WEBVTT - The Bolt Report | 28 October

0:00:14.770 --> 0:00:19.230
<v Speaker 1>I am barking about that, anyway. Tonight, surprise results from

0:00:19.310 --> 0:00:22.890
<v Speaker 1>Israel's elections coming up. And one of the world's biggest

0:00:22.940 --> 0:00:26.820
<v Speaker 1>sports stars in a huge brawl with China after simply

0:00:26.900 --> 0:00:29.820
<v Speaker 1>telling the truth. But watch him now crawl. It's a worry.

0:00:30.160 --> 0:00:32.000
<v Speaker 1>Plenty more, including Gemma and Caroline.

0:00:32.020 --> 0:00:32.480
<v Speaker 2>But first.

0:00:33.570 --> 0:00:38.309
<v Speaker 1>Two political disasters today came together. The Marrickville Golf Club

0:00:38.350 --> 0:00:40.670
<v Speaker 1>scandal that just got even worse for the Prime Minister,

0:00:41.409 --> 0:00:44.170
<v Speaker 1>and the inflation that also got worse, and that is

0:00:44.450 --> 0:00:47.540
<v Speaker 1>a problem for us all. And one of those disasters

0:00:47.659 --> 0:00:52.100
<v Speaker 1>actually helps to explain the other. Now, obviously, the one

0:00:52.120 --> 0:00:55.300
<v Speaker 1>that hits hardest is inflation, which today jumped higher than

0:00:55.360 --> 0:01:00.750
<v Speaker 1>expected to 4.3%. That's the headline rate. But the underlying

0:01:00.810 --> 0:01:04.110
<v Speaker 1>rate was also high, up to 3.6%. That's the rate

0:01:04.130 --> 0:01:06.789
<v Speaker 1>that strips out temporary factors. And the bad news is

0:01:06.850 --> 0:01:10.090
<v Speaker 1>that this rate is what the Reserve Bank will look

0:01:10.150 --> 0:01:14.110
<v Speaker 1>at when it decides next week whether to increase interest rates.

0:01:15.430 --> 0:01:20.510
<v Speaker 1>That's now odds on. Yet another rise in interest rates.

0:01:20.550 --> 0:01:23.370
<v Speaker 1>It'll be the fifth this year to add to these

0:01:23.610 --> 0:01:29.110
<v Speaker 1>rising prices for food and petrol especially. That's going to hurt. Now,

0:01:29.120 --> 0:01:31.569
<v Speaker 1>the Reserve Bank governor said we couldn't just blame all

0:01:31.610 --> 0:01:36.630
<v Speaker 1>this on foreign factors like the war in Iran. Inflation

0:01:36.670 --> 0:01:41.510
<v Speaker 1>was getting worse too. And that's, of course, because of

0:01:41.750 --> 0:01:43.190
<v Speaker 1>factors right here.

0:01:44.150 --> 0:01:47.390
<v Speaker 3>Although growth in the Australian economy is slowing as expected,

0:01:47.910 --> 0:01:51.080
<v Speaker 3>some of the international and domestic upside risks to inflation

0:01:51.120 --> 0:01:53.540
<v Speaker 3>have materialised or are materialising.

0:01:55.650 --> 0:02:00.230
<v Speaker 1>But as always, Treasure Jim Chalmers today did blame Iran

0:02:00.300 --> 0:02:04.000
<v Speaker 1>and all that, blamed all those damn foreigners for causing

0:02:04.060 --> 0:02:09.620
<v Speaker 1>us these problems instead of blaming what he could control

0:02:09.680 --> 0:02:13.570
<v Speaker 1>himself and has not, which is the government's own wild spending.

0:02:14.530 --> 0:02:17.830
<v Speaker 4>We already had an inflation challenge in our economy and

0:02:17.850 --> 0:02:20.070
<v Speaker 4>the war in the Middle East is making it worse.

0:02:20.730 --> 0:02:24.400
<v Speaker 4>We've seen higher oil prices driving higher inflation around the world.

0:02:25.080 --> 0:02:28.640
<v Speaker 4>And today's figures confirm that we are not immune from that.

0:02:30.660 --> 0:02:34.419
<v Speaker 1>Bull alert. The trim mean inflation figure I showed you,

0:02:34.480 --> 0:02:38.600
<v Speaker 1>that the Reserve Bank uses to decide interest rate rises,

0:02:38.880 --> 0:02:42.520
<v Speaker 1>actually cuts out factors like big price rises in petrol,

0:02:42.560 --> 0:02:47.640
<v Speaker 1>which go up and down. Jim, it's your big spending.

0:02:47.800 --> 0:02:50.560
<v Speaker 1>That's the crucial factor here. And the question then is,

0:02:50.720 --> 0:02:54.799
<v Speaker 1>why can't the government control it? so that inflation doesn't

0:02:54.820 --> 0:02:58.380
<v Speaker 1>get this bad. And that's where we come to the

0:02:58.419 --> 0:03:03.600
<v Speaker 1>Prime Minister's golf club scandal. That's what makes that even worse. Now,

0:03:03.650 --> 0:03:06.350
<v Speaker 1>so far, this has all been really a disaster for

0:03:06.389 --> 0:03:09.830
<v Speaker 1>Anthony Albanese because it confirms for many voters that he

0:03:09.870 --> 0:03:11.790
<v Speaker 1>really is a liar, or at least in this case,

0:03:11.810 --> 0:03:15.269
<v Speaker 1>someone you can't trust to tell the truth. He's a

0:03:15.290 --> 0:03:18.220
<v Speaker 1>man so reluctant to claim he's wrong or to admit

0:03:18.250 --> 0:03:23.300
<v Speaker 1>he's wrong that it took until yesterday, after weeks, months,

0:03:23.750 --> 0:03:25.209
<v Speaker 1>to finally admit that he'd made what he called a

0:03:25.230 --> 0:03:28.929
<v Speaker 1>mistake when he told this falsehood last month about why

0:03:28.990 --> 0:03:32.220
<v Speaker 1>he'd given $ 6 million of your money to his local

0:03:32.250 --> 0:03:33.420
<v Speaker 1>Marrickville golf club.

0:03:34.400 --> 0:03:39.180
<v Speaker 5>When it floods in Marrickville, raw sewerage flows into the

0:03:39.220 --> 0:03:39.840
<v Speaker 5>Cooks River.

0:03:40.440 --> 0:03:44.619
<v Speaker 1>That is what the funding is for. I always try

0:03:44.640 --> 0:03:48.380
<v Speaker 1>to be fair. It's not, you know, partisan politics kind

0:03:48.420 --> 0:03:50.840
<v Speaker 1>of stuff. I don't actually think his false statement to

0:03:50.880 --> 0:03:56.500
<v Speaker 1>Parliament is a hanging offence. It was pretty obviously a mistake.

0:03:57.100 --> 0:03:59.820
<v Speaker 1>And his real sin is one for voters to punish.

0:04:00.280 --> 0:04:03.460
<v Speaker 1>That bizarre reluctance of his to admit to a mistake

0:04:03.820 --> 0:04:07.630
<v Speaker 1>and fix it fast, long before everyone works out, hey,

0:04:08.790 --> 0:04:11.030
<v Speaker 1>I've heard about this and here's more proof that I

0:04:11.070 --> 0:04:15.130
<v Speaker 1>can't trust him. That's the disaster for him. But there's

0:04:15.210 --> 0:04:19.290
<v Speaker 1>now more because of all this. It's the excuses given

0:04:20.130 --> 0:04:23.739
<v Speaker 1>for saying that that $ 6 million grant was for Sewerage

0:04:23.800 --> 0:04:26.540
<v Speaker 1>works at the club. It was not correct.

0:04:26.560 --> 0:04:29.760
<v Speaker 5>The state government have moved in and are funding the project.

0:04:32.120 --> 0:04:36.100
<v Speaker 1>Now, his excuse is actually quite weird and quite telling. Now,

0:04:36.120 --> 0:04:39.179
<v Speaker 1>I bet he's saying, well, actually, yes, the $ 6 million,

0:04:39.500 --> 0:04:42.700
<v Speaker 1>he's saying it today, really. Again, it really was for

0:04:42.750 --> 0:04:46.880
<v Speaker 1>these very urgent sewage works, among other things. But in

0:04:46.900 --> 0:04:48.790
<v Speaker 1>the end, the New South Wales government stepped in to

0:04:48.870 --> 0:04:52.440
<v Speaker 1>pay for it itself. And this is a story that

0:04:52.500 --> 0:04:55.200
<v Speaker 1>Albanians and its ministers today stuck to again and again.

0:04:56.279 --> 0:04:59.320
<v Speaker 5>I've said that part of the original commitment of the

0:04:59.400 --> 0:05:02.490
<v Speaker 5>upgrade of Maracle Golf Club was going to fix the

0:05:02.529 --> 0:05:07.110
<v Speaker 5>long-running sewage issue that was to be part of renovations.

0:05:07.330 --> 0:05:09.960
<v Speaker 5>That isn't the case because the state government have stepped in.

0:05:10.800 --> 0:05:14.320
<v Speaker 5>and announced funding in September 2025.

0:05:14.320 --> 0:05:18.560
<v Speaker 6>When this funding commitment was made in April 2025, part

0:05:18.580 --> 0:05:22.870
<v Speaker 6>of the commitment included Sewerage Works. In September 2025, the

0:05:23.350 --> 0:05:26.430
<v Speaker 6>New South Wales government stepped in to fund the sewage-related

0:05:26.529 --> 0:05:28.789
<v Speaker 6>aspects of the club as they were pressing.

0:05:28.890 --> 0:05:32.990
<v Speaker 7>When he made that original commitment, the Sewerage Works were

0:05:33.070 --> 0:05:36.510
<v Speaker 7>part of the original commitment. The scope of that changed

0:05:36.570 --> 0:05:39.630
<v Speaker 7>because the state government stepped in to do the Sewerage Works.

0:05:40.330 --> 0:05:45.680
<v Speaker 1>And in Albanese's partial defence, as you probably got from

0:05:45.720 --> 0:05:48.640
<v Speaker 1>some hints in how that was answered, that $ 6 million

0:05:49.140 --> 0:05:52.040
<v Speaker 1>from the start was not just for sewerage works. It

0:05:52.080 --> 0:05:56.000
<v Speaker 1>was for other stuff as well, as documents at the

0:05:56.040 --> 0:06:00.760
<v Speaker 1>time made clear. Only $ 300, 000 was for the sewerage. But

0:06:00.810 --> 0:06:03.390
<v Speaker 1>the fact that Albanese went on and on about the

0:06:03.410 --> 0:06:08.170
<v Speaker 1>sewerage suggests that this was for him and his ministers

0:06:08.190 --> 0:06:12.280
<v Speaker 1>the crucial thing in this grant. But if this government then,

0:06:12.300 --> 0:06:16.610
<v Speaker 1>this is the curious thing, if this government then says

0:06:16.750 --> 0:06:20.190
<v Speaker 1>to the club, look, here's $ 6 million, I want you

0:06:20.230 --> 0:06:24.089
<v Speaker 1>to fix your sewerage especially, and then finds out, oh, dear,

0:06:24.950 --> 0:06:27.870
<v Speaker 1>the state government has stepped in and it's now going

0:06:27.890 --> 0:06:30.390
<v Speaker 1>to pay for those sewerage works instead. Shouldn't the government say,

0:06:31.070 --> 0:06:34.380
<v Speaker 1>hang on, we want that $ 6 million back? Or at

0:06:34.420 --> 0:06:36.039
<v Speaker 1>least the bit of it that was for the sewerage.

0:06:37.460 --> 0:06:40.190
<v Speaker 1>After all, I mean, you can't waste a cent. The

0:06:40.200 --> 0:06:43.849
<v Speaker 1>government's got a trillion-dollar debt now. Shouldn't be splashing cash

0:06:43.890 --> 0:06:47.850
<v Speaker 1>around like it was for free. Instead, it told this

0:06:47.970 --> 0:06:52.070
<v Speaker 1>lucky club, nah, keep the lot. So this $ 6 million

0:06:52.130 --> 0:06:55.409
<v Speaker 1>of our money is now going not on that sewage

0:06:55.450 --> 0:07:00.070
<v Speaker 1>work that Albanese keep talking about, but things like tizzing

0:07:00.130 --> 0:07:01.540
<v Speaker 1>up the club's pro shop.

0:07:02.600 --> 0:07:03.219
<v Speaker 2>It's barred.

0:07:04.040 --> 0:07:10.500
<v Speaker 1>It's alfresco facilities, plus new furnishings and more. There'll even

0:07:10.540 --> 0:07:13.660
<v Speaker 1>be a dog walking station, which I'm sure Toto would appreciate.

0:07:14.900 --> 0:07:19.690
<v Speaker 1>So already I'm thinking here, this government has no respect

0:07:19.750 --> 0:07:23.310
<v Speaker 1>for how it spends our taxes, not when it can

0:07:23.350 --> 0:07:27.330
<v Speaker 1>help Labor win votes. Now, I know $ 6 million is

0:07:27.390 --> 0:07:28.510
<v Speaker 1>a drop in the ocean and $ 300, 000 of that is

0:07:28.530 --> 0:07:34.210
<v Speaker 1>even less. But it's this kind of thinking that has

0:07:34.330 --> 0:07:40.490
<v Speaker 1>helped get our debt now to a trillion dollars. And

0:07:40.510 --> 0:07:43.990
<v Speaker 1>then I'm thinking, wait a minute. What are we talking about?

0:07:44.850 --> 0:07:47.870
<v Speaker 1>Why is a government with that level of debt even

0:07:47.950 --> 0:07:53.810
<v Speaker 1>considering spending millions on a golf club, of all things?

0:07:55.210 --> 0:07:59.940
<v Speaker 1>Golfers should pay for their own fun, surely. You know,

0:08:00.000 --> 0:08:04.900
<v Speaker 1>pay to play. And why is this government giving $ 6

0:08:04.560 --> 0:08:07.610
<v Speaker 1>million to this particular golf course and only this golf

0:08:07.650 --> 0:08:12.430
<v Speaker 1>course of the 1,500 or more golf courses in Australia?

0:08:14.510 --> 0:08:17.410
<v Speaker 1>Then again, I guess, you know, how many golf clubs

0:08:17.650 --> 0:08:21.060
<v Speaker 1>are just 200 metres from the Prime Minister's investment property

0:08:21.540 --> 0:08:24.420
<v Speaker 1>and in his electorate? How many are owned by a

0:08:24.480 --> 0:08:27.640
<v Speaker 1>council headed by Darcy Byrne, who worked for Albanese for

0:08:27.660 --> 0:08:30.250
<v Speaker 1>nearly a decade and is tipped one day to be

0:08:30.760 --> 0:08:34.319
<v Speaker 1>Labor's candidate, or at least the Socialist Left's, for his seat.

0:08:34.840 --> 0:08:35.979
<v Speaker 1>I'm talking about this guy.

0:08:36.840 --> 0:08:38.980
<v Speaker 8>With the Inner West Council election coming up on the

0:08:39.220 --> 0:08:42.060
<v Speaker 8>14th of September, we're so happy to have the support

0:08:42.100 --> 0:08:45.099
<v Speaker 8>of the Prime Minister of Australia, perhaps the most famous

0:08:45.140 --> 0:08:46.120
<v Speaker 8>Inner Westie of them all.

0:08:47.080 --> 0:08:50.179
<v Speaker 5>Well, Darcy, I want to support you and your Labor team.

0:08:51.380 --> 0:08:54.079
<v Speaker 1>So the poo may be cleared, but the stink remains.

0:08:54.760 --> 0:08:58.100
<v Speaker 1>And I'm afraid it's coming from the general direction of Albanese,

0:08:58.140 --> 0:09:02.059
<v Speaker 1>who's shown again. how he struggles with the truth, but

0:09:02.160 --> 0:09:09.370
<v Speaker 1>is a master at blowing your taxes. Now, the Prime

0:09:09.390 --> 0:09:13.870
<v Speaker 1>Minister did also today use the Helen Haynes defence, the tragedy,

0:09:13.929 --> 0:09:17.069
<v Speaker 1>exploit the tragedy, to try to stop the opposition from

0:09:17.270 --> 0:09:21.370
<v Speaker 1>laughing and groaning at him for blaming foreigners again for

0:09:21.870 --> 0:09:23.610
<v Speaker 1>today's terrible inflation figures.

0:09:24.610 --> 0:09:30.110
<v Speaker 5>The groaning that occurs opposite... This is about the RBA governor.

0:09:30.870 --> 0:09:33.980
<v Speaker 5>And we should turn the temperature down and maybe people

0:09:34.050 --> 0:09:36.880
<v Speaker 5>could stop interjecting.

0:09:37.440 --> 0:09:40.540
<v Speaker 1>Turn the temperature down rather than attack your poor Prime Minister.

0:09:40.900 --> 0:09:43.280
<v Speaker 1>Joining me is the political panel, Cameron Milner, former Chief

0:09:43.300 --> 0:09:45.819
<v Speaker 1>of Staff to Labor leader Bill Shorten, now Director of

0:09:45.900 --> 0:09:52.170
<v Speaker 1>GXO Strategies, and Michael Kossa, former New South Wales Labor Treasurer. Michael,

0:09:52.690 --> 0:09:57.020
<v Speaker 1>given your background, first the inflation figures... Looks almost certain

0:09:57.059 --> 0:09:59.230
<v Speaker 1>now that we are going to get another interest rate

0:09:59.290 --> 0:10:02.300
<v Speaker 1>rise as soon as next week, doesn't it?

0:10:03.420 --> 0:10:06.020
<v Speaker 9>Well, these figures are appalling and, you know, they were

0:10:06.480 --> 0:10:09.880
<v Speaker 9>eminently predictable. Everybody predicted that we would end up with

0:10:09.940 --> 0:10:14.240
<v Speaker 9>some further interest rate increases, whether it was next month

0:10:14.300 --> 0:10:16.910
<v Speaker 9>or the month after, that's where we were heading. I mean,

0:10:16.950 --> 0:10:19.710
<v Speaker 9>but Andrew, you're absolutely correct about that. I mean, the

0:10:19.770 --> 0:10:23.230
<v Speaker 9>trim mean is the problem here. We've got ingrained inflation.

0:10:23.880 --> 0:10:26.179
<v Speaker 9>The government's got no answers. I mean, I thought it

0:10:26.200 --> 0:10:30.760
<v Speaker 9>was pathetic today watching Albo trying to defend Chalmers.

0:10:30.850 --> 0:10:31.020
<v Speaker 1>I mean.

0:10:31.440 --> 0:10:34.600
<v Speaker 9>I mean, people forget that Chalmers had the gall, the

0:10:34.840 --> 0:10:37.280
<v Speaker 9>hubris to write an essay about three years ago about

0:10:37.330 --> 0:10:39.790
<v Speaker 9>how he was going to reform capitalism. And one of

0:10:39.809 --> 0:10:42.790
<v Speaker 9>the factors that he pointed at, Andrew, one of the

0:10:42.809 --> 0:10:47.750
<v Speaker 9>factors he pointed at was deregulation and austerity, the very

0:10:47.809 --> 0:10:51.550
<v Speaker 9>things that we require to get out of this mess

0:10:51.670 --> 0:10:55.890
<v Speaker 9>that we're in at the moment. He is chronically unable

0:10:55.929 --> 0:10:59.360
<v Speaker 9>to understand the problem, let alone come up with solutions. And,

0:10:59.380 --> 0:11:01.700
<v Speaker 9>you know, it's good having a PhD in Paul Keating,

0:11:01.760 --> 0:11:05.140
<v Speaker 9>but you really do need to understand how an economy works.

0:11:05.660 --> 0:11:11.290
<v Speaker 9>Record spending, you know, collapsed productivity and a treasurer that

0:11:11.450 --> 0:11:15.350
<v Speaker 9>is absolutely clueless. He's asking the community how to cut spending. Well, mate,

0:11:15.450 --> 0:11:19.290
<v Speaker 9>start with the NDIS. Everybody knows it's a rort. And,

0:11:19.429 --> 0:11:20.960
<v Speaker 9>you know, we're not going to get any sense out

0:11:21.000 --> 0:11:23.920
<v Speaker 9>of this. And as for Albo, mate, he loves throwing

0:11:23.960 --> 0:11:26.420
<v Speaker 9>mud at people. but when it starts coming back to him,

0:11:26.460 --> 0:11:28.859
<v Speaker 9>the glass drawer comes out. You know, he's abused more

0:11:28.900 --> 0:11:32.699
<v Speaker 9>people in his political career and claimed all sorts of

0:11:32.740 --> 0:11:35.330
<v Speaker 9>things than anybody that I know, and now he can't

0:11:35.370 --> 0:11:37.170
<v Speaker 9>take it and he wants to turn down the temperature.

0:11:38.309 --> 0:11:40.730
<v Speaker 1>Well, it's funny. Personally, I found him good company and

0:11:40.770 --> 0:11:43.030
<v Speaker 1>he still reaches out, so I give him credit for that.

0:11:43.570 --> 0:11:46.450
<v Speaker 1>If I've come across worse, let me tell you. But

0:11:46.470 --> 0:11:49.620
<v Speaker 1>the Prime Minister's response, Cameron, to being jeered today using

0:11:50.030 --> 0:11:53.610
<v Speaker 1>the attack on MP Helen Haynes by... actually a mentally

0:11:53.690 --> 0:11:56.189
<v Speaker 1>ill man, the son of family friends. I'm not quite

0:11:56.250 --> 0:11:58.630
<v Speaker 1>sure what lesson we can draw from that, but he

0:11:58.730 --> 0:12:02.699
<v Speaker 1>used it to stop people laughing at him. That seemed

0:12:02.720 --> 0:12:03.800
<v Speaker 1>to me a little odd.

0:12:06.050 --> 0:12:08.309
<v Speaker 2>Well, it's just perverse, isn't it? It's all so disgraceful.

0:12:08.330 --> 0:12:10.430
<v Speaker 8>I mean, you know, on Monday we're giving bouquets to

0:12:10.450 --> 0:12:12.369
<v Speaker 8>Helen Haynes, as we should, and now we're using her

0:12:12.410 --> 0:12:15.410
<v Speaker 8>as a straw man, you know, to protect Albo from

0:12:15.450 --> 0:12:17.670
<v Speaker 8>a bit of criticism. I mean, to your point, Michael,

0:12:17.690 --> 0:12:20.830
<v Speaker 8>I mean, this Albanese government is a bunch of economic arsonists,

0:12:21.150 --> 0:12:24.429
<v Speaker 8>economic arsonists, running around with a jerrycan full of budget overspend,

0:12:24.670 --> 0:12:25.780
<v Speaker 8>putting on the inflation fire.

0:12:25.960 --> 0:12:27.600
<v Speaker 2>I mean, these guys have got it out of control,

0:12:28.000 --> 0:12:28.819
<v Speaker 2>and now.

0:12:28.800 --> 0:12:30.780
<v Speaker 8>The RBA is going to put up interest rates next month,

0:12:30.940 --> 0:12:33.480
<v Speaker 8>potentially the week, month after, again, because of this reckless,

0:12:33.880 --> 0:12:34.760
<v Speaker 8>reckless overspend.

0:12:35.080 --> 0:12:37.300
<v Speaker 2>From Labor who just can't seem to stop spending money.

0:12:38.929 --> 0:12:42.170
<v Speaker 1>We saw more of the same, actually, I think, Michael,

0:12:42.230 --> 0:12:46.430
<v Speaker 1>from the Governments Resources Minister, Madeleine King, who also... used

0:12:46.490 --> 0:12:50.150
<v Speaker 1>the tragedy to try to mute media criticism and satire

0:12:50.170 --> 0:12:54.920
<v Speaker 1>of her hypocrisy. Now, look, maybe she's got a reason

0:12:55.000 --> 0:12:57.900
<v Speaker 1>to complain. I'll leave you to judge. But here she

0:12:57.980 --> 0:13:02.910
<v Speaker 1>is today complaining about a front-page cartoon responding to her

0:13:02.990 --> 0:13:05.750
<v Speaker 1>blaming the media for inciting such violence.

0:13:07.110 --> 0:13:10.510
<v Speaker 10>Image of me in a pot to be boiled. I mean,

0:13:11.150 --> 0:13:15.400
<v Speaker 10>this is what, you know, tabloids do. And, you know,

0:13:15.440 --> 0:13:18.400
<v Speaker 10>then the media just shares it and shares it and

0:13:18.440 --> 0:13:20.520
<v Speaker 10>shares it as an image. So it's sort of feeding

0:13:20.600 --> 0:13:23.940
<v Speaker 10>into the clickbait that we see.

0:13:24.059 --> 0:13:25.100
<v Speaker 2>And you're doing it again.

0:13:25.260 --> 0:13:27.980
<v Speaker 10>So, you know, fabulous. It sort of makes my point.

0:13:28.780 --> 0:13:30.660
<v Speaker 10>I don't really know what to say about the kind

0:13:30.730 --> 0:13:33.270
<v Speaker 10>of violence that implies.

0:13:35.230 --> 0:13:37.410
<v Speaker 1>Well, Michael, what did you make of that? Does she

0:13:37.429 --> 0:13:38.050
<v Speaker 1>have a point?

0:13:39.030 --> 0:13:41.380
<v Speaker 9>No, she doesn't have a point. It's a cartoon for

0:13:41.429 --> 0:13:45.120
<v Speaker 9>crying out loud. And, look, if she's so sensitive, and

0:13:45.440 --> 0:13:48.520
<v Speaker 9>I apply this to all politicians, not just her, they

0:13:48.559 --> 0:13:50.760
<v Speaker 9>ought to get out of politics. You know, it is

0:13:50.800 --> 0:13:55.200
<v Speaker 9>a contact sport. Yes, we don't want people advocating violence,

0:13:55.240 --> 0:13:57.179
<v Speaker 9>but I can tell you there are people in that

0:13:57.220 --> 0:14:02.070
<v Speaker 9>parliament that have supported, you know... claims of genocide in

0:14:02.610 --> 0:14:08.349
<v Speaker 9>Palestine and actually supported people that are potentially terrorists. So

0:14:08.650 --> 0:14:12.030
<v Speaker 9>let's be clear here. Robust political debate is part of

0:14:12.200 --> 0:14:15.800
<v Speaker 9>our system and it's important to the system. If people

0:14:16.200 --> 0:14:19.460
<v Speaker 9>are involved in individual threats, it's up to the police

0:14:19.760 --> 0:14:21.840
<v Speaker 9>to deal with that. Don't use it as an excuse

0:14:22.340 --> 0:14:24.730
<v Speaker 9>to not cop criticism for bad policies.

0:14:26.190 --> 0:14:29.470
<v Speaker 1>Unless I forget, when Aboriginal activists burned down burn the

0:14:29.550 --> 0:14:33.250
<v Speaker 1>front door of the old Parliament House, Independent Senator Lydia

0:14:33.310 --> 0:14:36.990
<v Speaker 1>Thorpe posted a tweet that to me was a very

0:14:37.110 --> 0:14:41.750
<v Speaker 1>clear celebration of that. Please, there's so much hypocrisy going on.

0:14:42.580 --> 0:14:47.180
<v Speaker 1>But the golf club affair, Cameron, what is the take

0:14:47.280 --> 0:14:49.480
<v Speaker 1>out for you from all that?

0:14:51.500 --> 0:14:53.500
<v Speaker 2>Well, the whole thing stinks, doesn't it? It stinks to

0:14:53.540 --> 0:14:53.950
<v Speaker 2>high heaven.

0:14:54.090 --> 0:14:57.510
<v Speaker 8>I mean, to hide behind sewerage as an excuse.

0:14:57.550 --> 0:14:59.650
<v Speaker 2>I mean, for goodness sake, can the Prime Minister get

0:14:59.790 --> 0:15:03.430
<v Speaker 2>any lower? I mean, in the end, finally the Prime.

0:15:03.330 --> 0:15:06.110
<v Speaker 8>Minister cut the crap today and came clean like this

0:15:06.150 --> 0:15:08.620
<v Speaker 8>and said he'd actually made a mistake. Well, goodness me,

0:15:08.980 --> 0:15:09.960
<v Speaker 8>everyone had known that for.

0:15:09.920 --> 0:15:12.120
<v Speaker 2>Weeks, for weeks. And this is the problem.

0:15:12.140 --> 0:15:14.100
<v Speaker 8>If he wants to turn the temperature down, he needs

0:15:14.120 --> 0:15:15.760
<v Speaker 8>to start doing a better job. If he wants to

0:15:15.780 --> 0:15:17.540
<v Speaker 8>turn the temperature down, stop lying.

0:15:19.340 --> 0:15:21.880
<v Speaker 1>Yeah, it's funny, isn't it, Michael? I guess he thought

0:15:22.440 --> 0:15:25.200
<v Speaker 1>that saying it was for sewerage when it's not, he

0:15:25.220 --> 0:15:27.100
<v Speaker 1>might not have known, but for saying it was sewerage

0:15:27.120 --> 0:15:29.560
<v Speaker 1>is far better than saying for what the money really

0:15:29.600 --> 0:15:32.739
<v Speaker 1>went on. Like we want to, you know, pay for

0:15:32.780 --> 0:15:37.920
<v Speaker 1>a really nice alfresco dining area and the bar, we'd

0:15:37.960 --> 0:15:40.640
<v Speaker 1>like that to look a bit nicer too and this

0:15:40.680 --> 0:15:44.620
<v Speaker 1>and that. $ 6 million for that? People would really be

0:15:44.800 --> 0:15:45.940
<v Speaker 1>right on to this con.

0:15:46.930 --> 0:15:49.460
<v Speaker 9>Yeah, it's a complete joke. But what is a joke

0:15:49.500 --> 0:15:51.220
<v Speaker 9>is the way the money was handed out. And I

0:15:51.260 --> 0:15:53.490
<v Speaker 9>think we shouldn't lose sight of that in all of this.

0:15:54.420 --> 0:15:57.620
<v Speaker 9>There should never be a process where the government invites

0:15:57.700 --> 0:16:03.630
<v Speaker 9>people to tender for these rorts and pork barrelling exercises. And,

0:16:03.670 --> 0:16:06.850
<v Speaker 9>you know, I'm really disgusted with the Federal Integrity Commission.

0:16:07.450 --> 0:16:09.810
<v Speaker 9>You know, these politicians in Canberra got together and made

0:16:09.890 --> 0:16:12.570
<v Speaker 9>sure it had no teeth. And this is precisely where

0:16:12.590 --> 0:16:14.489
<v Speaker 9>you needed to have teeth. You know, the New South

0:16:14.510 --> 0:16:18.890
<v Speaker 9>Wales Commission always puts out guidelines to head off potential

0:16:18.930 --> 0:16:22.760
<v Speaker 9>corruption or malfeasance before it occurs. Where are the guidelines

0:16:22.820 --> 0:16:26.580
<v Speaker 9>on these grants? Where is the Federal Integrity Commission dealing

0:16:26.620 --> 0:16:28.780
<v Speaker 9>with these grants? We don't want to see this again,

0:16:28.800 --> 0:16:30.620
<v Speaker 9>and the way it is, we'll see it again.

0:16:32.440 --> 0:16:36.540
<v Speaker 1>Well, Cameron, talking about the waste, One Nation's Barnaby Joyce

0:16:36.600 --> 0:16:41.390
<v Speaker 1>made an excellent point about that today, about a massive example,

0:16:41.770 --> 0:16:45.110
<v Speaker 1>never mind sewerage at a golf club, and got pure

0:16:45.250 --> 0:16:47.190
<v Speaker 1>drivel in response. Listen.

0:16:48.190 --> 0:16:50.360
<v Speaker 11>Why don't we look at getting rid of the climate

0:16:50.400 --> 0:16:54.490
<v Speaker 11>change department. There's $ 8. 7 billion a year we spend on it.

0:16:54.960 --> 0:16:59.160
<v Speaker 11>It would loosen up 5,700 full-time equivalent positions, which would

0:16:59.180 --> 0:17:02.790
<v Speaker 11>go through natural attrition. It's got absolutely no prospects whatsoever

0:17:02.810 --> 0:17:05.129
<v Speaker 11>of changing the climate or anything like that, and would

0:17:05.190 --> 0:17:07.590
<v Speaker 11>save us from jacking up taxes on capital gains tax

0:17:07.609 --> 0:17:11.949
<v Speaker 11>for small business, taxing superannuation funds, and taxing trusts.

0:17:12.170 --> 0:17:19.020
<v Speaker 5>There has been now decades of science and advice on

0:17:19.100 --> 0:17:26.860
<v Speaker 5>climate change, that it is real. I support responding to

0:17:26.900 --> 0:17:32.580
<v Speaker 5>the science of climate change, which does represent a challenge,

0:17:33.540 --> 0:17:38.050
<v Speaker 5>but also represents an enormous opportunity. It is a cost

0:17:38.070 --> 0:17:41.830
<v Speaker 5>of inaction as well. What we are seeing, not the

0:17:41.890 --> 0:17:47.780
<v Speaker 5>least of which is in the great state of Queensland

0:17:47.900 --> 0:17:56.460
<v Speaker 5>that the member represented in the other place is increasing

0:17:57.140 --> 0:18:01.929
<v Speaker 5>numbers and frequencies and intensity of extreme weather events.

0:18:03.010 --> 0:18:04.870
<v Speaker 1>Sorry to play it at length, but a very quick

0:18:05.130 --> 0:18:09.310
<v Speaker 1>fact check. Saying I believe in climate change is a catechism.

0:18:09.390 --> 0:18:12.659
<v Speaker 1>It's completely meaningless. I believe in climate change too. And

0:18:12.720 --> 0:18:15.540
<v Speaker 1>as for extreme weather, in fact, Australia, and this is

0:18:15.790 --> 0:18:19.950
<v Speaker 1>the science, and especially for Queensland, is in fact getting

0:18:20.230 --> 0:18:25.080
<v Speaker 1>fewer cyclones. And as for the cost, how, Cameron, could

0:18:25.190 --> 0:18:29.760
<v Speaker 1>man-made global warming cost us anything like the government's insane

0:18:30.160 --> 0:18:31.879
<v Speaker 1>global warming policies?

0:18:33.900 --> 0:18:36.200
<v Speaker 8>And I'm glad you played the whole clip of Albo

0:18:36.220 --> 0:18:37.760
<v Speaker 8>because it's a cure for your insomnia.

0:18:38.080 --> 0:18:40.010
<v Speaker 2>Cure for insomnia. I mean, it was just drivel, wasn't it?

0:18:40.359 --> 0:18:40.960
<v Speaker 2>Total drivel.

0:18:41.320 --> 0:18:44.840
<v Speaker 8>A fair question from Barnaby Joyce, which is, where's the $ 8.

0:18:43.640 --> 0:18:44.940
<v Speaker 2>7 billion going?

0:18:45.140 --> 0:18:48.240
<v Speaker 8>Why are the 5,500 public servants doing no good on

0:18:48.260 --> 0:18:50.740
<v Speaker 8>climate change? And the Prime Minister just gives a drivel answer.

0:18:51.420 --> 0:18:53.679
<v Speaker 8>This is the level of politics that Albanese wants to celebrate.

0:18:53.940 --> 0:18:55.540
<v Speaker 8>And this is the problem we've got with the parliament

0:18:55.830 --> 0:18:57.120
<v Speaker 8>and politics in our country right now.

0:18:58.810 --> 0:19:02.330
<v Speaker 1>And, Michael, isn't it... I would suggest that One Nation...

0:19:02.640 --> 0:19:06.909
<v Speaker 1>now starts asking every single opportunity for Chris Bowen and

0:19:06.930 --> 0:19:10.369
<v Speaker 1>the Prime Minister, for all these billions that you are

0:19:10.430 --> 0:19:14.570
<v Speaker 1>spending on climate change programs, by how much will the

0:19:14.630 --> 0:19:18.030
<v Speaker 1>temperature be lowered? By how much? I used to ask it.

0:19:18.050 --> 0:19:20.990
<v Speaker 1>It got known as the Bolt question. It got asked

0:19:21.050 --> 0:19:23.360
<v Speaker 1>of just about every Prime Minister for a while. People

0:19:23.380 --> 0:19:25.140
<v Speaker 1>have stopped asking. They should do it again.

0:19:26.480 --> 0:19:29.679
<v Speaker 9>Well, not just One Nation. Obviously, the Coalition should be doing.

0:19:29.420 --> 0:19:30.340
<v Speaker 1>That, Andrew.

0:19:30.400 --> 0:19:33.030
<v Speaker 9>I mean, I think that that's... Really the key question.

0:19:33.530 --> 0:19:35.369
<v Speaker 9>We all know the answer to that. I think the

0:19:35.390 --> 0:19:38.640
<v Speaker 9>chief scientist, and you've played it on your own program many,

0:19:38.680 --> 0:19:41.460
<v Speaker 9>many times, said it wouldn't do anything. But the thing

0:19:41.480 --> 0:19:44.879
<v Speaker 9>that annoys me about that is if you're serious about it, Albo,

0:19:44.940 --> 0:19:50.920
<v Speaker 9>where's the nuclear reactors? Everybody knows that's the key solution. And,

0:19:50.960 --> 0:19:53.040
<v Speaker 9>you know, if you're serious about it and you believe

0:19:53.080 --> 0:19:56.180
<v Speaker 9>in the science, I want to see a nuclear reactor

0:19:56.220 --> 0:19:58.660
<v Speaker 9>announced by this government. It's not going to happen because

0:19:58.720 --> 0:19:59.720
<v Speaker 9>it's about the Greens.

0:20:00.900 --> 0:20:03.910
<v Speaker 1>No, so true. Michael Costa, Cameron Milner, thank you very

0:20:03.950 --> 0:20:08.129
<v Speaker 1>much to you both. After the break, this morning we

0:20:08.150 --> 0:20:12.150
<v Speaker 1>were told that Benjamin Netanyahu looked finished in Israel's election.

0:20:12.690 --> 0:20:16.470
<v Speaker 1>But this evening, the news is, well, not so fast.

0:20:20.230 --> 0:20:22.320
<v Speaker 1>More than half the votes in Israel's election have now

0:20:22.359 --> 0:20:26.720
<v Speaker 1>been counted. And forget the early reports that Benjamin Netanyahu's finished.

0:20:28.020 --> 0:20:31.220
<v Speaker 1>He's the great survivor. The man hated by the left

0:20:31.260 --> 0:20:35.020
<v Speaker 1>around the world could actually be Prime Minister yet again.

0:20:35.080 --> 0:20:39.410
<v Speaker 1>In fact... It's looking a little healthy. Projections from actual

0:20:39.450 --> 0:20:44.030
<v Speaker 1>votes so far show that Netanyahu's right-wing Likud party is

0:20:44.050 --> 0:20:46.510
<v Speaker 1>tipped to win as many as 56 seats in the

0:20:46.550 --> 0:20:52.409
<v Speaker 1>parliament or Knesset, a Knesset of 120 seats, while his challenger,

0:20:52.630 --> 0:20:55.290
<v Speaker 1>Gadi Eizenkot, the former chief of staff of the Israeli

0:20:55.310 --> 0:20:59.990
<v Speaker 1>Defence Force, is 149. This is just an introduction.

0:21:03.090 --> 0:21:05.370
<v Speaker 12>We are still waiting for the true results. The true

0:21:05.390 --> 0:21:08.109
<v Speaker 12>results which we will receive over the next day or two.

0:21:08.800 --> 0:21:12.280
<v Speaker 12>With God's help, regarding the Likud, two things have become clear.

0:21:12.800 --> 0:21:16.020
<v Speaker 12>The first is unequivocal. The Likud is the largest party

0:21:16.220 --> 0:21:19.800
<v Speaker 12>in Israel. We must form a right-wing, national, strong government.

0:21:20.240 --> 0:21:23.220
<v Speaker 12>That is what must be done. We must not, just not,

0:21:23.560 --> 0:21:26.580
<v Speaker 12>endanger Israel and establish a government that is backed by

0:21:26.800 --> 0:21:35.359
<v Speaker 12>anti-Zionist Arab parties. Israel faces a singular historical opportunity, together

0:21:35.400 --> 0:21:38.619
<v Speaker 12>with our partner President Trump, to remove the existential threat

0:21:38.760 --> 0:21:40.220
<v Speaker 12>of Iran once and for all.

0:21:40.240 --> 0:21:43.900
<v Speaker 1>Now, of course, the key here is which party can

0:21:44.340 --> 0:21:47.040
<v Speaker 1>now form a coalition with minor parties that could take weeks,

0:21:47.160 --> 0:21:51.919
<v Speaker 1>even months, or also and or get the backing of

0:21:51.960 --> 0:21:56.040
<v Speaker 1>the Arab MPs, of whom there will be Some estimates

0:21:56.060 --> 0:22:00.320
<v Speaker 1>say 15, others 19. And these are politicians who don't

0:22:00.380 --> 0:22:11.409
<v Speaker 1>like Netanyahu and his more right-wing ministers. And by the way,

0:22:11.430 --> 0:22:14.150
<v Speaker 1>something for all those haters of Israel on our streets

0:22:14.190 --> 0:22:18.130
<v Speaker 1>to consider. Israel's Muslims, they can vote in free elections.

0:22:18.750 --> 0:22:22.500
<v Speaker 1>Palestine's Muslims, they can't. Joining me from Tel Aviv is

0:22:22.520 --> 0:22:26.330
<v Speaker 1>Ayla Nivi, a podcaster, excellent podcaster, by the way, and

0:22:26.550 --> 0:22:29.990
<v Speaker 1>former spokesman for the Netanyahu government during the first year

0:22:30.369 --> 0:22:32.800
<v Speaker 1>of the Gaza war. Ayla, thank you so much for

0:22:32.840 --> 0:22:38.270
<v Speaker 1>your time. Really appreciate it. Who has won? Nobody has won.

0:22:38.869 --> 0:22:41.010
<v Speaker 13>Look, here's what we know because the votes are still

0:22:41.050 --> 0:22:45.429
<v Speaker 13>being counted. Netanyahu's bloc has lost its majority. It is

0:22:45.590 --> 0:22:49.730
<v Speaker 13>extremely unlikely now that Netanyahu will have that magic number

0:22:49.850 --> 0:22:53.739
<v Speaker 13>of 61 together with the religious and far-right parties to

0:22:53.820 --> 0:22:57.340
<v Speaker 13>form a coalition. But at the same time, the opposition

0:22:57.580 --> 0:23:02.440
<v Speaker 13>bloc doesn't either. The Arabs produced record turnout, brought a

0:23:02.560 --> 0:23:06.320
<v Speaker 13>record result. And that means that the possibility of a

0:23:06.440 --> 0:23:10.820
<v Speaker 13>minority government backed by the Arab parties is no longer

0:23:11.000 --> 0:23:15.889
<v Speaker 13>so realistic. We're looking really at two options. Either there

0:23:16.030 --> 0:23:20.109
<v Speaker 13>is a unity government or Israel goes back to elections.

0:23:20.350 --> 0:23:22.950
<v Speaker 13>We will have to wait and see the full results.

0:23:23.670 --> 0:23:25.369
<v Speaker 13>But that's what it's looking like at the moment.

0:23:26.690 --> 0:23:33.900
<v Speaker 1>So what is the problem with Netanyahu's opponents? Forming government

0:23:34.060 --> 0:23:38.800
<v Speaker 1>with the permission, so to speak, of the Arab MPs,

0:23:38.840 --> 0:23:41.240
<v Speaker 1>they'll say, we're not going to join the government, but

0:23:41.260 --> 0:23:45.030
<v Speaker 1>we won't, we'll never vote against you. We won't have a,

0:23:46.510 --> 0:23:49.650
<v Speaker 1>let you lose a no confidence motion. Why can't that

0:23:49.730 --> 0:23:51.730
<v Speaker 1>be a credible way to keep going?

0:23:53.130 --> 0:23:56.159
<v Speaker 13>There has never been a minority government formed in Israel

0:23:56.280 --> 0:23:59.060
<v Speaker 13>after an election. Governments have lost their majorities, never a

0:23:59.100 --> 0:24:02.520
<v Speaker 13>minority government formed from the get-go. And if this happens,

0:24:02.560 --> 0:24:05.820
<v Speaker 13>it would be extremely unpopular because the Arab parties are

0:24:05.900 --> 0:24:10.020
<v Speaker 13>not considered by most parties to be natural partners for government.

0:24:10.080 --> 0:24:12.700
<v Speaker 13>I don't think most Australians would want a government formed

0:24:12.740 --> 0:24:16.720
<v Speaker 13>with an Islamist party or an Arab Communist party of Australia.

0:24:17.100 --> 0:24:21.869
<v Speaker 13>The fact is, despite Rahm making really serious steps towards

0:24:21.970 --> 0:24:25.510
<v Speaker 13>the Jewish parties to accommodate them. They still won't say

0:24:25.609 --> 0:24:29.560
<v Speaker 13>explicitly that Hamas is a terrorist organization. And the Joint

0:24:29.600 --> 0:24:32.220
<v Speaker 13>List is a communist party. One of their candidates said

0:24:32.240 --> 0:24:35.060
<v Speaker 13>they dedicate their victory to the people of Gaza and

0:24:35.160 --> 0:24:38.639
<v Speaker 13>occupied Jerusalem. So within the opposition bloc, there is a

0:24:38.700 --> 0:24:41.760
<v Speaker 13>fear that if they tried to form a minority government

0:24:42.100 --> 0:24:46.270
<v Speaker 13>backed by these parties from the outside, It would be unstable.

0:24:46.330 --> 0:24:48.659
<v Speaker 13>We would go back to elections. And in those elections,

0:24:48.740 --> 0:24:54.580
<v Speaker 13>Netanyahu would win a landslide. So it's mathematically possible. Much

0:24:54.640 --> 0:24:57.820
<v Speaker 13>more likely at the moment is that Netanyahu forms a

0:24:58.000 --> 0:25:01.240
<v Speaker 13>unity government of sorts. Someone breaks their promise not to

0:25:01.359 --> 0:25:04.890
<v Speaker 13>sit with him. Let's see how possible conflict with Iran

0:25:04.910 --> 0:25:07.830
<v Speaker 13>in the next few weeks can shape those coalition dynamics.

0:25:08.460 --> 0:25:12.040
<v Speaker 13>Or if everyone hunkers down in their positions, Israel could

0:25:12.100 --> 0:25:15.060
<v Speaker 13>get dragged back into fresh elections with Netanyahu as a

0:25:15.080 --> 0:25:16.119
<v Speaker 13>caretaker prime minister.

0:25:17.430 --> 0:25:19.230
<v Speaker 1>Now, Elon, I want to get to the mainstream issues

0:25:19.270 --> 0:25:22.010
<v Speaker 1>with you in a sec that were decisive in this election,

0:25:22.310 --> 0:25:26.570
<v Speaker 1>in your opinion. But I just want to tease out

0:25:26.630 --> 0:25:29.880
<v Speaker 1>that bit about... So here we had a massive turnout,

0:25:30.080 --> 0:25:36.860
<v Speaker 1>unusually big turnout, of Muslim voters, some Hamas-praising, some communists, etc.,

0:25:37.850 --> 0:25:42.139
<v Speaker 1>There's a high birth rate among Muslim Israelis. There's a

0:25:42.150 --> 0:25:45.320
<v Speaker 1>lot of Muslims, of course, demanding, you know, we want

0:25:45.340 --> 0:25:50.500
<v Speaker 1>a one-state solution, all that. What would that tell Israelis

0:25:50.600 --> 0:25:55.220
<v Speaker 1>when you could have such a block of quite important

0:25:55.260 --> 0:25:59.040
<v Speaker 1>votes in the Knesset by Muslim voters? What does it

0:25:59.060 --> 0:26:04.760
<v Speaker 1>tell them about things like immigration and one-state solutions and

0:26:04.940 --> 0:26:05.520
<v Speaker 1>birth rates?

0:26:07.330 --> 0:26:11.170
<v Speaker 13>Israel is changing demographically. When you look at children going

0:26:11.210 --> 0:26:15.600
<v Speaker 13>into first grade, half of them are either Arab or ultra-Orthodox.

0:26:16.160 --> 0:26:19.459
<v Speaker 13>Both population groups that don't serve in the army and

0:26:19.480 --> 0:26:23.879
<v Speaker 13>are definitely underrepresented in the workforce and the country's tax base.

0:26:24.220 --> 0:26:28.080
<v Speaker 13>These are demographic changes that will change Israel and force

0:26:28.119 --> 0:26:30.679
<v Speaker 13>it to make some very serious changes in how the

0:26:30.720 --> 0:26:34.250
<v Speaker 13>country is constructed. And it's going to change Israeli politics.

0:26:34.530 --> 0:26:38.290
<v Speaker 13>It will either require a way for parties to work

0:26:38.330 --> 0:26:41.129
<v Speaker 13>together with the Arab parties and bring them into the mainstream.

0:26:41.890 --> 0:26:45.470
<v Speaker 13>When you have 17, 18 seats and a 120 seat Knesset,

0:26:45.760 --> 0:26:49.500
<v Speaker 13>you can no longer ignore that. Or for the left

0:26:49.560 --> 0:26:51.420
<v Speaker 13>and right or what's left of the left across the

0:26:51.740 --> 0:26:54.800
<v Speaker 13>opposition in government to reach across and realize they have

0:26:54.900 --> 0:26:58.100
<v Speaker 13>much more in common as parties that want to bring

0:26:58.420 --> 0:27:02.740
<v Speaker 13>and build a safe, strong, secure Jewish homeland than the

0:27:02.810 --> 0:27:05.670
<v Speaker 13>left does with Arab parties and the right does with

0:27:05.950 --> 0:27:09.070
<v Speaker 13>ultra-Orthodox parties that campaigned on a promise to get out

0:27:09.130 --> 0:27:12.649
<v Speaker 13>of military service. So Israel's demographics are changing and that

0:27:12.690 --> 0:27:14.590
<v Speaker 13>is already having an impact on the elections.

0:27:16.280 --> 0:27:19.480
<v Speaker 1>Looks very well explained. And I think, you know, the

0:27:19.520 --> 0:27:23.240
<v Speaker 1>danger is when people say bring the Muslims into, you know,

0:27:23.359 --> 0:27:28.040
<v Speaker 1>a particular grouping of Jewish parties or Israeli parties, it

0:27:28.060 --> 0:27:29.840
<v Speaker 1>could actually go the other way. There will be people

0:27:29.880 --> 0:27:32.850
<v Speaker 1>who will feel they can exploit, go the other way.

0:27:32.900 --> 0:27:37.730
<v Speaker 1>The mainstream goes to the extreme, which is a little

0:27:37.750 --> 0:27:40.030
<v Speaker 1>bit what we've seen with our Labour Party. Now, what

0:27:40.090 --> 0:27:41.550
<v Speaker 1>were the decisive issues here?

0:27:43.570 --> 0:27:47.340
<v Speaker 13>Netanyahu made this about who is the right person to

0:27:47.480 --> 0:27:50.600
<v Speaker 13>finish the job. Israel is not out of the danger

0:27:50.619 --> 0:27:53.220
<v Speaker 13>zone yet in the longest war in its history. the

0:27:53.300 --> 0:27:56.760
<v Speaker 13>Iranian regime is still racing ahead with its ballistic missile

0:27:56.820 --> 0:27:59.660
<v Speaker 13>and nuclear weapons program. And Trump is, Netanyahu is saying,

0:28:00.000 --> 0:28:02.270
<v Speaker 13>I'm the only person who can take advantage of the

0:28:02.310 --> 0:28:04.910
<v Speaker 13>last two years of the Trump administration to finish the job.

0:28:05.170 --> 0:28:07.710
<v Speaker 13>He even posted an AI picture of a nuclear bomb

0:28:07.790 --> 0:28:10.850
<v Speaker 13>exploding in Tel Aviv saying, if you don't vote for me,

0:28:10.910 --> 0:28:13.900
<v Speaker 13>you're all going to die in a nuclear Holocaust. So

0:28:13.920 --> 0:28:20.020
<v Speaker 13>he's saying, the opposition would not have the courage of

0:28:20.060 --> 0:28:23.680
<v Speaker 13>their convictions to plow ahead, finish off Hamas, finish Hezbollah,

0:28:23.760 --> 0:28:26.640
<v Speaker 13>finish off the Iranian regime. Only I can do that.

0:28:27.020 --> 0:28:30.409
<v Speaker 13>The opposition, meanwhile, tried to make this about October 7th,

0:28:30.440 --> 0:28:33.600
<v Speaker 13>which happened on Netanyahu's watch. He's blocking a state commission

0:28:33.619 --> 0:28:36.020
<v Speaker 13>of inquiry. And about the question of who is meant

0:28:36.060 --> 0:28:40.010
<v Speaker 13>to fight this war, because Netanyahu's Main partners are the

0:28:40.110 --> 0:28:43.930
<v Speaker 13>ultra-Orthodox parties that are insisting on an exemption from military

0:28:43.990 --> 0:28:47.890
<v Speaker 13>service for tens of thousands of perfectly healthy young men

0:28:48.050 --> 0:28:50.790
<v Speaker 13>for religious reasons, while you have a whole generation of

0:28:50.870 --> 0:28:53.850
<v Speaker 13>men in their 30s who've done 600, 700 days of

0:28:53.910 --> 0:28:56.610
<v Speaker 13>reserve duty. They've been press ganged back into the army.

0:28:56.890 --> 0:29:01.090
<v Speaker 13>So the opposition tried to make this about equality in

0:29:01.110 --> 0:29:05.870
<v Speaker 13>the burden, in the duties of citizenship. as well, but

0:29:05.970 --> 0:29:09.270
<v Speaker 13>Netanyahu managed to cannibalise a lot within his own bloc,

0:29:09.330 --> 0:29:11.950
<v Speaker 13>and the Likud, by all accounts, will be the largest party.

0:29:13.670 --> 0:29:15.750
<v Speaker 1>Elon Levy, always great to talk to you. Thank you

0:29:15.790 --> 0:29:19.670
<v Speaker 1>so much for that. After the break, you thought we

0:29:19.710 --> 0:29:22.710
<v Speaker 1>said no to being divided by race in the Albanese

0:29:22.730 --> 0:29:27.430
<v Speaker 1>government's referendum on The Voice, and yet it's actually growing.

0:29:27.750 --> 0:29:29.880
<v Speaker 1>It's being imposed on you, and a new book today

0:29:29.990 --> 0:29:36.550
<v Speaker 1>blows the whistle. Few Australians realise how far the drive

0:29:36.610 --> 0:29:40.320
<v Speaker 1>to apartheid in this country has already gone. For instance,

0:29:40.360 --> 0:29:44.460
<v Speaker 1>Victoria has an Aboriginal-only kind of parliament. The First Peoples Assembly,

0:29:44.520 --> 0:29:48.540
<v Speaker 1>South Australia has one too. Most states have Aboriginal-only courts.

0:29:48.660 --> 0:29:52.890
<v Speaker 1>There are also race-based jobs in universities, government and even

0:29:52.930 --> 0:29:56.610
<v Speaker 1>football codes. And of course, there's government race-based benefits and

0:29:56.650 --> 0:30:00.670
<v Speaker 1>even cheap race-based tickets to a number of top arts events.

0:30:01.270 --> 0:30:04.210
<v Speaker 1>We're even being walled off from each other. And I mean,

0:30:04.230 --> 0:30:08.170
<v Speaker 1>you know, literally, you've got hospitals in Melbourne and Canberra.

0:30:08.190 --> 0:30:13.300
<v Speaker 1>They've got Aboriginal waiting rooms. You've got universities with Aboriginal-only

0:30:13.420 --> 0:30:17.420
<v Speaker 1>study areas. Our top football codes even pick teams based

0:30:17.520 --> 0:30:20.600
<v Speaker 1>on race. like the Indigenous All-Stars, as if that's a

0:30:20.640 --> 0:30:24.500
<v Speaker 1>great idea, pitching races against each other. Well, today, a

0:30:25.400 --> 0:30:29.490
<v Speaker 1>former federal Labor minister, Gary Johns, now chairman of Close

0:30:29.530 --> 0:30:33.390
<v Speaker 1>the Gap Research, has launched a book saying this is

0:30:33.710 --> 0:30:37.040
<v Speaker 1>a dead end. The book is called Australian Apartheid, the

0:30:37.120 --> 0:30:40.020
<v Speaker 1>Aboriginalisation of a Nation, and I spoke to him a

0:30:40.340 --> 0:30:43.740
<v Speaker 1>short while ago. Gary Johns, good to see you again.

0:30:43.760 --> 0:30:44.500
<v Speaker 1>Why this book?

0:30:47.890 --> 0:30:51.270
<v Speaker 14>Well, why this book and why Australian Apartheid, which is

0:30:51.490 --> 0:30:55.580
<v Speaker 14>the title? Because you recall the referendum of The Voice.

0:30:55.760 --> 0:31:02.160
<v Speaker 14>That was an attempt by the elites in this country, government, CEOs, churches, NGOs,

0:31:02.520 --> 0:31:05.820
<v Speaker 14>to divide us by race. I mean, Paul Aydin didn't

0:31:05.880 --> 0:31:09.280
<v Speaker 14>call it race always. They just talk about cultural First Nations.

0:31:09.760 --> 0:31:13.440
<v Speaker 14>But they were dividing Australians on a basis other than

0:31:13.680 --> 0:31:14.900
<v Speaker 14>our common citizenship.

0:31:15.560 --> 0:31:16.960
<v Speaker 1>So we brought together.

0:31:16.960 --> 0:31:21.180
<v Speaker 14>15 to 16 authors to explain the many ways in

0:31:21.240 --> 0:31:26.000
<v Speaker 14>which Australia is being Aboriginalised. So it's called the Aboriginalisation

0:31:26.300 --> 0:31:30.160
<v Speaker 14>of a nation. And I'll give you a nice little example.

0:31:30.200 --> 0:31:34.070
<v Speaker 14>So there are literally tens of thousands of Aboriginal people

0:31:34.110 --> 0:31:38.990
<v Speaker 14>who are hired by public services and semi-government organisations into

0:31:39.090 --> 0:31:43.470
<v Speaker 14>designated positions, i.e. only they can get the job. Now,

0:31:44.010 --> 0:31:46.270
<v Speaker 14>up until that time, the last 10 years or so,

0:31:46.750 --> 0:31:50.120
<v Speaker 14>Anyone who got a call from an Aboriginal person who

0:31:50.160 --> 0:31:52.840
<v Speaker 14>was a client would look after them, talk to the

0:31:52.880 --> 0:31:53.660
<v Speaker 14>Aboriginal person.

0:31:53.740 --> 0:31:54.680
<v Speaker 1>Now you know what happens?

0:31:55.320 --> 0:31:59.680
<v Speaker 14>That Aboriginal client gets sent over to the Aboriginal designated person.

0:32:00.140 --> 0:32:02.610
<v Speaker 1>We're dividing. We're not talking to each other anymore.

0:32:02.660 --> 0:32:06.610
<v Speaker 14>So it's just a good, common, recent example of this

0:32:06.950 --> 0:32:08.090
<v Speaker 14>Australian apartheid.

0:32:08.710 --> 0:32:12.090
<v Speaker 1>Yeah, I just think the referendum on The Voice was

0:32:12.470 --> 0:32:16.220
<v Speaker 1>an attempt by government to forwarders, fast forwarders on a

0:32:16.260 --> 0:32:19.040
<v Speaker 1>road that bit by bit were on already because of

0:32:19.120 --> 0:32:23.440
<v Speaker 1>all the things that I mentioned before. Why has the

0:32:23.480 --> 0:32:28.040
<v Speaker 1>government gone along with what really is segregation or even

0:32:28.120 --> 0:32:33.440
<v Speaker 1>apartheid when it's what many activists of the left, you know,

0:32:33.460 --> 0:32:36.800
<v Speaker 1>the kind of people that went to the public service

0:32:36.860 --> 0:32:41.340
<v Speaker 1>jobs or left-wing politics, your Labor Party, they actually condemned

0:32:41.420 --> 0:32:46.720
<v Speaker 1>it when it was in South Africa years ago. Yeah,

0:32:46.760 --> 0:32:49.640
<v Speaker 1>you're right. I mean, there's a massive inconsistency.

0:32:49.760 --> 0:32:53.480
<v Speaker 14>For instance, if you're a good leftist, many years ago

0:32:53.510 --> 0:32:56.770
<v Speaker 14>you would have said, let's ensure that Aboriginal people join

0:32:56.790 --> 0:32:59.810
<v Speaker 14>the workforce. You know, they can have solidarity with workers.

0:33:00.050 --> 0:33:01.930
<v Speaker 14>They can be the proletariat, if you like. So it

0:33:01.950 --> 0:33:05.470
<v Speaker 14>was a good left-wing thing. But they stopped talking about workers,

0:33:05.510 --> 0:33:08.080
<v Speaker 14>of course, in the labour movement 20, 30 years ago,

0:33:08.100 --> 0:33:11.160
<v Speaker 14>and they caught this new thing called identity.

0:33:11.760 --> 0:33:12.320
<v Speaker 1>So it was the.

0:33:12.300 --> 0:33:16.100
<v Speaker 14>Fact that you were different racially or culturally and that

0:33:16.130 --> 0:33:19.160
<v Speaker 14>brought you to the top of the oppressed groups. And

0:33:19.220 --> 0:33:21.940
<v Speaker 14>that became the obsession. And little by little, all of

0:33:21.980 --> 0:33:25.740
<v Speaker 14>those university educated Aboriginal people thought, well, this is a

0:33:25.760 --> 0:33:28.500
<v Speaker 14>good little earner. We will get a job berating the

0:33:28.560 --> 0:33:32.060
<v Speaker 14>rest of the country for the poor lives of the

0:33:32.460 --> 0:33:36.680
<v Speaker 14>relatively minor minority of Aboriginal people who are not doing well.

0:33:37.780 --> 0:33:41.400
<v Speaker 1>Well, of course, other Aborigines or Aboriginal Australians that have

0:33:41.460 --> 0:33:44.370
<v Speaker 1>assimilated well got good jobs. They don't take part in

0:33:44.390 --> 0:33:47.510
<v Speaker 1>any of that nonsense. And I've got to say, the

0:33:47.570 --> 0:33:51.430
<v Speaker 1>honeypot of Aboriginal-only jobs has attracted a lot of people

0:33:51.470 --> 0:33:53.990
<v Speaker 1>who are white claiming to be Aborigines too, which a

0:33:54.030 --> 0:33:57.830
<v Speaker 1>lot of activists are now complaining about, Aboriginal activists. What

0:33:57.870 --> 0:34:01.060
<v Speaker 1>does any of this, though, all these race games, all

0:34:01.100 --> 0:34:10.920
<v Speaker 1>this separatism, the race courts, the racial-based Aboriginal... parliaments, all that,

0:34:10.980 --> 0:34:13.660
<v Speaker 1>what has any of it got to do with stopping

0:34:13.700 --> 0:34:17.220
<v Speaker 1>the abuse of Aboriginal children that we are now seeing

0:34:17.640 --> 0:34:22.480
<v Speaker 1>tragically right now in so many Aboriginal settlements and all

0:34:22.500 --> 0:34:26.370
<v Speaker 1>the poverty and the domestic violence? To me, it looks

0:34:26.410 --> 0:34:32.030
<v Speaker 1>like displaced effort. Absolutely right.

0:34:32.550 --> 0:34:35.969
<v Speaker 14>Look, these communities, mainly the remote communities, is where the

0:34:36.010 --> 0:34:38.290
<v Speaker 14>mayhem occurs and They're not communities.

0:34:38.330 --> 0:34:39.290
<v Speaker 1>They are settlements.

0:34:39.370 --> 0:34:42.890
<v Speaker 14>They're the last place where, if you like, the church

0:34:42.930 --> 0:34:46.750
<v Speaker 14>has stopped or World War Two aircraft hangar or whatever.

0:34:47.150 --> 0:34:50.450
<v Speaker 14>That's where people settled. But we've been unable to make

0:34:50.489 --> 0:34:54.410
<v Speaker 14>them into communities. And that's blindly obvious because of the mayhem,

0:34:54.450 --> 0:34:56.680
<v Speaker 14>the abuse of children and so on. Look, this is

0:34:56.780 --> 0:35:01.379
<v Speaker 14>our Dunkirk moment. We have to think about how we

0:35:01.400 --> 0:35:03.540
<v Speaker 14>bring children away from those settlements.

0:35:04.020 --> 0:35:07.860
<v Speaker 1>I don't mean all at once. I mean in this sense.

0:35:07.760 --> 0:35:12.819
<v Speaker 14>Of lots of small means by which we have conversations

0:35:12.880 --> 0:35:16.580
<v Speaker 14>with families to say, your children will be better off elsewhere.

0:35:16.600 --> 0:35:17.910
<v Speaker 14>They must go to school.

0:35:18.610 --> 0:35:21.850
<v Speaker 1>Gary, we've gone through so many Dunkirk moments. I hate

0:35:21.870 --> 0:35:26.390
<v Speaker 1>to think, I remember talking to John Howard, I think

0:35:26.430 --> 0:35:29.310
<v Speaker 1>it was relatively early on, when he was boasting about

0:35:29.670 --> 0:35:32.719
<v Speaker 1>what this aid package they had given to WADAIR in

0:35:32.739 --> 0:35:36.259
<v Speaker 1>the Northern Territory. He said, Prime Minister, you could gold...

0:35:36.730 --> 0:35:39.469
<v Speaker 1>plate the taps and it won't make a difference. It's

0:35:39.550 --> 0:35:42.959
<v Speaker 1>not about that. And indeed, what remains a basket case

0:35:43.300 --> 0:35:47.360
<v Speaker 1>to this day. What is the alternative to this dead

0:35:47.480 --> 0:35:54.770
<v Speaker 1>end of, you know, valorising Aboriginal culture, promoting separatism, all

0:35:54.810 --> 0:35:57.270
<v Speaker 1>that kind of stuff? What is the alternative? Why would

0:35:57.350 --> 0:35:58.710
<v Speaker 1>the alternative be better?

0:36:01.320 --> 0:36:04.529
<v Speaker 14>The alternative is the path chosen by about 80% of

0:36:04.590 --> 0:36:07.810
<v Speaker 14>Aboriginal people who've come in. I come in, I mean,

0:36:07.850 --> 0:36:11.070
<v Speaker 14>they might physically come into the cities or the regions, whatever,

0:36:11.110 --> 0:36:14.680
<v Speaker 14>but mentally they do. They are prepared and able to

0:36:15.120 --> 0:36:16.880
<v Speaker 14>operate in the modern world and.

0:36:16.780 --> 0:36:17.620
<v Speaker 1>To produce value.

0:36:17.980 --> 0:36:22.320
<v Speaker 14>So we have to normalise the fact, make it common,

0:36:22.960 --> 0:36:27.970
<v Speaker 14>that children from remote communities will find life and work

0:36:28.650 --> 0:36:32.510
<v Speaker 14>and happiness elsewhere. In most cases, there are some communities

0:36:32.560 --> 0:36:35.140
<v Speaker 14>that might actually work. They're not just settlements, but they're

0:36:35.200 --> 0:36:40.100
<v Speaker 14>very rare. We need, we fortunately have a large institutional

0:36:40.140 --> 0:36:45.410
<v Speaker 14>base in schools. There are all sorts of groups now

0:36:45.510 --> 0:36:48.950
<v Speaker 14>who'll take children to their schools or into their homes

0:36:49.640 --> 0:36:53.549
<v Speaker 14>and Work with these kids for years, which you'll have

0:36:53.590 --> 0:36:56.770
<v Speaker 14>to do, in order to get them through school. There'll

0:36:56.810 --> 0:36:59.150
<v Speaker 14>be a lot of failure there, but at the moment

0:36:59.230 --> 0:37:00.190
<v Speaker 14>it's all failure.

0:37:00.530 --> 0:37:04.740
<v Speaker 1>That's why I'm so angry with the stolen generation, so-called

0:37:04.780 --> 0:37:08.040
<v Speaker 1>stolen generation story, or myth as I've called it, in

0:37:08.060 --> 0:37:12.440
<v Speaker 1>that it has terrified people out of integrating kids into

0:37:12.780 --> 0:37:19.680
<v Speaker 1>mainstream societies that portrayed Australia falsely as irredeemably racist, child-stealing, genocidal.

0:37:21.010 --> 0:37:24.670
<v Speaker 1>when we should, in fact, be encouraging this, as you say,

0:37:24.690 --> 0:37:30.020
<v Speaker 1>this move, mental move to Western norms, Western values, Western societies.

0:37:30.260 --> 0:37:33.380
<v Speaker 1>That's my opinion at any rate. Gary Johns, how do

0:37:33.420 --> 0:37:34.239
<v Speaker 1>we order your book?

0:37:35.300 --> 0:37:38.719
<v Speaker 14>Well, order it through Quadrant. Go online with Quadrant. It's

0:37:39.239 --> 0:37:40.000
<v Speaker 14>on sale now.

0:37:40.860 --> 0:37:44.930
<v Speaker 1>Well, congratulations, Gary. I know it's a pretty thankless task

0:37:44.989 --> 0:37:48.109
<v Speaker 1>trying to fight against this, but I think history will

0:37:48.150 --> 0:37:50.610
<v Speaker 1>prove you right. And the only question is counting how

0:37:50.650 --> 0:37:54.470
<v Speaker 1>many poor Aboriginal children have had to suffer for the wait.

0:37:54.810 --> 0:38:00.720
<v Speaker 1>Gary Johns, thank you so much. After the break, one

0:38:00.760 --> 0:38:04.820
<v Speaker 1>of soccer's greatest world stars is in a war with China,

0:38:05.660 --> 0:38:11.879
<v Speaker 1>but his surrender is a huge warning to us. To

0:38:11.920 --> 0:38:15.000
<v Speaker 1>a war between one of the world's greatest sports stars

0:38:15.160 --> 0:38:19.200
<v Speaker 1>and China's dictatorship. And the result is a warning of

0:38:19.280 --> 0:38:22.420
<v Speaker 1>how easily the West can surrender its freedoms. French soccer

0:38:22.440 --> 0:38:27.260
<v Speaker 1>superstar Kylian Mbappe is known as a dictator in his teams,

0:38:27.540 --> 0:38:29.980
<v Speaker 1>the French national one and his Real Madrid one in

0:38:30.020 --> 0:38:34.320
<v Speaker 1>Spain's La Liga. And there are jokes, joke memes picturing

0:38:34.360 --> 0:38:36.799
<v Speaker 1>him as a dictator. Back in April, he was asked

0:38:37.120 --> 0:38:39.460
<v Speaker 1>which of them he liked best. And he said, oh,

0:38:39.960 --> 0:38:44.460
<v Speaker 1>it's one of a video of me, of a guy

0:38:44.540 --> 0:38:49.940
<v Speaker 1>I think is a Chinese dictator. which seems, of course,

0:38:50.040 --> 0:38:52.700
<v Speaker 1>to be a reference to China's Mao Zedong, who was

0:38:52.719 --> 0:38:56.140
<v Speaker 1>the deadliest dictator of last century, a tyrant who killed

0:38:56.200 --> 0:39:01.800
<v Speaker 1>and starved tens of millions of Chinese people. China's communist

0:39:01.900 --> 0:39:05.120
<v Speaker 1>regime has only now got to hear of this and

0:39:05.180 --> 0:39:10.540
<v Speaker 1>has gone nuts. This week, broadcast in China for La

0:39:10.580 --> 0:39:14.060
<v Speaker 1>Liga games, Mbappe was dropped by Chinese companies and signed

0:39:14.080 --> 0:39:17.550
<v Speaker 1>him up to sell stuff, and now Mbappe is apologising

0:39:17.570 --> 0:39:20.150
<v Speaker 1>for telling the truth, and so are companies and soccer

0:39:20.170 --> 0:39:24.250
<v Speaker 1>administrators associated with him. Mbappe said, my comment was ill-judged,

0:39:24.530 --> 0:39:27.630
<v Speaker 1>and I now understand that it hurt many people in China, i.e.

0:39:27.690 --> 0:39:21.049
<v Speaker 1>the dictator there, and in Chinese communities, And what's so

0:39:21.070 --> 0:39:23.370
<v Speaker 1>telling in this is that China's dictatorship is so scared

0:39:23.390 --> 0:39:23.560
<v Speaker 1>of the.

0:39:37.110 --> 0:39:40.790
<v Speaker 1>Just the word dictator being spoken in China that its

0:39:40.810 --> 0:39:45.090
<v Speaker 1>state media refuses to use it even in reporting on Mbappe.

0:39:45.450 --> 0:39:48.870
<v Speaker 1>For instance, its Global Times paper said French football star

0:39:48.890 --> 0:39:52.320
<v Speaker 1>Kylian Mbappe has recently sparked a fierce backlash in China

0:39:52.580 --> 0:39:56.880
<v Speaker 1>after making extremely inappropriate remarks in a recent interview. Remarks

0:39:56.940 --> 0:40:00.270
<v Speaker 1>are never explained. It says, what did he say? Many

0:40:00.310 --> 0:40:03.390
<v Speaker 1>Chinese would rather not repeat it. No, you don't want

0:40:03.410 --> 0:40:06.259
<v Speaker 1>to be shot. And China's biggest social media site even

0:40:06.320 --> 0:40:09.379
<v Speaker 1>blurs out the word dictator from posts about all this.

0:40:10.330 --> 0:40:13.730
<v Speaker 1>Joining me are Caroline de Russo, commentator and president of

0:40:13.750 --> 0:40:18.430
<v Speaker 1>the West Australian Liberals, and Gemma Tonini, columnist and communications consultant,

0:40:18.870 --> 0:40:23.870
<v Speaker 1>now moonlighting over in Lombardy, one of the only areas

0:40:23.950 --> 0:40:27.029
<v Speaker 1>in Italy actually named after a German tribe, but having

0:40:27.090 --> 0:40:33.290
<v Speaker 1>a ball, I presume. Gemma, Mbappe apologising, La Liga crawling,

0:40:33.350 --> 0:40:36.030
<v Speaker 1>Chinese media too scared to even report the word dictator.

0:40:36.380 --> 0:40:37.700
<v Speaker 1>What does all this tell you?

0:40:39.180 --> 0:40:41.180
<v Speaker 3>It just tells us that everybody's a little bit weak

0:40:41.200 --> 0:40:44.310
<v Speaker 3>and maybe that there are commercial things at play. I mean,

0:40:44.670 --> 0:40:47.230
<v Speaker 3>let's not pretend that history is history. I mean, Mao

0:40:47.250 --> 0:40:50.110
<v Speaker 3>Zedong was a terrible dictator. Millions upon millions upon millions

0:40:50.150 --> 0:40:53.989
<v Speaker 3>of people were murdered. And if the Chinese government want

0:40:54.010 --> 0:40:55.529
<v Speaker 3>to jump up and down and say it's not true,

0:40:55.570 --> 0:40:57.549
<v Speaker 3>they can do that all the time, any time they want.

0:40:57.590 --> 0:40:59.220
<v Speaker 2>It doesn't mean that they are correct.

0:40:59.340 --> 0:41:02.620
<v Speaker 3>I can say that I've won five Wimbledons, Andrew, and

0:41:02.660 --> 0:41:04.640
<v Speaker 3>I have, you know, I was chucked out of year

0:41:04.700 --> 0:41:07.319
<v Speaker 3>five tennis camp just because I say something doesn't mean

0:41:07.360 --> 0:41:11.529
<v Speaker 3>it's true and I think sporting leaders, because he is

0:41:11.570 --> 0:41:14.060
<v Speaker 3>a leader, love to have an opinion, but when it's tested,

0:41:14.140 --> 0:41:16.100
<v Speaker 3>very few of them are actually prepared to stand up

0:41:16.160 --> 0:41:18.520
<v Speaker 3>and back their opinion. It's just disappointing, but we shouldn't

0:41:18.540 --> 0:41:20.239
<v Speaker 3>be disappointed because they're just sportsmen.

0:41:21.480 --> 0:41:26.200
<v Speaker 1>Well, for me, Caroline, that last bit that Gemma mentioned

0:41:26.239 --> 0:41:30.790
<v Speaker 1>there is the key thing. China can threaten and bully us, absolutely,

0:41:31.130 --> 0:41:34.090
<v Speaker 1>but it is powerless unless we're too greedy for Chinese

0:41:34.150 --> 0:41:39.050
<v Speaker 1>dollars or yen. Chinese dollars or Chinese audiences or Chinese

0:41:39.140 --> 0:41:42.350
<v Speaker 1>this and all that and give in, which is what

0:41:42.430 --> 0:41:45.730
<v Speaker 1>Mbappé has done. He'd prefer the money to his freedom

0:41:45.850 --> 0:41:48.270
<v Speaker 1>to speak the truth. That's the bottom line.

0:41:49.910 --> 0:41:50.840
<v Speaker 2>That is the bottom line.

0:41:50.880 --> 0:41:53.960
<v Speaker 15>And before I deal with that in substance, the Lombards

0:41:54.020 --> 0:41:57.320
<v Speaker 15>are basically German. They're not really Italian, so it's perfectly

0:41:57.580 --> 0:42:01.339
<v Speaker 15>acceptable that you refer to it in that way.

0:42:01.980 --> 0:42:03.340
<v Speaker 12>Second of all, in WA.

0:42:05.610 --> 0:42:08.049
<v Speaker 15>I can never help myself. WA, we had our state

0:42:08.090 --> 0:42:10.830
<v Speaker 15>conference on the weekend. I have finished after four years

0:42:10.890 --> 0:42:11.710
<v Speaker 15>as state president.

0:42:12.070 --> 0:42:13.270
<v Speaker 9>I have been paroled.

0:42:13.850 --> 0:42:17.490
<v Speaker 15>I'm still a federal vice president, though, but no longer

0:42:17.510 --> 0:42:21.460
<v Speaker 15>a state president. And then on to the substance of

0:42:21.719 --> 0:42:23.900
<v Speaker 15>your remarks.

0:42:23.920 --> 0:42:25.700
<v Speaker 9>Anything else you need to deal with, Caroline?

0:42:26.480 --> 0:42:27.000
<v Speaker 12>No, no, no.

0:42:27.200 --> 0:42:29.299
<v Speaker 15>They're all the caveats I need before I get to

0:42:29.340 --> 0:42:34.109
<v Speaker 15>the substance of the question. Andrew, you're absolutely right. But

0:42:34.469 --> 0:42:36.989
<v Speaker 15>there's a saying in business that if you only have

0:42:37.090 --> 0:42:41.400
<v Speaker 15>one customer or, you know, you have a biggest customer,

0:42:42.100 --> 0:42:45.520
<v Speaker 15>they own you. And evidently, that is the way that

0:42:45.600 --> 0:42:49.640
<v Speaker 15>certain people feel here and... Like we talk about, you know,

0:42:49.860 --> 0:42:52.790
<v Speaker 15>often about freedom of speech, that there are consequences to

0:42:52.850 --> 0:42:55.489
<v Speaker 15>freedom of speech. And in this case, this is what

0:42:55.550 --> 0:42:58.810
<v Speaker 15>happens when you do business with people who don't share

0:42:58.830 --> 0:43:00.169
<v Speaker 15>the same values as you.

0:43:00.690 --> 0:43:01.569
<v Speaker 2>And it's one thing.

0:43:01.610 --> 0:43:04.029
<v Speaker 15>And we saw it during COVID when we questioned the

0:43:04.150 --> 0:43:07.820
<v Speaker 15>origins of the virus. This happened to trade here in Australia.

0:43:08.420 --> 0:43:11.460
<v Speaker 15>So it is one thing to say these sorts of things.

0:43:11.480 --> 0:43:14.060
<v Speaker 15>There's one thing in other parts of the world to

0:43:14.080 --> 0:43:16.440
<v Speaker 15>get a reaction from the government. You don't normally see

0:43:16.460 --> 0:43:19.400
<v Speaker 15>it from the companies because they are independent of the government.

0:43:19.420 --> 0:43:20.900
<v Speaker 15>That is not the case in China.

0:43:21.340 --> 0:43:22.259
<v Speaker 1>So if this is.

0:43:22.660 --> 0:43:25.300
<v Speaker 15>If you do business with the Chinese, you do heavily

0:43:25.360 --> 0:43:28.299
<v Speaker 15>business with the Chinese, and in this case, I'm.

0:43:28.219 --> 0:43:28.530
<v Speaker 2>Going to be.

0:43:29.239 --> 0:43:32.680
<v Speaker 15>I'm going to be careful here and say the CCP

0:43:32.700 --> 0:43:35.230
<v Speaker 15>because this is where this ultimately comes from.

0:43:35.250 --> 0:43:36.250
<v Speaker 2>Yes.

0:43:36.710 --> 0:43:39.290
<v Speaker 15>There's a muddying of the waters here in this about

0:43:39.350 --> 0:43:42.270
<v Speaker 15>it offending the Chinese people. I think it offends the

0:43:42.290 --> 0:43:45.750
<v Speaker 15>CCP because they haven't managed to get rid of their dictators.

0:43:45.790 --> 0:43:50.089
<v Speaker 15>They're still producing them and it's evidently uncomfortable for them.

0:43:50.150 --> 0:43:52.870
<v Speaker 15>But when you do business with people who don't necessarily

0:43:52.910 --> 0:43:56.160
<v Speaker 15>share the same values as you, don't be surprised when

0:43:56.200 --> 0:43:59.799
<v Speaker 15>they kick up. over something as, frankly, benign as this.

0:43:59.860 --> 0:44:03.140
<v Speaker 1>No, it's so true. Whenever I hear Australian businessmen like

0:44:03.219 --> 0:44:05.759
<v Speaker 1>Andrew Forrest, you know, say, oh, China, you know, it's great,

0:44:05.840 --> 0:44:08.440
<v Speaker 1>it's the future, blah, blah, I always want to know

0:44:09.060 --> 0:44:12.740
<v Speaker 1>how dependent are you on Chinese money for your business?

0:44:13.180 --> 0:44:16.480
<v Speaker 1>And I just discount because you see, you see what

0:44:16.520 --> 0:44:21.210
<v Speaker 1>China does when you actually speak the truth. Gemma, I

0:44:21.270 --> 0:44:25.820
<v Speaker 1>don't know how much you've been following all this stuff

0:44:25.880 --> 0:44:28.739
<v Speaker 1>about the golf club and the money thrown at it

0:44:28.780 --> 0:44:32.690
<v Speaker 1>and all that, and what a scandal. Well, the thing is,

0:44:32.989 --> 0:44:36.790
<v Speaker 1>if that's a scandal, they're all into it, really. They're

0:44:36.870 --> 0:44:40.210
<v Speaker 1>all into it. What about, for instance, Labor and the

0:44:40.250 --> 0:44:44.260
<v Speaker 1>Liberals now in Victoria, the brokest state in this country,

0:44:45.040 --> 0:44:48.460
<v Speaker 1>both throwing huge grants, and I mean huge, at a

0:44:48.520 --> 0:44:51.900
<v Speaker 1>Hindu temple that just happens to be... in a critical

0:44:51.960 --> 0:44:56.070
<v Speaker 1>seat in Craigieburn, Melbourne's north, with lots of Indian voters.

0:44:56.350 --> 0:44:59.930
<v Speaker 1>I showed the other day a Labor minister promising this

0:45:00.030 --> 0:45:03.589
<v Speaker 1>temple half a million dollars, half a million, mind you,

0:45:03.810 --> 0:45:06.380
<v Speaker 1>to get more people through the door. And now, incredibly,

0:45:06.440 --> 0:45:09.100
<v Speaker 1>the Liberals have turned up to the very same temple

0:45:09.340 --> 0:45:15.860
<v Speaker 1>to promise even more, $ 600, 000. Gemma, why are taxpayers funding

0:45:15.920 --> 0:45:18.670
<v Speaker 1>Hindu and Muslim and even Christian places of worship?

0:45:21.600 --> 0:45:24.660
<v Speaker 3>Oh, that's a great question. I think there is some

0:45:24.700 --> 0:45:26.900
<v Speaker 3>nuance to it because I think Christians pay tax. I

0:45:26.960 --> 0:45:29.360
<v Speaker 3>certainly pay more than my fair share. Hindus and Muslims,

0:45:29.400 --> 0:45:31.840
<v Speaker 3>we all pay tax. There has to be a degree,

0:45:31.880 --> 0:45:34.890
<v Speaker 3>and I use that phrase very deliberately, there should be

0:45:35.210 --> 0:45:39.350
<v Speaker 3>a degree of government support for some of these things,

0:45:39.690 --> 0:45:42.489
<v Speaker 3>which is not what we're talking about here. And I

0:45:42.530 --> 0:45:44.489
<v Speaker 3>think you're right to raise it, but if we can

0:45:44.910 --> 0:45:48.089
<v Speaker 3>shimmy back 20 seconds to the Prime Minister and that

0:45:48.170 --> 0:45:52.820
<v Speaker 3>golf club, It's beyond just, oh, well, you know, he

0:45:53.200 --> 0:45:56.319
<v Speaker 3>told a fib in Parliament. It is deeply misleading what

0:45:56.340 --> 0:45:59.440
<v Speaker 3>the Prime Minister has said. You know, other people have

0:45:59.500 --> 0:46:02.360
<v Speaker 3>resigned for lesser. And it's a pattern of behaviour. We

0:46:02.390 --> 0:46:04.890
<v Speaker 3>can joke about the fact that he said, I didn't

0:46:04.910 --> 0:46:07.430
<v Speaker 3>do the melon thing. We can joke about the fact

0:46:07.450 --> 0:46:08.989
<v Speaker 3>that he said, I didn't fall off a stage when

0:46:09.050 --> 0:46:12.390
<v Speaker 3>obviously he fell off a stage. He told Parliament that

0:46:12.410 --> 0:46:15.879
<v Speaker 3>that money was for sewage works. The money was not

0:46:16.020 --> 0:46:19.200
<v Speaker 3>for sewage works. He denied having anything to do with

0:46:19.239 --> 0:46:21.730
<v Speaker 3>that club. We know that he has long had an

0:46:21.790 --> 0:46:25.109
<v Speaker 3>association with that club. This is the Prime Minister of

0:46:25.210 --> 0:46:28.730
<v Speaker 3>this country. Rot starts from the top, and God knows

0:46:28.790 --> 0:46:32.450
<v Speaker 3>how rotten it absolutely is, Andrew. He should resign, in

0:46:32.489 --> 0:46:36.440
<v Speaker 3>my view. He should resign. What he's done is it

0:46:36.540 --> 0:46:39.180
<v Speaker 3>fails the pub test, it fails the honesty test, it

0:46:39.239 --> 0:46:41.660
<v Speaker 3>fails every kind of leadership test. Imagine if you were

0:46:41.680 --> 0:46:44.890
<v Speaker 3>in corporate life. And the consequences, you would lose your job.

0:46:44.930 --> 0:46:48.870
<v Speaker 3>It's absolutely, it's black and white. But maybe, Andrew, we

0:46:48.930 --> 0:46:52.290
<v Speaker 3>are so, I don't know, we are so desensitised, maybe

0:46:52.330 --> 0:46:54.930
<v Speaker 3>we are just so tired of it, maybe our expectations

0:46:54.989 --> 0:46:57.270
<v Speaker 3>are so low because we've had such garbage leadership in

0:46:57.290 --> 0:46:59.630
<v Speaker 3>this country for so long. We've got to wake up.

0:47:00.030 --> 0:47:01.330
<v Speaker 3>We've got to hold them to account.

0:47:02.570 --> 0:47:06.680
<v Speaker 1>But, Caroline, you and Trevor said small things, but I

0:47:06.719 --> 0:47:11.239
<v Speaker 1>think it's the very... fact that he's lied even about

0:47:11.480 --> 0:47:14.239
<v Speaker 1>small things. What would it hurt him to say? Yes,

0:47:14.280 --> 0:47:16.319
<v Speaker 1>I did fall off the stage. I mean, where is

0:47:16.360 --> 0:47:18.700
<v Speaker 1>the political damage there? I fell off the stage. You know,

0:47:18.719 --> 0:47:23.430
<v Speaker 1>make a joke about it. Yes, look, I'm terribly sorry.

0:47:23.469 --> 0:47:25.890
<v Speaker 1>Made a mistake when I said it was just, you know,

0:47:25.910 --> 0:47:28.150
<v Speaker 1>for sewage works. It was just a mistake. And I

0:47:28.170 --> 0:47:31.270
<v Speaker 1>think it was originally just a mistake. Where is the

0:47:31.330 --> 0:47:34.609
<v Speaker 1>political harm? I don't understand it. And that's what makes

0:47:34.630 --> 0:47:38.050
<v Speaker 1>you think, golly, you know, what is it with this guy?

0:47:40.750 --> 0:47:43.370
<v Speaker 15>Well, he doesn't want to apologise for anything, even when

0:47:43.410 --> 0:47:45.649
<v Speaker 15>it's very, very obvious. And the thing is, is that,

0:47:45.850 --> 0:47:48.879
<v Speaker 15>you know, Australians, they have two eyes and two ears

0:47:48.940 --> 0:47:50.940
<v Speaker 15>and they can see and hear and... They know that

0:47:50.960 --> 0:47:52.200
<v Speaker 15>the PM fell off the stage.

0:47:52.219 --> 0:47:53.030
<v Speaker 6>You're absolutely right.

0:47:53.050 --> 0:47:55.850
<v Speaker 15>He should have just made a joke about it and

0:47:55.910 --> 0:47:58.850
<v Speaker 15>moved on and we would not be talking about it.

0:47:59.110 --> 0:48:02.549
<v Speaker 15>But it's very kind of Streisand effect, right? When you

0:48:02.570 --> 0:48:05.850
<v Speaker 15>bring attention to something that, you know, there shouldn't be

0:48:05.910 --> 0:48:09.040
<v Speaker 15>attention to, you end up amplifying it and it ends

0:48:09.160 --> 0:48:12.840
<v Speaker 15>up as a caricature. It takes on this personality of

0:48:12.920 --> 0:48:15.319
<v Speaker 15>its own. Like how often just in passing do we

0:48:15.360 --> 0:48:17.740
<v Speaker 15>talk about Albo saying, who didn't fall off the stage

0:48:17.780 --> 0:48:18.820
<v Speaker 15>and everyone laughs.

0:48:18.890 --> 0:48:20.810
<v Speaker 9>Like, you actually become.

0:48:20.469 --> 0:48:23.989
<v Speaker 15>A political caricature because you did not have the humility

0:48:24.030 --> 0:48:26.610
<v Speaker 15>in the moment to just go, I fell off the stage.

0:48:26.930 --> 0:48:29.840
<v Speaker 15>I've been campaigning for six weeks. I was absolutely exhausted.

0:48:30.219 --> 0:48:32.299
<v Speaker 15>You know, if the least I do is fall off

0:48:32.340 --> 0:48:34.200
<v Speaker 15>the stage, well, then I'm going to call it a win.

0:48:34.540 --> 0:48:35.419
<v Speaker 9>No one would have.

0:48:35.420 --> 0:48:37.160
<v Speaker 15>Ever talked about it again.

0:48:38.100 --> 0:48:38.299
<v Speaker 3>Yeah.

0:48:38.700 --> 0:48:41.299
<v Speaker 1>But that's exactly the point, isn't it? The fact that

0:48:41.320 --> 0:48:44.680
<v Speaker 1>he does it on such low stakes issue. I mean,

0:48:44.700 --> 0:48:46.730
<v Speaker 1>I can imagine, you know, you're not wanting to tell

0:48:46.750 --> 0:48:50.030
<v Speaker 1>the truth, you know, say he burbled out a state

0:48:50.070 --> 0:48:53.390
<v Speaker 1>secret to China. Fine, you know, I can... Well, not

0:48:53.469 --> 0:48:55.069
<v Speaker 1>fine that he did it and not fine that he

0:48:55.110 --> 0:48:57.850
<v Speaker 1>lies about it, but I understand why he'd lie about it.

0:48:58.070 --> 0:49:02.820
<v Speaker 1>The stage or this... Crazy. Caroline de Russo, Gemma Tonnini,

0:49:02.860 --> 0:49:06.080
<v Speaker 1>thank you very much to you both. Up next, Shari Markson.

0:49:06.219 --> 0:49:06.560
<v Speaker 1>Good night.