Speaker 1: On scous Australia. This is the Winner Panalty Show.
Speaker 2: Good evening, ann Welcome to the readA Paney Show. Coming
Speaker 2: up tonight, Anthony Albernizi follows in Joe Biden's footsteps, devoting
Speaker 2: billions of taxpayer funds to student debt forgiveness. Victoria's woke
Speaker 2: policies are being mocked internationally. I guess it was only
Speaker 2: a matter of time. Meanwhile, the Jasinda Allen government is
Speaker 2: refusing to say it will intervene after CFO me you Boss,
Speaker 2: John Sedka threatened the AFL. Gary Hardgrave will tell us
Speaker 2: about the Queensland government's budget black hole, and the always
Speaker 2: droll Army Horowitz will have the latest from the US,
Speaker 2: including the Hunter Biden Saga and David Limbrick on the
Speaker 2: shocking youth crime crisis in Victoria. And of course, your
Speaker 2: favorite segment Left is losing it. Tonight's starring Justin Trudeau
Speaker 2: and a Biden hating dog called Molly.
Speaker 1: I think my dog is a.
Speaker 2: Let's bring in the Deputy Director of the Institute of
Speaker 2: Public Affairs, Daniel Wilde. Dan, we're seeing the alban Easy
Speaker 2: government veering further and further towards leftist idealism with a
Speaker 2: raft of radical policies with the potential to do enormous harm.
Speaker 2: They've abandoned reason, it seems for this ideology. We saw
Speaker 2: it with the Voice, we're seeing it with the NDIS,
Speaker 2: their climate policies, the immigration detention debarcle, and increasingly in
Speaker 2: their response to the Israeli har mass war. And janetal
Speaker 2: Brigson has written a fantastic piece in Today's Australian pointing
Speaker 2: out the labor is being hijacked by activists. She says
Speaker 2: not only is idealism insufficient to secure results on its own,
Speaker 2: it will often hurt those it aims to help. Get
Speaker 2: The alban Easy government is bathing in the staff, submerging
Speaker 2: the rest of us in it too. Domestically idealistic policies,
Speaker 2: untethered from reality and from the lessons of the past
Speaker 2: are everywhere well said there. But how much longer can
Speaker 2: the government afford to listen to these radical activists, especially
Speaker 2: with their increasingly divorced from reality climate targets.
Speaker 3: Well reder.
Speaker 4: This government is clearly more radical than the Whitlam government.
Speaker 4: That's been the case now for a number of months.
Speaker 4: Anthony Abenezi ran as a sort of moderate centrist, sort
Speaker 4: of trying not to reveal his fairly radical past. But
Speaker 4: he's always been on the far left of the Labor Party.
Speaker 4: So those of us who have been watching politics for
Speaker 4: some time knew it was going to be the case
Speaker 4: that this would be a fairly radical government. You've had
Speaker 4: the Voice to Parliament, which was one of the most
Speaker 4: divisive proposals ever put to the Australian people and thankfully
Speaker 4: was rejected by sixty percent of Australians, including forty percent
Speaker 4: of Labor voters. You rightly mention net zero and the
Speaker 4: climate targets. They've got a renewables only, renewables everywhere policy
Speaker 4: and that's why we're seeing prices go up and the
Speaker 4: prospect of blackouts. And then there's the whole social agenda
Speaker 4: and the veering to the far left on the Hamas
Speaker 4: Palestine Israel situation. So look, I think the sheen has
Speaker 4: well and truly come off the Albernezi government as Australians
Speaker 4: learn more about just how divorced it is from the
Speaker 4: interests of concerns and values of mainstream Australia.
Speaker 2: Now, doesn't this sum up Victoria? The unions are running riot.
Speaker 2: Their CFM and you are threatening to impose a work
Speaker 2: slowdown on all AFL related projects unless the AFL sacks
Speaker 2: it's head of umpiring. The Herald Sun reveals that AFL
Speaker 2: employee Stephen McBurnie used to be a building watchdog regulator
Speaker 2: and he initiated a bunch of legal action against this
Speaker 2: CFMEU that's resulted in millions of dollars of penalties against them.
Speaker 2: And now they're essentially Daniel blackmailing the league to sack
Speaker 2: the head of umpiring or have their projects adversely effect there.
Speaker 2: They're holding the Tasmanian Stadium to ransom, threatening work to
Speaker 2: rule campaigns, and they're not shy about doing this. The
Speaker 2: Victorian SFMU boss John Sedka told The Australian this is
Speaker 2: going to cost the AFL a lot of efing money.
Speaker 2: I hope it's worth it. Projects without our full cooperation
Speaker 2: are going to be efing misery for them. They will
Speaker 2: regret the day they ever employed him. They just don't
Speaker 2: walk away from a role like that. This is the
Speaker 2: employee they're talking about. It costs the union millions of
Speaker 2: dollars and just think they can walk away into the
Speaker 2: effing sunset. It doesn't work that way. This is the
Speaker 2: real world. We go after our enemies, and he was
Speaker 2: our number one enemy and we will pursue him until
Speaker 2: the ends of the earth. These are direct quotes from
Speaker 2: John Sedka. Welcome to Victoria. You know who's running the
Speaker 2: show down here.
Speaker 4: Dan, Well, that's right, I've got to say, reader, though,
Speaker 4: it's hard to have sympathy for the AFL. I mean
Speaker 4: they've promoted every single left wing board under the sun,
Speaker 4: whether it's same sex marriage, whether it's the Voice to Parliament,
Speaker 4: whether it's climate change, whether it's Welcome to Country.
Speaker 3: It never ends.
Speaker 4: And the reality is it's not brought them the political
Speaker 4: protection they thought it would. So you know they're the wokeus,
Speaker 4: most visitive sporting code in the nation.
Speaker 3: The Tasmanian Stadium. It was a.
Speaker 4: Political move, not a move for footy fans. It was
Speaker 4: a political move to cozy up to the government in
Speaker 4: order to get money from it. So look, that's how
Speaker 4: the AFL operates. And I think this is really a
Speaker 4: test for the Victorian government, the Victorian state government, who
Speaker 4: clearly needs to intervene here and to set a clear
Speaker 4: demarcation that you can't you know, you just cut whatever
Speaker 4: you feelings are on the AFL. You can't just have
Speaker 4: a union official bullying and essentially holding these major projects
Speaker 4: to ransom.
Speaker 3: But I don't think the AFL have a lot.
Speaker 4: Of sympathy in the community because of what they've done
Speaker 4: to divide Australians over the last five years.
Speaker 2: You are absolutely right. They have been at the head
Speaker 2: of all the sporting bodies when it comes to playing
Speaker 2: political games, these divisive political games, alienating half their fan base,
Speaker 2: and because the league, the sport is so enormously popular,
Speaker 2: they've largely got away with it. Now to a story
Speaker 2: we've been covering for some time when you and I've
Speaker 2: chatted about this, and the Age newspaper is now published
Speaker 2: data backing up precisely what we've been talking about, and
Speaker 2: that's Victoria Labors war on property investors. The Age reveal
Speaker 2: the number of rental properties in Victoria has fallen by
Speaker 2: over ten thousand dad in just three months, and the
Speaker 2: past year nearly sixteen thousand rentals disappeared from the market.
Speaker 2: And it shouldn't be a shock when we look at
Speaker 2: the Labor government's war against mum and dad property investors.
Speaker 2: They've got increased land tax, they've got a bunch of
Speaker 2: unreasonable minimum standards that are being imposed on them, and
Speaker 2: no wonder Mum and Dad investors are putting their hardened elsewhere.
Speaker 2: But Dan, I mean, this is just catastrophic for renters
Speaker 2: because the number of properties available for rental are diminishing
Speaker 2: and of course rents are going up.
Speaker 4: Well that's right, reader, Look you've got two problems here.
Speaker 4: You've got the accelerator has been pushed on demand with
Speaker 4: the mass migration program, which has been completely out of
Speaker 4: for two years now.
Speaker 3: It's been at record levels.
Speaker 4: Our analysis showed that seventy percent of new builds last
Speaker 4: year were taken up by international students alone across Australia,
Speaker 4: not just in Victoria. And then at the same time,
Speaker 4: as you've identified, you've got the brakes being slammed on
Speaker 4: the supply side. We know how's in construction is down
Speaker 4: at nineteen eighties levels, and you've got all of the
Speaker 4: red tape the taxes that exist on constructing new houses
Speaker 4: in Victoria, but you know, just as importantly on those
Speaker 4: who want to invest in new properties.
Speaker 3: So you know, it's just basic supply and demand.
Speaker 4: If you push demand up and you bring supply down,
Speaker 4: you're going to get shortages and you're going.
Speaker 3: To have price rises.
Speaker 4: That's exactly what's happened, and it feeds into the broader
Speaker 4: issue reta, which is that Victoria is Australia's economic basket
Speaker 4: case and this just reinforces that reality.
Speaker 2: Sadly, it's hard to argue against that because our debt
Speaker 2: is out of control and if the state government wasn't
Speaker 2: enough with their war on landlords. So you've got a
Speaker 2: far left council in the north of Melbourne that, let's
Speaker 2: not forget, changed its name for Morland to mary Beck
Speaker 2: because there was once a Jamaican sugar plantation with slaves
Speaker 2: called Morland, so they had to change the name. This
Speaker 2: council is now considering a plan to double the council
Speaker 2: rates for landlords. I guess they really do hate renters
Speaker 2: in mary Beck, Dan, because you're going to make it
Speaker 2: very difficult and expensive for anyone to rent a property
Speaker 2: if you press ahead with this crazy policy.
Speaker 4: Well, that's right, I mean, obviously it's just going to
Speaker 4: make a bad situation worse.
Speaker 3: That's obvious. You know.
Speaker 4: I think you wrote about this council a couple of
Speaker 4: years ago when they were basically saying Australia they should
Speaker 4: be canceled, and they weren't going to celebrate it because
Speaker 4: it's a day of mourning and so forth. So this
Speaker 4: is one of the wokest councils that you'll ever come across.
Speaker 4: And you know they're supposed to be in favor of renters,
Speaker 4: but like you identify, if you put the cost up
Speaker 4: constructing dwellings or of having people invest in property, then
Speaker 4: that's going to flow through. That's what we've seen across
Speaker 4: the state and across Australia. So look, I think it's
Speaker 4: just a matter of time before young people finally wake
Speaker 4: up to the reality that these councils and these left
Speaker 4: wing governments are not acting in the interest of young
Speaker 4: Australians whatsoever.
Speaker 2: Now, last week Nigel Farage had a milkshake thrown on
Speaker 2: him in an assault some in the British media called
Speaker 2: a humbling moment some disgraceful reporting there. But now a
Speaker 2: man has been arrested after Farage was pelted with rocks
Speaker 2: on the campaign trail Let's have a look.
Speaker 5: Now.
Speaker 2: Farrage said that the local police in the Yorkshire village
Speaker 2: of Barnsley warned him not to walk through the town.
Speaker 2: But this is supposed to be Britain. Politicians should be
Speaker 2: able to campaign without the fear of being assaulted.
Speaker 3: Dat Well, that's right.
Speaker 4: I mean it's another example of the victim blaming that
Speaker 4: we've discussed. It's the job of the police to protect
Speaker 4: people who want to safely walk through the community, especially
Speaker 4: politicians when you're leading up to an election.
Speaker 3: It's vital to a democracy.
Speaker 4: I think good on the police, though it looks like
Speaker 4: they apprehended those individuals pretty quickly.
Speaker 3: There.
Speaker 4: Look, there's a broader thing here though, Riata, which is
Speaker 4: Nigel Farage has been one of these single most consequential
Speaker 4: figures in Western politics over the last decade. I mean,
Speaker 4: if it wasn't for Nigel Farage, we wouldn't have had Brexit.
Speaker 4: We've had basically fourteen years of Conservative government in name
Speaker 4: only in the UK. And I think regardless of how
Speaker 4: many seats Reform end up winning, if it's one or five,
Speaker 4: or ten or twenty, I don't know what it will be.
Speaker 4: But Nigel Farage a change debate. You know, he's need
Speaker 4: more attention, more publicity than the Conservatives. He's offering a
Speaker 4: different vision saying, look, you have to reduce migration. You've
Speaker 4: got to fix the culture, You've got to fix the
Speaker 4: broken political system. So look, here's a force like one
Speaker 4: we haven't seen for many years. And I think we
Speaker 4: need more political leaders like Nigel Farage that will make
Speaker 4: a debate, you know, and speak up for people that
Speaker 4: don't have a voice in politics.
Speaker 2: You're absolutely right about the Tories being a conservative in
Speaker 2: name only, and I think they've lost so much trust
Speaker 2: with their voters. They won in a landslide, but they
Speaker 2: governed like there were labor lighte and I think Farage
Speaker 2: is going to change that landscape again. And it's interesting
Speaker 2: we've got the UK about to veer to the hard
Speaker 2: left with a labor landslide at a time where most
Speaker 2: of Europe is going to the right, as we saw
Speaker 2: with the recent EU elections. So it's a fascinating time.
Speaker 6: Now.
Speaker 2: News of the Victorian government appointing a parliamentary section terry
Speaker 2: for Men's behavioral change, how Willian Well. It's been moked
Speaker 2: far and wide, including by one of our faith comics,
Speaker 2: Ryan Long. Let's have a look.
Speaker 7: Australia is officially appointed a Minister of Men's Behavior Change
Speaker 7: and he looks like a pretty cool guy who I
Speaker 7: would imagine is swimming in tons of However, because this
Speaker 7: guy is such a chat, it appears the Australian government
Speaker 7: has forgot to appoint a Minister of Women's Behavior Change,
Speaker 7: and so I will be officially appointing myself, Ryan Long
Speaker 7: to that position. I will be coming to Australia with
Speaker 7: my aggressive proposal to assist Australian ladies and improving their behavior,
Speaker 7: which will include no more saying you weren't hungry and
Speaker 7: then eating off your boyfriend's plate. If you wanted that meal,
Speaker 7: you should have got that meal.
Speaker 8: This isn't about no.
Speaker 7: Saying they aren't like other girls than being exactly like
Speaker 7: other girls. No more posting every moment of your life
Speaker 7: on social media. You get one post to showcase what
Speaker 7: you're doing a month, and the rest of the time
Speaker 7: you're just gonna have to live your life. And no
Speaker 7: more asking dudes to take the photos I have. No
Speaker 7: more fist fighting with your wife, and that one obviously
Speaker 7: only pertains. The less stories about work will now be
Speaker 7: limited to one minute, with the stated premise to be
Speaker 7: delivered with in the first thirty second.
Speaker 5: No more shop left.
Speaker 7: Talking behind each other's backs, then pretending to be friends
Speaker 7: in public will be var only fans. Jecks will only
Speaker 7: be allowed to scam the scene man out of money
Speaker 7: once you already got his money.
Speaker 1: Keep it moving.
Speaker 7: No more turning this sucker into a well. Now more
Speaker 7: poisoning your husband. Women will only be allowed one day
Speaker 7: a month to have their periods. Now, whatever changes you
Speaker 7: got to meet to have that happened before I get there,
Speaker 7: I recommend you start now.
Speaker 2: He's besmirched all of Australia with that policy. There is
Speaker 2: only just Victoria. But in the interest of equality, will
Speaker 2: we eventually get a Parliamentary Secretary for Women's Behavior change
Speaker 2: DAN to battle toxic femininity?
Speaker 4: Perhaps I would be holding my breath reader for that
Speaker 4: to happen. And look, I mean, there's so many things
Speaker 4: you can say about this, but what I would say
Speaker 4: is it's just another example of the divisiveness of the
Speaker 4: Victorian government. That's been a theme of this government. Whether
Speaker 4: it was in COVID, there was two sets of rules.
Speaker 4: If you were a Black Lives Matter protester, you could
Speaker 4: go out there and protest. If you were someone that
Speaker 4: didn't want lockdowns, you were arrested. Whether it's to do
Speaker 4: with the voice and the treaty process of dividing Victorians,
Speaker 4: the way they treated small business owners and workers as
Speaker 4: compared to big business and public servants. This is just
Speaker 4: another example a long line of very divisive policies in
Speaker 4: a very divisive attitude of the Victorian government. And I
Speaker 4: just think most people these days have just had a
Speaker 4: gutful of these sort of gestures where they don't really
Speaker 4: understand why someone's getting so much money to take on
Speaker 4: what is clearly a divisive, tokenistic role. So look, I
Speaker 4: think most people will hopefully see through this.
Speaker 2: Dan Wild, thank you so much for your time this evening.
Speaker 2: Let's bring in Sky News contributor Gary Hardgrave. Gary. Queensland's
Speaker 2: labor government is facing a massive budget black hole as
Speaker 2: their war on coal comes back to bite them. For
Speaker 2: the past two years, their controversial royalty is hike brought
Speaker 2: in twenty five billion from coal. The latest state budget
Speaker 2: reveals this will shrink to five billion a year by
Speaker 2: mid twenty twenty eight. So what's going to happen Our
Speaker 2: taxpayer is being expected to fill that massive gap, or
Speaker 2: is the government they're going to wake up and realize
Speaker 2: they can't walk away from coal because it's keeping them afloat.
Speaker 9: Yeah, the real answer for Queensland is to borrow the
Speaker 9: phrase from Donald Trump.
Speaker 1: Drill baby, drill, dig baby, dig, because.
Speaker 9: That's where the money comes from when it comes to
Speaker 9: Queensland's budget. But look, let's face it, this is a
Speaker 9: government that's lost its way.
Speaker 1: It is the walking dead.
Speaker 9: They can't wait till the twenty fourth of October because
Speaker 9: all of the traps that they've set for an incoming
Speaker 9: Chryso Furley government are already in place, so they have
Speaker 9: sabotage the next four or five or six years of
Speaker 9: Queensland economic life.
Speaker 1: Frankly, and until we.
Speaker 9: Get some certainty back into the system, you're not going
Speaker 9: to get the investment that we need. Because we've actually
Speaker 9: do in all seriousness, have to start new coal mines.
Speaker 1: We actually have to use.
Speaker 9: More coal to burn in our power stations to create
Speaker 9: cheaper electricity for other industries. And we used to have
Speaker 9: the cheapest electricity in the world.
Speaker 1: Sheer in Queensland. We had so much of it.
Speaker 9: It was just everywhere that back in the day of
Speaker 9: Jobioki Peterson. You know, I have a few issues with
Speaker 9: Joe who didn't But let me tell you, back in
Speaker 9: those days. There was so much electricity they're inventing new
Speaker 9: ways to use it. They put in an electrified railway
Speaker 9: line six hundred miles north of Brisbane to Rock Captain.
Speaker 9: They gave everybody money to go and buy those dreadful
Speaker 9: box like air conditions to hang out of their loungery
Speaker 9: and windows. Please use their electricity. We've got so much
Speaker 9: of it and it was so cheap. So we've got
Speaker 9: to get ourselves back to that Queensland. I think if
Speaker 9: we can reverse some of this renewable nonsense d Queensland
Speaker 9: will be the premier state, it'll be the powerhouse state,
Speaker 9: it'll be the state that's driving the whole of Australia.
Speaker 9: But under this mob, they've put up the white flow.
Speaker 9: They want to follow the internationalists, the wo green agenda
Speaker 9: that the world is turning away from. But that seems
Speaker 9: to be the only inspiration you've got for this current
Speaker 9: walking dead Queensland government.
Speaker 2: But you've got the Libs who've signed up to these
Speaker 2: Bolder Mission targets that the Queensland government wants to run with.
Speaker 2: So I do really hope there's a one eighty turn
Speaker 2: there at some point, because if they're going to be
Speaker 2: implementing similar policies. We're not going to be in a
Speaker 2: much better position. Elsewhere in the budget there is a
Speaker 2: promise to pump nearly thirty billion into the health system
Speaker 2: as it struggles with some of the worst hospital overcrowding
Speaker 2: and ambulance ramping times in the country. But again, where
Speaker 2: is this money coming from?
Speaker 1: Gary from borrowing? So we're just going to debt.
Speaker 9: We'll go further into debt and the taxpayer will wear
Speaker 9: it with increased charges. Victoria this other little one fifty
Speaker 9: two exactly know, I use it joke that Anastasia Palise
Speaker 9: Cook could be renamed Danastasia because she was taking all
Speaker 9: of her inspiration from Daniel andrews ACAKKBG whatever he is.
Speaker 9: I don't know whatever in particular a gong he's got.
Speaker 9: But you know here again, in all seriousness, there is
Speaker 9: a complete lack of proper planning for the future. We
Speaker 9: need more hospitals, We actually need four hundred more schools
Speaker 9: in Queensland, and no one.
Speaker 1: Knows where they're going to go.
Speaker 9: But a little gem fifty two point five million dollars
Speaker 9: being spent over the next four years to increase the
Speaker 9: number of staff for members of Parliament. The last thing
Speaker 9: we need is more members of Parliament. The last thing
Speaker 9: we need are more staffers. I mean, if you think
Speaker 9: the current crop of MPs all around our parliaments are bad,
Speaker 9: wait till you see their staff and they.
Speaker 1: All want the job somewhere down the track.
Speaker 9: So money is getting wasted and thirty billion into health,
Speaker 9: well they'll spend at least ten or fifteen billion on
Speaker 9: clipboard carriers going around checking who's actually doing the work
Speaker 9: got any given day.
Speaker 1: This is not a good plan.
Speaker 2: Well again that is the Victorian model. Again, that's just
Speaker 2: have a lot of bureaucrats, have a lot of public
Speaker 2: servants who are going to vote for labor and make
Speaker 2: sure you get re elected.
Speaker 6: Now.
Speaker 2: Today, Treasurer and Jim Charmers said that Australia's economy is
Speaker 2: on track for a soft landing that will see inflation
Speaker 2: back under control. It's currently just about the RBA's target
Speaker 2: of three point six percent. But I've got to say, Gary,
Speaker 2: I was in the supermarket yesterday and I'm sure I'm
Speaker 2: not alone in observing this. You would not think our
Speaker 2: inflation rate is anywhere around the four percent mark. If
Speaker 2: you look at things like grocery prices. They have increased
Speaker 2: considerably cost of living pressures from other things that aren't
Speaker 2: included in the basket of goods that we used to
Speaker 2: measure in inflation. I just wonder how divorce from reality
Speaker 2: that inflation figure is, because you only need to do
Speaker 2: the weekly shop to say how much more it's costing
Speaker 2: than a year ago and two years ago.
Speaker 9: Well, I think people are far worse off than they
Speaker 9: were a year ago than they were two years ago
Speaker 9: and three years ago. People get it, and they do
Speaker 9: see it, and people are denying themselves access to basic
Speaker 9: things or things they thought were basic, and the basket
Speaker 9: of goods, I think, is getting incredibly small reader and
Speaker 9: for a lot of people, the costs are cruling them.
Speaker 9: They're hurting them, they're panicking them. And they can give
Speaker 9: out subsidies, as they're apparently going to do after the
Speaker 9: first of July for power prices, but until we actually
Speaker 9: drop the price of electricity, which is cheap and reliable,
Speaker 9: that's what we need, cheap and reliable power in this country,
Speaker 9: everything is just going to.
Speaker 1: Keep going up.
Speaker 9: And when he talks about soft landing, the point is
Speaker 9: it's a landing.
Speaker 1: Things have got to go down before things can settle.
Speaker 9: Well, I don't think that until this government gets out
Speaker 9: of the energy market and stops fiddling around with renewables
Speaker 9: and ruining everybody's life and making them make a decision about.
Speaker 1: Whether they want to be warm or they want to eat.
Speaker 9: And that's kind of the decision a lot of Australians
Speaker 9: are making this week. Yet again, I just don't think
Speaker 9: this government can be trusted on anything.
Speaker 1: We need a longer term vision.
Speaker 9: I mean, this is why I support Peter Dutton at
Speaker 9: least putting nuclear on the table, because well, nuclear is
Speaker 9: not going to start tomorrow. It's reasonable to say that
Speaker 9: it's got to be part of the mix because hey,
Speaker 9: every other grown up country around the world has got
Speaker 9: it in their mix of energy.
Speaker 1: And for a good reason.
Speaker 2: Absolutely, and talking about cheap, reliable energy, the Australian Energy
Speaker 2: Market Operator insists that warnings of electricity shortfalls and unreliable
Speaker 2: supply is going to fire up investors to put more
Speaker 2: money into renewable projects. Oh Gary, if investors were really
Speaker 2: interested in renewables without all the market manipulation that we
Speaker 2: see from the government, we wouldn't need all these subsidies.
Speaker 2: We wouldn't need all these green tape around coal and gas.
Speaker 2: It would just happen organically.
Speaker 9: Helllria, I'm the less governed in my life kind of guy.
Speaker 9: You know, if governments trust you, they tax your less,
Speaker 9: they'd make you fill in few of forms, they'd have
Speaker 9: less intervention in your daily life. And for people in
Speaker 9: the energy market, they will invest where the technology will
Speaker 9: allow them to invest. But right now we're excluding a
Speaker 9: big chunk of technology from that mix. The super funds,
Speaker 9: the banks, they're saying no to coal. That's killing all
Speaker 9: of us. Stone dead right now. It's got to change.
Speaker 2: Gary Hartgrave, thank you so much for your time this evening,
Speaker 2: and still to coma left is losing it and it's
Speaker 2: a good one. And the latest from the US with
Speaker 2: Army Horowitz, welcome back. And now it's time for lefties
Speaker 2: losing it. And good news from Canada where the king
Speaker 2: of performative caring, the neo Marxist Kendole himself, Justin Trudeau,
Speaker 2: is floundering in the polls and he's now lashing out
Speaker 2: people rejecting far left parties.
Speaker 6: We have seen around the world a rise of populist
Speaker 6: right wing forces in just what every democracy that we've seen,
Speaker 6: and it is of concern to see political parties choosing
Speaker 6: to instrumentalize anger, fear, division, anxiety.
Speaker 2: So there you go. The swing to the right is
Speaker 2: all due to anger, fear, division, and anxiety, precisely what
Speaker 2: Trudeau pushed with his hard left policies for the past
Speaker 2: nine years. Never forget. Yeah, this is the monster who
Speaker 2: falsely branded Canadian truckers as extremists and white supremacist and
Speaker 2: then froze their bank accounts. Are adios Fidel Junior. Now
Speaker 2: to the leader of the free world, whose cognitive decline
Speaker 2: is obvious whether he is standing still he's glitching there,
Speaker 2: or when he tries to utter a rehearsed sentence. Here
Speaker 2: he again mixes up Ukraine with Iraq.
Speaker 10: The idea that we become semie solicious now, which some
Speaker 10: we're talking about, I mean, the idea we had to
Speaker 10: wead all those months just to get the money for
Speaker 10: a wreck and because we were reading. I mean, it's
Speaker 10: not who we are now.
Speaker 2: They say dogs are good judges of people. I mean, know,
Speaker 2: Joe Biden has had some big issues with his dogs
Speaker 2: going rogue and biting various people. Maybe the poor dog
Speaker 2: was angry because the leader of the free world keeps
Speaker 2: pulling his tail, and it seems the president's issues with
Speaker 2: the canine community extend beyond his own dogs. Watch this
Speaker 2: based dog lose it when Biden appears on TV.
Speaker 11: I don't know what kind of politically status my dog is. Right,
Speaker 11: there's Donald Trump. Did you see Donald Trump's what you are?
Speaker 11: With your help, we're going to win the bad We're
Speaker 11: going to.
Speaker 1: She's cool radical center.
Speaker 11: Please, I'm telling you, Molly relaxed, Relax. It's his Joe Biden.
Speaker 11: Why she really like? Here you go Biden relas.
Speaker 10: Like him.
Speaker 5: I don't know.
Speaker 11: I think my dog is on grip.
Speaker 5: Relax.
Speaker 2: That's my Molly is a good dog. Molly deserves more treats.
Speaker 6: Now.
Speaker 2: There are a lot of lefties who are trying to
Speaker 2: rewrite history and memory hold the monstrous things they said
Speaker 2: and advocated for during the COVID era, and two such
Speaker 2: men are the CuMo brothers, former New York Governor Andrew
Speaker 2: Kumo and former CNN anchor Chris Kumo, who got called
Speaker 2: out for this bs on the PbD podcast. Here he
Speaker 2: is with Dave Smith.
Speaker 11: There was so much talk that they don't want you
Speaker 11: to take ivmacin.
Speaker 10: Iromactin is the way to go.
Speaker 1: Take it.
Speaker 3: Joe Rogan got.
Speaker 10: Better from ivermactin. And by the way, I don't like
Speaker 10: what people did to Joe Rogan about ivermactin.
Speaker 5: I don't like you did it. No, no, no, you
Speaker 5: did find the clips, dude, Find the clips.
Speaker 3: You shamed Joe Rogan.
Speaker 5: Find thet he is taking horsts over you and Don
Speaker 5: Lemon were chuckling at I'll go find you just saw the.
Speaker 1: Clips watching I'm not chuckling.
Speaker 2: I'm listening to Don.
Speaker 3: But no, no, no, Here's what I'm talking about. Wasn't on
Speaker 3: there and it's absolutely there were.
Speaker 1: Oh here do we have it?
Speaker 8: Hold on, let's play the car.
Speaker 2: Head getting injecting drugs for animals and horse and.
Speaker 10: People telling them to what person you know you talk
Speaker 10: about like, you know, cancel culture and who to shame
Speaker 10: ivermectin a de wormer.
Speaker 1: Really, they are shaming themselves, that's what it is. They're
Speaker 1: shaving themselves.
Speaker 5: So you're taking a de warmer right now this game.
Speaker 2: You can't apologize for that.
Speaker 5: Best You weren't being clear that it was this and
Speaker 5: you know that.
Speaker 3: Dude, you're being so dishonest.
Speaker 2: Right now, Chris Kumo is now telling us he's taking ivermectin. Okay,
Speaker 2: jurd when it actually mattered, you were a coward and
Speaker 2: a bully during the COVID era, don't pretend to be
Speaker 2: red peeled. Now. President Joe Biden's son, the drug adult
Speaker 2: whore enthusiast, Hunter Biden, is now a convicted felon after
Speaker 2: Dury and Delaware found him guilty. This CNN reporter seemed
Speaker 2: a little bit crestfallen by the development.
Speaker 12: Well, if the jury has found Hunter Biden, the President
Speaker 12: signed guilty on all three counts in this case after
Speaker 12: three hours of deliberation. Count one is a false statement
Speaker 12: in the purchase of a firearm. Count two is false
Speaker 12: statement related to information required to be kepped by a
Speaker 12: Federal Firearms licensed dealer. Count three is possession of a
Speaker 12: firearm by a person who is an unlawful user or
Speaker 12: addicted to a controlled substance. So he has been found
Speaker 12: guilty on all three counts.
Speaker 2: Now, the Hunter trial was a bit different to the
Speaker 2: Trump trial. First, Hunter's judge wasn't a activist or donated
Speaker 2: to the Republicans. That's a big difference, and his prosecutor
Speaker 2: didn't campaign on a get Hunter platform, as happened in
Speaker 2: New York, or create charges out of thin air to
Speaker 2: get him. Indeed, Hunter has been protected throughout with the
Speaker 2: Department of Justice allowing the statute of limitations to expire
Speaker 2: on far more serious tax charges he was facing, and
Speaker 2: they've also declined to pursue him over even more serious
Speaker 2: bribery allegations. Both of those cases would possibly uncover the
Speaker 2: Biden families dodgy business dealings with the big guy, Joe
Speaker 2: Biden in the middle of the entire influence peddling scheme.
Speaker 2: And let's not forget they did try to give Hunter
Speaker 2: a sweet plea deal that fell apart. Now, let's also
Speaker 2: not forget that the bulk of the media, Joe Biden himself,
Speaker 2: and America's intelligence community were part of a massive disinformation
Speaker 2: campaign claiming that Hunter Biden's laptop and all the evidence
Speaker 2: it contained was Russian disinformation.
Speaker 5: One of the hallmarks of any sort of disinformation is
Speaker 5: you can't give it directly to somebody that is your
Speaker 5: target audience, so you need to find a way to
Speaker 5: essentially launder that disinformation.
Speaker 13: It looks like your classic disinformation campaign steal the information
Speaker 13: with a cyber attack, get the emails from Hunter Biden's
Speaker 13: account and then put them on these laptops that are
Speaker 13: left at a repair store.
Speaker 11: And that's how the information is now laundered.
Speaker 6: Damn.
Speaker 5: You know a story is shady when Facebook is saying whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa,
Speaker 5: Maybe people shouldn't see this.
Speaker 10: Fifty former national intelligence folks who said that what this
Speaker 10: he's accusing me of is a Russian plant? This classic Trump.
Speaker 10: We have four days left and all of a sudden,
Speaker 10: there's a laptop. It's the lastest effort in this desperate
Speaker 10: campaign to me and my family. The vast majority of
Speaker 10: the intelligence people have come out and said there's no
Speaker 10: basis at.
Speaker 9: All the story from the fall of Atri Sid Pucker.
Speaker 2: Said, yes, yes, yes, it's just straight out interference. It's
Speaker 2: saw a legitimate, one hundred percent accurate story by the
Speaker 2: New York Post branded Russian disinformation. And you'll recall the
Speaker 2: spies who lie, the intelligence experts that Joe Biden kept
Speaker 2: referring to there who signed a letter saying the laptop
Speaker 2: was fake news. And we had President Biden claiming that
Speaker 2: not only was Hunter Biden the smartest man he knows,
Speaker 2: but also the most decent.
Speaker 10: Hunter's my heart, and Hunter's been through some tough times.
Speaker 5: But he's fighting.
Speaker 10: He's fighting, He's never given up. He's the most honorable
Speaker 10: decent person I know.
Speaker 2: Most honorable decent person. He knows this crack aduled whar
Speaker 2: enthusiast who has not even met his daughter. His five
Speaker 2: year old daughter joining me now is a journalist and filmmaker,
Speaker 2: Army Horowitz. Army. He's been convicted. He faces a maximum
Speaker 2: prison sentence of twenty five years. That's highly unlikely. President
Speaker 2: Biden has said that he would not pardon his son
Speaker 2: if he was convicted. But will he change course now
Speaker 2: given that Hunter could face a possible prison term. Yeah.
Speaker 8: By the way, it is always remarkable to me to
Speaker 8: watch Biden from three years ago, listening to him speak
Speaker 8: and Joe Biden now, God, because interioration is so dear,
Speaker 8: it's amazing. Look, Joe Biden is in a bit of
Speaker 8: a pickle. He has to he has to agree that
Speaker 8: this was the right decision because he spent the last
Speaker 8: year talking about how you say and the justice system
Speaker 8: doesn't work? Who are undermining the US democratic institutions?
Speaker 13: Right?
Speaker 8: We remember that again coming from a man who spent
Speaker 8: the last three years demonizing the Supreme Court, saying it's
Speaker 8: an illegitimate institution and then threatening to pack it. So look,
Speaker 8: this wasn't how open a shut a case was this reader.
Speaker 8: Let me tell you this was done in Delaware, right, Willington, Delaware,
Speaker 8: his hometown. He won this town, ye, by ninety percent?
Speaker 8: Some context, some contexts for you, Yeah, no kidding, context
Speaker 8: Phuton won his election by less than that. That's how
Speaker 8: serious a player he is in Delaware. Yet he was
Speaker 8: still convicted. It shows you this was really an open
Speaker 8: and shut, clear cut case.
Speaker 2: Well, it was all on tape, a lot of it.
Speaker 2: So there was so much evidence on that laptop that
Speaker 2: hunted Biden, and it helpfully is amassed for the prosecution.
Speaker 2: So yeah, I'm not surprised that even that jewelry pool
Speaker 2: that is so heavily Democrat came back with this decision,
Speaker 2: and in very quick time as well. Now Here is
Speaker 2: a woman who was protesting peacefully outside the courtroom. She
Speaker 2: says she's served five years after being found guilty of
Speaker 2: similar offenses. I'm out here because I lost my your friend,
Speaker 2: I've lost my home. I spent five years in jail
Speaker 2: for obliviated serial numbers, and we saw President Biden make
Speaker 2: an unscheduled stop in Delaware to see his son Hunter
Speaker 2: and his grandson. Yeah, let's Hunt, I get the kid
Speaker 2: away from the grandpa. At least it's one child, one
Speaker 2: of Hunters offspring, that the President is acknowledging. This is
Speaker 2: one of the things that has shocked me throughout this
Speaker 2: presidency is that it is just so callous of the
Speaker 2: first family, not just Hunter Biden, but also Joe and Jill,
Speaker 2: that they talk about their grandchildren incessantly, and yet they
Speaker 2: don't acknowledge this little girl down in Arkansas. They've never
Speaker 2: met her, The father has a met her. He tried
Speaker 2: not to support her financially, and that seems to be
Speaker 2: just brushed over in the media. And I cannot imagine
Speaker 2: that would be happening if this was happening within the
Speaker 2: Trump family.
Speaker 8: Now, you're absolutely right, of course it when the double
Speaker 8: standard is obvious. They eve ensued to make sure the
Speaker 8: kid could use the Biden name, so they did. He
Speaker 8: probably end up making money from the Chinese at some point.
Speaker 8: They don't want to give that piece of pie away.
Speaker 2: Good point, now, Democrat Senator John Fetterman is drifting further
Speaker 2: and further away from his past political positions. He was
Speaker 2: once radically left, but now he says he's no longer
Speaker 2: a progressive.
Speaker 12: Some progressives have criticized you for being a different senator
Speaker 12: than you suggested you would be when you were a
Speaker 12: candidate for Senate.
Speaker 2: What do you say to that, Well, I wasn't.
Speaker 14: I was very clear for saying that for years, I'm
Speaker 14: not a progressive, and I just identified myself as just
Speaker 14: a regular Democrat. So it really wasn't any new news.
Speaker 13: Now.
Speaker 14: Eight years ago, I was a progressive, but the situations changed,
Speaker 14: and I've been very clear that I didn't leave that label.
Speaker 2: That label leaves me, and that progressive label is now
Speaker 2: owned by the likes of these imbeciles marching on American
Speaker 2: soil calling for Hezbula, a terrorist group, to kill Zionists.
Speaker 11: That's the law.
Speaker 2: AMMI uh, how is that allowed to happen. I'm all
Speaker 2: for free speech, for protest, for peaceful protests, but when
Speaker 2: you're calling on terror is to kill Zonus, which is
Speaker 2: what they were chanting there, that crosses the line.
Speaker 8: I would have thought, yeah, let's do that one first
Speaker 8: and then we'll go back to fedamen real quick, because
Speaker 8: I have some thoughts on that as well. Look, this
Speaker 8: is no shocks, really, this is not about Israel, it
Speaker 8: really isn't. This is really the anti Semitism gets to
Speaker 8: be on full displaced the quiet part out loud. Now,
Speaker 8: this is about the Intersexual Coalition, which has had institutional
Speaker 8: anti Semitism built into it by definitions.
Speaker 7: For people don't know, this is important.
Speaker 8: Intersectionality is the idea that all victims are connected through
Speaker 8: their victimhood and then the pyramid of oppression, and the
Speaker 8: higher you up at the pyramid, the more you are
Speaker 8: an oppressor. So what that says to them? Because the
Speaker 8: Marxist ideology says to them that Jews, because they are
Speaker 8: perceived by the left, by the Intersexual Coalition to be
Speaker 8: on the higher end, if not the tippy top of
Speaker 8: that pyramid, by definition, they are the biggest oppressors. Therefore
Speaker 8: they're allowed to call for the killing of Zionists and
Speaker 8: Jews because they are the fascist oppressors. Now get back
Speaker 8: to Feederman, which I find endlessly fascinating. Rita, I am
Speaker 8: a full on fetterhead. I'd admit that. Okay, Fetterman is
Speaker 8: somebody who the Democratic Party should be modeling themselves after
Speaker 8: if they want to win right. Christen Cinema another example
Speaker 8: of somebody who was progressive who moves the center. She
Speaker 8: is now no longer running because she doesn't feel at
Speaker 8: home the Democratic Party. But they're not, They're leaning into
Speaker 8: the progressive label. Fetterman is an unbelievable case study of this.
Speaker 5: Look, he was a progressive.
Speaker 8: He in fact sought out the endorsement of the Democratic
Speaker 8: Socialist Party at one point. At one point, Look, he
Speaker 8: has become a full on Zionist, talking the border. At
Speaker 8: one point he actually pointed to his wife's undocumented status
Speaker 8: to show his progressive bona fides. Fedderman is amazing. Fennamin
Speaker 8: himself has said I ended up leaving the Progressive Party
Speaker 8: after my brain damage.
Speaker 2: I'm going to leave that one alone. It's incredible the
Speaker 2: transformation and him referred to eight years ago. He's departed
Speaker 2: from those positions, but I think it's far more recent,
Speaker 2: just even a few years ago, three years ago, some
Speaker 2: of those positions this seemed to hold. He's done a
Speaker 2: radical one to eighty turn away from them. So yeah,
Speaker 2: he has become one of the more rational democrats, sort
Speaker 2: of the counter to the squad. Now what about these
Speaker 2: protesters we saw outside the White House? There seemed to
Speaker 2: be little consequences for the way they defaced public property,
Speaker 2: desecrated monuments, attacked offices, and again chanted for inter fada
Speaker 2: and for the killing of Zionists. Why is there continued tolerance?
Speaker 2: The Biden administration occasionally comes out and condemns this sort
Speaker 2: of behavior, but they're largely allowed to run riot.
Speaker 1: Yeah.
Speaker 8: Look, they're simply the administration simply does not want to
Speaker 8: continue having problems on their left flank, and that if
Speaker 8: they would start doing arresting people for sayings like that,
Speaker 8: that they would have more trouble and they already have.
Speaker 8: But unfortunately with their miscalculation is it's that kind of
Speaker 8: behavior which is losing in the election with the more
Speaker 8: important constituency, which is the independence the impendance. Look at
Speaker 8: this and they are disgusted by it reminds me of
Speaker 8: the Black Lives Look. I was walking around, I went
Speaker 8: to every major Black Lives Matter riot and rally, and
Speaker 8: everywhere I saw we've defaced and I didn't see a
Speaker 8: single arrest of someone who defaced property federal, state, local property.
Speaker 8: The same idea. They simply do not want to kiss off.
Speaker 1: The left lake.
Speaker 2: Me Horowitz, you are always on the money. Thank you
Speaker 2: for your time this evening.
Speaker 8: How is your pleasure?
Speaker 2: Stil to coming youth climbing victorious spirals out of control
Speaker 2: and another pediatric body steps up against the trans lobby.
Speaker 2: You're watching the Reader Paney Show. Joining me now is
Speaker 2: Victorian Libertarian MP David Limbrick. Let's talk about the front
Speaker 2: page of the Herald Sun today revealing, Hey, fourteen year
Speaker 2: old boy, one of the state's worst serial offenders, has
Speaker 2: had close to four hundred charges dropped against him because
Speaker 2: of his young age. Is accused of carrying out six
Speaker 2: armed robberies in many hours the same day he was
Speaker 2: bailed for other offenses. Why is he not behind is
Speaker 2: my first question, David. But soon these crimes won't even
Speaker 2: be called crimes because the age of criminal responsibility is
Speaker 2: going up in this state and if you're under fourteen
Speaker 2: you can pretty much do what you like without fearing
Speaker 2: police action.
Speaker 5: Well, firstly, I think it's awful that we've got a
Speaker 5: situation where there's a teenage boy, a child who's running
Speaker 5: around causing so much trouble and committing these awful, awful crimes.
Speaker 5: But you're absolutely right. The idea that's been promoted by
Speaker 5: many in the Left and the Greens that we're just
Speaker 5: simply raised the age of criminal responsibility to fourteen is
Speaker 5: absolutely untenable because many there's many children in that thirteen
Speaker 5: to fourteen year old age group, small numbers, but the
Speaker 5: ones that are committing crimes are committing serious crimes and
Speaker 5: there needs to be a much more balanced approach here.
Speaker 5: It's my understanding that the government, the Victorian government, is
Speaker 5: only going to twelve. They're being pushed by many the
Speaker 5: left to go further than that, but I think it's
Speaker 5: a lot more complicated.
Speaker 2: That'll be interesting because they were planning to go to fourteen.
Speaker 2: So if there's a little reconsideration of that, that's good.
Speaker 2: But I wonder how long that will last because we
Speaker 2: know the ideology of this party and where it stands
Speaker 2: on this issue. Now, you gave the Victorian Parliament a
Speaker 2: wonderful spray in my opinion on energy policy recently. Let's
Speaker 2: have a quick look.
Speaker 5: Even worse than Labour getting dragged along by the Greens
Speaker 5: is the coalition getting dragged along by Labor. Everything that
Speaker 5: Labor does they do to try and scare the coalition
Speaker 5: into doing stuff. They did it with the fracking ban,
Speaker 5: so coal seam gas was banned rather ridiculously, it was
Speaker 5: put into our constitution to ban it. What an absolutely
Speaker 5: ridiculous thing.
Speaker 2: Pretty decent effort there, David. You had to go with
Speaker 2: the Greens, Labor and the liberals there. But you are
Speaker 2: right because that's in our constitution. Now that insanity is
Speaker 2: in the constitution. And we've got this absurd situation of
Speaker 2: having gas shortages in a state sitting on hundreds of
Speaker 2: years of gas reserves.
Speaker 5: Yeah, I mean, the government's driving us into the dark.
Speaker 5: We've had successive governments institute these policies that have restricted
Speaker 5: the amount of technologies that are energy technologies that are
Speaker 5: available to us, like nuclear technology, like coal seam gas,
Speaker 5: these other technologies, and now we're in a situation where
Speaker 5: the government's complaining that we've got gas shortages. It's absolutely crazy.
Speaker 5: We need to keep the lights on, we do.
Speaker 2: And the Victorian government has approved its first gas extraction
Speaker 2: project in a decade on the Great Ocean Road. How
Speaker 2: do they explain this decision when they're treating gas like
Speaker 2: the great enemy. It's just so contradictory and incoherent their
Speaker 2: policy position.
Speaker 5: It's not as contradictory as what it first appears, like
Speaker 5: when they're doing the gas bands in the houses. My
Speaker 5: opinion is that they're actually doing that to restrict consumption
Speaker 5: because they're worried about shortages. That's why they're approving this.
Speaker 5: There is no high capacity renewables that will happen without
Speaker 5: gas backup, and they need the gas back up, both
Speaker 5: for industry and for power. Realities come to come home
Speaker 5: to them.
Speaker 2: Now, another major medical body, the American College of Pediatricians,
Speaker 2: is called for an immediate end to dangerous so called
Speaker 2: gender affirming operations and treatment for minors. This follows the
Speaker 2: CAST review. We've had all sorts of U turns in
Speaker 2: this area in Europe, throughout Scandinavia. When are we're going
Speaker 2: to see something happen in Australia at least an investigation
Speaker 2: of what's happening and whether it's the right set of
Speaker 2: procedures in place for gender confused kids.
Speaker 5: Yeah, we've had many of the reviews now like the
Speaker 5: CAST review, and many countries now have been doing a
Speaker 5: U turn. As you say, many in Europe are also
Speaker 5: states in the United States, but Australia just seems to
Speaker 5: be putting its head in the sand. There was a
Speaker 5: response from the Health Minister from the Victorian government just
Speaker 5: recently in a response to a petition on this topic,
Speaker 5: and they basically said everything's going fine. They even talked
Speaker 5: about the Cast Review as you know, increasing disinformation. Yeah,
Speaker 5: our governments like they've been captured by these activists. They
Speaker 5: have to face reality that what's happening is being questioned
Speaker 5: and we need to look at it much more seriously
Speaker 5: and stop giving stop looking at this medicine as something
Speaker 5: that you know isn't serious. It's very serious what they're
Speaker 5: doing here. And the interesting thing about what they said
Speaker 5: in the US was though also referring to social transitioning,
Speaker 5: which is not medically involved, but it's also, as was
Speaker 5: pointed out in the Cast Review, is a serious, active
Speaker 5: intervention that needs to considered carefully. And in Victoria we
Speaker 5: don't do that.
Speaker 2: We don't And to dismiss the CAST Review as disinformation,
Speaker 2: this was a review that took years. This is someone
Speaker 2: who is not in any way political ideologically driven. He
Speaker 2: was just looking at the evidence of what was happening
Speaker 2: and the outcomes, and I just wonder when we're going
Speaker 2: to have the coalition the state liberals make a stand
Speaker 2: on this issue because they seem to be right there
Speaker 2: with Labor promoting the complete extremes of this movement.
Speaker 5: Look, I think as we're seeing it's like a house
Speaker 5: of cards that's falling at the moment.
Speaker 2: Sooner or later everyone has state rock solid in this state.
Speaker 5: Well, I'm doing my best. I'm doing my best to
Speaker 5: push back against it. And look, I think more and
Speaker 5: more people are coming around to that position. You know,
Speaker 5: if you talk to average mums and dads at home
Speaker 5: and tell them who are don't know about this stuff,
Speaker 5: you talk, tell them about what's going on, they reject it. Right,
Speaker 5: They don't want to have this public debate. No one
Speaker 5: wants to have this public debate because they know that
Speaker 5: they'll lose.
Speaker 2: Yeah, you're so right. And I think this is part
Speaker 2: of the problem because the Libs are just so terrified
Speaker 2: of getting a backlash from the activists from the media.
Speaker 2: They say, well, this isn't a top issue. Of course,
Speaker 2: it's not a top issue, and many mums and dads
Speaker 2: don't even know about it. It's your job to actually
Speaker 2: tell them what's happening at schools and hospitals. David Linbrick,
Speaker 2: thank you so much. We do call you the unofficial
Speaker 2: opposition leader in this state, and you serve that role well.
Speaker 2: And that's it for me tonight. Up next is at Newsnight.
Speaker 2: I'll see you at eleven tomorrow with Douglas Murray. Good night,