WEBVTT - The Bolt Report | 14 October

0:00:15.770 --> 0:00:19.510
<v Speaker 1>Tonight, big show. Opposition leader Angus Taylor getting tough on

0:00:19.910 --> 0:00:25.200
<v Speaker 1>global warming schemes. But Climate Change Minister Chris Bowen, he

0:00:25.300 --> 0:00:29.700
<v Speaker 1>just keeps conning you. A fact check for him. Also tonight,

0:00:29.740 --> 0:00:33.280
<v Speaker 1>Greta Thunberg joins the violent riots in France and actually

0:00:33.720 --> 0:00:38.620
<v Speaker 1>praises them, despite... Oh dear, the terrible emissions from the rioters'

0:00:39.050 --> 0:00:42.430
<v Speaker 1>own fires. And how long could Donald Trump's new press

0:00:42.450 --> 0:00:48.270
<v Speaker 1>secretary last? Bad nerves and very dodgy qualifications. And plenty more,

0:00:48.590 --> 0:00:54.760
<v Speaker 1>including Gemma and Caroline. But first, what a sick joke

0:00:55.220 --> 0:00:57.800
<v Speaker 1>to see our Prime Minister and Treasurer arguing about who

0:00:57.860 --> 0:01:02.360
<v Speaker 1>can take the credit for being the least stupid. I mean,

0:01:02.380 --> 0:01:05.150
<v Speaker 1>the Muppets now running this country are We're told Anthony

0:01:05.209 --> 0:01:08.809
<v Speaker 1>Albanese put Jim Chalmers in his place at an Australian

0:01:08.850 --> 0:01:12.330
<v Speaker 1>Chamber of Commerce and Industry dinner last night, suggesting he'd

0:01:12.410 --> 0:01:15.610
<v Speaker 1>overruled his Treasurer to order a delay of a tax

0:01:15.650 --> 0:01:19.830
<v Speaker 1>office ban on credit card payments that had really outraged

0:01:19.890 --> 0:01:22.959
<v Speaker 1>business groups. They said they'd been blindsided. In fact, the

0:01:23.240 --> 0:01:25.440
<v Speaker 1>Chamber's boss made that clear at the dinner.

0:01:26.540 --> 0:01:30.259
<v Speaker 2>It was a decision taken without consultation. Prime Minister, to

0:01:30.319 --> 0:01:35.520
<v Speaker 2>your credit, your door was opened. You engaged, you listened

0:01:35.880 --> 0:01:39.320
<v Speaker 2>and you acted quickly to provide vital breathing space for

0:01:39.360 --> 0:01:43.780
<v Speaker 2>small business. We welcome that response and we will use

0:01:43.819 --> 0:01:46.399
<v Speaker 2>the additional time to work with the Tax Office now

0:01:46.480 --> 0:01:48.820
<v Speaker 2>to find a sustainable long-term solution.

0:01:50.800 --> 0:01:55.500
<v Speaker 1>Now Albanese did not question that very generous interpretation that

0:01:56.000 --> 0:02:00.800
<v Speaker 1>business had not been consulted ahead of the decision. At Albanese,

0:02:01.020 --> 0:02:03.400
<v Speaker 1>he had jumped in to fix things.

0:02:04.640 --> 0:02:10.500
<v Speaker 3>Andrew did text me last Thursday morning. And by Friday morning,

0:02:11.440 --> 0:02:17.930
<v Speaker 3>we had an announcement. And that was an example of

0:02:18.150 --> 0:02:21.270
<v Speaker 3>a relationship that takes time to develop as well. That

0:02:21.310 --> 0:02:24.610
<v Speaker 3>trust where you can have a discussion saying it's in hand.

0:02:25.690 --> 0:02:31.030
<v Speaker 3>I agree with what you are saying. And I'll get

0:02:31.070 --> 0:02:31.500
<v Speaker 3>it done.

0:02:34.060 --> 0:02:37.639
<v Speaker 1>Well, that relationship of trust seems to be unlike Albanese's

0:02:37.740 --> 0:02:42.299
<v Speaker 1>one with his treasurer, who today was a very grim Jim,

0:02:43.040 --> 0:02:46.049
<v Speaker 1>denying the clear implication of what you just heard. He said, no,

0:02:46.090 --> 0:02:49.210
<v Speaker 1>he wasn't overruled. In fact, he'd agreed with Albanese on

0:02:49.250 --> 0:02:55.010
<v Speaker 1>a fix last Wednesday, the night before that businessman's call.

0:02:55.980 --> 0:02:57.000
<v Speaker 4>Were you rolled by the PM?

0:02:57.560 --> 0:02:58.320
<v Speaker 1>No, not at all.

0:02:59.300 --> 0:03:02.840
<v Speaker 5>And it is true that there were discussions with ACCI

0:03:03.040 --> 0:03:05.839
<v Speaker 5>on Thursday. We were involved in some of those discussions

0:03:05.980 --> 0:03:09.680
<v Speaker 5>at office level. They were engaging with my team.

0:03:10.240 --> 0:03:11.910
<v Speaker 1>Were you overlooked by ACCI?

0:03:12.000 --> 0:03:13.930
<v Speaker 5>If you just let me set it out for you, Trudy,

0:03:13.970 --> 0:03:16.430
<v Speaker 5>Prime Minister and I were in discussions on Wednesday of

0:03:16.490 --> 0:03:19.540
<v Speaker 5>last week. He had a view, and I agree with it,

0:03:20.350 --> 0:03:22.970
<v Speaker 5>that we needed to step in to provide this longer

0:03:23.240 --> 0:03:26.060
<v Speaker 5>transition period to allow the ATO the time.

0:03:25.919 --> 0:03:26.540
<v Speaker 1>To get it right.

0:03:26.560 --> 0:03:28.780
<v Speaker 5>But it was his view, is that he decided to...

0:03:28.620 --> 0:03:30.919
<v Speaker 5>We had the same view. We had the same view.

0:03:34.320 --> 0:03:38.290
<v Speaker 1>The Prime Minister today seemed to think he'd better calm

0:03:38.330 --> 0:03:41.530
<v Speaker 1>things down and also denied in Parliament there'd been a

0:03:41.590 --> 0:03:45.530
<v Speaker 1>difference between the two men. But I said the commentary

0:03:45.570 --> 0:03:48.529
<v Speaker 1>you're hearing misses the real angle, and this is what

0:03:48.570 --> 0:03:54.680
<v Speaker 1>I mean. Why are these two blokes skiting or wrestling

0:03:54.700 --> 0:03:59.420
<v Speaker 1>for credit about how they finally fixed things, how they

0:03:59.520 --> 0:04:04.250
<v Speaker 1>fixed this pig's breakfast that they'd made with their ban

0:04:04.290 --> 0:04:09.650
<v Speaker 1>on credit card surcharges? you know, all the implications and

0:04:09.690 --> 0:04:14.790
<v Speaker 1>the unseen circumstances, when they'd never worked out the consequences

0:04:14.890 --> 0:04:18.930
<v Speaker 1>before it all hit the fan? Why did Albanese suggest

0:04:18.990 --> 0:04:23.190
<v Speaker 1>it took a special relationship with one business leader who

0:04:23.290 --> 0:04:27.610
<v Speaker 1>had his phone number to alert the government on Thursday

0:04:28.000 --> 0:04:30.820
<v Speaker 1>to problems that should have been worked through with business

0:04:31.339 --> 0:04:36.920
<v Speaker 1>weeks and weeks before? But I have bad news for you.

0:04:37.820 --> 0:04:40.980
<v Speaker 1>Even this was not the most startling example today of

0:04:41.020 --> 0:04:45.260
<v Speaker 1>this government not consulting businesses before almost literally destroying them,

0:04:46.290 --> 0:04:50.490
<v Speaker 1>and in this case for ludicrous reasons. The Federal Court

0:04:50.830 --> 0:04:55.670
<v Speaker 1>today whacked the government for not giving operators of the

0:04:55.670 --> 0:04:59.890
<v Speaker 1>$ 1. 3 billion Blaney gold mine in Western New South Wales

0:05:00.410 --> 0:05:06.260
<v Speaker 1>a fair hearing before deciding to block it. The court

0:05:06.350 --> 0:05:09.210
<v Speaker 1>overruled that decision and told the environment minister to decide

0:05:09.230 --> 0:05:13.270
<v Speaker 1>the case again, but this time properly. Now, what makes

0:05:14.690 --> 0:05:19.070
<v Speaker 1>this case even crazier is that the then environment minister,

0:05:19.130 --> 0:05:23.750
<v Speaker 1>Tanya Plibersek, since replaced, claimed two years ago that his

0:05:23.850 --> 0:05:27.980
<v Speaker 1>mind couldn't go ahead because an Aboriginal group claimed that

0:05:28.040 --> 0:05:34.580
<v Speaker 1>the blue-banded bee wouldn't like it. This bee's dreaming story

0:05:34.950 --> 0:05:38.620
<v Speaker 1>would be disturbed. I wonder how many bees she interviewed

0:05:38.660 --> 0:05:41.940
<v Speaker 1>to form that opinion. She wouldn't say too much, though.

0:05:42.839 --> 0:05:46.780
<v Speaker 1>Secret business, she said. Some of these traditions have been

0:05:46.820 --> 0:05:50.720
<v Speaker 1>disclosed to me privately and must remain confidential due to

0:05:50.760 --> 0:05:56.210
<v Speaker 1>their cultural sensitivity. Very convenient. Although Blibbersek did later say

0:05:56.250 --> 0:06:00.550
<v Speaker 1>that the mine's planned tailings dam would destroy the local river, although, really,

0:06:01.240 --> 0:06:04.760
<v Speaker 1>Come on, I mean, that proposal already got environmental approval.

0:06:05.040 --> 0:06:08.620
<v Speaker 1>The river would not, in fact, be destroyed. No, it

0:06:08.670 --> 0:06:11.070
<v Speaker 1>seemed to me back then that Plibersek was freaking that

0:06:11.089 --> 0:06:14.930
<v Speaker 1>she'd blocked this moan for plainly preposterous reasons and was

0:06:14.970 --> 0:06:19.170
<v Speaker 1>then looking for other excuses, since the local traditional owners,

0:06:19.250 --> 0:06:23.279
<v Speaker 1>the formal group, had already said the site was not sacred.

0:06:24.920 --> 0:06:29.029
<v Speaker 1>But Plibersek, chose to listen instead to some other people

0:06:29.130 --> 0:06:33.539
<v Speaker 1>identifying as Aboriginal, people that she wouldn't identify again. But

0:06:33.900 --> 0:06:36.520
<v Speaker 1>I will now read out some of the evidence we

0:06:36.660 --> 0:06:40.780
<v Speaker 1>do know was given by people identifying as Aboriginal who

0:06:40.900 --> 0:06:45.670
<v Speaker 1>did oppose the mine in the Independent Planning Commission hearings.

0:06:47.190 --> 0:06:50.890
<v Speaker 1>This is the artist Nyree Reynolds, who was backed by

0:06:50.990 --> 0:06:55.089
<v Speaker 1>Lisa Payton. Payton is a leader of that dissident group,

0:06:55.330 --> 0:06:59.380
<v Speaker 1>of some 18 people, the Wiradjuri Traditional Owners Central West

0:06:59.740 --> 0:07:05.520
<v Speaker 1>Aboriginal Corporation. And here's what that artist testified. She said,

0:07:06.500 --> 0:07:12.080
<v Speaker 1>I'm Nairie Reynolds. I have vocal dysphoria, which is paralysis

0:07:12.120 --> 0:07:16.350
<v Speaker 1>of my vocal cords. That's sad. I shouldn't imply it's not.

0:07:17.270 --> 0:07:21.650
<v Speaker 1>She also said, I have mesothelioma, which is cancer caused

0:07:21.710 --> 0:07:27.870
<v Speaker 1>by asbestos. So she said, This mind freaks me out, actually.

0:07:30.210 --> 0:07:32.650
<v Speaker 1>But why was that relevant? Because this mind doesn't cause

0:07:32.710 --> 0:07:38.790
<v Speaker 1>focal paralysis or mesothelioma. But this artist went on to

0:07:38.950 --> 0:07:42.570
<v Speaker 1>tell the planning commission, show it, a painting that she'd

0:07:42.630 --> 0:07:47.060
<v Speaker 1>actually done. And she said, I think the best way

0:07:47.520 --> 0:07:51.000
<v Speaker 1>is through my paintings. She said, this council, referring to

0:07:51.200 --> 0:07:54.880
<v Speaker 1>a local council, asked me to do a painting for

0:07:55.020 --> 0:07:59.700
<v Speaker 1>the billboard that's on the Midwestern Highway. It's the first

0:07:59.780 --> 0:08:04.250
<v Speaker 1>view of a registry country in Blaney Shire. So she said,

0:08:04.820 --> 0:08:07.200
<v Speaker 1>it's very, it's really important to me. So if the

0:08:07.230 --> 0:08:10.610
<v Speaker 1>mind goes there, this will be the only representation left

0:08:10.650 --> 0:08:12.290
<v Speaker 1>of what it was like. And this is also part

0:08:12.310 --> 0:08:18.870
<v Speaker 1>of the sacred triangle. The sacred triangle. Reynolds went on,

0:08:18.910 --> 0:08:21.550
<v Speaker 1>I heard about the mine. I imagined all my ancestors

0:08:21.850 --> 0:08:28.070
<v Speaker 1>leaving because that was the second billboard I'd done. When

0:08:28.110 --> 0:08:31.960
<v Speaker 1>we put the first billboard up, she said, I felt

0:08:32.059 --> 0:08:36.920
<v Speaker 1>the ancestors. It was just beautiful. Now I can see

0:08:36.960 --> 0:08:40.959
<v Speaker 1>that they're leaving, the spirits are leaving. So Is this

0:08:41.360 --> 0:08:45.850
<v Speaker 1>one of the reasons a $ 1 billion gold mine was

0:08:45.970 --> 0:08:49.110
<v Speaker 1>stopped by this government? The witness told the Commission she

0:08:49.130 --> 0:08:52.910
<v Speaker 1>also won the New South Wales Parliamentary Art Prize. Yet

0:08:53.110 --> 0:08:58.130
<v Speaker 1>never is there a real rational explanation for why this

0:08:58.250 --> 0:09:01.470
<v Speaker 1>mine site is sacred and why the local traditional owners

0:09:01.490 --> 0:09:05.700
<v Speaker 1>were wrong to say it was not. Now, New South

0:09:05.720 --> 0:09:08.120
<v Speaker 1>Wales Premier Chris Minns is a Labor man, but today

0:09:08.160 --> 0:09:11.410
<v Speaker 1>he made clear that Plibersek and the and the Albanese

0:09:11.429 --> 0:09:15.140
<v Speaker 1>government had got this very wrong. Look, I want that

0:09:15.200 --> 0:09:15.920
<v Speaker 1>mine to go ahead.

0:09:16.179 --> 0:09:21.120
<v Speaker 6>I understand that that's not the view of the federal government,

0:09:21.179 --> 0:09:22.500
<v Speaker 6>but we need the investment.

0:09:22.620 --> 0:09:24.620
<v Speaker 7>Was it the wrong call when they put the Section

0:09:24.620 --> 0:09:25.200
<v Speaker 7>10 on the mine?

0:09:25.480 --> 0:09:31.520
<v Speaker 1>Yes. But from the Prime Minister today, there was no apology,

0:09:32.210 --> 0:09:36.069
<v Speaker 1>no sorry for his government forcing a two-year delay on

0:09:36.730 --> 0:09:40.210
<v Speaker 1>this important mine... for such dubious reasons.

0:09:41.090 --> 0:09:43.569
<v Speaker 3>This is a complex legal case and as it's a

0:09:43.630 --> 0:09:47.510
<v Speaker 3>legal matter, we will work through the judgment together with

0:09:47.570 --> 0:09:52.120
<v Speaker 3>the Attorney-General and we'll consider the findings very carefully indeed.

0:09:54.320 --> 0:09:57.000
<v Speaker 1>And if you still wonder why Australia is getting poorer

0:09:57.440 --> 0:10:06.309
<v Speaker 1>under this government? Joining me is Opposition Leader Angus Taylor.

0:10:06.330 --> 0:10:09.920
<v Speaker 1>I spoke to him just a short while ago. Angus Taylor,

0:10:09.940 --> 0:10:13.710
<v Speaker 1>thank you so much for joining me. No apology today

0:10:13.850 --> 0:10:19.090
<v Speaker 1>from the Prime Minister for this bungled, blue-banded B-ban on

0:10:19.130 --> 0:10:22.350
<v Speaker 1>a billion-dollar mine. What should he actually do about it?

0:10:25.300 --> 0:10:27.819
<v Speaker 8>Well, first of all, he should apologise, Andrew, and thank

0:10:27.860 --> 0:10:31.860
<v Speaker 8>you for having me on. He should apologise because this

0:10:31.920 --> 0:10:35.160
<v Speaker 8>is a mine that really matters to that region. It's

0:10:35.220 --> 0:10:38.490
<v Speaker 8>got enormous support from across the local community. I was

0:10:38.520 --> 0:10:43.510
<v Speaker 8>there at Christmas earlier or just before the beginning of

0:10:43.550 --> 0:10:47.530
<v Speaker 8>this year. And it's a wonderful town, but it needs

0:10:47.590 --> 0:10:51.170
<v Speaker 8>the investment and it's strongly supportive of getting this mine up.

0:10:51.750 --> 0:10:55.309
<v Speaker 8>Tanya Plibersek, of course, killed it off. Now we've been

0:10:55.390 --> 0:10:58.829
<v Speaker 8>told that she got it wrong. And it's crucial now

0:10:58.890 --> 0:11:02.320
<v Speaker 8>that the government allow this mine to proceed. It is

0:11:03.080 --> 0:11:05.980
<v Speaker 8>one of the many projects across Australia that has not

0:11:06.040 --> 0:11:10.380
<v Speaker 8>been moving fast enough. We've got 40 projects now, mining projects,

0:11:10.400 --> 0:11:14.170
<v Speaker 8>particularly oil and gas projects, clogged up in approval processes.

0:11:15.309 --> 0:11:17.470
<v Speaker 8>And it means we are not getting the investment, the

0:11:17.530 --> 0:11:19.790
<v Speaker 8>jobs and the opportunities that we need as a country.

0:11:20.150 --> 0:11:23.989
<v Speaker 8>And this one in particular was blocked by Tanya Plibersek.

0:11:24.170 --> 0:11:28.750
<v Speaker 8>I mean, it's supported by the local Indigenous..... the Land Council,

0:11:29.010 --> 0:11:31.630
<v Speaker 8>and it's supported by the local community, it's supported by

0:11:31.670 --> 0:11:34.390
<v Speaker 8>the local government, and we need to get on with it.

0:11:35.550 --> 0:11:40.320
<v Speaker 1>Today, you move to fix up another ludicrous and ideological

0:11:40.380 --> 0:11:43.760
<v Speaker 1>restriction on business, the High Court decision that is to

0:11:43.840 --> 0:11:47.220
<v Speaker 1>stop the extension of a New South Wales coal mine

0:11:47.280 --> 0:11:51.650
<v Speaker 1>at Mount Pleasant... It said that the New South Wales

0:11:51.720 --> 0:11:55.819
<v Speaker 1>Independent Planning Commission should actively consider the emissions caused by

0:11:55.880 --> 0:12:01.750
<v Speaker 1>its customers overseas when they then burn the mine's coal.

0:12:01.770 --> 0:12:04.329
<v Speaker 1>You know, global warming and all that got to get

0:12:04.410 --> 0:12:06.840
<v Speaker 1>really tough. What are you going to now do about that?

0:12:10.380 --> 0:12:14.209
<v Speaker 8>Well, we've already moved legislation to stop this from happening

0:12:14.679 --> 0:12:18.490
<v Speaker 8>and we will pursue this. I've got to say, Andrew,

0:12:18.550 --> 0:12:21.790
<v Speaker 8>because this really matters. Now, for your viewers, this is

0:12:21.830 --> 0:12:25.469
<v Speaker 8>an absolute absurdity. It's part of this government's net zero

0:12:25.530 --> 0:12:29.370
<v Speaker 8>agenda that they're saying to businesses that they are now

0:12:29.530 --> 0:12:34.390
<v Speaker 8>accountable for the emissions of their customers. Now, you might say, well,

0:12:34.429 --> 0:12:37.699
<v Speaker 8>why does that matter? Well, what it means is every

0:12:37.750 --> 0:12:41.390
<v Speaker 8>mine in this country is now accountable for the emissions

0:12:41.490 --> 0:12:45.190
<v Speaker 8>of downstream processes. So an iron ore mine will be

0:12:45.230 --> 0:12:50.250
<v Speaker 8>accountable for the emissions of blast furnaces in China, a

0:12:50.350 --> 0:12:54.219
<v Speaker 8>coal mine accountable for the emissions of electricity generators in

0:12:54.260 --> 0:12:57.599
<v Speaker 8>Japan or China. It gets worse because it means the

0:12:57.840 --> 0:13:01.900
<v Speaker 8>banks will be accountable for the emissions of their farmer customers.

0:13:02.800 --> 0:13:05.739
<v Speaker 8>So we'll have banks having to account for the flatulence

0:13:06.300 --> 0:13:08.710
<v Speaker 8>of the sheep and cattle of farmers in this country.

0:13:09.040 --> 0:13:14.510
<v Speaker 8>This is madness, Andrew, absolute, utter madness. So we're moving

0:13:14.550 --> 0:13:21.250
<v Speaker 8>legislation that will prevent this from happening and ensure that

0:13:21.390 --> 0:13:25.050
<v Speaker 8>businesses are not accountable for those downstream emissions. The objective

0:13:25.090 --> 0:13:27.030
<v Speaker 8>here is very clear, by the way. The objective here

0:13:27.090 --> 0:13:29.310
<v Speaker 8>is very clear from the left. What they want to

0:13:29.330 --> 0:13:31.570
<v Speaker 8>do is they want to shut down our resource industry,

0:13:31.650 --> 0:13:35.290
<v Speaker 8>our coal industry, our iron ore industry, and they want

0:13:35.309 --> 0:13:39.550
<v Speaker 8>to put pressure on agriculture to reduce methane emissions in particular,

0:13:39.880 --> 0:13:43.750
<v Speaker 8>which is the flatulence of sheep and cattle. They want

0:13:43.770 --> 0:13:45.280
<v Speaker 8>to put pressure on this and they want to use

0:13:45.300 --> 0:13:48.699
<v Speaker 8>the banks and insurance companies and fertiliser companies to do that.

0:13:49.100 --> 0:13:52.319
<v Speaker 8>So we'll scrap this. It's all part of our broader

0:13:52.380 --> 0:13:55.360
<v Speaker 8>agenda to scrap the net zero agenda, which frankly is

0:13:55.420 --> 0:13:59.400
<v Speaker 8>imposing carbon taxes and impositions across our economy. We cannot

0:13:59.540 --> 0:14:00.699
<v Speaker 8>afford at a time like this.

0:14:01.730 --> 0:14:05.709
<v Speaker 1>Yeah, but clearly some people, the Greens in particular, whoever

0:14:05.750 --> 0:14:08.589
<v Speaker 1>drew up this legislation in New South Wales, they do

0:14:08.650 --> 0:14:12.050
<v Speaker 1>think we should be responsible for emissions caused by our

0:14:12.130 --> 0:14:17.230
<v Speaker 1>coal being burned overseas. Is this you saying that stopping

0:14:17.250 --> 0:14:19.720
<v Speaker 1>the world from global warming that way is not worth

0:14:19.770 --> 0:14:23.200
<v Speaker 1>the price? Is it that you don't think the global

0:14:23.220 --> 0:14:27.620
<v Speaker 1>warming crisis is that much of a crisis? What are

0:14:27.640 --> 0:14:29.320
<v Speaker 1>you saying about global warming itself?

0:14:32.560 --> 0:14:35.620
<v Speaker 8>Well, this is just a nonsense proposal. I mean, the

0:14:35.740 --> 0:14:39.729
<v Speaker 8>idea that you can be accountable for your customers' emissions

0:14:39.830 --> 0:14:45.130
<v Speaker 8>makes no sense at all, Andrew. And ultimately, I can't.

0:14:45.250 --> 0:14:46.630
<v Speaker 1>Control if I'm a business.

0:14:46.690 --> 0:14:48.690
<v Speaker 8>I can't control if I'm an iron ore mining business.

0:14:49.230 --> 0:14:52.970
<v Speaker 8>And you know why? The reason why the Greens like

0:14:53.010 --> 0:14:56.790
<v Speaker 8>this and why Labor has been going down this path, Andrew,

0:14:57.280 --> 0:15:00.040
<v Speaker 8>is because they do want to shut down these industries.

0:15:00.620 --> 0:15:04.220
<v Speaker 8>They do want to shut down the coal industry, the

0:15:04.260 --> 0:15:08.050
<v Speaker 8>gas industry. Of course, sadly, even the iron ore industry,

0:15:08.090 --> 0:15:10.550
<v Speaker 8>because the emissions downstream from iron ore, from the blast

0:15:10.570 --> 0:15:14.530
<v Speaker 8>furnaces in Japan and China and Korea, they want to

0:15:14.550 --> 0:15:16.810
<v Speaker 8>make the iron ore mines accountable for it. They don't

0:15:16.850 --> 0:15:19.320
<v Speaker 8>like these industries. They want them shut down. I don't

0:15:19.340 --> 0:15:21.440
<v Speaker 8>know what they want us doing, basket weaving or something,

0:15:22.220 --> 0:15:24.960
<v Speaker 8>but this is the direction they've been going in and

0:15:25.000 --> 0:15:27.400
<v Speaker 8>we have to fight it and that's why we're bringing

0:15:27.440 --> 0:15:29.420
<v Speaker 8>forward legislation to do exactly that.

0:15:30.390 --> 0:15:32.850
<v Speaker 1>Yeah, but they say they want that because global warming

0:15:32.910 --> 0:15:34.950
<v Speaker 1>is a threat and they want to stop it and

0:15:34.970 --> 0:15:37.650
<v Speaker 1>you've got to stop burning coal. You don't think it's

0:15:37.690 --> 0:15:40.980
<v Speaker 1>a threat big enough to warrant stopping the burning of coal?

0:15:42.400 --> 0:15:47.780
<v Speaker 8>Well, not this. This makes no sense. I mean, how

0:15:47.820 --> 0:15:50.000
<v Speaker 8>can you make someone accountable for what they're doing? Well,

0:15:50.020 --> 0:15:51.360
<v Speaker 8>it does if you want to stop global warming. It

0:15:51.380 --> 0:15:56.700
<v Speaker 8>makes no sense at all, Andrew. Well, I think even

0:15:56.720 --> 0:15:58.740
<v Speaker 8>if you want to stop global warming, this doesn't make

0:15:58.800 --> 0:16:01.590
<v Speaker 8>any sense because you can't control the emissions of your customers.

0:16:01.850 --> 0:16:04.390
<v Speaker 8>You can control what you do. I mean, this goes

0:16:04.430 --> 0:16:07.210
<v Speaker 8>beyond the basic principles of how we work as a country.

0:16:07.270 --> 0:16:09.650
<v Speaker 8>You can make someone accountable for what they do. You

0:16:09.710 --> 0:16:13.390
<v Speaker 8>can't make them accountable for what others do. And that's

0:16:13.450 --> 0:16:16.310
<v Speaker 8>why this is completely nonsensical on many measures.

0:16:16.840 --> 0:16:17.120
<v Speaker 1>Andrew.

0:16:17.140 --> 0:16:21.340
<v Speaker 8>I'd say the other point for me is that imposing

0:16:21.420 --> 0:16:25.120
<v Speaker 8>costs on our economy to bring emissions down at a

0:16:25.160 --> 0:16:27.820
<v Speaker 8>time like this does not make sense. And that's why

0:16:27.880 --> 0:16:31.610
<v Speaker 8>we will scrap net zero. It's why we will take

0:16:31.620 --> 0:16:35.750
<v Speaker 8>away Labor's carbon taxes on industry, on vehicles, on the

0:16:35.810 --> 0:16:39.510
<v Speaker 8>electricity grid. And it's why we are absolutely committed to

0:16:39.550 --> 0:16:42.270
<v Speaker 8>making sure we use the natural resources we have in

0:16:42.310 --> 0:16:44.910
<v Speaker 8>this country to get the cost of energy down to

0:16:44.950 --> 0:16:46.470
<v Speaker 8>make it affordable for Australians again.

0:16:48.120 --> 0:16:54.330
<v Speaker 1>I've reported before how the Albanese government promised $ 670, 000 to

0:16:55.090 --> 0:16:58.250
<v Speaker 1>a mosque which then mourned the death of a supreme

0:16:58.490 --> 0:17:03.270
<v Speaker 1>leader of Iran's terrorist regime. It also funded an Islamic

0:17:03.370 --> 0:17:07.230
<v Speaker 1>centre that the pilot who allegedly tried to crash a

0:17:07.290 --> 0:17:10.310
<v Speaker 1>plane load of Jews two weeks ago said he attended,

0:17:10.369 --> 0:17:12.870
<v Speaker 1>which the imam there denies, by the way, and which

0:17:13.030 --> 0:17:19.120
<v Speaker 1>I showed was attended also by some terrorists. Now we

0:17:19.140 --> 0:17:26.380
<v Speaker 1>learn that the government has given $ 300, 000 to an Islamic

0:17:26.480 --> 0:17:30.390
<v Speaker 1>media outlet in Sydney that preached this kind of hatred

0:17:30.790 --> 0:17:31.830
<v Speaker 1>of Jews. Have a listen.

0:17:32.810 --> 0:17:43.209
<v Speaker 9>Zionists are Jewish supremacists, as some scholars call them, are

0:17:43.369 --> 0:17:46.970
<v Speaker 9>mortal enemies of Islam. If you sit back and if

0:17:46.990 --> 0:17:50.410
<v Speaker 9>you want to don't do anything, well, they will come

0:17:50.490 --> 0:17:51.490
<v Speaker 9>after you regardless.

0:17:53.430 --> 0:17:58.070
<v Speaker 1>Zionist Jews wrap up together. The government today said it

0:17:58.090 --> 0:18:02.909
<v Speaker 1>would cancel that grant. It blames public servants for handing

0:18:02.950 --> 0:18:05.669
<v Speaker 1>it out or not checking or whatever. What do you

0:18:05.710 --> 0:18:08.040
<v Speaker 1>think is going on here and what would you change?

0:18:11.200 --> 0:18:14.619
<v Speaker 8>You know, Andrew, this is absolute nonsense from this government.

0:18:15.359 --> 0:18:20.180
<v Speaker 8>We found that grant and linked it to that organisation

0:18:20.340 --> 0:18:25.430
<v Speaker 8>from public information, from public information. And the government said, oh,

0:18:25.470 --> 0:18:30.410
<v Speaker 8>we weren't informed by the department. I mean, seriously, you've

0:18:30.510 --> 0:18:35.710
<v Speaker 8>got to wonder what is going on here. Giving $ 300, 000

0:18:34.270 --> 0:18:39.750
<v Speaker 8>to an organisation that calls a childcare centre bombing, a

0:18:39.770 --> 0:18:44.290
<v Speaker 8>Jewish childcare centre bombing, a sham. that likens Israel to

0:18:44.430 --> 0:18:45.570
<v Speaker 8>Nazi Germany.

0:18:47.030 --> 0:18:47.389
<v Speaker 1>This is.

0:18:48.800 --> 0:18:52.360
<v Speaker 8>It just doesn't pass the must that the government can

0:18:52.460 --> 0:18:55.760
<v Speaker 8>say that this is the department's fault. This is the

0:18:55.820 --> 0:18:59.169
<v Speaker 8>government's fault, and they need to take accountability for it.

0:18:59.920 --> 0:19:02.960
<v Speaker 8>I am glad they're not going to proceed with the grant,

0:19:03.530 --> 0:19:05.770
<v Speaker 8>but there's a lot more questions that need to be

0:19:05.850 --> 0:19:09.429
<v Speaker 8>answered beyond that. How the hell did this actually get through?

0:19:09.830 --> 0:19:11.430
<v Speaker 8>It should never have happened in the.

0:19:11.410 --> 0:19:14.899
<v Speaker 1>First place, Andrew. Angus Taylor, thank you so much for

0:19:14.920 --> 0:19:20.330
<v Speaker 1>your time. Good to be with you. After the break,

0:19:20.810 --> 0:19:24.290
<v Speaker 1>a big humiliating loss for Labor just now in the Senate,

0:19:24.710 --> 0:19:28.290
<v Speaker 1>and Chris Bone gets angry about his dud-clumb conference. But

0:19:28.350 --> 0:19:31.990
<v Speaker 1>in defending it, he misleads you yet again. The panel

0:19:32.050 --> 0:19:40.010
<v Speaker 1>after this. I know I keep giving you facts about Tuvalu,

0:19:40.030 --> 0:19:45.360
<v Speaker 1>a Pacific Island nation, but I'm telling you, every time

0:19:45.400 --> 0:19:48.250
<v Speaker 1>that Chris Bone tells the lies about this poor drowning

0:19:48.310 --> 0:19:52.760
<v Speaker 1>Tuvalu to flog his global war religion, I will correct him.

0:19:53.560 --> 0:19:56.359
<v Speaker 1>Like today, our climate change and energy minister was mocked

0:19:56.420 --> 0:20:01.480
<v Speaker 1>about his ridiculous global warming pre-conference in Tuvalu and Fiji,

0:20:01.520 --> 0:20:05.439
<v Speaker 1>which cost you, taxpayers, more than $ 20 million and was

0:20:05.480 --> 0:20:09.990
<v Speaker 1>such a flop that even Bowen couldn't keep his eyes open. Well,

0:20:10.030 --> 0:20:12.910
<v Speaker 1>the man hit the roof in Parliament today and claimed

0:20:12.970 --> 0:20:15.169
<v Speaker 1>he had to bring people to Tuvalu to see the

0:20:15.280 --> 0:20:16.930
<v Speaker 1>damage done by global warming.

0:20:16.950 --> 0:20:21.399
<v Speaker 3>A visit to Tuvalu was important in showing what is

0:20:21.500 --> 0:20:24.619
<v Speaker 3>at stake for their country as Australia is working with

0:20:24.640 --> 0:20:26.780
<v Speaker 3>them to deal with land reclamation.

0:20:28.640 --> 0:20:31.460
<v Speaker 1>What does it take to make Bowen and this government

0:20:31.640 --> 0:20:35.919
<v Speaker 1>listen to the science and stop wasting our money?

0:20:37.359 --> 0:20:37.459
<v Speaker 4>One.

0:20:38.190 --> 0:20:40.330
<v Speaker 1>The last big study of Tuvalu by top sea level

0:20:40.390 --> 0:20:43.770
<v Speaker 1>experts at Auckland University in 2018 found Tuvalu had actually

0:20:44.290 --> 0:20:49.380
<v Speaker 1>grown by 2.9% in the four decades to 2014.

0:20:49.380 --> 0:20:49.890
<v Speaker 10>Grown.

0:20:50.760 --> 0:20:54.740
<v Speaker 1>It's not drowning. And two, the Australian funded climate and

0:20:54.800 --> 0:20:57.960
<v Speaker 1>ocean support program in the Pacific said four years ago

0:20:58.740 --> 0:21:02.399
<v Speaker 1>In the greater southwest Pacific, that part of the ocean

0:21:02.420 --> 0:21:06.540
<v Speaker 1>with Tuvalu, the total number of severe tropical cyclones has

0:21:06.640 --> 0:21:10.379
<v Speaker 1>decreased over the last 40 seasons. The number of tropical

0:21:10.420 --> 0:21:15.270
<v Speaker 1>cyclones that became severe events has marginally declined. More land,

0:21:15.380 --> 0:21:19.990
<v Speaker 1>fewer cyclones. What is this damage that Chris Bone claims

0:21:20.250 --> 0:21:23.790
<v Speaker 1>he just had to show people and spend $ 20 million

0:21:23.890 --> 0:21:29.050
<v Speaker 1>of our money on that frolic? But on to breaking news.

0:21:30.119 --> 0:21:34.550
<v Speaker 1>The Albanese government's day has just got even worse. It's

0:21:34.590 --> 0:21:38.090
<v Speaker 1>been beaten in the Senate today, or this afternoon, and

0:21:38.130 --> 0:21:40.729
<v Speaker 1>a big saving had been planned and announced in this

0:21:40.770 --> 0:21:44.850
<v Speaker 1>year's budget. The government wanted to wind back health insurance

0:21:44.970 --> 0:21:50.430
<v Speaker 1>rebates for people over 65 and save $ 3 billion over

0:21:50.510 --> 0:21:56.169
<v Speaker 1>four years. Very controversially. unusually and maybe not surprisingly, the

0:21:56.359 --> 0:22:00.960
<v Speaker 1>Coalition and also crossbench senators, senators on the left, they

0:22:01.100 --> 0:22:04.879
<v Speaker 1>joined to successfully vote to scrap discussion on the bill.

0:22:05.859 --> 0:22:08.180
<v Speaker 1>Although Health Minister Mark Butler says he's going to try

0:22:08.220 --> 0:22:11.810
<v Speaker 1>again tomorrow to reintroduce it. Joining me is the political panel,

0:22:11.850 --> 0:22:14.369
<v Speaker 1>Cameron Milner, former Chief of Staff for Labor leader Bill Shorten,

0:22:14.390 --> 0:22:18.850
<v Speaker 1>now Director of GXO Strategies, and Michael Kosta, former New

0:22:18.890 --> 0:22:23.510
<v Speaker 1>South Wales Labor Treasurer. Michael, how big a defeat is

0:22:23.530 --> 0:22:24.350
<v Speaker 1>this for the government?

0:22:25.410 --> 0:22:28.830
<v Speaker 7>Well, it's a huge defeat. Clearly, they're in trouble on

0:22:28.869 --> 0:22:31.050
<v Speaker 7>this issue. But let me say, this is actually a win,

0:22:31.530 --> 0:22:34.110
<v Speaker 7>not so much for the opposition, for all the state governments.

0:22:34.190 --> 0:22:36.909
<v Speaker 7>I mean, the result of this mad policy was that

0:22:36.930 --> 0:22:38.909
<v Speaker 7>it was going to put more pressure on the public

0:22:39.050 --> 0:22:41.879
<v Speaker 7>hospital systems funded by the state governments. And I think

0:22:41.900 --> 0:22:44.100
<v Speaker 7>that's part of the issue here. I wouldn't be surprised

0:22:44.119 --> 0:22:46.120
<v Speaker 7>if there was a lot of lobbying going on from

0:22:46.180 --> 0:22:49.620
<v Speaker 7>state governments as well in relation to this issue. So

0:22:49.660 --> 0:22:51.760
<v Speaker 7>it is a big defeat for them. And it's a

0:22:52.100 --> 0:22:53.460
<v Speaker 7>worthy cause to go down.

0:22:56.200 --> 0:22:59.070
<v Speaker 1>But Cameron, I mean, this on top of a day

0:22:59.150 --> 0:23:05.070
<v Speaker 1>where you've had Jim Chalmers and the Prime Minister arguing,

0:23:05.090 --> 0:23:08.270
<v Speaker 1>you know, about who actually blew the whistle, you know,

0:23:08.470 --> 0:23:12.800
<v Speaker 1>decided to change the Australian tax office's ban on credit

0:23:12.820 --> 0:23:17.530
<v Speaker 1>card payments and Anthony Albanese then, you know, going backwards

0:23:17.590 --> 0:23:20.380
<v Speaker 1>at a million miles an hour on that impression that

0:23:20.720 --> 0:23:25.320
<v Speaker 1>it was him what done it and overruled Chalmers. I mean, really,

0:23:26.280 --> 0:23:30.790
<v Speaker 1>what a terrible day for this government. It was a shocker,

0:23:30.910 --> 0:23:32.380
<v Speaker 1>an absolute shocker. But to.

0:23:32.890 --> 0:23:34.410
<v Speaker 6>I disagree slightly, Michael. I think this is a good

0:23:34.450 --> 0:23:37.520
<v Speaker 6>day for Angus Taylor. He's defeated a really bad measure

0:23:37.840 --> 0:23:39.780
<v Speaker 6>in the Senate with the help of the Greens as well.

0:23:40.040 --> 0:23:41.820
<v Speaker 6>So the Liberals have had a win today, but they've

0:23:41.840 --> 0:23:44.300
<v Speaker 6>had a Liberal win on top of a complete schmuzzle,

0:23:44.580 --> 0:23:48.460
<v Speaker 6>an absolute disaster of a day for Albanese and his Treasurer.

0:23:48.660 --> 0:23:51.139
<v Speaker 6>There's dysfunction and distrust at the heart of this Albanese

0:23:51.160 --> 0:23:53.659
<v Speaker 6>government now. I mean, last night, the Prime Minister boasted

0:23:53.700 --> 0:23:56.520
<v Speaker 6>he'd rolled his Treasurer, rolled his Treasurer, and then, of course,

0:23:56.560 --> 0:23:59.220
<v Speaker 6>events change today and they will try to spin, spin, spin.

0:23:59.560 --> 0:24:01.939
<v Speaker 1>And, of course, the Prime Minister's lie didn't last 24 hours.

0:24:02.359 --> 0:24:04.600
<v Speaker 6>So, no, this is dysfunction at the top of the

0:24:04.640 --> 0:24:06.860
<v Speaker 6>government and the government should be out there fighting inflation

0:24:07.140 --> 0:24:09.379
<v Speaker 6>day in, day out. Instead, they're fighting each other and

0:24:09.400 --> 0:24:11.460
<v Speaker 6>they're fighting each other at the Treasurer and the Prime

0:24:11.480 --> 0:24:12.940
<v Speaker 6>Ministerial level within this government.

0:24:15.310 --> 0:24:20.510
<v Speaker 1>But, Michael... There's a lot of Treasurers that have been

0:24:20.550 --> 0:24:24.290
<v Speaker 1>at loggerheads with their Prime Ministers and quarrelling over who

0:24:24.330 --> 0:24:28.430
<v Speaker 1>took credit for what. You had Keating with, obviously, Bob Hawke.

0:24:28.470 --> 0:24:32.540
<v Speaker 1>You had Costello with John Howard. Why should it matter

0:24:32.600 --> 0:24:36.240
<v Speaker 1>that these two guys are also having a real ding-dong?

0:24:37.600 --> 0:24:39.960
<v Speaker 7>Well, it should matter, but let me correct you, Andrew.

0:24:40.000 --> 0:24:43.139
<v Speaker 7>I mean, both those Treasurers you mentioned actually stood up

0:24:43.180 --> 0:24:45.440
<v Speaker 7>to the Prime Ministers that they were dealing with on

0:24:45.680 --> 0:24:47.899
<v Speaker 7>key issues, and that's the role of the Treasurer. There

0:24:47.920 --> 0:24:52.560
<v Speaker 7>should be tension, creative tension, between Treasurers and Prime Ministers.

0:24:52.640 --> 0:24:54.940
<v Speaker 7>I know from my own experience that if you let

0:24:55.180 --> 0:24:58.119
<v Speaker 7>Prime Ministers or Premiers try and get away with everything,

0:24:58.140 --> 0:25:02.179
<v Speaker 7>you blow your budget out forever, because they're about winning votes,

0:25:02.290 --> 0:25:05.850
<v Speaker 7>not necessarily about budget management. And You know, that's a

0:25:05.880 --> 0:25:09.210
<v Speaker 7>sensible ballast. The problem you've got here is that I

0:25:09.230 --> 0:25:13.030
<v Speaker 7>think Anthony Albanese, who is, you know, good at numbers,

0:25:13.090 --> 0:25:16.230
<v Speaker 7>not economic numbers, factional numbers, realises he's got a problem

0:25:16.250 --> 0:25:18.889
<v Speaker 7>with Jim Chalmers. Jim Chalmers, and I've said this on

0:25:18.910 --> 0:25:22.550
<v Speaker 7>your program for years now, is an economic illiterate. I mean, look,

0:25:22.990 --> 0:25:26.490
<v Speaker 7>he's become an economic Nero, actually, fiddling around at the

0:25:26.570 --> 0:25:29.949
<v Speaker 7>edges while the economy crashes and burns. And, you know,

0:25:29.990 --> 0:25:33.750
<v Speaker 7>he's got a major problem with him. He's responsible primarily...

0:25:33.650 --> 0:25:38.990
<v Speaker 7>for this inflation, not Ukraine, not Trump and everything else.

0:25:39.250 --> 0:25:43.280
<v Speaker 7>He's the guy that designed the RBA to take a softly,

0:25:43.340 --> 0:25:46.060
<v Speaker 7>softly approach to go for the soft landing that's blown

0:25:46.119 --> 0:25:48.640
<v Speaker 7>up in his face. And he has to take some

0:25:48.700 --> 0:25:52.100
<v Speaker 7>responsibility for that. And I can understand what's going on here.

0:25:52.140 --> 0:25:54.330
<v Speaker 7>They're trying to position Jim Chalmers for the fall at

0:25:54.369 --> 0:25:56.050
<v Speaker 7>some point, probably after the next election.

0:25:58.420 --> 0:26:02.180
<v Speaker 1>Honestly, every time I hear Jim Chalmers and also Anthony Albanese,

0:26:02.200 --> 0:26:06.770
<v Speaker 1>but particularly Jim Chalmers, blame foreign events, blame something else,

0:26:07.130 --> 0:26:10.469
<v Speaker 1>blame something unforeseen for the fact that his budget's up

0:26:10.490 --> 0:26:12.670
<v Speaker 1>the carber and the debt's running out and blah, blah

0:26:12.690 --> 0:26:15.969
<v Speaker 1>and all that. I think someone forgot when he was

0:26:16.030 --> 0:26:18.369
<v Speaker 1>a kid to read in the story of Three Little Pigs,

0:26:18.890 --> 0:26:26.480
<v Speaker 1>build your house of brick, not straw or anything or mud,

0:26:27.320 --> 0:26:30.060
<v Speaker 1>so that it can withstand all these things. He doesn't

0:26:30.100 --> 0:26:33.100
<v Speaker 1>do it. He builds it of straw. The wind comes

0:26:33.180 --> 0:26:35.680
<v Speaker 1>and blows it down. He says, oh, my goodness me,

0:26:35.700 --> 0:26:38.560
<v Speaker 1>it was something else, not me. I mean, this is

0:26:38.580 --> 0:26:43.120
<v Speaker 1>the problem with this guy. Honestly, Cameron, what do you make?

0:26:43.180 --> 0:26:49.250
<v Speaker 1>Did you agree with Michael there about the tension here

0:26:49.310 --> 0:26:54.850
<v Speaker 1>and whose fault it is and blah, blah? Is Chalmers

0:26:54.869 --> 0:26:59.550
<v Speaker 1>the villain here or is Albert easy? I think Chalmers

0:26:59.570 --> 0:27:00.350
<v Speaker 1>is going to be the victim.

0:27:00.450 --> 0:27:03.490
<v Speaker 6>I think Chalmers is the victim because Albo is deeply insecure,

0:27:03.800 --> 0:27:07.340
<v Speaker 6>deeply jealous, even of Jim Chalmers in terms of his

0:27:07.380 --> 0:27:11.140
<v Speaker 6>talent and his ability. So Albo's problem is he doesn't

0:27:11.180 --> 0:27:14.400
<v Speaker 6>like dissent, doesn't like anyone questioning him. The Treasurer, I think,

0:27:14.440 --> 0:27:16.660
<v Speaker 6>does from time to time challenge him. But the real

0:27:16.720 --> 0:27:19.020
<v Speaker 6>issue here is it's not a house built on straw

0:27:19.040 --> 0:27:21.409
<v Speaker 6>or on rocks. It's a house built on lies, a

0:27:21.430 --> 0:27:24.870
<v Speaker 6>house built on lies. And that's what the trouble with

0:27:24.910 --> 0:27:26.970
<v Speaker 6>Labor is right now, and it's a rot from the top.

0:27:27.350 --> 0:27:33.640
<v Speaker 1>Albo can't stop lying. That's the problem with this government. Look,

0:27:34.980 --> 0:27:39.810
<v Speaker 1>I think that's endemic in the whole government, to be honest. I...

0:27:40.680 --> 0:27:45.179
<v Speaker 1>What a government. Michael, you heard Angus Taylor just before

0:27:45.240 --> 0:27:49.500
<v Speaker 1>you came on. I think his performance is improving, although

0:27:49.520 --> 0:27:52.690
<v Speaker 1>the question is, of course, is it enough and fast enough?

0:27:52.950 --> 0:27:56.190
<v Speaker 1>And I'm increasingly thinking one of his problems is that

0:27:56.430 --> 0:27:59.970
<v Speaker 1>the Liberal left will not free him to go as

0:28:00.070 --> 0:28:04.090
<v Speaker 1>far as he should in order to sound convincing and

0:28:04.130 --> 0:28:06.710
<v Speaker 1>convicted on things like climate change.

0:28:08.130 --> 0:28:10.390
<v Speaker 7>Well, Andrew, I think that's true. The Liberal left's always

0:28:10.730 --> 0:28:13.670
<v Speaker 7>been the major problem they've got, starting with, of course,

0:28:14.190 --> 0:28:16.270
<v Speaker 7>Turnbull as Prime Minister. But, you know, I mean, he's

0:28:16.330 --> 0:28:18.590
<v Speaker 7>also got his own issues to deal with. He's got

0:28:18.609 --> 0:28:21.750
<v Speaker 7>to explain why he did support net zero in the past.

0:28:22.330 --> 0:28:24.709
<v Speaker 7>And I think that's an issue that, you know, One

0:28:24.780 --> 0:28:27.800
<v Speaker 7>Nation has used very effectively against his credibility. Yes, I

0:28:27.820 --> 0:28:30.119
<v Speaker 7>think he's performed better, but it's easy to perform when

0:28:30.140 --> 0:28:33.109
<v Speaker 7>you've got so many targets out there. he should be

0:28:33.600 --> 0:28:37.080
<v Speaker 7>performing even better. I mean, you know, the Labor government

0:28:37.220 --> 0:28:39.430
<v Speaker 7>is in trouble on so many fronts. I mean, this RBA...

0:28:40.040 --> 0:28:42.979
<v Speaker 7>you know, credit card thing. Remember, these people were out

0:28:43.040 --> 0:28:46.880
<v Speaker 7>there touting this as a cost of living savings. Both

0:28:46.920 --> 0:28:49.900
<v Speaker 7>of them, that's Chalmers and Albo, put out, you know,

0:28:50.050 --> 0:28:53.190
<v Speaker 7>press releases and TikToks and all that sort of stuff.

0:28:54.090 --> 0:28:58.010
<v Speaker 7>This government should be on its bottom legs, but it's not.

0:28:58.510 --> 0:28:59.990
<v Speaker 7>It's still credible and it's still going to win the

0:29:00.010 --> 0:29:02.520
<v Speaker 7>next election based on the numbers we've seen in the polls.

0:29:04.660 --> 0:29:05.800
<v Speaker 1>Do you agree with that, Cameron?

0:29:08.040 --> 0:29:09.940
<v Speaker 6>Look, I think Taylor's doing a better job and certainly

0:29:09.960 --> 0:29:12.360
<v Speaker 6>his performance tonight was actually pretty good at it. So

0:29:12.380 --> 0:29:15.460
<v Speaker 6>I think we're seeing a genuine improvement from him over time.

0:29:16.060 --> 0:29:18.920
<v Speaker 6>But at times he's enemy and his problem is he's got,

0:29:18.940 --> 0:29:20.500
<v Speaker 6>you know, Josh Frydenberg who's going to get into the

0:29:20.520 --> 0:29:22.960
<v Speaker 6>parliament most likely after the next election and become a

0:29:22.980 --> 0:29:26.140
<v Speaker 6>leadership contender. You've got Andrew Hastie waiting in the wings.

0:29:26.400 --> 0:29:28.510
<v Speaker 6>So Taylor hasn't got much time left to actually get

0:29:28.550 --> 0:29:31.730
<v Speaker 6>that performance to set, but he is improving, Andrew.

0:29:34.140 --> 0:29:36.900
<v Speaker 1>Cameron Milner, Michael Koster, thank you very much to you both.

0:29:37.570 --> 0:29:39.970
<v Speaker 1>After the break, the King of Jordan drops in on Canberra.

0:29:40.860 --> 0:29:43.459
<v Speaker 1>Why didn't anyone in the government ask him why he's

0:29:43.500 --> 0:29:51.420
<v Speaker 1>protecting the terrorist who murdered a young Australian? As you know,

0:29:51.460 --> 0:29:53.940
<v Speaker 1>the Albanese government has been under huge fire for being

0:29:54.590 --> 0:30:01.430
<v Speaker 1>so soft on Islamic extremism and so hard on Israel. Well,

0:30:01.470 --> 0:30:07.010
<v Speaker 1>two more examples today, and I've already shown you one,

0:30:07.130 --> 0:30:16.050
<v Speaker 1>another massive government grant to Islamic radicals, this time $ 300, 000

0:30:13.370 --> 0:30:21.570
<v Speaker 1>to Western Sydney Islamic media organisation, One Path, which called

0:30:21.650 --> 0:30:25.550
<v Speaker 1>Jews mortal enemies. also claiming that the firebombing of a

0:30:25.570 --> 0:30:28.750
<v Speaker 1>Jewish childcare centre and anti-Semitic attacks on Sydney Jews were

0:30:28.930 --> 0:30:33.640
<v Speaker 1>all a sham, fakes and more. Oh, we'll do better,

0:30:33.980 --> 0:30:36.800
<v Speaker 1>said the multiculturalism minister, Anne Arley, herself Muslim.

0:30:37.840 --> 0:30:40.680
<v Speaker 6>The decision that the member refers to was a decision

0:30:40.700 --> 0:30:41.820
<v Speaker 6>that was made by the department.

0:30:42.440 --> 0:30:45.090
<v Speaker 4>The department has now sent one path a notice of

0:30:45.150 --> 0:30:46.390
<v Speaker 4>intention to terminate.

0:30:49.690 --> 0:30:52.930
<v Speaker 1>But to a second example today. You know that Foreign

0:30:52.950 --> 0:30:57.860
<v Speaker 1>Minister Penny Walton huge critic of Israel, refuses to accept

0:30:57.880 --> 0:31:00.660
<v Speaker 1>that the killing of Australian aid worker Zomri Franken in

0:31:00.700 --> 0:31:05.420
<v Speaker 1>Gaza two years ago was a tragic, tragic accident, a

0:31:05.620 --> 0:31:09.400
<v Speaker 1>mistake by the Israeli army, and officers have in fact

0:31:09.440 --> 0:31:15.580
<v Speaker 1>been punished. Wong raises this very often. But where is

0:31:15.620 --> 0:31:19.610
<v Speaker 1>the same concern for Malki Roth? That's the 15-year-old Jewish

0:31:19.660 --> 0:31:24.190
<v Speaker 1>Australian girl who was one of 16 people murdered, no accidents,

0:31:24.790 --> 0:31:31.350
<v Speaker 1>murdered 25 years ago by Palestinian terrorist Alam Tamini when

0:31:32.370 --> 0:31:36.710
<v Speaker 1>Tamini bombed a pizza restaurant in Israel. Now, the reason

0:31:36.850 --> 0:31:39.970
<v Speaker 1>I still raise this today is that the King of

0:31:40.060 --> 0:31:42.739
<v Speaker 1>Jordan has been in Australia meeting the Albanese government over

0:31:42.760 --> 0:31:45.180
<v Speaker 1>the past two days, and I've not heard one mention,

0:31:45.720 --> 0:31:49.700
<v Speaker 1>seen one press release by this government asking Jordan, asking

0:31:49.740 --> 0:31:55.990
<v Speaker 1>the King to stop protecting Malky's killer. You see, that killer,

0:31:57.690 --> 0:32:01.470
<v Speaker 1>Alam Tamini, is on the FBI's most wanted list still

0:32:01.800 --> 0:32:04.960
<v Speaker 1>because three of the people she killed were American. They

0:32:05.000 --> 0:32:08.500
<v Speaker 1>were brought to justice. But Jordan, which is, by the way,

0:32:08.520 --> 0:32:13.860
<v Speaker 1>a majority Palestinian state, will not extradite her to face punishment.

0:32:15.020 --> 0:32:19.020
<v Speaker 1>Joining me is Melky Roth's father, Arnold. Arnold, it's good

0:32:19.040 --> 0:32:22.430
<v Speaker 1>to catch up with you again. I have Not heard

0:32:22.470 --> 0:32:25.340
<v Speaker 1>your daughter's name mentioned once in the King of Jordan's visit.

0:32:25.940 --> 0:32:28.340
<v Speaker 1>Maybe someone whispered it to him in a corridor. I

0:32:28.380 --> 0:32:31.100
<v Speaker 1>do not know. But does that disappoint you?

0:32:33.260 --> 0:32:35.410
<v Speaker 11>Well, I'm not privy to the whispers any more than

0:32:35.450 --> 0:32:38.450
<v Speaker 11>you are, Andrew. But is it disappointing? Of course, it's

0:32:38.470 --> 0:32:42.310
<v Speaker 11>hugely disappointing. I should also say that I've grown accustomed

0:32:42.330 --> 0:32:46.130
<v Speaker 11>to this kind of disappointment at multiple levels. And here,

0:32:46.170 --> 0:32:49.080
<v Speaker 11>let me just make a brief and affectionate call out

0:32:49.180 --> 0:32:53.840
<v Speaker 11>to DFAT, Australia's Foreign Ministry. I've made several requests to

0:32:53.900 --> 0:32:57.680
<v Speaker 11>them over the past decade and gotten the same factually wrong,

0:32:57.720 --> 0:33:01.240
<v Speaker 11>disingenuous answers each time. It's hard not to notice how

0:33:01.260 --> 0:33:04.440
<v Speaker 11>opposed they are to exposing what Jordan does on the

0:33:04.460 --> 0:33:08.140
<v Speaker 11>Tamimi issue and the lengths that the civil servants go

0:33:08.160 --> 0:33:11.739
<v Speaker 11>to to justify their embrace of the kingdom and what

0:33:11.770 --> 0:33:14.410
<v Speaker 11>it stands for. They're not serving Australia's interests or values

0:33:14.450 --> 0:33:14.990
<v Speaker 11>by doing this.

0:33:17.670 --> 0:33:20.080
<v Speaker 1>Well, they do seem to be going out of their

0:33:20.100 --> 0:33:25.000
<v Speaker 1>way to placate Jordan. They're the nice Palestinian entity, I guess.

0:33:25.060 --> 0:33:28.900
<v Speaker 1>But what is Jordan up to here? Why won't it

0:33:29.000 --> 0:33:32.570
<v Speaker 1>make Tamimi face punishment? Because she's just wandering around the country.

0:33:34.410 --> 0:33:36.590
<v Speaker 11>Well, there's what they say explains it and there's what

0:33:36.610 --> 0:33:39.010
<v Speaker 11>they do that explains it. What they say is that

0:33:39.270 --> 0:33:42.430
<v Speaker 11>a Jordanian court, I know this to be true, handed

0:33:42.470 --> 0:33:44.920
<v Speaker 11>down a ruling in 2017, just a few days after

0:33:44.940 --> 0:33:49.300
<v Speaker 11>the charges against Tamimi were unsealed, after a five-year period

0:33:49.320 --> 0:33:53.760
<v Speaker 11>of silence in Washington. The court said that the extradition

0:33:53.800 --> 0:33:57.190
<v Speaker 11>treaty of 1995, we're getting right into the bowels of history,

0:33:57.730 --> 0:34:01.690
<v Speaker 11>was never properly ratified. They mean ratified by Jordan itself.

0:34:02.570 --> 0:34:04.900
<v Speaker 11>And as a result, and then you can finish that

0:34:04.960 --> 0:34:07.660
<v Speaker 11>sentence however you like, because no one gets it right.

0:34:08.570 --> 0:34:11.110
<v Speaker 11>There is a technical breach. It was done by Jordan.

0:34:11.210 --> 0:34:12.770
<v Speaker 11>It can be fixed by Jordan. It could have been

0:34:12.830 --> 0:34:16.350
<v Speaker 11>fixed every single day. It has never been fixed. So

0:34:16.850 --> 0:34:21.150
<v Speaker 11>that's the proximate cause. The real cause, she's phenomenally popular.

0:34:21.370 --> 0:34:22.150
<v Speaker 1>She's a celebrity.

0:34:22.290 --> 0:34:25.299
<v Speaker 11>They gave her her own TV show, which went to

0:34:25.390 --> 0:34:29.400
<v Speaker 11>air globally, reaching Sydney's western suburbs and Melbourne's northern suburbs

0:34:29.440 --> 0:34:30.900
<v Speaker 11>and all the rest of the world, wherever there are

0:34:30.960 --> 0:34:35.480
<v Speaker 11>Arabic speakers, for five years. So You have to imagine

0:34:35.540 --> 0:34:37.960
<v Speaker 11>that the king and all of the people around him

0:34:37.980 --> 0:34:40.799
<v Speaker 11>are a little uncomfortable about sticking their necks out and

0:34:40.860 --> 0:34:44.009
<v Speaker 11>saying that this woman, who is a celebrity, celebrity, celebrity,

0:34:44.739 --> 0:34:46.910
<v Speaker 11>is someone who we ought to be handing over to

0:34:46.989 --> 0:34:50.089
<v Speaker 11>the hated authorities in the United States and to do

0:34:50.130 --> 0:34:52.090
<v Speaker 11>it because she killed Jewish children.

0:34:55.110 --> 0:34:57.910
<v Speaker 1>Let's be clear about that. She went into a restaurant,

0:34:58.010 --> 0:35:01.670
<v Speaker 1>checked who she was going to kill, killed 16 people.

0:35:01.730 --> 0:35:04.299
<v Speaker 1>I think there were four of them were children. And

0:35:04.340 --> 0:35:07.259
<v Speaker 1>when she was told it was four, she said it

0:35:07.300 --> 0:35:11.460
<v Speaker 1>was a pity it wasn't more. How is someone like

0:35:11.520 --> 0:35:14.860
<v Speaker 1>that treated like a heroine in Jordan?

0:35:18.200 --> 0:35:20.440
<v Speaker 11>It's an excellent question. I'm not here to be the

0:35:20.500 --> 0:35:23.020
<v Speaker 11>advocate for Jordan. The figures are, in fact, worse than

0:35:23.040 --> 0:35:26.500
<v Speaker 11>the ones you just said. But you're right. For the

0:35:26.540 --> 0:35:28.960
<v Speaker 11>rest of us applying the kind of values that we

0:35:29.000 --> 0:35:32.140
<v Speaker 11>hold dear and that Jordan professes to hold dear as well,

0:35:32.180 --> 0:35:36.290
<v Speaker 11>and that's certainly the Australian government says at its very heart,

0:35:36.830 --> 0:35:39.190
<v Speaker 11>it's inconceivable that anybody would get up and make a

0:35:39.610 --> 0:35:41.770
<v Speaker 11>statement that says, no, we're not going to go after

0:35:41.790 --> 0:35:44.220
<v Speaker 11>Achlam Tamimi, nor are we going to ask our dear

0:35:44.260 --> 0:35:46.739
<v Speaker 11>friends in Jordan to do what they're obliged to do

0:35:46.780 --> 0:35:49.360
<v Speaker 11>under the treaty. So what do they do? They do

0:35:49.380 --> 0:35:52.719
<v Speaker 11>what everybody does. They look the other way and they

0:35:52.780 --> 0:35:54.900
<v Speaker 11>say nothing. So you were right in your opening words.

0:35:55.500 --> 0:35:58.690
<v Speaker 11>No one has mentioned Malki's name. No one has responded

0:35:58.770 --> 0:36:02.800
<v Speaker 11>to the visit of the king with bringing the Tamimi case,

0:36:03.060 --> 0:36:06.660
<v Speaker 11>she's the most wanted female fugitive that the United States has,

0:36:07.200 --> 0:36:10.020
<v Speaker 11>bringing that issue to the fore. And we can just

0:36:10.060 --> 0:36:12.470
<v Speaker 11>sit here and scratch our heads and say, well, what's

0:36:12.530 --> 0:36:16.010
<v Speaker 11>driving them? But what's driving them is unfortunately terribly, terribly clear.

0:36:18.570 --> 0:36:21.550
<v Speaker 1>And this government silence, what do you make of that?

0:36:21.590 --> 0:36:22.509
<v Speaker 1>How do you explain that?

0:36:24.739 --> 0:36:28.520
<v Speaker 11>If we're talking about the Australian government silence, let me

0:36:28.600 --> 0:36:34.020
<v Speaker 11>make my non-political credentials as clear as possible. The previous

0:36:34.060 --> 0:36:38.290
<v Speaker 11>governments that were not Labour did exactly as much as

0:36:38.390 --> 0:36:42.790
<v Speaker 11>the Labour government is currently doing. Let me emphasise that

0:36:42.890 --> 0:36:44.810
<v Speaker 11>our pursuit, the one that my wife and I have

0:36:44.870 --> 0:36:48.910
<v Speaker 11>conducted for years since the charges were unsealed in 2017,

0:36:48.910 --> 0:36:53.520
<v Speaker 11>has not a modicum, not a scrap of political interest

0:36:53.620 --> 0:36:57.130
<v Speaker 11>behind it. And it's also not about, look how pathetic

0:36:57.170 --> 0:36:59.110
<v Speaker 11>we are, we should get your sympathy.

0:36:59.150 --> 0:37:00.010
<v Speaker 1>It's about justice.

0:37:00.230 --> 0:37:02.740
<v Speaker 11>How many people can trample justice and get away with

0:37:02.800 --> 0:37:06.000
<v Speaker 11>it as clearly as all the officials in these various

0:37:06.040 --> 0:37:08.580
<v Speaker 11>countries have gotten away with it for years? We all

0:37:08.620 --> 0:37:09.740
<v Speaker 11>know why.

0:37:09.940 --> 0:37:10.900
<v Speaker 1>It's all political.

0:37:11.320 --> 0:37:15.600
<v Speaker 11>It's all what people perceive as being in their political

0:37:15.640 --> 0:37:19.640
<v Speaker 11>interests without ever articulating it. And somehow justice falls out

0:37:19.660 --> 0:37:21.100
<v Speaker 11>of the conversation completely.

0:37:24.750 --> 0:37:28.450
<v Speaker 1>Arnold Roth, you've been to hell for, well, you've been

0:37:28.489 --> 0:37:31.350
<v Speaker 1>in hell for many, many years. Thank you very much

0:37:31.390 --> 0:37:34.839
<v Speaker 1>for talking about this here. Good luck to you.

0:37:36.020 --> 0:37:36.859
<v Speaker 11>Thanks very much, Andrew.

0:37:37.920 --> 0:37:42.460
<v Speaker 1>After the break, Gemma and Caroline and the latest crusade

0:37:42.480 --> 0:37:46.680
<v Speaker 1>of Greta Thunberg, now at the violent riots in France.

0:37:51.190 --> 0:37:54.610
<v Speaker 1>Greta Thunberg is just exposed for I think she's really

0:37:54.630 --> 0:37:59.469
<v Speaker 1>been about all along. Destruction, and especially of Western society.

0:37:59.920 --> 0:38:03.380
<v Speaker 1>As a teenager, you'll know she was, somehow became the

0:38:03.420 --> 0:38:07.790
<v Speaker 1>goddess of the global warming cult. lecturing politicians around the world,

0:38:07.930 --> 0:38:12.690
<v Speaker 1>lecturing the United Nations, the Davos Forum, adults who should

0:38:12.730 --> 0:38:16.070
<v Speaker 1>have known better than to be scolded by a girl

0:38:16.690 --> 0:38:20.299
<v Speaker 1>who's still in school. She was so absolutist. People seem

0:38:20.320 --> 0:38:23.160
<v Speaker 1>to love that bit in particular. She says her superpower

0:38:23.180 --> 0:38:26.880
<v Speaker 1>is that she's got Asperger's. But as she got older

0:38:26.920 --> 0:38:32.100
<v Speaker 1>and less cute, she became, frankly, a bit boring, strident.

0:38:32.340 --> 0:38:35.920
<v Speaker 1>I don't know. She's now 23. And now she's jumped

0:38:35.960 --> 0:38:39.410
<v Speaker 1>on the anti-Israel bandwagon, which is the latest cause of

0:38:39.430 --> 0:38:46.230
<v Speaker 1>the hard left, accusing this symbol of Western culture falsely

0:38:46.489 --> 0:38:50.600
<v Speaker 1>of genocide. And yesterday she joined the anarchist and violent

0:38:50.719 --> 0:38:56.400
<v Speaker 1>riots in France. Riots supposedly over school conditions, but actually

0:38:56.540 --> 0:39:01.390
<v Speaker 1>by people, youths, many of them from the hard left

0:39:01.489 --> 0:39:06.719
<v Speaker 1>and from Muslim immigrants' families, burning schools as well as

0:39:06.780 --> 0:39:10.600
<v Speaker 1>burning cars and barricades and buses and causing lots of

0:39:10.640 --> 0:39:14.819
<v Speaker 1>those frightful emissions I thought would disgust her. But not

0:39:14.860 --> 0:39:19.260
<v Speaker 1>at all. She loves it and brought her Palestinian scarf

0:39:19.520 --> 0:39:20.240
<v Speaker 1>to the mayhem.

0:39:21.110 --> 0:39:23.910
<v Speaker 12>They have been going for almost three weeks now, students

0:39:23.989 --> 0:39:28.009
<v Speaker 12>occupying the school and teachers striking in solidarity with them,

0:39:28.050 --> 0:39:34.660
<v Speaker 12>which is an incredible... beautiful solidarity to see. And again,

0:39:34.680 --> 0:39:38.700
<v Speaker 12>the French students are now showing the world how we

0:39:38.800 --> 0:39:41.120
<v Speaker 12>should be standing up and how we should be revolting

0:39:41.200 --> 0:39:44.080
<v Speaker 12>against an extremely violent system.

0:39:45.969 --> 0:39:48.270
<v Speaker 1>My goodness, I hope that tens of thousands of young

0:39:48.290 --> 0:39:53.130
<v Speaker 1>Australian students Fans, don't follow that advice and bring what

0:39:53.170 --> 0:39:55.650
<v Speaker 1>you see in France to our streets. Joining me are

0:39:55.670 --> 0:40:00.020
<v Speaker 1>Gemma Tonini, columnist and communications consultant, and Carolyn DeRusso, commentator

0:40:00.060 --> 0:40:05.880
<v Speaker 1>and president of the West Australian Liberals. Gemma, this is

0:40:05.940 --> 0:40:08.900
<v Speaker 1>the way to protest, says Greta Thunberg, as she wears

0:40:08.920 --> 0:40:12.120
<v Speaker 1>the Palestinian keffiyeh, which to me seems to me to

0:40:12.180 --> 0:40:17.540
<v Speaker 1>symbolise the use of violence, horrific violence at times, for

0:40:17.580 --> 0:40:21.330
<v Speaker 1>political ends. What does all this preaching tell you?

0:40:22.150 --> 0:40:24.940
<v Speaker 4>Well, I wonder what's wrong with this cohort of people

0:40:25.000 --> 0:40:27.460
<v Speaker 4>and their solution to everything is just to set fire

0:40:27.500 --> 0:40:29.760
<v Speaker 4>to stuff. Like it's a little bit sort of backward,

0:40:29.800 --> 0:40:31.280
<v Speaker 4>don't you think? I don't like something.

0:40:31.620 --> 0:40:32.529
<v Speaker 10>I'll just torture it.

0:40:33.110 --> 0:40:35.430
<v Speaker 4>As for Greta Thunberg, she reminds me of something we

0:40:35.489 --> 0:40:37.410
<v Speaker 4>used to have in WA and Caro will know what

0:40:37.430 --> 0:40:38.430
<v Speaker 4>I'm about to talk about.

0:40:39.080 --> 0:40:41.060
<v Speaker 10>Schoolies Week at Rottnest Island.

0:40:41.100 --> 0:40:45.000
<v Speaker 4>You would always have a cohort of people who never

0:40:45.060 --> 0:40:48.430
<v Speaker 4>quite graduated. They might be 19, 20, 21, who always

0:40:48.590 --> 0:40:51.430
<v Speaker 4>went to Rottnest for Schoolies Week because they never kind

0:40:51.450 --> 0:40:53.130
<v Speaker 4>of got out of school mentality and we used to

0:40:53.150 --> 0:40:56.830
<v Speaker 4>call them toolies. And Greta Thunberg is the epitome of

0:40:56.870 --> 0:41:00.290
<v Speaker 4>a toolie. She's, you know, latched herself on like a

0:41:00.410 --> 0:41:03.180
<v Speaker 4>limpet to a rock to this protest, which has got

0:41:03.300 --> 0:41:08.319
<v Speaker 4>nothing to do with schooling and everything to do with radical... anarchy,

0:41:08.980 --> 0:41:12.670
<v Speaker 4>an element of radical Islam, political Islam in that, obviously

0:41:12.710 --> 0:41:16.210
<v Speaker 4>because she's wearing the keffiyeh. This is just, you know,

0:41:16.290 --> 0:41:19.140
<v Speaker 4>France entering its globalised, the intifada era.

0:41:19.180 --> 0:41:20.670
<v Speaker 10>I mean, they asked for it, they got it.

0:41:24.840 --> 0:41:26.200
<v Speaker 1>Caroline, what do you make of it?

0:41:29.030 --> 0:41:32.069
<v Speaker 13>What I always find interesting about Greta is that she's

0:41:32.110 --> 0:41:34.890
<v Speaker 13>almost the queen of the bad take or the bad position.

0:41:35.070 --> 0:41:36.200
<v Speaker 10>Like if there is.

0:41:36.280 --> 0:41:38.859
<v Speaker 13>A wrong side of something to be on, and like

0:41:38.880 --> 0:41:44.560
<v Speaker 13>you said earlier, very absolutist, no nuance, no real thinking

0:41:44.640 --> 0:41:48.109
<v Speaker 13>or caring of the bigger picture, she is always on

0:41:48.450 --> 0:41:52.370
<v Speaker 13>whatever far side of any single argument there is when,

0:41:52.890 --> 0:41:54.890
<v Speaker 13>you know, there's a whole lot of grey in the middle.

0:41:55.690 --> 0:41:59.030
<v Speaker 13>And there's a whole lot of, you know, more sophisticated

0:41:59.410 --> 0:42:02.890
<v Speaker 13>positions you can take, even if they're not necessarily positions

0:42:02.930 --> 0:42:06.379
<v Speaker 13>that I might agree with. But she never takes any

0:42:06.430 --> 0:42:10.779
<v Speaker 13>position with any sort of sophistication. It is always the bluntest,

0:42:10.960 --> 0:42:15.120
<v Speaker 13>the most brutal. She's just a total useful idiot.

0:42:15.300 --> 0:42:19.320
<v Speaker 10>Correct. And to think. And to think that, you know, gosh,

0:42:19.700 --> 0:42:20.660
<v Speaker 10>we'd really.

0:42:20.400 --> 0:42:23.630
<v Speaker 13>Like to be more educated, so we're going to burn

0:42:23.790 --> 0:42:28.770
<v Speaker 13>everything down, is a position in which normal, reasonable, everyday

0:42:28.870 --> 0:42:32.460
<v Speaker 13>people are going to go, yeah, that sounds sensible to me.

0:42:32.969 --> 0:42:36.500
<v Speaker 13>it's just never going to happen. And it doesn't matter

0:42:36.540 --> 0:42:39.900
<v Speaker 13>what it is, Andrew. It doesn't matter whether it's Palestine.

0:42:39.920 --> 0:42:42.759
<v Speaker 13>It doesn't matter whether it's climate change. It doesn't matter

0:42:42.800 --> 0:42:47.000
<v Speaker 13>whether it's these school protests. The single worst position that

0:42:47.040 --> 0:42:49.520
<v Speaker 13>you can find yourself in on any.

0:42:49.440 --> 0:42:50.240
<v Speaker 10>Of these issues.

0:42:50.680 --> 0:42:52.120
<v Speaker 13>And that's where you will find Greta.

0:42:52.460 --> 0:42:54.259
<v Speaker 4>And the other thing, Andrew, I would like to point

0:42:54.340 --> 0:42:58.129
<v Speaker 4>out is why are people, why are media platforming her?

0:42:58.850 --> 0:43:01.989
<v Speaker 10>Why are they platforming her? Why were they ever platforming her?

0:43:02.190 --> 0:43:04.910
<v Speaker 4>She was just a brat who, you know, a walking

0:43:05.150 --> 0:43:07.260
<v Speaker 4>example of what happens when you don't discipline children. That's

0:43:07.280 --> 0:43:09.100
<v Speaker 4>what she was back then. She's just some brat with

0:43:09.120 --> 0:43:11.980
<v Speaker 4>an attitude. And the world has, as you said, Andrew,

0:43:12.000 --> 0:43:14.299
<v Speaker 4>they've made her some sort of climate messiah back in

0:43:14.320 --> 0:43:17.820
<v Speaker 4>the day. And now they're interviewing her at these protests

0:43:18.020 --> 0:43:20.400
<v Speaker 4>as if she has anything.

0:43:20.430 --> 0:43:23.650
<v Speaker 10>Credible or meaningful. So the media has a role to

0:43:23.850 --> 0:43:27.029
<v Speaker 10>answer for. If they just zapped it of oxygen, it

0:43:27.050 --> 0:43:27.870
<v Speaker 10>would go away.

0:43:27.890 --> 0:43:35.730
<v Speaker 1>I'm not surprised, actually, that she's attracted to extreme things

0:43:36.270 --> 0:43:39.950
<v Speaker 1>and ones that verge on violence or where some of

0:43:39.969 --> 0:43:42.540
<v Speaker 1>the participants, a lot of the participants have used or

0:43:42.600 --> 0:43:48.070
<v Speaker 1>excused violence, because I think it's this It's just preaching

0:43:48.130 --> 0:43:49.910
<v Speaker 1>to a lot of people who seem to think that

0:43:50.190 --> 0:43:56.080
<v Speaker 1>anger and extremism shows how passionate and genuine and honest

0:43:56.680 --> 0:44:00.339
<v Speaker 1>and emotional you are. That's what I think it appeals to,

0:44:00.380 --> 0:44:03.420
<v Speaker 1>which has always been dangerous, the barbaric, you know, I

0:44:03.460 --> 0:44:06.080
<v Speaker 1>will not hear reason. I have a righteous anger. I

0:44:06.100 --> 0:44:09.560
<v Speaker 1>shall smite you. To another woman in the wars.

0:44:09.600 --> 0:44:11.680
<v Speaker 10>And, Andrew, when your position... Go ahead.

0:44:11.680 --> 0:44:14.480
<v Speaker 13>If your position is that the system is violent.

0:44:14.739 --> 0:44:15.009
<v Speaker 10>Yeah.

0:44:15.110 --> 0:44:17.650
<v Speaker 13>if your starting point is that the system is violent,

0:44:17.690 --> 0:44:20.710
<v Speaker 13>that means any reaction to the system is better than

0:44:20.750 --> 0:44:22.010
<v Speaker 13>the system that is violent.

0:44:22.070 --> 0:44:25.530
<v Speaker 10>And that's why you end up with these very aggressive positions... Correct.

0:44:25.850 --> 0:44:29.580
<v Speaker 13>because of the fundamental basis of where she's looking at

0:44:29.620 --> 0:44:30.060
<v Speaker 13>things from.

0:44:30.180 --> 0:44:31.580
<v Speaker 10>Can they just bring out the water cannons?

0:44:31.640 --> 0:44:33.500
<v Speaker 1>It's a licence to bully. Yeah, if you demonise the other,

0:44:33.560 --> 0:44:34.600
<v Speaker 1>it's a licence to bully. Totally.

0:44:35.400 --> 0:44:35.780
<v Speaker 11>Totally.

0:44:37.260 --> 0:44:39.879
<v Speaker 1>That's why it appeals to bullies. That's why the Palestinian

0:44:39.920 --> 0:44:43.680
<v Speaker 1>cause so appeals to so many bullies and so many

0:44:43.700 --> 0:44:46.560
<v Speaker 1>of the riots are violent when you don't see Jews

0:44:46.600 --> 0:44:49.799
<v Speaker 1>in the street protesting for Israel and burning stuff. You

0:44:49.840 --> 0:44:52.230
<v Speaker 1>don't see that. Now, to another woman in the wars

0:44:52.250 --> 0:44:54.870
<v Speaker 1>that I was going to switch to, I will now,

0:44:55.590 --> 0:44:59.000
<v Speaker 1>Donald Trump is a new press secretary. Katie Zachariah. Now,

0:44:59.480 --> 0:45:01.840
<v Speaker 1>she started work today, had a very nervous start. It

0:45:01.860 --> 0:45:04.180
<v Speaker 1>was in the news. She limited herself to answering just

0:45:04.219 --> 0:45:08.549
<v Speaker 1>three questions, read a long written speech, staring at the

0:45:08.590 --> 0:45:11.270
<v Speaker 1>floor and stumbling over some of the answers. But the

0:45:11.330 --> 0:45:15.130
<v Speaker 1>strange thing here is not only... Well, of course she

0:45:15.170 --> 0:45:19.510
<v Speaker 1>meets one of Donald Trump's key qualifications, which is be pretty,

0:45:19.890 --> 0:45:22.700
<v Speaker 1>but the other qualification that she claimed to have, a

0:45:23.200 --> 0:45:25.759
<v Speaker 1>law degree... Well, there's no record of it in the

0:45:25.860 --> 0:45:28.860
<v Speaker 1>United States. And look what happened when she was asked

0:45:28.900 --> 0:45:32.959
<v Speaker 1>about that yesterday overnight and gave an answer which seemed

0:45:32.980 --> 0:45:36.779
<v Speaker 1>to floor even her own boss. Look at this. Where

0:45:36.820 --> 0:45:37.980
<v Speaker 1>did she pass the bar exam?

0:45:38.000 --> 0:45:39.399
<v Speaker 8>Which state?

0:45:45.510 --> 0:45:49.310
<v Speaker 1>In China. She said in China. Donald Trump did a

0:45:49.350 --> 0:45:52.850
<v Speaker 1>double take on that. Gemma, China does not hand out

0:45:52.930 --> 0:45:56.680
<v Speaker 1>law degrees. How long do you expect Katie Zachariah to last?

0:45:56.920 --> 0:45:58.920
<v Speaker 4>I give her a week and that's been generous. Like,

0:45:58.980 --> 0:46:01.780
<v Speaker 4>it's such a deeply odd thing to say. And also, look,

0:46:01.800 --> 0:46:04.969
<v Speaker 4>can I just say, I've been around Andrew. I've seen

0:46:05.010 --> 0:46:06.989
<v Speaker 4>a few things. I can take care of myself. But

0:46:07.110 --> 0:46:10.089
<v Speaker 4>that job is not for the faint-hearted. And whether you

0:46:10.110 --> 0:46:11.529
<v Speaker 4>liked her or lumped her, and a lot of people

0:46:11.570 --> 0:46:13.290
<v Speaker 4>didn't like her because she was young and beautiful and

0:46:13.510 --> 0:46:16.549
<v Speaker 4>an absolute weapon at her job, Caroline Levitt did an

0:46:16.610 --> 0:46:18.950
<v Speaker 4>exceptional job at that role.

0:46:19.540 --> 0:46:20.580
<v Speaker 10>You wouldn't take that.

0:46:20.480 --> 0:46:23.719
<v Speaker 4>Job if you really understood what it meant, you know,

0:46:23.780 --> 0:46:26.600
<v Speaker 4>blithely or lightly. Every journalist in that press pack is

0:46:26.620 --> 0:46:28.670
<v Speaker 4>going to be looking into your past is going to be.

0:46:28.660 --> 0:46:30.790
<v Speaker 4>I mean, you're the spokesperson for the leader of the

0:46:30.850 --> 0:46:34.549
<v Speaker 4>free world. So if this young lady is telling pork

0:46:34.570 --> 0:46:37.250
<v Speaker 4>pies about her qualifications, she'll be gone quicker than it

0:46:37.290 --> 0:46:39.440
<v Speaker 4>takes me to demolish a, you know, mini Magnum.

0:46:39.900 --> 0:46:41.680
<v Speaker 10>So like a minute and a half, I don't know.

0:46:44.110 --> 0:46:45.870
<v Speaker 1>When I say it doesn't hand out law degrees, it

0:46:45.910 --> 0:46:47.730
<v Speaker 1>doesn't hand them out to foreigners.

0:46:47.370 --> 0:46:49.490
<v Speaker 10>Or that foreigners practise.

0:46:48.890 --> 0:46:51.529
<v Speaker 1>Law, as she claims to have done when she lived

0:46:51.590 --> 0:46:55.990
<v Speaker 1>in China. Caroline, Katie Sakurai, I mean, it's a tough job,

0:46:56.050 --> 0:47:00.470
<v Speaker 1>but dear goodness, you know, do you think maybe Trump

0:47:00.510 --> 0:47:03.210
<v Speaker 1>just gets blinded by someone's looks and doesn't look to

0:47:03.650 --> 0:47:05.790
<v Speaker 1>enough of their qualifications and abilities?

0:47:07.170 --> 0:47:10.009
<v Speaker 13>Well, look, I don't know, but you would think that

0:47:10.070 --> 0:47:13.839
<v Speaker 13>something as basic as your qualifications would be checked. And

0:47:13.880 --> 0:47:16.020
<v Speaker 13>I mean, you know, you go for any normal job

0:47:16.120 --> 0:47:18.299
<v Speaker 13>and those sorts of things are checked. I've had to

0:47:18.340 --> 0:47:21.020
<v Speaker 13>give out academic certificates before.

0:47:21.739 --> 0:47:23.779
<v Speaker 10>When I've gone for jobs, I've got a law degree. Actually,

0:47:23.820 --> 0:47:24.560
<v Speaker 10>I've got two of them.

0:47:24.980 --> 0:47:27.440
<v Speaker 13>And the thing that I find really interesting about her

0:47:27.580 --> 0:47:31.219
<v Speaker 13>answer about China is that legal systems around the world

0:47:31.260 --> 0:47:34.930
<v Speaker 13>are really different. And the Chinese legal system couldn't be

0:47:35.370 --> 0:47:39.310
<v Speaker 13>more different from the US legal system. So what I

0:47:39.330 --> 0:47:42.390
<v Speaker 13>want to know is where's the follow-up question of, you know,

0:47:42.989 --> 0:47:45.230
<v Speaker 13>did you do your degree in China? You passed the

0:47:45.250 --> 0:47:45.990
<v Speaker 13>bar in China.

0:47:46.050 --> 0:47:46.610
<v Speaker 10>Fabulous.

0:47:46.670 --> 0:47:50.810
<v Speaker 13>But of what absolute, what benefit, what use? is that

0:47:50.870 --> 0:47:53.970
<v Speaker 13>degree to the role that you're holding in the US

0:47:54.050 --> 0:47:57.660
<v Speaker 13>because they are absolute worlds apart. And obviously when people

0:47:58.080 --> 0:48:00.840
<v Speaker 13>come to Australia from other jurisdictions, different if it's a

0:48:00.860 --> 0:48:03.640
<v Speaker 13>common law jurisdiction like the UK, but, you know, there's

0:48:03.660 --> 0:48:05.540
<v Speaker 13>a lot of retraining involved.

0:48:05.580 --> 0:48:09.060
<v Speaker 10>So I'd be fascinated to see where this goes because

0:48:09.120 --> 0:48:12.010
<v Speaker 10>I reckon it's going to be a belter, Andrew. She's gone.

0:48:12.030 --> 0:48:13.550
<v Speaker 10>She's gone.

0:48:13.590 --> 0:48:18.989
<v Speaker 1>She's gone. Makes you wonder if the White House spokesman

0:48:19.030 --> 0:48:21.850
<v Speaker 1>has a spokesman because she may well need one very

0:48:22.010 --> 0:48:25.509
<v Speaker 1>shortly to handle all the press inquiries about this one.

0:48:26.719 --> 0:48:29.299
<v Speaker 1>Gemma Tonini, Carolyn DeRusso, thank you very much to you both.

0:48:29.360 --> 0:48:33.160
<v Speaker 1>That's it from me. Coming up next, Shari Markson. Good night.