1
00:00:05,921 --> 00:00:19,881
Speaker 1: Approache production. Welcome back to silent Secrets. Tonight, we drift

2
00:00:19,921 --> 00:00:23,441
Speaker 1: to the southern edge of Australia, to a strip of

3
00:00:23,481 --> 00:00:28,801
Speaker 1: water that looks calm from far away, but up close

4
00:00:29,961 --> 00:00:34,321
Speaker 1: it's full of cross currants, sudden weather, and old stories.

5
00:00:40,120 --> 00:00:46,560
Speaker 1: The bass strait. Close your eyes, take a slow breath

6
00:00:46,681 --> 00:00:58,361
Speaker 1: in and out. We're going back to Saturday, October twenty one,

7
00:00:58,761 --> 00:01:04,481
Speaker 1: nineteen seventy eight. A young pilot lifts off into the

8
00:01:04,521 --> 00:01:07,961
Speaker 1: evening line for a short trip over the water and

9
00:01:08,121 --> 00:01:16,241
Speaker 1: never returns. This is the disappearance of Frederick Valantiche a

10
00:01:16,360 --> 00:01:21,640
Speaker 1: voice on the radio, a mystery in the dark, and

11
00:01:21,721 --> 00:01:30,121
Speaker 1: a sound that's never fully been explained. Settle in, let

12
00:01:30,161 --> 00:01:35,560
Speaker 1: the day fall away. We'll keep our lights low, our

13
00:01:35,601 --> 00:01:41,761
Speaker 1: pace gentle, and will follow his flight, minute by minute

14
00:01:42,081 --> 00:01:59,641
Speaker 1: until the signal fades. It's late afternoon at Moraban Airport,

15
00:01:59,841 --> 00:02:06,321
Speaker 1: southeast of Melbourne. Hayar doors, yawn, open toolboxes roll back

16
00:02:06,361 --> 00:02:12,401
Speaker 1: into place. A single engine Cessna one two sits ready, metal,

17
00:02:12,681 --> 00:02:19,281
Speaker 1: warm from the sun. Frederick is twenty years old, young,

18
00:02:19,881 --> 00:02:25,520
Speaker 1: determined and steady. He loves flying. It makes sense to him.

19
00:02:26,001 --> 00:02:30,161
Speaker 1: The numbers, the checklists, the clean lines of the horizon,

20
00:02:31,841 --> 00:02:35,240
Speaker 1: he's not a veteran pilot, but he's logged his hours,

21
00:02:35,960 --> 00:02:41,761
Speaker 1: practice procedures, and he's prepared for this. He's file the

22
00:02:41,761 --> 00:02:47,240
Speaker 1: flight plan, depart Morabin, fly south southwest across the water

23
00:02:47,481 --> 00:02:51,401
Speaker 1: to King Island, and then turn around and come home

24
00:02:51,800 --> 00:02:56,280
Speaker 1: the same night. He checks the weather. The forecast is

25
00:02:56,321 --> 00:03:00,680
Speaker 1: good and clear. It's the kind of evening where the

26
00:03:00,761 --> 00:03:03,641
Speaker 1: light lingers just a little too long to call at night,

27
00:03:04,081 --> 00:03:08,641
Speaker 1: but the shadows are already in charge. He takes a

28
00:03:08,721 --> 00:03:14,881
Speaker 1: quiet moment in the cockpit, in a hale exhale, battery

29
00:03:15,001 --> 00:03:22,761
Speaker 1: on fuel, checked instruments, set, radio's tuned. It's a habit,

30
00:03:23,441 --> 00:03:29,881
Speaker 1: a ritual. Just after six pm, he taxes to the runway,

31
00:03:31,001 --> 00:03:42,481
Speaker 1: calls the tower, and rolls forward into flight. Below Frederick,

32
00:03:42,761 --> 00:03:49,001
Speaker 1: Melbourne slips away, grids of streets, tiny toy cars, the

33
00:03:49,081 --> 00:03:54,761
Speaker 1: last commuters heading home ahead. The Bass Strait a sheet

34
00:03:54,801 --> 00:04:01,201
Speaker 1: of blue that is never exactly still. If you've never

35
00:04:01,281 --> 00:04:06,561
Speaker 1: flown that way, picture this. The coast falls back like

36
00:04:06,601 --> 00:04:12,601
Speaker 1: a page turning. The land darkens, the water takes over.

37
00:04:13,641 --> 00:04:16,441
Speaker 1: Even on a clear night, there's a moment where the

38
00:04:16,481 --> 00:04:21,481
Speaker 1: sky and the sea are almost the same color, and

39
00:04:21,521 --> 00:04:26,481
Speaker 1: the horizon is more a feeling than a line. The

40
00:04:26,521 --> 00:04:30,841
Speaker 1: instruments become your eyes. The hum of the engine is

41
00:04:30,841 --> 00:04:39,520
Speaker 1: your anchor. Frederick levels out, steady altitude, heading south. He's

42
00:04:39,561 --> 00:04:45,721
Speaker 1: on schedule for the first hour. Everything is ordinary, radio checks,

43
00:04:46,161 --> 00:04:51,841
Speaker 1: coarse corrections, the small adjustments you barely notice until you're

44
00:04:51,880 --> 00:04:59,080
Speaker 1: looking for them. Routine can be soothing. Routine can be

45
00:04:59,241 --> 00:05:10,440
Speaker 1: a lullaby. In two three out two three, Then the

46
00:05:10,561 --> 00:05:20,041
Speaker 1: routine changes. Frederick keys the microphone to Melbourne Flight Service.

47
00:05:21,161 --> 00:05:27,721
Speaker 1: His voice is calm, clipped professional. He reports an unidentified

48
00:05:27,761 --> 00:05:32,521
Speaker 1: aircraft a little above him with bright lights. The controller

49
00:05:32,601 --> 00:05:38,521
Speaker 1: listens and asks for more details. Frederick says the object

50
00:05:38,561 --> 00:05:44,080
Speaker 1: is moving fast, circling and at times matching his speed.

51
00:05:45,481 --> 00:05:49,400
Speaker 1: He estimates it's a few hundred meters above him. He

52
00:05:49,521 --> 00:05:56,641
Speaker 1: mentions four bright lights. The controller checks known traffic, nothing

53
00:05:56,681 --> 00:06:04,001
Speaker 1: in the area, no scheduled flights, no military activity. Frederick

54
00:06:04,320 --> 00:06:08,921
Speaker 1: continues watching the lights. They're not behaving the way standard

55
00:06:08,921 --> 00:06:16,201
Speaker 1: aircraft do. They move, pull ahead, and drop behind. At

56
00:06:16,201 --> 00:06:19,761
Speaker 1: one point they seem to pass over him and then reappear.

57
00:06:21,481 --> 00:06:27,161
Speaker 1: His breathing is a little faster now, not panic, but effort,

58
00:06:28,361 --> 00:06:33,521
Speaker 1: the effort of tracking something you don't understand. Is there

59
00:06:33,561 --> 00:06:39,041
Speaker 1: any known traffic below five thousand? He asks, no known traffic,

60
00:06:39,721 --> 00:06:47,241
Speaker 1: the controller replies. Frederick describes a shiny, metallic surface. He

61
00:06:47,361 --> 00:06:52,601
Speaker 1: mentions a green light. He says quietly that it seems

62
00:06:53,241 --> 00:06:58,001
Speaker 1: like it's playing some sort of game, and then almost

63
00:06:58,081 --> 00:07:04,440
Speaker 1: to himself, it's not an aircraft. The controller notes his words,

64
00:07:05,320 --> 00:07:10,121
Speaker 1: keeps him talking and keeps him focused. That's his job.

65
00:07:11,161 --> 00:07:19,601
Speaker 1: Keep the pilot flying the plane. There are things pilots

66
00:07:19,681 --> 00:07:25,241
Speaker 1: learn early. Trust your instruments, not your eyes, fly the plane,

67
00:07:25,561 --> 00:07:29,201
Speaker 1: not the story in your head. If something feels off,

68
00:07:29,681 --> 00:07:34,161
Speaker 1: say it out loud. Frederick does all of those things,

69
00:07:35,321 --> 00:07:40,201
Speaker 1: But the pattern is strange. The lights seem to approach,

70
00:07:41,561 --> 00:07:48,801
Speaker 1: then vanish, then return. If it was another aircraft, it's

71
00:07:48,841 --> 00:07:54,961
Speaker 1: breaking the rules, closing in too tight, making unpredictable turns.

72
00:07:56,161 --> 00:08:03,761
Speaker 1: If it's not an aircraft, then what is it. The

73
00:08:03,841 --> 00:08:09,481
Speaker 1: controller asks him to identify his position. Frederick gives a

74
00:08:09,561 --> 00:08:14,601
Speaker 1: rough fix, heading towards King Island. He says, the object

75
00:08:14,681 --> 00:08:19,241
Speaker 1: is now above him. He looks up through the window shield,

76
00:08:20,081 --> 00:08:27,001
Speaker 1: greenish light metal reflecting the last scraps of twilight. He

77
00:08:27,081 --> 00:08:33,241
Speaker 1: can't define a wing shape. He can't define the fuselage

78
00:08:33,921 --> 00:08:39,241
Speaker 1: the sea below has turned slate. The sky is deepening

79
00:08:39,361 --> 00:08:48,841
Speaker 1: to blue black. A fragile line separates the two. Frederick

80
00:08:48,881 --> 00:08:52,801
Speaker 1: reports that he's having engine issues, a roughness like something

81
00:08:52,961 --> 00:08:57,721
Speaker 1: is interfering. He checks his systems, tries to stay ahead

82
00:08:57,721 --> 00:09:03,641
Speaker 1: of the problem. He keeps talking to the controller, voice steady,

83
00:09:04,361 --> 00:09:09,921
Speaker 1: a little tip around the edges. The controller's voice is

84
00:09:09,961 --> 00:09:19,761
Speaker 1: a metronome. Confirm position, Confirm heading, any immediate danger. Frederick replies,

85
00:09:20,441 --> 00:09:24,201
Speaker 1: the strange aircraft is hovering on top of me. Again.

86
00:09:29,361 --> 00:09:33,521
Speaker 1: At seven twelve pm, just over an hour into the flight,

87
00:09:34,481 --> 00:09:41,481
Speaker 1: the transmission changes. There's a harsh, metallic pulsing noise on

88
00:09:41,561 --> 00:09:52,001
Speaker 1: the frequency. It lasts about seventeen seconds. It doesn't sound

89
00:09:52,081 --> 00:09:57,321
Speaker 1: like engine noise. It doesn't sound like static. It's something else.

90
00:09:59,001 --> 00:10:05,681
Speaker 1: A grinding, a rasping, a modulation that bites the edge,

91
00:10:05,961 --> 00:10:24,241
Speaker 1: and then silence. The controller calls back, no reply again.

92
00:10:26,641 --> 00:10:32,921
Speaker 1: Nothing in the tower, and on the tapes, the absence

93
00:10:33,041 --> 00:10:36,921
Speaker 1: becomes the story. Silence has a way you can feel

94
00:10:37,521 --> 00:10:44,841
Speaker 1: when you're listening for a voice that doesn't return. Within hours,

95
00:10:44,881 --> 00:10:49,761
Speaker 1: the search begins. Aircraft sweep the corridors of the sea,

96
00:10:49,801 --> 00:10:58,281
Speaker 1: and sky boats fan out along the likely route. At

97
00:10:58,321 --> 00:11:04,681
Speaker 1: first light, they expand the grid, eyes scanning for wreckage, oil,

98
00:11:05,761 --> 00:11:14,721
Speaker 1: a life jacket, anything. They find nothing. No floating debris,

99
00:11:15,321 --> 00:11:29,041
Speaker 1: no emergency beacon, no sign. Here's what we know, slowly, gently,

100
00:11:30,521 --> 00:11:35,241
Speaker 1: just the pieces that fit. It's the evening of October

101
00:11:35,281 --> 00:11:40,281
Speaker 1: twenty one, nineteen seventy eight, over the bas Strait on

102
00:11:40,361 --> 00:11:44,241
Speaker 1: a plan route to king Island. The aircraft's a Cessna

103
00:11:44,441 --> 00:11:52,681
Speaker 1: one two, simple, reliable, single engine. The pilot is Frederick,

104
00:11:53,801 --> 00:11:59,761
Speaker 1: twenty years old, trained, not highly experienced, but familiar with

105
00:11:59,921 --> 00:12:08,201
Speaker 1: procedure and radio discipline. The weather is generally good, not perfect,

106
00:12:08,441 --> 00:12:14,601
Speaker 1: but not storm conditions. There were multiple communications between Melbourne

107
00:12:14,601 --> 00:12:20,521
Speaker 1: Flight Service describing an unidentified object with bright lights, a

108
00:12:20,561 --> 00:12:28,001
Speaker 1: metallic surface and a green light performing unusual maneuvers. The

109
00:12:28,041 --> 00:12:33,361
Speaker 1: final audio is a seventeen second metallic sound and then

110
00:12:35,001 --> 00:12:42,921
Speaker 1: radio silence. A multi day search finds no trace those

111
00:12:43,281 --> 00:12:49,841
Speaker 1: other lines on the page. The rest is conjecture, theory

112
00:12:50,081 --> 00:12:53,721
Speaker 1: and human nature. Trying to finish a story with a

113
00:12:53,761 --> 00:13:04,681
Speaker 1: missing paragraph. People try to solve mysteries because it makes

114
00:13:04,721 --> 00:13:10,321
Speaker 1: us feel safe. We like doors that close, but some

115
00:13:10,481 --> 00:13:18,521
Speaker 1: doors don't. There are several series about Frederick's disappearance. The

116
00:13:18,561 --> 00:13:24,361
Speaker 1: first is around spatial disorientation and a crash. Pilots can

117
00:13:24,441 --> 00:13:29,961
Speaker 1: sometimes become disoriented over water at night. The horizon blurs

118
00:13:30,881 --> 00:13:34,921
Speaker 1: your inner ears lie to you. Even good pilots have

119
00:13:35,001 --> 00:13:39,081
Speaker 1: been fooled by the dark. Maybe the lights he saw

120
00:13:39,601 --> 00:13:46,041
Speaker 1: were misinterpretations of stars, planets, the illusion of movements against

121
00:13:46,081 --> 00:13:50,921
Speaker 1: a moving sea. Maybe engine roughness led to a loss

122
00:13:50,921 --> 00:13:57,321
Speaker 1: of control, a descent into the black water. This is

123
00:13:57,361 --> 00:14:02,881
Speaker 1: a tidy explanation. It's also incomplete. It asks us to

124
00:14:03,001 --> 00:14:07,641
Speaker 1: fold those specific details circling the hovering and the metallic

125
00:14:07,721 --> 00:14:15,161
Speaker 1: sound into the general noise of a tragic accident. The

126
00:14:15,241 --> 00:14:20,321
Speaker 1: second theory is that it was a deliberate disappearance. Some

127
00:14:20,361 --> 00:14:26,601
Speaker 1: suggest a plan vanishing landing elsewhere, staging the scenario, But

128
00:14:26,721 --> 00:14:29,881
Speaker 1: searches along the route and on King Island didn't turn

129
00:14:29,961 --> 00:14:34,001
Speaker 1: up evidence of an unscheduled landing, and there's no clear

130
00:14:34,041 --> 00:14:40,721
Speaker 1: motive that ties to that story. Disappearances, by design, tend

131
00:14:40,801 --> 00:14:52,561
Speaker 1: to leave footprints, paper money sightings. This one didn't. The

132
00:14:52,561 --> 00:14:59,161
Speaker 1: third theory is mechanical failure. Engines can quit, systems can fail.

133
00:15:00,241 --> 00:15:06,361
Speaker 1: A single failure over the bastraighte at night is unforgiving.

134
00:15:09,321 --> 00:15:13,361
Speaker 1: The question here is the timing, the alleged presence of

135
00:15:13,401 --> 00:15:21,321
Speaker 1: another craft, the specific maneuvers described, and the seventeen second

136
00:15:21,441 --> 00:15:28,961
Speaker 1: noise immediately before the signal dies. And the final theory

137
00:15:29,561 --> 00:15:35,081
Speaker 1: is the unknown when the pilot says it's not an aircraft,

138
00:15:35,761 --> 00:15:42,721
Speaker 1: Some here fear, others hear certainty. Reports from that era

139
00:15:43,921 --> 00:15:49,561
Speaker 1: include sightings of unusual lights over the strait, not proofs,

140
00:15:49,681 --> 00:15:55,281
Speaker 1: just echoes. This theory is a placeholder for the part

141
00:15:55,281 --> 00:16:00,921
Speaker 1: of the story we don't have. Between the lines. There

142
00:16:00,921 --> 00:16:07,521
Speaker 1: are smaller ideas misidentified lights from the ground, reflections inside

143
00:16:07,521 --> 00:16:14,881
Speaker 1: the cockpit, a meteor, an optical effect, radio interference. Each

144
00:16:14,961 --> 00:16:20,201
Speaker 1: can explain a piece. Nothing explains all the pieces neatly,

145
00:16:21,361 --> 00:16:27,481
Speaker 1: and sometimes that's the point. The human brain wants a

146
00:16:27,521 --> 00:16:32,521
Speaker 1: single answer, and the world gives us pieces that refuse

147
00:16:32,641 --> 00:16:41,321
Speaker 1: to lock in. The radio exchange survives. If you listen,

148
00:16:41,481 --> 00:16:45,801
Speaker 1: the first thing you'll notice is the tone. Frederick sounds

149
00:16:45,841 --> 00:16:51,681
Speaker 1: like a pilot talking through a checklist, polite, controlled and focused.

150
00:16:53,121 --> 00:16:57,321
Speaker 1: The controller is steady, a calm lighthouse in the fog.

151
00:16:59,481 --> 00:17:03,961
Speaker 1: Then you hear it a shift, not panic, but that

152
00:17:04,121 --> 00:17:09,960
Speaker 1: leaned forward edge when reality doesn't line up. The metal

153
00:17:10,001 --> 00:17:13,561
Speaker 1: sound at the end is the part that stays with people.

154
00:17:15,441 --> 00:17:19,360
Speaker 1: Engineers have pulled it apart, filtered it, tried to match

155
00:17:19,400 --> 00:17:25,521
Speaker 1: it to known signatures, prop noise, magneto failure, radio feedback,

156
00:17:26,241 --> 00:17:33,801
Speaker 1: something external. The answer never lands with both feet. The

157
00:17:33,880 --> 00:17:38,801
Speaker 1: tape ends the same way bad dreams do, abruptly, with

158
00:17:38,961 --> 00:17:46,960
Speaker 1: you reaching for a conclusion that isn't there. Behind the

159
00:17:47,001 --> 00:17:50,400
Speaker 1: headlines and the theories is a family who waited for

160
00:17:50,481 --> 00:17:56,281
Speaker 1: footsteps that didn't come, an empty chair at the table,

161
00:17:56,721 --> 00:18:00,321
Speaker 1: a room where the air felt heavier because the person

162
00:18:00,360 --> 00:18:06,281
Speaker 1: who warmed it was gone. There's a kind of grief

163
00:18:06,640 --> 00:18:12,321
Speaker 1: that has no body, no wreckage, no final proof. It's

164
00:18:12,360 --> 00:18:16,640
Speaker 1: called ambiguous loss, when the mind knows something that's slightly over,

165
00:18:17,241 --> 00:18:23,001
Speaker 1: but the heart keeps leaving a light on The bass

166
00:18:23,001 --> 00:18:27,001
Speaker 1: strait for them isn't just water. It's a question that

167
00:18:27,160 --> 00:18:33,001
Speaker 1: never answers. Mysteries become folklore because people need a way

168
00:18:33,160 --> 00:18:39,481
Speaker 1: to carry them. They tell themselves the story with different endings.

169
00:18:40,241 --> 00:18:48,721
Speaker 1: He was taken, he escaped, he lost control. They try

170
00:18:48,721 --> 00:18:52,281
Speaker 1: them on like coats, and none of them fit quite right.

171
00:18:53,041 --> 00:19:00,120
Speaker 1: But it's better than standing cold with nothing. If you

172
00:19:00,160 --> 00:19:04,281
Speaker 1: fly that route now, the air looks the same, The

173
00:19:04,321 --> 00:19:09,720
Speaker 1: strait still folds and unfolds under you, moody, muscular, a

174
00:19:09,801 --> 00:19:14,921
Speaker 1: living thing. On clear nights, the stars can feel close

175
00:19:15,041 --> 00:19:21,001
Speaker 1: enough to touch. On hazy ones, you learn to lean

176
00:19:21,041 --> 00:19:27,640
Speaker 1: into your instruments, and your training and your trust. Every

177
00:19:27,681 --> 00:19:33,840
Speaker 1: few years someone mentions strange lights over the bastrait. Most

178
00:19:34,281 --> 00:19:42,681
Speaker 1: have explanations, a few do not. The sea holds the story.

179
00:19:43,441 --> 00:20:04,281
Speaker 1: Sometimes it keeps them forever. We've been flying with Frederick

180
00:20:04,441 --> 00:20:08,841
Speaker 1: for the last hour of his life, as far as

181
00:20:08,840 --> 00:20:16,600
Speaker 1: we can go, and plan a flight, a report, a

182
00:20:16,761 --> 00:20:24,201
Speaker 1: sound that's silence in another world. He makes the hop

183
00:20:24,241 --> 00:20:28,640
Speaker 1: to King Island, eats something warm at a cafe, checks

184
00:20:28,640 --> 00:20:32,961
Speaker 1: his fuel, turns back and lands up a rabin under

185
00:20:32,961 --> 00:20:37,680
Speaker 1: a quilt of city lights. In this world, we have

186
00:20:37,721 --> 00:20:45,160
Speaker 1: a gap where the ending should be. Take a slow

187
00:20:45,241 --> 00:20:53,521
Speaker 1: breath in an out let's your shoulders drop, that your

188
00:20:53,640 --> 00:21:01,680
Speaker 1: jaws soften. Whether the answer is ordinary or tragic, or

189
00:21:01,721 --> 00:21:09,001
Speaker 1: extraordinary and impossible, the truth is still out there, somewhere

190
00:21:09,041 --> 00:21:12,761
Speaker 1: between the last transmission and the first light of dawn.

191
00:21:14,281 --> 00:21:20,920
Speaker 1: Until then, the Bastrait holds its quite vigil, The radio

192
00:21:21,120 --> 00:21:27,120
Speaker 1: stay silent, and a young pilot's last words ripple outwards

193
00:21:27,160 --> 00:21:37,201
Speaker 1: softly into the dark. This has been silent secrets. Sleep well,

194
00:21:38,441 --> 00:23:08,120
Speaker 1: good night, sam IT, good day. Play a using them,