 7>so they're also not dependent on the system. But we

0:44:05.160 --> 0:44:08.040
<v Speaker 7>also need people to move through stages of life in

0:44:08.080 --> 0:44:11.419
<v Speaker 7>a graduated way. We need them to save, invest, buy

0:44:11.440 --> 0:44:14.570
<v Speaker 7>their own homes so they can retire with confidence. Instead,

0:44:14.610 --> 0:44:16.950
<v Speaker 7>the only answer we have at the moment is for

0:44:16.989 --> 0:44:18.630
<v Speaker 7>the government to pump more people in.

0:44:19.010 --> 0:44:20.770
<v Speaker 11>That's having an inflationary effect.

0:44:21.070 --> 0:44:23.330
<v Speaker 7>It's putting more demand on the cost of housing and

0:44:23.370 --> 0:44:26.760
<v Speaker 7>particularly rents. and it's actually meaning we're not setting ourselves

0:44:26.890 --> 0:44:30.140
<v Speaker 7>up for a stable and confident future. And, in fact,

0:44:30.360 --> 0:44:36.100
<v Speaker 7>even under the intergenerational report, we've got essentially the highest

0:44:36.180 --> 0:44:38.380
<v Speaker 7>share of income tax that we've ever had, and it's

0:44:38.440 --> 0:44:41.049
<v Speaker 7>baked in pretty much into the future. So we're not

0:44:41.090 --> 0:44:44.469
<v Speaker 7>even getting lower income taxes as the trade-off.

0:44:44.770 --> 0:44:45.730
<v Speaker 11>Until we pare back.

0:44:45.590 --> 0:44:49.290
<v Speaker 7>Government spending, we're not going to see a change because

0:44:49.310 --> 0:44:51.630
<v Speaker 7>we have too many people dependent on government.

0:44:51.950 --> 0:44:52.630
<v Speaker 9>Yeah, there's also.

0:44:53.590 --> 0:44:57.480
<v Speaker 2>an insight into the future, again, over the next 40 years, is, OK,

0:44:57.840 --> 0:45:00.660
<v Speaker 2>people's retirement, it happens around sort of your mid to

0:45:00.700 --> 0:45:04.020
<v Speaker 2>late 60s, but then life expectancy is going to go

0:45:04.160 --> 0:45:07.110
<v Speaker 2>deep into the 80s for men and touch 90 for women.

0:45:07.630 --> 0:45:11.170
<v Speaker 2>So there's a really serious question here that, again, I'm

0:45:11.190 --> 0:45:13.549
<v Speaker 2>not asking you to answer right now, but do you

0:45:13.630 --> 0:45:16.170
<v Speaker 2>see it as a potential question as well, is there's a.

0:45:16.230 --> 0:45:18.330
<v Speaker 1>Long distance between your mid-60s.

0:45:19.590 --> 0:45:23.790
<v Speaker 2>Let alone your mid-70s, let alone your mid-80s, let alone 90,

0:45:23.770 --> 0:45:26.720
<v Speaker 2>about how people are going to pay for their retirement.

0:45:27.010 --> 0:45:29.799
<v Speaker 2>Because previous generations have been able to buy a house

0:45:29.840 --> 0:45:33.520
<v Speaker 2>that's worth way more, that eventually, financial kaplunk, that money

0:45:33.580 --> 0:45:36.120
<v Speaker 2>pays for the back nine. If you are buying a

0:45:36.140 --> 0:45:39.760
<v Speaker 2>house that either slowly grows and doesn't make that improvement

0:45:39.930 --> 0:45:42.629
<v Speaker 2>or you never actually pay it off, what the hell

0:45:42.670 --> 0:45:45.510
<v Speaker 2>are millions of people going to do from their mid-60s?

0:45:47.750 --> 0:45:50.060
<v Speaker 7>We saw a report that was released last week from

0:45:50.140 --> 0:45:53.090
<v Speaker 7>Vanguard which showed a dramatic increase, and this is in

0:45:53.150 --> 0:45:56.580
<v Speaker 7>today's Intergenerational Report as well, a massive increase in the

0:45:56.640 --> 0:45:59.580
<v Speaker 7>number of people who are going towards retirement and they've

0:45:59.600 --> 0:46:02.089
<v Speaker 7>got a large super balance but they haven't paid off

0:46:02.120 --> 0:46:05.230
<v Speaker 7>the house, logically what's the first thing they do? They

0:46:05.270 --> 0:46:07.870
<v Speaker 7>take their super balance and they pay off their house

0:46:08.030 --> 0:46:10.750
<v Speaker 7>and then become dependent on the pension. This is why

0:46:10.770 --> 0:46:16.250
<v Speaker 7>prioritising super over home ownership doesn't make any logical economic sense.

0:46:16.810 --> 0:46:18.950
<v Speaker 7>But more of the point, we also need to encourage

0:46:19.110 --> 0:46:22.870
<v Speaker 7>or at least allow people older Australians, if they.

0:46:22.750 --> 0:46:25.510
<v Speaker 11>Want to work longer, to be able to work longer,

0:46:25.870 --> 0:46:26.250
<v Speaker 11>which is.

0:46:26.250 --> 0:46:28.959
<v Speaker 7>Why if you are getting the pension, we should be

0:46:29.280 --> 0:46:33.020
<v Speaker 7>providing more flexibility for people to continue to work.

0:46:33.480 --> 0:46:35.460
<v Speaker 11>Some people want to. Some people won't need to.

0:46:35.580 --> 0:46:38.550
<v Speaker 7>That's their choice too. But as you say, there's a

0:46:38.610 --> 0:46:41.370
<v Speaker 7>big gap between your early 60s or even your mid-60s

0:46:41.410 --> 0:46:43.810
<v Speaker 7>and when you get into your 80s or even early 90s.

0:46:43.850 --> 0:46:45.850
<v Speaker 7>No one's going to be working into their late 80s

0:46:45.930 --> 0:46:47.890
<v Speaker 7>or 90s. But if you want to work longer, you

0:46:47.910 --> 0:46:50.560
<v Speaker 7>want to defer the time you draw down from your super,

0:46:50.840 --> 0:46:53.180
<v Speaker 7>or frankly, if you just want to stay economically active

0:46:53.500 --> 0:46:56.380
<v Speaker 7>because you enjoy the social connection, we should provide the

0:46:56.420 --> 0:46:57.520
<v Speaker 7>flexibility to do so.

0:46:58.469 --> 0:47:01.620
<v Speaker 2>What do you think is the sneaky bit of politics

0:47:01.680 --> 0:47:02.600
<v Speaker 2>inside the document?

0:47:02.640 --> 0:47:05.600
<v Speaker 1>Because, again, just the way, you know.

0:47:05.840 --> 0:47:07.560
<v Speaker 2>They can decide to turn up the dials in the

0:47:08.219 --> 0:47:10.120
<v Speaker 2>2030s and turn down the dials in the 2040s to

0:47:10.239 --> 0:47:13.970
<v Speaker 2>help us get where we're going. But I was interested

0:47:14.010 --> 0:47:16.390
<v Speaker 2>in the way they were presenting things. I mentioned a

0:47:16.410 --> 0:47:18.130
<v Speaker 2>bit earlier in the show sort of what was a

0:47:18.190 --> 0:47:20.850
<v Speaker 2>nice clear graph about deficits for the next 40 years

0:47:20.870 --> 0:47:22.149
<v Speaker 2>and Now it just looks like sort.

0:47:22.050 --> 0:47:24.780
<v Speaker 1>Of visual vomit, hoping that no one will notice.

0:47:25.120 --> 0:47:27.400
<v Speaker 2>But were there things inside this where you just sort

0:47:27.440 --> 0:47:29.480
<v Speaker 2>of were taking a mental note going, oh, OK, they're

0:47:29.500 --> 0:47:32.750
<v Speaker 2>probably going to start heading in this direction to start

0:47:32.830 --> 0:47:33.830
<v Speaker 2>paying for things?

0:47:33.890 --> 0:47:34.810
<v Speaker 1>Could you notice anything?

0:47:36.570 --> 0:47:39.910
<v Speaker 7>The clearest thing was the gap between what the number

0:47:39.950 --> 0:47:45.850
<v Speaker 7>Reserve Bank uses for productivity, which is 0.7%, and the

0:47:45.910 --> 0:47:49.600
<v Speaker 7>number that they're using in this report, which is 1.2%. Now,

0:47:49.620 --> 0:47:51.680
<v Speaker 7>that might not sound like that big a deal, but

0:47:52.180 --> 0:47:55.600
<v Speaker 7>every year it continues to compound. And when you reflect

0:47:55.680 --> 0:47:59.060
<v Speaker 7>it in the volume of public debt that we're going

0:47:59.080 --> 0:48:02.240
<v Speaker 7>to have into the future, it essentially doubles the public

0:48:02.300 --> 0:48:03.790
<v Speaker 7>debt out to the 2060s.

0:48:03.780 --> 0:48:03.840
<v Speaker 9>So.

0:48:05.210 --> 0:48:09.129
<v Speaker 7>Australians won't just have more debt. They'll also be, of course,

0:48:09.190 --> 0:48:14.049
<v Speaker 7>paying higher taxes because today's debt is tomorrow's taxes. And

0:48:14.090 --> 0:48:18.070
<v Speaker 7>it's the compounding effect because they won't fix their spending addiction,

0:48:18.410 --> 0:48:21.410
<v Speaker 7>their inflation addiction, and that's all going to be pushed

0:48:21.489 --> 0:48:22.770
<v Speaker 7>on to future generations.

0:48:22.770 --> 0:48:25.110
<v Speaker 1>100%. Thank you very much, Tim. Do appreciate it. We'll

0:48:25.130 --> 0:48:25.950
<v Speaker 1>talk to you again very soon.

0:48:27.270 --> 0:48:27.830
<v Speaker 11>Thanks for having me.

0:48:28.590 --> 0:48:29.290
<v Speaker 1>Good man, Tim Wilson.

0:48:29.310 --> 0:48:31.690
<v Speaker 2>Plenty more on that report. But next, a choice between

0:48:31.810 --> 0:48:33.610
<v Speaker 2>two Labor fools and a Green.

0:48:33.670 --> 0:48:34.390
<v Speaker 1>Which one will I pick?

0:48:40.070 --> 0:48:42.930
<v Speaker 2>When looking for silly politicians doing silly things on social media.

0:48:42.950 --> 0:48:50.960
<v Speaker 1>Let's go with the green, Nick McKim. Yes! Forget Go Work,

0:48:51.000 --> 0:48:53.090
<v Speaker 1>Go Broke. It's Go Work, Get Dubs.

0:48:53.190 --> 0:48:54.069
<v Speaker 6>We are so back.

0:48:55.810 --> 0:48:57.290
<v Speaker 1>While you were working. See you tomorrow.